Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP318: Performance Marketing - A Modern Optimisation & Measurement Framework, with Vervaunt Co-founder Josh Duggan
Transcript
- 0:00North Beam has very recently launched the news that they're
- 0:03being given impression user logs for the last 30 days.
- 0:08So in that example, if I watched a brand ad on Meta 29 days ago,
- 0:12I then watched a product video 15 days ago, and then I go on to
- 0:17click ADPA and buy. There's only currently one
- 0:20solution which can tie that together, which I think is quite
- 0:22interesting. You listen to Inside Commerce, a
- 0:26weekly ecom strategy, technology and CX focus podcast hosted by
- 0:29experienced digital consultants and re platform specialist James
- 0:32Geddon Paul Rogers. Get insights into ecom strategy,
- 0:34leading brands, hear from industry thought leaders and
- 0:37leading tech vendors with practical advice to help you
- 0:39improve your online CX. This episode is sponsored by
- 0:44Shopify. We are doing a kind of like
- 0:48round up around like paid media performance, marketing trends,
- 0:53measurement. An update with Josh from
- 0:56Vivonne, who joined us earlier in the year to talk about
- 0:58general trends of the market. I think it was quite, quite a
- 1:00few months ago, but Josh, welcome back to the podcast.
- 1:03Yeah, amazing. Yeah.
- 1:04Thank you very much for having me as always.
- 1:07And last night was Von's Christmas party, so there's a
- 1:12degree of, of mental slowness from both of us today, although
- 1:15I finished earlier. So I'm obviously feeling a
- 1:17little bit more sprightly. But for, for people who've not
- 1:21met you before, listeners who, who don't know what your role
- 1:24is, Von do you want to give people a bit of a flavour for
- 1:26who you are and what you do? Yeah, certainly.
- 1:28Yeah. So I'm Josh, one of the Co
- 1:29founders of VON. So I've been in performance
- 1:32marketing for probably 14 years or so, but the Vault was formed
- 1:37about 8 years ago. We work with some amazing
- 1:40brands. So quite, quite often it's kind
- 1:43of like in the retail and premium fashion space.
- 1:46Yeah, I work with Doc Martens, Champion, Mulberry, Paul Smith,
- 1:50Osprey and yeah, quite a broad range, but some amazing like
- 1:54globally recognised brands. And in terms of my role, so I'd
- 1:57say I'm about 7% of my time is spent working with clients.
- 2:00So I'll be very focused on specific challenges.
- 2:03So measurement and attribution would be a pretty key area where
- 2:07I'd normally come in and give recommendations around third
- 2:10party solutions or you know, how to loop in finance and manage
- 2:13those discussions, create strategy, international
- 2:17planning, any board level conversations or you know, kind
- 2:21of like PE conversations, I'd normally come in.
- 2:23So yeah, they're always been focused on paid.
- 2:26They were massive passion. And yeah, if you have a 30%,
- 2:30it's obviously just the admin of being a Co founder of business.
- 2:33Yeah, the the the non glamorous, but rather important stuff to
- 2:36keep a busy and and I highly recommend follow follow Josh on
- 2:41LinkedIn. Always post useful interest in
- 2:43updates and like industry trend data.
- 2:46So well worth listening to what he's saying.
- 2:49Let's get into it. So before we start talking
- 2:51specifically about the like measurement, where measurements
- 2:54gone and how some of the modern platforms are enabling far
- 2:56smarter like attribution targeting and and improvement,
- 3:01let's just do a quick obviously the the big trade and weekend of
- 3:04black fund has just happened. Retailers have gone into bunkers
- 3:07and they're emerging the other side.
- 3:11Do you want to give give us a bit of a flavour of what you've
- 3:13seen and what trends? I guess from my, I don't work
- 3:16with people on the performance marketing like you do, but the
- 3:19clients I work with and I've been speaking to generally have
- 3:21found a a decent Black Friday, not a little decent.
- 3:26A few of them have had double digit year on year growth.
- 3:29People are up, up on budget, up on last year saw some some data
- 3:33released by some of the banks like Nationwide, for example,
- 3:36was saying that Black Friday the transaction come through their
- 3:40networks. They saw an 8.7% jump in
- 3:43transactions versus the same period last year.
- 3:45So it feels like it's positive in terms of total numbers, but
- 3:50I've also seen a little enough evidence from a a retailer as
- 3:55well to suggest that actually the margins are a little bit
- 3:58stronger this year that that some of the, I think the average
- 4:00discounts for some retailers lower.
- 4:03I don't know whether that holds true to what you're seeing with
- 4:05your client base. No, certainly.
- 4:08So I think that's probably quite a lot to digest over the Black
- 4:11Friday weekend. So I think the first thing I'd
- 4:14probably call out. So over Fake Friday, I'd say
- 4:18that's how, you know, the narrative of the longer shopping
- 4:21period has probably existed for, you know, two to three periods
- 4:24now. You know, Black Friday's not
- 4:25just a weekend, it's an extended period over November.
- 4:29So a lot of our clients were launching around the fake Friday
- 4:34period and we came into the office Monday.
- 4:37Obviously we've been tracking and kind of optimizing over the
- 4:39weekend. But on the Monday morning, I
- 4:41think it's for the first time in the Vance history, we had more
- 4:45clients down than up year on year.
- 4:48So we were just looking at the Friday to Monday or Friday to
- 4:51Sunday period. And we've got a kind of like a
- 4:55good of hypotheses around essentially kind of like what we
- 4:58think could have driven that and could have drove that.
