Latest / Signal & Noise: Bringing Clarity to Media, Data, Tech and AI / Possible 2026 Day 1: AI, AdTech, CTV & the Future of Media | Signal & Noise Compilation
Transcript
- 0:03This is signal and noise, bringing clarity to data, tech
- 0:07and AI. I read along it here, signal and
- 0:15noise. We're coming close to the tail
- 0:17end of day number one at possible event in Miami.
- 0:20We're at the Mad Connect Mad mansion here, which is it's a
- 0:24nice spot. Do you agree?
- 0:26And I'm here with the one and only Sarah Caputo or as you say
- 0:29in Long Island, Caputo, right? I prefer Caputo.
- 0:31It's great to see you. Good to see you guys too.
- 0:35So we got a lot of great stuff to talk about today.
- 0:37You want, I think the conversation we had before,
- 0:39bring your own models, some new standards for Cummings.
- 0:42I you sounded really excited about us.
- 0:44I'm really keen to dig in. Yeah.
- 0:46I'm not sure how much you've been talking about that today,
- 0:48but the advertising protocols are coming and they're forming
- 0:52the committee's now. It's been something that's been
- 0:56open for about 6 weeks. So I've been consulting with
- 0:59different CE OS and founders on getting part of that process
- 1:02proactively. And it's actually going to break
- 1:05down everything from the model, which is anthropic.
- 1:08There is audience protocols, there's algorithm protocols as
- 1:13well as other measurement governance ideas that are coming
- 1:17to the table to really actually level set programmatic landscape
- 1:20for the first time in I think 12 to 15 years since the original
- 1:25standards were set by the IAB tech Lab and others.
- 1:28So it's very exciting. So these are separate from like
- 1:30the recent protocols that were like for like AD CP, for
- 1:33example, or or used to be the two Ucps.
- 1:35I know it's a little confusing for people, but like how?
- 1:37How did these standards relate to those?
- 1:39It's really crazy how many acronyms they've come up with.
- 1:42I actually studied for like 4 hours one night to try to
- 1:45actually digest it understand it.
- 1:47AD CP is actually a part of the AA and P AA and P is the broader
- 1:52overall acronym that they have created.
- 1:55So it's the Agentic Advertising Management Protocol and that was
- 1:59set at February 20th. And ACP is a subset of that.
- 2:01If I'm not mistaken exactly. And ADS contracts protocol which
- 2:05is ADS CP is actually the layer where we think and anticipate
- 2:09that the buyers are going to actually gain more control.
- 2:13Right now the front door to buy is typically the demand side
- 2:16platform, the DSP and that's where the brief goes in audience
- 2:19like how do you actually want this to show up?
- 2:22What type of inventory? There.
- 2:24Right, exactly. It's all the basics of how we
- 2:26run a campaign. So consider it the front door
- 2:29that actually is likely to push now to an agnostic layer above
- 2:35the DSP, even SSP. So DSP kind of goes headless
- 2:38then? And I mean, it's more visionary
- 2:42at this point in time, but in theory, yes, it's actually going
- 2:46to end up being the front door where everything lives in the
- 2:49buyer's hands or the agency's hands within the ad CP, which is
- 2:53the ads context protocol. So all of that can actually
- 2:55happen now diagnostically above the technology and I'm thinking
- 3:00through different elements like bringing your own algo or models
- 3:04that are available like a chalice solution.
- 3:07Chalice touch right now. Be able to actually come in and
- 3:10think about the power this will actually give the brand or the
- 3:13agency to actually create their own controls and use that
- 3:20consistently across all partners.
- 3:22Especially if you have a more less and modest brand, more
- 3:25aggressive budget, they're going to be able to actually take that
- 3:28and decision a little bit better, but with more
- 3:30transparency and control against theoretical.
- 3:33So sounds like a lot of functionality is currently in
- 3:36ADSP like Margaret side of it. And this is a trend that's been
- 3:38going on for a while with with companies like Chalice that are
- 3:40taking, you know, the bidding algorithms right and there and
- 3:43other people have launched needs to do that.
- 3:45So I see why this would be great for an advertiser, probably
- 3:49great for an agency who wants more flexibility.
- 3:51Like what does it do for the DSPS though?
- 3:53For the DSPS, I have an article coming out on this in the next
- 3:56few days where my theory is that the walled gardens stay walled
- 4:01and and frankly from a compliance perspective, the data
- 4:04needs to live within their ecosystem.
- 4:06It's really difficult to share that out regardless, but you
- 4:09think about Google and Amazon remaining the way they are, and
- 4:12even Meta falls into that category.
- 4:14They're not going to share anything different.
- 4:16In fact, they might. Owned and operated inventory
- 4:18anyway, right. You know, plus Audix extensions
- 4:21for us. But you're right.
- 4:21I mean, that's theirs. They control it.
- 4:23Yeah. And such a walled garden.
- 4:25OK, that makes sense for open web then.
- 4:27Open web, I think if you're not owning any first party data, and
- 4:31that doesn't even just mean the tech or the rails, I mean actual
- 4:33data. I actually think it becomes a
- 4:36little bit more, I don't want to say commoditized as the right
- 4:38term, but you have to really lean in.
- 4:40And this is where I've been trying to advise publicly on
- 4:43some of these, some of these independents that really lean
- 4:46into service and strategy that will still ultimately play a
- 4:50huge role in the agencies and the brands that need that arm.
- 4:54That extension of buying. How to measure how to actually
- 4:57optimize those campaigns and truly map that back to some sort
- 5:01of incremental return is going to be very important still.
- 5:05So you think about like the stock adapt, the trade dust
- 5:07models where they're really known for their gold level
- 5:09service standard. I would go all in on that and
- 5:13really over index on that because it's still very much
- 5:15needed. It's interesting I noticed that
- 5:17trend with DSPS like for example as a big global farm, I helped
- 5:20them with an in housing initiative over several years.
- 5:22They in house they did not add buying but like data tech a lot
- 5:25of process related to the agency was still doing the buys.
- 5:28They even in house the contracts and went paper direct with the
- 5:31platforms including the trade desk.
- 5:32What I was interesting was the The Trade Desk had almost like a
- 5:36forward deployed, I don't want to say engineer, but a forward
- 5:38deployed employee who really had a desk at in this time.
- 5:43It was pretty cool and it was, I thought it was a fantastic
- 5:46model. Stuff like if you need to
- 5:47differentiate, that's the way to do it.
- 5:49At Allstate, I had eight hours, I had DSP hours and I did that
- 5:53actually when I was CEO of midsize agency to make sure that
- 5:57there was an extension. They actually had space in our
- 5:59offices to do that exactly exact thing.
- 6:02That's smart. So I mean, you think about if
- 6:05their functionality migrates like OK, bidding algorithms,
- 6:08some decisioning if the whole front end of the DSP gets
- 6:13abstracted away, right, In theory, like their take rates
- 6:18will probably need to fall. But to your point, if they add
- 6:20wrap around versus body these other things, it could offset.
- 6:22But it's a different model though.
- 6:23I mean, I, I, I think it's going to be a pretty big shake up in
- 6:26the space because you're selling software that has a take rate
- 6:29versus selling consulting hours regardless whether there's time
- 6:34material or fixed fee with your margin is going to be, let's say
- 6:37you know, roughly 50% versus with software where your margin
- 6:40might be or SAS it's like 90%, right.
- 6:43It's my guess is it will be impacted though.
- 6:46Yeah. I that's actually where I think
- 6:48that buyers are and I always says are willing to pay more for
- 6:51service. And I think about that and how
- 6:53it equalizes on the back end for the brand and the end campaign.
- 6:56I don't care where the hours show up.
- 6:58If my agency is spending less because they're getting more
- 7:01from their desk. It all equalizes like effort and
- 7:03value out is how I consider this to be.
- 7:06So in terms of that economic pattern, you see that the
- 7:11independents do actually usually have a higher take rate because
- 7:15of that service. So ultimately, you're right,
- 7:17they have to make up for in some way, shape or form, but you can
- 7:21actually justify it to the brand or for the brand if they're, you
- 7:25know, basically contributing to what I call FT ES, the full time
- 7:28employee model, because that that's money that's being saved
- 7:30somewhere in the chain. Yeah, I mean, like there's a lot
- 7:33of debate now. I'm sure you're you're in the
- 7:35debates about like the FT it's only impacted right, As if a lot
- 7:38of these things are automated. There's I don't see a world
- 7:41where there were know people, but there certainly will be
- 7:43fewer people, which is probably a good thing anyway.
- 7:45Yeah. So even with Agentic and the
- 7:48front end of some of these DSPS that are launching, I had a
- 7:50conversation with someone from Goodway earlier and I was
- 7:53basically saying that there's so much that our teams can't even
- 7:57do to get into the supply where it's showing up, the ad load,
- 8:02the frequencies and other things that are actually in the data.
- 8:06If you dig enough that we can't actually again, optimized too to
- 8:12the extent that we should. So I'm hopeful that it's less
- 8:15time clicking buttons to actually set things up and, and
- 8:18more tedious tasks and we actually move it to signals,
- 8:22signal and noise. So the, the signals are there.
- 8:24They're actually becoming more granular and and at a scale
- 8:29we've never seen because of the LL NS ability to actually parse
- 8:32and pull that out. Well, I think that's Chalice
- 8:33just whole like not whole, but like a part of their proposition
- 8:36as I understand it. We had, we had Adam on the pod
- 8:39few weeks ago. Is that all of that incredibly
- 8:43rich signal on the supply side, which DSP is only because of the
- 8:46speed of the processing and the volume of the data.
- 8:48They can only take a small subset of it really in order to
- 8:51make their decisions like his, like his explanation was, well,
- 8:54we have all this rich signal, we're building LLM that we can
- 8:57play different places and this LLM is going to have all of that
- 9:00signal to me much better decisions on.
- 9:02So it makes sense what you're saying.
- 9:03Yeah, I'm hope, I hope so. And I hope we can inverse that
- 9:06also to contextual. That's something else that I
- 9:08find interesting. If you actually start to model
- 9:10around the behavioral signals that exempt exist we got for the
- 9:13signal doesn't exist because of the consent problem, an issue
- 9:16that we're all facing. So I think that there's ways to
- 9:18use that data and. Then you get away from the ID
- 9:19trap to like everything needs to be and even the way the DSP is
- 9:22like the way they buy a lot of people like are not super deep
- 9:24and take might not know this but like traffic with IDs
- 9:27prioritized by DSD. So I think having the pulling
- 9:29better contextual signals, it should be very powerful.
- 9:33Yeah, I believe so. And the data on what's actually
- 9:36missed in the targetable population is huge.
- 9:40There's a lot of good inventory that's clean, that actually fits
- 9:43the market audience that doesn't actually see the time of day.
- 9:46So it's inflating CPMS and constricting the supply where we
- 9:49really shouldn't. So hopefully opening this up a
- 9:51little bit will help us to solve that problem.
- 9:54What's the timeline for some of these protocols?
- 9:56But I'm not going to ask you for timeline for like DSPS that
- 9:59maybe you maybe you have a guess, but like, but just the
- 10:01timeline for these protocols being launched and like what are
- 10:04you seeing in terms of experimentation so far?
- 10:07They're actually starting now. I mean index exchange just
- 10:10launched part of buying within their own system different
- 10:15because they also the SSPS have quite a bit of signal and
- 10:18they're seeing parts of the ecosystem put dinner the
- 10:21identifying either from research and planning to the actual
- 10:24setup. Then you got the optimization
- 10:26and that never been an attribution on repeat on the
- 10:27back end. So those are the four cycles
- 10:29that I really, you know, brought my head around the terms of the
- 10:31milestones. Each of those are actually
- 10:33starting to become more agentic. So we've got talk to you, your
- 10:37data, you've got the set up on the front end, chatting with the
- 10:40interface in order to optimize. I I'm also consulting with a few
- 10:44of the measurement and optimization kind of partners
- 10:46that show you agnostically above the DSP what you should actually
- 10:51optimize to and why. And then you can also flip
- 10:54between the models. There's one partner called Sling
- 10:56Wave. I really love that's, that's got
- 10:58some interesting and tooling, but it's happening now.
- 11:01It's it's really like the Long story short, it is happening.
- 11:05So it's a matter of when we get to actual agent, agent and
- 11:08playing together the pieces, it's just going to be trial,
- 11:10error and time to kind of start to push it forward with more
- 11:13momentum. People don't realize even like,
- 11:16you know, programmatic, when that came out, there was a lot
- 11:18of, you know, started small. There was a lot of trial and
- 11:20error. It's not like it took off
- 11:21overnight and suddenly, you know, most traffic was and was
- 11:24programmatic or was didable and it took it took a while.
- 11:26So I that does not surprise me that we see something similar in
- 11:30terms maybe a little faster. I think, I think tech tech
- 11:32accelerates a little faster now. And certainly with AI, I've
- 11:35never seen things change as quickly.
- 11:37But you're right. I mean, difference between
- 11:40things being possible, you know, no pun intended, and I and
- 11:43things actually like being like being released now.
- 11:49Those are different things. Yeah, the accelerations there.
- 11:52But I you always have a test thoughtfully, always have a test
- 11:55budget and test thoughtfully. That's just my biggest advice.
- 11:57Honey, that's a team that's come up a lot today, Saturday, like
- 12:00the whole like back to basics. I go, OK, we like marketing
- 12:03really shouldn't like there's no magic formula like it's really
- 12:06should be about testing things and trying things and seeing
- 12:09what works and then seeing, OK, can things work better, right?
- 12:12And then maybe something works today, but it doesn't work
- 12:14tomorrow. Or maybe something worked
- 12:17yesterday and it it'll work next year.
- 12:19So I think constant testing and trying and, and being flexible
- 12:24and, and not, we're not trying to prove or disprove anything.
- 12:27We're just trying to see what works right?
- 12:29Right. I always love tests.
- 12:31It's always what I start with in any sort of brief, usually get
- 12:34campaigns and you're in this world, there is always a
- 12:38research brief to get to the media plan and then also the
- 12:41creative. But where does the measurement
- 12:43brief show up? And so I'm a huge proponent of
- 12:46three briefs onset, including the measurement brief.
- 12:49I like that testing and learning needs to be in there.
- 12:51Your source of truth needs to be in there.
- 12:53You've got micro and platform metrics and then you've got your
- 12:56out of platform metrics. And then you've got your BI
- 12:58layer, which is the layer I love to live is making sure that
- 13:01that's intersected as much as possible to truly understand
- 13:04incremental business. So the measurement brief is
- 13:06something that I really want people to take this
- 13:08conversation. Incrementality and you can't and
- 13:11that's another one of these words that I think it came to I
- 13:13maybe it started last year, but like get like getting OK, like
- 13:16proving that your marketing actually is effective and and
- 13:19that it works and be able to stand what works.
- 13:22What does it and having up where these work and maybe dialing
- 13:24back where they don't right or they work less well?
- 13:26Yeah, in platform and out of platform.
- 13:30And the last point on that is that these tools are starting to
- 13:32allow to do that. There's match market
- 13:34incrementalities to be very difficult to do to have to
- 13:37actually assess the data power lifts for all the things that
- 13:41you know are included in measurement and testing.
- 13:44There's actually platforms now that can automate that as long
- 13:46as they have access to your business intelligence to break
- 13:48it down and then give you the markets and and the test
- 13:51protocol. Any big trends in terms of like
- 13:54measurement? I know there's been a lot of
- 13:55people saying how, you know, platform platform metrics
- 13:59shouldn't be trusted up. There's a big debate on Twitter
- 14:02recently, but some people saying they should be like they're
- 14:04better because the signal straight from the other people
- 14:07say no, you really can't trust making me gained.
- 14:09Any thoughts there? I always start with a layered
- 14:12model, like a short term, mid term, long term.
- 14:15Long term is going to be more of your like longer trackers, you
- 14:18know, MMM, we'll sit into that. Sometimes it could be a little
- 14:22bit more frequent. But on the short term, I
- 14:24actually like to use the longer term and mid term tests that are
- 14:29done outside of the platform and basically incrementality test,
- 14:33which is my gold standard. I do those frequently, usually
- 14:36every three to six months to understand what haircut to take
- 14:39to the platform metrics so that you can still actually use the
- 14:42platform metrics that are over reporting.
- 14:45And then the second piece of that is just making sure that
- 14:47tagging and tracking is constantly checked and that
- 14:50you're not, you know, with any blind spots, double counting or
- 14:53over counting in ways that you can actually control.
- 14:56Because at the end of the day, they will over report in most
- 14:59cases. But if you know what haircut to
- 15:01take to that directional, you can actually make very quick
- 15:04decisions and then constantly do that on repeat so that you have
- 15:06this like checks and balances. It's not like, oh, they're good
- 15:09or they're not good. It's OK.
- 15:10Well, like there's something you can glean from these.
- 15:12Yeah. Don't you know, take everything
- 15:14with a grain of salt, like compare things to eliminate
- 15:18duplication over accounting and like, but they're like, I think
- 15:20when you when you look at several different, that's a
- 15:23reporting environments looking at the same data like, like when
- 15:28you extrapolate, you can find the truth.
- 15:29Yeah, you can definitely find directional results.
- 15:32And then from a source of truth perspective, it is the longer
- 15:35term tried and true testing. And just as long as everyone
- 15:39knows, going wide eyes, wide open, that sometimes as models
- 15:43take some time. So like new, for example, new
- 15:46platform forms and new partners are going to take time to ramp
- 15:49up regression modeling requires a lot of data, you know, and a
- 15:53lot of history. So those things will take some
- 15:56time. That's why I love an incubator
- 15:58or test budget. So it goes back to that other
- 16:00point is like don't actually put the test budget within the
- 16:03results that you should expect and don't and don't actually
- 16:06make really quick decisions on anything you're testing that's
- 16:08new because at the end of the day, sometimes that takes a
- 16:11little time. Well, this has been a great
- 16:14discussion. Before we go, I did want to
- 16:15comment on on the watch. That's that's vintage, right?
- 16:19In 1985, yeah, I. Love it, where'd you get it?
- 16:22My director of technology when I was CDO of the agency, gave it
- 16:25to me as a holiday gift. And his name's Chris Van Meter.
- 16:29Hello, Chris. And yeah, it's just a good
- 16:31reminder of how it outdated good tech gets so quickly and it's.
- 16:35And for those who can't see it, like what brand is that?
- 16:37Is that a cat I see outside? It has like the vintage like old
- 16:40school keyboard on it? I think I used to have seeing
- 16:43what I should have. It's probably worth a lot now.
- 16:44I should have saved. It I don't even know how people
- 16:46use it. The buttons are so small it's
- 16:48insane. You need like a pencil or.
- 16:51Yeah, small fingers that you had and it's still hard.
- 16:54Yeah. Well, this is a very a great
- 16:56discussion as always. Thanks for the insights.
- 16:59It was great to catch up and we will I'm sure we'll have you
- 17:01again and signal a noise for a longer form podcast soon, but
- 17:04this was a great little segment for possible.
- 17:05Thank you. I.
- 17:06Appreciate it. I'll see you at the dinner
- 17:07tonight for sure. This is real long appear signal
- 17:11and noise and we're at possible event in Miami and this is the
- 17:15end of day one. It's been a great day.
- 17:17We've had lots of great discussions about everything
- 17:19from of course AI, supply path optimization, attribution,
- 17:24targeting, measurement, you name it.
- 17:26To wrap up our day here, I've got a special guest, MK Marsden
- 17:29and you are the CEO of sales suit that you have a long and
- 17:33distinguished career in advertising and marketing that
- 17:35includes senior roles at lots of different companies, including
- 17:38Axiom Epsilon. I can rattle a bunch of names,
- 17:41but it's it's a cool career. I think we can probably touch
- 17:45that a little bit, but love to first start out by maybe telling
- 17:48the audience a little bit about yourself and your current role
- 17:51as as CEO of Sales Sleuth. OK, great.
- 17:53First of all, thank you for having me tonight.
- 17:56I appreciate this. I.
- 17:57Want you and brother shout out to Mark Sabatini for introducing
- 17:59us. Yeah, yeah.
- 18:00And that's all part of it, right?
- 18:02How you treat your network, trust that you build over
- 18:05decades and that you continue to build on.
- 18:08It's a big part of what we are doing right now at Sales Sleuth.
- 18:11But yeah, I started, I'm a computer scientist by accident.
- 18:14I wanted to be a vet. That didn't work.
- 18:16So I went into computers and I started in IT software.
- 18:20So one of the companies that I was involved with was Nobel.
- 18:23We went from 0 to $1.82 billion in seven years.
- 18:28And I thought this was magical and I believe that computers
- 18:32were going to make the world a better place and and everything
- 18:35was going to be automated. I grew up on the Jetsons.
- 18:37It was going to be fantastic. So I got tired of IT software
- 18:41and I was like, how do people use all these tools we're
- 18:43creating? So I went into Martech and
- 18:46they're more. Exciting than IT software.
- 18:48Well, yes and no. They're different, right?
- 18:51Like it's a, it's a different problem that you're solving.
- 18:53So I created transactional e-mail.
- 18:57I was like, Oh my God, we're in marketing and everybody's order
- 19:00confirm and shipping confirm is in Courier texts and is ugly and
- 19:04it's opened. Everybody opens it all the time.
- 19:07So let's invent that. And now what I'm looking at is
- 19:10just B to B sales is a mess and post COVID, we've lost
- 19:18procurement. You got 22 people involved in
- 19:21everybody. To thank for creating
- 19:23procurement. You're.
- 19:25Welcome. Yeah.
- 19:27Whoever thought we'd want procurement, right?
- 19:29It's just we can, we can go back to our politics from last night
- 19:33to talk about things we didn't think we would want that we got.
- 19:36But so now you've got 22 people involved in purchasing
- 19:41enterprise software or enterprise solutions.
- 19:44They don't even know how they buy as a company.
- 19:48And here are the poor sales reps with no proper insights.
- 19:53There's nothing in Salesforce. There's the lies we tell the
- 19:58finance department so that we don't get in trouble and we
- 20:01might get our Commission checks. So there's no intelligence
- 20:04tagging pages and putting predictive analytics.
- 20:07That's not intelligence, that's tagging so.
- 20:11I was sitting around doing it the old fashioned way and I was
- 20:14like, no, there's got to be a better answer.
- 20:16So we decided to build the first buyer centered sales
- 20:22intelligence solution for for enterprise and selling to
- 20:27salespeople is fantastic. It's.
- 20:29Interesting. I think that like you're looking
- 20:31at within Martech and AD tech and I think you could add sales
- 20:35tech, service tech, right? And these are distinct.
- 20:38I don't think they get enough coverage to be honest with you.
- 20:40And I think especially sales tech, I mean like because you
- 20:43think like what is considered sales tech?
- 20:44Like CRM kind of is, right? Yep.
- 20:46Could also put like like like tools like sixth sense, like
- 20:49lead management, things like that, sales automation, but it's
- 20:52not it's an area that is huge. It's like, I think,
- 20:55underappreciated. I would agree.
- 20:57And one of the things I I thought I would go raise a round
- 21:00of funding. BC's have no interest in sales
- 21:04productivity. So thinking about that.
