Latest / AV SuperFriends / AV SuperFriends: Off the Rails - Design Bid Build Litigate
Transcript
- 0:03>> Chris Dechter: This is AV Super Friends off the Rails, an almost
- 0:05regularly scheduled open discussion on audio and
- 0:08video in higher education. We'll sound off about
- 0:11our most brilliant ideas, our dumbest mistakes,
- 0:13and everything in between. And because this
- 0:15conversation will almost certainly go off the
- 0:17rails at some point, we'll end up covering just
- 0:19about everything else. And now, the AV Super
- 0:22Friends for November 7, 2025. It's the best
- 0:30sounding and most cross disciplined collaborative
- 0:32podcast in higher ed. This is the AV super friends
- 0:35off the rails, episode number 126.
- 0:38>> Marc Cholewczynski: There's no discipline here.
- 0:40>> Chris Dechter: Cross discipline. Broadcasting live from high atop
- 0:44the temporary scaffolding of your campus's multi
- 0:47phase learning innovation center and next to that
- 0:49fenced off mud pit formerly known as parking lot
- 0:5217, we're bringing you the latest in higher ed
- 0:55technology instructional spaces and the mysterious
- 0:57timeline of that capital project that was
- 0:59definitely going to break ground last summer.
- 1:01So grab your hardhat, grab your safety vest and
- 1:03your unapproved change order because it's time for
- 1:05another Friday afternoon podcast adventure with
- 1:07the AV Super Friends. Hello, and let's say hello
- 1:10to our panel. You can't say hello.
- 1:12>> Marc Cholewczynski: I said it. I beat you to it.
- 1:13>> Chris Dechter: Let's say hello to our panel of AV Super Friends.
- 1:17I'm going to say let's say hello and then I
- 1:19introduce you. We've done this a couple of times.
- 1:21>> Marc Cholewczynski: It's in the notes.
- 1:22>> Chris Dechter: Let's say hello to our panel with this. our first
- 1:27panelist leads a cross functional team dedicated
- 1:30to balancing the emotional and electrical needs of
- 1:33all classroom sources. He's a director of Holistic
- 1:36Input Management from Kansas City. Say hello to
- 1:38Mr. Jamie Reinhart.
- 1:40>> Jamie Rinehart: The secret to Yoga Cable Yoga. Cable yoga.
- 1:46>> Chris Dechter: Our next panelist is tasked with future proofing
- 1:48all pathways, both physical and philosophical. He
- 1:51spearheads the empty M before pulling campaign to
- 1:54promote conduit mindfulness. He's a chief conduit
- 1:57optimization officer from Corvallis, Oregon. Say
- 1:59hello to Mr. Mark Cholewczynski.
- 2:00>> Marc Cholewczynski: Hello there. basically what we're doing is we're
- 2:02taking all the conduits out. Just explore the
- 2:05space.
- 2:07>> Chris Dechter: Free air.
- 2:07>> Marc Cholewczynski: Free air.
- 2:09>> Jamie Rinehart: We just go.
- 2:10>> Craig Park: It's all wireless.
- 2:11>> Marc Cholewczynski: Just wild. They really just explore the
- 2:13capabilities. It's amazing.
- 2:15>> Chris Dechter: Our next panelist balances the acoustic energy of
- 2:18rooms and the emotional energy of faculty
- 2:20meetings. He once tuned a ceiling mic array using
- 2:23only intuition and the sound of disappointment.
- 2:25He's a senior manager for Environmental Echo and
- 2:28Reverb control from Greensboro, North Carolina.
- 2:30Say hello to Mr. Larry Darling.
- 2:32>> Larry Darling: Yep, it sounds about right. And it feels m about
- 2:34right.
- 2:35>> Chris Dechter: Perfect Our next panelist oversees Enterprise Wise
- 2:40and this Enterprise Wide initiatives to ensure
- 2:42that every network packet finds its ultimate
- 2:45purpose. He's a vice president of Strategic Signal
- 2:47Flow from Bowling Green, Kentucky. Say hello to
- 2:49Mr. Justin Rexing.
- 2:50>> Justin Rexing: Isn't that what a switch, does? Every Ethernet
- 2:53frame is charge potential on copper.
- 2:56>> Chris Dechter: That's it.
- 2:57>> Justin Rexing: That's all I'm.
- 2:57>> Jamie Rinehart: Yeah, but you're the vice president.
- 2:59>> Marc Cholewczynski: Vice president of Q.
- 3:00>> Chris Dechter: That's your job.
- 3:01>> Larry Darling: Yeah.
- 3:03>> Justin Rexing: But there's things that do my job for me.
- 3:06>> Marc Cholewczynski: Don't tell people that. Yeah, come on.
- 3:08>> Larry Darling: that's what vice presidents do.
- 3:11>> Chris Dechter: Delegate. Delegate.
- 3:13>> Justin Rexing: Okay.
- 3:13>> Chris Dechter: And finally, joined by a special guest panelist
- 3:15who advises clients on the philosophical
- 3:17implications of placing a projector where a
- 3:20chandelier should be. He's a senior consultant for
- 3:22existential building Information modeling From
- 3:24Charleston, South Carolina. Say hello to Mr. Craig
- 3:26Park.
- 3:27>> Craig Park: Welcome and thank you for putting me on the show.
- 3:32>> Chris Dechter: All right, so, on today's show, we're going to
- 3:34discuss large capital projects and that process of
- 3:38working relationships with AV consultants and all
- 3:40that fun stuff and why you have to use AV over IP
- 3:43or else. True. That's literally what that article
- 3:47is just like. Yes, but first, a little bit of
- 3:51housekeeping.
- 3:52So, before we get buried under another round of
- 3:54change orders, let's talk about a little bit of
- 3:56logistics here. if you're listening to this As a
- 3:57recorded MP3, remember, we do stream live most
- 4:00Fridays. Almost every Friday. We missed a few here
- 4:02and there at about 3:15 Eastern, 12:15 Pacific, or
- 4:05whenever Justin finishes his sight walk. You can
- 4:07join us for that live on Twitter, LinkedIn or
- 4:09YouTube. If you can't make it road, or when
- 4:12Justin's on the way back from Cyclone. If you
- 4:16can't make it live, please, join us on the
- 4:17socials, follow us on Twitter, LinkedIn, Blue sky,
- 4:20and YouTube. And please spread the word. share the
- 4:22show with your friends, your colleagues, your
- 4:24project managers, any consultants you're working
- 4:25with, even the contractor who swears we'll get to
- 4:28it later because AV is part of phase six. and if
- 4:31you feel like tackling a few people on the job
- 4:33site and forcing them to listen to a few episodes,
- 4:35we support that initiative.
- 4:37>> Justin Rexing: What's phase five?
- 4:38>> Chris Dechter: Don't worry about that. Okay. it's not funded.
- 4:40>> Marc Cholewczynski: Don't worry.
- 4:41>> Chris Dechter: If you'd like to support our project, please
- 4:42consider donating your contributions help to keep
- 4:44us bringing you the honest content that you love
- 4:46or the you least love to value engineer. And if
- 4:49you can, you can find the donation link on the
- 4:50show notes, that you're listening to in this
- 4:51episode or on our website. we do want to hear from
- 4:53you. So if there's a topic you want us to cover,
- 4:55please send us an email to mailbag at
- 4:56AVSuperFriends or drop a comment on the
- 4:58aforementioned socials. And finally, while you're
- 5:01out there listening on YouTube, Spotify, Apple
- 5:03Podcasts, or wherever the heck you're listening to
- 5:05this thing, please leave a rating and review. It
- 5:06does force more people. People to see this. It
- 5:09pops to the top of their list, they get confused
- 5:11by the interesting show art, they click it, and
- 5:14all of a sudden they're listening to this
- 5:15nonsense. It's a trick, though.
- 5:17>> Marc Cholewczynski: We'd like to believe that.
- 5:18>> Jamie Rinehart: I mean, does any rating help the algorithm?
- 5:21>> Marc Cholewczynski: Anything?
- 5:21>> Chris Dechter: So yes, but don't be that guy. Good.
- 5:24>> Jamie Rinehart: It just matters if somebody interacts.
- 5:26>> Chris Dechter: Jamie, do not be a dick and vote us down. So.
- 5:29>> Justin Rexing: Oh my God, so sassy.
- 5:33>> Chris Dechter: So to answer the question, Jamie, yes, it does
- 5:36dramatically affect the. The algorithm by voting
- 5:39down. So. Yeah. Good Lord. Anyway, we've talked
- 5:45about this before. Okay.
- 5:46>> Jamie Rinehart: Certainly there in Wyoming.
- 5:48>> Chris Dechter: I'm just saying. I know where you're going with
- 5:50this.
- 5:50>> Larry Darling: Wow, it's snowing again.
- 5:53>> Chris Dechter: it is supposed to snow this weekend, so. Yes.
- 5:55>> Speaker G: So.
- 5:56>> Chris Dechter: All right, let's take a quick break and we're
- 5:59going to. Which one is this one?
- 6:01>> Justin Rexing: A break. We haven't done anything yet.
- 6:03>> Chris Dechter: Before we get to the news. Union, take a quick
- 6:05break.
- 6:05>> Marc Cholewczynski: This is union break.
- 6:07>> Justin Rexing: Union versus.
- 6:07>> Chris Dechter: We're going to run. This is a brand new
- 6:09commercial, never been heard on this show,
- 6:12debuting right now. oh, not that one.
- 6:16>> Justin Rexing: Okay.
- 6:19>> Speaker G: Are you tired of rigorous standards? Sick of
- 6:22engineers asking hard questions? Then say hello to
- 6:26AVSF Acknowledged, the industry's most prestigious
- 6:30certification program that tests absolutely
- 6:34nothing. That's right. Send us your gear. Any
- 6:37gear, from pliers to projectors. And after a brief
- 6:41inspection where we mutter things like looks good
- 6:43or sounds great or works just as you'd expect,
- 6:48boom. You're AVSF acknowledged. And manufacturers
- 6:53love it. Because nothing says quality like a
- 6:56rubber stamp, a paid invoice, and a vague review
- 6:59that reads like it was written by your cousin who
- 7:01borrowed the thing once. So don't waste time on
- 7:05peer review, lab conditions, or, heaven forbid,
- 7:08actual feedback. Join the growing list of proud
- 7:12partners already touting our meaningless seal of
- 7:15approval.
- 7:16>> Craig Park: AVSF accepted.
- 7:18>> Speaker G: Where credibility comes standard.
- 7:20>> Craig Park: For a small fee, an independent amalgamated joint.
- 7:27>> Marc Cholewczynski: It happened, Justin. It happened. You cannot hide
- 7:30from. Doesn't matter.
- 7:33>> Chris Dechter: There was a, there was an audio issue in that one.
- 7:35I'm not. I can fix that.
- 7:36>> Marc Cholewczynski: Yeah.
- 7:36>> Justin Rexing: Who's the second dude that chimed in?
- 7:38>> Chris Dechter: That's the second dude.
- 7:40>> Jamie Rinehart: That's Mr. Second Dilage. That.
- 7:42>> Marc Cholewczynski: That happened.
- 7:45>> Chris Dechter: All right, now, that said, you've waited for it
- 7:46all week or for like two weeks, Three weeks. It's
- 7:49been like three weeks since we've done this show.
- 7:50let's do the news. Justin, sing along. Yeah.
- 7:58>> Justin Rexing: Nothing is as good as the original.
- 8:01>> Chris Dechter: never. Yeah.
- 8:02>> Jamie Rinehart: Yeah.
- 8:02>> Chris Dechter: And this. This week's news comes from. Well, it
- 8:05comes from Biamp because it's.
- 8:06>> Marc Cholewczynski: That's all our news anymore.
- 8:07>> Chris Dechter: Technically a product announcement. this was
- 8:10announced at Infocom, but is now shipping and
- 8:11available in firmware. I think some of you said
- 8:13you're even messing with this right now. To test
- 8:14it out, I attempted to. So Biamp announced the
- 8:17newest firmware for, their parlay mics and their
- 8:20Forte X processors, which supports presenter lift,
- 8:23meaning voice lift. I presumably guided towards
- 8:26the presenter at the front of the room. But voice
- 8:27lift without needing to wear a microphone, which
- 8:29is a pretty slick feature. Other manufacturers
- 8:32have it as well, but pretty slick feature. They're
- 8:33adding this to the microphones you already have to
- 8:36provide increased voice lift for. Whether it's an
- 8:39ADA compliancy thing or you just want better audio
- 8:41in the room, or you want to make sure they get.
- 8:43They get heard. Or the ever popular. They got
- 8:45halfway through the lecture and they forgot to
- 8:47clip on the microphone. So at least there's
- 8:49something there. and because this is a free update
- 8:52to the mics you already have everyone go select
- 8:55everything in your Sage View console, click
- 8:57Update. Update right now.
