Latest / The HERD FIT / S05E136 No RX, No Scaled: The Impact of a Levels System
Transcript
- 0:05David Syvertsen: Hey everybody, welcome to the Herd Fit Podcast with Sam Rhee and and myself, coach David Syvertsen.
- 0:10David Syvertsen: His podcast is aimed at helping anyone and everyone looking to enhance their healthy lifestyle through fitness, nutrition and, most importantly, mindset.
- 0:19David Syvertsen: Alright, welcome back to the Herd Fit Podcast.
- 0:23David Syvertsen: I'm Coach David Silverson.
- 0:24David Syvertsen: I'm here with my co-host, dr and Coach Samri.
- 0:27David Syvertsen: We are going to dive into a topic today, right away.
- 0:30David Syvertsen: That is something that is very relevant to what we've discussed several times.
- 0:35David Syvertsen: We've done an actual episode on Rx for scale.
- 0:38David Syvertsen: This actual conversation comes up on a near weekly basis, whether it's banter in the gym, in this podcast room with the coaches, and sometimes I feel like it's not enough.
- 0:52David Syvertsen: This is a hill I will die on.
- 0:54David Syvertsen: I think every workout and cross-it should have a prescription with weights, movements, volume, loads, times.
- 1:00David Syvertsen: To just throw movements and say, hey, go pick your own weight every single day, go pick your volume every single day.
- 1:06David Syvertsen: It just wouldn't be cross-fit if that's what it was.
- 1:09David Syvertsen: In the effort to make everything better in time, we never want to settle.
- 1:15David Syvertsen: I've been thinking about this for well over a year, about getting away from just Rx and just scaled.
- 1:24David Syvertsen: The cross-it open has done this.
- 1:25David Syvertsen: When I started, there was just Rx.
- 1:28David Syvertsen: Here's the workout guys Can't do it.
- 1:31David Syvertsen: Okay, here's the workout.
- 1:32David Syvertsen: There's no scaled.
- 1:33David Syvertsen: And then they brought in a scale division about five years into it, six years into it, and now there's foundations.
- 1:40David Syvertsen: So cross-fit is kind of doing this with the open and I've always used cross-fit and the way they prescribe workouts, especially in the open, to use as a barometer for what we're doing.
- 1:50David Syvertsen: We're trying to match the open caliber workouts and maybe in some cases quarterfinal.
- 1:56David Syvertsen: But I think there's something left to do.
- 1:58David Syvertsen: I think it's not good enough and I don't have the solution yet.
- 2:01David Syvertsen: And, like any problem that comes up, you come up with potential solutions and you try it out.
- 2:06David Syvertsen: So cross-fit bison is trying something January, february, once, twice a week, once or twice a week, and it's called the Levels System.
- 2:16David Syvertsen: I mean there's specific workouts that have Level 1, level 2, etc.
- 2:20David Syvertsen: And we'll talk into how many levels there can be.
- 2:22David Syvertsen: Complicated, yes, complex, yes, new.
- 2:25David Syvertsen: Yes, uncomfortable for some, yes, confusing.
- 2:29David Syvertsen: Absolutely Don't fix.
- 2:30David Syvertsen: What isn't broken is the thought that keeps coming into my head.
- 2:32David Syvertsen: Have our X scale down from there.
- 2:35David Syvertsen: Sam, this relates to something we've disagreed on in the past Having a master's RX, having age group RX.
- 2:43David Syvertsen: They're very, very much against that idea and does this approach, that conversation, or because it's not doing with age, it makes a little bit more sense.
- 2:55Sam Rhee: It makes more sense because it's not I don't want to say discriminating, but it's not stratifying people according to some criteria.
- 3:03Sam Rhee: So that would be the equivalent of saying if you weigh 150 pounds plus, you got to do it this way.
- 3:10Sam Rhee: If you're under 150 pounds, use it this way.
- 3:12Sam Rhee: Like, why would you do that?
- 3:13Sam Rhee: That makes no sense.
- 3:14Sam Rhee: Same with age.
- 3:16Sam Rhee: We have some 35 plus athletes that are crushing the under 35.
- 3:24Sam Rhee: So why would you use an arbitrary number of age to figure out who's doing what?
- 3:32Sam Rhee: Now, that being said, once I hit 55, am I going to jump for joy because I could do better in the open?
- 3:38Sam Rhee: Absolutely I will, and I'll take it because that's the way they set it up.
- 3:41Sam Rhee: But for an everyday evaluation of myself, I don't like that age.
- 3:47Sam Rhee: Masters, rx Now levels, and we'll talk about this too, because I have now we've done a couple levels workouts, at least one, and I have some mixed feelings about it.
- 3:58Sam Rhee: And I want to talk about one of the workouts and sort of where, like, how you stratified it, what you thought about it, and then my experience with it, and then also looking at the whiteboard, because it really means a different way to look at the whiteboard more than anything else, because if there wasn't the level system I might have scaled the workout to this, that or the other thing.
- 4:21Sam Rhee: But depending on the workout, but I think the levels, it has some pluses and minuses in it and I think that it was so interesting to me looking at the whiteboard that first day.
- 4:34David Syvertsen: So let's introduce the actual concept behind the level system.
