Latest / And Now For Something Completely Machinima / S6 E225 Machinima News Omnibus (May 2026)
Transcript
- Phil Rice 00:42 hello and welcome to And now for something completely machinima, the podcast about machinima, virtual production and related technologies. My name is Phil rice, and I'm here with my co hosts. Tracy Harwood, hello and Damien Valentine. Hello. Ricky Grove, his camera is still frozen, so we we we wish him the best and hope his face isn't getting tired from from that smirk. So but I'm sure he'll be back to unfrozen in no time. So we've got some news to cover this week. There's a bit going on, so I have a whole bunch this time. So I'm going to let my comrades go first here. So Tracy, why don't you lead off with your item? Tracy Harwood 01:45 Sure, I've only got one item actually this month, and I'm super interested to see how this plays out. Actually, it's the release of the much anticipated Kane Parsons, or otherwise known as Kane pixels, production of the live version of the back rooms. Well, I say that, but I mean the trailer announcing the release of it, the release of it will actually be the 29th of May. Gotta say, I think by then, probably the world may have actually exploded in anticipation of what's going to be seen with this film. I actually happened to pick up the trailer on our feed a couple of days ago, actually on the day that it was released, and already by the time I had viewed it, there were over 5 million views of it, and I dropped in just before we recorded them this afternoon, and it's now at 11 million views. Just four days later. I think that's pretty unbelievable. Mind you, the original short is now up to 75 million views. So for Kane's sake, I really hope the film lives up to the hype, but somehow I'm kind of less convinced the trailer, I have to say, has this kind of Five Nights at Freddy's or scream feel about it. So it's clearly kind of tapping into that summer horror vibe that we have tended to see being released year after year for the last, I don't know how many years, I think it'd be fair to say I'm not likely to be the core audience for it, though, but considering that the whole thing came from a single photograph and a creepy pasta thread, I do think it's absolutely astonishing to see the journey that this thing has taken to get to the big screen. And for that, I'm super excited for the Creator. I will put the original review that we did to the short when it first came out upon our channel, so that you can see the link and the trailer of where it's at today. So yeah, that's my news. Phil Rice 04:02 Good. It does look like intriguing trailer. I'm probably not the my movie going habits wouldn't suggest that I'm the typical audience for psychological horror. However, it's, you know, it's not, not out of the question. And it looks like if they've attracted some interesting cast members, like, Yeah, I agree, not no names, and that's saying something. So I think for me it's they're going to have to have, they're going to have to have crafted a narrative for it to work as a movie. So, and there's lots of user inspired, it's basically, it's the backrooms itself. Isn't a narrative, right? It's a canvas. It's a it's a concept of a world. And then users have kind of, you know, created all these narratives there. So how did they manage that? Did they come up with something? Original? Is it going to be derived from? Is it going to be some attempt at amalgamation of other stuff? You know, if you think about if someone were to go to make a movie of of a video game that has a narrative, then usually the big evaluation is going to be, how faithful were they to that right? So how does it work when the the for lack of it's not a game. I know a video game was made about this, but this is just a this is just an empty canvas. This is probably a not dissimilar challenge to what the makers of the Minecraft movie had to do because Minecraft itself only has like hints of a narrative by way of stacked achievements that you're supposed to go through in the game, but there's no characters and well, that had a surprising, surprisingly successful theater run. I don't know how long. I don't know how well it will hold up over time. I don't know if it's going to be one of those that we will look back on and call a cult classic, but it was part of kind of a pretty interesting phenomenon in the theaters. How much of that was just a new explosion of post covid freedom that happened to coincide with the release. Time will tell. I guess you know. So, yeah, interesting challenge to to come up with an error, because ultimately, when you're making a movie like this is based on something that 70 million people are aware of or have interest in, then you're just trying to see, you know that if you're smart, you know, you can't make everybody happy, but can you make enough people happy to where it will turn a profit? I don't know that's that's going to be interesting to see. Tracy Harwood 06:50 Yeah, the journey alone is worth the watch. I think, yeah. Damien Valentine 06:54 I hope it's successful. Yeah, I'm intrigued by the concept of back rooms, but I haven't really followed it that closely, beyond the things you talked about and watching a couple of the videos, they have attracted quite an impressive cast for this, which I feel like these actors aren't desperate for work, so they're only going to write Phil Rice 07:16 things exactly. Damien, yeah, Damien Valentine 07:19 yeah, I don't know. Well, yeah, I don't know if I'll go watch it this scenario, if I'll watch it at home, if we see it at some point, but, yeah, I don't know if it's because I'm not really invested in it that much. And so we'll see. I'll definitely watch it at home, but whether or not I'll venture out or not, or just wait, right? I don't know. We'll see. But yeah, for I hope you're successful. I hope the people who are invested in backrooms enjoy it and have a great time watching it. This is kind Phil Rice 07:48 of nerdy, but you know what I would really love to see, and maybe, if this is successful, maybe this will follow is a really well done, professional documentary on the phenomena that pieces together because we've, we've, you know, a sleuth can go out there, and we've pieced together quite a bit just from little kind of cursory research. But to have a real good documentary filmmaker tell the story of this that culminates in this, this film that's much more interesting to me than it is what narrative they construct for this. Tracy Harwood 08:24 Yeah, but you know, the thing that I really like when because I was reading the credits for it as well, Kane Parsons has actually managed to be the Director of it. Phil Rice 08:35 Good for him. That's remarkable. Tracy Harwood 08:36 I'm really pleased to see that good for Phil Rice 08:38 him, because this is an A 24 film, if I'm not mistaken, is