Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Brian Train
Transcript
- 0:04Out of the street corners. They scream. You knew it was coming.
- 0:08You've been waiting for this for months, rumor hardened into fear, and now
- 0:12they scream at you, the sirens, their hysterical wail, tearing through the
- 0:16white noise of the city, and you run. You run to pick up
- 0:20those things that can never be replaced, a picture of them in the days
- 0:24when they still loved you, your mother's wedding ring. And then you turn
- 0:27to your shelf of games. You only have room for five. Five Games
- 0:34for Doomsday. Five Games for Doomsday as a show in which board game personalities
- 0:41are thrust into a cabin in the woods to outrun an oncoming disaster, but
- 0:45can only take five of their games with them. But which will they choose?
- 0:50My guest this week is prolific war game designer, writer and thinker about
- 0:54games. He has many credits to his name, including A Distant Plane,
- 0:58Colonial Twilight, and a Rebuss Fanya. He has written for multiple publications and
- 1:02is currently an education officer in one of the most beautiful cities in the world,
- 1:06Victoria, British Columbia. My guest this week is Brian Train. Brian,
- 1:10Welcome to the Cabin Hi, Ben, very happy to be here.
- 1:14Thanks for inviting me to mend your ears. So my first question is how
- 1:17difficult was it for you to pick the five games to take to the cabin.
- 1:21It was difficult. I have my reasons for each one, and as
- 1:26a matter of fact, the last one on the list, I would like
- 1:30to change it for something else. I was a little bit torn as to
- 1:34whether I should be going for games that I would like to take with me
- 1:38and play either forever or for as long as it takes for the apocalypse to
- 1:42come out and claim me at the cabin, or should I be taking my
- 1:46own work to try and finish these projects off again before the apocalypse comes to
- 1:52claim me in the cabin. And I'm not a designer myself, but I've
- 1:57spoken to many designers and often they will have multiple projects on the go.
- 2:01Are you one of those two? Yes? I usually have you know,
- 2:06four, five or so you know on the cook At the same time,
- 2:10I don't have a lot of work where I've started it and then just abandoned
- 2:15it. Some designers are like that. I try and do my best to
- 2:20get things as thoroughly worked out as they possibly could, and I may come
- 2:23back to something later you know, later later on, but I'm usually working
- 2:29with you know, a few things at the same time. It depends on
- 2:31the surges of inspiration too. I think I've been you know, pretty productive
- 2:37the last couple of years, um, you know, with a turning out
- 2:39a number of games, but they're ones that I just haven't quite gotten to
- 2:44the point where I want to release them just yet. But they are fairly
- 2:49worked out ideas, so I'm pleased. And to a degree of these games
- 2:53reiterations of other systems or you know, completely original ideas of your own.
- 3:00Well, some are and some aren't. I have probably about sixty published wargame
- 3:07designs so far, and about half of them belong to one or another of
- 3:14a sort of five or six families or systems like game systems that I've developed.
- 3:20So within these families, there'd be anywhere from like four to eight or
- 3:24nine games that follow the same general rules framework, although there will be a
- 3:31lot of adaptation, you know, to adapt it to the particular conflict you
- 3:36know, or emphasis that I want to give it. And that's about half
- 3:39of it, and the other half are things that are our systems that I've
- 3:46I've never used before. And might never use again. So they're real one
- 3:50offs, although I will take aspects of that, I like, you know,
- 3:53from one or another these designs and incorporate them into other work that comes
- 3:57later. And there are a few examples of games where I've collaborated with people
- 4:01and we've kind of worked out the system together, or it's been adapted from
- 4:05a system that someone else invented. I have a few cases of those.
- 4:09And then sometimes I will run across a particular concept in someone else's game,
- 4:15uh, you know, like the like the hidden trader kind of concept,
- 4:18or the endless tern mechanism that you can find, and I think that's a
- 4:25really interesting idea, and then I just do a riff of my own off
- 4:28that basic idea. And to degree is game design standing on the shoulders of
- 4:32giants, It definitely is. I'm certainly crouching on the shoulders of giants.
- 4:43This is uh, you know. Board war gaming is a niche of a
- 4:48niche of a niche. It kind of peaked in popularity in the early eighties,
- 4:55and then the kind of people who are playing those games in the during
- 5:00the eighties, they grew up, got out of school, they started having
- 5:02kids, and careers and things, and at the same time, personal computers
- 5:08came along and kind of removed the necessity in order to play these games with
- 5:13people. And it was a little while yet before desktop publishing came along,
- 5:17so there was a bit of a gap before people were able to start making
- 5:20them, making their own versions for themselves, which started to emerge in the
- 5:25nineties. So it kind of peaked then, but it didn't die because the
- 5:30Internet as it came along again, put these like minded people back in touch
- 5:34with each other and they started to trade games and ideas with each other.
- 5:40And then, of course the last twenty years they've seen a real renaissance a
- 5:44board game playing generally in North American society at well, the beginning of course
- 5:49in Europe, but then it made its way over to America in Canada,
- 5:54where you know, something like board game cafes, for example. I don't
- 5:59know how old they are, how lone they've been in Europe, but ten
- 6:03years ago they almost didn't exist in Canada or North America, but now they're
- 6:10fairly common. So let's go back to the beginning then, So you were
- 6:12born in Canada, and Canadians have a reputation for being incredibly nice. How
- 6:18true do you think that is? Well, I suppose nice is a relative
- 6:23term when you come to think about it. I think that Canadians are generally
- 6:28polite and courteous to outsiders. And you know, you told me that you
- 6:30have been to Canada, so you've seen it in action. But I also
- 6:35think difficulties might arise when we encounter people who think that being nice and polite
- 6:40are signs of weakness or stupidity, and we can be considerably less pleasant and
- 6:45accommodating when this happens. I was looking you asked me these questions, and
- 6:49a few years I looked up a quote that I found a few years ago
- 6:54from a Canadian writing in The Guardian about the Canadian character, and she said,
- 7:00quote, if a nation of millions can have a collective character, then
- 7:02it is true what is said about Canadians. We are a stoic, rule
- 7:06abiding and polite people. We're also smug, passive, aggressive and proud.
- 7:12So if you like your maple syrup blaced with pists, we'll deliver cans of
- 7:15the stuff heated with quaint winter scenes sold at a mark up with a smile.
- 7:19I had to laugh at that. Now I don't think we arrived at
- 7:23this collective character strictly in opposition to whatever condensed description you might want to use
- 7:28the American collective character, even though a common joke is high I'm a Canadian,
- 7:32I like an American, but without the guns. I mean, at
- 7:36one time in our early history, a large portion of the Canadian population was
- 7:41transplanted Americans. A lot of political refugees. These are displaced loyalists after the
- 7:46Revolutionary War, some freed slaves, and then in the twentieth century of very
- 7:50few draft dodgers or else more often they were economic adventures. So there are
- 7:57homesteaders who are looking to get some land and props on the prairies, people
- 8:01who came up for the Klondike gold Rush, or to seek their fortune trapping,
- 8:05that kind of thing. So from time to time, you know,
- 8:07considerable portion of the Canadian population has been made up of first or second generation
- 8:13transplanted Americans. But you know, within Canada this has never been a serious
- 8:16contention. Even in the War of eighteen twelve. You know, when the
- 8:20United States actually invaded Canada, the Americans who were living in Canada that the
- 8:26Americans had entered did not rise up and help the invaders, which is what
- 8:31some of them expected to happen. So they had transferred their loyalties, you
- 8:35know, pretty thoroughly to Canada, or at least away from America. And
- 8:39it's funny, you know, we have a lot of common points in our
- 8:41history, you know, all wide open frontier to the west that required suppressing
- 8:46you know, the indigenous people, and so there's there's that. But in
- 8:50the end, you know, the the Americans fought a violent revolution revolution,
- 8:56they fought a revolutionary war to get their independence from Britain. But we got
- 9:00our independence from Britain one hundred and fifty years ago, not through a violent,
- 9:03drawn out war that polarized and antagonized the population. But essentially it was
- 9:07because we were costing too much. We weren't giving good return on investment,
- 9:13and we were costing too much in terms of money and troops to garrison.
- 9:16So it was just too unjustified of an imperial expense to garrison and exploit the
- 9:22country anymore. So they just let us go. Anyway, we could go
- 9:26on like this, but let's not. So you served in the Canadian Armed
- 9:31Forces? What led you there? What was the experience? Like, well,
- 9:35I was in the militia, which is like the British Territorial Army.
- 9:39For nine years in the eighties, I was in the infantry, and I
- 9:43was a corporal before I became an officer, and as an officer, I
- 9:48still served several years of full time service in staff positions, including being adjutant
- 9:52of an infantry battalion, which is a very interesting experience. I joined because,
- 9:58of course I had always been interested in the military, and my feeling
- 10:01then and my feeling now that public service of any kind is an important component
- 10:05of being a full citizen of your country and being a full contributor to the
- 10:11society. However, I wasn't the armed forces. But I do not call
- 10:16myself a veteran, because again, this was in the eighties and my service
- 10:20was all in peace time. So I sometimes I when I'm joking, I
- 10:26call myself a cold war and actor. From time to time. I was
- 10:30variously cold, wet, tired, or hungry while I was in uniform,
- 10:33but nobody ever shot at me except with blank rounds. So that's why I
- 10:39don't call myself a veteran. I will say, though, that my time
- 10:41in the military gave me a deep appreciation for the effects of chaos, the
- 10:46order counter order, disorder process, the misdirection, the wastage and frustration of
- 10:52effort and time and resources, the many ways in which command control can be
- 10:56misapplied, misunderstood, or ignored, the unpredictability of effects first and second order
- 11:01of anything you do. In short, all the things that are wrapped up
- 11:05in the word friction, you know as close as it's used it. And
- 11:09I think this is a common reaction for people who have lived in the military,
- 11:13for that matter, in any large organization, and in my games,
- 11:18I think it's translated into a healthy respect and a reflection for random events,
- 11:22nonlinear results, and just the way friction effects plans, and just the way,
- 11:28excuse me, plans can fall apart, so that I think that's been
- 11:35one of the lasting effects of my service. And how did games enter your
- 11:41life? Well? I got into war gaming in the late nineteen seventies when
- 11:46I was about fifteen or sixteen years old. Before that, I played much
- 11:50the same games as other kids, but I like the military theme ones,
- 11:52I like risk, I like chess, that kind of thing. The first
- 11:56war game I ever saw was World War three by SPI at my friend's house.
- 12:01It belonged to his elder brother. It had a lot of it featured
- 12:05a map of the whole world, and it had a lot of mushroom cloud
- 12:09character counters in the countermix, So I found that fascinating. The first war
- 12:16game that I actually owned was in nineteen seventy eight. I was fifteen years
- 12:18old, and my favorite uncle sent me a copy of Tactics Too for Christmas,
- 12:24which is an introductory war game that the company had made available for a
- 12:28long time. And there was I was off and I don't think my parents
- 12:31ever forgave him for it. Yeah, as you know, Victoria is a
- 12:35fairly small city and at the time, there was essentially only one store that
- 12:41sold war games or anything like it. And I had very little pocket money
- 12:46to buy what was their artists, and I had no money to send away
- 12:48for other games. So my early purchases of war games were whatever I could
- 12:52afford or trade for, so, you know, used games and that sort
- 12:58of thing. The was one type of game that was being published by a
- 13:03company called Mada Gaming at the time, and they produced these things they were
- 13:07called microgames, and they came in a small plastic baggy and they were generally
- 13:13science fiction or fantasy type games. And they came with a very short rule
- 13:18book and a small map and a sheet of thin card a card strip cut
- 13:28counters that you had to cut out yourself, and very cheap, very cheaply
- 13:33made, very cheap to buy, but some interesting design problems in the ideas.
