Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Pedaling Profit: The Economic Case for Paid Cycling
Transcript
- 0:10You pull into an empty space, turn off the ignition, and you
- 0:12think you know. Great free parking.
- 0:14Right. It feels like a win.
- 0:16Yeah, it feels like a minor daily victory, but that little
- 0:19rectangle of asphalt is actually costing your city and well up to
- 0:23$70,000. Which is wild when you actually
- 0:25break the numbers down. It really is.
- 0:27So welcome to the deep dive. Whether you are, you know,
- 0:30prepping for a local City Council meeting or you're just
- 0:33insanely curious about how cities actually work behind the
- 0:36scenes, we're going to completely flip your perspective
- 0:38on parking today. You really are.
- 0:40OK, let's unpack this. We are looking at a stack of
- 0:43sources today. We've got a 2020 report on the
- 0:46City of Vancouver Sustainable Commuting program.
- 0:49Some really eye opening economic papers from Transport from
- 0:53London and global data from the Institute for Transportation and
- 0:56Development Policy. And the main focus here, the
- 0:58primary goal of this deep dive, is explaining exactly how
- 1:02municipalities can use parking fees to, you know, directly
- 1:06finance incentives for sustainable transportation.
- 1:09Right. And we're analyzing the massive,
- 1:11completely surprising financial advantages this creates for the
- 1:15city itself, because I've got the perfect expert with me to
- 1:18connect the dots between urban geography and municipal
- 1:22economics. Well, thanks.
- 1:23And you know, while parking seems like this incredibly
- 1:26boring necessity, it is actually this massive untapped financial
- 1:30lever. It can totally reshape how a
- 1:33city breathes and functions. So let's start with the baseline
- 1:36problem, the hidden economics of quote UN quote, free parking.
- 1:41I mean, free parking is incredibly expensive for the
- 1:43municipality and it fundamentally contradicts
- 1:45climate goals. There's this concept, the high
- 1:48cost of free parking from urban planners like Donald Shupe.
- 1:52And I think like this free parking is like going to an all
- 1:54you can eat buffet where even if you just drink a glass of tap
- 1:57water, you're still secretly paying the $30 cover charge.
- 2:00Right, it's just hidden. Hidden in your taxes, your rent,
- 2:04everything. What's fascinating here is when
- 2:05you look at real world data, So Vancouver city staff is a
- 2:09perfect case study. Right now, about 46% of their
- 2:13staff drive a loan to work, and the city provides about 4000 of
- 2:18its own employees with access to free parking.
- 2:21Which sounds like a nice perk. It does, but let's do the
- 2:23staggering math on this Every single undeveloped parking stall
- 2:28in Vancouver requires between 180 and 350 square feet.
- 2:33Wow, OK. And in that real estate market,
- 2:36each spot is worth between 36,000 and $70,000.
- 2:40Wait, really? A single parking spot.
- 2:42A single spot. So by offering this free perk,
- 2:45the city is essentially paying about $7,000,000 a year in
- 2:49opportunity cost. Just to store.
- 2:50Cars just to store empty cars. Yeah.
- 2:52And it gets worse. By subsidizing this, they are
- 2:55encouraging their own staff to live further away.
- 2:58All right. Because you can just drive in
- 2:59for free. Exactly.
- 3:01So these employees live in the suburbs, pay their property
- 3:03taxes to a different municipality, and then drive
- 3:06into Vancouver, bringing congestion and pollution with
- 3:08them. So the city is paying $7,000,000
- 3:10a year to pollute its itself and lose tax revenue.
- 3:13Basically yes. OK, so if giving away parking is
- 3:17financially draining the city and causing all this traffic,
- 3:20how can a municipality ethically reverse this without causing a
- 3:25massive employee revolt? Well, this leads us to the
- 3:27mechanism of funding sustainable transit.
- 3:30Flipping the script, essentially the Vancouver Sustainable
- 3:33Commuting Program, the SCP proposed a solution.
- 3:37They had a program deficit of up to $1.6 million for green
- 3:42incentives and. Nobody wants to raise general
- 3:44taxes for that. Exactly.
- 3:45So instead of raising taxes, they just charge a modest fee
- 3:48for those formerly free staff parking spots, like $10 a month,
- 3:53or even better, a daily rate of $0.50 to $5.
- 3:56Here's where it gets really interesting because they collect
- 3:58those fees, right? And then they use that exact
- 4:01revenue to fund tangible rewards for the non drivers.
