Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Skid Steers as Weapons and the Continued Legal Battles Over Health Worker Vaccinations
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for our regular segment with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 0:03Adam Stirling: It's Legally Speaking on CFAX 1070.
- 0:06Adam Stirling: Morning, michael.
- 0:07Adam Stirling: How are we doing?
- 0:07Adam Stirling: Hey, good morning, I'm doing great.
- 0:09Adam Stirling: Always good to be here.
- 0:10Adam Stirling: Some interesting stories on the agenda this week.
- 0:12Adam Stirling: Where shall we start?
- 0:15Michael Mulligan: Well, why don't we start in Vernon if for no other reason than to realize that not all problems that we might have in Victoria are isolated to Victoria?
- 0:24Michael Mulligan: Indeed, so this is an interesting case.
- 0:28Michael Mulligan: It's a man who was in his 60s, with no previous criminal record, who was charged with both dangerous driving and assault with a weapon.
- 0:40Michael Mulligan: The interesting elements include the alleged weapon in assault or the alleged weapon was a skid steer like a digger device and the alleged driving of an assault were in relation to an effort to remove two people from his property, and a few elements of this could ring true in Victoria as well.
- 1:04Michael Mulligan: First of all, the background involves two people who are described as homeless and claim to have been taking one last bicycle ride on a bicycle trail in Vernon before planning to apparently that day go and leave the drug subculture to deal with their substance use disorder, who decided to stop and take a rest on this man's property.
- 1:32Michael Mulligan: Apparently that had been an issue with other individuals stopping.
- 1:37Michael Mulligan: Sounds like the bike lane went by his property and there have been issues in the past, although no indication that these two people had previously been on the man's property.
- 1:48Michael Mulligan: The man gets home the skid steer owner and decides to go over and ask these people to leave his lawn.
- 1:56Michael Mulligan: They don't move from where they are.
- 2:00Michael Mulligan: Apparently they thought they had a right to be there.
- 2:02Michael Mulligan: The man then tried calling bylaw.
- 2:05Michael Mulligan: They told him to phone the police.
- 2:07Michael Mulligan: He didn't phone the police.
- 2:08Michael Mulligan: Instead, what he did was turn on his lawn sprinkler, trying to get the people to move.
- 2:13Michael Mulligan: By doing that they got wet, but they didn't leave.
- 2:16Michael Mulligan: The man then decided to turn it up a notch by going and getting in his skid steer bobcat, which he used for his landscaping business.
- 2:24Michael Mulligan: This is where things start to go sideways.
- 2:26Michael Mulligan: The property owner decides to go over and use the skid steer to push the property of the two people Apparently they had all of their worldly belongings with them push their property off of his yard in order to try to get the people to move.
- 2:46Michael Mulligan: That didn't produce a positive outcome, probably combined with the sprinkler effort.
- 2:51Michael Mulligan: And now this and things escalated further, with the male individual deciding to try to stop the bobcat using a chain and then also apparently picking up a handsaw and damaging a flower bed.
- 3:11Michael Mulligan: I guess out of anger for the effort to remove the belongings with the skid steer, the man then pushed the belongings more than just off his property, which was something the judge focused on pushing them further down the bicycle path to in front of his neighbor's house, which were not appreciated by the neighbor and certainly not by the two people involved, and in that entire process, the female person who was on the property.
- 3:37Michael Mulligan: It was unclear whether she was hit by the skid steer in the shin there is some dispute about that but the evidence appeared to be that the driver of the skid steer was driving the skid steer towards these people trying to get them to get off his yard, may or may not have contacted with them, that's made contact with the shin of the woman, and so the judge had to sort out is this dangerous driving and is this an assault with a weapon?
- 4:12Michael Mulligan: And part of that legal analysis starts with well, what is a weapon?
- 4:15Michael Mulligan: And usually it's not going to be a skid steer.
- 4:17Michael Mulligan: But the definition of weapon in the criminal code for the purpose of the assault provision is pretty broad.