- 21:07Why is that do you think? Got me right.
- 21:09Like you're investing in a company, wouldn't you want them
- 21:12to be able to sell their solution?
- 21:13Like wouldn't sales be the first?
- 21:16Like. How you ship software, right?
- 21:19I know. So isn't it the most interesting
- 21:21thing that we've never provided salespeople with the actual
- 21:26intelligence they need to do their function, and they're the
- 21:29most critical function to the growth of your business?
- 21:33Totally interesting to you think about like the best salespeople
- 21:36are so much more productive and better than the rest of the
- 21:40salespeople and like having worked with lots of sales people
- 21:44in my career like if a sales person is amazing, you'll put up
- 21:47with a lot, right Yeah, because they're so they're so good
- 21:50they're so effective So like what do you think in my
- 21:53understanding, a lot of the sales tech tools, OK, let's find
- 21:55out what these best people are doing Let's give them tools
- 21:58processes and and and solutions that can help the rest of the
- 22:02sales people be closer to that is like do you look.
- 22:05At it that way maybe or. So I look at when we created
- 22:10digital marketing, we created a landscape where we could see
- 22:16what buyers were consuming across the entire Internet.
- 22:21And what we hadn't created yet was a reader to read all of
- 22:26that. And with the large like getting
- 22:29so good, I mean think about it large language module, they're
- 22:33great at reading content. A lot of content very quickly,
- 22:36Sure, yeah. Right, so we read everything
- 22:39about the seller's account, like everything.
- 22:42Their SCC report, their Edgar report, what's said on Reddit,
- 22:46what's on Kaptara, what's on G2, what's in Quora, everything.
- 22:51And then what we do that other people won't do and a software
- 22:53engineer would never figure out is we score it against what the
- 22:58seller sells. And that's where my 40 years of
- 23:01sales expertise combined with my computer science work comes in.
- 23:06So why do we not have sales tools?
- 23:09Software engineers know nothing about sales.
- 23:13No disagreement. They don't, right?
- 23:15Right. And so it took a salesperson to
- 23:19stop and crush my brain for 18 months and get the help of
- 23:23people like you and Sabatini and and it took large language
- 23:27modules to get out of the sausage factory of first party
- 23:32data and 3rd party data to be able to like CE OS are
- 23:36publishing their mobile phone numbers that are in public.
- 23:42Domain, I've seen this more and more it it, I think it's
- 23:45essentially it's a really interesting development.
- 23:47I'm seeing CEOs put their numbers, put their emails and
- 23:50I'm I'm imagining people reach out to them, right?
- 23:52I mean, they must be, no? People like, listen, it's like
- 23:56his phone numbers in his signature line.
- 23:58What do you mean you haven't called them?
- 24:00Like what It's? Like it's published, but like
- 24:03the salesperson, I've no idea, no way how to get, no idea all
- 24:05of it. That's why.
- 24:06Right. Because it's like they can't
- 24:08imagine it. It's like it's right.
- 24:11There he put it on his LinkedIn profile, which apparently didn't
- 24:15go to right. Exactly.
- 24:17And partially it's because you're you're managing a book of
- 24:21business that's 203040 accounts. You're spending 20 hours a week
- 24:26updating Salesforce, attending training, doing QBRS, doing RFPs
- 24:30that you're never going to win that are cut paste from the last
- 24:33RFP that didn't win. So you're spending all this time
- 24:36do these things that aren't even material to yourself?
- 24:41At a large consulting firm I worked at, we RFPs were like,
- 24:45when you're on the bench, you would do RFP, respond RFPs.
- 24:47I remember the success rate was under 10%.
- 24:50It was just like a death March. You would do these 150 page
- 24:53responses. I remember like I'm not
- 24:56exaggerating, staying up all night to do these damn things.
- 24:58This is what a junior consultant and then knowing that like there
- 25:02was zero chance you could have waited.
- 25:03It was totally demoralizing. And you're giving away all your
- 25:06IP. You're giving away your pricing.
- 25:08You're giving away all your IP for nothing.
- 25:11You're getting nothing in return.
- 25:13In every RFP I've ever written, in any company I've ever LED,
- 25:18I've offered $100 in the RFP response.
- 25:21If you read this far, call me, I'll give.
- 25:24You $100. I have never paid it, never
- 25:27once, and I've done that. So you like you put at the end
- 25:30of the RFP spots like in the. To see part or governance,
- 25:35there's something you know that they're just like never going to
- 25:38read and they don't. And you're like, it's all insane
- 25:42theater. It's theater.
- 25:44What is it? Sales theater?
- 25:46I guess you would think it is right to say we're going to
- 25:48pretend that we want this and you're going to you're going to
- 25:50pretend that you care about making it.
- 25:52And you're going to pretend it matters.
- 25:53And I'm going to pretend that we're.
- 25:55Going to pretend we read it right and then we're going to
- 25:57award it to McKenzie anyway. Yeah, yeah, because he gets
- 26:00fired for that. Because the CEOs former McKenzie
- 26:03and he's best buddies with the partner, I mean.
- 26:05You just play golf with them. It's on his Facebook page.
- 26:07We could tell you that. Well, like I saw a lot of
- 26:10software cells too, right? It's like, oh, like as a sales
- 26:12person went golfing, you know, with or kid goes to school with
- 26:16the CE OS daughter. So totally right.
- 26:19Totally. So it is about relationships.
- 26:23But if you don't know what their problem is, like, imagine
- 26:27starting a relationship where you ask no questions of the
- 26:30other person. It's kind of like dating in
- 26:332026, right? Like it's bad, it doesn't lead
- 26:37to any. Sense it seems to be as bad.
- 26:39Right. It's bad.
- 26:41Rest assured. You know, how can you, how can
- 26:44you build anything? So if you're not doing
- 26:46discovery, if you don't have a good sense of what their
- 26:49business problem is, how they're buying, what they're worried
- 26:53about, what their existing technology is, you can't.
- 26:57And if you've got 22 people that you have to know on each
- 27:01account, and if you've got 40 accounts that you're accountable
- 27:04for, humans can't do this. So we took the human sales
- 27:09brain, the best of the human sales brain, and put it in a
- 27:12platform so salespeople could do what they're really good at.
- 27:15And is this the salesperson in any industry or there is there
- 27:19specific like vertical you're focusing on?
- 27:21So I haven't, and I got a lot of advice today at Possible to
- 27:24focus on verticals. It's a self learned system so.
- 27:29In theory it could work. Really.
- 27:31Anywhere in theory it can. The more complex the service
- 27:35offering and the more complex the purchasing, the better for
- 27:38us. We can make a bigger difference
- 27:41faster in complexity. So if you have one product and
- 27:4610 customers, you don't need me if you've got a product offering
- 27:51of 70 products. 10,000 customers.
- 27:54And 10,000 and there's 22 people on the purchase.
- 27:58If you're a data center guy, there's 40 people involved in
- 28:01the purchase of a data center. Where those people came from,
- 28:04who they have relationships with, what their bias?
- 28:07Just influencers. Some are, some can derail it,
- 28:11like totally like the legal guy or the privacy guy or the
- 28:13infosec person. Like they're not signing the
- 28:15check, but you know if, but if you're, if you piss them off,
- 28:18you're not, or you run afoul of them in any way, you're not
- 28:20going to win that deal. Totally, totally.
- 28:22And they're going to take great joy in derailing it at the end.
- 28:26So again, like people put, you know, 16 months of effort into
- 28:30it on the buy and sell side and you don't even know who the guy
- 28:34is. He's working at home and in, you
- 28:37know, Utah and you're working at home in Chicago and you've never
- 28:40met and you never will meet because they don't come to the
- 28:42sales meetings or the so the buyers don't even know.
- 28:46And then they get bamboozled. So they're not getting what they
- 28:50need. And everybody is just putting so
- 28:54much wasted energy in the process.
- 28:58What did you see today? I don't know how many sessions
- 29:01you got a chance to go to. I know you spent some time on
- 29:03site like anything you see jump out that you think is really
- 29:05interesting that change your perspective or that's maybe a
- 29:09cool trend that is coming this year.
- 29:12And I was here all day, so I didn't go to a single session.
- 29:14So I'm actually very interested in hearing.
- 29:16So I got really, really affirmed.
- 29:19I think I'm really on to something.
- 29:20I didn't bump into anybody who is doing what I'm doing.
- 29:24I didn't bump into anybody who said, oh, I don't need that.
- 29:28I didn't bump into anybody who's crushing quota, hitting their
- 29:32growth numbers, and everything's working.
- 29:36We have unbounded enthusiasm at these events, right?
- 29:42But it's like, OK, I have a widget and you have a thingy and
- 29:46I have a problem. No sort, no shortage of
- 29:48enthusiasm. That's right.
- 29:49No, no, no. It's unbounded.
- 29:50It's so loud in that lobby I can barely hear.
- 29:53I had a headache last year and I think I like for a couple days
- 29:57my hearing was slightly damaged it was so loud.
- 29:59It's worse than the last concert I went to, right?
- 30:02Like. Something about that, the volume
- 30:04of people stuffed in that like bar area, but then there's some
- 30:08of that ceiling like. Echoes.
- 30:10It doesn't. It's so freaking loud.
- 30:11Yeah, I remember it was terrible last year.
- 30:13So I went to the AI sessions, obviously, because that's what
- 30:17I'm interested in and I'm. We get helicopters here, we
- 30:21don't get loud conference. Yeah, it's the guys coming home
- 30:25from their hedge fund right there, $20 million houses in
- 30:28Miami. Again, like the way that we're
- 30:30using the tools, I always try to solve the problem from a brand
- 30:35new lands and a brand new design.
- 30:38What we seem to be doing is taking crappy data or a crappy
- 30:44original structure and doing more of it in AI versus sitting
- 30:49back and saying what is it really from a brand standpoint
- 30:54that we're trying to cause here and to whom and how do we do
- 30:59that right? We just seem to run to the next
- 31:02innovation And and I'm all about the pause, like stop, there's
- 31:07some, we have too much stuff. Well, I think as an industry we
- 31:11I agree with that. We love our trendy, cool,
- 31:14newest, shiniest objects. We chase after them incessantly
- 31:18and every every six months a year there is one, right?
- 31:20I mean, there's some new thing and you know, maybe AI being
- 31:24within AI there's like there's different like it'll be the
- 31:28Gentek AI like you know, and that just really started end of
- 31:33last year with some of the some of the LLM releases, right.
- 31:36Yeah, the way that we're calling a Gentek AI now started, you
- 31:41know, a couple of years ago. If you're my age, you've known
- 31:46about AI since before you started in your first year
- 31:50computer science class and you worked in predictive analytics
- 31:53and you worked in shape and machine learning.
- 31:56And so, you know, again, like here goes the marketing wagon of
- 32:02AI and agentic frameworks and, you know, workflows and things
- 32:06like that. And we've been doing a lot of
- 32:08this stuff for a really, really long time.
- 32:12Sometimes maybe the some of the old things we weren't wrong,
- 32:16right, and we shouldn't forget. That was interesting because I
- 32:19actually was AI want to say computer science drop, but I
- 32:25first year of college I studied computer science.
- 32:27It's funny. I remember this is back when it
- 32:29was like Cobalt Fortran Pascal, right?
- 32:31That's what I did. And then I, I didn't love it,
- 32:36I'll be honest, right? Which is I, yeah, I liked coding
- 32:39just for fun, but I just, I didn't like doing it for
- 32:41assignments, right? And then and then I was talking
- 32:44to my father about he's a nuclear, nuclear physicist.
- 32:46I remember he was saying how cobalt such a great language,
- 32:51you know, because it's a pre object based language.
- 32:53He was saying how he has programs that he wrote in the
- 32:5660s, mid to late 60s that he runs in the detectors or
- 33:00particle accelerators that work better than the stuff they had.
- 33:04I thought that was wild. Yeah, no.
- 33:05And it's true, right. So I started in the same
- 33:08environment that you did, my first company that I'm Canadian.
- 33:13The first company was an object oriented database and we sold it
- 33:17to the Americans and I end up in the States because my colleagues
- 33:20don't want to come. And then we regressed the
- 33:24sequel. That's like, why are we going
- 33:26backwards? And now we're just finally
- 33:29really into object oriented databases.
- 33:32This was 1986, right? We have these texts and then we
- 33:37go running around in the new VC funded shiny thing that has lots
- 33:44of marketing and we don't ask ourselves, is this, is this
- 33:50worth it? Is this the best thing?
- 33:51Is this the tool I need? And I'm a little bit worried.
- 33:55I'm writing, you know, some stuff on AI governance at the
- 33:58enterprise level and things. It feels a little bit like we
- 34:01put nuclear bombs and children's lunch pails, right?
- 34:06We don't let people build bridges without a certain degree
- 34:10of education certification. We don't let.
- 34:13Learn the hard way right? Like.
- 34:14Or we do, Yeah, they, I think. It was in Washington state or
- 34:18something like that, right? Or the boat hits it and
- 34:20everything collapses. We don't let you know.
- 34:23People fly airplanes, whether they're gas or electric,
- 34:28because. We've got the proper training.
- 34:29Certification, the proper training.
- 34:31Why are we letting people with no training write in large
- 34:36language modules and pretend they understand data and pretend
- 34:41that they understand the needs of the enterprise?
- 34:45It's dangerous. Look, getting back to sales, I
- 34:49mean I think that and I wrote this article about this
- 34:54published the end of last week about like this how I call the
- 34:58in the IRL in real life rebellion.
- 35:00How like the whole, what made me think about this was I remember
- 35:04I was doing a stint as I had a commercial for a software
- 35:06company last summer and we sent out thousands of emails to a
- 35:09really good list. We had thousands of opens, not a
- 35:12single click. And 1st I thought, OK, the
- 35:15emails broken, like the links are broken, something's wrong.
- 35:18I mean, having worked in e-mail marketing for years, I would
- 35:20probably sign insertion orders for billions of emails going out
- 35:23right back in the day because a lot of early media was realized
- 35:26that. So I knew a lot about e-mail
- 35:28marketing it as much as you, but I knew a lot about it.
- 35:31I remember think I was just, something's broken, right?
- 35:33Then we did all the testing. It wasn't.
- 35:35And I realized people, the way people interact with brands,
- 35:40work with companies, make decisions and what software
- 35:43they're going to buy and come into, what companies, which
- 35:44companies they want to work with has totally changed.
- 35:47And I think that this means that where the rubber meets Rd. is,
- 35:50yeah, marketing has to change. I think that's going to be more,
- 35:52maybe more pull than push, but also salespeople become more
- 35:55important. I agree.
- 35:56People are tuning out. You better have a good sales
- 35:58team, right? Yeah, for sure.
- 36:01And when the salesperson actually gets that, that meeting
- 36:06or that nanosecond I literally gave an elevator pitch coming
- 36:10down the building today in an elevator, in an elevator.
- 36:13I love it that I waited. For forever.
- 36:15And it was like my first real elevator pitch.
- 36:17I mean, the guy goes, what do you do?
- 36:20And I said, oh, I have. You asked, right?
- 36:22Yeah. I mean like and he's like.
- 36:24I need that. He's like, I got an ICP of 1000
- 36:28and things like that and like fantastic.
- 36:29How do I get in touch with you? Oh, take a picture of my
- 36:31LinkedIn profile. Boom.
- 36:33Connect with a guy done between floor 30 and ground I love.
- 36:38It. People want to talk to people
- 36:42about their business problems. They want to look you in the eye
- 36:46and know that they can fix it and you.
- 36:47Could have sent this guy 50 multi touch emails.
- 36:52You could have like lit them up on Facebook with the same
- 36:54audience. You could have like and he
- 36:56wouldn't care. Nope.
- 36:57Right. Would have tuned it out
- 36:58probably. Completely wild.
- 37:00Completely. So yes, I think salespeople are
- 37:03critical. I want to be the I want to be
- 37:07the champion for the sales, for the quota caring salesperson,
- 37:11account manager. Say it.
- 37:13You know we fire them. We ruined their careers.
- 37:17We, you know, they they had. We put up with them and then,
- 37:20but without them we wouldn't have any revenue.
- 37:22Totally, totally. That's funny.
- 37:24Well, this has been a really cool conversation.
- 37:26I'm glad we got to have you Pier in the pod and glad, glad I got
- 37:29to hang out with you and get to know you this time.
- 37:30And we would love to have you back for a longer forum
- 37:33discussion on signal and noise at a time soon.
- 37:37I would love to do that with you.
- 37:38Awesome. Thank you.
- 37:39Thank you, Longacre here for signal and noise at a possible
- 37:44event down in Miami. And it's a beautiful day.
- 37:47This is day #1 and I'm here with Oh Brianna.
- 37:52Alvarez. Alvarez, Lopez.
- 37:53It's a mouthful. I know it is.
- 37:54It's a lot I. Love it though my name is Rio,
- 37:58so I get I get a lot of it's a little easier, but great to have
- 38:02you here and I appreciate you coming down to the mid mansion
- 38:06here. Yeah, thanks for having me.
- 38:08Excited to be here today. So love to talk about #1 tell
- 38:13the viewers a little bit about you, your background, and the
- 38:17company needs to go that you're the CMO at I.
- 38:20Am yes. So I'm Aubriana and I've been in
- 38:25the data and AD tech space for a little over 15 years now.
- 38:30And so I started off with working with lots of of data,
- 38:34lots of IP intelligence and you know, that was working with
- 38:37advertisers and then I worked at Samsung ads for a while.
- 38:40So got my cut my teeth a little bit on the CTV side of things
- 38:44and. Was this right when you're kind
- 38:45of starting out Samsung ads? Yeah, it was pretty early days.
- 38:48We were, I was there kind of in the beginning of that transition
- 38:52and it was really interesting to see how that developed over
- 38:54time, right. And then was it was pre, pre 7
- 38:58figures for for that, you know, side of the business and all
- 39:01it's, it's massive. So it was really fun.
- 39:03It's. A huge revenue stream for them.
- 39:04So it must have been cool like during that like beginning and.
- 39:07It was, it was so fun because it was kind of like this family
- 39:12inside of this massive organization.
- 39:14And it was to see how that tracked and, you know, grew.
- 39:17It was really, really fun to be a part of.
- 39:18But something that, you know, overtime resonated is that
- 39:21there's a lot of data, right? Data was the new oil 20 years
- 39:24ago, and then that expanded and then now we have all of these
- 39:28tools and technologies that have come into this industry to make
- 39:31things more rich and, you know, better and more exciting.
- 39:35And, and I just saw, you know, there's still a gap in terms of
- 39:38like how things come together, right, Even within one
- 39:42organization, how do those tools and technologies come together?
- 39:45And so that's really, you know, the premise was at Ignicio,
- 39:48people should not be shipping spreadsheets and sending slacks
- 39:52at midnight. We still do that, right, a
- 39:55little bit. But you know, there's, there's
- 39:56things that we're like, we should not be paper pushers as
- 39:59human beings. And we have a lot of worth and,
- 40:02and getting back to human connection.
- 40:03And so the premise was there's a way to fix this.
- 40:06And I think we can use AI to do so.
- 40:07And so Agnesia was born. So looking at the problem
- 40:10statement, so it's like, let me see if I'm getting this right.
- 40:14So like all of these manual processes within ad tech, I
- 40:17mean, is that fair to say? You think that's what's broken
- 40:20or that's a place that where there's tons of room for that
- 40:22for improvement, right? Yes, I think fundamentally we
- 40:25have moved from less tools to so many more tools.
- 40:29However, those tools are very siloed and So what happens in
- 40:33one area of the business for an organization doesn't translate
- 40:37to the next. And so there's humans that are
- 40:39standing there and stitching things together.
- 40:41The analogy that I like to give is that I think ad tech is like
- 40:45an airport, let's call it Atlanta.
- 40:46You know, I was in Atlanta for 11 years.
- 40:50Nobody's faking, right? You know, you got, you have a
- 40:53train at the airport and there's no air traffic control.
- 40:56So imagine, you know, everything is having human handoffs.
- 41:00There's humans standing between different data sets, and they're
- 41:04directing that together, just like at an airport.
- 41:06And then on top of that, each of those tools or technologies are
- 41:10speaking different languages. So yes, fundamentally humans are
- 41:13stitching things together. Something that should be maybe 1
- 41:16Workflow is various and separated and takes weeks and
- 41:20months to do. You think about it from the
- 41:22planning, this groups of people doing planning, there's other
- 41:25groups of people doing activation, there's different
- 41:27people are probably involved in creative and audience
- 41:29development and 3rd party data that's and then different teams
- 41:33for measurement. You're right.
- 41:34It's like there's tons to hand off.
- 41:35Research and what we found is there's 53 days for the average
- 41:38campaign to go from conception to actually like lift off, and
- 41:43that's about 17 different people.
- 41:44Along timelines, a lot of people, I guess it's not
- 41:46surprising for anyone who works in media, but I think for people
- 41:49who don't have a media background, it's probably a
- 41:51shocking number. And then add in how many tools
- 41:53they're using. Maybe 2025?
- 41:56I'm not a math person, but if I were to like think about all the
- 41:59complexities there, I'm pretty sure it's a high number.
- 42:01Because it's a big number. Yeah, yeah.
- 42:02And that and the number of people, number of tools, the
- 42:07timeline itself. Like again, I don't think that's
- 42:10super shocked. Nothing could go wrong.
- 42:11Yeah, Never right. Yeah.
- 42:14I mean, everything about every handoff, there's an opportunity
- 42:16for something to go wrong. There's an opportunity for
- 42:18someone to do a fat finger mistake for something to put the
- 42:21wrong thing in here. Even I was working with one
- 42:23client just on looking at are the right is the right creative
- 42:28for the right ads serving up based on the metadata and like
- 42:31like like which which which Geo they're in which audience
- 42:35segment which which offer even like it would be shocking.
- 42:39There's no compliance can sometimes be really low.
- 42:42And not only from a compliance standpoint, but from an actual
- 42:46like operations standpoint. How often do you get that
- 42:49information back in real time, or in time enough to actually do
- 42:53something about that the campaign's already run?
- 42:56Sure. Yeah, Ad's already started,
- 42:57budget's already spent, right? Yeah, yeah.
- 43:00So yeah, I agreed. It's it's a big problem.
- 43:02So AII guess the premise here is AI opens up the possibility to
- 43:06finally do something about this, right?
- 43:08Well, yes and no. I'm glad you asked that
- 43:11question. I think, yes, I think there's
- 43:15the ability for AI to orchestrate and when it's done
- 43:18in the right way, there is I think a lot of endless benefits
- 43:21to this industry. Where I think we're getting it
- 43:23wrong right this second though, is that the conception maybe is
- 43:28that AI just helps everybody move faster.
- 43:30But AI in the setup and the way that we have things in this
- 43:34industry today is just chaos at machine speed, right?
- 43:38Like we are just providing yet another tool, yet another
- 43:41technology, yet there's no operational layer that's
- 43:44stitching those AI tools and technology together.
- 43:47So unless there's an operational layer or orchestration layer to
- 43:50bring it all together, I think there's still a big gap.
- 43:55Who do you think's going to like?
- 43:57OK, so you have the different tools.