- 8:58>> Marc Cholewczynski: Pow. Send it. Five, four. I. It's weird. Like, I
- 9:03was kind of intrigued by it when I saw it. I was
- 9:06like, oh, yeah, I kind of remember the whisperings
- 9:08about this. And it was like, oh, well, I guess
- 9:11I'll get that at some point. But then they kind of
- 9:13brought it back to my inbox. I was like, oh, yes,
- 9:15that. That's that thing. Let me. Let me force that
- 9:18to my sandbox.
- 9:19>> Chris Dechter: That's why they sent you. They sent me.
- 9:20>> Marc Cholewczynski: It reminded m. Me. I was like, cool. But I'm
- 9:23actually probably less concerned. Like the voice
- 9:27lift piece and more just like the tracking piece
- 9:29of it. Right? And so, like, more so how we're
- 9:33using our sandbox for, transcription and a lot of
- 9:37that stuff with our teams room environment. You
- 9:38can puke and whatever it is.
- 9:40>> Chris Dechter: But you mean like, forced? Like. Like directing
- 9:42the. The beams towards certain spaces? Is that
- 9:44what you're getting.
- 9:45>> Marc Cholewczynski: Yeah, like that, that whole piece. Because of the
- 9:48ability to get the meeting notes and all that.
- 9:51It's not about somebody on the far side or
- 9:53anything like that. I don't care about that.
- 9:54That's not what I'm really focusing on. I focus
- 9:56about being able to more reliably send this person
- 10:00to the machine learning piece of it. And that part
- 10:02and what additional capability I give now, you all
- 10:04can hate that and that's fine.
- 10:06>> Larry Darling: But I just think it's interesting how you've like
- 10:09completely like the analog space is no longer
- 10:13important. It's all about the data.
- 10:14>> Marc Cholewczynski: It is important, but there's only so much that we
- 10:17can talk about.
- 10:18>> Justin Rexing: Thank you, Larry.
- 10:19>> Jamie Rinehart: Yeah. Screw you people. You don't need anything m
- 10:22the people. You get the meeting notes later.
- 10:25>> Chris Dechter: Yeah, I'm not even paying attention because I know
- 10:26there's gonna be an AI summary.
- 10:28>> Justin Rexing: We don't care about our analog space. That's what
- 10:30the data.
- 10:31>> Marc Cholewczynski: Show me the data, Mark. Show it to me.
- 10:32>> Justin Rexing: It's right there.
- 10:33>> Marc Cholewczynski: I'm not saying ignore it together. I'm saying I'm
- 10:37intrigued by the ability for me to be able to more
- 10:41reliably provide that for transportation.
- 10:43>> Chris Dechter: What are you eating? And did you bring enough for
- 10:44everybody?
- 10:45>> Marc Cholewczynski: I did. It's my lunch. Sorry. so you act like
- 10:48you're in.
- 10:48>> Jamie Rinehart: A different time zone.
- 10:50>> Marc Cholewczynski: I'm not. I'm not. I'm actually on the east coast
- 10:52time zone. It's been a big lunch. no, no, I'm here
- 10:55with you guys. That's. At least that was my. My
- 11:00intrigue around the capability of that. And did it
- 11:04change how we would look at just our overhead
- 11:06microphones in that space and maybe we can get
- 11:08out. Get out of needing to have livelier
- 11:10microphones more so for just capturing
- 11:12conversation and idea and not necessarily for the
- 11:15remote delivery.
- 11:17>> Jamie Rinehart: So did you download this?
- 11:20>> Marc Cholewczynski: Yes.
- 11:20>> Jamie Rinehart: Did you try to use it?
- 11:21>> Marc Cholewczynski: I've not tried to use it. It's sitting on there. I
- 11:23have it. It's there. It's been. You have it?
- 11:25>> Jamie Rinehart: It's ready.
- 11:26>> Marc Cholewczynski: It's ready to go.
- 11:26>> Justin Rexing: Is it collecting metrics?
- 11:27>> Marc Cholewczynski: I hope so.
- 11:28>> Justin Rexing: Speak.
- 11:28>> Marc Cholewczynski: It's listening to us right now.
- 11:30>> Chris Dechter: It's aimed directly at the door into the restroom.
- 11:32>> Jamie Rinehart: As part of this. Right. They updated the software.
- 11:36Right. And they changed icons. It's different.
- 11:39Yeah. So, get ready. There's some things that are
- 11:42moved, and some things that they've. Some port.
- 11:46They. I now have new firewall, violations. So now
- 11:50I am unable to use this at the Moment. So double
- 11:54check it before you start pushing because I wanted
- 11:57to see how it worked. so I downloaded it to my
- 12:00test unit in the office and my computer said, oh,
- 12:03hell no.
- 12:05>> Justin Rexing: So the firewall in your computer?
- 12:07>> Jamie Rinehart: Yeah, it's just the enterprise management
- 12:10firewalls. I'm gonna have to.
- 12:11>> Chris Dechter: We can fix that real quick.
- 12:13>> Jamie Rinehart: The system changed and it's tagged as.
- 12:18>> Marc Cholewczynski: A different software now, so it doesn't, it thinks
- 12:20it's different.
- 12:21>> Jamie Rinehart: Yeah, it's probably something stupid just like
- 12:23that. I, I don't know. I, I tried it for about 15
- 12:26and a half seconds. it told me no and so I got mad
- 12:29and I left.
- 12:30>> Chris Dechter: You wanna, you wanna avoid stamp it.
- 12:32>> Marc Cholewczynski: You want to just accept it at least.
- 12:34>> Jamie Rinehart: Yeah. But so I did, I did attempt to use it. I
- 12:37couldn't, but I did notice that.
- 12:40>> Chris Dechter: Great feedback when I was, when I.
- 12:42>> Jamie Rinehart: Was looking for some of the parts. I'm like, oh, I
- 12:44just need to add my unit into the equipment. Wait,
- 12:47that's moved. Oh, wait. So give yourself a few
- 12:50minutes to reorient yourself with the new.
- 12:53>> Chris Dechter: Well, but importantly, Jamie, both you and Mark,
- 12:55you both said, I rolled this out on my test system
- 12:58and see how it goes. As opposed to my suggestion
- 13:01of select all update, roll it. Class starts in
- 13:06three minutes early in the day.
- 13:06>> Marc Cholewczynski: Do that. You got to wait till later on Friday to
- 13:08do.
- 13:09>> Chris Dechter: You can't just 8:57am pow.
- 13:12>> Marc Cholewczynski: I thought it was like 4:59 on Friday. Push it and
- 13:15that way it's ready to go.
- 13:15>> Chris Dechter: No, no, I want to be there to like to, to enjoy
- 13:18the fruits of my labor, to see all the spaces that
- 13:19have now been updated.
- 13:20>> Larry Darling: But you'll be there all, all weekend, so it'll be
- 13:22okay.
- 13:23>> Jamie Rinehart: Ah, I typically like to push that, you know, on
- 13:25Monday morning before I.
- 13:26>> Justin Rexing: Head out Friday and then go home and do your
- 13:29weekend stuff and then come in Monday for the
- 13:31surprise.
- 13:31>> Jamie Rinehart: Just wait for it. Just wait for it. I'll be
- 13:34interested to see how it works.
- 13:35>> Marc Cholewczynski: Yeah, yeah.
- 13:36>> Chris Dechter: I think anything that, that, that provides
- 13:39improved audio, whether it's in room or for
- 13:41meetings, especially low, low impact, low profile,
- 13:44sort of stuff like this. Which is one of the
- 13:45reasons that ceiling mics in general and as they
- 13:48have improved dramatically in the last, what, six
- 13:50to eight years sort of thing. Ceiling mics are
- 13:52great because you don't have to worry about
- 13:53getting it off the charger. You only worry about
- 13:55putting it on and clipping it on the right way or
- 13:57turning it on or unmute. It's just there. and the
- 14:00Audio may not be as good as somebody wearing a lav
- 14:03or holding a handheld appropriately, but. But this
- 14:07audio is way better than no audio. So.
- 14:10In fact, Jamie, just the other day I was telling
- 14:11someone about how we used to install the little,
- 14:14gooseneck, mics on each desk, which, which was not
- 14:17a great audio source, but it was way better than
- 14:19them doing their entire lecture and forgetting to
- 14:22wear a microphone. So at least they had some
- 14:23audio.
- 14:25>> Marc Cholewczynski: As they walk by.
- 14:26>> Larry Darling: Yeah.
- 14:27>> Marc Cholewczynski: This is what I sound like in that curve.
- 14:28>> Chris Dechter: That Doppler effect.
- 14:29>> Marc Cholewczynski: Exactly.
- 14:31>> Justin Rexing: So I thought that was spatial audio.
- 14:33>> Marc Cholewczynski: That was special with that is M.
- 14:36>> Chris Dechter: I'll run that one now. Don't help me.
- 14:38>> Justin Rexing: That's exactly what that is.
- 14:41>> Marc Cholewczynski: Yeah, I know. I think it's intriguing they're
- 14:43doing their.
- 14:44>> Chris Dechter: Part to push that out there. Added bonus to the
- 14:47mics you already have. Unless you're like me and
- 14:49you have. What did I count the other day? 600. And
- 14:50some of the, first generation, which point they
- 14:53were like, that don't qualify. You don't get that.
- 14:57>> Jamie Rinehart: The place where this would be the most useful, you
- 15:00can't use it. Can't use it.
- 15:02>> Larry Darling: Where would that be?
- 15:04>> Marc Cholewczynski: Everywhere.
- 15:04>> Jamie Rinehart: He has any space that this would be useful.
- 15:06>> Chris Dechter: All the rooms that have the dingly dangle golf
- 15:08ball.
- 15:09>> Jamie Rinehart: That have the dingly dingles.
- 15:10>> Larry Darling: Yes, true.
- 15:11>> Jamie Rinehart: All of the Christmas ornaments hanging out of the
- 15:13ceiling.
- 15:14>> Larry Darling: Oh, yes. I like those.
- 15:16>> Justin Rexing: We've even got rid of those. we have. We had rid
- 15:21of all those hanging mics. Yeah.
- 15:23>> Larry Darling: Do you have rooms without speakers? Why do you
- 15:25have mics?
- 15:26>> Chris Dechter: That's for recording.
- 15:29>> Craig Park: Wild.
- 15:29>> Justin Rexing: It's wild.
- 15:31>> Marc Cholewczynski: It's accessible.
- 15:32>> Chris Dechter: It's for voice lift. Larry.
- 15:34>> Craig Park: Yeah.
- 15:34>> Justin Rexing: We just assume our voice lift building over here.
- 15:37This is our building with no audio. This is, this
- 15:41is our building with 55 inch TVs in every room.
- 15:44>> Jamie Rinehart: It's presenter lift. They just grab hold and lift.
- 15:47>> Marc Cholewczynski: I recently came across the room we did long ago in
- 15:51that first rev of like the devios shipped and they
- 15:54had their own little dingle dangly microphone
- 15:56balls. But they looked so suspiciously similar to
- 15:59the other ones that came out. And then I had
- 16:01forgotten that they are not the same microphones.
- 16:04I was like, why are these not working? I think
- 16:06they did.
- 16:06>> Jamie Rinehart: They were not.
- 16:07>> Marc Cholewczynski: They are not at all the same microphone. No, the
- 16:09box looks the same. Everything except the text on
- 16:11them seems to be exactly the same. They're not.
- 16:14They don't work. So anyway, they made their way
- 16:17to.
- 16:17>> Chris Dechter: The added bonus for anybody with the, appropriate
- 16:19mics and DSP hardware free, feature, updates. So
- 16:22there you go. And a very cool feature by the way.
- 16:24So, other manufacturers do provide the same sort
- 16:27of capability and then there's also the places
- 16:29that just do it through, you know, right on the
- 16:31edge of ringing live mixing. Please don't do that.
- 16:34But I keep finding those,
- 16:35>> Marc Cholewczynski: Does it have the triangulation data path?
- 16:38>> Chris Dechter: The what? The analog ring version?
- 16:40>> Marc Cholewczynski: No, this, this software. Does it, does it give you
- 16:42steerability with other things?
- 16:44>> Larry Darling: Oh, for like cameras.
- 16:46>> Marc Cholewczynski: And that's why I didn't dig into that nuance.
- 16:48>> Chris Dechter: Yes, like the old version.
- 16:50>> Marc Cholewczynski: And sometimes there's ways to do it.
- 16:52>> Chris Dechter: I don't think it's built in way. But there are
- 16:54ways to do it. So.
- 16:55>> Marc Cholewczynski: Yeah, I know you can, you can build your own
- 16:57little Rube Goldberg thing.
- 16:58>> Jamie Rinehart: No.
- 16:58>> Marc Cholewczynski: Yeah, come on, man. I need to feed the machine.
- 17:02>> Jamie Rinehart: I can't even get it to work. And I'll tell you.
- 17:03No.
- 17:05>> Chris Dechter: Craig, let me throw it to you on this one. What
- 17:07are you seeing from the standpoint of projects? Is
- 17:10voice lift a request? Is voice lift a requirement?
- 17:14Is something like this adequate for providing in
- 17:17room voice lift to ensure you at least get some
- 17:19audio or what are your thoughts?