- 4:24Michael Mulligan: Weapon in the criminal code for the purpose of the assault provision is pretty broad and it says that a weapon means anything used, designed to be used or intended for use in causing death or injury to any person or for the purpose of threatening or intimidating any person.
- 4:36Michael Mulligan: That's the definition.
- 4:37Michael Mulligan: And so, given that broad definition, even though you're not usually going to have a skid steer device as a weapon, the judge found that it did constitute a weapon here.
- 4:46Michael Mulligan: And then the other challenge for the Bobcat driver property owner is that the definition of what can constitute an assault is fairly broad.
- 4:57Michael Mulligan: And first of all, the judge seemed to accept that this woman's shin was contacted by the skid steer.
- 5:04Michael Mulligan: Accept that this woman's shin was contacted by the skid steer, but you can also commit an assault if you're engaged in the threatened application of force to someone else, and the judge found as well that that was made out on the basis of how the bobcat was being driven.
- 5:22Michael Mulligan: All of that then brought the judge to the analysis of dangerous driving.
- 5:26Michael Mulligan: And again, you don't usually see a lot of dangerous driving cases involving landscaping equipment, but the legal analysis would be the same as if you were dealing with a car.
- 5:38Michael Mulligan: And this was an issue for the Supreme Court of Canada a number of years ago in terms of what's required for the criminal code offense of dangerous driving, and the Supreme Court of Canada a number of years ago in terms of what's required for the criminal code offense of dangerous driving and the Supreme Court of Canada had to wrestle with the issue of does that require somebody to intentionally drive in a dangerous way?
- 5:55Michael Mulligan: Because you know the issue is, most criminal offenses involve an element of mens rea, right Like the intent to do something wrong.
- 6:02Michael Mulligan: And the issue was well, well, does that mean that somebody has to constitute the criminal offense of dangerous driving as opposed to, for example, driving without due care and attention under the Motor Vehicle Act?
- 6:13Michael Mulligan: Does that mean that the person has to set out saying, okay, I'm about to be dangerous, here I go, or is something sort of less than that?
- 6:21Michael Mulligan: What is required?
- 6:23Michael Mulligan: And ultimately the Supreme Court of Canada landed on less than that, in the sense that the mens rea required for dangerous driving doesn't involve a necessity to prove the person subjectively intended to drive in a dangerous way.
- 6:37Michael Mulligan: What's required is for the Crown to prove that the driving was a marked departure from the standard of care of a reasonably prudent driver.
- 6:46Michael Mulligan: So it's sort of objective in that way.
- 6:48Adam Stirling: Yeah.
- 6:49Michael Mulligan: And sometimes the way I describe that to people is it's like you know what's the difference between driving without due care and attention and dangerous driving.
- 6:57Michael Mulligan: You know, what is a marked departure?
- 6:59Michael Mulligan: Sometimes I would describe that as you know, it's the kind of driving that would cause people to say, oh my goodness, that person is going to kill someone, right, and you know, phone the police out of worry about the driving, as opposed to just hey, you shouldn't have been changing your CD for so long, or hey, that person's going a bit fast.
- 7:17Michael Mulligan: And so here the judge didn't have too much difficulty finding that the bobcat was being driven in that kind of a way, a marked departure from the standard of care of a reasonably prudent driver.
- 7:30Michael Mulligan: Because it was quite close to these people might have made contact with the shin of the woman, and so on the basis of that, the judge found that not only was assault with a weapon made out, but dangerous driving was made out.
- 7:44Michael Mulligan: One of the implications of that and it's not dealt with in the decision is that if you get a criminal code driving conviction like that, you're going to wind up with a driving prohibition imposed under the Motor Vehicle Act, and so that's going to be a significant consequence for somebody who operates machinery and is a landscaping business.
- 8:06Michael Mulligan: So that's the outcome of it, and I thought it was worth mentioning both for those legal concepts of what's a weapon and what's dangerous, driving the conviction.