that, right? Yeah, yeah. And they're, they're not small potatoes. I mean, exactly. That's really impressive, that, yeah, however that came to be, that should be in the documentary too. That's fascinating. Yeah, that doesn't happen very often. Tracy Harwood 08:57 That's it. That's your money, Damien Valentine 09:02 right? Right? I I've got two pieces of news. The first one is Starfield, which is a game we've been following for a while, and we've recently discussed some of the films shortly after last month's recording session. And it's usually the case with real vision. Doing this to us, I kind of mentioned that there was some kind of update coming, but they hadn't revealed any details. Well, they did reveal the details a few days later, there are two expansions coming. One's free, so I'll talk about that one. First, it's called free lanes, and it's kind of an overhaul of how space flight works in the game. So previously, you can take off in your spaceship, and you can fly around in space, but if you want to go to another planet, you go to the map, and you say where you want to go, and you kind of get this little brief cut scene of your ship jumping into this vortex, and then brief loading screen, and then you're at wherever you wanted to go. There was no real means to. To fly manually. It would take a very long time if you tried it. I don't know if it's even possible, because of the way the game was designed, what they've done here is, instead of that cut scene and loading, there's now an actual gameplay system in place, so you kind of jump faster than light, but you're still in the game. You can get out of your pilot seat, you can walk around the ship, interact with anyone you've got a board. You can do it, you know, interact with any of the ship systems, or whatever you want to do on the ship. If you get attacked, an alarm will sound, and you can rush to the pilot seat and deal with that. And, you know, there's a whole lot of other stuff that they're adding to it, so it'd be quite intriguing to see what that's going to do. And the next thing is the page DLC called Terra Nomada, and some of this goes alongside the free lanes update. Basically it's a new enemy, which is a group of humans that went off into deep space, and they've come back because they want to conquer everything, and they've got this huge army of robots. So there's a new threat. And if you're flying around in space, they can pull you out and, you know, they stop your ship and attack you. And you know, that's a whole new thing to deal with. I think there's meant to be some kind of story with that as well, which they obviously, they're keeping that very quiet because they want people to experience it. But you see things go well together, is my understanding. And there's a deep dive video which should be included as well, which where the developers are talking about this. So they both get released at the same time, which, as we record this is on Tuesday. By the time this goes out, they'll be available. And, you know, Starfield fans will have had a chance to play it. One of the things I want to talk about was the Terra Nomada. The trailer for it showed they're showing off parts of the experience of the robots attacking. And there were cut scenes that were not like the cut scenes you typically expect from Bethesda, where it's all straight from your character's perspective. These were cinematic cut scenes like you'd expect in Mass Effect. Now I don't know if they were made specifically for the trailer, or if that's going to be part of the game, when you actually play through that story, and I don't know whether or not if those camera options are going to be added to the tool set, they were definitely filmed in engine. It wasn't a pre rendered thing. So there must be some capability for it there. So if that is something that users can have, then maybe we'll see some more interesting Starfield machinima once people Phil Rice 12:48 figure out sorely, sorely needed. Oh yes, yeah, because since our last discussion of Starfield, I have explored the lack of tools extensively, all the console commands, everything. And while Starfield, from a machinima point of view, Starfield has an absolutely astounding photo mode, I think maybe the best photo mode, overall that I've ever seen in a game. You can actually change the pose of the character, you can change their facial expression, you can run all kinds of filters and change the lighting, and it's phenomenal. And the fidelity of the resulting photo is spectacular. And it feels like just, they're just right on the cusp of, okay, so how about a camera that we can actually use? Yeah? So I sure hope so, because I thought the same thing Damien, when I saw the trailer, I thought, man, where are those tools? You've got them. Why aren't you putting them out? Yeah, you know, why wouldn't they like, I can understand if we could, like, look and see. Okay, so there's a clear economic reason why it makes no sense for them to release those because yada yada yada, I just can't fill in the yada yada yada there. I don't see any reason that they wouldn't, except maybe that they don't. They don't think that there's demand. You know, I don't know. I earnestly hope that they will release that, because it'll change everything. Damien Valentine 14:29 Well, pathetic seemed to one of the few developers that actually encouraged fans to be creative and create more stuff. They actually built that into the game, which a lot of developers don't do that anymore, because the publishers don't want fans creating content when they could make content that could be sold, but they're still like fans to be creative. So absolutely, more tools for that, even if it's just for cinematic stuff. You can't make mods with that, but you can make videos and tell stories, which is important. So yeah, we need that. So I really hope it's included. I did see some. In the deep dive video about more camera photo mode options. I don't know if that's gonna be anything about video, but it's just, I think it's more like more character poses and stuff like that, which, right, that's good too. Phil Rice 15:12 That's good too. Yeah, and hey, for those, for those who don't know, the reason that photo mode isn't a solution for Machinima is photo mode freezes the the action in the game. Yeah, that obviously makes sense for photos, right? But, you know, it's you can't use the photo mode camera and settings for moving pictures, so that's what Damien Valentine 15:36 we're most year before, like, soft things will still be animated, like, if you've got, if you've got character with, like, a long coat on and it's blowing in the breeze, that's true. Phil Rice 15:47 Yeah? Cloth physics and hair physics, I think, still work, yeah, but that Damien Valentine 15:50 doesn't help you tell the story. No, that's the look at. But, yeah, Phil Rice 15:55 and you can't