- 5:00But yeah, so it kind of began doing these daily trend updates
- 5:04to all of our clients. So we've got about 60 clients
- 5:07across the agency, all very similar in terms of vertical and
- 5:10size. We were basically giving kind of
- 5:13like a snapshot around how is CAC performing in different
- 5:16markets, what's the year on year trend and nuance?
- 5:19Where are we seeing growth, Where are we seeing challenges?
- 5:21And I think that gave a lot of kind of like, yeah, a lot of
- 5:26support for kind of like people who were, you know, slightly
- 5:28behind Target, what they didn't expect.
- 5:30And that what we've seen since then is just a complete shift in
- 5:34the kind of like spending patterns.
- 5:36So Black Friday weekend itself was huge and absolutely massive.
- 5:41So we kind of like recovered all of the amount where we were down
- 5:45the week prior. And yeah, vast majority, I think
- 5:48probably 80% of our clients were up Black Friday.
- 5:51And we normally look at an average change of year on year
- 5:56growth rich clients, we normally look like the average change.
- 5:58But if we just looked at combined revenue, which Vivant
- 6:01drew for all of our clients, it was up about 10% for November.
- 6:06So the whole period for us was really strong, predominantly
- 6:10driven by the Black Friday, Cyber Monday weekend.
- 6:12And then if we've, yeah, I've kind of like some good updates
- 6:16from Google as well. So on their side, their
- 6:18reporting, I think about 2.3% year on year growth in purchases
- 6:24from their end. So essentially kind of like from
- 6:26all of that they've got. And so, yeah, and it was an
- 6:29interesting graph Google shared a couple years ago actually
- 6:31where I don't think it might have been last year.
- 6:34So about 3 years ago, Black Friday's growth was about 15%
- 6:38year on year. The year after it was about 10%.
- 6:41The year after last year was up about 7 or 6.
- 6:44So you've got the rate of growth has just been coming down and
- 6:47down, down and now it's at 3%. So I think next year will be the
- 6:51interesting one. But yeah, we, we had some
- 6:53clients where I think, I think what was quite nice is we had so
- 6:58many clients. So we just really proved the
- 7:00value of performance marketing. So we had hourly trackers set up
- 7:04for all of our clients. So on a Saturday morning we give
- 7:07an update. Saturday afternoon we give an
- 7:09update and we've got a clearview of hour by hour how we're
- 7:11trading on the year and against a Friday.
- 7:15And there are so many examples of our clients like OK, we think
- 7:18we're doing quite well. We're going to throw in an
- 7:20extra, you know, 20K of budget for the day and then we see it
- 7:24within the hours. So, yeah, if I looked at, yeah,
- 7:28not to call out, but Paul Smith from Strasbury, I know
- 7:30specifically kind of like we were very focused on the like
- 7:34hour to hour numbers and as soon as we made a change it was kind
- 7:38of like scene site wide and yeah, it was kind of just huge
- 7:42all around. So yeah, really positive.
- 7:44As I said, I think the, the broader concern would be that
- 7:47global rate of growth has just come down and the point of where
- 7:51it was 15 some three years ago and about 2 1/2% now.
- 7:55So it'd be interesting to see what retailers can do next year.
- 7:57But the to your final point is I'd say across the board and a
- 8:03lot of our clients were I guess less generous of discounting.
- 8:07So might not necessarily have been site wide and might have
- 8:13been slower to, to add kind of like core lines, the promotion
- 8:17top line figure might have been a bit lower in terms of the
- 8:20percentage off. And yeah, I'd say profitability
- 8:24I guess has probably been the bigger focus.
- 8:26We'd have a lot of clients where gross is up 10% and net is up
- 8:3030, just where they're like really trading the site hard.
- 8:34There's been a massive shift towards advertisers prioritising
- 8:39full price as well. So for Doc Martins, we will
- 8:42basically have like a very clear again our by our view as full
- 8:48price sale price. So we've just, so you know,
- 8:50we're making sure we prioritise all prices file and yeah, quite,
- 8:56quite a lot of change. But overall it's, it's been
- 8:58really positive, which is, yeah, it's quite nice.
- 9:01What do Mattel, Victoria Beckham, Sennheiser and Glossier
- 9:06all have in common? They power their businesses with
- 9:10Shopify. Shopify is the most innovative
- 9:14and scaled commerce platform on the planet.
- 9:17It also happens to have the best converting check out on the
- 9:20planet Shopify, Powering the future of Enterprise commerce.
- 9:26Find out more at shopify.com/enterprise.
- 9:30Yeah, it's a good call out on the on the overall rate of
- 9:32growth and it's, it's inevitable.
- 9:34If you look at the economic situation that persists and the
- 9:38impact of budget, so many people have been squeezed like in the
- 9:41UK tax thresholds held again, which means people are paying
- 9:45relatively more tax, therefore disposable incomes are under
- 9:49pressure. And that that definitely
- 9:50impacts. I mean premium brands are some
- 9:54of the, the real premium ones you're working with are
- 9:57insulated partly from it. But the aspirational market is
- 10:00the one where you you see that dropping out a little bit
- 10:02because people people defer that aspirational purchase.
- 10:07Yeah, yeah, certainly. But that was really interesting.