- 4:37David Syvertsen: This actually idea, I want to say, was probably first put into my head during the LaRong challenges.
- 4:44David Syvertsen: If you remember back to these January February pre reset challenges that our gym did, they released a workout every Monday for the entire challenge.
- 4:53David Syvertsen: Like there was five or six of these, there wasn't just one, and each one of them had different levels and it was basically RX plus RX and scaled, and you essentially had to pick one of those, but then we would have to modify a couple things for a couple of people.
- 5:07David Syvertsen: So, and back then, level three was the hardest.
- 5:11David Syvertsen: I'm going to tell us why we're doing it this way.
- 5:14David Syvertsen: Level one is the hardest way of doing a workout here and because I'm not sure how many levels there should be.
- 5:21David Syvertsen: So if you know this week, you know this episode is going to come out after we did a workout this last Tuesday that had hang cleans, sit ups and jump rope, and level one was the hardest.
- 5:34David Syvertsen: It had weights that I don't know.
- 5:36David Syvertsen: Maybe three to 5% of our gym can move in a workout.
- 5:39David Syvertsen: Then you have level two, which is equivalent to what a normal bison RX would be.
- 5:43David Syvertsen: Level three would be a little bit easier.
- 5:45David Syvertsen: But now and that's where I was going to end it where you have three levels and then you have skilled, hey, I couldn't do any of those.
- 5:51David Syvertsen: I had to scale or I had to mix and match them.
- 5:52David Syvertsen: But now, because I did this with the bison benchmark workout, the reset workout, I created five levels where I think 95% of our gym could pick one of those levels, and you're going down to really lightweight, empty barbell caliber weights, and, because of our experience and how many people we see work out on a daily basis, I have a very good feeling that everyone in our gym can can hit one of these levels.
- 6:18David Syvertsen: And, in time, though, you can add levels.
- 6:21David Syvertsen: If it's, hey, we need something easier, let's add level five, let's let's add level six.
- 6:25David Syvertsen: So that's why I'm starting with.
- 6:28David Syvertsen: Level one is by far the hardest level, and it's a little bit harder than what we're normally used to going.
- 6:32David Syvertsen: If you looked at our bison program from the outside, you would say pretty hard programming, not the hardest We've seen, the hardest, mayhem, proven right.
- 6:41David Syvertsen: And then level two would be where we bison arches, bison, sorry, level one is harder than that, all right, and I would say gotta be careful for saying this.
- 6:54David Syvertsen: It would be more for the people that are competing or trying to compete at the highest level Quarterfinals, semifinals, maybe even the games.
- 7:00David Syvertsen: Right, that's who that programming is for.
- 7:03David Syvertsen: Level two would be hey, I'm really fit, I can pretty much do everything across it.
- 7:07David Syvertsen: I'm never going to have to scale, work out in the open.
- 7:12David Syvertsen: I could.
- 7:12David Syvertsen: I'm going to make quarterfinals.
- 7:13David Syvertsen: I'm level two all day, every day.
- 7:16David Syvertsen: Level three would be for those that have been bison for a long time hey, what was bison arcs like six, seven years ago?
- 7:21David Syvertsen: And you've been here long enough that you would know that contrast between now and then.
- 7:24David Syvertsen: Some of you guys don't know.
- 7:26David Syvertsen: But it's a little lighter, a little less volume, a little bit less complexity.
- 7:29David Syvertsen: Still not easy by any means.
- 7:31David Syvertsen: But then you start going down to level four, level five At some point it's got to end, but you're also trying to keep this inclusive.
- 7:39David Syvertsen: Sam, when you start hearing level one, level two harder, easier, is this too complex?
- 7:46Sam Rhee: It's not for the athletes.
- 7:48Sam Rhee: I would say when you look at it, because you can choose where it actually helps the athletes on one level, Because you can look at it and be like, oh, I can do all of those things.
- 7:56Sam Rhee: When you stratify it like that, it does take some time, if you're just arc scale, to figure out what your scaled is Right.
- 8:03Sam Rhee: This helps you if you typically scale workouts where you should go with it as a programmer.
- 8:11Sam Rhee: How much extra time does it take to put together a workout with levels versus arc scale?
- 8:16David Syvertsen: Not as much.
- 8:17David Syvertsen: Other people have offered advice and guidance on with me on this and they said it's going to be too much work for you.
- 8:23David Syvertsen: It would be a lot of upfront work because essentially I would just take all of the weights, just put them to a spreadsheet and say when level two is this, level one is this.
- 8:31David Syvertsen: Basically what I would do is program level two because that's what bison RX would be, and then I would just say, all right, when I see this weight, level one's got to be this, level two's got to be that, level three's got to be that, all right.
- 8:41David Syvertsen: And like that would be some upfront work.
- 8:43David Syvertsen: But I already have some stuff on my computer, on a spreadsheet that makes that process a little bit easier.
- 8:47David Syvertsen: So it wouldn't be a lot of upfront work.
- 8:50David Syvertsen: The problem with work and complexity for at the programmer is you have to find consistency and really when you're looking at levels, I would say nine out of 10 times it has to do with the weights.
- 9:03David Syvertsen: You know every now and then you could throw some more complicated or strict gymnastics in, but you don't want to play with the volume too much.
