Latest / Bourbon Bytes Podcast / Michter’s Barrel Strength Rye Review: Does It Still Deserve the Hype?
Transcript
- 0:00Today on The Bourbon Bytes Podcast, New Riff drops its oldest Headliner Blend ever,
- 0:05Bardstown Bourbon Company goes tropical, and Heaven Hill unveils a first-of-its-kind double
- 0:10mash. Plus, I'm revisiting one of my favorite barrel-strength rye whiskeys of all time.
- 0:28Hello everyone and welcome to The Bourbon Bytes Podcast. I'm your host,
- 0:32Clifton, and this is the week of July 23rd, 2026. I feel like this month is lasting forever,
- 0:38but I don't mind it. I'm really enjoying the weather out here in Southern California,
- 0:42and I feel a little guilty saying that because I know a lot of you guys are being hammered by just
- 0:46terrible weather around the country. So I feel for every one of those areas that are flooding
- 0:51or those massive heat waves, just I hope it all chills out soon and we can get on with better
- 0:57days. But man, the weather this time of year is so crazy. But today is not about that. Today is
- 1:04about the latest and greatest in the world of whiskey in terms of news, and I'm really excited
- 1:09to be revisiting one of my favorite whiskeys of all time. So it's going to be a good episode.
- 1:13Hopefully you have a glass poured, whether it be a bourbon or a cup of coffee, depending on the time
- 1:18of day, or a little bit of both if it's one of those days, because I get that too. But our first
- 1:23news story comes to us from New Riff. They are releasing their 2026 Headliner blend. This is
- 1:30their third year releasing this, and it is a blend of three distinct whiskeys, all aged at least 10
- 1:36years old. Now proceeds of this release will benefit Big Brothers and Big Sisters of the
- 1:41Greater Cincinnati and Tri-State Trails, which is a great organization. I never really got a chance
- 1:46to volunteer with them, but I really wanted to when I was in college. I ended up going with another
- 1:50organization and helping out in some lower-income schools instead. But Big Brothers Big Sisters is
- 1:55definitely one that I would have supported if I had more time on my hands. But this year's release
- 2:00features 50% of an 11-year-old malted rye bourbon, 25% of an 11-year-old rye, and 25% of a 10-year-old
- 2:09Balboa rye. So they're throwing all of their fun experimental releases into this headliner. This is
- 2:14the first time that every component is at least a decade old, and it's New Riff's first 50-50 bourbon
- 2:20and rye blend ever released. By the way, the label on this is super cool. I love it. It kind of reminds
- 2:25me a bit of like a mix of a Avril Lavigne and like a Paramore album cover, just with all the, you know,
- 2:31bright text, a little bit disjointed, a little bit funky. Really, really cool. So check out the label
- 2:36if you haven't yet. It's really exciting. Now personally, I've not had a chance to try this one,
- 2:40but I do love some of the experimental stuff that New Riff does. This one in particular is bottled
- 2:45without chill filtration and is bottled at 118.8 proof, and it will retail for about $150 per bottle.
- 2:53Now it's going to be available starting this Friday at the distillery for the New Riff Whiskey
- 2:58Club members. There's a limit of one bottle per person, and bottles must be picked up at the
- 3:02distillery. No shipping is offered at this time. That's one of the saddest things about New Riff is,
- 3:07you know, it's hard to get these things out of Kentucky. They're so wildly popular, they rarely
- 3:12make it out of the state. Sometimes I'll see them come out, you know, several months after.
- 3:16Like, I just saw the New Riff Winter Whiskey at my local store. I almost picked it up, but I figured
- 3:21I had enough bottles for next week's live stream. Next Thursday, I'm going to be doing a New Riff
- 3:26stream where I'm comparing the bourbon and the rye to the eight-year version of the bourbon and
- 3:31rye. So yeah, I'm looking forward to doing that stream next Thursday on YouTube at youtube.com
- 3:35slash bourbon bytes. But yeah, unfortunately, I will not have this Headliner Blend for that live
- 3:39stream. But I wanted to talk about it anyways, because it is a really cool bottle. It's for a
- 3:43really good cause. And man, 10-year-old New Riff, it's definitely getting up there in age. I'm just
- 3:48excited to try the eight-year next week. Well, speaking of new releases, this one's a fun one.
