Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 176. From Stereotypes to Synergy: Communicating Across Generations
Transcript
- 0:00Matt Abrahams: Communicating among the different generations in the workplace can be quite challenging.
- 0:04Some companies have between four and five generations working side by side.
- 0:11My name is Matt Abrahams, and I teach strategic communication at Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:17Welcome to Think Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:25Today, I'm excited to speak with Bob McCann.
- 0:28Bob holds his primary faculty appointment at the UCLA Anderson School of Management, where he is also the director of the Leadership Communication Program, and a secondary appointment at the UCLA Henry Samueli School of Engineering in Applied Science.
- 0:43Bob teaches courses in leadership communication, entrepreneurship, global leadership, and persuasion.
- 0:50Bob is also a consultant and founded the McCann Group.
- 0:53Bob, I'm really excited to have our conversation today.
- 0:56Bob McCann: Thank you.
- 0:56It's really nice of you to invite me.
- 0:57I really appreciate it.
- 0:59Matt Abrahams: Thanks.
- 0:59Shall we get started?
- 1:00Bob McCann: Let's do it.
- 1:01Matt Abrahams: A lot of your research and work focuses on intergenerational interactions in the workplace.
- 1:06Can you give us some context around this issue?
- 1:08Why should we care about generational interactions?
- 1:12Bob McCann: We should care because in our current landscape, we have four, five, maybe even six generations in the workplace at the same time.
- 1:22And so there's a tremendous opportunity for meeting and interacting with people who are different than you, for increasing a variety of potential outcomes in business in a positive way if we can maximize our intergenerational engagement.
- 1:38I think that it's a particularly important topic and a topic that means a lot to me.
- 1:43I mean, my dad is ninety-seven years old.
- 1:46And still works fifty hours a week.
- 1:49So I think all of us as researchers, as academics, we need to study something that we care about.
- 1:54Matt Abrahams: That's amazing, by the way.
- 1:56And certainly we're graduating students all the time who enter the workplace and they're working with people who've been there for a longer time.
- 2:02What, and how do you look at a generation?
- 2:04What is a generation?
- 2:05We have these names for them, but what does it mean?
- 2:08Bob McCann: It's a good question, and there's not necessarily one answer to the question.
- 2:12So, we can look at a generation as sort of a span of twenty to thirty years.
- 2:17Then there's the more socially constructed generations that demographers might use that is often pinned around a specific event in time.
- 2:26So, for example, the great generation, as I mentioned, my father, that that generation might be tied to World War Two, whereas the baby boom generation, a very large one is more of a demographically based generation.
- 2:38Matt Abrahams: Okay.
- 2:39So there are lots of ways of categorizing.
- 2:40Bob McCann: There are.
- 2:41Matt Abrahams: The bottom line is we have people with lots of different experiences in the workplace at the same time, and those groups or generations tend to have certain characteristics that stand out.
- 2:52Bob McCann: That's right.
- 2:52And I think sometimes we exaggerate or overemphasize the similarities and, or differences in a generation.
- 2:59But on the other hand, it's a handy tool.
- 3:02It's a handy tool as well.
- 3:03Matt Abrahams: Yeah.
- 3:03So this academic year is the first year that all of our students are primarily Gen Z.
- 3:09We use these names to help categorize based on a timestamp.
- 3:13In your work, what are things that leaders and companies can do to help around these generational issues?
- 3:20Bob McCann: So if we start at an organizational level, it would well serve most companies in some sense regardless of whether they're small, medium or large to have age diversity as a part of their DEI efforts.
- 3:33So we often have, talk about gender diversity and we talk about ethnic diversity and sexual orientation and ability and disability and cognition and so on and so forth.
- 3:44That's wonderful as we should.
- 3:46However, ageism and age diversity sometimes gets forgotten.
- 3:50There are little things organizations can do.
- 3:52They can scan their own website to see if it, let's just imagine an older worker was looking at the Stanford Business School website, scan for images.
- 4:00Maybe it would look like a more welcoming place for an older individual if they saw different images on the website.
- 4:05Certainly would want to have anti bias training.
- 4:08As you move to the next level it could be job ads, for example.
- 4:12We can look what kind of language do we use in our job ads.
