Latest / The KAJ Masterclass LIVE / Why traditional job interview questions are useless
Transcript
- 0:23Coming live from Reno. Nevada.
- 0:25USA is our guest this morning. Welcome to this very special
- 0:30edition of the cage, a masterclass life.
- 0:32The show which ensures that you profit from your time.
- 0:35Spent here with experts, either through the industry, insights
- 0:39information or simply learning from them.
- 0:43And today we have Bill Bryant PSG CEO at the Bryan group and
- 0:47we'll be talking about leadership, how to make them
- 0:51more effective and efficient and why traditional you Job
- 0:53interviews, questions are useless, and what should we be
- 0:56asking candidates? Instead?
- 0:58Welcome to the show, Bill. Well, thank you.
- 1:01Ray, J. A real pleasure to be here.
- 1:02Thanks for the invitation, thank you.
- 1:05And thank you for having you on the show, because we'll be
- 1:08learning something very practical.
- 1:09That is needed by so many businesses.
- 1:12So many HR departments and other places organizations all across,
- 1:18not old, you just globally, but so much also in India because
- 1:22this has led to Great dress Nation and so much so-called
- 1:25toxicity as workplaces and stresses.
- 1:28So about you build, exactly? You know, you are the CEO at the
- 1:32brine group, what exactly does your company do?
- 1:37We are a company that really focuses on performance and
- 1:42talent management and the development of leaders and we
- 1:46also do executive Search work for both businesses and
- 1:51education institutions, higher ed.
- 1:53As well as like superintendents of school systems.
- 1:58Right. Right?
- 1:59And you see you are an expert at developing and implementing
- 2:03competency and Behavioral Science based hiring and OD
- 2:07system that just work better from embedding.
- 2:10Guided storytelling interviews into the hiring process to
- 2:13developing Superstar performance models your work has improved
- 2:17the functioning of organizations in every sector and you have
- 2:20improve the functioning of companies as diverse as and user
- 2:24Bush Major League Baseball, the US Navy and the The Washoe
- 2:28County School District so just to understand from you.
- 2:32Bill you say that, you know, in today's time Not like the
- 2:38traditional questions, those questions are not going to work.
- 2:41In fact, you tell them useless and we should be asking
- 2:44something else. Firstly help us understand.
- 2:48Why do you think in today's time, those old traditional
- 2:51questions of hiring candidates does not work.
- 2:55Okay. AJ, they've never worked people.
- 2:59Think they do, they have their favorite questions, but
- 3:02basically, it ends up being intuition based and often
- 3:06intuition as well. Wrong, for example, people will
- 3:09get hired if they dress better, if they've got Charisma, if they
- 3:14have experience, but Charisma is not correlated with competence
- 3:19experience, is not correlated with confidence.
- 3:22So you really have to understand how do you get into the person's
- 3:26mind to really figure out what their motivations are and the
- 3:30only predictor of future performance and skills is past
- 3:34performance. So the question is, how do you
- 3:37get Past performance. If I can give you a little
- 3:39snapshot on History here, I'll give you the research of give
- 3:43you the research background on this.
- 3:47I was in the Army and then get a doctorate in Clinical Psychology
- 3:51and worked in the clinical realm for for almost 10 years, on the
- 3:55staff of the hospital, and so forth, decided to shift.
- 3:59And in that shift, I had the great Good Fortune of being
- 4:01hired by the fellow, by the name of David McClelland, and anybody
- 4:06who's been in Even universally around the world into MBA
- 4:10programs and things like that have probably run into
- 4:13McClelland in his social motives Theory.
- 4:16Now, McClellan, fortunate for me was a top competency, researcher
- 4:23worldwide, and motivation, researcher and he developed an
- 4:28approach to interviewing based on what's called critical
- 4:32incidents and that started actually military interviewing
- 4:36around Things that had gone wrong on the battlefield, things
- 4:42things along those lines. But he refined it some and I
- 4:45refined it further. But what we found out in doing
- 4:49research and we do this, have done it, I've done it.
- 4:52For the last 45 years is that when you are studying, the
- 4:57difference between Superstar leaders and average your poor,
- 5:02the only way that you can find out what the difference is is by
- 5:06getting what we're calling an in-depth stories, personal
- 5:09stories that have occurred in the person's life.
- 5:13All of the traditional questions, tell me about
- 5:16yourself. What are your strengths?
- 5:17What are your limitations? What would others say about?
- 5:20You are useless. They have no predictive validity
- 5:23as to what the person will demonstrate in a new position or
- 5:27what they were, what their strengths really are.
- 5:30So in this type of a situation, the only way to get at someone's
- 5:36past behavior and to prove that they can demonstrate what you
- 5:41need in the job is to get them to tell stories.
- 5:45I can give you what that looks like.
- 5:47If you would like me to guess. Yes, please.
- 5:50Okay, so let's say you're you are going to come to work for
- 5:54me. And I you've made it through two
- 5:57or three different cuts, okay? And you've made it down to the,
- 6:03you know, last four or five and you're not going to do the
- 6:06storytelling on everybody that you look at, you've got to have
- 6:10a sieve to kind of sort some out because it's pretty intense, and
- 6:14it takes a fair amount of time. You can do some abbreviated
- 6:17versions. So, we're down there.
