Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Why electric cars lose horsepower on highways?
Transcript
- 0:10Welcome to the deep dive everyone.
- 0:11We are so genuinely glad you're here joining us today.
- 0:14Yeah, thanks for tuning in. So you know when you walk into a
- 0:18car dealership today and those glossy marketing brochures are
- 0:21just practically screaming at you?
- 0:23Oh. Absolutely.
- 0:24They're designed to do exactly that.
- 0:25Right, they hand you this like beautiful pamphlet for a brand
- 0:29new electric vehicle and it's all about the massive numbers.
- 0:32It's being flashy stats. Exactly like zero to 60 in three
- 0:36seconds. 203 hundred, 400 horsepower.
- 0:41And it's presented to you as this absolute, unwavering fact.
- 0:45Right, like it's a guarantee? Yeah, you assume.
- 0:47Hey, I buy a car with 300 horsepower, I get 300
- 0:50horsepower. But it turns out that brochure
- 0:53is actually telling you only half the story.
- 0:55Very true. There's a lot hiding just
- 0:57beneath the surface. So for today's Deep Dive, our
- 0:59mission is to uncover the secret double life of electric motors.
- 1:03We're going to breakdown this topic in a really simple,
- 1:05engaging way for you. It's.
- 1:07Fascinating topic honestly. It really is, because the other
- 1:10half of that story involves these hidden numbers.
- 1:14Extreme heat and this like crazy engineering battle just to keep
- 1:19your car moving safely on the highway.
- 1:21Yeah, the heat is a huge factor that most drivers never even
- 1:23think. About exactly.
- 1:25And to figure this out, we've brought in a really great stack
- 1:27of sources. Today.
- 1:28We've got a detailed breakdown of EV powertrains called
- 1:30Paradox, a really stark performance analysis on electric
- 1:34versus internal combustion engines called Performance, and
- 1:39surprisingly, a technical guide on E bike motors from BIC
- 1:42Tricks. That E bike source is actually
- 1:45going to be crucial later on. Oh, I bet so.
- 1:47OK, let's unpack this because by the end of this deep dive, you
- 1:50are going to have the ultimate Insider's Guide to decoding EV
- 1:53performance numbers so you never get tripped by that marketing
- 1:56hype on your next road trip. Which is so important because
- 1:58it's a massive shift in how we you don't need to think about
- 2:01vehicle performance entirely, right?
- 2:03Like you test drive a car around the block, it throws you back in
- 2:06your seat at a green light, and you naturally expect it to be
- 2:09the exact same car when you're say, 3 hours into a summer road
- 2:12trip. But it's not.
- 2:14No, not at all. Yeah, the physics of electricity
- 2:16have a very different plan. So we need to look under the
- 2:19hood and really decode what's going on here, because looking
- 2:22at the performance source, there is a fundamental difference
- 2:25between the two types of power listed for these vehicles.
- 2:28Right. Peak power versus nominal power.
- 2:30Yeah, peak and nominal, and these two numbers paint
- 2:33completely different pictures. Let's start with peak power,
- 2:36which is that flashy number printed in bold on the brochure.
- 2:41Well, peak power is the absolute maximum effort the electric
- 2:45motor can produce. It's the Sprint.
- 2:47OK. But the crucial caveat, the part
- 2:49they totally leave out of the sales pitch is that it can only
- 2:52produce that maximum effort for a very, very limited time.
- 2:56Wait, really? Like how limited?
- 2:57Extremely limited. Think of it as just a sudden
- 2:59burst of energy to get you off the line quickly, or, you know,
- 3:03to make a rapid pass in city traffic.
- 3:05It is inherently unsustainable. Wow OK so just to make sure I'm
- 3:10wrapping my head around this, is peak power basically like
- 3:14sprinting to catch a bus while nominal power is your like
- 3:18sustainable jogging pace for a 5K?
- 3:21That is a highly accurate way to visualize it.
- 3:23Yeah. OK, good.
