Latest / Deep Dive / Customer Loyalty Starts with Solving Real Problems: The Foundation of Every Successful Business
Transcript
- 0:00Every single year companies spend like billions of dollars
- 0:03on market research. I mean, they run these elaborate
- 0:05focus groups. Right.
- 0:06Yeah, and they send out just endless surveys to everybody.
- 0:09Exactly. They corner you in shopping
- 0:10malls and they essentially just ask us, the consumers, exactly
- 0:13what we want, right? And yet if you actually look at
- 0:16the statistics, something like 80% of new products just totally
- 0:21fail. They crash and burn.
- 0:22Which is pretty wild. It is so if we have all this
- 0:26data, you know, if we are constantly asking people what
- 0:28they desire, why are we failing so spectacularly?
- 0:31Well, it's mostly because as a species we are basically just
- 0:36chronic polite liars. Which is a terrifying
- 0:39realization, especially if your entire livelihood depends on
- 0:44building something that other people actually find valuable.
- 0:47Yeah, totally. Because we had this really deep
- 0:49seated assumption that if you just ask someone a direct
- 0:52question about what they want to buy, they will give you a
- 0:54direct, honest answer. Right, like a robot.
- 0:57Exactly. But human psychology simply
- 1:00doesn't work that way. When you put someone on the
- 1:02spot, their brain doesn't objectively calculate their
- 1:05future purchasing habit. Oh, not at all.
- 1:07Right, their brain instantly goes into social preservation
- 1:10mode. And that disconnect, you know,
- 1:12between what we think we are building and how humans actually
- 1:15behave is exactly what we are unpacking in today's deep dive.
- 1:18So welcome to the conversation. And glad to be here.
- 1:21Today, our mission is to basically shortcut your path to
- 1:24being truly well informed about how markets actually operate in
- 1:28reality, not just in theory. Because the theory is often
- 1:31completely divorced from what happens on the ground.
- 1:33Oh 100%. We are looking at a fundamental
- 1:36paradigm shift regarding what value actually is, and we're
- 1:40going to give you the tool kit to extract the truth from people
- 1:43who are instinctively trying to lie to you out of sheer
- 1:46politeness. Yeah.
- 1:48And to do this, we are synthesizing 2 really incredible
- 1:52sources today. Which I am so excited about.
- 1:55Me too. First, we have this highly
- 1:58influential and honestly somewhat controversial academic
- 2:00paper. It's titled Surface Dominant
- 2:03Logic, a Necessary Step by Robert F Lush and Steven L
- 2:08Vargo. Which is quite a mouthful.
- 2:10It is, yeah. But it's this heavy hitting
- 2:12theoretical teardown of modern economics.
- 2:14Yeah. And then to ground those massive
- 2:17theories and practical reality, we are pairing it with a
- 2:20brilliant, gritty handbook called The Mom Test by Rob
- 2:24Fitzpatrick. Which is such a good title.
- 2:26It really is, and it's essentially a survival guide for
- 2:29talking to customers without getting lied to.
- 2:30And the way these two sources connect is genuinely mind
- 2:34blowing. Like we're going to start at the
- 2:35absolute zenith of economic theory, literally redefining
- 2:38what a global economy even is, and then we were going to plunge
- 2:41straight into the awkward, sweaty reality of sitting across
- 2:45a coffee shop table from someone.
- 2:47Just desperately trying to figure out if your business idea
- 2:49is actually worth pursuing. Exactly.
- 2:51So let's dive into the theory first.
- 2:53Because Lush and Vargo didn't just write a paper, they
- 2:56basically started in an academic turf war.
- 2:58Oh, they absolutely did. They introduced this framework
- 3:01called Service Dominant Logic, or SD Logic for short, and when
- 3:05they published this they were actively defending their theory
- 3:09against some very vocal critics. Yeah, they were taking some
- 3:12heat. A lot of heat in this specific
- 3:14paper. They're responding to John and
- 3:16Nicholas O'Shaughnessy, who just came out swinging.
- 3:18What were they saying? Well, the O'Shaughnessy is
- 3:20essentially called SD logic, A backward step.
- 3:23They labeled it regressive and they argued that it was just
- 3:26this wrong headed tech obsessed delusion.
- 3:29OK, let's unpack this right away, because why on earth are
- 3:33academics getting into a mudslinging match over a
- 3:36business theory? Like what nerve did Lush embargo
- 3:39actually strike? Well, they struck at the very
- 3:42foundation of how we've been taught to view the world since
- 3:46basically the Industrial Revolution.
- 3:48Wow, OK. Yeah, the dominant mindset of
- 3:50the past century, the one that critics are fiercely defending,
- 3:54is what Lesh and Vargo call goods Dominant logic, or GD
- 3:57logic. GD logic.
- 3:59OK, right? And GD logic focuses entirely on
- 4:02the output. It's this really entrenched
- 4:04belief that value is something a company physically creates
- 4:09inside a factory. So it's about the tangible
- 4:11stuff. Exactly.
- 4:13You take raw materials, you assemble them into a thing, a
- 4:15tangible good, and you literally embed value into that physical
- 4:18object, and then you push it across a counter to a consumer.
- 4:22So it's basically the Henry Ford Ford model.
- 4:24Like Ford builds the Model T on an assembly line.
- 4:27The factory workers imbue the steel and the rubber with value
- 4:32through their hard labor. Exactly.
- 4:34So the car now holds that value almost like a bucket holds
- 4:37water. I buy the car, I take the bucket
- 4:39of value home and I slowly consume it over time.
- 4:42Precisely. That is GD logic in a nutshell.
- 4:44And our entire global accounting system, you know, our inventory
- 4:48management, our entire business vocabulary is built completely
- 4:51around. This and we literally count
- 4:52units sold. Right, but Lesh and Vargo argue
- 4:55that this output oriented view is a complete illusion.
- 4:58An illusion. Yeah, they call it a
- 4:59hallucination brought on by the manufacturing boom.
- 5:02They propose SD logic which just flips the entire board over.
- 5:08In their view, the focus should not be on the thing being
- 5:11traded, it should be on the knowledge and skills being
- 5:14applied. Now this is where their
- 5:16definition of service really caught me off guard because
- 5:19normally, you know, when I think of the service industry, I think
- 5:21of restaurants or hair salons or maybe consulting.
- 5:25The stuff that isn't manufactured.
- 5:26Exactly, but Lush and Vargo define service singular, not
- 5:31plural, as the application of specialized competences.
- 5:34Right, which means the application of knowledge and
- 5:36skills through deeds, processes and performances, basically for
- 5:41the benefit of another entity. So under this new logic, the
- 5:44physical object is totally secondary.
- 5:46Completely secondary. The paper gives us really
- 5:48fascinating example about a tailor.
- 5:50Oh the tailor example is great. Walk us through that.
