Latest / Beyond This by Zaheerah Bham Ismail / When tragedy strikes - Season 2 - Episode 8: why do we forward before we pause?
Transcript
- 0:14Assalam olicom rahmatullahi wabarakatuh and welcome back to
- 0:18Beyond This with me Zahira Bam Ismael.
- 0:21Today's conversation is something that affects every
- 0:23single one of us as members of this community because either we
- 0:28part of it, either we contributing to it or we
- 0:31commenting on it. And I think it's something that
- 0:34we need to realise this conversation, this episode is
- 0:37not just for sensationalism. It's about how we as a community
- 0:41deal with tragedy that affects us and our responsibility and
- 0:45our roles in it. So often we hear of something
- 0:48happening, something tragic unfolding, whether we watching
- 0:52it or someone videos it or a message, something that's
- 0:54happened to someone's family. And we so quick to forward these
- 0:58messages out thinking we helping, but in actual fact, we
- 1:03end up doing far more harm to the situation than we are doing
- 1:07any form of help. We watch things unfold and they,
- 1:12we, we don't live in a bubble. We don't live in a utopia.
- 1:15We know that there are many things that are happening in our
- 1:17communities, in people's homes, things that we see outside with
- 1:23whatever it is, whatever the kind of news is, it's not
- 1:25specific to any one particular incident.
- 1:28But the truth of it is we have to wonder and we have to
- 1:31question our own individual responsibility in it.
- 1:35Just because we receive a message on social media, just
- 1:38because we receive a video on social media, just because we
- 1:42receive somebody else's narrative on social media or on
- 1:47our Whatsapps, doesn't mean we have to forward it.
- 1:50We have to get out of this mindset of feeling.
- 1:52I'm the first one that saw it. I'm the first one that's sharing
- 1:54it. I've got inside information.
- 1:56So what it means nothing. We have to stop just pressing
- 2:00forward without thinking about the dignity of the families that
- 2:04this affects. You know, so many times people
- 2:08will say ohh, but it's true. Just because it's true doesn't
- 2:11mean it's that we need to shade and justice because we shade
- 2:14doesn't make it true either. Everything will always be seen
- 2:17from a different perspective. We have no idea what any
- 2:20particular family or families are going through and with us
- 2:23sharing information or misinformation.
- 2:26All we do is we take away the dignity of the families
- 2:29involved. I often see car accident pitches
- 2:33being forwarded, horrific pictures being forwarded.
- 2:35And I wonder if that was my family member, would I have
- 2:38really wanted somebody else to just forward this out without
- 2:42feeling anything for it? You know, when we forward these
- 2:45messages out and we talk about it and we have these discussions
- 2:48about it and we all have an opinion and essay about it, we
- 2:51fail to realise that those very families that have been so
- 2:54deeply affected by it are still living that reality.
- 2:59You and I, even though we get to switch off in a wave of the
- 3:02things that don't haunt us after we see them or we hear them, but
- 3:07our lives still continue. And those families lives have
- 3:10stopped in that moment. Those families lives have been
- 3:13deeply affected by the trauma of that moment.
- 3:17And all of us continue having an opinion.
- 3:19And what we don't seem to understand is every single time
- 3:22we press forward or we shade or we make a comment about it, or
- 3:26we share an opinion on it, or we share what we think the truth is
- 3:30on it, we contributing to taking away the dignity of that family.
- 3:35And we don't even realise how deeply that's going to affect
- 3:39them and how it's going to affect everyone around them.
- 3:42So when we talk about that responsibility that we have,
- 3:45that responsibility starts with me and you.
- 3:48We need to step away from sensationalism.
- 3:51We are blessed to have communities where we have
- 3:55security teams, we have people that are part of burial teams.
- 3:59We have people that are in leadership position within those
- 4:02communities who are in the forefront of this.
- 4:05Leave them to do what they need to do.
- 4:08If you are part of those groups, there's a confidentiality that
- 4:11goes without saying that you are part of those groups, that you
- 4:14get to keep that information and the dignity of the people
- 4:17strongly in that group alone. Not come home, not cheat with
- 4:21other family members, not cheat with friends, not share that you
- 4:24were the first on the scene. It's irrelevant.
- 4:28Urgency doesn't create empathy. We don't need to be putting
- 4:32information out. We can put a general message out
- 4:35as a community. As a community, we can make dua
- 4:38for the people that have been affected by it.