- 9:12David Syvertsen: You don't want to play with the time of a workout too much, because now you're really starting to separate the gym and everyone's doing different workouts and you never want to do that.
- 9:20David Syvertsen: But that's getting kind of ahead of myself right now in terms of why I don't want to do this.
- 9:24David Syvertsen: I want to talk about why I want to do this, and the reason why is the gap between, let's say I hate using this term, I use it very seldomly the best and worst is bigger than it's ever been.
- 9:35David Syvertsen: I would even say the gap between goals in this gym is more than it's ever been, and as the gym grows, the membership grows.
- 9:48David Syvertsen: Now you're seeing a, it's one thing if you have one or two people shooting for something and they're at a certain level.
- 9:52David Syvertsen: When you have 15 to 20, when you have 30, when you have you know the amount of people that we have that are really pursuing something at a high level you feel more pressure to serve them, right?
- 10:03David Syvertsen: I feel a lot of pressure programming to protect people, especially new people, especially people that are older and they have no desire to compete.
- 10:09David Syvertsen: They don't want to push that hard, they just want to work out and not get hurt.
- 10:12David Syvertsen: That's the majority of our gym, all right, the vast majority, I would even say.
- 10:16David Syvertsen: But I still feel a lot of pressure to serve the people that are on the opposite side, where they're not just pursuing health, they are pursuing performance, they're pursuing sport and they need to be pushed.
- 10:25David Syvertsen: What?
- 10:27David Syvertsen: For some of them, one workout per day it's not enough.
- 10:28David Syvertsen: So I feel like I'm leaving them short as a coach, as a programmer, as a guide, whatever.
- 10:36David Syvertsen: If I don't try to push them um with the other guys, I'm not going to be able to do that.
- 10:41David Syvertsen: I'm going to be able to push them as a coach, as a programmer, as a guide, whatever.
- 10:46David Syvertsen: If I don't try to push them um without just adding more workouts to their day.
- 10:52Sam Rhee: I see this as a coach and it's my job as a coach to make it a real experience for the top and the bottom of performers regardless and to make them see the meaning and the value in it.
- 11:04Sam Rhee: That is the challenge as a coach executing your programming.
- 11:08Sam Rhee: This past week we had.
- 11:10Sam Rhee: The workout I coached was very light hang power snatches at 50% of a one rep max and then followed by a 2K rope.
- 11:18Sam Rhee: Now that wasn't, on paper, the most exciting workout, and if you're someone who just comes in and you want to get a sweat on and you just want to work out, you would look at that and be like, why on God's green earth would I do this?
- 11:32Sam Rhee: And it was my job as a coach if you stepped in that door to show you that there was value in working on your snatch technique and thinking about how to drive your hips quickly in order to move that bar fast.
- 11:45David Syvertsen: You did a very good job of that, but I'm not just saying that you did a very good job of that.
- 11:48Sam Rhee: Thanks and to see that that will help you, even as an athlete who just wants to work out for the day, like there's going to be tremendous value in that to move well with that.
- 12:01Sam Rhee: And then to figure out how to convince those guys that you know, instead of just rowing 2K at 50% of your effort, like really trying to give a max effort, strategizing, thinking about it, when you put even the most casual athletes into a position to perform, you are pushing their envelope so that even their most casual workouts are going to be better.
- 12:25Sam Rhee: And when you can do that, you've brought value to them and they can see that Even the top performers you know they might want to go.
- 12:34Sam Rhee: You know what.
- 12:35Sam Rhee: I know how to snatch at 50% of my weight.
- 12:38Sam Rhee: I need to.
- 12:38Sam Rhee: You can do better.
- 12:40Sam Rhee: You can improve your technique.
- 12:41Sam Rhee: You can do fat.
- 12:42Sam Rhee: Listen, don't go up on the weight.
- 12:44Sam Rhee: Just check your ego and see how fast you can drive your hips, how fast can you move that barbell, and if they bought into it, that helped them.
- 12:53Sam Rhee: And then the 2K Rove.
- 12:54Sam Rhee: It's actually a little bit harder sometimes to convince the best athletes to do that because they know how awful it can get.
- 13:02Sam Rhee: So when you show up at a 6 AM and you convince someone to maybe go 10% harder than maybe they would have, like they thought.
- 13:10Sam Rhee: You know I can give an 80% effort.
- 13:11Sam Rhee: I'm going to give a 90.
- 13:12Sam Rhee: There's value in that too, and so I think every day and we see that more and more there is a challenge in finding people to buy in at both levels, and I think the level system will help with that.
- 13:26Sam Rhee: Honestly, I think, instead of just saying I was scaled, to say I was level three or level four brings more meaning and value to your workout.
- 13:37David Syvertsen: So those are the pros right there, that it does, it keeps you on track, it keeps you in check, based on where you are and what your goals are.
- 13:45David Syvertsen: And some of the cons of doing this is obviously complexity for the programmer, right, which, if you're going to do it, you're going to have to accept some of that.
- 13:53David Syvertsen: It's also some complexity for coaches too, because here's the situation.
- 13:59David Syvertsen: I'm going to give a mixed modal workout example, and this is just going to add stress to a coach.