- 3:24When you Sprint for the bus, your body is producing peak
- 3:26output. You're moving fast, but your
- 3:29heart rate spikes. Lactic acid builds up your core
- 3:32temperature rises. Right, you get exhausted.
- 3:34Exactly. You physically cannot maintain
- 3:37that Sprint for three miles. You have to slow down to a jog
- 3:41your nominal pace so your body's natural cooling systems can
- 3:44actually keep up. OK, that makes total sense.
- 3:46And in. An EV That physical exertion
- 3:49translates directly into heat. With the motor, the inverter,
- 3:52the battery, they all start to overheat.
- 3:54Right, Heat is the enemy here. But I mean, this drives me a bit
- 3:57crazy. If you know a human can only
- 3:59Sprint for 10 seconds, you don't enter them in a marathon and
- 4:02advertise their Sprint speed as their marathon pace, right?
- 4:04You really shouldn't know. So why are automakers allowed to
- 4:07highlight only the Sprint speed when most drivers taking a road
- 4:10trip are going to spend hours at a jogging pace?
- 4:13What's fascinating here is that we basically have a century of
- 4:15conditioning from internal combustion engines to blame for
- 4:18that. Oh, really?
- 4:19How so? Well, in a traditional gas or
- 4:21diesel car, the stated maximum horsepower on the brochure is,
- 4:26generally speaking, what the engine can maintain continuously
- 4:29on the highway. Wait.
- 4:30Continuously. Yeah.
- 4:32An internal combustion engine is literally designed around
- 4:34containing continuous explosions.
- 4:36Its entire cooling system, the massive radiator, the coolant
- 4:40loops, it's built from the ground up to handle a continuous
- 4:43maximum thermal load. Oh.
- 4:45Wow, I never really thought about it that way.
- 4:47Right. So if a gas car says it has 150
- 4:49horsepower, you can theoretically take it to the
- 4:52autobahn and run it near that limit for hours.
- 4:54Assuming you don't run out of gas, obviously.
- 4:56Exactly, but in an EV that continuous Hwy. power is
- 5:00actually the much lower nominal number.
- 5:03The rules of thermodynamics completely changed, but the
- 5:06marketing language just carried over from the old terminology.
- 5:09That is wild. So that nominal power, the
- 5:11continuous jogging pace is actually tested and regulated
- 5:15right? Like the ECER 8530 minute norm.
- 5:20Exactly. They put the vehicle under a
- 5:22continuous load for 30 straight minutes to find its true thermal
- 5:25limit. OK, so this gap between peak and
- 5:28nominal isn't just an automotive marketing trick, it's the harsh
- 5:32physical reality of electric motors.
- 5:34It's pure physics. And to understand the why behind
- 5:37those physics, let's look at the Biktrix source and scale all the
- 5:41way down from a two ton car to a bicycle.
- 5:44The E bike microcosm is such a brilliant way to look at this.
- 5:47Right, because it isolates the exact same physics.
- 5:49So how do these E bike motors actually operate under pressure?
- 5:53Well in an E bike, just like in a high end EV, you have a
- 5:56controller acting as the brain, and this controller is
- 6:00constantly, like by the millisecond, calculating your
- 6:03speed, your velocity, and the torque demand.
- 6:06So when you hit a steep hill and pedal hard, the controller
- 6:09allows the motor to hit its peak wattage for an incredibly short
- 6:13burst, sometimes just a fraction of the second.
- 6:15Wait hold on, if the motor can hit that peak wattage why not
- 6:19just let it run at that level to get up a massive hill?
- 6:21Like why throttle my power when I need it the most?
- 6:24Because doing so makes the electrical coils far too hot.
- 6:27Oh, the heat again. Yeah, an electric motor creates
- 6:30motion by running electrical current through tightly wound
- 6:33copper coils. When you push maximum current
- 6:35through them, they experience electrical resistance.
- 6:38And resistance creates heat. Rapidly.
