Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / Smilin' Through (1932)
Transcript
- 0:13Hello everyone and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:20I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And today we're smiling from
- 0:23ear to ear because we can't wait to talk about
- 0:27this movie. And also because this is the first
- 0:29movie of this sixth Academy year that we're going
- 0:33to cover. I completely forgot about it, but here
- 0:35we are. This is not the first year, but it is
- 0:38the second year, hopefully I'm getting this right,
- 0:40that you have not seen. These movies. At least
- 0:44in totality. You've seen some of them. I have
- 0:47not seen any of these movies. Yes. That is correct.
- 0:51I've not seen a single one of these movies. I
- 0:52thought you'd seen Fugitive. From a chain gang?
- 0:54Yeah. No. Never. Not the Harrison Ford movie.
- 0:57I didn't kill my wife. I don't care. I don't
- 1:01care. Yes. Okay. So you've not seen any of these
- 1:04movies. Not at all. Neither have I. So, second
- 1:08year in a row we're doing this. My favorite kind
- 1:10of year, honestly. Very fun. It's so exciting.
- 1:13No expectations. And if you tuned in for all
- 1:16of the last Academy year, it was the same there.
- 1:18And we were so pleasantly surprised with just
- 1:21the quality of every movie we covered. Yeah.
- 1:23And I'm excited to see if we have another just
- 1:26all -star year. Yeah. And, you know, maybe we
- 1:29loved all these movies, too. And we'll get right
- 1:33into that right after this. If we had an ad or
- 1:36something. Oh, I was like, are we plugging? No,
- 1:38we don't have an ad. I was like, uh. No. And
- 1:40I also love that you're cutting the sound or
- 1:42the silence. So it's just going to sound like
- 1:44immediately. You're like, do we have one? Yeah.
- 1:46Do we have one? No, we don't. Today's episode
- 1:48is brought to you by Crest. Because we're smiling
- 1:52through. Wow. What a 1932 advertisement. Yeah.
- 1:55I think Colgate was around first. Toothpaste.
- 1:59Have you heard of toothpaste? It's changing lives.
- 2:02We're talking about Smiling Through. This is
- 2:04our first movie of the six Academy Award year.
- 2:07It came out in 1932. I actually have the date
- 2:11here. Let me see if I can pull it up in like
- 2:14five seconds. I can. The date it was released?
- 2:17Correct. This was September 24th, 1932 is when
- 2:20this was released in the theaters. Nice. Smiling
- 2:22Through does have, you're not going to believe
- 2:25this, everyone, one nomination. We're back. We're
- 2:28back. We're getting right back into it. The last
- 2:31movie that we covered here was Grand Hotel, and
- 2:34that was another example of a film that was nominated
- 2:37for Best Picture and only Best Picture, in this
- 2:39case, Outstanding Production. Right. On behalf
- 2:42of also MGM. Correct. And we mentioned this as
- 2:45well. Grand Hotel did win. And we said that was
- 2:48the only film ever to be nominated for one Academy
- 2:52Award and taking it home. So it's kind of a spoiler
- 2:55when we'll see that now. Yeah. That you know,
- 2:57oh, well, clearly that didn't win. Right. So
- 3:00sorry about that. But also. You probably have
- 3:03an idea. You can look up. You have the internet.
- 3:05Yeah, you're looking at it. But hopefully you're
- 3:06waiting with us to find out in real time, which
- 3:08we also know, but we're not telling. Kyle, do
- 3:10you want to walk through the cast? Sure. I will
- 3:12say this was directed by Sidney Franklin, and
- 3:15this stars... Yeah, are you familiar with this
- 3:19person? Yeah, I've heard of her. This stars Norma
- 3:23Shearer. Frederick March. And Leslie Howard.
- 3:28Oh, I should say who they are. Norma Shearer
- 3:30as Kathleen or Moonyeen. Frederick March as Kenneth
- 3:34Wayne or Jeremy. Right? Jeremy? Okay. Because
- 3:38they call him Jerry as well. Yeah. I think Ken
- 3:41for Kenneth and Jerry for Jeremy. It's too many
- 3:43names. I agree. Too many names. Too many people.
- 3:45And Leslie Howard as Sir John Carteret. I like
- 3:49to just go with like who's top billing. Yes.
- 3:52And then if there's anybody that like Boris Karloff.
- 3:55If he shows up, that's when I'm like, yes, and
- 3:57also. But those are the three headliners there.
- 4:01For sure. There's a couple other people, but
- 4:03to be honest, this movie is about five people
- 4:05total. There's some background actors, but otherwise
- 4:07there's like five characters who have names.
- 4:09I don't think there's enough background actors.
- 4:12There's not. I think you're right. Honestly,
- 4:13I'll talk about how that affected my opinion
- 4:15of the movie a little bit. We'll get there, too.
- 4:18So this was based on a play that was written
- 4:20by Jane Cowell and Jane Murfin. The Janes are
- 4:23just writing plays. Yeah. That's the proof there.
- 4:25And then the movie adaptation of that play was
- 4:29written by Ernest Vajda and Claudine West. So
- 4:33the plot of Smiling Through, we are introduced
- 4:37very early on to Sir John Carteret. Yes. And
- 4:41how he is mourning the loss of his wife seemingly
- 4:43from years ago. And her name is Moon Ying Claire.
- 4:47I want to go ahead and stop. Moon Ying. Okay.
- 4:51How'd this name, because the first time that
- 4:54we see or hear this name is on a tombstone. Right.
- 4:56On the very beginning of the movie. So how did
- 4:59this? uh, name catch you. So right away, uh,
- 5:02I, I watched about half of this with Ziggy and
- 5:04we were both like, well, that's an interesting
- 5:06name. Right. Where did that come from? And when
- 5:09I read the synopsis for the movie, I was like,
- 5:10maybe this involves like someone like an international
- 5:15individual or like a native American or something.
- 5:18I was like, what is this? And then I saw that
- 5:20it was Norma Shearer and I was like, what? You're
- 5:22like, well, who cares? And we looked it up and
- 5:24this, uh, this name was made. semi -popular from
- 5:28this play in this movie like it's an original
- 5:31name not a ton of um historical accuracy in the
- 5:34name just more the name came from the play they
- 5:36created it yeah copy uh there's there's some
- 5:39like oh maybe it was irish and it derives from
- 5:41the the term little moon or something like that
- 5:44but it really is like it exists in this and that's
- 5:47about it not a ton of context then so you know
- 5:49i'm sure we'll find it but yeah that i saw that
- 5:51name and i was like what Yeah. Who's that? What's
- 5:54a Moon Yin? And then, yeah, it ends up being
- 5:56his wife who was passed many years prior. Yes.
- 5:59And he is dealing with this. He is then presented
- 6:03with the idea that, or the truth, that his late
- 6:07wife, Moon Yin, her sibling had a child. And
- 6:11both, I believe it's her sister? Yeah, her sister
- 6:15has a child. Her sister and her husband have
- 6:16died. Yeah. And now this five -year -old needs
- 6:19somewhere to go. And John's like... That's not
- 6:22my problem. Yeah. That's not something I can
- 6:23do. And then the five -year -old walks in and
- 6:26was like, just gives him mouth. It's just like,
- 6:28hey, I don't think I like you very much. You
- 6:30seem mean. You seem mean. You want to look after
- 6:32me for the next 13 years? I think they both rage
- 6:36bait each other into being guardians. He's a
- 6:39guardian. I thought that was very funny. She's
- 6:43also just very excited to be like, here's my
- 6:45dress. And then check out the panties underneath.
- 6:47He's like, all right, look, we're cool. Just
- 6:48take it easy. Let's celebrate a birthday here.
- 6:51Can I speak on her? Please. So Cora Sue Collins
- 6:54is playing the young Kathleen, who eventually
- 6:58becomes Norma Shearer. But she was a child actress
- 7:01who starred in 47 films. She was born in 1927,
- 7:05passed away. april 27th 2025 oh wow last year
- 7:1198 she was one of the last living uh actresses
- 7:15from like the the 1920s 1930s wow crazy right
- 7:21that's not she's very cute in this movie she's
- 7:23very cute she only has like maybe three minutes
- 7:25of screen time it's even not a lot but very effective
- 7:28um and it's very funny how she just again rage
- 7:32baits this guy Like they both make each other
- 7:35so mad that you're like, ah, these two are going
- 7:37to get along. It's very good. So he decides to
- 7:38adopt. Her name is Kathleen. Decides to adopt
- 7:42Kathleen. And we jump forward in time to where
- 7:45Owen, I kind of want to clear this with you first,
- 7:48that Owen just kind of lives with John. Or at
- 7:53least Owen's there all the time. Yeah. And well,
- 7:56they are all wealthy people. Right. So I guess
- 7:59he's just got this big old place. So he's like,
- 8:01why don't you just stay with me, dog? Hang out
- 8:03with me. But that's not even true. Because then
- 8:04later on, someone goes to Owen's house and is
- 8:07like, hey, you got to go and see John. And then
- 8:09he ends up going. Unless it was on the complete
- 8:12other side of the property and he has to drive
- 8:14over. It's the in -law suite. The in -law suite,
- 8:16of course. So Owen, John, and Kathleen are now
- 8:19celebrating her, is it 18th birthday? I think
- 8:22so. It's her birthday. And we've jumped forward
- 8:24in time like 13, 15 years or so. And we then
- 8:28see her. striking up a conversation with a potential
- 8:33suitor named Willie that she's not very interested
- 8:35in, but more just passing the time. I love Willie.
