Latest / Together 4 Good: Making Sense of Life and Faith / Midsummer Reflection: what we are learning from the Nones
Transcript
- 0:04Welcome to the Together for Good Podcast, a podcast specifically
- 0:07designed to inspire, challenge and uplift you during your daily
- 0:10walk of faith. Friends, we're about midway
- 0:13through the summer. Can you believe it?
- 0:15In Denver, it finally stopped raining and starting to feel
- 0:18like actual summer. But as a part of this, I wanted
- 0:22to take a little bit of a break and just give you some
- 0:25reflections on what I've been hearing from these conversations
- 0:29we've been sharing on the podcast all summer long.
- 0:32So this is sort of a review, but also hopefully to point out some
- 0:36of the things I heard in my conversation with Shelly and
- 0:39with Andy and Coach Jen about why they no longer go to church.
- 0:44If you've missed any of those episodes, be sure to check back
- 0:46in the feed or if you just want to press on, you'll get a good
- 0:49summary and sense of some of the things that those 3 individuals
- 0:52said. This is just my reflections, but
- 0:55I'm also giving an eye towards what should the church be doing
- 1:00in light of what we're hearing from those who have left?
- 1:03What could we emphasize more strongly?
- 1:06What could we guard against? Where have we failed?
- 1:09I think this is an important thing for us to consider.
- 1:12Hopefully also it gives you a better sense of why I've been
- 1:15sharing these nun conversations with people who have no
- 1:19religious affiliation. I hope you enjoy it.
- 1:21It's something a little different.
- 1:23Be on the lookout for more interviews in the weeks ahead.
- 1:26But now, some reflections on the first half of these summer
- 1:30podcasts. Friends, we're about midway
- 1:37through the summer, and as you probably noticed here on this
- 1:40podcast feed, I have been conducting a series of
- 1:43interviews over the course of this summer with a lot of my
- 1:46longtime friends about their experience in the church.
- 1:50And in particular, I'm seeking out individuals who have no more
- 1:54connection to a church, who don't attend regularly, a series
- 1:58that we're affectionately calling the nuns NONES.
- 2:03And in the course of these interviews, I thought it might
- 2:06be smart here in the middle of summer to just stop and to sort
- 2:10of reorient ourselves, to summarize a little bit of what
- 2:14we heard, but to also help us think about what we should be
- 2:18taking away from these different interviews.
- 2:21I had some people asking, like, hey, why are you doing this?
- 2:24And so I thought, hey, why not make a podcast episode Exactly
- 2:27about why I'm doing this and what I think is important that
- 2:30we can learn together as people of faith through these different
- 2:34conversations that I've recorded and shared with all of you.
- 2:37Additionally, I'll confess I am having trouble at the moment
- 2:41lining up the next people to interview, so there was sort of
- 2:45a gap in the schedule here. I do have, I think three to four
- 2:49more none interviews if I can convince these people to come on
- 2:54the podcast and or get our schedules aligned.
- 2:58So stay tuned for more. But this is sort of the
- 3:00Midsummer break as we investigate and rethink so to
- 3:03this point. And here's the nice thing too.
- 3:05If you haven't been listening to the Together for good podcast
- 3:08and you've missed those previous interviews interviews, I mean,
- 3:11what have you been doing? But no, there's grace abounds.
- 3:15This is a nice summary for you as well, where you can kind of
- 3:18be like, oh, that's what that's about.
- 3:19And if something sounds interesting, I do encourage you
- 3:20to go back in the feed and listen to some of those older
- 3:24conversations that we have there.
- 3:26But I think the way to really look at as we continue through
- 3:30the summer and as we reflect on what we've already heard, I hope
- 3:33that as people who maybe attend church on a regular basis, I
- 3:37think that's the majority of our audience.
- 3:40For us to listen to these stories and think and be honest
- 3:43about the ways that the church has failed some of these people.
- 3:47To also think about what we can be guarding against in the
- 3:50future. And to really think about how we
- 3:53can present ourselves differently so that we're
- 3:56emphasizing the types of things that really matter to people as
- 4:00opposed to maybe, you know, less emphasis on the stuff that has
- 4:05scared people away from church. So those are kind of the three
- 4:09pieces that I'm using to frame this conversation that we're
- 4:13having here today, the three pieces that I'm using to
- 4:16understand also what we've heard already.
