Latest / Bloomberg Law / SCOTUS Skeptical of Another Public Corruption Law
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 1: A jury of seven men and five women has been
- 0:13Speaker 1: sworn in to hear Donald Trump's hush money case. One
- 0:17Speaker 1: alternate juror has also been selected. That means five more
- 0:21Speaker 1: alternates have to be selected to round out the panel
- 0:24Speaker 1: that will decide the first ever criminal case against a
- 0:27Speaker 1: former US president. Jury selection got off to a slow
- 0:31Speaker 1: start this morning after two previously sworn in jurors were dismissed,
- 0:37Speaker 1: one because she expressed doubts about her ability to be
- 0:40Speaker 1: fair and impartial after some of her personal information had
- 0:43Speaker 1: been made public, the second because prosecutors told the judge
- 0:48Speaker 1: they had information that the man was arrested in the
- 0:51Speaker 1: nineteen nineties for tearing down conservative political advertisements. Judge One
- 0:56Speaker 1: Mreshan says he's hopeful the jury selection process will be
- 1:00Speaker 1: wrapped up tomorrow and opening statements can take place on Monday.
- 1:05Speaker 1: Turning down to legal news on the Supreme Court, the
- 1:08Speaker 1: facts are undisputed. James Snyder, the former mayor of a
- 1:12Speaker 1: Northwest Indiana town, received thirteen thousand dollars from a trucking
- 1:17Speaker 1: company one month after was awarded city contracts worth more
- 1:21Speaker 1: than one point one million dollars in a bidding process
- 1:25Speaker 1: he oversaw. Snyder was convicted by a jury of bribery,
- 1:29Speaker 1: and then convicted by a second jury in a retrial.
- 1:33Speaker 1: But the Supreme Court, which has been having its own
- 1:35Speaker 1: problems of late with unreported gifts to justices, seem to
- 1:40Speaker 1: think that thirteen thousand dollars was like taking a teacher
- 1:44Speaker 1: to the cheesecake factory as a thank you or buying
- 1:47Speaker 1: a gift card to Starbucks. Here's Justice Neil gorsicch.
- 1:52Speaker 2: It can mean something more than that. It can mean
- 1:53Speaker 2: a venal sin, It can mean a mortal sin. How
- 1:57Speaker 2: does somebody who accepts the cheesecake factory no a trip
- 2:01Speaker 2: to the cheesecake factory for nice treatment at the hospital,
- 2:05Speaker 2: for treating my child well in school, for an arrest made?
- 2:11Speaker 2: How does that person know whether that falls on the
- 2:13Speaker 2: what you call the wrongfulness side of the equation or not.
- 2:18Speaker 1: For the Justices, the question was whether the bribery law
- 2:21Speaker 1: covers gratuities paid after the fact or only covers bribes
- 2:26Speaker 1: before the fact, meaning a tit for town agreement. Joining
- 2:30Speaker 1: me to answer this question and others is business law
- 2:33Speaker 1: professor Eric Tally of Columbia Law School Law School Eric.
- 2:38Speaker 1: This case centers on the scope of eighteen USC. Six
- 2:43Speaker 1: sixty six, a federal bribery law which has been in
- 2:47Speaker 1: effect for a long time.
- 2:49Speaker 3: Oh yeah, this antibribery law has been around for a
- 2:52Speaker 3: long time. There have been very many prosecutions under it
- 2:56Speaker 3: and prior situations involving this that this has not been
- 3:00Speaker 3: an issue. So it's no or at least it hasn't been
- 3:03Speaker 3: thought to be at issue by the judges that are
- 3:05Speaker 3: hearing these cases. So this is in some ways kind
- 3:06Speaker 3: of a novel legal argument applied to a pretty old statue.
- 3:10Speaker 1: The law makes it a crime for certain state or
- 3:13Speaker 1: local officials to corruptly accept anything of value over five
- 3:18Speaker 1: thousand dollars. The word corruptly seemed to be a problem
- 3:22Speaker 1: for the justices.
- 3:24Speaker 3: Yes, and the key issue on the question of corruptly
- 3:28Speaker 3: seems to be, at least in part, circulating around a
- 3:31Speaker 3: question of timing, and a lot of the Q and
- 3:35Speaker 3: A during the oral argument was all about, you know,
- 3:40Speaker 3: the timing of a payment that, let's just say, for
- 3:43Speaker 3: argument's sake, exceeds five thousand dollars. But the hypotheticals that
- 3:48Speaker 3: were being bandied about involved situations like taking someone out
- 3:52Speaker 3: to dinner at the cheesecake factory. I don't know if
- 3:55Speaker 3: you've been to the cheesecake factory lately, but lately I've
- 3:58Speaker 3: never run up anything like a five one hundred dollars
- 4:00Speaker 3: bill of the cheesecake factory. So it wouldn't actually hit
- 4:03Speaker 3: that status tarror threshold.
- 4:05Speaker 1: Well, Kavanaugh said, you don't know if the concert tickets,
- 4:08Speaker 1: the game tickets, the gift card to Starbucks, whatever, where
- 4:12Speaker 1: is the line? So there's that vagueness. I mean, are
- 4:15Speaker 1: they really talking about a more than five thousand dollars
- 4:19Speaker 1: gift card to Starbucks?
- 4:21Speaker 3: Super odd? I mean, just so of my or brought
- 4:23Speaker 3: this up, but it ended up sort of, this question
- 4:25Speaker 3: of corruptly ended up floating around in its own mist right,
- 4:29Speaker 3: independent of the dollar amount. Look, a lot of times
- 4:32Speaker 3: in these situations there will be either inside the statute
- 4:37Speaker 3: or kind of a reasonable construction of statute, a judge
- 4:40Speaker 3: will come in and say, listen, we're going to impose
- 4:43Speaker 3: a you know, it's sometimes called a materiality threshold or
- 4:46Speaker 3: a materiality test on some sort of suspect payment. And
- 4:50Speaker 3: the definition of materiality is itself. It's a little foggy.