- 8:38I liked Willie fine. I want to talk about this
- 8:41scene where they're outside. In the rain. In
- 8:44the rain. Yeah. They're underneath a tree, and
- 8:47it's raining, and you can start to hear thunder,
- 8:50and then all of a sudden it cuts, and there's
- 8:52a crack of lightning that hits a tree and splits
- 8:56it in half. And then the other half of the tree
- 8:58falls burning onto the ground. The way that this
- 9:02is cut, I was like, oh, so they died. They're
- 9:05standing underneath a tree. And then the camera
- 9:08just immediately cuts to a wide shot of a tree
- 9:10getting split in half with lightning. Right.
- 9:12And then it cuts back to them. They're like,
- 9:14we got to get out of here in front of the same
- 9:16tree. And I was like, uh, what? So I don't know.
- 9:19They didn't die. There's a lot of people playing
- 9:21multiple characters in this. And I think the
- 9:23same can be said about the trees. Those poor
- 9:27Ents. So I'll go ahead and stop here real quick.
- 9:31This movie kind of from this point has a little
- 9:33bit of a gothic feel. I would say from the opening
- 9:35scene, we open on the cemetery where Mu Yin's
- 9:39grave exists. And we even go as far as having
- 9:44a ghost. In this movie. Yes. And one of the opening
- 9:48shots is John speaking to Moon Ying and hoping
- 9:52for a response beyond the grave. And she appears
- 9:55in like a ghastly form. I love this because they
- 9:59do that old technique of kind of filming her
- 10:01in that spot, but then superimposing that afterwards.
- 10:04Yeah. So she's kind of translucent. Exactly.
- 10:06It's spooky. It is. And I love the fact that
- 10:09he's not really looking directly at her. He's
- 10:12just kind of, like, speaking in that general
- 10:13direction, and she tends to be there. That kind
- 10:16of lends itself to more of the ghastly appearance.
- 10:19Yeah. And this seemed very gothic to me. 100%.
- 10:23And then you have that tree scene with, like,
- 10:25the lightning. Like, that's a—again, I'd kind
- 10:27of like to talk about how they did this. It's
- 10:29a big -budget thing. Yeah. They actually hired
- 10:32lightning to come out and split a tree in half.
- 10:34Well, it's just like how they used to do the
- 10:36old Twister show at Universal Studios. True.
- 10:38Tree gets split in half by lightning there. Yeah,
- 10:41but then they put fire on it. So, again, just
- 10:43a very cool effect. Very cool. Very happy to
- 10:45see it. And then they retreat, Willie and Kathleen,
- 10:48to the nearest mansion that they can find, which
- 10:50belongs to the Waynes, Wayne Manor, if you will.
- 10:53Oh, my goodness. I know. And they find a way
- 10:56to sneak in, and it turns out that a place where
- 10:59they think no one has lived for many, many years
- 11:01actually has someone living there. And it happens
- 11:05to be a gentleman named Kenneth Wayne. Yeah.
- 11:07I had some questions at first because they're
- 11:09like, yeah, no one's been here for like 10 to
- 11:1115 years. And I was like, there's a fire. Right.
- 11:13There's a fire in the fireplace right now. Like,
- 11:15what do you mean no one's been here for 10 to
- 11:1715 years? Well, that's what's really fun. I think
- 11:18that Norma Shearer's character here gets some
- 11:22really fun dialogue. And she's painted as this
- 11:25very, like, inquisitive, adventurous person.
- 11:29Because she's the one that's like, let's go inside
- 11:30this spooky house. Yeah, it's exciting. And Willie.
- 11:33is just like i don't know zoinks and it's he's
- 11:37so funny to me this whole time because she's
- 11:40she's kind of sherlock holmesing the place looking
- 11:43around and she's finding letters and she's like
- 11:45i don't know normally when someone leaves a house
- 11:48they're not flipping chairs and leaving papers
- 11:51on the floor for wedding invitations what really
- 11:54happened here and he's like I don't know. Has
- 11:57it stopped raining yet? Can we go home? It's
- 11:59very funny. Not only does she notice the paper,
- 12:02but she clocks that it is a wedding invitation
- 12:04to her aunt, her late aunt. Yeah. And their wedding.
- 12:08And to John as well. And she starts then painting.
- 12:14painting the picture of, Oh, I know what happened.
- 12:17The guy who lived here, whose name was Jeremy
- 12:19Wayne, he must've saw this invite. And of course
- 12:22he was so in love with my aunt that he ended
- 12:24up taking his own life. And that's why this place
- 12:27has been uninhabited. It makes total sense. And
- 12:30then in comes in Kenneth, Ken Wayne. And he says,
- 12:34you know, my dad used to live here and now I
- 12:37live here as well. And I've just gone back into
- 12:40town. He works in the military, correct? He was
- 12:44an American who came overseas specifically to
- 12:47join up. Copy. He's like, if there's a war, I'm
- 12:50fighting in it. Right. And she's like, go on.
- 12:53You and I should talk. I like a man in uniform.
- 12:55She essentially pushes Willie out a window. She
- 12:58does. When this happens, she's like, you can
- 13:00leave. That's fine. They drink wine from... 1847.
- 13:0647. That's what it was. Really fun scene after
- 13:08this where she's having dinner with Owen and
- 13:10John. And they're like, yeah, this 1917 drink
- 13:14is pretty good, huh? She's like, no, 47. Yeah.
- 13:18But it's fine. And they're like, where were you
- 13:19drinking a 47? What do you know of 47? And she's
- 13:22like, how do you know? Just over at the Wayne
- 13:25Manor. Yeah. And of course, it's when she mentions
- 13:29Jeremy Wayne or the Waynes in general that John.
- 13:33Just feels like he's seen it. He looks like he's
- 13:35seen a ghost. Yes. And he's like, well, that's
- 13:37not possible. He's dead. Like, how could this
- 13:40be? And he starts like this kind of unravels
- 13:43a mystery for him. Clearly, there's a relationship
- 13:46now building towards Kathleen or between Kathleen
- 13:49and Ken. And John doesn't like this. And we're
- 13:52kind of wondering what this is. Yeah. This is
- 13:54where I want to go ahead and stop and say, if
- 13:57you haven't seen this movie and you're interested
- 13:59in what we've described so far. I suggest you
- 14:01go and do that. I agree. I think this movie is
- 14:04one of the first movies that not only relies
- 14:08heavily on kind of a plot twist, but it's a pretty
- 14:11good one. I think it is a good one. And here's
- 14:13the problem. I suggest you don't read anything
- 14:16about this. Yeah. Don't go on IMDb. Don't look
- 14:20at Wikipedia. Don't look at the description.
- 14:21I'll get into it in a few minutes here. But the
- 14:23description... And this is a problem. In the
- 14:271930s, there was an issue I'm starting to see
- 14:30where the synopsis is like what happens at the
- 14:34end of the movie. Yeah. And I don't know if that's
- 14:37a modern thing or if like you open up the paper.
- 14:41in the 30s to see what's playing. And it was
- 14:43that exact thing that's like, and then everybody
- 14:46died. I'll give you a great example. East Lynn.
- 14:48If you go and read the synopsis of East Lynn,
- 14:50they say that the plot is that a mother who has
- 14:54recently lost her sight. goes to visit her son
- 14:57before he dies. Yes. And that is the last 10
- 15:00minutes of that movie. Right. The last 10 minutes
- 15:02you can't see now. Right. So what are we doing
- 15:05where that's happening? This is a similar situation.
- 15:08It's not the last 10 minutes, but it's about
- 15:1030, 35, 40 minutes in. And it is a very large
- 15:13part of it. So again, we are going to spoil this
- 15:15aspect of the movie. Right. So if you want to
- 15:17watch this on your own, I suggest you go and
- 15:19do that now. Now, with that said. What we find
- 15:22is that Kathleen goes outside to John to try
- 15:25and comfort him and ask him, well, what exactly
- 15:27is your problem with him? What happened? And
- 15:29he then describes what happened at our wedding,
- 15:32the day before our wedding. Best scene in the
- 15:34movie. I thought this was... So what happens
- 15:37is they're sitting outside of their mansion.
- 15:39Yeah. And he describes what happened the day
- 15:41before our wedding. And the camera pans to the
- 15:44right. And it cuts into the swamp. And without
- 15:48the camera breaking... All of a sudden now there's
- 15:50a cast of characters that have appeared in that
- 15:53port on the other side of the lake or river or
- 15:55whatever it might be. And they are portraying
- 15:57the day before their wedding. And this is just
- 16:00different characters. And it's happening behind
- 16:03them in real time. I thought this was remarkable.
- 16:06It's so cool. I loved this shot. I loved the
- 16:08way it moved. I loved how this led to the party.
- 16:11And then the camera cuts. And then, of course,
- 16:13we see John back without his makeup and everything
- 16:16because it's back then. Yeah. 30 years, I think,
- 16:18is what I read. In the distance between their
- 16:21wedding. Yeah, yeah, something like that. And
- 16:23where we are now. So, about 30 years of a difference.
