Latest / First Encounter—A Historical Romance Podcast / S1 E15—Closed Door and Low Spice Historical Romance with Nichole Van
Transcript
- Andie James: Hello, everyone, and welcome to First Encounter. My name is Andie James, and I am a historical romance enthusiast and author. And I am joined again, or for the first time, depending on what you've listened to, by Nicole Van today. I'm very excited to talk to her about her books. I say again because we did a bonus episode of the podcast that was released last Wednesday, where we talked about AI and how it's affecting publishing spaces and all the questions we have and no answers basically. But it was a great discussion. So I hope if you have not seen that episode that you'll go back and look at that. But now we're here to talk about books because that's what we're all about. Historical romance. We love it. So Nicole is one of my favorite historical romance authors. I absolutely adore her books. And so I'm very excited to talk to you about them now. And just thank you for taking so much time with me, both the other episode and today. Nichole Van: I'm happy to be here. Andie James: Yeah, great. Well, let me just introduce you a little bit and then we can dive right into all the goodness. Nicole is a writer, photographer, designer, and generally disorganized person. I can identify with that. Though originally from the Rocky Mountains, she has lived all over the world, including Italy and the UK. She and her family recently returned to the US after spending six years in Scotland. We are definitely gonna talk about that. And Nicole currently lives atop a mountain in the Rockies with her husband, three children, and a feckless cat named Jane Pawsten, which is just the best cat name in the world. Nichole Van: She is she it we we got a cat so we could have like you know, we I live in the mountains. You gotta have a cat. And if you don't want rodents in your house, Andie James: You gotta have a cat. Yeah. Nichole Van: she just hangs out in the garage. She never leaves. She was hired for a job Andie James: I love it. I love it. Nichole Van: and she's like, no. I'm just it's nice in here. I'm just gonna stay in the garage. Jane Pawsten. I know. Andie James: Jane Pawsten that's the best. That's the best. I love it. Well, again, thank you for joining me today. and before we even just dive into all the goodness about historical romance, I I have to mention that Nicole has a new book out. And Nichole Van: Do. Andie James: when this episode airs, it will have come out just yesterday, I believe. So it's not out yet when we're recording this, but when you hear it, it'll be available for you. Nichole Van: So exciting. Yeah. It'll be available. Andie James: Yes, and it she let me read a copy early and you guys, it's so good. so this is book two in the Earls of Cairnfell series, and it's called A Lass Beloved. And we're gonna talk about it, but it was just Matt. I love it. I love it. Matthias. Nichole Van: I know, Matthias is the best. He's a great character. Andie James: Love him, yes. so everyone, we're gonna talk about it, but just know that that book is now available. So Before we dive into your background in books, I just want to know a little bit more about your relationship with romance general and historical romance specifically. So like when did you fall in love with this genre? When did you start reading it? And when did you decide to write it? Small questions. Nichole Van: So I know small question, literally cannot remember a time when I did not love historical romance. Like I can't remember when I first read Anna Green Gables, which is historical romance when I first read like Andie James: It is? I love having a free gable stuff. Nichole Van: I seem to remember going through I was probably like eleven or eleven, ten or eleven. And I went through a summer where the our library had Georgette Hayer Hayer. Georgette Hayer, her entire back catalogue. And so I read every single one of her books like in one summer when I was young. And it just I've always, always, always, always loved romance. Like I can't even remember a time when I didn't. as far as writing romance, I wrote a lot as a teenager. And then I just didn't do anything with writing or even reading really for probably 15 years. and I I did get my degree in my grad degree is in English. But I was rhetoric. I wasn't creative writing or literature. And I did a lot of technical writing. I've written multiple technical writing manuals. I've written manuals Andie James: Okay. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: about teaching. I even wrote a manual about teaching. This is a fun fact. Fun, fun old Nicole Lore. I wrote a manual that was a freshman English writing course for at the university level. And long story short, it won a like a huge grant, like six Andie James: Nice. Nichole Van: figure grant from the Pew Foundation. The first humanities course in the country to ever win this grant award for the development of a freshman course. So that's what I did for like a hot minute. and Andie James: Nice. Nice. Nichole Van: it wasn't until 2012 that I actually picked up a pen again and started writing. And and the first series I wrote wasn't actually straight historical romance. It was historical romance time travel. It was like Bridgerton meets Outlander. Yeah, it was really fun. Andie James: No. I know, and I've not read that series yet. Yeah. Nichole Van: and And so it took me a minute. I historical romance was always my love, but it took me a minute before I went into like straight historical romance. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: but especially moving to Scotland helped with that. So lots of inspiration Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: there. Andie James: Yeah. So you did live in Scotland for a while and obviously Nichole Van: Yes, yeah. Andie James: great inspiration. And I mean your books really feel so I okay, so you've written like twenty plus books now. You've written a lot. Nichole Van: Yeah, I think I think the one that just came out was twenty like actual novels, not novellas or anything, I think was number Andie James: Right. Nichole Van: twenty five. Andie James: Wow. Okay. That's impressive. I've written five. so Nichole Van: Ha ha Andie James: yeah, so you've been writing for a while and as you said, your first series is kind of little genre blend, little time travel, and then there was another series, Brothers Mal Yes. Nichole Van: The Brothers Maldaddy, that was Italian. and it does have still a h lot of historical elements in it. just the way the plot is with it. It's supernatural, but there's it's contemporary supernatural is how I term it, but it definitely has a lot of ties to the Regency era, but Regency era in Italy, during the time period. Andie James: Hey. Nichole Van: So it's actually very it was a lot of really fun research and stuff that I did for that series. Yes. Yeah. Andie James: So those are the early series that I have not read. I someday I will. Time. Time. Yeah. I know. I'm very excited because I love your writing. Nichole Van: They're still fun. They're they're they're they're still me. Yeah. Andie James: and I how did I find you? I don't even know. I think it was early 2025. and I can't remember how I found you. I I mean, it was like Amazon algorithm because of something I was reading. And I realized I'd downloaded one of your books previously on like a free promotion thing or a sale or something. And so I was like, I'll start there. And it was Love Practically. So I think I'm getting that title right. and so I read that series first. So that is the the Penn-Leiths and then I went back and read your Brotherhood series, which is I guess the first Nichole Van: Yeah, it's first gen, second gen. Yeah. Andie James: Real Yeah. But so that is when your books though kind of really went historical romance and they're Okay. Nichole Van: Yes, I had a couple one-offs before that. Seeing Miss Heartstone I think was the first straight historical that I wrote. and then yeah, but the it was really once I started writing the Scottish romance that I really Andie James: Yes. Nichole Van: deep dove into it. Andie James: And I love them because they're Scottish, but they're not like like when I think Scottish romance, I think more kind of like Highlander, maybe more like 1600s, right? And so, Nichole Van: Yeah. Yeah. Andie James: but you're writing Regency and Early Victorian set in Scotland. So it's like almost a blend of kind of what we love in these different kind of pockets of historical romance. Because you've got all the beautiful Scottish But time period, it's it's a little closer to a lot of what's being written currently. And they're great. So I've read the Brotherhood series, I've read the Penn-Leiths series, and then your new series has two books now out, The Earls of Cairnfell. And it's kind of separate. So those those two series I mentioned are are kind of connected, like you said, kind of first, second generation. Nichole Van: Yeah, there there's definitely overlap in characters between the two series. Andie James: There is, yeah. And I will say one thing I've noticed about your writing is you love some contentious families. It's great. No, it's great. I love it. I love it. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: Well, there's so much inherent drama in a contentious family, you know? It's like I think that one of the advantages of having written twenty-five books is that I'm more comfortable writing messiness. Like it's Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: it's difficult to write a messy plot. It's like a not a messy plot. I mean it's really easy to write a messy plot. Let me be very clear about that. That's actually quite simple. But to write a messy, complicated emotional situation, it's much easier to have it be clear black, clear white, clear whatever. Andie James: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Nichole Van: It's easier. to hold it in your head. It's much harder to make it complicated. But as as I've as I've matured as an author, it's been really fun to write these very complex characters and complex situations where there is a lot of grey area and a lot Andie James: No, that's great. Yeah. Nichole Van: of emotional stuff to be navigated. It's fun. Andie James: Yeah. Well in the first book in the current series is A Tartan Love and it's very Romeo and Juliet. I mean it's just it's so great. You know, it's the people falling in love from the feuding families and well Nichole Van: It was so fun. Yeah. Andie James: feuding's maybe a little strong, but well, maybe not. I don't know. Yeah. Nichole Van: Yeah. Well that that was sort of that that was actually the setup. Like that was the whole goal is to have sort of a Romeo Juliet vibe between these two families and then to kind of watch all that interaction play out. Andie James: Yeah. And it's just it's beautiful. So yeah, I reread before this. I reread A Tartan Love, and then I read A Lass Beloved, which is the new iteration or the new volume. Nichole Van: And new bug. Yeah. Andie James: and it's just gorgeous. I love your writing and it reminds me so one of the things that we wanted to talk about today, because I always ask people like, Do you have a topic you want to talk about? Like, I I I want to talk about your books, but like is there something related to historical romance that we can discuss. And I loved what you mentioned would be an interesting thing to talk about is I for lack of a better word, I guess spice level and how we talk about that and different markets and different reading groups and people who read whatever. And that's something that for me has always been a huge part of what I've struggled with, I guess, in terms of how do I talk about my books, how do I market my books? 'cause I feel like my own books are very at a in between place. and your books I think to me are very similar. I book group them in my mind with Mimi Matthews in terms of the way that you approach the spice, I guess, in that it's it's closed door, but it's very sensual and it's very accepting of sex. It's not judgmental about sex, it sees it as a natural part of relationships. You're just not showing the action, right? But it's still very Nichole Van: Exactly. Andie James: sensual. It's very they're sexy books, you know? And Nichole Van: Thank you. Andie James: they're very romantic. and I Nichole Van: Thank you. I I just have to say I appreciate that you caught all that, because that's absolutely where I'm at with it. I I feel like when we start talking about spice level, like in in my head, there's actually as I write, there's a very distinct separation between sensuality and tension and an emotion and sex. And like you can have all of this without having this. Like you don't actually Andie James: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yes. Nichole Van: If it's done really well, you don't actually need the explicit content. And if it's done poorly, the explicit content isn't actually helping. And that that's a reason Andie James: Right. Nichole Van: why if you for me is sometimes if I'm reading something and I'm like, this just feels really extraneous. Like I'm not feeling this. And if I can just skip it 'cause I don't care about it, then Andie James: Mm. Nichole Van: it wasn't written very well in the first place. So that's just my opinion. Andie James: Yeah. No, it's interesting because I so I read it all. I've closed door to open door to I I read it all. but when it comes to what I write, like I just don't write very explicit. And it's I I sh I've always struggled with how to explain and market my own books because to me, the way I define it, they are open door in the We're in the moment with them, but they're not explicit. It's like the emotions of the moment that we're exploring, but I don't like fully close the door. And so I've played with the terminology door cracked. Like, you know, like I don't Nichole Van: Yeah. Andie James: know. I think one time I said Mimi Matthews with the door cracked. Like it's I'm trying to get at that kind of same because it's like it's like a step further than your books and her books, but it's not it's still not like I don't know. And so I've really struggled with it. And because people that want closed door and don't wanna read that, like my books might be too much. But then I don't wanna put them in promotions for like steamy books because then Nichole Van: Yeah. Andie James: like my books are gonna disappoint. Like it's just kind of this. Nichole Van: It's it's so hard and especially when you're talking about like in the clean book world, there is a list. Like there are very strict rules and very strict guidelines Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: that you do not cross. And if you cross those lines, then Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: there's a huge bunch of readers that aren't gonna consider you clean anymore. Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: and I might push right up against that line, Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: but I know what lines not to cross. And so I even Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: though I personally wouldn't think it was necessarily like it's still clean. Do you know what I mean? I know some Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: readers wouldn't consider it clean and so Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Nichole Van: That's been a choice that I've made. But you bring up an interesting thing, which is I do read a wide variety for myself. and we can discuss, I don't know if we're if we're gonna get into it. I actually did, I think I mentioned this to you. I did a really Andie James: Yes. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: good live with a sex therapist, licensed sex therapist. She's phenomenal, by the way. and we talked about this very openly, Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: kind of like because I think a lot of the reasons why people avoid spice, sometimes it just makes people feel very uncomfortable. Other times it can make someone Anyway, there's a number of reasons why you someone chooses not to read spice. And in that live we talked about how to understand when the content of what you are reading is actually impacting your emotional health as well as any intimate relationships you may have in your life. Andie James: Right. Yeah. Nichole Van: and so for me I take this stuff that we talked about in that live as sort of my guideline. And then when I feel something pushing up against what I feel are my lines, that's Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: that's my line. but I finally just kind of accepted I want to write at the spice level that I like to read. And this is the spice level I like to read. where it has steam, it has heat, we acknowledge that we're adults and we think about sex, like for the love. Like, come on. Like what 30 year old guy out Andie James: Yes. Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: there is like, I have no idea what this is even happening here? Like, please, you know what I mean? Like, come on. that's Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: my opinion. But but I don't need to go beyond the door of the bedroom. necessarily into that into those intimate moments, even though I do have books where, you know, there's a fade to black and there is, you know, an implication. And it might even faintly drift into the bedroom a tiny bit, like like you said, emotionally or thought wise. but never really crosses into anything explicit. So Andie James: Yeah. And it's so interesting because you mentioned as you were talking about that right there, you were talking about right, there's kind of a space for marketing and readers that's called like the clean reading space. Nichole Van: Yeah. Yeah. Andie James: And I've never used that term personally because to me I think it implies that sex is then dirty, which I don't Yeah. And so I don't love the terminology. Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: Yeah. No, and I'm with you on that. I don't love the term either. I think that it 'cause it's it's a very natural, very very mm the word I keep thinking of is welcome. It's it's a very happy part of human existence. You know what I mean? And it's it Andie James: Yeah. Well I think it's a natural part of human relationships, right? Nichole Van: is and and it is a fantastic, wonderful, beautiful Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: thing and should be celebrated and explored and not like shoved away like it's some kind of like, well. Mm, you know, 'cause it's not. It's fantastic and we should just we should be talk openly. Andie James: Right. Right. Right. And so I guess just how much you personally are willing to to engage like how much you're okay with, like you said, figuring Nichole Van: Yeah. Yeah. Andie James: out your own line. And I don't know. I mean, like I said, as a reader, I'm willing to read a lot. But where it gets me, I think, and this is why I think the difference because people I know that read the spectrum, like us, like I think it's what they're looking for. is just a really good love story. And because you can have a super spicy book that is just as romantic because it's so well integrated and it gets at those emotions and it gets us those pieces. And then the books that don't do it for me as much are like I I feel like you think you need to hit a certain like spice level and you're just kind of splicing these scenes in and it doesn't really either fit the characters you built to this point or all of a sudden something they do in the bedroom is out of character you know, and it it feels like it's there for the sake of being there. Nichole Van: Exactly. No, and you do see a lot of that. Like I can I I feel like that's probably one actually, ironically, one of my hardest things as a reader is Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: that I don't really necessarily care about the spectrum, but I really dislike that. I Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: dislike that I'm I'm reading and it's a but we have all this great like kinetic chemistry or whatever, and then all of a sudden it's like, we hit X percentage of the book. I guess we need to have a sex scene now. And you're like, wait, what no, that did not that was not That was not in the plan. Like I did not feel that. That didn't feel like that was organic. That just felt like you hit a you you Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: were you were like filling an editorial need or something. And Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: yeah. So I'm I'm with you on it. Like it just it's it's a hard one. I and I think that's part of the problem. And I think it's been interesting. We've seen, it was Abby Jimenez, her latest one, just had a fade to black. She didn't have a sex scene at all in it. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: and I think a lot a lot of people were like, because some of her books have been, you know, pretty spicy. And and I and I'm not even quite sure why she didn't. but I d I think she just felt like the characters did they just wasn't part of the characters MO, it wasn't part of the story. I know Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: Christina Lauren had something like that too, where it just wasn't it just didn't feel right to the plot and I applaud them. Really? Andie James: I did that in my last book. My latest release came out in January, ended up being kisses only. And it's not because I'm like all of a sudden like I can't have a sex scene. It just for those for the slice of the story I was telling, so part of it is, you know, time period, whatever, they didn't they didn't get married in the book, which I don't believe marriage has to be, you know, like you have Nichole Van: No. Andie James: to be married. But for those characters in the time period in which I was writing them and their values and w how they're brought up, like it would have been out of character. Nichole Van: Which I have to say I applaud you for that because I think that that is one of the hardest things as authors, that we are always putting our morality on our characters. And you can say you're not doing it, but for the love you are. Do you know what I mean? Like if you're writing historical romance Andie James: Yeah, yeah. Nichole Van: and your your worldview is I think casual sex is fine, and so you have this sweet virgin vicar's daughter who just decides to throw it away for a night and sleep with the rogue that's coming through the village. I'm like, sweetheart. They don't do that. Like they would not do that. Like that she Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: was not raised in an environment and and the consequences of that kind of behavior for her life, she would not do that. She wouldn't. unless she was just a very specific kind of person that wanted Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: to rebel or something. And so then you gotta build that as an author. But it's interesting that you say that. You can, but you gotta think about that, you know. Andie James: Yeah. And you can build that. You can build the character to be the rebel. You can build the yeah. But you have to do that. And so for me, you know, and it's like and so I think in general, like I said, most my books are I would consider open door. This last one ended up being kisses only, but open door like barely. but it's interesting though, because other people, like in reviews, I've had people refer to My earlier books, not the latest, as Kisses Only, because I don't go into