- 8:15Michael Mulligan: But it's also just an example of, I guess, the level of frustration, not only in Victoria and Vancouver but other parts of the province you know, with some of the social disorder that we've all seen or many of have seen, that's flowed from drug use and so that's not limited to larger cities.
- 8:38Michael Mulligan: That's the sort of frustration that's resulted in this very unfortunate incident.
- 8:43Michael Mulligan: Clearly, you know, don't take the skid steer into your own hands, but you know you can tell reading this thing that what this person just eventually was otherwise described as law-abiding and no record, eventually it sounds like just went overboard after dealing with, sounds like multiple occasions when people were trespassing and transient people living on or being on this property and these people not responding, being on his property and these people not responding.
- 9:13Michael Mulligan: I must say I also smiled with the clearly this would come from the evidence of the two people that they were allegedly going on one last bike ride to the beach before going to get away from the drug subculture and get treatment for their substance use disorder.
- 9:27Michael Mulligan: You know, I must say, as a criminal lawyer who spent a lot of time sitting in remand court, you, with some frequency, hear similar stories of good intentions that you know that of course get interfered with when you know just that one, last, one, last trip I was just on my way to the treatment center and it just happens to be that this was the unfortunate time that I usually first.
- 9:52Michael Mulligan: First it gets arrested or something goes haywire.
- 9:54Michael Mulligan: You know they get picked up on that outstanding warrant or whatever it might be.
- 9:58Michael Mulligan: But you know here.
- 9:59Michael Mulligan: You know, after some 20 years of being homeless and being addicted to drugs it sounds like that was their explanation this was their one last trip by bicycle to the beach before they were planning to go get clean.
- 10:11Michael Mulligan: So that's the story out of Vernon and, if nothing else, it's a cautionary tale and should make you feel like perhaps we're not alone dealing with some of these things.
- 10:22Michael Mulligan: There are obviously issues and frustrations all over British Columbia.
- 10:26Michael Mulligan: So that's the skid steer and the dangerous driving All right Up.
- 10:29Adam Stirling: Next, on Legally Speaking challenges to public health orders firing health workers who are not vaccinated largely dismissed.
- 10:37Adam Stirling: What does that mean?
- 10:38Adam Stirling: We'll talk about it after this.
- 10:39Adam Stirling: Back on the air here at CFAX 1070.
- 10:42Adam Stirling: Legally Speaking as we continue with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defence Lawyers Michael, you and I have discussed a number of times British Columbia's public health orders with respect to vaccination requirements in the workplace and there was an update in this matter this week.
- 10:56Michael Mulligan: British Columbia's public health orders with respect to vaccination requirements in the workplace, and there was an update in this matter this week.
- 11:01Michael Mulligan: Indeed, there was, and there are a few interesting elements to it.
- 11:04Michael Mulligan: First of all, this was a challenge brought to public health orders made by Dr Bonnie Henry in October of 2023.
- 11:09Michael Mulligan: So it's sort of interesting because it's dealing with orders that were made, you know, not that long ago, and this was a challenge heard.
- 11:23Michael Mulligan: The court heard together 15 different challenges combined into this one case, and the case was comprised of a whole collection of people who were healthcare workers in British Columbia.
- 11:32Michael Mulligan: There's a surgeon, several doctors, administrators, therapists, nurses, nurse practitioners, a whole bunch of people, psychiatrists all of whom had been fired for not getting vaccinated for COVID vaccinated for COVID and the challenges that were brought included, first of all, a challenge to the reasonableness of the decision to fire all of these people as a result of not being vaccinated in 2023.
- 12:08Michael Mulligan: And so part of the argument there was hey, this is no longer an emergency.
- 12:11Michael Mulligan: And so part of the argument there was hey, this is no longer an emergency.
- 12:14Michael Mulligan: You know, virtually everyone who wished to be vaccinated was vaccinated.