- 4:15So if we have ads such as, I'm looking for a vibrant worker and a fresh face to work in a fast paced environment, we have to be careful for ageist code words.
- 4:26So I think that at an organizational level, intergenerational mentoring, where we have reverse age mentoring, is something we see a lot now in the research.
- 4:36Intergenerational team formation is something else we see.
- 4:40These are all sort of at the corporate and leadership level.
- 4:43And then ultimately, I think a lot of the research is quite useful.
- 4:47If we look, go back twenty years ago, it was that the problem of the stereotypes and so on was well researched, but the solutions were not.
- 4:54And now we're starting to see a lot of the solutions.
- 4:57Matt Abrahams: Absolutely.
- 4:57And underlying everything you shared is this notion that diversity in all types is beneficial to organizations, not just gender or cultural diversity, but also age diversity is really beneficial and anything you can do to foster that.
- 5:12How do the different groups communicate differently in the workplace?
- 5:17Can you help us tease out some of the fact from the stereotypes?
- 5:21Bob McCann: Generally speaking, the stereotypes about older people tend to be negative.
- 5:26Communicatively challenged, frail, slow.
- 5:29Then we have workplace stereotypes.
- 5:32Older workers as struggling with technology or older workers as being less productive.
- 5:36These are stereotypes now.
- 5:38Older workers as being slower on the job.
- 5:42Older workers as being more loyal.
- 5:44Uh, older workers as being more trustworthy.
- 5:47So there are a variety of positive and negative stereotypes that we can see in the organizations.
- 5:54There is the stereotype literature, which is robust.
- 5:57And then there's the communication literature, which looks at what are some of the communication patterns that we see in organizations and outside of organizations that may in some sense, play along with these stereotypes.
- 6:11So for example, you may be over accommodative, you may be under accommodative, you may dismiss someone communicatively because you view them as an out group as opposed to an age in group.
- 6:25So a lot of the communication can track along in that way, too.
- 6:29Then, of course, there's age discrimination, and that is what I studied years ago.
- 6:32I started looking at age discrimination cases.
- 6:36And we started to bucket out different types of language that we found utilized in age discrimination cases.
- 6:43And attract very handily with these stereotypes, you could literally bucket them into the out to pasture stereotype.
- 6:50So it's really fascinating how communication and stereotypes, everything here go together.
- 6:56Matt Abrahams: Absolutely.
- 6:57And just as you identified some of the stereotypes that younger workers have of older workers, older workers absolutely have stereotypes of younger workers as not focused or not caring to the same degree.
- 7:09It sounds to me like part of what we have to do is be aware that this stereotyping happens.
- 7:14And then it sounds like there are things we can do through communication to help, one, bust those stereotypes, but also help facilitate interaction.
- 7:22And I'd like to drill down a bit more there.
- 7:24Are there things that you know from the literature or your work that can help bring better interaction among the generations?
- 7:32Bob McCann: The key would be quality contact over quantity of contact.
- 7:38So as an example, we now see many companies moving into shadow boards.
- 7:42So we have a board of directors, which may be senior, older person heavy, and younger people are brought into the boards to shadow the older board of directors people.
- 7:53So that is an example of bringing a young person into a group that they may be excluded, and the quality of contact there can be quite strong.
- 8:02Another one would be age mentoring.
- 8:04So a younger worker might mentor, and this is done in quite a few companies.
- 8:08Now I'm seeing it in the pharmaceutical industry and where a younger person might mentor an older worker on technology and an older worker may share wisdom with a younger person on something else.
- 8:19Cross training is another.
- 8:20So there are many organization, organizational initiatives that stress quality of context.
- 8:26So just getting together at the pub or the bar for a party, may not be quality content.
- 8:32Matt Abrahams: I like these examples because there are things that you can build into organizations, inviting younger people to boards where maybe older people are sitting on it, forming teams in a way that's very diverse in terms of age and other perspectives.
- 8:46And it seems to me that the actual quality of the interaction is also important.
- 8:50So if I'm facilitating a meeting, perhaps I make sure that I'm hearing from lots of different people.
- 8:56It might be that the older person talks more or the younger person talks less or the language, that in vocabulary are different.
- 9:03And I as a facilitator of those interactions need to be very careful to make sure that everybody is literally speaking the same language and has the opportunity in terms of talk time as well.