- 4:19So in particular, how have we failed individuals?
- 4:22As you listen to the conversations that I've had with
- 4:24Shelley and Andy and Coach Jen, you heard specifically from
- 4:30Coach Jen. She talked a lot about the
- 4:33hypocrisy of Christians a lot of the time and how people will
- 4:38take certain things for granted and and they'll take certain
- 4:40truths and act certain ways at church and then behave
- 4:43completely differently. And they'll even, you know,
- 4:46maybe receive God's grace for themselves and and and talk
- 4:49about what a gift that is for their life.
- 4:50But then have no capacity towards sharing that grace with
- 4:53others. And I think that's such an
- 4:55incredible insight for us to really think about is the ways
- 4:59that the things we say at church, that the things that we
- 5:02know are true about God will. Hopefully we are conduits of
- 5:07those truths. Hopefully we are carrying
- 5:09forward into the world the very nature of God's character.
- 5:13I'm not saying that we become godly ourself, but that we have
- 5:17a duty to reflect what we've received from God.
- 5:21In the Lutheran Church, there's a really common phrase that
- 5:23appears. There's a lot of Lutheran
- 5:25theological writing and in particular, different documents,
- 5:28et cetera, And it talks about how Our Calling is always in
- 5:33light of and in response to God's grace.
- 5:36So it always starts with grace, what God does for us first.
- 5:39But then in light of that grace, and in response to that grace,
- 5:43we should care for others, do good works in the world.
- 5:49There's always this weird balance between good works and
- 5:52God's grace. And what I think we can often
- 5:55fall into is this trap of thinking that because of God's
- 5:59grace, we don't have to do good works at all.
- 6:01And certainly there's writing from Martin Luther himself where
- 6:04he talks about good works are not what earn you salvation,
- 6:07right? No, it is a gift from God.
- 6:10However, Luther also writes about how in light of and in
- 6:14response to God's grace, we need to serve our neighbors.
- 6:17We need to act with love and compassion, the same love and
- 6:20compassion that we ourselves have received.
- 6:23We have a responsibility to carry that forward into the
- 6:25world. And so imagine, you know, if the
- 6:27if the church acted more like this, if the church was more
- 6:31reflective of God's grace and less hypocritical, how much
- 6:35different would the world be? Who?
- 6:36Who would still be involved in church communities if we could
- 6:41act in this way? See, these are the reasons we
- 6:43have these conversations, is for us to ask the hard questions of
- 6:46ourself and to really think about our responsibility as a
- 6:50Christian. If we're going to claim that
- 6:51identity and title for ourself, well then how should we respond
- 6:55and how should we behave? And how has that title in the
- 6:59past gone awry for different people, different churches,
- 7:02different situations? The other piece that I kind of
- 7:06mentioned is that we can be thinking about what we can guard
- 7:10against. This is very similar to that
- 7:12question of how has the Church failed?
- 7:14But in the course of these conversations with people who
- 7:17are no longer connected with the church, we heard about insisting
- 7:20on the rules. This is something that that
- 7:22interview with Shelly that came up where she grew up in the
- 7:26Catholic Church and had there was so much emphasis for her on
- 7:28the rules and the things that she needed to do.
- 7:30And finally, one day, she just said, like, wait a second, like,
- 7:33why do I have to do all of this stuff now?
- 7:36I'm not lobbying for a complete just like, expulsion of any and
- 7:41all rules or expectations, right?
- 7:44This kind of goes hand in hand with what I was saying before,
- 7:47but it's in light of and in response to God's grace.
- 7:50And So what if the church emphasized rules less?
- 7:54Again, I'm not not lobbying for anarchy or anything like that,
- 7:59but but historically there has been such an emphasis on morals,
- 8:02and not even on morals necessarily, but also on on just
- 8:07certain expectations like, oh, you have to dress up to go to
- 8:10church. Oh, like, you better do things
- 8:12the right way when you're in this church building.
- 8:15And I understand, but that's really important to some people,
- 8:17you know, having a sense of the sacred and honoring God through
- 8:22the ways that we present ourselves.
- 8:24I understand why that's so important for certain people.
- 8:27And yet, in the same moment, I can also see how that can feel
- 8:30like such a turnoff to folks who just want a place where they
- 8:33feel like they can belong, who are having a really hard time in
- 8:37their life. And for them to walk into our
- 8:39doors and then feel like, gosh, like everyone was judging me
- 8:42because I didn't know when to stand up or when to sit down or
- 8:45I accidentally dropped my wafer in the communion cup like that.