- 14:04David Syvertsen: Let's say there's a workout Amrap 20, five ring muscle ups, 10 hand cleans, 35 double unders.
- 14:12David Syvertsen: All right, there's the workout Five muscle ups, 10 hand cleans, 35 double unders.
- 14:17David Syvertsen: Mixed modal, level one.
- 14:19David Syvertsen: That's your workout.
- 14:21David Syvertsen: That's the toughest version.
- 14:22David Syvertsen: Your Rx weight is 205, 135.
- 14:26David Syvertsen: And you have to do crossovers instead of double unders.
- 14:28David Syvertsen: Level two by Sennar X ring or bar muscle ups, rx weight 135, 95, double unders.
- 14:38David Syvertsen: We have people in this gym that want to do those ring muscle ups and crossovers, but they can't lift that weight.
- 14:43David Syvertsen: So now they really can't do the level one workout.
- 14:46David Syvertsen: But they could do everything, but they just there's one thing they can't do.
- 14:48David Syvertsen: So what do you do in that situation?
- 14:50David Syvertsen: Right, I could think of 20 people in this gym that would have to.
- 14:54David Syvertsen: They want level one, but there's one thing in there they can't do, so they're going to modify it.
- 14:59David Syvertsen: They're going to take the level one gymnastics.
- 15:00David Syvertsen: They're going to take the level two weight, or vice versa.
- 15:03David Syvertsen: They're going to take the level one gymnastics sorry, the level one weight, level two gymnastics.
- 15:07David Syvertsen: And now what is that?
- 15:08David Syvertsen: Are we going to have a coach write one dash, two ring muscle?
- 15:11David Syvertsen: No, we're not.
- 15:11David Syvertsen: We've gotten away from that years ago.
- 15:13David Syvertsen: We're not writing down every detail of your workout.
- 15:15David Syvertsen: There's too many of you Right.
- 15:17David Syvertsen: So in my eyes, it's you're picking level one and level two period.
- 15:20David Syvertsen: That's it.
- 15:21David Syvertsen: It's like the open right, or you're skilled, so you're going to have level one, level two, level three on that whiteboard.
- 15:27David Syvertsen: You're the one moving to the workouts.
- 15:29David Syvertsen: Or you're skilled.
- 15:29David Syvertsen: And what I like about this?
- 15:31David Syvertsen: I'm going to reverse the con that this will help negate, get rid of.
- 15:37David Syvertsen: Rx is good and skilled as bad, because you will have some of the best athletes in this gym that will have an SC next to their name.
- 15:42David Syvertsen: And now, because I've been trying to preach this and I think it's a losing battle right now, but I will not give up.
- 15:48David Syvertsen: You know, when you scale workout, it doesn't mean you're bad at CrossFit, it doesn't mean you're out of shape.
- 15:52David Syvertsen: It just means you changed it.
- 15:53David Syvertsen: All right, here's the RX prescriptions.
- 15:54David Syvertsen: You had to change it.
- 15:56David Syvertsen: You know this is quoting Rafi last week.
- 15:57David Syvertsen: It's like, yeah, because you couldn't do this.
- 15:59David Syvertsen: You know he didn't get doesn't get an acting job because he's too good looking or not good looking enough, too tall or not tall enough, right.
- 16:05David Syvertsen: It's like anytime you can't do level one because you're not strong enough, that's okay.
- 16:09David Syvertsen: You couldn't do level two because you couldn't do the gymnastics.
- 16:12David Syvertsen: So you're going to scale, but that doesn't mean you're not good enough.
- 16:15David Syvertsen: It's just the truth of the matter in the moment.
- 16:17David Syvertsen: So the con is that it can make things more complicated, more thinking for the athlete and the coach.
- 16:24David Syvertsen: But the pro that comes from that con is that it can really change the perspective of athletes and coaches of what this actually is.
- 16:31David Syvertsen: It is stimulus training.
- 16:33David Syvertsen: We're trying to get everyone in the room on the same page.
- 16:39Sam Rhee: Let's go through.
- 16:40Sam Rhee: Can we go through a real life example here?
- 16:43Sam Rhee: Because I want to talk about this week's workout Well, last week's, yeah, yeah, yeah, sure, yeah.
- 16:47Sam Rhee: Because I will tell you what my thoughts were, figuring out what to do and how I thought about it, looking at the whiteboard Compared to other athletes the reset one.
- 16:58David Syvertsen: Shoulder overhead, yeah, ground overhead.
- 17:00David Syvertsen: Burbitt's target, yes.
- 17:01Sam Rhee: Yeah, so if you could go through the different levels and then I would tell you what I thought about choosing my levels and what I thought about going through the whiteboard afterwards and what I think people might think about it.
- 17:19David Syvertsen: Here we go.
- 17:19David Syvertsen: 12 minute workout 12 ground to overhead, 18 burpees to target, 18 ground overhead, 12 burpees to target.
- 17:26David Syvertsen: All right, change weight 8 ground to overhead, 12 burpees, 12 ground to overhead, 8 burpees.
- 17:33David Syvertsen: Change weight again 4 ground to overhead, 6 burpees to target, 6 ground to overhead, 4 burpees to target.