- 17:21>> Craig Park: Yes, probably in every project that has some
- 17:25either lecture capture or hybrid streaming
- 17:29component to the pedagogy that's happening in the
- 17:32classroom, Voicelift is a great solution. And
- 17:36certainly, as somebody said earlier, the quality
- 17:40of those ceiling mics has gotten to the point now
- 17:43where we can almost leave the acoustician out of
- 17:45the room. I don't want to ever say that out loud
- 17:48to my friends who are acousticians, but, it has
- 17:51gotten pretty incredible what you can do, with
- 17:54them, on pickup and to your point, to free the
- 17:58faculty from being able to wander without worrying
- 18:02about lavaliers or battery packs or anything else.
- 18:08>> Chris Dechter: Yeah, the battery pack one bit us the other day
- 18:10that they didn't put the mic back on the charging
- 18:13base. One of the few rooms that has a charging
- 18:14base took the mic off and it died in the middle of
- 18:16the thing. And then they were angry with. I'm
- 18:17like, I, I don't control chemical physics. But
- 18:20hey, ah, we have folks like.
- 18:23>> Marc Cholewczynski: It dies too fast. Like it lasts for four hours. So
- 18:25I don't know what you're talking about. Or six
- 18:27hours. Even some.
- 18:28>> Chris Dechter: The new lithium ones are like 12 to 16. It's still
- 18:31not the next day, which is the usual complaint I
- 18:33get kind.
- 18:34>> Craig Park: Of the room still wearing it.
- 18:35>> Marc Cholewczynski: Yeah, we always. Yeah, they'll walk out of the
- 18:37room and then, oh, it's gone.
- 18:38>> Chris Dechter: We'll put a new one in there.
- 18:39>> Marc Cholewczynski: A couple of days later. Oh, there's two mics in
- 18:40this room now.
- 18:42>> Chris Dechter: Trying to use both. It's louder. yeah. Usually the
- 18:46complaint we get is the battery's dead. It's the
- 18:48first class in the morning, the battery's dead
- 18:49again. I'm like, yeah, because the last person
- 18:50left it off. It doesn't work overnight.
- 18:52>> Marc Cholewczynski: Well, don't you parachute in at night and take
- 18:53care of that for them?
- 18:54>> Chris Dechter: Yeah, yeah, it's right at the top of my list. Get
- 18:57right to it. Yeah.
- 18:58>> Marc Cholewczynski: Okay, cool.
- 18:59>> Chris Dechter: All right, well, let's, let's close this one out.
- 19:01We'll take a quick break. We're gonna come back
- 19:02and we're talk with Craig in depth about lots of
- 19:04projects and how we wrangle all that stuff and
- 19:07trying to figure out that process and all sorts of
- 19:09fun topics here. So let's see.
- 19:11this one, the AV Super Friends, are sponsored by
- 19:16Computer Comforts Incorporated. CCI has been
- 19:20building tech furniture for the education market
- 19:22since 1987. Instructor lecterns, computer lab
- 19:26tables, collaborative tables, and active learning
- 19:28clusters are just a few of the many innovative
- 19:30products made by cci. Speaking of lecterns,
- 19:33Computer Comforts has just released evolv. If
- 19:36you're looking to future proof your classroom,
- 19:38EVOLV is the Swiss army knife of lecterns.
- 19:41Seriously, this flexible lectern does it all. Not
- 19:44only is EVOLV sit to stand and ADA compliant, it's
- 19:48also packed with tech friendly features. And the
- 19:50best part, it ships fully assembled and ready for
- 19:53action. Check out the 90 second video to see all
- 19:56the options, visit computercomforts.com evolve.
- 20:08>> Marc Cholewczynski: Swiss Army Knife.
- 20:09>> Chris Dechter: It's a Swiss army knife. Electric.
- 20:11>> Jamie Rinehart: Great. We have, we've acknowledged that product
- 20:14too.
- 20:15>> Chris Dechter: We've even accepted, actually, we've acknowledged
- 20:17that one in person. So. All right, well, let's get
- 20:19right to it. Okay.
- 20:21>> Craig Park: What?
- 20:24>> Chris Dechter: Gotta play this one.
- 20:25>> Marc Cholewczynski: That's right.
- 20:26>> Chris Dechter: It cost a lot of God.
- 20:28>> Marc Cholewczynski: We owe royalties contractually and for producing
- 20:31that one for us.
- 20:32>> Chris Dechter: so, joined today by our special guest panelist,
- 20:35Craig park, from, from Clark and Anderson. Craig,
- 20:37why don't you give US the, the 32nd overview of,
- 20:39of who you are and what you're doing and then,
- 20:41we'll jump right into the, some of the stuff we
- 20:42talked about at etc and, and all that fun stuff.
- 20:45>> Craig Park: Sounds good. Thanks, Chris. Craig Park. I'm an
- 20:47architect by training and went into audio Visual
- 20:51consulting. Right out of college I had interned
- 20:54for an AV consultant, back in California when I
- 20:57was in school for architecture. I was looking for
- 21:01a job in an architect's office and they all went
- 21:05to USC and I went to Cal Poly and those intern
- 21:07jobs went to the USC students. So I ended up
- 21:10working for a company called Hubert Wilkie, which
- 21:13is now known as Shen Milsen Wilkie and probably
- 21:15the oldest and one of the more well known firms.
- 21:18And I ended up there for quite a number of years.
- 21:21I got back into architecture in the early 2000s
- 21:25and did that for about 10 years and then came back
- 21:28into AV consulting in 2010. and in 2022 joined
- 21:34Clark and Anderson. My first time. Rather than
- 21:36being an independent consultant working inside of
- 21:39an architectural engineering practice. We're a 200
- 21:42person AE with offices across the country and
- 21:46specialize in science and tech kinds of projects,
- 21:48mostly in higher ed. About 80% of our practices,
- 21:51labs and research and classrooms in STEM education
- 21:56facilities. been active in the industry through
- 21:58all that career. been on the Avixa board, when it
- 22:01was Navajo.
- 22:04>> Larry Darling: Nice.
- 22:05>> Craig Park: So there you go. I won't give away how old am I?
- 22:08but I have seen the evolution of Avixa from its
- 22:12beginnings to where it is today. but I'm also
- 22:16involved in the AIA and a couple of us scup,
- 22:20Society of College and University Planning, appa,
- 22:22the association of Physical Plant Administrators
- 22:26which are all the facilities management staff on
- 22:28the campuses. and also working with ed spaces and
- 22:32a 4LE on the K12 sector. So education has been my
- 22:36practice area for the last about 15 years.
- 22:40>> Chris Dechter: And now also a podcast host.
- 22:42>> Craig Park: Yes, a post of EDUP smartspace, part of the EDUP
- 22:45experience Ecosystems of Higher Education related
- 22:49podcasts. So hopefully we'll have all you folks on
- 22:52my show in the real. In the real soon now.
- 22:55>> Chris Dechter: Okay. But we only come as a group.
- 22:57>> Marc Cholewczynski: We'll see how you feel about that.
- 22:58>> Craig Park: This one. Yeah, this one's over. We'll, I'll let
- 23:02you know.
- 23:02>> Jamie Rinehart: How fast can we sink Craig's ship?
- 23:05>> Chris Dechter: So, Craig, a few weeks ago at the the ETC
- 23:07Conference, you had, you had presented a kind of a
- 23:10model on I'm going to paraphrase here and probably
- 23:13shortchange here, but a model on trying to like
- 23:16maintain appropriate communication throughout a
- 23:18project process for all the stakeholders at the
- 23:21table to ensure that what we end up with, at the,
- 23:23at the, at the end of the project, the Final
- 23:24delivered project is what we were talking about at
- 23:26the beginning of the project and that everybody
- 23:28is, is happy and copacetic and all that fun stuff.
- 23:31Is that, that a fair 18 second shakedown?
- 23:34>> Craig Park: Absolutely. The reason that I, because I made.
- 23:37>> Chris Dechter: Most of it up.
- 23:37>> Craig Park: So yeah, no, it was pretty, pretty, pretty close.
- 23:40It certainly was what my goal was. being in the
- 23:43industry for now, for 40 plus years, I have been
- 23:46called to projects too late, where the architects
- 23:50have made decisions that compromise the quality of
- 23:52how AV can work, whether it be acoustics or
- 23:55lighting or shape or just we forgot the
- 23:59infrastructure, to the point where it's become,
- 24:02yeah, it's all wireless, that we I'm becoming a
- 24:06more vocal advocate for early engagement with the
- 24:10A.V.I.T. team, as early in the project as
- 24:14possible. and I now have a pulpit within the Clark
- 24:17and Anderson firm where they hear that and we're
- 24:20now brought to the table. And the first thing I
- 24:23say is where's Chris or where's Jamie in that
- 24:26conversation before those projects start? and that
- 24:29we, what you heard me advocate though at etc was
- 24:32that it's not a one and done. That's a continual
- 24:35conversation through the LIFO project. And what
- 24:39folks are on the operations, side or even the
- 24:42faculty side don't often recognize that the time
- 24:45from when we start day one, when I call first
- 24:48pencil on paper for collecting data about a
- 24:51project to the day it opens is three years from
- 24:54now. And we all know that the technology is going
- 24:58to advance in that time, and that things need to
- 25:01be accommodated. so you know, how do we focus on
- 25:04good infrastructure planning knowing that the
- 25:07systems will likely to be somewhat different, if
- 25:10not completely different than what we're using
- 25:12today.
- 25:14>> Chris Dechter: So yeah, let's jump right in on that. And we kind
- 25:16of, right before the show, we talked kind of where
- 25:18we want to start this conversation because we came
- 25:20up with a list of potential topics and as you
- 25:22pointed out Craig, I mean any one of those could
- 25:24be an hour long conversation. So this will be our
- 25:26longest episode at 17 hours. So everyone just
- 25:30stay, stay tuned.
- 25:31so I'm going to start with this conversation or
- 25:33this, this point in the conversation. We'll see
- 25:34where it goes. Okay. And you mentioned it there
- 25:36briefly. But how do we br that gap when we're part
- 25:39of a larger capital construction project, as you
- 25:41mentioned, multi year, multi phase project sort of
- 25:43thing invariably. How do we bridge the gap between
- 25:45those initial conversations between what we
- 25:47generally as the owner's representative or the
- 25:49owner's technology representative. What we would
- 25:52like to see, what we'd like to have in these
- 25:54spaces, what we'd like to see as far as technology
- 25:55deployments and infrastructure and all that. And
- 25:58then three years later, kind of like, well, here's
- 26:00what we ended up with, which maybe 50% of the way
- 26:03there something, you know, lots of moving pieces,
- 26:05lots of things change. How do we ensure that what
- 26:08we talk about in those early meetings aligns with
- 26:11what shows up on, you know, on day one? And then
- 26:14the ever popular question of like, why can't I
- 26:17just give you a copy of my current classroom
- 26:19standards and let's just use that. Sure.
- 26:22>> Craig Park: Well, okay. The why is that? the communication gap
- 26:26between the six phases that the architects go
- 26:30through. is the telephone, the game of telephone.
- 26:35That happens in almost every project and it's not
- 26:38unique to avit. It happens on furniture, it
- 26:42happens on lots of different parts of the project.
- 26:44And I witnessed that. So I think what I advocate
- 26:48for is a, consistent presence in the room in all
- 26:52of the, what are known as colloquially as the OAC
- 26:56meetings, owner, architect, contractor, that
- 26:59happen on average, every two to three weeks, from
- 27:03the beginning to the end. And I know that that's a
- 27:05commitment, from your staff, which is already
- 27:07stretched, to how do I get someone in the room.
- 27:11But at a minimum, review the meeting notes from
- 27:14those meetings so that if a technology related
- 27:17topic comes up that you can have that. But as I
- 27:20mentioned in the presentation I did at etc. Was
- 27:23that the design team, architects and engineers
- 27:27present our quote unquote solutions at the ends of
- 27:31each of those phases. and we give those to the
- 27:34client for significant review. I can't tell you
- 27:37how often that review actually never happens. So
- 27:40we don't get any feedback from them. sometimes we
- 27:42do and sometimes they're really detailed and
- 27:44they're really good. And sometimes that has
- 27:46happened recently. Where? Oh, by the way, our
- 27:49campus standards that we gave you 24 months ago.
- 27:53We just did an update. So here's the new one which
- 27:56fortunately came ahead of writing the technical
- 27:58spec for the project. This happens at Kansas
- 28:01State. so now the technical specs for a project
- 28:04are going to reflect something different than what
- 28:07it was when we started two years ago.
- 28:09>> Marc Cholewczynski: So I think I want to pull on a little bit of those
- 28:12threads. I think that's. And one, I want to
- 28:16acknowledge that this can be a really tricky
- 28:19conversation for a lot of folks. a couple of
- 28:22pieces you said, like talking to Jamie, making
- 28:25sure they're at the table and the like. But then
- 28:27the other piece you had said that presenting
- 28:31solutions. Right. And I think we've all gone
- 28:35through different versions of this, early on in
- 28:38the process. And I think people around the room
- 28:40here, I don't think we're at a solutions point yet
- 28:44in that conversation. Right. I think that's where,
- 28:46we get really tripped up. And oftentimes it feels
- 28:49like we're out over our skis a little bit when we
- 28:52haven't really gotten to a point where we feel
- 28:54it's time to really talk about things and boxes
- 28:57and stuff of that nature. And oftentimes it's
- 28:59like, why are we having this? What stuff's gonna
- 29:01be their conversation so early?