- 9:14The operationalization of the communication, not just the ways in which we're organizing also are important.
- 9:21Bob McCann: That's correct.
- 9:22And I think, is it Amazon where a lot of the younger employees are actually in different meetings are asked to speak first in the meeting?
- 9:29Matt Abrahams: Right.
- 9:29So the more junior which tends to be related to age.
- 9:33Bob McCann: So it's the same idea in some sense.
- 9:35And I think these type of initiatives are really useful and they don't really cost much money.
- 9:40In many cases.
- 9:41Matt Abrahams: Right.
- 9:41And the research that I'm familiar with shows that meetings, for example, are more productive and people feel better about their contributions and how the whole group is working.
- 9:51You mentioned technology as an example of some of the mentoring that can happen.
- 9:55I'm curious, based on what you know about this, how technology plays in this, how does technology play both as something that can help in these circumstances and perhaps actually drive even bigger wedges in between the generations?
- 10:08Bob McCann: Let's just talk, I think the interaction between technology and training is an, if, can we go down that road?
- 10:14Matt Abrahams: Sure.
- 10:15Absolutely.
- 10:15Bob McCann: So there is research, some of it rather unfortunate, that older workers are often denied training.
- 10:22We also know from some research that when a trainer knows that an individual is an older worker, they will provide less quality training and shorter training to the older individual.
- 10:34There's some interesting studies done on that.
- 10:36Number one, if we could work to bust some of those stereotypes in and of itself, that would be helpful.
- 10:43However, older workers do train differently, but from the research, it would suggest there is a preference towards live training.
- 10:49There's a preference towards storytelling and training.
- 10:52There's a preference towards self paced training.
- 10:55There's a preference towards an interactive engagement in training.
- 10:59So I don't think it's necessarily the technology that the older workers can't necessarily handle, but they need to be trained in many cases in a way that is differently.
- 11:10So all we need to do on a given weekday afternoon, go to an Apple store.
- 11:15The periphery of the store are all younger people, but in the middle of the store, it's all older individuals training.
- 11:22I think that's a perfect illustration of some of the differences.
- 11:26Matt Abrahams: I really appreciate what you did in your answer, which was to take a question that's based on a stereotype about technology and turn it into what I think is really more important.
- 11:35Which is understanding how people interact with and learn not just technology, but I think more broadly to capture and truly benefit from diversity of any type we really have to reflect on how people like to learn, like to engage.
- 11:50And we have to adjust.
- 11:51As somebody, prior to my academic career, who ran learning and development, it was very clear that you have to be very cognizant about how people best receive new information and training.
- 12:03This has been a fascinating conversation and one that I think opens up my mind and I hope everybody listening in to this notion that we need to be very cognizant of how we communicate when interacting with people older than us or younger than us.
- 12:18And there are things we can do institutionally within an organization, but also in our own practices to better serve those needs.
- 12:26I end every one of these episodes with three questions.
- 12:29One, I make special just for you.
- 12:31And then two that everybody else answers.
- 12:33Are you up for answering these?
- 12:34Bob McCann: Go for it.
- 12:35Matt Abrahams: So one of the areas that you study is persuasion.
- 12:38If you were to go into an organization and try to persuade them to implement one thing that you think would make a big difference in how folks of different generations communicate, what would you advocate for?
- 12:50Bob McCann: Who am I persuading?
- 12:51I like the, I always need to know who the audience is.
- 12:53Am I persuading the senior leadership?
- 12:55Matt Abrahams: Yeah, your leadership.
- 12:56Bob McCann: I would persuade them to implement initiatives to have all employees in the organization, regardless of how small or how large it is, to diversify their networks.
- 13:08Your LinkedIn network, it could be the people on your phone, it could be your, all the people that you feel that are in your network.
- 13:14Scan for diversity, scan for age, scan for culture, scan for gender, find opportunities around common interests that you can meet and engage with people that are different than you.
- 13:31Because if they can create opportunities for the organization, the people in the company to deeply engage with people that are not like themselves.
- 13:42I think that could probably have as big an impact as anything you would see in an organization.
- 13:47So I'm trying to go maybe deeper than you thought.
- 13:49Matt Abrahams: No, no.
