Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Subprime Isn’t Sublime, Toyota Sales Lift, Joby Lifts Off
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Uh-oh. Ah. Got him. Ha ha. That's not really- I don't-... the morning intro. [laughs] Joke's on us. Let's go. Joke's on us. It is Thursday, June 29th.
- 0:09We have a special guest on the show today, Matt Lasher from West Herr. We're talking about subprime lending, Toyota sales lift, and a company called Joby. Everywhere I go- Not the Joby you're thinking of...
- 0:19people wanna know who I is and who I'm not. Or is it the same comp- Well- Is it the same company? I don't think so. Is it the same... No, there's no way it's the same company.
- 0:25It's hard for the, that word is so unique, like if you write it in all caps, it's hard for it not to look like the same company. But good morning. We have a, a great Thursday, and it's the day before the month close.
- 0:35So everybody is on point today. Man, everybody's all geared up. Little- Everybody's walking in with a little swagger, you know. Little extra hair gel. [laughs] Uh, did you see- That's so true. I feel like- Did
- 0:48you- [laughs] I feel like hockey players and automotive sales managers have something in common, right?
- 0:54[laughs] Just like they basically s- [laughs] They basically supply all, uh, they like, they care for the supply of hair gel in the world. [laughs] Right? I don't know how that works. I don't know.
- 1:04There's a lot of pro- It's been a long time since I've used hair gel. But back in the day I definitely, you know, I was in Philly, Jersey, I used a lot of hair gel. Italian kid. Come on. Yeah, yeah. Come on.
- 1:14[laughs] Absolutely. You, yeah. [laughs] Uh, well, look, today we have a really exciting Auto Collabs episode. If you're not aware, Auto Collabs- Ugh...
- 1:21is our longer form podcast where we get to sit down with Michael Cirillo, the three of us, and execute like a really, a, a deeper conversation with somebody in the industry. Um, and this is an extra special one.
- 1:32It's Ed Roberts of Bozard Ford. Absolutely. Wrote a new book, it's about to come out, called Mile One Leadership, and we, uh, this is probably the fastest release ever. We recorded it yesterday afternoon.
- 1:42We wanted to get it out. So it releases today. So you can search Auto Collabs on, uh, your favorite podcast platform, or go to our YouTube channel and you can actually see the interview.
- 1:52And Ed Roberts is the kind of guy that's worth watching, just his body language.
- 1:55He is, like I would, yeah, I would say fine, listen to the podcast, but you gotta watch it because there's a couple little things about his office that we allude to, and then just you see the care in his eyes, like the way he leans in, the way he cares.
- 2:10You just see it. So you gotta go to a-, check out Auto Collabs. You can hear it right now. I believe it's live. And then you can watch it, uh, at noon today streamed and then, and then ongoing, so. So great.
- 2:20He had us taking notes. Hey, Ed Roberts is actually gonna be a speaker at ASOTU CON in September. Um, you can get a discounted ticket. Today's the last, uh, today and tomorrow- Today...
- 2:29are the last two days of the, the most discounted ticket you'll be able to get. You can go to asotucon.com and, uh, get that, lock it in if you can right now.
- 2:38Um, and Ed Roberts is gonna be the kind of person that is worth meeting in person. Speaking of people who are worth meeting in person- That's right. segue. Time. Uh, we'll segue to an intro to a guest.
- 2:49We're introducing- Wow... you to the show Matt Lasher with West Herr. You know him, you love him. He is so... I mean, do, do you use hair gel? Actually, your hair looks great.
- 2:59Doesn't look like gel, it's more of like a- Not too, a little bit... loose hold product. A little bit. Yeah. It's some pomade. No, you, just- A pomade. Of course you use a pomade. [laughs] Of course he does.
- 3:07Just a gentleman of all gentlemen. Just a little dab, a little bit of this going on. [laughs] Just put it in there. That's it. Uh, you look good this morning, Matt. Thanks for joining us.
- 3:15Obviously you're on your way- Good morning... from somewhere to somewhere. Um, but hey, it works today. Thank you. Yes, yes. Dropping kids off at school, off to the office. That's what we're doing today.
- 3:24It's the automotive story right there. Well, let me read the story- There you go... and why we have you here, then we'll get into it.
