Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Social Psychology Explained: History, Principles & Research Methods
Transcript
- 0:00So quick question for you. Who do you think is
- 0:03happier, like an athlete who wins a silver medal
- 0:06or one who wins a bronze medal? Oh, that's a
- 0:08good one. Right. And OK, here's another one.
- 0:11If you are just absolutely furious, does punching
- 0:14a pillow actually calm you down? I mean, I feel
- 0:18like everyone thinks they know the answers to
- 0:19those. Exactly. But welcome to the psychology
- 0:23undergrad, everybody. We are two psychology undergrads.
- 0:27Just, you know. reviewing our notes and unpacking
- 0:30the mechanisms that drive literally every single
- 0:32human interaction. So glad you're joining our
- 0:35study session today. Yeah, it's great to have
- 0:37you here. We're looking at the foundational concepts
- 0:39of social psychology today. So definitely keep
- 0:41your answers to those two questions in mind.
- 0:43Yeah, because we are going to figure out exactly
- 0:46why humans act the way they do around others
- 0:48and honestly why our quote unquote common sense
- 0:51is just often completely backwards, totally backwards.
- 0:54And I think those questions are the perfect starting
- 0:56point. Right? Because they highlight the whole
- 0:59mission of social psychology. Like, we all interact
- 1:02with people every single day, so we kind of assume
- 1:04we're experts on human behavior. Right, because
- 1:06we do it all the time. Exactly. But when you
- 1:09actually put that human intuition under a scientific
- 1:11microscope, the results are just deeply surprising.
- 1:15I mean, we are looking at the scientific study
- 1:17of how we feel about, think about, and behave
- 1:23toward the people around us. Yeah, and before
- 1:25we can look at the research methods that actually
- 1:27answer the whole metal and pillow thing, we have
- 1:29to establish a baseline. Like, you can't understand
- 1:31complex social behavior without first breaking
- 1:34down the individual human experience into its
- 1:36most basic parts. Right, which brings us to the
- 1:39ABCs. Yes, the ABCs of social psychology. And
- 1:45to help, you know, lock this in for the exam
- 1:47or just life, I like to think of it as the heart,
- 1:50the hands, and the head. Oh, I like that. The
- 1:52heart, hands, and head. It's a really useful
- 1:54framework. So let's start with affect, you know,
- 1:56the heart. This encompasses the feelings we experience,
- 2:00specifically our moods and our emotions. And
- 2:03we really shouldn't think of affect as just fleeting
- 2:06or, like, irrational feelings. From an evolutionary
- 2:09standpoint, effect is this highly tuned internal
- 2:13alarm system. It's an information highway, essentially.
- 2:16Like if you feel happy, your affect is signaling
- 2:19that things are going well. Right. Which naturally
- 2:21encourages you to seek out socialization. Yeah,
- 2:23exactly. But if you feel anxious or angry, it's
- 2:27a signal that your environment might actually
- 2:29be dangerous, preparing you to either fight or
- 2:31flee. Which is purely a survival mechanism. And
- 2:34that flows directly into the bee, right? Behavior
- 2:36of the hands is what we actually do, how we interact
- 2:39with each other. Right. And in social psychology,
- 2:42behavior often boils down to two main concepts.
- 2:44So there's social exchange and reciprocal altruism.
- 2:48Okay. So social exchange is basically the economic
- 2:50side of human interaction, right? Yeah, pretty
- 2:53much. We constantly and usually subconsciously
- 2:55share goods, services, and emotions just to maximize
- 2:59our rewards and minimize our costs. Exactly.
- 3:02So like joining a study group, it costs you time.
- 3:05Maybe you have to share some of your own notes,
- 3:06but the reward is a better grade. and, you know,
- 3:10a social network. You're constantly weighing
- 3:12that cost -benefit analysis. Yeah. But reciprocal
- 3:16altruism is a little bit different, I think.
- 3:18That's more like cooperating with someone with
- 3:20the expectation that they'll return the favor
- 3:22eventually. Right. It was kind of the whole foundation
- 3:24of living in a society. Like, I help you move
- 3:26your couch today, and I fully expect you to help
- 3:28me jumpstart my car next month. Yep, exactly.
- 3:31And then we bring in the C. Cognition, the head.