- 43:58So it sounds like the tools are going to stay there, but
- 44:00there'll be a layer built on top of them that like, you know,
- 44:03they can connect to that by MCP server.
- 44:05Then there'll be some kind of a gentic plane almost on top.
- 44:09Like how? Like is this something that in
- 44:13your opinion a brand should own, an agency should own?
- 44:16Would this be a platform thing? Like what?
- 44:18What was? What would be the?
- 44:20Where do you think this sits and resides?
- 44:21Or does it not matter? I think it really does matter.
- 44:25One of the most important things I think is where it sits.
- 44:27So who owns it? Do I think a brand, an agency, a
- 44:31data platform should own an operational layer?
- 44:33Absolutely. And I think the reason why it
- 44:36needs to be owned as anybody who has any type of proprietor data
- 44:39or is bringing in client data brand assets, they need to have
- 44:42some level of control. Now who owns it and how it's
- 44:46owned it is more important. So is it owned specifically
- 44:50within their own one client cloud or is it something that
- 44:53they're shipping data out to? I don't think that anybody is
- 44:55ready to do that, right? You don't want to give up that
- 44:58control and governance, so AI that.
- 45:00Should be brand for sure. Well, nobody does.
- 45:02I mean retention of what is the your bread and butter or your,
- 45:07you know, you don't want to be giving that over to anybody.
- 45:11And so that was the premise that we built Agnesia with this
- 45:14thing. You know, we certainly want our
- 45:16clients to have speed, but speed without governance and
- 45:19efficiency is not really a win. Is it fair to say that a lot of
- 45:23the stuff being done in AI like the governance, the governance
- 45:27is where it should be in your opinion?
- 45:28I don't think governance is where it should be in most
- 45:31cases, but there's a big spectrum of how companies are
- 45:35incorporating AI. Some are just like, no, we don't
- 45:38want to do it. Some are like, let's test
- 45:40everything, but we don't really have a plan for how that's going
- 45:42to roll out. I think that governance is not
- 45:45the antithesis to speed, honestly.
- 45:47It's really what the unlock is. So if you have an idea, what we
- 45:50do with ignicio is if you have an idea of how you want your
- 45:53governance to be, that's the way that your setup should be from
- 45:55the get go. Once you have that governance in
- 45:57place, it creates trust. And you can run fast.
- 45:59Right. Yeah.
- 45:59So when the CMO trusts that you have an agentic layer and
- 46:02operating system that's making the choices that are best for
- 46:05your brand, then you're going to be able to move with agility.
- 46:08But whenever you're kind of stuck in governance, post tool
- 46:13integration, that's a tough spot to be in.
- 46:16Who the users of of Agesia are going to be at these media
- 46:19buyers on the agency side and the brand side maybe both for
- 46:22brands of in house certain things like who do you see like
- 46:25being the people using this? There's a few different Icps, if
- 46:28you will, right? There's a few different hands on
- 46:30keyboard users and varieties. I'll give a couple of different
- 46:33examples. We work a lot with data
- 46:34platforms. So you think about, you know,
- 46:37companies that are providing, let's say, audience data.
- 46:39The way that that audience data is built and the way that they
- 46:42bring that in comes from a lot of different data streams.
- 46:44Perhaps they have an SDK, perhaps they have some type of
- 46:48panel data that they're bringing in.
- 46:50And all that data has to be enriched.
- 46:51It needs to be normalized. It needs to fit with a structure
- 46:53taxonomy. And so the way that that process
- 46:56happens, you know, you have data analysts and engineers typically
- 46:59pulling that together. Well, that's the use case where
- 47:01a data analyst or somebody who sits on that side would use
- 47:05ignicio to pull all of that together.
- 47:07And now instead of having, you know, a team of 10, perhaps they
- 47:09have one that can oversee a team of 10 agents that can pull those
- 47:12things together. Another use case would certainly
- 47:15be on the media planning side. As you brought up Rio, you know
- 47:17you've got what planners they want to have one, how do I very
- 47:21quickly and effectively respond to these RF is because sometimes
- 47:25it's the first, the first one that responds they get right.
- 47:29And so how do I be really quick and effective and how do I
- 47:32utilize my historical data, my historical campaign data, brands
- 47:35that I've worked on, products that I have available and fill
- 47:38that out without having to rely on humans respond in one 2-3
- 47:42days. Sometimes that's just the gap
- 47:43that gets the business right. And so that's another key area.
- 47:48And then I would say finally on the brand side, yes, we're
- 47:50starting to see more of insights, right?
- 47:53So how do I effectively measure this across all of the different
- 47:57measurement tools and technologies that I have?
- 47:59But I'm one key place that I can quickly and easily ask questions
- 48:03in natural language where I don't need to do sequel queries
- 48:06to find out something. Or how do I leverage insights
- 48:09that I don't even need even know exists there, right?
- 48:12Like what are hidden audiences that I should be going after
- 48:15that I'm not leveraging? So I think a lot on on that
- 48:17capability is, is using a niche to as well.
- 48:21See as AI starting to automate a lot of these processes, like
- 48:24where do you see the role of of people and humans in this
- 48:27process? Do you do you think that the
- 48:29whole thing eventually just because automated and there's
- 48:31almost no people? Do you think people remain
- 48:33heavily involved or it's too early to even know for sure yet?
- 48:37I firmly believe that humans will always be part of this
- 48:41industry. I think one of the beautiful
- 48:43things about being in this industry is connecting with the
- 48:45great humans that we get. To because.
- 48:48They are, you know, because let's face it, we're not like
- 48:51saving children or even puppies here.
- 48:53We are selling advertising, right?
- 48:54But I think that it's so important that we maintain that
- 48:57human connection. What I think AI does when it's
- 49:00used the right way, especially with agnesia, the way we think
- 49:02about this is that it frees them up to actually be strategic.
- 49:05I think we live in this world where we're constantly in this
- 49:10response frame of mind. We don't have enough time to
- 49:13ponder, to think and to maybe allow our our minds to linger a
- 49:17little bit about the what ifs for clients, right, for use
- 49:20cases. And this is really what I think
- 49:23is an unlock for us. It's.
- 49:23Interesting you bring it up, but I because the 11 criticism I've
- 49:27been reading a lot recently about AI as well.
- 49:28If you use AI, your brain is going to atrophy because you're
- 49:32not going to be doing certain things.
- 49:34And OK, maybe there's an argument for that, But I I think
- 49:38I tend to agree with your point, which is actually saying
- 49:40opposite saying like, I even think about the way we were on
- 49:43this podcast. There's no way we could do this
- 49:47with so few people and all the moving parts without a lot of
- 49:49AI. Now, AI sometimes isn't perfect.
- 49:51Like the discussion got essentially got your title
- 49:53wrong, right? So it does make mistakes
- 49:55sometimes. But when I think of all of the
- 49:58documents it prepares, briefs, summaries, incredible
- 50:03recommendations for questions that will come.
- 50:05We could do that in our own, but it just take longer, right?
- 50:07So we use AI to assist all that. I do think it frees us.
- 50:10So I think I was just looking at this anecdotally, this one
- 50:13example, like you know, from running the podcast, I think it
- 50:15does free us up to do is to do more strategic things.
- 50:19I'm not not now. I do think people tend to prefer
- 50:22or gravitate towards doing the things they like to do.
- 50:26So I think for certain people who like operational things, it
- 50:29may seem more of a threat, but I think people who like to think
- 50:31strategically, use their Gray matter, solve the big problems,
- 50:34I think it's a become like, I agree with you.
- 50:36Well, I mean, let me just step away from like founder CMO role
- 50:40for a second. I think that it's a refinement
- 50:43right of of my thinking process and and strategy.
- 50:48So we've lived with this inner dialogue our entire lives, but
- 50:52now having something to kind of process that inner dialogue with
- 50:56just a little bit when it comes to your ideation sometimes is
- 51:00the thing that takes your idea from, you know, 2 to 10, right?
- 51:04And, and I, I believe that that is where the humans are always
- 51:08going to be in the loop. I use it all the time to to, you
- 51:11know, refine this ideas. It's a terrible idea and you
- 51:13don't want to have that conversation with a real human
- 51:15all the time. Sometimes you just need what
- 51:18other, you know, challenge this, play the devil's advocate to me,
- 51:20right? And I think that there's a, a
- 51:23place for that because sometimes it just gets your mind, you
- 51:26know, sparked into another, another dimension of what could
- 51:29be, what should be. And I think that very much
- 51:32applies in an industry that is fundamentally creative, right?
- 51:36How we've taken the creativity a little bit away from what we do
- 51:40in some aspects. And I think that we, we have the
- 51:42ability to get that back. So I don't know, I would push
- 51:45back on that a little bit. You know, I think that we did
- 51:50stray from creativity. I think this obsession with
- 51:55vanity metrics, performance, I mean, which, you know, pushing
- 51:59people through a funnel, we, we've talked to other people
- 52:01about this today too, that they maybe, maybe it went a little
- 52:04too far. I guess that's how the Internet
- 52:06got wired and, and that's what we, we trained ourselves to do.
- 52:09But focusing more on creativity, on messaging and it helps.
- 52:14That's great. But I think you're right.
- 52:15I mean, I'm seeing people focus on it more.
- 52:17And the people that use AI the best, I think almost
- 52:20paradoxically, are the ones who tend to be the most creative and
- 52:24have the most experience. I I find that like what they're
- 52:27getting is an output from using an AI using less an LLM.
- 52:31It is qualitatively much better than something that you know.
- 52:35Someone who doesn't know how to write a prompt, doesn't have the
- 52:37background to use as an input is going to get out of it.
- 52:41Yeah, and I feel like it's a little less about the prompt
- 52:43because are there people who are going to have their roles
- 52:49replaced by AII? Would be a miss to to say
- 52:53there's not like there is there is going to.
- 52:55Be every automation rate thing about like telephone operators
- 52:58don't exist anymore, right? I mean, and you know, I don't
- 53:00think anyone's bemoaning that. So yeah, continues.
- 53:02No. So I do think that that's going
- 53:04to happen, but there's an opportunity right now to figure
- 53:07out what does that mean for your area of expertise.
- 53:10And I think when you own control or narrative or input, you
- 53:16fundamentally can step into a leadership, you know, role into
- 53:20that area. So whether that's in operations
- 53:23or whether that's in creative, whether that's in storytelling,
- 53:26audiences planning or measurement and insights,
- 53:28there's there is a lot of of, I would say like white space.
- 53:33Yeah. I agree.
- 53:34I also think certain jobs, I mean most jobs if not all jobs
- 53:39will be impacted and will change right?
- 53:41So many tasks will be automated using.
- 53:42But what I think it's interesting to like there's the
- 53:46there's the example people give out radiologists, right?
- 53:48How there was a prediction that machine learning would
- 53:51completely wipe out radiologists.
- 53:52And they're actually more radiologists employed now.
- 53:54And part of that is there was a huge pent up demand for
- 53:57radiologists. It was just unmet.
- 53:59And then OK, well, like this unlocked a lot more, it made
- 54:02them much more productive. So guess what?
- 54:04There's actually the unmet demand is now, you know, more
- 54:09being met than it was for I think with certain things like
- 54:11engineering, like they're, as we're finding, OK, a lot of most
- 54:14coding is now done. I think more than half of coding
- 54:18is now done with AI, right? But there's, I think there's
- 54:19probably more, just as much, not more demand for engineers.
- 54:22I mean, I know this debate about that, but I, that's how I think
- 54:26there's a lot of pent up demand for that, that as an output like
- 54:29writing code, right? So my guess is they'll probably
- 54:32be more. So I will see.
- 54:33It may impact hiring, maybe junior roles, but I think the
- 54:36jury's still out. We don't even know.
- 54:38Yeah, I'm not sure that we know. I think there's going to be
- 54:40shifts for sure. But how that how that pans out
- 54:44I'm interested to see. Well, you're definitely in an
- 54:47exciting space. I am rooting for you and I'll be
- 54:50keen to follow your updates and see how the CEO progresses and,
- 54:55and all the all the news, all the news you have about new
- 54:59features, new additions, client wins or Brianna, thanks so much
- 55:02for coming and spending some time with us today as it was a
- 55:04fun discussion and I look forward to our next.
- 55:06One thank you so much for you. Real long here for signal and
- 55:09noise and this is possible events in Miami and we're in the
- 55:14beginning day #1 and I've got a special guest, Pete Blackdaw,
- 55:17who is the founder and CEO of Brand Ranked AI.
- 55:20So great to be here. Beautiful day in Miami, huh?
- 55:25Yeah, what a. Great setup.
- 55:27It is a nice setup. I'm not going to go back.
- 55:30I can't blame you. So shout out to the Mad Connect
- 55:33crew for giving us this incredible location here on the
- 55:35rooftop. So people excited to get you
- 55:38here to talk about your company, what you're doing.
- 55:42You know, it's a hot space right now.
- 55:44And love to maybe I think when we were talking before this,
- 55:47before this, we are centering on trust and not being kind of a
- 55:50new currency that is incredibly and maybe increasingly important
- 55:54now, love, maybe we can start the conversation now.
- 55:56Love your thoughts on it. I think the way to think about
- 55:59that is take a step back and just say why are these cancer
- 56:03engines, some call them lol, why are they so popular to the to
- 56:09the tune of like 2.55 billion props a day?
- 56:13And I think they're seeing that hockey sick growth because
- 56:18consumers are incredibly. Satisfied with what they're
- 56:20getting. And the responses are trusted.
- 56:24It's not that there aren't hallucinations or misinformation
- 56:28here and there, but generally there's a lot of happy consumers
- 56:32that are getting fantastic results, so good that they're
- 56:36not always clicking. In fact, that's kind of creating
- 56:38a lot of turmoil in the industry.
- 56:40And so, you know, trust is everything in this environment.
- 56:43And you've got these LLMS that are trying to continue to win
- 56:48the loyalty and the continued usage.
- 56:50Of these consumers. And you know, that presents a
- 56:53lot of challenges for brands in terms of how do you show up in
- 56:56that type of environment and how do you show up credibly.
- 57:00I think what's different about answers versus search is that I
- 57:03think search, you could game it. A lot more.
- 57:06For you can manipulate it, you could everyone sizes to a step
- 57:09ahead of or two ahead of Google, right?
- 57:11They're always adjusting it but it.
- 57:12Became a bit. Of a tragedy to comments
- 57:14everyone was trying to game the system so you never really knew
- 57:17what was organic versus aid and this is an environment where all
- 57:21of the answer engines. In fact, there's almost, I mean
- 57:23bloody wars between Anthropic and Chachi T to almost see who
- 57:27can be the purest. You know who could be the least
- 57:29corrupted by? We all saw the ads on a Super
- 57:33Bowl, right? They built on a real insight,
- 57:34right? It's like I, you know, the
- 57:35consumers are like, what the hell is this?
- 57:38And so, yeah, So I think kind of preserving that trust is really
- 57:41critical. And then brands need to figure
- 57:43out how do you build credibility in that model?
- 57:47And it's not an overnight thing. They've got to do it over time.
- 57:52What? It's like, how is Brandon AI
- 57:54doing that? Can you maybe explain to the the
- 57:56viewers? Because it's, it's a space
- 57:58that's nascent is changing quickly.
- 58:00And you're right, like like like so fundamentally, this is my
- 58:04second trust startup. My first startup was called
- 58:07planetfeedback.com. We sold it to Nielsen and it
- 58:10kind of did a similar thing where we metered social media
- 58:14consumer feedback and it's all about the consumer in power.
- 58:18Same model here where we are measuring what the answered
- 58:21engines are saying about brands. We're fundamentally measuring
- 58:26answer share. And we're looking at, I'd say
- 58:28our core metric is our metrics roll up into a brand health and
- 58:33trust scorecard, which we believe and we know is kind of
- 58:36predictive to business outcomes. And we have 3 building blocks
- 58:40visibility. Do you show up vulnerability?
- 58:43How do you show up? Because oftentimes you can be
- 58:45visible, but the story is really negative and so it just pushes
- 58:49the concern away. And then readiness, which is
- 58:51like, do you know how to market to algorithms?
- 58:54And what we do? Is we have about 80 clients and
- 58:57we will test 200 Trump's per day for answering against those
- 59:04three different variables and it's infinitely revealing a
- 59:09brand value you can understanding where you have
- 59:12weaknesses, where you have long. Term.
- 59:13Issues to fix and and it's works across the different LLMS like
- 59:19you'll we measure you know, 678 of them and they all think
- 59:23differently. They're like different TikTok
- 59:25influencers. They all have their own
- 59:28personality, so to speak. Right?
- 59:31College radical. They're very righteous.
- 59:33They stick it to the man. They tend to default to ethics.
- 59:37If they think you're bsing on sustainability, they'll call you
- 59:40out. They'll find it to a Pentagon.
- 59:42What to do? If I remember right, weren't
- 59:43they? Yeah.
- 59:43They ran us in trouble there. Yeah, sure.
- 59:45Research you know they may be buying Super Bowl ads but
- 59:49they're not they're probably the last ones that are going to
- 59:51integrate advertising into their core model and they can afford
- 59:54to do that because they have a great subscription that's BB
- 59:56model too right and rock is a little bit all over the map.
- 1:00:00They're hard to predict but they're edgy for sure.
- 1:00:02Chachi BT is kind of straight down the middle deep sea cause a
- 1:00:05much broader distribution of Asian sources, which is really
- 1:00:08interesting because if you say what's the best skin care
- 1:00:11product there's a very good chance you're going to get a
- 1:00:13product from Korea. IBK beauty, right yeah, yeah.
- 1:00:16So that that. Makes that really interesting.
- 1:00:18And then perplexity tends to, you know, they're very into
- 1:00:23citations and they're still trying to figure out their
- 1:00:25model. So to some extent their
- 1:00:26responses have changed quite a bit.
- 1:00:29So yeah, we, we, we, we, we keep track on them.
- 1:00:32And brands cannot afford not to know because here here's what's
- 1:00:36critical. It's not just consumers that are
- 1:00:38looking at this. Like every single retailer is
- 1:00:43setting up teams to analyze brands before they pitch their
- 1:00:46products. Every financial analyst, every
- 1:00:48journalist, every NGO, every determined.
- 1:00:50Detractor is using. LLMS as a CHEAT SHEET.
- 1:00:54To learn about brands. So there's a lot of different
- 1:00:56dimensions. You got your buyers that are now
- 1:00:58using it before they buy and you got these influencers that are
- 1:01:00kind of addicted to it. So they can sound.
- 1:01:03Smarter about the brands, but they're often digging up dirt
- 1:01:06interesting or digging up things that you know that maybe aren't
- 1:01:09totally accurate. That's it.
- 1:01:11So you think about like people are using the web for all those
- 1:01:15things today. This is just a new way of access
- 1:01:17to information in a curated way where it's an answer engines
- 1:01:19giving it back to you so you can see what you'd want it to be.
- 1:01:21You'd want to know what these things are saying.
- 1:01:23If you're Brad different than search.
- 1:01:24So search you were competing for one. 10 blue links and you
- 1:01:28could. Then kind of make your choice
- 1:01:29about what you thought was most relevant here.
- 1:01:32You've got everything rolled up like a brand smoothie.
- 1:01:35They're kind of taking all these different elements and they're
- 1:01:37kind of blending it together into what is largely perceived
- 1:01:40as a single sparks of truth. And you said hallucinations.
- 1:01:44There are there are negatives out there, but generally they're
- 1:01:47doing a very good job of bringing credible synthesized
- 1:01:52answers to consumers that are almost like good enough where
- 1:01:55they're like, I don't even need to click.
- 1:01:57Yeah. And the hallucinations have got,
- 1:01:59I've minimized over time too. I mean, the hallucinations have
- 1:02:01minimized. I mean, I think it's under 5%.
- 1:02:03I mean, I think if you use them correctly, you know, you'll
- 1:02:05verify things anyway. So I think that I think that is
- 1:02:07a little overblown. Can I be honest?
- 1:02:10And I think it's a controllable too.
- 1:02:11Listen, brands, you know, one of the most important issues for
- 1:02:15brands that understand is readiness, which is like, do you
- 1:02:18know how to embark into algorithms?
- 1:02:19And I would say, you know, if I looked at all the brands that
- 1:02:21are possible, I'd say despite all the talk about a guy.
- 1:02:25Only about 20% of them are. Truly AI ready.
- 1:02:29Do they really know how to market the algorithm?
- 1:02:31Then one of the very first things I do, but I sit to when I
- 1:02:33talk to a brand or CMO, especially the ones that are
- 1:02:36waxy and Co addict about AII go to their website and I type in a
- 1:02:40really obvious question like, you know, tell me about your
- 1:02:42product. How does your product work?
- 1:02:44What's in your product? Blank, blank, blank, blank, slap
- 1:02:47in the face. And so brands today are 99%
- 1:02:52optimized for conversion, not for curiosity.
- 1:02:55And that is where the digital industry has evolved.
- 1:02:58And I felt a lot of pressure when I was at Nestle, but it's
- 1:03:01led to a certain like cultural blindness to marketers when
- 1:03:05we've become answer illiterate. So the world's biggest
- 1:03:08advertising that spend the most money and to talk to most about
- 1:03:12emotional bonding, they do not know how to answer questions on
- 1:03:15their own media, which is the right?
- 1:03:16Because what we learned across thousands and thousands of
- 1:03:20audits is that your brand websites are the number one
- 1:03:22influencer. Of your answer.
- 1:03:24Share those things almost need to be re architected so we spent
- 1:03:272530 years architecting everything for conversions and
- 1:03:30for the funnel but now like with with AI and AI search is
- 1:03:34completely changing that right the full circle so when I first
- 1:03:37started remember the early. Days.
- 1:03:40We also, blissfully and innocently.
- 1:03:42Called it interactive. Marketing and so our first
- 1:03:44instinct was like, oh, we're going to be able to have an
- 1:03:47exchange signal and signal out. Consumers are going to ask us
- 1:03:50questions. In fact, a lot of the early
- 1:03:52innovations when I created the first interactive marketing
- 1:03:55team, the PNG, we have things like Pampers Parenting
- 1:03:58Institute, Thai, you know, stain detective, they're all very like
- 1:04:02ask a question, get a response and then what happened is that.
- 1:04:06We moved very aggressively to. Digital targeting at scale and a
- 1:04:10lot of that worked, a lot of that was based on algorithms,
- 1:04:13but we kind of lost the high touch and then as Ecrommers came
- 1:04:17around, everything was just about optimized for conversion
- 1:04:21and so that left a lot of collateral damage.
- 1:04:23Now you've got these LLMS, if you really think about it step
- 1:04:26up, they have become the most consumer centric vehicles in the
- 1:04:30history of marketing. They are elegant, friction free,
- 1:04:34ad free, multilingual, multimodal, empathetic, and it's
- 1:04:39just the beginning, right? And they're only going to get
- 1:04:41better. Yeah, and what I.
- 1:04:43Often tell Simo it's like. This is a consumer expectations
- 1:04:47replication, not an AI run. In brands, if they really want
- 1:04:51to be content ready, they've got almost like think about like
- 1:04:54what are the consumer needs? Like what will consumer want to
- 1:04:57know about my brand and then build the content.
