Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / What To Expect From Practice
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.metigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.n ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:19This is I love you. Keep going.
- 0:21It is July 27th, 2023 at 7:35 PM Pacific Daylight Time.
- 0:28And I was. Talking to some people this week
- 0:31and the topic that kept coming up over and over again is what
- 0:36to expect from practice, which I thought was quite an interesting
- 0:40topic, mainly because what to expect from practice really is
- 0:45very dependent on what you're practicing.
- 0:49And what's also quite interesting is in the West,
- 0:53where we really do sort of. Construct these kinds of
- 0:58practices that we do from a lot of different sources.
- 1:01It's unpredictable what actually is going to happen from the way
- 1:05that you practice. So I thought that that was an
- 1:08interesting conversation to have.
- 1:12We have a lot of resources for understanding what practice is.
- 1:19Most of them are not through lineages or.
- 1:24Traditional practices that come out of monastic communities.
- 1:31We are very big on these small aspects of practice that are
- 1:40explained in books and through different ways of gathering the
- 1:46information that are really in some sense.
- 1:49Secularized, pulled out of the context of the tradition that
- 1:53they come from. And so because we can grab them
- 2:01from all over the place, we in some sense are assembling for
- 2:05ourselves the a practice that's unique to the way that each of
- 2:11us practices. And whereas in a lineage type
- 2:17practice, that's very defined and the stages are very defined,
- 2:21the expectations of what comes from that kind of practice are
- 2:24also quite predictable. If you practice for instance in
- 2:30one of my favorite practices, which is the six lamps practice,
- 2:34that comes from a Bond Buddhism. If you practice in the way that
- 2:39the six lamps is set up, you tend to have these.
- 2:43Visions or it's often called vision practice, which aren't
- 2:45quite predictable, but when you gather different ways of
- 2:51practicing for yourself and assemble them, then you have the
- 2:57kind you have the results that come from the kind of practice
- 3:00that you but if but if you are the one who's creating the path
- 3:03and and practicing in that particular way.
- 3:11The results, then, aren't predictable.
- 3:14Who here really has a teacher that they're they've organized
- 3:19their practice around and are in regular contact with that
- 3:23teacher and explaining the progression of the practice and
- 3:26then being given the the next instructions to follow.
- 3:33When I started practicing, I. Actually, I think through my own
- 3:40conditioning had a very hard time fitting into different
- 3:44communities and hanging out very long in a particular community.
- 3:48And so I would take in the teachings that were offered and
- 3:51develop a practice around that. But then when I moved to another
- 3:56community, the the way in which I practice and what I understood
- 4:00about practice would change. I often hear in in.
- 4:07The community of meditators, the expectation of certain things
- 4:13happening from practice, and then the conversation around
- 4:17whether or not you get there or you don't get there.
- 4:21But I often find it divorced from a traditional way of having
- 4:25those outcomes. The teacher that I found was
- 4:30shinzen young and even though he's said this is now. 25 years
- 4:37ago that he was teaching Theravada meditation, actually,
- 4:43when my understanding of what the different kinds of practice
- 4:48are as deep, and I could see that actually he was drawing
- 4:53from a lot of different practices that he'd done in
- 4:56creating a way of practicing. So he was originally in Japan in
- 5:04a. Japanese Vatriana Monastery.
- 5:08He studied in Taiwan with a traditional Theravada teacher.
- 5:14His I think relationship with Sasaki Roshi, which he was his
- 5:22translator that lasted for 30 years, was also greatly
- 5:26influencing the way in which he described practice.
- 5:29So in some sense the. Practice that he developed was
- 5:34this Great Western experiment of of assembling a practice from
- 5:40across all of the different vehicles, and then of course the
- 5:48process of then secularizing it so that the instructions are, in
- 5:54a Western sense, removed from the associated texts.
- 6:00That the practices came from so that it's hard to trace where
- 6:07something in the practice comes from.
- 6:10Not an uncommon experience. And also if you're sitting with
- 6:19me, you're also sitting with somebody who has come in from
- 6:22that tradition and and assembled a way of practicing.