- 3:34And this is where it gets incredibly complex.
- 3:36Because it's all in the brain. Right. Cognition
- 3:39is all about how we think and learn about others.
- 3:42Like, humans have this highly evolved cerebral
- 3:44cortex. And a massive portion of our brain power
- 3:48is specifically geared toward social cognition.
- 3:51We build these things called schemas. Basically
- 3:53mental blueprints, right? Exactly. They're knowledge
- 3:56representations we hold about a person or a group.
- 3:59And we develop attitudes which are just our baseline
- 4:01liking or disliking of something. But, you know,
- 4:04here is why I think the ABCs are more than just
- 4:07a memorization list. They don't operate in a
- 4:09vacuum. The reason human interaction isn't just
- 4:12a simple math equation is that different people
- 4:15use their cognition like their unique schemas
- 4:18to interpret the exact same event completely
- 4:21differently. That is such a crucial point. So
- 4:23let's say a co -worker offers to help you with
- 4:26a project. Okay. If your schema for that person
- 4:29is that they are kind and collaborative, your
- 4:33affect, your feelings will be positive, and your
- 4:35behavior will be to accept the help. Right, makes
- 4:38sense. But if your schema tells you that that
- 4:40specific coworker is fiercely competitive, you
- 4:43might interpret that exact same offer as an attempt
- 4:46to seal credit. Oh wow, yeah. So your affect
- 4:49immediately shifts to suspicion and your behavior
- 4:51becomes defensive. The event itself didn't change
- 4:54at all, the cognition did. Which brings us to
- 4:56a massive pivot point in our notes. So we have
- 4:58the ABCs, the individual parts. But what happens
- 5:01when you take that individual with their specific
- 5:03heart, hands, and head and drop them into a really
- 5:07pressured social environment? Enter Kurt Lewin.
- 5:09Yes, the father of social psychology. He formalized
- 5:13this dynamic into an equation, which is behavior
- 5:16is a function of the person and the social situation.
- 5:20B equals F of P and E. Right. And Lewin's equation
- 5:24insists that you can never really look at behavior
- 5:28by only looking at the person. You always, always
- 5:30have to factor in the environment. And historically,
- 5:34social psychologists have found something deeply
- 5:35unsettling about this. Yeah. That the situation
- 5:39is frequently a much stronger influence on behavior
- 5:41than a person's actual innate personality. Yes.
- 5:45I always think of Lewin's equation like a recipe
- 5:47to remember it better. Your unique traits, your
- 5:50ABCs, your morals, those are the raw ingredients.
- 5:53But the situation is the oven. OK. I like where
- 5:55this is going. You can have the absolute best,
- 5:58highest quality ingredients. But if you put that
- 5:59cake in an oven, cranked up to 1 ,000 degrees,
- 6:02the cake is going to burn. The environment just
- 6:04ruins the ingredients. That is a phenomenal way
- 6:07to visualize it. And we really have to remember
- 6:10the historical context here too. The field of
- 6:13social psychology was fundamentally energized
- 6:15by a very, very hot oven. which was World War
- 6:19II. Researchers were trying to comprehend the
- 6:22incomprehensible scale of the Holocaust. You
- 6:25had psychologists like Stanley Milgram and Philip
- 6:27Zimbardo conducting these famous experiments
- 6:29specifically to understand how ordinary, seemingly
- 6:33good people could be influenced by authority
- 6:36figures to commit terrible atrocities. The burning
- 6:38question was basically, does evil require evil
- 6:41people or just an evil situation? Exactly. And
- 6:44the research often pointed to the situation over
- 6:47power. But, and this is what I find profoundly
- 6:49moving, we also have historical examples of the
- 6:52exact opposite happening. When we talk about
- 6:55morality and human resilience, we have to look
- 6:57at the story of Raoul Wallenberg. Wallenberg's
- 6:59story is one of the most powerful case studies
- 7:01in human behavior, hands down. He was a Swedish
- 7:04diplomat coming from a very wealthy, comfortable
- 7:06family. In 1944, he was stationed in Budapest,
- 7:09Hungary. Which was a moment when the situation
- 7:11could not have been more tyrannical or deadly.