- 4:04Let's close loop. Yeah, carrots and sticks.
- 4:06If you walk or bike, you get up to $50.00 a month in gift cards
- 4:09through platforms like gorka dot dot com or you get up to a 20%
- 4:14transit rebate. And this isn't just a theory, it
- 4:16works. A great historical example is
- 4:18the Seattle Children's Hospital. Oh.
- 4:20Right, the 1994 data. Yeah, in 1994, seventy, 8% of
- 4:25their staff drove alone, 78%. That is a lot of cars.
- 4:29So they started charging staff for parking but, and this is
- 4:32crucial, they only allowed daily rates.
- 4:36To avoid the sunk cost fallacy. Exactly, if you pay for a
- 4:39monthly pass you have that mentality of well I already paid
- 4:42for the month so I might as well drive.
- 4:44Right. Even if it's a nice day and you
- 4:45kind of want to ride your bike. Precisely so.
- 4:47Daily rates only, and they offered a $3.50 daily commute
- 4:51bonus for active transit. So you wake up and say do I pay
- 4:535 bucks today or do I make 350? Yes, the friction is intentional
- 4:57and by 2019 they dropped their drive alone rate to just 33%.
- 5:02That is a massive behavioral shift.
- 5:04Yeah, but wait people, I hate losing perks.
- 5:07I mean, status quo bias is real. Won't employees fight this tooth
- 5:10and nail? Well, humans naturally resist
- 5:13change. That's a given, and that's why
- 5:15the sources point to Copenhagen's model.
- 5:17OK, how do they handle it? They didn't do it overnight.
- 5:19They remove about two to 3% of parking spaces every single
- 5:23year. Oh, so it's gradual.
- 5:24Very gradual, they slowly wean the public off auto dependency
- 5:28while incrementally raising parking costs in the city center
- 5:32to about $5.00 an hour. It's like boiling a frog, but
- 5:35you know, in a good eco friendly way.
- 5:37Exactly, it gives people time to adapt to the new transit
- 5:40features being built. OK, so paying employees to bikes
- 5:43sounds super nice for the employees, but what is in it for
- 5:46the city's bottom line? Like why should local government
- 5:49care about subsidizing bikes? This is where we get into the
- 5:52municipal goldmine. It's about space and efficiency,
- 5:55right? Remember those $70,000 parking
- 5:57stalls in Vancouver? Yeah, the second funding option
- 6:01for the city is divesting that real estate.
- 6:03Selling or repurposing just 6 to 44 underused parking stalls a
- 6:08year. Oh, wow.
- 6:09Because if you don't need them for cars, you can sell them,
- 6:11turn them into lay down yards, or use them for facility
- 6:14expansions. It creates massive municipal
- 6:17wealth or saves the city from having to buy new land.
- 6:20And the spatial efficiency is just crazy.
- 6:22You can fit what, like 10 bicycles into a single car
- 6:25parking space? Easily.
- 6:27And if we connect this to the bigger picture, the Transport
- 6:31for London or TfL data is stunning.
- 6:34They found that for every £1.00 spent on cycling infrastructure,
- 6:38there is a 13 LB return wait. Really a 13 to one ROI that is I
- 6:42mean what stock is giving you 13 to 1?
- 6:45Right. And it's because of jobs and
- 6:46local supply chains. Cycling infrastructure creates
- 6:49up to 34 local jobs per $1 million spent.
- 6:54Because it's local labor, right? Pouring concrete grade and
- 6:56sidewalk. Compared to just eight jobs for
- 6:59traditional Rd. spending which usually goes to huge non local
- 7:02heavy machinery firms. That makes total sense.
- 7:04But the other massive financial benefit is reducing congestion
- 7:07and wear and tear. Congestion costs London £9.5
- 7:11billion a year in lost productivity. 1.5 billion with
- 7:14AB. With AB and segregated, cycle
- 7:17lanes are just better at moving humans through tight spaces.
- 7:20During morning peak hours on Blackfriars bridge, the cycle
- 7:23lanes move 1938 people per hour OK.
- 7:26The adjacent car lanes, which are wider, only move 1542.
- 7:30The bikes literally just process more taxpayers to the same
- 7:33bottleneck. Yes, and furthermore a bicycle
- 7:36causes 165 thousandth the wear and tear on municipal roads
- 7:40compared to a car. 165 thousandth.
- 7:42Yes. So by moving people out of cars,
- 7:45you are drastically slashing the city's road maintenance budget.
