Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Commercial Loan Underwriting That Satisfies NCUA
Transcript
- 0:05Often credit proposal has a cover page and a lot of what we've talked about,
- 0:10that justification should probably be on the front page so the reader then
- 0:14knows what the risk rate is, the level of risk associated with that credit.
- 0:19A summary of the relationship that we just talked about is
- 0:24important to have on the front page.
- 0:26And another thing that's important to have on that front page
- 0:30is any exceptions to policy.
- 0:33And again, a brief explanation why it's an acceptable exception to policy.
- 0:38And what that does, if the cover page has important information like
- 0:42that, then the reader, as they review the cover page, , they're going
- 0:46to have a good sense for the deal.
- 0:49the risk associated with the deal, and if there are those policy exceptions.
- 0:54You don't want somebody to read something on page two and say, hey, wait, that's
- 1:00a policy exception, and then not explain what it is for another two pages when you
- 1:05get into the financial section, because they've just read two pages saying, hey,
- 1:09what else is wrong with this credit?
- 1:11Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark with a special Archive
- 1:14episode of With Flying Colors.
- 1:16I hope you enjoy.
- 1:21Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 1:25Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 1:28your exam with Flying Colors.
- 1:31The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 1:33Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 1:36If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 1:39team and receive support to optimize NCUA so you save time and
- 1:44money, visit us at marktreichel.
- 1:46com.
- 1:46Hello,
- 1:54I'm Mark Treichel, and you are listening to With Flying Colors, the podcast where
- 1:59I interview subject matter experts to provide credit union leaders with tips
- 2:04on how you can achieve success with NCUA and pass your exam with flying colors.
- 2:13Today, I'm joined by Vin Vieten, who previously was on
- 2:16to talk about credit culture.
- 2:18Today, Vin and I are going to talk about financial analysis, credit
- 2:23proposals, and a philosophical discussion on global cash flow.
- 2:27And of course, all three of these relate to commercial lending
- 2:31or member business lending.
- 2:32Vin, before we jump in for people who are just meeting you for the
- 2:36first time, could you share a little bit about who you are and your
- 2:39career and your experience at NCUA?
- 2:43Sure.
- 2:43Good morning, Mark and everyone.
- 2:45Yeah, I was the senior credit specialist.
- 2:49At the NCOA for about 11 years, I retired last February.
- 2:55And prior to that, I had actually worked for a concrete company as controller
- 3:02managing the banking relationships.
- 3:04And then prior to that, I was a senior loan office in some
- 3:07community banks in New England.
- 3:09So I've been able to experience lending from The lender's point
- 3:15perspective, the borrower's perspective, and then as a regulator.
- 3:19So I've all three of those experiences were just great to give me, to give
- 3:26me and confirm my perspective on the importance of commercial lending and
- 3:31supporting your borrower's needs.
- 3:33Very good.
- 3:34Yeah.
- 3:34So Vin, you've really, from every angle, so you have a very unique perspective.
- 3:38You've applied for business loans when you were at the concrete company.
- 3:43You reviewed business loans when you were at the bank, and then you wrote regulation
- 3:48and guidance at NCUA as the regulator, so you really touched it all, which, again,
- 3:53really provides you with a perspective that not many people out there have.
- 3:57So let's jump in.
- 3:58Let's, uh, let's talk about financial analysis as it
- 4:01relates to commercial lending.
- 4:04And then the floor is yours.
- 4:06The financial analysis and credit approval document are really the most, are very
- 4:11important pieces of commercial lending.
- 4:13And of course, the financial analysis allows you to understand the financial
- 4:17strength and condition of the borrower.
- 4:19And then the credit approval documents, the loan request and
- 4:24support for the credit decision.
- 4:28And the financial analysis, we did find there was a many different approaches.
- 4:33to financial analysis in the credit union industry.
- 4:37So when the rule was rewritten five years ago, we emphasize
- 4:44the importance of consistent and accurate financial analysis.
- 4:49You'll find in the preamble to the proposed rule, and Mark, you will have
- 4:54links to these documents, correct?
- 4:58Yes.
- 4:58So I will put thing that you think needs to be put in the show notes.
- 5:02I can link to the show notes for the show.
- 5:04So someone wants to go to that link.
- 5:05They can find it.
- 5:06There will also be a transcript of our interview on my website, marktreichel.
- 5:12com, which will also have the link.
- 5:14There'll be two, then the two important links that I'd like people to reference
- 5:19would be the link to the examiner's guide regarding financial analysis
- 5:24and the credit approval document.
- 5:26And then also.
- 5:28To two or three pages in the preamble.
- 5:33To the proposed rule, which was issued in July of 2015, though
- 5:40it's a few years back, it's still the standard that the board, the
- 5:45NCOA board set as expectations for financial analysis and risk assessment.
- 5:50Let me pause you right there.
- 5:51So you're referencing the preamble to the rule, the preamble often.
- 5:55Is almost more revealing than the actual regulation because it
- 5:59tells you what staff was thinking.
- 6:01And more importantly, what the board was thinking.
- 6:03So it can actually.
- 6:04provide examples that credit unions can look to and apply to the regulation
- 6:10and really understand what was meant by the words that are in the regulation.
- 6:14Even though what we're going to reference is the proposed rule, the language,
- 6:17that's something that you can look to to make sure that you're complying with
- 6:21the intent of what NCUA is thinking and what the board was thinking at that time.