- 6:26I tend to focus on the. Meditation based attachment work
- 6:31because I think that it's a preliminary practice that really
- 6:34opens up the possibilities for deep practice in a more
- 6:41traditional way later. But that because in the West, so
- 6:45many of us are inclined toward a psychological understanding of
- 6:50what's actually happening and the psychological way of
- 6:53describing what's happening. So that can be a useful way of
- 6:57practicing, particularly in the beginning when we are beginning
- 7:02to examine our conditioning and how our conditioning interferes
- 7:07with the the happiness of life. I think in the West, because it
- 7:14still isn't so mainstream to practice meditation in the way
- 7:20that the Eastern practices have come here.
- 7:27I guess what I mean by that is if you go to Asia and enter into
- 7:33contact with the monastic communities there, meditation is
- 7:39not the primary practice. They have a bunch of different
- 7:45ways of being in the monastery as a monastic.
- 7:49Not all of them are centered on. Meditation.
- 7:53But in the West, largely the meditation communities, even in
- 7:57the name of them, have formed around the practice of
- 8:01meditation. So in the nonreligious non Asian
- 8:07communities that have grown up in the West around the
- 8:12exploration of insight and enlightenment, meditation is the
- 8:19main vehicle. The different ways in which you
- 8:28can come into the practice is, you know, widely varied.
- 8:33Really depends on who it is that is explaining this to you.
- 8:40When I started my meditation practice.
- 8:43So this is going back to the the 60s really, you know my
- 8:50introduction to. The practice of meditation was
- 8:54through The Beatles White Album. If you know the record, it's a
- 8:59lovely record by the way. And then the Maharishi and The
- 9:06Beatles going to Indian learning to meditate and then that
- 9:13practice really coming up as Transcendental Meditation and
- 9:18that early piece of. Mantra practice and then various
- 9:27kinds of concentration practice associated with the breath.
- 9:31I think the the deep dive I did on my own was through Ram Das's
- 9:36book Be Here Now, which came out in the early 70s, but I wasn't
- 9:43able to find a community very well with that practice.
- 9:47When I moved to New York, and during the period of AIDS there,
- 9:52when life was so painful and so stressful, the monasteries that
- 9:57were nearby were Tibetan. There was an opening of the
- 10:02Tibetan practices, the particularly Trumpa.
- 10:15And then it wasn't really until the 90s when I came out to LA
- 10:18that I discovered the. Theravada practices and they
- 10:22were so simple in comparison. I'm as a gay person growing up
- 10:30in the the 60s, developed a reaction to organized religion
- 10:39because of the hostility toward the.
- 10:49Predicament I found myself in, which was to be a gay person in
- 10:54the world where was illegal and they put you in jail for it,
- 11:00supported by the contention that it was a sinful and
- 11:05psychologically maladaptive. So the pageantry of the Tibetan
- 11:13way of practicing was easily associated with the pageantry
- 11:18of. Christianity the I started
- 11:30practicing an ordinary Dharma which was a traditional meta
- 11:33vipos in a way of practicing. But the main teacher there,
- 11:38Katrina Reed, the main teacher was Tetan Han who was a Zen
- 11:44teacher. So just pointing to those ways
- 11:49in which practice is organized. In Practicing Loving Kindness
- 12:01around that time, also Sharon Salzburg's book came out.
- 12:08Those results were actually much more predictable than anything
- 12:12else that I had done so far, because there was a description
- 12:15of how to practice and what to expect, and in practicing in
- 12:20that limited way around those concepts.
- 12:23The the results did begin to unfold in a way that was
- 12:26predictable, but the insight pass did not really unfold in
- 12:32that way until I got to shin set, and in practicing there
- 12:40with the techniques that he had developed, I began to have
- 12:44traditional stages of. Insight that really mapped along
- 12:51the progress of insight, as Bahasi said.
- 12:53I had described in his manual of insight the 16 stages.