- 6:21And what I say to you is, I say, AJ, great to have you today.
- 6:25Today, you've made it here to the Final Cut.
- 6:28We're going to do something a bit different.
- 6:30You've probably never experienced before in an
- 6:33interview, we're going to be doing storytelling.
- 6:37And so what do I mean by storytelling or what I want you
- 6:40to think about and to do is just think back in your career, let's
- 6:45say from your higher, secondary education, you're graduating
- 6:49from there. Before you go on to you know
- 6:52your bachelor's degree or your next degree and you can go you
- 6:59can go back as far as that and tell me.
- 7:03If there are any things that have stood out in your career,
- 7:06that is To think back about them give you aglow with something
- 7:11that turned out really well. And I'm going to ask you for two
- 7:14or three stories that turned out really well, starting way back
- 7:18with and right up to the present time and then I'm going to ask
- 7:22you and by the way, these positive stories, don't mean
- 7:26that you end up on the front page of the India times or
- 7:30whatever. They, you know, the newspaper is
- 7:33it just means something that has stuck with you.
- 7:35That feels really good. On the downside, doesn't have to
- 7:39be abject failure because we're looking both up stories and down
- 7:43stories, but it's something that stuck with you that you don't
- 7:49feel good about didn't turn out the way you wanted it to went
- 7:52over budget. You got pushed back.
- 7:56Typically, those types of stories are stories that when
- 7:59you think about it, you'd like to do what people would call a
- 8:02do-over. Why if I could do that one over
- 8:05again I sure would Now I'm going to be editorial here for a
- 8:10moment and just say the reason that you asked for high points
- 8:12and low points, is that we know through research that anything
- 8:16that has emotion tied to, it will be remembered at a much
- 8:20deeper level much higher level of detail in terms of thoughts
- 8:27feelings and behaviors. Now, this interview doesn't work
- 8:30if you haven't taken the time to specify, for example, how are
- 8:37you Going to measure in the interview role proficiencies the
- 8:40Hat. Somebody has had to wear well
- 8:42and different jobs. Well, multiple hats.
- 8:46You need to know the competencies and how you're
- 8:48measuring them. You need to know the leadership
- 8:50style and all of these have to have definitions of measures.
- 8:55Or the interview is wasted because you don't know what
- 8:58you're looking for. And you don't know how to
- 9:00measure what you're hearing. Another thing that we do that's
- 9:04unique is we create something called derailers and these are
- 9:09measures of failure factors that people can have lots of good
- 9:13competencies and skills. But if they demonstrate one or
- 9:17two things, you know, they were a real jerk under certain
- 9:20circumstances. Why should I have wipes out all
- 9:23the good stuff they're doing right?
- 9:24You know, if you tell a hundred choose and what La One Lie, what
- 9:29do you remembered for the lie? It's the same.
- 9:32With leadership, if you show a bad leadership style or do
- 9:35certain things, even if it's not as frequent as some of the good
- 9:38things you do, you know, that's going to be a real problem.
- 9:43So the question is, how do we get it that stuff?
- 9:46So in telling stories, let me give you an example.
- 9:52Let's say you're telling me a story that you want to get a
- 9:55grant of 500,000 dollars to expand your podcast and to have
- 10:02a greater impact to get on different channels, whatever the
- 10:06case may be, and you've got to go to the board of directors for
- 10:11a foundation who is giving out these type of grants for the
- 10:15good work that you're doing, you know, bringing practical skills
- 10:18to everybody. And so you tell me, we've talked
- 10:22the beginning of the story and I won't go in there.
- 10:23But here's an example you tell me, okay, I'm at the foundation.
- 10:30I'm about ready to walk into the boardroom and I'm open the door
- 10:34and I said, wait a minute, hold on, before you open that door,
- 10:38your hands on the doorknob. What were you thinking?
- 10:42What were you feeling? You open the door.
- 10:47What did you see? What did you do, next recreate
- 10:51the conversation with the board? That's the level of detail you
- 10:56need and if you have a set of criteria like a particularly
- 11:00around influence skills which are often missed.
- 11:03Its you'll get a very different response of somebody who is low
- 11:07on political Savvy and influence skills.
- 11:09Say well what do you mean Bill? My hands on the door.
- 11:12I open the door and I walked in, I look A seat.
- 11:15And I sat down somebody who is much more Savvy, and if this is
- 11:19what you're looking for, says, yeah, I opened the door.
- 11:22And then I skate, I scanned the room instantly and they were
- 11:26people there. I hadn't counted on, I hadn't
- 11:28been able to do some homework about them, so I don't know what
- 11:30to say to them. That would influence them to
- 11:33give me the money and then I had to figure out, you know, whom
- 11:38should I sit next to? Because I've got to get
- 11:41somebody's ear even during the conversation, I'm making the
- 11:44fish. Each you see what the difference
- 11:46is and how storytelling illuminates for you.