- 5:53OK, so if you go to a tailor and they measure you and they sew a
- 5:56custom suit specifically for your body, traditional GD
- 6:00economics classifieds that as a service.
- 6:02Because it's customized, right? That makes sense under the old
- 6:05rules. But if that exact same tailor,
- 6:07using the exact same sewing machine and the exact same
- 6:09thread goes to work in a massive factory and just sews standard
- 6:14size 42 suits that are shipped to a department store, suddenly
- 6:20traditional economics classifieds that as
- 6:22manufacturing. Which logically makes absolutely
- 6:24no sense. None.
- 6:26Because the physical action hasn't changed.
- 6:28The skill hasn't changed. Yeah, the fundamental reality of
- 6:31what is happening, you know, a human being applying their
- 6:34specialized knowledge of textiles and geometry to create
- 6:38clothing, is identical. And totally identical.
- 6:40The only thing that changed is this arbitrary classification
- 6:43based on the distribution method.
- 6:45It's completely arbitrary and actually makes me think about
- 6:47buying a lawn mower. Oh, that's a good one.
- 6:49Right, because if you go to a hardware store and buy a heavy
- 6:52gas powered lawn mower, traditional GD logic says you
- 6:56just purchased a physical good. Right, you own a machine now.
- 6:59But let's be honest, you don't actually want a lawn mower if
- 7:03you listening to this right now. Think about it.
- 7:05Nobody inherently desires to own a loud, dangerous piece of metal
- 7:10and plastic that takes up half your garage and smells like
- 7:13gasoline. No, nobody wants that.
- 7:15What you actually want is the service of having a short
- 7:17manicured lawn. The physical lawn mower is just
- 7:20a distribution mechanism for that service.
- 7:23There's a brilliant way to frame it.
- 7:25You are not buying metal, you are buying the crystallized
- 7:28knowledge and skills of the engineers who designed the
- 7:31blade, the motor and the wheels applied to your specific problem
- 7:35of tall grass in your front yard.
- 7:36Exactly and. The physical object is just the
- 7:39vessel. But what's truly fascinating
- 7:41here is how SAR, Lesch and Vargo actually pushed this concept.
- 7:44They go all the way. Don't.
- 7:45They they really do because they don't just say some things are
- 7:48services. They have these foundational
- 7:49premises in the paper and foundational premise 6 or FP6
- 7:54states boldly all economies are service economies.
- 7:57Wait, all of them even like ancient agrarian economies?
- 8:01Because a tomato is definitely a physical good.
- 8:03It grows in the dirt. I know it sounds
- 8:05counterintuitive, but they reject the traditional
- 8:08historical timeline that says humanity transition from an
- 8:11agricultural era to an industrial era to a modern
- 8:15service era. So what did they say instead?
- 8:17They argue we have always been in a service economy.
- 8:20Think about the farmer growing that tomato.
- 8:23They're applying specialized generational knowledge of soil
- 8:26chemistry, weather patterns and biology to provide a service
- 8:30sustenance to someone else. I see, so the tomato is just the
- 8:34delivery mechanism for the farmers knowledge of
- 8:37agriculture? Exactly.
- 8:39And if we connect this to the bigger picture, they point out
- 8:41that this service for service exchange is the bedrock of how
- 8:45all entities survive. They even point to biology,
- 8:47right? Yeah.
- 8:48The concept of mutualism, like a bee pollinating a flower while
- 8:52gathering nectar, that is fundamentally A specialized
- 8:55service being exchanged for another specialized service.
- 8:58OK, this completely shatters the illusion of the product for me.
- 9:01But if we accept this, you know, if value isn't a physical thing
- 9:04that we can just build on an assembly line and stockpile in a
- 9:07giant warehouse, then where does the value actually live?
- 9:10That is the $1,000,000 question. Right, like who gets to decide
- 9:13what a product, or rather a service distribution mechanism
- 9:17is actually worth? Well, this brings us to the
- 9:19ultimate really radical premise of SAD logic.
- 9:24This is the concept that forces us to completely rethink how we
- 9:29approach our customers. OK.
- 9:30It's foundational premise 10 or FP10.
- 9:33Let's lay it out, because this one is quite a mouthful.
- 9:35It really is FP 10 states value is always uniquely and
- 9:39phenomenologically determined by the beneficiary.
- 9:42Phenomenologically, I literally had to read that sentence three
- 9:44times. That is a heavy $5 academic
- 9:47word. It is, yeah, but it's incredibly
- 9:49precise once you unpack it. Great.
- 9:51When they say value is phenomenologically determined,
- 9:54they mean that value is entirely idiosyncratic.
- 9:56Meaning it's unique to the person.
- 9:58Yes, it is experiential. That is deeply contextual, and
- 10:02it is laden with personal meaning.
- 10:04Value does not exist objectively out there in the world.
- 10:07It only exists in the lived experience of the person
- 10:10actually using it. OK, let's ground this in reality
- 10:12for the listener. Think about just a standard
- 10:14white ceramic cup of black coffee.
- 10:17Good example, right? So if value is manufactured in a
- 10:21factory, then that cup of coffee has an objective static value.
- 10:25It has, say, $0.50 of beans, $0.10 of water, and a little bit
- 10:28of Labor. It's an objective $2.00 object.
- 10:31Under GD logic, yes. But if value is
- 10:34phenomenological, that cup of coffee's value changes wildly
- 10:38depending on the context. Like, if you are rushing to a
- 10:41incredibly stressful 8:00 AM meeting and you haven't slept,
- 10:45that coffee is a vital lifeline. It's fuel.
- 10:48It's probably worth 10 bucks to you in that exact moment,
- 10:51Absolutely. But if you are sitting on a
- 10:52quiet porch on a Sunday morning just listening to the birds,
- 10:55that exact same cup of coffee with the exact same chemical
- 10:58makeup is now a relaxation ritual.
- 11:01The value transformed entirely because your contacts changed.
- 11:04That is a perfect translation of the theory.
- 11:06The enterprise, the coffee shop did not create the value.
- 11:09They didn't. No.
- 11:10Under SD Logic's Foundational Premise 7, an enterprise can
- 11:14only make value propositions. The coffee shop can only brew
- 11:17the beans and offer the cup. But you, the beneficiary, are
- 11:20the only one who decides if it's actually valuable.
- 11:24And you make that decision based entirely on the specific,
- 11:27chaotic, messy reality of your own life in that exact moment.
- 11:32Which means the traditional Mad Men style of advertising is
- 11:35totally backwards. Oh, entirely.
- 11:37How so? Walk down that path a bit.
- 11:39Well, think about the Don Draper approach, right?
- 11:41Yeah. A bunch of executives sit in a
- 11:43boardroom, completely isolated from the outside world.
- 11:47They dream up a product, They decide what its value is
- 11:49internally. Yep.
- 11:51And then they design this clever psychological advertising
- 11:54campaign to convince the public that they need it.