capture the video of that. When you take the picture, obviously, it's still just still image. You can't capture the video that without I guess you can hide the interface, can't you? Yeah, yeah, and so, but it's still that's there's always do with with that hammer, Damien Valentine 16:10 the Take Photo button, just like that. That isn't really practical. But yeah, so, yeah. I hope we get some video tools there, or at least it opens up the possibility for a fan to do something. So I'm excited to play these two expansions. Obviously, free lanes is lifts up. The name is free. So you're going to get that regardless. And Terra namazo looks interesting, the threat that the robotic threat, are quite interested to explore that. And apparently you can get one as a recruit, and it sounds like they modeled him on HK 47 from night sealed Republic, which is one of my favorite games, but I found one of my favorite characters from that game. Phil Rice 16:52 I'm trying to remember. It's been a long time since I played that game. He was Damien Valentine 16:56 the very sarcastic and psychopathic assassin droid that pretends to be like when you first meet him. He pretends to be harmless, like c3 Po, then you buy him, and then he, he reveals who he really is, killing everything that Phil Rice 17:10 vaguely rings a bell. Yeah, so Damien Valentine 17:13 this new robot that you can recruit to your team in the game, my understanding is he's going to have a very similar personality. So I like, I like red books like that. Phil Rice 17:23 So, like, whatever the name of the one was in Rogue One. And, yeah, k2 so, yeah, wonderful, yeah. Damien Valentine 17:36 So, yeah, I look forward to seeing what happens with that. And then the next thing is Fortnite news. And Fortnite and Star Wars news, over the last few years, fortnight, have teamed up with Lucasfilm and Disney to produce some Star Wars themed events. These have been limited run things where they usually tie in with some release. And I've not tried Fortnite, so I kind of missed I'm big Star Wars fan, but I don't really find Fortnite as a game that really appeals to me that much. So I have never played any of these things. What they've done is all those assets, even though the events have gone. If you missed them, you've missed them. That's it. All. The assets still exist. What they've done is they have made all of those assets and the tools available to the Fortnite community to use for free. And it's not just the grace of you can place them. You can actually use Fortnite to create whole games, which I did not know until I saw this, and so fans are already using these assets to create Star Wars games they'd like to see that aren't being made officially, like an interpretation of what Battlefront three would look like, because EA won't make a Battlefront three for whatever Reason. So fans are doing it using this content, and they can. They've got all the stormtroopers, and they've got vehicles and spaceships, and I saw a couple of things of like someone made like a basic space flight simulator. You got the death star in the background, and there's X things and TIE Fighters shooting each other, and you fly in those ships, and you multiplayer and all of that. So maybe at some point to give this a try, but hopefully without the fortnight bit getting in the way. That's not really my kind of game. But I think this is great because, you know, you can use these assets, and you can make a film with it if you want to. Probably not enough for me to do any air to the Empire stuff, because they're not going to have all the content I need there, but that's a very specific story. But if you want to create the Star Wars story, and you've got your own thing in mind, and this covers it, well, there's another platform you can use for machinima. And, yeah, another thing. I'm just intrigued to see what people do with it. But that's it. That's my news for this month. Phil Rice 19:58 Yeah. All right, so let me, let me dive into my stack here. Then a couple quick mentions that I'll make one. I found a very nice tutorial. A lot more machinima creators that I talked to are using DaVinci Resolve as their video editor. Not everybody, but more are. Part of the benefit of that one is that there is a free version that's quite capable. The paid one is if you need those extra features, it's well worth it. I don't regret that at all. But this, this creator, put together a video on how to optimize the settings for DaVinci Resolve. Because DaVinci Resolve is designed for originally, was designed for professional production studios who have quite magnanimous resources at their disposal. And by default, many of the features of DaVinci Resolve are set for that. And the result is, is that performance may not be ideal on your hardware, or it may eat up resources. There's a caching feature that, while very helpful, can eat up gigabytes, I mean, hundreds of gigabytes of disk space if you're not careful, and it kind of can catch you off guard, because you don't realize your drive is filling up. He covers all of that in this video, and also focuses on the stuff that can make operations run faster. It's very helpful. I've tested everything in there, and some of which I had learned elsewhere, and some stuff was new to me. So we'll include a link to that that video in our notes. Headshot three is coming. Headshot is the plugin for i for character creator that basically gives you the access to these methods of easily creating unique characters, you know, metahuman type stuff, right? Headshot, one and two. The main innovation there was that if you take a nicely lit and properly framed, high resolution photograph of a face, it can, sometimes, with a little massaging, can convert that into a very workable and accurate looking 3d character. I think the main innovation on that part of the headshot process is that you can now AI generate a face directly in the program, if you want to, you can still do the other method, and it is superior in the way that it handles it, but they're they're basically integrating some of those features to make the end result be easier to create and more accurate. So that's certainly going to be interesting to play with. There's another whole aspect of headshot that I have not played with much, but basically you can you're bringing in a model, and it maps the face to it very accurately. We ought to have warlord on as a guest or an interviewee at some point, because I think he's he's played with that a bit more than I do. He designs characters in Zbrush and software like that. Sometimes that's just that's not, not part of my current workflow. But headshot three looks pretty cool. The only thing I'm upset about it with is that they offer several bundles as part of the pre launch, and none of them really map to my situation. You know, they've got one where buy headshot two