Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Sandor Clegane (Game of Thrones)(2017 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:07Hey, deserving listeners. Just me today, I thought, in preparation for
- 0:12season seven of Game of Thrones, the TV show and HBO, I thought
- 0:16I would do a series of episodes on Game of Thrones. I've already done
- 0:21one on Circy earlier, and a year or two ago I did episodes on
- 0:28Jeoffrey and Ramsey. And so today I thought I would do an episode on
- 0:33Sandor Klagane, otherwise known as the Hound. Many many people, many of
- 0:38people have asked me to do an episode on the Hound. So here we
- 0:42go. I'm going to do a deep dive on him, his history before
- 0:47the books and the TV show start, also his story once the books begin
- 0:53and the TV show begins, and I will analyze as personality as we go,
- 0:57because I think he has a lot of interesting twists and turns in his
- 1:02history and his story that can inform us as to why he was the way
- 1:07that he was, and he was actually a very complex character. This is
- 1:11this Psychology in Seattle podcast. I'm your host, doctor Kirk Honda. I'm
- 1:15a professor, and I'm a therapist, and I'm also a Game of Thrones
- 1:21nerd. All Right, so this is a massive spoiler episode I'm gonna talk
- 1:26all the way through to the end of season six of the TV show and
- 1:30the end of book five of A Song of Ice and Fire. So if
- 1:37you don't want that to be spoiled, don't listen to this, go out
- 1:41and read the books and or watch the TV show and then come back here,
- 1:44all right. Sandor Klagang, otherwise known as the Hound. Sandor Klagane,
- 1:51is a member of House Klagang, which is a very close house to
- 1:57cast Rely Rock, which is near the west coast of West Ros. He
- 2:04is. He is the younger brother of the current head of the household Sir
- 2:08Gregor Klagane or the Mountain that rides. He's five years older. Gregor is
- 2:15the Mountain, is five years older than the Hound, and both the Mountain
- 2:21and the Hound are considered to be two of the most fierce and dangerous fighters
- 2:25in West ros. The reason why he is nicknamed the Hound is partially because
- 2:31he's fierce like a hound, and he's also unquestioningly obedient to his masters like
- 2:38a dog would be. And Clagane the house symbol is three dogs, so
- 2:46that's another reason why he's called the Hound. He is a large man.
- 2:52He's six foot six, same as the actor who plays him on TV,
- 2:57but he's not as big as his brother. His brother in the books is
- 3:00eight feet tall, and they sort of try to portray this in the TV
- 3:05show. But just the mad I mean, I think the tallest at eight
- 3:08feet that's that's a tall dude and large, right, so he's like just
- 3:15mammoth, you know, compare But the hound Sandor's large himself, but he's
- 3:21not as wide. He's more mobile than the mountain is and he often wears
- 3:29a helm that looks like a dog, and they portray this in the TV
- 3:36show pretty well. All right, So where does his life begin? Well,
- 3:39in the year twenty seventy, he's born and again he is born into
- 3:46the Klagane household, and he has an older brother who's five years older.
- 3:52And it's assumed that his older brother, Gregor, abused him throughout his life.
- 3:59And one part killer moment that Gregor abused Sander was his older brother threw
- 4:04away a toy, so Gregor's like, I'm done with this toy, and
- 4:10then Sandor, little Sandor, finds this toy and starts playing with it because
- 4:16he figured his older brother no longer wanted it. But then Gregor, the
- 4:21older brother, saw his younger brother playing with his old toy, and he
- 4:26got angry and he grabbed Sandor's head and smashed his face into a fire,
- 4:34a burning brazier. And this it was no just minor burn. It wasn't
- 4:42just like blisters. He burned part of his face off, and for the
- 4:47rest of his life, the left side of his face is described as being
- 4:51slick and black, and it's you know, poked with craters and has deep
- 4:58cracks in and it oozes red puss all the time. And his job bone
- 5:03is actually exposed. So he burnt this boy, his younger brother, so
- 5:10badly that his flesh was burnt off and never returned. So just imagine what
- 5:15that looks like that you can see his job bone and his ear was burnt
- 5:20off and there's just a hole sitting there. They didn't they don't portray this
- 5:25in the TV show, thank god, because it would be nasty. But
- 5:30just know that in the books it's a lot worse. It's pretty bad in
- 5:32the TV show, but in the books it's just you know, horrendous.
- 5:36So this experience for little Sander probably was dramatic in all likelihood, right,
- 5:45and probably resulted in PTSD, which results in him being afraid of fire throughout
- 5:50his entire life, and he had a massive hatred for his older brother,
- 5:56which we could see is justified his father. We should mention Gregor and Sanders's
- 6:02father covered up the shame of the Mountain's brutality by telling others that sanders bed
- 6:10caught on fire and that's how he burnt his face. And so it was
- 6:14a big secret, and they don't portray this in the TV show well enough,
- 6:17but it was extremely secret in terms of why Gregor's face was deformed.
- 6:24Everyone thought it was because he got his bed caught on fire as a child,
- 6:28but to a very small set of people, they knew the real truth,
- 6:33which was that Gregor burnt his face. So just imagine this one for
- 6:39a second. And you're a young boy, your brother purposely burns your face
- 6:46and almost kills you. It's one thing to say push your younger brother into
- 6:50a fire, which would be terrible, but it's another thing to grab I
- 6:56mean, if the Mountain is eight foot eight feet tall as an adult,
- 7:00imagine him as a younger boy. He was probably quite large then too,
- 7:05And just imagine your older brother grabbing your head and sticking it into a fire
- 7:13and holding it there long enough to melt your face off. That would be
- 7:18just terrible. And then your father tells everyone that it was just an accident
- 7:21and that you might be to blame because it was your bed that caught on
- 7:25fire, and as a young person, your face is burnt. Half of
- 7:31it's burnt off, which I'm just assuming was not attractive to other people,
- 7:38and other people probably ran away from him. No one wants to be your
- 7:41friend, no girl wants to hang out with you. You're alone for the
- 7:46rest of your life, all because your brother was upset that you were playing
- 7:50with one of his old toys that he threw away. You just imagine what
- 7:55that would do to your development and the way that you considered attachments because this,
- 7:59again, it wasn't a bully at school. This is your older brother
- 8:01who's supposed to have your back. And then presumably you blame your parents for
- 8:05not supporting you or trying to save you or anything. So this is the
- 8:11early childhood environment in which Sanders personality developed. Again, we can assume that
- 8:18Gregor was a constant threat to Sander, not just in this particular situation,
- 8:24and we can assume that Gregor regularly abused Sander without anyone there to help him.