- 13:37And I really like that kind of a sort of bare bones, cheap
- 13:41esthetic approach that nevertheless still contained a quality game an interesting problem inside it.
- 13:48And I still like that approach forty years down the road, and I think
- 13:52I have that reflected in about a quarter of all the games that I have
- 13:56are slightly more than a quarter of all the games I've done are available through
- 14:00what we call print and play, where someone will download the files and as
- 14:05PDFs generally, and print them out themselves. So stick your own counters,
- 14:11piece together, your own map. But hopefully it's an interesting idea that will
- 14:15within the game, that will compel you to go to that little bit of
- 14:18work by yourself. So your first game then is Go. How opaque is
- 14:24this game? I don't remember just when I got interested in Go. It
- 14:31was likely in the late eighties, soon before I went to Japan. I'd
- 14:37read about it of course, but I never really learned how to play until
- 14:39I think fairly shortly before I left. And there, of course, in
- 14:43Japan, I had plenty of opportunity to play, but I always got crushed,
- 14:46especially by twelve year old boys at the schools that I was working at,
- 14:50you know, because they've been playing for a long time. You know,
- 14:52Go, She'll be that kind of thing. I still enjoy Go very
- 14:56much, even though I don't play any better than I ever did. I
- 15:01like it because it's so different. It's got an empty board that fills up
- 15:05during play. The pieces are not differentiated at all. They're just black or
- 15:11white. It's a game that moves without any actual movement because you don't move
- 15:18any of the pieces. You put them down and sometimes you take them up.
- 15:20And the requirement for each move in a game of Go to do at
- 15:26least two jobs. It has to be both an attacking stone and a defending
- 15:30stone. And above all, the aura of psychological threats and promises that you
- 15:37are that is behind every well made move during the game. That's I think
- 15:43that's why I like the game because it's not generally linear. It's linear in
- 15:46short segments, but as a whole, the approach or the game is nonlinear
- 15:50and it's very psychological in its form. Chess in its way, I think,
- 15:56is very linear and formulaic and of course susceptible to brute force computer analysis.
- 16:03That's why computers are good at chess, and it's only lately, very
- 16:07lately, that they have become good at all at goal. But that is
- 16:11a fairly recent you know, like computers, they were used. They used
- 16:15computers to crack chess a long time ago, but they're only just getting to
- 16:18the point now of computing power and AI and learning techniques that they've used to
- 16:26crack Go. And so a game like Go it seemingly the opposite of the
- 16:32kind of games you design. Can someone who designs games like you draw anything
- 16:37from the design of Go and bring it into the field that you work in?
- 16:42Oh? I think so definitely. Again I mentioned the non linear character
- 16:47of the game, Uh, the idea that you can, you know,
- 16:52simply appear in the enemy's rear. I think that there are definite um there
- 17:00are definite things that you can draw from Go and try. And because Go
- 17:06was originally created as a model sort of a metaphor for training for war,
- 17:11and it's about the nonlinearity of conflict and about working around flanks and the surprise
- 17:18move, and above all its psychological character, the imply threat behind every move.
- 17:22I like that, and I try to put that kind of quality into
- 17:26my games as much as I can. It's not really a literal translation,
- 17:33although I do. I have designed a couple of semi abstract games that aren't
- 17:37as simple as Go. One as Guerilla Checkers, which we'll be talking about
- 17:41in a little while, which I think that's maybe the most direct inspiration that
- 17:47I've had from Go. But again, the idea of nonlinear results, random
- 17:53events, surprise, you know, that sort of thing I find. I
- 17:59see those and Go. I see those as good qualities of any game,
- 18:03really, and I like to put that into my game designs. And not
- 18:07only that. I bring my goboard to the cabin because it has a large
- 18:12nineteen by nineteen grid on the map. So the board and stones are the
- 18:18root for a whole family of very intelligent, abstract games that other people have
- 18:22made. Um there's a very clever geek list on board game Geek that uses
- 18:26the Go board as a game system. So I could take this thing to
- 18:30the cabin. There's a lot of other games I could play on that board
- 18:33besides goal. So I want to talk now about your life outside of games.
- 18:37So you were one of the last people to be denied entry into East
- 18:41Berlin, and as I'm currently sitting in East Berlin, I find that fascinating.
- 18:45What's the story behind that. Yeah, I was surprised to hear that
- 18:51you that you're living in Berlin. Now, Well, the story about that
- 18:55is that back in the eighties, uh, you know, before I got
- 18:59into designing games and stuff like that, I was into something called mail art
- 19:03or correspondence art. And this really doesn't There's not so much of this going
- 19:08on nowadays because postage has become very expensive and a lot of of sort of
- 19:15I guess personal artists moved on to the Internet. But back then there was
- 19:18this. There were these networks of people who traded self made art in the
- 19:25forms of you know, collages, postcards, drawings, all kinds of things
- 19:30and just sent them back and forth to each other. There was sort of
- 19:34like an underground network of cassettes, you know, like cassettes and tapes of
- 19:41people making their own music, you know, and passing them along as well.
- 19:44So these kind of networks kind of existed in parallel and I got into
- 19:48correspondence art and I started corresponding with a number of people in different countries,
- 19:52and one of them was a guy excuse me, who lived in Berlin.
- 19:57And after a few years of corresponding back and forth, he came out and
- 20:02visited me in Victoria, and a year or two later I went back and
- 20:07visited him in Berlin. And I went over in nineteen eighty eight and nineteen
- 20:11eighty nine, and in eighty eight visited and we had took a day trip
- 20:15over into East Berlin, which I found really interesting obviously, and you know,
- 20:22when I went back to visit him again the following year in nineteen eighty
- 20:25nine, I wanted to go over again for a day trip and see what
- 20:27was going on. And the day that we chose to go over was October
- 20:32sixth, which is East Germany's national day. It's their day of their founding
- 20:36as a country, and they have a big military parade. It's public holiday,
- 20:40everyone's walking around. Gorbachev was supposed to be in town, you know,
- 20:45to see the parade and that kind of thing, so we thought we
- 20:48would go over for that day. And what we didn't know though, was
- 20:52that a couple of days prior, these anti government protests in Leipzig had gotten
- 20:56out of hand and the government tried to put them down with the city police,
- 21:03and the city police refused to break the riots, so they trucked in
- 21:06a bunch of factory militia from outside of town and used them to break the
- 21:10riots. And of course no one knew that this kind of thing was happening,
- 21:15or at least no one I was talking to. So at the time,
- 21:18you know, there were a lot of East Germans piling over the walls
- 21:22of embassies and things like that, asking for refuge, but we didn't think
- 21:29that was going to get them out to anything. But this was really starting
- 21:34to frighten the East German government to the point where they thought, oh god,
- 21:37we don't want things to get out of hand in Berlin on this day,
- 21:41because you know, back in nineteen fifty three there had been these anti
- 21:44government riots in Berlin that were put down quite violently, and they didn't want
- 21:48to go through that again and have all of that happened, of course in
- 21:51front of Gorbachev, so they said, okay, find no one from the
- 21:53West gets in on that day. And we didn't know that, of course.
- 21:57So we got on the train. There's an elevated train that took you
- 22:02into Friedrichstrassa about a mile inside East Berlin, so we didn't have to cross
- 22:07a checkpoint Charlie or whatever, and then you go through the passport control.
- 22:14So we did that and we got off at the platform at Tredi Strasa and
- 22:18the first thing I noticed was there's twice as many guards as there had been
- 22:21a previous year, and they had big dogs and everything. And this big
- 22:23fat border guard came over and stuck out his hand passport and we handed over
- 22:30our passports and he said kannadish and said, yeah, kannadish. And I
- 22:36was traveling with a couple of Americans friends at the time too, yeas he
- 22:38seen Americana. And then he just passed, shoved our passports back, kind
- 22:42of race no entry. So I wasn't going to argue with him, and
- 22:49so we stood around on the platform for you know, about fifteen minutes,
- 22:53and you said, no place else to go, and we got back on
- 22:56the train and went back into West Berlin. I think we went to the
- 22:59big open air flea market. I don't know if they still have them in
- 23:03Berlin. That's how we spent the rest of the day. But it wasn't
- 23:07until and I had to leave Berlin go back to Canada a couple of days
- 23:10later, so I had no chance to try again. And then three weeks
- 23:14later the wall came down. And so that was my story of how I
- 23:18was one of the last people to be kept out of East Berlin. The
- 23:21timing was almost perfect. I just missed the freight train of history exactly.
- 23:26So you also participated in the JET program. What was that experience like and
- 23:30how did it shoop you? I suppose I should explain what the JET program
- 23:36is. Perhaps the JET stands for Japan Exchange and Training Program, and this
- 23:41is a program that was started in the I guess the mid eighties or the
- 23:48late eighties. Who was four or five years old when I joined it in
- 23:53the army. I found that I liked teaching recruits, and I had thought
- 23:56about becoming a school teacher from my career, but I wanted to try teaching
- 24:02first, like actually teaching in a classroom without going back to school for a
- 24:06teaching degree. So in nineteen ninety I joined this program which was run it
- 24:12was kind of jointly run by the Japanese National Ministry of Education in their Ministry
- 24:17of Foreign Affairs, and I was assigned to work for the Board of Education
- 24:22of Kutamatsu City in Yamagushi Prefecture. This is a small city actually about the
- 24:26same size as Victoria, at the south end of the main island Honshu.
- 24:32And I worked in middle schools, which is grade seven to nine, so
- 24:34the kids were like twelve to fifteen years old, as what they called an
- 24:38assistant language teacher, and what I did was team teaching with Japanese teachers of
- 24:44English. So the usual Japanese teacher for the English class would be there and
- 24:49I would join him or her for the day and we would do a lesson.
- 24:52And I rotated amongst several schools that they had in the district. But
- 25:00I worked for the Board of Education, and I would just I would go
- 25:02where they sent me, and once in a while I would do other some
- 25:04kind of you know internationalization thing, you know, like sometimes public speaking,
- 25:11or I got to do the voice over the English language voice or for a
- 25:14promotional video they did about the city, you know that kind of thing.
- 25:18I stayed until nineteen ninety two, so I served two years there. I
- 25:22enjoyed myself. I liked living in Japan, but I found that I didn't
- 25:26like the idea of being a school teacher. I was often working with teachers
- 25:30who had been teaching longer than I'd been alive, and I realized in the
- 25:34end it was it's the students who are the lucky ones because they get to
- 25:37graduate and leave. So that was enough. You know. Again, I
- 25:45kind of enjoyed the work, but it wasn't the sort of thing that I
- 25:47wanted to do for a career. So I came back to Canada in nineteen
- 25:51ninety two. You want to work as a policy analyst for the Ministry of
- 25:53Health. What challenges that present? Yes, Well, when I came back
- 25:57in nineteen ninety two, I was looking around, of course, for the
- 26:02next big thing, and I did start work as a policy analyst in what
- 26:06was then called the Aboriginal Health Policy Branch of my province's Ministry of Health.
- 26:11I didn't analyze any policy though, that was just the job title. I
- 26:17did what jobs I was given to do, and in the end it involved
- 26:22contract management, writing contracts, managing contracts and projects, doing research, a
- 26:29lot of writing, budget modeling and budget control. You know, I had
- 26:33control of a fairly large budget. That kind of thing I was just kind
- 26:36of trying to I was kind of learning all these things on the fly,
- 26:40really, and it was it was an interesting and valuable introduction to work.
