Latest / Automotive State of The Union / An Anonymous 43.2M Call, Private Acquisitions To The Moon, and Phone Call Friday
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] It's Friday, November 19th, and everybody woke up this morning to find out an anonymous phone caller beat 19,000 people to the Constitution.
- 0:13Everywhere I go, the people really wanna know who I is and who I be. They stop and stare when they see me. Friday bounce. And consider once knowing me.
- 0:20Like we talked earlier, like when you're in your own chair versus the hotel chair, the bounce goes deep. But on Friday, the bounce to the music goes a little bit deeper.
- 0:29We're just gonna skim over this story 'cause we talked about it yesterday. Uh, so a lot of people got together. If, if, if you're not in crypto, just bear with us for a second.
- 0:39There's something called a DAO, D-A-O, where people can raise money together to buy things. It's governed by the people. And they got together and raised $40 million-ish
- 0:52to buy one of the remaining copies of the Constitution. And everyone, there's a lot of energy around it, and people were like, "Yes, we're gonna do this. Constitution- "This is gonna happen.
- 1:01People are gonna be able to-... it's gonna be owned by the people," right? There's-... vote on what goes on with it. Yeah, all this stuff...
- 1:05there's, there's a lot of poetic justice around it too, honestly, if you think about it. Yeah, yeah. Like, hey, hey, the people should own this copy of the Constitution.
- 1:12So Sotheby's last night, they're act- [laughs] the DAO members, they had a Twitter space. They're doing a victory lap, and then this phone call comes in, and the anonymous caller was like, "I've got 42,000...
- 1:26I mean 43.2 million." [laughs] That's- And that was the end of that. [laughs] A- and there it went. Now- Let's talk first. Let's- [laughs] Sorry. Yeah. Meant to do this. [record scratch] Uh, yeah.
- 1:39[laughs] Let's roll back that celebration. It's funny because, you know, o- on a, on an, on an auction site like that, typically you wanna kinda hold your cards, right?
- 1:46But the, the truth of the matter was is there wasn't the... there was no ability for this DAO to hold its cards because it was now a public, you know, space where- Ledger. Public ledger of how much money's in there.
- 1:58Ledger. So you know what the max bid is. Exactly. Yes. Dang. So all the anonymous phone caller had to know was, "Nah, I can... I'm willing to go higher than that." Right. [laughs] And boom, it's done. Right? All over.
- 2:06So a little, little piece of pop culture. [laughs] Not just pop culture, actually. It's, it's probably a lot more significant, just the fact that a DAO can raise money that quickly.
- 2:15That is a, a pretty, a pretty substantial thing that will change, will cha-... Imagine if you did a DAO for, like, car ownership. Huh. You buy a car. I don't know. All right.
- 2:27We're gonna get too heady on a Friday, and it's gonna make everyone turn this off. So let's talk about something [laughs] that's a little less heady. [laughs] Right? Let's talk about Black Friday for one second.
- 2:34We didn't talk about this in our pre-meeting. Oh, yeah. Like, I don't know if everyone's noticed, but Black Friday was, like, last week. [laughs] Yeah. I, I- It started-... that's what I felt like.
- 2:43I was like, "Yeah, that, that come and, came and went." [laughs] How, how many emails are in your inbox right now like, "Black Friday starts yesterday. Black Friday starts, starts, starts, starts"? Yeah.
- 2:53The, I, I feel like, uh, I, I feel like Dick's Sporting Goods has had Black Friday now seven times. Yeah. So...
- 2:59[laughs] Well, what's happened now, the second you see, like, a big deal, like, now you can pretty much be, uh, certain that you're gonna get, like, that 30% off for the rest- Right... of the year. Right.
- 3:10Like, whenever you decide. And it probably won't get any better than that because they're not gonna train people to, like, "Oh, don't take the first deal." Right? Wait, wait, wait, wait. Either way, another little piece.
- 3:21You probably notice it. It's probably in your inbox. But speaking of Black Friday and deals... Stop. Segway. Time.
- 3:27[upbeat music] So the Hague Report came out just, uh, a couple of days ago and, um, there's something going on with, [laughs] with dealership transactions and values, Kyle, don't you think? Yeah, there's a lot.