- 4:54Speaker 3: It usually circulates around and you know what a reasonable
- 4:56Speaker 3: person think, this is a big payment that would change
- 4:59Speaker 3: someone's judgment. But that has worked all over the place
- 5:01Speaker 3: and all types of financial crimes and financial civil actions.
- 5:04Speaker 3: Materiality is a very very common workhorse. That was oddly,
- 5:09Speaker 3: it wasn't quite absent, but it seemed to be suppressed
- 5:12Speaker 3: pretty far down the list in the oral argument.
- 5:15Speaker 1: Was there a division between the liberal and the conservatives, because,
- 5:20Speaker 1: I know, Brett Kavanaugh at one point said that he
- 5:23Speaker 1: was concerned about ensnaring the nineteen million state and local
- 5:26Speaker 1: officials who are subject to the law, and then Alena
- 5:28Speaker 1: Kagan chimed in that includes employees of public hospitals and universities.
- 5:34Speaker 1: Was there a split ideological Well.
- 5:37Speaker 3: Yeah, maybe, or maybe not. Like usually you would think
- 5:39Speaker 3: that Kagan is, you know, sort of coming down on
- 5:42Speaker 3: plausibly different sides than Kavani is, though they're both a
- 5:45Speaker 3: little bit more centrist in the approach that they have.
- 5:49Speaker 3: You know, Atlanta Kagan put a hypothetical forward about providing
- 5:52Speaker 3: some life saving you know, a university hospital deciding to
- 5:55Speaker 3: provide some life saving operation or service to a billionaire
- 5:58Speaker 3: in the hopes that they would later get a big
- 6:01Speaker 3: charitable donation to the university. Wouldn't that be a problem.
- 6:04Speaker 3: So that much of the oral argument seems to devolve
- 6:07Speaker 3: into like kind of a non stop set of hypotheticals,
- 6:12Speaker 3: each somewhat more extraordinary than the others. And you know,
- 6:16Speaker 3: that kind of is where the two lawyers had to go. Now,
- 6:19Speaker 3: I think the lawyer for mister Snyder was quite happy
- 6:21Speaker 3: to go there, because the entire theory on the case
- 6:24Speaker 3: is it's just impossible to draw lines in this type
- 6:27Speaker 3: of a situation. And the government's attorneys pretty much had
- 6:30Speaker 3: to say, now, line drawing is hard, but it's always hard,
- 6:33Speaker 3: and the government's going to only, you know, bring these
- 6:35Speaker 3: cases when it feels like it's a good case that's
- 6:38Speaker 3: consistent with you know, public policy associated with the anti
- 6:41Speaker 3: bribery Statute. But that itself, you know, at least to
- 6:44Speaker 3: some judges and maybe to some observers, is a type
- 6:47Speaker 3: of assurance that's really hard to check later on. And
- 6:50Speaker 3: so you know, I think, you know, the court is
- 6:51Speaker 3: probably going to have to be forced into some sort
- 6:54Speaker 3: of a line drawing exercise here. The big issue that
- 6:57Speaker 3: was brought up in the case was in this particular scenario,
- 7:01Speaker 3: and even Kavanaugh said the facts were really good for
- 7:04Speaker 3: the government prosecutors. In this case, a mister Snyder had
- 7:08Speaker 3: had allegedly sort of rigged a contract bidding process when
- 7:12Speaker 3: he was mayor of Portage, Indiana, and the company that
- 7:15Speaker 3: won that bidding process he had been in consistent contact with,
- 7:19Speaker 3: and then pretty shortly after the contract was awarded to them,
- 7:23Speaker 3: they handed over a thirteen thousand dollars check, ostensibly for
- 7:27Speaker 3: consulting services to be provided in the future. And so
- 7:30Speaker 3: the line drawing exercise between his administration of the bidding
- 7:34Speaker 3: process and the thirteen thousand dollars check seems pretty direct.
- 7:37Speaker 3: But the point that his attorneys were making, they were
- 7:40Speaker 3: making quite vehemently at the court, is that, well, no,
- 7:43Speaker 3: this would have to be payments that are made before
- 7:47Speaker 3: the favor is granted and not after. And this came afterwards.
- 7:50Speaker 3: And there are too many hypothetical situations that would lead
- 7:53Speaker 3: us on lawyers like to talk about slippery slopes to hell,
- 7:57Speaker 3: and this was one, and that's what caused us to
- 7:59Speaker 3: go into the dinner out of gratitude for your high
- 8:01Speaker 3: school English teacher at the cheesecake factories. And is that
- 8:04Speaker 3: a bribe.
- 8:05Speaker 1: So the government's attorney suggested that the government typically wouldn't
- 8:09Speaker 1: prosecute fringe cases, but Chief Justice Roberts noted that in
- 8:14Speaker 1: recent cases, the Court has been skeptical of prosecutors trust
- 8:17Speaker 1: us arguments. We've had several cases where we've made the
- 8:21Speaker 1: very clear point that we don't rely on the good
- 8:23Speaker 1: faith of the prosecutors in deciding cases like this, And
- 8:27Speaker 1: that sort of came up in the argument for the
- 8:30Speaker 1: January sixth obstruction charge, where the Solicitor General was arguing
- 8:35Speaker 1: about how prosecutors would charge under that statute and they
- 8:39Speaker 1: would require all these different elements. What are the justices
- 8:43Speaker 1: afraid of here?