- 3:28According to Experian, dealerships are finding it harder to secure subprime auto loans due to a decline in subprime customers being able to get loans and leases as factors like inflation, rising gas prices, ending stimulus funds have affected their credit worthiness and increased debt to income ratio, uh, ratios, which may be turning to, and meaning they'll often turn to credit cards for n- financial support.
- 3:51Uh, the proportion of subprime used vehicle loans has reached near record lows with such borrowers only involved now in 14% of all loans and leases on new and used vehicles in Q1.
- 4:01Um, also there's an increase in late auto payments among subprime borrowers, higher than during the late 2000s recession, so we're going way back according to S&P Global Mobility analysis- Sure... of TransUnion data.
- 4:13And here's a quote, and then we're gonna get to Matt. Um, Michael Oventhaw, COO for Automotive Credit Corporation, said, "What we're seeing now are some of the lowest FICO scores we've seen in years.
- 4:22Consumers who might have qualified for loans in the past are not even close," uh, as he says. So Matt, you obviously are on the ground- Wow...
- 4:30uh, very involved in the subprime market with your product Streamline and, and the, you know, the, the vast operations of West Herr. What's your like boots on the ground take on all this?
- 4:39Well, first I think you gotta take that human approach. I mean, the reality is 40% of consumers have a credit score of 680 or less. Credit scores or FICO scores haven't dramatically shifted.
- 4:49They, they trended upwards slightly during COVID, but they haven't dramatically shifted over the historical averages. The scary part, and you alluded to it, perhaps is the credit card utilization is rising- Mm...
- 5:00amongst sort of what I'll call the have-nots bucket, um, versus the haves bucket. The haves bucket, continuing to spend, everything's good, life is great. But the have-nots bucket, life has gotten really expensive.
- 5:12Things have gotten more challenging. The fees are coming back. The interest rates are higher. Cost of living is just harder.
- 5:19So I think those buyers are being squeezed at like a real, you know, personal level, um, which is presenting some challenges. But also in the auto space, all we've done really is we're sort of reverting back to the mean.
- 5:31Two years ago there wasn't a problem with getting anybody approved because of inflated book values- Mm...
- 5:37because of false equity in their trade-ins, because of artificially high cash down because of government subsidies and other things. Mm.
- 5:45As all of that stuff sort of resert, r- reverts back, dealers now are finding it more difficult to get a loan approved, right? But this is all about understanding the lender. The lender is trying to mitigate risk, right?
- 5:57Risk. Now, what that means is sort of subprime-... borrowing, right?
- 6:02Um, however, I think the lenders perhaps, if I could just broadly say, ha- have, have overreacted slightly because there's so much uncertainty about the future. People aren't- Right...
- 6:12sure what the health of the economy b- will be in six months.
- 6:15So these lenders and the leaders at the lender, at the banks, have to think of, like, "Okay, if the economy collapses in six months, what happens to my auto loan portfo- portfolio?"
- 6:25So, uh, but, but all lenders have moved off FICO anyways, and it's now an internal scoring mechanism. So the best lenders are the ones that understand the stories. It's not about the absolute FICO score.
- 6:35It's about where you are in your life. So if you just got laid off at your job but you just got a new one, that's okay. If you just went bankrupt but you're going through that process, that might be okay.
- 6:45If you just went through a divorce but are working your way out of it, that's okay, right? And so I think a lot of lenders are adapting to that.
- 6:51And dealers can best su- serve the customer by understanding the risk issue at the lender level, right? Right. And finding cars that mitigate the risk for the customer and managing affordability. Yeah.
- 7:03It's, it's interesting because, like, the, the dealer is kind of, uh, right now playing a, a big part in the storyline and being the middle man to care for the consumer and the lender at the same time because they have a responsible th- or responsibility both to the consumer to find the car that meets the needs, the budget, and, and the financial responsibility that also matches portfolio management that they're responsible for on the lender side, and understanding how to manage risk for the lender when selecting the vehicle for the consumer.
- 7:36And this is where, like, actually this is where dealers are so important. Like, we talk about dealers and, and their importance in the community, but actually... and, and, like, after sales, but after...
- 7:48I- actually in the sales pipeline here, this is actually a piece where dealers can play a part to, like, really be one-to-one with people and, and, like, know, "Okay, great. Here's the, here's the financial risk.
