Latest / Brighter Path: Data, Marketing, Entertainment, and Storytelling / ELLA LANGLEY Has a Historic Hit With “Choosin’ Texas.” Where Did the Audience Go Next?

Transcript

ELLA LANGLEY Has a Historic Hit With “Choosin’ Texas.” Where Did the Audience Go Next? · Brighter Path: Data, Marketing, Entertainment, and Storytelling

• 0:00
  Ella Langley just did something no song in the history of the
• 0:03
  Billboard Hot 100 had done before.
• 0:05
  Choose in Texas has now spent 23 weeks at #1 passing All I Want
• 0:10
  for Christmas Is You for the longest run at the top of the
• 0:12
  chart. When a song gets that big, the
• 0:15
  easiest thing to do is keep talking about the song.
• 0:18
  How many weeks at #1 How many streams?
• 0:20
  How high did it go internationally?
• 0:22
  How much bigger can it still get?
• 0:25
  I wanted to look in the other direction because at some point,
• 0:27
  the size of a hit can actually make it harder to understand
• 0:30
  what is happening with the artist behind it.
• 0:33
  Choose in Texas has reached people who probably had very
• 0:36
  little relationship with Ella Langley before hearing the song.
• 0:40
  Some found it through country radio, some through streaming or
• 0:42
  Tiktok, and others encountered it after the record had already
• 0:46
  moved well outside country. But hearing one enormous song
• 0:50
  and choosing to become an Ella Langley listener are two very
• 0:53
  different behaviors. So the question I wanted to
• 0:55
  answer was, what happened to all of those people after choosing
• 0:59
  Texas Brought them Through the Door?
• 1:01
  Did they stay with that one song, or did they start
• 1:03
  listening to be her? Did they open Dandelion or go
• 1:06
  backward into Hungover? Did they start buying concert
• 1:09
  tickets? And as Elle expanded outside the
• 1:12
  US, were international audiences following the same path, or were
• 1:15
  they mostly consuming one giant American crossover record?
• 1:19
  That distinction changed the way I looked at what is happening
• 1:22
  around Ella right now. Because underneath the historic
• 1:24
  #1 there are signs of something that may ultimately matter much
• 1:28
  more to her career. People appear to be staying, and
• 1:31
  to understand why, I think you have to start with what existed
• 1:34
  before Choose in Texas. Ella wasn't starting from zero
• 1:37
  when this record exploded. She already had a meaningful
• 1:40
  country audience, and that audience had already shown an
• 1:43
  ability to move. Her collaborations with Riley
• 1:46
  Green were an important part of that first phase.
• 1:49
  You Look Like You Love Me reached number one at Country
• 1:51
  Radio. They followed that with another
• 1:53
  #1 and then Ella reached number one at Country Airplay as a solo
• 1:57
  artist with Choose in Texas. I think that progression matters
• 2:01
  because the Riley Green relationship helped introduce
• 2:03
  Ella to a larger country audience, but she didn't remain
• 2:06
  dependent on it. Country radio started responding
• 2:09
  to Ella herself. Festival audiences were becoming
• 2:12
  familiar with her, and Hungover gave listeners a larger body of
• 2:15
  work to move into. So when Choosing Texas exploded,
• 2:19
  it wasn't creating the entire Ella Langley audience.
• 2:22
  It was dramatically expanding, one that was already developing.
• 2:26
  That expansion has obviously been extraordinary.
• 2:28
  The song moved beyond country radio, became a mainstream US
• 2:32
  record and then started traveling internationally.
• 2:35
  It reached number one in the UK after a long climb, became
• 2:38
  extremely strong in Canada and Australia, and spent months
• 2:42
  among the biggest songs on Spotify globally.
• 2:45
  The obvious word for all of that is crossover, but the more I
• 2:49
  looked at the audience behavior, the less useful that single word
• 2:52
  became. The song crossed over first.
• 2:55
  What I wanted to understand was whether Ella followed it and the
• 3:00
  US. Gives us some.
• 3:01
  Pretty compelling evidence that she has be her climbed all the
• 3:05
  way to #2 on the Hot 100. While I Can't Love You Anymore,
• 3:10
  her collaboration with Morgan Wallen reached #4 at one point,
• 3:15
  Ella had three songs around the top ten.
• 3:18
  While Dandelion was still sitting among the biggest albums
• 3:21
  in the country months after release, that doesn't look like
• 3:25
  an audience concentrated entirely around 1 record.