now and then, you know, you get this discount on character creator five and headshot three, but it's like, well, I already have headshot two. Damien Valentine 23:35 Yeah, exactly the same position. Phil Rice 23:36 I can't find anything that maps to my situation where I've already got character creator for I've already got headshot two. There's no discount for me right now. So the more I see with CC five, the more I'm really drawn towards it. But I think that that right now, it looks like my best move is going to just cross my fingers and hold out for the eventual iClone nine. CC five bundle, which is how I got actually, it was I clone seven, and CC three is where, and then, then you can upgrade smoothly and such. But anyway, the videos demonstrating what headshot three can do are pretty remarkable. They're, they're really, they're not real. Illusion is not slowing down at all in terms of improving their their software and and making use of various technologies to do so. There's a really nice video for the pre launch, but there's another one where it actually shows the process. This is by a Creator that they used to create a character for blender that ultimately it was going to end up in Blender. But they used character creator five and headshot to create this character model based. Based on a real person that that's one of the the producers of the video, and it's pretty fascinating. It's a little bit fast paced, like it. It's not a it's not a step by step tutorial, but it's a very nice overview to show what's possible. So we'll include, we'll include a link to that one as well. In terms of AI, there's some interesting things. One, there is a there's a tool that's just titling itself, not A, not the most ambiguous title I've ever heard it. They're titling itself free. Mo cap, and it is a GitHub project. It is free, and there's a lot of these things that have been floating out there, but all of the ones that I've seen, they tend to be either very buggy, or they tend to require kind of a non traditional setup where you have to manually deal with Python packages and things like that, or it only runs on Linux, or, you know, all those limitations. And this one seems to be prioritizing the ease of use for installing and using this. And it is a free program. I believe that the emphasis is video to mocap. I don't think that it's designed to work with markers and such, but it's, it's, it's nice to see these, these kinds of things maturing, and I think that's what this is a sign of. In that same vein, Nvidia just released and just announced, and it's kind of like in a open, public test phase right now. They're calling it kimono, k, i, m, O, D, O, and this is, it's the only instance of a text to mocap thing that I've seen that is actually free to use now, I don't think it's going to stay free to use forever. That just doesn't seem very realistic, but you can go use it as of the time that we're recording this video. You can go use it right now, and it works now. The end result motion file is a BVH file, which is you can bring that into iClone and convert it to an iClone motion. It's fairly straightforward to do. I've only gotten about halfway through my testing of it in that I've generated a few text to motions to bvhs, but I haven't done the iClone part yet. So basically, just plan on that, if not on this channel, then on my channel, on YouTube. I will put out a tutorial for that once I've tested it fully. It's an interesting approach to getting some unusual motion types that you might need when you don't have a full on motion capture rig or a suit, or you're just not getting the right results from video. So it's, it's, it's a another way of of generating motion that I think is is pretty Damien Valentine 28:12 interesting, or you want to do something that'd be incredibly dangerous to do, Phil Rice 28:17 yeah, that too, right? Yeah, absolutely. So AI voice, so 11 labs, if you're interested in AI voice, at all 11 Labs has kind of been the go to place to do that. And part of the challenge with that is that it's a subscription, so there's ongoing expense for it. There are alternatives to 11 labs, but ultimately, you're always paying something, if it's not in the form of AI credits that you can use to generate or if it's a monthly fee, there's something. But if you wanted to experiment around with AI voice there is a tool called voice box. The website for its voice box.sh, and this is a voice cloning and text to speech program, but it runs completely locally. It is completely free. I don't know if it will stay free forever, but it kind of sounds like that's their intent. I've actually done a full tutorial showing exactly how this thing works. We'll link to that in our show notes. Take about 30 minutes or so, and I went through the entire process and gave you my honest review of it. You know, for the too long. You know, too long. Didn't read people out there. It's not, it doesn't hold a candle yet to what 11 labs can do, but it's interesting development, and they, they seem to be aspiring to replicating the functions that people currently do pay for with 11 labs as something that you could do. You locally so and for free. So this kind of falls in the open source category. Tracy Harwood 30:11 Would it also solve some of the issues to do with security as well, and I and ownership of your own voice IP, if Phil Rice 30:22 it's absolutely because you basically can take about 30 seconds of audio of a voice and create a clone and then reuse it, and all of that lives locally on your machine. Yeah, there are external resources that you download into the program that the transcription engine, the Whisper transcription engine. You download a version of that in, and then you can download one of several options for the text to speech, and it looks like it's built modularly to where it will support, you know, newer versions of those as they come out. But yeah, everything lives and runs locally on the PC. So interesting, development, fascinating. One more thing related to realusion is just a video that I caught that I think, that they shared through their their newsletter of somebody who used character creator and I clone to ultimately land at their project in Houdini, which is a higher end 3d animation, kind of considered traditional 3d animation software that we won't really talk about on here, because it's kind of clearly outside the bounds of machinima. It's professional tool. It's quite expensive, but the results that they get and to see that this is all powered, ultimately by characters made in in character creator and I clone animations, and it is just gorgeous. So I don't know what the title of the film is. It's mentioned in their overview, but it's this masquerade dance, kind of Japanese themed. It's beautiful. So we'll include a link to that so you can see that it's just, it's inspiring, I would