Latest / The National Debt Podcast with Fexingo: Treasury, Borrowing, and Long-Term Fiscal Outlook / The Hidden Cost of a Soft Jobs Market
Transcript
- Lucas: So the headline this week was a bit of a shocker: the US economy actually lost 23,000 jobs in July. That's not just a miss—it's the kind of number that makes you sit up. And for a show about the national debt, it's a pretty big deal. Luna: Right, because usually we talk about jobs as a labor market story, but you're saying it's a debt story too. Lucas: Exactly. And it's not just about the human cost—though that's real. It's about what a softer labor market does to the government's balance sheet. Fewer people working means less income tax revenue, less payroll tax revenue. And at the same time, more people might need unemployment benefits or other safety net programs. So the deficit widens from both ends. Luna: And we're already running a deficit of about 1.77 trillion dollars. That's what the fiscal year 2025 numbers showed, right? Lucas: Yeah, and it's actually down a bit from the previous year—1.77 trillion versus 1.81 trillion. But here's the thing: even with a smaller deficit, the debt keeps climbing. We crossed 39 trillion in January, and the debt to gdp ratio is now 122.6 percent. And when growth slows, that ratio gets worse even if the deficit shrinks. Luna: So the jobs report is like a canary in the coal mine for the debt trajectory. Lucas: Exactly. And here's the number that ties it all together: the 10-year Treasury yield is at 4.69 percent. That's up from 4.63 a few days ago. So while the economy softens, long-term borrowing costs are actually ticking up. That's not a great combination. Luna: Why would long-term yields go up when the economy is weakening? Usually that would push them down. Lucas: Well, partly because the market is worried about the supply of Treasuries. The government has to keep rolling over that debt, and there's a lot of it. Plus, the Federal Reserve is still shrinking its balance sheet. That means the Treasury has to find other buyers for all these bonds, and they have to offer higher yields to attract them. Luna: So we're paying more to borrow, while we're also collecting less in taxes. That's a double whammy. Lucas: Right. And the term premium is part of that. We've talked about it before, but the term premium is basically the extra compensation investors demand for holding long-term bonds instead of rolling over short-term ones. That's been creeping up, and it's adding to the cost of the debt. Luna: And that's not just an abstract concept—it's real money. Lucas: Absolutely. Look, the 30-year yield is already at 5.22 percent. That's the highest it's been in a while. And when you think about the fact that the average maturity of the US debt is around six years, a lot of that debt is going to be refinanced at these higher rates. Luna: So what's the Fed's role here? They're holding rates steady at 3.63 percent, but they're also paying interest on reserves. That's another cost on the debt. Lucas: Yeah, the Fed pays banks 3.65 percent on reserves, and that's essentially a transfer from the Treasury to the banks. It's one of those hidden costs that doesn't show up in the deficit numbers directly, but it's there. In fact, we did a whole episode on that—how the Fed's interest on reserves adds to the debt. Luna: But today we're focusing on the jobs report and what it means for the debt. So let's say the economy continues to cool. What happens to the deficit? Lucas: Well, if growth slows, tax revenues fall. And if the Fed eventually has to cut rates to support the economy, that could actually help with short-term borrowing costs, but it might also signal that the economy is weaker than we thought. And that could push long-term yields even higher, because investors might worry about the fiscal path. Luna: So it's a bit of a catch-22. Lucas: Exactly. Lower rates might reduce interest costs on new debt, but they could also reflect a weaker economy, which means less revenue. And the market might demand a bigger term premium if they think the debt is unsustainable. Luna: One thing that struck me in the ADP report earlier in the week—private companies added just 44,000 workers in July. That's way below expectations. So it's not just the government numbers; the private sector is feeling it too. Lucas: Yeah, that's a good point. The ADP number was a precursor to the weak BLS report. And it suggests that the labor market is genuinely softening, not just a blip. Luna: So if this trend continues, we could see the deficit widen even further. And that's on top of the structural issues like aging population and rising healthcare costs. Lucas: Right. And those are long-term drivers, but the cyclical stuff matters too. A recession would be terrible for the debt ratio. We saw that in 2020 and 2008. The debt to gdp jumped sharply in both cases. Luna: And that's why this jobs report is more than just a headline. It's a warning sign. Lucas: It is. And you know, something that often gets lost in all this is that the interest cost on the debt is now one of the biggest line items in the federal budget. It's bigger than defense, bigger than Medicaid. And it's only going to grow as we refinance at higher rates. Luna: And that's the part that feels like a slow-moving train wreck. Lucas: Maybe, but it's not inevitable. There are things we can do, like tax reform, spending cuts, or even just letting the economy grow faster. But none of that is easy politically. Luna: And speaking of what's not easy—how do we keep making this show? We don't have ads, and we're listener-funded. A lot of listeners chip in a few bucks a month through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's literally what keeps us going. Lucas: Yeah, it's a small but mighty group. And we're grateful for every one of them. If you've been getting something out of these conversations, and you have a couple dollars to spare, that link is the easiest way to support us. Luna: No pressure, just an honest ask. Now, back to the numbers. Lucas: So let's talk about what this means for the Treasury's refinancing plans. They're going to have to keep issuing a lot of debt, and with yields where they are, the interest expense is going to climb. Luna: And the yield curve is still positively sloped. The 10-year minus 2-year spread is about 46 basis points. That's actually pretty steep compared to a year ago. Lucas: Yeah, and that's interesting because a steep curve usually signals expectations of stronger growth or higher inflation. But right now, with the economy slowing, it might just be that the market is demanding a higher term premium. Luna: So the curve might be telling us more about the debt than about the economy. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a problem because it means the government has to pay more to borrow for the long term, which feeds back into the debt. Luna: It's almost like a vicious cycle. Lucas: It can be. But the key takeaway from this episode is that a soft jobs market isn't just bad for workers—it's bad for the fiscal outlook. And that's something we all have a stake in. Luna: So the next time you see a jobs report, think about the debt. I know I will. Lucas: And if you want to dig deeper, we've got a whole back catalog on the debt. But for now, thanks for listening, and we'll see you next time.