explicit detail about what's happening, even though it's pretty clear what's happening. Like I Nichole Van: Pretty clear what's happening, yeah. Andie James: did, I did, I kind of this will only hit a certain generation. But I did land on an example I like for my books, is that they're like Notting Hill, if you've seen that movie, where it's Nichole Van: That movie. Andie James: like, you know what's happening. Nichole Van: Yes. Andie James: But like we don't show like the actual moment, but the lead up and the immediately after, it's very clear what's happened and there's we're still showing intimate moments with them. And so I was like, I feel like my books are like Notting Hill. Like that's you know, like that level. I don't know. It's interesting. Nichole Van: I love that analogy. I love that. Andie James: But yeah, I just i I I've always struggled, like I said, because I feel like some people consider my would consider my books steamy because I do discuss it. I'm open about it. These characters are having sex. Except for the latest. But they have their moments. They have their intimate moments together. but like I don't necessarily feel like I can promo them with like steamy books. And it's too much for like people that want closed door. It's like it's just this weird in between. And something I I saw, I mean I don't know if we can make terms take off. I certainly can't. I'm not big enough. But Where I don't even remember where I saw this, but it was recently, like within the last month. Someone was like, How would you describe their books? And instead of just kind of the two, they had three options, which I appreciated. There was like, I can't r I think they said sweet and steamy, but they had an in-between term that was sexy. And I was like, maybe my books are like the sexy books. I was like, Nichole Van: sexy. I like that. Andie James: maybe I can market them that way because I don't know. But anyways, I'm going off now. But but it's really interesting because I think there's a lot of readers who read all of it like I do. and they're just looking for a good story. And the author I have seen, again on my corner of the internet that I kind of live in, the author I have seen really embraced is Mimi Matthews. and I love that people love her books because, you know. Nichole Van: yeah. She's fantastic. Andie James: She's great. I love her books so much. and I think because people the the comments I've seen, so people who read and enjoy Steamy but love Mimi Matthews, the thing I've seen is that it's that attitude around it, right? It's like she's not showing it but she's not shaming. She's it's a natural part of this character and love story development. we're just maybe not showing these moments in detail. and so I think it's I don't know where I'm going with that, but Nichole Van: Well, I think that I think the the point you're bringing up is that we are allowing characters to be themselves. and Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: going back to to the other to our earlier comment about, you know, not like like your your book was just kisses only because that's what the characters you had written. that's what Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: they would have been. But I think the opposite is also true in the in like we'll use the sweet, because I agree with you quickly. We'll say the sweet book world. that Andie James: Mm-hmm. Discrete books. Sure. Great. Nichole Van: A lot of times you're putting this morality onto the characters that we're gonna keep it super clean, but it's like that Andie James: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: isn't the character, like they're in love with this person, they're married. Like for the love, they're gonna have a sexy thought. Like they will, you know? And I think for Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: me, I just got tired of pretending because I think my earlier books are probably more sweet than what I've written, say, in the last three or four years. I mean, they're all still very much in the clean genre, but Andie James: Okay. Yeah, yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Nichole Van: but I definitely have been including more discussion of sex and stuff, I'd say, in recent years. For that very reason, I just got tired of like. having to like tow some line that just felt very artificial to my characters. and Andie James: Within Nichole Van: like they're adults, they're gonna be thinking and talking about sex. Now does it mean that it's crass? No. Does it mean that I'm, you know, crossing lines? No. But like you like you can have a discussion of sex without it being those things. and you can treat it as if it exists and people do it and we're hoping to do it as characters. You know what I mean? Like we can we can include all of this information in there. Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: and that I think is what when you start talking about a book being sexy, which I love that term, Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: that's fantastic, that's what we mean. Like it's a book that doesn't ignore reality. It treats our characters like adults. And I think I Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yes. Nichole Van: mean I I don't write young characters. My characters tend to be late twenties, early thirties, like up to almost forty in some cases, even older than forty in some cases. Because I like I struggle with young love. I'm sorry. I'm sorry to everyone out there that met their like soulmate at age sixteen and like has been madly in love Andie James: I hear you. I hear you. Yeah. Nichole Van: and writes eighteen year olds and love it loves it. I just I know why this is tragic to say. I know why people write eighteen year olds because they're so much easier to write because they're stupid. Andie James: Okay. Nichole Van: Which is terrible of me to say. I know I just insulted like so many authors. I'm so sorry. But it's harder to write an older character because they're more complex. They've experienced more of Andie James: Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: life and and that goes right along with sex too. Like It's gonna be included if the character is older because they are not so naive. They've thought about these things. They've been exposed to these things. Like even in even in a historical world, you're not escaping it. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Well, I mean, 'cause the thing is, like we said, it is a natural part of human life and relationships, right? And it's always existed and it's always happened. And we like to think, you know, like, in the olden days no one did it and it's like, that's not true. Like, yeah, that's not true at all. but I think it's interesting, like you were saying, with the age piece and also I think just the experience piece. I've had writing historical and I write, you know, the aristocracy and all that stuff, like which is a whole other issue, but that's another conversation. But you know, we love Austen. We fell in love with these things and at least Nichole Van: Yeah. It's true. Andie James: I did. and so You know, I was like, well, how can I like set things up where I can write slightly older characters and you know, figuring this out and I if you include my upcoming book well, I guess I have a novella coming out in October, but the the next book in my series. So like looking at the my first six books, four of them will include widows. Nichole Van: Really. I love that. Andie James: And 'cause I was like, it's a way that like they've already experienced some life. And so I can age them up. I can have them experiencing more mature emotions because of the things they've been through, be them good or bad. and so it was just I was like I it wasn't necessarily intentional, but I look back and I'm like, my God, I've written so many widows. Like I just Yes. Yes. Yeah. Nichole Van: First all, very common to be a widow back then. Like very few people like married. When they I this was forever ago. I saw some s statistic. It was like if you lived to the age of seventy or something, like say in the eighteen hundreds, you had an average of three or four different like marriage partners over the years because Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: just they died for a variety of reasons. So yeah. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. So I don't know. I don't know. I write Regency and I was like, how can we make this a little the last book part of it like why it ended up kisses only too is my heroine was nineteen and she's by far the youngest I've written. Nichole Van: yeah. Yes. Andie James: and it was hard. It was hard Nichole Van: Mm-hmm. Andie James: to write that for me. I'm forty two, like I whatever. I don't remember. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: and it's like there's a certain level of just like that is just it's hard for me to capture. Andie James: And I set that up for myself because it's a it's it follows a family and so she's the young part you Nichole Van: Yes, yeah. Andie James: know, and so like I said, you know, I I didn't think that through when I set up imagin my series, but like I don't know, it's weird. 'Cause sometimes we can control our characters and sometimes I feel like we can't. Like they just kinda come to us. Nichole Van: It's really true. Like the number of times I've gone into a book with like a specific character in mind, like they were gonna be blah. And then as I'm writing them, the character's like, Yeah, but and it's funny 'cause you hear authors talking like that and it's like, I made you up. Like, how can we not Andie James: Yeah. I did, yeah, yeah. Nichole Van: And yet well I think chemistry is the same thing. Like I've had characters before where I start writing them and like they have no chemistry. And I'm like, I'm telling you to have chemistry and they're like, Yeah, but we don't have chemistry and I'm like, All right, so obviously I need Andie James: I Nichole Van: to literally change one of you. Andie James: Yeah. I don't know. Nichole Van: Have chemistry. Like I I so Nicole Lore, which I know this isn't this series, it's my the my Penn-Leiths series. When I first wrote that Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: series, when I originally pitched it, anyway, it was supposed to be Ethan, who is my hero in book three, was supposed to be paired with Isolde who is my heroine in book four. Right? The second I started Andie James: No. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Nichole Van: brainstorming that book, the I was like, 'Cause right after right after I had finished love, right, right as I was finishing love practically, I was looking ahead and Andie James: Mm. Nichole Van: and I was like, there was no chemistry there. There was nothing Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: there to latch onto. There was no story, there was nothing. And so that is when Tristan was born. Of n out of necessity. And it was fantastic. Andie James: Yes. And he so I don't know. People listening may not have read your books here because we appeal to Yeah. Yeah. I was gonna say I Nichole Van: Which really you should experience, Tristan. If you experience nothing that I've written, it should be Tristan. Andie James: I don't know, I think one of my favorite books of yours is the second book in the Penn-Leiths series, Adjacent But Only Just, because I Nichole Van: adjacent. Yeah. Andie James: Malcolm I d I that book did something to me. I don't know. Like I I just yeah. Nichole Van: Well the whole series started with that book. Like, it all started with that book 'cause I actually wrote that book as a novella first and I always wanted to rewrite Andie James: Okay. Nichole Van: it. And so then it but it w it would have been a very poor first book in the series. So that's why the whole family got reimagined and the whole thing got redone. Andie James: I love it. I love it. But I think kind of just from the the the little time I've been in the orbit of your books since I discovered them early last year. the book that seems to really be like everyone holds up for you is the fourth book in that series you were just mentioning, A Heart Sufficient is I got that right. Yes, devoted to the next one. Nichole Van: Yeah, huh. Yeah. Andie James: Yeah. and It Tristan and Isolde Tristan and Isolde I love it. But Nichole Van: I know. Andie James: they just they there's something that book is magical. There is something about those two. And I think it's because it's when we first meet Tristan. Do we first meet him in book? No, we meet him in book two. Yeah. Yeah. No, it's okay. It's okay. Yeah. Nichole Van: In book two, 'cause he didn't exist in book one, sorry. The the Nicole book lore. Yeah, yeah, I would have had a mention of him in book one if I had envisioned him as a character. Yeah, you know how it goes. It just happens. I had to fix my mistake. Andie James: Well, if you knew, it's okay. I understand. All right, Cries, I get this. But yeah, so he he is not someone we like when we meet him. He is he's quite very stiff, has his duty, has his you know, very mm and it comes into contention with, you know, other characters we know and love. And But when he falls, dude, it just it's one of those like a man broken apart stories w that we love. And that book Nichole Van: Yeah. Shattered. Andie James: just I mean, I love, like I said, Adjacent, but Only Just there's something about that book that just but A Heart Sufficient Nichole Van: Malcolm. It's like yeah, the heartbreak. Yeah. Andie James: God. And when they're like marooned on an island together, like it's a whole thing. It's just it's gorgeous. and I feel like Nichole Van: It's so yummy. Yeah, it's good. It's crumptious. Andie James: that's the book of yours I see uplifted the most. I don't know. But I really love this new series. And like I said, you got a new book out. So let's transition to that. So we mentioned Nichole Van: Let's transition to that. I love it. Andie James: Yeah, we mentioned that the first book, A Tartan Love. I would say of all your books I've read, that's the one that is like closest to the line of like the sexy Steamy. Nichole Van: It is well it and the characters okay, I'm giving a spoiler here, so you can mute if you don't want to spoiler. It's in the it's in the Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: product description. Anyway, the characters are married though. And so it's like Andie James: Yes. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: it's steamy, but it is steamy in the sense, I mean, first of all, hands don't wander, like there's no real description of a lot of stuff. Do you know what I mean? it's just but the but the emotion is like intense. And I think that that's a lot of time and I think that's a lot of what the readers react to is it's like if you Andie James: The motion's intense. Yeah. Yes. Nichole Van: actually look at the words on the page, it really isn't that steamy. Andie James: no. No, it's not. It's not. It's just that emotional connection. Nichole Van: it's just that no, no, no, no, no. But I just think it's so interesting that readers describe it that way, 'cause I'm like, I feel like it's pretty like if 'cause I actually sit down and compare it, you know, this Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: book to that book and what I actually wrote, to A to make sure I'm not repeating myself, but B also to to make sure I'm keeping the level the same, you know. And if you look Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: at it, it's very similar. It's just that the emotion going into like the kissing scenes and stuff in that book is just like a gut punch because the longing and the yearning and like the impossibility of their situation