- 10:10I love hearing this is the great thing about working with people
- 10:12where they've got access to all of the data across a wide range
- 10:15of client bases. Yeah, we we had one of our
- 10:18hypotheses was basically that because every year of a window
- 10:23has been extending and so many advertisers will have, you know,
- 10:27like a say a three day e-mail CRM strategy where they need to
- 10:31change the promo or they need to do something to keep, you know,
- 10:35a three-week sale period interesting.
- 10:37And normally ends on Black Friday with the biggest sale
- 10:41moment with the most lines, the highest discount that the prime
- 10:44example would be extra 10. Like so many clients and
- 10:47advertisers will be doing extra 10 on the Sunday, Monday.
- 10:51And I think the consumer's just savvy enough to learn fake
- 10:54Friday isn't the heart of the discount.
- 10:57The heart of the discount is at the end on Black Friday weekend.
- 11:01And yeah, for now it's kind of like a loose hypothesis we've
- 11:05been building just with clients where it like, yeah, the the
- 11:09trading numbers just completely don't fulfill what it was last
- 11:13year. But overall it's up.
- 11:15So yeah, I'm sure there's loads of reasons, but I certainly
- 11:18think we've we've got so many clients where extra terms
- 11:20Sunday, Monday, if they did it last year, then naturally the
- 11:23consumer's not going to be, you know, hammering sale on the fake
- 11:26Friday or just wait. No, you if you build an
- 11:29expectation and the behaviour, it's hard to break people out
- 11:33the patterns. So but that that data piece
- 11:36leads us nicely into the measurement.
- 11:39Thing is obviously you cannot understand the data without
- 11:42really good granular measurements.
- 11:44So one of the key focuses for this episode is about your view
- 11:49on measurement tools, because we've had the inevitable
- 11:52acceleration of AI tooling into data sets.
- 11:57Love to know where how you've seen this evolve, how you are
- 12:01seeing more modern tools being used?
- 12:03Like what? What is the difference it means
- 12:05to merchants in terms of what they can now analyse and do?
- 12:09Yeah, yeah, 100%. So I think, I think the yeah, I
- 12:11think the first thing is, I mean, it'd be interesting to see
- 12:15a graph of the number of measurement tools which have
- 12:18kind of like been introduced over the last five years and you
- 12:21know, definitely would be a bit hockey stick towards kind of
- 12:24like the last 2-3 years or so. And I think what's happening is
- 12:29retailers and appetizers now have just got so many options in
- 12:32terms of what technologies to look at.
- 12:34So I guess in terms of the most common tools our clients would
- 12:39use, so Triple Whale, Phosphor, N Beam and Ndema, I've got
- 12:44really interesting proposition which I'm sure we'll come on to.
- 12:48But I guess the one of the challenges with measurement
- 12:52today is say, for instance, you had two platforms running
- 12:56against each other and they just give you a completely different
- 12:59robust. And then you're taking that then
- 13:03to your CFO or finance team. And you're basically just
- 13:06relying on the kind of like, you know, the black box
- 13:10infrastructure and modelling or regression modelling or MMM or
- 13:14however they do it. You're basically just like
- 13:16relying on that as your complete forum to make decisions.
- 13:19And I think what's what's quite interesting as I just think
- 13:23there's so much more advertisers can do before they really start
- 13:29to understand if you know, if a matter OS is 3 to 1 or 4 to 1.
- 13:34And there's a lot of work which I think is being missed before
- 13:37that. So I, I certainly my in my final
- 13:41recommendation, I'll touch around why it's worthwhile
- 13:44having a third party jewel. And I think you certainly want
- 13:46to have them at a decent level. And but my problem is if you
- 13:51just suddenly take that as gospel and then you report it
- 13:53internally, it never really gets, you know, acfos back like,
- 13:58you know, really never gets their back in.
- 14:00They will much more tangible, proven examples of an, you know,
- 14:05whether it's Geo based testing or incrementality testing,
- 14:08whatever else it is, it's quite difficult to just go, you know,
- 14:11so triple well, for instance, has seven attribution models.
- 14:16And so if you chose triple well as your kind of right source of
- 14:19truth, and then you're talking finance and they go, oh, what
- 14:22model you're using. And and then you say, you know,
- 14:24we're using this one. You then have to justify that
- 14:27the CEO. So you've already got yourself
- 14:28in a discussion where it's like what model are you choosing as
- 14:31opposed to, you know, what platform you've chosen.
- 14:33So yeah, I was going to spend a bit of time just going through
- 14:36what I think brands can do already where there's just so
- 14:41much data available and so much potential for you to kind of
- 14:46like really build interesting conversations, drive more
- 14:48profitability is kind of like the more the bigger theme for
- 14:51our talk around. And then you would start to
- 14:54enhance all of that with a third party tool.
- 14:57And yeah, I can just go through some ideas if that works.
- 15:00Yeah, let's go for it. Let's.
- 15:01Let's get a love line freefall. OK, great.
- 15:04Yeah, I mean, so, so, yeah, So our Christmas party last night,
- 15:07so I was speaking to a few clients about this, but for
- 15:10Matters Matter, ad spend on Matter in Q3 this year grew 25%
- 15:15year on year. And again, if you look at kind
- 15:18of like Matters ad revenues, again, it's just a consistent
- 15:21growth and there's no way that next year ad spend on Matter is
- 15:26not going to be increasing and CPMS are going to increase
- 15:30alongside that. So all of our clients,
- 15:32realistically, the truth will be you need to spend at least 10%
- 15:36more just to maintain the current coverage that you've
- 15:41achieved this year. So you're kind of going in and
- 15:44the challenge day one. So what our focus wants is going
- 15:48to be is really orientated around driving much more value
- 15:53from every pound that we do spend.