- 12:18Michael Mulligan: Other arguments included.
- 12:19Michael Mulligan: This is unreasonable because other people are permitted into health facilities, who are not vaccinated, patients, construction workers, all kinds of other people.
- 12:30Michael Mulligan: And so there was an argument that, hey, this is just not reasonable to fire all of these people or not permit them to return to work in 2023, arguing, hey, this isn't some earlier time dealing with COVID and various other?
- 12:47Michael Mulligan: And I should say, on that front, the important thing to bear in mind is that when you're doing what's called a judicial doing a judicial review of an administrative decision in this case, the administrative decision issuing this order in 2023 prohibiting these people from working or firing them the analysis in court is not an analysis of whether the judge thinks that was the right decision.
- 13:12Michael Mulligan: It's an assessment of whether the decision is reasonable.
- 13:14Michael Mulligan: Like you know, is this a decision within the realm of reasonable decisions that somebody could have made with the evidence available to them, and on that assessment, the judge concluded that well, of course, there are all kinds of different factors in 2023, scientific evidence about the state of COVID and all of these things found that, nonetheless, there was enough evidence to conclude that the order even in 2023, remained a reasonable one, with one interesting exception one of the categories of people who were fired were people who worked remotely, and so on that particular ground, the judge found that the decision to fire them or not permit them to return to work where they work remotely and have no interaction with patients at all.
- 14:12Michael Mulligan: it applied to them too, and the judge found that for that category of health workers it did not appear to be reasonable.
- 14:19Adam Stirling: Yeah, that makes sense Order that be reviewed.
- 14:22Michael Mulligan: Why would you fire the person who works at home on the?
- 14:24Michael Mulligan: That be reviewed.
- 14:27Michael Mulligan: Why would you fire the person who works at home over Skype or something?
- 14:31Michael Mulligan: And so the other challenges that were brought included a challenge that this breached the religious freedom Some of the people here there was evidence that I think the nurse practitioner in this claim attended a church which opposed vaccination on the basis that it quote, attended a church which opposed vaccination on the basis that, it quote, interfered with the providence of God.
- 14:48Michael Mulligan: Close quote and the judge found that it did in fact breach her freedom of religion because she had religious grounds for not getting vaccinated, but nonetheless.
- 15:01Michael Mulligan: The judge then engaged in a weighing and found that the importance of the public health objectives outweighed the breach of her religious freedom and it was constitutionally permissible to fire the nurse practitioner.
- 15:19Michael Mulligan: No-transcript protect your right to be, to work or to work in any specific profession, nor does it protect people against the stress or hardship of being refused entry into a profession or their ability to work, and so found that the constitutional arguments didn't fly here for the people who had non-religious grounds, and even the religious ground, even though that was infringed on a weighing, concluded that that was permissible.
- 16:24Michael Mulligan: Interestingly, the current state of affairs it's reflected in the judgment requires that in order to be employed or continue to be employed it's necessary for health care workers to be vaccinated.
- 16:40Michael Mulligan: But there isn't a requirement although they recommend it that health care workers receive an updated vaccine against the XBB.1.5 vaccine, although that is a requirement for new people who wish to work in any of the health fields in British Columbia.
- 17:00Michael Mulligan: So if somebody, even now, in 2024, even if they were originally vaccinated, they would be unable to get employment in a health field as a result of the order unless they also received the newest booster version.
- 17:16Michael Mulligan: And so that requirement applies to new people that wish to get jobs as nurses or doctors.
- 17:21Michael Mulligan: But they won't fire people who haven't got the booster, they just recommend it, which is an interesting distinction.
- 17:30Michael Mulligan: And so that's the state of affairs.
- 17:31Michael Mulligan: Virtually all of it was dismissed, with that one exception that it was viewed as unreasonable to fire people that work remotely for not being vaccinated, which it's surprising that that wouldn't have been apparent to anyone earlier that perhaps that is not a reasonable requirement.