- 1:05:00And that's how you influence the algorithms.
- 1:05:02Most brands, when I say they're only 20% AI optimized, they
- 1:05:06haven't even started to build the book of truth or they're
- 1:05:09heavily relying on outside parties.
- 1:05:11But the good news about LLMS, they will give brands the
- 1:05:13benefit of the doubt, especially if anything is even
- 1:05:16directionally negative crisis recall, you know, they try to
- 1:05:22give a balanced answer to find something negative.
- 1:05:24It'll usually explain it and I'll usually can written
- 1:05:26something. That's been my experience.
- 1:05:28Where? Else would you go like it?
- 1:05:30Like help is becoming one of the biggest uses?
- 1:05:33Like yes, third parties like Myo Clinic, those are critical, but
- 1:05:37like the original manufacturer of the drugs is.
- 1:05:40Probably going to have. The best instructions on how to
- 1:05:43use them right and so yeah so if I were an agency, I would be
- 1:05:48starting a whole new business and like literally re
- 1:05:50architecting brand websites, making them, you know, content
- 1:05:53liquidity. I would be, I would be thinking
- 1:05:57about the assets that have the content that don't get read by
- 1:06:01AI. So for example we work with a
- 1:06:03lot. Of clients a lot of.
- 1:06:03Clients are trying to make sure that they get full
- 1:06:06sustainability scores. They put a lot of effort into
- 1:06:08it. They promised the street it all
- 1:06:10the time and we'll analyze them and say, Oh my gosh, your scores
- 1:06:13are really low. And there's another reason why
- 1:06:16they're just not submitting it to the the end pins, are they?
- 1:06:20This is like where the is like dysfunctional.
- 1:06:22You got the you haven't used you took the time to make the
- 1:06:25content. A lot of the carpom groups to
- 1:06:27really check the box off compliance.
- 1:06:29We did it. They're not thinking about going
- 1:06:31to get. Read by the LLMS. Then you got
- 1:06:33the marketers. That are almost trying to game
- 1:06:34the system and so I mean think you have to game the system you
- 1:06:37just to make sure that you're that you're getting the credit
- 1:06:40you deserve and that's kind of what we do We'll we'll do these.
- 1:06:43Audits and. We'll say, you know, I think
- 1:06:45you're better than this. You should be getting better
- 1:06:47product, product, you know, better credit for product
- 1:06:49performance being sustainable. And here's what you need to do.
- 1:06:54You need to overhaul your FAQs. You need to re architect your
- 1:06:57website. You need to think more about
- 1:06:59content liquidity, not PDF's. And then we'll sometimes see
- 1:07:02results in a matter of weeks. But it does require
- 1:07:06organizational agility. This is why this is so much
- 1:07:09bigger than the search team. A lot of the search teams have
- 1:07:12kind of taken the mantle of AEO. That's not enough.
- 1:07:14You need the CMO to orchestrate this because it's very, it's
- 1:07:19kind of a governance issue that we're getting picky.
- 1:07:22They may have the content already, but it needs to be
- 1:07:25maybe taken from APDF and put in, put onto a website.
- 1:07:28And they need to make sure that they have all the hooks into
- 1:07:32these LLMS and they have a strategy for connecting with
- 1:07:34them and updating them. You're right.
- 1:07:36I mean, it's more of a, it's a just more of a big C
- 1:07:38communication issue right then. And it's even more complex than
- 1:07:42that. So I'm giving a big speech to
- 1:07:43one of the largest health companies on Wednesday.
- 1:07:46And the title of the speech is R&D is the new Market.
- 1:07:49And you may say what, Peter, you're on drugs.
- 1:07:50What are you talking about? The reality is it the LLMS,
- 1:07:54especially in our topic, but even ChatGPT, they cut through
- 1:07:57the span and the slogans to the substance.
- 1:07:59So the brands that market their science to the algorithms went
- 1:08:05so they're so smart, they will literally be able to know.
- 1:08:08That's interesting. That must be so challenging for
- 1:08:10let's say a global pharma because Rd. runs completely
- 1:08:13separately right from the commercial or which is sales
- 1:08:15marketing or from, I mean it's a common marketing silos insights
- 1:08:20and markets think differently about this.
- 1:08:22That's a really good point taking their academic Rd.
- 1:08:27articles and we have made them more liquid so they are more
- 1:08:31available. And then those companies have
- 1:08:32gotten higher product performance scores because what
- 1:08:36is happening like if the key is not just to be visible, it's to
- 1:08:39be recommended. What makes you recommended you
- 1:08:42have to be the best and you have to kind of fall into this
- 1:08:45definition of of value like one of the biggest risks to brands
- 1:08:49right now, especially in like the.
- 1:08:51Consumer. Goods.
- 1:08:51Area. And against, I guess risking
- 1:08:55consumer goods. Surprising is that I'll just, I
- 1:09:00don't know, go ahead. Private label.
- 1:09:02Private label is showing up like crazy because the algorithms are
- 1:09:05so good at figuring out, OK, this competitor to Tide is 90%
- 1:09:10of the thing, OK, at 40% of the price.
- 1:09:13So they're not going all the way to price.
- 1:09:15But there's the bots are so good at knowing that it's
- 1:09:18statistically almost it'll suggest you'll start it up to
- 1:09:21you right away. Yeah.
- 1:09:23And in fact a lot of the manufacturers like like Kroger
- 1:09:26for example. Has.
- 1:09:27Private label product, they're actually better than a lot of
- 1:09:29manufacturers on greed. So you've got a lot of consumers
- 1:09:31that are like the Costco ones are excellent right there.
- 1:09:33They're like, I want good products, good value, but they
- 1:09:36got to be sustainable. And so this is where life's
- 1:09:38going to get really, really tricky.
- 1:09:40And So what I've been telling brands like you have really got
- 1:09:43to get your act together in justifying your premium in the
- 1:09:46age of AI. That's why exactly say this
- 1:09:48isn't an SCO. Well, I think then I think
- 1:09:51advertising has to probably come into at some point because
- 1:09:53retail media, that was the issue too, right?
- 1:09:54But obviously you can, you can advertise in, you can advertise
- 1:09:58your brand, right? So which was I think the way I'm
- 1:10:01telling is advertising is not going to necessarily change your
- 1:10:06organic answer. That's the trick.
- 1:10:08Now some will believe that it will.
- 1:10:11And we got all sorts of models that are emerging.
- 1:10:14Amazon's got one that's sponsored inside the prompt or
- 1:10:17you know, chat TVT has got one ostensibly around Google's a
- 1:10:21little bit fuzzy. They might be the ones that kind
- 1:10:23of get away because they've gotten away with a pretty
- 1:10:26blended approach. But but again, in the world of
- 1:10:28consumer expectations, I'm not sure there will be a high
- 1:10:31tolerance for nothing. So this take you, they need to
- 1:10:35mail this. And if they, and if they don't
- 1:10:37like, they're going to like they're not going to be
- 1:10:40represented at all. Or they might be represented in
- 1:10:42a way they don't want it if they don't do it right.
- 1:10:43And they may need to reboot some things that maybe I don't
- 1:10:46remember. Like when I was first at Nestle
- 1:10:48running digital, you know, I spent a lot of time on paid
- 1:10:51owner and not only. And I'd say that's more
- 1:10:53important than ever before. Like own media is actually very
- 1:10:57strategic. You know, at the end of the day,
- 1:10:59when I was just like left websites for dad, it was like,
- 1:11:02Oh yeah, you can't, you know, market to where the consumers
- 1:11:04are and they're not going there now.
- 1:11:07You know, websites, customer service, customer experience is
- 1:11:12really, really strategic because that's what the LLMS were
- 1:11:15fascinating. So you're getting less traffic
- 1:11:18because you know people are going to these answer engines
- 1:11:21and they're not necessarily clicking through.
- 1:11:23But your point is that the content's more important than
- 1:11:25ever. Yeah, in fact.
- 1:11:27You may get. Less traffic.
- 1:11:29But you may get. Higher overall conversion
- 1:11:32because the consumers are coming in are actually really, really
- 1:11:36convinced. And so, yeah, so it's a totally,
- 1:11:38it's a totally that wild. That is wild.
- 1:11:40Yeah, totally is. I'm just finished a book called
- 1:11:43The Answer Economy. It's all about this notion that
- 1:11:46the brands that really understand the winners are going
- 1:11:51to be those that know how to answer questions.
- 1:11:53Forget AI, forget all the buzzwords about AI, just like
- 1:11:55it's fundamentally old fashioned, you know, marketing
- 1:11:59basics like anticipate the needs, make sure you have
- 1:12:02content and then really make sure that you're, you know,
- 1:12:06those boring basics like product superiority, right?
- 1:12:09Those things matter because it's not like APNG side by side.
- 1:12:12It's much more sophisticated now.
- 1:12:14So you're right, it's back to basics.
- 1:12:15This is the stuff like, you know, as a young marketer, this
- 1:12:18is where everything started, right?
- 1:12:20So we spent decades doing this stuff and then maybe we forgot
- 1:12:23about gotten some bad habits. Right, honey, I launched, you
- 1:12:27know, I do a lot of AI generated songs, probably to a fault, but
- 1:12:29now I've now put together song books for my clients with all AI
- 1:12:33generated songs. It's just lessons.
- 1:12:35OK, got it, got it. OK, sure engine.
- 1:12:37So like so I released my first album like like 3 months ago and
- 1:12:41the very first song was called Pregun the boring basics, who's
- 1:12:44like a reggae, and it was a last check it out.
- 1:12:46Lights went nuts. But it is funny.
- 1:12:48Like oh. Friends are like.
- 1:12:51Consumers, they have the attention span of a fleece, so
- 1:12:53you really got to like also spoon feed them things that kind
- 1:12:57of. Emotionally resonate, but.
- 1:12:58A Generally music is wild. I mean, Joe Rogan kept playing
- 1:13:02that one. It was I think it was a 50 Cent
- 1:13:06song, but it was like someone singing it with like soul singer
- 1:13:09singing it and he like he kept saying this is my favorite song
- 1:13:12now. So it was really surprisingly
- 1:13:13good. So I did I just a couple days
- 1:13:15ago I did a. A rap.
- 1:13:17Battle between possible and con. You got to send me that one.
- 1:13:23And in my book I have at the end of every chapter I invented what
- 1:13:27I call the take away trap. So literally every chapter has
- 1:13:30like a recap. In song Hey whatever it takes
- 1:13:34podcast. Song.
- 1:13:35Yeah, lots of new formats. Yeah.
- 1:13:38Well, thank you so much for coming here.
- 1:13:40It's been a great conversation. You're you're in town the whole
- 1:13:42week for possible yeah I heard through Wednesday.
- 1:13:45I got a panel today on AES, still looking forward to that,
- 1:13:48and got a bunch of clients that are here.
- 1:13:49They're so kind of, you know, schmooze and soak up from Sun.
- 1:13:53Yeah, I'm. Already feeling really
- 1:13:55dehydrated? But yeah, we have some water
- 1:13:58downstairs and thanks again for making the trip out here and
- 1:14:01enjoy this show all. Right, so we have Patrick Duggan
- 1:14:06here and a little impromptu session.
- 1:14:09Let's do it you know, just because you know when we're
- 1:14:12sitting backstage backstage, I mean over there and and we're
- 1:14:17having a little chat about all things AIA really fascinating
- 1:14:20topic randomly unearthed itself, which is.
- 1:14:23Which is harder than AI these days.
- 1:14:25Everybody's just AI and then what?
- 1:14:27Right, Yeah, exactly. Well, this one actually had a
- 1:14:29point and I liked it. So I just wanted to dig into
- 1:14:32into a little bit, which is you talk about AI monetization and
- 1:14:35how, you know, there's almost like a mad scramble for AI
- 1:14:38companies now to to go, well, we've got people using it, yeah.
- 1:14:43But that's not making us the money we need to pay back all of
- 1:14:49the debt or pay back what we need to make what we need to
- 1:14:52make. Yeah.
- 1:14:53Tell me what you told me. Unpack that in terms of the
- 1:14:56individual versus enterprise shift.
- 1:14:59Yeah, and just add a layer of that, right?
- 1:15:01Like brands are thinking about, I want to give access to AI, but
- 1:15:05no way to kind of gatekeeper Guardrail.
- 1:15:08Yeah, the usage and consumption, which is where the model is
- 1:15:12going from like a pricing perspective, right.
- 1:15:14So if I unleash Claude to you and I and we really find a way
- 1:15:19to use it and we're driving a lot of consumption, well, that's
- 1:15:21driving usage out the rails, right?
- 1:15:23So a lot of figuring out the balance.
- 1:15:25What we were talking about a little before is I as an
- 1:15:28individual may be using Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini, others for my
- 1:15:33own personal use, mixing in some professional use.
- 1:15:36How do I keep the guard rails and the usage around I've got
- 1:15:40my, you know, my guarded brand content or my, you know,
- 1:15:44individual Pi or whatever the case may be that I need to
- 1:15:47maintain? I got to think about enterprise
- 1:15:50level brands for this, right? And the AI companies are
- 1:15:52thinking about the same way. Yeah, right.
- 1:15:54And I was talking about this to someone yesterday as well.
- 1:15:57And it seems to be the case that a lot of a lot of AI companies
- 1:16:01obviously built by the token. So it's all usage based, which
- 1:16:04is a model that CF OS are not yet used to.
- 1:16:08And therefore, it's almost exacerbating, like they'll get a
- 1:16:13bill due at the end of the month, it's way bigger than what
- 1:16:15they expected. And that is exacerbating the
- 1:16:18need to, I guess, maybe reduce headcount even.
- 1:16:22When I think that's the great unknown about how do I make sure
- 1:16:26that the users of its understand the impact of what they're
- 1:16:29doing, right? Like, oh, I built out this
- 1:16:31really great deck and I want to make APDF versus PowerPoint,
- 1:16:35whatever. Yeah.
- 1:16:36And it's so far downstream, like, I don't know, token
- 1:16:38consumption. I don't know the actual usage
- 1:16:40that's occurring. Meanwhile, bills are
- 1:16:42skyrocketing, right? Or like, hey, like I'm just
- 1:16:44playing around with it. I'm going to make Mavis Beacon
- 1:16:47game. Like, I played that when I was a
- 1:16:48kid. Like, oh.
- 1:16:49What I can make? Like HTML code thing, I don't
- 1:16:52have to do it myself anymore. Meanwhile, like the bill comes
- 1:16:55at the end of month, right? And to your point, the CFO
- 1:16:56panics and it's, I think everybody with the great
- 1:16:59question is, is this going to take jobs?
- 1:17:03Is it going to make more people more efficient?
- 1:17:05What does it actually mean? And you know, how companies like
- 1:17:10B to B companies or martech or ad tech companies are thinking
- 1:17:12about that, so different than how brands are thinking about
- 1:17:15that, how that drive usage or engagement for them or what
- 1:17:19their end goals are, right. And so as I'm thinking about it,
- 1:17:22I strategy talking with companies, it's really around
- 1:17:25what are you actually trying to accomplish, which is the same
- 1:17:28challenge that's existed for 10 or 15 years as we've moved into
- 1:17:32this digital. Era.
- 1:17:33It's a new. It's a same question, new
- 1:17:35problem in the sense of how do I do it with?
- 1:17:37AI. What are you really trying to
- 1:17:39accomplish and what are the measurable outcomes that exist
- 1:17:41in this world of it? Like people say outside the box,
- 1:17:45there's not even a boxing, right?
- 1:17:47It's so far past that. So the reimagining of what's
- 1:17:50real and what's not is even the start of like, how do I get to
- 1:17:52some real outcomes? Yeah, yeah.
- 1:17:54And it's wild that I mean, the on Vogue LLM of the day, I guess
- 1:17:59is, you know, a year ago you couldn't have convinced me that
- 1:18:02anyone other than ChatGPT would be ChatGPT enterprise would
- 1:18:06obsessing or, you know, the employees would be obsessing
- 1:18:08over it. Whereas now it feels like with
- 1:18:10Claude design, Claude artifacts, live artifacts, Claude code,
- 1:18:13obviously, it feels like Anthropic is the darling of the
- 1:18:16day in terms of what you've just talked about, which is people
- 1:18:19using it to do XY or Z, Yeah. Is that what you're seeing as
- 1:18:22well? You know, in my personal usage,
- 1:18:25that's certainly how I feel. And I think if you as you look
- 1:18:28at the business models, one of the things I really love about
- 1:18:31Anthropic is their goal of scaling is really around
- 1:18:34governance and kind of guided responsibility on the product.
- 1:18:38The way that they talk about themselves and the generation of
- 1:18:41their spin off really right was around, hey, all of this AI
- 1:18:44usage is out of control. How do we do it in a way?
- 1:18:47And how do we make ourselves be the beacon of governments?
- 1:18:50Because that's the other thing people aren't talking about,
- 1:18:52like, like, yeah, there's the government lawsuits and all
- 1:18:55these sorts of things. But when governance comes on a
- 1:18:57federal level, it's like how we talk about third party data,
- 1:18:59right? Individual states creating their
- 1:19:01own privacy laws and all of that.
- 1:19:03Well, what's going to be the step for that from AI, right?
- 1:19:05And I think their vision of we want to stay in front of that
- 1:19:08and make the Googles and the open AIS of the world have to
- 1:19:11spend so much money to catch us on governance is a really smart
- 1:19:14strategy. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:19:16And and yeah, you, we, the other, the other thing that I
- 1:19:19guess was really interesting to think about is I guess the, that
- 1:19:23the incoming waves of salespeople and go to market
- 1:19:26people. And so where do you think
- 1:19:27they're going to like if you're going to hypothesize on like who
- 1:19:31all these new people salespeople go after and where the
- 1:19:34battleground is? Is it?
- 1:19:36Is there agencies? Is it direct brands?
- 1:19:39Yeah, I think it's a great question.
- 1:19:41And as a partnerships guy, partnerships in my blood, it's
- 1:19:44fascinating to me, right, Because you're talking about
- 1:19:47folks selling a thing right now that you don't really have to
- 1:19:50sell, right? People are buying left and
- 1:19:52right. They want to get engaged as
- 1:19:53quickly as possible. They want to get these tools in
- 1:19:55their hands. So a lot of folks are looking at
- 1:19:57this and just saying I don't need partnerships, I don't need
- 1:20:00this engagement. I don't need these Co sell
- 1:20:02models in a lot of cases, right? Google has historically really
- 1:20:05well at resale. I think a lot of people are
- 1:20:07throwing a lot of stuff against the wall to see what works.
- 1:20:10But I think as you think about the large consulting firms, the
- 1:20:13agencies, like nobody's going to give this revenue up that's
- 1:20:16historically been theirs. How do they protect their mode
- 1:20:19in terms of engagement, helping brands along?
- 1:20:22That's not going to change with the AI world, right?
- 1:20:24And so I think there's going to be this flood of usage.
- 1:20:26There's going to be this terror of I've overspent on
- 1:20:29consumption. How do I, how do I become
- 1:20:31efficient on consumption is kind of the next level.
- 1:20:33And I think there's a space very much so, where agency, these
- 1:20:37Gsis and even, you know, hyper scalers and technology partners
- 1:20:41are going to play a significant role.
- 1:20:42And it's going to be kind of an evolution shift, but it's going
- 1:20:45to feel familiar in a lot of ways.
- 1:20:47I think the speed and velocity in which it moves because of the
- 1:20:50world of AI is what's going to make it feel different because
- 1:20:52it's moving so much. Faster, Yeah.
- 1:20:54Yeah, it'll give whiplash for sure, but I think the same
- 1:20:56patterns will play out. I believe so for now, and this
- 1:21:00is a whole new world, so we could all be wrong on this, but
- 1:21:02I feel like we've seen a little bit of this before.
- 1:21:04I've talked to folks who compare this to the.com days, right?
- 1:21:07And it's like, where do you make your bets, right?
- 1:21:10It was infrastructure then is where a lot of the bets happened
- 1:21:12duringthe.com days, who were the winners of the day applications,
- 1:21:16right? And so I think that there's an
- 1:21:17interesting play to see how this plays out as we evolve.
- 1:21:21Like, yes, there's a lot of momentum right now with
- 1:21:23infrastructure, right? The investments that even if we
- 1:21:26talk about Anthropic that we just saw AWS announce more
- 1:21:29investment, right? Google's made a significant
- 1:21:31investment. Competitors are investing in the
- 1:21:34same product. Who wins in the day in terms of
- 1:21:37infrastructure versus the application where applications
- 1:21:39go as it relates to this, which is going to be crazy to watch
- 1:21:43over the next 12? Months.
- 1:21:43Oh absolutely, yeah. I sit there and look at all the
- 1:21:48analogies that get drawn as to AI is like electricity and you
- 1:21:52know the electricity company meters you, but the people that
- 1:21:55run the businesses make the money and it's that kind of
- 1:21:58thinking. But then also you do see Claude,
- 1:22:01building tools that, yes, like other business are going to get
- 1:22:05steamrolled by even for design called artifacts.
- 1:22:08Totally. There's so many dashboard
- 1:22:10companies. So many.
- 1:22:11Yeah, yeah, there's there's so many businesses out there that I
- 1:22:15mean that that is so the electricity analogy, it made
- 1:22:19sense when I heard it, but it isn't actually happening like
- 1:22:21that. Yeah.
- 1:22:22So yeah, it's an interest to look.
- 1:22:25At Well, and like we think about ISPs and the way that they're
- 1:22:28building their mouth like a mousetrap that leverages all
- 1:22:30these tools. So it's really just a mousetrap,
- 1:22:33right? So if you build something
- 1:22:34spectacular, how long until that's either synchronized on a
- 1:22:38larger platform that grants it more accessibility?
- 1:22:41Or how long until some of these companies leading the charge are
- 1:22:44like, like we can we can build that into the solution or the
- 1:22:47tool itself. And like the great ideas
- 1:22:50immediately been monopolized, right?
- 1:22:52So like how you Moat, those sorts of things are like make
- 1:22:54your presence there, I think is a real challenge for brands
- 1:22:57building really, really cool things, leveraging AI.
- 1:23:00Yeah. It's a really fascinating topic
- 1:23:02and I'm sure we're going to come around to it, but thank you for
- 1:23:05humoring me on this impromptu session, and we'll catch you the
- 1:23:09next time. Yeah, sounds great.
- 1:23:11Listen, I would love a good improv.
- 1:23:12So greatly appreciated time as always and hope you have a great
- 1:23:14rest of the week. Thank you, Matt.
- 1:23:16Cheers. Always beaming in from possible
- 1:23:20day one Miami 2026. I've got a very special guest,
- 1:23:24Nathan Thomas, the CEO of Thomas Media Consulting.
- 1:23:27Welcome. Thank you guys.
- 1:23:29Glad to have you. He is an expert in supply chain,
- 1:23:32supply path optimization and everything associated with it,
- 1:23:35right? Yeah, I think it's a good way to
- 1:23:37put it the. Supply guy here.