- 13:49I think that's absolutely wonderful and important.
- 13:53And I like how you rooted it in everybody look at what you are doing.
- 13:57Look at your phone, look at your LinkedIn network.
- 13:59Notice that and as a leader, what can you do to expand those networks for the people?
- 14:04I think that's fantastic advice.
- 14:06Question number two.
- 14:07Who's a communicator that you admire and why?
- 14:10Bob McCann: Indra Nooyi.
- 14:11Matt Abrahams: Tell me more.
- 14:12Bob McCann: In business school, we always hear rockstar.
- 14:14This person's a rockstar, and that person's a rockstar.
- 14:17I think it's overused, quite frankly, not with Indra Nooyi.
- 14:22The language that Indra Nooyi uses is vivid.
- 14:27The storytelling is audience centric and engaging.
- 14:34You feel like Indra's stories are our stories.
- 14:39The way I've seen Indra work audiences and react and be in tune with them and engaged is fascinating.
- 14:48I think Indra Nooyi is one of the most authentic speakers I've ever seen.
- 14:53Just listen to the word choice, her body language, her ease, her articulation.
- 14:59Matt Abrahams: She certainly is a good communicator and as the former CEO of PepsiCo, somebody who is very important in my life since I enjoy so many of those products regularly.
- 15:09So she is the chief executive of the PepsiCo company and that's a very good speaker and a very good choice.
- 15:17Final question.
- 15:19What are the first three ingredients that go into a successful communication recipe?
- 15:24Bob McCann: So as you know, I, or maybe don't know, I was raised just outside of Boston.
- 15:27So we think in terms of sports.
- 15:29So Bill Belichick, the New England Patriots over and over and over talked about the three phases of the game.
- 15:34Offense, defense, special teams.
- 15:37So there's our NFL football analogy.
- 15:40I feel that we need to be prepared for our offense.
- 15:43So I'm very, I really am a systems person here.
- 15:46It's probably 'cause I teach at the school of engineering.
- 15:48Starting with the offense, your metrics, your data, your statistics, your stories, your internal evidence, your external evidence.
- 15:58I work with the students to make sure their offense is strong and they're generally pretty good.
- 16:01I think they undersell the stories, they undersell the soft evidence.
- 16:04They probably overdo the quantitative evidence.
- 16:06But the defense I think is less.
- 16:08By defense I mean, being ready for friction, being ready for objections.
- 16:11I'm sure you know the book, the human element.
- 16:14I think students under prepare for that.
- 16:15If you can be ready for those objections, in many cases, the defense can become the offense.
- 16:21And then the final is the sort of special sauce, the special team for the NFL analogy is that we then look deeply at the audience and we look at our micro level and our macro level persuasion.
- 16:32We look at different persuasive techniques.
- 16:35So really for me, it's those three things.
- 16:36If someone always understands the audience, they're in tune, they're ready for Q and A, and they can prepare for those three areas, I think they're going to be in good shape.
- 16:46Matt Abrahams: I like the analogy in that.
- 16:47It signals that we shouldn't focus just on all the reasons why for something.
- 16:52We also have to think about when our message meets the people in the resistance, hesitation, concern, and we need to be prepared for that.
- 16:59And I agree many people are underprepared.
- 17:01And then we need to look at the tools that we have, the special tools that can help us leveraging some of the influence tactics that you mentioned.
- 17:07And absolutely, I agree that everything is predicated on understanding the audience and appreciating where they're at.
- 17:14Bob, this has been a fascinating conversation.
- 17:16I appreciate you giving us insight into yet another area of diversity that we need to be thinking about in our communication and organizations, particularly around age and generations.
- 17:25Lots of very practical and tactical bits of advice.
- 17:28Thank you.
- 17:29Bob McCann: Thank you, man.
- 17:30It's a pleasure.
- 17:33Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of Think Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast To learn more about diversity in the workplace, please listen to episode 67 with Michele Gelfand and episode 21 with Sarah Soule.
- 17:47This episode was produced by Jenny Luna, Michael Riley, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 17:53Our music is from Floyd Wonder.
- 17:55Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts, be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 18:01Also follow us on LinkedIn and Instagram.
- 18:04And check out fastersmarter.io for deep dive videos, English language learning content, and our newsletter.