say, leans in the direction of realism, not not stylized, and it's just just extraordinarily well done. So All right, so there's one more topic that I want to kind of go through without bogging us down too much, but it's kind of just all hinged on a question, and that is, has AI turned a corner? And what I mean by that is more in terms of public attitudes about it. Are they shifting? And should we be surprised at that, based on everything that we've covered over this time? So I think the the event that kind of, to me, really signaled that that okay, something has has changed, is the fact that open AI has announced that probably as of the date that we released this episode, Sora, video generation will not exist anymore. And the reason that that's significant is because go back in time 12 months, and it was heralded as the Hollywood killer, as the this is going to change everything forever and and all of that. It was the tool that that of all the video generation tools, was probably the one that was the most hyped at being this catalyst for change in the entire way that movies are made, and now they're just shutting it down open. AI is not going away. Chat. GPT is still growing strong. They've got other things that they're invested in, but whatever the situation is it, there's just no incentive for them to keep it open without the Disney deal that fell apart, that they were kind of banking on, I think, for a way to make it not lose so much money, I think, is what it comes down to. And why does it lose so much money? Well, not just because of the resource usage, but also because of all the the legal issues that result from the way that Sora trains to get its content. You know, it's using copyrighted material, and it's the it's kind of come back to bite them. But does this? Does this signal the beginning of a larger trend in that regard? Because if Sora can fall, and that was one of the biggest, maybe second only to, like to mid journey, or something like that. Mid journey's had challenges of its own in that regard. So I think it's a big deal. Damien Valentine 34:53 I remember we talked about the Disney deal as a couple of months ago, and I said it would last about a year. Phil Rice 35:00 Earth. We were both we were both way long. Damien Valentine 35:04 Yes, yeah, when I said that, I thought it would be a year because they'd wait for the Mandalorian grogu and Avengers Doomsday, and I thought a fan's gonna make something would be better received, and Disney aren't gonna like that. When I said that, I didn't realize that I was gonna be so wrong that it wouldn't actually get to public use. Yeah, I don't know if the Disney deal ended when open air decided to close down. Sora like there's obviously some discussion between them that we are not privy to. So I don't know if Disney said we're not going to do this and then it got shut down, or if open AI said, we can't do this even with Disney, and then Disney backed out. Obviously, there's no point then funding something that open. Ai aren't going to continue running. I also don't know, right? So Disney invested $1 billion into this. I don't know if they're going to get all that back. I don't know how much of it's been spent. Phil Rice 36:01 The more I've read on it, I'm not sure that that that that actually happened yet, right? Okay, I don't think the money actually changed hands. I think the deal fell apart before it was begun, really, okay. Maybe there were some preliminary movements, but when it came time to actually sign, you're right. We don't know who, but somebody said, Nah, we're not going to do this. I suspect it was Disney that is the one who pulled back, because, as we discussed in that episode, it's like, what is their incentive there? Like, how do they make how do they monetize their end of this, just having people show up on Disney plus just to go generate AI Video Star Wars. Is that enough is are they going to be able to to quantify a result there in terms of more Disney plus subscriptions that are coming? Because, oh, and, you know, having access to all the Marvel and Star Wars universe is not enough, but being able to create our own AI videos with that stuff is it just seemed implausible to me. So that's my suspicion. But you're right. We don't know for sure who started it, but maybe the more pressing issue would be why, and I think that it's not simply about the money. It's something that maybe comes before the money. And I suspect that there's a shifting they're noticing the shift in public sentiment, the AI fatigue that's starting to happen because of all the slop that has gone everywhere, and more and more awareness of that is growing, and there's we've we talked about this in previous episodes too that we we wondered, at what point is the public gonna go? I just don't want to see this anymore. You know, Damien, I think you felt that way about 24 months ago. Oh yeah, but the rest is lower. I know, right, so, but I hear people that have nothing to do with technology. I'll overhear conversations in restaurants and people talking about, it's all this slop, all this AI garbage. I mean, it's, it's part of the conversation. So I have to feel like at some point that becomes big enough to where the company realizes I'm not putting a billion dollars down to towards something that everybody's already starting to move past, you know? So is there any other evidence of that? And so Damien Valentine 38:35 looking Microsoft, they were putting a lot of money into AI, and they've massively scaled back. Because initially, the the current CEO, I forget his name off the top of my head, he was saying, oh, AI is going to be great. And then, like, two or three months later, they were really massively scaling back, because no one's using their AI tools for anything. And it's the same with Nvidia, that they've been really pushing AI, and they've got this new dlss Five, which is supposed to use AI to fill in frames, to make things faster. And it's just been massively rejected by pretty much everyone. Like they showed off some games that they didn't actually use request permission from from the companies, but they put it through their filter. And the fan reaction from this is saying, well, that this looks terrible. It looks like aI slope. It's not we want to see the original vision of the artists who made the games. We don't want to see it put through a filter to look photo realistic, especially if that game isn't designed to look photo realistic. And so Nvidia have been trying to say, Oh no, it's not like that. It's going to be wonderful and all that stuff. But the reaction to that, it's been so negative, and I see it with other things as well as, like people is completely losing interest in AI generated content. Tracy Harwood 39:50 Yeah, yeah. However, I do think, because I was just looking up what, who have they partnered with subsequent to