- 1:23:38He does supply guy. So I think on that topic of
- 1:23:42there's been a lot of talk about supply chain optimization,
- 1:23:45supply path optimization, excuse me, we're not talking
- 1:23:48manufacturing here. And, and a lot of the, the black
- 1:23:50box challenge that happens within the programmatic
- 1:23:53ecosystem of whether it's, you know, Doctor Fu talking about
- 1:23:56take rates, right? And publishers, not, you know,
- 1:23:59sort of getting the short end of the stick when it comes to
- 1:24:01getting paid for monetizing their, their, their properties.
- 1:24:04Where do you think a lot of the where are we today?
- 1:24:07And, and, and like, have we fixed some of these problems?
- 1:24:09This SPL lived up to to the hype, into the, you know.
- 1:24:14Yeah, I mean, I think it's an interesting topic because both
- 1:24:17sides kind of approach it from such a different angle, right,
- 1:24:20The demand side versus the supply side.
- 1:24:22And me really deal my whole professional career dealing with
- 1:24:26helping publishers monetize themselves, right.
- 1:24:28You know, sometimes you you can feel a little bit at a
- 1:24:31disadvantage where you have the demand side, you know, mandating
- 1:24:35a lot of things, wanting a lot of data, wanting a lot of
- 1:24:38transparency, but then really on the flip side, often not
- 1:24:41providing that. Right.
- 1:24:42Yeah. Hey I want to.
- 1:24:43See as a feedback. As a feedback like, hey, you're
- 1:24:46buying me for this amount, I'm not getting bid log level bid
- 1:24:49data back or why wasn't why am I on a blacklist or you know, just
- 1:24:53making some easy examples here. But it really has to go both
- 1:24:58ways right on the transparency spectrum.
- 1:25:00And look, I think over the last years, a lot has got better, but
- 1:25:05it's still a mess of, I would say, ad tech vendors and
- 1:25:10intermediaries. And God knows.
- 1:25:11What else is in the middle right?
- 1:25:13So I think even more so than transparently understanding, OK,
- 1:25:18I'm, I'm buying this supply through this channel, which is
- 1:25:21obviously extremely important is also OK, what are all the steps
- 1:25:25involved in with all the middle men involved here, right?
- 1:25:27And how is that affecting my media dollar on both sides?
- 1:25:30Right, Yeah, Yeah, We just, we had a conversation with Dave
- 1:25:32Rosner earlier today and Jill Lux last week from permeative
- 1:25:36and they're solving kind of this problem.
- 1:25:38One of their big theses is, is that that advertisers should
- 1:25:41focus and Doctor Fu talks about this as well, should focus on
- 1:25:44going direct, right? Because because publishers one
- 1:25:47aren't taking advantage of the amount of first party publisher
- 1:25:50audience data. They it's not being passed
- 1:25:53through to the the DSPS, right? There's only a small segment of
- 1:25:56that data. And so they're what do you, what
- 1:25:58do you think about that topic in terms of, of publishers and and
- 1:26:02brands sort of joining, you know, sort of that Venn diagram
- 1:26:04between publisher? Yeah, with consumers is kind of
- 1:26:07the third piece. It's in cutting out the
- 1:26:09intermediaries. 100%, I mean, it's so relevant and so
- 1:26:13important. I mean, if we think about it
- 1:26:15really from a high level, what's the most direct supply path you
- 1:26:18could do? You can hand an IO to a
- 1:26:21publisher and they run your media.
- 1:26:23There was 0 hops, right? But of course, that's typically
- 1:26:27not what's wanted. We want to buy through different
- 1:26:30channels at scale and that's when all the mess kind of.
- 1:26:32Happens. Yeah.
- 1:26:33And you think it's a complexity mess mess.
- 1:26:35I mean, you know, because if you're hiring an agency, right,
- 1:26:38they can be do principle, they can do principal based buying to
- 1:26:40do volume discounts, which is kind of a reach play.
- 1:26:43Sure. But is it too much to ask your
- 1:26:45agency to say, hey, manage these 10 platforms, yeah, or these 10
- 1:26:49publishers? These are the places where 80%
- 1:26:51of my my traffic is going to come from where my audience is
- 1:26:54going to be at. Is it too much to ask agencies
- 1:26:56to do that or does? Or is that complexity argument
- 1:26:58real in terms of there's just so many places where you can buy
- 1:27:01direct, Yeah, that we need to simplify the the actual buying
- 1:27:04process? Goes a little bit to this kind
- 1:27:07of obsession with identifiers and audience play right where
- 1:27:10hey I'm looking for these specific identifiers and the
- 1:27:13only really way to scale across that means you have to buy it
- 1:27:16really broad across this big swath of the industry.
- 1:27:19Yes it's going to one publisher may not work.
- 1:27:22I mean that's where I think, you know, obviously this is a little
- 1:27:25bit of a different topic, but there's so many competing new
- 1:27:28protocols coming out. Yeah.
- 1:27:30And one area where I think I'm really fascinated with like AD
- 1:27:33CP and those things that those direct to publisher executions
- 1:27:38that are really kind of traditionally will be handled
- 1:27:40one off with an IO that is our ad CP is actually very good for
- 1:27:45that, right where it can agents kind of collapsing that chain
- 1:27:49and you executing with individual publishers at scale
- 1:27:52where beforehand it was a lot of back and forth and I could see
- 1:27:55why that's really not feasible on the agent.
- 1:27:58Work behind it. A lot of work to be done.
- 1:28:01It's not baked yet, but you know, it's, it's, I think that's
- 1:28:03a good step there. And then to your point on the
- 1:28:05first party data, I mean a key topic, I do a lot of work on
- 1:28:09that with many publishers, right?
- 1:28:12They are sitting on the audience, right?
- 1:28:15The audience comes to them. On a treasure trail of data,
- 1:28:18much of which they're not leveraging in the advertising
- 1:28:20supply. Exactly.
- 1:28:21I mean, often it's just I'm just sending bid requests through,
- 1:28:24right. And then as you mentioned with
- 1:28:27DSP's kind of throttling inventory, QPS identifiers not
- 1:28:32being there, yeah. And they're doing that to
- 1:28:34control bandwidth. Yeah, makes whole toll taking
- 1:28:38right, because it becomes too costly to bring in all of a
- 1:28:40publishers data. Exactly.
- 1:28:42More revealing from a contextual behavioral way.
- 1:28:46It would be more revealing about who their audience really is and
- 1:28:48what their kind of propensities are.
- 1:28:50Yeah, right. You think, you think that, that,
- 1:28:52that throttling and because you mentioned, you mentioned like ID
- 1:28:54matching, right and they're pushing for sort of reach.
- 1:28:58Is that really an onboarding plan that we're talking about?
- 1:29:00Like you're onboarding a certain number of IDs, you're matching
- 1:29:02them against what exists within that DSP, which might only be a
- 1:29:0650% right, right. But are those, are we, are we
- 1:29:10in, are the days numbered when it comes to onboarding and then
- 1:29:13are like are we in a better place from a publisher data
- 1:29:17control perspective to not even need onboarding anymore?
- 1:29:22Yeah. And I think that really depends
- 1:29:24what what's supposed to happen with the data, right.
- 1:29:26If it has to leave your for your, your publisher wall, so to
- 1:29:29say that it can go into someone else's system and that system
- 1:29:33needs to have that data to make buying decisions, yeah, then
- 1:29:36yes, you have to obviously onboard it into that other
- 1:29:39system, yeah. You've got a match with.
- 1:29:40That you've got a match and that gets back to kind of the ID
- 1:29:43obsession, right? I mean, every DSP and probably
- 1:29:47SSPS and others are primarily looking for their IDs, right?
- 1:29:50Like that's most important to them.
- 1:29:52Yes, it can transact on other things, but by doing so you also
- 1:29:56leave out a massive part of the Internet where there are no IDs
- 1:29:59or you know, those, those IDs that look in the match are not
- 1:30:02present. So, you know, working deeper
- 1:30:05with the supply side to figuring out, OK, what kind of outcomes
- 1:30:09is the advertiser looking for and what does the publisher
- 1:30:11have? Yeah, and, and try to match it
- 1:30:14up as best as possible. I mean, that seems to be like a
- 1:30:16really fruitful connection. And and a more direct data
- 1:30:19connection, right. And with, with sort of the
- 1:30:21growth of data lake houses, data warehouses or data, you know,
- 1:30:24data warehouse native applications, clean rooms, you
- 1:30:27could argue as well. And it does allow for kind of a
- 1:30:29pseudonymized match between data sources.
- 1:30:32But I think the challenge that I've seen is that is that
- 1:30:35advertisers and agencies just haven't had the level of access
- 1:30:39they need to that publisher data.
- 1:30:40So publishers aren't taking enough advantage of the rich
- 1:30:43data resource they have, which can more effectively drive
- 1:30:46better segmentation, better targeting, hopefully better
- 1:30:49outcomes because it's more aligned to just a much broader
- 1:30:52profile of an audience. Right.
- 1:30:55Yeah. And I think the the other thing
- 1:30:56to mention there is that, look, there's only so many publishers
- 1:30:59that have all this authenticated traffic, right?
- 1:31:02Logged in users. There's just going to be a ton
- 1:31:04of publishers just don't have that.
- 1:31:05Yeah. So if that's all you're looking
- 1:31:07at, then again you're ignoring. It it's an authenticated premium
- 1:31:11publisher, but do you think that that's, well, let's let's get on
- 1:31:14that path. Do you think that the
- 1:31:15authenticated audience member, you know, and Rio and I were
- 1:31:19talking about this with, with Joe in our last podcast is, you
- 1:31:23know, do you think that reflects really what like media
- 1:31:26consumption is going to look like going forward where more
- 1:31:29people are going to be basically interacting with less media
- 1:31:33channels, media channels. We looked at our own experiences
- 1:31:36and we're like, you know, how many, how many news publications
- 1:31:38do you read? How many CTV publications or,
- 1:31:41or, or media companies do you subscribe to the Netflix's
- 1:31:43otherwise? And you know, I could probably
- 1:31:45count the total and it's less than 20, right?
- 1:31:48It's not a huge amount, right? And is that right?
- 1:31:50Do you think that's reflective of over our overarching consumer
- 1:31:54behavior in general where people tend to focus and authenticate
- 1:31:57more frequently and have a tighter relationship with
- 1:31:59certain publishers versus just defaulting to kind of the open
- 1:32:03the long tail web? Yeah, right.
- 1:32:05I mean, look, I think it's kind of a mixed answer to be honest,
- 1:32:07right? I think what you said is totally
- 1:32:09true. I mean, if I think about myself,
- 1:32:11what websites do I go to and what apps do I use?
- 1:32:15I can probably count it on like one hand.
- 1:32:17Yeah, it's like it's the same ones all over.
- 1:32:19So all of this. So which kind of goes back to
- 1:32:22the supply path quality, if you're seeing a ton of
- 1:32:24impressions and volume on random, like, apps and website,
- 1:32:28is that real? Like, yeah, because I mean, if
- 1:32:31I'm trying to reach CTV, isn't everybody on, I don't know,
- 1:32:34Netflix, Hulu? And then it kind of really
- 1:32:36tapers off like you. Authenticated premium publishers
- 1:32:39and then you've got all of the Southern inventory.
- 1:32:41It may not even be appearing on the television.
- 1:32:44Right. What I will say though is this
- 1:32:46is that we can't forget the fact that there are kind of niche
- 1:32:52audiences that may I actually have a lot of scales sometimes
- 1:32:55that aren't just not on those traditional platforms.
- 1:32:58And I think a lot about South Gaming has always been near and
- 1:33:01dear to my. Heart that's.
- 1:33:02It I think it's let's. Cover that topic.
- 1:33:05It's just a phenomenal area where, you know, you're kind of
- 1:33:07insulated from AI, right? You're not going to let AI play
- 1:33:11a game for you. Yeah.
- 1:33:12And defeat the purpose. So they're insulated from that
- 1:33:14traffic. You know, you've got a captive
- 1:33:15audience. It's a human captive audience.
- 1:33:18Vastly underserved. I mean, based on the, you know,
- 1:33:21advertiser date, Global ad spend is like 5% on gaming or
- 1:33:25something. Yeah, whereas the attention on
- 1:33:27gaming is more than CTV for like Gen.
- 1:33:29Z. For and when we talk about
- 1:33:31advertising or we can we breakdown the types of sort of
- 1:33:34game advertisements. I think of app lovin of sort of
- 1:33:36this circular, let's advertise and promote other games within
- 1:33:40gaming and that has. Historically been the biggest
- 1:33:43revenue driver on the app side. It's just advertising other
- 1:33:45apps, yeah, which is interesting because that made them be really
- 1:33:49good at that performance aspect. Yeah.
- 1:33:51Yeah, which like within they expanded to like, oh, this is
- 1:33:54outcome. Like the app has been kind of
- 1:33:56doing that for a minute, right? Yeah, I won't be able to
- 1:33:58download or. Something can you replicate
- 1:34:00those outcomes when you're now dealing with brand advertising,
- 1:34:03whether it's a direct response up in that or like your local
- 1:34:06auto dealership or if it's a product placement?
- 1:34:08Yeah. Can a company like Apple Oven
- 1:34:10duplicate the experience that they created with with, you know
- 1:34:13advertising apps and other games within the app experience?
- 1:34:17Can they take that model and translate?
- 1:34:19Have you seen any evidence that suggests that they are doing?
- 1:34:22I mean, Apple haven't used their system them seems like they're
- 1:34:24very successful. I think they're still probably
- 1:34:27early on and really branching out into non endemic
- 1:34:30advertisers. I'm not saying it's not
- 1:34:32happening, but I don't think it's at scale yet.
- 1:34:35But I think the data and the foundation they have are
- 1:34:37probably argued is pretty good to do that.
- 1:34:40But but then on some of. The models that particularly
- 1:34:43tend to the intent to convert. Or whatever it.
- 1:34:45Might be just say on the gaming side, I mean, I used to game
- 1:34:48when I was young. I'm not as so much in the weeds,
- 1:34:51but there are so many gaming environments that are just
- 1:34:55massive in terms of audience and attention, but greatly
- 1:34:58underserved and misunderstood. We're talking Fortnite maps,
- 1:35:03Minecraft servers. My teenage boys life like for
- 1:35:08for like 8th grade until like until they develop social lives,
- 1:35:12right, non online social lives. But it was an extraordinary
- 1:35:16amount of time that they spent within that playing these
- 1:35:19multiplayer. Games and what's interesting is,
- 1:35:21you know, you kind of think that OK, you're playing Fortnite, you
- 1:35:24bought Fortnite from Epic, they're running the ads, but no,
- 1:35:27there's all these external developers that make Fortnite
- 1:35:30apps and in the maps and in those maps you can run ads and
- 1:35:34do other brand integrations and the attention there is insane,
- 1:35:38the amount of people that are on there.
- 1:35:39Whereas Epic is fundamentally the publisher of the game, but
- 1:35:42they have these. Developers in to like create
- 1:35:46content essentially, right? Same for Roblox.
- 1:35:48I mean, Roblox is kind of the platform, if you will.
- 1:35:51And then there's Roblox game developers and those game
- 1:35:53developers inside their games can do certain things and they
- 1:35:56attract a specific. And what's the what's the reason
- 1:35:59for that? Was it a crowdsourcing to expand
- 1:36:01and the the the like to give the ability to deliver more
- 1:36:05advertising or was it just a lack of bandwidth and time and
- 1:36:08attention that? That yeah, I don't think that,
- 1:36:10you know, advertising was at the forefront of the of the idea of
- 1:36:14wanting to do this. But I think it's just kind of
- 1:36:17people, they want a more content, they want a more users,
- 1:36:20they want a more engagement on their platform or their games
- 1:36:23that they build. And then these outside
- 1:36:25developers kind of came in and started doing that and has
- 1:36:28really bolster that ecosystem that kind of same as you want
- 1:36:30like a good App Store ecosystem, like, yeah, the only apps that
- 1:36:34are on there from Apple. It's not very exciting.
- 1:36:36So you think you think that was a good decision that some of
- 1:36:39some of the kind of epic games made to allow this to happen?
- 1:36:41Or do you do you think that they gained and learned from what
- 1:36:44these developers were were building like in their ecosystem
- 1:36:48so they can then charge forward with their own advertising?
- 1:36:50Yeah. I mean, there's definitely been
- 1:36:52some of that, right? I mean, for example, let's take
- 1:36:55Roblox. I mean they've been over the
- 1:36:57years definitely playing with their kind of monetization
- 1:37:00strategies and what they allow and what they know.
- 1:37:03And I, I know there was certain companies that did like years
- 1:37:06ago, some preliminary advertising in Roblox and then
- 1:37:09they got shut down because Roblox started doing it
- 1:37:11themselves. Yeah, right.
- 1:37:12So they come to certain businesses just went out of
- 1:37:15business, right? Because, yeah, we took it over,
- 1:37:17right. It's kind of like kind of an odd
- 1:37:19thing where you have, I don't know, let's other advertisers
- 1:37:22advertise on Facebook, like, right.
- 1:37:24Why would Facebook do that in the long run?
- 1:37:25But they certainly need that content and that community.
- 1:37:28So I don't really see that going away.
- 1:37:30It's going to change. Yeah.
- 1:37:31And it probably is tied. I mean, just supposition would
- 1:37:33be that it's tied to kind of the community and that they don't
- 1:37:36want to threaten that the sanctity of that community.
- 1:37:39Correct, it's very important. Yeah.
- 1:37:41And so. So what do you think the future?
- 1:37:43Of sort of in game advertising, we've been talking about this
- 1:37:45for a long time. You're saying it doesn't hasn't
- 1:37:47really increased above. What's the percentage?
- 1:37:495% five. Percent of Total Media spend
- 1:37:51maybe, right? You know, understanding the
- 1:37:54amount of time spent, which is a pretty important metric that
- 1:37:57certain age groups spend in game, certain demographics,
- 1:38:00right? Probably largely male, largely
- 1:38:03teenage. Yeah, I mean, I don't even know
- 1:38:04if that's necessary necessarily true anymore depending on the
- 1:38:07game. I think that's I mean I don't
- 1:38:08want to out myself in my age, but we're kind of a little older
- 1:38:11here. Like I was only the boys that
- 1:38:13play a game. I don't think that is anymore
- 1:38:15like you have really have a a. Pretty wide it's very wide
- 1:38:19special. So what, what are the, what do
- 1:38:20Epic Games and all these other players have to do to to really
- 1:38:23develop? And in the sense it's their own
- 1:38:24role, it's within their own gaming ecosystem and advertising
- 1:38:28model that can scale and grow and and keep consumer, keep
- 1:38:32gamers coming back because they're not.
- 1:38:34Is it product placement? Is it?
- 1:38:37There is, I think there's a few things here and I'm actually
- 1:38:39working on some personal projects in this area to
- 1:38:42hopefully solve some of these problems with some other
- 1:38:44colleagues. But I do think it's, it's a it's
- 1:38:48a fragmentation on both the inventory, the formats and the
- 1:38:52data. Yeah, that is kind of hindered.
- 1:38:54And and lastly, and this is actually important one kind of
- 1:38:57just a misunderstanding on the brand and agency side, what
- 1:39:01gaming is, right? Because if if you as an agency
- 1:39:04get let's say we have video budget, right, OK, where does
- 1:39:08gaming fit in? Is video really is digital
- 1:39:11media, but in game has video placements.
- 1:39:14Is that video? Is that experimental?
- 1:39:18What is the? Form factor of this video isn't
- 1:39:21like a spot odd 50 is it CTV because he's.
- 1:39:24Planted on the Xbox and there's a video and you know, so I don't
- 1:39:29think they quite understand that yet.
- 1:39:30And it's sometimes, you know, you have these all this is my
- 1:39:33social budget. This is my and it doesn't where
- 1:39:35do I fit it? So I think that's a big one.
- 1:39:39But then to going back on the other side, you know, again, for
- 1:39:42example, identity, you know, while I still believe not
- 1:39:45everything should be tied to identifiers and hashed emails
- 1:39:48and whatnot, you know, there is the need on the broader gaming
- 1:39:54ecosystem to kind of coalesce. Yeah, right.
- 1:39:56Where you can then take someone that plays Roblox and you know
- 1:40:01who that is when they log into Discord and you know who that
- 1:40:04person is. There's a total disconnect.
- 1:40:06Right. There's a little disconnect and
- 1:40:07then the formats, right? Like.
- 1:40:09Cuz you're not. You're not going like cookies
- 1:40:10are following you around browser environment.
- 1:40:12That's not there. You're that's not there.
- 1:40:14You're. Sitting on the you might be in a
- 1:40:16you. Might be in a.
- 1:40:17Client or you might be in the console or whatever it may be
- 1:40:20right and then and then the formats right like OK, I did it
- 1:40:24a dynamic game. I don't know I put a say a
- 1:40:28billboard or I put a Wu Tang clan Nike branded store in in in
- 1:40:33a Fortnite map and people are interactive.
- 1:40:35What is that on an impression level?
- 1:40:37How do you translate that to this?
- 1:40:39Is this CPM over here when I won banners, right?
- 1:40:43So like and those are things that, you know, I think we want
- 1:40:46to solve. There needs to be, there needs
- 1:40:48to be a fundamental standardization and then and
- 1:40:50then a cross-platform. If you want to say
- 1:40:53cross-platform, some sort of identifier that can can
- 1:40:57persistently follow players that even if it's not within the same
- 1:41:01gaming because it's like an Epic Games game, right?
- 1:41:04It's it could be another type of game on another platform.
- 1:41:06Yeah, reminds me a little bit of open AP on the kind of
- 1:41:09television audience side where where competitors essentially
- 1:41:13came together, right and did something.
- 1:41:16So definitely working on that personally on some projects and
- 1:41:19then, yeah, I'm excited for that.
- 1:41:20That's awesome. Yeah.
- 1:41:21That we haven't talked to a ton of people about gaming.
- 1:41:23I think we had an earlier interview but but you mentioned
- 1:41:25the Wu Tang Clan and you realize that you just planted the seed
- 1:41:28in my. Hand it was actually not planned
- 1:41:30or delivered at all. This that.
- 1:41:32Little did people know that you had a hip hop past.
- 1:41:36In Switzerland, I did. Yeah, Tell.
- 1:41:38Us about that. In my old days in Switzerland,
- 1:41:41yeah. First I started on actually
- 1:41:42writing graffiti and then I had to lay low for a minute after
- 1:41:46certain things happened. Wow.
- 1:41:47Then I had to I got into more rap and I was assigned to a
- 1:41:50label in in Switzerland and there's YouTube videos.
- 1:41:54Wow. DM me for the link.
- 1:41:55No, Yeah, yeah, it's on Spotify. You know, that's.
- 1:41:59And So what marked industry? Yeah, so I was always extremely
- 1:42:02interested in advertising and marketing.
- 1:42:04And when I was going to school, I always knew I wanted to end up
- 1:42:07somewhere here. But I didn't know anything about
- 1:42:08ad tech. I was teaching me economics at
- 1:42:10the University of Zurich. OK before I move.
- 1:42:13This where you did the graffiti was the streets of Zurich.
- 1:42:15Streets of Basel. It's a Basel.