- 15:54So I'll talk for a couple of examples, but we've been doing a
- 15:58bit of work recently which thinks quite nice in terms of
- 16:00understanding how LTV is impacted by the 1st item
- 16:06ordered. So and kind of like this to talk
- 16:09us through to the premise of having like an allowable CAC.
- 16:12So essentially rather than having a business wide CAC, the
- 16:16amount we're happy to spend on acquiring customer, we build
- 16:20specific packs based on much more business orientated and
- 16:25data. So it might be LTV and might be
- 16:28worth of the products returned, it might be in a margin.
- 16:30And if for else, I'll talk throughout in a moment.
- 16:32But in terms of the LTV piece, a lot of work we've been doing is,
- 16:35yeah, understanding if the first ice ordered impacts purchasing
- 16:40behaviour within 12 months. And we've got an amazing example
- 16:44for one client. So they're a jewellery brand and
- 16:47their AOV is about 100 lbs. And we did a bit of work and we
- 16:52looked at the LTV based on the first item ordered.
- 16:55And when we put it in a graph, you could see that the AOV
- 16:59really contributed to LTV. So the first and, and this is
- 17:03LTV after the first purchase. So the AOV isn't influencing LTV
- 17:07because it's the day after. And then what we found was the
- 17:12customers who spent over £200 on their first order, so double the
- 17:16AOV, they spent seven times more in the first year than every
- 17:21other customer who spent under £200.
- 17:24And as I said, this is the day after purchase, so it's the 364
- 17:27days following date of purchase. And and then for us, that's just
- 17:31such a argument where if we're going into next year where ad
- 17:35spend is increasing, we can justify spending 30% more on
- 17:42these customers because we know they drive 7 times more back in
- 17:45any in a 12 month window. And, and I think this is kind of
- 17:49like the data, which I would be really encouraging brands to
- 17:52look at next year. So as opposed to talking through
- 17:56whether you know North Beam, give us this ROAS, Matic versus
- 18:00ROAS and it's a difference of five to three or whatever it
- 18:03might be. I think the true value is like
- 18:06really driving tangible profitability for clients and,
- 18:10and and you kind of let you like your retailer and a couple more
- 18:14examples around that. So if you were to build like an
- 18:16allowable cat model, I think that LTV 1 is quite nice.
- 18:20So there'll be certain products where you can justify spending
- 18:23more if you know that they drive more repeat or higher LTV, but
- 18:28then there's so many other factors you might want to bake
- 18:29in. So like returns would be quite a
- 18:31big one. So we work for a number of multi
- 18:33brand retailers or we work with a lot of retailers.
- 18:35So they have quite a broad category of products.
- 18:39So Paul Smith literally sell, you know, furniture to bikes to
- 18:43underwear to candles to everything.
- 18:46And their return rate varies quite heavily by area, as you
- 18:50would imagine. So there's going to be a lot of
- 18:52value in US spending more on products with a lower return
- 18:57rate and reducing our spend on products which will return quite
- 19:01a lot. You know, we've got some clients
- 19:02where return rates are up to 35% across the board.
- 19:06So if we begin, you know, lowering that down to 25%, even
- 19:10if the cap is higher because we're paying more to match the
- 19:13ad costs, we know the profitability of the business is
- 19:15better. So essentially just shifting
- 19:17like all metrics down to net. So we've got like a full view of
- 19:22what is the net impact of the business and then of our ideas
- 19:25would be, you know, like margin would be a pretty big one.
- 19:27Most, most of our clients are brands themselves and they've
- 19:31got a pretty consistent margin across the board, but it's
- 19:33always something we would, you know, dissect and look at.
- 19:37And then another one might be stock.
- 19:38So essentially this would be more of a scoring mechanism that
- 19:42you apply. But if you've got like stagnant
- 19:44stock, which is, you know, costing a lot to maintain the
- 19:47warehouse, it's not moving, that's probably a way you could
- 19:50justify and spending a bit more on getting rid of it because you
- 19:55know, that it just kind of like helps the business business long
- 19:57term. So yes, one of our goals will be
- 19:59to move to like an allowable CAC system.
- 20:02So we're, we're paying a certain amount of money per customer
- 20:07based on how valuable they'll be and from a profitability
- 20:11perspective. So yeah, I think that's a
- 20:12really, really decent one. And there's a lot you can do
- 20:15there. And I think there's, well, a lot
- 20:17you can do around your own. Testing as well.
- 20:20So for most of our clients will probably be using CAC or cost of
- 20:25sale or Mer. So it will be the relationship
- 20:28between ad spend and site wide numbers.
- 20:32So we're not yet answering the ridiculously impossible
- 20:36challenge of attribution in terms of like really giving a
- 20:40contribution to channel X, Channel Y.
- 20:43What we're doing is focusing on the overall impact for business
- 20:47and then starting to understand how that evolves with with kind
- 20:52of like different levels of investment.
- 20:53So the first metric I would want to understand if I was in a
- 20:57brand would be our incremental CAC.
- 21:00So essentially that would be the cost of every new customer.
- 21:05And and then so say, say your CAC's £50 and we drive 100
- 21:11customers a week. If we want to go and acquire 120
- 21:15customers next week and CAC goes to 60 LB.