- 11:57They are trying to dictate the value to the consumer.
- 12:00Which is peer GD logic. Exactly.
- 12:02But if value is phenomenological, if it
- 12:04literally only exists in the context of the user's messy
- 12:07daily life, then and sitting in a boardroom guessing what people
- 12:10want is like shooting blindfolded.
- 12:12You cannot mandate value. You have to understand the
- 12:14customers lived experience first before you build anything.
- 12:17That is exactly the implication. And honestly, it is a terrifying
- 12:21realization for most companies, I bet, because it raises a
- 12:24massive practical problem if the customer holds all the cards,
- 12:29you know, if the truth of what is valuable only exists inside
- 12:32their head, then we have to talk to them.
- 12:34We have to extract that phenomenological truth, right?
- 12:38But humans are incredibly complex emotional creatures.
- 12:42How do you extract the truth about what someone values
- 12:45without contaminating the data? And this is exactly where we
- 12:48pivot from the high level academic theory into the gritty
- 12:52reality of the Mom Test by Rob Fitzpatrick.
- 12:54Yes, the perfect bridge. Because if you just walk up to
- 12:57someone on the street or worse your friends and family and say,
- 12:59hey, I have this idea for an app, is it valuable?
- 13:02You are going to get terrible data.
- 13:04The worst data. Fitzpatrick's whole premise is
- 13:06right there in the title. You shouldn't ask anyone if your
- 13:08business is a good idea, especially not your mom.
- 13:11Because she loves you, right? Yeah.
- 13:13And her primary objective is not to give you sound market
- 13:16research. Her primary objective is to
- 13:18protect your feelings. Exactly.
- 13:21Fitzpatrick uses this brilliant metaphor that really stuck with
- 13:24me. He says that having
- 13:26conversations with potential customers is like conducting A
- 13:29delicate archaeological dig. I love that analogy.
- 13:32The truth of what they phenomenologically value is
- 13:35buried down there in the dirt, but it is incredibly fragile.
- 13:39And most entrepreneurs approach this archaeological site
- 13:43completely wrong. Oh they show up with a bulldozer
- 13:46and a creative dynamite. They really do.
- 13:48They run up to people and use these heavy-handed leading
- 13:51questions like do you think this is a good idea or would you pay
- 13:54$20.00 a month for this? Or even don't you think the
- 13:57current software on the market is terrible?
- 14:00Yeah, that is conversational dynamite.
- 14:01You blow up the site, you shatter the delicate truth into
- 14:04a million pieces, and all you are left with is rubber, right?
- 14:08But on the other end of the spectrum, some people are so
- 14:11terrified of getting bad news that they show up to the dig
- 14:13site with a toothbrush. They just lightly brush away the
- 14:16loose topsoil, having polite conversations about the weather,
- 14:20and they never actually dig deep enough to unearth anything of
- 14:23actual value. The dynamite approach is so
- 14:26common though, and it's fascinating because it triggers
- 14:29what Fitzpatrick calls the pathos problem.
- 14:32The pathos problem OK, this is the psychological core of why
- 14:35people lie to us. Let's dig into the mechanics of
- 14:37this. Why is it that when I pitch an
- 14:40idea even to a total stranger, they suddenly become
- 14:43untrustworthy? It actually comes down to human
- 14:46evolution and social cohesion. The pathos problem occurs the
- 14:50exact moment you expose your ego to the person you were talking
- 14:54to. Expose my ego.
- 14:55Yeah, the moment you say I have this idea I've been working on
- 14:58for six months. What do you think?
- 15:00You have made yourself socially vulnerable.
- 15:02You have tied yourself worth to this concept.
- 15:05And most humans, despite what we might read on the Internet, are
- 15:08not inherently malicious in face to face interactions.
- 15:10Exactly. When they see you expose your
- 15:13ego, their natural, deeply ingrained evolutionary instinct
- 15:17is to protect social harmony. They don't want to be the one to
- 15:20crush your dreams. Because it's awkward.
- 15:22Very awkward. Delivering bad news creates
- 15:25social friction, so their brain instantly calculates that the
- 15:30easiest, safest route to end the conversation smoothly is just to
- 15:34protect your feelings. So they lie, they give you a
- 15:36false positive, they say something like, oh wow, that
- 15:39sounds really interesting. Or I could definitely see my
- 15:42cousin using that. Right.
- 15:44They aren't trying to sabotage your business, they're just
- 15:46trying to be supportive friends or polite strangers.
- 15:50But in the business world, a supportive lie is toxic.
- 15:53It's lethal. It is literally the number one
- 15:55reason founders spend their life savings building products nobody
- 15:59buys. They mistake social politeness
- 16:01from market validation. Which perfectly connects back to
- 16:04SD logic. It does if value is uniquely
- 16:07determined by the user's actual lived experience.
- 16:10Asking them to guess if a hypothetical product has value
- 16:14completely breaks the laws of human psychology.
- 16:16They can't possibly know what the phenomenological value of
- 16:19your non existent an app is. Exactly, so since they don't
- 16:22know and you've exposed your ego, they just default to polite
- 16:26fluff. So the $1,000,000 question for
- 16:29you How do we bypass the pathos problem?
- 16:32How do we become skilled conversational archaeologists
- 16:36who can unearth the truth without shattering it?
- 16:38Well, Fitzpatrick lays out three golden rules for the Mom test.
- 16:42They sound incredibly simple, but in practice they require a
- 16:46complete rewiring of how you talk to people.
- 16:48OK, what are they? Rule #1 Talk about their life
- 16:52instead of your idea. Rule #2 Ask about specific
- 16:56instances in the past instead of generic routines or opinions
- 16:59about the future. OK, specific past.
- 17:02And rule #3 talk less and listen more.
- 17:06These rules are essentially A cloaking device.
- 17:08Like if you never mention your idea, you never expose your ego.
- 17:12If your ego isn't exposed, their social protection mechanism
- 17:15never activates. You bypass the pathos problem
- 17:18entirely. Exactly.
- 17:19I want to illustrate how drastically these rules change a
- 17:22conversation. Let's walk through the legendary
- 17:24example from the book The iPad Cookbook scenario.
- 17:27This perfectly captures the difference between dynamite and
- 17:30a delicate excavation. It's such a classic.
- 17:32Set the scene for the first conversation, the failure.
- 17:34OK, so a son goes over to his mom's house.
- 17:37He's got this burning idea for a business.
- 17:39He sits down and says, mom, I have this idea for a business.
- 17:42Can I run it by you? Boom, Dynamite detonated.
- 17:46Exactly. Ego exposed, pathos problem
- 17:49activated, he immediately launches into a pitch.
- 17:53He says. You love your iPad, right?
- 17:55Would you buy a digital cookbook app for it?