- 8:31So Sander is in a constant place of fear of being harmed or even
- 8:39killed by a sadistic and aggressive, humongous older brother. So what does Sander
- 8:45do. Well, he learns that he has to be quiet. He can't
- 8:50talk, He needs to be silent so that he doesn't bother his older brother.
- 8:54And he learns how to obey orders to stay out of trouble. He's
- 8:56very good at obeying orders in the beginning of the storyline of the book,
- 9:01anyway, But deep down he hates everyone, which is justified because no one
- 9:09was there to help him as a child. And he learns that he has
- 9:11the stuff his feelings, his feelings of fear, and his feelings of trauma
- 9:16reactions, and his feelings of pain and anger, and he learns to avoid
- 9:20relationships with other people. Okay, so let's just keep that in mind as
- 9:28we move forward in the story. Now, another bit of his childhood that
- 9:33we could talk about is it's not clear, but in the books it's rumored
- 9:37that Sander and Gregor had a sister who died mysteriously, and it's rumored also
- 9:46that Gregor killed this sister for whatever reason. So, but either way,
- 9:54this would have been rough for him to have a sister and then to have
- 9:56her die, and maybe this is why he The two people he bonded with
- 10:01in the story were both little girls, Aria and Sansa. But more on
- 10:05that later. Okay, So the normal career or life for someone in Sander's
- 10:15position is to become a knight. He is a up and coming person in
- 10:24a somewhat well known house, one of the lesser houses near Cashley Rock for
- 10:28the Lanisters, and the normal track would be to try to become a knight,
- 10:37and that's how you get your fame, and that's how you maybe even
- 10:39make money, and that's how you get your honor and all that kind of
- 10:43stuff. And his older brother, Gregor, definitely followed in that path.
- 10:50His brother was knighted by Prince Regar Targeriam. This is before Robert's rebellion.
- 10:56When this happened, Sandor became extremely disillusioned about what it meant to be a
- 11:01knight. So as a child, Sander's like, Oh, I'm going to
- 11:05be a knight. I'm going to be sir, I'm going to be sir.
- 11:07Sandor it sounds great, and then his then the Prince Prince Regar knights
- 11:16Gregor, and Sander's like, you're knighting that guy. I thought that knights
- 11:22were good and chivalrous and honorable, and but my brother is dishonorable and sadistic,
- 11:28and he's a terrible human being. He's like the worst person on the
- 11:33planet as far as I can tell. And Prince Regar made him a knight.
- 11:37So from that day forward, Sander refused to be knighted, even though
- 11:41he could have been a knight if he wanted. Presumably, so this is
- 11:46a major turning point in his life. Instead of taking the typical road of
- 11:50working your way up the ladder in society, he decided to reject all of
- 11:54it. He decided he would concentrate on duty, but also on killing.
- 12:01He said, you know, killing is the sweetest thing or something. Another
- 12:05thing we can say about Sanders' personality development is that, according to birth order
- 12:11research, later born children, meaning that they're not the firstborn. Later born
- 12:16children sometimes find their identity by choosing a different path from their older siblings,
- 12:22particularly if the children are not given enough attachment security. The theory goes that
- 12:26if you deny children attachment security, they might resort to behaving within a very
- 12:33narrow set of behaviors, so they stick out as like the star or the
- 12:39bad apple, the scapegoat, or the smart one, or the athletic one,
- 12:43or the funny one or the cute one, and later borns, as
- 12:48their personality is developing, they look for new niches to fill so that they
- 12:54can get love and attention for that particular set of behaviors and identities. So,
- 13:01for instance, you have a family with parents that are struggling with one
- 13:05thing or another and they're not able to give the children enough attachment. The
- 13:09whole idea is is that if you give kids enough attachment security, they don't
- 13:13need to specialize in terms of their identities. They're just they have more flexibility
- 13:18and they can be more well rounded in their personality. But if you deny
- 13:22children that security, the children might resort to Okay, you know, the
- 13:26siblings sort of unconsciously decide that they're going to gravitate toward their own camp of
- 13:35identities and behaviors. And so if the firstborn child, for whatever reason,
- 13:41identifies as the conservative, good kid, the one who gets good grades,
- 13:48the one who's good at sports, then the next child in line again,
- 13:54if they're denied attachment security, will decide that they're not they're going to be
- 13:58bad, to be bad at school, and they're going to be bad at
- 14:01sports and that sort of thing. It sounds funny, but it's shown a
- 14:07lot when you actually look at family systems, and the idea goes is that
- 14:13every child wants attention, and if they don't get enough proper attachment security and
- 14:18proper love and proper attention, then they will get attention one way or the
- 14:22other. And sometimes kids will get attention through bad behavior. And so since
- 14:28Gregor had already established himself as the sadistic Night, Sandar was going to be
- 14:35the anti night, you know whatever. The opposite of the Night is not
- 14:39a bandit or a criminal, but sort of the anti night. And I
- 14:46think that's exactly what the Hound became. Okay, So now we're at the
- 14:50point of the Hound, or Sander Klagan being aged twelve, and this is
- 14:58when Robert's rebellion ha pins and during this time Sandor is a part of the
- 15:05Lanisters' men. So because House Clagane is actually really close to the Lanister House,
- 15:16it would make sense that they would be that they would be they would
- 15:22pledge fealty to the Lanisters. And so when Taiwan tricked the Mad King into
- 15:31thinking that Taiwan was coming to save the Mad King from Robert and Edward,
- 15:37Taiwan instead decided to sack the city to show his allegiance to King Robert because
- 15:45Taiwan figured that Robert was going to win. And during this time, young
- 15:52twelve year old Sander was a part of Taiwan's army. And when they sacked
- 15:56the city, this is when Sandor killed his first his first person. He
- 16:00killed someone during that time, and this was when Taiwan ordered his men to
- 16:06slaughter all the Targarians and slaughter a lot of people. And this was when
- 16:11the Mountain Gregor Sanders older brother, found his way into the where the chambers
- 16:22of Prince Agon and Princess Elia or Eliyah. I don't know how to pronounce
- 16:26it him, but anyway, the mountain killed the infant Prince Agon, son
- 16:33of Prince Regar, which would have been the future king. So this is
- 16:37Prince Agon would have been king. I think if so, Prince Regar was
- 16:41going to be king after the Mad King, if if I'm remembering right.