- 29:03>> Larry Darling: Yeah, I think I wanted to echo what Mark was
- 29:06saying. A lot of times like I've been in this
- 29:08situation where we've gotten these solutions to
- 29:11review, but we don't really understand what the
- 29:13problem is yet. Like we haven't had a chance to
- 29:17talk with the instructional designers, the
- 29:19faculty, like the people who are wanting to use
- 29:22this unique space to teach in a new way. And if we
- 29:26don't understand how they're planning to use the
- 29:30room, I can't say whether this design is going to
- 29:33be successful or not. And I agree we need to be
- 29:37there early, but it seems like we're often there
- 29:40when the technology discussion happens, not when
- 29:45how the program of the space happens.
- 29:47>> Craig Park: Thank you. And maybe I mischaracterized the word
- 29:52solutions because I don't want to sound like it's
- 29:54a one line diagram of how the technology is going
- 29:56to be interconnected in this room. It really is.
- 29:59If you look at. I was in a programming meeting
- 30:02yesterday for two buildings at a local university.
- 30:05We met with, the PhD researchers who will be using
- 30:09the labs, the faculty will be teaching in the
- 30:11classrooms. We met with the students arranged from
- 30:14sophomores to seniors who are in that program
- 30:17about what they experience in their current
- 30:20classrooms. It's an interesting project because
- 30:22it's renovation, of a building and the addition of
- 30:24a new building that are 30 miles apart. But they
- 30:28will be interconnected because the labs that
- 30:30happen out in the field will be video streamed to
- 30:34the classrooms on the campus so that those
- 30:37students can witness what's happening in the, in
- 30:38the field research. what we were talking about
- 30:42yesterday was what kinds of rooms need to be in
- 30:47this building and what happens in those rooms, not
- 30:50how, what they do, they talk, are they recorded.
- 30:54We actually didn't even get to that level. We were
- 30:55really just talking about how many students are in
- 30:57that space or how many research are in that space.
- 31:00That level of what I call functional and perfect
- 31:04performance expectation is really what happens
- 31:06through the first half of the project, through the
- 31:10end of design development. And it isn't really
- 31:13until the end of that first half of programming,
- 31:17schematic design, design development. The
- 31:19architects break down the project where we finally
- 31:22get to say, this is how, this is how big this room
- 31:26is. So this is how big that screen needs to be or
- 31:28screens and this is how many loudspeakers are in
- 31:32that ceiling to give you good coverage and how
- 31:34many microphones are in that ceil to give you good
- 31:36coverage. we're not even at that point of talking
- 31:38about what's the human interface, how do we
- 31:41control it. It really is just the, what I call the
- 31:43physics of oral clarity and visual acuity. You
- 31:47know, how do you cover the room with sound and how
- 31:50do you provide enough image square footage that
- 31:53you can see and read? Assuming that a professor
- 31:56doesn't do 16 point type.
- 31:59>> Marc Cholewczynski: Yeah.
- 31:59>> Jamie Rinehart: Oh, don't worry. PowerPoints4.3 is perfect.
- 32:01>> Marc Cholewczynski: We're not doing like.
- 32:02>> Craig Park: There you go. Well, that, there's that too. M. I,
- 32:05I don't know if did I. So I, I don't want to over
- 32:08characterize. I have seen, I've been in meetings
- 32:12where solutions are suggested too early that this
- 32:17needs to be what brand? I mean down to the brand
- 32:19level. I want, you know. Yeah, Sony Bravia
- 32:22monitors. And I, I said I don't know.
- 32:25>> Larry Darling: yeah, we don't care about the stuff really.
- 32:28>> Marc Cholewczynski: At some point. But not right now.
- 32:30>> Craig Park: At some point, but not then.
- 32:31>> Chris Dechter: Yeah, no, we want the experience screen.
- 32:33>> Craig Park: Of a certain size because who knows if, you know,
- 32:36if there's a rapid drop in the price of dvled. We
- 32:39could all have video walls, in five years.
- 32:43>> Justin Rexing: Can we back up a little bit? Is that okay to back
- 32:46up?
- 32:46>> Marc Cholewczynski: We can go. We have a time machine, Justin. We can
- 32:48go forward and backward.
- 32:49>> Justin Rexing: So something that is bothering me with the process
- 32:54is. And you say, you know, we asked for the Chris,
- 32:59we asked for the Jamie when you first come in.
- 33:02Every university is different. So for example, if
- 33:05a consultant comes on our campus, you are
- 33:07literally taking my job away. And then there's
- 33:10other, other areas where they don't even have an
- 33:13integration program or it's just support. Right.
- 33:16And so they always rely on integrators. So what
- 33:19happens when you walk in to your first meetings
- 33:22and you try to engage the design team and the
- 33:25owner's representative who might be facilities.
- 33:28Yeah, let's say there's a facilities it war going
- 33:31on. And let's say when you ask for those people
- 33:34they say well they're not going to be involved in
- 33:36this project. We're going to handle this on our
- 33:39own. What, what is that conversation like? Because
- 33:42you know that's not going to probably go well. Is
- 33:45there, is that, is there any red flags with that?
- 33:47Or how do you handle different situations for each
- 33:50unique university when they do have a full design
- 33:54engineer that always does that in integration and
- 33:58like what, what do you do in those situations?
- 34:01>> Craig Park: Well clearly that's the political minefield that
- 34:04we all walk through. in any collaborative
- 34:07organization where you've got outside interests
- 34:09being brought in to help make something happen. So
- 34:13to your point, it always depends on what resources
- 34:18are available and what is, what do they expect to
- 34:21be able to do what? You know, I have rarely seen
- 34:26an internal team or an integrator who has revit as
- 34:31their, in their toolkit to be able to produce the
- 34:34kind of. Not saying that you, that there are out
- 34:38there, but rarely. and so we asked that question
- 34:42and I asked that question yesterday when I was at
- 34:46the local university and we have a meeting and
- 34:48they weren't in the room because this was
- 34:51considered a information gathering meeting with
- 34:54faculty and students. but we are.
- 34:56>> Justin Rexing: They should be though.
- 34:58>> Craig Park: But they should be. They should be. And so we're
- 35:00meeting on Monday. I said I can't go forward with
- 35:03any kind of help on the kinds of. And this is just
- 35:08rationalizing the available budget to the goals of
- 35:13the unit that will be occupying these buildings.
- 35:17So I can't make any call on what that budget
- 35:19should be until I talk to the in house technology
- 35:23folks. So everyone is a different model. and every
- 35:27team is different in terms of what their resources
- 35:29are internally and externally. We try to be a
- 35:31collaborator. That's our goal.
- 35:33It's been my goal as a consultant when I had my
- 35:35own practice back in the west coast in the 80s and
- 35:3990s and it's been my practice here, building the
- 35:42practice at Clark and Henderson.
- 35:43>> Justin Rexing: Do you change your approach a little bit based
- 35:46upon that dynamic of the AV experts in house
- 35:50versus if they have none or if they do have some.
- 35:52Is there, is there a set of questions you ask and
- 35:55kind of how do you get to that answer?
- 35:57>> Craig Park: How, how will this be supported? Because I've been
- 36:01on campuses that totally rely on a third party
- 36:03integrator to be there on, on site Support. And I
- 36:08will tell you that the, the ones I run into is
- 36:10where that integrator has the bigger voice and
- 36:13they oversell M. they go in selling product.
- 36:16>> Chris Dechter: Right?
- 36:16>> Craig Park: Yeah.
- 36:17>> Marc Cholewczynski: the registers margin.
- 36:20>> Craig Park: It's what they do. It's why it's, you know, it's
- 36:22the argument consultants have made throughout
- 36:24history is that we're independent. We're not
- 36:27independent. We make, we have biases towards
- 36:30products. I, I joked that, you know, back in the
- 36:33day when AMX took me out to dinner for fine French
- 36:36food and a hundred dollar bottle of Chardonnay
- 36:39versus the guy from Crestron who brought in
- 36:40lasagna, it was you know, who am I going to spec
- 36:44tomorrow?
- 36:45>> Justin Rexing: see, I hate that. I hate that. Damn it. I, oh this
- 36:50is the problem with our industry and consultants
- 36:53because that is not in our best interest.
- 36:56>> Craig Park: Right, right. And so, but that was a, a done in
- 37:00the spirit of AV super friends when I wrote that
- 37:03article about is it, is it top of mind or full of
- 37:06stomach that made the choices that I made? But
- 37:09the, the reality is that the, when the integrators
- 37:12are a big voice in the room they tend to over sell
- 37:17hardware solutions because it's their, they're in
- 37:19their interest to make money.
- 37:21>> Justin Rexing: But I've seen consultants do that too. Well, that
- 37:25I've worked with, I've never worked with you but
- 37:27I've every 100% of the consultants up design
- 37:30everything and when we suggest why don't we remove
- 37:33this? Because you don't need that and it needs to
- 37:35become more efficient. It never gets removed. But
- 37:38any ads that I suggest get added back in.
- 37:41>> Craig Park: Of course. Well and I can say it may be truly as
- 37:45a, and I, and I can say, and I've had this comment
- 37:48made about me in the industry for the, in the 40
- 37:50years is that because I come with a, not an
- 37:55engineering technical mindset. I come with an
- 37:57architect's three dimensional visualize the space
- 38:00mindset. I've always said, you know, I'm an
- 38:03architect first and an engineer second. I grew up,
- 38:06my father was a telecommunications engineer. I
- 38:09grew up looking at what line diagrams for missiles
- 38:12in space. so I understood the connectivity between
- 38:14devices but that's not really what I'm trying to
- 38:18focus on. I'm really trying to focus on function
- 38:20and performance and I know that there's a variety
- 38:23of gear that out there will do that. So I don't
- 38:26know that I'm unique but I certainly say that
- 38:28that's the message I have with my teams when I've
- 38:32been leading the organization. So when it was with
- 38:35my practice in San Francisco and one in the
- 38:37Midwest, and now at Clark and Henderson, that's
- 38:40certainly our attitude. I, I've argued with lots
- 38:43of other consultants who gold plate. I've, I have
- 38:46walked into rooms with eight equipment racks for a
- 38:50hundred seat.
- 38:51>> Justin Rexing: Seminar room or DMPs 5,000 for one input, one
- 38:56output classroom.
- 38:57>> Craig Park: Yeah, yeah. It blows my mind to see what they got
- 39:02away with and I'm not and get away with in a bad
- 39:04way. I call, you know, how do we raise the bar
- 39:06instead of lower the bar? and raise the bar is to
- 39:09engage you all in those conversations early and
- 39:13often through the process. It's not always
- 39:15perfect. There are as you mentioned institutional
- 39:20sides of the university and college systems that
- 39:22say these are silos that are not going to be
- 39:25crossed, that they are independent and we'll get
- 39:28to you when it's your turn. I've heard that
- 39:30before. I can advocate. I made that advocacy clear
- 39:35when I was at etc. I've told this story since I
- 39:40wrote an article for SMVC in 1986 which is giving
- 39:45away a little bit of my age about how consultants,
- 39:49contractors and users could work together better.
- 39:51It's something I, you know, message I've been
- 39:53signaling all along doesn't always work, doesn't
- 39:55mean it's wrong. I like to think that it's the
- 39:58right way to do things. And and the projects where
- 40:00you asked in one of the questions you say, you
- 40:02know, when projects that are good, the ones that I
- 40:05consider the most successful are the ones when
- 40:07those conversations happen early and continuously
- 40:10through the life of the project. And we were co
- 40:12creating the solution, whether we were just the
- 40:16documenters in the revit model or we were bringing
- 40:19ideas about this is how this might work with you
- 40:22know, some integration of lighting or acoustics or
- 40:24some other part of the architecture.
- 40:26>> Marc Cholewczynski: Yeah, I think it's a really good like maybe a
- 40:29slight pivot there, Craig. I think there, there
- 40:31are opportunities and there are examples where it
- 40:33is good. And I think mileage may vary right.
- 40:36Depending on how we see consultants coming in and
- 40:40doing that work.
- 40:41But I keep getting drawn back to the definition of
- 40:44success here in this conversation in that to a
- 40:48common learning in space. I think our standards
- 40:50that we do kind of day in, day out probably
- 40:52represent our current portfolio of services that
- 40:56are successful for us from a support standpoint.
- 40:58These are the things we're going to do day in and
- 41:00day out every day. Twice on Sunday. And it's going
- 41:02to work ourselves. Staffs are aligned with it. Our
- 41:04capabilities are in line. And we feel that if we
- 41:09adopt that, where we can to define that success,
- 41:13that this is actually meeting and say, well,
- 41:16here's the areas maybe that we have an opportunity
- 41:18to consult, on in that, you know, how do we do
- 41:22some of these edge pieces? And we would love to
- 41:26engage in that conversation, but sometimes, we are
- 41:30left in this position where we're having to deal
- 41:32with the flooding of the zone, right? We have all
- 41:36this stuff that's coming towards us. We're going
- 41:38to respond to this, do this, and blah, blah, blah.