- 1:42:17Yeah. So then I moved, I moved to
- 1:42:19Florida right around when I turned 30 and I started at what
- 1:42:24was then called Entergy, now Playwire, one of the premier
- 1:42:27publisher side monetization firms.
- 1:42:30And then was there for 16 years to kind of built a lot of the ad
- 1:42:33OPS, yield OPS data practices over there.
- 1:42:35And now I'm solo as a consulting, doing my own thing
- 1:42:38and talk to the guys like you. Nice.
- 1:42:40Well, thanks for joining us it. This has been wonderful.
- 1:42:42We had quite a windy backdrop. Nice 1 though.
- 1:42:46But it is nice we're on on the roof on a little island right
- 1:42:49outside of Miami and it's a pleasure talking to you.
- 1:42:51Thanks for joining us today. And we'll, we'll have you on the
- 1:42:54pod for a full length. So I'd love that anytime.
- 1:42:56All right, man. Thank you, Brad.
- 1:42:57Thank you, Rio. Hi, this is Rio longer here.
- 1:43:00We're signaling Noise podcast and we are day one of possible.
- 1:43:04It's beautiful day here with the Mad Connect Mansion, which is
- 1:43:08right just off Miami Beach and we're kicking off the first day.
- 1:43:11So we have a special guest joining us at kick off possible
- 1:43:14Nathan Lindberg from VP of Global Brand Partnerships.
- 1:43:18Overall Fads. Thank you for coming.
- 1:43:19What a great time to be here. I mean, this is absolutely
- 1:43:22gorgeous, beautiful day in Miami.
- 1:43:23I mean, what else could we ask? For I think they get a lot of
- 1:43:25beautiful days, but. I'm jealous.
- 1:43:28I'm jealous. Especially living up in the
- 1:43:29Northeast. It's a it's a very different
- 1:43:31picture down here in January. It's been a tough year for you
- 1:43:33guys, yeah. Don't need the snow coming to
- 1:43:36me. It's funny, I flew in from
- 1:43:37Denver. In Denver it was 43° and like.
- 1:43:41Yeah, you guys are very generous this year, passing all your snow
- 1:43:44on us. I really appreciate.
- 1:43:45That we didn't get much. Really glad you could make it
- 1:43:48here. We're really excited to hear
- 1:43:51about you about, about your company.
- 1:43:53I mean, it's, I think it's an area that people don't realize
- 1:43:57how big it is and how important it is.
- 1:43:59So you can start up by telling listeners a little bit about a
- 1:44:02little bit about your background and love to understand the
- 1:44:05business and what makes it tick and the revenue model and all
- 1:44:08that. Yeah, I mean, I, I come from
- 1:44:10video games. So I've been selling video game
- 1:44:12advertising for over 20 years now.
- 1:44:14I started in print, I moved into digital and web.
- 1:44:17I worked at Amazon for a little while on the Twitch brand.
- 1:44:21I spent some time at Epic Games. So I've been able to see kind of
- 1:44:24the burgeoning, what I would call creator economy that exists
- 1:44:27within the video game space. It's a, it's a new area for
- 1:44:31video games. But as we've seen and we've
- 1:44:33talked about many times in your podcast, the creator economy is
- 1:44:36happening in every industry. It's happening everywhere,
- 1:44:38whether it's YouTube creators, whether it's Spotify artists,
- 1:44:41like everyone is finding ways to create their own content.
- 1:44:45And it's because there's just an insatiable appetite, right?
- 1:44:48The, the access to data, the access to information is so much
- 1:44:51faster than it was 10/15/20 years ago, right?
- 1:44:54Like some of us still remember what that dial up tone sounded
- 1:44:57like. Some of us remember that from
- 1:45:01the late 1900s. And now it's just information is
- 1:45:04so fast and the audience their, their appetite for content is
- 1:45:07insatiable. Industry can't keep up.
- 1:45:10And we've seen that transition happen with film and TV and now
- 1:45:13the YouTube and Twitch. And now we're seeing it kind of
- 1:45:15move into video games. And that's where Overwolf is
- 1:45:18really trying to position itself.
- 1:45:20It has a platform where tools and and apps and mods and and
- 1:45:24the things that gamers want can be created by individual content
- 1:45:27creators to help them then monetize and have a more
- 1:45:29enjoyable gaming experience. So do you work with like gaming
- 1:45:32platforms that then have creators who are publishing
- 1:45:34games there or do you work like just with creators themselves?
- 1:45:37How does that? Yeah, we stick on them in the
- 1:45:39middle. So our job is to kind of we've
- 1:45:41created a tools and services platform that's powered by
- 1:45:44advertising. And that tools and services
- 1:45:46platform allows you, if you're a really excited player of let's
- 1:45:50say League of Legends, you want to create an app or a website
- 1:45:54that helps people play League of Legends a little bit better.
- 1:45:57You can go and create that using Overwolf suite of tools and
- 1:45:59services. And we have a monetization
- 1:46:01platform set up to help you then monetize that.
- 1:46:04And you get 50 to 70% of the ad revenue that comes into your
- 1:46:08platform. And so it creates a really
- 1:46:10strong value exchange for the consumer.
- 1:46:13It helps the game pushers because we obviously that
- 1:46:15moderate everything. Sure.
- 1:46:17And at the end of the day, people are having a more
- 1:46:19enjoyable gaming experience and more content is being created
- 1:46:22for the games they love. It's kind of a win, win, win for
- 1:46:25everybody. 5070%, that's a good share.
- 1:46:29As someone who's worked on other platforms and services and see
- 1:46:32what the Rev shares are for those.
- 1:46:34What are they for example? I mean, I've certainly seen
- 1:46:36platforms where it's sub 20%. And so if you think about that
- 1:46:41in relation, yeah, I guess it's a really great deal for
- 1:46:43creators, especially knowing that the advertising that sits
- 1:46:46in those ecosystems and services that you're using, which are
- 1:46:49free, having that ability to say, hey, like this is
- 1:46:52wonderful. And the fact that I'm getting a
- 1:46:53tool and a service that I'm enjoying, it's for free.
- 1:46:56And then the person that is has made this is getting a 50 to 70%
- 1:47:01Rev share. That's that's awesome.
- 1:47:03Has AI changed that at all? Are there more creators now
- 1:47:06because of it? I'm imagining that's the case,
- 1:47:08correct? We're seeing in AI, say we see
- 1:47:10an efficiencies in in the AI angle.
- 1:47:12Obviously, you're not able to create these apps and tools and
- 1:47:15services quite yet with AI technology, but certainly we're
- 1:47:18seeing people innovate and certainly optimize those
- 1:47:21experiences. I think that when you look at
- 1:47:24how AI has affected other platforms like social and stuff
- 1:47:27like that, and the AI slop that you hear from people.
- 1:47:30A lot of it, a lot of that. You know, gaming seems to be a
- 1:47:33bit of a, of a of a kind of a strong Moat around that in terms
- 1:47:37of preventing those opportunities.
- 1:47:38We're not seeing just the the lawlessness of content creation.
- 1:47:42We're seeing innovation, we're seeing efficiency, but we're not
- 1:47:45seeing just the lawlessness of IP flowing everywhere and stuff
- 1:47:48like that. And we think that that's, you
- 1:47:50know, for brands especially who are concerned about that stuff,
- 1:47:53it's a place where you can kind of feel a little bit more
- 1:47:55comfortable about where your ads are running.
- 1:47:58I think many people don't appreciate how big of a business
- 1:48:01this is. Like are there numbers you can
- 1:48:03give us in terms of number of creators, What types of revenue
- 1:48:07numbers some of these big creators and publishers are
- 1:48:09seeing? Yeah.
- 1:48:10We've, we've set some aspirational goals for
- 1:48:12ourselves. Our CEO has this focus to trying
- 1:48:15to pay out a billion dollars to creators by 20-30.
- 1:48:20So we have a strong focus and a North Star and we've hit about
- 1:48:23300 million last year in payouts to creators.
- 1:48:26Some of our creators are getting beer money for the weekend.
- 1:48:29Others nothing wrong. Beer.
- 1:48:30Nothing wrong with it. Others are seeing generational
- 1:48:33wealth. Some of our app developers have
- 1:48:35sold their apps and their businesses for over €40 million.
- 1:48:39So we are seeing those opportunities, we are seeing
- 1:48:41this new create for economy that's happening and it's
- 1:48:44happening in a different way than you would see on a YouTube
- 1:48:47or a twitch or other kind of what I would call entertainment
- 1:48:51based platforms, right? These are people who are
- 1:48:53creating the tools and services that you you enjoy versus
- 1:48:56someone who gets on a microphone and and talks, entertains that
- 1:48:59way. And I use the analogy of if
- 1:49:02you're in a coffee shop and George Clooney walks in, you
- 1:49:06know George Clooney, you know who he looks like, you know who
- 1:49:08he is, right? If you know Banksy walks in very
- 1:49:12famous artist right? You know his work.
- 1:49:15But if? He if he was recently, no one
- 1:49:16even knew who he was, right? So that's the beauty of I think
- 1:49:20what our creator economy is. It's the tools and services
- 1:49:22people. It's those behind the scenes
- 1:49:24that are making great works. It's a very different take on
- 1:49:27creator economy, but it's nonetheless valuable and it's
- 1:49:30nonetheless lucrative. I mean, these creators are, as I
- 1:49:32said, are making anywhere from some beer money for the weekend
- 1:49:35all the way through to to fully generational wealth.
- 1:49:41Where do the creators come from? Are these just normal people who
- 1:49:43who are interested in it? Are these are these people who
- 1:49:46like, like you've been in the industry for a while, Like,
- 1:49:48what's your take on that? All walks of life.
- 1:49:51One of my favourites is a gentleman named Sandy.
- 1:49:53Sandy is a total girl dad, his daughter has epilepsy, has a
- 1:49:57hard time playing video games. He ended up making some mods
- 1:50:00that helped and allowed her to play in a much more tame
- 1:50:03environment. He used our platform and then
- 1:50:06sell them to other parents and families who also could use
- 1:50:09that. And now he has a business where
- 1:50:10he can stay home with his family and he works as a small little
- 1:50:13studio and he makes anywhere from 10 to $25,000 a month.
- 1:50:18Not a bad business. And he would tell you first and
- 1:50:19foremost that that was never in his, in his like mindset coming
- 1:50:23out of school. You also see, you know, lifelong
- 1:50:25gamers who want to, you know, provide that value as well.
- 1:50:28So it's a really mixed batch. We have, you know, over 187,000
- 1:50:31creators across the world who are making apps, tools and
- 1:50:34services. And that I think really it's,
- 1:50:37it's a very welcoming and, and kind of opportunistic area right
- 1:50:39now that we see more and more people coming.
- 1:50:41I think that AI makes it a lot easier than to create and to to
- 1:50:45kind of maintain those situations, which makes it even
- 1:50:48more, I think approachable from that perspective.
- 1:50:51How can you respond to people who might like question like why
- 1:50:55do you need ads in these games Or like what, what's, what's the
- 1:50:57whole point to people who maybe are not big on the ads?
- 1:51:01Things like what's the value proposition?
- 1:51:03Both from a consumer point of view, obviously from a from a
- 1:51:06creator point of view, you know, the monetization I made, it
- 1:51:08makes so much sense. So guys that, you know, people
- 1:51:10like the guy who's described can work from home, yeah, publish
- 1:51:12games and get checks every month.
- 1:51:14But you know, from a, let's say a user perspective.
- 1:51:16See argument for ads. Well, I would say that, you
- 1:51:19know, the the question is do you want to pay for it or do you
- 1:51:21want an advertiser to pay for it.
- 1:51:23And what we have seen is that when you have an ad environment
- 1:51:26that is non intrusive, that is complementary to the experience
- 1:51:29and it's giving value both to the creator who makes it and to
- 1:51:32the users who's using it, people are fine with it.
- 1:51:35Gamers in general, I hear this a lot from brands and agents.
- 1:51:39Oh, gamers don't like advertising.
- 1:51:41Gamers are people. They don't like bad advertising
- 1:51:43or irrelevant advertising. So if you create a situation
- 1:51:46where I'm doing something and you interrupt me and say, hey,
- 1:51:50pay attention to this, I feel like that's already a negative
- 1:51:53situation that you're creating through that advertising medium.
- 1:51:56So if you can figure out the right way to put the right
- 1:51:59message in front of the right audience, we've seen around Lyft
- 1:52:03studies, we've seen a ton of quantitative results that show
- 1:52:06that our audience really appreciates the fact that they
- 1:52:08don't have to be nickel and dimed for services.
- 1:52:11And instead those advertising dollars go directly into the
- 1:52:14pockets of people who make their favorite tools and services.
- 1:52:16So it's a. It's a value exchange.
- 1:52:18I think it's a good point. I think people under appreciate
- 1:52:21just how many people use these games.
- 1:52:23But let's say you go on a bus, right, you'll see all these
- 1:52:25people plan their funds. Many of them are playing games
- 1:52:27and most of those games, to your point are at supported and
- 1:52:29there's no way everyone's going to either once to where is going
- 1:52:33to be able to pay for these for these to the, you know, the ad
- 1:52:36supported model, I think makes a ton of sense.
- 1:52:38So your role as a VP of Global brand partnerships, like what
- 1:52:42can you maybe explain what entails and.
- 1:52:44Yeah, it's, it's finding the right brands and advertisers to
- 1:52:46be in this space and to to partner not only on the
- 1:52:49day-to-day media transactions we do, but create bigger and more
- 1:52:53kind of altruistic partnerships across the platform.
- 1:52:55So not just running ads in our kind of IAB standard media areas
- 1:53:01on our website, but actually creating long term campaigns
- 1:53:04where users can play and win and earn.
- 1:53:07We have a number of different ways that we help brands really
- 1:53:10get into the space and actually work with users from an
- 1:53:13engagement perspective. So imagine being able to play
- 1:53:16your favorite game, do a certain number of things, win a prize
- 1:53:19from a brand that's a great experience for you.
- 1:53:22It's a great experience for the brand.
- 1:53:23And so our team is really focused on not only here in the
- 1:53:26US, but globally, trying to find the right brands and agencies
- 1:53:29and partners to come in and play a bigger role in that ecosystem
- 1:53:32and help to drive more premium revenue to our creators.
- 1:53:36What types of brands are advertising or what sectors are
- 1:53:38you getting the most interest from right now?
- 1:53:40Yeah, it's, it's great. We see.
- 1:53:41A lot of different partners. We just wrapped up a campaign
- 1:53:44with the folks H&R Block, which you would think, OK, taxes
- 1:53:47gamers, but actually one of the largest small business groups
- 1:53:51out there are content creators and creators building out, oh,
- 1:53:54that's. Interesting.
- 1:53:55So we actually, we saw, we had a great campaign, we worked with
- 1:53:57them on promoting their different activations and stuff
- 1:54:00like that. And they came back to us and
- 1:54:02said that not only was it the best gaming partnership that
- 1:54:05they've done, but it was one of the best partnerships period
- 1:54:08that they did. Which for me is really important
- 1:54:10because we want to get outside the idea of, oh, we're just good
- 1:54:13for gamers. We're great for brands across
- 1:54:15the board. We've seen some really great
- 1:54:18opportunities with travel and tourism.
- 1:54:20Universal Orlando Resource, we've worked with recently.
- 1:54:23Few SRS are always a favorite with this McDonald's or Little
- 1:54:26Caesars. So we see a pretty good variety
- 1:54:29across the board in terms of what brands and agencies want to
- 1:54:31work with us. Entertainment's popular and then
- 1:54:33obviously endemic game publishers are very curious
- 1:54:36about kind of how we can help them connect with their future
- 1:54:39audiences and grow their overall target there.
- 1:54:43So your payouts, the goal is to be paid a billion, you said by
- 1:54:4620-30. Yeah, those aggressive goals.
- 1:54:48And then what's what's, what's in order to pay out a billion,
- 1:54:52how big if you're just doing the math here, So a billion dollars
- 1:54:57and if you're paying out let's say 50 to 70%, right?
- 1:55:00So you know that's pretty big ad number, right it?
- 1:55:03Is it is and it's not just ads that help support a business.
- 1:55:06So we do have payments and other verticals within our business.
- 1:55:10So there are other areas that we're also generating revenue
- 1:55:13for. So across the board, we're
- 1:55:15trying to kind of build this kind of payout system.
- 1:55:17So whether it's our ads business, our tax kind of
- 1:55:20payments business, there's a whole suite of tools and
- 1:55:24services that we're trying to help to get to that billion
- 1:55:26dollar number. So it's not just ads because
- 1:55:28that would make us a pretty big player in the ads business, but
- 1:55:31we're on our way. And I think that we're, you
- 1:55:33know, from an ad perspective, being able to put brands in an
- 1:55:37environment like video games is really valuable.
- 1:55:40And we're hearing that especially from kind of research
- 1:55:43companies like Adelaide, you talk about attention and the
- 1:55:45value of attention scores and video games are very, I mean, if
- 1:55:50you have a, a child or a significant other that plays
- 1:55:53games, it takes many, many times to get their attention right
- 1:55:56because they're locked in and focused and advertisers can't
- 1:55:59find that everywhere. And so they're, you know, this
- 1:56:01is an opportunity where if we can get it right with the
- 1:56:04correct kind of partnership between the ad and the consumer
- 1:56:08so that it's a pleasant experience for both sides and we
- 1:56:10can track it and we can put data on it and we can do those other
- 1:56:13things. I think that advertisers are
- 1:56:16really exciting, strong Val prop.
- 1:56:17We want to be in that environment, right?
- 1:56:18If you say to somebody, do you want to be in an environment
- 1:56:21where your audience is highly engaged and is going to see your
- 1:56:25ad and is going to have a much higher level of retention,
- 1:56:28everyone's going to say yes. You can tell them an awful lot
- 1:56:30about this, these audiences as well.
- 1:56:32Yeah, and it's a big thing that we're talking about this week at
- 1:56:34Possible. We're, you know, this is our
- 1:56:36first time we've launched an ad product at an event.
- 1:56:39So we're excited to talk about Gamer Grid, which is our new
- 1:56:42kind of first party data management platform.
- 1:56:44We're combining it with Arcspan and Live Ramp Data to give
- 1:56:47advertisers a much better understanding of their audience
- 1:56:51in this high attention environment.
- 1:56:53And I think that when we change that narrative, it ends up
- 1:56:55becoming a much more easy thing for someone to consume and
- 1:56:58perform, to buy, because too often we're being told you have
- 1:57:02to target gamers. That's a large group of people.
- 1:57:06Now, as you mentioned, everybody from people playing on mobile
- 1:57:08games, PC games, console switches, a lot of people
- 1:57:12playing games these days. And to see one holistic group
- 1:57:15needs to be reached. It's not the case they.
- 1:57:17Can take their audience, enrich it with let's say on board to
- 1:57:21put get a ramp ID, then match it up against your.
- 1:57:23See the overlap and target audience specifically.
- 1:57:25Exactly. And they can buy it direct.
- 1:57:27They can buy it through programmatic direct and this is
- 1:57:29a way for them to find their audience in our high attention
- 1:57:33environment, which is video games.
- 1:57:34And I think that that's much more as a much better way for
- 1:57:37this industry to work. I think that as someone who's
- 1:57:40spent so much time in video games, we have never made it
- 1:57:43easy for advertisers to buy our platform and our service.
- 1:57:46And it's the reason why, you know, we look at games like
- 1:57:49Grand Theft Auto 6, which are going to release later this
- 1:57:51year. Largest entertainment franchise
- 1:57:54launch ever. Oh, it's a multi billion dollar
- 1:57:56franchise, right? I mean, I don't think people
- 1:57:57appreciate like these games launch and they will do 10s of
- 1:58:00millions of dollars of sales like in the first few days.
- 1:58:02And we still. Outperform movies.
- 1:58:04And we're still on pace with podcasts in terms of of revenue.
- 1:58:08And you look at TV and, and, and CTV that are light years ahead
- 1:58:12of gaming. And we got to, we have to fix
- 1:58:13that. And that is a big reason why
- 1:58:15making it easier to transact through the kind of ads and
- 1:58:19situations that Overwolf is building, IAB standard trackable
- 1:58:23first party, third party data layering that's going to help
- 1:58:26the ad industry go. I'm comfortable with this this I
- 1:58:29can actually. Fix this.
- 1:58:31Maybe you can help fix podcasts next.
- 1:58:33Audio is totally under monetized as well.
- 1:58:35It is but but. Together.
- 1:58:37It has a lot of problems in terms of fragmentation and lack
- 1:58:39of. Just.
- 1:58:42Understanding is even even comparing metrics across the
- 1:58:44audio platforms is your challenge.
- 1:58:46I don't think gaming is quite as.
- 1:58:47I mean, gaming has a lot too. You look at game publishers all
- 1:58:50operate on their own infrastructures and so having
- 1:58:53that consistent synergy is really difficult.
- 1:58:55It's the, it's the power of Overwolf to be across 1500 games
- 1:58:59as opposed to, you know, a platform like a Roblox or a
- 1:59:02Fortnite, which is, you know, vertically integrated.
- 1:59:04But there's they don't talk to each other.
- 1:59:07And so to have a platform like Overwolf that sit over 1500
- 1:59:10games, you can have a much different strategy than if
- 1:59:13you're just working with one game publisher on one
- 1:59:15activation. Oh, really exciting.
- 1:59:17I'm we're going to be looking out for those announcements
- 1:59:20here. Possible love the pants by the.
- 1:59:22Way oh fantastic trying to keep that vibe you know I got to make
- 1:59:25that Florida vibe work yeah if. You're coming to Florida.
- 1:59:27Why not right, Especially, you know, perfect weather like this
- 1:59:29and beautiful sunshine. So well, good luck here.
- 1:59:32Possible enjoy the next few days.
- 1:59:34Appreciate you coming by and and maybe we should check back in in
- 1:59:37a few months and do a do one of one of our feature length long
- 1:59:40form pods. I think that'd be a lot of fun.
- 1:59:42Excellent, good to see you. Thanks.
- 1:59:44So much, yeah. All right, so we are at Signal
- 1:59:46Noise day one in the mansion on Venetian Way.
- 1:59:51It's beautiful place here. And we have Dave Rosno, who's
- 1:59:53the CMO of Permitive. That's right.
- 1:59:56Thank you very much for joining. Us great to be here, yeah.
- 1:59:59And we actually hosted, well, Rio and Brett the the the hosts
- 2:00:04of Signal Noise actually hosted Joe who's from permitive.
- 2:00:07I don't think the podcast has been released yet, so maybe
- 2:00:09we'll give some some sneak previews on the way.
- 2:00:12Everything you want to know about Permutive in two podcasts
- 2:00:15right there with signal and Noise.
- 2:00:17Epic. Right.
- 2:00:18So you look, you just joined. Actually you're not.
- 2:00:20You've not been at permutive even what, three months?
- 2:00:23I'm about 10 weeks, been so far loving it and I have all kinds
- 2:00:28of. I still have enough of my old
- 2:00:30perspective to bring to the conversation.
- 2:00:32What was your old perspective out of interest?