- 3:42I mean, just the, the overall percentage raise in, in, not, uh... and, and interestingly enough, not in private acquisitions but in public ac- acquisitions. Mm-hmm.
- 3:54So the, the publics are the ones that are seeing, what did you calculate? Over a 500% increase year over year? 587% increase in the amount of public store, uh, uh, public acquisitions.
- 4:08So that's public companies acquiring stores.
- 4:11Which is interesting because there's, there's kind of this, like, move to conglomeration, but, and we've talked about this, you and I have talked about this, in this, uh, you know, need for a delivery network and a servicing network for these larg- larger organizations that are moving to compete in the, uh, Carvana, CarMax space, especially on used cars.
- 4:32But knowing that their, that their real, you know, that the, that the real ability to beat them is in new cars because they have the new cars. So I think that's interesting.
- 4:42But then, you know, when you, when you said good deals, it kind of, it, it brought this around because the next part of the Hague Report that came out is that, um, the multiple is actually being outpaced by the actual value of the acquired store or blue sky.
- 4:57You know? So th- there's still kind of some hesitancy on the multiple, 'cause you would think that the multiple would pace with the trajectory of the value.
- 5:06Um, so, so actually the private companies are, are surprisingly, even though the, the dollar amounts, right? We're, we're hearing about the Prime acquisition by Group One.
- 5:16We're hearing about all these acquisitions of, uh, of large dealer groups, and we see the dollar amount.
- 5:24But, uh, just thinking about the actual trajectory of the multiple on the, on the actual value is, is kind of interesting. The mul- You know, actually, now that you're saying it- But-...
- 5:32it kind of makes sense because the multiple is typically based on some level of ROI over a period of time. Mm. Yep.
- 5:39And because the future, the future ROI is real, I mean, like, we can't see much further than six months, right, and have a guess on what we think it's gonna be.
- 5:48So I, I guess it kind of makes sense that the multiple is gonna stay put, but the value, because it's just an irrational time.
- 5:56And so if you, if you like, uh, the exact numbers, so in 2020 there were 39 public acquisitionsAnd in 2021, the estimate is by the end of the year we will be at 500- I'm sorry, 229. True. So we went from 39 to 229.
- 6:12And in the private side, in 2020 there were 305, and in 2021 it notched up just 13% to 346. So a much, much, much bigger jump in the public acquisitions, economy of scale, unified customer experience.
- 6:29It shouldn't surprise us that we're seeing this activity.
- 6:32Um, and I think, I think this could be good for the industry in the sense like, look, I like, I like the idea of things being spread out, you know, more than consolidated.
- 6:41I think that gives us kind of more variety, flavor, less risk.
- 6:43But at the same time, I think the public acquisitions are going to help tech partners and platforms, and they're gon- they're gonna show the rest of the industry what's possible. Yeah.
- 6:54And, and I think because of that, it's a good thing. So if you're a savvy dealer and you're paying attention, guess what?
- 7:00These platforms, this tech, yes, maybe the public's have some, you know, internal dev, dev and, and all that stuff, but guess what? There's much less of a gap than you think between what you can deliver on a small level.
- 7:11There really, really is. And, and I think that that's just kind of the, some of these larger groups and, and even mid-size groups are, are right now building a concept car.
- 7:21And, and that concept car will become a production car- Mm-hmm... pretty quickly. I like that analogy.
- 7:26Probably a lot quicker than, you know, what, what we typically see in the tech world, just because, you know, speed and efficiency goes a lot quicker these days.
- 7:34And so, um, just watch what the concept car is, especially for the smaller dealers or smaller, uh, groups and, and see where you can start to produ- build the production car from a tech or process side i- at, i- on a local level.
- 7:47Uh, because I think that that'll do two things.
- 7:50One, it'll actually, when, when someone comes calling to purchase, you'll, you'll have, you will have a higher multiple, or you'll know whether or not the value is there, you know, to be purchased, so. You know what?
- 8:03I think we should try... It is Phone Call Friday, and we're gonna try to call Alan Haig. We're gonna go for it. [phone ringing] All right, let's see if he picks up. I haven't spoken to him in a while.
