Latest / Saladin: The Muslim Leader Who Defeated Crusaders — Fexingo History / Saladin's Siege of Jerusalem 1187: The Peaceful Conquest
Transcript
- Lucas: So after Hattin, Saladin's forces swept through the Crusader states. By September 1187, he had taken Acre, Jaffa, and most of the coast. But the big prize — Jerusalem — still held out. Luna: And Jerusalem was the symbolic heart of the Crusader kingdom. Lucas: Exactly. Saladin knew that taking it would be the ultimate statement. But he also knew the history. In 1099, the First Crusaders had stormed the city and massacred nearly everyone — Muslims, Jews, even Eastern Christians. That memory was seared into the Islamic world. Lucas: So when his army approached Jerusalem in late September, he didn't just attack blindly. He offered terms first. He sent envoys to the city, asking for a peaceful surrender. Luna: What was the response from inside? Lucas: The city was defended by Balian of Ibelin — a Frankish noble who had survived Hattin. He was a pragmatic man. He knew they couldn't hold out long. But the Crusaders inside were determined. They refused Saladin's initial offer. Lucas: So Saladin laid siege. His engineers set up mangonels — those are stone-throwing siege engines — near the northern wall, around what is now the Damascus Gate. For several days, they bombarded the walls. The defenders fought back fiercely, but they were outnumbered and running low on supplies. Luna: Did the siege go on for long? Lucas: About a week or so. By early October, the walls were beginning to crack. Balian realized that if the city fell by storm, it would be a repeat of 1099 — but this time with the Muslims as the attackers. He went to negotiate with Saladin personally. Lucas: According to Imad ad-Din al-Isfahani, who was Saladin's secretary, Balian warned that if no terms were given, the defenders would fight to the death, destroy the city, and even kill their own families rather than be enslaved. He said, 'We will burn our possessions, slaughter our women and children, and leave you nothing but rubble.' Luna: That's a powerful threat — but was it credible? Lucas: Saladin took it seriously. He didn't want a destroyed city. He wanted Jerusalem intact — the Dome of the Rock, the al-Aqsa Mosque, the whole place as a statement of Islamic victory. So he agreed to terms. Lucas: The deal was this: the city would surrender peacefully. In exchange, the Crusader inhabitants could leave safely. But there was a ransom. Each man had to pay ten dinars, each woman five, each child one. The poor who couldn't pay would become slaves. Luna: That's a lot of money for ordinary people. How many could actually afford it? Lucas: Not many. Estimates say there were about 60,000 people in Jerusalem at the time. Most were too poor to pay. Balian managed to negotiate a lump sum of 30,000 dinars from the treasury to free 7,000 of the poorest, but that still left thousands. Lucas: Saladin's own chroniclers, like Ibn al-Athir, record that after the ransom period ended, many were still enslaved. But Saladin did something remarkable. He ordered that the elderly and some women be freed without payment. And he personally released many captives — including the wives and children of Crusader knights. Lucas: Compare that to 1099, when the Crusaders had slaughtered everyone in the city. Saladin's behavior was seen as chivalrous even by his enemies. The Frankish chronicler Ernoul wrote that Saladin showed 'great mercy'. Luna: It really cemented his reputation for generosity. Lucas: Yes. And it was strategic too. By treating the defeated well, he made future surrenders more likely. Other cities would see that giving up to Saladin was better than resisting. Lucas: On October 2, 1187, Saladin entered Jerusalem. But he didn't ride in triumphantly with his army. He walked — according to some accounts — to the Dome of the Rock. He ordered the cross that the Crusaders had placed on top of the building to be removed, and the building to be purified with rosewater. Luna: That must have been an incredibly symbolic moment. Lucas: Absolutely. The Dome of the Rock was where the Prophet Muhammad had ascended to heaven, according to Islamic tradition. For Muslims, reclaiming it was a huge deal. Saladin also restored the al-Aqsa Mosque, which the Crusaders had used as a palace and stable. Lucas: But he didn't destroy Christian holy sites. He allowed Christian pilgrims to continue visiting, and he left the Church of the Holy Sepulchre intact — though he did close it for a few days to make a point. Luna: So he was both a conqueror and a diplomat. Lucas: Exactly. And that's what made him so effective. He understood that ruling a diverse population required more than just military force. Lucas: Speaking of which, it's worth noting that this kind of deep dive into history takes a lot of research and time. We're able to keep this show ad-free because a handful of listeners chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's literally what funds episodes like this. Luna: Yeah, it's a small group that makes it possible for us to keep going. Lucas: And we're grateful for that. But back to Jerusalem — after the surrender, Saladin faced the challenge of repopulating the city. Many Muslims had left during Crusader rule, so he encouraged families from surrounding areas to move in. He also granted Jewish families permission to return — something the Crusaders had banned. Luna: So Jerusalem became more diverse under Saladin? Lucas: In many ways, yes. The conquest wasn't just a military victory; it was a rebuilding of the city's character. Saladin established new schools and hospitals, and he restored the Islamic character of the city while allowing other faiths to exist. Lucas: But the Crusaders didn't give up. The loss of Jerusalem triggered the Third Crusade, led by Richard the Lionheart and Philip Augustus. They would arrive in 1191, and Saladin would face his greatest challenge yet. Luna: That's for another episode. Lucas: Exactly. For now, we leave Saladin in Jerusalem, having achieved what no Muslim leader had done in nearly a century — reclaiming the holy city without the bloodshed that stained its capture in 1099.