- 21:19And we know that kind of like the extra amount we might have
- 21:22had to pay for those customers could be 100 lbs there.
- 21:25But as soon as you as soon as you understand that, that kind
- 21:27of removes any problem and challenge of incrementality or
- 21:32attribution because you just know that we when we spend more,
- 21:36every new customer costs costs us £100.
- 21:40And and then that, that again is just kind of like purely net
- 21:43need for business purely driven by paid.
- 21:46And, and then basically what we're finding, we just see, see
- 21:49these as conversations which get more buy in and more trust from
- 21:53finance. And if you're able to truly show
- 21:57a profit number or an overall number for the business, it just
- 22:01seems to have a lot more merit. And then we would kind of like
- 22:05support that with third party solutions.
- 22:08I'm sure we'll talk through what third party solutions can do in
- 22:11a moment. But yeah, just a final one on
- 22:13the brand side itself or advertise side and I guess the
- 22:17whole Geo testing piece as well. So I think this is probably
- 22:20going to get quite a lot of growth over the next couple of
- 22:24years. So Google are currently
- 22:25introducing Geo based testing. So essentially the goal would be
- 22:30that you identify 20 cities and when they're grouped into 210
- 22:35cities an H, the performance is just consistent and very similar
- 22:39over time. And then what the goal would be
- 22:42is you've got your kind of like line graph of revenue of both
- 22:45Citigroup A, Citigroup B. And then when you increase
- 22:48investment in only Citigroup A the additional revenue drive and
- 22:54divided by the additional spend, is that kind of like incremental
- 22:57ROI? And then you've got a proven or
- 23:00the the best time to do this would be with like brand
- 23:03awareness. So if you start running, you
- 23:05know, above above the line media brand awareness, it's got a
- 23:08slightly longer lag between interaction engagement, purchase
- 23:13and one of the cleanest ways to test that would be Geo based and
- 23:19Google are currently investing in it.
- 23:20Matter launched something a couple of years ago and a lot of
- 23:24the third party tools are looking to enable this through
- 23:27their platform. And yeah, it's just something I
- 23:32think appetizers should be starting to look at today.
- 23:34And again, it's just one of those things where you can take
- 23:36it through to your finance team. You know, we've we've got a .95
- 23:39correlation between these two city groups.
- 23:41As soon as we turned on brand stand, correlation lowers and
- 23:45uplifters here uplift minus additional spend equals
- 23:50increments ROI. Yeah.
- 23:51I mean, the great thing is it's very easy to to validate that
- 23:55through the sales data in an ecom platform based on the
- 23:59customer ordering. Oh, A. 100% yeah.
- 24:02Yeah, exactly. You could ship anywhere, it
- 24:04could be a gift, but you can do it on the billing to know where
- 24:06the person who's bought has come from.
- 24:07So yeah, it's really I like that.
- 24:09If you reminds me of the funnel days, I used to having direct
- 24:12mail when he used to do like geographical testing.
- 24:14So you would you would test some some some direct mailers in a
- 24:18very specific. Geographic, yeah, as.
- 24:20Your audience cohort targeting and you would measure
- 24:24incrementality on web-based on the order base.
- 24:28Nice. So yeah, so that's really good
- 24:30that they're baking that in. And let's get into the third
- 24:32party systems because yeah, I know that you've worked with a
- 24:36lot of different tech. I know that that Vivant has have
- 24:39worked quite closely this year with with Deema and they're
- 24:43making a lot of waves in terms of providing a, a kind of deeper
- 24:47business intelligence set. So do you want to talk about
- 24:50what what is good in 3rd party tools and what can people get
- 24:55that's added value? Amazing.
- 24:58Yeah, certainly. So in terms of the yeah, in
- 25:01terms of the added value, I think the thirst and yeah, I
- 25:05think theme has almost got a separate proposition.
- 25:07So I might just come under those at the end.
- 25:09But in terms of a day one MTA slash MMM, kind of like based
- 25:15solution, I think the first benefit I would find is the
- 25:20level of detail that you can get from fingerprinting.
- 25:23So essentially someone like triple well or North beam,
- 25:26especially a really strong at this where triple well, you can
- 25:30go in, You can look at your over the last two months, take all
- 25:35new customers and you can download similar kind of like
- 25:38GA, you know, UA back in the day.
- 25:42And you can download a user report of the last six months
- 25:45and look at every interaction that that user has had before
- 25:49come into the site. So the triple whale, as I
- 25:51mentioned, it's I still think it's difficult if we're in a if
- 25:55we're in a financial discussion and we say, you know, we're
- 25:58using the total impact ROAS of triple whale and we believe ROAS
- 26:03is 3 to one on meta. It's still quite difficult to
- 26:07get buy in for that. Whereas I think if we take to
- 26:09them actually out of all of your new customers we've driven in
- 26:13the last four months, 40% of them have landed on the site at
- 26:18least once from a met rat. And I think that's just like a
- 26:21really, really like strong evidence.
- 26:25I mean, it's just like a objective number, whereas I
- 26:29think sometimes in the, when you're truly getting a number
- 26:33like an ROI to something, it's, you know, it's a bit more
- 26:36subjective and it's a bit more relying on behind the scenes
- 26:40logic, which, you know, I've spoke to most tools and it's
- 26:44quite difficult to truly explain how those systems work or it's
- 26:49quite difficult for them to kind of like show evidence backed
- 26:52reasoning behind it. So especially with M the man I,
- 26:55I would love the capability where it shows you our, our
- 26:59regression modelling, our M the man it's assigning 30% of
- 27:03overall contribution back to meta.