- 26:48But the workplace. The workplace wasn't especially good. The problem that we were
- 26:56the problems that we were working on were pretty much insoluble, I think without
- 27:02a major reordering of well a major rework of history and some very fundamental social
- 27:10and economic changes in our society. So it was a problem that would never
- 27:14really be solved. And the Ministry of Health breaucratically didn't have a very good
- 27:19culture, not a very efficient place, and it wasn't really the kind of
- 27:25thing that it wasn't really the kind of public sector problem that I really wanted
- 27:30to work on. I liked education, and I really did want to work
- 27:34not an education itself, not as a school teacher, but let's say adjacent
- 27:37education. And so after about four years in the Ministry of Health, I
- 27:44moved over to the Ministry of Advanced Education as what they call an education officer,
- 27:48and I've been there ever since, for the last twenty five years,
- 27:52and I do a lot of research and writing and much of my job is
- 27:56taken up with co op education program and other forms of work integrated learning.
- 28:03I like the subject matter. Almost everybody looks on education as a desirable public
- 28:07good, and the people I work with and the ministry culture is very good,
- 28:10So all in all, I've been pretty happy. And best of all,
- 28:12when I got this job at Advanced Education, I was told it was
- 28:17partly because of the accuracy and conciseness of my writing, just the general quality
- 28:21of my writing, And frankly, I put that down to having had already
- 28:26having had four or five years of discipline learning to write game rules, which
- 28:30I think you'll agree is a very exacting form of technical writing. So war
- 28:36games help me to get where I am today. I'm very happy about that.
- 28:40And one of the pros and cons of working in the public sector.
- 28:44And have you ever been tempted to go into the private sector where the money
- 28:48is My work in the public sector is normally a lot more pro than con
- 28:53I'm I'm really proud to be a public servant. Maybe that sounds a little
- 28:57corny to some people, but to me, it means helping people with their
- 29:03problems and helping to make society run more smoothly, or at least not get
- 29:07any worse. Some days are like that. And with respect to education,
- 29:12you know, this is all working to help people to fulfill their ambitions and
- 29:15their dreams, and to help them with any problems they encounter on the way
- 29:19of doing that. The cons of course come when I run up against the
- 29:23limitations of my job. I work in a hierarchical organization where people above me
- 29:30sometimes have a different ideas, or they have a different framework of frame of
- 29:34reference or sense of priorities than I do of what's important or urgent. And
- 29:41often some of the problems to society that government tries to fix never really seem
- 29:47to get fixed. And you know that was why I left the Ministry of
- 29:48Health. But you know it would probably these these sort of internal to the
- 29:53organization frustrations would be largely the same if I worked in the private sector.
- 29:59I think, um, and you know it's it's I suppose in some respects,
- 30:04you know, I could be pulling down more money as a consultant or
- 30:07something like that in the private sector. But honestly, I enjoy, you
- 30:12know what, I enjoy what I'm doing where I am um, I have
- 30:17a few more years before I retire. But I'm really not contemplating, you
- 30:22know, I've never really contemplated a life in the private sector. So your
- 30:26next game, then, you've already mentioned it. It's Guerrilla Checkers. Why
- 30:30are you taking this one to the cabin? Mhmm. Guerrilla Checkers is,
- 30:37and I'm just for the listeners. That's that's guerrilla, as in Fighters in
- 30:41the Jungle as opposed to great Apes in the Jungle. Yeah, and I
- 30:48don't know what they would be using for playing pieces either out in the jungle.
- 30:53Um. Yeah. I was joking with a British friend of mine once
- 30:56and said maybe I should rename it Partisan Drafts, you know, in order
- 31:02to so there'd be no mistake. Guerrilla Checkers is. It's the simplest game
- 31:08I've ever designed, with the shortest rules, but it's the one that I'm
- 31:14most proud of. Actually. It's a simple idea and encapsulates a great deal.
- 31:18I think of these kind of the atmosphere of asymmetric warfare, of asymmetry
- 31:23in games, which is kind of what I'm interested in and what I'm trying
- 31:26to get at in a lot of my game designs. I really wish that
- 31:30I had this sort of simple idea more often, but simple ideas are surprisingly
- 31:36hard to find. How the game about came about was I had been working
- 31:41with some other people on a game about Afghanistan, and in the middle of
- 31:45the night, about twelve or thirteen years ago, I was staring at the
- 31:49ceiling, you know, the way middle aged men do, and I was
- 31:53instead of thinking about the roof leaking or how bad a person I've been in
- 31:56my life, I was instead thinking about this game we were working on in
- 32:01Afghanistan, and about how in Afghanistan, the insurgents and the counterinsurgents there they
- 32:08both occupy the same section of the world at the same time, but they
- 32:13approached the physical terrain, you know, ridges and gullies and roads, and
- 32:16the human terrain of villages, tribes, historical relationships in completely different ways from
- 32:22each other. So why not have an abstract game where the two sides are
- 32:28playing with very different pieces, working in very different ways, but they're using
- 32:31the same board with the same ultimate aim of neutralizing the enemy, albeit in
- 32:37different ways. And so I just got this idea in my game, you
- 32:43know, it just popped into my head and I got up. It was
- 32:45like by that time it was like five o'clock in the morning. I got
- 32:49up, got out of checkerboard and some pieces, and I started started playing
- 32:53it out. And so there are many variants on classic abstract games. What
- 32:59makes this one unique? Do you think it's interesting? Because it actually isn't
- 33:04a variation on a classic abstract game. It's like a remix of checkers and
- 33:09goal. So the insurgent, or rather the counterinsurgent player has six pieces that
- 33:16move like kings in checkers, so they move by sliding or by the capture
- 33:23by jumping. But the other side, the insurgent, they have sixty six
- 33:29small pieces that don't move. This is the goal part, because they're placed
- 33:32on the points of the squares within on the checkerboard, and they're used to
- 33:39surround the larger pieces the checkers and kill them, whereas the counterinsurgents they capture
- 33:47the insurgents by simply jumping over the point in between the two squares. So
- 33:52it's a mashup of checkers and go. And when I first thought of this,
- 33:57I thought someone must have thought of this before. I ran through every
- 34:00online director or catalog of abstract games I could find, because I was sure
- 34:05someone must have invented this, but I never found proof of this, which
- 34:07seems you know, still it seems to be the the essence of asymmetric warfare.
- 34:13There are asymmetric um, classic abstract games out there like nfatafo or Fox
- 34:20and Geese uh and other games like that. UM. And yet you know,
- 34:25if you look at these games, they're completely different from guerrilla checkers.
- 34:30But again you know, they're asymmetric games, uh, strategy games. UM.
- 34:35And this is what I was looking for, was it was asymmetry,
- 34:38and so you don't, I haven't found anything else like it, So I
- 34:42guess I might have been the first. You know, one day, probably
- 34:45I'll find out that someone else thought of it, like forty years ago.
- 34:49UM. And of course you know, when I the actual rules to the
- 34:53game are are very short, but when I give out copies of this game,
- 34:59I include a few hints on play, and they're tricked out with quotes
- 35:01from chairman now writing on guerrilla Warfare. And so you've already mentioned this in
- 35:07connection with GO. But to all extent, are games a good analog for
- 35:14real conflict? I mean, can you can can generals learn about potential future
- 35:23conflict by playing games like this? I really think they can. Games are
- 35:32about conflict and competition generally, or classic games are at any event, And
- 35:37I mentioned about Go being invented as a model for warfare and chess. Of
- 35:44course, all the different variations of chess over the years are about the different
- 35:49grades of leaders and warriors, you know, in society at the time,
- 35:54and the rules are kind of in a sense, they're somewhat reflective of the
- 36:00society at the time as well. So chess has a lot of variations like
- 36:05that and has had a lot of variations over the years. Hanef tafel I
- 36:09mentioned, you know, that's all about guarding the king and bringing the king
- 36:15to safety, or protecting the king against a mob of enemies. So these
- 36:17are all analogs for real conflicts that happened at the time. Of course,
- 36:23it's very, very heavily abstracted. There's a book that was written back in
- 36:30nineteen sixty nine by an American academic called The Protracted Game, and it was
- 36:36his attempt to link GO to ideas of Maoist revolutionary warfare, and going back
- 36:44even further, Life Magazine did a piece in nineteen forty two on Go and
- 36:50trying to link that to Japanese strategy in the Pacific, because at this time
- 36:54the Japanese Empire was leaping and bounding all over the Pacific, you know,
- 36:59before it was being backed by the Americans. So this was these were very
- 37:06conscious efforts on the part of these these writers to mirror what was happening in
- 37:12the world and trying to model it or trying to relate it to the game,
- 37:17and of course to try and relate what was going on back to the
- 37:22culture of the people who were doing that at the time, because of course
- 37:28Go is originally a Chinese game that came to Japan later on, but they're
- 37:31both both games are very ingrained in Chinese and Japanese culture, and so they're
- 37:38trying to I guess it's not really an essentialist argument, but trying to say
- 37:44that there's something in uh, you know, in Chinese or Japanese culture that
- 37:50suits their thoughts, which means their strategy to what is actually going on.
- 37:57I mean, these are need illustrations, but to me, they're just an
- 38:00illustration of how far you can stretch metaphor before it snaps. I think though,
- 38:06that there is a real value not just for military officers but for people
- 38:12generally to play these kinds of deep abstract games. I was asked a while
- 38:17back to talk to some officers and students at the US Army War College in
- 38:22Pennsylvania a couple of years ago on the value of simple games, and you
- 38:29know, even abstract games. They don't have to be detailed war games,
- 38:31but just the value of simple abstract games as a way of breaking mental moles
- 38:38and channels and rots that people find themselves into and just helping with their mental
- 38:44flexibility, their plasticity seeing things from a different point of view again, you
- 38:51know, asymmetry between things because you know, while you may be a military
- 38:55officer, you realize one first things you realize is there's ever a fair fight.
- 39:00In fact, you don't want a fair fight. You want to go
- 39:04in with every advantage that you have and every disadvantage that can be inflicted on
- 39:08the enemy. So there needs to be, you know, definite asymmetry.
- 39:15I mean, as far as the civilian market goes, things have to be
- 39:17competitive and you know, and entertaining for the punter. But you know,
- 39:21for the professional military officer, it's a point of keeping their mind open and
- 39:30being able to work in many many on many levels, and in hopefully in
- 39:35unexpected ways. So I think that there's a lot of value in games like
- 39:39Guerrilla Checkers. Uh, you know Nffatafel. There's someone I know who's on
- 39:45faculty at that war college I mentioned who really likes the value of Nftaffel as
- 39:50a tool for training intelligence analysts. And of course you know there are some
- 39:53game designers. Earlier we were talking about Mark Herman and of Okarunka, who
- 39:59work you know in this general field, and they see the value of using
- 40:04games for this kind of thing. Often the simpler the better, but you
- 40:08know, detail is do where it can be useful. So I want to
- 40:13go on there and talk about your workers, designer, So when did you
- 40:15decide that you wanted to make games as well as play them? Well,
- 40:21as I said, I started to play war games in the late seventies.