- 16:27And I kind of want to take the time to point
- 16:29out that what happened here was that Lee Garns
- 16:34was the cinematographer for this movie. Gotcha.
- 16:37If you don't remember the name, Lee Garns was
- 16:40the cinematographer for Shanghai Express. And
- 16:42won the award for cinematography for Shanghai
- 16:46Express. He left during production and Charles
- 16:49G. Clark took over, but Garns didn't get a screen
- 16:53credit. This is me wishcasting, okay? I have
- 16:56no proof behind this. This feels like a Lee Garn
- 16:59shot. This shot that we're talking about of panning
- 17:01to the right feels like a Lee Garn shot because
- 17:04nothing like that happens again for the rest
- 17:06of the movie. Sure, yeah. It's kind of like when
- 17:09we talked about Grand Hotel and there's a couple
- 17:12of shots where you're like, wow, this is incredible.
- 17:14but it doesn't happen afterwards. Yeah. That
- 17:15it just feels like, and this is true for Grand
- 17:18Hotel as well in terms of how it feels, it felt
- 17:20like a different vision than what happened in
- 17:23the rest. Yeah. And it makes a bit of sense with
- 17:24the behind the scenes here with cinematographers.
- 17:27I think that's a big detractor for a lot of these
- 17:29movies is I see things like Shanghai Express
- 17:32that really carry these really unique camera
- 17:34choices. Couldn't use that word in the right
- 17:37context, but... You see them throughout the entire
- 17:40movie, and you can tell that, like, before they
- 17:42started filming, they sat down with a complete
- 17:46storyboard and were like, this is a shot I want,
- 17:48this is a shot I want. And with a lot of these
- 17:50other movies, Grand Hotel, with this movie specifically,
- 17:53it feels like they storyboarded a specific shot,
- 17:56and they were like, this is going to be such
- 17:58a good moment. And that's it. Like, I don't know.
- 18:02It almost feels like their storyboard time was
- 18:03very limited, and they had to just skip over
- 18:05that and be like, all right, and we'll shoot
- 18:06the rest like a stage play. Right. It's also
- 18:09interesting to say, you know, we recorded our
- 18:12Grand Hotel episode not too long ago. So this
- 18:14is why it's fresh in our minds. But also, it's
- 18:17interesting that both of these moments in both
- 18:19Grand Hotel and Smiling Through take place within
- 18:22like the 30 minute mark in the movie. Because
- 18:24then you're like, wow, this is so captivating.
- 18:27I can't wait to see what happens after this.
- 18:29And you're almost a bit disappointed that nothing
- 18:31like that happens again. Yeah. And it just feels
- 18:34kind of not flat, but it's not nearly as interesting
- 18:37as that one sequence. And I wonder how much of
- 18:39that is, as an audience member, like they're
- 18:42trying to hook you at the beginning. Because
- 18:44I don't know about you, but when I start a movie
- 18:46and I'm being introduced to characters, unless
- 18:48it's done in like a unique way, I'm kind of like,
- 18:50okay, and there's that person and there's that
- 18:52person. And I feel like I'm just kind of going
- 18:55through the motion. But when they do things like
- 18:57this with these unique camera transitions and
- 18:59things, it keeps me engaged visually as well.
- 19:03Then when you get to the point where the characters
- 19:05and the narrative have to kind of carry it, they
- 19:07remove those hooks, those visual hooks a little
- 19:10bit. And I always wonder if that's a choice.
- 19:14Maybe, but to me it feels like, well, that was
- 19:16such an easy thing for you. Not easy, but it
- 19:18was so... possible for you to do this that i
- 19:21i wonder why you can't do things like that afterwards
- 19:24yeah it's not that every movie should have one
- 19:25shot like that it's i'm interested in your cinematography
- 19:28after that it just wasn't the same so i don't
- 19:30mean to disrespect uh charles g clark like that
- 19:33and say well you weren't the one who did this
- 19:35incredible shot it was lee yarns but i'm saying
- 19:37that it feels indicative of what was possible
- 19:40in shanghai express yeah and it's interesting
- 19:43to note that nothing like that happened afterwards
- 19:45But we'll leave that alone. You know, it could
- 19:46be related to the director as well, Sidney Franklin.
- 19:49Because we did say that Lee Garns worked very
- 19:51closely with Joseph von Sternberg. Right. It
- 19:54could very well be. And obviously these movies
- 19:56came out not too far apart. So there's chances
- 19:58of, you know, everyone's working on different
- 20:00sets. There's actually some art direction we're
- 20:02going to talk about later. And I looked at the
- 20:04credits for this art director. It's like 20 movies
- 20:08in one year. Really? And then it continues. Oh,
- 20:10yeah. The art director is Cedric Gibbons, is
- 20:13it not? I believe so. Yeah. That's Cedric Gibbons.
- 20:17Yeah. We just talked about him with the Grand
- 20:18Hotel. He's the one that made the... Case in
- 20:22point, man. Wizard of Oz, Singing in the Rain,
- 20:25Philadelphia Story, Freaks. Look at IMDb. It's
- 20:28not just the titles in which they worked on.
- 20:31It is how many. It's insane. And it is like,
- 20:34if you want to get Carpal Tunnel... scroll through
- 20:36art direction for cedric gibbons according this
- 20:39is a lot according to letterboxd and i know they
- 20:42add like stuff for sure you know shows up in
- 20:45extra material or whatever 842 films what can
- 20:49you imagine saying i worked on 842 films right
- 20:52and that's one of those things where cedric gibbons
- 20:55um you know each studio had their people that
- 20:58work specifically on things you also have douglas
- 21:00shearer who was the the sound designer on this
- 21:02yes so that contributes a lot to that oh of course
- 21:07he has so many movies he's pumping out production
- 21:09design on everything mgm does for sure and uh
- 21:12i'll go ahead and skip to this part uh talking
- 21:15about cedric gibbons i don't know if you know
- 21:17this or if you read about this moon yin's tombstone
- 21:20actually appears in one other movie really yes
- 21:23so obviously it's one of the opening shots of
- 21:25smiling through but cedric gibbons was the art
- 21:28director for david copperfield as well And so
- 21:31that was 1935 in David Copperfield. If you watch,
- 21:34at one point he's next to the grave of his mother,
- 21:36David Copperfield's mother. Yeah. And next to
- 21:38that is Moonene's grave. Really? You can actually
- 21:41see her tombstone. A little Easter egg. It's
- 21:43a nice little Easter egg to see in there. So
- 21:45when we cover David Copperfield later in a couple
- 21:47years, well, a couple months for us. Yeah. Yeah.
- 21:50When we get to David Copperfield, we'll be able
- 21:52to talk a little bit more about that. Very cool.
- 21:54But that's for the art direction. I say all of
- 21:56this to say that this is currently leading to
- 21:58the flashback sequence that serves as kind of
- 22:00the middle third, the second third of this movie.
- 22:03Maybe the second, like two fourths. Either way.
- 22:06The best part. Hands down, I think the best part
- 22:11of this is the flashback that we see. And we
- 22:13won't go through every bit of it, but clearly
- 22:15it shows that there is a little bit of a romance,
- 22:17one -sided even, between... Kenneth's husband,
- 22:22or husband, well, Kenneth's father, Jeremy. Right.
- 22:25And Jeremy was infatuated with Moon Yin. Right.
- 22:29They were like childhood crushes. Correct. And
- 22:31did not think that John was worthy of this honor
- 22:35of marrying her. So he's trying to sweep her
- 22:38away. She's not interested, even though they
- 22:40share a kiss, and he kind of forces a kiss on
- 22:42her. Very ugly. She very quickly is like, let's
- 22:45just forget that happened. Let's go back to the
- 22:46party and everything. This takes up about 25
- 22:50minutes of the movie, which again, I really appreciated
- 22:53this. So definitely watch it. But, and again,
- 22:55we're going to dive right into the spoiler. So
- 22:57heads up if you haven't seen the movie and you're
- 22:59interested in watching this play out in real
- 23:01time, which we fully suggest. It becomes clear
- 23:05that she's not going to leave and she's going
- 23:07to go through with the wedding. And Jeremy then
- 23:10takes it upon himself, clearly drunk as well,
- 23:13to infiltrate the wedding, which he's been invited
- 23:15to. But he like sneaks in specifically through
- 23:18the back door and he then confronts and says,
- 23:22hey, you can't do this. Now, before we get to
- 23:25the very dramatic part of this, I do want to
- 23:27point out something I thought was very funny
- 23:28in that now in weddings, obviously things have
- 23:31changed because back then he says the officiant
- 23:33says something and they all say, I will, I will.
- 23:36Yeah. I do. But there's different verses to it.
- 23:39I thought it was very funny that he comes out
- 23:41and he's like, you're not going to get married.
- 23:43I won't let this wedding happen. And the officiant
- 23:45says what we say now for weddings that he doesn't
- 23:49say then. But he says, you hold your peace. You
- 23:52sit down and hold your peace. Right. And I was
- 23:54like, wait a minute. That's what we do now. Yeah.
- 23:56Did we say that now because of Jeremy Wayne?
- 24:00And we're like, we can't have Jeremy Waynes walking
- 24:01around here. Like, if you have something to say,
- 24:03say it now or forever hold your peace. Yeah.