- 27:06And here is the time stamped periods as to why.
- 27:09So you know, on this period you spent more on Meta, here was the
- 27:12uplift and this period where the Google and met spend had this
- 27:15relationship, this was the revenue.
- 27:17So we've assigned it here. So I think that piece is missing
- 27:20from media mix modelling currently where it's like the I
- 27:26guess the explanation around how it's got to where it's got to
- 27:29whereas what a lot of the MTA based solutions and obviously a
- 27:33lot of the tools do both. But I think what the MTA data
- 27:35allows is that kind of just really true core objective data
- 27:41you can take into a into a boardroom.
- 27:43And I think another example for triple well would be so the
- 27:47prime example for matter would be matter still attributes all
- 27:51of its sales back to the last click.
- 27:53So if we run 5 grand films and a user is kind of like constantly,
- 28:01you know, watching those films, watching their films and then
- 28:04they go on and click ADPA ad and then go on to buy and the DPA,
- 28:08you know, it's just the final piece to pie matter of signs
- 28:11that conversion to the DPA ad. So what you what why are you
- 28:16with need and you'd want an MTA tool is if someone clicks on the
- 28:19site from the brand ad, you've got that piece of Gurney, which
- 28:24is fundamental. So I'm certainly not here to say
- 28:26third party tools aren't necessary or needed.
- 28:28I think there's just so much work you've been doing day one
- 28:31around that profitability cat piece.
- 28:33And then when you are using a third party tool, I wouldn't
- 28:36just take the, you know, the given Roas's gospel.
- 28:40I'd really go in and kind of like look at your data yourself.
- 28:44And you know, for instance, if you took that, if you took every
- 28:47customer journey over the last 12 months from triple L and you
- 28:51put it in a pivot table and you essentially just built all of
- 28:55the journeys out, you could see what are the most common
- 28:57journeys. You could see how often is
- 28:59matter a touch point in a journey.
- 29:01You could almost start to understand your own DDA model.
- 29:04So you could almost start to understand how this conversion
- 29:06rate and change if they are exposed to a brand add on matter
- 29:10versus they only come through Google Shopping.
- 29:13So you can almost like build what in essence DDA modelling
- 29:15is. And so I think that sounds
- 29:18pretty interesting. I think just back on the actual
- 29:20measurement tools. So one of the bigger changes to
- 29:23the landscapes has actually been N beam have just come out of a
- 29:28pretty big update. So not sure how how they're the
- 29:33only one, but basically they're the only provider now where meta
- 29:36are sharing impression user logs back to North beam.
- 29:42So in that scenario I just mentioned.
- 29:44So say say I watch a brand film on Matter for 30 seconds and I
- 29:52like love the brand film really really engaged. 25 hours later I
- 29:57click on an image ad and then go on to buy.
- 30:00Not one measurement tool currently sees that because
- 30:04Matters attribution window only covers a 24 hour period of a
- 30:08view based interaction. So you could So it's very, very
- 30:12difficult today to manage brand spend properly or to like fully
- 30:16understand brand spend without doing a Geo test, without doing
- 30:19a control exposed. And but N Beam said a very, very
- 30:23recently launched the news that essentially they're being given
- 30:28impression user logs the last 30 days.
- 30:31So in that example, if I watched a brand ad on Meta 29 days ago,
- 30:38really buy into it. I found watch a product video 15
- 30:41days ago and then I go on to click ADPA and buy.
- 30:46There's only currently one solution which can tie that
- 30:48together, which I think is quite interesting.
- 30:51And there's that I think I like, I expect to see so much change
- 30:53in the measurement, measurement play in the measurement space.
- 30:56And one thing what I love is how DMR have come to the market.
- 31:01So if I look at them specifically, I think they're
- 31:05another option where all of that piece I said at the start around
- 31:10how much more brands can be doing before, before relying on
- 31:14an attribution tool to tell you a row as there's so much more
- 31:17data you can be building yourself.
- 31:19And DMA have basically just gone and enabled all of that out the
- 31:23box. So you would basically go in and
- 31:27it gives you, you know, contribution margin 1-2 down to
- 31:31a product level and of like here's how much you've spent on
- 31:35this product on Google Shopping, indexing the ad name from Meta.
- 31:39So if the creative name matches the product, it will pull in
- 31:43that ad spend. 30% of our agency spend on Meta is catalog ads
- 31:48where is a, it's basically the product feed.
- 31:51So it's a single product going through the PDP folks and last
- 31:53spend goes there. So all of that data is pushed in
- 31:57the product and then it just gives you the sequential view of
- 32:03every bit of data after that. So you know, pull in the margin.
- 32:06So it'll tell you the actual profit that you drove from that
- 32:09purchase. It will tell you for returns.
- 32:12So it'll tell you kind of like, yeah, gross profit minus
- 32:15returns. It will tell you the stock.
- 32:17So it'll tell you whether you actually want to be pushing that
- 32:20product. And and then basically it'll
- 32:22just give you like a final number around how efficient it
- 32:25is. And it also gives you actually
- 32:27the new customers. So down to you've imagine you've
- 32:29got a list of all of your products and it's talking you
- 32:31through 80% of customers were new who bought this item.