- 41:39And we're not. We're not getting the. The energy.
- 41:42We get to actually focus on these one. Things.
- 41:44We're spending too much time having to respond to.
- 41:48No, this is not our standard thing. This is the
- 41:50standard thing. And we're spending a lot of
- 41:51administrative cycles. And it almost feels
- 41:55intentional that we're just going to overwhelm the
- 41:58client with all of this response and all this
- 42:01stuff. And then we're gonna do this thing over
- 42:02here, and then we're gonna. We're gonna. We're
- 42:05gonna do this, and then it's gonna jump out of the
- 42:08box and then we're gonna have arcs of sex. And
- 42:10that's. That's gonna be our picture we're gonna
- 42:11put on our website because that's gonna be our
- 42:13next thing we're gonna sell. And so oftentimes it
- 42:17feels like there's almost this. We're being taken
- 42:20advantage of because we're trying to do all seven.
- 42:22We're trying to all do it. But I wanna go back to
- 42:23like, what is that? Def. Really start with like,
- 42:29what. What is that? What are the actual. What's
- 42:31the language that is success? When we, when we. If
- 42:34you're coming to the table and I'm coming to the
- 42:36table, what does success look like for you? And
- 42:38then maybe we'll share what success like, looks
- 42:40like for us.
- 42:41>> Craig Park: Okay, so fundamentally, it's. When this project
- 42:45opens, do the. Does the technology in the room
- 42:48help improve the communication from the faculty to
- 42:53the students? And do the results of that
- 42:57pedagogical experience, supported by technology,
- 43:00improve learning outcomes? Do students come out of
- 43:03this space better equipped to do whatever they've
- 43:06learned in whatever department, whatever it might
- 43:08be, because the technology helped them collaborate
- 43:11better, learn better, because they could hear or
- 43:14see better? that's the bottom line. it doesn't
- 43:17really matter. it can be as simple as. As it wants
- 43:20to Be.
- 43:22>> Marc Cholewczynski: Sometimes nothing is better than something.
- 43:24>> Craig Park: Something is. Sometimes nothing is better. I saw
- 43:27very simple systems at my local university this
- 43:30week. However, the screens were undersized and
- 43:34everyone said, this is our standard screen. It's
- 43:38in every screen.
- 43:40>> Justin Rexing: There is no standard screen.
- 43:42>> Craig Park: This is ours.
- 43:43>> Marc Cholewczynski: There's no standard size for a screen. Let's just
- 43:45agree on that.
- 43:48>> Chris Dechter: Craig, in that scenario, stop listening to.
- 43:49>> Jamie Rinehart: This them 86 inches squared.
- 43:53>> Justin Rexing: That is not correct.
- 43:55>> Craig Park: No.
- 43:55>> Justin Rexing: Anyway, this is why consultants exist.
- 43:59>> Craig Park: No. Well, to say we could have done it
- 44:01differently, that would be the that's the old joke
- 44:04about how many light bulbs. but the my point was
- 44:08that they all recognize that their current
- 44:10standard for an off the shelf interactive screen
- 44:14which is in every classroom. It's easy to use, but
- 44:18too small for the room size. Nobody sized it based
- 44:20on discus standards.
- 44:22>> Justin Rexing: But Craig, no one complains. No one's ever
- 44:24complained.
- 44:25>> Craig Park: Everyone complained. no. I have the notes.
- 44:29Everyone said if we can't have a bigger screen,
- 44:32can we have more screens? Because then they're
- 44:34closer to us than we can see. And I heard your
- 44:37podcast the other.
- 44:37>> Justin Rexing: Day about just everybody issue laptops and no AV
- 44:40at that point. Like that solution.
- 44:43>> Marc Cholewczynski: That's a solution about that.
- 44:44>> Craig Park: Yeah, it is a solution. We, and I've talked about
- 44:46it before, I'm not sure that assumes everybody has
- 44:49a laptop.
- 44:50>> Jamie Rinehart: Right.
- 44:50>> Marc Cholewczynski: It's an equitable piece of playing to them.
- 44:52>> Craig Park: Yeah, it's the equity part too.
- 44:54>> Justin Rexing: So going back to what you were saying at the very
- 44:56beginning of this is, is measuring student
- 44:58outcomes. That's difficult for consultants because
- 45:01they're usually gone by day seven. So you know,
- 45:05with, with that measuring outcomes that sometimes
- 45:08they. Not a semester, that's years of measuring
- 45:11that. So it's hard to say that that's a metric of
- 45:14success when the building opens for a consultant
- 45:19vision.
- 45:20>> Craig Park: True. I'm just saying it's my goal to say. I would
- 45:25like the feedback to say it worked or it didn't
- 45:28work. I would love to. You know, you're right. I
- 45:31will say the one thing I've learned in joining an
- 45:33architectural engineering firm is that the
- 45:35contracts that your universities have with us,
- 45:38often depending on the client and depends on the
- 45:41university. I have a one year look back. So a year
- 45:46later, let's go back and see how did this all work
- 45:48from everything from H vac to electrical to
- 45:52lighting to technology. and that's really been a
- 45:56pleasure that we get to get that feedback loop now
- 45:59may still be to your point soon enough or, or, or
- 46:03long Enough. But we do get some feedback.
- 46:09>> Jamie Rinehart: That'S, that's interesting because I think some of
- 46:13us in the process aren't aware of that.
- 46:16>> Larry Darling: Yeah.
- 46:17>> Jamie Rinehart: And that feed. So. And then where does that
- 46:19feedback come from? So your initial meetings are
- 46:22set up with you know, end users and stakeholders.
- 46:25You know, there's always Daddy Warbuck's got to
- 46:27sign the check. He's there too. But the
- 46:29stakeholders are there. Students, the faculty, if
- 46:33you can get some of the staff responsible as you
- 46:35can, your notes are taken and then we skip to that
- 46:39one year review. But is it the same people? Right?
- 46:45Is that one real review of the same people? Or was
- 46:47it just the contractual stakeholders? Because
- 46:50that's where some of this falls apart too is that
- 46:52there is. It's like, okay, you handed, or we put
- 46:56in this plan right together. Right? We put in this
- 46:59plan. It's not really what anybody, what people
- 47:03think they want and what they really want, you
- 47:06know, is different. And so that's why that's part
- 47:11of this confusion, especially for those of us that
- 47:13maybe integrate and do a lot of the, the actual
- 47:17technology integration where like frequently I
- 47:22will use one of you guys basically for that revit
- 47:26model. We'll take it from there. But we don't get
- 47:29access to the user notes from the beginning. So
- 47:32what was promised is not what's delivered.
- 47:35Therefore the message is skewed. And so that's a
- 47:38big gap there too.
- 47:40>> Larry Darling: Yeah. And to kind of go along with that, you said
- 47:43several things that made me happy, like the
- 47:46successful learning outcomes. Because that's like
- 47:49my happy place. My concern is it doesn't really
- 47:54matter about the technology we put in if no one
- 47:57has gotten in front of the end user and said your
- 48:02plans for teaching and learning in this space
- 48:06don't align with the physical characteristics of
- 48:10the space. And I feel like we're trying to solve a
- 48:13lot of issues with technology, whether it's
- 48:15ceiling height, whether it's square foot per
- 48:18student in active learning spaces that by the time
- 48:22we get the solutions, like there's no way to fix
- 48:26some of that. And I was curious, like does your.
- 48:31In a, typical architecture? Because I've, I've
- 48:33always either been on an integrator and higher ed.
- 48:36I've never worked architecture site. Is there any
- 48:39expertise there in teaching and learning on these
- 48:43groups that are having these discussions up front?
- 48:46>> Craig Park: The teams that I can only speak to us, but I'll
- 48:49also speak to my role as a consultant to other
- 48:52architects and I've consulted with hundreds of
- 48:54architects it depends. there are firms that have,
- 48:59like Clark Anderson has a higher education and a,
- 49:03science and technology related higher education
- 49:06subset of architects who do. That's all they work
- 49:09on. So they spend enough time with educators and
- 49:12with campus facilities planning and campus
- 49:15facilities management teams. Teams to understand
- 49:19the impact on pedagogy from the way they design
- 49:22space. there are architects who don't. Who, who
- 49:25have maybe have a workplace or healthcare
- 49:27background but win a project and are doing,
- 49:30higher, ed, thinking that a space is a spaces of
- 49:32space. I've been on those kind of teams too, where
- 49:35we've designed glass wall classrooms and wonder
- 49:38why that didn't work.
- 49:41>> Justin Rexing: that's a great point. Like, have you ever been a
- 49:43part of a. Part of a design or a who. Where
- 49:46you're, where you're like, you know, this is a
- 49:48really bad idea. You know, this shit's not going
- 49:50to work. You know, De said, enough, I cannot do
- 49:54this. I'm backing out. We quit.
- 49:56>> Craig Park: I have, I have said as loud as I can and on paper
- 50:01this is not going to work. I have shown you in the
- 50:04model I have a, A glass wall auditorium in Atlanta
- 50:07I can still point to. It got built.
- 50:10>> Justin Rexing: so you did it begrudgingly. Like you did it
- 50:13anyway.
- 50:13>> Craig Park: I said, here.
- 50:14>> Marc Cholewczynski: No, dumb idea.
- 50:17>> Jamie Rinehart: Please sign here. This is stupid.
- 50:20>> Craig Park: Well, I was telling a friend earlier, I wrote an
- 50:23article. Why didn't you tell me? I was being
- 50:26stupid.
- 50:27>> Justin Rexing: We, tried to, but you didn't listen.
- 50:29>> Marc Cholewczynski: There was enough, there was enough zeros on that
- 50:31check, right?
- 50:34>> Craig Park: Well, no, on my check though. That wasn't the
- 50:35issue. The issue was they came back to me
- 50:37afterwards and said, we want to use this
- 50:41projector.
- 50:42>> Speaker G: Oh.
- 50:42>> Craig Park: And I said, why? Well, because we use it. It's one
- 50:46of our portable solutions and we find it really
- 50:48works. It's inappropriate for this room in a fixed
- 50:51installation. Doesn't matter. We want this
- 50:54projector. I said, okay, we specked it. It went
- 50:56in, they called up and said, it's not bright
- 50:59enough and it's higher resolution enough. And I
- 51:02said, I told you. Well, you didn't tell us loud
- 51:05enough so you have to pay to replace it.
- 51:06>> Marc Cholewczynski: See, I think that that's a really good point
- 51:08though, because too often does this become a legal
- 51:12conversation. It feels right. And it's like
- 51:14there's we can have all this conversation and meet
- 51:16and sing Kumbaya together. And all of a sudden
- 51:19it's he who has paid the lawyer to document the
- 51:22best that's ultimately going to win in the end.
- 51:25And it often feels that way, that it doesn't
- 51:29matter what we talk about. It's who has put the
- 51:31energy into, to writing down this fine print, in
- 51:35submitting it into a way. And once that's in the
- 51:41project and whatever it is, it is now the burden
- 51:43of proof for everybody else.
- 51:45>> Craig Park: Right. Unfortunately, the good news, it doesn't
- 51:48happen that often. but it does happen and I will
- 51:52say that I try and make sure that we are, if a
- 51:56decision's being made that goes against the laws
- 51:59of physics, that I'm making sure that that's in
- 52:02the record, the court record, that this is going
- 52:05to be a problem later on. And I can't do anything
- 52:08about that because I can't rewrite those laws.
- 52:10Right. and but but on the flip side of that, back
- 52:14to the original conversation. I have worked with a
- 52:17campuses. You somewhere in the questions was
- 52:19what's a good example? I worked with UT
- 52:21Southwestern now 10 years ago on a project where
- 52:25they had a faculty group redesign their curriculum
- 52:30and they spent two years doing it before they
- 52:33hired the architects who were higher education
- 52:36experts and a consultant to come in and design an
- 52:39active learning space for them. and it became the
- 52:42model for their team based learning classes all
- 52:44over the campus. and it's AV over ip. I know it's
- 52:48your favorite subject, but it was it was a very
- 52:52successful project and the AV and IT folks were in
- 52:57the room from the beginning. Now I will say in
- 52:59that particular campus they were separate
- 53:01departments who had their own turf wars. And you
- 53:05could feel that dynamic when you were in the room
- 53:07with them. But at the end they understood that
- 53:10this was going to become a model sort of test,
- 53:14case for this shift in pedagogical approach for
- 53:17teaching medicine. And at the end of the day it
- 53:20worked. And 10 years later that architect is still
- 53:23showing that project as the model for how you can
- 53:26do a collaborative teaching, environment that
- 53:29works at a simple enough from a functional level
- 53:32that a single faculty can teach in a large group
- 53:35of team based cohorts. So that to me is still one
- 53:39of the highlights. And it was an early application
- 53:42of a new technology. We hadn't done necessarily
- 53:44networked AV really at any level before. And this
- 53:47is 250 students in 42 teams of six in one row.