- 8:45Speaker 3: Well, I think there is a justified caution or skepticism
- 8:49Speaker 3: about statutory authorizations that give prosecutors too much of a
- 8:55Speaker 3: blank check and what they're going to go forward on
- 8:58Speaker 3: and charge people with. If the check is too much
- 9:01Speaker 3: of a blank check, then it's not inconceivable that political
- 9:05Speaker 3: calculations may end up either entering or being perceived to
- 9:09Speaker 3: have entered into a prosecutor's decision about whom to go
- 9:13Speaker 3: after and whom to leave alone. And so I think
- 9:15Speaker 3: that that's part of what the Court has been trying
- 9:18Speaker 3: to grapple with and you know, in fairness, there have
- 9:20Speaker 3: been several high profile cases involving various types of applications
- 9:26Speaker 3: of this and other anti bribery or anti corruption statutes
- 9:29Speaker 3: in which politics is pretty hard to ignore. There was
- 9:32Speaker 3: a twenty twenty case that involved the infamous Bridgegate scenario
- 9:37Speaker 3: in which Chris Christy was alleged to have had his
- 9:41Speaker 3: subordinates closed down the GW Bridge in order to punish
- 9:44Speaker 3: his political foes. And then the prosecution was brought at
- 9:48Speaker 3: least allegedly for political reasons, sort of anti Chris Christy,
- 9:52Speaker 3: anti Republican reasons, and the Supreme Court ended up actually
- 9:55Speaker 3: reversing that conviction, but on kind of weird technical grounds
- 9:58Speaker 3: about what was motivating the these operatives. So they sort
- 10:01Speaker 3: of found kind of maybe even unrelated fault reasons to
- 10:05Speaker 3: reverse in some of these cases. And you know that
- 10:07Speaker 3: maybe what is being put forward here this kind of
- 10:10Speaker 3: idea that well, if the payment happens after the political
- 10:14Speaker 3: favor is given, then that can't possibly be corruption. That's
- 10:16Speaker 3: a nice bright line rule, you know, as the government
- 10:19Speaker 3: lawyers were bringing up, probably correctly, is that if if
- 10:22Speaker 3: you established that as a bright line rule that will
- 10:25Speaker 3: be kind of a gold embossed invitation for how you
- 10:28Speaker 3: should structure corruption payments in the future. Right that, you know,
- 10:32Speaker 3: you always have the political actor go first, wait some
- 10:35Speaker 3: you know, requisite short amount of time, and then the
- 10:37Speaker 3: payment comes second. And you know, in some ways, the
- 10:40Speaker 3: ease with which one could engineer around that type of
- 10:43Speaker 3: a definition, I think it's going to make it difficult
- 10:46Speaker 3: for a majority of the judges to ignore that as
- 10:49Speaker 3: a kind of an obvious sort of response from the
- 10:52Speaker 3: other side.
- 10:53Speaker 1: The Supreme Court over the years has made it harder
- 10:56Speaker 1: and harder to prosecute politicians and other public officials for corruption,
- 11:02Speaker 1: starting in twenty sixteen.
- 11:04Speaker 3: Right, Yeah, the skepticism goes at least back to a
- 11:08Speaker 3: twenty sixteen case, and there have been several others, both
- 11:11Speaker 3: at the federal level and the state level, and so
- 11:15Speaker 3: there is on some level a little bit of a
- 11:19Speaker 3: I guess it's sort of a trend here where the
- 11:21Speaker 3: judges have become, i don't know, increasingly worried about the
- 11:25Speaker 3: possibility that these antibribery or anti corruption statutes are being
- 11:30Speaker 3: used for political reasons, and therefore, you know, they're trying
- 11:33Speaker 3: to carve back on them you know, I guess another
- 11:36Speaker 3: factor of this is sort of almost a meta factor June,
- 11:40Speaker 3: which is that one of the bodies of the federal
- 11:43Speaker 3: government that has come under immense scrutiny recently is the
- 11:46Speaker 3: Supreme Court itself for whether there are you know, friends
- 11:50Speaker 3: of justices of the Supreme Court who bestow all kinds
- 11:54Speaker 3: of valuable gifts on them out of friendship or for
- 11:57Speaker 3: people they care about, and whether that itself is something
- 12:01Speaker 3: that should trigger at least suspicion, if not considerable hand
- 12:05Speaker 3: ringing amongst people who are trying to regularly court. There's
- 12:08Speaker 3: big separation of powers issues, and the Supreme Court itself
- 12:11Speaker 3: basically decided to promulgate its own ethics guideline. But a
- 12:14Speaker 3: lot of people think it's somewhat toothless. It is not
- 12:17Speaker 3: a subtle fact that Justice Thomas, who's been one of
- 12:20Speaker 3: the people who's been at the center of this Maelstrom,
- 12:23Speaker 3: decided not to even participate in the oral argument, but
- 12:26Speaker 3: he is going to participate in the judgment through briefs
- 12:28Speaker 3: and through reading the transcript. That was sort of an
- 12:31Speaker 3: odd decision that didn't really have much of an explanation. So,
- 12:34Speaker 3: you know, I think all aspects of this are in
- 12:37Speaker 3: some ways delicate, and I think the fact that the
- 12:40Speaker 3: Supreme Court itself has gotten dragged a little bit into
- 12:43Speaker 3: its own kerfuffles around when are expressions of gratitude that
- 12:49Speaker 3: may have significant monetary value, when of the appropriate and
- 12:52Speaker 3: when do they trigger considerations and concerns about corruption and bribery?
- 12:57Speaker 1: Coming up next on the Bloomberg Law Show, I'll continue
- 12:59Speaker 1: this conference as with Professor Eric Tally of Columbia Law School.
- 13:03Speaker 1: How might the Justice's rule in this case? And Tesla's
- 13:06Speaker 1: shareholders will be voting on that Elon Musk pay package
- 13:11Speaker 1: that was thrown out by a Delaware court. This is Bloomberg.
- 13:18Speaker 1: The Supreme Court seemed skeptical of another public corruption law.
- 13:22Speaker 1: The Justice has appeared likely to side with a former
- 13:25Speaker 1: Indiana mayor convicted of receiving a thirteen thousand dollars bribe
- 13:30Speaker 1: from a trucking company after it was awarded city contracts.