- 11:50What's on that person's mind? What's front of Mind?
- 11:53How do they think feel and act and you have to use the
- 11:58technique during their storytelling to bring that out?
- 12:03Right bill. So I just wonder it's been so
- 12:06many years and the same pattern people have been following all
- 12:11those top industry guys. The top CEOs, the top hiding
- 12:15firms smaller, hiring firms. Even a path breaking hiring
- 12:20problems. Recruiting agencies everywhere.
- 12:23Anyone in the best practices. I don't know.
- 12:26I've never read those books, but I don't know.
- 12:28What are there in those best practices, but what we see
- 12:32certainly today, Say, is that a lot of candidates are not happy?
- 12:37Even several instances companies are not happy, what culture is
- 12:42not happy, it has lead to toxicity, it has led to more
- 12:45stress and more therapists into the work system and you are
- 12:49still trying to find out what exactly is the problem.
- 12:53So what is it? That has led to us at this
- 12:57particular Crossroad in terms of workplace has enough because Is,
- 13:03does it mean that the HR does not know that the youngster was
- 13:06just passed out of an management school or college?
- 13:10They don't know. Hiring is it or they their mind
- 13:13is corrupt? No, is it that?
- 13:16Is it leadership problem? Or is it?
- 13:19Somebody else? Is it just the society?
- 13:21As a whole that we have started producing workers?
- 13:24We have started looking at hiring workers, who are just
- 13:28confirm is you have a set of questions and you just ask them,
- 13:32tell us about About you. And just to answer that question
- 13:35has there might be millions and millions of you know searches or
- 13:38just from the website. It said yeah we're what has led
- 13:42us to this situation, a lack of understanding of Behavioral
- 13:47Science 41, and recognition that you have to identify what fit
- 13:56means in your organization. and, Just an in a broad sense.
- 14:04I can count on one hand in the 50 years.
- 14:08I've done Consulting with organizations, from worldwide
- 14:11organizations down to smaller, mom-and-pop.
- 14:14I can count on one hand when the, when the issues, whether
- 14:19it's quiet, quitting or great resignation.
- 14:22Haven't been a problem with leadership.
- 14:25It's always leadership, always leadership.
- 14:29So what does that mean? That Means that leaders don't
- 14:33understand people to start with, they don't have a profound
- 14:36knowledge of Behavioral Science and people.
- 14:40And they really don't understand how to influence well and it's
- 14:46really fascinating. I've done a lot of leader
- 14:50development competency research for a Fortune, 500 companies.
- 14:54And one of the things you always do because you have to get
- 14:58buy-in from the company as you go around to senior managers,
- 15:01and they want you to create these competency model so they
- 15:04can hire to it, they can develop to it and you ask them, okay?
- 15:09So what are your Superstars doing?
- 15:10Because that's your model, you want to have everybody perform
- 15:14like a superstar and so they'll give me a list of stuff and then
- 15:19I go out and I do the guided storytelling with their
- 15:22Superstars, their average. Poor and what comes out is that
- 15:28the superstars first of all, if let's say you ended up with 10,
- 15:33competencies really you know detailed types of skills, that
- 15:37make him a superstar, 8 of those 10 will have nothing to do with
- 15:42technical competence. It will have to do with the
- 15:45ability to influence resilience compassion.
- 15:49It's much more, the personality aspects and a lot of that is
- 15:54just Frankly trainable. Anybody can get better at
- 15:58anything but, you know, it's going to take too long.
- 16:02You want them to hit the ground running, you don't have 10 years
- 16:05to change their personality. So you've got to, you've got to
- 16:08be sophisticated about this. You've got to know which
- 16:10trainable are not trainable and like, I'm saying, 8 out of every
- 16:1510, competencies for the superstars are have nothing to
- 16:19do with technical competence. As a matter of fact that many
- 16:21cases. It's the inverse, the higher,
- 16:23the technical God Since the lousier the leadership.
- 16:27So you've let me go back to something.
- 16:30Have you ever heard of the Peter Principle?
- 16:34Not exactly. Yeah yeah I think there was a
- 16:37fellow by the name of Peter Townsend, who wrote a book
- 16:40called that but what he said was you rise to your level of your
- 16:44incompetence, so people are doing okay and all of a sudden
- 16:47they're doing a crummy job, we see it around the world and
- 16:51every business of every type. Well, no modesty here.
- 16:55The Brian principle is that you rise to your level of your
- 17:00inability to influence. You rise to your level of your
- 17:04inability to influence. So this profound understanding
- 17:08and Leadership of influence. And there's a mantra because
- 17:12it's all around relationship, not building relationships for
- 17:15their own sake, but to get people motivated and to do the
- 17:18work and to work in teams. Well, but the Mantra of a leader
- 17:22has to be heart before head. Touch before task and
- 17:28relationship before relevance, and rigor and if you don't start
- 17:32there with that mindset, you will never get people motivated
- 17:36or bought in to what you're really, trying to get them to
- 17:40do, and how they will, if they will use their discretionary
- 17:43effort on your behalf or not. When you talk about the great
- 17:47resignation or particularly the quiet quitting, you've got
- 17:51people just doing the minimum sorts of things to get by.