- 16:45And then Prince Agon would have been king after Prince Rigar. But anyway,
- 16:47the Mountain, under orders from Taiwan, broke in to the chambers and found
- 16:53the infant in a crib and picked him up and smashed Okay, just a
- 16:57little trigger warning here, there's gonna this section is going to have some not
- 17:03so good stuff, so you might want to skip forward five minutes if you
- 17:06want to avoid this. But anyway, the Mountain picks up Prince Agon from
- 17:10the crib and smashes his head against the wall and instantly killing him. And
- 17:17then the Mountain Gregor Klegane, finds Prince Elia or Eliyah and rapes and then
- 17:26kills her, supposedly with the infant's blood and brains still on his hands.
- 17:33This is all described in the book. I'm not making this up, so
- 17:36if you remember I so remember when Oberon Martel the Viper comes to King's landing
- 17:41and Tyrian is on trial for killing for killing Joffrey. This is eighteen years
- 17:48later, by the way Oberon Martel. So Tyrian says, I want I
- 17:55want to have trial by combat, and Circe picks the Mountain because the Mountain
- 18:04is one of the most badass you know, fighters of all time. Well,
- 18:11then Tyrian's like, who's gonna fight for me? And then over and
- 18:14Martell steps forward and says, I'll fight for you. Not because Oberen loves
- 18:18Tyrian, but because Oberen desperately wants to kill Gregor Colgane because Gregor Clagane raped
- 18:25and killed his sister. You know, this is when in the TV show
- 18:30and in the books, Oberen is during the trial by combat. He's like
- 18:34Elia Martel, Princess of Dorn, You raped her, you murdered her,
- 18:38you killed her children. And he's just saying that over and over again.
- 18:42And you know, this is a horrendous scene. This is the scene when
- 18:47Gregor splits Oberon's head open like a melon. Oh god, And all the
- 18:56while while he's toying with the mountain, you're just thinking, kill him,
- 19:00don't give him a chance to fight back. And of course he doesn't do
- 19:07that, and he does manage to fight back, and it's a terrible,
- 19:11terrible thing, all right, So what else can we say? Okay,
- 19:17So, right after Robert's rebellion and Robert becomes king, Gregor and Sanders's father
- 19:25dies in a hunting accident, which seems like a common way to go,
- 19:30since that's how King Robert went as well. But there are rumors that Gregor
- 19:36the Mountain killed his father so he could be head of the house. But
- 19:40there are a lot of bad rumors about the Mountain. There were rumors that
- 19:42the Mountain killed their sister too. There were also rumors at the Mountain had
- 19:48killed his first two wives. There were also rumors at the Mountain routinely killed
- 19:52as servants. There were confirmed rumors at the Mountain routinely raped women. But
- 20:00the other rumors could have just been for a fact, and the Mountain might
- 20:03have even liked those rumors, because people when they're afraid of you are not
- 20:07as good in combat, and so it's hard to know. But I wouldn't
- 20:11put it past Gregor to have killed his father and his sister and his wives.
- 20:18I mean, he certainly was a terrible person. But anyway, after
- 20:26the father Klagane dies, this makes Gregor head of the house, which is
- 20:30currently still true. Now. That must have not been very pleasant for Sander
- 20:37because before, presumably he could go to his father, you know, Sander
- 20:40could go to his father and say, please protect me from my brother.
- 20:41But now his brother's head of the house. So what does Sander do.
- 20:47Well, he runs away from the house and asked to be a part of
- 20:52the Lanister House. So here we have an example of how he copes with
- 20:57situations that are not going so well for him. He will run and try
- 21:03to join some other faction that he feels safer in, presumably, which he'll
- 21:10do again later, which we'll get into more in a second. Okay,
- 21:14So now this brings us in terms of history up to the times of the
- 21:19first book and the first episode of the TV show. He is now age
- 21:25about twenty seven or twenty eight, and Sandar is the bodyguard of Prince Jeoffrey,
- 21:33and Jeoffrey calls him Dog if you remember from the books and TV show.
- 21:38In the books, Circe says that the hound is a surrogate father for
- 21:45Jeoffrey, which I guess could have been a source of self esteem for Sander.
- 21:49He's like, well, I'm a surro good father that you know.