- 40:22And after I had started playing them for a couple of years and I under
- 40:27started to understand what went into a game design, and I wanted to play
- 40:32more and more different games. I found it was very hard to find games
- 40:37on subjects that I was personally interested in and wanted to play, and that
- 40:42was mostly because these games had not even been designed. I was interested in
- 40:46the Vietnam War, for example. I was interested in contemporary conflicts, and
- 40:51at the time, there were few to know games on the Vietnam War because
- 40:58at this time it was like the American people kind of didn't want to remember,
- 41:04you know, having gone through this war. So there was a bit
- 41:07of you know, a bit of amnesia, I guess social amnesia about that,
- 41:12or at least it was it was. It wasn't encouraged um So I
- 41:17wanted to, you know, I wanted to play these things on topics that
- 41:21I found interesting. So I began to think, you know, of making
- 41:25the thing that I wanted to see in the world. And my first efforts
- 41:29were really primitive. Honestly, there were maps with hand drawn hexes because it
- 41:32didn't even have access to a photocopier. I didn't get you know, I
- 41:37was years away from the first personal computer I ever got. Um counters made
- 41:43from shirt cardboard, you know, typewritten rules, that kind of thing,
- 41:46And that was my very very first finished effort. That was in nineteen eighty
- 41:51two. It was a somewhat derivative game on the Pusan Perimeter campaign in Korea
- 41:54nineteen fifty when the UN forces were crammed down in small corner of the Korean
- 42:00Peninsula. There's only one coffee of this game, of course, because everything
- 42:05about it was handmade, with rules typed on a manual typewriter. I didn't
- 42:08even have carbon paper, so it still less access to a photocopier. That
- 42:15is, of any of your listeners remember what carbon paper was. Anyway,
- 42:17I think I might still have the thing around somewhere, but you know,
- 42:21that's from forty years ago, and that's my first finish design. However,
- 42:23it wasn't until a few years later in nineteen ninety when I was in Japan
- 42:29and most of my collection was on the other side of the ocean, because
- 42:32it came to Japan with you know, a duffel bag and a small you
- 42:37know, haversack, you know, for whatever I could could take with me.
- 42:43So again I had a bit of time. I had a little bit
- 42:45of space. So again I wanted to play games because for once in my
- 42:50life had I had a bit of time and space. But there were no
- 42:52games available. So the first complete game that I designed that I think was
- 43:00you know where I made more than one copy of, or couldn't make more
- 43:01than one copy of, was in Japan, and one night I used to
- 43:07go to the video store down the street, and one night I rented a
- 43:09movie from the video place, and it was called Powerplay. It was an
- 43:13action movie that had been made in nineteen seventy eight, and it starred Peter
- 43:16O'Toole and David Hemmings and Donald Pleasants as army officers and secret policemen who are
- 43:23plotting or four and against a coup data in an imaginary country. And this
- 43:29is about how they old betray each other. So I found this interesting because
- 43:32I'd always been interested in the coup coup data from the time I was in
- 43:37high school and had read a book about it, and I was inspired to
- 43:40make a game version of this movie. And it's a very short game.
- 43:45It has about forty or fifty counters place in less than one hour to cover
- 43:47both the planning and execution phases of a coup. Unfortunately, the title I
- 43:52picked was also Powerplay. I'm really bad at picking titles. I can design
- 43:58these things, but I can't catchy names for them generally. But that was,
- 44:04you know, my first completed design. I did a thorough redesign of
- 44:07it a bit later that I renamed it was such a thorough redesign. Its
- 44:12essentially a new game, and I called it Palace Coup, which is maybe
- 44:15what I should have done at the beginning, and it's one of it's an
- 44:20example of one of the games I have available now for print and play.
- 44:24You know, there are certain games I have that aren't really commercially salable,
- 44:29that don't have enough numbers, but I want to make them available to people
- 44:32so they can get this for not very much money or for free. That
- 44:37was the first game I ever designed. I designed too while I was in
- 44:39Japan. The second one was called Civil Power, which is a tactical team
- 44:45about making and breaking urban riots. Again, I was interested in this aspect
- 44:50of police and military operations during my time in the Army, where it's called
- 44:53aid of the Civil Power. But the game design was inspired by an external
- 44:59event, so I mentioned. I had few games to play when I was
- 45:02living in Japan. I also had very few English language books to read,
- 45:07so I would send away from aig to get books from a used bookstore in
- 45:12Tokyo that had a big selection of English language books, and their catalog included
- 45:17The Great Shark Hunt, which is a collection of articles by Hunter s Thompson,
- 45:22And the piece I liked best in the book was a piece that Thompson
- 45:25wrote called the Police Chief, and he signed it as his author surrogate personality
- 45:30Raoul Duke, Master of Weapons. And in the piece, Duke is raging
- 45:37in really violent language about the inadequacy of equipment in the police armory to deal
- 45:40with protesters and hippies and civil disorder. So I was inspired by the spirit
- 45:45of gonzo journalism, and I thought, why not design something about riots,
- 45:51because at this time there was like nothing out there as far as I knew,
- 45:55in the way of war games on the subject of riots. So the
- 46:00original version of this game was completed in nineteen ninety two, and the list
- 46:04of scenarios had things like Chicago nineteen sixty eight, a Belfast scenario, that
- 46:09sort of thing. The historical examples were obvious, of course, Paris nineteen
- 46:15sixty eight, that kind of thing, but the last. But I also
- 46:20put in lots of scenarios that were drawn from headlines in the English language newspaper
- 46:23I subscribed to in Japan. So I would read a story in the newspaper,
- 46:28you know, about a student riot and soul or a confrontation with Neo
- 46:31Nazis in Pretoria or the Rodney King riots, you know, in nineteen ninety
- 46:37two in Los Angeles. So I would read a story about this and I
- 46:39would come up with a game scenario for it, in this Civil Power,
- 46:44And this was the beginning I think of my idea, and I hope we'll
- 46:47be able to talk about this later, about game design as a form of
- 46:52citizen journalism. And people can still do this with the game today, because
- 46:58Civil Power was designed in the get go as what we call a sandbox game,
- 47:04something with fairly generic elements, where people are able and encouraged to come
- 47:08up with their own kind of scenarios and settings for things to play, you
- 47:13know, to take the pieces and play out new games and new scenarios by
- 47:16themselves. And so that was in Japan. After I came back to Canada,
- 47:23I designed a few more games from nineteen ninety three to nineteen ninety six,
- 47:28and they were on topics like the Tupamarow urban guerrillas in Uruguay, the
- 47:32Shining Path or the Sendero Luminoso guerrillas in Peru, and the UN intervention in
- 47:37Somalia. This is the early nineties, so these are all topics about counterinsurgency
- 47:43and irregular warfare. So I was already kind of getting into getting into that
- 47:49idea. How difficult was it for you to get your designs published? And
- 47:53I mean, as a general rule, do you think the war game arena
- 48:00is easier to approach the people who would publish your game than the greater board
- 48:05game arena or is there no difference. I think there's a great difference,
- 48:08because, as they said earlier, board war gaming is a niche of a
- 48:12niche of a niche. The best selling war games of all time, at
- 48:17least of recent history, you know, because I said that, you know,
- 48:21the sort of hobby of detail, really detailed board war games kind of
- 48:25peaked in the early eighties, so it's still chugging along, but numbers are
- 48:30very, very reduced from what they were before. So what you would call
- 48:36like a real classic kind of conventional war game, they have press runs of
- 48:40just a few thousand, uh, you know, even some of the most
- 48:44popular designs that I've had, you know, like a Distant Plane for example,
- 48:50from GMT, I don't believe there are more than maybe ten or twelve
- 48:53thousand copies out there, and eurogames that have any kind of traction at all.
- 49:00Uh. They you know, they they they're printed in numbers far far
- 49:05larger than that. Um and of course all of this is vanishingly small next
- 49:10to the video game and computer game industry, you know, where you'll have,
- 49:15you know, even something that that's only approximately about the same kind of
- 49:20thing will have millions of players literally uh and uh and only a few thousand
- 49:25so they and you know, that makes the economics of publishing these things really
- 49:31cock eyed because it's such a small it's an exercise in small everything. Small
- 49:39press runs uh you know, aren't done cheaply, a hell of a lot
- 49:45of volunteer labor and hours um uh. So you either go that way if
- 49:52you want to do formal publishing, or as I said, you know earlier,
- 49:57I was talking about meta gaming and their micro games and their chief homespun
- 50:00kind of aesthetic, and you go that way completely. And I've got a
- 50:05foot in both camps because I have published games with GMT Games, which is
- 50:10the biggest publisher. I think at least of board war games what people would
- 50:16generally accept as board you know, detailed complex board war games. And at
- 50:22the same time, you know, at least a quarter to a third of
- 50:27my work is available as print and play. So these are PDF files that
- 50:31I with art that I make myself. Uh you know, I use open
- 50:36Office or Libra office, you know, which is I don't know what you
- 50:38call it, a bundle of software or something, just to do the self
- 50:42publishing. You know, I type out the rules and a word like document.
- 50:47I make the counter sheheet on something that is somewhat like an Excel spreadsheet
- 50:52that you can print, or it's a drawing document. Same thing for the
- 50:57map, you know, if there is even if there is a map or
- 51:00cards, it's it's a very schematic looking thing, so graphically not very adventurous.
- 51:07But again this suits the topic because this is for somebody to download and
- 51:13print out on their home printer or maybe take to a coffee shop or something
- 51:16like that. But that's you know, that's kind of the desktop publishing or
- 51:22DTP ghetto. And I still have a foot there because again I like that
- 51:28approach, and that is also how I got started in designing these games as
- 51:31well. Back in nineteen ninety five, I got in touch with a fellow
- 51:37gamer and we created the microgame co Op, which we later had to call
- 51:40microgame Design Group for a vaguely amusing anecdotes tied with that, but we don't
- 51:46go into that now. And what we did was we sold games in desktop
- 51:51publishing format. These were like color photocopies, you know, or laser prints
- 51:57of things, packaged in like comic book bags, and we sold them for
- 52:01a little bit more than what a cost to produce and mail them. We
- 52:05were not looking for profit, which is why we called ourselves a co op.
- 52:07We invited designs from ourselves and from other designers because we wanted to provide
- 52:15new designers a chance to have their designs exposed for little risk and little cost
- 52:20and no pay because again we were nonprofit, and even more importantly, they
- 52:25get things out with very little delay. It takes years and years for a
- 52:30wargame to be formally published through even with a small company. And so the
- 52:36Microgame Design Group was running for about eight years and we published forty titles in
- 52:40eight years, and some very intelligent games came out, and we certainly moved
- 52:45product and we gave a start to some other prolific wargame designers. They got
- 52:51their start here and got their name out there, and we never spent any
- 52:55money on advertising for example, we just made it available and let word of
- 53:00mouth do the rest. And of course in the end it didn't hurt that
- 53:02we were nonprofit by design and not by outcome, which I made us almost
- 53:07completely unique. So I put out ten titles myself through the Microgame Design Group,
- 53:14and many of them were republished later by other companies that gave them better
- 53:17quality components and somewhat larger press runs. But largely it was the same game
- 53:22design though, same idea, just better presentation. And it was a few
- 53:27years, of course before my work started to get noticed and picked up by
- 53:30these other publishers you know who again weren't very much bigger, and I put
- 53:35out stuff. Now over the years, I've been designing for twenty five years
- 53:38more and publishing stuff, and I put out stuff over through like a dozen
- 53:44different companies, some big or many small, and even the big ones,
- 53:47as I said, are small when you think about it. And again there's
- 53:52still a part of my work is just it's not really saleable. It's not
- 53:57wouldn't be commercial successfully, or there are games I've had published that are now
- 54:01out of print, but I would still like to make them available to people.