• 3:29
  People are moving sideways into other current songs, and they're
• 3:33
  also moving deeper into the album.
• 3:36
  Dandelion debuted at number one with 169,000 equivalent album
• 3:41
  units, which is obviously a strong opening, but opening week
• 3:45
  mostly tells us how much immediate demand was waiting for
• 3:48
  the album. I'm more interested in what
• 3:51
  happened afterward because the album stayed active, and within
• 3:55
  that consumption, there isn't only one song doing all the
• 3:58
  work. Be her weren't for the wind.
• 4:02
  I can't love you anymore. Loving life again, Jaded
• 4:06
  Dandelion. Bottom of your boots and earlier
• 4:09
  material. Are all part.
• 4:11
  Of the listening behavior around Ella, I tend to separate.
• 4:14
  This into three different things.
• 4:16
  Hit consumption where somebody wants choose in Texas, catalog
• 4:20
  consumption where that song creates enough curiosity for
• 4:23
  somebody to explore the album or go backward into earlier music.
• 4:27
  And then artist consumption where the listener starts making
• 4:30
  choices because the name Ella Lingli itself has become
• 4:33
  meaningful to them. That is the transition I think
• 4:36
  we're watching right now. Hit consumption is obviously
• 4:39
  enormous, catalog consumption is becoming meaningful, and artist
• 4:42
  consumption is increasingly visible through multiple songs,
• 4:45
  album persistence, and live demand.
• 4:48
  Once I started looking at the international markets through
• 4:51
  those 3 layers, the story became even more interesting because
• 4:54
  they aren't all developing the same way.
• 4:57
  Canada might actually be one of the clearest examples of what
• 5:00
  deeper crossover looks like. Choose in Texas has moved beyond
• 5:04
  country formats there into Chr, adult contemporary, hot AC and
• 5:09
  broader radio. At the same time Dandelion
• 5:12
  reached number. One and multiple.
• 5:14
  Album tracks appeared. On The Canadian.
• 5:16
  Hot 100, The entry point may still be choose in Texas, but
• 5:20
  the behavior around it is widening.
• 5:22
  With the audience. Increasingly responding to Ella
• 5:24
  across songs and formats. Rather than treating her as the.
• 5:27
  Country artist attached to 1 crossover record.
• 5:31
  Australia gives us another signal that I find particularly
• 5:34
  useful. Choose in Texas became a major
• 5:37
  record there, and Dandelion has performed strongly, but Hungover
• 5:40
  has also continued. Appearing on the Australian
• 5:42
  Country Albums chart. Going backward in the catalog
• 5:46
  requires a different kind of curiosity.
• 5:49
  Someone discovers the current song, moves into the current
• 5:52
  album, and then decides there's enough interest in Ella herself
• 5:55
  to see what she was making before this moment.
• 5:58
  That's exactly the kind of behavior I look for when I'm
• 6:01
  trying to understand whether an audience is getting bigger than
• 6:03
  the song that introduced it. The UK is developing
• 6:06
  differently. Choose in Texas reached #1 after
• 6:09
  a long climb, and Dandelion has shown staying power.
• 6:12
  So there is clearly more happening than one song briefly
• 6:15
  Catching Fire. But the secondary song movement
• 6:18
  hasn't developed to the same degree.
• 6:20
  I don't see that as a weakness. I see it as a different stage in
• 6:23
  the audience relationship. In the US and Canada, the artist
• 6:28
  relationship is much farther along.
• 6:30
  Australia is showing encouraging catalog depth.
• 6:33
  While in the. UK the song is still doing more
• 6:35
  of the introduction. That's why I'd be careful about
• 6:38
  saying Ella has simply become a global artist.
• 6:41
  What I see right now is a very strong expansion through the
• 6:44
  major English speaking markets, with different levels of depth
• 6:47
  inside each one. Those differences matter because
• 6:51
  the next behavior gets much more commercial, and that's touring.
• 6:55
  Streaming can be fairly low friction, while buying a concert
• 6:58
  ticket asks a lot more of somebody.
• 7:00
  You have to choose the artist and the date.
• 7:02
  Spend the money, leave the house.
• 7:05
  And give that artist a significant part of your.
• 7:07
  Evening Ella's Live. Progression has moved from
• 7:11
  larger clubs into theaters and now arenas.
• 7:14
  Her headline run performed strongly enough to expand with
• 7:17
  another. 21 dates. Including Red Rocks and two
• 7:20
  shows at the. Greek Theatre.