- 21:53Also, Sander is used to psychopaths, so Sander probably could handle Jeoffrey pretty
- 22:00well, since Jeoffrey was just another psychopath like the Mountain was. But Circe
- 22:06might have just been saying that Sander was a circuit father. For Jeoffrey as
- 22:10a way of saying that King Robert was not a good father to Jeoffrey,
- 22:14which was true. Okay, So in the first book, in the first
- 22:18season, Jeoffrey bullies Micah, the butcher's son, if you remember this,
- 22:23and Aria and her dire wolf, you know, save Micah and injure,
- 22:30injure Jeoffrey so and Aria and the dire Wolf run away and hide, and
- 22:37then the King sends men out to find Aria and the dire Wolf, and
- 22:42the Lanisters send the Hound to capture Micah. In the TV show, the
- 22:48hound catches Micah and splits him in two and he has some line to Edward
- 22:56like he didn't run fast enough or something like that. But anyway, for
- 23:00this reason, Aria Aria Stark later puts the hound or Sander Colgane on her
- 23:08list of people to assassinate. If you remember her at Nights, you know
- 23:14saying Gregor Colgane blah blah blah. So just to visit that list for a
- 23:21second. Her list changed over time because she would add and subtract people as
- 23:26time went on, but her list, her total list included Sir Gregor Clagane,
- 23:33but by the end of book five, she thinks that Gregor is dead,
- 23:38but in fact, Gregor's just a zombie Mountain. She also had Dunson
- 23:44on the list for stealing Gendre's helmet, and he's still alive as far as
- 23:48we know. She also had Poliver for stealing Needle her little sword, and
- 23:56Poliver was killed by the Hound in the at tavern. If you remember that,
- 24:02I think in the TV show she kills Pouliver, but I don't remember,
- 24:07okay. Chiswick For was also on the list for his participation participation in
- 24:12a gang rape, and Aria asks Jack and Hagar to kill him, and
- 24:18Jack and Agar does kill him because Jack and Hagar always kills people that he
- 24:22says he's gonna kill. She also had raf the Sweetling raft the Sweetling for
- 24:27killing Loamy Green green Hands, and Aria killed him. She also had the
- 24:33Tickler on the list. It's a nickname because he tortures people and she hated
- 24:42him, and Aria killed him in that tavern when Pouliver died. She also
- 24:48had the Hound or Gregor Kleigane on the list for killing Micah, but Aria
- 24:56later took him off the list because they became sort of friends. But then,
- 25:03if you know she he when Gregor was about to die skipping forward the
- 25:08story and he's like, please, you know, put me out of my
- 25:11misery. Aria denies him this, so she got revenge for Micah kind of
- 25:19in the end. Aria also had Sir Armory on the list for killing Urine
- 25:25and he died randomly. She also had Sir Ellan Payne for beheading her father,
- 25:30but Sir Ellen Payne is still alive. She also had Sir Maaron Trent
- 25:37on the list for killing Cirio Farrell the sword Dancer or water Dancer I can't
- 25:44remember, and Sir Marion Trent is still alive in the books, but in
- 25:48the TV show, Aria killed Sir Maaron Trent in the brothel if you remember
- 25:52that awesome scene. Aria also had Geoffrey on the list for ordering the execution
- 25:59of her father, and we all know that Jeoffrey is dead poisoned by Elena
- 26:04Terrell and Peter Baylish little Finger. She also has Circe on the list for
- 26:10her part in her father's death death and at the end of book five,
- 26:15Circe is still alive and kicking. And she also had Wees on the list
- 26:21for abusing Aria. And Aria asked Ja Jack and Nagar to kill him,
- 26:27and and he does kill him. So Aria is on a lot of people
- 26:33on our list, and not many of them are still alive. See,
- 26:37so Circe's still alive. Sirmaron Trent is still alive in the books, Sir
- 26:41Allen Payne is still alive, and Dunson is still alive as far as oh
- 26:47and Gregor is still you know, kind of alive. So out of I
- 26:52don't know ten or twelve people on our list, there's there's still six people
- 26:59left that she has. Well, she probably doesn't know Gregor is alive,
- 27:02so she still has a number. So circey anyway, Okay, getting back
- 27:07to Sander Cogaine. If you remember in the first season of the TV show,
- 27:15in the first book, there's Attorney, a tournament to celebrate Eduard becoming
- 27:18the hand of the King and also I think to celebrate Sansa's patrothal to Jeoffrey.
- 27:26In this Attorney, Sander is an awesome fighter and he beats Lord Renlee
- 27:33Brathian. If you remember Renley, he unhorses him in the joust. Then
- 27:37Sander defeats Sir Jamie even you know, he beats Jamie when he has two
- 27:45hands and Sandor went. So when if you remember this from the TV show,
- 27:52when Sir Lauris Terrell the Night of Flowers is about to be killed by
- 27:56the mountain, Sandor jumps in and saves Sir Lauris. It's at this moment
- 28:03that all of Sander's rage comes out and he is actually trying to They're actually
- 28:11trying to kill each other in this moment. But then King Robert commands the
- 28:15hound to stop, and the hound immediately stops, and so this is portraying
- 28:21the TV show really well. This shows how loyal Sander is to the King.
- 28:26Sir Lauris is super thankful, naturally that Sander saved his life, and
- 28:33since he's an honorable guy, Sir Lauris forfeits to Sander because Lauris and Sander
- 28:41were supposed to joust in the finals, because that was supposed to happen.
- 28:47But then Lauris is like, I forfeit the tourney to Sander, which is,
- 28:52you know, good guy, Lauris Lauris was, you know, I
- 28:56like that guy. This made Sandor Champion of the Attorney, which is a
- 29:00big deal. It's like winning the super Bowl or something. This was perhaps
- 29:04the first time in Sander's life, that everyone was cheering for him instead of
- 29:10turning away from him and his disfigurement. Even Sanse the soft little Sansa was
- 29:18cheering for him. And I speculate that this is when Sandor and his inner
- 29:25heartlight like the Grinch, when the heart started to grow and grow. I
- 29:30think this is the moment when Sander's heart began to grow because everyone was cheering
- 29:36for him. Everyone was saying what a great guy he was. He defeated
- 29:41his older brother and he saved the day, and he saved the night of
- 29:45flowers, and everyone's cheering and even Sansy's cheering for him, and I think
- 29:51that this opened his heart. Okay, so before we move on with the
- 29:56rest of this discussion, let's take a little break. Okay, we're back
- 30:07from the break. If you haven't already become a patron of the podcast,
- 30:10do so now. Do so now, especially if you're one of those people
- 30:15out there who was just sort of on the fence, like, oh,
- 30:17I thought about becoming patron, but then you know, just do it,
- 30:19Just do it, Just do it, man, just do it. I'm
- 30:23a shrink, so I know how to manipulate people through the podcast airwaves.
- 30:30Just go to your computer, become a patron. When people become patrons,
- 30:34we all win because then we all get us dedicate more time to this little
- 30:40thing, of this little podcast, and we get to make it better and
- 30:45better. And if for those of you who've been listening a long time,
- 30:48you know it's been getting better and better over time, and that's because we're
- 30:51all able to spend more time on it, which is totally because people have
- 30:53become patrons. So thank you so much for that. So go to patreon
- 30:59dot com. Become a patie of the podcast. Do it now, Do
- 31:03it now? Okay, So let's move on with Sander's story, all right.
