Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How the Pygmalion Effect Shapes Your Office Reputation
Transcript
- Lucas: So Luna, I want to ask you something. Have you ever had a boss who just assumed you'd nail a project before you even started? Luna: Yeah, actually, a few. And you know what, I usually did nail them. But I also had a boss who assumed I'd mess up a client presentation, and somehow I did. Lucas: Exactly. And that's not a coincidence. That's the Pygmalion effect, named after the Greek sculptor who fell in love with a statue he carved. In psychology, it means that higher expectations lead to better performance, and lower expectations lead to worse performance. Luna: So it's a self-fulfilling prophecy, basically. But how does that play out in a modern office? Lucas: Well, there's a classic study from 1968 by Rosenthal and Jacobson. They went into an elementary school and told teachers that certain students were 'late bloomers' who were about to show big intellectual gains. In reality, these kids were chosen at random. But by the end of the year, those randomly labeled kids had actually improved more on IQ tests than their peers. The teachers had unconsciously given them more attention, more encouragement, and more time to answer questions. Luna: So the teachers' belief literally changed the kids' outcomes. And the same thing happens with our bosses and us. Lucas: Right. And it's not just about being liked. It's about access to opportunities. When your boss sees you as a high performer, you get the stretch assignments, the visibility, the benefit of the doubt in tough meetings. When they see you as average, you get the routine work, and your mistakes are noticed more. Luna: I've seen that happen. There was a guy on my team who was labeled 'not a strategic thinker,' so he never got invited to planning sessions. And surprise, he never developed that skill. Lucas: That's the trap. The expectation becomes a ceiling. And the thing is, most bosses don't realize they're doing it. It's often subconscious. They have a quick first impression, maybe based on your background or your first project, and then they look for evidence that confirms it. Luna: So what can we do about it, if we suspect our boss has low expectations of us? Lucas: The first step is to reset the expectation. And there's a specific technique I've seen work. It's a bit like the foot-in-the-door technique we talked about in episode 135, but reversed. Instead of asking for a big commitment, you start with a small, but visible, win that challenges their assumption. Luna: Like what? Can you give me a concrete example? Lucas: Sure. So say your boss thinks you're not great at public speaking. You volunteer to present the team's status update at the weekly sync. It's a low-stakes meeting, but your boss sees you handle it smoothly. Now their expectation shifts a little. Then you ask to present to a client. Step by step, you're changing their internal model of you. Luna: That makes sense. But there's also a risk, right? What if you fail when you try to raise their expectations? Lucas: That's the tricky part. If you take on a stretch assignment and stumble, you might confirm their low expectations. So you need to be strategic. Pick something where you're confident you can deliver, but that's still noticeable. It's like the saying, 'under-promise and over-deliver.' Luna: But what if your boss has unrealistically high expectations of you, the opposite problem? That can be just as stressful. Lucas: Yeah, that's the other side of the coin. The Pygmalion effect can also create a lot of pressure. You're the 'golden child,' and you're terrified of slipping. And if you slip, the fall can be harder. Luna: I remember being that golden child once. I got promoted fast, and then I made one mistake, and suddenly my boss started micromanaging me. It was like the halo effect vanished overnight. Lucas: Exactly. So the goal isn't just to raise expectations, it's to manage them. You want your boss to have realistic but positive expectations, built on evidence, not on a first impression. Luna: And how do you do that in a way that doesn't feel manipulative? Lucas: That's a great question, and I think it comes down to intent. You're not trying to fool them, you're trying to show your true capabilities. And you're also giving them a more accurate picture of what you can do. That's not manipulation, that's good communication. Luna: But there's a line, right? If you're just telling your boss what they want to hear, that's different. Lucas: Right. And that's the ethical boundary. The Pygmalion effect is about genuinely improving your performance to meet higher expectations, not about spinning a false image. If you're just presenting a polished version of yourself without substance, that's building a reputation on sand. Luna: So we should be honest with ourselves, too. Are we actually capable of meeting those higher expectations, or are we just hoping to fake it? Lucas: And that's where the Pygmalion effect becomes a tool for growth. If your boss expects great things, you might actually become great. But you have to do the work. It's a push, not a magic wand. Luna: I love that. And before we go further, I have to say, if this episode has been helpful, if it's made you think about your own office dynamics, you can help us keep making it ad-free. Lucas? Lucas: Yeah, we're listener-funded, and every little bit helps. If today was worth a coffee to you, that's the link — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: Even five dollars keeps the lights on. But no pressure, honestly. Lucas: Alright, back to it. So we've talked about how to manage your boss's expectations. But there's another angle: what about the expectations you have of yourself? The Pygmalion effect can work internally, too. Luna: Oh, that's interesting. So if I believe I'm going to do well, I'm more likely to do well? Lucas: There's actually research on that, too. In a study on employee self-expectations, when people were told they were likely to succeed on a task, they performed better than those who were told they'd struggle. And that's even when the task was the same. So it's not just about others' beliefs; your own beliefs matter just as much. Luna: But is that just positive thinking? I feel like there's a line between that and delusion. Lucas: It's not just about thinking happy thoughts. It's about setting a concrete, challenging goal and then building a plan to get there. When you believe you can do it, you're more likely to put in the effort and seek out resources. That's the mechanism. Luna: So it's a self-fulfilling prophecy, but you're the prophet. Lucas: Exactly. And that's something you can use even if your boss is not on board. You can set high expectations for yourself, then deliver on them, and eventually, your boss's expectations will catch up. Luna: But what about the reverse? If you think you're going to fail, you probably will. Is that like the Golem effect? Lucas: You've done your homework. The Golem effect is the negative version of Pygmalion. Low expectations lead to low performance. And it's just as powerful. That's why it's so important to be aware of the expectations you hold, both about yourself and about your colleagues. Luna: And what about teams? If a manager has high expectations for the whole team, does that lift everyone? Lucas: There's a concept called collective efficacy, which is a group's shared belief in its ability to succeed. And research shows that teams with high collective efficacy perform better. So a strong leader can create a high-expectation culture that lifts everyone's game. Luna: So it's not just about how you treat individuals, it's about the vibe you set for the whole room. Lucas: Right. And if you're in a leadership position yourself, even a team lead, you can use the Pygmalion effect intentionally. Give your people challenging but achievable goals, and express your confidence in them. That's not manipulation, that's good management. Luna: But what if you're dealing with a boss who has a fixed mindset about you? They think you're just a 'numbers person' and you'll never be creative. Can you really change that? Lucas: It's harder, but not impossible. The key is to gather evidence that contradicts their belief, and to do it in a way that's not confrontational. You might take on a project that requires creativity and make it visible. Over time, your actions can outweigh their initial impression. Luna: So it's a long game. You're not going to flip their belief overnight. Lucas: No, and patience is key. But also, know when to cut your losses. If your boss is truly rigid and never updates their view, that might be a sign to look for a different sponsor within the company, or even a different company altogether. Luna: That's a good point. It's not always your responsibility to change them. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the thing about the Pygmalion effect: it's powerful, but it's not deterministic. You have agency. You can shape it, but you can't fully control it. So use it where you can, and know when to walk away. Luna: So today's takeaway: be aware of the expectations you hold and the ones others hold of you, and actively work to align them with your goals. Lucas: And next time you're in a meeting, notice who's getting the benefit of the doubt. Could be you, if you've been managing your reputation well.