- 24:04Like, this is your one opportunity. Correct.
- 24:06That's it. Yeah. After this. You can't bust into
- 24:09the room with the spoiler. It almost felt like
- 24:13a fourth wall break a little bit. When the official
- 24:14was like, you hold your peace. And then like
- 24:16a wink at the camera. We're past that point.
- 24:18Yeah. We're beyond that now. But I thought that
- 24:20was funny. So he then says, no, I will ensure
- 24:23this doesn't happen. Pulls out a gun. And he
- 24:26is about to shoot John. Jeremy. No, John. Yes,
- 24:29I'm sorry. So Jeremy's about to shoot John. Yes.
- 24:31And before he can, Moon Yin intervenes and gets
- 24:35in the middle, and she takes the bullet. She's
- 24:37like, Mr. President. Yeah, get down! And she
- 24:41takes the bullet. Yeah. I thought it was interesting.
- 24:44We talked recently about the first instance of
- 24:47where we thought there might be blood in the
- 24:50champ of him punching the wall. Turns out in
- 24:52Wings, there's some blood there, too, of course.
- 24:54Right. But... This, I thought, was one of the
- 24:57most visceral examples of blood yet, because
- 24:59from a gunshot wound, we see, through a white
- 25:02wedding dress, like a bullet. Yeah. And we see,
- 25:05like, the blood pooling. It's very striking,
- 25:08that visual. Yeah. I mean, like, again, in black
- 25:11and white especially, but, like, seeing a white
- 25:12wedding dress and then, like, that. uh wound
- 25:14with blood pooling up i thought was very visual
- 25:17uh very striking like you said uh and then this
- 25:20indicates that moon yin has been killed yeah
- 25:22and she dies very shortly after being um wounded
- 25:25like this and i will say these movies have have
- 25:29a way of like being a little melodramatic with
- 25:32with deaths especially i go back and i think
- 25:35about i think it was alibi as well when uh the
- 25:39the like secret agent kind of guy dies and he
- 25:42has like a 20 minute death scene. Yes. Yeah.
- 25:46It's, it's very similar to that. This is a little
- 25:48like, tell the kids I love them. Right, right.
- 25:50But it's Norma Shearer. So she's fantastic. Of
- 25:53course. One thing we actually haven't talked
- 25:55about yet is you mentioned it kind of at the
- 25:57top, but it's worth mentioning. Oh, right, right.
- 25:59That she, Norma Shearer portrays both Moon Yin
- 26:03and Kathleen. Yeah. So in this flashback, when
- 26:06you go back and you see what really happened.
- 26:08She is playing essentially her aunt as well.
- 26:12And another fun part with this, because there
- 26:14is such a big time jump, Leslie Howard, you get
- 26:18to see him kind of in his youth, but then he's
- 26:21also aged up by like 30, 40 years. Good makeup
- 26:25too. Yeah, it looks great. Because I thought
- 26:26he looked really good in the current years as
- 26:28an older man. Yeah, his performance as well of
- 26:31playing an older individual is fantastic. His
- 26:33movements are all, I mean, you can tell. I think
- 26:36he falls asleep. While he's playing chess at
- 26:38one point. There's like a running gag of him
- 26:39just like falling asleep while he's playing chess
- 26:41with Owen. Yeah. So and then that also goes for
- 26:45Frederick March as well. He portrays Ken Wayne,
- 26:48Kenneth Wayne, but he also plays his father,
- 26:50Jeremy Wayne. Yeah. So he gets like kind of the
- 26:52most interesting thing for me where he gets to
- 26:54play a little bit of the hero and the villain
- 26:56like that aspect. I thought he did really well
- 26:59in this. Which is so interesting as well, because
- 27:01last year he won Best Actor for Dr. Jekyll and
- 27:05Mr. Hyde. clearly he's versed in this yeah what
- 27:08a perfect thing to play like the good and the
- 27:10bad well it's it's he's really really good at
- 27:13it because he plays weasley extremely well but
- 27:16then he plays charming extremely well yeah like
- 27:18just as well thought this was great great performance
- 27:21from him but then this is clearly you know we
- 27:23then cut our flashback and we're back in present
- 27:26times and this is john's hesitation and john
- 27:28says like you you cannot be interested in this
- 27:31guy You can't be with him because he is the son
- 27:34of a murderer. Yeah. And he took my love away
- 27:36from me. And your aunt. And your aunt. Like,
- 27:38how can you love this man? Yeah. And the answer
- 27:41is like very easily because he's so charming
- 27:43and he is not a representation of who his father
- 27:45was. And. this kind of is the rest of the movie
- 27:48is the, will they, won't they, is this going
- 27:50to happen? Will John ever approve? And it's considered
- 27:54like, this isn't like the greatest love story
- 27:56of all time or anything, or even considered that
- 27:58that was something that was held more for a movie
- 28:01that we talked about last year. Shanghai express.
- 28:03It might've been, it definitely was a grand hotel.
- 28:06It was one of them. I've seen something where
- 28:08it was like indicated, like the greatest love
- 28:09story of all time. Um, but. In reality, I think
- 28:13this is considered in a high regard of a great
- 28:16love story. Yeah. Aerosmith? Don't think it was
- 28:20Aerosmith. The greatest plague of all time. Bad
- 28:22girl? It was not bad girl. I may have made that
- 28:26up. We'll see. Perfect. This is something that
- 28:28existed for a long time. This wasn't only for
- 28:31this movie. Obviously, we said this was based
- 28:34on a play. That play appeared in Broadway in
- 28:371919. Right. And then even after this movie,
- 28:40there was actually a 30 -minute radio adaptation
- 28:42that was on the radio, duh, for Smiling Through.
- 28:46In 1939, interesting thing, Norma Shearer came
- 28:49back. to do Kathleen and Moonene as a performance
- 28:53for the radio adaptation. For the radio. Okay.
- 28:55Correct. So even before and after this movie,
- 28:58there was a legacy of this story and this romance
- 29:00specifically between Kathleen and Ken. Yeah.
- 29:03I thought that was really notable. I'm not going
- 29:06to tell you. I thought it was like one of the
- 29:07best love stories, but I think on paper and from
- 29:11the first half of this, I was on board. And I
- 29:15think this was the kind of movie where I was
- 29:17like, oh, yeah, we're cooking. This is great.
- 29:19I love the direction of this. And unfortunately,
- 29:22we tend to see a trend here. The last movie we've
- 29:26talked about was Grand Hotel. And we talked about
- 29:28how this had a very interesting and promising
- 29:30first half and then failed to follow through
- 29:34in the back half. Now, this movie is about maybe
- 29:3790, 95 minutes long. It's not terribly long.
- 29:41But there is something on the back end that doesn't
- 29:44feel as forward projecting as the first half
- 29:47does. Right. Did you feel that way? Totally,
- 29:49totally. After that flashback, I really was starting
- 29:52to lose interest. And I think what happens a
- 29:54lot, I mentioned how much I enjoyed Norma Shearer's
- 29:59character when she's in the haunted house and
- 30:01she's like. deducing what happened in this story
- 30:04and all of that she feels like a real character
- 30:07and a really engaging character and i think a
- 30:10lot of the times for me what happens is once
- 30:12you have these characters start to interact with
- 30:14each other especially when a romance builds they
- 30:17fall into a very like narrow box and and it just
- 30:23becomes a romance you know This guy says the
- 30:26sweetest things ever. She says, oh, thank you,
- 30:29my love, my dear. And that's kind of it. You
- 30:32lose a lot of the very personal traits of these
- 30:36people. And then I'm just like, okay, they love
- 30:39each other. Cool. Yeah, and there's a couple
- 30:42scenes where I think this is really sold, but
- 30:43unfortunately a lot of that falls in the first
- 30:46half of the movie. Even before the flashback
- 30:48sequence, we see where Ken and Kathleen... get
- 30:52breakfast together or lunch yeah and they're
- 30:54eating lunch and it's been three hours since
- 30:57they've eaten lunch and now they're actually
- 30:58well you know what why don't we just go ahead
- 31:00and make dinner you don't serve dinner here how
- 31:02hard can it be why don't you just let us in the
- 31:04kitchen we'll make some dinner that sounds easy
- 31:05and then they end up making dinner for them so
- 31:07they stay even longer so they're finding excuses
- 31:09to be with each other for even longer periods
- 31:12of time and stay in one place i thought that
- 31:14scene of them like talking not talking the chef
- 31:17into that or the waitress but more so like them
- 31:20biting time for themselves yeah so they can spend
- 31:23more time together i thought that was excellent
- 31:24i really like the meet cutes in a lot of these
- 31:27movies and then like the first date where they're
- 31:29kind of like you know oh i i don't have to go
- 31:34home right now like that kind of environment
- 31:36with with the couples it's when they turn into
- 31:39that like super devotion devoted to each other
- 31:42and just we have to do whatever we can to be
- 31:44in love like that's such a boring trope that
- 31:47shows up in almost every movie and it really
- 31:50takes me out of it yeah and i think the problem
- 31:53is that this movie suffers from a back half that
- 31:56is i have one rule and i hope you don't break
- 32:00that rule and she's like well i'm gonna break
- 32:02that rule but i wonder if anything's gonna happen
- 32:05because of it or if it's gonna be i break that
- 32:07rule and then he's like hey you shouldn't have
- 32:09broken that rule and you're like yeah i'm sorry
- 32:10i guess i shouldn't have and then you aren't
- 32:12with him but then the war happens but then you
- 32:15want to be with them, but then you don't, but
- 32:17then you do. And it's a lot of will they, won't
- 32:19they? Yeah. And that, it feels like the last
- 32:22half is like 90 minutes on its own. It does.