- 53:52>> Marc Cholewczynski: Sounds like a coordination.
- 53:55>> Craig Park: Yeah, I think the teaching coordination is much
- 53:58harder than the technology.
- 53:59>> Chris Dechter: Did you say 42 different student groups of. Holy
- 54:02smokes.
- 54:02>> Marc Cholewczynski: I've seen Rooms that big and I've panicked just by
- 54:04walking in.
- 54:05>> Larry Darling: Yeah.
- 54:05>> Craig Park: And it replaced the 250 seat auditorium.
- 54:08>> Chris Dechter: Yeah, I was going to say did it start, start with
- 54:10the capacity being like. That was where they
- 54:12started. They work back.
- 54:12>> Craig Park: That's their second and third year clerkship for
- 54:14the med school. And they have some stuff, we've
- 54:17seen.
- 54:17>> Marc Cholewczynski: Stuff like up in Portland at some other med
- 54:18schools, very similar coaches, massive active
- 54:21learning style rooms. They're just like holy moly,
- 54:23like what's going on here?
- 54:24>> Craig Park: Yeah. And that, you know Dr. Stahl who was led
- 54:26that faculty group, we presented this project a
- 54:29year later at scup and he said, you know, when I
- 54:32walked into Craig's room in which I didn't have
- 54:35gray hair before that moment, he said I thought I
- 54:39would need two TAs and a tech support person in
- 54:42the room. And I now teach this room by myself. The
- 54:46only thing is that the distributed sound is so
- 54:49good that I can't tell when the team A six has an
- 54:55answer. We had to put a light that lights atop
- 54:58their monitor to let me know where they are in the
- 55:00room, know who's, who's speaking. It's because
- 55:02it's a push to talk for each of the teams. But it
- 55:06was one where we control the acoustics and the
- 55:08lighting and the distribution of underfloor of
- 55:11network, cabling. And the AV and the IT rooms are
- 55:17adjacent but there is a physical wall because the
- 55:20two departments wanted a physical wall between the
- 55:23AV racks and the IT racks though they actually
- 55:26didn't really need to have a wall cables run
- 55:29through the floor and over, over the top anyway.
- 55:33But, but that group, that group was there. There
- 55:35was somebody from the avit AV and IT teams in all
- 55:39those meetings over the. At that point, I think it
- 55:42was about nine months of planning monthly meetings
- 55:45in every room so that we had input and at the end
- 55:49of the day it was successful. Yes. Go ahead,
- 55:51Larry.
- 55:52>> Larry Darling: I, I'm about to get kicked off the show and so I'm
- 55:54okay with that.
- 55:55>> Chris Dechter: I'm going to play that commercial.
- 55:56>> Larry Darling: Then I know immediately that's okay.
- 55:57>> Marc Cholewczynski: This is usually my excited.
- 55:59>> Larry Darling: I'm sure the technology worked flawlessly and you.
- 56:02And that was done well. But I think what made that
- 56:06space successful was the fact that it was driven
- 56:10by faculty and learning design and there was an
- 56:15investment put in to make sure that the faculty
- 56:19were supported and instructional designers were
- 56:22provided for. I think that's what makes active
- 56:26learning spaces successful.
- 56:28>> Craig Park: Well, I think that's what makes all Learning
- 56:29spaces work to your point is that if we're not
- 56:32having that collaborative conversation between
- 56:35instructional design faculty delivery and the
- 56:38technology and the facility side, in what are our
- 56:41goals? In the beginning you hit it on the nose.
- 56:44You see the issue. And I said this in my
- 56:49presentation. Chris and Justin Herd me. We need to
- 56:52be louder voices at the beginning of the project
- 56:53to say this is important.
- 56:56>> Justin Rexing: Man, I've been loud and I've been.
- 56:58>> Marc Cholewczynski: Ooh, yeah, they just escort you out though,
- 57:00Justin. yeah, there's different legal
- 57:03conversations going on there.
- 57:04>> Justin Rexing: So you know, speaking of being loud and easy to
- 57:06use systems and all that, we want to talk about
- 57:09Punch out. I got a couple questions about punch
- 57:12out and like the limits old school game.
- 57:15>> Chris Dechter: Yeah. Mike Tyson's Punch Out.
- 57:17>> Craig Park: So that's the punch listing process of.
- 57:19>> Justin Rexing: Yeah, yeah. So let's say commissioning.
- 57:21>> Chris Dechter: Commissioning process.
- 57:21>> Justin Rexing: Yeah. Commissioning punch list. You come in and
- 57:23you're verifying what the integrator did. And
- 57:25let's say that you find something egregious. And
- 57:29of course there's payment withhold. But let's say
- 57:31that whatever egregious mistake that happened that
- 57:35is causing lots of problems, that might be a code
- 57:39violation, it's a very obvious thing. And the
- 57:43integrator says, you know what, just keep our
- 57:45money. Because to redo all that and to fix it,
- 57:47it's just not worth our time. So you can just have
- 57:52the rest of our money. And how do you deal with
- 57:54situations where you can't get the integrator to
- 57:57follow up on a punch item.
- 58:01>> Chris Dechter: Because.
- 58:01>> Justin Rexing: Now you don't have money. Because now they said,
- 58:04well that money's not worth it to us because
- 58:06time's more valuable now.
- 58:08>> Craig Park: Well, you either find another integrator to come
- 58:11in and do that work.
- 58:13>> Justin Rexing: You go after insurance bonds, you go after
- 58:15insurance.
- 58:16>> Craig Park: Ah. And errors and omissions insurance, insurance
- 58:19on everybody's carries those business insurance
- 58:21for that liability. you know, they've shifted the
- 58:25delivery model of projects now to CM at risk.
- 58:28>> Craig Park: which means the construction manager in theory
- 58:32covers that. where in the, in the design bid,
- 58:36build, litigate model is. Do you get what you just
- 58:41described where everybody's an independent
- 58:43contract and whether you fulfilled it or not, I am
- 58:46working. I am the, the chair of the South Carolina
- 58:48Architectural Foundation. We have a new building
- 58:51in Columbia called the center for Architecture. It
- 58:53has a very nice, relatively simple AV system with
- 58:57three projectors and a decent sound system.
- 59:00however, the EQ in a very hard room is not very
- 59:05good and I can't get the integrator to come back
- 59:08and tune the room, because he doesn't have a
- 59:13contract. Now we're going to solve that problem by
- 59:15paying him to come back, and he will. But, but
- 59:18it's. We got the certificate of occupancy in
- 59:20October of 23. Where are we today, two years
- 59:23later?
- 59:25>> Justin Rexing: that's not fair for the client's money to have
- 59:27them.
- 59:28>> Craig Park: No, it's not. We have. It's hard, hard to put on
- 59:30exhibits and, and do presentations in the space
- 59:33because of a ring that we, We've learned to move
- 59:36the microphone, to get out of that ring zone. But
- 59:39it's a, it's an architect. You know, I, I can go
- 59:41down the. The. Why architects need to learn to
- 59:45design with their ears. Because that particular
- 59:48room was not designed by me. And I wasn't, I was
- 59:50just. I'm, I'm the.
- 59:51>> Marc Cholewczynski: Nobody hears the website.
- 59:53>> Justin Rexing: Well, architects in architect school should be
- 59:56studying acoustics.
- 59:57>> Craig Park: I mean, that's like, I have argued for that one
- 1:00:00too. And, and I think they should learn about
- 1:00:02technology. Technology as well. we learned in my,
- 1:00:05my education, I learned structural engineering and
- 1:00:08I learned about a, minute worth of acoustics and a
- 1:00:10minute worth of lighting, in the five years of
- 1:00:13school. and so you learn it all.
- 1:00:16>> Justin Rexing: Acoustics and lighting exist.
- 1:00:17>> Jamie Rinehart: Craig, that was way back in like the 30s, right?
- 1:00:20>> Craig Park: I know. It was analog. Everything was analog. I've
- 1:00:23been doing this since. It was Shadow Buddies and
- 1:00:26yeah, Dixie cups and straight.
- 1:00:28>> Jamie Rinehart: He was still lighting gas, gas lanterns.
- 1:00:31>> Chris Dechter: Kerosene lanterns.
- 1:00:34>> Craig Park: I made a presentation at Jamie's University about
- 1:00:38the future of technology for the block school
- 1:00:40building back in the 2014. And the first slide I
- 1:00:45show is a slide for a picture of a classroom in
- 1:00:491906. That's a kerosene fired, glass slide
- 1:00:54projector in a room with no ventilation. And 20
- 1:00:58architects learning architecture, architectural
- 1:01:00history. And this is the problem because this is
- 1:01:04how architects are taught about av, is with
- 1:01:07ancient technology.
- 1:01:09>> Marc Cholewczynski: So Craig, as we kind of get ready to wrap up this
- 1:01:12little chunk of this conversation, I'm curious.
- 1:01:14Let's get out of the legalese conversation a
- 1:01:16little bit here. and get off of the, the things,
- 1:01:17that things have gone wrong, but through your
- 1:01:19years and kind of where you are now, you know,
- 1:01:22when you're broad in the conversation, what types
- 1:01:25of, of whether it be trends or technologies or
- 1:01:27opportunities, what's exciting you the most? You
- 1:01:29think that's out there right now, but I'm not
- 1:01:31going to let you say AV over IP or anything
- 1:01:33hybrid. And so 3D.
- 1:01:35>> Craig Park: Can I say AI?
- 1:01:36>> Marc Cholewczynski: You can, but, But I want to. You got to elaborate
- 1:01:40on that because I want to know, like, specific
- 1:01:42examples.
- 1:01:42>> Justin Rexing: Example.
- 1:01:42>> Marc Cholewczynski: Because I think everybody's gonna say AI and data.
- 1:01:45I understand that, but, you know, I think the
- 1:01:47standard stuff. Let's assume that stuff's being
- 1:01:50dealt with and we're not talking about COVID
- 1:01:51response stuff because we're all doing that. We're
- 1:01:53doing all that easy stuff. Where's the opportunity
- 1:01:56for us to really engage and think about what is
- 1:01:59this going to be looking like moving forward? And
- 1:02:01let's pretend we got all the legal stuff right,
- 1:02:03and everything's gonna work together. We're gonna
- 1:02:04have this conversation. Where are we engaging and
- 1:02:06where are we excited? What's going on here?
- 1:02:08>> Chris Dechter: Here?
- 1:02:09>> Craig Park: Well, I, I do think that, two, A couple of things
- 1:02:13on the visual side. I'm, I'm intrigued by, the
- 1:02:17continual development of DVLED as a solution for
- 1:02:21visualization, because it gives us a bigger canvas
- 1:02:24to work with and things that. With, with a much
- 1:02:27longer half life.
- 1:02:29>> Marc Cholewczynski: I'm using these 720p slides. I'm not changing
- 1:02:31them. I don't care what you're doing.
- 1:02:32>> Craig Park: Okay, There you go. There you go. We do not put
- 1:02:35them anywhere on the wall. I am intrigued by MCP
- 1:02:40as a bridge for AI, to physical devices. Damn it.
- 1:02:43All of you take that high theory. I realize, you
- 1:02:48know, it's not something that we can.
- 1:02:51>> Marc Cholewczynski: Context, protocol, bolting in capability, what
- 1:02:54that means.
- 1:02:55>> Speaker H: Yeah, if you like, I can search the web.
- 1:02:56>> Marc Cholewczynski: There she is. There she is.
- 1:02:59>> Craig Park: And I didn't even say her name.
- 1:03:02>> Marc Cholewczynski: That's Siri, MCP gone wrong.
- 1:03:04>> Craig Park: So.
- 1:03:05>> Justin Rexing: Yeah, I wouldn't celebrate that mark too much
- 1:03:08there.
- 1:03:09>> Marc Cholewczynski: I don't have that.
- 1:03:10>> Jamie Rinehart: I, I think it's very appropriate that all the
- 1:03:12Duke's money's going into figuring out how to use
- 1:03:14the Internet.
- 1:03:15>> Chris Dechter: Richard.
- 1:03:17>> Justin Rexing: Okay, yeah, yeah, but that. Thank you for that
- 1:03:20comment, Jamie.
- 1:03:24>> Craig Park: but, you know, the, the continual improvement of
- 1:03:29the way that we. And acceptance of the way that we
- 1:03:33collaborate, we wouldn't have had these kinds of
- 1:03:37conversations, that we do now with our teams using
- 1:03:41video, and the ability to be hybrid or high flex
- 1:03:46or whatever you want to call it, without the
- 1:03:49improvement of, of the technologies to make it
- 1:03:51easy and the quality is good and we can trust it,
- 1:03:55for the most part, you know, and I'm going to buy
- 1:03:58a T shirt that says I'm on mute, for every meeting
- 1:04:01I walk into, because I always am when I forget to
- 1:04:03be. but I am, I am intrigued with where AI is
- 1:04:07going and I am intrigued with the network basis of
- 1:04:11that that lets us manage it as another data
- 1:04:15stream. so I've been saying, and it's funny that
- 1:04:20she should jump in that I think we're going to see
- 1:04:23conversational control of rooms. A.I. would call
- 1:04:26it contextual, that it recognizes how many people
- 1:04:29in the room and self adjust the systems to match
- 1:04:31the audience. But I do think that would be nice if
- 1:04:34we could have a conversational control that would
- 1:04:36say I want to be able to connect my classroom to
- 1:04:39Penn or to you know, another location. Just by
- 1:04:42saying that that gets really hairy.