- 6:41If the controller lets you run at peak wattage all the way up
- 6:44that hill, the enamel insulation wrapped around those copper
- 6:47coils would literally melt off. Oh wow, that sounds
- 6:52catastrophic. It is the motor would short
- 6:54circuit and destroy itself in seconds, so the motor must
- 6:57artificially throttle down. To protect itself.
- 6:59Exactly, and it actually throttles down to less than the
- 7:03nominal output to give the coils time to cool to a safe operating
- 7:06level. That is fascinating, but if peak
- 7:09wattage is basically dangerous to sustain, why even listed on
- 7:13an E bike spec sheet? It's mostly listed as an
- 7:16industry standard because DI, IRS, and project developers need
- 7:19it for advanced level custom builds.
- 7:21They need to know the absolute thermal limits to design their
- 7:24fuses. Right, but for the average user.
- 7:26For the average user, it is a dangerous metric to rely on for
- 7:30continuous power. It will leave you very
- 7:33disappointed on a long hill. OK, so let's scale this back up
- 7:36to the cars. If a tiny E bike motor has to
- 7:39throttle down just to protect its coils from melting, the
- 7:42thermal stress on an electric car pushing highway speeds must
- 7:46be massive. Oh, it's monumental.
- 7:48Pushing a heavy vehicle through the air at 80 mph requires
- 7:52relentless, constant energy. Which brings us to what actually
- 7:56happens when you take an EV on a road trip.
- 7:59Let's unpack these stark realities from the performance
- 8:01source. Yeah, the data paints a very
- 8:03clear picture of 2 completely different driving experiences.
- 8:07Right, because in the city, your EV uses peak power constantly,
- 8:10right? It's incredibly agile, you get
- 8:12instant torque at stoplights and it doesn't overheat.
- 8:15Exactly, because in stop and go traffic, the motor has plenty of
- 8:19time to cool down while you're waiting at the red light.
- 8:21But then you merge onto the highway.
- 8:23You set the cruise control to 130 kilometers per hour, and
- 8:26after just a few kilometers the electronics realize the thermal
- 8:29limit is approaching and they artificially clamped down on the
- 8:32power to stabilize at the nominal rating.
- 8:34They have to to prevent thermal damage.
- 8:36OK, here's where it gets really interesting.
- 8:38I'm going to read some of the comparisons from the source data
- 8:40because it blew my mind. Go for it.
- 8:43A Citroen EC3 drops from 113 CV peak to just 45 CV continuous,
- 8:50meaning on the highway it performs essentially like an old
- 8:5454 CV Fiat Panda 1.1 fire. It's a huge drop.
- 8:59And it gets crazier. Adacia spring drops from 65 to
- 9:0224 CV which is literally like a Liggy micro car and a Peugeot
- 9:07E2O8 drops from 156 down to 78 CV.
- 9:11Half its power gone. Right, so if my brand new EV
- 9:14suddenly turns into a micro car on the highway with barely any
- 9:17passing power left, how does anyone safely take a road trip?
- 9:21Well, there is some nuance here we should clarify.
- 9:23Your top speed is still reachable.
- 9:24OK, so I won't just suddenly slow down on the Interstate.
- 9:27No, no. Once you are at 80 mph, it only
- 9:30takes a fraction of your power to maintain that speed against
- 9:32wind resistance. So you can hold your speed.
- 9:34Got it. But what is almost entirely gone
- 9:37is your reserve power. So if you suddenly need to
- 9:40accelerate or pass a truck on an incline, the car has no extra
- 9:44power to give you without overheating.
- 9:46Wow, so acceleration becomes totally sluggish.
- 9:49Exactly. However, high end efficiency
- 9:52changes the game entirely. Right, like the Tesla Model 3
- 9:56RWD, the source notes it drops from 283 CV to 120 CV.
- 10:00Which acts roughly like a Ford Focus 1.5 TDCI on the highway.
- 10:04So even though it's dropping 120, CV is still a much higher
- 10:07baseline of continuous path. Precisely, it proves that
- 10:11advanced thermal management can retain enough baseline power to
- 10:14keep the car feeling responsive even under heavy stress.