- 4:40But this constant forwarding out really takes nothing except the
- 4:44dignity of the families that are affected by it.
- 4:46And we really do make it very difficult for the first
- 4:49responders jobs. We really make their jobs far
- 4:52more difficult because if we respected the fact that they
- 4:55were on the scene to do their job, we won't have to worry
- 4:57about is somebody filming it to make sure that we've got the
- 5:00story behind the scenes. Why do we need to know the
- 5:02story? The Quran speaks so strongly
- 5:05about backbiting, about gossiping, about slander.
- 5:07This is part of it. When we adding our opinion and
- 5:10on things that we know nothing about.
- 5:12This is how we become part of the gossip and the slander.
- 5:15When we already passing our own fatwas and our own thoughts on
- 5:19how someone passed away or what happened in somebody's home and
- 5:22what resorted to this, we have no idea.
- 5:25Unless you're living in that home, you will have no idea.
- 5:28Unless you part of the story itself, you won't have any idea.
- 5:30And even when you are part of the story itself, they'll
- 5:33probably be 3 different truths to it.
- 5:36But it's not up to us to be able to lend our opinions to it.
- 5:40So how do we end up stopping this?
- 5:42We've got to be having conversations with our children.
- 5:44We have to also tell our children the importance of not
- 5:47forwarding these videos about not needing to know that you
- 5:50were the first on the scene or somebody sent it to you and you
- 5:52have first information on it. We have to stop this posting of
- 5:56videos, posting of messages, posting of information of
- 6:00accident scenes, of anything that affects the dignity of
- 6:03other people. Yes, if it's to be able to get
- 6:06help, put it onto the right chats and get the help you need.
- 6:08We all have emergency contact numbers of almost every single
- 6:12town. Get in touch with the people,
- 6:13they send it to them and let them be able to deal with it.
- 6:16But let's stop this forwarding just for the sake of
- 6:19sensationalism. If many times videos get
- 6:22forwarded out without any trigger warning of what people
- 6:26are going to see, many of us will just open up our WhatsApp
- 6:28chats. We pick it up and you don't even
- 6:31realise that that very video that you've opened U is
- 6:34something that ends up haunting you that you didn't even want to
- 6:36end up seeing. So this is not a responsibility.
- 6:40And we complain about everybody else.
- 6:41It starts with me and you. We need to stop sharing this
- 6:44misinformation. We need to stop sharing things
- 6:47just because they forwarded. And we need to understand that
- 6:50when we forward it, we also may be sending it to children, to
- 6:53adults that may be very vulnerable to the disturbing
- 6:56content that they may be seeing. We have no idea what other
- 6:59traumas they've been through in their life that this triggers so
- 7:01much more for them. So how do we forward it out
- 7:04without any sense of responsibility, of understanding
- 7:06what other people are going through, that we provide this to
- 7:09their phones and then we we leave them to deal with their
- 7:12own traumas. Just because we received
- 7:15something does not mean we need to forward it.
- 7:18Once it comes to your phone, just stop, delete it off your
- 7:21phone, put it aside. Make sure you are not part of
- 7:24having to share that to anybody else.
- 7:27You know, we always talk about the three gatekeepers.
- 7:31Is it true? Is it necessary and is it going
- 7:35to be safe for the next person? But also is it respectful?
- 7:40Is it mine to share? Do these kind of things belong
- 7:43on a public space? Do they belong on a public
- 7:45platform? If it was your family, would you
- 7:47want it out there? If it was your child, would you
- 7:50want it out there? If it was my family, would I
- 7:52want something like that being circulated all over?
- 7:54If your answer is no, you have no right to share in any
- 7:57conversation, to share in any forwarding to Shane, any opinion
- 8:01on it. And no, this is not for public
- 8:03education or scrutiny. What we can do is get our
- 8:07community members together, make sure people are talking to our
- 8:10children, make sure that they understand what we need to be
- 8:13doing as part of a community instead of just pressing forward
- 8:17on every single thing that comes to our phones.
- 8:19If we have phones, we have a responsibility on how we share
- 8:22what comes to it as well, just as much as we do in real life.
- 8:25I think it's so important that we protect the dignity of
- 8:29families over and above everything else, the same way we
- 8:32would want our dignity protected, whether it's through
- 8:35pictures, whether it's through stories that are shared, whether
- 8:38through gossip, whether through any tragedy that affects any
- 8:42family. We need to ask, if I was put
- 8:45into that position, how would I want my dignity protected?