- 8:49That can really leave a negative imprint on people.
- 8:51And it's a way where we are not being incredibly, you know,
- 8:55really welcoming to those who God sends our way.
- 8:59And I really do believe that that the people who walk through
- 9:01our doors are sent by the Holy Spirit and that we have a
- 9:03responsibility to welcome them. It says that even in the
- 9:07scriptures that when we welcome strangers, some have entertained
- 9:10angels in their presence. Also kind of thinking on the
- 9:13insisting on the rules, I'm reminded of sorry mom, I don't
- 9:21know if you're listening or not, but I am reminded of how I was
- 9:24always forced to wear my church shoes and that there were church
- 9:27shoes that I hated to wear as a kid.
- 9:29It was my least favorite part. I didn't want to go to church
- 9:32because I had to wear those stupid church shoes.
- 9:35And as soon as I would get in the Pew, I would take my shoes
- 9:37off. And if then, my mother would
- 9:41often be horribly embarrassed that I was there without shoes
- 9:44on in my stocking feet. And so it was always this mad
- 9:47scramble for me to get my shoes on so I could go up for
- 9:49communion. Because the worst thing that
- 9:51could happen would be that I'd go up for communion without
- 9:53shoes on in my stocking feet. And, you know, and that leaves a
- 9:57negative imprint. What was that teaching me?
- 10:00In those moments when we emphasize the rules so
- 10:03stringently, what message does that often convey?
- 10:09Again, in retrospect, I understand a lot of it, and I
- 10:12understand why people really care about how we present
- 10:16ourselves to the world and how we present ourselves in God's
- 10:19house, as some people would call it.
- 10:21And in the same sense, what if we didn't put quite as much a
- 10:24premium on it? What if the premium was much
- 10:26more so? Unwelcome And hospitality and
- 10:29care for the stranger or the newcomer in our midst.
- 10:33How much differently would the church look if that's what we
- 10:37focused on? That's what we emphasized.
- 10:41Another piece attached to this that we heard in my conversation
- 10:45with Coach Jen was about the insistence on shame.
- 10:48And Coach Jen really talked about that, about how a lot of
- 10:51her experience growing up in the church seemed to to tell her
- 10:54that she needed to get in line and do these types of things.
- 10:58And so it became really difficult for her to go back to
- 11:01church when she knew that she hadn't lived up to those moral
- 11:05expectations that were drilled within her during her youth.
- 11:09Then she suddenly didn't want to go back and step into a church
- 11:12environment when she was in college because she knew all
- 11:15these ways that she had failed. Again, I'm not lobbying for
- 11:19complete anarchy and no sense of rules or expectations.
- 11:23But what if the focus was much more so on this gift of grace
- 11:28that we've received, on this gift of grace that God is
- 11:31continually trying to offer us? What if?
- 11:35And couldn't that be more formative as well for someone
- 11:39who's made mistakes rather than feeling like because of their
- 11:43mistakes, that can no longer walk through church doors?
- 11:46What if they could come here, mistakes in all, and then hear a
- 11:49message of God's grace? How much more transformative
- 11:52might that be for them, For them to realize that they are loved
- 11:55and expected despite their worst moments that they've had, that
- 12:00that doesn't preclude them from this community and from this
- 12:03love of God? Couldn't that inherently also
- 12:06change their behavior, Transform them inside and out to say like,
- 12:09no, I no longer want to be the person who does XY&Z when we
- 12:13insist on shame. I don't think it's as effective
- 12:16for transforming behavior either in a real practical sense.
- 12:22So I do. Yeah, we're hitting on a
- 12:25continual themes here, but how much different would the church
- 12:28look? How many more people would still
- 12:30be involved if our emphasis was on welcome, hospitality, love
- 12:34and grace, and helping people to know that they are so much more
- 12:39than their worst moment or their last mistake?
- 12:44Another piece within all of this, something that we can
- 12:48really be thinking about it is inauthentic behavior.
- 12:53This is a part that we heard from my friend Shelly.
- 12:56Or sorry, not from my friend Shelly, but from my friend Andy,
- 12:59who grew up in the church and his dad was one of the pastors.