- 13:34Speaker 1: I've been talking to Professor Eric Tally of Columbia Law School,
- 13:38Speaker 1: and Eric, these public corruption cases are hard to prosecute,
- 13:41Speaker 1: aren't they. You know, public officials and these kind of bribes,
- 13:45Speaker 1: they don't leave notes or emails saying thanks so much
- 13:48Speaker 1: for that. I was happy to.
- 13:50Speaker 3: Help you out. Yet typically they don't. There have been
- 13:54Speaker 3: some cases in which, you know that have larga been
- 13:56Speaker 3: overturned that sort of said, well, you have to have
- 13:58Speaker 3: a written contract on bribery. I think everyone realizes that
- 14:01Speaker 3: that's an easy one to engineer your way around. So
- 14:03Speaker 3: you have to demonstrate either a conversation or a set
- 14:07Speaker 3: of conversations that establishes this understanding, or a set of
- 14:11Speaker 3: patterns and practices of behavior whose only reasonable construction or
- 14:17Speaker 3: interpretation would be Yeah, these folks are acting as though
- 14:20Speaker 3: they are in a quid pro quo that they are
- 14:23Speaker 3: recognizing through either their communicative acts or hard to misinterpret actions,
- 14:28Speaker 3: and that makes it tough. Right, everyone is on notice
- 14:31Speaker 3: that this is an issue in involving any public official.
- 14:35Speaker 2: You know.
- 14:35Speaker 3: The possible irony about this case is if the court
- 14:37Speaker 3: decides to go with this timing argument. I think it's unlikely,
- 14:41Speaker 3: but they might. Then in fact, it sort of sets
- 14:44Speaker 3: up a formula in which the payment just gets made
- 14:47Speaker 3: after the fact, and it's possible that people will just
- 14:49Speaker 3: be much more upfront about it now that they know
- 14:51Speaker 3: they've got a safe harbor, because they're not gonna We're
- 14:53Speaker 3: gonna wait, you know, we're gonna set the alarm clock
- 14:56Speaker 3: after the political favor and just wait for the payment
- 14:58Speaker 3: until it's seemed to sit with it the Supreme Court process.
- 15:00Speaker 3: That's one of the reasons why I doubt they're going
- 15:03Speaker 3: to go in that direction. It's it's not rocket science
- 15:05Speaker 3: to predict that that would be a response to this
- 15:07Speaker 3: kind of bright line rule that mister Snyder's lawyers were
- 15:11Speaker 3: asking for.
- 15:12Speaker 1: What other way could they go considering their concerns about
- 15:15Speaker 1: the Starbucks cards.
- 15:17Speaker 3: Yeah, I think that most of the absurd situations involved
- 15:21Speaker 3: little perks that are kind of pocket change type perks,
- 15:25Speaker 3: and that once things got large, including the five thousand
- 15:28Speaker 3: dollars trigger in this situation, then that would be large
- 15:33Speaker 3: enough to trigger not only the explicit trigger, but also
- 15:37Speaker 3: a judicial interpretation that yes, this is large enough that
- 15:41Speaker 3: it could affect someone's judgment. And that's one of the
- 15:43Speaker 3: reasons why I feel like the Court may well end
- 15:46Speaker 3: up borrowing from a half dozen, if not more than
- 15:50Speaker 3: a dozen other areas of you know, financial fraud and
- 15:54Speaker 3: white collar crime that all sort of turns on materiality. So,
- 15:59Speaker 3: for instance, if I decide I'm going to trade on
- 16:01Speaker 3: inside information because I've gotten some kind of an insider
- 16:05Speaker 3: tip that I'm not really authorized to trade on, but
- 16:07Speaker 3: I trade one share and I make a buck seventy five,
- 16:10Speaker 3: that may not be prosecuted. Or if the nature of
- 16:14Speaker 3: the information I've gotten is just not probabilistically as helpful
- 16:18Speaker 3: as it might otherwise, be sure, it's inside information, but
- 16:21Speaker 3: it's not material enough to matter, And that may end
- 16:25Speaker 3: up being a helpful lever for the Supreme Court when
- 16:28Speaker 3: they try to decide this case. If they don't go
- 16:30Speaker 3: with the timing part, they're going to have to have
- 16:32Speaker 3: some sort of a cutoff, and a materiality cutoff is
- 16:35Speaker 3: not a crazy place to put it. That's why you
- 16:36Speaker 3: see it so many other areas of law.
- 16:39Speaker 1: Speaking of a buck seventy five, what's happening with Elon
- 16:43Speaker 1: Musk and his Tesla pay package that was fifty six
- 16:48Speaker 1: billion dollars.
- 16:49Speaker 3: Well, our friend mister Musk is definitely added again. It's
- 16:53Speaker 3: not surprising that he has, you know, you know, basically
- 16:57Speaker 3: been planning a formal response to his you know, pretty
- 17:02Speaker 3: significant loss in the Delaware Chancery Court in January of
- 17:06Speaker 3: twenty twenty four invalidating his at the time, fifty five
- 17:10Speaker 3: fifty six billion dollar compensation contract. I think a lot
- 17:15Speaker 3: of people were sort of betting on one of two
- 17:17Speaker 3: things to happen. One possibility is that he would, you know,
- 17:20Speaker 3: wait for a final judgment and appeal, and there's every
- 17:23Speaker 3: indication that he intends to do that. But another possibility
- 17:27Speaker 3: is that, you know, having had his compensation contract thrown
- 17:32Speaker 3: out by the judge because of a defective process by
- 17:37Speaker 3: which it was approved both the board level and the shareholders,
- 17:40Speaker 3: they've decided in a public filing they made the other
- 17:43Speaker 3: day to go out to the shareholders and ask them
- 17:46Speaker 3: to quote ratify unquote his twenty eighteen package. And they've
- 17:52Speaker 3: done so in kind of a clever way, but it
- 17:55Speaker 3: effectively is trying to fix one of the infirmities in
- 17:59Speaker 3: the in the that the package got approved. They're not
- 18:03Speaker 3: really redoing anything at the board level, but they are
- 18:05Speaker 3: going out to get a shareholder approval this time with
- 18:09Speaker 3: full information because we've got a case out there and
- 18:11Speaker 3: there's a long, copious disclosure about what the judge found
- 18:15Speaker 3: in that case. And I think that they are hoping
- 18:17Speaker 3: that if they got a vote from their stockholders, they
- 18:21Speaker 3: could either go back and try to use that on
- 18:24Speaker 3: appeal or possibly say well, listen, we're just going to
- 18:28Speaker 3: award once again a big options award to mister Musk
- 18:32Speaker 3: because it's been authorized by the stockholders with their eyes
- 18:36Speaker 3: wide open. And so that is going out to the
- 18:40Speaker 3: to the stockholders of Tesla at the next annual meeting.