- 1:04:45>> Justin Rexing: Craig.
- 1:04:45>> Craig Park: I, I know it today.
- 1:04:48>> Marc Cholewczynski: I agree. I think you might have people on both
- 1:04:50sides of the aisle, but I think, yeah, you know,
- 1:04:52as we look at AI as kind of the democrat
- 1:04:55democratizing element that allows capability for
- 1:04:58once. We used to have to do all this mechanical
- 1:05:01things and do all this bespoke programming and all
- 1:05:03this, you know, wiring to that. When we start
- 1:05:06understanding that, okay, at that application
- 1:05:07layer and in cloud and beyond, how are we getting
- 1:05:10there and how does that transform we're doing. I
- 1:05:12think that's a really good kind of focus of like
- 1:05:15what may be capable tomorrow. But some people
- 1:05:18probably hear it and they're like no way in hell.
- 1:05:20I'm just trying to get through these next couple
- 1:05:21years and you know, don't pull the rug out front
- 1:05:24of me right now.
- 1:05:26>> Craig Park: And again I think that's the perspective. And we,
- 1:05:29you know, we're designing 50 year buildings,
- 1:05:31buildings with eight year technologies. if that.
- 1:05:36And we, if, yeah, if that, if that.
- 1:05:38>> Justin Rexing: 20, 20 year. Here we got 20 years now.
- 1:05:41>> Craig Park: Yeah, but we have to, how do we plan for that
- 1:05:44continual, evolution in a way. And that was one of
- 1:05:48your questions. I, I struggle with that because I
- 1:05:50don't, I don't, I understand the budgetary issues.
- 1:05:53Most campuses have a bigger budget for deferred
- 1:05:57maintenance than they do for capital projects. and
- 1:06:00no way to fund it.
- 1:06:02>> Marc Cholewczynski: Deferred, just means we're not doing that.
- 1:06:03>> Craig Park: Technology is a component of that. and so you have
- 1:06:06this you know, variety of kinds of spaces across
- 1:06:10any campus that are either well equipped or poorly
- 1:06:12equipped, depending on what, where they are in the
- 1:06:14recycle. I don't have a solution for that. I'm
- 1:06:18just acknowledging I'm aware of the problem. and I
- 1:06:21emphasize, But you know, what we try and do is Is
- 1:06:25plan as much pathway, ease of pathway. as opposed
- 1:06:31to buried pathway.
- 1:06:33>> Marc Cholewczynski: Is that like the philosophical approach really?
- 1:06:35>> Chris Dechter: If.
- 1:06:36>> Marc Cholewczynski: If in doubt, just focus on layer one.
- 1:06:39>> Chris Dechter: It never hurts.
- 1:06:40>> Marc Cholewczynski: Right? Is that to get out of free. Like I don't
- 1:06:41know what it's going to be tomorrow, but it's
- 1:06:43probably going to need some pathway. Well, but you
- 1:06:45just agree on that.
- 1:06:48>> Craig Park: That's the most important part. It is
- 1:06:50infrastructure. Infrastructure. Infrastructure are
- 1:06:52the three most important parts of technology
- 1:06:55planning. but you also have to be aware as we just
- 1:06:58had the conversation is where are things going?
- 1:07:01Where is it likely to land? and do we have and
- 1:07:03who.
- 1:07:04>> Marc Cholewczynski: Owns the service to move those things up? That
- 1:07:06because it may not be me, it may not be Chris, it
- 1:07:08may not be Justin. Are they in the room?
- 1:07:11>> Chris Dechter: It is Justin though.
- 1:07:12>> Justin Rexing: It's never me. It's. I don't know. I don't know.
- 1:07:16>> Craig Park: Or it might be the foundation who's got a donor.
- 1:07:18>> Marc Cholewczynski: Right? Yeah, exactly. Are they in the room right
- 1:07:20now? I don't know.
- 1:07:21>> Craig Park: Yeah, no, I've been in. I've been in that room
- 1:07:24where the 8 million dollar check was handed over.
- 1:07:26And so the donor wants a high tech building and
- 1:07:29was it at least.
- 1:07:30>> Chris Dechter: A big novelty check?
- 1:07:31>> Marc Cholewczynski: It had to be a novel check.
- 1:07:32>> Craig Park: No, it wasn't. It wasn't. But it was a letter. He
- 1:07:37did hold up a letter. It was a chancellor.
- 1:07:38>> Jamie Rinehart: It's an iou.
- 1:07:40>> Chris Dechter: I have a whole checkbook of novelty checks and
- 1:07:42it's taken me years to get through them. I still
- 1:07:43have them.
- 1:07:45>> Craig Park: Grocery store hates me three years later. To the
- 1:07:47point we've made a couple of times in this
- 1:07:49conversation is that the campus said we. The
- 1:07:52campus abit folks said we can't support that level
- 1:07:56of really cool stuff so we're gonna mothball it.
- 1:08:01And I. No, no, I was gonna say we're gonna dumb it
- 1:08:04down. And that's value engineer to use. We're
- 1:08:06going to simplify it to a. A lesser than you. You.
- 1:08:12You could have. But ultimately the room works and
- 1:08:15it still works today. and it wasn't he. The donor
- 1:08:19wrote a letter saying, I don't think it's what we.
- 1:08:21What I thought it might be. But if the teachers
- 1:08:25are happy and the students are graduating with
- 1:08:26degrees in physics, which is. Turns out to be that
- 1:08:29department, then I'm. I'm cool with it.
- 1:08:31>> Marc Cholewczynski: So PS I will not be donating next year.
- 1:08:34>> Justin Rexing: Never what the donor envisioned. No, it never is.
- 1:08:38>> Marc Cholewczynski: All right.
- 1:08:38>> Craig Park: Yeah.
- 1:08:38>> Chris Dechter: No. Hope that donor is old enough that.
- 1:08:41>> Justin Rexing: They don't worry about yeah, that's right.
- 1:08:43>> Speaker G: Yeah.
- 1:08:44>> Larry Darling: I, and I think that AI is going to fundamentally
- 1:08:46change how we design spaces. But I really think
- 1:08:50it's going to be because not so much of what we've
- 1:08:54been talking about, but because we're going to
- 1:08:56have to shift to a competency based education,
- 1:08:58change the way that.
- 1:08:59>> Marc Cholewczynski: Education is delivered, period. Yeah.
- 1:09:01>> Larry Darling: Because deliverables are no longer something you
- 1:09:04can judge a student's mastery of a subject.
- 1:09:06>> Marc Cholewczynski: That's hunter gathering.
- 1:09:07>> Larry Darling: We're going to have to find something else. So
- 1:09:10it's more experiential learning spaces that we're
- 1:09:12going to have to convert a lot.
- 1:09:13>> Chris Dechter: Larry, what you're saying is all going to be MiG
- 1:09:15and TiG Welding.
- 1:09:16>> Larry Darling: it might be.
- 1:09:17>> Marc Cholewczynski: I'm just saying it's going to be a lab.
- 1:09:19>> Larry Darling: Like it's. In five years things are going to look
- 1:09:21different.
- 1:09:21>> Craig Park: It's going to be. You've watched your lecture on
- 1:09:23Tick Tock last night and now you're coming into
- 1:09:25the, the lab to learn how to physically do that
- 1:09:28thing.
- 1:09:29>> Jamie Rinehart: M.
- 1:09:29>> Craig Park: And part of that thing is how do I prompt AI to
- 1:09:33give me the answer to so I don't have.
- 1:09:35>> Chris Dechter: To watch this whole video.
- 1:09:36>> Marc Cholewczynski: You don't have to prompt. It's going to know
- 1:09:37you're there anyway. It's going to say, hey, I
- 1:09:39noticed you're here. And let me just take this
- 1:09:41content and bring it ready for you individually.
- 1:09:44>> Chris Dechter: Well, let's, let's put a pin in things here. We
- 1:09:46could go on forever. We would go on for hours.
- 1:09:48>> Marc Cholewczynski: This is volume one.
- 1:09:50>> Chris Dechter: 16 hours to go. So yes, let's, let's, let's.
- 1:09:52Craig, let's find a time. We'll schedule another
- 1:09:55visit for you and we'll continue.
- 1:09:57>> Craig Park: I think it is the most valuable conversations the
- 1:10:00architects and engineers and consultants who are
- 1:10:02listening to the show is that, and I told you, and
- 1:10:06I'm not kissing up to the hosts here is to say
- 1:10:09when I first heard AV Super Friends, I think two
- 1:10:12and a half or three years ago when I was working
- 1:10:14at the Sextant group before they got acquired by
- 1:10:17Megalith NV5. I came back to the, to the
- 1:10:20principals meeting and said you all have to listen
- 1:10:22to these. These are the voices of the real people
- 1:10:25in the room who are making this stuff work after
- 1:10:27we leave. To your point, Justin, that's Yes, we.
- 1:10:31>> Marc Cholewczynski: Have to live with these decisions for years.
- 1:10:33>> Chris Dechter: And Craig, we still get the hate mail from that.
- 1:10:35>> Justin Rexing: That's the hardest part of being in our chairs. If
- 1:10:37you're a consultant Listening to this standing up.
- 1:10:39You all just collect your checks and leave the
- 1:10:42building at seven days after it opens and we never
- 1:10:45see you again. And it's hard as hell to keep that
- 1:10:48building running with all the. That we got to deal
- 1:10:51with because no one listened to us in the first
- 1:10:53place. nothing's labeled. We don't know what's
- 1:10:55what. Everything's not working. Somehow it got
- 1:10:58signed off on, somebody got paid. Don't know how
- 1:11:00that happened.
- 1:11:00>> Marc Cholewczynski: Email came to click here to issue payment, and
- 1:11:03they said, well, you know.
- 1:11:04>> Craig Park: And I, you know, I, I told Chris at the beginning
- 1:11:07of this, I, I take responsibility for being all
- 1:11:09architects and all AV consultants.
- 1:11:11>> Jamie Rinehart: Yeah.
- 1:11:11>> Craig Park: So I, I'll take that on, with the same mantle,
- 1:11:14but. And I know, you know, I have had great
- 1:11:16projects, and I've had projects where I've screwed
- 1:11:18up, too.
- 1:11:18>> Marc Cholewczynski: Yeah.
- 1:11:18>> Craig Park: So, you know, that happens. That's. We're all
- 1:11:20human and, and, I'm sure that that never happens
- 1:11:23to you guys, but that.
- 1:11:24>> Chris Dechter: Oh, we all.
- 1:11:24>> Jamie Rinehart: Yeah, let's not be throwing stones.
- 1:11:27>> Justin Rexing: I mean, we're all making mistakes here. It's just
- 1:11:29how you become.
- 1:11:30>> Craig Park: Learn from those things you do learn and move
- 1:11:33forward in a way that is more collaborative and
- 1:11:35more community communicative. Those two pieces
- 1:11:38being the key first attempt in learning.
- 1:11:40All right, thanks, Chris, for the invitation.
- 1:11:42>> Chris Dechter: Oh, no. Well, we got one more segment out of here.
- 1:11:47>> Marc Cholewczynski: This has all been the easy piece.
- 1:11:49>> Chris Dechter: Yeah. So we're gonna take a quick break and come
- 1:11:50back. We're talking about why AV over IP has to be
- 1:11:52in every space. But first to our conversation
- 1:11:54briefly here about natural language processing and
- 1:11:57AI. stuff I do want to say before we close out
- 1:11:59here for everyone listening. Okay, Google, delete
- 1:12:02all my photos. Hey, Siri, navigate home Alexa.
- 1:12:08Play country music now. Now, I've screwed up
- 1:12:10everyone's life there.
- 1:12:12>> Justin Rexing: So, yes, I see what you're doing there.
- 1:12:14>> Jamie Rinehart: Good thing we're on headphones.
- 1:12:15>> Chris Dechter: Yeah. Ah, for you guys.
- 1:12:18All right, let's take a quick break. We'll come
- 1:12:19back, we'll talk about AV over IP being the future
- 1:12:21of the future, apparently.
- 1:12:24>> Justin Rexing: Delete all my photos.
- 1:12:26>> Speaker H: This fall, your AV system just got a whole lot
- 1:12:29cozier. Introducing the independent Amalgamated
- 1:12:32Limited edition Pumpkin Spice AV collection. Why
- 1:12:36should your coffee have all the Fun Rich Amber
- 1:12:41LEDs, cinnamon tinted cable jackets, and the
- 1:12:45unmistakable aroma of nutmeg wafting from your
- 1:12:48lavalier mic every time you clip it on from
- 1:12:52presentation switchers that crunch like piles of
- 1:12:54fallen leaves when they change sources to cameras
- 1:12:58that autofocus only on flannel this season. Your
- 1:13:02classrooms and meeting rooms aren't just smart,
- 1:13:05they're deliciously festive. But act fast. This
- 1:13:08pumpkin spice gear will disappear faster than
- 1:13:11decorative gourds at a farmer's market. Available
- 1:13:14through November or until the first snowfall.