- 12:59What was interesting about that was that I was having those
- 13:04typical stages unfolding from during the practice of
- 13:07meditation. But since I was in a secular
- 13:10community, those stages weren't really acknowledged.
- 13:13And so I found that the. The initial experiences of
- 13:18dissolution, which is the fifth stage, was not really understood
- 13:26in the way that I was describing it, nor was it anticipated from
- 13:30the way that I was practicing, and so that I ended up in in a
- 13:37in. The Buddhist term for it is
- 13:39knowledge of miseries, but in the West we often call it the
- 13:42dark night of the soul, which corresponds to.
- 13:47Saint John of the Cross or Teresa Lavila?
- 13:57And what Christian? So George, it sounds like you're
- 14:04maybe advocating or implying that maps are unnecessary or
- 14:10helpful part of practicing that like one should have goals.
- 14:16At least they give an understanding of where you're at
- 14:17so that you have some context or like.
- 14:19What do you think about the importance of maps or whether
- 14:23you can practice without them? I like practice maps or Dharma
- 14:29maps because it's it moves you through the the various kinds of
- 14:36insights that are necessary to make progress on the path and
- 14:40also you can evaluate how your practice is going in that way.
- 14:45I was in Chinzen's community and he's quite adamant that because
- 14:51maps are not universal, that we shouldn't advocate one map or
- 14:58another, That you should organically understand what
- 15:03practice appeals to, so that you do the practice and then have it
- 15:06develop over time and in relationship to a teacher.
- 15:10Have the teacher digest what experiences you're having.
- 15:15And then have them explain the insights that you're having, and
- 15:20then recommend the next series of practices that you can do so
- 15:26that you move towards the goal of enlightenment.
- 15:33But then. The goal of enlightenment in the
- 15:37Terravada tradition is different than the goal of enlightenment
- 15:40in the Zen tradition is different than the goal of
- 15:43enlightenment in the Tibetan tradition.
- 15:46And so which enlightenment really are?
- 15:49Are we talking about it at that point?
- 15:54And then again, we could turn to the individual and ask the
- 15:58individual what it is that they're hoping to get out of
- 16:01their practice. What is the reason that they're
- 16:03practicing it? Try and tailor the practice so
- 16:08that that would happen, but then are you in a dialogue with a
- 16:14teacher that's consistent enough that you could get the feedback
- 16:18that you need in order for that to happen in the West?
- 16:22I don't notice that we have set up structures in meditation
- 16:27communities where that's a real ongoing possibility.
- 16:34You have then the West. At least in the communities I've
- 16:39been involved in, the main intense practices is formed
- 16:44around retreats, and so you have access to the teachers while
- 16:48you're on retreat, but if you're not on retreat, often the access
- 16:52is limited. There is a lot of conversation
- 17:06about people getting into trouble in in in the the process
- 17:11of insight that happens because they're the either there,
- 17:19there's aspects of their self experience which is are
- 17:23presented to them in a way that's difficult for them to
- 17:25imagine or or integrate and also the the nature of.
- 17:32The way that we create our experience of conceptual reality
- 17:37can be undermined in a way that it creates a sense of
- 17:42fearfulness rather than a sense of insight and safety.
- 17:52I think that what we are doing in developing these communities
- 17:57around meditation practices and developing an understanding of
- 18:01the nature of the human condition that.
- 18:05We can reflect on how practice is well organized.
- 18:11Obviously we need a lot of different ways of practicing
- 18:15because there's a lot of variation in the way that people
- 18:17are. Certainly the different
- 18:21traditions develop and have developed in different cultures.
- 18:27In the West, we are taking in really since the late 1950s.
- 18:33These Asian ideas and running them through the the structures
- 18:39of our culture and we can expect them to evolve and change and be
- 18:45reflective of our culture that that would be a desirable and
- 18:51ordinary process that would happen.
- 18:54We wouldn't. We don't need to restrict so
- 18:58much of the changes that will come, but we do need to
- 19:01preserve. The the value of the teaching in
- 19:07terms of the insight that it can offer us that making sense.