- 7:15The Nazis were deporting 10 to 12 ,000 Jews to
- 7:18gas chambers every single day. Yeah. And Wallenberg
- 7:21stepped into this horrific environment. And instead
- 7:24of conforming to the situation or just keeping
- 7:26his head down, which would have been the safest,
- 7:28most instinctual self -preservation tactic. He
- 7:32fought back using bureaucracy, of all things.
- 7:34Yes. He set up an office and basically hired
- 7:37400 Jewish volunteers just to give them diplomatic
- 7:40protection. And he invented a completely fake
- 7:44official looking Swedish passport called the
- 7:46Schützpass. He just made it up. Just made it
- 7:48up. Yeah. And handed it out to tens of thousands
- 7:50of people claiming they were under the protection
- 7:52of the Swedish government. He was literally utilizing
- 7:55the psychology of authority against the perpetrators.
- 7:58It's incredible. He created 32 safe houses, flying
- 8:02the Swedish flag over them to deter the Nazis.
- 8:05And his defiance just escalated. Right. Because
- 8:08as the Soviet army was invading from the East,
- 8:10the Nazis were preparing to basically slaughter
- 8:13the remaining Jews. population in Budapest. And
- 8:16Wallenberg sent a message directly to the Nazi
- 8:18commander, explicitly threatening that if the
- 8:21assault proceeded, Wallenberg would personally
- 8:23ensure the commander was hanged for crimes against
- 8:26humanity. And the crazy part is the commander
- 8:28backed down. He did. Wallenberg's sheer force
- 8:30of will saved up to a hundred thousand lives.
- 8:34Tragically, he was arrested by the Soviets shortly
- 8:37after and just vanished into their prison system.
- 8:40But his story isn't just a historical footnote.
- 8:43completely challenges that very cynical survival
- 8:46of the fittest view of human nature. It really
- 8:49does. Because evolutionary psychology often suggests
- 8:51human nature relies on two fundamental motivations.
- 8:55The first is self -concern, you know, protecting
- 8:57ourselves and our close kin. Right. We favor
- 8:59the reproductive success of our relatives, which
- 9:01is a concept known as kin selection, if the biological
- 9:03drive to ensure your genetic line survives. And
- 9:06if Wallenberg were entirely driven by self -concern,
- 9:09he would have just stayed in Sweden. Absolutely.
- 9:12But the second evolutionary motivation is other
- 9:14concern. We are deeply motivated to affiliate
- 9:18with, accept, and be accepted by strangers to
- 9:21build functional cooperative communities. Which
- 9:23is huge. Yeah, there's a profound moral implication
- 9:27here. It's so easy to look at the world and conclude
- 9:29that human beings are inherently selfish, you
- 9:32know, driven only by biological greed. But the
- 9:35underlying science shows that human beings are
- 9:37fundamentally wired to behave morally toward
- 9:39others and to display true altruism. And Wallenberg's
- 9:43actions represent the ultimate triumph of other
- 9:46concern. His moral compass extended far beyond
- 9:49his genetic kin. It extended to complete strangers
- 9:52in a foreign country. He's the perfect example
- 9:55of an individual's powerful moral ingredients
- 9:57that are internal person, overcoming a profoundly
- 10:00evil social situation. It proves that while our
- 10:02genes might be programmed for survival, individual
- 10:05human beings possess a capacity for profound
- 10:07self -sacrificing morality. Exactly. So, okay,
- 10:10we are biologically hardwired for connection.
- 10:12We need community. We have this deep -seated
- 10:14other concern. But that brings up a really dark
- 10:16inverse question. If we absolutely need that
- 10:18connection to survive, What happens when a group
- 10:21uses that need against us? What happens when
- 10:24a community completely cuts someone off? That
- 10:29taps directly into the mechanics of social influence.
- 10:32Because we desire affiliation so strongly, the
- 10:35people around us exert immense pressure on us.
- 10:37And this leads to the creation of social norms.
- 10:40Right, the shared, culturally defined ways of
- 10:43thinking and behaving. I actually think of norms
- 10:45as the invisible gravity of a culture. Invisible
- 10:47gravity, I like that. You don't see it, but it
- 10:49keeps everyone in orbit. It dictates what you
- 10:51eat for breakfast, how close you stand to someone
- 10:53in an elevator, how you express grief. But what
- 10:56happens when you break that gravity? Well, when
- 10:59you violate those norms, the group can deploy
- 11:01one of the most agonizing punishments in the
- 11:04human experience, which is ostracism. Yeah. And
- 11:07a really striking example of this in the textbook
- 11:09is a religious practice used among the Amish.