the Disney deal, and they partnered with Amazon. And Nvidia and Softbank, and in that intervening period, they've raised 120 billion in funding, which, to me, indicates they're going more for base models and linking in a corporate ecosystem, I would suggest. So I don't think they're going anywhere soon as to I just think that Phil Rice 40:21 the No, I don't think open AI is going anywhere soon, but I think specifically the Disney video generation, I think is they're, they're basically someone has decided this is not where we want to put our our efforts anymore. Well, I think Tracy Harwood 40:37 they can stay ahead of the kickback if they partner in the way that they have now, why would they be linking with Amazon? It's got to be to do with the the, you know, the work stream, rather than the Amazon. Phil Rice 40:52 Amazon has a they have a customized version of what is essentially chat GPT at its core that they use in house, and apparently the employees have been told that use of that tool. There's a name for it that I can't remember now, Tracy Harwood 41:13 is it? But something Phil Rice 41:15 like that? It's something short, but I can't remember what it's called, but they've been mandated. It's it's mandatory that it be used, and even then they're getting pushback. Yeah, I don't know how connected that is to this, but I think that if you have revulsion to one use of AI, it's inevitable that it's going to bleed over to attitudes about AI generally, which maybe is harmful, because I think tools like chat, GPT and cloud. I mean, there's just no, no question that they are impressed. They are part of the future. They're very impressive. And yeah, when you set AI to do what it does, well, yeah, it's a game changer, for sure, Tracy Harwood 41:56 from what I understand in terms of the next steps of advice. I mean, there's a couple of big next steps in computing. My understanding of it, Nvidia, for example, is going into robotics. So so to me, if what you're looking at is they understand animation, and they understand animation in a 3d context, to me, what they're doing would make perfect sense as a match for the next big step that somebody like Nvidia is right taking. And that's not filmmaking, that's actual animation of robotic things. Yeah, I think Phil Rice 42:36 as as significant of that, it's not AI as the outer skin that we see quite it's aI underneath. And I think that's where the trend will go. And if you look at how real illusion has been making use of AI in theirs, it's not out in front necessarily. It's incorporated as a component exactly that you can optionally or optionally not use, right? But it's there. I think that to some degree, Adobe, if you look at the way they integrated AI powered features into Photoshop with generative fill and things like that, that was successful, whereas when they put out a separate product for just raw AI generation and output that's not doing as well, that's not being embraced on a larger scale. They're really struggling to get artists to to accept that, but those same artists will fire up Photoshop and they're using AI and don't even know it. So I think that that's ultimately where the destination for this will lie as far as the public attitudes. It's interesting to see some some other coincidental events. There's a French or a French Canadian duo called Agen de poitouin. They're from Quebec, from a small town in Quebec, and they've exploded onto the scene. And there's two guys, two people, a guy with a double neck guitar, you know, bass and guitar, and a rack of pedals and a looping machine, and a drummer, and they're both extraordinary musicians. And the guitars are both tuned to use micro tonal intervals, so they're not standard a 440 intervals that they're not keys you can play on a piano. You know they're in between those pitches, very strange sounding and almost at first at first listen, it almost sounds like, Wait, is this guitar out of tune? Well, it is, but quite deliberately and Calculatedly, so, you know. And it's this live performance. The performers wear costumes. You don't have no you can't see their faces. You can only see their I think the only flesh visible is painted hands. And feet, and it's really all about the performance, the human performance. There's nothing electronically driven about what they're doing. I think it's not a coincidence that that type of thing, even though it's kind of strange and it's a very strange sound, right? But I think the fact that it's human driven performance is part of why that's being embraced. I think the success of project Hail Mary is interesting, you know, for especially in light of, if we go back in time 12 months, oh, Hollywood's dead. This movie is just rocking the charts, and it's really, really good. It's a really good movie. And I don't know it's, it's, it's interesting stuff, neural viz, who we love, who you know is actually has been using AI video tools to create really interesting stuff. He paused his Patreon back in October, and has hasn't made a video since now. As he describes it, it's just fatigue of the solo creator. He's been really pushing it hard and needed a break. But I can't help but wonder, we've, we've, we've speculated sometimes about what kind of pushback is he probably constantly running into from people who just regardless, regardless of his excellent looking result. The idea of AI being used in that way is just, it's not growing in popularity, that's for sure, you know. So I can't help but wonder if that's part of the the fatigue of kind of feeling like it's just constantly uphill, and public sentiment is not changing on that. So I'm wondering, Is he rethinking, not just how to manage his time so he doesn't burn out, but also, is this the most effective way for me to be making stuff? It's a speculation, but it's just it is interesting that these things are happening so close, Damien Valentine 47:19 it's the George Lucas effect. I don't know if that's what it's really called, but one of the reasons he sold Lucasfilm to Disney was he was so exhausted. Of every time he did something, fans hating it, saying this is he ruined Star Wars, and of my childhood yet again, with whatever this latest thing is. And it's fine, whatever he's done, it's just not what they grew up with so, you know, he got so tired of that that he just couldn't deal with it anymore. He wanted it out of his life, so he sold it to Disney. So, yeah, if, if you're using AI to create content, you're going to get a lot of Tracy Harwood 47:56 my point of view. There is a whole lot of irrational response to this whole lot of irrational Oh, I agree, and it truly makes not a lot of sense, actually, because these are tools that you know, AI has been used within tool sets that we've commented on for donkeys years, and all of a sudden it's like, no, no, don't want to use that. Can't use that. Not