- 19:18The early practice of and early teachings of the Buddha, the
- 19:22Terravata practice, went into China and over hundreds of years
- 19:28evolved into. Chan and then Japan over
- 19:35hundreds of years developed into Zen and then went into Tibet and
- 19:41over hundreds of years developed into Vagiana practice.
- 19:46Each of those cultures being infused into the way that the
- 19:51teaching is described so that it's relevant for members of
- 19:55those cultures is what I think is happening here.
- 20:00The teachings are evolving in their description so that people
- 20:06who are embedded in these cultures can relate to them in a
- 20:10way that is useful to them and at the same time the the insight
- 20:19into the nature of the human condition and enlightenment is
- 20:26being preserved. What I noticed in the West is,
- 20:33because it is not a central, ordinary organizing principle,
- 20:43Buddhist meditation, that it it appeals to a subset of people in
- 20:51our society that come because the the pursuit through the
- 20:58traditional avenues for addressing suffering have not
- 21:03been relieving enough of that suffering.
- 21:07And so we turn to alternatives outside of that, a central
- 21:13culture, one of which is Buddhist meditation, and that we
- 21:21come to it to address our experience of suffering.
- 21:28That's why I think that using a reflection in psychology is, is
- 21:38useful in our culture because we're used to looking at the
- 21:43nature of our suffering through that reflection.
- 21:52And I think that one of the things that's curious about the
- 21:55way that we practiced the West, of course, is we've dispensed
- 21:58with the traditional preliminary practices pretty quickly.
- 22:02I mean, are you doing your 100,000 prostrations before you
- 22:07begin your Tibetan practice or are you jumping over that and
- 22:12going right in? When I was in Miramar several
- 22:16years ago, I went to a monastery and I was assigned A monk who's
- 22:27going to take me around the monastery, and the exchange was
- 22:31that I would help him refine his English and he would talk to me
- 22:37about the meditation. But he'd been in the monastery
- 22:40for five years and he was still doing breath counting to enter
- 22:46into Janic states. And that the the teacher, his
- 22:50teacher, was not yet satisfied at the stability of his Janic
- 22:54states that he would then be allowed to move into a insight
- 22:58practice. Do you know anybody here would
- 23:02be willing to do five years of just breath counting before they
- 23:07would be offered an insight practice?
- 23:12I I, I, I think that that would be unlikely these with the
- 23:17people that I'm aware of. We like to go fast.
- 23:22We like to go all the way to the advanced practices that start
- 23:27there. Christian.
- 23:30George, do you think that like a really Westernized Buddhism can
- 23:34arise, that's not like totally commodified, like meditate, so
- 23:39you can be a better CEO kind of stuff, whatever Peter Thiel is
- 23:44doing. I I think that the, the
- 23:47mindfulness aspect of it is is in some sense fitting in to that
- 23:57process. But I don't.
- 23:59I certainly don't think that the the stuff that we do here or
- 24:03most of the the teaching that's interesting to me personally is
- 24:08in that vein. I think that really the that's
- 24:15the very surface of what's possible from practice and when
- 24:19you see the depth of practice and and see that the the very
- 24:24superficial, the very superficial outcomes from that
- 24:30kind of practice it it loses its interest almost immediately as
- 24:34those insights open. The one aspect of course is the
- 24:47ethical aspect of it. Are you adopting a non harming
- 24:52stance and organizing your life in that way?
- 25:04Or have you simply skipped over that preliminary part of the
- 25:08practice or you don't address any of that?
- 25:17What I like to say is, in the beginning of of deep practice,
- 25:22you make the decision to become a good person, and what that
- 25:27means is that you make a decision to live in an ethical
- 25:31way in the world. You don't make a decision to be
- 25:39a little bit happier or to be a little less stressed.
- 25:43You have to really examine the intention and actions that you
- 25:48take in the world and move yourself in the direction of an
- 25:52ethical stance. If you look at the precepts for
- 25:58laypeople, that would be a framework for that.