- 31:11When Eduard attempts to arrest Serce for having illegitimate children, a bunch of
- 31:19bad guys, including Sandor, slaughtered Eduard's men. So just know that that
- 31:25was happening, but it could be hard to argue if you want to be
- 31:29on Sander's side, that Sander was just following orders like everybody else. Also,
- 31:36after Sir Bariston sell Me is dismissed from the King's Guard, he's the
- 31:41guy who ends up with denaries if you remember him, the older guy,
- 31:44Sir Barriston sell Me is dismissed. Jeoffrey replaces sell Me with Sandor, even
- 31:51though Sandor is not a knight, which was the custom. So Sandor became
- 31:56the first bodyguard of the king even though he's not a night, which is
- 32:00interesting. Sandor is often in charge of protecting Sansa as a result, who
- 32:07is initially terrified of Sandor. This is why I think Sandor's heart begins to
- 32:15even grow even more and he becomes even more human in the story because he
- 32:22is charged with really protecting Sansa. He seems to have a really have a
- 32:28soft spot in his heart for Sanda. He even tries to protect her from
- 32:31jeoffrey sadism, even though he is very loyal to Geoffrey and he's in his
- 32:39stunted, blunt way. He is often trying to help her adjust to the
- 32:45cutthroat world of King's Landing by telling her that people can't be trusted and that
- 32:51you know, everyone lies, and she has to protect herself. And so
- 32:55here we have a question. We have some questions. Is this because Sandor
- 33:00misses his sister who died when he was a child. Is it like Sander
- 33:06is trying to save his sister. Maybe he's even trying to in a he
- 33:09has a fantasy about saving his sister from his brother. And because we have
- 33:15a very similar situation here. As a child, he had Gregor, the
- 33:21sadistic person, and then his sister, who we could assume was not sadistic,
- 33:27and Sander liked his sister and probably was often trying to save his sister
- 33:32from his brother. And in this situation he has this sweet Sanse and then
- 33:37this sadistic Jeoffrey, and so he's caught in this triangle. Again. To
- 33:45me, this is when I realized in the books and in the TV show,
- 33:49this is when I realized that Sandor had a good heart deep down.
- 33:52You know, this was the first time because up until this point in the
- 33:55story, you're just like Sandor is a one bad as cold mfort. But
- 34:01this is when you realize, oh, he actually does have a heart.
- 34:06Okay, So in the books there's a fair amount of talking between Sandor and
- 34:10Sans, So I just thought i'd give you some quotes between the two of
- 34:15them. In one moment, Sandor says to Sans, killing is the sweetest
- 34:21thing there is unquote. I think in the TV show, Sanders says this
- 34:25to Ariya. But so Sanders says, killing is the sweetest thing there is.
- 34:31Sander's killed a lot of dudes by this point. Sandor, in another
- 34:37moment, says to Sansa, what do you think a night is for a
- 34:40girl? So this is when Sandor is trying to disabuse Sansa of her fanciful
- 34:46ideas of knighthood. And remember that Sandor hates knights, and particularly because his
- 34:52older brother is a knight. Right, okay, so quote, what do
- 34:57you think a night is for a girl? You think it's all taking favors
- 35:01from ladies and looking fine in gold plate. Knights are for killing. I
- 35:07killed my first man at twelve. I've lost count of how many I've killed
- 35:10since then. High lords with old names, fat rich men dressed in velvet
- 35:16knights puffed up like bladders with their honors. Yes, and women and children
- 35:22too. They're all meat, and I'm the butcher unquote many crickets, all
- 35:30right. Another conversation back and forth between Sander and sans Sander says, if
- 35:37there are gods, they made sheep so wolves could eat mutton, and they
- 35:42made the week for the strong to play with. Then Santa says, true
- 35:46knights protect the week. Then Sanders says, there are no true knights,
- 35:52no more than there are gods. If you can't protect yourself, die and
- 35:57get out of the way of those who can. Sharp steel and strong arms
- 36:00rule this world. Don't ever believe any different Sansa, You're awful, sandor
- 36:08I'm honest. It's the world. It's awful. I think this highlights just
- 36:14the awesome prose of George Martin. I think it's personally. I'm not a
- 36:20writer, so I don't know, but I imagine it's sort of hard to
- 36:23write dialogue in this sort of world. And I think that it's one of
- 36:30the best things about the books. And I think why the TV show works
- 36:34so well, because the dialogue is pretty great in the TV show. But
- 36:37when you read the books, every paragraph has stuff like this where you're just
- 36:42like, eh, and it's just it just it's so meaty, you know,
- 36:45there's so many little moments like that you can just sense, you know,
- 36:50Sansa is this innocent girl and she's she's just like, you're awful,
- 36:55and Sander's like, I'm honest, it's the world. It's awful. It's
- 37:00it's this turn of sentiments in I don't know how to discover not a literary
- 37:07critic, but I don't know, I like it. Okay, skipping four
- 37:13in the story, there's one time when we see Sander's personality emerging even more.
- 37:19Joffrey is super pissed about the defeat during the War of Five Kings,
- 37:24in which his uncle dies and maybe even Jamie gets captured. But anyway,
- 37:29Jeffrey is super pissed and Sance is right next to him, and so and
- 37:35you know, Santz's older brother is ruining Jeoffrey's life, and Jeffrey commands Sander
- 37:42Klagane to beat sans He turns to you dog beat Sansa, and Sander didn't
- 37:49know what to do, and he's just sitting there in the store, and
- 37:52you're like, oh my god, what's he gonna do? Is he gonna
- 37:53beat Sansa. He can't do that. That's that's not how this story is
- 37:58going. And he can't deny Jeoffrey and if he does, Jeffrey's gonna have
- 38:00him killed. But Sander is saved by the bell when someone randomly threw a
- 38:06melon at Sansa. So someone just you know, some other person in the
- 38:09court came out of nowhere and started abusing Sansa, which distracted Jeoffrey, and
- 38:15then Jeoffrey commanded other men to strip Sansa naked and beat her, which they
- 38:20did or started to do, and then Terrian arrived and saved everybody. And
- 38:23then Sander took his cloak off and put it on Sansa to give her to
- 38:31you know, clothe her. So we see here that Sandor has his own
- 38:37mind. He's starting to emerge. He is not following orders blindly anymore,
- 38:45all because of his fondness for Sansa. He's beginning to develop his own sense
- 38:50of self. He's no longer depending on masters to define who he is.
- 38:55Through his empathy for sans he is his inner strength and his inner identity.