- 11:12When someone severely violates the rulings of
- 11:14an elder, they can be placed under a Maidun.
- 11:17Right, where the community entirely stops speaking
- 11:20to them. But it's not just like ignoring someone
- 11:22at a party. It is a total severing of social
- 11:25ties. Yeah, it's extreme. They won't eat with
- 11:27the person. They won't do business with them.
- 11:29They effectively treat the person as if they
- 11:32no longer exist until that person makes amends
- 11:35and conforms back to the norms. And the psychological
- 11:38mechanics behind the Maidung exist everywhere.
- 11:41Honestly, not just in strict religious communities.
- 11:44It happens in modern relationships when someone
- 11:46uses the silent treatment or online is cyber
- 11:49ostracism where a group Collectively blocks or
- 11:52ignores an individual. So when someone gives
- 11:54you the silent treatment, they aren't just being
- 11:56petty They are literally weaponizing our evolutionary
- 11:59biology, right? They are targeting our foundational
- 12:02need for connection precisely withholding affiliation
- 12:05is a super calculated tactic used to force conformity
- 12:09But what is truly staggering is how the human
- 12:11body processes this punishment. Oh yeah, the
- 12:14neuroscience part of this is wild. It is. Neuroscientists
- 12:17have used fMRI machines to monitor the brain
- 12:20activity of people experiencing simulated social
- 12:23exclusion. And they discover that social pain
- 12:26literally hurts. The brain registers the sting
- 12:29of rejection in the exact same neural pathways
- 12:32that process actual physical pain. Oh, that is
- 12:34just wild to me. It means the phrase heartbroken
- 12:37isn't just a metaphor. No, not at all. Your brain
- 12:40cannot tell the difference between being kicked
- 12:42out of a social group and being physically struck.
- 12:45Exactly. This is why having a stable support
- 12:48network is one of the most critical factors for
- 12:51human well -being. People with adequate social
- 12:53support are happier. fewer psychological problems,
- 12:57and they physically live longer. Social isolation
- 13:00is devastating because it attacks our core biological
- 13:02programming. We are built to belong. Okay, so
- 13:06if social gravity is invisible and our need to
- 13:09belong is so powerful that it dictates our behavior
- 13:11without us even realizing it, that brings us
- 13:14to a major problem. It means our own internal
- 13:16compass, our common sense is deeply flawed. Oh,
- 13:19absolutely. We think we understand exactly why
- 13:21we do things, but we usually don't. Which is
- 13:23precisely why social psychology cannot just rely
- 13:26on philosophical pondering or everyday observation.
- 13:29It must use the empirical approach. We have to
- 13:33systematically analyze observable data rather
- 13:36than just trusting our gut. And let's prove that
- 13:39right now by circling back to the hook from the
- 13:41beginning of our deep dive, the common sense
- 13:43test. Let's do it. First question, who is happier?
- 13:46The silver medalist or the bronze medalist? Common
- 13:50sense almost universally says silver, because
- 13:52second place is objectively better than third
- 13:54place. Right. But the empirical research shows
- 13:57the bronze medalist is actually visibly happier.
- 14:00Visibly happier. Yes. And the mechanism behind
- 14:02this is called counterfactual thinking. Basically,
- 14:06cognitive comparisons. The silver medalist compares
- 14:08up. They're fixated on the counterfactual. If
- 14:11I had just been a fraction of a second faster,
- 14:13I would have won gold. Their baseline of comparison
- 14:16is perfection, so they feel a profound sense
- 14:19of loss. But the bronze medalist compares down.
- 14:21They aren't looking at the gold. They are looking
- 14:23at fourth place. Their counterfactual is, I almost
- 14:26didn't get a medal at all. So their emotional
- 14:29response is sheer relief and joy. The objective
- 14:32reality that second is better than third is completely
- 14:35overridden by the subjective cognitive comparison.
