Latest / Why Humans Lie / The Quiet Theft of a Life: How Vernon Stole Dale's Identity

Transcript

The Quiet Theft of a Life: How Vernon Stole Dale's Identity · Why Humans Lie

0:03
Speaker 1: On a Tuesday afternoon in February of two thy nineteen,
0:07
Speaker 1: a church volunteer named Diane Campbell walked up the front
0:11
Speaker 1: path of a house on Milhaven Road carrying a tray
0:14
Speaker 1: of scalloped potatoes. The door was unlocked. She pushed it
0:19
Speaker 1: open and stopped on the kitchen counter sat a ceramic bowl.
0:23
Speaker 1: Inside it, a driver's license, a Medicare card, and two
0:27
Speaker 1: ATM cards, all belonging to the man who lived there.
0:31
Speaker 1: A stack of documents roughly eight inches tall, held together
0:35
Speaker 1: with a rubber band, sat on the table. The top
0:38
Speaker 1: sheet was a power of attorney. The name on it
0:41
Speaker 1: was not the homeowner's. Dale Zimmermann was sixty two years old,
0:46
Speaker 1: and he was gone, not deceased, not hospitalized, simply absent
0:51
Speaker 1: from the life he had built over six decades, in
0:54
Speaker 1: ways that would take investigators months to fully understand. Because
0:59
Speaker 1: what happened to Dale was not a break in. There
1:02
Speaker 1: was no forced entry, no violence, no moment of obvious crisis.
1:07
Speaker 1: What happened to Dale was slower than that, and in
1:10
Speaker 1: many ways far more complete. To understand what was taken
1:14
Speaker 1: from Dale Zimmermann, you first have to understand what he
1:17
Speaker 1: had built. Dale grew up in Calverton, and he spent
1:21
Speaker 1: twenty seven years as a technical drafter at a civil
1:24
Speaker 1: engineering firm, the kind of meticulous, mineu patient work that
1:29
Speaker 1: suits a man who prefers precision to noise. He married,
1:33
Speaker 1: divorced in two thousand and one and never remarried. He
1:37
Speaker 1: had one biological child, a daughter named Pam, who eventually
1:41
Speaker 1: settled in Tucson. By most measures, the divorce could have
1:45
Speaker 1: marked the beginning of a smaller life. Instead, Dale expanded.
1:50
Speaker 1: At forty three, he became a foster father. Over the
1:54
Speaker 1: next fifteen years, he took in eleven children. He was
1:58
Speaker 1: fifty eight when the last placement ended. That was not
2:01
Speaker 1: a coincidence of circumstance. That was a choice made again
2:05
Speaker 1: and again for a decade and a half. In two
2:08
Speaker 1: thousand sixteen, Dale retired early. A moderate coronary condition had
2:13
Speaker 1: accelerated the decision. He was fifty nine. He left a
2:18
Speaker 1: firm with roughly ninety four thousand dollars in savings, a pension,
2:23
Speaker 1: a regional investment account, and a house on Milhaven Road
2:27
Speaker 1: that carried no mortgage. By any practical measure, he was secure.
2:32
Speaker 1: He kept a journal from his years as a foster
2:34
Speaker 1: parent a note book with a marbled black and white cover,
2:38
Speaker 1: The last entry dated from before two thousand seventeen. On
2:42
Speaker 1: the inside back cover, investigators would later find a handwritten
2:45
Speaker 1: note that note will matter, but that comes later. On
2:50
Speaker 1: the refrigerator hung a photograph from a back yard barbecue
2:53
Speaker 1: in the summer of two thousand twelve, seven of his
2:56
Speaker 1: eleven foster children, all of them smiling. Dale had kept
3:00
Speaker 1: it there for years. It was still there when Diane
3:04
Speaker 1: Campbell walked through the door. His daughter Pam called every
3:08
Speaker 1: Wednesday morning eight in the morning, Dale's time, six in
3:12
Speaker 1: the morning. Hers. She had not missed a single call
3:15
Speaker 1: in eleven years from two thousand seven through twenty eighteen,
3:19
Speaker 1: not once until December of twenty eighteen, when the calls
3:24
Speaker 1: simply stopped being answered. Pam had tried to reach him,
3:28
Speaker 1: She had left messages, she had sent texts. By February
3:33
Speaker 1: of two thousy nineteen, she had not spoken to her
3:37
Speaker 1: father in months, and she did not yet know why.