- 17:58It's only $40, which is way cheaper than buying hardcover
- 18:01cookbooks. You can share recipes with your
- 18:04friends and it even has videos of celebrity chefs making the
- 18:06meals. Don't you think that's a great
- 18:08idea? He is breaking every single
- 18:10rule. Every single one.
- 18:12He's talking about his idea, not her life.
- 18:15He's asking for opinions on a hypothetical future, and he is
- 18:18doing all the talking. He isn't learning.
- 18:20He is actively demanding validation.
- 18:22Exactly. And how does mom react?
- 18:24She's cornered. She loves her son, so she says.
- 18:27Oh oh honey, that sounds amazing, $40 is a great deal for
- 18:30all those features. Will I have pictures of the
- 18:32food? Of course she asks that.
- 18:34Right, and the sun's eyes light up.
- 18:36He takes this as a feature request.
- 18:38He says yes, high res pictures. Mom smiles and says that's
- 18:42wonderful, you are so smart. And what happens next?
- 18:45The Sun leaves the house, pumping his first.
- 18:49He is completely convinced he has achieved product market fit.
- 18:53He quits his day job, remortgages his house, spends a
- 18:56year coding the app, launches it on the App Store, and hears
- 18:59crickets. Complete silence.
- 19:01He goes bankrupt because literally no one, not even his
- 19:05mother who said it was amazing, actually buys it.
- 19:07It is the ultimate tragic false positive.
- 19:10Like, let's analyze Mom's responses there.
- 19:12She rationalized the $40 price tag hypothetically because it
- 19:16wasn't real money leaving your bank.
- 19:17Account right? It was just theoretical money.
- 19:19Exactly, she gave a non committal compliment that sounds
- 19:22amazing just to keep the social interaction pleasant and when
- 19:25she asked will it have pictures she wasn't making a genuine
- 19:28feature request. She wasn't, no.
- 19:30She was just grabbing the most obvious attribute of a cookbook
- 19:34to prove to her son that she was actively listening to his pitch.
- 19:39She had absolutely 0 intention of ever changing her cooking
- 19:42habits to use a digital app. Oh man.
- 19:46So how do we fix this? Let's rewind the tape and
- 19:49actually pass the test this time.
- 19:50OK, let's hear the good version. The son walks into the house,
- 19:53but this time he keeps his idea entirely hidden.
- 19:56He says, hey mom, how's that new iPad treating you?
- 19:59She says, oh I love it, I use it every day.
- 20:02He asks what did you last do on it?
- 20:05Oh, notice the phrasing there. Right, not what do you usually
- 20:08do, but what did you last do? He is asking about a specific
- 20:12past event. That is a crucial distinction.
- 20:14Past actions are concrete facts. Generic statements like I
- 20:18usually do. This are often aspirational lies
- 20:20we tell ourselves about the person we wish we were.
- 20:22Right, like I usually eat salads.
- 20:24Not sure you do. So she says I was looking up
- 20:27places to stay for our trip to London.
- 20:29He asks did you use an app for that?
- 20:31She says no, I just opened Safari and used Google.
- 20:33I don't really know how to find new apps in the store.
- 20:36Stop the tape right there. That is a massive business
- 20:39saving piece of data. Huge because he just uncovered a
- 20:43critical market risk regarding App Store discovery.
- 20:46If his target demographic, older women with iPads, uses Google
- 20:51instead of searching the Apple App Store, his entire
- 20:53distribution and marketing strategy for a native app might
- 20:57be fatally flawed from day one. And.
- 20:58He hasn't even brought up food yet.
- 21:00He's already gathered more valuable data than the entire
- 21:02first conversation. But he keeps digging.
- 21:05He looks over at her kitchen counter and says, hey, where did
- 21:08those two new hardcover cookbooks come from?
- 21:10She sighs and says, there were Christmas gifts from your aunt.
- 21:14I haven't even opened them. As if I need another generic
- 21:17lasagna recipe at my age. I've been cooking for 40 years.
- 21:20Another absolute goldmine of phenomenological truth.
- 21:23Yes, she is explicitly stating that she does not value generic
- 21:26recipes. Her lived context is that she
- 21:29already possesses that knowledge.
- 21:31Furthermore, he just discovered that the gift market for
- 21:34physical cookbooks is strong, but the actual daily usage of
- 21:37those gifts is incredibly low. So building an app around
- 21:41generic weeknight recipes would be a total waste of time for
- 21:44this demographic. Absolutely.
- 21:45But he pushes one more time. He asks.
- 21:48Well, what's the last cookbook you did buy for yourself with
- 21:50your own money? Just think about it for a
- 21:53minute, then, she says. Actually, about three months ago
- 21:56I bought a highly specific vegan cookbook because your father's
- 21:59cholesterol was high and the doctor said we need to eat
- 22:02healthier. But I didn't know how to cook
- 22:04vegan food. This is the SD logic FP10
- 22:08playing out in real time. It really is.
- 22:10By asking about her lived experience, he uncovered the
- 22:13actual mechanism of value. He just discovered 2 entirely
- 22:17distinct customer segments. Break those down for.
- 22:20Me, you have older, experienced cooks who will only spend money
- 22:22on niche, specialized recipes tied to specific urgent health
- 22:26contexts. And by implication you have a
- 22:29second segment, younger, inexperienced cooks who might
- 22:32need generic lasagna recipes. But they probably don't have the
- 22:35disposable income or the habit of paying a premium for fancy
- 22:39cookbooks. They probably just use free
- 22:41blogs. The irony is just staggering to
- 22:44me. In that second conversation, the
- 22:46Sun got infinitely better, highly actionable business data.
- 22:50And he did it by never mentioning his idea.
- 22:53Yeah, if you want to find out if people actually care about what
- 22:56you are building, you basically have to hide the fact that you
- 22:58are building it. It feels completely
- 23:01counterintuitive because our instinct is always to pitch, but
- 23:04it is the only way to get clean, uncontaminated data.
- 23:10However, bypassing the pathos problem is really only step 100.
- 23:15There's more. Oh yeah, even if you ask the
- 23:18right questions about the past, people will still throw bad data
- 23:21at you. In a conversational
- 23:23archaeological dig. You're going to encounter fools
- 23:25goal, right? Fitzpatrick identifies 3
- 23:27specific types of bad data that will actively sabotage your
- 23:31business if you don't know how to recognize and deflect them.
- 23:34Let's break these down, because recognizing them in real time
- 23:37definitely takes practice. The three types of bad data are
- 23:40compliments, fluff, and ideas. Right, let's start with
- 23:42compliments. OK, according to the book,
- 23:44compliments in a customer interview are entirely
- 23:47worthless. They are arguably worse than
- 23:49worthless because they create a false sense of momentum.
- 23:52They feel like progress. You leave a meeting where
- 23:55everyone told you your idea was brilliant and you feel great.
- 23:58You feel like a genius. Exactly.
- 24:00But think about this logically. Venture capitalists, whose
- 24:04entire professional existence is dedicated to judging the future
- 24:07value of businesses, are wrong the vast majority of the time.