- 7:48Potholes, asphalt patching, all of it goes down OK.
- 7:51So the city saves on real estate, Rd. maintenance and
- 7:55congestion, but what about the local economy?
- 7:58Because if I'm a local business owner, I want parking right out
- 8:00front so people can buy my stuff, right?
- 8:02That is the assumption, yes. Yeah.
- 8:03Taking away parking sounds like retail suicide.
- 8:06Doesn't losing parking kill local business?
- 8:08That is probably the biggest myth in urban planning.
- 8:11The TfL data completely dismantles this.
- 8:14They did a study on Lee Bridge Rd.
- 8:16OK. What happened there?
- 8:17The retailers perceive they genuinely believe that 63% of
- 8:21their customers drove to the shops, but when they actually
- 8:24measured it, only 20% did. Oh wow, that is a massive
- 8:27disconnect. It's the windshield perspective.
- 8:29The shop owner drives, so they assume everyone else drives.
- 8:32Exactly. And the reality is improving
- 8:35walking and cycling conditions actually boosts retail trade by
- 8:38up to 30%. I love this detail from the
- 8:41sources. The economics of the pedestrian.
- 8:44Customers who walk or cycle visit shops like 12 to 16 * a
- 8:49month. Yes, compared to just 8 visits
- 8:51for drivers. Because you know when you're
- 8:53walking the barrier to entry is 0.
- 8:55You see a bakery, you smell a croissant.
- 8:58You just walk. In right, you don't have to find
- 8:59a parking spot. And because of that frequency,
- 9:02walkers actually spend 40% more overall. 40% more, that's huge
- 9:06for a local business. It is Cycle parking delivers
- 9:08five times the retail spend per square meter compared to car
- 9:12parking. Plus, retail vacancies actually
- 9:14drop by 17% on streets with cycle infrastructure.
- 9:17So it's a total retail boom. It is, but this raises an
- 9:20important question What happens to a city's healthcare burden
- 9:23when its citizens physically move more?
- 9:25Oh, the health dividend. Yes, if every Londoner walked or
- 9:29cycled for just 20 minutes a day, just 20 minutes of
- 9:32incidental commuting, the NHS would save £1.7 billion / 25
- 9:37years. That is staggering just from a
- 9:40daily commute. Because it creates massive
- 9:42reductions in chronic illnesses. Type 2 diabetes drops by 35 to
- 9:4650%. Depression goes down.
- 9:49Alzheimer's rates decrease. And it makes sense, right?
- 9:51Because it's habituated. You don't have to force yourself
- 9:54to go to the gym, you just have to get to work.
- 9:56Exactly. It's baked into your day.
- 9:57And going back to how cities can track this using apps like gorka
- 10:01dot dot com, the point allocation is brilliant.
- 10:05It really is. Because transit users get 15
- 10:07points, bikers get 20, but walkers get 25 points.
- 10:12They reward Walker's the absolute most because a
- 10:15pedestrian takes up the least municipal space, only like 20
- 10:18square feet when moving, and cost the city the absolute least
- 10:22in infrastructure. They are essentially subsidizing
- 10:24the behavior that is most profitable for the municipality.
- 10:27So what does this whole mean? Let's synthesize this.
- 10:30We started by looking at a financial drain, subsidized
- 10:34space hogging, free parking, right?
- 10:36And we've seen how a city can transform that exact same space
- 10:39into a green funding engine. Just by charging a daily rate.
- 10:42Exactly. By charging a daily rate for a
- 10:45parking space, A city can actually pay its citizens to
- 10:48bike or walk. They drastically reduce Rd.
- 10:50maintenance. They boost local retail by 30%
- 10:54and they save billions in healthcare.
- 10:56And you know, it's important to remind people this isn't some
- 10:59ideological war on cars, right? Right.
- 11:01It is just smart, basic municipal economics.
- 11:05It's about recognizing that city streets are meant to move
- 11:08people, not store empty metal boxes.
- 11:10That is the perfect way to put it, and I want to leave you, our
- 11:13listener, with a final thought to Mull over today.
- 11:16If parking fees can entirely fund a city's green revolution
- 11:20while making citizens healthier and wealthier, what other quote
- 11:24UN quote free urban spaces are we completely mispricing right
- 11:27now? That's a great question.
- 11:29Right next time you walk past a massive half empty parking lot,
- 11:32ask yourself what could that space actually be doing for you?
- 11:36Thanks so much for joining us on this deep dive and keep
- 11:39questioning the world around you.