Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Negotiating Commercial Leases for Small Tenants: Practical Strategies and Common Pitfalls
Transcript
- 0:03Greetings, everyone. My name is Howard Gould.
- 0:07I am co -chair of the real estate section for
- 0:10the Beverly Hills Bar Association. And happy
- 0:15to have everybody joining us today for our program
- 0:18on negotiating commercial leases for small tenants.
- 0:22Before we begin, I'm gonna let you know what
- 0:25some of our upcoming programs are and make a
- 0:28couple of announcements. Next week on July 2nd,
- 0:33We're doing a program on the Davis -Stirling
- 0:35Act, which of course is the act that governs
- 0:39most homeowner associations. Michael Kushner
- 0:43is the speaker for that event about practical
- 0:47aspects and some of the basics of the Davis -Stirling
- 0:51Act. We're doing a second program in July on
- 0:54the 25th, which is going to be about landlord
- 0:58insurance for lack of habitability claims in
- 1:01landlord tenant. cases. Very often, lack of habitability
- 1:07is raised as a defense. And there is a possibility
- 1:10of insurance coverage. And Steve Raucher, former
- 1:14president of the Beverly Hills Bar, is going
- 1:16to give that presentation. And Steve's area of
- 1:20emphasis obviously is insurance matters. We're
- 1:24going to do a program that's a little unusual
- 1:25for us on August 20th. It's sort of a litigation
- 1:30theme. CCP section 664 .6 on settlements has
- 1:35been revised. There's some specific things that
- 1:39relate to probate law and family law and certain
- 1:45things that practitioners need to know when they're
- 1:48settling things and, of course, a large number
- 1:50of real estate parcels end up getting transferred
- 1:55through both probate and family law matters.
- 1:59Al Provenziano, the incoming president of the
- 2:01Beverly Hills Bars, the speaker on the family
- 2:03law aspects, and Scott Rom is going to talk about
- 2:06the probate aspects of 664 .6. On September 17th,
- 2:13we're anticipating Larry Jacobson, again, doing
- 2:16a review of the 2025 important real estate cases.
- 2:21And in October, we anticipate a program on SB
- 2:2479, the transient -oriented. a housing development
- 2:28statute that is going to change the face of places
- 2:31like LA by allowing larger scale developments
- 2:35near transit oriented developments, often bordering
- 2:40single family residential neighborhoods. In terms
- 2:45of today's program, you can find a link to the
- 2:48program materials in the chat if you haven't
- 2:50already downloaded those. We aren't going to
- 2:55use the chat for questions and answers. Those
- 2:57will go in the Q &A section, which I'll monitor
- 3:01as we go through and attempt to raise the issues
- 3:04from the Q &A at appropriate places during the
- 3:06program. Your MCLA certifications or certificates,
- 3:11excuse me, are sent out very promptly by the
- 3:13Beverly Hills Bar, so you should look for those
- 3:16soon after the presentation. It's my great privilege
- 3:21to have Brian Mashin joining us again this year.
- 3:26He's lectured for us the last couple of years
- 3:28on AIR lease forms and AIR purchase and sale
- 3:31agreements. Always a great... Pleasure to have
- 3:34Brian here. And this year, he's put together
- 3:37a program that is not going to run you through
- 3:39the forms, but it's really how to negotiate a
- 3:42commercial lease for small tenants who obviously
- 3:44frequently don't have the leverage of larger
- 3:47tenants and give you some practical strategies
- 3:49and some of the common pitfalls. Brian is the
- 3:53principal of his own firm, the Mashian Law Group,
- 3:56where he represents institutional, midsize, and
- 3:59entrepreneurial clients in office. retail and
- 4:03industrial real estate transactions. This includes
- 4:07leasing, subleasing, purchases and sales and
- 4:10other transactions. Brian spent 20 years at the
- 4:13Buchalter firm where he was a partner. He is
- 4:16currently chair of the contracts committee of
- 4:19the AIR, American Industrial Real Estate, commercial
- 4:22real estate section. AIR is an association of
- 4:26commercial real estate brokers that publishes
- 4:29leases. Purchases sale contracts and listing
- 4:31agreements And they have a library of more than
- 4:3570 contracts that are now published in all 50
- 4:38states Brian was previously chair of this real
- 4:42estate section of the Beverly Hills bar For the
- 4:45executive committee putting on programs like
- 4:47this one He was previously on the steering committee
- 4:50of the commercial development and leasing subsection
- 4:53of the real property section of the Los Angeles
- 4:56County Bar Association He speaks at the International
- 5:00Council of Shopping Centers. A lot of people
- 5:02know his ICSC at their conferences. And he was
- 5:05on the editorial board of the Shopping Center
- 5:07Law Report. Brian has written numerous articles,
- 5:12sends out some very interesting articles by email
- 5:15from time to time, and has obviously had numerous
- 5:19speaking engagements. Brian's undergraduate degree
- 5:23is in economics and Political Science from UCLA.
- 5:26He also got his law degree at UCLA where he was
- 5:28an editor of the Law Review. Brian, thank you
- 5:31for joining us. Thank you, Howard. Thank you
- 5:35for having me join you today. Let me share my
- 5:39PowerPoint and let's make sure I'm doing it correctly,
- 5:43Howard. Yes, it's on the screen. Perfect. Thank
- 5:47you. So this I find to be an interesting topic.
- 5:52I attended a seminar on this topic as a younger
- 5:54lawyer. And I think the challenge of doing a
- 5:58commercial lease for a small tenant is still
- 6:01there because what we have to do as a lawyer
- 6:05for negotiating a small lease is really limited
- 6:11by quite a lot of factors like The leverage imbalance.
- 6:22Typically, the small tenant doesn't have the
- 6:25kind of leverage that it would require to negotiate
- 6:28a lease to make it a fair or more balanced lease
- 6:30because it's a big project, the tenant has a
- 6:33small portion of the overall project and the
- 6:35landlord doesn't have the patience or the desire
- 6:39to negotiate a lease with a small tenant. The
- 6:44fact of the matter is most commercial leases
- 6:47start as heavily landlord oriented because it's
- 6:50the landlord who prepares the contract and the
- 6:53landlord often presents the same form lease to
- 6:56a small tenant as it does to a large tenant.
- 6:59So a small tenant has to really overcome a lot
- 7:03of obstacles that a large tenant has the budget
- 7:06and the time and the incentive to do it. The
- 7:09same issues are presented in both situations.
- 7:11If you're a small tenant dealing with a landlord
- 7:13form, it's the same issues. It's the same 200,
- 7:16300 plus issues. And the fact is that the small
- 7:20tenant can just be damaged proportionately as
- 7:24much as a large tenant if the lease is not negotiated
- 7:27properly and its interests aren't protected.
- 7:33The challenge from a lawyer's perspective is
- 7:36that the small tenants usually don't have the
- 7:38bargaining leverage like I just mentioned. The
- 7:40small tenants don't have an in -house counsel
- 7:42or the legal budget. They oftentimes, they come
- 7:45to the lawyer and say, look, this is... I want
- 7:48to open a business. I don't have a lot of money
- 7:50to spend on lawyers. I have this much money.
- 7:53And that's really the budgetary constraints that
- 7:57you have to work with. And also, a lot of the
- 8:00small tenants don't have the operational sophistication
- 8:03that the larger tenants have. The larger tenants
- 8:06have a staff or they have a... infrastructure
- 8:10which deals with construction and the things
- 8:14of that nature whereas a small tenant they usually
- 8:16are they handle everything on their own and They
- 8:20don't have the financial flexibility as a large
- 8:22tenant and I've seen many small tenants Oftentimes
- 8:26signed at least as is presented a lot of the
- 8:29AIR leases. I got to tell you they get signed
- 8:32Quite often as they're presented to the tenants
- 8:34by the landlord It's a it's a printed lease tenants
- 8:37look at it and they say it's a standard on top
- 8:40They read the business terms. They look at they
- 8:42said wow, it's printed. It says a standard I
- 8:45don't really know how to understand this lease
- 8:48and it looks right Okay, they go look at the
- 8:50addendum that a few points that they negotiated
- 8:53are in there and often times tenants sign it
- 8:56and then the problems are manifested later when
- 8:59they run into problems during the course of construction,
- 9:02during the course of operation, etc. So from
- 9:07a lawyer's perspective, it could take you 20
- 9:09years or more to build a reputation as a good
- 9:12lawyer, but 20 minutes to ruin it because if
- 9:14you do one bad deal and I often say, you know,
- 9:17it's that one small thing that you didn't want
- 9:20to really do, but you did and it ends up going
- 9:22badly and it could end up creating a lot of negative
- 9:25noise about the lawyer. So you really want to
- 9:28either turn it away and say, I don't want to
- 9:30do it, or if you do it, you got to do it right.