- 24:12Most startups fail, even the heavily funded ones.
- 24:15That's a really good point. So if a professional BC with
- 24:18spreadsheets and analysts is usually wrong, the opinion of a
- 24:22random person in a coffee shop who says I love your idea is
- 24:25statistically meaningless. So how do you handle it like if
- 24:28you accidentally slip up? Because we are human and
- 24:31sometimes we get excited and slip into pitch mode and the
- 24:33person says wow, that sounds brilliant.
- 24:35What is the tactical response? You have to deflect an anchor.
- 24:39You cannot let the compliment hang in the air and validate
- 24:42your ego. You have to immediately deflate
- 24:43it. Right.
- 24:44So you say something like, oh, sorry, I just got excited and
- 24:47slipped into pitch mode there. Please ignore that.
- 24:49Let's go back to what you were just saying about how you
- 24:51currently struggle to solve this problem.
- 24:53Yeah, you literally bat the complement away like a family
- 24:56and anchor the conversation back to the concrete reality of their
- 24:59current life. Which brings us to the second
- 25:01type of bad data fluff. Fluff is incredibly pervasive.
- 25:08What counts as fluff? It is anything generic, anything
- 25:12future tense or anything hypothetical phrases like I
- 25:16usually do this or I will definitely start doing that or I
- 25:19might use a feature like that if you built it.
- 25:21I feel like the absolute deadliest phrase in the entire
- 25:24English language for an entrepreneur is.
- 25:26I would definitely buy that. Oh, without a doubt.
- 25:28It sounds so concrete. It sounds like a commitment, but
- 25:31it's a psychological trap. Human beings are wildly,
- 25:35irrationally optimistic about who they will be in the future.
- 25:38I know I am. Right In the hypothetical
- 25:40future, I am a better version of myself.
- 25:44In the future, I'm going to exercise every single day.
- 25:47I'm going to learn conversational French and I'm
- 25:50going to proactively buy your B to B productivity software and
- 25:55integrate it seamlessly into my workflow.
- 25:57But today? Today I'm going to sit on the
- 25:59couch, watch Netflix, and keep using my messy Excel
- 26:03spreadsheets. It's so true.
- 26:04We buy gym memberships for our future selves, but our present
- 26:08selves never actually go. Exactly.
- 26:10To deal with fluff, you also have to aggressively anchor it
- 26:13to the past, right? Like if someone says I always
- 26:16struggle with organizing my emails, it's a huge problem for
- 26:19me. You do not say would an AI
- 26:21e-mail sorting app help you? Because that just invites more
- 26:23fluff. Exactly.
- 26:25Instead you say when is the last time that e-mail disorganization
- 26:28caused a real problem for you? Talk me through that specific
- 26:31day step by step. Right, You force their brain out
- 26:34of the hypothetical future and drag it back into the
- 26:36unglamorous concrete past. If they can't remember the last
- 26:39time it was a problem, it's not a real problem.
- 26:41Which perfectly sets up the 3rd and frankly the most seductive
- 26:45form of bad data ideas. Oh, ideas are tricky.
- 26:49Because once a customer actually gets engaged in a conversation,
- 26:52they will inevitably start pitching you features.
- 26:55They'll say, you know what this app really needs?
- 26:57It needs to sync natively with Microsoft Excel.
- 27:00Oh, and it needs a blockchain integration for security.
- 27:03And as a founder, you start scribbling these down furiously,
- 27:06thinking the customer is literally handing me the
- 27:09blueprint to success. They are telling me exactly what
- 27:12to build. But Fitzpatrick shares the story
- 27:15in the book that is so painfully hilarious, and it perfectly
- 27:18illustrates why taking customer feature requests at face value
- 27:22is a terrible idea. It's the MTV Analytics dashboard
- 27:26story. Yes, the MTV story.
- 27:28Please walk us through this one, because it's the ultimate
- 27:30cautionary tale. OK, so Fitzpatrick's company is
- 27:33trying to land big enterprise clients and they get a meeting
- 27:35with MTVMTV, looks at their stuff and says we like this, but
- 27:39we have a major problem. We need deep analytics and
- 27:42reports for our advertising campaigns to show our clients.
- 27:45It seems like a reasonable request.
- 27:46Right, so Fitzpatrick thinks, great, they want analytics.
- 27:50He goes back to his office, goes into a cave, codes his heart
- 27:54out, and builds this beautiful, highly complex self-serve
- 27:57analytics dashboard. With all the bells and whistles.
- 28:00Oh yeah, it has graphs, charts, real time data feeds.
- 28:04He demos it for MTV, they own AF and he thinks he has absolutely
- 28:09nailed it. But the reality of their
- 28:10phenomenological value was completely different from what
- 28:13they asked for. Totally different because a few
- 28:15weeks later, every Friday afternoon, his phone starts
- 28:19ringing. It's the MTV reps.
- 28:21And what do they want? They are asking him, the founder
- 28:23of the software company, to manually log into the database,
- 28:27export a raw CSV data file of the week's stats, and e-mail it
- 28:30to. Them, even though they have a
- 28:31self-serve dashboard they can use themselves.
- 28:34Refuse to serve themselves. So he dutifully thinks, OK, they
- 28:37want CSV's. He spends a week coding a slick
- 28:40export to CSV button right into the dashboard.
- 28:43Problem solved. Right.
- 28:44Let me guess, Nope. Nope, a few weeks later they
- 28:47start calling him again on Fridays.
- 28:49Hey Rob, CSV's are a bit messy. Could you export it as APDF and
- 28:53e-mail it to us? Oh no.
- 28:55So, gritting his teeth, he spends another two weeks coding
- 28:58a complex export to PDF rendering engine into the
- 29:02software. He is slowly becoming a feature
- 29:05factory. He is blindly building whatever
- 29:08they ask for without ever stopping to understand why they
- 29:11are asking for. It precisely, and it culminates
- 29:14in this breaking point. They call him again and ask,
- 29:16hey, can you add our specific MTV logo and some custom
- 29:19corporate colors to the top of the PDF exports?
- 29:22Wow. He is completely exasperated at
- 29:24this point. He finally stops acting like a
- 29:26short order cook and asks a diagnostic question.
- 29:29He says why do you want custom logos on the PDFs?
- 29:32I look at the server logs. Nobody from MTV is even logging
- 29:35into the dashboard to read the data in the first place.
- 29:37And what was the MTV rep's response?
- 29:39The Rep says, oh, nobody here actually reads these numbers.
- 29:42Our advertising clients just like to get an e-mail from us at
- 29:45the end of the week, and we think they'd be happier if the
- 29:47report looked a bit fancier with our logo on it.
- 29:49Oh, that is a gut punch to an engineer's soul.