- 26:04The non harming, not lying, not stealing, not engaging sexual
- 26:10misconduct that causes harm, not engaging in intoxicants that
- 26:18lead to heedlessness. One of the things that that I
- 26:25think is interesting about the communities of people that
- 26:28gather around meditation practices who've exhausted other
- 26:33avenues of in their attempts to relieve their own suffering is
- 26:41that the surface level stuff isn't strong enough to help them
- 26:48and so they tend to dive deeper in.
- 26:56The world is filled with suffering and how do you hold
- 27:02the space for that without needing to restrict it or turn
- 27:06away from. If you grew up in a way that
- 27:11there was a lot of suffering in your life, you're used to people
- 27:16turning away from intensity of your suffering, finding a
- 27:23community of people where that doesn't happen as an
- 27:26extraordinary value. At Medigroup WE we teach mainly
- 27:36a practice of I like to call it meditation and attachment.
- 27:41So we use traditional meditation investigation strategies to
- 27:46explore the conditioning and understanding the conditioning
- 27:52that we've experienced through the attachment lens can be very
- 27:58helpful. We you asked a question earlier
- 28:02Christian about maps. The attachment map is a
- 28:06wonderful way to explore conditioning and it it tends to
- 28:12resonate more deeply for me than the poetry of India 2500 years
- 28:19ago or the Zen poetry or the Tibetan poetry.
- 28:24That these descriptions then allow you to use your meditation
- 28:29practices to investigate the these structures and then also
- 28:36to begin to change them, still relying on this understanding
- 28:42that we take in the sensing data.
- 28:46Mind of course is organizing what that data is And then that
- 28:51ultimate reality that we are able to experience through that
- 28:55sensing data and mind is compared to a perceptual
- 29:00database of previously defined sensing moments.
- 29:04And then we take that and roll it into the construction of
- 29:10conceptual reality that's happening for us in each moment
- 29:14as we make it, as we begin to explore that mechanism of
- 29:19converting the Sensing experience, that ultimate
- 29:22reality into conceptual reality. What we begin to understand is
- 29:27these working models that create the basis of conceptual reality.
- 29:34That if you grew up in a in a family system where you were
- 29:38valued, whether you're where your preferences were valued,
- 29:42where your experience and interpretations were valued,
- 29:50what you'll notice in each moment that you create
- 29:54conceptual reality, that's there you have an expectation that
- 30:01your preferences matter, that your opinions matter, that you
- 30:05should be taken care of, and it's right there and everything
- 30:09that you've created in terms of conceptual reality.
- 30:14But if you had a different kind of upbringing, those Basiss are
- 30:20also there in conceptual reality.
- 30:23If you grew up in a household where your preferences didn't
- 30:27matter, then you create moment by moment these realities where
- 30:33your preferences don't matter. If you grew up in a in a family
- 30:39system where you had no value, you create these tableaus of
- 30:44conceptual reality that are infused with the understanding
- 30:49that you have no value. Then this is really the insight,
- 30:53that traditional insight into the nature of our experience
- 30:57that we need to be able to see that we can begin to affect the
- 31:03way that we have operated based on those working models.
- 31:08When you look at the experience of that's described in
- 31:13attachment theory, it accounts for that does those first
- 31:21experiences of the child. And understanding that we do not
- 31:25see ourselves through our own sensing experience.
- 31:33What we see is the reflection of ourselves in the eyes of the
- 31:37caregiver and that that's the basis of the working models and
- 31:41that reflective capacity. And we construct these things
- 31:47and we need to be able to actually get in there and pull
- 31:50apart these working models ourselves and examine whether
- 31:54they're actually reflective of who we are and reflective of the
- 31:58experience of the present moment as it's unfolding for us.
- 32:03Or that our capacity to experience the present moment is
- 32:10distorted or clouded by the incapacity of the working models
- 32:15to take that in and then begin to make those modifications
- 32:19there. One of the things to give you an
- 32:26example, the metaphor that the Buddha used to describe this was
- 32:34the the chariot. Do you know the the the story of
- 32:39the the chariot as the Buddha described it?