- 9:36And from being the lawyer for the tenant, it's
- 9:39critical for the lawyer to really focus on important
- 9:42issues. As negotiating a large lease, I have
- 9:47the luxury, and most lawyers have the luxury
- 9:49of having a checklist, having the addendum that
- 9:52you can you can go with, oh, you red -liners
- 9:55sent back the lease and you present a couple
- 9:57of hundred issues and you work through the issues
- 10:00laboriously with the other lawyer, with the landlord's
- 10:02lawyer. So what it really is the challenge is
- 10:07to focus on what's important and it may be counterintuitive,
- 10:11but it's almost better to have a more senior
- 10:13lawyer who has the experience and and the knowledge
- 10:18of what's important, what's unimportant. It's
- 10:22maybe better to have a more senior lawyer do
- 10:24the small lease rather than a junior lawyer,
- 10:26but I think the economic realities of our business
- 10:29is such that oftentimes the younger lawyers are
- 10:32given the smaller leases to negotiate because
- 10:35their hourly rate is less or for whatever other
- 10:39reason. So what's happened now with our with
- 10:45the introduction of artificial intelligence,
- 10:47we have a new reality in these negotiations.
- 10:50It is pretty typical. for a client to run the
- 10:53lease through AI before they come and talk to
- 10:56a lawyer or even after they talk to the lawyer.
- 10:59The AI has really radically changed the client's
- 11:04approach to leasing. The AI will summarize the
- 11:07lease and the difficult to understand legal language
- 11:11of the leases are summarized and simplified by
- 11:13AI so the clients have a... a better understanding
- 11:19of what the lease provisions mean. It interprets
- 11:21and explains the clauses. Clients can ask questions,
- 11:24follow up questions. What does this mean? No,
- 11:26I don't understand that and AI will explain.
- 11:30There's lots of programs out there and there's
- 11:32just basically some AI that's readily available
- 11:35to the public as well that will suggest edits.
- 11:38The AI will point out obvious risks in the transaction
- 11:42and it will identify, depending on what the prompt
- 11:46is, hundreds of issues. It depends on what the
- 11:49client asks AI to do, and it can identify many,
- 11:52many issues. But AI still struggles with what
- 11:57is market. The market is king in any transaction.
- 12:02And even a small tenant can have leverage in
- 12:09this down market where it's a tenant market or
- 12:13it's a buyer's market. the tenant can have leverage.
- 12:17And it's not something that I think that, of
- 12:19course, you can ask AI, do I have leverage, et
- 12:22cetera, but I don't think that AI has a real
- 12:25time sense of that. And the market leverage assessment
- 12:28is a very critical thing to have in the back
- 12:32of your mind as you're negotiating. And that's
- 12:34very important to identify what truly matters
- 12:36in the deal with the market and also finding
- 12:39out from the client what is important to the
- 12:42client. That's really where the rubber meets
- 12:44the road here, is to spend the time with the
- 12:46client to understand what are their key pressure
- 12:49points and make sure we cover those. And the
- 12:53other thing that AI still struggles with is the
- 12:55negotiation, the psychology and the strategy
- 12:57of the negotiation, which is obviously much more
- 13:00significant in a larger transaction, but it's
- 13:02still there with a smaller lease. And AI has
- 13:08also impacted the lawyer side of the transaction.
- 13:12Like Howard said in the beginning, forms used
- 13:15to be very important. Our practice, the real
- 13:18estate practice is heavily forms based. But with
- 13:23AI and the sheer amount of information and forms
- 13:28and templates that are available publicly, a
- 13:31lawyer having his or her own form is not as important.
- 13:35Maybe it's going to be gone soon. I doubt it.
- 13:38Certainly, I have my forms. I still keep them.
- 13:40I use them as a resource. There are many resources
- 13:44like the CEB, PLI, many other sources where lease
- 13:48form books and resources are available. So gone
- 13:52are the days where people used to create their
- 13:54own forms. You can still use them through the
- 13:58AI and other publicly available sources. One
- 14:01thing that I especially like in negotiating a
- 14:04small lease is to use the AI feature of having
- 14:07a Zoom meeting with a client, discuss the lease,
- 14:10go through what's important with them, and then
- 14:12have AI recorder and summarize the client discussions.
- 14:16That actually simplifies one part of the role
- 14:22of the function and role and function of the
- 14:26lawyer in the transaction. Because I think as
- 14:28a lawyer, in these negotiations, you really have
- 14:30two sides or two adversaries you need to be concerned
- 14:33about. One is the landlord, and the other one
- 14:34is your client. You need to protect yourself
- 14:36against both. So if you advise the client to
- 14:39do something and they decide not to do it and
- 14:41not follow your advice, then you need to be able
- 14:43to document that. And AI is a fabulous tool for
- 14:46being able to very easily record and summarize
- 14:50the client discussions. So what are we talking
- 14:54about? What is a small lease? I'd say somewhere
- 14:56between the sizes about three to five thousand
- 14:58square foot. The term usually runs from three
- 15:01to five years, maybe with one or two five or
- 15:03three year options to extend the term of the
- 15:06lease. The rent will run anywhere from five to
- 15:0910 grand a month and the condition of the space
- 15:12is usually the way it is pre -existing with little
- 15:15or no tenant improvements. I'm not going to talk
- 15:18about work letters or TI allowances today because
- 15:22it would just not be enough time, but that's
- 15:26a significant issue. And it's typically not a
- 15:28heavily negotiated item with the small leases
- 15:30that we're talking about today. I would note,
- 15:36Brian, that you just recently sent out an article
- 15:39about how the work letters of the TI improvement
- 15:43provisions and how that really is a separate
- 15:46contract within the lease itself and the importance
- 15:49it can have. Yeah, that's a three -part newsletter
- 15:52that I did the first part this month and the
- 15:56second one is coming out next week. And it's
- 15:58about really how a work letter or even the work
- 16:02letter makes it sound like it's not as important
- 16:04of a part of a lease, but it's really a construction
- 16:06contract. And the reality is a lot. There's a
- 16:09lot of money that's spent by both sides in the
- 16:11work letter. So that needs to be really paid
- 16:13attention to and heavily negotiated if necessary.
- 16:17But like I said, we're thinking of we're talking
- 16:21about a hypothetical small lease where the tenant
- 16:23improvements are not that significant. So to
- 16:27negotiate a lease on behalf of a small tenant,
- 16:30you really need to ask, as a lawyer, three questions.
- 16:33Is this point important? Yeah, I bring it up
- 16:36in every lease. Is it obtainable? Is the landlord
- 16:39going to even entertain my discussion? And is
- 16:42it worth spending the political capital on? Because
- 16:45a landlord or a landlord lawyer will turn off
- 16:47the tenant or the tenant's lawyer if you ask
- 16:48too many questions. And if you have way too many
- 16:52comments, they're just going to tune out the
- 16:55lawyer or the tenant. So you really, I think,
- 16:57have to be very mindful of picking your battles.
- 17:02Make sure you only present the issues that are
- 17:05critical. And this was an interesting challenge
- 17:09for me to come up with my top 10, 12, 13 issues.
- 17:12And here's my picks. The first one is the base
- 17:16rent. Obviously not the amount of the rent, because
- 17:18that's not my job as a lawyer. That's the broker
- 17:20or the client's choice. But the rent is based
- 17:23often on the size of the space. And the size
- 17:25is oftentimes wrong. That's just the reality
- 17:29of our business. And sometimes it's wrong, unintentionally
- 17:32or unknowingly. You know, in the contracts committee,
- 17:37we're having discussions about how do we solve
- 17:39or eliminate? I don't think we can eliminate.
- 17:41We can we can reduce or mitigate some of the
- 17:43risk that's created by virtue of the fact that
- 17:45most transactions end up using wrong size information.