and like the heartbreak Andie James: The yearning is off the charts in that book, yeah. Nichole Van: and the difficulty and and that's what that's what we love, right? That was my whole goal. Andie James: No, it's so good. It's so good. And I don't yeah, I don't think it's necessarily any steamier. It ja I don't know how to explain it. There's just that emotional Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: No, so the emotion is really, really strong. And and so when and when so and I always think of like sexual tension in the book, it's like a rubber band that's being pulled tight. And you want Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: when the when it snaps, you want it to like slap. You know what I mean? You want it to have the really sharp like reaction. And that one, the tension is really, really strong when it when it finally snaps. Andie James: It's great. It's great. But this new book was also just I loved it. It's it and Nichole Van: Good. It's a quiet book. It is quieter. Andie James: but I love it. I love quiet books. I like cozy books. I Nichole Van: So good. Andie James: like, you know, one of the things I've always said about my own books is I I write more character focused versus plot focused. You have a great balance. You have a great balance. Nichole Van: Yes, that is true. you're thank you. I I I do know if I had to err on one side or the other, I would err on character over plot. Like that's definitely what I prefer. Andie James: Yeah. Like I I remember I created an Instagram post one time where I was trying to like I was like, I feel like I need to know how to describe my books to people. Like have I written enough to have themes, you know, like things I can pull out. And I I love a wild romp. Like I love to read them, Nichole Van: Yeah. Andie James: but that's just not what I write. Like it just doesn't come out of me that way. And I I was just like, you know, no one's ever gonna get kidnapped in one of my books. Like that's just, you know, like that's just not an Andie James thing. Nichole Van: No, no. Andie James: but So anyways, all that to say, I appreciate a quiet book. But I Nichole Van: Thank you. Well and Andie James: really they're both just gorgeous people, but I really love Matthias. And I loved him when we met him in the first book. Nichole Van: He Yes, so Matthias in the first book, background for for people who are reading this, this is not a spoiler. Matthias in the first book, he is the heroine's brother and Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: and he was born without he's missing his right arm, like right at right at the elbow. so there's sort of like a disability rep in the book and how that has impacted his life. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: and the lens, I did a lot of research looking at the lens through which disability was viewed, because losing a limb in battle and stuff was different. Than just being born with that one. Being born without one is like, there's Andie James: Yes. And we talk about that a lot. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: something wrong with your line, like your bloodline. Like that's icky. and and like how does he deal with that? I mean, he's a Duke's son, but also there's been a lot of negativity around his missing arm and how he was how he was included in his family and actually raised with his family, even though he was missing an arm, which seems odd, but typically children with disabilities like that a lot of times were farmed out like they were just sent to live with a caretaker Andie James: Wow. Nichole Van: and were never part of the family because it was seen as and not all families did this, obviously. There was they ran a gamut. but yeah. It and so he's a very damaged sort of you Andie James: Yes. Nichole Van: know, you y you take somebody who's already kind of shy and and not awkward, but just shy. Shy, a little bit of anxiety, social anxiety, and then you give him this disfigurement. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: and yeah. He just hasn't really reached for much in life. And so the book is Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: this book is him deciding he's going to reach for something. It is beautiful. Andie James: Yes. And it's beautiful. And I and I, you know, not that I personally can identify at all with a his disability, but I could tell that you'd done a lot of research. You treat it with a lot of care. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: Did well and thank you. Thank you. Because I did do a lot of research. And also there's a horse element in this book. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: that Matthias has an affinity to horses. And I did work very closely with a horse trainer Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: to make sure I got all of the the details right in the book. And she read through the you know, she read through drafts and anyway, it was really funny. There there were definitely points in the book where she'd be like, my gosh, blah blah blah, you got that part so spot on. It's exactly what you do when you're training, blah, blah, blah. And and I was like thanks, I just literally copied verbatim what you told me. Like that was actually you. I mean I I wrote it in my own words, but I Andie James: I have a horse coat coming up and I'm nervous. Nichole Van: literally took exactly what you told me and like just put that in there. So so anyway. Andie James: Yeah, wrote it. Had him say it kind of thing. Yeah. No, but you kind of mentioned two things that I think and and if this is too spoiler, you just tell me and I'll edit it out. But I two kind of two aspects that I think you really look into in the book and examine in different ways in regards to Matthias's disability is the family part. Like, cause it's very interesting because he was kept in the family. He was accepted. His siblings certainly accept him. But there was also, it was really like his his mother's attitude, the attitude of the main nurse in charge of his care, like really damaged him. Like, cause it was very much seen as he's kind of this aberration, something's wrong. stay away from me, you're not. like everyone el you know, and so it's kind of just th this combo of both. Like he had the goodness where he was accepted and loved by part of his family, but then he also experienced kind of that rejection that's had long standing effects on him. And so I I it was an interesting balance, but I feel like you examine both. Nichole Van: Thank you. Well, and that was that was my my goal. I feel like it's been easy in the past just to write a singular bad character that like causes the damage. And and Andie James: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: that that's very kind of one note, very easy to do. And I wanted to create something that was more complex, where it was a a series of complex issues that had caused 'cause that really is usually how it is in real life. That it's not just Andie James: Mm hmm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. yeah. Nichole Van: any one specific thing or one specific person. And in Matthias's case, it's a c it is very much a combination of his own reticence, his own Andie James: Yes. Nichole Van: And and and then just this deep insecurity, you know, with with his arm. and yeah, go ahead. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Well Sorry, I I didn't I just the other piece though that you do so beautifully, because time wise of when this takes place, it's right after the Napoleonic Wars. Nichole Van: Yes, it is. Andie James: And so a lot of people mistake, you you just touched on this earlier, but a lot of people mistake that his injury is a war wound and they think they kind of approach it from like, you're this heroic person, and he has to be like, no. I was born this way. This is not some Nichole Van: Yeah. Andie James: I'm not this man of valor who, you know, went off to war and you know, and so it's kind of like this re injury to his his pride almost. And there's a couple of times Nichole Van: Yes, just repeated. Andie James: yeah. And you know, there's a couple of times where he's encountered with that as he meets new people and y even the heroine kind of assumes that at the beginning, right? Because that's what you would see in the world around you at the time. Nichole Van: And it and it's a very common assumption. Like he's tall, he's he's athletic, Andie James: Yes. Nichole Van: he has kind of a military bearing about him, he's missing a limb. Of course you would assume that he was it was that he was a soldier and was injured in Andie James: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: war. and he doesn't see that. I think that was one of the things, it's actually one of my reader questions at the end. I always do. And that was one of my reader questions, is that Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: he's so hyper fixated on that fact, Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Nichole Van: on the on the on the humiliation that he has to say. Andie James: Yes. Nichole Van: No, I was just born this way. And then watch people's reaction to that, which usually is like, because that's very kind of Andie James: Okay. Yeah. Nichole Van: forward and not really something you would say. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: and he never once clocks the fact that like you just freaking look like a soldier and like that's why people make this assumption, which isn't as awful, you know what I mean? Andie James: Like well. Nichole Van: And and he just never clocks that. And it and it's sort Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: of an interesting for me at least, an interesting examination of how we always assume the worst about ourselves based on other people's reaction. Andie James: Yeah. No, yeah, it was really well done. Nichole Van: Thank you. Andie James: and I the other kind of piece of this book too is just kind of the long term yearning and Nichole Van: Yeah. Andie James: I these characters d I guess didn't encounter each other, but Matthias was aware of her for many, many years and just had this kind of I don't want to say infatuation. That that makes it seem, I don't know. Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: Definitely was a crush. I mean, it was like this was someone that he had seen, and this isn't too terribly spoilery, because it is actually in the product description. This is someone that he had seen from from a distance in London and Andie James: The very beginning. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: deeply admired her and saw her repeatedly for several months and never worked up the courage to talk to her. and then all of a sudden, you know, he rents a house in the Highlands and she's his housekeeper. There's Cecily, like she's his housekeeper, Andie James: There there's Cecily. Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: and it's like, how did she like that? Andie James: Yeah, yeah. Nichole Van: You know, and then as yeah, then just coming to learn her story and her backstory and what happened to her Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: and him trying to just change enough to deal, you know, with life, Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: but the wall still between them because she is his housekeeper and that is a hard wall. Andie James: Yeah. But just that we love that long term attraction longing kind of it's so great. Falls first and hard. Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: Yeah. He he falls first, like just so gone. Yeah, love it. Andie James: Even from afar. It's great. but yeah, no, it was just I really loved it. And I didn't like I said, I I liked that it's a quieter book. I don't know, because I just There's so much internal character piece there because it's such it's a very deep into the psychology book. Yeah. Nichole Van: It is. And and psychology in the sense of like they're both on a journey of healing and and Andie James: Yes. Nichole Van: yet trying to write it without one of my goals is to write historical books about emotional healing without using technical modern jargon. and that Andie James: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: one was this book was difficult for that in the sense that like I'm talking about horse training as well. And Andie James: I can see that. I can see that, yeah. Nichole Van: and so that that was probably one of the more difficult pieces is like trying to discuss these things without using modern terminology or even modern techniques specifically without calling those out. So there were definitely challenges, Andie James: That's Nichole Van: but but I do I love just these quiet psychological explorations of character Andie James: Right. Nichole Van: and love and relationships. I do love it. Andie James: So great. Yeah. I it I that is the hard part of historical because I think I mean, maybe people are writing without wanting to comment on modern issues, but I think it just kind of naturally comes out in us. I I certainly have things I wanna say in my books. And how do you say it in a way that doesn't come across then as super modern and takes you kind of out of the setting of the story and Nichole Van: Exactly. And that is a hard one. I mean, you talk about putting your morality on characters. You know what I mean? Like it Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: it is really hard when you write when you write historical because Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: there are a lot of things that you and and if you dig hard enough you can find the exceptions to the rule. but yeah. Yeah, exactly. That's gonna support Andie James: Yes. There's always a historical example you can find somewhere. Nichole Van: what you want. But at the same time it's like, but nah, that was very rare, you know, and you kind of have to acknowledge that at least in Andie James: It was rare. Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: your writing. Andie James: Yeah, it's interesting because I'm the the next book in my current series that I'm I'm dealing with, I'm I'm writing it right now. And I'm very much trying to say I have my female main character. This isn't spoiler. It's it'll all this details will be out Nichole Van: Mm-hmm. Andie James: soon, but She's never been able to have a child. And we know very much so at that time that inheritance and lines Nichole Van: Yeah. Andie James: and heirs was big. and it's just trying to comment, I think, as we see right now our government saying, women need to be having more children and we need to all these things. And it's like there's more to a woman's worth than her ability. To provide children. Like that's what I'm trying to say. Yes. Yes. Nichole Van: Yes. Yes. I I am I am I am I am more than the sum of my womb, basically. Yes. Andie James: And so that's that's kind of like the high level message I'm trying to to bring across with this book. and it's like, how do you say that without sounding all like modern day preachy and like, you know. Nichole Van: Especially in a time period where, you know, children were really honestly how a woman was viewed as worthy, you know what I mean? Andie James: Yes. Nichole Van: And also children were the way that you provided for your future. You know, if I had a son who could work and I Andie James: Yes. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: that I would assume that I would have a place as mom, I would have a place to live with him. A daughter, may not not so much, but a son for sure. And yeah. Andie James: Hope so. Yeah. Yeah. Well, it's interesting. I so I am big Jane Austen fan. I mean, that's probably I don't know how I started my love of all romance things. And well, as you said, Anne of Green Gables and all these different, you know, I've always loved the love story. Nichole Van: Yes, all of it. Yeah. Andie James: but I recently watched the new series The Other Bennett Sister. They adapted that book. Nichole Van: yeah, yeah. Andie James: yeah. it's so good. I could do a whole episode on that. But it's interesting the way that they portray Mrs. Bennett in that. because I I still don't think they made her a likable character. But they certainly there's moments when she's talking with Mary and explaining like, I push you because I had to guarantee your future. Like I had five daughters. We're gonna lose our ha we've already, you know, like your cousin gets everything when your father dies. Like, how do I make sure that you're protected and selfishly me, that you can then take me in to, you know, your married life once, I need and so i I'm sympathetic to that. I can understand that. I still I still think she's a bit of a shrew in the way that they they didn't like ref like make you like her, but you can understand kind of Where she's coming. Nichole Van: Well th the the exactly the scope of women was so narrow. Like what Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: was permitted and what wasn't permitted, especially in the upper classes. And so your options were very limited. I think that it Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: if we're just speaking of movies, you go back to it's what the two thousand five Pride and Prejudice, where you have the Charlotte character who gives that speech to Lizzie, you know, I'm Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: X years old and I'm terrified. And I'm like, that Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: was very real to the time period. And Andie James: Very real. Nichole Van: Very real. And the number of women that married just so it's like my choice is to marry or to starve or to like prostitute myself. Those are my choices. And a lot of women would just choose to marry because that was at least a respectable form of prostitution. Terrible to say, but that is lo that is a way to look at it, you know? Andie James: Yeah. I know. I've got a novella coming out in October that's part of kind of a multi author series. And my main character is a spinster and not necessarily of her choosing. And but it's it's interesting and I've thought about I still have four more books to write of my current series, but I've thought about what comes next. And I I I really am interested in examining kind of maybe a series about spinsters and the different reasons why they find themselves in that circumstance. If it's a happy thing, if it's not, it's you know, I don't know. Anyways, the the choices for women. Very limited. Very, very limited. Nichole Van: Yes. Very limited. Yes. Andie James: But that makes it fun to write because then I mean the re one of the reasons I love historical. I mean, I I've only written historical I I have ideas for other genres. I won't say I'll never write contemporary or romantasy or whatever. But I really love historical because I think that social setting we're far enough distanced from it that we can see it more objectively than we see the limitations in our own social. Nichole Van: That's very true. Yeah. Andie James: setting right. because we still have them for sure. We just they feel normal to us. Yeah, they feel normal to us now. But like the distance, Nichole Van: It's true. And and I think that's a very, very good insight, actually. I think that's fantastic. Yeah. Andie James: like I almost see historical the same way I see like fantasy or sci-fi, where it's like you can comment on current day things because you can tweak things or set up the world just enough that it like mirrors us enough that you go, like Nichole Van: hm, that's interesting. Andie James: Hmm. it's enough distance to be able to see those things and comment. And looking the setting itself creates more tension and conflict, I think, because there were such limitations and I feel like I I'm seeing more people recently being like, We're so tired of Regency. Take us out of the ballroom. We're over it. And I get it. I get it. But the reason I still love it and I still eat it up and I like to write it is because even though it's absurd how much power the aristocracy had, there were very definitive rules along with that. And it creates these natural conflicts that I just love to exploit. It's fun. Nichole Van: I I'm with you. I think that's one of the reasons why I gravitate toward historical as well, because it's very easy to create what we call, you know, the wall, like the the thing that's keeping the characters apart. And they were very, Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: very real social constraints that they experienced Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: during the time period, especially if the higher up you were in the class, the more I think you would feel some of those social constraints when it came to romantic relationships. And Andie James: Yes. Yes. Nichole Van: and it's really hard in speaking as someone who, you know, I have a contemporary romance coming out next spring. and I looking at moving into writing another contemporary romance in the next couple of months. And it's hard. Like what is my wall? Like what what is 'cause like in a modern society there's very little that keeps people apart. And the things that do legitimately keep people apart are actually things that should keep people apart. Do you know what I mean? Like he's your sa he's your brother, like biologically. No, Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: we're just saying no to that. Like you're actually still married to somebody else. Well you gotta get divorced first and then you know what I mean? Like there's no real the the the real walls that actually exist exist for a reason. And everything else is just kind of psychological or emotional. Which to me which in some ways is less interesting to write when it comes to contemporary, because it's like you're just too damaged at the moment to be in a relationship. Go do a few years of therapy and come back, you know, and then we can and then we can talk relationship. And I think Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: that that's why I love historicals, because it's much easier to take really h emotionally healthy, really grounded characters, but there is a very specific reason why they should not be together and And they gotta somehow fight their way through that very specific reason and make sacrifices along the way. Like usually it does require giving up something in order for them to be together and a very real something. That's part of why why the conflict is feels real to the reader, is that there is actually a real stake involved and there's gonna be a consequence. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. I love it. I love it so much. But well, I feel like we've been talking forever because we filmed our other episode before this. But it's really only been almost an hour. But I will let you go. But I just thank you so much for chatting with me today. Everyone, go read Nicole's books. They're so lush and emotional and just they're beautiful. They'll give you everything you want in a romance. They're just great. so A Lass Beloved just came out, but she's got tons of other stuff you can go read. Nichole Van: So much. Andie James: So much. Go read the backlist. and thank you for just the thoughtful conversation that we had earlier about AI. Thank you for the conversation around heat levels and how that affects what we read and what we like and what we write and all of that. But yeah. We'll have thank you. Nichole Van: Thank you. Thank you so much for having me. This has been so fun. Andie James: I've had fun too. So everyone, happy reading, happy listening, and we'll see you next time. All right, bye.