- 29:52It's devastating. MTV never wanted to understand
- 29:56their data. They didn't want real time
- 29:58analytics. They didn't want interactive
- 29:59charts. Their only actual problem was
- 30:02client management. They just wanted to look good to
- 30:04their clients. Exactly.
- 30:05They just wanted to keep their clients feeling warm and fuzzy.
- 30:09If Fitzpatrick had dug beneath their initial request for
- 30:12analytics during that first meeting, he never would have
- 30:15spent months building a complex software dashboard.
- 30:19What could he have done instead? He could have just paid an
- 30:21intern minimum wage to hand make a pretty PDF report in Microsoft
- 30:25Word once a week and charged MTV thousands of dollars for it.
- 30:29Which perfectly illustrates the rule for handling the ideas type
- 30:32of bad data. We must treat customer ideas and
- 30:35feature requests as symptoms, not cures.
- 30:38Symptoms, right? Ideas should be understood, not
- 30:41blindly obeyed. When a customer demands a
- 30:44feature like I need a blockchain integration, you have to dig
- 30:47beneath it. You ask why do you want that?
- 30:49What specific task does that let you achieve?
- 30:52How are you currently coping without it?
- 30:54You're playing detective. Exactly.
- 30:56Yeah. You are looking for their
- 30:57underlying motivation. You are looking for their
- 31:00phenomenological value, not taking their amateur engineering
- 31:04advice. OK, so if you are listening to
- 31:06this, you now know how to dodge compliments, anchor fluff and
- 31:10dig under ideas. You are a conversational ninja.
- 31:13Hopefully. But here is the terrifying part.
- 31:16You can follow all all of these rules flawlessly, you can
- 31:19execute the MOM test perfectly, and you can still spend years
- 31:23building something nobody wants if you ignore the elephant in
- 31:26the room. Ah, you're talking about the
- 31:27danger of the premature zoom. Yes, the premature zoom.
- 31:32This happens when you lock onto a trivial problem before you
- 31:34establish if the person actually cares about the broader category
- 31:37at all. It's zooming in on a single
- 31:39pixel and missing the entire picture.
- 31:42The book is a really great example of this.
- 31:44Yeah, the interview about a fitness app.
- 31:45Let's role play that. Let's say I'm the interviewer
- 31:47and you're the potential customer.
- 31:49I sit down with you and I immediately zoom in.
- 31:51I ask what is your biggest problem when it comes to going
- 31:55to the gym? And as the polite interviewee, I
- 31:59think for a second trying to be helpful and I say, well,
- 32:02probably the time it takes to get there.
- 32:03I live pretty far away, so convenience is a big issue.
- 32:06Boom, as the interviewer my eyes light up.
- 32:10I have validation. The customer said convenience is
- 32:13the biggest problem. I am going to build an at home
- 32:17VR fitness app to solve the convenience problem.
- 32:20I'm going to be rich. But you missed the elephant.
- 32:22I completely missed it because if I had started the
- 32:26conversation broader before zooming in on the problems of
- 32:29the gym and simply asked how often do you go to for the gym,
- 32:33what would you have said? I would have said, oh, I never
- 32:35go to the gym. I haven't worked out in five
- 32:37years. Exactly.
- 32:38Convenience is a problem, sure, but it is a hypothetical problem
- 32:41for someone who has absolutely 0 intention of ever solving it
- 32:45right. Because I zoomed in so fast, I
- 32:47effectively led the witness. I assumed fitness was a priority
- 32:50in your life. I forced you to name a barrier,
- 32:53and then I took that barrier as gospel.
- 32:55This highlights the fundamental difference between building a
- 32:57painkiller and building a vitamin.
- 32:59Explain that difference. A painkiller solves a must solve
- 33:03bleeding neck problem. If your arm is broken, you are
- 33:07actively seeking a solution. You will jump through hoops, you
- 33:10will tolerate a terrible user interface, and you will pay good
- 33:14money to fix. It because the pain is acute.
- 33:17Exactly. A vitamin, on the other hand,
- 33:19solves a nice to have problem. It's theoretically good for you,
- 33:23but you might forget to take it and you certainly are desperate
- 33:25for it. To find out if a problem is a
- 33:28painkiller, we have to ask cost and value questions.
- 33:31Like what? How do I figure out if they are
- 33:33actually in pain? You ask behavioral questions
- 33:36about their past attempts to solve it.
- 33:39Are you currently spending any money to try and fix this?
- 33:42Have you spent your weekend searching for a workaround?
- 33:44Did you download any clunky open source software to patch it?
- 33:48And if they say no? If someone tells you a problem
- 33:50is the absolute bane of their existence, but they haven't even
- 33:52done a 5 minute Google search to find a solution, they are not a
- 33:56potential customer. They are just a complainer and
- 33:59you cannot build a business on complainers.
- 34:01That is such a clarifying distinction.
- 34:03Are they a complainer or are they a customer?
- 34:06And this brings up another massive structural concept from
- 34:10the sources that dictates who you should even be talking to.
- 34:12What's that? It's the difference between
- 34:14product risk and market risk because depending on what you
- 34:18are building, the questions you need to ask change completely.
- 34:22This is vital. Let's clearly define those two
- 34:24terms for the listener. OK.
- 34:26So market risk asks the fundamental question, do people
- 34:30actually want this and will they pay for it?
- 34:33Product risk on the other hand, asks can I actually build this
- 34:37thing and can I get it to function?
- 34:39And it is absolutely critical to know which one of those risks is
- 34:42the primary threat to your specific business model.
- 34:45Exactly. Fitzpatrick uses the digital
- 34:47advertising industry as a perfect example of this.
- 34:49If you go to a major advertiser like Nike and ask, hey will you
- 34:54pay me money if I can guarantee 1,000,000 highly targeted page
- 34:57views from teenage runners to your new shoe drop, they will
- 35:01look at you like you are a complete idiot.
- 35:02Because the answer is obvious. Yes, they'll say yes, obviously.
- 35:06That is literally how the advertising industry works.
- 35:09Here is our rate card. You do not need to do 50 MOM
- 35:13test interviews to validate that market.
- 35:15The market is proven. Right.
- 35:17The risk there is entirely product risk.
- 35:20Can you as a founder actually build a website or an app that
- 35:24is sticky enough to generate a million targeted views?
- 35:27That is an engineering and content challenge, not a market
- 35:30validation challenge. Video games are another great
- 35:33example of pure product risk. You don't need to interview a
- 35:36bunch of teenagers and ask, do you like having fun?
- 35:39Would you pay $20.00 for a game that is incredibly fun and
- 35:43engaging? Of course they would.
- 35:44Right. The risk is whether your
- 35:46specific studio can actually code a game that achieves that
- 35:49phenomenological state of fun. You validate that by building
- 35:53prototypes and having them play it, not by asking them abstract
- 35:56questions. But on the flip side, if you are
- 35:59building something completely novel, let's say a new B2B
- 36:02software for managing esoteric maritime supply chains, you have
- 36:06massive market risk. Because nobody knows if they
- 36:08want it. Exactly.