- 17:46Michael Mulligan: And so even on that ground, the judge didn't just reverse it, the judge sent it back for reconsideration, and so Dr Henry will need to revisit or reconsider the government decision to fire those people who work remotely or not permit them to apply for work again.
- 18:08Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest on COVID.
- 18:10Michael Mulligan: The litigation continues and, interestingly, the orders continue even into 2024.
- 18:17Adam Stirling: All right, we have four minutes left and I think we still have that one story with the benefits and the CCP or CPP payments.
- 18:28Michael Mulligan: Indeed, we do so.
- 18:29Michael Mulligan: Uh, this was a application brought by a fellow who had been receiving uh persons with disability benefits and the essence of those it's like a higher amount of social assistance that would be provided by the province if somebody uh has a disability.
- 18:44Michael Mulligan: Um, it's still not a plush amount of money, but more than, I suppose, what's provided if somebody doesn't have a disability.
- 18:50Michael Mulligan: And the issue or the claim here was that this person then became eligible for Canadian pension plan disability payments and the policy the provincial policy is to deduct dollar for dollar any other income the person's receiving, in this case these Canadian pension plan disability benefits.
- 19:14Michael Mulligan: And the complaint the recipient had even though the dollar amount of the two things is the same at the end of the day was that the CPP benefits are taxable, and so the result for him was that when the province deducted the CPP benefits from his persons with disability benefits, he had to then pay tax and it resulted in him having less money.
- 19:43Michael Mulligan: And so he brought this claim, arguing that it meant that the province was being unjustly enriched by not having to pay him more for his persons with disability benefits.
- 19:59Michael Mulligan: The amount involved was a deduction in his person with disability benefits of $642 a month.
- 20:06Michael Mulligan: I guess that's how much he was getting from CPP.
- 20:09Michael Mulligan: But the problem with that even though I suppose there's certainly an argument based on hey, is this fair right?
- 20:17Michael Mulligan: Should there be a lower amount?
- 20:19Michael Mulligan: If somebody's getting CPP benefits, that doesn't make out a cause of action, right?
- 20:25Michael Mulligan: You can't succeed in a court claim by arguing, hey, that doesn't make out a cause of action, right.
- 20:27Michael Mulligan: You can't succeed in a court claim by arguing, hey, that's not fair.
- 20:30Michael Mulligan: Or you know, hey, that legislation shouldn't say that you need to have some legal cause of action.
- 20:38Michael Mulligan: And so the judge here was dealing with an application by counsel for the province of British Columbia to have this claim dismissed, showing on the basis that it had no prospect of success.
- 20:52Michael Mulligan: It was just doomed to fail.
- 20:53Michael Mulligan: And the judge at the end of the day concluded that indeed that was the case, that even though the man's winding up with less money as a result of this federal payment and how the province deals with deducting that, that that didn't make out a tort or cause of action against the provincial government.
- 21:13Michael Mulligan: And so the result is that even though the man's getting less money and even the, he doesn't have a basis to bring a court case to complain about it.
- 21:22Michael Mulligan: The I suppose the small mercy for the man at the end of the day is that the council didn't seek costs against him when the claim was dismissed, because ordinarily, of course, costs would follow the cause and if you sue and don't succeed, the default position would be you're going to need to pay a portion of the legal expenses of the party that you sued.
- 21:46Michael Mulligan: So while the man's going to wind up with less money every month, at least he won't be winding up with an order that he pay the costs of the provincial government in having his claim dismissed.
- 21:56Adam Stirling: Yeah, that's actually an important thing to point out, as always, michael, thank you so much.
- 22:01Michael Mulligan: Very good.
- 22:01Michael Mulligan: Thank you so much.
- 22:02Michael Mulligan: Always a pleasure to be here.
- 22:03Michael Mulligan: All right, Michael.
- 22:03Adam Stirling: Mulligan, with Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 22:05Adam Stirling: Legally speaking, we do.