interested in that. Speaker 2 48:25 And I would say, I'm sorry, go ahead. Well, I was Tracy Harwood 48:29 just, I find it disingenuous from from so many folks to sort of comment in the way that they are without actually really fully understanding what these tools are capable of doing. So I don't have an awful lot of time for this kind of irrational negativity without actually seeing the quality of the work that some people are actually doing. And I agree there's an awful lot of shit and slot that we see on YouTube, but it's not the only rubbish that we see on YouTube, and we're Phil Rice 49:00 actually going to review a film here in a couple of weeks that that is a great example of just extraordinarily wonderful use of those tools. Tracy Harwood 49:10 Yeah, exactly, yeah. So I don't, I don't get the response to, I understand some of it, but not a lot of it, if I'm honest, and I have to say this, the debates that I'm kind of seeing being being had around IP, and, you know, the way that governments are trying to think about and think around the issues around copyright, also don't make an awful lot of sense to Me. It's just not an awful lot of proper thinking about what creatives need to do to get their their their work out into a domain where an audience can see it and can then choose to buy or invest in it, or commission the artists, or anything like that, because the the. Way it's evolved. It's been it's been so anti and negative that these people are never going to get their work in front of an audience, because it's just not going to be anywhere that's usefully discoverable. So what are they doing? Shooting themselves in the foot, in my view, controversial view, I know, but that is my view. Damien Valentine 50:22 People are just exhausted of AI generated content, because there's so much of it and they're so easy to produce that it's just automatic revulsion to any of it, no matter how good it looks. Tracy Harwood 50:35 I really don't accept that they are just anti for the sake of being anti without any logic. Well, you can search for content. You can spend some time doing we spend hours doing what we do with this channel. We are looking for stuff that we want to review, and in that process, we discard a lot of stuff that we don't want to touch. And some of it is more purely AI generated stuff, and some of it is using it embedded within the tools that have been used in the creative process make a choice. Phil Rice 51:06 I think it's helpful to to to frame this as such, because I think that while, while some of the reaction is over the top and irrational, it's also not new. Tracy Harwood 51:20 No, it's not new by any means. Phil Rice 51:25 Impressionism as a painting style was a direct reaction to the introduction of the photograph, and it was a sense of at that point, there became a divide those who really liked this new technology, and those who said, We've got to change and we're going to make things in a way that a photograph can't do anymore, right? And so you end up with with Van Gogh, I think that the same type of thing, it's a little harder to figure out to line that up around the advent of motion pictures. But when motion pictures first debuted on the scene in the early 20th century, it looked like it was going to fail. Immediately, it just looked like no one was going to go along with it. And there immediately was a vaudeville revival, live performances, people on the stage, and this argument ensued of that superior to anything you could put on a screen. This new technology is going to ruin everything, if we let it. And that divide happened. The same thing happened when electronics became a part of music, and when MIDI came around, there was immediately, right after electronic music emerged in the 60s or 70s. Then immediately there was a folk revival. And all of a sudden, James Taylor and Jim Croce and all these acoustic artists and folk music was beloved more than ever by some as a revulsion against or a rebellion against the role of electronics. But what happened in all those cases was eventually there was convergence, and it wasn't total dominance of one technology over the other. There was a coexistence that ended up happening. And it may be overly optimistic, but I think that that's what's at the end of this AI battle ultimately will be a convergence and a kind of a piece made of where these things, you know, can be used. And it probably will happen faster with AI than it did with these other things, because everything seems to happen faster now than it did at the time that Van Gogh started painting, you know, so, but yeah, I think that that's, I think that's part of what's going on, is it's just a normal reaction, particularly acutely in the art World, reaction to radical technology and whatever else AI is. And it's radical technology for sure, like, maybe the most that we've ever seen, so most Tracy Harwood 54:11 accessible, probably, that we've seen, yeah, yeah. Phil Rice 54:13 And which, if you think about it, okay, so when photographs came around, it wasn't that immediately anyone could go out and get a Kodak disposable at their drugstore, right? But eventually, that's what it became. And then so one could take a position there that will that just means that now, now the world is filled with all these disposable photographs, and then in the digital age, it got even more so, you know, I've heard comedians joke in stand up routines about that. You know, when I look back at when I go to my grandma's house and she shows me old photos, it's events, it's things and families and stuff. And when people go back and look at my phone in the future, when I'm a grandpa, they're going to see pictures of my food. Tracy Harwood 54:57 Or, if you lose your phone, nothing at all, because what is the. Other thing they say that, right, we're going to be the only generation that have nothing to show for what we've done in our lives. Nothing. Yeah, whether Phil Rice 55:09 this is, whether this is ironic of me to do or not, I thought an interesting thing to do would be to gather all this information and feed it into chat GPT and see what chat GPT had to say about it. And so I posited, here's my theory, here's what I'm citing as that tear this apart or tell me I'm wrong, or tell me I'm right, or whatever. But what? How do you assess this information? And the response was kind of interesting. First of all, when, when chat GPT began its response. It said, here's a possible title to put to this, if this were going to be put into an article or something. And the title that it used was December 2025, to march 2026, the moment creative AI lost its inevitability narrative, which was interesting, right? So here's, here's the bullet points, basically, of what it went through. It says the sea change is not that AI is disappearing from Creative Industries. Is that the center of gravity is