- 3:54Bardstown Bourbon Company just announced their Victoria Pineapple Finished Whiskey. Yeah, you
- 4:00heard that right. Pineapple Finished Whiskey. This is a Kentucky exclusive, and it is a marriage of
- 4:05mature bourbon and rye. And they said they set out to explore flavors that could be achieved
- 4:10through patience, process, and barrel influence rather than shortcuts. Dan Calloway, who's their
- 4:15master blender, says the goal was never to make a whiskey taste like pineapple. The goal was to
- 4:20understand what made these barrels so special in the first place. Now, this release is named
- 4:24after the Victoria Pineapple, which is apparently a variety celebrated for its intense sweetness,
- 4:30fragrant aroma, and historic connection to premium rum production on Barbados. So they
- 4:35custom blend of bourbon and rye in Caribbean-sourced pineapple rum casks. And what is pineapple rum?
- 4:42Well, apparently the production process of this actually added the Victoria Pineapples directly
- 4:48into the rum for maturation. Now, here's where it gets crazy. So Bardstown Bourbon Company
- 4:53seeked to mirror the process. So when they added their whiskey blend into this used barrel,
- 4:59they actually added fresh pineapple into it as well, and they let it sit there for 27 months.
- 5:04They replicated what was going on with this rum. I have no idea how this is going to taste. Listen,
- 5:10I've had pineapple flavored rum, but I've never had some of this distinctive pineapple matured
- 5:15rum. It sounds really, really cool. And I'm a big fan of Caribbean rum. So if I try this,
- 5:21I'm going to have to seek out a bottle of this pineapple rum to get a sense of what that flavor
- 5:25profile is and see how it compares to a whiskey that's also been blended with pineapples in the
- 5:31barrel. Now, this was going to be bottled at 106 proof. It's going to be available at the
- 5:36Bardstown Bourbon Company Distillery and Louisville Tasting Room starting this Friday as well
- 5:40for a suggested retail price of $140. It definitely seems like a fun summer drink.
- 5:48Haven't had a chance to try it. I don't know if any samples are on their way to me. If they are,
- 5:52I will definitely give this a review for you guys and let you know. I'll probably do a live
- 5:55stream where I compare it to the rum if it does come in. So fingers crossed, but not getting my
- 6:00hopes up. This is a very limited release. Another limited release worth talking about is the new
- 6:05Yellowstone Bourbon. This is their 11th release of their limited edition series. It is a blend
- 6:11of 7 and 14 year old Kentucky straight bourbons finished in ruby and tawny port cask, then married
- 6:17and bottled at a potent 101 proof. That's their words, not mine. I've tried some of these Yellowstone
- 6:23limited edition releases in the past. They are good. They're quite a bit pricey for what they
- 6:28are. You know, I think the flavor influence of the casks isn't as strong as I like it to be.
- 6:33This one comes in at $99 for a 750 milliliter bottle, which is fair for a 7 to 14 year old
- 6:39bourbon blend. Now this isn't coming out until this August, but if you are a fan of Yellowstone
- 6:44releases, this sounds like one of their strongest finishes yet. I do love a port finish, so maybe
- 6:49this will be the one that changes my mind. Maybe this will be the Yellowstone that convinces me to
- 6:52finally start buying Yellowstone. And last new whiskey release, I got to talk about the new
- 6:58Heaven Hill Double Mash bottled in bond. Now this is a follow up to the blue label bottled in bond
- 7:05that we all know and love from Heaven Hill, but this one is basically the same label. It just is
- 7:10red and it says double mash on it. It is a nine year old bottled in bond bourbon, bottled at 100
- 7:16proof, of course, and it unites their traditional and weeded bourbon mash bills, which I think is,
- 7:22I said, the first of a kind for Heaven Hill. So they're taking two thirds of their traditional
- 7:26mash bill, which is the 78% corn, 10% rye and 12% malted barley mash bill with one third of their
- 7:32wheated bourbon mash bill, which is 68% corn, 20% wheat and 12% malted barley. So this is like
- 7:38combining a Elijah Craig with a Larceny. Retail on it's only about $50. They say it's limited
- 7:44quantities available nationwide and it's going to start coming out this August. I think this is a fun
- 7:49companion to the bottled in bond bourbon and it kind of fits the middle ground between their
- 7:53Old Fitzgerald seven year, which is now a regular release everywhere or limited, but still available
- 7:59and their bottled in bond bourbon. It's kind of the blend of the two together, but even older. So
- 8:04I support it. I would love a chance to try it. I'm just a big fan of what Heaven Hill does and
- 8:09both of those mash bills I'm a big fan of and yeah, I'm just excited to give those a try,
- 8:13especially at the $50 price point. I think $50 for a bottled in bond nine year old bourbon,
- 8:18you can't go wrong with that price. All right, well that does it for this week's news. Now it's
- 8:22time to get into our Byte-Sized review. All right. Well, if you saw the thumbnail of this podcast,
- 8:36you know that I am drinking Michter's Barrel Strength Rye, and this was one of the first
- 8:42cast strength ryes that I ever fell in love with. Now this was originally released back in 2015.