- 2:00:35Well, you know, I, I've been on the buy side for a long time, so
- 2:00:38I'm pretty sensitive to what people are saying in the market
- 2:00:41and how to screen through it. And then in the previous role we
- 2:00:48had to play a big role in popularizing curation.
- 2:00:50So I hope we get to talk about that and you know what, where it
- 2:00:53was and where it is. Absolutely.
- 2:00:55Yeah, yeah. So the buy side is giving you a
- 2:00:58really interesting lens. Obviously, I'm sure a big part
- 2:01:01of what attracted you to permit affirmative to you was that that
- 2:01:05violins what what is your mission as you've come in your
- 2:01:0910 weeks in what they what they giving you in Ted light.
- 2:01:12This is what the nut we want you to crack.
- 2:01:14You know, I think the most important, well, there's two
- 2:01:17things. There's what's important and
- 2:01:18there's what I love to do, right.
- 2:01:20So what's important is how do you differentiate in the
- 2:01:24marketplace and how do you say it in a way that makes sense for
- 2:01:27the buy side, right? There is a lot of technology and
- 2:01:30attack and mostly the buy side should not have to care about
- 2:01:35that. What they should care about is I
- 2:01:37can do something for my agency, for my brand, for my client,
- 2:01:41better, more effective than I did yesterday or make it easier.
- 2:01:45So I don't really care about your tech.
- 2:01:46I don't care if you were vibe coding the last five years in a
- 2:01:48basement and spent $100 million or if you got a genius with an
- 2:01:53MBA in a data science MB AAPHD in data science and they've just
- 2:01:59come up with something yesterday.
- 2:02:00If it makes my life better on the buy side, that should be the
- 2:02:03story. So that's story number one.
- 2:02:05What how do we take permutive, which is the leader in
- 2:02:09enterprise publishing data support and DMP?
- 2:02:14How do we take that and share what we've done for the buy
- 2:02:17side? So that's the job.
- 2:02:19You're not saying that sell side tech overcooks it are you with
- 2:02:23the attacking? No, I think it's just like my
- 2:02:27sensitivity is having been in meetings.
- 2:02:29We're successful. This goes for everybody.
- 2:02:32Yeah, this goes for branded trays at stadiums.
- 2:02:36Yeah, sorry if you're watching. It was a good meeting and I love
- 2:02:40you. But like that I have a very
- 2:02:42clear recollection, like you're not solving the world.
- 2:02:45Tell me how you helped me and put it in the right pitch.
- 2:02:48The thing I like personal. So that's what I think is so
- 2:02:50important, you know, for permutative and like why it's so
- 2:02:54important to explain what what we're doing in a way that makes
- 2:02:57sense for for the advertisers. What I love, however, and that
- 2:03:02what really got me to be so excited to join, is when you
- 2:03:08meet a company and you realize that there is this enormous
- 2:03:13amount of information and something both scaled and new
- 2:03:17that the world doesn't know about.
- 2:03:18Like it's like you're a diver and you found an under an
- 2:03:23underwater city and you're like, nobody knows about this.
- 2:03:27Like this is the kind of thing I want to make noise in the market
- 2:03:29about. And that's what's happened to
- 2:03:31Permutis this decade of working with publishers and creating
- 2:03:35data that the buy side is unaware of the depths.
- 2:03:39There, right. OK, so this is interesting.
- 2:03:41Give me a little teaser, I guess as to what some of those things
- 2:03:45that have kind of gone on earth or OK, those those gems that
- 2:03:48you're you've come in and gone by.
- 2:03:50Well, we should be definitely OK talking more about this.
- 2:03:53Absolutely. You know to cross over to a
- 2:03:56little bit of what we were going to talk about anyway.
- 2:04:00So you know there's this whole notion of first party data
- 2:04:03segments, right? Is that important in the market?
- 2:04:07Is it over hyped? The truth is that in a world
- 2:04:11that is increasingly working with the support of AI, so AI
- 2:04:16augmented real truth at the key is like the most important
- 2:04:21thing. Yeah, I think we all learned
- 2:04:23some new vernacular in the last two or three years is all this
- 2:04:26money has gone into AI and LLMS about, about training data,
- 2:04:31right? Like the whole world for some
- 2:04:33reason now knows everything about training data.
- 2:04:35You know, if you have an AI, let's say augmented system,
- 2:04:38which is where I think we are right now in our journey as an
- 2:04:42industry. If you have an AI augmented
- 2:04:44system and you don't have the best source of truth, which is
- 2:04:48actually what consumers are doing, then the whole thing
- 2:04:51falls apart. So what Permutive has done which
- 2:04:55is very different than what I've seen in other places is create a
- 2:04:58much more robust first party data set on behalf of
- 2:05:04publishers. And so instead of the six key
- 2:05:07areas that typically are used to transact for programmatic, which
- 2:05:12is kind of what we were using in the rest of the digital
- 2:05:16ecosystem, it's magnitudes greater.
- 2:05:19It is thousands and thousands and thousands of pieces of
- 2:05:23information that are being tracked over time that help
- 2:05:26publishers be better publishers. But that entire much more robust
- 2:05:30look at the consumer has not been pulled over to the buy
- 2:05:34side. So this notion that you had like
- 2:05:376 elements versus this high definition picture of your
- 2:05:41audience, so you can actually buy your specific audience,
- 2:05:44better approximate the brief drive, better performance
- 2:05:47because you are buying the right people.
- 2:05:49Like all of that is going to be net new.
- 2:05:51And I think something that we're going to be hearing a lot about.
- 2:05:54OK this. Is so that that's the underwater
- 2:05:56city. Yeah, this is really
- 2:05:57fascinating. Do you feel like that that is
- 2:06:00currently going on tap, that the buy side just doesn't know about
- 2:06:03those publisher direct audiences?
- 2:06:06Well, I hope it's not just me. Yeah, I hope I'm not the only
- 2:06:10one. But yeah, this notion of a key
- 2:06:12value pair and this notion of how much information is possible
- 2:06:19to grab on behalf that publishers have been doing.
- 2:06:21And maybe this is special because of permutative.
- 2:06:24I'm still new because we've been a SAS technology with a ton of
- 2:06:29funding that's been doing this for a decade and we've just been
- 2:06:31going and going and going. So we're already supporting the
- 2:06:35majority of enterprise publishers around the world, but
- 2:06:39I don't think buy side is aware that there is this treasure
- 2:06:43trove of first party data that will better allow them to say
- 2:06:47this is who I want and market, let me buy that specific person
- 2:06:50and then optimize based on like what you're telling me are the
- 2:06:53signals back. And it's that, it's that.
- 2:06:56What do you think that's a root cause of?
- 2:06:58Is that the fact that they've been used to buying from parties
- 2:07:04or is it they've been used to buying contextual?
- 2:07:08What do you think? What do you think buyers do that
- 2:07:10just causes them to have that blind spot?
- 2:07:12Oh, this is not a buyer's thing. This just hasn't been available
- 2:07:16on the buy side. So this is a company that has
- 2:07:20traditionally been working with publishers and publishers needed
- 2:07:24this one. We have accrued 182,000
- 2:07:28segments. There's no reason to have a
- 2:07:30first party deterministic data set like that unless it's in the
- 2:07:34service of publishers meeting advertiser needs.
- 2:07:37So this is just something that's new to the marketplace.
- 2:07:39Sometimes something new comes up.
- 2:07:42We've seen it, it creates a step change in what's possible in the
- 2:07:45digital ecosystem. And so I just think we've just
- 2:07:49started talking to the buy side in about the last year or so.
- 2:07:53And so this is just one of those things where we're going to be
- 2:07:56sharing it and figuring out the solutions and it'll.
- 2:07:58Be rolling out fantastic. OK, so this is really
- 2:08:01interesting and does this does this segue into curation for
- 2:08:06you? If you wanted to, yeah.
- 2:08:07I mean, it really touches every part of the digital ecosystem.
- 2:08:11Right. So let's talk about a little bit
- 2:08:12about duration, what you believe it has been up until now and
- 2:08:16what, what is it? What is it destined to be all
- 2:08:20what sort, what potential has it got?
- 2:08:22Because I, you know, I have heard lots of different lenses
- 2:08:26on it. It's the new ad network, it's
- 2:08:29new way of doing this. It takes margin.
- 2:08:31Well, there's lots of different lenses that you hear on online.
- 2:08:35And so help me break it down. Oh, let me define it like this.
- 2:08:41I've had this conversation a lot because in my former role get a
- 2:08:45lot to popularize curation. Yeah.
- 2:08:47So I think it's really important to keep in mind that there's two
- 2:08:50kinds of curation. There's regular curation and
- 2:08:54good curation. Good curation is how it started,
- 2:08:58right, which is the offering should be you have a unique data
- 2:09:03set, you're combining that with inventory into multi pub PNPS.
- 2:09:09You're activating that on the supply side.
- 2:09:11So Part 1, unique data set. Part 2, combining it with multi
- 2:09:16pub, you taking that data, combining it with multi pub,
- 2:09:20activating it in PNPS on the supply side.
- 2:09:23Three, you're optimizing it in real time, right?
- 2:09:26This is a huge upgrade for the whole system because you're
- 2:09:29taking the data, which is your source, your insight, and you're
- 2:09:33taking it out of a 30 to 45 day review cycle and bringing it
- 2:09:36into real time. That's just an upgrade for the
- 2:09:38whole system. That kind of jump ahead.
- 2:09:41However, the word curation is a regular word and in some cases
- 2:09:47it means ad network, like we're curating inventory, by the way,
- 2:09:51good idea to curate inventory. Yeah.
- 2:09:55But when you talk about why curation became a trend, it's
- 2:09:59those three things together. That's the good version.
- 2:10:02Yeah. But I think it's so important.
- 2:10:04OK, I like that. I also, I, I heard different
- 2:10:08lenses on it as well. And one of them that we stuck
- 2:10:10out to me was the idea of a chef in the kitchen knowing what
- 2:10:14they're doing, being a well bane chef and having access to the
- 2:10:18all of the ingredients in one place as opposed to what we had
- 2:10:22been doing for a long time, which is different parts of the
- 2:10:26ecosystem having different ingredients like the SSB having
- 2:10:30inventory, the DSB having data, yeah.
- 2:10:33And never the too short meat until the bid happens.
- 2:10:36Whereas whereas with curation it was, you know, it was
- 2:10:40interesting to me to think about the fact that you could
- 2:10:43prepackage and predict start that on.
- 2:10:46Yeah, the chef metaphor I love. First off, I love.
- 2:10:50I mean, you never met anybody who likes good metaphor.
- 2:10:53I looked down at my notes. They're full of metaphors.
- 2:10:56I worry sometimes a chef metaphor might be more like the
- 2:11:00inventory. And I hear so many people
- 2:11:02talking about curating the inventory unique first.
- 2:11:07What you really want is that unique first party data set
- 2:11:10activated on the supply side to get the real time.
- 2:11:13Like bringing real time into data is a game changer.
- 2:11:16You know, one of the things that we've been working on is this
- 2:11:20organization called Atria that we support.
- 2:11:22So this is a number of publishers in Europe.
- 2:11:25We said we want to get together and create our own curation
- 2:11:30solution and there have been a lot of discussion in curation.
- 2:11:34Is this net positive for publishers?
- 2:11:37A lot of the SSPD shared data that showed that it was
- 2:11:40incremental value, that curation was actually driving incremental
- 2:11:43revenue and incremental value for publishers.
- 2:11:46But I think I love the Atria example because, one, it shows
- 2:11:50that publishers are leaning into it and there's no better signal
- 2:11:52that duration can be positive for pubs than pubs saying we
- 2:11:56want to take our destiny into our own hands and this is the
- 2:11:58route. And then two, I love it because
- 2:12:00it's permeative tech underneath it powering.
- 2:12:03Right. OK.
- 2:12:04So let's rewind it a little bit because I want to unpack what's
- 2:12:08something really important you said.
- 2:12:09Publishers taking their destiny into their own hand.
- 2:12:12So help explain what Atria is to me, as if I'm a complete noob
- 2:12:18and haven't got any idea what it is.
- 2:12:20Sure. Yeah.
- 2:12:21So Atria is a group of 6 publishers in Europe, yeah, that
- 2:12:26have gotten together. They're all permutive clients
- 2:12:29and said we want to create our own closed curation solution so
- 2:12:34we can bring more scale across our audiences, but take
- 2:12:37advantage of all the things that good curation allows for.
- 2:12:42So on our pipes, on permitted infrastructure, we've helped
- 2:12:45them put that together and support it.
- 2:12:47And it just launched and it's really off to a great start.
- 2:12:49Fantastic. And and the and that's the
- 2:12:52mission at hand, is to help publishers take control.
- 2:12:55Yeah. And I think it's also about
- 2:12:56scale. You know, so publishers are in
- 2:13:00this situation where the buy side is, their expectations are
- 2:13:05being set by companies with spectacular technology at the
- 2:13:08walled gardens and they have scale.
- 2:13:11So certainly the first party data solution that publishers
- 2:13:16have is much more robust and the buy side has more opportunity to
- 2:13:20capitalize on that. They have a lot more control
- 2:13:23when they're working by the publisher.
- 2:13:24So how do those publishers work together to bring together more
- 2:13:28scale to make that equation more attractive for advertisers and
- 2:13:32agencies? So that I think is the is the
- 2:13:34thinking behind it. I love it.
- 2:13:36OK, and let's let's now switch our attention to the most
- 2:13:41buzzword, the buzzword of them all, which is AI, of course.
- 2:13:45Let's talk about how to how do you feel that intersects with
- 2:13:48what Permutive's mission is and and obviously that it poses an
- 2:13:54existential threat to leave the publishing industry and what
- 2:13:59does So what is your narrative change to be when it comes to a
- 2:14:03publisher? You know, we did most anti ad
- 2:14:07tech thing ever when it comes to AI affirmative, which was we
- 2:14:12built it and we didn't say anything.
- 2:14:14We're normally you tell you tell the entire industry what you're
- 2:14:17thinking and planning, Yeah. And then you go ahead and build
- 2:14:19it. So we've already built agents
- 2:14:22into our technology. They're already supporting
- 2:14:25hundreds of millions of dollars of publisher revenue.
- 2:14:30And what we've seen is it's just augmenting the entire process.
- 2:14:34So I'll give you a couple of examples.
- 2:14:38One is the amount of time it takes to respond to an RFP can
- 2:14:43go from days to literally 15 minutes.
- 2:14:46And you know, if you're a publisher selling in, that is
- 2:14:49the game changer. It means you can take on a lot
- 2:14:52more business, it means you can pitch more, but most
- 2:14:54importantly, you can work in a whole nother pacing and see what
- 2:14:57the outcomes are. The other thing that is amazing
- 2:15:01is it helps you better unlock your first party data.
- 2:15:05So there's a premium publisher group that we work with in
- 2:15:08Europe that because they have so much more insight and can work
- 2:15:13so much more quickly with the data, they're able to win
- 2:15:16clients, brands that they didn't think they could even compete
- 2:15:20with because they could say, oh, actually you would never come to
- 2:15:23us, but our audience for what you're looking for is bigger
- 2:15:26than the classic leaders in the category.
- 2:15:29So it's allowing them to increase the Tam and if, you
- 2:15:33know, you're on the revenue side and you say, hey, our DMP and
- 2:15:38their agentic agents are helping us increase our Tam, not just
- 2:15:42win the biz, our share of the pie.
- 2:15:44That's pretty good day, yeah. Yeah, that's one time.
- 2:15:47And is is that just on merit of being fresher and being sort of
- 2:15:51quicker to the table on pitches? It's, it's the ability to number
- 2:15:55crunch in a way that no one could before.
- 2:15:58And I think, and we'll see if, when you have your interview
- 2:16:02with Joe, if it lines up, there's just this, there's this
- 2:16:06weight that comes with our history as a SAS company, but
- 2:16:12not that it was built with this in mind.
- 2:16:14But when you're a SAS company, you're that much closer to being
- 2:16:17able to add AI into the mix because everything has to work
- 2:16:20automatically anyway, where that might be more difficult as a
- 2:16:24managed service company. So I think we just had, we saw
- 2:16:27this to immediate opportunity to make our processes better, what
- 2:16:31our solutions were for clients better.
- 2:16:34And it has turned into with AI this just upgrade.
- 2:16:37So it used to be if you want to figure out how to meet an RFP,
- 2:16:40you might want to talk to the person who knew your
- 2:16:43segmentation or your taxonomy the best and like really work
- 2:16:46through it. Now.
- 2:16:47The agents are great at that. It's like having your best
- 2:16:50librarian who've been at the company forever and knows all of
- 2:16:53your thousands of segments and can pull that together really
- 2:16:55quickly. It's like it's having the person
- 2:16:57you always want responding to the RFP always on at your
- 2:17:01fingertips. I love it and it's, you know,
- 2:17:04given like marrying that with something of the else important
- 2:17:09you said, which was real time data, which I also think as an
- 2:17:13industry we've spent a lot of time not having access to real
- 2:17:16time data, right? Not saying that, you know, I
- 2:17:19think that that's been a real thing in our industry where we
- 2:17:23talk about data, but only recently is it becoming really,
- 2:17:27really, really fresh. And so those things combined
- 2:17:31shout out that, you know, things are becoming so much more
- 2:17:34efficient. That's exactly right.
- 2:17:36And the thing that is going to continuously change is we're
- 2:17:41going to realize what we can cut down lag in a lot of places.
- 2:17:44Because let's face it, if you are talking to the buy side and
- 2:17:49the original upgrade was taking the recency of the data or the
- 2:17:53optimization from like 30 to 45 days real time, that's huge.
- 2:17:59Now we're going to keep finding as we have better technology,
- 2:18:02there are all these little spots that can unlock more opportunity
- 2:18:06with buy side. You can get faster over here.
- 2:18:09And you know, in any other industry, shaving, second
- 2:18:13shaving day, shaving weeks, whatever it is, provides a huge
- 2:18:16competitive advantage. So I think you're going to see
- 2:18:19smart tech companies, smart agencies, smart brands, like
- 2:18:24sniffing out who's on the cutting edge here because things
- 2:18:27are changing again. And like if they weren't leading
- 2:18:30before, here's our opportunity to have a real competitive
- 2:18:33advantage for the next two or three years.
- 2:18:34Yeah, Yeah, I totally see that as well.
- 2:18:36The next couple of years are filled with huge leaps in, in, I
- 2:18:42love the terminology. They're smart agencies, smart
- 2:18:44brands is sort of the discerning between who's using it right and
- 2:18:48not. So I think that will be the
- 2:18:49difference. Well, we all had a pass before
- 2:18:53on like in the beginning of the industry, we all had a pass on
- 2:18:55like how quickly we changed and then we realized, wait a second,
- 2:18:59technology might drive a real competitive advantage very
- 2:19:03quickly. And so I think, you know, there
- 2:19:05are now groups that are looking for that moment where if they
- 2:19:09jump in first and they can adopt some change, there can be a real
- 2:19:13advantage. Fantastic.
- 2:19:15This is a really good place to to leave us.
- 2:19:18But thank you so much Dave Rosner.
- 2:19:19I really appreciate your time. Wonderful.
- 2:19:23Excellent. Thank you.
- 2:19:25Bye. Alongacre here for signal and
- 2:19:28noise day number one for possible here with a special
- 2:19:30guest errors 11 from M and advisory.
- 2:19:32Good to see, as always. Good to see you, Rio.
- 2:19:34So I know you you can't meet or talk about quality didn't.
- 2:19:38You. How'd you know?
- 2:19:40Well, your reputation proceed doing the other episode we did
- 2:19:43together did really well. We got a lot of good feedback
- 2:19:45about your discussion about quality and outcomes and all
- 2:19:48that. So maybe stop there.
- 2:19:50Like, why is quality? Why are you so doggedly pursuing
- 2:19:54quality? Why does it matter?
- 2:19:56And why should why should people care?
- 2:19:58I think the story is for those that don't know, I spent most of
- 2:20:02my career at Google. I was there for 13 years and
- 2:20:05what I really saw was sort of that race to the bottom for the
- 2:20:09industry and it wasn't just a price, it was on quality as
- 2:20:11well. And what that ultimately the
- 2:20:15reason for all of that was buyers just didn't care that
- 2:20:19much. They didn't insert the quality
- 2:20:20controls. They started chasing cookies and
- 2:20:24users and attribution and kind of ignored the media quality.
- 2:20:28That plays a really important role in also driving marketing
- 2:20:31effectiveness. Do you think brands care?
- 2:20:35Do you think buyers care? I know it's a loaded question.
- 2:20:39It's tough because it's not a clear yes, no, there's generally
- 2:20:41no binaries in this world. There are buyers that care.
- 2:20:46They are, I would say, the minority.
- 2:20:48Many will say they care. How many have actually put those
- 2:20:51things into practice? They're in the minority.
- 2:20:54But I do think that most enterprise buyers, as they learn
- 2:20:58and they understand that their money is going not just the
- 2:21:01amount of money that's going towards lower quality media, but
- 2:21:03they're overpaying for that. That's when they become aware
- 2:21:07and real estate. So MFA is perfect example.
- 2:21:09Do buyers care about MFA? I mean, I think it should, they
- 2:21:12should. And I the outrage that you see
- 2:21:14on the Internet makes you think that they do, whether they've
- 2:21:18done anything about it, what they've done that's actually
- 2:21:20systemic and sustainable. Those are sort of open-ended.
- 2:21:23We don't know yet exactly if we've solved MFA or we've sort
- 2:21:26of. MFA is interesting one because I
- 2:21:28remember like with clients, they would tell you they don't want
- 2:21:31MFA and then, but if you pull out all the MFA sites, CPMS,
- 2:21:35they go up, right? I mean just naturally because
- 2:21:37you're paying low CPMS for inventory, right?
- 2:21:40So I always thought that was an interesting like, if you really
- 2:21:43care, you should be willing to pay more for quality, right?
- 2:21:45Yeah, there's that's exactly the story.
- 2:21:48There's definitely the paying for quality.
- 2:21:49It's moving away from cost and thinking about value.
- 2:21:52And I think one of the important stories, a narrative that I talk
- 2:21:56about a lot is it's not just I, I don't think low quality media
- 2:22:00is bad, right? You just have to pay the right
- 2:22:01amount for it. And the question is how much of
- 2:22:04your budget is also you're that you're signing towards this low
- 2:22:07quality media is can you be effective if you're spending too
- 2:22:10much of your ads on MFA sites where there's 20 ads around it
- 2:22:13or on CTV, you're spending 40% of your budget overnight.
- 2:22:18Can you be as effective? I'm not saying you shouldn't
- 2:22:20spend there and I'm not saying you shouldn't, you know, maybe
- 2:22:22it is worth the same, but it's probably worth less to you.
- 2:22:24And so it's more of that allocation of budget and it's
- 2:22:27moving away from this concept of average CPMS because that's
- 2:22:30really, I think one of the biggest scourges.
- 2:22:32If you were to reallocate from a lower quality but cheaper media
- 2:22:37towards higher quality media, even if you'd kept everything at
- 2:22:40the same price, in theory that would be a good thing, but your
- 2:22:44average CPMS would go up. And that's often what the
- 2:22:46procurement teams are looking at.