- 32:43Where is the chariotness in the chariot?
- 32:47When you take the chariot apart and you lay all of the pieces on
- 32:50the ground, you have the wheels, you have the yoke, you have the
- 32:54platform, you have the rail, you have the reins.
- 33:00All of that is there axle. You lay it all on the ground.
- 33:05Where in the wheel is the chariot?
- 33:09Where in the axle is the chariot?
- 33:12Where is in the yolk? Where in the yolk is the
- 33:15chariot. But when you put the whole thing
- 33:18together and all of those pieces are there, you have the
- 33:21chariotness of the chariot. You can stand on it, you can
- 33:25hitch it to a horse, you can ride it.
- 33:29So when the sense of self is gathered together from all of
- 33:33the different pieces that make up that experience, including
- 33:37that working model of the sense of self, we have the experience
- 33:40of self. But when you describe attachment
- 33:44conditioning and what happens and how that creates distortions
- 33:50in the view that are predictable based on that attachment
- 33:54conditioning, I could recognize that view almost immediately.
- 34:01But the metaphor of the chariot and is was not actually
- 34:04illustrating that. I heard a lecture in the the
- 34:09late 90s by Alan Shore who was speaking at the Neuropsychiatric
- 34:17Institute at UCLA. He gave a lecture on
- 34:21disorganized attachment and he said this is the pattern of
- 34:25people's lives who have disorganized detachment.
- 34:29And he described this pattern of a lot of beginnings, sometimes
- 34:35really bright beginnings, and then some middles.
- 34:39Not a lot of middles, but some middles and then almost no
- 34:42finishes. Because the the the emotional
- 34:46difficulty of integrating into a team of people and sustaining
- 34:51those relationships, and also the anxiety about succeeding
- 34:55often combined in in this way that created that pattern.
- 35:02I identified it immediately. It was a pattern that I'd been
- 35:05wrestling with all of my life, trying to figure out how I could
- 35:09affect, so that I didn't have to have these bright beginnings and
- 35:14some troubled middles and no finishes.
- 35:16Because it was so painful to repeat.
- 35:19That without feeling any sense of agency to undo it.
- 35:26That making sense, that that that description of of how
- 35:33conditioning tends to unfold was immediately useful to me.
- 35:39Whereas the the the poetry, although I could understand it
- 35:43and intellectually in it made sense and I even enjoyed it did
- 35:49not offer the same Ave. of exploration that resulted in the
- 35:56release of the patterns. So that's what I like.
- 36:04And then I also like the idea of preliminary practices.
- 36:09I know that we don't tend to do many of them, but I do think
- 36:12that if you have attachment adverse attachment conditioning,
- 36:19working through that adverse attachment conditioning is a
- 36:24preliminary practice before going on to a deep insight
- 36:28practice, you move through that conditioning, which you can do
- 36:32pretty quickly. Develop your meditation skill in
- 36:37working with these patterns of conditioning which are easily
- 36:41described. Not only do you learn the
- 36:44techniques and how to operate them, but you clear away the
- 36:47obstacles that then allow you to Sprint the more classical
- 36:54investigations of what enlightenment is.
- 36:57Which is really to see in a deep way the way that these
- 37:05conditioned responses to what's actually happened to you inform.
- 37:10The way that you create each moment of conceptual reality.
- 37:17And that the only way to really undo that habitual construction
- 37:23of these limiting ideas about self and world is through that
- 37:28practice. But really seeing it clearly,
- 37:33watching it unfold moment by moment, that making sense.
- 37:43Hello, if you practice in the traditional Mahasi map, you do
- 37:50the one set of meditation strategies.
- 37:53It tends to lead to the the next insight in along the path and
- 37:58you do the practices for that insight.
- 38:02It moves you into the next insight, and you move all along
- 38:06and just in an ordinary flow. If you do the six lamps practice
- 38:10through each of the lamp stages, you move in that way, and that
- 38:16can be quite useful, I think. Or you can assemble, as as many
- 38:22of us do in the West, these these grab bags of practice and
- 38:29then be surprised by what happened.