- 32:35Here's the ad spend you had assigned to it.
- 32:37Here's the contribution margin, here's the amount of stock and
- 32:40then say here's the cap as if that was your like final most
- 32:43important metric. And day one that just gives so
- 32:47much opportunity to just reoptimize how you're spending
- 32:51budget. Like we're doing this manually
- 32:54currently for clients and here's a great piece of work to do.
- 32:58And I think you know, we've got so many clients where one of
- 33:00their, they've got a lot of strong products where we're just
- 33:03not essentially spending enough behind it, where the CAC
- 33:06suggests that we've got capability to spend more.
- 33:09And actually back to the back to the whole kind of like testing
- 33:12piece as well. What a way to prove
- 33:14incrementality if you just completely double investment on
- 33:18a certain group of products and you measure the uplift of those
- 33:22versus others. So we did this for one of our
- 33:25clients recently actually, where we just completely doubled down
- 33:29on a specific suit over summer and it was like everywhere,
- 33:33double the investment in content, probably quadrupled the
- 33:36ad spend. And what a way to measure the
- 33:40overall impact where you just compare that suit specifically
- 33:44against the rest of the website and how it traded.
- 33:47So you know, websites grown 15% year on year, that suit's grown
- 33:5170, but 55% difference might divided by your ad spend is
- 33:58essentially kind of like, you know, your true ROI of that big
- 34:01push. And but essentially what Dema
- 34:04does is it just gives you all of its day-to-day one and it's all
- 34:08out the box. It's the first tool to really be
- 34:11looking at this. And their narrative is they've
- 34:14built the tool for CF OS and I can completely understand that.
- 34:18I think if you look back to what I was saying earlier in the talk
- 34:21around how I would want to, what data I'd want to going to see
- 34:25CFO, you know, it's not going to be a a robust we've been given
- 34:30from a tool. It's going to be objective data
- 34:33and which really helps us make the next decision.
- 34:36So yeah, the other, the other challenge I sometimes find with
- 34:39the measurement tools is it's all quite and especially I'm the
- 34:41man where, you know, the other man is looking back over 2
- 34:44years. Most of our clients spend the
- 34:47majority of our budget in two channels, you know, so and
- 34:50there's not too much you can learn if the, you know, you're
- 34:54not going to be too far off of assuming quite accurately what
- 34:57we are or what the bro us will be.
- 34:59And whereas something like DMA, yeah, just gives you kind of
- 35:02like 10 times more context around a product level.
- 35:06Are you driving new customers profitably?
- 35:09Where's our scope to spend more? They've built in all of the Geo
- 35:12based capability themselves. So basically out-of-the-box it
- 35:16will just give you recommended testing environments.
- 35:20So it might just say, you know, here's 20 states in the US
- 35:25versus 10. And over the last two years,
- 35:28they've performed exactly in line.
- 35:31And we propose that you run your test in these 20 States and the
- 35:35reporting will basically just be, you know, the line graph of
- 35:39the predicted exposed group based on the control group and
- 35:44the actual revenue of the exposed group.
- 35:47So it'll tell you that kind of like uplift.
- 35:49So yeah, I think it's just, I just think it's a solution,
- 35:52which, yeah, it's definitely gives you, it's a bit easier to
- 35:57kind of like build a narrative and get backing for AD spend and
- 36:01make better decisions. And it definitely helps you
- 36:05drive more profits. I think it's yeah, I think I
- 36:08think it wouldn't surprise me if I saw the other tools starting
- 36:11to layer in some of this stuff. And and I said N Beam have just
- 36:16had a yeah, really, really decent like update from their
- 36:20side. And then you have a triple round
- 36:23fosters, to be honest, and probably more commonly used.
- 36:25My clients definitely have, you know, definitely have a really
- 36:29strong place and definitely have a really good offering.
- 36:32My focus is making sure they use their capability or, and just
- 36:37make sure that we're, you know, every piece of data that we can
- 36:40pull out, we're using it properly.
- 36:42And we're not just like lazily relying on a third party tool to
- 36:46tell us the answer. We're really, really pulling out
- 36:50all of the additional data it does give us.
- 36:52And I, I, you know, yeah, I'd love to wear in a measurement
- 36:55tool. You know, I think there's so
- 36:56much value in them. And but I think you also need to
- 36:59be kind of like very, very focused on making sure the
- 37:02tool's used properly. I mean, sometimes maybe I've
- 37:06seen, you know, CF OS asking people how the tools got the
- 37:09answer and no one really knows. I think that I think there's
- 37:12like a lot of, yeah, a lot of upskilling to be done in terms
- 37:16of like, why are we using this tool?
- 37:17How do we get the best out, best outfit?
- 37:20And the whole KPI alignment piece is massive at the moment
- 37:24in terms of having all teams fully agreed on the KPI's.
- 37:29And yeah, that's a big trend we're seeing currently.
- 37:33And where, where do you, where do you see this headed in terms
- 37:37of do you, do you think it's just going to become ubiquitous
- 37:40where every brand is using a third party tool like this to do
- 37:45the analysis just because the value add intelligent or is it,
- 37:48is it really dependent on the scale of the investment in terms
- 37:51of like volume of ad spend to get the the marginal benefits
- 37:55out of it? I mean, that's a very good
- 37:57question. I think, I think that I think
- 38:01realistically anyone at a decent size, well if not use a third
- 38:07party solution, we'll be building the capability to pull
- 38:10this data out themselves. And as I said, we're kind of
- 38:14like the LTV by first item ordered.