- 54:06So I have my own imprint of that are called BTR games, and
- 54:10these are print and play items that are either available very cheaply through an online
- 54:15outfit called war Game Vault, or you can get them free from my website
- 54:20and just download the thing for free and about a quarter to a third sixteen
- 54:22seventeen games I've done are available this way. So you designed many games based
- 54:28in many different eras of history. What draws you to these subjects? I
- 54:36mostly do modern stuff. I've only done one game that takes place before nineteen
- 54:40ten, and that was on the eighteen forty eight revolutions across Europe. That
- 54:45was actually an act of creative procrastination. I was writing a magazine article for
- 54:52Strategy and Tactics Magazine at about the revolutions, and I hit writer's block,
- 54:58and stead of just sitting there doing nothing, I decided to take my research
- 55:04and turn it into a game as a way of kind of restarting the engine
- 55:07on the article. And it worked. But again, that's the only example
- 55:12of something I've done before in nineteen ten. I design mostly on modern periods
- 55:15or contemporary conflicts because I'm personally interested in learning more about them and researching and
- 55:22building models of them. And trying to figure out, you know, what
- 55:25contribution they've made to the world that we live in today. And then I
- 55:30publish these things or just make them available in the hopes that people will try
- 55:32my model and you know, learn a bit about my interpretation about the world
- 55:37about them, or you know, of course, fair enough, maybe they'll
- 55:42disagree with me enough to go out and do some independent reading, you know,
- 55:45maybe designing of their own. I don't mind that. I like that.
- 55:47Let one hundred fours bloom, right, And of course it after nineteen
- 55:53forty five, or even before in nineteen forty five, the default mode of
- 55:57conflict recently, and possibly for most of history when you think about it,
- 56:00the default mode of conflict is insurgency and irregular warfare and at least very highly
- 56:07asymmetric conflict. And at the time I started designing in the early nineties,
- 56:12I was one of the very very few people. Plowing in the coin field
- 56:17is the joke that I make, and I never really get tired of it,
- 56:21and maybe I should, but coin counterinsurgency plowing in the coin field,
- 56:25ha ha. I'm happy to say that I've got more company now, you
- 56:29know, people designing more and more games about you know, insurgency in guerrilla
- 56:32warfare. But I think this is still a really underserved area of game design.
- 56:37You know, even after nine to eleven, when you might expect that
- 56:40there would be some more interest in serious games on this kind of conflict,
- 56:45it just didn't materialize. And you know, I came to the conclusion,
- 56:49you know that I cling to today that all war gamers are interested in history,
- 56:53and many may have an incredibly in depth knowledge of certain periods of history,
- 57:00but most of them, by and large don't seem to be any more
- 57:02interested in current events than non war gamers. So it continues to be a
- 57:08really underserved area. See your next game, then His minute Man, the
- 57:13Second American Revolution, And so rather than deal with an historical battle, this
- 57:16is a speculative game. How plausible is it? Well, it's it's a
- 57:29very interesting game. And when I got a copy of it was it was
- 57:35still a fairly new game. It's called the full title is Minuteman the Second
- 57:39American Revolution, and it came out in nineteen seventy six as one of a
- 57:44series of power politics games that were designed by James Dunnigan, who's my favorite
- 57:49game designer. And one thing I always liked about him was his willingness to
- 57:52experiment, to play around with ideas and speculate about past and current events,
- 57:58and Minuteman is a great example of that. And there's a small family of
- 58:05games that postually a second American Civil War. Actually I've built I looked around.
- 58:10I built a geek list of these on board game Geek the other day.
- 58:14I had no trouble finding about a dozen titles. But all of these
- 58:17games start in medias res as it were, with both sides ready to go
- 58:22at it in a full civil war. And the only game that kind of
- 58:24covers the build up, the run up to an insurgency in the USA among
- 58:30this family of games is Minuteman, although it can take an hour or two
- 58:34to the point where you're prepared to launch open warfare for the revolution. And
- 58:38it was that that I found rather interesting about the game, because you have
- 58:43to go through this whole clandestine phase of going to different cities and setting up,
- 58:47you know, networks through your agents, and meanwhile the government is trying
- 58:52to fancy in and there they've got their own counter counter agents and that kind
- 58:57of thing. So it's it's a game that can be played out on a
- 59:00number of levels like that, and I really liked it at the time.
- 59:06I played a lot of it. But are we are we Are we close
- 59:12to round two of the American Civil War? I really don't think so.
- 59:15In game language, you know, in the language of Minuteman, the US
- 59:21is no more than maybe one or two unrest markers, you know, here
- 59:24and there on the map. Personally, I feel that, I mean,
- 59:30there's this whole thread in American culture about American decline, declinism, and if
- 59:37it ever gets to the point of sustained over civil violence in the United States,
- 59:44I don't think it will be a decline into an organized civil war or
- 59:46even a tribal based, you know, conflict like Somalia. That's a violence
- 59:52fantasy that's almost as removed as imagining a Nazi, Soviet, or Asian occupation
- 59:58of the United States, which again is a thread of American culture, literature,
- 1:00:02and even games. You know, one of the most popular almost war
- 1:00:07games is Fortress America, which you may or may not have heard of,
- 1:00:13but anyway, that's been popular since the eighties, and that's got a three
- 1:00:16way invasion of the United States. I think instead, you know, if
- 1:00:22it happens when it happens, it could exempt it would probably resemble something more
- 1:00:27like the former Soviet Union and maybe end up something like a local mafia state,
- 1:00:31you know, no widespread invasions, just to slide into kind of an
- 1:00:36immovable oligarchic kleptocracy where a few people are actually starving, but even fewer have
- 1:00:40much of a chance of advancing or changing in the present order. This is
- 1:00:45another resonance with Minuteman the Second American Revolution because Dunnigan's introductory notes he gives the
- 1:00:51backstory for Minuteman in the game, because you have to kind of when you've
- 1:00:57got an alternate history game like this, you have to kind of get chin,
- 1:01:00you know, the background. These were notes that he wrote like forty
- 1:01:04five years ago, but I think they're still really poignant and they provide more
- 1:01:07insights into the current situation. So very interesting. But where there is violence,
- 1:01:14I think it will be localized, low level, sporadic and uneven.
- 1:01:17It won't be red states against blue states. I think it will be purple
- 1:01:22purple throughout, a patchy purple throughout, and it will come to resemble something
- 1:01:25like an American Years of Lead. Are you're familiar with the Years of lead
- 1:01:31expression, I'm okay. In Italy. You remember, in Italy in the
- 1:01:37nineteen seventies and the eighties they had trouble with both left and right wing organized
- 1:01:43terrorism, and in Italy that's called the aid Piombo or the years of Lead,
- 1:01:47because the left and the right extremists they're striking at each other. The
- 1:01:52government is incidentally involved here and there. There are things like until recently,
- 1:01:57the worst civilian bombing by a orst organization was the right wing set off a
- 1:02:02bomb in a railway station in Bologna in the early eighties, killed I think
- 1:02:07something like seventy or eighty people. You know, of course we've done better
- 1:02:12than that since then, but that was a startling example of violence. But
- 1:02:16that was how it was. It was like left and right smacking each other,
- 1:02:21you know, in Italy. Meanwhile, the government is trying to keep
- 1:02:25order on top of all of this. And I think that you know,
- 1:02:29there are probably enough soreheads of all stripes and inclinations in the United States to
- 1:02:32cause trouble, but not enough on an organized and mobile scale where you can
- 1:02:37model it on more than a tactical level. It'll be like neighborhood versus neighborhood
- 1:02:42like the early days of the Syrian Civil War. Fractal violence, fractal all
- 1:02:49the way down, and the question, the only question remaining is how much
- 1:02:54is there, how much energy is there to keep that level of agro,
- 1:02:58you know, kind of stoked and running, and to keep stoking the cycle
- 1:03:01of strike and counter strike before what's left of American infrastructure breaks down and well
- 1:03:07the snacks run out. You know, it's difficult to organize a raid on
- 1:03:10those bastards over in Sycamore Street when the water stopped running six days ago and
- 1:03:15you've got Trotskys in your pants. You know, that tends to divert people's
- 1:03:19attention. But maybe that will be the end of the culture war. Who
- 1:03:23knows. So I want to talk now about your writing. So you don't
- 1:03:29only design games, but you write about them too? Why? Because I
- 1:03:34can get paid twice? I used to do a series of games. I
- 1:03:42have had to publish a series of games published in Strategy and Tactics magazine,
- 1:03:47which is published by Decision Games. This was a magazine that James Dunnigan started
- 1:03:52back in nineteen seventy sixty nine seventy and Decision Games is still publishing it.
- 1:03:58They're closing in, i think, on their four hundred issue now, And
- 1:04:01this is a game. This is a magazine that comes out every two or
- 1:04:05three months with a fully playable board war game inside it. And there are
- 1:04:13very few of these magazines have existed through time, and of course, with
- 1:04:15four hundred issues, nearly Strategy and Tactics is the longest lift of them.
- 1:04:20So I've had a number of games come out through there. And when the
- 1:04:27normal practice is that the magazine, the game in the issue is related to
- 1:04:34the major historical article that's in the magazine, and usually the designer gets the
- 1:04:40chance to write the lead article that is about the conflict that they've designed the
- 1:04:45game about, and so the research does double duty. So again with this
- 1:04:49setup, you get paid twice because you get paid for the game design that
- 1:04:53you worked out, and of course all the research that you've done incidental creating
- 1:04:57the game. You write that up into an accompanying article and you get paid
- 1:05:00for that too. Not a lot, but you to get paid. But
- 1:05:04it's good because this way it gets you get an even greater opportunity to demonstrate
- 1:05:14just the depths of research that you've done, the things that you are important,
- 1:05:17you think, are important to the design and to the conflict, and
- 1:05:21so the two are meant to work together, and I think they really do.
- 1:05:26It's much better than a set of designers notes, which often are quite
- 1:05:30short. And so do all games fetishize conflict? And if so, is
- 1:05:39that healthy? I don't know if they really fetishize conflict. I don't think
- 1:05:45it's so much objectification as it is a kind of obsessive interpretation. I can
- 1:05:53only speak for my own work. There are lots of war games out there
- 1:05:57that build themselves as you know, big dumb pens or pushed you know,
- 1:06:00where people shove counters around all day without paying too much attention to reality,
- 1:06:04you know, whatever it is that they might actually be be modeling. They're
- 1:06:09just they're having fun, and too many people it's just like working out bits
- 1:06:13of a math puzzle, you know. It's like a grown up sudoku enemy
- 1:06:15seem to some. And then there are other people who play games, and
- 1:06:19then they look at them as just kind of an intricate puzzle that they can
- 1:06:24try to break, you know, by exploiting blopholes and the rules or the
- 1:06:28mechanics or something like that. I'm all for letting people enjoy things. But
- 1:06:32these people, their motivations are not the same as mine. A lot of
- 1:06:38the games I've designed deal with the really grimy corners of history, you know,
- 1:06:42insurgency, guerrilla warfare, terrorism, you know, conflicts that incidentally involve
- 1:06:49genocide, this kind of thing. Even people who don't think that the entire
- 1:06:56hobby of war gaming should be condemned out of hand for being in bad tape
- 1:07:00will still bulk at war games on these topics, especially contemporary conflicts. Voco
- 1:07:06Runka, you know you've you've talked to him before. We He and I
- 1:07:12together wrote a chapter length commentary on this phenomenon in an anthology on war games
- 1:07:17that came out a few years ago from MIT Press, which is a little
- 1:07:24brush with academia, and in it we called it the indecency of recency.