• 7:21
  In Los Angeles, for me, that is one of the strongest pieces of
• 7:25
  evidence in this entire story. Because people aren't only
• 7:29
  consuming Ella Langley through a song or a playlist.
• 7:32
  A meaningful part of the US audience is increasingly making
• 7:35
  a decision around Ella herself. I'm also less.
• 7:39
  Interested in whether? Every seed of every out of date
• 7:42
  immediately sells. Then I am in the direction of
• 7:45
  that behavior. She can increasingly put her own
• 7:47
  name at the top of the bill and ask people to show up
• 7:50
  specifically for her. The next version of that test is
• 7:54
  international. There is already.
• 7:57
  Meaningful digital demand in places like the UK and
• 8:00
  Australia. So what happens when Ella asks
• 8:02
  those audiences to make the same?
• 8:04
  Transition from streams. Into a local headline live
• 8:07
  business. If that happens, the audience
• 8:11
  relationship moves another step deeper instead of exporting a
• 8:14
  successful. American Song.
• 8:16
  She begins developing markets where people have enough of a
• 8:19
  relationship with Ella Langley to spend money and time
• 8:22
  specifically on her. At the same time, the number of
• 8:26
  ways people can discover Ella is expanding.
• 8:29
  American Eagle brought her into its campaign.
• 8:31
  This year. Putting her into a different
• 8:33
  cultural environment around denim, fashion and a younger
• 8:37
  consumer audience, I'm interested in that because it
• 8:40
  creates another doorway. For most of Ella's rise, the
• 8:43
  paths into the audience were relatively easy to identify.
• 8:46
  Country radio, streaming festivals and collaborations
• 8:50
  with artists like Riley Green. Now someone can encounter her
• 8:54
  through fashion retail, Stagecoach related content or
• 8:57
  social media that has relatively little to do with country radio.
• 9:01
  That doesn't make fashion a major Ella Langley business
• 9:04
  overnight, but it does widen the number of places where somebody
• 9:07
  can meet the artists before they ever decide to play an album.
• 9:10
  Recently, even Drake has created another unusual entry point.
• 9:15
  He attended one of Ella's shows, publicly praised her
• 9:17
  songwriting, played Choose in Texas while D Jing, and
• 9:21
  previewed his own R&B interpretation of the song.
• 9:25
  What I find interesting there isn't really the celebrity
• 9:27
  association itself. It's where the song is now able
• 9:30
  to travel, because Choose in Texas is appearing in cultural
• 9:34
  spaces that Ella's earlier music probably would not have reached
• 9:37
  on its own. The question after that is the
• 9:39
  same one I've been asking throughout this analysis.
• 9:42
  Where does the audience go next? If someone encounters Ella
• 9:45
  through Drake, do they stop at Choosing Texas or do they
• 9:48
  eventually play Be Her? If somebody sees her through
• 9:52
  American Eagle, does that create curiosity around the music?
• 9:55
  If somebody in Australia discovers her through a
• 9:57
  mainstream playlist, do they eventually open Hungover or buy
• 10:00
  a concert ticket? Those are very different
• 10:03
  behaviors from simply accumulating exposure.
• 10:07
  Ella also has another advantage because she has been building a
• 10:10
  network of audience entry points through collaborations for
• 10:13
  several years. Riley Green was important in
• 10:16
  that first phase, with those records helping introduce her to
• 10:19
  a much larger country audience before Ella eventually converted
• 10:22
  that visibility into solo country success.
• 10:25
  Morgan Wallen now creates another connection point into an
• 10:28
  enormous contemporary country audience with significant
• 10:31
  mainstream overlap, while Coetzel creates a different
• 10:34
  adjacency around country rock. Miranda Lambert brings something
• 10:38
  I see differently from the others.
• 10:40
  Her role around the writing and production of Choose in Texas
• 10:43
  and Dandelion feels less like borrowed reach and more like
• 10:46
  creative credibility and connection to an established
• 10:49
  country lineage. When you put those pieces
• 10:51
  together, the audience map around Ella becomes much richer
• 10:54
  than the Hot 100 headline suggests.
• 10:57
  Country radio continues feeding the core audience.
• 11:00
  Collaborators introduce adjacent audiences.
• 11:03
  Streaming and social dramatically widened discovery.
• 11:06
  International charts open new markets, touring converts some
• 11:09
  of that attention into physical behavior, and fashion creates
• 11:12
  another cultural entry point. Sitting in the middle of all of
• 11:16
  it is one historically large song, accelerating how quickly
• 11:19
  those different audiences are encountering Ella.