- 32:26It's really long. It starts to drag. And it's
- 32:28only like maybe 45 minutes, but it just, it drags
- 32:31so severely. Yeah. And then there's even a romance
- 32:33where she, or a side plot where she kind of gets
- 32:36back with Willie a little bit, but not really.
- 32:39I just did Willie and really not Willie. Um,
- 32:44and she, uh, and then of course she wants to
- 32:46be with, she wants to be with Ken more than anything,
- 32:49but she feels like she can't because she can't
- 32:51get past this with John. Yeah. Uh, uncle, uncle
- 32:53John, really father John at this point. I didn't
- 32:56mean to do that either. Father John. I'm sorry
- 32:58about that. Uh, that was not intentional, but
- 33:00then we'll just jump to the end here. And ultimately
- 33:02what happens is Owen gets on John's, uh, good
- 33:06side here of like, Hey man. What are you doing?
- 33:09Actually, before that, I do want to talk about
- 33:11one scene that I did think kind of broke up the
- 33:13monotony of this a bit. And that's where John
- 33:16has his first meeting with Ken. And Ken is there's
- 33:20I actually like this scene a lot of the I'm going
- 33:24to say maid or like someone who works at the
- 33:27mansion. Oh, she's trying to get Kathleen's attention.
- 33:31Without speaking loud to interrupt Owen and basically
- 33:34not get John's attention. Yes. But to get Kathleen's.
- 33:38And they're doing like a mouthing of words of
- 33:41like, he wants to see you. Like, come see him.
- 33:44And she's like, no, tell him I'm not here. He
- 33:45won't leave. I thought this was very funny. And
- 33:48then, of course, John's like, hey, I could see
- 33:50both of you. What are you doing? Right. Which
- 33:52was great. And she's like, okay, look, he's here.
- 33:55Ken's here. And she's like, okay, well, I'm going
- 33:57to go see him. He's like, you can't. And she's
- 34:00like, can I just bring him in? He's like, fine.
- 34:02So Ken comes in and he has this whole like little
- 34:05speech of like, hey, I hope you can kind of see
- 34:07past everything that happened with my family.
- 34:09Like, please know that's not me. Right. But I
- 34:11have the best intentions with your kind of daughter.
- 34:14And John stands up and then has probably my favorite
- 34:18line in the movie. It just kind of struck me
- 34:19the way he said it, where he says, I understand
- 34:22only one thing about a Wayne. The quality of
- 34:25your breed is not to take its medicine. Which,
- 34:28I gotta be honest, if someone said that to me,
- 34:30I'd be like, that is the most offensive thing
- 34:32that I've ever heard, and I don't know what it
- 34:34means. Right. I can't decipher that right now,
- 34:37but like, how dare you? You don't say things
- 34:39to me I can't understand. How dare. That's how
- 34:43I felt in that moment of like, man, that's a
- 34:44bar. I don't know what it means right now, but
- 34:47that is a bar. I really like that line, and you
- 34:49can tell it kind of cuts deep for Ken, too. But
- 34:52this... Just completely cements the idea of like,
- 34:54I'm never going to be okay with this. Right.
- 34:56And then that cuts to later on when Owen is having
- 34:59this conversation of like, look, man, if you
- 35:02want her to be happy, this is just what you have
- 35:03to do. You have to let this be in the past and
- 35:05you have to look past these things. You got to
- 35:07make peace with us. And ultimately he decides
- 35:09if I want any kind of semblance of a relationship
- 35:11with her, I have to get past this. And he does
- 35:14very quickly kind of turn around and be like,
- 35:17hey, go get him. He's waiting for you. Like,
- 35:19why don't you go get him? But also, one request.
- 35:22Can you bring him here so I can... Meet with
- 35:24him because I'd like to see both of you. Yeah.
- 35:26Meaning not in like a confrontation way, but
- 35:28more like I'd like to be a part of your life.
- 35:30Yeah. With this. And she's thrilled. And she's
- 35:33like, absolutely. And she leaves. And this is
- 35:35when she stops by Owen's house on the way out
- 35:37and be like, hey, you should go over to John.
- 35:39He's got great news. Like, go see him immediately.
- 35:41But the way she says it, she definitely buried
- 35:43the lead because she's like, you got to go see
- 35:45John right now. Bye. Yeah. And leaves. And Owen's
- 35:48like, so he's dead. Great. And he like rushes
- 35:51over. And when he rushes over. I yearn to have
- 35:54this kind of like comfort in being a landowner
- 35:57where I'm just sitting on my back deck at my
- 35:59chess game and someone just runs in and they're
- 36:02just like, I'm here to help. And he's like, oh,
- 36:04hey man, what's up? He's not like, what's the
- 36:06matter? He's like, oh, what's going on, dude?
- 36:08Yeah. He's like, oh, I thought you were like
- 36:09in trouble. He's like, nope, just sitting here.
- 36:12You want to play chess? Cool, let's play chess.
- 36:13Yeah. And then fills him in like, nope, she's
- 36:15going to get Ken. They're going to be together
- 36:17and they're going to come here. Great. Owen's
- 36:19very proud of him. And they play their game.
- 36:21Do you want to take over? From here. So this
- 36:25is hard because I've had started to lose interest
- 36:28at this point. I can tag him where you need me
- 36:30to. Yeah. Really, all it boils down to is like
- 36:33he gives them his blessing and then he dies.
- 36:38He dies. He dies in the trope that we've already
- 36:41said of him falling asleep during his game where
- 36:43Owen's like, ah, wake up, you old so -and -so.
- 36:46You dropped your cigar. But he's dead. And...
- 36:50That's one thing, but it does lead itself to
- 36:53an extended scene where he is now appearing as
- 36:56an apparition the same way that Moon Yin has.
- 36:59And then they share a dance together. Yeah. And
- 37:02they're dancing in the backyard together, and
- 37:04then it cuts. So we don't get to see Kathleen
- 37:06or Ken or anything or them finding out. We're
- 37:08just seeing more their John and Moon Yin's relationship
- 37:12beyond the grave. And, you know, I think back.
- 37:18In watching the movies that we have in the past
- 37:20couple months, I look back to our criticism of
- 37:23East Lynn. And I look back to us being like,
- 37:25well, this is too melodramatic for me. And I
- 37:27hold that opinion. Yeah. However, there are examples
- 37:32of this movie being too melodramatic. I think
- 37:34this ending is a little too, like, this movie
- 37:37can't decide if it's gothic or not. Because parts
- 37:40of it do feel pretty gothic, especially this
- 37:41ending. But I think there are things that break
- 37:43up the melodrama. Sure, yeah. The scene that
- 37:48we talked about of the memory transition to the
- 37:50wedding, I thought that was breathtaking. Yeah.
- 37:54The camera trickery used for the apparition side,
- 37:57I thought that was interesting. Even the lines
- 38:00and the... chemistry between these characters.
- 38:03That whole sequence of the flashback of the wedding,
- 38:05I thought was a really great storytelling too.
- 38:07But then everything after that, it just kind
- 38:09of became like, well, then this happens and then
- 38:12that happens. And isn't this awful? And this
- 38:14is terrible. The biggest offender there is Ken
- 38:17goes off to war and. Two seconds later, he's
- 38:21back getting off the train. And they do this
- 38:24kind of interesting shot where you see just the
- 38:26feet of soldiers getting off. And there's like
- 38:28three people who have had a leg amputated. And
- 38:32you're like, oh, is that Ken? No. Is that Ken?
- 38:35No. Is that Ken? And then a guy gets off the
- 38:37train who's blind. And you're like, is that Ken?
- 38:40No. And Ken finally gets off. He's got crutches.
- 38:44Yeah, he's got crutches, but he still has both
- 38:45his legs. He's fine. He's injured at the time.
- 38:48Yeah, yeah. But it is one of those things where
- 38:51obviously the whole point of his character is
- 38:54he's come over to join the war. So, you know,
- 38:57he needs to come back some way of what makes
- 38:59more sense than an injury. But it does just feel
- 39:02like on this week's episode of Days of Our Lives.
- 39:05Like he went to war, but he's OK. But is he really
- 39:08OK? Yeah. Yeah. The only thing and this is kind
- 39:12of like in like my ears perk up during certain
- 39:14things. But when Ken comes back from the war,
- 39:20he's talking with Owen. And Owen's like, hey,
- 39:22maybe something can happen between you and Kathleen.
- 39:25Who knows? Maybe everything's okay now. And he
- 39:27has another great line that I didn't write down,
- 39:30but I'm paraphrasing. Owen says, well, she's
- 39:33in love with you. She's infatuated with you.