- 1:07:30You know, people generally don't want to be reminded of these grim, distasteful
- 1:07:36kind of conflicts because there's this not a fetishization, but certainly, as I
- 1:07:45say, an obsession with details and just a general eliding of the nature of
- 1:07:53warfare and a romanticizing of it. And that's kind of, I think,
- 1:08:00really kind of fooling yourself, and you know, societies they tend to not
- 1:08:03want to think about these kinds of conflicts. You know, I mentioned earlier
- 1:08:09about there not when I started working, there are almost no Vietnam titles out
- 1:08:13there because nobody really wanted to publish or read much about the Vietnam War.
- 1:08:17A few years ago, I designed Colonial Twilight, which was only the second
- 1:08:23game, a second or third game ever published in any language on the French
- 1:08:28Algerian War. And to this day, you know, there's still an awful
- 1:08:30lot of social amnesia about the Algerian conflict in French society. The French government
- 1:08:38didn't even get around calling it a war until almost two thousand and yet this
- 1:08:44is a conflict that you know, poisoned French politics and their society for many,
- 1:08:50many years, and I think continues to nowadays. But it's something that
- 1:08:55nobody really wanted to hear about, to read about. So that's something that
- 1:09:00you know, it's not fetishized, it's not romanticized, it's simply you know,
- 1:09:04kind of erased. It's it's absent. But that's that's another question,
- 1:09:10I think. And you've written for academic texts, as you've mentioned, as
- 1:09:14well as magazines. What are the differences in those styles of writing. Well,
- 1:09:20I'm not an academic. Um. I've seen enough of the academic field
- 1:09:26of game studies to dislike it. Twice now, I've gone to national conferences
- 1:09:30of the American Popular Cultural Association, which are like sociologists, and that's kind
- 1:09:35of thing, and they have a field of game studies within it. And
- 1:09:40I went to these conferences to present papers I had written on board war games,
- 1:09:44and each time there'd be like a collection of eighty or ninety presentations made
- 1:09:48in the game studies department, and there were most two or three that did
- 1:09:54not deal with some aspect of computer games or video games or the people that
- 1:09:58play them. So it would be me reading my paper and someone else talking
- 1:10:02about you know, maybe literary analysis of Dungeons and Dragons manuals or board games
- 1:10:08of the eighties that doubled its warning for kids to stay away from strangers with
- 1:10:12pockets full of drugs, you know, that kind of thing. You know,
- 1:10:15it's sort of like a social aspect. I've never seen a field of
- 1:10:18inquiry so persistently and willfully ignorant of its analog past and present. This is
- 1:10:26changing a little bit. I now that they know that there's at least one
- 1:10:29academic journal out there that's devoted to analog games, and there are conferences that,
- 1:10:33you know, at any rate ignore the topic less than they used to.
- 1:10:35But still the academic field of game studies is overwhelmingly directed towards computer and
- 1:10:41video games. You know their design, their audience, you know their ideology,
- 1:10:45this kind of thing. So I mentioned this before, but an interesting
- 1:10:49garbage can live that I've been banging on for a while is the idea of
- 1:10:54game design citizen journalism. And the second time I went to one of these
- 1:10:58academic conferences that was a topic. And I have a piece in an anthology
- 1:11:01that's coming out next year that goes into this idea a greater length. About
- 1:11:05fifteen years ago, there was a stir in the game studies world about what
- 1:11:10they called news games. These were supposed to be computer or video games with
- 1:11:14an ideological agenda or a pedagogical agenda. Put it that way, similar to
- 1:11:18the objectives of journalism. There was an academic called Ian bogost I don't know
- 1:11:25how to pronounce his name. He wrote a book about news games in twenty
- 1:11:29eleven about the promise of these things and ten years later he wrote a magazine
- 1:11:33article declaring them dead and the whole experiment of failure. I wasn't too surprised
- 1:11:39about that, because this man rarely ever writes about analog games. And the
- 1:11:45fact remains, though, that the practice of producing analog or analog news games
- 1:11:49predates video games by a very long time, and it continues today, and
- 1:11:55a lot of them I think stand just not as commemorative one off subs are
- 1:12:00just like ephemera. They're examples of citizen based social criticism and analytic journalism.
- 1:12:05And I think, in writing about this, there are three types of analog
- 1:12:11news games. There's one that uses a reskin of like a well known popular
- 1:12:15game to make a point. There's another academic who writes about game studies called
- 1:12:18Mary Flanagan. She also designs games herself, analog and computer. Very intelligent
- 1:12:24person, very intelligent anthology, and she talks a lot in this critical playbook
- 1:12:30giving examples of people reskinning classic games that people already know how to play,
- 1:12:33but giving them a political or social gloss. That's a comment. Also,
- 1:12:40there are people who have designed original game designs but with simple mechanics, again
- 1:12:45to put across a point. And then the third type is the historical board
- 1:12:47wor game, which is what I've been doing, which is a procedurally very
- 1:12:53heavy item that's informed by data and techniques of operational research. And that's this
- 1:13:00last one is the sort of trying this kind of engagement at citizen journalism and
- 1:13:05comment and trying to present and share your ideas about a situation or what you
- 1:13:12think is important about a situation is a sort of thing that I'm trying to
- 1:13:15do with games that are about contemporary events and are produced very close to the
- 1:13:20time of the actual event. I've done games like I mentioned before about civil
- 1:13:24power, where I would create scenarios from newspaper headlines you know that I read
- 1:13:29that week. I've designed a game called Battle of Seattle, which is about
- 1:13:32the Antiwto riots in Seattle at the end of nineteen ninety nine. I had
- 1:13:40completed that game within a couple of weeks of the actual event. In twenty
- 1:13:44fourteen, I put out a game called Ukrainian Crisis Over. I designed it
- 1:13:48in forty eight hours over the very weekend of that sham referendum that the Russians
- 1:13:54held in Crimea, where Crimea decided to go back and rejoin Russia and very
- 1:14:00much like there would be an over Russian invasion at the time. Now this
- 1:14:03is twenty fourteen, So in forty eight hours, I put together this fairly
- 1:14:06simple political military information warfare type game that tried to model the situation. So
- 1:14:15that's the kind of thing that I'm trying to do. And James Dunnigan again
- 1:14:18my favorite designer. He was the one also one of the first people to
- 1:14:23design and publish war games in this vein like almost in the same news cycle
- 1:14:28as these things came out, and he said about war games generally, if
- 1:14:31you can play them, you can design them. And he meant this especially
- 1:14:35in terms of analog games. You know, he was working again in the
- 1:14:40time before computer games really came along. Playing an analog game is very different
- 1:14:45from playing a computer game, because playing an analog game brings its players into
- 1:14:49really intimate contact with the game's design and its mechanics that are expressed through its
- 1:14:55rules. You can't help but have to understand if you're thinking about it at
- 1:15:00all. To be exposed to the game's structure and logic and intent in a
- 1:15:03very different way from the unseen code that underlies a digital game, and I
- 1:15:10think this is important. This gives power to the person who likes to play
- 1:15:13games and maybe has something of their own to say in that they can change
- 1:15:16the game, alter it, subvert it, parity, invert it to suit
- 1:15:20their own purposes. And it's this kind of critical questioning attitude that people obviously
- 1:15:27have, and I think they can express it through analog news schemes. And
- 1:15:31I think this gives an added dimension and a potential function to what we would
- 1:15:34call, you know, citizen journalism as a form of interpreting modern day events
- 1:15:40or significant chapters of history that have been ignored and bringing them to people's notice.
- 1:15:45And that's what really separates it from you know, efforts that people had
- 1:15:49on digital news games, which you know, and which need to have a
- 1:15:55code or uh, you know, and and a platform and technology, and
- 1:16:00it's you know, in the end, a very frustrating kind of black box
- 1:16:02syndrome into this. So anyway, I don't want to read too much into
- 1:16:06this. I don't think it's doing anything super profound. Maybe it's unusual,
- 1:16:11but maybe not really profound. But I think this isn't just part of what
- 1:16:15you'd call it's part of what you'd call my design ethos, And so do
- 1:16:19you feel when writing about games? And it's may be different if you're writing
- 1:16:25about the historical context of a wall game, But do you ever feel a
- 1:16:29bit like poacher turned gamekeeper when writing about games as opposed to designing them.
- 1:16:34I really like that turn of phrase, thank you. I like the history
- 1:16:40of board board games. I've been playing a long time. I like talking
- 1:16:44and writing about games. I don't enjoy writing about the processes of game design
- 1:16:51very much. And I really really dislike writing or even talking about creativity or
- 1:16:57the creative process generally. It's just a little bit too made up for me.
- 1:17:02It's Uh. I like to just do what I do. I like
- 1:17:05to try not to think too much about what I'm doing. Uh, put
- 1:17:11it that way. And um, but I do. I do like to
- 1:17:15talk and to other people about, you know, about the history of games.
- 1:17:19You know, what has been done in a certain field. You know
- 1:17:23how people have explored you know, a certain idea or a problem in the
- 1:17:26past. Um, it's it's it's a lot of fun. You know when
- 1:17:30I go to game conventions and I run into other game designers, and you
- 1:17:34know, we don't spend our time talking about you know, creativity or or
- 1:17:40or that kind of in that sort of made a sense. Instead we talk
- 1:17:43to each other about, you know, mechanical problems that we've solved. It's
- 1:17:47like, um, I think it was Picasso, might have been Picasso who
- 1:17:50said that it was the kind of It's Sunday. Painters get together and they
- 1:17:55talk about truth and beauty and the internal varity of art, and professional artists
- 1:17:59get together and they just talk about where you can score a good pullet knife
- 1:18:02for cheap turpentine. So your next game then is A Distant Plane and this
- 1:18:09is a coin gain. What does that system bring to wargaming? Well,
- 1:18:17that A Distant Plane is the third in a series of games that came out
- 1:18:27and had been designed by Vocal, and I guess after a while, after
- 1:18:38I've been designing for a while, my games started to become noticed by some
- 1:18:44people in the professional war gaming field. And in two thousand and seven I
- 1:18:50was invited to a meeting of the Military Operations Research Society, which is a
- 1:19:00you know, the professional analysts, military analysts, that kind of thing,
- 1:19:05because they had a special event about irregular warfare and I ran into somebody there
- 1:19:14who was a teaching colleague of Volcos at the Sherman Kent School for International Analysis,
- 1:19:20which is where the CIA trains its analysts, and he at the time
- 1:19:26I had worked out this game on the Algerian War, and this was a
- 1:19:30case study that he prepared in in his classes, and so we worked together
- 1:19:35to put this sort of degritted version of the game that he could play quickly
- 1:19:41in the classroom. And Volco saw this being used in the classroom and he
- 1:19:48picked up a copy for himself for his study, and he found some ideas
- 1:19:54in my Algeria game that partially inspired his creation of what we call the GMT
- 1:19:58coin system, which now of course has at least a dozen volumes in it.
- 1:20:02And it wasn't until a couple of years later, this is about twenty
- 1:20:06twenty nine, twenty ten around that time, and he publishes Day and Abyss,
- 1:20:11which is the first volume in the series about coin. And then a
- 1:20:15couple of years later we get together and we meet at a conference and we
- 1:20:18agree, the two of us to work together on a Distant Plane, which
- 1:20:23is about Afghanistan. The thing about these games is that there are people out
- 1:20:31there who refuse to call these war games because they have different reasons or another.
- 1:20:35These these these games, they use wooden bits instead of you know,
- 1:20:41cardboard counters with numbers and pictures on them. The turn structure is weird and
- 1:20:45asymmetrical. You don't roll the dice very often, that sort of thing.