3:41
Speaker 1: She would find out. Within forty eight hours of Adult
3:44
Speaker 1: Protective Services making contact, she was on a plane to Calverton.
3:48
Speaker 1: Within that period, the caseworker assigned to Dale's file was
3:52
Speaker 1: Alice Bowers, a licensed clinical social worker with the Calverton
3:57
Speaker 1: County Adult Protection Division. She was assigned in two days
4:00
Speaker 1: after Diane's call to nine one one. What Alice Bowers
4:04
Speaker 1: found when she eventually located Dale eleven days after the
4:08
Speaker 1: house on Milhaven Road was discovered empty, that is, nine
4:12
Speaker 1: days after she was assigned, was a man who was
4:15
Speaker 1: physically intact, but who had been in a very specific
4:19
Speaker 1: and deliberate way, separated from everything that made him himself,
4:24
Speaker 1: his documents, his finances, his daughter, his own account of
4:29
Speaker 1: who he was. That separation had not happened overnight. It
4:33
Speaker 1: had taken almost two years, and it had begun, as
4:38
Speaker 1: these things often do, with a bench. Vernon Dempsey had
4:41
Speaker 1: been watching Calvary Lutheran for six weeks before he ever
4:45
Speaker 1: sat down next to Dale Zimmerman. That detail matters. He
4:49
Speaker 1: had followed the church's public page long enough to know
4:53
Speaker 1: the congregation's rhythms, who attended, who volunteered, who showed up alone,
4:58
Speaker 1: starting in March of tw twenty seventeen. He began that
5:02
Speaker 1: observation in April of two thousand seventeen, On a Tuesday,
5:06
Speaker 1: he chose a park bench near enough to Dale's regular
5:10
Speaker 1: route to make the meeting feel accidental. It was not accidental.
5:14
Speaker 1: Dale was sixty two years old, recently retired and living
5:18
Speaker 1: alone in a paid off house on Milhaven Road. He
5:21
Speaker 1: had spent fifteen years opening that house to children who
5:24
Speaker 1: needed it. He had twenty seven years of precise technical
5:29
Speaker 1: work behind him. He was, by every external measure, a
5:33
Speaker 1: man who had given steadily and asked for very little
5:37
Speaker 1: in return. Dempsey saw that clearly. What followed was a
5:42
Speaker 1: slow and deliberate excavation of everything Dale believed about himself.
5:46
Speaker 1: The first phase was simple presence. Dempsey appeared regularly on
5:52
Speaker 1: walks at church adjacent events, in the quiet spaces where
5:56
Speaker 1: a retired man spent his days. He listened, He asked questions,
6:02
Speaker 1: He remembered the answers For a man who had spent
6:04
Speaker 1: years caring for others. That kind of attention was not nothing.
6:09
Speaker 1: But here is the thing. The attention had a direction.
6:13
Speaker 1: By October of two thousand seventeen, Dale had begun writing
6:17
Speaker 1: something in the back of his Foster Care note book,
6:20
Speaker 1: the same note book with the marbled black and white
6:23
Speaker 1: cover that held fifteen years of children's names and progress notes.
6:27
Speaker 1: The last official entry had been made months earlier. What
6:31
Speaker 1: he wrote on the inside back cover was not a record.
6:34
Speaker 1: It was a question, a troubled one. The note read
6:38
Speaker 1: V says I gave too much and got nothing back.
6:42
Speaker 1: He says I should think about what I'm owed. I
6:45
Speaker 1: don't know if that's right, but he says it a lot.