- 18:44Speaker 3: And they decided to include another thing, which is almost
- 18:48Speaker 3: a direct channel from one of Elon Musk's tweets after
- 18:53Speaker 3: the opinion saying, you know, we're going to reincorporate out
- 18:57Speaker 3: of Delaware and into Texas. Sure enough, that's another proposal
- 19:00Speaker 3: is being put in front of the shareholders to reincorporate
- 19:03Speaker 3: away from Delaware and into Texas with the thought, at
- 19:09Speaker 3: least this is what's in the proxy materials, is that
- 19:12Speaker 3: Texas is going to be a more friendly place and
- 19:14Speaker 3: more predictable place to know what's going on in terms
- 19:18Speaker 3: of corporate law and fiduciary duty lawsuits. Now, I will
- 19:22Speaker 3: tell you June that you know this, this kind of
- 19:25Speaker 3: you know, possibility has been floating around for months. A
- 19:28Speaker 3: lot of the you know, corporate law junkies that I
- 19:31Speaker 3: run around with have been, you know, I've been sort
- 19:33Speaker 3: of talking about this and these are folks that you know,
- 19:35Speaker 3: they've been teaching corporate law for decades, and one of
- 19:38Speaker 3: the things I always like to ask them is, quick,
- 19:40Speaker 3: name your five favorite Texas corporate law cases. And usually
- 19:45Speaker 3: people can get two, maybe three into that list, and
- 19:48Speaker 3: then they run out of it. The fact of the
- 19:50Speaker 3: matter is Texas really doesn't have that much of an
- 19:53Speaker 3: of a developed set of corporate law precedents, and the
- 19:57Speaker 3: ones that they do have often a seek guy from
- 20:00Speaker 3: guessware from Delaware. So it's kind of an odd situation
- 20:05Speaker 3: to make that statement to stockholders. Weirdly enough, there have
- 20:10Speaker 3: been a whole spate of cases in Delaware that in
- 20:15Speaker 3: which the judges seem to have been receptive to them,
- 20:18Speaker 3: in which a shareholder says the very act of putting
- 20:22Speaker 3: to the shareholders a vote to reincorporate itself can be
- 20:26Speaker 3: a conflicted at a financially conflicted transaction, and therefore should
- 20:31Speaker 3: be analyzed under exactly the same test that got used
- 20:35Speaker 3: to analyze Elon Musk's compensation contract. So there's a kind
- 20:40Speaker 3: of an interesting meta story here, which is that both
- 20:43Speaker 3: of these stockholder votes themselves might be thought of as
- 20:47Speaker 3: independent new actions that each of each of which could
- 20:50Speaker 3: be potentially challenged by stockholder litigation, and I have every
- 20:54Speaker 3: reason to think at some point they will.
- 20:57Speaker 1: And this is pretty aggressive and nervy even for him,
- 21:01Speaker 1: since he's laid off ten percent of Tesla's workforce.
- 21:05Speaker 3: Yeah, I mean, this is not the greatest time to
- 21:07Speaker 3: be sort of selling the narrative that Tesla can do
- 21:11Speaker 3: no wrong so long as Elon is at the helm, right,
- 21:13Speaker 3: that was a pretty saleable story two or three years ago.
- 21:16Speaker 3: And I think there were a lot more of the
- 21:18Speaker 3: I don't know what to call them, the Elon stands
- 21:20Speaker 3: that were basically going to, you know, back him under
- 21:24Speaker 3: any circumstances. There are still many of those out there,
- 21:27Speaker 3: and many of them hold Tesla shares. But I think
- 21:30Speaker 3: a lot of folks are looking at their portfolio and say, well,
- 21:32Speaker 3: I went and really overweight in Tesla because I believed
- 21:35Speaker 3: in Elon Musk and I guess I still do. But
- 21:38Speaker 3: these these shares are not doing as well. And maybe
- 21:41Speaker 3: I can tell myself a story that the whole reason
- 21:42Speaker 3: they're not doing well is because, you know, Delaware is
- 21:45Speaker 3: treating mister Musk, you know, poorly. But the fact of
- 21:49Speaker 3: the matter is, if you're paying attention to the electronic
- 21:52Speaker 3: vehicle segment. You will realize that this is you know,
- 21:54Speaker 3: this is definitely at least a correction within that segment.
- 21:58Speaker 3: The you know, sales across the board have cooled, It's
- 22:01Speaker 3: not just Tesla or sales cooled. And as a result,
- 22:05Speaker 3: you know that you just can't expect this type of
- 22:08Speaker 3: high velocity growth trajectory going forward, even under Elon Musk.