- 38:31But then you the IT is a rather spectacular range of knowledge
- 38:35that you need in order to understand what's actually
- 38:38happening from the variations of practice that you're doing.
- 38:44You know, Do you like to cook? I like to cook, and I cook quite
- 38:50a bit, and I'd like to make my own recipes based on my
- 38:56particular tastes. And I will work on one
- 39:02particular dish over a period of time until it's just really the
- 39:05way that I like it. And then I'll cook it a few
- 39:07times and then I'll lose interest and move on to
- 39:09something. But then I'll remember it and
- 39:11want to recreate it. And sometimes I leave out one of
- 39:20the ingredients and I'll taste it and it won't work at all.
- 39:24And then I'll have to reengineer it.
- 39:29Christian. Whenever I make something,
- 39:33George, I I like. The first time I make it, it's
- 39:36really, really good because I follow the recipe and then times
- 39:41I really fuck it up because I start freestyling.
- 39:46You have to get through that part until you get to the the
- 39:49moment of perfection. When it's it meets your taste
- 39:54buds exactly. So do you think the the, the the
- 40:00sort of cafeteria approach versus just kind of picking one
- 40:03thing and sticking to it? Like is that something that we
- 40:06even have control over? Is that kind of like people will
- 40:08just gravitate to whichever one makes sense for them?
- 40:11Or like, which one do you recommend?
- 40:15Just like pick a path and stick with it.
- 40:19I think if you're early in practice it's better to pick a a
- 40:24defined way of working so that you can see how insight opens
- 40:32into insight opens into insight that and that it's predictable.
- 40:38But then also there's a vast range of ways of practicing, and
- 40:47that some exploration is also useful.
- 40:51I I when I having been a long time practitioner in Shinzen's
- 41:02world, when I began to go into the Tibetan practice, I didn't
- 41:07need to spend a lot of time in the preliminary practices
- 41:12because I could always already do everything as it came up.
- 41:17It was described differently, but it wasn't a big issue for me
- 41:22to be able to practice in the way that they recommended and
- 41:26have the insight that they offered in that.
- 41:29It really wasn't until getting into the the more esoteric
- 41:33practices where the that foundational practice that I had
- 41:38didn't really apply much. And so then it was a much more
- 41:41involved way of practicing in order to have the insights that
- 41:47were recommended. But because I understood the
- 41:52nature of insight in in practice, it was also not as
- 42:02laborious as it was in the beginning of the taraval product
- 42:05practice. And because I think a lot of the
- 42:11the obstacles that get into the way of practice had already been
- 42:16pushed through in the earlier practice, that also didn't
- 42:20happen. So what I noticed was the
- 42:21movement through the the map and the insights came quite quickly
- 42:31and I didn't have to begin again the way that I did with the
- 42:35Theravada practice. But why don't we do a little
- 42:41meditation practice? I thought that we could start
- 42:43with a little bit of breath counting and then do a see her
- 42:47feel focus in, focus out, which is a good insight practice, all
- 42:55right, and the period of meditation coming back into the
- 42:59present moment, experience the outside.
- 43:09So we have a few things coming up.
- 43:12We have a level 1 coming up starting in August, if I can
- 43:18find the dates on that. So August 12th for four
- 43:29Saturdays from 9:00 to 1:15, we have a Level 0 coming up on our
- 43:39new Level 0 is going to be on Thursday, August 3rd, and then
- 43:46we're going to have a new level 2 starting
- 44:00on September 21st. So those are the main things
- 44:06that are coming up I'll take a look at most of that stuff is on
- 44:10the website already. Really appreciate your practice.
- 44:15I do offer the teachings freely, but I do hope that if you can
- 44:18make a donation, you will. There's a link on the website to
- 44:21make a donation. Any amount is helpful.
- 44:24It supports me and also the work that Meta Group is doing.
- 44:27I really appreciate you. Thank you and I'll see you soon.
- 44:31Bye.