- 8:48I was not drinking bourbon at all in that time period. I was barely old enough to drink at all,
- 8:53but I did try a 2019 release of this that made me fall in love with Michter's in general. So I'm very
- 8:59excited to revisit or visit for the first time for me a 2016 version of it. Now this is essentially
- 9:06just a barrel strength version of standard Michter's Rye. There's not an age statement,
- 9:10but it's believed to be about six to eight years old. And what's unique about Michter's is their
- 9:15barrel entry proof is only 103 proof. So it's interesting to see these come in at different
- 9:21proof points when they're bottled. Now I don't have the specific proof of this one, but looking
- 9:25at its sister barrels, it's around 113 to 114 proof just based on other ones. This is barrel
- 9:32number 16C410, but others in the similar range are right around 113, 114. So I'm just going to guess
- 9:39this is around that proof. Now, I unfortunately don't remember who sent me this sample, but I
- 9:43want to say a huge thank you to whoever it was. Because you obviously know my tastes and I'm really
- 9:49excited to revisit this classic. I think Michter's Rye is really good. I'm a big fan of their flavor
- 9:54profile. I've had their 10 year version. Of course I've had the Toasted Barrel Strength Rye, but
- 9:59even their standard barrel proof rye has just always been one of my favorites. So
- 10:03it's been a minute since I've tried it. So I'm excited to finally give it a review for the
- 10:06podcast. Let's go ahead and give it a nose. Oh, wow, man, that even just smells old. I mean,
- 10:13it has that vintage character that I've gotten on some other whiskeys from around that time period.
- 10:18Like I said, I wasn't drinking at the time, but I've been fortunate enough to find some older
- 10:22bottles of like Wild Turkey and the, you know, 2011 to 2015 age range, which isn't that long
- 10:27ago, but honestly, in the scheme of things, you know, that's 10 plus years. So the flavor profile,
- 10:32I think has changed quite a bit from back then. And I can just get it on the nose. This has a
- 10:37little bit of that copper note that I get on some older whiskeys, but one thing's for sure. This is
- 10:42definitely a rye. This is reading very, very herbaceous on the nose. I would say minty, but
- 10:49it's weird because it's like a minty and like a citrus thing happening at the same time. Very,
- 10:55very bright. Like I said, very different from a bourbon. It's got some nice baking spices there.
- 11:00Definitely more like a traditional rye bread kind of note, just amped up with that herbaceous like
- 11:06menthol kind of thing going on. There's definitely a bit of sweetness there, but it's leaning more
- 11:10floral. And again, back in the, the plant world of things, it's unique for sure. It's definitely
- 11:16not like I remember on the nose, but let's see how it holds up on the palate. Cheers.
- 11:24Ah, there we go. That is the flavor that I love. Wow. Crazy different from the nose. I mean,
- 11:29it has a little bit of that vintage quality that I was getting on the nose, but this is so much
- 11:33richer on the palate. And honestly, it drinks a really decent proof. Like it's a little hot,
- 11:39but the nose makes you think it's going to be higher proof than it is on the palate. It
- 11:42lingers on the mid palate and finish and really goes deeper and darker than I would have ever
- 11:48expected based on that nose alone. It's like a blend of brown sugar and a little bit of like
- 11:53burnt sugar, like a little bit too caramelized sugar, but it kind of rounds out those brighter
- 11:58notes from the nose and kind of makes it more cohesive in general. And there's definitely a
- 12:02lot of oak happening here. I mean, like I said, six to eight years old is what this is expected
- 12:06to be. I would guess maybe this initial release is potentially older just because that oak is
- 12:11showing up in such a strong way on the palate. I didn't get it on the nose, but on the palate,
- 12:16it is there. It is rich. And it's definitely, um, competing with some of those sweeter notes
- 12:21because it has that tannic element to it. The more and more I drink it, the more spicy it is
- 12:25on the palate, but it's like a spiced fruit. You know, on my live stream last week, I was
- 12:29reviewing a rum that had a very specific Christmas or like holiday spice to it.