- 17:55Bye. And they're not giving you any
- 17:57discretionary effort. And often when you're not
- 18:00watching, they're watching something on YouTube, that's all
- 18:05leadership. And so when we get back now to
- 18:08talking about the hiring process, do you know how to hire
- 18:12for people who will fit your culture?
- 18:14Do you have the definitions from a role perspective competency
- 18:18and leadership style? That will, in fact that detail
- 18:23valid measurable that will. In fact, hit me.
- 18:26Culture, even though I have created models for hiring and
- 18:31development, in hundreds of cases, I have never created
- 18:36models that were exactly the same.
- 18:39The reason being that you and your company have a unique set
- 18:43of goals and culture that has to be captured.
- 18:48And once you've captured it and, you know, given it high high
- 18:52level of detail, then you can use the guided story.
- 18:55Tell him to see will this person fit?
- 18:58Do they have the skills? But will they also fit our
- 19:01culture? Even if it's a toxic culture
- 19:04because some people will thrive in a tough place.
- 19:08So it's people are fascinating, they're amazing, but, you know,
- 19:14to add just a little bit more to it.
- 19:18We are social creatures. Most people don't go to work to
- 19:22work. Most work is boring as hell.
- 19:26They go to work to socialize. One of the things that killed
- 19:31the workplace was covid and not being able to socialize and you
- 19:36as a, as a leader, you've got to understand that and how do you
- 19:39provide people with the social context that they get
- 19:44relationship needs met because they will do work.
- 19:48In the service of the relationship but not just to do
- 19:52the work. Forget it.
- 19:53Forget paychecks, don't matter. They do I meet at a basic level
- 19:57but it's really people only work to socialize.
- 20:02So there's a, there's a, this is when I talk about Behavioral
- 20:05Science, there's a lot AJ that goes into the mix of having a
- 20:09company, be sophisticated, and understand, Behavioral Science,
- 20:15and competency research. And some of the things that are
- 20:18really necessary. You can make a huge difference
- 20:21in your culture and your productivity if you understand
- 20:24this. Right, right, Billy.
- 20:28I'm not let me ask you a couple of things that you mentioned.
- 20:32One was leadership. Who is a leader today?
- 20:36Is it, somebody who has just passed on out from a big
- 20:40management school, and he's put into a leadership position.
- 20:44Is he a leader? No.
- 20:45Is he your manager? Your Leader?
- 20:48Is it the CEO? That is the leader.
- 20:50Is it the CHR? Oh, who's the leader?
- 20:52Is it? The HR manager who is the
- 20:53leader? Is it?
- 20:54The board? Who is the leader?
- 20:56You see if the CEO, who's the leader all the CX Susan, who is
- 21:00a leader one? Yeah.
- 21:01Well if they have a position in which they have to influence and
- 21:06motivate others, they have to have leadership skills and that
- 21:11has to progress in a scaffolding way to get greater and greater
- 21:15and greater. So, for example, somebody at a
- 21:18supervisory level, Has to think about influence, maybe this
- 21:24much. Okay, and how do I get my team
- 21:27that I'm working with to get the job done, meet deadlines, and so
- 21:31forth, when I work with CEOs, at their level, the influence
- 21:37thinking has to be, you know, this big they spend 75 80 90
- 21:43percent of their time thinking about how do I influence
- 21:46everybody? How do I beat the competition?
- 21:50How do I I convinced funders to give me the banks to give me the
- 21:55funding that I want. They live in an influence world.
- 21:58So with every job you go up the influence, requirements go up.
- 22:03But you have to be sophisticated enough to know how to then use
- 22:06influence, what are the influence skills at each level
- 22:10that are most critical? So, everybody should be a
- 22:12leader. That's at least in a supervisory
- 22:15position if they're not just an individual contributor.
- 22:19But in today's world also, Even individual contributors now are
- 22:23asking to be more team players and if you're a team player is
- 22:26got to get more sophisticated about influence skills as well.
- 22:31And who are these Superstars that you mentioned about because
- 22:35everybody seems to be looking for super stars within their
- 22:38organization. Are they the rainmakers?
- 22:42Are they, the ones who are making the most amount of money?
- 22:45Or is it somebody who's holding the organization like a glue and
- 22:49may not have been from a top Management's?
- 22:51Who is that? Who is the Superstar that we are
- 22:54so talking about? Yeah, well so well for one thing
- 22:58as you mentioned, you know, MBA programs and stuff I have yet to
- 23:03see one that understands influence, they teach
- 23:07traditional sorts of stuff and the numbers and this and that
- 23:10but they really don't understand the influence of leadership what
- 23:14they call leadership, is usually just a different form of
- 23:17management and administration is a huge difference.
- 23:24Upstate the question. Again, I got myself off track,
- 23:27no problem. So who is the Superstar of the
- 23:39signs? They don't understand.