- 39:35No, she's in love with you. And he was like,
- 39:37all right, you're a doctor. Cure her. Cut it
- 39:41out of her. And I thought that was a really cool
- 39:43line of him being like, well, what can you do
- 39:45medically to stop her from being in love? Give
- 39:46her pills. Fix it. Yeah. He was begging him,
- 39:50especially cut it out of her. I thought it was
- 39:53a really interesting line. So there's bits like
- 39:55that that kind of brought me back into it. But
- 39:58for the most part, it just sits in that melodrama.
- 40:01It does. And doesn't do anything to break it
- 40:02up. So it stopped me from really liking it as
- 40:06much as I thought I was enjoying it. Yeah. Again,
- 40:09I... I feel bad because I think we said almost
- 40:12the exact same thing about Grand Hotel. I loved
- 40:14the first half of this. I thought it was mesmerizing.
- 40:17And then it just kind of got a little sleepy
- 40:20for me. Yeah. It's a bummer because I really
- 40:23like Norma Shearer, as we all know. I really
- 40:25like Frederick March. And I think they're a great
- 40:27couple in this together. But it really is kind
- 40:32of like the melodrama. And that's a word that
- 40:34we will continue to use like over and over and
- 40:37over. I have a feeling. But... It just feels
- 40:39too soapy is really what it boils down to. Soapy
- 40:44is the right word. But I don't think that stopped
- 40:45me from enjoying what I enjoyed of this movie.
- 40:48Yeah. It didn't tarnish the entire reputation
- 40:51of it. It was just more, oh, that's a shame that
- 40:54this could have been like a four and a half,
- 40:56like a five star for me in the way I'm enjoying
- 40:57it. And it just did not pan out that way. Yeah.
- 41:00Yeah. And it's really a bummer that it's the
- 41:04romance, too, that I'm kind of like. Okay, yeah,
- 41:07I get it. You guys love each other. Let's move
- 41:08on. Let's get a grip. But I remember when we
- 41:12talked to Kim Luperi about Five Star Final, and
- 41:15she was talking about, like, the lengths of movies.
- 41:18She's like, yeah, Five Star Final was long. And
- 41:20I think that movie is, like, an hour and 40 minutes.
- 41:23Yeah, she was talking, like, how ideally movies
- 41:25are, like, 45 to 50 minutes or, like, 60. Yeah,
- 41:28and at some point she said, like, bring back
- 41:3060 to 70 minute movies. And this is one of those
- 41:33movies where I was like. perfect 70 minute movie
- 41:35yeah that's brilliant she's right yeah so it's
- 41:39i don't know if this was 80 like 80 minutes long
- 41:43perfect yeah this is right where it needs to
- 41:45be and i think the runtime is 98 minutes yeah
- 41:48so it is right around that feels about 20 minutes
- 41:50too long totally totally so that makes it's so
- 41:52weird to say that about like an hour and a half
- 41:55hour to 40 minute movie but i get it Well, I
- 41:58mean, if you think about it, even when we're
- 41:59telling each other stories and stuff, you'll
- 42:01be like, yeah, Ryan told that story about five
- 42:03minutes longer than he should have. It was a
- 42:0415 -minute story. So you're cutting about a third
- 42:07of that out. So it happens with storytelling
- 42:09in general. It doesn't have to just be film.
- 42:12Songs can be like, oh, this thing needs to be
- 42:14two minutes less. Totally. So it happens. And
- 42:17I think sometimes we just get lost. I don't want
- 42:20to say in the sauce, but we just get lost in
- 42:22the storytelling atmosphere. And that's why I
- 42:24wish so much that... the the camera work and
- 42:27the imagery was utilized more throughout the
- 42:29entire film because that does kind of justify
- 42:31the run length it does uh and i think that's
- 42:36what i'm looking for so i'm looking for a justification
- 42:37of why this story is still going yes and the
- 42:39camera work does not give us anything that that
- 42:41justifies no i like the ghosts ghosts are cool
- 42:44when the ghosts show up at the end i'm like oh
- 42:46yeah i'm cool with this yeah that's neat yeah
- 42:47but then again it's just i had a hard time not
- 42:50hearing like haunted mansion sure playing in
- 42:53the background just because like they are twirling
- 42:55around i just heard like the the whole thing
- 42:58but anyways uh one thing i wanted to bring up
- 43:00that i saw in my research was something where
- 43:02it's like well i'll tell the story first it was
- 43:05frederick march and he was telling a story to
- 43:09his cousin so this is a he said she said situation
- 43:11so don't look too far into it it's all about
- 43:14the he said she said what how many other podcasts
- 43:18do you think there are that cover the oscars
- 43:20that are quoting limp biscuit songs Not enough.
- 43:22Not enough. Not enough. And that's why we're
- 43:24here, everyone. Yep. That's why you voted us
- 43:26the number one Limp Bizkit podcast. And if you're
- 43:29wondering what made us think about quoting Limp
- 43:32Bizkit, it's just one of those days. Every day.
- 43:35Those are the two songs I know. So I'm tapped
- 43:38on that. Let's keep this rolling. Oh, three.
- 43:41You're so right. I forgot about that. Anyways,
- 43:43point is, we're a Lumbisco podcast now. He was
- 43:46talking with, uh, Frederick Mark was talking
- 43:48with his cousin and he had said, yeah, you know,
- 43:50it was really great to work alongside Norma Shearer.
- 43:52She's great. But the only problem is that she's
- 43:54really like, she wants the best out of everyone.
- 43:57So she like. would be really upset if someone
- 43:59wasn't giving their best role or wasn't like
- 44:01acting up to her par. Yeah. And he said like
- 44:04specifically her love scenes, like the scenes
- 44:06where like we're supposed to be like in love
- 44:07or like passionate towards each other. Like she
- 44:10really just wasn't happy with my performance
- 44:12in that. Yeah. And her cousin or his cousin was
- 44:14like, isn't that on you? Like that sounds like
- 44:18it's less about her and it's more on you that
- 44:20you weren't like up to the love scenes with her.
- 44:22Yeah. And I got to tell you, I don't know if
- 44:24you ever heard this. meme trend where someone's
- 44:27like batman couldn't have gotten this information
- 44:29out of me yeah yeah this is it for me right where
- 44:32if like norma sheer was like i don't think you're
- 44:34as in love with me as i need you to be right
- 44:36now i need you to be more present for our love
- 44:37scenes i'd be like and that is the grave for
- 44:40me right i will never admit to anyone that i
- 44:42was not enough for norma sheer yeah nobody would
- 44:45ever hear those words so batman couldn't have
- 44:48beaten this information out of me you know what's
- 44:50kind of funny about that they share a kiss on
- 44:53screen I think this is what he's referring to.
- 44:55And Ziggy and I, or I think Ziggy called it out.
- 44:59She's like, kisses from this era are so funny
- 45:01because they just kind of like press their mouths
- 45:02together. Yeah. And like, they're not even really
- 45:05kissing. But I had to rewind it because it kind
- 45:08of grossed me out a little bit. They definitely
- 45:10open mouth kissed because there is a long strand
- 45:14of saliva that just like. And I was, I was like.
- 45:20My dude's really trying to please Norma Shearer.
- 45:23He's giving it all he's got. And this is before,
- 45:25like, sex scenes existed or anything, obviously.
- 45:27So I think when he says love scenes, he's including,
- 45:29like, them kissing. And he wasn't enough. Like,
- 45:32his kissing scenes weren't good enough for her.
- 45:34Which, again, I'm never admitting this. Maybe
- 45:36that's what happened. Maybe she saw that happen.
- 45:38She's like, yuck. She's like, we're done. Can
- 45:41we actually kill him in war? Is this something
- 45:43we can do? I think John dies in war, actually,
- 45:45everyone. Let's revisit that. Ken. John. Damn.
- 45:49See, too many people. It's confusing. There's
- 45:51only three people and there's too many. Oh, maybe
- 45:52that was a kiss with John. I don't remember who
- 45:54she was kissing. Because maybe she was Moonyin.
- 45:56And that would make more sense because they have
- 45:58more of a passionate relationship. Yeah. So maybe
- 46:00that was it. But also John didn't die in war.
- 46:02Nope. He died in chess. Neither did Ken. He died
- 46:05in chess. He died in the real battle. Yeah, the
- 46:10chess battle. Yeah. Mixed bag, man. Mixed bag.
- 46:14I think I'm a little... lighter on this than
- 46:18i am heavier in terms of my criticism of it we'll
- 46:21talk about that with our ratings but i mean norma
- 46:24sheer it almost maybe we should do this it almost
- 46:27feels like it's easy to kind of skip past how
- 46:30good of a job norma sheer does because she's
- 46:31so good right so you're not like hey let me pinpoint
- 46:34how good she is in this because you anticipate
- 46:36she's going to be and spoiler alert she is she's
- 46:39extremely uh extremely effective in this role
- 46:43and i felt the same way about frederick march
- 46:44yeah i was excited for both of them And they
- 46:47both exceeded my expectations, I would say. I
- 46:50really like Leslie Howard as John as well. Yeah.
- 46:53And this is the first movie I've ever seen him
- 46:55in. So I was like, oh, this is great. Especially
- 46:57with him kind of playing dual roles as well,
- 47:00at least dual ages. He was fantastic. It's interesting.