- 17:50And it's important to discuss that with the client
- 17:54because. The size of the space obviously directly
- 17:57impacts the base rent. And if it's a multi -tenant
- 18:00situation, it affects tenants per rather share
- 18:03of the common area expenses that the tenant pays.
- 18:06So it's a quick, easy discussion with the client
- 18:09to say, have you measured the space? Or do you
- 18:14have any idea of how big is the project and your
- 18:17sense of it? And obviously, it's much more difficult
- 18:19for a tenant to measure a big shopping center
- 18:21or an office building. The most important thing
- 18:25is to actually bring up the topic with the client
- 18:28so that I've covered my neck and I've told them
- 18:31about making sure that they verify the size.
- 18:34Now measurements are much easier to do nowadays
- 18:37because of the technology, laser, lots of different
- 18:40ways. I was doing an industrial lease and I told
- 18:44the client that they should measure and they
- 18:46went on Google Earth and they use the Google
- 18:49Earth images and they were engineers. They could
- 18:53figure out based on the picture, and they triangulated
- 18:56and figured out what the size of the roof was.
- 18:58And then they said, look, we're satisfied. It's
- 19:00close enough. And I felt like, OK, I did my job.
- 19:06And what's important is to really tell the client
- 19:09to measure the space before the lease is signed.
- 19:12And like I said, it's much easier to measure
- 19:15now. If it's not possible practically to measure
- 19:19the space, because for example, there's a new
- 19:21demising wall that's being put in, so you actually
- 19:24don't have the exact configuration of the space,
- 19:26that's a perfect opportunity to ask for a right
- 19:29to measure the space. Let's say within 90 days
- 19:31after the commencement date, once the demising
- 19:34wall is up, we say we want to have a right to
- 19:36measure, and then we're going to retroactively
- 19:38and prospectively adjust the rent based on the
- 19:40verified score footage. That's something that
- 19:44affects how much the rent is paid throughout
- 19:46the term of the lease. So it's I consider it
- 19:48to be a significant issue. The next significant
- 19:51issue I think is obviously taxes, insurance and
- 19:53camp charges. No big surprise here. The problem
- 19:56is that if the lease terms are negotiated and
- 20:03then the lawyer tries to change or negotiate
- 20:07some of these what the business people consider
- 20:09business terms, then you're fighting an uphill
- 20:13battle. So it's important. Sometimes I get a
- 20:15call from a client, hey, I'm thinking about leasing
- 20:17the space. What do I do? And I think it's important
- 20:23as a lawyer to tell the client, let me see the
- 20:25letter of intent before you finalize it. Because
- 20:28it's very important and it's a smart strategy
- 20:31to use the LOI stage to negotiate the business
- 20:35terms. some of these business terms that can
- 20:37become obviously negotiated at a later point.
- 20:41Try to fix the economics before you go to the
- 20:46stage of drafting the lease. A lot of times brokers
- 20:50or deploys will say, oh, we'll handle it in the
- 20:53lease or to be determined or to be discussed
- 20:55in the lease. That often means that it's too
- 20:59late for you as a lawyer to try to do something
- 21:01about it. One of the things that I ask for is
- 21:06the landlord's billings for the current year
- 21:08to date and the prior two years. It's very important
- 21:12to get that information. Oftentimes I see that
- 21:15brokers do not ask for this information when
- 21:18they're negotiating the business term. So it's
- 21:21very helpful for the client to see what those
- 21:24billings are. Then they get a much better idea
- 21:27of what their actual total occupancy costs are
- 21:30going to be once they sign the lease. And it's
- 21:34also very interesting that if you get billing
- 21:37records or billings that are professionally prepared,
- 21:40they look right, they look great, then you're
- 21:43more likely dealing with a landlord who's going
- 21:45to manage their building well. If you get something
- 21:47that looks like it was just recently put out
- 21:50of, you know, they pulled it out of a shoe box
- 21:52and they're just giving you something, or they
- 21:53say we don't have it, then that should be ringing
- 21:56the alarm bells to make you think, okay, well,
- 21:59we really need to make sure we deal with the
- 22:03operating expenses of taxes and insurance, and
- 22:06this issue very clearly because the landlord
- 22:09is probably not handling it properly. So this
- 22:12issue really manifests in the single tenant versus
- 22:14a multi -tenant occupancy. This issue shows up
- 22:17in two different sections of the lease. If it's
- 22:20a single tenant, there's typically a provision
- 22:25for taxes, another one for insurance, and then
- 22:30the maintenance, repair, and replacement of the
- 22:33premises. It falls into three different sections
- 22:36of the lease. The multi -tenant occupancies,
- 22:39all of these are lumped together on the operating
- 22:41expenses or CAMs or, you know, they all fall
- 22:44into one pool of operating expenses. I've seen
- 22:49also some industrial landlords in a single tenancy
- 22:53will bill taxes and insurance and they choose
- 22:57to do the maintenance repair themselves and they
- 23:00bill it as operating expenses. So sometimes you
- 23:02see even a single tenancy where there really
- 23:04is no common areas, the landlords will try to
- 23:08manage the maintenance obligations by having
- 23:12operating expenses paid for by a single tenant.
- 23:16What's important is to ask for the right to audit.
- 23:18Tell the client, hey, you do not as a matter
- 23:21of You don't have an implied right. There's no
- 23:24cases that I've seen, if somebody has seen it.
- 23:26I mean, the last case was the Octagon Plaza case,
- 23:30which interpreted an AIR lease and that tenant
- 23:32was told by the court, no, you don't have a right
- 23:35to audit in the lease. So, and I'm not aware
- 23:38of any California cases which give a, by right,
- 23:42by law, right to audit common area operating
- 23:44expenses. But it's good to ask to make sure you
- 23:48told the client and It's not often that a small
- 23:51tenant would get the right to audit. What's really
- 23:55sad is that sometimes I get the right to audit
- 23:58and the tenant doesn't use it. They just don't
- 24:02care. They're focused on running their business
- 24:05and they don't really pay that much attention
- 24:07to the can bills. They get it, they pay it, and
- 24:10then they move on. But it's good for you as a
- 24:16lawyer to make sure you ask. the landlord for
- 24:18the right to audit or tell the tenant do you
- 24:20want to have the right to audit. So property
- 24:24taxes is the single largest item of operating
- 24:28expenses for most real estate and in California
- 24:30obviously we have the prop 13 regime where the
- 24:33change in ownership triggers a reassessment of
- 24:36the property. And a Prop 13 protection whereby
- 24:39the tenant is not obligated to pay the increase
- 24:42in property taxes due to the change in ownership
- 24:44of the property is a very critical thing to even
- 24:48talk about. Are you going to get it? I seldom
- 24:52get it. And it's a very hard fought battle because
- 24:56it directly affects the value of the landlord's
- 25:00property when you reduce the net operating income
- 25:04of the property after sale. So it's very seldom
- 25:07that... a small tenant will get a Prop 13 protection.
- 25:12But again, it's important for me to bring it
- 25:15up to the client to tell them, look, this is
- 25:17something that's very important, because you
- 25:18have no control over when the landlord sells,
- 25:22how much they sell it for. And then potentially,
- 25:24you can have a sudden large increase in taxes,
- 25:27and there's no way around it. You have to pay
- 25:29it. So this is something that I make sure I bring
- 25:32up, even if the brokers tell me, hey, you know
- 25:35what? We tried it. talk to the client at least
- 25:39and I make sure I record and I make a record
- 25:41that I talk to them about it and in the single
- 25:45tenant leases obviously it's also good to get
- 25:47the right to contest taxes and if you have an
- 25:51option to extend a fair market rent like in if
- 25:55you have a base share operating expense arrangement
- 25:58like in office leases I want to make sure that
- 26:01with the market rent adjustment, the base year
- 26:04for taxes gets reset because that's a big protection
- 26:07for a tenant who stays in an office building
- 26:09for let's say five years and then they exercise
- 26:12an option. The rent goes to market and then they
- 26:17get a new base year. The other thing that I talk
- 26:20to the client about property taxes is if I say,
- 26:23let's ask for property protection. And if the
- 26:26landlord says, look, we have no plans to sell,
- 26:29which is not atypical. We say, look, if you do
- 26:32decide to sell, give us a right of first refusal
- 26:34to buy the property. So at least we're not just
- 26:37paying the high taxes without getting some benefit.