- 14:39It completely overrides it. And then there's
- 14:41the second question. Does punching a pillow calm
- 14:44you down when you're angry? Right. Common sense
- 14:47relies on the idea of catharsis. The idea that
- 14:50anger is like steam in a kettle and you have
- 14:53to let it out so you don't explode. So intuitively
- 14:55punching a pillow should relieve the pressure.
- 14:58But the empirical data proves that completely
- 15:00wrong. Engaging in aggressive behavior even toward
- 15:03an inanimate object actually increases your aggressive
- 15:07tendencies. Yeah, it makes it worse. By punching
- 15:09the pillow, you aren't releasing anger, you are
- 15:12rehearsing it. You're priming your brain's neural
- 15:14pathways for aggression, which keeps your physiological
- 15:17arousal high. You are essentially pouring gasoline
- 15:20on the fire. Nevers has countless examples of
- 15:22this. Research shows people pull less hard in
- 15:25a tug of war when they are in a group compared
- 15:27to when they pull alone, which is a phenomenon
- 15:30called social loafing or subliminal advertising.
- 15:33Despite decades of marketers claiming they can
- 15:36brainwash you with hidden flashes of images,
- 15:38the data shows it's actually incredibly ineffective
- 15:40at changing consumer behavior. But here's the
- 15:43funny thing about all of this. The moment you
- 15:45explain the bronze medalist comparing down, or
- 15:48the pillow punching rehearsing aggression, it
- 15:51instantly makes sense. And we all think, oh yeah,
- 15:54I knew that. I call it the I knew it all along
- 15:56syndrome. Oh yeah. In psychology, that's known
- 15:59as hindsight bias. It is our innate tendency
- 16:02to think we could have predicted an outcome after
- 16:04learning what that outcome is. Once we hear the
- 16:07explanation, our brains seamlessly integrated
- 16:10into our worldview. Basically tricking us into
- 16:13thinking psychology is just common sense. And
- 16:15to combat that bias, researchers have to use
- 16:18really rigorous research designs. Usually this
- 16:21falls into three categories, right? Observational,
- 16:23correlational, and experimental. Right. But observational
- 16:26research is sometimes the only way to study really
- 16:29intense phenomena that you can't ethically recreate.
- 16:32And this leads to one of my absolute favorite
- 16:34studies in the history of psychology. Oh, I know
- 16:35which one you're talking about. Leon Festinger
- 16:37infiltrating a doomsday cult in 1954. It is a
- 16:41landmark piece of observational research. So
- 16:44Festinger learned about a group whose leader
- 16:46claimed to be receiving automatic writing from
- 16:49aliens on a planet called Clarion. Clarion? Yeah.
- 16:53These aliens supposedly warned that the world
- 16:55would be destroyed by a massive flood on December
- 16:5821, 1954. but that the true believers would be
- 17:01rescued by a flying saucer at midnight. Obviously.
- 17:04Spoiler alert. The world did not end. But Festinger
- 17:07didn't actually care about the aliens. He wanted
- 17:09to see the exact moment the prophecy failed.
- 17:12Exactly. Because you can't put an advertisement
- 17:14in the paper saying, wanted people to join a
- 17:16fake doomsday cult for a psych experiment. No,
- 17:19definitely not ethical. Right. You have to observe
- 17:21them in the wild. So Festinger and his colleagues
- 17:23joined the cult undercover. And they sat with
- 17:26the group on the night of December 20th. Midnight
- 17:29arrived. No flying saucer, right? 12 .05 passes,
- 17:3312 .10. The group just sat there in stunned,
- 17:37terrified silence. But then the leader received
- 17:41another quote unquote message. She announced
- 17:44that the aliens had spared the earth, specifically
- 17:46because this small group of believers had spread
- 17:49so much light and faith. Instead of admitting
- 17:51they were wrong, they just doubled down. They
- 17:53literally immediately started calling newspapers
- 17:56to spread the word. And Festinger realized that
- 17:58the members were experiencing this massive psychological
- 18:01tension. They had quit their jobs. They had given
- 18:03away their money. To admit they were wrong would
- 18:05just shatter their egos. So to resolve the tension,
- 18:08they basically changed their perception of reality.
- 18:11They decided their faith saved the world. And
- 18:13this incredible observation led directly to Festinger
- 18:16formulating the theory of cognitive dissonance,
- 18:19which is the mental discomfort we feel when our
- 18:21beliefs contradict our reality or our actions.