- 22:12Speaker 3: I think some people might might come to the really
- 22:15Speaker 3: realization of and then at that point, if that's where
- 22:18Speaker 3: you get in terms of thinking through this, well, then
- 22:21Speaker 3: we've got a CEO who's you know, basically trying to
- 22:24Speaker 3: claim a big chunk of stock of the company by
- 22:27Speaker 3: basically resurrecting an options award that's been nullified, and wants
- 22:33Speaker 3: to move the entire company to Texas, where we don't
- 22:37Speaker 3: really even know what's going to be going on. If
- 22:40Speaker 3: you know, if if mister Musk, you know, decides to
- 22:43Speaker 3: start using Tesla as more of a personal piggybag, so
- 22:47Speaker 3: I could I could see some stockholders deciding that they've
- 22:50Speaker 3: lost at least a little bit of faith in the
- 22:53Speaker 3: Church of Elon Musk and and you know, deciding that
- 22:56Speaker 3: they might want to at least play the field a
- 22:59Speaker 3: little bit try to figure out, you know, whether they
- 23:01Speaker 3: want to support one or both or neither of these
- 23:05Speaker 3: proposals that is going to be going before stockholders. One
- 23:08Speaker 3: of the things that's interesting about this June is that
- 23:10Speaker 3: a lot of times, you know, the stocks of companies
- 23:14Speaker 3: are sometimes owned by big institutional investors and hedge funds,
- 23:17Speaker 3: but then there are a lot of retail investors that
- 23:20Speaker 3: you know, just own own stock because they're infatuated with
- 23:23Speaker 3: the company, or it's part of some you know, other
- 23:25Speaker 3: sort of you know, highly highly tailored investment plan. Test
- 23:30Speaker 3: had a lot of retail investors that people that just
- 23:33Speaker 3: just individual rando people who just own the stock, and
- 23:37Speaker 3: those are some of the hardest people to predict in
- 23:39Speaker 3: terms of what their proclivities are going to do. So
- 23:42Speaker 3: so you know that I can imagine that there may
- 23:45Speaker 3: well be an activist who comes out and says, we
- 23:48Speaker 3: got to vote against these things. I'm gonna you know,
- 23:51Speaker 3: I'm going to wage a contest against mister Musk. If
- 23:54Speaker 3: that happens, it actually then then you know, if this
- 23:57Speaker 3: becomes a contested vote, then it's not as easy for
- 24:01Speaker 3: Musk and Tesla to collect votes from all these retail stockholders.
- 24:06Speaker 3: You can't do it with an automated approach anymore. That
- 24:10Speaker 3: you really kind of have to go through the formal
- 24:12Speaker 3: rules of engagement. So I think it might be it'll
- 24:15Speaker 3: be really interesting to see if there is a stockholder
- 24:17Speaker 3: out there who is willing to come forward and say, yeah,
- 24:20Speaker 3: I don't think this is good, and I'm going to
- 24:22Speaker 3: actually run a you know, a contested vote process to
- 24:29Speaker 3: basically get this thing defeated or at least one of
- 24:32Speaker 3: these two proposals defeated. You know, still early days and
- 24:35Speaker 3: there's still some time to do that, but that could
- 24:40Speaker 3: turn out to be a sort of an interesting.
- 24:42Speaker 1: Moment out of many interesting moments. Thanks so much, Eric.
- 24:46Speaker 1: That's Professor Eric Talley of Columbia Law School. Four years ago,
- 24:50Speaker 1: only the state of Arkansas had a ban on providing
- 24:53Speaker 1: gender transition care for minors. Today, nearly half the states
- 24:58Speaker 1: haven't acted such ban, and the Supreme Court has stepped
- 25:02Speaker 1: into the culture war battle over transgender rights by allowing
- 25:06Speaker 1: Idaho to enforce its ban on providing gender affirming care
- 25:10Speaker 1: for minors while litigation plays out. It was a six
- 25:14Speaker 1: to three vote, with the conservative justices in the majority.
- 25:18Speaker 1: And the liberal justices in the minority. Joining me is
- 25:21Speaker 1: healthcare attorney Harry Nelson of Nelson Hardiman Harry. Four years ago,
- 25:25Speaker 1: just one state had this kind of a ban on
- 25:29Speaker 1: gender affirming care. Now twenty three states do. That seems
- 25:34Speaker 1: remarkably fast.
- 25:35Speaker 4: I think this issue of gender affirming care has definitely
- 25:40Speaker 4: been an activating issue, even say, an electrifying issue for
- 25:46Speaker 4: voters for conservatives and you know, for voters on the right.
- 25:49Speaker 4: I think that we've seen this issue as kind of
- 25:52Speaker 4: an extension of this red blue divide and clearly something
- 25:56Speaker 4: that is troubling a lot of people. And so yeah,
- 25:59Speaker 4: it's definitely clearly gained them a more conservative approach.
- 26:05Speaker 1: Are there generally accepted or approved clinical guidelines for treating
- 26:11Speaker 1: teenagers or youth with gender dysphoria.
- 26:14Speaker 4: So we've seen a significant shift going on around the
- 26:17Speaker 4: world right originally to the whole you know, position in
- 26:22Speaker 4: favor of gender firming care and essentially supporting you know,
- 26:26Speaker 4: children and their parents at the year and younger ages
- 26:28Speaker 4: to start receiving whether it's puberty blockers or other forms
- 26:33Speaker 4: of care. And we do see that the sort of
- 26:35Speaker 4: research that's out there has raised questions we saw Just
- 26:39Speaker 4: last month in England, the National Health Service said that
- 26:43Speaker 4: it would stop prescribing puberty blockers to kids and that
- 26:46Speaker 4: all gender firming care needs to be evidence based and
- 26:48Speaker 4: based on extra clinical opinions. So there definitely are two
- 26:51Speaker 4: opposing camps, one sort of saying, wait, we don't have
- 26:55Speaker 4: enough evidence to support this sort of transformative, radical care,
- 27:00Speaker 4: and the other, you know, advancing civil liberty argument and
- 27:04Speaker 4: an argument official harm to these children if they don't
- 27:06Speaker 4: get gender or firming care right, that it tots them
- 27:09Speaker 4: up for all kinds of mental health risks, for potential suicidality.