• 11:22
  That's why Ella Langley is crossing over.
• 11:24
  Feels too simple to me. There is genre krossover from
• 11:28
  country into mainstream music. Geographic crossover from the US
• 11:32
  into Canada, Australia and the UK, Behavioral crossover from
• 11:37
  individual song listening into albums and catalog, Commercial
• 11:41
  crossover from streaming into ticket buying, and the beginning
• 11:45
  of cultural crossover into fashion and spaces that sit
• 11:48
  outside country music itself. They aren't equally developed,
• 11:53
  and I think that is actually one of the healthier things about
• 11:55
  what is happening. Ella's mainstream growth isn't
• 11:59
  requiring the country audience to disappear.
• 12:02
  Country radio festivals and collaborations are still doing
• 12:05
  work, and the existing country audience is still there, while a
• 12:09
  much larger mainstream layer forms around it.
• 12:13
  So the next phase doesn't require Ella to somehow become
• 12:16
  less country in order to get bigger.
• 12:19
  It requires the new audience to keep finding reasons to choose
• 12:23
  Ella beyond the song that introduced them.
• 12:26
  That makes the next solo record a much more useful test to me
• 12:30
  than whether choosing Texas adds a 24th or 25th week.
• 12:34
  At #1. 23 Weeks has already answered the question of whether
• 12:39
  this song is enormous. What happens with the next song
• 12:42
  starts answering a different question.
• 12:45
  Does the mainstream audience move with her?
• 12:49
  I'll be watching whether another solo record penetrates the
• 12:52
  playlist and radio formats that opened during this run, whether
• 12:56
  Canada continues responding across formats, whether the UK
• 13:00
  begins moving a second or third Ella song at scale, whether
• 13:05
  Australian listeners continue moving backward through the
• 13:08
  catalog, and eventually whether those international listeners
• 13:12
  become concert audiences. Those behaviors will tell us
• 13:16
  much more about what Choosing Texas actually built.
• 13:20
  And the timing of that question is particularly interesting
• 13:23
  right now because the attention around Ella is about to change.
• 13:26
  Taylor Swift has new music arriving, which means streaming,
• 13:29
  playlist, radio and social conversation are all going to
• 13:33
  have another enormous release competing for attention at
• 13:36
  exactly the moment Ella has reached this historic peak.
• 13:39
  I'm not interested in turning that into an Ella versus Taylor
• 13:42
  chart battle. What I'm interested in is what
• 13:45
  happens when some of the attention that has surrounded
• 13:47
  Choosing Texas for months starts moving somewhere else.
• 13:50
  Because from an audience perspective, that actually gives
• 13:53
  us a better test of Ella than another week where everything
• 13:56
  remains exactly as it has been. Ella doesn't need every casual
• 14:00
  listener who discovered Choose in Texas to stay.
• 14:03
  A record this large will always have a much wider audience than
• 14:06
  the artist ultimately retains. What matters is how much of that
• 14:10
  enormous outer audience moves inward, How many people now
• 14:14
  recognize Ella rather than only the song, Choose another record,
• 14:17
  stay with Dandelion, explore hungover, buy a ticket, and
• 14:21
  eventually follow her into whatever comes next.
• 14:24
  That is where I think the most important part of this story is
• 14:27
  hiding. Ella Langley has already proved
• 14:30
  she can have one of the biggest songs in the world, but
• 14:33
  underneath it, she is beginning to show something much harder to
• 14:35
  build an audience that behaves like an artist audience.
• 14:39
  They're listening to more than one record, moving into the
• 14:42
  album, traveling backward through the catalog, and
• 14:44
  increasingly buying tickets to see Ella herself.
• 14:48
  That behaviour is also beginning to appear across multiple
• 14:51
  markets, even if those markets are moving at different speeds.
• 14:54
  So I don't think the next stage of Ella Langley's career will
• 14:57
  really be determined by how high Choosing Texas ultimately goes.
• 15:01
  We already know the answer to that question.
• 15:03
  It went about as high as a song can go.
• 15:06
  The more interesting question is where all of those people go
• 15:09
  when choosing Texas is no longer the thing commanding the room.
• 15:12
  23 Weeks at #1 tells us how big choose in Texas became.
• 15:17
  What happens after #1 will tell us how big Ella Langley became.
• 15:21
  If you enjoy looking at entertainment and culture
• 15:24
  through where audiences actually move after the big moment,
• 15:27
  follow brighter path. That's what I'll keep digging
• 15:29
  into here.