- 36:10You might be an incredible coder, so there's no product
- 36:12risk. You absolutely can build it, but
- 36:14you have to prove that the supply chain managers actually
- 36:17experience enough pain with their current systems that they
- 36:20will endure the switching costs to adopt your new solution.
- 36:24And that requires deep Mom test style conversational
- 36:29archaeology. Yes.
- 36:31OK, so let's synthesize this. You've navigated the risks.
- 36:34You've avoided the premature zoom.
- 36:36You've deflected the compliments and anchored the fluff.
- 36:39You've done the work and you finally have a prototype or a
- 36:42concrete idea to show a customer in a follow up meeting.
- 36:46The moment of truth. Right.
- 36:48How do you know if that meeting was actually successful?
- 36:50Because I've been in this situation and it's so easy to
- 36:53fall victim to what Fitzpatrick calls the zombie leads.
- 36:57Zombie leads. Yeah, the absolute bane of the
- 36:59B2B sales cycle. They are the worst.
- 37:02Zombie leads are those people who constantly agree to take
- 37:04your meetings. You demo the software, they nod
- 37:07along, they say wow this looks great.
- 37:08The interface is really slick, definitely keep me in the loop
- 37:11on your progress. But they never, ever give you a
- 37:14dime. They just string you along,
- 37:16draining your time, your calendar, and your emotional
- 37:19energy. And the reason we get stuck with
- 37:21zombie leads is because we fundamentally misunderstand how
- 37:24to structure a meeting. We fall into the meeting anti
- 37:28pattern. The meeting anti pattern.
- 37:30This is the tendency to over formalize every single customer
- 37:34interaction. Right.
- 37:35We have this corporate conditioning that says every
- 37:36business conversation needs to be a 45 minute calendar block.
- 37:40It needs a formal agenda, a slick 12 slide PowerPoint deck,
- 37:44and we need to be sitting in a boardroom drinking expensive
- 37:47coffee. But Fitzpatrick argues that
- 37:49formal meetings are actually incredibly dangerous, especially
- 37:52in the early stages of validation.
- 37:54Let's explore the psychology of that Why is a formal meeting
- 37:57dangerous? Well, because when you set up a
- 37:59formal 45 minute calendar invite, you inherently create a
- 38:04dynamic where the customer feels like they're doing you a massive
- 38:07favor just by sitting there. True, they are giving up an hour
- 38:11of their busy day for you. And when people feel like they
- 38:13are doing you a favor, the Panthos problem shifts into
- 38:16OverDrive. Oh, because they feel bad for
- 38:18you? Exactly.
- 38:19They want to be nice. They are highly prone to polite
- 38:23lying just to get through the 45 minutes and get you out of their
- 38:27office smoothly without a confrontation.
- 38:29So they give you compliments and fluff turning into a zombie.
- 38:32Exactly, This is why Fitzpatrick heavily advocates for keeping
- 38:37early conversations incredibly casual. 5 to 10 minute chats at
- 38:41an industry conference or catching someone for a quick
- 38:44coffee if it feels like they're doing you a favor by talking to
- 38:47you. The setting is too formal and
- 38:49the data will be corrupted by politeness.
- 38:51That makes perfect sense for discovery, but eventually you do
- 38:54have to transition from a casual chat about their past problems
- 38:57to actually showing them a product and asking them to buy
- 39:00it. Right, you can't just be an
- 39:01undercover archaeologist forever.
- 39:02Exactly. And this is where we have to
- 39:05seek what the book calls advancement and commitment.
- 39:08This is the ultimate litmus test.
- 39:10If you finish a meeting and you don't know exactly what the
- 39:13specific concrete next step is, that meeting was a failure.
- 39:17It was just a pleasant chat. A meeting only succeeds if you
- 39:20secure a commitment. And commitment is not a vague
- 39:23promise like we'll review it next quarter.
- 39:26No, not at all. Fitzpatrick outlines 3 specific
- 39:29currencies of conversation that prove a customer is actually
- 39:32serious. Those currencies are time,
- 39:36reputation and cash. Let's break those currencies
- 39:39down because this is how you separate the buyers from the
- 39:41complainers. OK, let's start with time.
- 39:43Right. A compliment costs a customer
- 39:46absolutely nothing, which is exactly why it's worth nothing.
- 39:49But if you ask them for a time commitment, for example, this
- 39:52sounds like it might solve your problem.
- 39:54Will you commit to sitting down with my lead engineer for two
- 39:57hours next Tuesday to rigorously test the new wireframes?
- 40:02And they say yes, that is real data.
- 40:04Because they're paying with their time.
- 40:06Exactly. They're giving up a valuable
- 40:08finite resource to help you. They wouldn't do that if they
- 40:11didn't phenomenologically value the potential solution.
- 40:14Time is good. What about reputation?
- 40:16Reputation is an even stronger currency.
- 40:18Let's say you show them the software and they say this looks
- 40:20great, I want our department to use it.
- 40:23You reply. OK, fantastic.
- 40:25Will you introduce me to your boss or your head procurement
- 40:27officer right now so we can discuss a pilot program?
- 40:31That's a bold ask. It is.
- 40:33And if they hesitate, if they say, well let me talk to them
- 40:35first offline, they don't actually believe in your product
- 40:39enough to risk their internal political capital.
- 40:43But if they make the intro, you have massive validation.
- 40:46And the final currency, cash, is pretty obvious.
- 40:50Very obvious. A deposit, a preorder, a signed
- 40:53letter of intent doesn't have to be the full price, but money has
- 40:57to change hands. If they aren't willing to give
- 40:59up time, reputation or cash, they are a zombie lead.
- 41:02And you have to cure zombie leads by forcing a rejection.
- 41:05Forcing A rejection, yes. This is where entrepreneurs need
- 41:08to develop a thick skin. A polite firm know from a
- 41:11customer is incredibly valuable data.
- 41:14It lets you cross them off the list and move on to a real
- 41:16prospect. That makes sense.
- 41:18A wishy washy let me know when version 2.0 launches is a
- 41:22stalling tactic that can waste years of a founders life.
- 41:26You have to push for the no. OK, so we've covered how to
- 41:28navigate the meeting, how to spot the bad data, and how to
- 41:31force a commitment. But this brings up the most
- 41:33terrifying practical question of all.
- 41:35What's that? If we shouldn't use formal
- 41:37calendar invites, but we desperately need these casual
- 41:40conversations to avoid building the wrong thing, how do we
- 41:44actually get people to talk to us in the 1st place, Especially
- 41:47if we are entering a brand new industry where we have
- 41:50absolutely zero connections? This is the bottleneck.
- 41:53This is where a lot of brilliant engineers and thinkers just
- 41:56freeze up cold. Calling strangers is brutal.