- 12:33This is almost in that territory. And I said, that was very much clove or cardamom.
- 12:38Um, this is definitely leading towards cinnamon and clove, um, which are rare to me on a rye
- 12:43whiskey. I think honestly, this is one of the more unique tasting rye whiskeys I've ever had.
- 12:48And there's definitely a little bit of fruitiness here. If there's anything I can relate it to,
- 12:51I would say a little bit of like a plum. And I think that kind of compliments that cinnamon and
- 12:56clove flavor that I'm getting. That kind of reminds me of a bit of a holiday spice finish
- 13:00is of course, nice and long leans back in towards that herbal element, a little bit menthol on the
- 13:05very end of the finish, which I was getting on the nose. So it kind of makes sense to kind of
- 13:09round out that way as well. I mean, overall, this is a very unique whiskey. It definitely
- 13:14doesn't taste like I remember it tasting, but of course I first had it about seven years ago
- 13:19and this release is from 10 years ago. So things change. This is obviously some of their source
- 13:25distillate. I'm not exactly sure where it's from. Um, but this is definitely different than I
- 13:29remember it tasting. That being said, it's still very good and it's very much unlike most
- 13:34cask strength rye whiskeys you can get today. Now retail on this was $75 when it first came out.
- 13:41I think more recently retail has been closer to $120. I think that's a very fair price. Listen,
- 13:47it's always weird revisiting these older whiskeys for review because it's going to be a bit different
- 13:51than your experience if you pick up a bottle today. But if you do see a vintage bottle of this
- 13:55from 2015 or 2016, I want to let you know how I think about it in 2026. Is it worth paying the
- 14:02secondary for a vintage bottle? Well, let's go ahead and get into our rating because we rate
- 14:07everything out of a one to 10 scale here. We don't complicate it with different scores of nose, palate,
- 14:12finish, anything like that. It's just a single score for a single whiskey. And while this is
- 14:16incredibly unique, it's a little bit different from what I'm used to with some of their more
- 14:21releases. But that being said, it's really cool to try something from 10 years ago, especially
- 14:27one of their first releases of barrel strength rye. It's interesting to see how it's evolved.
- 14:31I personally think it's better now than it was back then, but I'm still going to give this a solid
- 14:36seven out of 10. Definitely nowhere near as good as some of the ones I've loved. Of course,
- 14:41I love their Toasted Rye at barrel strength even more than the barrel strength rye, but I've given
- 14:46the barrel strength rye from 2019 that I had. I think I gave that a 10 out of 10 when I reviewed
- 14:50it on my YouTube channel. So this one is not quite up there in terms of what I remember,
- 14:57but you know, memory fades, things change. Maybe this is just a specific bottling of it that just
- 15:02wasn't quite my jam, but seven out of 10 is a solid score for a barrel strength rye. Personally,
- 15:09I would have loved if the nose was a little bit more rich. I would have loved if the palate
- 15:13was a little bit brighter and finish. I wouldn't actually change anything about the finish. The
- 15:17finish is great, but I just think they're a little bit mismatched in terms of nose and palate. I
- 15:22wish they would have kind of been a little bit more similar because they're great things in both
- 15:25of them, but competing, they're a little odd. So if you get a chance to try an older release of
- 15:30this, definitely give it a try. I just personally have preferred the later releases and will
- 15:34continue to seek them out. If there's any other whiskeys that you'd like me to re-review or revisit
- 15:39since starting my YouTube channel, please let me know. I mean, I've been doing videos on there
- 15:44since 2018. I've been doing whiskey reviews. So there's definitely, my palate has changed
- 15:49quite a bit, I'm sure. And there's definitely some whiskeys that have changed as well. So
- 15:54would be really fun to revisit some of my previous favorites or some of my previous
- 15:58not so favorites and see how I feel about them today. Let me know if that's something you want
- 16:03to see. You can join our discord server at bourbonbytes.com. Leave any feedback or suggestions
- 16:08you want. I'm always happy to have them. You can also email me, contact@bourbonbytes.com.
- 16:13Until next time, this has been the Bourbon Bytes podcast, a whiskey podcast with a gaming twist.
- 16:19I'm your host Clifton. Cheers, and I will talk to you next week. Bye.