- 38:17We're doing that with clients currently we're building hack
- 38:21views at product level and at category level.
- 38:23So day one, we can see where clients should be spending more
- 38:26or where we think they have potential to spend more.
- 38:28And third party solutions do that out the box and provide,
- 38:34you know, as I mentioned, the fingerprinting piece, the MMM
- 38:37piece. And so I think there will be a
- 38:40massive shift towards measurement.
- 38:43And I think the bigger change will be realistically finance
- 38:47teams getting on board with what the KPIs are, how it's tracked,
- 38:51what tests we're introducing and then if that would just be a
- 38:55decision made in the business, whether it's internal capability
- 38:59and time goes into that or it's utilized via a third party.
- 39:05Yeah, I think that's that's really interesting is the, I
- 39:08guess the closer involvement of a finance team in the
- 39:13understanding of the value of this upfront rather than trying
- 39:18to have to go cap in hand because you want more budget to
- 39:21do more paid media and having a cynical person who's not been
- 39:24bought in the journey and doesn't buy into the data.
- 39:29Yeah, Yeah, exactly. I think and you know we've got
- 39:32most of our clients now will be I think our average cost sale is
- 39:37probably 15 to 18% across the agency.
- 39:39And like we've got some clients that growing rapidly where it's
- 39:42above 20. And it's now just such a
- 39:46commercial decision for the business around how performance
- 39:50marketing budget is spent, where it's spent, how it's tracked, is
- 39:55it incremental. I mean, I don't think we said on
- 39:57the last Stan podcast we did actually, it's almost like for
- 40:00return of brand spending mentality.
- 40:02So you know, I've been in search was my first role.
- 40:06So I've been in search 14 years. And I thought like if I had a
- 40:09graph of branding mentality tests, you know, it would have
- 40:13been 14 years ago very prominent, 8 years ago, very
- 40:16prominent. And then you know the last two.
- 40:19Three years, it's kind of come back again and and it's just
- 40:23because you know, so much spend is going into it CF OS be
- 40:26searching they'll be arguing, you know, is this incremental?
- 40:30Do we need to stand 20P on a bid for our brand term and or do we
- 40:35want to build the demand, all of that and building demand and
- 40:39everything else. So yeah, I think, I think that's
- 40:42such a big part of the equation. And you know, we've got some
- 40:45brands who are just like fully reliant on performance
- 40:47marketing. Like they've, you know, they've
- 40:48grow for business via I'd say organic as well, but organic and
- 40:53paid social. We've got a lot of clients that
- 40:55have grown businesses there. And as a result, you kind of
- 40:59need to make sure everyone's aligned around, you know, how
- 41:02much we spending, how much can we spend?
- 41:04What does initiative, additional speed?
- 41:06What does additional spend mean for the business and everything
- 41:10else? Yeah, I find it, I find it
- 41:12fascinating. I'm going to draw, I'm drawing
- 41:15closest here because I could ask you loads and loads of rabbit
- 41:18hole questions now about measuring.
- 41:20But I think the important thing is people listen is, is that the
- 41:24intelligence behind measuring the performance marketing and
- 41:26the removal of ambiguity is completely the direction of
- 41:30travel. And, and it definitely feels
- 41:32that I'd for a long time. I mean, I've been in the
- 41:34industry for a long time and, and continuously attribution
- 41:37models have come up. I've been criticised, people
- 41:39have debated and said which one should be used and people look
- 41:42at three different numbers and don't know why.
- 41:44And that removing the ambiguity that comes with that.
- 41:47You either, you either fix an, an attribution model and say we
- 41:51don't care, we're just looking at the trends and we believe in
- 41:53the model 11 if it's not accurate, but at least we or
- 41:55you, as you said, you switch to a, a different and smarter set
- 41:59of KPIs and measure it that way. So it feels like there's there's
- 42:02quite a clear direction of travel in the industry.
- 42:05Yeah, certainly. But look, Josh, I always really
- 42:08enjoy, always learn loads talking to you and listening to
- 42:11you. For anyone listening to who is
- 42:14interested by this or has got more questions and thinking, oh
- 42:17God, like, how do we, how do we do this or what should we be
- 42:21focused on? Why Josh's contact details on
- 42:23the landing page, reach out, connect with him on LinkedIn.
- 42:26So let's say he's got a lot of advice to share.
- 42:29And if you, if you're needing any support with optimizing your
- 42:32performance marketing, you know who to speak to.
- 42:35Josh, thanks for joining us. Amazing.
- 42:37Yeah, thanks for traveling today and yeah, enjoy the rest of your
- 42:39afternoon. Yeah, take care.
- 42:41Thanks for listening, everyone. You're listening to the Inside
- 42:44Commerce podcast. Hosted by experienced
- 42:46consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers, Inside Commerce is your
- 42:50fast track to digital knowledge, featuring interviews with
- 42:52leading e-commerce retailers, industry thought leads and the
- 42:55C-Suite. Key tech companies to explore
- 42:57the latest digital strategy, customer experience and tech.
- 43:00Discover what the latest trends really mean and get practical
- 43:03advice based on experience to help fine tune your E Comm
- 43:06strategy and taste. Follow us on LinkedIn and reach
- 43:10out to James and Paul if you'd like to discuss an E comms
- 43:12project. We hope you enjoy the latest
- 43:14episode.