6:48
Speaker 1: That sentence, he says it a lot, is the image
6:51
Speaker 1: that opens everything. Dempsey had been repeating a version of
6:54
Speaker 1: that idea steadily enough that Dale felt the need to
6:57
Speaker 1: write it down, not because he agreed with it, because
7:01
Speaker 1: he was trying to decide whether he did. That is
7:04
Speaker 1: not persuasion in the ordinary sense. That is the slow
7:08
Speaker 1: installation of a different story about a person's own life,
7:11
Speaker 1: told back to them in their own voice, until it
7:14
Speaker 1: becomes indistinguishable from a thought they had themselves. Two months
7:18
Speaker 1: after that note was written, on a Thursday in December
7:22
Speaker 1: of twenty seventeen, Dale Zimmerman sat across from a notary
7:26
Speaker 1: named Phil Garrett at a tax preparation office on the
7:29
Speaker 1: east side of Calverton. In a window of ninety minutes,
7:33
Speaker 1: three documents were notarized. A power of attorney in Dempsey's name,
7:38
Speaker 1: an amendment to Dale's will, a health care proxy Phil
7:42
Speaker 1: Garrett would later recall that Dale appeared calm and oriented.
7:46
Speaker 1: He could not confirm whether any one else had been
7:49
Speaker 1: present in the room during the signing three documents nineteen
7:53
Speaker 1: minutes everything Dale owned on paper redirected. The financial evidence
7:58
Speaker 1: confirms the timeline at M withdrawals had begun irregularly in
8:03
Speaker 1: August of two thousand seventeen, between three hundred and eight
8:07
Speaker 1: hundred dollars one to two times per week. Those withdrawals
8:11
Speaker 1: continued over roughly a year and a half through late
8:14
Speaker 1: twenty eighteen, totaling approximately twenty two thousand dollars from an
8:21
Speaker 1: account that had held roughly ninety four thousand dollars at
8:25
Speaker 1: Dale's retirement. Forensic analysis of Dempsey's phone confirmed what the
8:30
Speaker 1: bank records implied. For two years, Dempsey was directing Dale's
8:35
Speaker 1: movements and contacts by text message. What phyllis Odom, the
8:40
Speaker 1: branch manager who handled Dale's account, saw in person, was
8:44
Speaker 1: a man who never showed signs of distress during his visits.
8:48
Speaker 1: What she did not know was that Dempsey drove Dale
8:51
Speaker 1: to those appointments and waited outside in the car. Dale
8:55
Speaker 1: was calm at the bank because he believed he was
8:58
Speaker 1: making his own choices. That belief had been constructed over months,
9:02
Speaker 1: one repeated phrase at a time. The clearest record of
9:05
Speaker 1: what had been done to Dale Zimmerman exists in a
9:08
Speaker 1: single phone call. In September of twenty eighteen. Pam reached
9:13
Speaker 1: her father. It was not a Wednesday, The regular calls
9:17
Speaker 1: had already begun to break down. Dale answered, he spoke.
9:22
Speaker 1: His voice, by Pam's account, was flat in a way
9:26
Speaker 1: she did not recognize. And then he said, I think
9:29
Speaker 1: I've been a burden to people my whole life, and
9:32
Speaker 1: I am grateful that someone finally understands that fifteen years
9:36
Speaker 1: of foster children, twenty seven years of technical draftsmanship, a
9:42
Speaker 1: daughter who had called every Wednesday morning for eleven years
9:45
Speaker 1: without missing once, a paid off house, a life built
9:50
Speaker 1: on showing up. He believed he had been a burden.
9:53
Speaker 1: That sentence did not come from Dale Zimmerman. It came
9:57
Speaker 1: from Vernon Dempsey, spoken so many times over so many
10:01
Speaker 1: months that Dale could no longer locate the scene between
10:04
Speaker 1: someone else's judgment and his own. This is what investigators
10:08
Speaker 1: would later describe as the core mechanism. Not force, not threats,
10:13
Speaker 1: not deception about facts, A rewritten identity. A new story
10:18
Speaker 1: about who Dale was delivered to him privately, consistently, and
10:23
Speaker 1: with apparent warmth. One month after that phone call, in
10:26
Speaker 1: October of twenty eighteen, a text message from Dempsey to
10:31
Speaker 1: Dale was recovered from forensic analysis of Dempsey's phone. It read,
10:35
Speaker 1: She's been filling your head with noise and you don't
10:39
Speaker 1: need that. She pam the Wednesday calls. By November, Dempsey
10:45
Speaker 1: had moved Dale out of Milhaven Road entirely into a
10:49
Speaker 1: residential motel forty minutes north of Calverton. The justification given
10:54
Speaker 1: was home repairs. No repair work was ever contracted. The
10:58
Speaker 1: motel room was paid for with a check from Dale's account.