- 1:20:48These are very different from the conventional run of war games. And of course,
- 1:20:55the great majority of board war games focus on episodes of conventional war and
- 1:21:00there's this common lexicon of mechanics, traditions, structures, and especially unspoken practiced
- 1:21:06assumptions among them. It's a set of norms of how a game is put
- 1:21:11together and what concepts it holds in its basic structure and how the players expect
- 1:21:15it to be played. But the coin system and wargames generally that focus on
- 1:21:21irregular warfare and counterinsurgency, they try to model a form of complex and indeterminate,
- 1:21:29nonlinear conflict. They only partly share that language, and inevitably they end
- 1:21:33up questioning those norms. And this is the kind of new face that these
- 1:21:39coin games I think bring to war gaming. I think it's the approach that's
- 1:21:43the more satisfying one in trying to model the contemporary world. Even though the
- 1:21:46coin system has been applied to conflicts of all ages from our thury in Britain
- 1:21:53to the near future. But I also think it's the more realistic one in
- 1:21:57describing and modeling warfare generally, I've tried to adopt some of these same critical
- 1:22:02principles, and I think that they end up, in a sense, subverting
- 1:22:05the design and the play of this greater body of games. There's different axas
- 1:22:13about this. I've got a whole speel about this, but basically it just
- 1:22:15boils down to on the one hand, we have a conventional game which is
- 1:22:20kind of a binary conflict with a zero sum versus a coin system game which
- 1:22:27has multiple, albeit frictional, but multiple points of view. You have an
- 1:22:32ordered situation versus a continuously chaotic and nonlinear game state. A conventional war game
- 1:22:41tends to have rigid treatments of time and space and force, but these distinctions
- 1:22:45are almost meaningless in a coin system game. And then finally, you have
- 1:22:50symmetry versus asymmetry of information, of methods, and of objectives. So these
- 1:22:57subvert a lot of how war games had been played up to that point.
- 1:23:01And of course nowadays there's a lot of experimentation going on, and there's more
- 1:23:05and more game war games coming around to accepting these alternative points of view,
- 1:23:10this flexibility about structure and intention and method. I'm really glad to see that.
- 1:23:15Now. I can't say if this is due significantly to the GMT coin
- 1:23:18series, or whether it's the effect of Eurogames and the amazing variety of game
- 1:23:27mechanics that they bring. I think it's some of each, but it's certainly
- 1:23:31it's shown people that there's an awful lot that's possible, and I think the
- 1:23:35coin system as contributed to that kind of thing. Now, you've kind of
- 1:23:41touched on this earlier in the interview, but you know this is a modern
- 1:23:44conflict. What are the particular challenges to designing something so contemporary? Well,
- 1:23:56really it's well, I mean, talk about it, talk about a distant
- 1:24:00planement. The game came out in The game came out in twenty thirteen,
- 1:24:11and we were VOCO and I were very careful about putting language in its playbook
- 1:24:16and in the designers notes about how this game was a product of our thoughts
- 1:24:20and our research up to twenty twelve and twenty thirteen, and the period covered
- 1:24:26by the game was intended to end in twenty fourteen, which was the end
- 1:24:30of the NATO's combat mission in Afghanistan, so that happened. The game was
- 1:24:36published, The war did not finish until twenty twenty one, and we were
- 1:24:45careful at the time to talk about how we did not claim any kind of
- 1:24:47predictive value for the game. We meant that and to condemn the game because
- 1:24:53it couldn't perfectly model a situation eight years after, you know, the planned
- 1:24:58end of that game, which was a situation in reality that only came out
- 1:25:02with political events and arrangements that were far beyond the framework of the original game
- 1:25:09design, combined with what in game terms, would have been a lot of
- 1:25:13really deliberately bad and counterproductive play. So it all seems a bit much.
- 1:25:17That's the risk you have when you're designing a game on a conflict that is
- 1:25:23still going on, but you're careful. You have to be careful not to
- 1:25:28claim any kind of predictive value for it. These war games, they're not
- 1:25:32perfect time machines. They do not They cannot be counted on to perfectly replicate
- 1:25:40a past battle or war anymore than they can a future battle or war,
- 1:25:47because there's so much that can go on. What they do is they provide
- 1:25:51you with a framework of rules and mechanics in a situation where you kind of
- 1:25:57you explore that problem space, and it's like an experiment in that you generate
- 1:26:01a range of results. Now, the test of a war game, the
- 1:26:04test of an historical wor game is can it reproduce the actual historical event.
- 1:26:11If it cannot do that, then it's failed as a working But so almost
- 1:26:15always that is the case. But what you can also demonstrate there is that
- 1:26:19what historically what happened is wasn't inevitable. You know, maybe it wasn't the
- 1:26:28most likely outcome even maybe it was maybe it was a ring, or maybe
- 1:26:31it was some kind of an outlier event. And so the point is is
- 1:26:38that it gives you a way of exploring a situation, of exploring a problem,
- 1:26:43whether it's past or future, and you can't you know, it's unreasonable
- 1:26:47to expect, you know, a kind of prediction like this. So that's
- 1:26:53a criticism that people level against it. You know, people expect it to
- 1:26:56be all literal and and tidy, and yeah, we said this was going
- 1:26:59to happen four years ago. The game proves it. Um, No,
- 1:27:03that's not the point of playing these games. The point of playing these games
- 1:27:06is to try and figure out what could be happening. This is how the
- 1:27:11professional military approaches their war games. They don't necessarily care, you know,
- 1:27:17whether one side wins or the other. They care about what went into the
- 1:27:20ultimate decision to the ultimate outcome. And again the problem with contemporary conflicts is
- 1:27:29that they are painful ones. They can they involve people who are alive,
- 1:27:38or they people or you know, the players potentially, you know, if
- 1:27:41they weren't involved in the conflict themselves. They know people you know, who
- 1:27:46were in the conflict, and it can be very painful to them. I've
- 1:27:49had people talk about you know, a distant plane for example, they say,
- 1:27:54well, you know, I admire the design, but personally, I
- 1:27:58can't bring myself to play it. Um. I had a you know,
- 1:28:01a backhanded compliment from somebody once who said, yes, I played it is
- 1:28:05complaining, but I stopped playing it because it was bringing me the same feelings
- 1:28:11of frustration and confusion that I experienced when I was a marine. And Hellmann
- 1:28:16province. Uh so, you know I made that. I guess in a
- 1:28:23sense, the game that I made made that emotional connection with him, and
- 1:28:28I'm sad that it was. It was painful, you know, in frustrating
- 1:28:30form um. But that's again a risk you know, with with contemporary conflicts,
- 1:28:35and a lot of people think, you know, to do a game
- 1:28:39like this on a contemporary conflict is trivializing it. We talked a little while
- 1:28:43ago about fetishizing and romanticizing conflict. Um. Again, you know, I
- 1:28:47have my own take on that. So since it's publication, as you said,
- 1:28:51we've seen the American withdrawal from Afghanistan. What are your views on that?
- 1:29:00Again, in game terms, the situation in twenty twenty one was far
- 1:29:05removed from I think, almost anything that a distant plane could have modeled.
- 1:29:11But in game terms, in twenty twenty one, it was as if the
- 1:29:15Coalition player suddenly stood up and said, okay, last bus home is at
- 1:29:17eleven, I have to be on it. And then he starts sweeping up
- 1:29:20the game bits into the box lid because it's his copy of the game,
- 1:29:25and the government, the Afghan government player in the game is looking on.
- 1:29:29He doesn't mind, you know, because he's kind of disengaged. He has
- 1:29:31to get up early tomorrow. He checked out a little while back, and
- 1:29:34the Taliban player. He declares victory because at the time that the Coalition players
- 1:29:40started sweeping the bits into the game box, he was ahead, and everyone
- 1:29:44lets him have it. But again, as I say, there were aspects,
- 1:29:49larger changes and shifts, you know, in the framework of the conflict
- 1:29:53itself and among the factions and combatants that weren't there, I think, or
- 1:30:00weren't as pronounced as when Vocal and I were working on the game, you
- 1:30:04know, ten years, almost ten years before the end of the actual war.
- 1:30:08And as they said, deliberately we set the end of the period covered
- 1:30:14by the game of twenty fourteen because we didn't know and wouldn't want to claim
- 1:30:17to know what would happen after the end of NATO's combat mission in Afghanistan.
- 1:30:24It's the same thing with the Ukrainian crisis. The game that I mentioned a
- 1:30:28while back. You know, it's a game that's set for twenty fourteen,
- 1:30:32and it covers it's meant to cover the first six months or so of the
- 1:30:36conflict up to the first Minsk Agreement in September of twenty fourteen. It did
- 1:30:43not predict, you know, Putin's invasion of twenty twenty two, except to
- 1:30:46maybe give the passing comment that you know, if Putin had been playing that
- 1:30:50game, he would have so thoroughly has already thoroughly lost the diplomatic sub game
- 1:30:57and the information warfare that Ganda subgame, and so he launches the military subgame
- 1:31:03and kicks the table over at the same time. So what we're seeing now
- 1:31:09is the piece is heading for the floor. So I want to know about
- 1:31:11the future. What games do you have coming out in the future, well,
- 1:31:15coming out in the next year or two. I have Brief Border Wars
- 1:31:19Volume two from Compass Games. This is a set of four smaller games within
- 1:31:28one box that are played according to a basic rules structure, but then there's
- 1:31:34rules modules that are particular to each conflict. This is volume two. Volume
- 1:31:40one was quite popular, so the publisher wanted a volume two. I've just
- 1:31:43signed off on the files for that. It'll be published later this year,
- 1:31:48and no sooner was that done when the editor said, oh, the publisher
- 1:31:53wants volume three, so can you get work on that. Another one I'm
- 1:31:58working on is China's War from GMT Games. This is a GMT coin system
- 1:32:03game covering China from nineteen thirty seven to nineteen forty one. So it's four
- 1:32:10players, and that it goes from thirty you know, the initial Japanese invasion
- 1:32:15to the point where the front you know, it's more or less shut down
- 1:32:20in nineteen forty one, and then you know, the action transfers to elsewhere
- 1:32:26in the Pacific. This would be the first coin system game to cover a
- 1:32:30World War two conflict that's formally published stuff. I'm also working on eight or
- 1:32:36nine other projects in the last year or so. That I've completed most of
- 1:32:41them, I will probably make them available for free. I spent a lot
- 1:32:45of time last year designing a spoke game war game for the California Army National
- 1:32:54Guard on large scale combat operations in urban areas, and I was inspired by
- 1:33:01doing that game to do a number of smaller sort of spinoff games, not
- 1:33:08using the same system, but focusing on different aspects of urban conflict. I'm
- 1:33:13particularly interested in the idea of conflict within cities now, especially modern irregular warfare
- 1:33:19within cities. It's something that's, you know, it's happening now, it's
- 1:33:25inevitable, and it's going to get a lot worse, and it's a problem
- 1:33:28that really needs to be studied, and so in my way, I'm trying
- 1:33:32to explore that, you know, by myself, and you've designed a few
- 1:33:36games based on the disintegration of French imperialism. What interests you about that period
- 1:33:43of history. Well, I didn't mean to pick on the French particularly,
- 1:33:47although you might think that because I've done three games on the Algeria War,
- 1:33:53I've also done four on Afghanistan, which has witnessed the disintegration of something else,
- 1:33:58another type of imperialism. I have tried to give a little bit of
- 1:34:01equal time to British imperialism because they did a game on the Cypress emergency in
- 1:34:05the fifties. I'm interested in this because well, I've always been interested in
- 1:34:14the ideas of irregular warfare, guerrilla conflict and insurgency, and often this is
- 1:34:21a nationalist insurgency. A few years ago a book came out called The Sling
- 1:34:28and the Stone. It was written by a Marine colonel and he talked about
- 1:34:32three somewhat overlapping waves of insurgencies that started after World War Two. The first
- 1:34:38was a wave of anti colonialist uprisings and wars, and that Cyprus was one
- 1:34:45of them. The war in Algeria as another example, and of course all
- 1:34:47across Africa. Then there was a wave of conflicts to decide which groups would
- 1:34:54dominate within these newly independent areas, and often these were tribally based. And
- 1:35:00then there's a wave of transporder and regional conflicts because the artificial divisions and states
- 1:35:05that were created by the colonial empires, the borders that they had drawn without
- 1:35:11any respect to the people's within them. As those crumble and fall away,
- 1:35:15there's a new wave of regional conflict. And then there's you know, the
- 1:35:20growing urbanism, the move to the cities that's going on now, and I
- 1:35:26think it's this last wave and the flood of people into the cities with an
- 1:35:30infrastructure that can't deal with it. And as relevant as these contemporary conflicts may
- 1:35:35be to us now, again there are not very many civilian market games about
- 1:35:41these problems. So again this is a gap that I'm interested in personally and
- 1:35:45that you know, I like to you know, I like to fill.