- 47:03If you look at the cast, like the credits of
- 47:05this, they actually don't credit Norma and Frederick
- 47:08as Moon Yin and Jeremy. They only credit them
- 47:11as Kathleen and Kenneth and just don't credit
- 47:13Mooney or Jeremy because they thought this was
- 47:16like too confusing. Yeah. For audiences. So they
- 47:19just kind of left it as is. But when you watch
- 47:21it, it's very clear that they're both playing
- 47:23each other. I think the only time I got confused
- 47:26is when Norma was trying to like explain her
- 47:29relationship to somebody. And she's like, yes,
- 47:31my aunt was in love with John, who is now my
- 47:35father. I like Ken. Owen is guilty of this in
- 47:38the beginning of the movie, where he's like,
- 47:40you're not going to believe this, John, but your
- 47:43late partner's sister's daughter is here, but
- 47:47your late partner's sister and her husband died.
- 47:50Like, sister -in -law. Right. Sister -in -law
- 47:53is the word you're looking for, and niece is
- 47:55the other word you're looking for. Exactly. Let's
- 47:57stop doing this whole, this person belongs to
- 47:59this person, which means this. Yeah. But when
- 48:01Owen said that, I definitely paused it and was
- 48:03looking up, I was like, my brother's sister's
- 48:05daughter. Okay, got it. Like, I'm there. What
- 48:09you're describing is my niece. He went a long
- 48:11way about it. But I really, I did enjoy a large
- 48:14portion of this. I can't say I loved the back
- 48:17half, maybe. Maybe the back third. But it just,
- 48:21it brings the movie to a screeching halt. I feel
- 48:23the same way. But I will say, I have a feeling
- 48:26that, ooh, ooh, that my rating would have been
- 48:30a little bit higher if I hadn't read the synopsis
- 48:33for this. Do you think it spoiled it for you?
- 48:35It did. Yeah. Because I was like, what do you
- 48:37mean? Like, if I had waited five more minutes,
- 48:39I wouldn't have seen this synopsis and it would
- 48:40have just gotten this organic story. And I would
- 48:42have been like, whoa, what a twist. I think that's
- 48:46where my ability to have my eyes glaze over really
- 48:49came in clutch. Because I read the synopsis and
- 48:52I was like, huh? And then I watched the movie
- 48:54and I was like, oh, okay. But when you read the
- 48:57synopsis, you're like, yeah, it definitely says
- 48:58this. Right. Yeah. Yeah. Now in hindsight, I'm
- 49:01like, spoiler. Yeah. Like, it really needs to
- 49:05be the first 10 to 15 minutes of this movie,
- 49:07and that's the synopsis. But instead, it's like,
- 49:09no, this is what Remember Me is about. Do you
- 49:12remember the movie Remember Me? I do remember
- 49:14Remember Me. Right. So if they're like, hey,
- 49:15it's a 9 -11 movie, you're like, well, no, the
- 49:17last scene is, but it's not a movie about that.
- 49:19Right. So, again, don't read IMDb. If you've
- 49:23gotten this far, then it's all for nothing. Sure.
- 49:26But my hope is that people can watch this movie
- 49:28and not read those synopsis or synopsy, I guess,
- 49:31and walk into this blind. Because I think that's
- 49:33the best way to do this. I agree. Totally agree.
- 49:37I don't have a lot of other things to say about
- 49:40this, really. No, I mean, I think it was smart
- 49:43of us to not break down every single thing that
- 49:46happens. Because you can kind of summarize the
- 49:4820, 25 minutes of the wedding flashback with
- 49:51just... drama and there's a shooting right and
- 49:54you can cover everything in the synopsis really
- 49:57unfortunately yes which we'll try not to do or
- 50:00continue uh to do not moving forward or continue
- 50:03not to moving forward wow words so do you want
- 50:06to hop into our ratings i do okay i think you
- 50:10should go first i was a little more critical
- 50:11of this sure i think i was i was tired after
- 50:14a long day of six flags And I was like, wow,
- 50:17my body hurts. That thing really whipped me around.
- 50:19You were invited to the mansion, right? The monster
- 50:24mansion? Yeah, you were invited to a picnic.
- 50:28I was. I can't remember the next line. This joke
- 50:32is for like two people who've been to Six Flags
- 50:35and know this ride and know the song attached
- 50:37to it. Side note, monster mansion is so scary.
- 50:41It's so scary. I was terrified. You're going
- 50:43the wrong way. And we went the wrong way. My
- 50:47favorite part is the back end where he like sees
- 50:49you, the sheriff character who looks like Barney.
- 50:52And he's like, okay, this way out. That like
- 50:56vocal stim has stayed with me. When we were headed
- 50:58into the marsh, there was like something that
- 51:01mildly resembled an alligator. And it so perfectly
- 51:05turned its head and was looking directly at me.
- 51:08Did you think it was weird when it says the word
- 51:10Kyle? They program it like E .T. He's like, welcome
- 51:14to the marsh, Kyle. But my favorite thing about
- 51:17that, we're still in the weeds. My favorite thing
- 51:19about that is how his voice has gotten warped
- 51:22over time because the E .T. ride was introduced
- 51:24in the 90s. So now they're like, so long. That's
- 51:31not my name, but okay. So long sound of gears.
- 51:35It's very scary. But yes, you were at Six Flags.
- 51:38I was at Six Flags. So yeah. I just, I really
- 51:44started losing interest in a big way. Clearly.
- 51:46And that's kind of a bummer. So I gave it two
- 51:48and a half stars. Sure. Again, feels low. Do
- 51:51you think revisiting this, that would change?
- 51:54Up or down? Maybe. Probably. It's one of those
- 51:59things where I think every time I rewatch any
- 52:01of these movies, I'd be like, okay, well, I know
- 52:03what's coming. I know what I have to look forward
- 52:05to. And I know when I can probably check out
- 52:08a little bit. enjoy other parts of this movie
- 52:12more let me ask you this how often when you had
- 52:15watched uh in previous years where you've seen
- 52:18these movies before and you're revisiting them
- 52:19for the pod how often did your rating increase
- 52:22on that second viewing pretty often i would say
- 52:25okay so more than likely you'd be at like a three
- 52:28when you revisit this yeah more not guaranteed
- 52:32yeah but probably right yeah yeah that okay that
- 52:36makes sense and i feel like it'd be the same
- 52:37thing for me too like we talked about grand hotel
- 52:39uh on our last episode um well our last movie
- 52:42episode and i feel like it'd be the same thing
- 52:45for me where maybe i'm a little bit higher as
- 52:46i revisit it because i have no expectations now
- 52:49yeah um but i will tell you that i was a bit
- 52:52higher on smiling three than you uh i rated three
- 52:55and a half stars now You might be asking yourself,
- 52:58did you do that? Because Kyle is listed as two
- 53:00and a half stars and Bryce is listed as three
- 53:02stars. So you just rounded out with three and
- 53:04a half, perhaps. But I did really like the first
- 53:09half of this. And I thought the camera work of
- 53:11the memory transition to the day before the wedding,
- 53:15I thought that was great. I really liked the
- 53:16gothic style of the ghost apparition appearing
- 53:20on screen. I thought that the twist that's introduced
- 53:24on this was... done really well i like that it
- 53:26comes at the halfway point and i wish that this
- 53:29came more organically for me and not reading
- 53:31it on imdb as the first sentence of the synopsis
- 53:34sure um because at first i was like oh i'm watching
- 53:37the wrong movie i was like oh no this just hasn't
- 53:39happened yet so why are we doing that when i'm
- 53:42like 40 minutes into this movie yeah so For those
- 53:45reasons, I really wanted to like Smiling Through,
- 53:47and I think I pushed a little bit more. I also
- 53:49think Norma Shearer's doing great work here.
- 53:51She's so good. I have a feeling I'd probably
- 53:53still be at three and a half on a second rewatch
- 53:55of this. Maybe a little bit lower. I don't know
- 53:58if I'm going to go much higher than this for
- 54:00Smiling Through. Maybe. I feel like more Grand
- 54:03Hotel I'll probably revisit and maybe be a little
- 54:06more keen on. Yeah, yeah. But I liked Smiling
- 54:09Through. I feel like we got just about everything
- 54:11we wanted to from this movie. I agree. The parts
- 54:14we didn't like, I don't think there's a lot to
- 54:16pull from that that we could enjoy more on a
- 54:19rewatch. Something that I think is worth revisiting
- 54:21in the future or looking back on is the what
- 54:24if of these. You know, we talk about how with
- 54:29One Hour With You. There was another director
- 54:32who came in and then Ernst Lubitsch came back
- 54:36and then took the rest of it. What would have
- 54:39happened if Ernst Lubitsch didn't come back?
- 54:41What would have happened if Ernst was here the
- 54:42entire time? In this same place with Lee Garns,
- 54:45what would have happened? What kind of movie
- 54:46would have been if Lee Garns wasn't involved
- 54:48or was involved through the whole entirety of
- 54:51the movie? I have a sneaking suspicion that that
- 54:54shot that I love so much was a Lee Garns idea
- 54:56based on what we've seen in Shanghai Express.
- 54:59So I wonder what the rest of the movie would
- 55:00have looked like. uh or to your point maybe it
- 55:02was more a decision made by sydney franklin on
- 55:06this could be so could be who's to say but uh
- 55:09just to that information i'd say three and a
- 55:11half stars is where i feel most comfortable i
- 55:12think that's solid how about your double feature
- 55:14so my double feature uh we keep talking about
- 55:18grand hotel i did something grand hotel with
- 55:20a double feature for love actually From the director
- 55:23Richard Curtis. Right. And it's funny because
- 55:25this movie also reminded me of the romance angle
- 55:29of how long your love can last even after passing.