11:01
Speaker 1: Dempsey did not live there. He visited every few days.
11:05
Speaker 1: Dale was not locked in that room. He was not
11:08
Speaker 1: physically restrained. He was there because, by that point the
11:13
Speaker 1: version of himself that might have questioned the arrangement had
11:17
Speaker 1: been carefully dismantled. He was there because he had been
11:20
Speaker 1: made to believe that the people who loved him were noise,
11:23
Speaker 1: and that the man visiting him every few days was
11:25
Speaker 1: the only one who truly understood. In December of twenty eighteen,
11:30
Speaker 1: the Wednesday calls stopped being answered altogether. Picture the motel room,
11:35
Speaker 1: forty minutes north of Calverton. Dale Zimmermann is sixty two
11:40
Speaker 1: years old, living in a room paid for with his
11:43
Speaker 1: own money, visited every few days by a man who
11:46
Speaker 1: holds his power of attorney, his amended will, and his
11:50
Speaker 1: health care proxy. His driver's license is in a ceramic
11:53
Speaker 1: bowl back at the empty house on Milhaven Road. His
11:57
Speaker 1: ATM cards are in that same bowl. His daughter's calls
12:01
Speaker 1: go unanswered. One version of this story says Dale was
12:05
Speaker 1: deceived about circumstances, that Dempsey fabricated a practical need, manufactured
12:11
Speaker 1: a crisis, move Dale somewhere while he extracted what remained.
12:15
Speaker 1: That version fits some of the facts. The repair story
12:19
Speaker 1: was false, the motel was paid by Dale's funds, The
12:22
Speaker 1: isolation was real. But that version collapses the moment you
12:27
Speaker 1: read the note book. Dale wrote that note in October
12:30
Speaker 1: of twenty seventeen, fourteen months before he was moved to
12:34
Speaker 1: the motel. He wrote it because Dempsey had been saying
12:37
Speaker 1: the same thing, the same thing, repeatedly long enough that
12:41
Speaker 1: Dale needed to examine it on paper. He was not
12:45
Speaker 1: deceived about facts. He was being reshaped at the level
12:48
Speaker 1: of belief, the practical deceptions, the repair story, the documents,
12:53
Speaker 1: the financial withdrawals were not the mechanism. They were the
12:57
Speaker 1: evidence of a mechanism that had already run its course
13:00
Speaker 1: by the time they occurred. Consider the ninety minute documents
13:04
Speaker 1: signing in December of twenty seventeen. Phil Garrett saw a
13:08
Speaker 1: calm man, a man who did not appear coerced. That
13:12
Speaker 1: is the surface detail that initially suggests Dale was in
13:16
Speaker 1: control of his decisions. A listener who fixes on Garrett's
13:20
Speaker 1: account expects one conclusion that Dale signed willingly, that he
13:25
Speaker 1: was competent, that the documents reflect his genuine intentions at
13:29
Speaker 1: that moment. But the note book entry comes two months earlier.
13:33
Speaker 1: Dale was already questioning whether his entire adult life had
13:36
Speaker 1: been a mistake. He was already writing down the stranger's
13:40
Speaker 1: verdict on his own character. By the time he sat
13:43
Speaker 1: across from Phil Garrett, the destination had already been decided.
13:47
Speaker 1: The signing was not the moment Dale lost his autonomy.