- 18:24But, you know, here's where I get a little tripped
- 18:26up by the science. I get how you can observe
- 18:28a cult, but if you want to run an actual experiment
- 18:30to prove cognitive dissonance or love or prejudice,
- 18:34how do you do that? It's tricky. Because you
- 18:37can't put dissonance on a scale and weigh it.
- 18:39If it's invisible, how do we know it's rigorous
- 18:42science and not just a researcher's subjective
- 18:45opinion? That is the ultimate challenge of psychological
- 18:48research, and it's solved by a process called
- 18:50operationalization. You have to transition from
- 18:52a conceptual variable to an operational definition.
- 18:56Okay, break that down for me. So the conceptual
- 18:58variable is the abstract idea you want to study.
- 19:01Let's say the conceptual variable is how much
- 19:03Sarah likes Robert. You cannot directly measure
- 19:07liking. It's an invisible emotion. Right. So
- 19:10you have to create an operational definition,
- 19:12which is the concrete, physical, measurable behavior
- 19:16that represents the concept. So instead of trying
- 19:19to measure the abstract feeling of affection,
- 19:22you measure the physical reality. Like you measure
- 19:24how many millimeters her pupils dilate when Robert
- 19:26walks into the room. Yes, exactly. Or you track
- 19:29how many hours a week she voluntarily chooses
- 19:31to spend with them. Or, at the very simplest,
- 19:34you use a self -report questionnaire where she
- 19:36ranks her feelings on a numeric scale. Exactly.
- 19:39You make the invisible visible. Going back to
- 19:42the pillow -punching experiment, the conceptual
- 19:44variable is aggression. The operational definition
- 19:47might be measuring a person's heart rate, or
- 19:50giving them an opportunity to administer a loud,
- 19:54unpleasant noise blast to another participant
- 19:56in a game, and then measuring how long they hold
- 19:59down the button. Oh, wow. Right. If they hold
- 20:01the noise button longer after punching the pillow,
- 20:04you have empirically proven that the aggression
- 20:06increased. You've completely bypassed intuition.
- 20:09That brings it all together perfectly. We covered
- 20:11a massive amount of ground in this study session
- 20:13today. We really did. We started with the foundational
- 20:16ABCs, effect, behavior, and cognition, the individual
- 20:20ingredients of the human experience. We explored
- 20:23Lewin's equation, highlighting how behavior is
- 20:25a function of the person and the situation. And
- 20:28we saw the profound moral implications of that
- 20:30in Raoul Wallenberg's story, which proves that
- 20:32human nature possesses this extraordinary capacity
- 20:35for other concern and true altruism. We also
- 20:38looked at how our deep evolutionary need for
- 20:40connection makes social norms so powerful and
- 20:43how is weaponized to the point that it literally
- 20:47causes physical pain in the human brain. And
- 20:49finally, we dismantled our reliance on common
- 20:52sense and hindsight bias. We saw why we need
- 20:55empirical observation, like Festinger's cult
- 20:58study, and how we transition from abstract conceptual
- 21:01variables to concrete operational definitions.
- 21:04Right. And before we wrap up, I really want to
- 21:06leave you with a final thought to mull over as
- 21:08you navigate the rest of your day. Think about
- 21:10the most significant decision you made recently.
- 21:13Maybe it was a career choice, how you handled
- 21:15an argument, or even just what you decided to
- 21:17wear today. Ask yourself, how much of that choice
- 21:20was truly driven by your own unique personality,
- 21:23your internal moral compass, the person? And
- 21:26how much of it was quietly, invisibly dictated
- 21:29by the situation? The unwritten social norms,
- 21:32the subtle fear of being ostracized, or the gravitational
- 21:34pull of the people around you. Are you truly
- 21:36the independent author of all your actions, or
- 21:38are you just reacting to the invisible gravity
- 21:40of your environment? It's a question that completely
- 21:43shifts how you view your own autonomy. And I
- 21:46think it makes you look at every interaction
- 21:48just a little bit differently. It absolutely
- 21:51does. Well, thank you so much for joining our
- 21:52study session here on The Psychology Undergrad.
- 21:55Keep questioning your common sense, and we'll
- 21:57catch you next time.