- 1:13:17Pumpkin spice AV fall into better quality
- 1:13:21conferencing from Independent Amalgamated. Not
- 1:13:25compatible with summer firmware. May cause sudden
- 1:13:28cravings for pie. Use in moderation, please.
- 1:13:35>> Chris Dechter: I want pie now.
- 1:13:36>> Marc Cholewczynski: Pumpkin spice.
- 1:13:39>> Chris Dechter: All right, so for our, our, our final topic here.
- 1:13:41it's a, it's a shorty. this comes from, our good
- 1:13:43friends over at AV Nation, who will report on
- 1:13:46anything. and the title of this one is AV over IP
- 1:13:49and Higher Education From Hype to Higher Purpose.
- 1:13:52And it's a weird article. link in the show notes.
- 1:13:54It's a weird article.
- 1:13:55>> Marc Cholewczynski: It's like an ad though.
- 1:13:56>> Chris Dechter: It's like an ad, but I can't tell from who. And it
- 1:14:00also is wrong in many, many, many, many, many
- 1:14:04ways.
- 1:14:05>> Jamie Rinehart: But it's right.
- 1:14:06>> Chris Dechter: It's right in other ways. Craig, you mentioned
- 1:14:08earlier we're talking about active, learning rooms
- 1:14:09and AV over IP maybe. Makes perfect sense for a
- 1:14:11scenario like that. I want flexibility, I want
- 1:14:13expandability. AV over IP all day long. Why am I
- 1:14:17putting all my stuff on the network if it doesn't
- 1:14:18need to be there? Why am I attaching all my stuff
- 1:14:20to the cloud if it doesn't need to go there? Why
- 1:14:22do I need AV over IP in places where I don't need
- 1:14:24AV over ip?
- 1:14:26>> Marc Cholewczynski: No, we need the data.
- 1:14:28>> Craig Park: Does it, does it give you away in those rooms? To
- 1:14:31your description, the little huddle room, of six
- 1:14:34people that students book to have a team based
- 1:14:36meeting if it's connected to your network?
- 1:14:39>> Chris Dechter: They don't book those.
- 1:14:41>> Craig Park: Whoever books it, no one. Does it, does it make it
- 1:14:44easier for you to manage that space? Know what's
- 1:14:47going on? How healthy is that space because it's
- 1:14:50there? Or do you just wait for the trouble ticket?
- 1:14:52>> Chris Dechter: Well, and here's the point, you're not wrong
- 1:14:53there. But none of that technically requires AV
- 1:14:56over ip. I can do all of that because all those
- 1:14:59endpoints are already on the network running VGA
- 1:15:02endpoints in a monitoring.
- 1:15:03>> Marc Cholewczynski: System and roll up in data and download
- 1:15:05dashboards. Like that's necessarily the AV over IP
- 1:15:08conversation.
- 1:15:08>> Craig Park: So.
- 1:15:08>> Justin Rexing: Yeah, all that existed well before AV over IP
- 1:15:12existed.
- 1:15:12>> Chris Dechter: No, Justin, last year in an encoder.
- 1:15:15>> Craig Park: Decoder at the every device. We just need a
- 1:15:18network connection to the seat, to the room.
- 1:15:21>> Jamie Rinehart: and the best part is, is everybody uses this
- 1:15:23technology on an island, so you can't get it
- 1:15:27anyway. It's my favorite, Craig.
- 1:15:31>> Larry Darling: You may not start there, but you'll end up there.
- 1:15:34>> Chris Dechter: We're all going to end up on an island one of
- 1:15:35these days.
- 1:15:36>> Jamie Rinehart: Let's connect all of these AV over IP devices to
- 1:15:39the switch that's in this one lockdown cabinet
- 1:15:41that nothing can reach from anywhere unless you're
- 1:15:43in the room with your local laptop. Great, thanks.
- 1:15:45>> Marc Cholewczynski: It's not the correct use case to just replace a
- 1:15:47switcher with avi.
- 1:15:50>> Chris Dechter: That's the way this article reads is like take
- 1:15:52your, your HDBASET chassis, which we all did 12,
- 1:15:5415 years ago, take that, throw it away and replace
- 1:15:57it with a giant network switch doing the exact
- 1:15:59same thing. Like, what do we really gain there?
- 1:16:03>> Marc Cholewczynski: It.
- 1:16:03>> Chris Dechter: so. So it's. It was just a. It was a weirdly
- 1:16:05phrased article. I know what they're saying. I
- 1:16:07know what they were trying to get across. I can't
- 1:16:10tell who the ad is by because it wasn't called
- 1:16:12out.
- 1:16:13>> Marc Cholewczynski: well, there were some like, so I'm not sure.
- 1:16:17Messaging I heard recently, but I don't, I don't
- 1:16:19opinion on them. There's some good points in this
- 1:16:21article for those like, definitely go check and
- 1:16:23read on that. And like that question, is it being
- 1:16:25forced? I think that's a good question. Are we
- 1:16:28forcing it in places where.
- 1:16:29>> Chris Dechter: Maybe we shouldn't from a manufacturer standpoint,
- 1:16:31all day long? Yes. In the most inappropriate
- 1:16:34places possible. So, Craig, to your point, huddle
- 1:16:37rube, that goes nowhere. That needs to be AV over
- 1:16:39IP to get. I, I kid you not.
- 1:16:40>> Justin Rexing: I've seen ones stupid.
- 1:16:42>> Chris Dechter: Wait for this. Justin. I've seen ones to go from
- 1:16:44that connection point at the table just to the
- 1:16:46display, the huddle space to the display and it's.
- 1:16:48There's a fricking encoder and decoder in there.
- 1:16:50>> Justin Rexing: The network switch above the ceiling on a Dr.
- 1:16:52>> Larry Darling: In the idf way out there.
- 1:16:53>> Chris Dechter: Yeah, it all runs down the hall and back. It's
- 1:16:56ridiculous.
- 1:16:56>> Marc Cholewczynski: So I think generically we can do a poll quickly
- 1:17:01around room. is AV over IP innovation at this
- 1:17:04point?
- 1:17:05>> Justin Rexing: No, it's just a different way of doing another
- 1:17:07transport.
- 1:17:08>> Craig Park: Right, right, right.
- 1:17:09>> Marc Cholewczynski: But I, I think there are folks out there that
- 1:17:11believe that even in the industry that, no, this
- 1:17:14is innovative. And this person. I think, I think
- 1:17:16we're back.
- 1:17:16>> Justin Rexing: I've seen anything innovative in like two and a
- 1:17:19half years and I feel.
- 1:17:21>> Marc Cholewczynski: Like we're just past that conversation now. Like,
- 1:17:23if you have the reason and you want to have that
- 1:17:25connected piece and you want that and you have to
- 1:17:27disperse that in a way that's more like easy and
- 1:17:29economically feasible. Like yeah, it makes sense.
- 1:17:32>> Jamie Rinehart: It's another.
- 1:17:33>> Craig Park: Well in the last segment I didn't get to say when
- 1:17:35you were asking about what's the future look like
- 1:17:37is I want to say gigabit passive optical
- 1:17:40networking that we're running fiber to all these
- 1:17:42devices and yeah.
- 1:17:44>> Justin Rexing: Oh God.
- 1:17:45>> Craig Park: Dude.
- 1:17:46>> Marc Cholewczynski: I don't know Justin.
- 1:17:49>> Justin Rexing: I mean it sounds like the future. Like I like the
- 1:17:51glass thing but.
- 1:17:53>> Chris Dechter: I'm going retro with Cat 3.
- 1:17:55>> Justin Rexing: Yeah that's just well bandwidth. We don't need the
- 1:17:59bandwidth in there. We don't need there's today
- 1:18:03but 50.
- 1:18:03>> Craig Park: Years from now again I'm banking on compression.
- 1:18:06>> Justin Rexing: We're gonna run 1080p from 15 years from now based
- 1:18:09upon the room size that we have. Right. So we
- 1:18:11always go back to physics.
- 1:18:12>> Craig Park: So it's like well the, the other the the the
- 1:18:15upside is it's cheaper than copper.
- 1:18:18>> Justin Rexing: Well that show me that on paper you know that's
- 1:18:21where yeah I mean I can believe that down the road
- 1:18:23where it is maybe cheaper to do glass maybe the
- 1:18:26technical expertise everybody my support team and
- 1:18:29everybody on my team can terminate glass M like
- 1:18:32that's especially.
- 1:18:34>> Craig Park: Right now it's still it still goes to some
- 1:18:37middleware or middle device a MUX of some sort
- 1:18:40that takes that copper that takes the glass to
- 1:18:43back to copper because we don't I don't have fiber
- 1:18:46input to my laptop.
- 1:18:47>> Justin Rexing: maybe you do projector.
- 1:18:49>> Chris Dechter: I don't have copper input on my.
- 1:18:51>> Justin Rexing: Laptop put on our projector screen.
- 1:18:53>> Marc Cholewczynski: I don't think we're going to be forcing EV signals
- 1:18:55around spaces. I honestly don't believe that not
- 1:18:58today.
- 1:18:58>> Craig Park: But tomorrow something to I think it's but we can
- 1:19:00connect IDF cloud since we do that with with glass
- 1:19:03now.
- 1:19:04>> Marc Cholewczynski: We'Ll be doing ah session join things that are
- 1:19:06going to be more software delivered.
- 1:19:07>> Craig Park: we've got a project that they're adding two floors
- 1:19:10to an existing building. The weight of the
- 1:19:13additional two floors was more than the original
- 1:19:15geotech support structural support. So we looked
- 1:19:19at how that planning how much does everything
- 1:19:23weigh in those floors and fiber was a real
- 1:19:26solution to because it's lighter than copper. So
- 1:19:30you know when we redesigned the whole building
- 1:19:32then it made sense and it's also a residence hall
- 1:19:35so the density of device locations makes sense.
- 1:19:37>> Marc Cholewczynski: If you're gonna build a risky one, make it the
- 1:19:39residence hall.
- 1:19:42>> Chris Dechter: Justin's got Some broken dorms. All right, all
- 1:19:45right.
- 1:19:46>> Justin Rexing: we don't.
- 1:19:47>> Marc Cholewczynski: Yeah, not now.
- 1:19:49>> Justin Rexing: That's a different shift.
- 1:19:51>> Chris Dechter: Well, let's, let's wrap there. Craig, if people
- 1:19:52want to get in touch with you, they want to reach
- 1:19:54out, they want to hear more from you. Where, where
- 1:19:55are they going? Where are we sending them?
- 1:19:56>> Craig Park: They're going to go to Craig. you can go to Clark
- 1:20:00and Anderson. E N E R S E N. my. you can find me
- 1:20:04on the Digital Experience Design tab on our
- 1:20:07website. you can find me on LinkedIn, Greg Park.
- 1:20:11you can find me at edup SmartSpace, our podcast.
- 1:20:15And, you can find me at Scup and Appa and Etc. And
- 1:20:19Hetma. talking with, with Joe and Chris on, cattle
- 1:20:24groups about the future of maybe.
- 1:20:27>> Chris Dechter: Very good. Well, if you want the future, it's
- 1:20:29apparently adds floors to buildings. Just keep
- 1:20:31going. Just do them below. It's easier that way.
- 1:20:36All right, well, we're going to roll out Craig,
- 1:20:38hang out for a minute here, and we'll, we'll wrap
- 1:20:39up some stuff here after, after the show. But,
- 1:20:41we'll see everyone next, week for more nonsense.
- 1:20:43And we'll schedule another visit with Craig down
- 1:20:45the road to, continue our conversation on building
- 1:20:48relationships with consultants, and doing things
- 1:20:50right.
- 1:20:50>> Justin Rexing: Thanks, Craig.
- 1:20:51>> Craig Park: Thank you.
- 1:20:56>> Chris Dechter: Well, we've managed to ruin yet another episode of
- 1:20:58AV Super Friends off the Rails. You can contact us
- 1:21:01with questions, topic ideas, or General
- 1:21:03complaints@mailbagvsuperfriends.com if you
- 1:21:07complain loud enough, we might just invite you on
- 1:21:09the show.
- 1:21:12>> Marc Cholewczynski: Nice work, everyone.
- 1:21:14>> Justin Rexing: Sharp broadcast.
- 1:21:15>> Chris Dechter: Really good. Everyone on the floor as well. Really
- 1:21:18a lot of hustle.
- 1:21:19>> Craig Park: I liked it.
- 1:21:20>> Chris Dechter: The opinions expressed by the AV Super Friends are
- 1:21:22solely those of the individuals and do not
- 1:21:24represent their respective institutions,
- 1:21:26organizations, companies or clients.