13:51
Speaker 1: It was the moment the loss was made legal. Beverly
13:54
Speaker 1: Oakes did not know Dale Zimmerman. She had never heard
13:58
Speaker 1: his name, But twelve years before Diane Campbell walked through
14:03
Speaker 1: the door on Milhaven Road. Beverly was a thirty two
14:07
Speaker 1: year old widow in Harlow City, two hundred miles east,
14:11
Speaker 1: two hundred miles east, who had recently joined a grief
14:15
Speaker 1: support group. A man who called himself Warren Denson had
14:19
Speaker 1: noticed her there. He was attentive, He listened, He asked
14:24
Speaker 1: questions and remembered the answers. He told her over months
14:28
Speaker 1: a particular story about who she was and what she deserved.
14:33
Speaker 1: When her sister sat her down with bank statements eight
14:36
Speaker 1: months later, the total damage was contained, but only because
14:40
Speaker 1: some one on the outside could still reach her. Dale
14:43
Speaker 1: had no one left on the outside Dempsey had seen
14:47
Speaker 1: to that. The strongest evidence against the idea that this
14:51
Speaker 1: was opportunistic, that Dempsey was simply an abuser who found
14:55
Speaker 1: a vulnerable man and improvised is the six weeks of
14:59
Speaker 1: surveillance before the park bench. He had followed, the church page,
15:03
Speaker 1: he had studied, the congregation. He had selected Dale Zimmerman
15:07
Speaker 1: before Dale Zimmerman had any idea he existed. And when
15:11
Speaker 1: he ran the same sequence on Beverly Oaks, he used
15:15
Speaker 1: a different name in a different city. That is not improvisation.
15:19
Speaker 1: That is a method tested, refined, and deployed again. The
15:24
Speaker 1: document that sat on top of that eight inch stack
15:27
Speaker 1: of papers in Diane Campbell's hands was the power of attorney.
15:31
Speaker 1: Everything else, the withdrawals, the motel, the unanswered calls had
15:36
Speaker 1: been built on top of it. But the power of
15:39
Speaker 1: attorney had been built on something older and harder to see.
15:43
Speaker 1: A sixty two year old man writing in the back
15:45
Speaker 1: of a notebook trying to decide whether the best years
15:48
Speaker 1: of his life had meant anything at all. Dempsey had
15:51
Speaker 1: not stolen Dale's money. First. He had stolen Dale's story
15:55
Speaker 1: about himself. The money followed because everything else already had
15:59
Speaker 1: Vernon v and Dempsey was arrested on a Thursday in
16:02
Speaker 1: late February of two thousand nineteen. He denied everything in
16:06
Speaker 1: the preliminary hearing. He denied it through discovery. He denied it.
16:11
Speaker 1: Into the first week of trial, he denied it. He
16:14
Speaker 1: attempted to enter a guilty plea to five counts, four
16:17
Speaker 1: counts of financial exploitation of a vulnerable adult and one
16:21
Speaker 1: count of elder abuse, but the judge rejected the plea
16:25
Speaker 1: at the prosecution's request. The case proceeded to trial. The
16:29
Speaker 1: jury deliberated for less than three hours before returning a
16:33
Speaker 1: verdict of guilty on all five counts. Three weeks after
16:37
Speaker 1: the arrest, a woman named Beverly Oakes called the Adult
16:40
Speaker 1: Protective Services office in Calverton. She was forty four years old.
16:46
Speaker 1: She told the intake worker that she recognized the name
16:49
Speaker 1: Vernon Dempsey from news coverage. She had known him as
16:53
Speaker 1: Warren Denson twelve years earlier in Harlow City, two hundred
16:58
Speaker 1: miles east of Calverton. She had met him in a
17:01
Speaker 1: grief support group. She had been thirty two and recently widowed.
17:06
Speaker 1: The sequence he had run on her was identical proximity attention,
17:11
Speaker 1: the slow reframing of who she was, and then the erosion.
17:15
Speaker 1: Her sister had reached her in time. She had never
17:18
Speaker 1: filed a police report. Beverly brought photographs, a partial phone number,
17:23
Speaker 1: a diary from that period. The state opened the parallel investigation.
17:27
Speaker 1: Whether that investigation produced additional charges is not part of
17:31
Speaker 1: the public record at the time of this reporting. What
17:34
Speaker 1: is part of the record is what Beverly's call confirmed.