shifting from replacement fantasies to controlled backstage and disclosed use. I think that's just like, so good. Normally, AI, writing is like, horrible. I've got this, got this friend who, for whatever reason, he's decided that his Facebook feed is now going to be chat GPT renderings of his philosophical thoughts. And it's just like so obviously AI, but sometimes they come up with pretty interesting stuff. So it goes on to say audiences and institutions seem more open to AI as an assistive tool than as a substitute for authorship, performance or artistic identity. Soros shut down platform, authentication tools, disclosure labels, copyright pressure and visible backlash to AI first film projects all point in that direction. And then it said a few caveats to keep in mind. One, this is something Tracy mentioned just a few minutes ago. There is still heavy investment in AI creation tools and training ecosystems, including AI film education and dedicated AI film festivals. So this is not a one way collapse story. Second thing, some of them, some of the strongest evidence here, is about distribution, trust and rights management, not purely about taste. So it's kind of pushing back a little bit on on my theory that the public is has finally totally had enough. And this is broad project Hail Mary is best treated as a supportive cultural signal, not a direct referendum on AI which that's fair. So interesting, Damien Valentine 57:58 interesting stuff that's twice you brought up project Hail Mary, and the only thing I think of there's no AI used to make it. As far as I'm aware. Phil Rice 58:07 For me, Project Hail Mary was more of the fact that because AI generated video by its mostly by its its Twitter slash x supporters, has been positioned for like 24 solid months as the this is the end of Hollywood. There could be any big Hollywood. And guys who reviews, review movies on YouTube that I follow, and they talk about kind of with remorse that, well, we're never going to see movies like this again, talking about some movie that was made 10 years ago, whatever. We're never going to see big blood budget movies again. Well, that's not the conversations going on in Hollywood offices right now. I would bet, no, I'll bet there's a whole bunch of sci fi projects that are getting looked at now because they're trying to figure out, what about this made it so good? It's not just that it was sci fi. Damien Valentine 59:00 They didn't even use a single green screen for it, like for the outside stuff. They used the volume, like in the Mandalorian that they built a real set of the outside the ship. So he's up there, obviously, for space, you can't build that. So he had the LED screens around him to create all the lighting, everything, and even when he's outside, and you've got the the astrophage, the camera, and all this stuff that wasn't CGI. They put a water tank in front of the camera, and they put some stuff in it, so those particles are actually floating around in the water. And I think they put a purple light on it or something to to get that effect. So it's very old school effects, but they wanted to make it as practical as Tracy Harwood 59:41 possible, retro futuristic mate is what they call that, yeah. Phil Rice 59:45 And yet the result is stunning, like it's better looking than CGI. So I think those decisions were, were a direct reaction to Yeah, Damien Valentine 59:57 the only CGI I could tell. CGI was when they're talking outside and the thing explodes in the background, because the explosion is so massive that you probably don't want to set off that many explosives beyond film set. Yeah, I think that was the only CGI Phil Rice 1:00:12 thing that was, yeah, I think there was, there was certainly some compositing going on, but it's not the way that say Star Wars James Cameron makes, oh, yeah, you know, with actors with the points all over him in a big green room, or the way some of the Star Wars sequels were made too, because that's just the way things were being made, you know. And so it's, it is interesting that for a pretty major film, that they would say, we can still do things another way and get great results. And on top of that, you know, it all that would have been great, but if it wasn't also paired up with a really well told story, it wouldn't have mattered, you know, it wouldn't have even been noticed. So it's a lot of things converging at once for that film. Damien Valentine 1:01:02 The thing about Project Hail Mary, he watched that in 20 years. The way they did effects, that's still going to look stunning. You watch Phantom Menace now that CGI looks awful. Yes, and when they're doing the promotional videos for the Star Wars films, they usually miss out the prequels because the CGI is aged so badly that it's either the original trilogy or the new stuff, and you can maybe get a couple of shots of the prequels in to show completeness. Yeah, but you know, it just doesn't age well. Phil Rice 1:01:31 So isn't it funny how? Because you and I both remember when those first came out, when the first trailer dropped for Phantom Menace, and was like, whoa. It was. It was way ahead, right? So that's really interesting how time changes our our way of looking at that, yeah, Tracy Harwood 1:01:51 I still haven't seen it. Project, Hail Mary, no, so I do, I do want Phil Rice 1:01:59 to see but I haven't yet on the Damien Valentine 1:02:02 try and avoid as much as you can. It's a mystery, and you learn about stuff as the main character does, so go in as spoiler free as you can. Tracy Harwood 1:02:12 Okay, well, I'll try. Phil Rice 1:02:15 It's emotionally gripping too, Oh, yeah. Like it's not just some hard sci fi thing or something. It's got real heart. Tracy Harwood 1:02:25 Yeah, it's so do you know the other The weird thing about that I kind of knew you were going to talk about Hail Mary is because your pick, Damien the egg, that we're going to do as our next film discussion is actually by the same author, yes. Why isn't it, yeah, well, so Okay, so there's the connection, isn't is there? Not that was Yeah, yeah. So I look forward to that in a few minutes. Phil Rice 1:02:56 Okay, all right. Well, that is our news for this month. Audience, what did you think of what we talked about? Let us know in the comments or drop us an email at talk at completely machinima.com I keep getting distracted because some Starfleet officer keeps walking behind Damien. Damien Valentine 1:03:14 Yeah, I did tell her to go away, but Phil Rice 1:03:16 she keeps to tell them we're filming right now. Damien Valentine 1:03:19 Yeah, she's half cling on. You don't really want to annoy her too much. I understand Phil Rice 1:03:23 I understand it well. That's all for this week. My name is Phil rice. On behalf of my co hosts, Damian Valentine and Tracy Harwood, we wish you a great day, and we'll see you next time bye bye. You.