- 8:16I don't think he's gonna pick up. [phone ringing] Maybe he will. Who knows? I don't know. It's early on a Friday. Anything can happen. He's probably like, "Why is Paul calling me?" [laughs] "What is happening?" And
- 8:30let's see if we get the voicemail. [beep] It's the end. Hi, this is Alan Haig. Please leave me a message and I'll get back to you as soon as I can. Boy, that's quintessential Alan Haig right there. That voicemail.
- 8:42[laughs] That- All right, we tried. That's true. We, we have, uh, we have another, we have, uh, another person that we're gonna try calling in a moment. But, uh, I like that metaphor, Kyle.
- 8:50That concept car, production car. That's a, that fits this really, really well. Yeah, yeah. And I think it's, it's easier for, you know, a lot of, a lot of auto dealers to kind of wrap their head around.
- 9:01Um, because a lot of times, you know, especially the smaller dealers that do, you said these larger dealers or dealer groups have the dev wor- have the internal developers, right? Yep.
- 9:12And so it's like there's no way we could ever accomplish X. We've just got to get our ground game right. That's just not gonna be- Not true... the reality over the next two to three years. Don't believe that. Right?
- 9:21That's, that's... There's so many people building so many amazing things. The velocity of the aggregation of data and tech platforms, it is picking up with lightning speed. Yes. Yeah. You know?
- 9:34That's, that kind of gets us to... Oh my gosh, we're gonna do another segue. Stop. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] Speaking of data and aggregation and things working together- Yeah...
- 9:44there's a lot of things that people don't talk about at a conference that they were talking about at the AAAS conference, which has been renamed, by the way.
- 9:51Yes, the Modern Retail Conference, which I really, really like because it's not called the Digital Retail Conference. [laughs] Yes. Thank God. Thank goodness. Oh, we're so good. Right? Okay.
- 10:01So Kyle, talk, talk to us about what we were hearing that people don't usually hear. I mean, this is part of your regular conversation and vernacular, but you were hearing this from the stage. Yeah. I'm, I... Okay.
- 10:12So, uh, so three m- big themes that I kind of caught- And we got four and a half minutes left, so- So we gotta make a call... just so you know, 'cause we got a phone call... real quick.
- 10:19So the, the major themes were APIs, data layers/CDPs,
- 10:26and websites that we've shoved to these, like, cost-efficient models that actually prohibit innovation at the vendor and dealer side. And so thinking about
- 10:41dealers and dealer groups talking about forcing the OEM, the vendors, to live on APIs, creating CDPs and data lakes that can be executed at the dealer or group level, and starting to think about websites as, as a lot, uh, a lot more expensive to get out what you need out of it from a data and experience perspective.
- 11:07It's a revolutionary thought from, from, from auto dealers. So I'm proud of the people at AAAS- Yes... that were bringing that to the stage. And it's just the beginning.
- 11:16I think, we haven't used this one in a while, but it's merited. [nerd alert sound] Did I do that? Yes. We brought it back. That's our, that's our nerd alert.
- 11:25[laughs] When that happens, when you hear that, just buckle up for a minute. Sorry I didn't give you advance warning, but I didn't know where it was going. But I should've known. All right, Phone Call Friday.
- 11:33Uh, we have a couple minutes left. Let's see if Dan Moore, who is in Arizona, by the way. [phone ringing] So he's a f- [laughs] a couple hours, or actually only two hours because they don't- Got him on the early rise.
- 11:45Yeah. Let's see. [phone ringing] Has he got it going on? If there's an echo, we know he's in the bathroom. [laughs] What are you guys chuckling about? Yes. Yes. Good morning.
- 11:58[laughs] Welcome to the Automotive Troublemakers podcast. Dan Moore, it is... You're in, you're in Arizona. We were like, "If it's echoing, we know he's in the bathroom"I'm, I'm not in the bathroom, so you're lucky.
- 12:09[laughs] There you go. [laughs] What, what, um... So we were just talking about AAAS- That's a different... Is that, is that, like, a different podcast? No, we don't have... No, no.