- 8:01Here's the, here's the current economy. Here's where the consumer is actually needing to be met at, and how do we make all of those come together so that we can serve that ar- that area of the community?"
- 8:12'Cause that area, uh, of the community still needs transportation. So I love how you pin that. It's like,
- 8:18"Hey, look, as the dealer, you can look at both sides and, and, and clearly see it and serve both sides well even in this, like, tight economy, um, that's being pointed to." Mm-hmm. Uh-oh. We lost Matt. Uh-oh.
- 8:31Did you just drink your Grimace milkshake? No, no. We're good. Oh. I just dropped my phone. We're good. Oh. [laughs] Wow. He's holding his phone really steady.
- 8:37Matt, um, so I think there's a couple cool things going on here from your perspective.
- 8:42Obviously, West Herr, one of the dealership groups that, um, basically built a software product to solve a problem that they were having. This specific problem is one that you all have built a product for.
- 8:54It's not a sponsored post, but Streamline is the name of the product. And, um, you've really focused in on this area. Um, can you just tell us why you built the product the way you did? Like, what it actually does?
- 9:05'Cause it solves a pretty simple, a s- it's like a, it's like a very linear, simple solution for this product. I mean, for this problem. You have to, you have to be able to communicate the why to affordability.
- 9:19So if you can transparently explain to consumers, "These are the cars that you can afford and get approved on," in a way that's transparent, easy to understand on bo- by both sides, inexperienced sales people [laughs]- Right...
- 9:31customers as well, right? If you can communicate the why in a way that makes sense to both sides, you can find a solution, right? Nobody... Consumers do not understand that the $10,000 used car is now $20,000.
- 9:47They don't understand that interest rates have gone from 3% to 9%. They don't understand that they had, thought they had equity and no longer do.
- 9:56Dealers' jobs in building relationships, we can communicate the art of the deal. We can build a relationship that's beneficial to the customer, help them get into a, making a good financial decision.
- 10:08That what an opportunity, what a gift for the dealerships to be able to service our customers in a way that's beneficial to them. Also beneficial to you 'cause you get to make a deal, right?
- 10:18Uh, but yeah, Streamline was just about finding cars that customers can afford and get approved on. That's it. We built it in '16, and so we've been doing this way before the pandemic. Yeah.
- 10:27And ultimately, this problem- Great... is coming back. And I think that you, you nailed something that, you know, we've been alluding to for the last, you know, for the last week or two.
- 10:35But yesterday, I think it was, Kyle, we talked about the, the coming... Yeah, it was the, the Cox Automotive report where Jonathan Smoke was like, "Hey," like, "Used cars are about to depreciate."
- 10:45Like, you're about to see that depreciation a lot, which means there are a lot more consumers that probably looked or checked or got a vehicle price a few months ago. And when- Yep...
- 10:55they think that they have that level of equity in their vehicle a few month from now, it's gonna be a substantially different picture, which is even gonna complicate, um, the issue, it seems.
- 11:03Matt, as always, great to have you. Thanks, uh, for bringing some of your, uh, insight- Love it... and energy to everybody. Thank you, guys. Happy to be here. Thank you so much. We'll talk to you soon.
- 11:15All right, we're gonna go to the next story. Toyota's global sales saw a significant increase in May as both parts and supply shortages seem to be letting up. I mean, this is a pretty simple, uh, simple story.
- 11:25Basically, the company reported a 10% bump in global sales increase in May year over year, selling a total of about 838,000 vehicles, attributing that increase to saying, like, "Hey, we ha- our supplies, our parts, our things are, like, easing up."
- 11:38In Japan, their sales went up 35%. Um, and here's, like, an interesting- Holy cow... point too, is that almost a third of all vehicles sold were hybrids. Really? Yep. Almost a third. Wow. I mean, like, I, I actually...
- 11:51You know, it's interesting 'cause they don't, like, promote it like crazy- No, they don't... at least from, from what I see.
- 11:56'Cause I watch, like, I see To- Toyota commercials a lot and, like, Toyota ads just because, like, they're hitting, they're hitting me because I'm always in the automotive ecosystem, whether I'm in market or not. Yep.
- 12:07And, like, you just don't see it as, like, this massive narrative, like, "We're hybrid," but it's just, it's just they just do it. Right. Because it's not, it's not like... It's weird.
- 12:16Like, the hybrid component is not in style or out of style.Right? Yep. It's like a basic pair of jeans, [laughs] right? Yes.