- 17:39David Syvertsen: Change weight for the third time MAX ground to overhead and remaining time.
- 17:44David Syvertsen: It is a 12 minute workout.
- 17:45David Syvertsen: Level 1, the hardest starts off 75-55, 125-85, 175-115, 225-145.
- 17:55David Syvertsen: Level 2, 75-55, 95-65, 135-95, 185-125.
- 18:01David Syvertsen: Level 3, 65-45, 85-55, 115-75, 155-105.
- 18:09David Syvertsen: Level 4, the final level right 45-35, 65-45, 75-55, 95-65.
- 18:17David Syvertsen: So you come into the whiteboard, you see that workout, the burpees and ground to overhead, which means cleaning, jerk or snatch, combination of the two.
- 18:24David Syvertsen: And then they say, hey, this is where you change weights.
- 18:27David Syvertsen: Well, what are my weights?
- 18:28David Syvertsen: You have to pick a level level 1 through 4, choose your battle.
- 18:32David Syvertsen: We gave some guidance at the whiteboard.
- 18:34David Syvertsen: There's your level workout.
- 18:36Sam Rhee: So that was an easier one to program, because the only thing that changed for the levels were the weights for the ground to overhead, and the hardest one was what was the initial weight for level 1?
- 18:49Sam Rhee: 75-55 was the initial weight, and you finished max ground to overhead at 225-145, right.
- 18:56Sam Rhee: And then the lightest one was similar right.
- 18:59David Syvertsen: The lightest one was 45-35 start, 95-65 end right.
- 19:05Sam Rhee: So, looking at that you're looking at to determine what level you need to be at as an athlete.
- 19:12Sam Rhee: You need to see what kind of weights you can move for a ground to overhead.
- 19:15Sam Rhee: And the first thing you always look at is because the light weights are easy for anybody, even for most like for a lot of people, even the ones who are level 4 athletes, they're like I could probably do 175-pound whatever, and we struggle with that all the time as coaches Right.
- 19:32Sam Rhee: And you're looking at it like Can I do one?
- 19:35Sam Rhee: Yeah but can you do it over the course of a?
- 19:37David Syvertsen: workout.
- 19:38David Syvertsen: Sorry, let me interrupt.
- 19:39David Syvertsen: Yeah, this is exactly why the level system is a good thing.
- 19:42David Syvertsen: Someone will see that 75, 55 in level one the hardest level, right, and be like, bro, I can RX this because they think they're good, because RX will be next to their name, right, but they're not getting the feel out of the workout, of what it's supposed to be right.
- 19:59Sam Rhee: Cause they're capped out at maybe the first or second weight Exactly and they're like 30 reps.
- 20:05David Syvertsen: Yeah, they did 30 reps in the workout.
- 20:06David Syvertsen: We're really we're trying to get you guys like 90, 100, 120, 130 in that workout and we tell people we have to say this at the whiteboard of the time that first barbell should feel like a piece of paper, not your 80% of your 100 max.
- 20:20Sam Rhee: So then the other thing is you look at the heaviest weight and you're like, can I do?
- 20:26Sam Rhee: If you're a guy, 225 ground to overheads, can I do 185?
- 20:31Sam Rhee: Can I do whatever?
- 20:32Sam Rhee: And so personally, I was like I don't think I can do 225.
- 20:37Sam Rhee: That's my PR and that was years ago.
- 20:40Sam Rhee: I haven't even gotten close to that right now.
- 20:43Sam Rhee: Right.
- 20:43Sam Rhee: But do I do level one, knowing it's a challenge just to get through and maybe I don't even get to that last barbell?
- 20:53Sam Rhee: And I know a bunch of people who did level one did that, or maybe they just got one.
- 20:57Sam Rhee: How many reps is it to get to the max?
- 20:59Sam Rhee: 125?
- 21:00Sam Rhee: 120 was to get to the max, to the max, okay.
- 21:03Sam Rhee: So there's some people that got capped at 120, doing level one.
- 21:07Sam Rhee: So a lot of 120s, yeah.
- 21:08Sam Rhee: And I said I could probably do that.
- 21:10Sam Rhee: Or do I try to push myself and get level two and know that I can do 185 at the end, even though it's a lighter barbell, and just move faster?
- 21:23Sam Rhee: And I chose to do level two because I said I really want to see if I can get to that last barbell and see how many I can do.
- 21:33Sam Rhee: I don't feel like I should just try to go and get capped out without getting to 225, without having any intention on it.
- 21:39Sam Rhee: Right and a smart decision.
- 21:41Sam Rhee: And I might be a little scared because I might try to hit 225 and hurt myself or something at the end.
- 21:47Sam Rhee: Absolutely so I did that and I did well for myself.
- 21:51Sam Rhee: I don't remember I got into the 185s and I did, I mean maybe without about a minute left or so you get to get to there.
- 21:59Sam Rhee: I got Two or three, I got more than that.
- 22:01Sam Rhee: Yeah Well, you said you had a minute left.
- 22:05David Syvertsen: So, like About a minute 30 and I.
- 22:06David Syvertsen: That changes things, because a minute, you just don't have that much time to look at that point.
- 22:09David Syvertsen: Dude, I got six done.