- 12:17[laughs] I guess, I mean, it's better to be a podcast. Never mind. Um, so- [laughs] They call it ToiletCast? I'm confused. Yeah. Oh, no, no, no, no, no, no, no.
- 12:25So we were just talking about AAAS and how, um, kind of the energy is shifting around the conversation with data and integrating that, um, across platforms, and how it's accessible to more people than ever before.
- 12:37Just give us your quick take, you know, um, on, on that vibe and that energy that you see rising in the auto industry.
- 12:44Well, I think, um, I think the light bulb turned on, and people are talking about it, and it's forcing everybody to come together.
- 12:51So I, I def- think coming back from that conference and hearing, you know, people like Andy Wright talk about the data and, and how they need to have more access to it and kind of bring down these walls, and people need to talk more and communicate across platforms, I- it's gonna be...
- 13:08I- I'm excited as we head into the new year. Uh, the possibilities of seeing, um, that data flow through so many different systems and really helping dealers connect the dots on more than- Yeah...
- 13:18just marketing, but just their business as a whole. Mm. Yeah, for sure.
- 13:22Dan, uh, you know, Andy, uh, since you said him, he, he brought this idea of the OEMs mandating data as the access to, you know, programs as opposed to, you know, like, some vendor, you know, Loctite or, or UX/UI, and, and the APIs or vendor.
- 13:42How does that land on you as a vendor in the space, um, you know, as the requirement to, to be drawn to the OEM standards?
- 13:50I, I mean, listen, i- if we're actually getting down to your performance is being measured, and it's measured on a even playing field, I think that that's a no-brainer.
- 13:59Um, I, I think it's one of those things, if you think of everything that's been built, reporting on your metrics is kind of the afterthought of everything else.
- 14:08It's more of a justification so you don't get the cancellation letter. Mm-hmm. So I think if we're really and truly measuring performance, that changes the game.
- 14:15And it, it's not a, it's not a slap in the face or a negative. It's actually a positive because if you're on...
- 14:20If everything is standardized, you can understand what you have to march to, how you better your own platform, how you better your performance.
- 14:27So I think the dealer, the vendor communities, and the OEMs all win if everybody can check the ego at the door, align on some standardization, and then execute against it.
- 14:37So what you're saying is you're a fan of objective measurement. Always have been. [laughs] Always will be. [laughs] That doesn't surprise me. My friend, thank you so much for picking up the phone so early.
- 14:50It, it's great to hear your voice, great to have your energy. And if you want to give the people something to go out on, what, what are you saying to everybody heading into the weekend?
- 14:58Um, well, A, first, take a minute, enjoy time with the family, and enjoy your week. And then second, um, hey, own your own stuff. Own your data. Yes. I love it. Thank you so much, my friend. We'll talk to you soon.
- 15:11All right, guys. Thanks. Yep, bye. Oh, I'm so glad he picked up. I know. That was good. [laughs] And, and he leaned right in. It's exact- Yeah, both of us laughing... ly, yeah. [laughs] Yeah.
- 15:23I love- We gotta stop laughing when people ask. What are you laughing at? What are, what are you guys laughing at, right? He just knew both of us were on. [laughs] He's heard the podcast before. He know what's up.
- 15:32He, he knew what's up, yeah. So you're saying you like the way he leaned in? Yeah, he leaned into, uh, th- this idea that... And he's been talking about this for a while, but that there, that there's this data...
- 15:43A- and I think... And he didn't really expand on this. It's not a standardization of the data that you have to be measured by.
- 15:50It's a standardization on how the data moves, and that's the important part, I think, uh, that, that we need to lean into as an industry. [upbeat music] Well, thanks for listening this week.
- 16:00It's been an awesome week, our most downloaded week ever. The, the arc is going up. More and more people on the podcast, just like you. Enjoy your weekend. We'll see you back here Monday morning, ready to bounce.
- 16:11Everywhere I go, the people really wanna know who I is and who I be. They stop and stare when they see me. If I said it once, no need to repeat. Run up on me, watch you fall to your knees.
- 16:20Tip my hat when it's time for the kill. Ain't no beats when you really real. I am the boss. I am the don. I am-