- 23:40That's the skill set, that's required.
- 23:42So it means we are looking at something different that in what
- 23:45is required, that's why it has led to quite quit quitting.
- 23:48And the great resignation, people are still getting it,
- 23:52right? As I said, sir, I have been
- 23:53talking. To so many people therapist been
- 23:56due respect to them, they should be where they should be, but
- 24:00what are they doing? Within organizations when
- 24:02organizations have to make them as part of their, you know,
- 24:06work-life balance? Or I don't know.
- 24:08That Grieves me, I really feel very bad looking at youngsters
- 24:13dealing with issues. That should refer not beaten.
- 24:17Yeah, yeah. We've never done
- 24:19internationally. A good job of bringing the
- 24:23younger generation along. On and we don't have the models.
- 24:28There aren't enough models of good leadership.
- 24:31And the thing that we tend to see in this is pretty well
- 24:33established by research is a lot of the people that make it to
- 24:37the top are not good people. As a matter of fact from an
- 24:41actual psychiatric psychological point of view, one out of every
- 24:46five of your top CEOs military leaders otherwise have been
- 24:50identified as Psychopaths. So what does that say to people
- 24:54in terms? Terms of manipulation and
- 24:56self-aggrandizement. You know, where's the right
- 24:58models? And then you get people to go up
- 25:01but they they don't understand how to be a top leader, but they
- 25:05got pushed up there because who else is there?
- 25:08You know, it's by default, which is crazy.
- 25:11When we do competency research for a company to identify, what
- 25:16the superstars are doing, we look at it within Department
- 25:20because a sales superstar has different thinking different
- 25:23skills than And an operation Superstar but what is is a
- 25:28little bit strange. When you do the research and
- 25:31it's accepted in the research field is that nominations for
- 25:35Superstars work. And what I mean by that is I go
- 25:38into a company and I say, in this particular job, give me 15
- 25:43to 20 of your Superstars and they'll say, what do you mean?
- 25:48And I'll say well I can give you a couple parameters but just who
- 25:52are the people when people look at At them, they say, hey, AJ's
- 25:56a superstar, okay? And Tony's a superstar and you
- 26:01know different people are superstars, people can identify
- 26:05who the superstars are what they can't identify.
- 26:08And any valid detail is what makes them a superstar that's
- 26:18there was this big Telling that they were perhaps not fit for
- 26:31that company. Now, if they were so there can
- 26:34be always been accusations and all these things happen, there
- 26:38are, you know, changes leadership changes.
- 26:41Yeah, but here's the changes gave a very different sort of
- 26:44impression as if they were not superstars, who have considered
- 26:48to be their superstar, that point it up, but actually that
- 26:51led to what that big companies He is today in such a bad shape.
- 26:57Yeah, what of it should they believe in yesterday or today?
- 27:00We live in today, I believe water today because if you use
- 27:06just the bottom line, they never made money.
- 27:08I think we're talking about the same.
- 27:10Same company that was just brought, they didn't make money,
- 27:15they may have been superstars in their technical Realm.
- 27:19But where they superstars from a marketing leadership,
- 27:23understanding the public point of view.
- 27:25And if you hear the reports of how time was being spent by
- 27:29people in that company time, was not being used very effectively
- 27:33at all. So it very situationally, The
- 27:37Situation's changed, there's no doubt about it.
- 27:40And every time there's a major change in goals leadership or
- 27:43otherwise, you have to re-calibrate the whole system.
- 27:50You have to look at it all over again and say what will a
- 27:53superstar look like in this environment?
- 27:55Do we have any give you a fascinating story?
- 27:58We were, we were called in to help a come a very large,
- 28:04Entergy come Energy company in the United States and this is
- 28:09when energy was deregulated and what I mean by deregulated in
- 28:15the energy business, the, you know, big energy firms did
- 28:18everything they They transmitted and they sold at retail at the
- 28:24industry or at home or whatever. Well, that changed.
- 28:30And now all of a sudden you can't have all three, you're
- 28:34either owner of the generation or the transmission, or
- 28:37otherwise, and they never because it was regulated.
- 28:42They never had to have marketing people.
- 28:45Who had real marketing skills, which is a lot of influence, you
- 28:51know, buy from US versus the other Energy company next door
- 28:54and so we had to go in and create a profile because they
- 29:00didn't have any marketing Superstars internally.
- 29:03We had to identify companies that were similar to them and
- 29:07study their Superstars as a starting point.
- 29:10And then over time as people started to get into the job and
- 29:15get Ali good. We could say, hey, that person
- 29:18is a superstar. Let's do the guided storytelling
- 29:21where them, let's see what they are.
- 29:23In fact, demonstrating when dealing with customers, so it's
- 29:27an organic moving Target. And and if you're going to be
- 29:31successful and competitive you've got to get in front of
- 29:34it, I don't think the company that was just bought was in
- 29:37front of it at all. And hadn't proved at least from
- 29:41a bottom-line point of view. They're worth.