- 22:10David Syvertsen: Okay, awesome, let's go.
- 22:11Sam Rhee: All right, there, you go so and I looked at the whiteboard and there were not that many guys that did level two, maybe like four or three.
- 22:21Sam Rhee: Okay, most of the people I look at the whiteboard, who I compare myself to, did level one and they might have gotten one or two.
- 22:30Sam Rhee: A lot of them got capped out of 120.
- 22:32Sam Rhee: Didn't even try it Right, and so it was really hard for me to compare myself with anyone.
- 22:40Sam Rhee: Now, does my happiness with a workout depend on who I who might compare myself to?
- 22:47Sam Rhee: It does not, although I did look at it and I did see Aaron, your brother.
- 22:51Sam Rhee: He got one more rep than me, he got 127.
- 22:54Sam Rhee: And I said I did pretty well.
- 22:55Sam Rhee: Yeah, compared to Aaron, I'm really happy with that.
- 22:58Sam Rhee: But but I was unable to sort of compare myself to others whom I sort of wanted to.
- 23:06David Syvertsen: It's kind of rough, though, because you come at six, so there's only been one class there.
- 23:10Sam Rhee: No at the end of the day when I look at it.
- 23:11David Syvertsen: Oh, look, because I feel like there's a more than that on level two.
- 23:15Sam Rhee: I wish there were some people that had done level two that didn't.
- 23:19David Syvertsen: So here's a downfall of this level system is you're leaving it up to them, right, like if we were really.
- 23:24David Syvertsen: I mean, this is an option where I tell you what level you're doing, but that's probably a little too in-depth, a little too controlling.
- 23:32David Syvertsen: But if I did that, I think you would have been more fulfilled from this regard where, like you know, we say, because we did give the approach, hey guys, you should be able to lift that last barbell, but you might not even get there.
- 23:45David Syvertsen: So as long as you can get through the third one, it's okay.
- 23:47David Syvertsen: But again, it's a guess.
- 23:49David Syvertsen: So I understand what you're saying, that you wish more people did level two so that you can compare yourself.
- 23:57Sam Rhee: And that's a selfish reason.
- 23:59Sam Rhee: And did I get a great workout?
- 24:01Sam Rhee: I absolutely did.
- 24:02Sam Rhee: Did I push myself?
- 24:02Sam Rhee: Yes, am I happy that I did it at level two and not level one?
- 24:06Sam Rhee: Yes, do I wish if this happened every day?
- 24:11Sam Rhee: Would that start to change the way I chose my levels?
- 24:15Sam Rhee: It might Right, it might.
- 24:19David Syvertsen: And that's.
- 24:20David Syvertsen: I've seen this before where we have a, you know, a pretty hard workout that the whole gym does.
- 24:24David Syvertsen: It's not heavy, it's not light, it's just kind of in the middle, right, like most of our programming is.
- 24:27David Syvertsen: It's balanced.
- 24:29David Syvertsen: And you'll see some people that RX plus it and we've had episodes we've talked about RX plus the good, the bad.
- 24:35David Syvertsen: You know, mind your own business, kind of stuff, right, don't let the ego control it.
- 24:39David Syvertsen: Like, do you really have an intention behind doing it?
- 24:41David Syvertsen: But I truly do think there's some very honest, real reasoning behind it.
- 24:46David Syvertsen: It's like hey, I'm trying to get to this level of CrossFit sport or this level of fitness.
- 24:53David Syvertsen: Take the sport out of it.
- 24:54David Syvertsen: I need these weights to be heavier.
- 24:56David Syvertsen: And you're gonna have some old school CrossFit truthers say, no, just go faster, just go intense.
- 25:01David Syvertsen: I use that line sometimes, right, like no.
- 25:03David Syvertsen: Nick Squier asked me if he should use a 30 pound ball for this last bison benchmark.
- 25:07David Syvertsen: Oh right, the wall ball, perpiboxium pover one, yeah.
- 25:10David Syvertsen: And I said, no, go faster.
- 25:11David Syvertsen: And I'll tell you what.
- 25:13David Syvertsen: I think that he did more work.
- 25:17David Syvertsen: He worked harder because he went with a 20 pound ball.
- 25:21David Syvertsen: Some view it as nope.
- 25:23David Syvertsen: 30 pound ball is a better workout because it's heavier.
- 25:25David Syvertsen: It's more than it's 50% more weight Every single rep.
- 25:27David Syvertsen: Think about all those reps.
- 25:28David Syvertsen: Dave, you probably went slower.
- 25:30David Syvertsen: You probably broke it up.
- 25:30David Syvertsen: There are some people that could have done that with a 30 pound ball, so should they be doing it?
- 25:35David Syvertsen: This is where this this is like a nonstop, always present thinking process that you're probably never gonna have a clear solution to, but I think the intention of thinking about it this way like Sam thinking about other people should have done level two.
- 25:51David Syvertsen: I'm thinking certain people should have done level two, but that person could have done level three.
- 25:55David Syvertsen: You know, level one, whatever right it almost is it too much complexity for what it's worth.
- 26:01David Syvertsen: What we're trying to do here is across it by some affiliate.
- 26:06Sam Rhee: That I think we're gonna have to answer.