- 10:18So it all comes down to heat management.
- 10:20If heat kills highway performance, who's actually
- 10:22building cars that solve this problem?
- 10:24Well, looking at the Paradox source, we can outline the gold
- 10:27standards of EV engineering. It's all based on a well made
- 10:30powertrain and superior thermal management.
- 10:33OK. Let's break that down by
- 10:34segment. In segment A, the compact cars,
- 10:37the Fiat 500 E has a perfectly balanced liquid cooling system
- 10:41preventing those drastic drops. Liquid cooling is absolutely
- 10:44essential. And the Honda ENY 1 uses a
- 10:47platform designed specifically for thermal stability over
- 10:50instant thrust. Right, they tuned it for
- 10:52consistency rather than just sprinting.
- 10:53Then moving to segment B, the MG4 extended range features an
- 10:57oversized thermal system to avoid significant highway cuts.
- 11:02A great brute force solution having a massive of thermal
- 11:05buffer. And the Volvo EX30 uses refined
- 11:08Geely architecture, but the real heavy hitters are in segment C,
- 11:11right? Oh without a doubt the Hyundai I
- 11:13out of five and the Kia EV6. Right, because they use an 800
- 11:17Volt architecture and that generates drastically less heat
- 11:20at high speeds. It's a game changer for thermal
- 11:22limits. So let me try an analogy here.
- 11:24Is the 800 Volt system in the Hyundai in Kia.
- 11:27Is that essentially like upgrading your home's plumbing
- 11:30to a wider pipe, allowing you to move the same amount of water
- 11:33pressure but with way less friction and storm stress on the
- 11:35system? I completely agree with that
- 11:37analogy. Yes, by doubling the voltage you
- 11:40cut the current in half, and the current is what generates the
- 11:44friction or the heat in the wires.
- 11:45So it stays cooler naturally. Exactly.
- 11:48And of course, the Tesla Model 3 RWD remains the absolute
- 11:52benchmark in this segment due to its inverters, heat management,
- 11:55and brilliant software logic. Right, so synthesizing all of
- 11:58this, you're saying there are basically three key pillars of a
- 12:01reliable EV? Yes.
- 12:04First, active liquid thermal management, keeping the battery
- 12:07and motor in the ideal temperature range.
- 12:09Second, native modern electric platforms, meaning cars designed
- 12:13from the ground up to be electric, not just adapted from
- 12:16old gas cars. Right, they need the airflow.
- 12:18And 3rd, the presence of a heat pump.
- 12:21This is vital to drastically optimize energy and reduce
- 12:24thermal stress during long trips.
- 12:26So what does this all mean for you are a listener?
- 12:29Well if you were just commuting in the city picking up
- 12:31groceries, peak power marketing is honestly perfectly fine for
- 12:35your needs. You'll love the instant torque
- 12:36and you'll never hit the thermal limits.
- 12:38But if you plan to drive on the highway, you now know the
- 12:41secret. You have to look past the
- 12:43marketing. Don't be dazzled by the sprint's
- 12:45beat. Exactly.
- 12:47Demand to know the nominal power.
- 12:49Seek out those 800 Volt architectures and make sure the
- 12:52car has a heat pump. You are now armed with the
- 12:56actual physics of car shopping. And, you know, leaving you with
- 13:00a broader thought here. If electric vehicle performance
- 13:04is this incredibly sensitive to temperature and thermal limits
- 13:08today, how will rising global temperatures and extreme summer
- 13:12heat waves fundamentally alter how automotive engineers have to
- 13:17design these cooling systems in the next decade?
- 13:19Oh wow, that is a massive question to ponder.
- 13:22The climate itself dictating the engineering.
- 13:24The thermal headroom is shrinking every year.
- 13:26Well, that gives us all a lot to think about.
- 13:28Thank you so much for joining us on this deep dive today.
- 13:30We deeply appreciate your time and curiosity as we explored all
- 13:34of this. Yes, thank you for listening.
- 13:35Keep asking the right questions and we'll see you on the next
- 13:38one.