- 27:13Speaker 4: So we have these really radically opposed camps and not
- 27:16Speaker 4: a great body of evidence. Frankly on either side.
- 27:19Speaker 1: Idaho's law seems pretty broad. It bars more than twenty treatments,
- 27:24Speaker 1: including puberty blockers, and doctors and pharmacists who violate the
- 27:28Speaker 1: law and face up to ten years in prison. Is
- 27:30Speaker 1: that par for the course for these laws or is
- 27:33Speaker 1: it broader than usual.
- 27:35Speaker 4: It's definitely in line with some of the other states
- 27:37Speaker 4: of the stronger laws, I mean definitely. The approach of
- 27:40Speaker 4: using criminal sanctions against physicians and pharmacists is in I
- 27:45Speaker 4: believe most of the laws of these states that have
- 27:47Speaker 4: banned this care.
- 27:49Speaker 1: This is a narrow question that's before the Supreme Court
- 27:54Speaker 1: about temporary injunctions.
- 27:56Speaker 4: Right, Yeah, the Supreme Court essentially, you know, allowed this
- 27:59Speaker 4: law to go into effect. It didn't decide anything with finale.
- 28:03Speaker 4: It just said that Idaho was entitled to enforce this
- 28:06Speaker 4: ban on gender firming care for minors except for the.
- 28:10Speaker 1: Two petitioners here. But the ACLU, which represents them, said
- 28:14Speaker 1: that this won't protect the teenagers because medical providers won't
- 28:19Speaker 1: risk triggering a law that could put them behind bars
- 28:23Speaker 1: for a decade, and the teens would have to give
- 28:26Speaker 1: up their anonymity, So it may not even help the
- 28:30Speaker 1: two who are petitioning.
- 28:32Speaker 4: Right. By the way, I should say that the families
- 28:34Speaker 4: here and the teens have an option of traveling out
- 28:36Speaker 4: of state. Nobody, nobody can stop them from traveling to
- 28:38Speaker 4: a jurisdiction that is allowing this kind of care. So
- 28:42Speaker 4: what's at stake here is whether you can get this
- 28:43Speaker 4: care in Idaho, which is a problem, but there still
- 28:46Speaker 4: is an option to travel and get the care elsewhere.
- 28:48Speaker 1: Let's just say you have a family who can't afford
- 28:50Speaker 1: to go outside Idaho for this kind of care. If
- 28:54Speaker 1: the band goes into effect young people who are using
- 28:57Speaker 1: the puberty blockers, let's say they have to stop, then
- 29:01Speaker 1: puberty begins, So the question is sort of moot.
- 29:04Speaker 4: Then it certainly means that they're going to go through
- 29:06Speaker 4: physical changes that are going to make them much more,
- 29:10Speaker 4: you know, strongly appearing like males. Right Like, they're going
- 29:12Speaker 4: to be bigger and thicker and have a male frame,
- 29:17Speaker 4: male facial features. So it won't prevent them in the
- 29:19Speaker 4: future from getting gender firming care, but it will make
- 29:22Speaker 4: it harder for them to sort of have a transition
- 29:25Speaker 4: that's less noticeable. By the way, I think they're in
- 29:27Speaker 4: addition to puberty blockets, I believe these two trans girls,
- 29:31Speaker 4: who the stage is calling adolescent boys, were also receiving estrogen.
- 29:35Speaker 4: So it's really both drugs in combination that we're at
- 29:37Speaker 4: issue here.
- 29:38Speaker 1: So the Justice isn't the majority cast this less about
- 29:43Speaker 1: the substance of the law than the reach of the
- 29:46Speaker 1: district judges. Injunction Justice Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh, there
- 29:51Speaker 1: were two thirteen page opinions. They said that the High
- 29:55Speaker 1: Court was trying to tackle what has become a nettlesome
- 29:58Speaker 1: issue nationwide and statewide injunctions issued by a single judge
- 30:03Speaker 1: on a major controversy. But they've been complaining about this
- 30:07Speaker 1: for years. Wow. Is it striking that they chose this
- 30:12Speaker 1: case to, you know, draw a line in the sand.
- 30:15Speaker 4: It's a good question. I think what was striking about
- 30:17Speaker 4: this case was it was a narrow jurisdictional question of,
- 30:21Speaker 4: you know, what the power of Idaho was to put
- 30:24Speaker 4: the law into effect, and what the power of the
- 30:26Speaker 4: lower courts, the district court here is that, you know,
- 30:29Speaker 4: found that these adolescents should continue receiving care to avoid
- 30:32Speaker 4: severe psychological distress. It's possible that it was practical in
- 30:36Speaker 4: the sense that it was a narrow of jurisdictional issue
- 30:39Speaker 4: of what the rights of the Idaho courts versus the
- 30:41Speaker 4: Idaho legislature was, and not forcing the Supreme Court to
- 30:46Speaker 4: go through the messy and controversial question of actually addressing
- 30:51Speaker 4: the broader issue of the rights of parents, the rights
- 30:54Speaker 4: of children, and this whole messy, sticky subject of how
- 30:58Speaker 4: far we let children go what ages in receiving gender
- 31:01Speaker 4: affirming care.
- 31:03Speaker 1: So Justice Katanji Brown Jackson running for herself, and Justice
- 31:06Speaker 1: Sonia Sotomayor said this Court is not compelled to rise
- 31:10Speaker 1: and respond every time an applicant rushes to us with
- 31:13Speaker 1: an alleged emergency, and it's especially important for us to
- 31:16Speaker 1: refrain from doing so in novel, highly charged and unsettled circumstances.
- 31:23Speaker 1: I mean that the Supreme Court could have just ignored this, right, Yeah, you.