- 39:04Throughout his life he is being abused to the point where he doesn't have time
- 39:08or the space to think about who he is. And then his and in
- 39:15this moment, his brother isn't around, so he's a little freer to decide,
- 39:22and he's had a lifetime of gaining his own power, and then he
- 39:25has empathy for Sansa, and this, you know, grows his heart,
- 39:31so to speak. Right moving forward, the story, as Stanis's army is
- 39:37approaching King's Landing, and it's thought by all the people that Stanis is gonna
- 39:43win. The people in King's Landing, the common folk are starting to freak
- 39:47out naturally, and also there's not enough food to go around because I think
- 39:53Tyrian was rationing the food so that the army could be fed or so,
- 39:58I can't remember. But the common people they riot when King Joffrey and others
- 40:04are walking in public, and in the confusion, Sansa has pulled from her
- 40:09horse and nearly raped and killed. But Sandor saves the day, and we
- 40:15see that in the TV show too. Moving forward the story, when Stanis's
- 40:20army attacks kings Landing during the Battle of the Black Water, Sandor is one
- 40:24of the key commanders who pushed back Stanis and his army. But when Tyrian
- 40:30uses wildfire to blow up all the ships, Sanders PTSD is triggered and he
- 40:37freaks out naturally. He runs away from the battle, even though Tyrian is
- 40:43commanding him to stay. At this point, I think this is a crossroads
- 40:47for Sanders. Sanders like I used to be. I used to identify as
- 40:52a loyal hound. I used to serve my master, but then this sweet
- 40:59Sansa came into my life, and I have empathy for her, just like
- 41:05my sister that I used to have and that you know, possibly my older
- 41:09brother killed her. And now I have a chance to save the girl and
- 41:16do something good in this world. And I can't do that by being the
- 41:22loyal hound anymore. It's been a lifetime of me being loyal and serving others.
- 41:30But I can't stand serving these sadistic assholes all the time. And I
- 41:37don't care about knighthood and I don't care about the latter of society. So
- 41:43and here I am in this battle of Blackwater, and there's fire all around
- 41:47me. I can't trust this world to protect me from the things that I'm
- 41:52afraid of. And he probably even thinks that more wildfire is going to be
- 41:59used, right because he's like, you know, okay, here's wildfire again.
- 42:01We haven't seen that in a while, and is it going to be
- 42:06used again? This is no good for my life. So again, he
- 42:10could he could have decided scided to stay and continue, as you know,
- 42:15somewhat glamorous life as the king's number one guard. But if he left,
- 42:22if he decided to go a different route, where would he go? He
- 42:27would be a hunted man. If he left right, because he would,
- 42:30it's like treason or not treason, but abandoning your post is probably, you
- 42:35know, death to someone in his position. And he he has an inkling
- 42:42to save Sansa from Jeoffrey, and so he he's probably and again I'm just
- 42:49taking all these guesses as fictional character, so he doesn't really exist. But
- 42:52if he did exist, he's probably sitting there thinking, Okay, wildfire,
- 42:57I'm out of here. That's the that's the straw that broke the camel's back.
- 43:00I'm out of here. And he runs away from the battle. Tyrrian's
- 43:04yelling at him, and he's thinking. He's thinking. He's thinking two things.
- 43:07I think, at this point, I'm going to get drunk, which
- 43:09he does because that's what a lot of people do when they have a trauma
- 43:13reaction, a fight or flight reaction. You often drink to calm or to
- 43:15numb yourself from the pain and the distress that you feel. But the second
- 43:21thing he's thinking is I'm leaving. I'm getting that, I'm gon get the
- 43:22f out of here, and I want to save Sansa. But if I
- 43:28save Sansa from Jeoffrey, where am I going to take her. So he's
- 43:31thinking, okay, I'll take I'll rescue Sansa, and I'll bring her to
- 43:37Rob Stark, the King of the North. Presumably I could even serve Rob
- 43:43instead of Geoffrey. I heard Rob is a good guy and Jeoffrey is a
- 43:46terrible person. So in the middle of the battle he runs away. He
- 43:50finds Booze gets drunk to soothe his distress, which is common for people with
- 43:54PTSD. Then he hides in Sants's room and when Sansa comes into her room,
- 44:00he emerges from the shadows, which freaks her out, and asks her
- 44:05to come with him to the North, but she refuses. Now this is
- 44:10people get angry at Sanse at this moment. It's like, just go with
- 44:14Sander, you should go with him. But mind you, she's thirteen at
- 44:17the time, so she's very young. She's engaged. She's engaged to marry
- 44:23the king of West Ros, which is a big deal. Right. I've
- 44:30seen people go through much worse things for much less on Survivor TV show,
- 44:36so it's not unheard of to say, well, yeah, my life sucks,
- 44:38but I'm going to be queen of everything. And then you are in
- 44:44the middle of this Battle of the Blackwater, and you're not sure how things
- 44:46are going to go. And then all of a sudden, this drunken,
- 44:49horrifying monster emerges from the shadows and asks you to come with him north.
- 44:54So I think she's ambivalent, but she says no, And in his sadness
- 45:04or something, Sander asks her to sing him a song, and she's freaking
- 45:09out. She just sings this random song for him, and then Sander rips
- 45:14off his king's guard cloaks, throws it on the ground, and leaves.
- 45:19And after Sander leaves, Aria Sansa misses Sander, and she keeps his cloak,
- 45:29his bloody cloak, because he was in the battle killing people's blood or
- 45:32she has his bloody his bloody cloak in a chest that she secretly keeps and
- 45:37sometimes looks at as a way of remembering Sandor and missing him. So Sander
- 45:45heads north, and sanders captured by the Brotherhood without Banners. This is when
- 45:52Sander meets Ariya, who was also captured by the Brotherhood. If you remember,
- 45:55they put the Brotherhood puts Sander on trial being a bad person and killing
- 46:00a bunch of people, but they don't have enough evidence so they decide to
- 46:05let the gods decide by having him do the trial by combat another trial by
- 46:09combat. You know, it's believed that if if you have trial by combat
- 46:13combat, the gods will make sure that the innocent person wins. And so
- 46:19Sander is made to fight Sir Barrick or Lord Barbarrick anyway, Barrick don Darien,
- 46:25and they say, if Sander wins, then the gods are saying that
- 46:29Sanders innocent. Now, normally Sander would easily kill Barrick, but Barrick pulls
- 46:35out a flaming blade, which again triggers Sanders PTSD and Sander has a tougher
- 46:43time, but Sander wins anyway and then kills Barrick Dundarian. But Barrick dun
- 46:47Darian's brought back to life and they let Sander go after taking all this money,
- 46:54you know, for the cause of the Brotherhood without Bannish. Sander later
- 46:59kidnap as Aria so he can ransom her to Rob Stark and maybe even work
- 47:05for rob Stark. And everyone knows where Rob Stark will be. Rob Stark
- 47:09will be at the Twins with the phrase for the wedding of Edmir Tully and
- 47:15Roslin Fray. So Sander and Aria set off for the Twins, and Aria
- 47:22at this point hates Sandor and thinks he's a monster, but at the same
- 47:27time she's like, well, I'm gonna be reunited with my brother. So
- 47:30great time passes and they arrive just in time for the Red wedding, and
- 47:36Rob's men are all getting drunk. King Rob, you know, King of
- 47:39the North Robs all the Stark men are getting drunk because there's a wedding for
- 47:44Edmire Tully and the Phrase Men, the evil Phrase Men, are staying sober,
- 47:52and then they when the signal goes, they slaughter Rob Stark, Rob
- 47:55Stark's wife, Rob Stark's mother and all the other They also kill all the
- 48:04Northman soldiers, and the Phrase also try to kill Sandor and Ariya, but
- 48:09Sander fights back and kills a bunch of them and they get away, and
- 48:15so they set off for the Veil to ransom Aria to Lisa Aaron, the
- 48:21Moon Door Lady if you remember her, because Lisa Aaron is related to Aria.