- 2:22:47And that's sort of that red flag that they see.
- 2:22:50There's a time and a place maybe for like low quality, low CPM,
- 2:22:53like within a brand's let's say media plan.
- 2:22:55Absolutely. The concept is called the the
- 2:22:57mere exposure effect. And so there's sort of a lot of
- 2:23:00research around this to show that just for Coca-Cola to serve
- 2:23:03you this tiny little ADD that you see over and over again,
- 2:23:06that's enough for them to sort of be in the back of your mind,
- 2:23:09at least not top of mind, but back of your mind for when
- 2:23:11you're thirsty, you're going to think about their brand.
- 2:23:14And so there is value for that low quality media, but it has to
- 2:23:16be cheap enough to be worth it. So it's like building the right
- 2:23:20plan to account for, OK, we're going to spend some on high CPM,
- 2:23:23high quality CTV. We're going to spend some on let
- 2:23:26this low quality, you know, long tail stuff that's going to be
- 2:23:30made more more ubiquitous, but knowing what they're paying for
- 2:23:33and planning for that. Yeah, and it is sort of campaign
- 2:23:35specific. And so that's easy for Coca-Cola
- 2:23:37because everyone knows they're red iconic brand, they're going
- 2:23:40to buy it everything else. But if you're a brand new
- 2:23:42marketer or a brand new product that needs to get out to market,
- 2:23:45the low quality media probably won't do the trick.
- 2:23:47You need to sort of like at least first people to understand
- 2:23:50what your product is and who you are and then you can do sort of
- 2:23:53more that like repetition through lower quality exposures
- 2:23:57just to make sure they're top of mind for when those people do
- 2:23:59enter the market. What's the like the angle for
- 2:24:02the publishers here? Because obviously focusing on
- 2:24:04quality, like as a former planner and buyer, I mean, you
- 2:24:11in theory should be helping the big, the premium publishers,
- 2:24:13right, Because there's a focus in quality and getting your ads
- 2:24:15in front of the right places with the right, you know, the
- 2:24:17right publications with, with great content, with great
- 2:24:20audience data. I mean, that should be I would
- 2:24:22think of course in quality is going to be better for them,
- 2:24:24correct? Absolutely, yeah.
- 2:24:25I mean, there's a lot of people that have been sort of screwed
- 2:24:29over in this sort of race to the bottom and quality publishers
- 2:24:33probably more than anybody else. And so we've seen money move
- 2:24:38from where it should have gone, higher quality publishers
- 2:24:41towards that sort of lower quality MFA.
- 2:24:43As buyers shift to higher quality, it's going to go
- 2:24:45towards publishers that have fewer ads on the page, that have
- 2:24:47more attentive audiences, maybe more loyal audiences, maybe
- 2:24:50audiences that have given them their data.
- 2:24:52And so they can use that as well to sort of make even more value
- 2:24:55out of the impression that they. You've talked a lot in your
- 2:24:58writing about vanity metrics and how you just you don't like
- 2:25:01them. You think it's forced.
- 2:25:04I think the obsession with vanity metrics has made brands
- 2:25:07and made buyers focus on the wrong things.
- 2:25:09Can you explain that? Yeah.
- 2:25:10So we're in a very dynamic ecosystem.
- 2:25:14And so nothing is static, nothing remains good.
- 2:25:17When viewability first came out, it was a really valuable metric
- 2:25:20because it chopped off all of this inventory that wasn't
- 2:25:24valuable at all. And I wouldn't say it's a vanity
- 2:25:26metric entirely. It's not broadly, but in
- 2:25:29isolation it's a vanity metric it.
- 2:25:31Would be like one example. It is an example, yeah.
- 2:25:33Completed views is another one and that's the one that I think
- 2:25:36is a little bit easier to understand.
- 2:25:37When video, when online video came out, most video ads were
- 2:25:42sort of the large full screen sound on ads.
- 2:25:45And so a completed view was a pretty good proxy that somebody
- 2:25:48watched it and was sort of attentive when out stream video
- 2:25:52came along and you had all these small muted video players
- 2:25:55playing on the bottom. Below the fold or whatever.
- 2:25:57OK. They completed too.
- 2:25:59And so completed views viewability or you know,
- 2:26:01completed completion rate, that became a vanity metric.
- 2:26:05And it's easy to game. Is your.
- 2:26:06Point it became it was game. Now what I like I wouldn't throw
- 2:26:11that metric away. What I would say is you have to
- 2:26:14add other metrics on top. Quality needs to be multi
- 2:26:16dimensional and so just the fact that it completed is enough
- 2:26:19completed plus it was a large ad plus the sound was on.
- 2:26:23That's a really telling set of signals that tell you that that
- 2:26:26was of the highest quality of the type of ads you can get.
- 2:26:30Turning to video, CTV is a lot of budget going.
- 2:26:33I think I was reading the other day it's going to grow 18% this
- 2:26:36year, which is, you know, pretty remarkable.
- 2:26:39And then obviously traditional and traditional like linear
- 2:26:43television is shrinking, but CTV growing a lot.
- 2:26:46There's I think it was initially this perception that it was all
- 2:26:51high quality. The CPMS are higher, but there's
- 2:26:53been a lot, I think you talked about gaming and like like
- 2:26:55there's been a lot of, I think that especially CTV and has been
- 2:26:58debates about what is real CTV inventory in stream versus out
- 2:27:01stream. Like the viewers who are not
- 2:27:04deep into space might, might not know a lot of these terms.
- 2:27:06Maybe you can just walk us through that real quick.
- 2:27:08Like like what is real CTV inventory in stream versus out
- 2:27:11stream And like what would you what do you consider quality?
- 2:27:13Yeah. So I don't want to be the one to
- 2:27:15determine what is CTV because I do think that it's it's a little
- 2:27:19bit in the eye of the beholder of the consumer and of the
- 2:27:23advertiser. So each one of them might decide
- 2:27:25that feels like CTV to me and we should consider both of those.
- 2:27:29I think one of the issues we have is that we have like served
- 2:27:31this broad category. And so we do have a category
- 2:27:33problem with CTV and online video where like who knows?
- 2:27:36They, they are these channels that are, as I tell it, they're
- 2:27:39not a monolith. It's really high quality.
- 2:27:43The most premium thing that you can think of is CTV and all of
- 2:27:46the, and then you have some of the lowest quality, some home
- 2:27:48screen, the small muted videos that are autoplay that also
- 2:27:52consider themselves in those categories.
- 2:27:54And so we have to think about what are those qualities metrics
- 2:27:56that will determine the relative value of different impressions
- 2:28:01or different, you know, buckets of media within each of those
- 2:28:04channels. We talked to Doctor Fu a couple
- 2:28:07weeks ago on this pod and and his I even asked them like role
- 2:28:10of CTV at web. He his opinion is CTV is not
- 2:28:14part of open web. It is a separate thing and
- 2:28:18opinion on that because it sounds like what you're saying
- 2:28:20is a lot of online video that just like maybe it is CTV,
- 2:28:23right? Even if it's not like on a
- 2:28:25premium, let's say it's not Amazon Prime Video, it's not
- 2:28:28Hulu, it's not like what we can definitely consider TTB.
- 2:28:31It sounds like there's a you're saying there's a Gray area of
- 2:28:33stuff that some brands, some advertisers may be fine with it
- 2:28:36may consider it CTB. Yeah, absolutely.
- 2:28:38And I think it would be foolish for somebody to just when you
- 2:28:40draw an arbitrary line, and that's sort of the issue with
- 2:28:42the binaries, You're first of all too often valuing everything
- 2:28:47that's above that line as equal, but then you're saying
- 2:28:50everything below that line is worth 0.
- 2:28:52And that's not true. There is value even in those
- 2:28:54small little. You did video ads.
- 2:28:56And so this is like moving away from binaries on the sort of
- 2:29:00Doctor Fu comment, I disagree. I actually think it's more
- 2:29:03helpful to consider CTV as part of the open web.
- 2:29:06The way that I've looked at the open web and I haven't seen this
- 2:29:09framing in a while that that I've put together, but it's this
- 2:29:12idea of like the openness of digitally transactable media.
- 2:29:17And so when there is a buying platform that is exclusively of
- 2:29:23able to access certain content to what they own, right Google
- 2:29:26only Google, only alphabets, their DSP can access YouTube, so
- 2:29:31YouTube. Is not played inventory for.
- 2:29:32Google exactly that. And and owned and operated and
- 2:29:35so and it's exclusive to them. That's not the open web.
- 2:29:37That's on video. For the walled gardens, walled
- 2:29:40gardens and everything else is the open web.
- 2:29:43And so CTV should be part of the open web.
- 2:29:46We don't have to think about the open web is like, what's the
- 2:29:48browser, you know? Jesse Foo was saying how he
- 2:29:51believes buyers go to the platforms themselves To go to
- 2:29:55Amazon BSP, go to, you know, for Amazon Prime Video to DV 360 for
- 2:30:00YouTube, Go to, you know whose platform for.
- 2:30:04He was saying go to them, I should go to them, not work
- 2:30:07through a DSP by direct. That was his thesis.
- 2:30:09I'd never heard that before. It's actually it reminded me
- 2:30:13what he was saying that I've always been a fan of too.
- 2:30:17There is a very finite amount of human time and attention, but we
- 2:30:23have pretended like it is infinite because there are
- 2:30:25infinite number of impressions. There is always.
- 2:30:28You can always. Creepy, not human impressions
- 2:30:30necessarily. Not necessarily human
- 2:30:32impressions, but they are. But then there's twenty of them
- 2:30:34on a page. But the amount of time and
- 2:30:36attention that people can spend on any of those as is finite.
- 2:30:41And so we've seen all of these things grow.
- 2:30:43The time and attention that people haven't spent on this
- 2:30:45media has not necessarily grown that imbalance of sort of supply
- 2:30:49and demand. And I believe when we finally
- 2:30:52recognize it as such, right when people realize that they're
- 2:30:55buying 20 ad on a page instead of the one that they should be
- 2:30:58focusing on. When we deal with that supply
- 2:31:01scarcity that actually exists, the price is going to go way up
- 2:31:05because the demand is still going to be really high.
- 2:31:07So think about the most premium CTV, actual people watching
- 2:31:11sound on video. There's not that.
- 2:31:13Only so much, but it's. A limited amount.
- 2:31:15When buyers actually concentrate their demand there, the prices
- 2:31:19are going to go up and most of that supply is not going to be
- 2:31:22transacted in this sort of programmatic DFP Biddle, at
- 2:31:25least not in a Biddle Bowl, right?
- 2:31:27It's going to be a seller's market where they can say, hey,
- 2:31:30I've got something that almost nobody else has.
- 2:31:32I am going to keep reserve because if you don't buy it from
- 2:31:35me upfront in a guaranteed and pay me the top dollar for it,
- 2:31:38somebody else will. The Super Bowl gets sold out
- 2:31:40every single year. So looking at biddable versus
- 2:31:44non biddable, I know in CTV now the majority is biddable.
- 2:31:48If I'm not mistaken, I don't think so.
- 2:31:49No, I don't think so. Not.
- 2:31:51What is the split you have Any idea roughly?
- 2:31:54Who was I listening to recently? It'll come to me at Satari.
- 2:31:59Satari CEO, He was at Market Texture and he's been a couple
- 2:32:02of other events. He's saying that the vast
- 2:32:05majority of what they're seeing, like 90% of CTV is not
- 2:32:08transacted in a bit of a way. It might be running through
- 2:32:10programmatic pipes, but it's not biddable like those are set
- 2:32:14guaranteed prices of how much is going to be filled.
- 2:32:17Maybe there's a little bit of intelligence of things moving
- 2:32:20around, a little bit of optimization, but it's not a per
- 2:32:22impression sort of priced media. Right, there's no open exchange.
- 2:32:27Or it's not. I mean, even some PMPMPS are
- 2:32:30still biddable too. They're they're still a little
- 2:32:31bit bit, I think most of it is almost it's closer to a
- 2:32:34reservation, it's closer to an IO deal.
- 2:32:36Maybe there's a little bit of intelligence.
- 2:32:38Going back to the future, right, That's like, you know how, how
- 2:32:40things used to be, right? When you're, when you're buying,
- 2:32:42buying linear television, right, you're, you're going to the
- 2:32:44upfront. So I think 90 up to 95% used to
- 2:32:47be transaction throughout front and there was a scatter market
- 2:32:49which was more expensive. Interestingly enough, it was not
- 2:32:52a race to launch your point. There's only limited inventory.
- 2:32:54And that's the advantage to buyers that buy in advance,
- 2:32:57right? You're going to pay more to go
- 2:32:58into the scatter. And so you want to buy it, you
- 2:33:01want to reserve it, you want to hold on to it.
- 2:33:02That's how markets that are non commoditized, right?
- 2:33:05You have a differentiated market and people will buy.
- 2:33:08There's always going to be buyers that want the best stuff
- 2:33:10and they're willing to pay more for it.
- 2:33:12They're going to pay premium. They want that early access.
- 2:33:14And so that's what we need to sort of return to because we've
- 2:33:16treated media as this undifferentiated commodity.
- 2:33:19And now we're starting to realize there are qualitative
- 2:33:22differences, There's scarcity on the really good stuff, and
- 2:33:25that's going to be transacted differently than sort of this.
- 2:33:28What we had is that remnant programmatic space.
- 2:33:30That's interesting. So what sounds like a thesis is
- 2:33:32saying if you want quality, you you should be able to understand
- 2:33:38differencing quality and not quality, but also like you
- 2:33:40should be like branch, be willing to pay for it and you
- 2:33:42should understand like there's a limited quality inventory.
- 2:33:45It should cost a premium and you should you should factor into
- 2:33:48your media plan. Yeah, that's, that's the story.
- 2:33:51You have to factor that in. Don't pay for all media the
- 2:33:54same, right, If not all created equal.
- 2:33:56And so once you have that basic premise, there's really small
- 2:33:58things to do. Like on CTV, the example of that
- 2:34:01I always show most DSPS in that sort of programmatic or even non
- 2:34:05programatic, non biddable environments, a lot of spend
- 2:34:08happens in the middle of the night, right, because budgets
- 2:34:11need to get spent. And so they're spending twenty,
- 2:34:133040% of those CTV budgets in the middle of the night.
- 2:34:17And there's not. Those are mostly not people
- 2:34:19watching. I'm guessing correct, they might
- 2:34:20be. CTV is a 1 to 1, so it's a
- 2:34:22little bit different than linear TV.
- 2:34:23So I'm not saying it's worth 0. It's probably worth less.
- 2:34:26But the problem is the buyers are paying the same amount for
- 2:34:28every single hour of the day. So at 2:00 AM and 2:00 PM and
- 2:34:318:00 PM, they're paying the same CTM, which doesn't compute for
- 2:34:34most advertisers. If they know prime time.
- 2:34:36Not only is it like more prime glamorous, but also there's
- 2:34:39probably more people in the room when.
- 2:34:40You look at day parts, it would be different rates for normal
- 2:34:43television there's. A little bit different than than
- 2:34:45linear, which wasn't bought on it per impression.
- 2:34:48So I acknowledge it's probably not going to be a one to one
- 2:34:50match. But most advertisers would look
- 2:34:52at this and say, I don't want to spend 30% of my budget
- 2:34:54overnight. And I certainly don't want to
- 2:34:56pay the same CPMS at 2:00 AM as I would to reach a user who
- 2:34:59might just be more receptive to the message at 2:00 PM or 8:00
- 2:35:02PM or there's going to be more people in the room.
- 2:35:04And so that little trick and that really like obvious
- 2:35:08example, I think it's enough to open people's eyes and say, oh,
- 2:35:10what other quality signals are we undervaluing?
- 2:35:14So you've been on the quality bandwagon now for Spin at least
- 2:35:17a year, right? It's been about 10 years, 10
- 2:35:20years, yeah. Like, you know, really up in
- 2:35:22Adam for probably closer to two, but it was our attention for at
- 2:35:26least 5 plus years before that. Do you think are you noticing a
- 2:35:28difference? Absolutely, Yeah.
- 2:35:30I mean, people are talking about it more.
- 2:35:31I mean, the paper, the paper that I'm about to release now
- 2:35:35that was commissioned by STEM, the Coalition for Innovation and
- 2:35:37Media Measurement, that came about because they noticed
- 2:35:40everyone's talking about quality.
- 2:35:42It's the buzzword, but no one defined what it means.
- 2:35:45And it's hard to sort of like move together as an industry
- 2:35:47without this definition. So SIM decided we're going to
- 2:35:50move forward. We're going to help define what
- 2:35:51quality means. That really helps their
- 2:35:53constituents in the CTV world, both advertisers and publishers
- 2:35:57that have been a little bit stuck.
- 2:35:59They I, in my opinion, was not the right approach to sort of
- 2:36:03make the fight about premium, right As they're like, no, we're
- 2:36:06premium and we're better. I don't like premium
- 2:36:08particularly because this is another binary and it's still
- 2:36:11subjective. But then you say like, oh.
- 2:36:13Premium. You're what, right?
- 2:36:14Exactly. And it's quality is actually a
- 2:36:16little bit more granular. And so you can have high quality
- 2:36:18and medium quality and low quality and low quality is fine,
- 2:36:21but at the right place. And so it adds a little bit more
- 2:36:24of that granularity and the nuance that I think is needed to
- 2:36:26tell that story. Because if I'm looking at
- 2:36:28YouTube and I tell this story like YouTube is gigantic and it
- 2:36:32has some really high quality stuff, right?
- 2:36:33Like, no doubt about it. Find anything on YouTube, I mean
- 2:36:35you can find some incredible content.
- 2:36:37It's incredible. And to the point, I think
- 2:36:39YouTube's still like right, it's there like top one percent, 5%.
- 2:36:43Any single user and any single advertiser would look at that
- 2:36:46and say that is as high quality as any other media that I can
- 2:36:49possibly find. But that's their top 1 to 5%.
- 2:36:52The vest of their content is not that.
- 2:36:54The vast majority, there's a lot of medium quality stuff, the
- 2:36:57stuff that we watch every day, but there's also people just
- 2:36:59playing music videos in the background on their TV.
- 2:37:02There's also lots of kids content and now probably even
- 2:37:04more AI, whatever slot that's that's playing there.
- 2:37:07There's a lot of low quality stuff, which I'm not saying
- 2:37:10don't buy and don't pay any amount of money for.
- 2:37:12I'm just saying don't spend 3040% of your budget on that and
- 2:37:16be like, oh, this is my YouTube. Glad that average CPM, the
- 2:37:19average completed view or whatever else that you're
- 2:37:22looking at that is not telling the story and you know, a little
- 2:37:25bit of deviation, but just because they can do, and this
- 2:37:29applies to Amazon, This applies to everyone else because you can
- 2:37:31do some attribution from video down to a search or to a
- 2:37:36purchase is not proof of of the totality of the effectiveness.
- 2:37:41I'm not even if you sort of ignore the fact that attribution
- 2:37:44can be games. It doesn't tell the full story
- 2:37:46of the and the long term value of people being exposed to ads,
- 2:37:50remembering that brand, buying it later, sometimes in a way
- 2:37:53that you have no way to actually track and prove or in a more of
- 2:37:56a probabilistic model where it's like, you know, me and my wife,
- 2:37:59she saw the ad, I made the purchase.
- 2:38:02They're going to attribute that to my household, but I didn't
- 2:38:04see the ad. And so do you know George Box
- 2:38:09was a famous mathematician. He is a famous quote said all
- 2:38:13models are wrong. Some are useful.
- 2:38:15I like that. It's it's a great quote.
- 2:38:17And I think that's sort of where we've gone wrong because we have
- 2:38:20been, our world has been modeled.
- 2:38:22We've pretended that it. Was taking every in the model.
- 2:38:24Exactly. And we haven't sort of said, Oh
- 2:38:26well, they're not perfect. And so if you put that little
- 2:38:28margin of error, then you actually you're forced to sort
- 2:38:32of prove it and triangulate and confirm it in different ways.
- 2:38:35I think that's. You hit on something important.
- 2:38:36I think a lot like marketing really is about it's rare that
- 2:38:40there's a right or wrong answer. OK, well, how right is this
- 2:38:42answer? How wrong is this answer or this
- 2:38:44approach? And let's try it out.
- 2:38:45Let's test it, let's test it, let's test it.
- 2:38:47I mean, I think people, I mean, and with these platforms, it's
- 2:38:51easy to test, but I think a lot of what happens now is all let's
- 2:38:53implement this and let's set forget it, right?
- 2:38:55Because it's because it's hard. So maybe and maybe AI changes
- 2:38:58that. Not fully.
- 2:39:00It might help in some ways, but it could hurt too, right.
- 2:39:02If the incentives aren't aligned and then we're still measuring
- 2:39:04things, assigning too much certain certainty to the models
- 2:39:08that's that could be really detrimental.
- 2:39:10And so it really depends on what checks we have.
- 2:39:12The one thing sort of going back to your point earlier saying
- 2:39:15well, like we're going back in time, I talk about the quality
- 2:39:18controls that we had in the broadcaster and there were
- 2:39:20multiple quality controls. But ultimately the maybe the
- 2:39:23most important one is that we knew that there was no
- 2:39:26deterministic 100% certainty. Everything was probabilistic.
- 2:39:30Everything was statistically significant.
- 2:39:32We looked up to short in the long term.
- 2:39:33It wasn't 100% perfectly effective, but an average across
- 2:39:37populations. We knew that it was.
- 2:39:39We got into this precision era where we sort of got that.
- 2:39:42We're like, oh, actually the attribution model.
- 2:39:44Precision, right? We we thought we were in.
- 2:39:45Precision exactly. So we followed it.
- 2:39:48It wasn't accurate, but it was precise and we followed that we
- 2:39:51even though it was models. Cookies and we had these models
- 2:39:54for attribution, for MTA and all these other things.
- 2:39:57Which I, I think to a time they probably worked well, but once
- 2:39:59they scaled and sort of got out of control without the quality
- 2:40:01control as it got worse. So now we're going a little bit
- 2:40:04back to the future and we have to re embrace this idea that
- 2:40:06most advertising you can't know specifically.
- 2:40:09Precisely how it where every single ad and how it affected
- 2:40:12every single person. You have to look at
- 2:40:13probabilistic, you have to look at populations, you have to
- 2:40:16understand that there's models involved.
- 2:40:18Everything just gets statistically significant.
- 2:40:20There's ranges of probabilities and you look over the short and
- 2:40:22the long term together. Well, there's been a great
- 2:40:25discussion. We'd love to get you back on the
- 2:40:27pod for for a long form, you know, 6090 minute discussion.
- 2:40:32This it's an incredible topic and the you know, the previous
- 2:40:35episode we put out like continues to get a lot of views.
- 2:40:38So thanks again for coming by and I'm sure I'll see you in the
- 2:40:40next couple days. Yeah, I'd love to chat when the
- 2:40:42quality paper comes out. I think that you'll you'll
- 2:40:44appreciate a lot of the frameworks and principles and
- 2:40:46then there'll be another great discussion from there.
- 2:40:48Nice, love it. Awesome.
- 2:40:49Thanks for you.