- 13:03And one of his experiences in that setting was also how people
- 13:09treated him differently and had different expectations for him.
- 13:12Because he was the pastor's son and he just didn't like the way
- 13:16that so much of it didn't feel real or didn't.
- 13:19He didn't feel like people actually knew him for who he
- 13:22was, they only knew him for their expectations.
- 13:25Similarly, Coach Jen kind of also touched on this with her
- 13:29talk about hypocrisy, about how people would present one way at
- 13:32church but then be something completely different during the
- 13:35week we need to church should be a place where we can be ourself
- 13:40hopefully, and be accepted for who we are.
- 13:43Inauthentic behavior is also the product of people thinking that
- 13:46they have to be a certain way in order to be present in a church
- 13:49environment. People thinking that they have,
- 13:52you know that there are these list of expectations and so they
- 13:55better not let anyone see their rough edges because if they do
- 13:59then they will suddenly no longer be welcome in this space.
- 14:03It's a tough balance. It's a really, it takes a lot of
- 14:05courage and vulnerability, but I think that it's something really
- 14:09important for churches, for Christians to consider.
- 14:12How can you be most fully yourself?
- 14:14Because you know that's who God created you to be, and that's
- 14:17who God loves. Is you the true you, not some
- 14:22sort of mask that you're putting on in order to fit in or to feel
- 14:27accepted? And OK, we need to cultivate
- 14:30greater authenticity within all of our church spaces.
- 14:33I think moving on to this sense of what can we present
- 14:39differently? Or rather like, what should the
- 14:41church be emphasizing? I guess I've been touching on
- 14:43this already, but I do think that there's something
- 14:46interesting about the search for truth.
- 14:50Shelly talked about how she was kind of put off in some ways by
- 14:56how church was always presenting itself as true, so to speak.
- 15:01And for her, as a scientist, this was really just hard to
- 15:04connect and reconcile because there was for her a lot of
- 15:08things that her logical brain was, was not jiving with what
- 15:13she was hearing in church. She, you know, was using her
- 15:16scientist brains and like, wait, but how can that be true?
- 15:18Can how can this be true? And I think a really important
- 15:21thing for churches to emphasize, for Christians to emphasize too,
- 15:24is that we do have truth. It's a capital T truth, and that
- 15:29doesn't necessarily work the same as scientific or historical
- 15:35truth with a lowercase T So much of what the Scriptures tell us
- 15:42of what our experience of the life of faith, it works on a
- 15:45different level than the tivic scientific method that we have
- 15:49today. And that's OK.
- 15:51I don't think we should be afraid of that.
- 15:54This book, this collection of stories, has been giving
- 15:56people's life meaning and direction and purpose for
- 16:01thousands of years. There is real truth within there
- 16:05about what it means to be human, how to exist within this world,
- 16:09purpose for our life. And so if we can focus more on
- 16:13that and not try and get pulled into these debates, there's
- 16:17always these debates like science versus religion.
- 16:20And I really think that the two can easily coexist together
- 16:24because they're kind of talking about different pieces of
- 16:27things. Science is something that God
- 16:30has given us, the human capacity to understand the inner workings
- 16:35of the universe on a cellular and galactic level.
- 16:38It's amazing. And those things don't have to
- 16:42be negated by the truths of the scriptures that tell us about a
- 16:46loving God who creates us, who gives our life meaning, purpose,
- 16:50and direction, who continually is working to save us and God's
- 16:54people. There's just a different way of
- 16:57kind of understanding these sacred stories that we have that
- 17:01in no way needs to conflict with science.
- 17:03I think some people, like Shelly, get turned off by the
- 17:07church because the church continues to insist that they
- 17:10have to turn off their scientific brain.
- 17:12It's one thing I love about the Lutheran Church, because I think
- 17:14we do a really good job of holding all of these things
- 17:18together, of recognizing that truth can have a scientific and
- 17:23historical realm and truth can have a a spiritual realm as
- 17:29well. That's just as important and
- 17:32just as meaningful as those other pieces.
- 17:35OK, another person. Part of all of this, right, in
- 17:39terms of what the church should emphasize, I think is the
- 17:41empowering of others. We heard this from my
- 17:44conversation with Andy. In the course of that, Andy
- 17:47talked about how he was empowered by the director of
- 17:52this summer camp to work on staff one summer.