- 48:28It's Aria's ant. So this is where the books and the TV show
- 48:32branch off in terms of the story of sand Oracle Gain. In the books,
- 48:36Sandor and Aria never reached the veil because the path the veil is closed
- 48:39from snow, I think, and so they head off to one of Aria's
- 48:45a different Aria relative relatives, one of the Tulley's in the Riverlands. And
- 48:52when they go to a tavern, while Sandor is getting drunk because he's drinking
- 48:58more and more I'm gonna seeing due to his PTSD, they encounter some of
- 49:02Gregor's men and they fight, and Aria participates in this fight. Sander gets
- 49:09seriously injured and after a while after the fight, Sander realizes he's going to
- 49:15die and he sits down underneath a tree and he asks Aria to kill him
- 49:22in mercy, but she refuses and leaves him to die slowly, just like
- 49:28the TV show. In the TV show, it's a little different, they
- 49:31actually arrive at the veil and learn that Lisa had just died, so once
- 49:37again, they arrive too late, and that's when Aria laughs hysterically, and
- 49:42then they run into Brienn, who was looking for Aria. So this never
- 49:45happens in the books. Brian and Sandor mistakenly think that their enemies and so
- 49:53they fight. This is one of my favorite scenes in the TV show.
- 49:55The fight is amazing. Sometimes I'll just google this fight and watch it for
- 50:00fun. It's just so awesome. I've never seen a fight scene quite like
- 50:04this one. And as you know, Brion wins and Sandor is mortally wounded
- 50:09and falls off a cliff and at the bottom of the cliff he's dying and
- 50:15he asks Aria for mercy killing and she refuses, which is another great scene
- 50:22in the TV show. Okay, so there are rumors in the books that
- 50:30the Hound is still alive. Now in the TV show, we know that
- 50:34by season six, we know that he somehow survived as wounds and became a
- 50:38peaceful dude working with a bunch of hippies, and then some bad dudes killed
- 50:44all the hippies, and then Sandor joins the Brotherhood. But in the book
- 50:50there's all these rumors about this guy in the hound helm going around killing all
- 50:57these people, and there's room that the Brotherhood found him. And then there's
- 51:04another part of the book five in which a man tells Brienne that he personally
- 51:09witnessed the death of the Hound, so he came upon after Aria left.
- 51:14This man, I think a priest of some sort came upon the Hound and
- 51:17saw him die and then buried him and then left his helm on top of
- 51:22his grave. And then this man surmises that someone stole the helm and is
- 51:25using it to scare people. And then later in the story, but at
- 51:29this point you're thinking, well, maybe maybe the Hound is still alive.
- 51:31But then Brian finds a dude who is wearing Sandor's helm, and this confirms
- 51:38that it's just an impostor. But so just as you think, okay,
- 51:45the chapter of Sandra Gain is over, there are additional hints that Sandor might
- 51:51be alive somewhere. It's hard to tell. I personally think that George Martin
- 51:55has killed Sandor in the story, but he wants to keep some rumors about
- 52:01him being alive. And then the fans, of course want Sandor to be
- 52:06alive, and so everyone's sort of reading into it to find that he's still
- 52:10alive. Now, the fact that he came back to life in the TV
- 52:15show indicates that George Martin actually might have signed off on that, because that
- 52:20might be a storyline in the future. But I don't know, So let's
- 52:27speculate about the future of Sander Klegane the Hound. Moving forward into books,
- 52:35six and seven and moving forward into season seven and eight. Now, some
- 52:39people hate it when people speculate about the future, but I'm here to tell
- 52:43you that I'm almost always wrong when I speculate about the future of characters,
- 52:47So don't worry about anything being spoiled because I often am really bad at predicting
- 52:53where writers are going to go with things. But for me, I think
- 52:59that in the books, I think George Martin will keep him a mystery.
- 53:04That's the sort of thing that George Martin would do. But maybe George will
- 53:10have him with the Brotherhood, which would make sense because these men are,
- 53:16you know, basically good, but they reject all that Knighthood stuff just like
- 53:20Sander does. And the Brotherhood can bring people back from the dead, so
- 53:23there's that. But I think ultimately George Martin's going to leave him as a
- 53:29mystery. There's just too many other characters to focus on in in books six
- 53:34and seven, so I don't know. Now. In the TV show,
- 53:39I think Sandor is going to have an epic storyline, just like you know,
- 53:45Circe and John Snow and all the others, because they wouldn't have wasted
- 53:51precious time on him in season six, if he was just going to be
- 53:54a minor player in seasons seven and eight. So if I to speculate,
- 54:00I would predict that he and the rest of the Brotherhood are going to join
- 54:05forces with John Snow, which would bring Sander Black back, Sandor back to
- 54:12Sansa. And if the TV writers really wanted to make it epic, Sandor
- 54:17will sacrifice himself for Sansa somehow to save her life or something. And if
- 54:23the TV writers wanted to make it super epic, they would have him die
- 54:29while he's fighting his brother the Mountain Zombie. Or maybe Aria will somehow meet
- 54:35up with Sandor and they'll ride off into the sunset together so they can have
- 54:38fun adventures killing people who deserve to be killed. I don't know. There
- 54:44are so many possibilities. We'll see, all right. What can I say
- 54:47about his personality? Well, as as a young boy, he as I
- 54:54said before, he was probably like anyone else. He was probably he the
- 55:00same disposition as anybody else. He was probably nice and optimistic in all those
- 55:06things. But his brother's sadism and intimidation and abuse and terribleness made him not
- 55:14trust other people, and you know, particularly burning his face off and this
- 55:21burnt face was a constant reminder of the way in which his brother abused him
- 55:27and made him feel weak and small. So this was probably, you know,
- 55:35very important in his personality development. And if he didn't have an older
- 55:39brother like this, you just have to wonder what his personality would have been
- 55:43like. Also, Sander likely suffered from PTSD. There's not a ton of
- 55:49evidence of that in the story, but there's definite indications of it, because
- 55:58aggression can be a symptom OFTSD. I once had a client who in my
- 56:04early career who really taught me this. He he was eighteen nineteen and had
- 56:12been abused as a child and abandoned, and in his teenage years he got
- 56:17into a lot of trouble, naturally given his history, and he said that
- 56:23when he got into fights with people, he loved it. I remember,
- 56:30I remember, I just was asking, in this non judgmental way, just,
- 56:32you know, tell me more, what do you mean you love it?