- 26:40So it's sometimes an idea that a client likes
- 26:43because as an owner user, they're able to get
- 26:46very favorable SBA loans with very high loan
- 26:49to value ratios of 90%. And sometimes the user
- 26:54is the best buyer for the property. maybe the
- 26:56landlord will give him a right of first refusal
- 26:59to buy the property when they say no to a prop
- 27:0313 protection. So that's a good thing too. That's
- 27:08like a fallback to ask for and have a discussion
- 27:10with the client about it. Two points here, Brian.
- 27:14I mean, I like that right of first refusal. This
- 27:17is a point where the lawyer may have a role that
- 27:20the broker won't take on, which is to talk seriously
- 27:23to the tenant about how long their lease should
- 27:25be and also have the tenant talk to other tenants
- 27:29if it's a multi -tenant building because those
- 27:31tenants may know more than the landlord is going
- 27:33to tell you about what the landlord is actually
- 27:35doing in management, what their plans are, whether
- 27:38they're going to sell. And if they're going to
- 27:40sell soon, it may be that tenant wants a three
- 27:43-year lease and not a five -year lease, but the
- 27:45broker's interest is having a longer lease. And
- 27:48they may or may not seriously discuss that with
- 27:50the tenant. But if they really think the landlord
- 27:53is going to sell and they're going to get hit
- 27:55with Prop 13 increases that could be very large,
- 27:59they may prefer a smaller lease with an option.
- 28:02That's an excellent point, Howard. And I think
- 28:05There are lots of fallbacks to deal with Prop
- 28:0813. The tenant can negotiate a one -time exclusion
- 28:12or two -time exclusion of change in ownership.
- 28:14You can negotiate a dollar cap on how much the
- 28:17tenant will pay for the increase in taxes. You
- 28:19can negotiate a percentage increase. So there's
- 28:22lots of creative ways to address the risk that's
- 28:28created by the change in ownership and the sudden
- 28:31large increase in property taxes. But what's
- 28:34really important is, again, to bring up the point
- 28:36with the tenant, because a lot of times it's
- 28:38not brought up and the clients don't think about
- 28:41it. The brokers may not bring it up either. But
- 28:43this whole discussion of property taxes really
- 28:46needs to be done in context. And as a lawyer,
- 28:49you've got to ask exactly what Howard was saying.
- 28:52How long is the lease term? If it's a short -term
- 28:55lease, then it's not going to be as significant
- 28:57of an issue. If it's a long -term lease, if you
- 29:00have a 25, 30 -year lease, then there's a much
- 29:03higher likelihood of having a change in ownership
- 29:05happen during the term of the lease. The other
- 29:08component of this assessment is really to figure
- 29:10out how is the current assessed value in relation
- 29:16to the current market value. If the same ownership
- 29:21has held this property for many many years and
- 29:23the current assessed value of the property is
- 29:25significantly below the current market value,
- 29:28And if there is a change in ownership, then you're
- 29:30going to have a large increase in property taxes
- 29:33and the tenant can't, maybe they can't afford
- 29:36that and they can't budget for it. So these are
- 29:39two good questions to ask and have a discussion
- 29:41with the tenant about to find out how concerned
- 29:45are they about this risk, which is beyond their
- 29:47control. It's also important to think about what
- 29:51is the reimbursement, the operating expense reimbursement
- 29:53arrangement? Is it on a net or base year deal?
- 29:57Obviously, if it's a base year, depends on what
- 30:01the base year is. And if it's a net, then the
- 30:05exposure doesn't really make a difference because
- 30:07the tenant pays at all. But if you have a base
- 30:10year, that's for example, if you're doing a lease
- 30:12in 2026 in the middle and you negotiate a 2027
- 30:17base year, then you've got some protection if
- 30:20the sale happens in the 2027 year, then the tenant
- 30:25a lot of the increase could be absorbed in the
- 30:28base share and it may not be passed through to
- 30:30the tenant. So that's another thing to look at.
- 30:34The other thing to look at is if it's a base
- 30:37share, how is the base share defined? Sometimes
- 30:40the lease is defined based on a fiscal year,
- 30:43sometimes based on a calendar year that the lease
- 30:45is signed. So those are subtleties of this point
- 30:48that you should look at and discuss with a client.
- 30:54Insurance. Now obviously everybody knows what's
- 30:58happened to the insurance industry in California
- 31:00after the Palisades fire and one of the things
- 31:03that I always tell the clients to do is to send
- 31:06the lease to their insurance broker or insurance
- 31:08risk manager, have them look at the lease provisions
- 31:11to make sure that they can in fact provide the
- 31:15insurance that's required of them and how much
- 31:17is it going to cost? They need to have an idea
- 31:21of what is the premium for the current coverage
- 31:25that they're required to provide. And that's
- 31:28an easy thing to tell the client to do and get
- 31:33a bid, get an idea what the cost is going to
- 31:36be. And increasingly landlords are asking tenants
- 31:39to have higher and higher coverages, 5 million,
- 31:4210 million. Five million, it used to be one and
- 31:46two, now it's two and five, or with an umbrella.
- 31:50So these coverages are creeping up and they're
- 31:52getting more and more expensive. And the ratings
- 31:55and the fact that the insurance provider has
- 31:57to be admitted in California, we had a lot of
- 31:59the admitted carriers leaving, but now it seems
- 32:02like they're coming back. One of the issues that
- 32:07I also bring up is the earthquake interest. Typically,
- 32:10the tenant is required to reimburse the landlord
- 32:11for the commercial general liability insurance
- 32:16and the fire insurance. And on top of that is
- 32:21earthquake insurance. Earthquake insurance, as
- 32:23we all know, can be very expensive and it has
- 32:26a high deductible. And one of the things that
- 32:30I get as part of getting the current billings
- 32:36by the landlord. does it include earthquake insurance?
- 32:41And if it doesn't include earthquake insurance,
- 32:44then I say, okay, if you're not carrying it now,
- 32:45I don't wanna pay for it later if you decide
- 32:47to carry it. And if they're carrying it now,
- 32:51then I tried to negotiate a cap on the tenant's
- 32:56contribution of the earthquake insurance. Because
- 32:59that... is again, something that could very easily
- 33:03increase exponentially after an earthquake and
- 33:06something that the tenant can't really budget.
- 33:09So it's important to have that discussion as
- 33:12well with a client. So the other cams kind of,
- 33:22they usually fall in a pool of operating expenses.
- 33:25And as a small tenant, you have, I've never had
- 33:28the leverage to negotiate a line item exclusion
- 33:31from the definition of common area operating
- 33:34expenses. And even if you do as a lawyer succeed
- 33:40in negotiating line item exclusion of certain
- 33:44expenses from the definition of operating expenses,
- 33:47the reality is that when the landlord bills it,
- 33:50there's no way the tenant can know if they are
- 33:53actually not being charged for things that were
- 33:55negotiated in the lease. without doing an audit.
- 33:59And seldom does a small tenant want to bother
- 34:02with doing an audit. They don't have the budget.
- 34:03They don't have the time. And the operating expense
- 34:08provision of leases is one of those provisions
- 34:10that a lot of lawyer time goes into negotiating.
- 34:13And oftentimes, it's not adhered to by the management
- 34:16or the administrative staff. They typically send
- 34:20out their billings in the same fashion to every
- 34:22tenant in the building. seldom I've seen the
- 34:26landlords management and accounting staff goes
- 34:29through the lease and make sure that they adhere
- 34:31strictly to what the items that were negotiated
- 34:33to be excluded from definition, their typical
- 34:37standard operating expense definition. This has
- 34:40been such a problem that prologists came up with
- 34:43what they called a clear lease. It was supposed
- 34:46to be a shorter lease to reduce negotiation time
- 34:48and legal costs. And what Prologis did, they
- 34:51said, let's combine the base rent with a fixed
- 34:54charge for operating expenses. And they thought
- 34:56that they would achieve their goal of giving
- 34:59the tenant cost certainty, and they would eliminate
- 35:03CAMM reconciliations and also negotiation of
- 35:06CAMMs during the lease discussions. I don't know
- 35:09how successful that was. I negotiated the Prologis'
- 35:13clear lease. You know, obviously I've negotiated
- 35:16it, so it does shorten it, but probably not as
- 35:20much as ProLodge has hoped. Westfield is another
- 35:23company that they will sometimes include cams,
- 35:31cap it as an amount, and include it as part of
- 35:33a fixed amount that the tenant will pay along
- 35:35with base rent. That was also met, again, with
- 35:38the same idea of reducing the legal fees to negotiate
- 35:43operating expenses and reduce or eliminate the
- 35:46Canberra Considiation headache and the staff.