- 1:35:48There are a lot of games out there where the object is to build an
- 1:35:51empire. It's a whole genre called I think they call it four X explore
- 1:35:58exploit, I can't remember it. All xes are, but the objective exterminate,
- 1:36:02expand that's it. Yes, it's all about extermination and expansion. Eventually
- 1:36:09that's great. Um, you know, and you have one or more players
- 1:36:12who are playing these games and you're trying to build an empire. But I
- 1:36:15find the breakdown and the dissolution of these things just as interesting. One of
- 1:36:19my favorite bands is Devo. I don't know if you know them. It's
- 1:36:25an American band, and back in nineteen seventy eight they describe their music as
- 1:36:30the important sound of things falling apart, and that's maybe that's maybe that's what
- 1:36:35I'm trying to do here. I'm trying to make music about or game music
- 1:36:41about things falling apart. What can bull games teach us about the nature of
- 1:36:47human beings? Well, I think it's really ironic. The war games attempt
- 1:36:55to portray the behavior of our species at its most illogical and atavistic through a
- 1:37:01framework of consistent logical regulations and math, and usually a very prim concern to
- 1:37:10confine the game to what is thought to be militarily significant. Spoken about that
- 1:37:15before, but you know that's rationalism for you, right. So when push
- 1:37:18comes to shove, you know, we're still a large pack of brain eating
- 1:37:24apes, and most war games, they missed that point, deliberately or accidentally.
- 1:37:29They're good at telling us what happened historically and how it happened or how
- 1:37:33it could have happened, but the why of conflict not so much. There
- 1:37:39are very few games that are about the very nature of conflict. Games are
- 1:37:45about conflict and competition. There are, of course, exceptions out there about
- 1:37:49cooperative games, people cooperating towards in particular you know and state, even though
- 1:37:57they might have their own agendas within that, there's still the exception. And
- 1:38:03perhaps it's also because that's the exception in human behavior and not the rule.
- 1:38:10We wish it were the other way. And so, what contribution do you
- 1:38:13think that you've made to the world of games? Will I've made some unusual
- 1:38:23things. I don't think I've made anything really profound. I've dirtied a lot
- 1:38:28of paper that could have been used for something else. I know that much.
- 1:38:32I like to think that maybe I've shown people different ways to do different
- 1:38:36things, and I've taken to heart. You've done again James Dunagan's comment that
- 1:38:42if you can play these four games, you can design them. Anybody can
- 1:38:45design a game on just about anything, I think, but like anything in
- 1:38:49life, it takes persistence and work to get any good at it. And
- 1:38:54you know, after almost thirty years, I'm still not sure I'm reliably good
- 1:38:58at any of this sixty designs down the road, but I I have taken
- 1:39:04a few paths that people often weren't inclined to take. But again, is
- 1:39:13it really profound? Did I change? You know that the practice of games?
- 1:39:16I don't know. I don't think so. But that's just part of
- 1:39:23my ethos, you know, I guess is to share information, to share
- 1:39:26my interpretation of things, and to scratch my personal creative itch and in a
- 1:39:31sense amuse me. Is it ethical if I just if I say I'm in
- 1:39:36it to amuse me and my creative need. Well, if you look at
- 1:39:43it as a consequentialist result, your motivations are completely unimportant. It is the
- 1:39:50greater net happiness that you've brought to the world. And so, you know,
- 1:39:55people seem to be fans of your games, so I think ethically you're
- 1:39:59in the clear. Good. That's good to know. Thanks. So your
- 1:40:05last game, then, is City Fights Modern combat in the urban environment.
- 1:40:10And this was published by SPI. How important were they as a publisher?
- 1:40:15They were very important as board ward game designers. They were not the first.
- 1:40:19The first was the Avalon Hill Game Company to produce these things in any
- 1:40:26you know, in any volume, but they would come out with only maybe
- 1:40:29two or three game you know games a year in the sixties. And then
- 1:40:33SPI came along in the early seventies and this was done again together with some
- 1:40:38like minded people, and they were turning out dozens and dozens of them every
- 1:40:42year. And they went at it at this pace until about nineteen eighty two
- 1:40:45when the whole thing, you know, all the wheels fell off the bus
- 1:40:47and they went out of business. But they churned out so much and they
- 1:40:55brought so many new ideas and covered so many con licks. And there was
- 1:41:02a person who worked in the company called Redmond Simmons and who gave war games
- 1:41:09their graphic look. That is really really important because this was maybe the first
- 1:41:15person who was really thinking about how a game should be designed graphically to communicate
- 1:41:21information and to make play of it easier. So they were critical, absolutely
- 1:41:28critical and crucial, you know, to the growth of the hobby. And
- 1:41:30of course after they imploded, you know, in the early eighties, you
- 1:41:33know, the hobby kind of imploded too because of other things that were going
- 1:41:36on at the time, but they were critical. And the City Fight is
- 1:41:41a game that came out in the late seventies. It is an extremely detailed
- 1:41:47game on tactical urban combat in a mythical German village, and it's played what
- 1:41:55they call double blind, so you have the two players and they're playing,
- 1:42:00but they cannot see everything on the board. So the game is the game
- 1:42:04has been compared to two boxers, you know, with earplugs in and blindfolds
- 1:42:10on, kind of wandering around trying to find the other guys so they can
- 1:42:14punch him. And that's, you know, in large part, you know
- 1:42:17what the game has to teach, but it's also very very detailed, you
- 1:42:20know, because it is a tactical game. I kind of when after I
- 1:42:26sent you this list of games, I kind of wanted to change my choice
- 1:42:29there, because, as I've been saying, I'm very interested in urban warfare.
- 1:42:34Maybe instead of City Fight, I'd like to substitute one or more of
- 1:42:39these urban warfare projects I'm currently working on, because sometimes it seems like it's
- 1:42:43going to take an apocalypse long period of without distraction and a secluded cabin so
- 1:42:47I can finish it off. There's one I've been working on called the Scalable
- 1:42:53Urban Simulation that I think has some purpose and certainly needs some testing, and
- 1:42:58I still think again it certainly it's an important, an urgent topic, even
- 1:43:00if there's a global apocalypse going on outside the cabin. And in reflection,
- 1:43:06while city fight, it's an intense and it's a detailed simulation of urban combat.
- 1:43:12It's a tactical level. I generally don't work at the tactical level.
- 1:43:15I like the idea of operational level games. That's where most of mine evan
- 1:43:20pitched at. And then there's the double blind aspect, because I assume I'm
- 1:43:25alone in the cabin. I can't really play something a double blind game,
- 1:43:30even I'm not that schizophrenic. But I do really like the idea of asymmetry
- 1:43:35of information in games and hidden information. I don't know if you've ever had
- 1:43:40the opportunity to be in a game or to watch a game where the players
- 1:43:45don't have complete information about what the other side is doing or even what they're
- 1:43:49doing, and it's amazing to see how people react to that and how their
- 1:43:55style of play changes. Does the urban nature of this game leads to a
- 1:44:00great attention when you play. Um, I think so because the urban environment
- 1:44:05is an intense one. It's far different from a game, a word game
- 1:44:15that takes place you know, in the North African desert or you know,
- 1:44:19you know field a field in Europe or or Britain or something like that.
- 1:44:25The urban environment is, it's tangled, it's intense. Uh, your radios
- 1:44:30don't work, your supply gets lost, there's civilians wandering around all over the
- 1:44:35place that you have to you have to mind, you don't know where the
- 1:44:40enemy is. Uh, it's it's intense, it's confusing, It's all of
- 1:44:46these these aspects of conflict, Uh that don't that are frustrating and unfair to
- 1:44:56or seem that way to a game player. Uh. That's another thing that
- 1:45:00attracts me to games that are set, you know, in an urban environment,
- 1:45:05is because they are that much more claustrophobic and intense that way. So
- 1:45:11one more question then, So you're you're heading out to Victoria towards the coast
- 1:45:15to the cabin, and you go around a corner the back door of the
- 1:45:19car flies open. Four of the games fly down a ravine into a river.
- 1:45:24And a swept away to posterity. Which game do you hope is sitting
- 1:45:28on the back seat of the car? I had to think about that.
- 1:45:31I think I think I'd save the goal set because unlike the other games,
- 1:45:36you can play go when it's raining or when the wind is blowing. It
- 1:45:40doesn't you know, it doesn't dissolve your game into pulp when it's raining and
- 1:45:45set ups a breeze and you can carry the rules around in your head.
- 1:45:49Excellent. So if people want to get hold of you, they want to
- 1:45:51know what you're up to, your new stuff and all of that, how
- 1:45:55can they go about doing that? Sure? Well, I have a web
- 1:46:00site where I talk about my game design projects and thoughts I have about games
- 1:46:04things that are going on. You can also download eight or nine of my
- 1:46:09games for free if you are interested in any of these topics that have spoken
- 1:46:13about. And the r L is br Train b r t r ai N
- 1:46:18dot WordPress dot com. And if that doesn't work, the name of the
- 1:46:24website is Ludic Futurism and my personal email if you want to contact me is
- 1:46:31Brian dot Train, br i N dot trii n at gmail dot com.
- 1:46:38Excellence Well, Brian Train Thank you very much. Thank you. This has
- 1:46:42been great. You can support the show in many ways. You can tell
- 1:46:45your friends, you can talk about it on social media. You can talk
- 1:46:47about it in your own blog, podcast, or video. You can support
- 1:46:50it directly by going to Patreon dot com, forward slash five g f D
- 1:46:54for a rolling donation, or for a one off donation, hitting the PayPal
- 1:46:57link at the bottom of the website five Games Doomsday dot com. It's these
- 1:47:00donations that keep the show going. Also, if you want to say something
- 1:47:03nice about the show, if you want to say something horrible about the show,
- 1:47:06can contact me on Twitter at five Games for Doomsday or send me an
- 1:47:11email at five Games for Doomsday at gmail dot com. If you want to
- 1:47:14join the discord, go to five Games for Doomsday dot com and follow the
- 1:47:16link there. And if I've managed to hop away from the half drunk bottles
- 1:47:20of mangla and the adverts for shit I don't want, I'll see you in
- 1:47:24two weeks for another five Games for Doomsday