- 12:23And, and the, the, the reality is everyone's, like, the sex appeal of an EV is getting all the press, when Toyota's, like, literally a third of their vehicles are hybrids, and you look at the carbon offset that that's actually producing- Psh.
- 12:34Right... and it is, like, more than all the EV companies combined.
- 12:38[laughs] Yo, we just went, I, okay, I'm, I'm, I'm, like, more a Toyota fan than I ever have been, 'cause I've now had a van, a Toyota Sienna for six months. Hybrid probably. Which is a hybrid. Yep. Track with me.
- 12:51On our trip to see family, on highways, we got 35.4 miles to the gallon in a van. Big old van. Big old van. That had some power to it, right? We're not talking a little four-cylinder either. No, that thing runs.
- 13:05Like, this sucker goes. [laughs] That thing runs, no doubt. Yeah. You can, you can get up to speed and n- and not realize it real quick, so it's- Yeah, I mean-... it's pretty wild...
- 13:13they, so basically, the hybrids accounted for 261,000 vehicles. They did say they did sell about 10,000 straight EVs, so I mean- Yep...
- 13:21substantially fewer, but I mean, this is just one of those things where you wonder if the tail's wagging the dog in a lot of the conversation.
- 13:26In typical Toyota, they're just doing things differently, and they're just being very consistent and marching forward, and historically, they tend to be right. Speaking of doing things differently. Stop. Segway.
- 13:37It's time. [upbeat music] All right, we got some more air travel coming up. Yeah, I thought it was awesome. [laughs] Two in a row. Here we go.
- 13:46So California-based Joby Aviation has received approval from the FAA to begin flight testing its electric air taxi prototype, moving closer to commercial operations. Excited about these. Targeted for, track this, 2025.
- 14:00Uh- I love it... the business model is akin to, like, a ride-share app. Basically, uh, it's gonna, uh, try and compete in a growing market of electric vertical takeoff and landing aircraft manufacturers.
- 14:11Uh, the CEO of Toyota North America, t- uh, uh, Testo- Tetsuo Oyama- Good job... that, I'm gonna m- that, yeah. It's all right. Oyama. We'll, we'll give it to you. [laughs] Uh, will, will join Joby Aviation's board.
- 14:23Uh, Toyota's the company's largest external shareholder- How about that?... with an investment of around $400 million. So look, [laughs] Toyota's still not messing around, y'all. Which one you betting on? [laughs] Joby.
- 14:34Man, I'm... [laughs] Joby or, yeah, the- [laughs] What, what was it called yesterday that we went through? But, um- Uh, that was a little different... yeah, so they, so again, set to go in 2025.
- 14:44Um, they, uh, Joby will also deliver, uh, its first aircraft in March of 2024, uh, un- with the US Air Force under a $131 million contract. Ah, military contracts. Um, so track, track with this. This is crazy.
- 14:59After that news, this is a big jump. [laughs] Shares jumped 26%. I wish I was paying attention to this news. It's too late now. Man. But look, Toyota obviously understands manufacturing and transportation.
- 15:13Um, these ve- I'm so excited about these. Like, I would get in one of these. Yes. Yeah, because- If it's, if Toyota's got a hand in it, too, that helps me with the, the trust factor. Well, and it's commercial ops.
- 15:22It's like, it's like ride share. Yeah. So you can, uh, like yesterday we were saying, "Oh, would I drive it? Would I be a part of it?" Right. "What's the pilot's license?" Yeah.
- 15:28This is like a pilot-operated vehicle that's a, like a ride share app. So, uh, I, I, I agree. So if you're flying to Atlanta or Chicago or LA, right, these ve- I can't, I feel like- All day...
- 15:39we're gonna be kind of early adopters of this, this type of transportation, because- Yeah, because, like, 15 to 20 minutes to any location as opposed to an hour to an hour and a half in traffic in some of these major cities, all day.
- 15:51Done. Yep. Let's go. Yep, yep, yep. Oh, well, that's, uh, we had a guest, so a little bit longer of a show. Thanks for being with us today.
- 15:58Been getting a lot of comments about people seeing more than cars out there in the wild. If you haven't seen it yet, go to morethancars.tv and see what's going on over here in this little corner of the world.
- 16:07[upbeat music]