- 35:51The easiest way for a small tenant to approach
- 35:54this issue is to negotiate a cap on operating
- 35:56expenses. And ideally, you want a cap on all
- 35:59operating expenses. The problem with that is
- 36:01that if the landlord agrees to a cap on all operating
- 36:04expenses, that includes a cap on taxes. And that,
- 36:08again, is a major concession by Landlord. They
- 36:11don't want to cap the tenant's contribution to
- 36:14taxes because if they do decide to sell, then
- 36:17that inability to recapture the increases in
- 36:22taxes will affect the value of the property.
- 36:27So usually the cap I've seen is on controllable
- 36:31expenses. So then one of the questions becomes
- 36:36is the cap compounded or cumulative, which is
- 36:39a very important question because if you negotiate
- 36:41a 5 % cap, is that 5 % based on the first years
- 36:45or is it on the prior years? And what happens
- 36:49if the 5 % cap isn't reached in one year but
- 36:53the next year? the increase is actually 7%. Can
- 36:57you go back and recoup some of the cap that wasn't
- 37:00captured in one year? That's a good discussion
- 37:02to have with a client. Obviously, this goes right
- 37:05to the bottom line. From the lawyer's perspective,
- 37:09you got to really take a very close look at what's
- 37:12the definition of controllable. That's where
- 37:14the battle becomes. A typical landlord definition
- 37:18of not controllable is taxes, which is, again,
- 37:22that's something that they don't control. If
- 37:24they sell it, you could say, well, no, it's controllable.
- 37:27You decide when to sell. But I've not seen taxes
- 37:31typically be included in what's controllable.
- 37:34Insurance, again, is not controllable. Utilities,
- 37:38security expenses are somewhat. But then you
- 37:42run into a problem where, as a tenant, you want
- 37:45the landlord to provide the requisite security
- 37:47for the safety of the shopping center or the
- 37:49office building. But then... They say, well,
- 37:52if you want us to do that, then you have to let
- 37:54us charge what's appropriate, put the right staff,
- 37:56get the right equipment. So there is a tension
- 37:59there and trying to put security expenses and
- 38:02controllable expenses. Capital expenses, usually
- 38:06that, I think that's an easier battle because
- 38:11that gets amortized over the reasonably expected
- 38:13useful life of the capital item. cost to comply
- 38:17with laws. Usually there's an exclusion for failure
- 38:21for cost to comply with laws which were violated
- 38:23as of the lease commencement date. Management
- 38:26fees really are controllable because you know
- 38:30they're usually around three, four, five percent
- 38:32and it's not something that the landlord cannot
- 38:35control. So those are the major components of
- 38:39what gets negotiated in controllable operating
- 38:42expenses. The next topic to me is assignment
- 38:46of self -letting. It's a very significant issue
- 38:48because it affects the tenants ability to sell
- 38:51the business, retire. If somebody, if you're
- 38:55negotiating a lease for a doctor or... a professional,
- 38:59what if they get sick, they die? What if the
- 39:03business wants to be handed down from the first
- 39:05generation or the business is downsizing or wants
- 39:09to merge with a bigger company? So the assignment
- 39:12of subletting is the governor for all of those.
- 39:16And I think it's absolutely critical to insist
- 39:20on the tenant's ability to assign or sublet with
- 39:22landlords' consent not to be unreasonably withheld.
- 39:25Now, most of the time, I see the leases start
- 39:28out with that provision. In California, there's
- 39:31not too many leases that I've seen where the
- 39:32landlord says they can absolutely withhold. They
- 39:38absolutely prohibit transfers or the transfer
- 39:40is subject to landlords' arbitrary consent. The
- 39:44one thing that's important to pay attention to
- 39:46is to eliminate the recapture right, especially
- 39:49for retail and industrial tenants, because they
- 39:51end up having a significant amount of money invested
- 39:53in the space, whether it's machinery and equipment,
- 39:57or the retail tenant is dependent on that particular
- 40:00location's visibility and access to signage.
- 40:03So they really don't want to lose that location.
- 40:06So I remember this one client came to me. She
- 40:09had a very successful pretzel kiosk in one of
- 40:14the local regional centers and she had a tenant,
- 40:17somebody who wanted to buy her business, she
- 40:19went to the landlord and said, sure, sure, go
- 40:21ahead, you want to sell, just ask us for our
- 40:22consent. She never looked at her lease. I think
- 40:26she didn't look at it when she signed it. She
- 40:28didn't look at it when she was going to sell
- 40:29the business. So she goes to the landlord and
- 40:31says, yeah, I want to sell my business. I want
- 40:33your consent. And the landlord says, great, now
- 40:35we're going to cancel your lease. And she was
- 40:38so distraught because here she was going to make
- 40:40$400 ,000 selling her business and it went poof
- 40:44up in smoke. Fortunately for her, the recapture
- 40:47right was not well drafted and we were able to
- 40:51negotiate some kind of a pretty good settlement
- 40:54for her. And she was able to still do the sale
- 40:55and get most of the value of her business. But
- 40:58you got to really focus on the recapture right.
- 41:01The other thing to focus on is eliminating any
- 41:04adjustment to market rent on a transfer. That's
- 41:06a killer. because a lot of times the small businesses
- 41:09value comes from having a certain amount of cash
- 41:13flow. And if the rent adjusts to market, that
- 41:16means the cash flow for the buyer is gonna be
- 41:18a lot less and the buyer is not gonna pay as
- 41:20much. So that's important for the buyer, for
- 41:23the tenant to eliminate adjustment to fair market
- 41:26rent on transfer. Quite a lot of leases have
- 41:31the indirect transfers restrictions. If it's
- 41:34an LLC corporation or partnership, they put a
- 41:3725 % or more change in ownership of the entity
- 41:42is considered an assignment. So it's important
- 41:44to have as high a threshold as possible, 51 %
- 41:47or more. critical to exclude the sale of business,
- 41:50because if the business is sold as a stock sale
- 41:53or an asset transfer, you really don't want to
- 41:55have any of those, either the recapture or the
- 42:00change to market triggered. Preferably, you want
- 42:04to have the ability to sell the business and
- 42:07not go through the regular lease provisions,
- 42:10which require tenants to submit lots of information
- 42:13and the landlord can sit on things for up to
- 42:1630 days sometimes. It's also critical to exclude
- 42:20from indirect transfers, the entity transfers,
- 42:23the transfers of the beneficial ownership between
- 42:25the initial owners or to their affiliates. The
- 42:28affiliates transfers is a pretty standard one,
- 42:31but I don't know how significant it is for a
- 42:33small tenant because typically they don't have
- 42:35affiliates. They usually just sell the business.
- 42:42prevalent in the landlord leases typically calls
- 42:44for 50 -50 split or 75 to landlord, 25 to tenant.
- 42:50You got to look at how long is the lease term?
- 42:52How often is the rent adjusted? Is there really
- 42:54a likelihood that the market rent is going to
- 42:56be above the contract rent? And in either situation,
- 43:01it's important to exclude the sale of the business,
- 43:04the goodwill, the assets. None of that should
- 43:05be considered as part of the profit that the
- 43:07landlord is going to get any of it. and quite
- 43:10a lot of landlord written profit sharing provisions
- 43:12include those items. What's very important to
- 43:18a small tenant is the transferability of the
- 43:20options, especially extension options, which
- 43:22are very typical in leases. And most leases,
- 43:27the AIR leases, Section 39, they make the options
- 43:29non -transferable. They make it personal to the
- 43:32original tenant. And if the option is not transferable,
- 43:36that could really significantly affect the tenants
- 43:40ability to sell its business and get the highest
- 43:43market value for it. Because the buyer wants
- 43:47to make sure that they have the right to continue
- 43:49to occupy and operate the business at that location,
- 43:52but with a personal non -transferable option,
- 43:55the tenant is unable to market the space and
- 43:59get the most money for its business. So it's
- 44:03important to negotiate. for the transferability
- 44:06options. Ideally, you want the options to be
- 44:09freely transferable. Seldom are you going to
- 44:11get that. And I think a reasonable compromise
- 44:14is for the option to be transferable to an assiny
- 44:18that's approved by the landlord and hopefully
- 44:20a consent by the landlord can't be unreasonably
- 44:22withheld. Quite often you see the tenants ability
- 44:26to exercise the option is subject to the tenant
- 44:29not being in default and being open and operating.