- 26:09Sam Rhee: Well, I think we can answer that question better.
- 26:11Sam Rhee: Like months into trying this, I will say I talked to Nick Squire after that and you heard him more.
- 26:18Sam Rhee: By making him do multiple rounds of 31 wall balls on broken, which beat the living tar out of him, and he would not have been able to do that if it was a 30 pound wall ball.
- 26:29Sam Rhee: He admitted it was a better or he acknowledged not admitted it, it acknowledged it was a better workout to go at 20 and go faster, go unbroken, which that is where some of these complexity subtleties about the level system is going to be dependent on the coaches.
- 26:50David Syvertsen: And I don't wanna put all that on coaches, because it can be really tough to explain this when we're already pinched for time in a lot of cases.
- 26:57Sam Rhee: You have to know the athletes well in order to help guide them, and otherwise these athletes are gonna self guide and they will do what we just worry about.
- 27:04Sam Rhee: They'll go too heavy or too hard and not get the required stimulus, or they'll go too light and also not get the required stimulus.
- 27:14David Syvertsen: A way to combat that is you come up with I've seen gyms do this before.
- 27:17David Syvertsen: Don't love it, but there's Mary behind it you create a chart, you put it somewhere in the gym, you send it to people, put it on your phone.
- 27:23David Syvertsen: This is, these are the things you have to be able to do to be a level one athlete here.
- 27:27David Syvertsen: Can't do one of them.
- 27:29David Syvertsen: Sorry, you can't do level one.
- 27:30David Syvertsen: You gotta stick with level two.
- 27:32David Syvertsen: 10 unbroken ring muscles will be up there.
- 27:34David Syvertsen: That's probably a little too controlling, but you could come up with because we need objectivity here, right?
- 27:41David Syvertsen: You don't want someone coming in and be like, oh dude, I crushed snatches and muscle ups like I can do this, but I can't walk on my hands, so I can't do level one.
- 27:48David Syvertsen: It's.
- 27:49David Syvertsen: You can come up with certain rules for people and it can be movement based as well, and we try to do this at the whiteboard.
- 27:56David Syvertsen: Hey guys, you should be able to snatch this unbroken if you're gonna do this.
- 27:59David Syvertsen: We just did sumo dead of pipe holes yesterday and it caught a lot of people off guard and I said guys, make today's weight change, weight choice on the sumos, not the hand cleans.
- 28:08David Syvertsen: I know you can hand clean it.
- 28:09David Syvertsen: Can you do eight sumos in a row and I saw people doing singles from the beginning because it was too heavy.
- 28:13David Syvertsen: I'm like yep, too heavy, you know, and like you guys really slowed down because of it.
- 28:16David Syvertsen: So you can give some guidance per movement, per kind of workout to the entire gym and take because you do.
- 28:23David Syvertsen: Part of this is you gotta protect people from themselves, right?
- 28:26David Syvertsen: And I actually think another reason why I wanna keep trying this is I think this can help get people healthier and protect them.
- 28:35Sam Rhee: The problem is is that when you stratify it like that, it's going to be where, as an athlete, I'm going to say I will never be able to do level one.
- 28:44Sam Rhee: Why do I?
- 28:46Sam Rhee: It kinda caps me or puts a ceiling on things, and I know a lot of people who are scaled athletes.
- 28:54Sam Rhee: It means a lot to them to be able to do a certain workout, not every day, but a certain workout as RX.
- 29:02Sam Rhee: I see people cry and so you take that away from them.
- 29:08Sam Rhee: And now they're like well, I'm never gonna be a level one athlete, I'll always be level two, or I'm always level three, I'll never be level two.
- 29:14Sam Rhee: And now that incentive to go a little harder or keep improving or trying might not be as obvious to them.
- 29:25David Syvertsen: But maybe it could.
- 29:26David Syvertsen: But if I take away the hey, if you can't do this, you can't do level one period you could say, hey, certain you can pick every day what level you are based on what kind of athlete you are.
- 29:33David Syvertsen: Maybe it can give someone that will never be a complete RX athlete they're never gonna get to that point, it's not even goal there's.
- 29:40David Syvertsen: But there's that one movement, those two movements that they can crush, and they see that workout three days ahead of time.
- 29:46David Syvertsen: Like yo, I'm going level one today.
- 29:47David Syvertsen: I'm one of the big dogs today because I can do this.
- 29:51David Syvertsen: But it takes away the pressure of needing to do everything to be a level one athlete.
- 29:55David Syvertsen: Right, you throw pistols into that level one test, I'm out.
- 29:58David Syvertsen: So that means I can never do level one again.
- 30:01David Syvertsen: If anything, it's gonna make me less inspired to work on other things.
- 30:05David Syvertsen: But if I'm allowed to pick level one today, level three yesterday, level two tomorrow, right, it can really almost expose objectively what my weaknesses are like on a very truth basis.
- 30:17David Syvertsen: And if I want to get better at these movements, hey, I can never level one.
- 30:22David Syvertsen: A workout that has strict handstand push-ups in it sucks.
- 30:25David Syvertsen: Well, guess what it's gonna make you do.
- 30:27David Syvertsen: If you care a lot about it, you're going to put extra work into those strict handstand push-ups so that when it comes up, I'm gonna go.