- 29:45Right, right? So let's move from Superstars to
- 29:49Solutions and you are a man of Solutions in terms of again,
- 29:53will take leadership as well as employee hiding.
- 29:57Yeah. So if we take first as employee
- 30:00hide, then how do we make that whole process better?
- 30:05Because the most important part is, when you look at the job
- 30:10description and it keeps on floating everywhere all across
- 30:13the internet, you will see job. Options that are not only.
- 30:18I would say almost you have point of, you know, impossible
- 30:21and sometimes and that keeps getting copied by one person,
- 30:25another person and that keeps on floating, it's like, you know,
- 30:28those kids a lot of content on the internet with the standard
- 30:31job description is junk, okay? Junk worthless.
- 30:37If you don't know how to create job, descriptions, that are
- 30:40truly measure role. Proficiencies competency
- 30:43proficiencies. On leadership style
- 30:46proficiencies and and you have a way of validating those against
- 30:51what the superstars are doing, then you're wasting your time,
- 30:55it's a crapshoot, it's 50/50 your confidence in hiring is to
- 31:01flip of a flip of the coin. You may have favorite questions
- 31:05or whatever the case may be. That I can tell you over time
- 31:08that doesn't work and it doesn't work overtime.
- 31:10Also, if you're thinking from a talent management point of view
- 31:14because you should have Profiles at this level, the next level,
- 31:18the next level, the next level. Remember what I said, what makes
- 31:22four Superstars. A lot of their qualities are not
- 31:25trainable, so you better be looking at it in a scaffolded
- 31:29fashion and how do you bring people along if you want
- 31:32Superstar leaders grown from within then the even the basic
- 31:37person that walks in the door? Who isn't supervising?
- 31:40Yet you do profiles on them and you interview them to see if
- 31:45they Of the capacity to develop and and the different thing,
- 31:49like one of the, one of the one of the very large International
- 31:52drug companies. I was brought in to create two
- 31:56paths for them. One path was how to become a
- 31:59technical Superstar and the other Pathways become a
- 32:03leadership Superstar. Because to to be both in, many
- 32:07respects is almost impossible because the traits qualities
- 32:10attributes are not the same, but unfortunately, most companies
- 32:14are big enough to have that luxury to do that.
- 32:19Right. Thank you.
- 32:20And in terms of leadership, how do they improve their whatever
- 32:27in terms of understanding people in terms of, you know, getting
- 32:31onto the right path? The right sort of leadership
- 32:34ultimately. See a CO Still Remains the CEO.
- 32:38It all depends on which path. You take a path which is, you
- 32:42know, a path, which is bitten or something new.
- 32:45That actually is required. I wonder why many people People
- 32:49are afraid of is it that they have so much of pressure of
- 32:52bottom lines, or is it just they don't want to do it.
- 32:55It's like it's like a new King on the throne and they just want
- 32:58to feel like, what the throne is about like, is about sure.
- 33:03Sure. Well, a lot of this goes back to
- 33:06a trait that isn't particularly trainable, which is risk
- 33:09aversion. There are people who have a much
- 33:13higher tolerance for risk and ambiguity willing to take
- 33:17chances. And those people are going to
- 33:19step up and move and others are more concerned about, you know,
- 33:26their job, the pay the compensation, they are going to
- 33:30be more safety concerned, so that's, that's part of it.
- 33:34It's not the whole picture but it's one of its an element that
- 33:37plays a big role in to who will strive enough to do it.
- 33:41The other, the other thing that you have to look at to is
- 33:43leaders have to be Savvy enough to make a differentiation
- 33:49between extroverts and quiet competence.
- 33:54There are many people who are introverts, who have tons of
- 33:58competence and skills. Whereas the other people you
- 34:04know, who have more, you know, day-to-day interaction, maybe
- 34:08more Charisma will be given more slack because they seem to, you
- 34:16know, they're more bubbly, they get along when they really don't
- 34:19have the competence required in the job.
- 34:22That's why there's so much false positives in hiring false.
- 34:28Potter's mean, you're hiring people who you think have
- 34:30confidence. You don't just because of how
- 34:32they carry themselves, how they interviewed, but that's because
- 34:35you haven't had the detailed criteria and the guide is
- 34:38storytelling to really weed out the storytelling levels, the
- 34:44playing field so that it pushes all of that surface stuff aside.
- 34:49Now how slick as your language? How do you dress how do the
- 34:52other stuff? I'll take a diamond in the
- 34:54rough. Any day if that person's got the
- 34:57right stuff and we know over time it can Be developed even
- 35:02further a refined. So these are things where your
- 35:05HR departments have to get a lot more sophisticated.
- 35:08There are very few from my perspective, sophisticated HR
- 35:12departments, their HR departments are terrific.
- 35:14You got to have them and they try to take care of their
- 35:17people, but a lot of the Behavioral Science just hasn't
- 35:19gotten into practice yet. Right, right?
- 35:24There's so many tools available that is not official
- 35:27intelligence also. Now there is so much of you
- 35:29know, you don't even need to go through those documents by on
- 35:35paper you just have to do the search and still I don't know.