- 41:59It is soul crushing, but Fitzpatrick shares the ultimate
- 42:01hack for securing your conversations.
- 42:03It is a highly specific five part framing sequence that he
- 42:06uses for cold emails or LinkedIn introductions.
- 42:09I call it the very few Wizards Properly Ask framework.
- 42:13Very few Wizards properly ask VFWPA.
- 42:17Yeah, I love a good mnemonic. Let's hear the five steps of the
- 42:20Wizard framework. OK, if you are writing a cold
- 42:22outreach message, you must hit these 5 beats.
- 42:26Step one is vision. You state the big overarching
- 42:31problem you're trying to solve in the industry.
- 42:32But, and this is crucial, you do not mention your specific idea
- 42:36or solution. OK, Vision first.
- 42:38Step 2 is framing. You explicitly state what stage
- 42:42you are at, usually just starting out, and you clarify
- 42:44immediately that you have absolutely nothing to sell them.
- 42:47So dropping the sales pressure. Exactly.
- 42:49Step 3 is weakness. You show vulnerability by
- 42:52mentioning a specific gap in your own knowledge.
- 42:55Step 4 is pedestal. You explain why they
- 42:59specifically are the perfect expert to fill that knowledge
- 43:01gap. Flattery, essentially.
- 43:03But sincere flattery and Step 5 is the ask you ask for a very
- 43:08brief low friction amount of their time.
- 43:10That sequence is incredibly disarming.
- 43:12It completely bypasses the recipients natural sales defense
- 43:16mechanism. It really is magic.
- 43:17The book is a great example. Imagine you are a software
- 43:20developer trying to build a tool for commercial landlords, but
- 43:23you don't know any landlords. You find an e-mail address for
- 43:26one and you write this ready hi name.
- 43:29I'm trying to make office rental less of a pain for new
- 43:32businesses. That is the vision.
- 43:34I'm just starting out, I have nothing to sell, but I want to
- 43:37to make sure I'm building something that actually helps
- 43:39the industry. That's the framing.
- 43:41I've only ever been a tenant so I'm really struggling to
- 43:43understand how the economics work from the landlord's
- 43:46perspective. That's the weakness.
- 43:48I saw you've been managing commercial real estate in the
- 43:50city for two decades, and you could really help me cut through
- 43:53the fog. That's the pedestal.
- 43:55Do you have 10 minutes for a quick chat next week?
- 43:57And that's the ask. It's brilliant because it plays
- 44:01on human nature in a profoundly positive way.
- 44:05It really does. People actually love giving
- 44:07advice, they love talking about their own expertise, and they
- 44:10love feeling like an authority figure.
- 44:13By framing it this way, you position the potential customer
- 44:17as an esteemed industry advisor, not a sales target.
- 44:21It changes everything. It completely changes the power
- 44:24dynamic of the meeting from a defensive guarded posture to a
- 44:28collaborative mentoring 1. So we have covered a massive
- 44:32amount of ground today. Let's synthesize everything for
- 44:35you, the listener, because we want you to walk away with a
- 44:37unified theory of value and validation.
- 44:40We truly started at the absolute zenith of economic theory with
- 44:44Lush and Vargo, and we drilled all the way down into the
- 44:47psychological phrasing of a cold e-mail with Rob Fitzpatrick.
- 44:51Exactly. From the academic side, service
- 44:53dominant logic teaches us that value is not a physical good
- 44:57that we manufacture in a vacuum and shove down people's throats.
- 45:00Right Value is an ongoing service.
- 45:02It is the application of specialized knowledge Co created
- 45:05with the customer. And most importantly, that value
- 45:08is phenomenological. It only exists in the specific
- 45:11contextual lived reality of the beneficiary's mind.
- 45:15And because that value lives exclusively in their mind, we
- 45:19have to go in there and get it. But as the Mom test showed us,
- 45:23the human mind is a minefield of politeness, optimism and ego
- 45:27protection. Right, because humans are
- 45:29evolutionarily wired to protect our feelings and maintain social
- 45:32harmony. They are terrible at predicting
- 45:34their own future behavior or evaluating our hypothetical
- 45:37ideas. Which means we have to adapt.
- 45:40So we have to put away the dynamite.
- 45:42We have to become delicate conversational archaeologists.
- 45:45We can't ask them to validate our brilliant ideas.
- 45:48We have to investigate their past.
- 45:50Actions. We have to dig into their
- 45:51current active pains. We have to deflect their
- 45:54worthless compliments, anchor their fluffy promises to
- 45:57reality, and relentlessly dig beneath their feature requests
- 46:01to find the actual phenomenological truth of what
- 46:05they value. If we pull back and look at the
- 46:07synthesis of these two sources, it leaves us with a rather
- 46:10profound implication for the future of business and
- 46:13technology. It really is.
- 46:14I want to leave you, the listener, with a final thought
- 46:16to ponder as you go about your week.
- 46:19If D logic is fundamentally correct and value is entirely
- 46:23phenomenological, meaning it is unique to every single
- 46:27individual and every specific fleeting moment, And if the MOM
- 46:30test is correct, proving that customers cannot accurately
- 46:33articulate their future desires even when they try to be
- 46:36helpful, then where is the concept of a business actually
- 46:40heading? That is the $1,000,000 or
- 46:43perhaps trillion dollar question.
- 46:45Perhaps the ultimate future business models won't rely on
- 46:48pitches or static products or even market research at all.
- 46:52If we are entering an era of hyper adaptive AI driven
- 46:56platforms, the future might look like completely blank,
- 47:00open-ended ecosystems. Like what exactly?
- 47:03Systems where the customer doesn't even realize they are
- 47:05participating in market research.
- 47:07Instead, through their daily unconscious behavior and their
- 47:11micro interactions with the AI, they dynamically and
- 47:14automatically Co create the exact service they need in real
- 47:17time. The system adapts to their
- 47:20phenomenological reality so seamlessly and with such
- 47:23personalization that traditional focus groups, surveys, and even
- 47:26the concept of the mom test become entirely obsolete.
- 47:29We stop asking people what they want, and we build living
- 47:32systems that just become exactly what they need and the moment
- 47:35they need it. Wow, that completely breaks the
- 47:37physics textbook of business all over again.
- 47:40You start out thinking you were building a suspension bridge.
- 47:42You know, something rigid, predictable, measurable, and
- 47:45permanent. But if you truly understand
- 47:48phenomenological value in human psychology, you realize you
- 47:52aren't building a bridge at all. You are navigating the murky,
- 47:56constantly shifting, Muddy Waters of human behavior, trying
- 48:00to build a boat while you're already sailing it.
- 48:02Beautifully said. Thank you so much for joining us
- 48:05on this deep dive. We hope you take these tools,
- 48:07put away the conversational dynamite, grab your toothbrush
- 48:10and go out and practice being a true conversational
- 48:13archaeologist in your own life. We'll see you next time.