- 31:26Speaker 4: Really have two really profoundly different positions about what was
- 31:30Speaker 4: protecting children and justice. Katangi Brown is definitely, you know,
- 31:34Speaker 4: making a fair point that every time the Supreme Court
- 31:37Speaker 4: takes one of these opportunities and weighs in, it is
- 31:39Speaker 4: taking an aggressive position. It certainly would have been the
- 31:44Speaker 4: more judicially conservative. It would have shown more restraints that
- 31:48Speaker 4: just allow the lower court ruling to stand and not
- 31:51Speaker 4: get involved here.
- 31:52Speaker 1: So this straightened me out on one thing. Is this
- 31:58Speaker 1: I mean, is this before the Ninth Court of Appeals.
- 32:01Speaker 1: Yet where does the case stand in the lower courts?
- 32:04Speaker 4: The lower court ruling was the ruling that basically had
- 32:07Speaker 4: imposed a stay, meaning that the law wasn't going into
- 32:10Speaker 4: a force because of the risk of your psychological distress,
- 32:14Speaker 4: and the Ninth Circuit had affirmed. So this was essentially
- 32:17Speaker 4: a reversal of the Ninth Circuit and the lower court
- 32:20Speaker 4: in terms of allowing this slow to go into effect.
- 32:22Speaker 1: Praising the court's decision, Idaho's attorney general said the law
- 32:27Speaker 1: ensurer's miners will not be subjected to life altering drugs
- 32:30Speaker 1: and procedures. Quote. Denying the basic truth that boys and
- 32:34Speaker 1: girls are biologically different hurts our kids.
- 32:38Speaker 4: You know, you're looking straight obviously, you know he's expressing
- 32:44Speaker 4: the view that children are being exposed in American schools
- 32:49Speaker 4: and just in our culture at this moment to a
- 32:51Speaker 4: suggestiveness of the fact that they are born in the
- 32:55Speaker 4: wrong body, or that they are a different gender than
- 32:58Speaker 4: the gender assigned to the biologically at perth. In a way,
- 33:01Speaker 4: it mirrors the abortion issue, and that we have like
- 33:04Speaker 4: deeply held fundamental beliefs about what it means to protect kids,
- 33:08Speaker 4: right it is protecting kids preventing them from being at
- 33:12Speaker 4: risk psychologically, or if tecting kids, preventing them from being
- 33:16Speaker 4: exposed to the possibility of exploring whether this is something
- 33:21Speaker 4: that's appropriate for them. Clearly, you know, what we've seen
- 33:24Speaker 4: is that on the right there's a growing body of
- 33:26Speaker 4: people concerned that our schools and just all of the
- 33:29Speaker 4: sort of messaging around kids is encouraging them to go
- 33:33Speaker 4: down this path. But obviously his view is going to
- 33:36Speaker 4: start representing half of the conversation.
- 33:39Speaker 1: Backing up your theory, there is the Christian nationalist legal
- 33:43Speaker 1: organization Aligance Defending Freedom jumped into this to represent the
- 33:47Speaker 1: state of Idaho, and they're the group that brought mif
- 33:52Speaker 1: of Bristom to the Supreme Court.
- 33:54Speaker 4: Yeah, these issues have really become sort of really adjacent
- 33:57Speaker 4: and related questions about, you know, the personal right of
- 34:01Speaker 4: both the people who are experiencing and asking gender firming
- 34:06Speaker 4: care and their parents versus these you know, traditional societal
- 34:11Speaker 4: expectations and definitely with a certain religious quality to them.
- 34:16Speaker 4: So I think this one personally is trigated because we
- 34:19Speaker 4: have competing camps that in Europe, in the UK in particular,
- 34:24Speaker 4: itching back on whether this is healthy and on the
- 34:28Speaker 4: fact that genderferming care can always be delivered earlier. What
- 34:31Speaker 4: we're really fighting about is under eighteen, how young can
- 34:34Speaker 4: we believe children and take their desire for gender ferming
- 34:39Speaker 4: care and their parents support for it to be controlling
- 34:42Speaker 4: of their decisions. I think these two questions are going
- 34:45Speaker 4: to continue to be going hand in hand, reflecting this
- 34:48Speaker 4: sort of way that the conversation is dominated by these
- 34:51Speaker 4: fundamental views of personal rights, healthcare.
- 34:54Speaker 1: And the justices are deliberating behind the scenes on a
- 34:59Speaker 1: set of a including one that's presented by the Biden
- 35:02Speaker 1: administration in a Tennessee case. They don't seem unwilling to
- 35:06Speaker 1: jump into culture war issues, but with the federal courts divided,
- 35:11Speaker 1: the lower federal courts, it seems like it's something they
- 35:15Speaker 1: should take up.
- 35:16Speaker 4: I would imagine that ultimately, you know, given the decision
- 35:20Speaker 4: in the Dabbs case said we're leaving this to the state.
- 35:23Speaker 4: We're not going to decide this issue at the federal level.
- 35:25Speaker 4: It's logical to think that the Supreme Court would sort
- 35:28Speaker 4: of align similarly and really leave this to the state.
- 35:31Speaker 4: But I think we're going to find.
- 35:33Speaker 1: Out in the next year or two that timing seems
- 35:35Speaker 1: just about right. Thanks so much, Harry. That's Harry Nelson
- 35:38Speaker 1: of Nelson Hardiman, And that's it for this edition of
- 35:41Speaker 1: the Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you can always get the
- 35:44Speaker 1: latest legal news on our Bloomberg Law Podcast. You can
- 35:47Speaker 1: find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at www dot
- 35:51Speaker 1: Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast Slash Law, and remember to
- 35:55Speaker 1: tune into the Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight at ten
- 35:59Speaker 1: pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso and you're listening
- 36:02Speaker 1: to Bloomberg. Mhm