- 8:48And when you protect the dignity of another person, a loss,
- 8:51Subhanallah, will protect yours. Nobody's grief should be a
- 8:56public spectacle, nobody's pain should be a public spectacle,
- 9:00and nobody's tragedy should be up for public consumption at any
- 9:04level. And this is where we as a
- 9:07community understand that every human being deserves dignity,
- 9:11even in death, and that responsibility starts with us.
- 9:15We want to do something good when we hear something bad is
- 9:18happened. Pray for the families that are
- 9:20affected. Go to the home if you know them
- 9:23and privately offer assistance to the families.
- 9:26Offer practical help. If there's a place that you can
- 9:29donate, donate responsibly and only share official support
- 9:33information that is meant to go out.
- 9:35I promise you, every community, especially in the ones we know
- 9:40have strong response units, have strong first responders, have
- 9:45strong security teams, rely on them to send out an official
- 9:48message, rely on them to send out an official note and that is
- 9:52about the only thing that gets forwarded and nothing more than
- 9:55that. So the moment we ask how can I
- 9:58help and not just react, know that that's the time we start
- 10:01acting like responsible adults because our children are
- 10:04watching us. And if we want to set the tone
- 10:05for what comes ahead, we've got to do the right thing right now.
- 10:10Our responsibility starts with teaching our children digital
- 10:13character education, not just forwarding.
- 10:16Not to speculate publicly. Not to treat tragedy as cheap
- 10:23entertainment. We're not here for that.
- 10:25And we need to be able to also report harmful content when we
- 10:28do see it. Sometimes we know people forward
- 10:32because out of fear, sometimes because they're feeling shocked.
- 10:35Sometimes they need to feel informed.
- 10:38Sometimes it's the desire to be the first one there.
- 10:41Sometimes it's societal pressure, but we have to
- 10:45understand that being the first is not the same as being
- 10:48responsible. And this is something we have to
- 10:50teach our children and also remind ourselves about on a
- 10:53consistent basis because it's really, really important.
- 10:57And I said it earlier, urgency should never replace empathy.
- 11:01However we want. A response should be done in a
- 11:03very responsible manner, in the right direction, to the right
- 11:07teams, on a regular basis. So simple guidelines and I don't
- 11:10even know why we still need to be saying this, but really, if
- 11:14you are getting graphic content, don't forward it.
- 11:17Don't name victims or families without any confirmation, no
- 11:20speculation or rumours. She only verified emergency
- 11:24updates and respect the family's privacy.
- 11:27Very often we'll hear of an accident happening and the
- 11:29family's names are out there before the family has even been
- 11:32informed. It's not our job to do that.
- 11:34Wait for the official ones. And these messages can be shared
- 11:37on your school group's most groups, community WhatsApp
- 11:40groups, parent networks. Because the sooner we start
- 11:42showing a responsible digital footprint, the sooner everybody
- 11:46starts following suit to ensure that they don't get to be
- 11:50irresponsible with how they're using their phones or messages.
- 11:53And I think we need to also understand that from an Islamic
- 11:56perspective, because Islam emphasises dignity, it
- 11:59emphasises preserving it, it emphasises avoiding gossip and
- 12:03speculation, it emphasises protecting the honour of others.
- 12:06And it also emphasises only speaking what is beneficial.
- 12:10And I think this is something that we need to be able to do
- 12:13because we all have a moral accountability to it as well.
- 12:17So our mind, the mindset shift, has to move from reaction to
- 12:21responsibility, from curiosity to compassion, and from seed to
- 12:27sensitivity. Because not every single thing
- 12:30deserves amplification. Some moments deserve silence.
- 12:36Some moments deserve prayer, and every single moment deserves
- 12:40dignity. As individuals, as responsible
- 12:45individuals, part of our community, we need to be able to
- 12:48ensure that we're doing right by everyone around us.
- 12:52And always ask yourself, what if it was me in that position?
- 12:55Mela protect us. Mella protect our families.
- 12:58Mela, protect our community. Let's make the right decisions
- 13:02from here, right now, in this moment, because what comes next
- 13:06starts right here. Assalamualaikum rahmatullahi
- 13:09wabarakatuh.