- 44:32These are These are ways that the landlords try
- 44:35to take back the options that they really didn't
- 44:37want to give, but they gave to make the deal.
- 44:40So from the tenant's perspective, depending on
- 44:42how likely it is that the tenant is going to
- 44:44sell or some other provision, which is going
- 44:48to trigger the assignment, you want to eliminate
- 44:50these conditions to the exercise of the option
- 44:53or have a right to cure them. The transferability
- 44:59is critical to the sale of the business, especially
- 45:02if the lease term extension option is at a fixed
- 45:04price and not market. Brian, in those situations,
- 45:08if it's really a crucial issue to the tenant,
- 45:11can they sometimes enter a bankruptcy and still
- 45:14have the right to make the transfer as a result
- 45:17of being in bankruptcy? Yeah, I'm not a bankruptcy
- 45:19lawyer, but as you're saying, Howard, there's
- 45:22bankruptcy provisions that trump retail leases.
- 45:25I don't think it applies to all leases because
- 45:27there's some bankruptcy provisions that allow
- 45:30the bankruptcy court to override the lease provisions.
- 45:35Right. Personal guarantees is the one I also
- 45:39focus on because quite often the tenant will
- 45:41be operating through a corporation or LLC and
- 45:44they end up giving personal guarantees. what
- 45:47they don't realize is that the guarantee continues
- 45:51even if they sell the business. A lot of business
- 45:56people don't appreciate that, yeah, they could
- 45:58sell the business, but their company is on the
- 46:00hook and so is their guarantee. So I make sure
- 46:02that we have a discussion with the client or
- 46:06try to negotiate and enter the guarantee once
- 46:09the business is sold to a buyer who is approved
- 46:11by the landlord. And that's a critical thing
- 46:16for for a tenant. I've had tenants who say, look,
- 46:19if I'm going to continue to be liable, I don't
- 46:20want to sell the business. I don't want to have
- 46:23the downside of that. So it's important to make
- 46:26sure the client appreciates their continued liability
- 46:28under the guarantee. There's lots of ways the
- 46:32guarantees can be negotiated, the good guy guarantee,
- 46:34which basically says the tenants, the guarantor's
- 46:38obligations go away if the tenant doesn't pay
- 46:41rent. the tenant voluntarily vacates the space
- 46:45so it doesn't force the landlord to file an eviction
- 46:47and drag the landlord through an unlawful detainer.
- 46:51It's important to also discuss with the client.
- 46:53Maybe you want to have burn -offs on your guarantee.
- 46:55If you have a 10 -year lease, your guarantee
- 46:58should start to burn off after a year or two
- 47:00or three once you've been a good tenant. That
- 47:03liability should start to go down because you've
- 47:05now proven yourself. Or put a cap and have the
- 47:09cap go down. It could be a rolling, it could
- 47:11be a stated dollar amount of cap or it could
- 47:13be a rolling 12 month cap. The other thing to
- 47:16explore is using security deposits instead of
- 47:19guarantees. Some clients will prefer to give
- 47:21six months security deposit instead of giving
- 47:23a personal guarantee. And some landlords are
- 47:25willing to make that horse trade. They figure,
- 47:27okay, if I have six months, that covers me for
- 47:30the rent and the turnover costs and blah, and
- 47:33I'm okay not getting the personal guarantee.
- 47:36So that's a very good discussion to have with
- 47:38the client. The next section that's important,
- 47:42which is the maintenance, repair and replacement
- 47:44section. From a tennis perspective that this
- 47:47provision is. typically very broadly written
- 47:50to make the tenant responsible for both structural
- 47:53and non -structural portions of the premises.
- 47:56So I try to, by a few words, limit the tenants
- 47:59obligations to the interior non -structural portions
- 48:02of the premises. That way I'm excluding the foundation,
- 48:06the floor and ceiling slabs, the roof structure,
- 48:08curtain walls, columns, you know, those major
- 48:11expensive portions. So I just try to limit it
- 48:14to the interior non -structural portions. and
- 48:17also try to avoid being responsible for the replacement
- 48:20of the building systems, mechanical, electrical,
- 48:23fire life safety, plumbing, the sprinkler system,
- 48:26and the HVAC. If you can't eliminate it, maybe
- 48:30you can say, okay, the landlord replaces it,
- 48:32then you amortize it over the reasonably expected
- 48:34useful life of the item, and the tenant pays
- 48:36his pro rata share of that cost for the duration
- 48:40of the lease. This is I think this slide brings
- 48:46up an issue that comes up quite often in leases.
- 48:50It's the roof that needs to be repaired or replaced,
- 48:53the asphalt parking, the paving has worn out,
- 48:56the HVAC needs to be replaced, or one of the
- 49:01utility mains breaks. The utility mains are very
- 49:03expensive. These are the expensive items that
- 49:06the tenants get upset about having to pay for.
- 49:09The roof membrane is, again, these are something
- 49:12that a tenant should Do an inspection before
- 49:15signing the lease. Get a good idea of what's
- 49:17the current condition at the lease inception
- 49:19so they can go to the landlord before signing
- 49:22the lease and saying, look, your roof is on its
- 49:24last leg. I'm not going to pay to replace it.
- 49:27You need to be responsible for replacing it.
- 49:30Or the asphalt paving has lots of cracks, lots
- 49:33of cracks. So you need to take care of it. And
- 49:37the HVAC is something that I tip. routinely tell
- 49:40clients, get an HVAC guide, not just the general
- 49:43inspector, because they do a much better inspection
- 49:46of the HVAC. They go check the compressor. You
- 49:49get a cheap report on the current condition of
- 49:53the expected useful life of the HVAC. That inspection
- 49:56easily pays for itself. HVAC units can be very
- 50:01expensive. It's either you eliminate or you ask
- 50:06the landlord to amortize the replacement cost
- 50:10over the item's reasonably expected useful life.
- 50:13And that's something that the clients really
- 50:14appreciate because that really ends up being
- 50:17an expensive item. Let me see. The condition
- 50:29of the space at the beginning of the lease. Pretty
- 50:33commonsensical, but a lot of landlord leases
- 50:35don't say what the tenant reasonably expects
- 50:41the space to be in. The tenants expect that these
- 50:46items are in fact exist, but the lease says,
- 50:51hey, the tenant takes it the way it is, as is,
- 50:53where is, with all faults, whether known or unknown.
- 50:56And it's important to have the tenant, again,
- 50:58do an inspection. And from the tenants' lawyer's
- 51:04perspective, this is not too big of an ask. I
- 51:08think it's within the reasonable expectations
- 51:10of normal business people to say, okay, if you're
- 51:13gonna lease a space to a tenant, it should be
- 51:16in the condition so that the tenant can conduct
- 51:18its normal business operations. So obviously
- 51:23that's... comes down to the construction of the
- 51:26physical improvement. So you want to make sure
- 51:27that's all done before the lease starts and the
- 51:30tenant has to start paying rent. The compliance
- 51:34with applicable laws is an important one, especially
- 51:36today's with we have these professional plaintiffs
- 51:38who are ADA plaintiffs. They sue. I don't know
- 51:44how many people have gotten by without getting
- 51:46sued. It seems like everybody gets sued by an
- 51:48ADA plaintiff, whether you're a landlord or a
- 51:51tenant. And it's something to really look at
- 51:54and have a discussion with the tenant. Do you
- 51:57want to do an ADA phase? Do you want to do a
- 51:59CASP inspection, a certified access specialist
- 52:01professional inspection? And what's really important
- 52:05there, if you're in a single tenancy, is to make
- 52:09sure that the van accessible handicap spade with
- 52:12the blue striping and the placards and all that
- 52:14stuff is there. And the only way to know that
- 52:16is to have a CASP inspector do the inspection,
- 52:20write up a report, send it to the landlord before
- 52:23you sign the lease and say, hey, look, the space
- 52:25doesn't have the ADA required parking spaces
- 52:29or a path to travel. We're going to get sued.