- 35:39Why is it leading to a lot of you know Hartman in place
- 35:44workplaces? If the hiring process has been
- 35:47so robust. So in terms of even leadership
- 35:51again here, Is it that leadership is just acting the
- 35:55way it is because there is no leadership evaluation because
- 35:59only an acquisition will deter mean that they have to be there
- 36:03or not. Nothing else or only the bottom
- 36:06line, then there is the board which they are to responsible
- 36:09to. But what about the leadership?
- 36:12The managerial leadership? Why are there?
- 36:15No proper evaluations done. If there is a well-liked were
- 36:20toxic culture? Yeah.
- 36:23Get a job for easily in another organization.
- 36:25Is it connections or where is that evaluation happening?
- 36:28Within that organization? Why is this fight?
- 36:31Quitting not being questioned and responsibilities put on the
- 36:35people who should be answerable to this?
- 36:37Well, once again, they don't understand leadership and many
- 36:40who are decent leaders or bad leaders don't understand why
- 36:44they're good or bad. I'll go back to that study.
- 36:48I was talking about the large Fortune 500, I went around and
- 36:51asked all the leaders, but when I did the research, what I found
- 36:55was that it was there were 13 competencies in the model.
- 36:59And 10 of those competencies had to do with the ability to
- 37:03influence yet, in my conversations with all the top
- 37:06leaders. They only pick two of the ten as
- 37:10distinguishing between Superstars are not.
- 37:12People don't understand influence.
- 37:16Too, kind of encapsulate the importance of this after
- 37:22studying leaders. And it took me a while to get
- 37:24this under my belt, you can list all of their role proficiencies
- 37:28company's leadership styles, but it really boils down to two
- 37:31factors and it's something that I actually copyrighted, and it's
- 37:37called tight thinking, t.i. te. And what it is, is think
- 37:44influence. Think energy energy is the
- 37:48little mystery ingredient here. I always wondered, why are these
- 37:53Superstars? I see the influence stuff, but
- 37:55also, what else are they doing? That makes them so darn
- 37:59effective and what I found was, it wasn't just how somebody used
- 38:04resources. The top Superstars always looked
- 38:08when they were putting goals on people's plates and stuff.
- 38:11Does this person does this team? Does this department?
- 38:15Don't have enough energy. Even if they have the skill and
- 38:19the will is there enough energy. For them to get this done and
- 38:26therefore they can appropriately.
- 38:27Adjust their time Horizons for meeting goals based on the
- 38:31energy available, this isn't another issue around the
- 38:34pandemic drives me nuts. I work with a lot of school
- 38:39systems and Screen school systems are trying to catch up
- 38:44because covid costs, the kids that they're not keeping up with
- 38:48their grade levels and all of that sort of stuff and In one
- 38:53case I saw from a large school district tens of thousands of
- 38:57kids this plan and the plan was 75 pages long and had two
- 39:04sentences on leadership in it. It was all about what teachers
- 39:08have to do. And these are the programs kids
- 39:10have to do absolute, you know, formula for disaster, because it
- 39:17was no understanding that people are burned out the kids, don't
- 39:22have the energy. Teachers don't have the energy.
- 39:24I was, I was hired by a foundation to go in to a very
- 39:28large 7 of their large school districts.
- 39:31They were giving tons millions of dollars to they same Grill.
- 39:34Are we spending our money? Well, and I knew before I went
- 39:38in, just give me the money and I'll tell you, no, they're not,
- 39:42but I went in. And for example, one school
- 39:45system and I do I do in a day, I can tell them exactly where
- 39:49their money is going, where the energy is going.
- 39:51Why they're failing. A whole bunch of stuff but in
- 39:54addition to just doing what they were supposed to do to educate
- 39:57kids, they had on their platter 150 programs that they've gotten
- 40:05grants for to improve things. And immediately you say to
- 40:09yourself, do you understand human beings because human
- 40:13beings can't do any more than 12 at tops.
- 40:16Three things at any one time so this totally overloads and when
- 40:21you over go, The motivation goes out the door.
- 40:24You talk about quiet quitting. You want quiet quitting over
- 40:27gold people. Don't understand them, don't
- 40:30understand Behavioral Science. So it all gets back to that AJ.
- 40:35Right bit. So in short, how can, you know,
- 40:38there are a lot of firms and I keep on talking to so many of
- 40:42them and some owners, I know personally.
- 40:46So so many people want to actually make their work place.
- 40:50A very happy place but so many are still not able to.
- 40:56Yeah. How can they make their
- 40:58workplace? Better.
- 41:00Workplace, and leadership in turn.
- 41:02They get the right sort of literacy.
- 41:04How do they do that? And second question is so that
- 41:07you can respond at your own pace is in this present atmosphere.
- 41:14How is it that they can employees can make their life
- 41:17better? Somebody who's looking for a
- 41:19job? How should, what should he
- 41:22determine with? How we should start his process
- 41:25of entering into the workforce, which is good for his body, my
- 41:30as well as pocket for his future.
- 41:33Well, you've got the two sides of the story here, right?