17:38
Speaker 1: Dempsey had done this before Dale. He had done it
17:40
Speaker 1: under a different name in a different city. To a
17:43
Speaker 1: different grieving person. The method had been running longer than
17:47
Speaker 1: any one in Calverton knew when Diane Campbell walked through
17:50
Speaker 1: that door with a tray of scalloped potatoes. The records
17:53
Speaker 1: pulled from Dempsey's phone showed two years of text messages
17:57
Speaker 1: directing Dale's movements and isolating his contact. The power of attorney,
18:02
Speaker 1: the will Amendment, the health care proxy, All three notarized
18:06
Speaker 1: in a single ninety minute window in December of twenty seventeen,
18:11
Speaker 1: had transferred legal control of Dale's decisions to Dempsey before
18:15
Speaker 1: most of those text messages were even sent. The legal
18:18
Speaker 1: architecture came first. The isolation was its enforcement mechanism. Dale
18:23
Speaker 1: Zimmermann returned to Milhaven Road in March of twenty nineteen.
18:28
Speaker 1: Paam resumed the Wednesday calls eight in the morning her time,
18:33
Speaker 1: six in the morning hers, the same hour they had
18:36
Speaker 1: kept without interruption for eleven years until December of two
18:40
Speaker 1: thousand eighteen. Alice Bowers, the licensed clinical social worker who
18:45
Speaker 1: had located Dale at the residential motel eleven days after
18:49
Speaker 1: the house was found empty, worked with him for fourteen
18:52
Speaker 1: months in a structured therapeutic capacity. The work of rebuilding
18:57
Speaker 1: a person's story about themselves. Someone has spent two years
19:02
Speaker 1: systematically dismantling it does not move on a court schedule.
19:06
Speaker 1: There is a photograph still on Dale Zimmerman's refrigerator, a
19:10
Speaker 1: summer barbecue twenty twelve, seven of his eleven foster children,
19:15
Speaker 1: all of them smiling. Dale spent fifteen years doing that work,
19:19
Speaker 1: from the time he was forty three until he was
19:22
Speaker 1: fifty eight. Eleven children who moved through his house on
19:25
Speaker 1: Milhaven Road, each of them carrying something difficult, each of
19:29
Speaker 1: them needing someone to stay. That is not the biography
19:33
Speaker 1: of a man who gave too much and got nothing back.
19:36
Speaker 1: That is the line Dempsey planted, and for nearly two years,
19:40
Speaker 1: it was the story Dale lived inside. The mechanism that
19:44
Speaker 1: made it possible was not unusual cunning. It was the
19:47
Speaker 1: exploitation of something ordinary. An older man alone in a
19:52
Speaker 1: house he owned outright, with a modest retirement account, with
19:57
Speaker 1: a modest retirement account and a quiet Wednesday morning phone
20:02
Speaker 1: call he looked forward to all week. Dempsey found that
20:05
Speaker 1: specific shape of solitude and built an entire operation around it.
20:10
Speaker 1: He spent six weeks studying the church page before he
20:13
Speaker 1: sat down on the park bench. He had a name
20:15
Speaker 1: ready for the next city. The Adult Protective Services system
20:19
Speaker 1: in Calverton County did not catch this. A bank manager
20:23
Speaker 1: noticed a pattern and flagged it internally, but never intervened.
20:28
Speaker 1: A notary processed three documents in ninety minutes and remembered
20:32
Speaker 1: Dale as calm and oriented. None of the systems designed
20:35
Speaker 1: to catch exactly this kind of exploitation caught it. Diane
20:39
Speaker 1: Campbell caught it. A volunteer carrying potatoes who found an
20:44
Speaker 1: unlocked door and stood at the threshold and called for help.
20:49
Speaker 1: Dale Zimmerman is sixty two years old. He has a
20:53
Speaker 1: daughter in Tucson who calls every Wednesday. He has a
20:56
Speaker 1: photograph on his refrigerator that shows him what he was
21:00
Speaker 1: for any one told him otherwise, He kept the note book.
21:03
Speaker 1: This show is made by Obo Media