- 52:31I don't want to pay for it. So you would spend
- 52:35the money to bring the parking lot, not the inside.
- 52:40The parking lot, the access ways, the path to
- 52:42travel up to compliance with ADA. On the other
- 52:46hand, you can have issues with even your front
- 52:49door or build outs that are not compliant with
- 52:53the ADA. And you don't want to have to make those
- 52:57changes if you're leasing a space that wasn't
- 52:59compliant when you leased it. Absolutely. Absolutely.
- 53:03And it's not just paying the money to fix it,
- 53:05but it's sending the lawsuit. You pay anywhere
- 53:08from, you know, I don't know what the going rate
- 53:10in the market is, but it's really the tenants
- 53:13get so upset because it's basically they feel
- 53:15like they're being blackmailed to pay money and
- 53:18then fix it. But that's something to have a discussion.
- 53:23I oftentimes go on Google Earth. I look at the
- 53:26space. before the client signs it, I look for
- 53:29some of the obvious signs of ADA compliance.
- 53:32I look at the roof of the building from the satellite
- 53:34pictures. You'd be amazed how much you can learn
- 53:37just from looking at the Google Earth. And these
- 53:40are questions that you can bring up. If you see
- 53:42ponding on the roof, if you see the tree branches
- 53:45coming over the roof, you can tell the client,
- 53:48look, there's going to be problems with the roof.
- 53:49You need to get that addressed before we sign
- 53:52the lease. Again, you want to advise them to
- 53:55talk to their neighboring tenants if it's a multi
- 53:57-tenant building. Absolutely. The other thing
- 54:00that's important, getting a phase one report
- 54:03is not as critical for a retail or an office
- 54:07building. Usually, there's not as much of an
- 54:10environmental, but with an industrial use that
- 54:12has some chemicals or some processing of chemicals,
- 54:17it's very important to have that discussion with
- 54:19the client to make sure that that client understands
- 54:22their potential liability under federal state
- 54:25laws for hazmat and recommended them that they
- 54:29pay for a hazmat or ask the landlord for a phase
- 54:32one, it's important to have the discussion. Maybe
- 54:35the client opts to say, look, I don't want to
- 54:37pay the 2 ,500 or 3 ,000 it costs today to do
- 54:39a phase one. If they have a clean use, maybe
- 54:43that's okay. But from the lawyer's perspective,
- 54:46again, you're covering your neck to make sure
- 54:48you told the client to get it. The other thing
- 54:53that's important to make sure that the condition
- 54:55of space satisfies at the lease commencement
- 54:57date is to make sure the building systems and
- 55:00utilities are available and operational. Ideally,
- 55:03you want to get some kind of a warranty from
- 55:05the landlord, for example, that the HVAC is going
- 55:08to be working for at least six to nine months
- 55:10so that the building goes through at least three
- 55:13out of four seasons and the tenant turns on the
- 55:15heating and the cooling functions to make sure
- 55:18the HVAC works. You want the roof to go through
- 55:21at least one measurable rainfall so that you
- 55:24can determine whether the roof leaks. So these
- 55:26are things that would, again, this all depends
- 55:30on what is the client's expectations. Parking
- 55:33spaces, critical obviously to most businesses
- 55:36in LA and California. You want to make sure your
- 55:39parking spaces for your customers and employees
- 55:41are available and accessible, and you have access
- 55:43to the premises 24 -7. So, my last item is the
- 55:50permitted and exclusive use. From the tennis
- 55:54perspective, it's important to negotiate for
- 55:56as broad of a permitted use as possible. This
- 56:01is important for giving the tenant the right
- 56:04to assign a sublet with less restrictions. Because
- 56:07in California, a legitimate basis for a landlord
- 56:09to deny consent to a proposed assignment of sublease
- 56:12is that the proposed assignee or subtenant's
- 56:16use is not permitted in the lease. So if the
- 56:21lease provides for a broad use, then that makes
- 56:25it easier for the tenant to assign a sublease.
- 56:27If it's a narrow lease, then you have to fit
- 56:29within that narrow permitted use in trying to
- 56:33assign her sublease. This is an important impact
- 56:37that it has on the landlord's right to reject
- 56:40the transfer. For retail tenants, obviously exclusive
- 56:43use rights is a discussion that you must have
- 56:45with a client. It depends on what their business
- 56:49model is. Do they care for competition? Some
- 56:51tenants want competition because they actually
- 56:55like to have somebody's similar use nearby. Some
- 56:57don't. So this is something to discuss and see
- 57:01if you want to negotiate the exclusive use right
- 57:04in the shopping center. Obviously, you have to
- 57:07look at all the other existing permitted and
- 57:10exclusive uses to see how valuable the exclusive
- 57:14use rights that you may be given. This is also
- 57:17an important issue for the future evolution of
- 57:20the business. If the business grows or the tenants,
- 57:25for example, wants to pivot from being a Mexican
- 57:27restaurant to a Chinese restaurant because the
- 57:30Mexican concept didn't work. So the use has to
- 57:33be broad enough to permit the tenant to pivot
- 57:34like that. We have some questions, Brian, that
- 57:38I'd like to run through with you. Please. One
- 57:40question is, have you ever been able to get a
- 57:42most favored nation clause in a lease for a tenant?
- 57:46Not for a small tenant. For a bigger tenant,
- 57:48yes. But for a small tenant like this, honestly,
- 57:51it's not something that I think I can get and
- 57:56I don't have the leverage for it. So the other
- 58:02sort of difficult question is what happens when
- 58:05you get a landlord and they just say no to all
- 58:08of your requests for the small tenant? Do you
- 58:10have anything that you can do in those situations?
- 58:13First thing is to make sure that I've done my
- 58:16job. Look, we're lawyers, we're not guarantors,
- 58:18we're not insurance companies, we're not here
- 58:21to, you know, we're advisors, right? And I think
- 58:25one of the things that we got to keep in mind
- 58:28is that a lot of these points that we raise ultimately
- 58:32become business decisions. What we do is make
- 58:36the client aware of the fact that here's an issue,
- 58:38here's a risk. We've asked for it, the landlord
- 58:41says no. If you've tried the compromises that
- 58:44you know, and then you you're getting shut out
- 58:49market is king like i said market is king one
- 58:52of these business decisions i knew a broker who
- 58:54got sued once when they were showing somebody
- 58:57i think it was a large industrial property then
- 58:59they showed him another one across the street
- 59:01and they the client decided to rent the one across
- 59:05the street and then they found out it was in
- 59:07a different jurisdiction that had a business
- 59:09tax that the other one didn't and the broker
- 59:11got sued over this issue and it's not really
- 59:15a legal issue and it's more of a business issue
- 59:17but it's something people don't think about is
- 59:19to check what the rules are in the jurisdiction
- 59:22where they're going to lease especially in Southern
- 59:24California where you have so many jurisdictions
- 59:26and you often don't know where one starts and
- 59:29one ends. That's an excellent point. We had another
- 59:32comment here that someone had a landlord refuse
- 59:36to honor the assignment and was requiring a new
- 59:39lease from the purchaser of the business. That
- 59:42sounds like sort of push come to shove on a legal
- 59:45issue. Yeah, it's an interesting question because
- 59:49if you're trying to assign the lease, and let's
- 59:53assume for our discussion that the landlord was
- 59:56duty bound to be reasonable. That's a completely
- 1:00:00different discussion and analysis versus negotiating
- 1:00:03a new lease, because then there's no duty to
- 1:00:05be reasonable in negotiating a new lease. When
- 1:00:09the tenant wants to assign the lease that it
- 1:00:11has, the landlord has to be reasonable. And as
- 1:00:15a tenant who's selling, you have to be very careful
- 1:00:18to make sure you don't give up your rights and
- 1:00:20your claims against the landlord for being unreasonable.