- 17:54He hadn't considered at all of that as a possibility for his
- 17:58life. And then that became ended up
- 18:00becoming a very important part of his story.
- 18:03He worked at summer camp for six years and even contemplated
- 18:07going off to seminary to continue doing ministry work.
- 18:10And so it just goes to show you how incredible changes in
- 18:15people's life can happen when we simply ask, when we say to a
- 18:18person, hey, I see this gift within you, that's something
- 18:21that the church needs to be doing again and again.
- 18:23That's how people will stay involved and connected.
- 18:27I wonder. I didn't get a chance to ask
- 18:29Andy this question. I didn't think to do it.
- 18:31But if if if this person Jessica, hadn't reached out and
- 18:35asked him to be on staff that summer, would he have left the
- 18:38church a lot sooner? Would that have kind of been the
- 18:40end of his connection with the Christian faith in ministry?
- 18:44I venture to guess there's a real possibility that that would
- 18:47be true. And so the more that the church
- 18:49can do to see gifts in young people and in anyone, frankly,
- 18:54not just young people, but to see gifts, to call them out, to
- 18:57affirm them, and to try and give people really practical places
- 19:00where they can then put those gifts into action.
- 19:03What an incredibly powerful thing we can do to continue to
- 19:07keep people connected to our communities.
- 19:11Speaking of community, that's also just a piece that we heard
- 19:14in all three people's stories. They all talked about how one of
- 19:19the ways they continue to be a spiritual person is through
- 19:22their friends, their relationships, their community.
- 19:24There really is something sacred and holy about having a group of
- 19:29people, having a community to connect to and belong to.
- 19:33Coach Jen talked a little bit about how she has that community
- 19:37today, and so she really doesn't feel like there's anything she's
- 19:40missing by not going to church. But but she does think if she
- 19:44didn't have such an incredible group of people around her, that
- 19:48maybe she would be looking for a church community, for that place
- 19:51to build those important relationships, those authentic
- 19:54relationships. And so the more that the church
- 19:57can do this, the more that we can create spaces where people
- 20:00can feel like they belong, like they have friends who care about
- 20:04them, the more that we can create real, authentic
- 20:07community. The more we're doing the work
- 20:09that God has called us to and the more connected people will
- 20:13feel and going along with connection.
- 20:15That's a big part of what Shelly talked about too, was the
- 20:18importance of connection and a place for depth.
- 20:22She really loves being able to have those deeper conversations
- 20:26about the nature of life, the mysteries of what it means to be
- 20:30human, those you know pieces, those deeper conversations that
- 20:33the Bible leads us into all the time.
- 20:36Shelley loves being able to have those conversations with other
- 20:39people. And so the more that the church,
- 20:41I think, can Createspace for that, for us to get below the
- 20:44surface, for not just to be like, hey, crazy weather we've
- 20:47been having lately, hey, where are you going on vacation this
- 20:50week? All that's good, that's the
- 20:52ground level. But the more that we can
- 20:55Createspace, for people to really dig in to what's going on
- 20:58in their hearts, what's going on in their life that they really
- 21:01care about and want to process with someone else, all of that
- 21:06are things I believe that the church could really be doing a
- 21:09better job of would be be emphasizing more.
- 21:12Not that we're doing a bad job of it here at Bethany in
- 21:15particular. I think there's a lot we have to
- 21:16be proud of when I point this all out.
- 21:18But just as I reflect on these conversations and on the way
- 21:22that the church is presenting itself to the world as a whole,
- 21:25these are the things that I'm seeing, that that I hope we can
- 21:29continue here at Bethany and in other congregations and just in
- 21:32our life as Christians as well. Ways that we can push forward,
- 21:38an expression of the church that will be more meaningful for
- 21:42people, that will be a place they want to embrace and be a
- 21:47part of and hold up. So there you go.
- 21:51There's A Midsummer update, everyone.
- 21:53There's some thoughts on my conversations with Shelly and
- 21:56Andy and Coach Jen. Again, if you missed any of them
- 21:59and you want to listen there just back further in the feed,
- 22:01feel free to check it out and be on the lookout for further
- 22:05interviews with the nuns. Maybe at the end of the summer.
- 22:08I'll try and do another recap if I hear anything new from my
- 22:11additional interviews coming up in the weeks and months ahead.
- 22:15But as always, friends, thanks for listening for your support
- 22:18of the podcast. Stay in peace.