- 41:36The right, well, the boss in the employee.
- 41:38So if we're starting with the boss again, because everything
- 41:42ends up on their doorstep, then it's back to Really getting into
- 41:48some leadership training and understanding that is a lot
- 41:52different than they've ever had before.
- 41:55You know, understanding Behavioral Science understanding
- 41:58that most people don't work to work, they work to socialize.
- 42:02And there are a lot of stories behind that, so that's the first
- 42:06place. And then understand the tight
- 42:08thinking, think influence, think energy and what does that look
- 42:12like at every level and it differs and look at What your
- 42:17Superstars are doing. Look at who people will follow
- 42:21anywhere, do anything for and figure out?
- 42:23Can you measure it? And that's one way of starting
- 42:26to say, well, if that's what they're doing, what should I be
- 42:29doing? Now?
- 42:30From the employee side, they've got to be a lot more
- 42:35self-directed in terms of even the first job, when they walk in
- 42:39the door, have you researched the company?
- 42:43Have you, you know, going out on a limb and calls Following the
- 42:47company to talk to you about what's going on and most people
- 42:51will respond. You know, you'll talk to some
- 42:53people say, well, I couldn't do that.
- 42:55I am not an employee addict to say what?
- 42:58Wait, a minute. Are you trying to create a
- 43:00career for yourself or letting somebody else Define it for you?
- 43:04So that initiative, that self-motivation, that drive.
- 43:08And for some people, it's they'll never do it because it's
- 43:11not in their genes, but others, if you can give them a model and
- 43:15help them develop some courage to, you know, Define themselves
- 43:20and recognize that in today's world in, you know, way back
- 43:23when you would work for one or two companies for your whole
- 43:26life. Now most people are going to
- 43:28have 8 10, 12 jobs at some point in time and just understand
- 43:32what's the progression. But people have to be more
- 43:35strategic even in their first job as what will this lead you
- 43:38to for the second job to the third job?
- 43:41Do you understand your own talent management progression
- 43:45are not? So There's this, we need this
- 43:50podcast, the last about four days for us today to take you
- 43:54through the tools and things that are going on.
- 43:57But hopefully, his stimulate some thought for people anyway?
- 44:01Absolutely. Absolutely.
- 44:02It will it will and obviously a lot of people are listening to.
- 44:07It will be seeing it also and I'm sure Lord will come out of
- 44:12this. Nothing goes into waste, you
- 44:15know, given all those Those stupid job descriptions, they
- 44:18don't go waste people. Keep them copying a whopping.
- 44:21This, I'm sure the good ideas also will get a reverberated.
- 44:25Oh yeah, let me leave it. One other tip, stop doing panel
- 44:29interviews, they are a total waste of time.
- 44:32Unless the competency you're looking for is someone who does
- 44:36well with panel interviews, but that isn't really what you're
- 44:39looking for and it forces you to ask the same stupid questions
- 44:44and not do. It's storytelling which is the
- 44:48only thing that's going to work for you.
- 44:50Absolutely, absolutely. So what can a lot of companies
- 44:54who want to do better from wherever they are?
- 44:59How do they, what do they connect with what?
- 45:02Exactly can you can they connect vu4 with you for and how do they
- 45:08do that? How does it work?
- 45:10Well, the best thing to do is just to drop a line to info So
- 45:17at T BG l.com, in other words, info at the Brian group
- 45:22leaders.com info at T BG L.com. We always get back within a
- 45:27business day because we don't answer phones that we don't know
- 45:34because it weighs so damn much time.
- 45:37So if a number comes in but if they leave a volt, if also I
- 45:41talked I thought I don't do that.
- 45:46I sometimes if you call back your day is gone.
- 45:50Yeah. Oh absolutely.
- 45:52So also if they did want to call directly but I would encourage
- 45:55them to send a note first because then we can do a little
- 45:58homework on our side and be more prepared to respond to them.
- 46:01But if they want to call, they can call 40, 1965 eight three,
- 46:08four, five, four zero, one nine, six, five, eight, three, four,
- 46:11five, and that's that's in the states.
- 46:14And for us, we are Pacific time. So three hours different than on
- 46:19the East Coast. Right.
- 46:22Right? And and happy where there's some
- 46:24free downloads of tools on our website.
- 46:27To take a look at, and the meter isn't always running for us.
- 46:32We want people just to get better.
- 46:34We want people to succeed. So, you know, let's have a
- 46:36conversation or to whatever, right.
- 46:40Let's have a conversation. And I can tell you, this was a
- 46:43great conversation in terms of insights, and I'm sure this will
- 46:47lead to a lot of good. Students, for people who
- 46:52actually want to make things better.
- 46:54Okay, thank you so much for your time.
- 46:56Indeed, will welcome, really. Appreciate it.
- 46:59Thought your questions were right on target.
- 47:01Thank you. Thank you.
- 47:04Thank you, indeed. And look forward to talking to
- 47:07you again soon with this. It's a wrap on this, very
- 47:10special edition of the cage, a master closet, thank you.
- 47:13Once again.