- 1:00:24And sometimes that situation happens because
- 1:00:27the tenant doesn't want to be responsible for
- 1:00:31the lease after they sell the business. They
- 1:00:33rather the new person sign a new lease, so they're
- 1:00:37off the hook. So there's the trade -off. And
- 1:00:40it happens quite often. And if you have been
- 1:00:43unsuccessful in negotiating the lease of liability
- 1:00:46on sale of the business, then unfortunately,
- 1:00:48that's what you're stuck with. Another question
- 1:00:52is what clause can you negotiate or try to include
- 1:00:55in the event the landlord goes through a bankruptcy
- 1:00:58or a default on a loan and there's a possible
- 1:01:01foreclosure because I think you know obviously
- 1:01:04sometimes if you have a recorded loan that precedes
- 1:01:10preceded the lease, your lease could be wiped
- 1:01:12out by that foreclosure. Excellent question and
- 1:01:17this is a risk that's prevalent that exists in
- 1:01:20small leases, large leases. And if there's a
- 1:01:25loan that predates the lease, and exactly like
- 1:01:28you said, Howard, if the loan is foreclosed,
- 1:01:30that terminates the lease unless the tenant signs
- 1:01:34a subordination non -disturbance and a torment
- 1:01:36agreement with the lender before they sign the
- 1:01:40lease. And that's the solution is to make sure
- 1:01:44that the tenant is not dispossessed on a foreclosure.
- 1:01:48This is especially important if you have a client
- 1:01:50who's going to come in and spend a lot of money
- 1:01:54of their own money. If they're going to spend
- 1:01:57their own money improving the space, if they're
- 1:01:59going to spend millions of dollars improving
- 1:02:00a space and there's a loan on there, you want
- 1:02:03to make sure that you get it on disturbance as
- 1:02:05a condition to the lease commencement date. Because
- 1:02:08once the lease starts, you start paying rent,
- 1:02:12Good luck trying to get the landlord to get you
- 1:02:14that SNDA. They don't care anymore. So what you
- 1:02:17want to do is you want to make sure that you
- 1:02:19get the SNDA as a lease commencement date. I
- 1:02:21remember years ago, I negotiated that landlord
- 1:02:24wouldn't give us the SNDA before we signed the
- 1:02:26lease. And I said, OK, for every day that you're
- 1:02:28late, beyond a certain amount of time, then we
- 1:02:31get a day's free rent for the delay in delivering
- 1:02:36the SNDA. And it was very ironic. Hundreds of
- 1:02:40days went by and we actually ended up accumulating
- 1:02:43a lot of free rent by my client at the end of
- 1:02:45the day said, I don't care. We got the SNDA.
- 1:02:47I don't want to upset the landlord. I want to
- 1:02:49have a good long -term relationship with them.
- 1:02:51I don't want to do a gotcha. But you got to build
- 1:02:54the motivation and incentive for the landlord
- 1:02:56to get you the SNDA. So you got to do it either
- 1:02:58before the lease starts and you start paying
- 1:03:00rent or build some kind of a penalty or some
- 1:03:02kind of a... Hopefully the lender will agree
- 1:03:04as long as you're... going to torn to them that
- 1:03:08they'll let you stay at whatever the rent is
- 1:03:11you've negotiated. Somebody did note 11 USC 502
- 1:03:15BC regarding I think the bankruptcy issue on
- 1:03:19the claims for commercial leases. One or two
- 1:03:22other things we just wanted to mention, you know,
- 1:03:25you really want to inquire about special circumstances
- 1:03:28for your client, you know, if especially if you're
- 1:03:32talking about lawyers, doctors, other people
- 1:03:35who were the business is completely reliant on
- 1:03:38that one or two people. You know, how old are
- 1:03:41they? I have had senior doctors where I was able
- 1:03:45to get the landlord to agree to a retirement
- 1:03:47clause. And as long as they gave six notice and
- 1:03:49they were leaving the practice of medicine, they
- 1:03:52could terminate their lease. And that was very,
- 1:03:55very important to them under the circumstances
- 1:03:57where they were maybe in their early sixties
- 1:03:59and, you know, maybe had health issues or other
- 1:04:02things like that. And it brings up question of
- 1:04:05all the things you talk to your client about
- 1:04:07at the beginning, their age, their business timeline,
- 1:04:10how long they think they're going to be in business,
- 1:04:12what expansion they may need, because if they
- 1:04:14need it and they can't get it, now they have
- 1:04:17a big... Big problem. You already mentioned the
- 1:04:20parking is sometimes a major issue and you assume
- 1:04:22you're going to always have the parking you see
- 1:04:24at the beginning, but you know, sometimes there
- 1:04:27are other changes made in the in the property
- 1:04:30and and for retail tenants. Sometimes the storage
- 1:04:32is an issue and one of the. things that it's
- 1:04:35great to tell people in any real estate transaction
- 1:04:38leasing buying a house anything else is what
- 1:04:41are the assumptions you're making and go talk
- 1:04:44to your neighbors even in buying a house go talk
- 1:04:47to the neighbors you you'll find out interesting
- 1:04:49things sometimes about what's going on in the
- 1:04:51area and of course the other thing is big issues
- 1:04:54sometimes is is the signage um yeah those are
- 1:04:58excellent points yeah you know what i what i
- 1:05:01say you know i do these presentations for brokers
- 1:05:03and i tell them and I'm going to tell the same
- 1:05:05thing to us as lawyers is we only get into trouble
- 1:05:09and you only get sued because the client was
- 1:05:11upset and disappointed. They didn't get what
- 1:05:14they want and I think the critical thing is to
- 1:05:16make sure we understand what are the hot points
- 1:05:19for the client and exactly what you said Howard.
- 1:05:23What is, how long is he gonna be in business?
- 1:05:25Does he have a succession plan? They're gonna
- 1:05:27sell. All of that is a discussion to have and
- 1:05:29it's not so much, we gotta stop the knee jerk
- 1:05:32reaction of going to a checklist or going to
- 1:05:34a form or an addendum that I use and see if I
- 1:05:37can just walk it through and make a bunch of
- 1:05:39comments. That's really not, that's not where
- 1:05:41it's at. And the final point that I would make
- 1:05:44on this, which you've touched upon in part, is
- 1:05:47that when you have a business and it has multiple
- 1:05:49owners, which sometimes is the case, you need
- 1:05:53to... Talk to them about how these lease obligations
- 1:05:56are gonna affect things if they have an internal
- 1:05:59buyout You know if there's guarantees and somebody's
- 1:06:03well, it says okay. It's time to buy me out And
- 1:06:05then they say well wait a minute I'm gonna still
- 1:06:07be stuck on the guarantee and I'm gonna be relying
- 1:06:09on how my former business partners run this business
- 1:06:12and whether they pay the rent and things like
- 1:06:14that and So when you have multiple in a sense
- 1:06:17multiple clients because there's multiple owners
- 1:06:20of the business Sometimes it's tricky to think
- 1:06:23about the things you really need to ask them
- 1:06:25about. How many law firms had personal guarantees
- 1:06:28by the partners? who had left, and they were
- 1:06:31still on the hook for guarantees of the lease.
- 1:06:34When Finley Cumble, years ago, crumbled, I had
- 1:06:37a friend who was nominally a partner, really
- 1:06:39didn't get treated like a partner, but he was
- 1:06:42liable for their leases when the bankruptcy happened.
- 1:06:45And Brobeck -Fleger, I always heard that they
- 1:06:48ended up, which was a really, really old line
- 1:06:50San Francisco firm, that part of the reason they
- 1:06:53disappeared is they took too big and too expensive
- 1:06:55a lease in Silicon Valley. And sometimes leases...
- 1:06:59I know of a large retail operation in my hometown
- 1:07:02in the Midwest where the younger generation expanded
- 1:07:06into some very expensive leases and then the
- 1:07:09economy went bad and those leases brought down
- 1:07:12all parts of the business in a sense because
- 1:07:15they had overextended and they didn't separate
- 1:07:18the entities to keep the... loss of the new expensive
- 1:07:24leases from dragging down the old successful
- 1:07:26part of the business. So a lot of considerations
- 1:07:29and it's a great topic. And thank you so much
- 1:07:35for doing this, Brian. Very interesting subject
- 1:07:37and a lot of earned wisdom that you're imparting
- 1:07:40to everybody. I appreciate it. Thank you, Howard,
- 1:07:42for having me. Thank you, everyone, for attending.