- 30:34David Syvertsen: And one of the things that we always want to teach people you should work on your weaknesses.
- 30:37Sam Rhee: Do you think the cache or the allure of being a level one athlete will be the same as being an RX athlete at some point?
- 30:45David Syvertsen: Yeah, absolutely Like you only get to wear this shirt.
- 30:47David Syvertsen: If you're level one, you get a blue shirt.
- 30:51David Syvertsen: If you've done a hundred level one workouts, you get there at gyms that do stuff like no, absolutely, and I teach their own.
- 30:57David Syvertsen: I think more than that it would.
- 30:59David Syvertsen: This is one of my cons that I'm actually probably more worried about than anything is people staying not in their own lane and looking at what other people are doing what levels they're doing and like that person shouldn't be doing level one.
- 31:14Sam Rhee: I'm better than them, that was me.
- 31:16David Syvertsen: Yeah, and that happens on a day-to-day basis.
- 31:19David Syvertsen: Why did that person Rx?
- 31:20David Syvertsen: You know I was like why do you care?
- 31:22Sam Rhee: Shut up, yeah it's just gonna work out.
- 31:23Sam Rhee: I had to tell myself that that's hard.
- 31:26David Syvertsen: And if it's an everyday, you got that one next to your name, one next to your name.
- 31:29David Syvertsen: Oh, I crushed that person in the open.
- 31:30David Syvertsen: Why are they doing one?
- 31:31David Syvertsen: I'm doing two.
- 31:31David Syvertsen: You know it's like that.
- 31:33David Syvertsen: It can get us.
- 31:34David Syvertsen: It can create issues that don't currently exist right now.
- 31:37David Syvertsen: You know it's a quote Ryan Radcliffe like is that net negative or net positive?
- 31:41David Syvertsen: There are positives that will come from this.
- 31:44David Syvertsen: There are negatives, which one is more?
- 31:46David Syvertsen: And that's basically what needs to make the decision on whether or not we do level workouts from here on out.
- 31:52David Syvertsen: The last thing I wanna say is that, before we wrap this up is, I don't want this to turn into every single workout that's gonna have levels.
- 31:58David Syvertsen: There are, like, what if the workout is seven minutes of burpees?
- 32:01David Syvertsen: Like you're gonna make level one do eight minutes and level three do five, because now you're really fracturing the gym.
- 32:07David Syvertsen: You know a lot of rep schemes and workouts have flow to them, like numerically there's mathematical relationships between schemes and numbers and you know we're not gonna make 21, 15, nine that's Fran, but level one.
- 32:19David Syvertsen: You're doing 24, 17, 11,.
- 32:21David Syvertsen: You know, with 100 pounds instead of like you're starting to get away from the togetherness.
- 32:25David Syvertsen: So it can't be an everyday thing, it can't be an every movement thing.
- 32:29David Syvertsen: Most of it would center around loads on the barbell and then complexity of gymnastics, but everything else, I think, would remain the same.
- 32:38David Syvertsen: So again, this is just an ongoing topic in my head.
- 32:41David Syvertsen: I've had a lot of conversations with people.
- 32:43David Syvertsen: I always want feedback, because I do.
- 32:46David Syvertsen: At the end of the day, the people determine what we're gonna do.
- 32:48David Syvertsen: You know, if everyone hates it, we don't do it.
- 32:50David Syvertsen: But you know we've talked about this with MastersRX.
- 32:52David Syvertsen: You know a lot of people come at different angles.
- 32:54David Syvertsen: There are people passionately on both sides because it makes them feel good, it makes them feel bad and again, majority rules in a lot of cases in it.
- 33:02David Syvertsen: So your opinion matters to me on this subject.
- 33:05David Syvertsen: Do you like the idea of levels?
- 33:07David Syvertsen: Is it too complex?
- 33:08David Syvertsen: Does it make your decision making easier or harder?
- 33:11David Syvertsen: Does it make it easier to get to your next level?
- 33:14David Syvertsen: Fitness?
- 33:14David Syvertsen: Does it impact your ego, your decision making?
- 33:17David Syvertsen: All that?
- 33:18Sam Rhee: I do appreciate the fact that, as a programmer, you're taking on these different variations and challenges because it's time consuming.
- 33:24Sam Rhee: Yeah, if you wanted to go easy, you would just be like, why bother, let me just stick to RX scale.
- 33:29Sam Rhee: We know that works.
- 33:30Sam Rhee: I do appreciate this.
- 33:32Sam Rhee: I know I'm gonna take a lot as an athlete out of trying levels.
- 33:35Sam Rhee: I may effing hate it, but at that point.
- 33:38Sam Rhee: But regardless the fact that if you as a gym or as a programmer want to experiment with this and see if it works for you, that I think we can all appreciate is an effort that is worthwhile trying.
- 33:51David Syvertsen: Absolutely All right.
- 33:51David Syvertsen: Thank you guys.
- 33:52David Syvertsen: We'll see you next week.
- 33:54David Syvertsen: Thank you everybody for taking the time out of your day to listen to the Herdfit podcast.
- 33:58David Syvertsen: Be on the lookout for next week's episode.