- 55:33And Richard Curtis does this as well in his 2013
- 55:35film About Time. Ah, yes. I love About Time.
- 55:40Any movie that you can introduce the supernatural
- 55:43idea of time travel and blend it into like, is
- 55:46it a supernatural sci -fi movie? No, it's just
- 55:49a rom -com. really more of a rom -drom, but that
- 55:53happens to feature time travel. And I love this
- 55:56movie, and I think that this handles the idea
- 55:59of loss and what you do with your time and every...
- 56:03Continue, sorry. Are you good? I dropped my pen
- 56:05cap, that's all. Okay. This is very sad. I wasn't
- 56:08sure if this was the end of Smiling Through,
- 56:11where you've dropped your cigar, and I'm like,
- 56:12wake up, dummy. You're right, that's it. You're
- 56:15just dead. End of pod. I think that this movie
- 56:19handles the idea of loss and what you would do
- 56:23to keep that and time moving through your hands
- 56:25in a really adept way. Is that the word I'm looking
- 56:29for? I love the way it handles the romance of
- 56:31this. I'm sorry. Is this the one with Rachel
- 56:34McAdams and Channing Tatum? You're thinking of
- 56:37The Vow. Okay. For anyone who's not aware, I
- 56:40just want you to know. Vast knowledge on rom
- 56:43-coms, so come at me with that. No, so many.
- 56:46You're talking about The Vow. What I'm referring
- 56:48to is Rachel McAdams and Domino Gleeson. Oh.
- 56:52Bill Nighy's in this as well. Have I seen this
- 56:55movie? I think you have. I rated it. You rated
- 56:57it. That doesn't mean I've seen it, because I
- 56:59don't remember this. Well, I hope it does. I
- 57:02would love to imagine that it does mean that,
- 57:03actually. Normally it does, but... You should
- 57:05see this movie. I might be thinking about it.
- 57:07This also kind of hinges on the melodrama just
- 57:10a little bit, but the Richard Curtis of it helps
- 57:13it feel a little lighter than that. Devastating
- 57:15movie, but I love it. Reminded me a lot of Smiling
- 57:17Through in the sense of John and Moonene's relationship
- 57:21and what they go through. And the idea of him
- 57:23seeing her through time with apparitions reminds
- 57:26me of About Time a Good Bit. I'm keeping the
- 57:30Richard Curtis trend alive, even though that
- 57:32was last month. I like it. I like it. I have
- 57:36seen this movie. Weird. I have no memory of that.
- 57:39Fun fact. We played the song, not the song, but
- 57:42one of the songs in this movie is How Long Will
- 57:44I Love You? And we played that at our wedding.
- 57:47I think that was when my mom and I danced. I
- 57:49chose that song. That's very sweet. It's a great
- 57:51song. Well, I feel bad for being like... No,
- 57:54you shouldn't. I may have seen it. I don't know.
- 57:55I think it's really funny that you're like, well,
- 57:58I rated it, so that doesn't mean I've seen it.
- 58:00I was like, that's exactly what it should mean.
- 58:01Well, I just meant like maybe I put the wrong
- 58:04movie down. We should pre -rate movies. We should
- 58:05get the ability to be like, this is how much
- 58:07I think I'm going to like this movie. That's
- 58:08not a bad idea. And then compare it. That could
- 58:10be fun. So my double feature, I was going to
- 58:13go with the wonderful film starring Robert Pattinson
- 58:17and Emily DeRaven, Remember Me. I ruined it.
- 58:22You totally spoiled and ruined. You weren't for
- 58:25real. I was. For real? That's what I was going
- 58:28to put, yeah. And then you nonchalantly brought
- 58:30it up and just ruined everything about my plan.
- 58:33Homie, I cannot believe that. Instead, I'm going
- 58:36to go with the 1983 film Return of the Jedi because
- 58:40there are ghosts dancing at the end with Ewoks.
- 58:44I need a minute. I cannot believe you're going
- 58:48to choose to remember me. Yep. So are you a fan
- 58:52of that movie? I like Remember Me a lot. Really?
- 58:55I think when you get to the end of it, when I
- 58:57first saw it at that age, I was like, oh my God.
- 59:00And now when I watch it, I'm like, yep, here
- 59:03we go. That's one where I, if I was in the theater
- 59:06and I saw that, I'd be like looking around of
- 59:08being like, not even like a shocked way, just
- 59:10more like, what? Right. This is what we're doing.
- 59:14Whoever, I mean, I guess we spoiled it already,
- 59:16but whoever seemed to remember me, see Remember
- 59:17Me and let us know your thoughts. So, Return
- 59:20of the Jedi does, in fact, feature ghosts dancing.
- 59:23It does. You're right. Three ghosts. I'm surprised
- 59:25you didn't do Fellowship of the Ring Extended
- 59:27Edition with that little parade of the ghosts
- 59:30walking through the forest. You know what I'm
- 59:31talking about? Those aren't ghosts. Are they
- 59:33not? The green apparitions? They're just elves.
- 59:36I thought they were, like, glowing green. They're
- 59:38just pretty. I wish I glowed green when I was
- 59:43pretty. Well, you know, it's not easy being green.
- 59:46Anyway, Return of the Jedi. yitcha and check
- 59:51out my double feature of smiling through and
- 59:53return of the jedi i think we should still count
- 59:55remember me i already crossed it out in my notebook
- 59:58so there's nothing we can do about it now so
- 1:00:01oh i cannot believe that happened yeah let's
- 1:00:04just put this out of its misery there are confusing
- 1:00:05relationships in return of the jedi if i really
- 1:00:08need to dig in that's true yeah they're they're
- 1:00:10like uh yeah i'm your sister and she's like whoa
- 1:00:15That's true. They're not just like, you're my
- 1:00:17sister. They were like, well, there's your dad,
- 1:00:20who happens to be my father. Yeah. And then he
- 1:00:22had a daughter, which makes you my sibling. We're
- 1:00:25just siblings. Just say that. Exactly. Yeah.
- 1:00:27Yep. Yeah, you're right. There you go. And then
- 1:00:28Han Solo's all like, oh, which is how I was when
- 1:00:33I finally realized, oh, that's her niece. Yeah.
- 1:00:37Perfect. He also comes out of Carbonite in that
- 1:00:39movie, right? Yeah. Yeah. Which is similar to
- 1:00:42when Ken gets off the train. Exactly. Because
- 1:00:44you're like, hey, are you like dead? And he's
- 1:00:46like, nope, completely fine. Perfect double feature.
- 1:00:48Just give me a minute. Yeah. And there's a couple
- 1:00:50times where you think that John is dead, but
- 1:00:53somehow he returns. Much like the Jedi. Oh, I
- 1:00:56was going to say Palpatine. Yeah. Somehow. Somehow
- 1:00:59Palpatine's returned. Different movie. Anyway,
- 1:01:01that's my dumb double feature because you ruined
- 1:01:03my good double feature. So. Anyway. I have no
- 1:01:08words. That's Smiling Through. If you have any
- 1:01:10thoughts on this movie or any other films from
- 1:01:14the sixth Academy Awards, we made it. I'm so
- 1:01:17excited to get to a new year. We're here. We
- 1:01:19have new movies to talk about. It's going to
- 1:01:20be a really nice year. Is this our first year
- 1:01:23of 10 nominations? I think it is. Because last
- 1:01:26month it was like eight, maybe nine. We had the
- 1:01:2998th Academy Awards that had 10 nominations.
- 1:01:32Oh, sure. But yeah, historically, this is the
- 1:01:34first time this many films were nominated. This
- 1:01:36is the first year. Yeah. Of the Oscars with 10
- 1:01:38nominations. Absolutely. For Best Picture, that
- 1:01:40is. So if you have thoughts on those movies or
- 1:01:42even the fact that there are 10 of them, shoot
- 1:01:44us an email at outaopodcast at gmail .com. Check
- 1:01:48out the Patreon at patreon .com slash outaopodcast.
- 1:01:52Rate and review the show on your... podcast platform
- 1:01:55of choice listen to me say podcast 87 more times
- 1:01:59and stay tuned for next episode these are going
- 1:02:02to be coming out like three episodes a week this
- 1:02:04month right month because there are so many so
- 1:02:08if you are watching these movies along with us
- 1:02:11sorry you kind of have to crack down uh it's
- 1:02:14It's tough for us too. Or if you're Ashton, I
- 1:02:17know you're thrilled because she's like, I'm
- 1:02:19caught up. What do I do now? Right. Don't worry.
- 1:02:21There will be three episodes coming out every
- 1:02:22week. Work harder is what you have to do. Yeah.
- 1:02:25But next episode we'll be covering. Remember
- 1:02:27me. I am a fugitive from a chain gang. So I'm
- 1:02:32excited. I'm excited too. I've heard really good
- 1:02:35things. And it's the return of Mervyn Leroy.
- 1:02:38Yes. Yeah. Very excited. So stay tuned for that.
- 1:02:42But until next time. I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And
- 1:02:46we'll see you at the movies.