- 56:34You know, what is it about it that you love? And trying
- 56:37to just listen to him. And I'll never forget he said, when I
- 56:43punch people like other boys in the face, it's like time slows down and
- 56:51I can see the blood spurting out of their mouth as I punched them,
- 56:54or out of their nose. It's and it's just the best feeling in the
- 57:00world just to see another person's face being bashed in. As a young person,
- 57:07and you know, I'm twenty seven at the time, I was terrified
- 57:12by this. I just thought, oh my god. But as I started
- 57:15to learn more about humans and trauma, I learned that this is a way
- 57:22of coping with trauma. When you're abused, you have a number of coping
- 57:29mechanisms. You can decide to become passive, and you can internalize all of
- 57:36your issues and become depressed and anxious. Another option available to you is you
- 57:40can externalize all of your anger and pain and you can take it out on
- 57:45other people, and you can become aggressive as a way of dealing with things.
- 57:51And this is how the cycle of abuse just perpetuates, because each time
- 57:54you abuse a child, they grow up, they have children, they have
- 57:59a greater likelihood of abusing their children, and then you know, the cycle
- 58:02just continues. Having said that, not everyone who's abused abuses their children.
- 58:07That's silly, but that's how the cycle, you know, perpetuates itself.
- 58:14So the idea is that Sandor was abused by his brother and later on in
- 58:22life he suffered from PTSD, and when he would have his PTSD triggered,
- 58:29he basically has the classic four options. He can fight, he can fight,
- 58:35he can freeze, or he can appease. And long ago he learned
- 58:39that running or freezing or appeasing didn't work. So he fought in response to
- 58:44being triggered. And he was a good fighter, so it was a self
- 58:49it was a source of self esteem and power for him to fight, and
- 58:52so when he was triggered, he would fight, and he made sure that
- 58:58he was good at fighting, which he was. But PTSD is is more
- 59:02complicated in that, and there's it's not it's not it's a very it's a
- 59:07very distressing condition. When someone's PTSD is triggered, people feel awful. They're
- 59:12very distressed for a long period of time. They feel their nervous system is
- 59:16in a state that that it's it does not feel good. It's like walking
- 59:21around in a constant state of fight or flight without any remedy, without anything
- 59:27to run away from, without anything to fight, and it doesn't feel good.
- 59:30And alcohol is a common source of comfort in that situation, and Sandor
- 59:32definitely drank a lot to cope with the symptoms, particularly after the Battle of
- 59:36Blackwater in which he experienced this explosive wildfire, and this drinking ultimately did him
- 59:45in because if he had been sober for his final battle in the books anyway,
- 59:49he might have survived it. Okay, another thing we can say about
- 59:54his personality and the TV show when he bumps into Brienne, his lack of
- 1:00:00trust results in him getting into a fight with her. You know, if
- 1:00:04he had just slowed down, and if he had listened to Brienne, he
- 1:00:08would have realized that she could be trusted and that she was on his side,
- 1:00:13they could have joined up together. Imagine that Brienne and Podrick and Aria
- 1:00:22and Sandor, they could have all traveled the countryside together and eventually met up
- 1:00:29with Rob. That would have been rad But because Sander's abusive childhood, it
- 1:00:37made it very difficult for him to trust anyone, particularly people who were powerful.
- 1:00:43So he likely transferred his issues with his older brother on to Brienne in
- 1:00:46that moment, and so he chose to fight her instead. And it just
- 1:00:52makes you sad for Sanders, and particularly a TV show you know, he's
- 1:00:57really a tragic character. The last thing I'll say about his personality is,
- 1:01:04again, as I've been talking about, the only people who managed to get
- 1:01:07him to open up were Sansa Anariya. This points to a possible relationship with
- 1:01:13his sister that we don't know anything about. But again, his sister died
- 1:01:16when he was very young, and whether or not Gregor, his older brother,
- 1:01:22killed his sister, I'm guessing that Gregor was at least abusive to her,
- 1:01:28and that Sender the Hound felt bonded to her and wanted to protect her,
- 1:01:32So he likely transferred all of his issues with his sister onto Sansa Aaria.
- 1:01:40Sansa and Aara were the only two people who managed to get him to
- 1:01:45open up, who managed to get him to be a human being and helped
- 1:01:52him to develop his own sense of self. When he was suffering during the
- 1:01:57Battle of the Blackwater, when all the wild fire was freaking him out,
- 1:02:00where did he go? Well, he went to Sants's room, and he
- 1:02:04went to sans and he said, let's go together. I can save you
- 1:02:07from this terrible place called King's Landing. When he was suffering with his wounds
- 1:02:14and about to die. What did he do? He begged Aria to put
- 1:02:19him out of his misery, and tragically both Sans and Aria rejected him.
- 1:02:25In these moments, it's it just makes me sad to think about that.
- 1:02:30He's truly a tragic character. Right. Well, that does it for that
- 1:02:37episode of psychology in Seattle. I'm going to do more episodes on Game of
- 1:02:40Thrones, so look out for that. Please take care of yourself because you
- 1:02:46deserve it. You really really deserve care from others and from yourself. Sad