- 6:26Yes, exactly.
- 6:27And the reason why the proposed rule is acceptable in this case, there's
- 6:30a two step process is I think most people are aware of you propose a rule,
- 6:34there's reaction from the stakeholders.
- 6:37And then there's a final rule.
- 6:39The proposed rule that we issued did not change very
- 6:42much and not in a material way.
- 6:45Therefore, Any of the discussion that you'll find in the proposed rule
- 6:51generally still applies and was the intent of the board and the staff.
- 6:55It's very important, especially in this case, the proposed rule
- 6:59will out and in the other sections of the rule to and it does.
- 7:03It explains very well what the board expectations were.
- 7:07In fact, I always find the proposed preamble more insightful because the
- 7:13preamble to the final rule generally It's just comments from stakeholders
- 7:19and reaction from the agency, but the actual specific instructions
- 7:23and intent are generally better.
- 7:26And especially in this case, outlined in the proposed rule,
- 7:29then that's a great point.
- 7:30So, if the proposal.
- 7:33If the final rule is similar to the proposal, you're going to find more
- 7:36meat in the proposed preamble in a situation where there was a material
- 7:40change that the board made in the final rule, that preamble might have
- 7:44a little bit more meat, but I never really thought of it that way, that
- 7:47the proposal probably has more meat.
- 7:49So that's a good thing to.
- 7:50Yeah, sure.
- 7:50And again, one of the problems with preambles are is nobody
- 7:53knows where to find them.
- 7:55So we're hoping to make this a little bit easier for you by establishing a link.
- 8:00On the website for you to just click on.
- 8:02You're good at finding them.
- 8:03And Steve Farr is good at finding them.
- 8:05And another person who helps me on topics other than commercial ending,
- 8:08although actually he helped me on a commercial ending project that you
- 8:11and I were working on for a client.
- 8:12But yeah, it's, they're not the easiest things to find, but once you
- 8:15find the tricks of how to do it, they are out there and we, again, we will
- 8:19post them in the show notes so that you can see what Ben's referring to.
- 8:22So what else on financial analysis is there?
- 8:25It should be well organized market.
- 8:26And that's, and, uh, And a structured approach that all lenders hopefully
- 8:32follow now every deal is different.
- 8:34So you do have to be able to mend it and as you need to based on the borrower.
- 8:40But I always found in my financial analysis, you want to, you're
- 8:43looking to establish what are the trends of the business?
- 8:46Really?
- 8:46What are the, for all the financial Strength of the business, but
- 8:50mostly the trends of the business.
- 8:52So you're going to need a reasonable amount of financial performance.
- 8:57And that means the, how many years back are you going to take a look
- 9:01at the financial performance?
- 9:03The standard is three years worth of activity plus current
- 9:06financial information for that year, the current year.
- 9:10However, uh, that of course you can only, if it's only been a business for
- 9:14two years, you can only get two years worth, but sometimes you may need more
- 9:18than that and use your judgment to what's sufficient, but ultimately you shouldn't
- 9:23be able to establish the trend that a business, the financial trends of that
- 9:27business, you're going to, that's going to lead to following the financial analysis.
- 9:33You're going to have a debt service ability, which is some
- 9:36type of cashflow analysis.
- 9:37You can use traditional cashflow.
- 9:40You can use UCA, which is uniform credit analysis, two, two different
- 9:46methods of, and there's other methods of cashflow, but be careful.
- 9:51If you, whatever you choose to loo to use, make sure that you understand what it's.
- 9:58What the analysis is telling you, and also that it accurate
- 10:01accurately represents that borrower's ability to service the debt.
- 10:06I know with the UCA cashflow at that does a good job of establishing some influence
- 10:14and changes on the balance sheet, which should not just be listed, but
- 10:19understood what's causing those changes.
- 10:23There should be income and expense trend discussed, and again, balance
- 10:27sheet changes, like I just mentioned, and the borrower should have a
- 10:31satisfactory payment history.
- 10:33So, when looking at the analysis, I always, and this is my personal
- 10:40opinion, Preference how you just make.
- 10:43I think the important thing is that it's consistent.
- 10:45I always looked at the income statement 1st to see what the trend is in revenue.
- 10:49Then look at the gross profit trends, expense trend and then net profit.
- 10:53Trends and then look at those influences on the balance sheet and then did
- 10:58a discussion on the balance sheet.
- 10:59So I think it's very important that.
- 11:05The lending institution has a consistent approach and logical approach to the
- 11:11way they approach their credit analysis.
- 11:13So, Vin, as you're talking, I'm thinking of some of the conversations we've
- 11:17had with my clients who have had some commercial lending and were wanting, The
- 11:24wanting to improve their processes for their members and also to satisfy NCUA.
- 11:30And I'm thinking of a couple of examples where you talked about when you look
- 11:33at this financial analysis, like owner draws or owner influxes of cash into
- 11:40the business, and I, I remember some interesting con where owners were
- 11:43having to put money in and as you were looking at a particular credit.
- 11:48what that meant to you.
- 11:49Do you remember that situation?
- 11:50Is there any color you can add to, to, to what I just thought?
- 11:54Yeah, yes, I will.
- 11:55But I just thought of something else.
- 11:56As you said that Mark, it's really what I went to work at a bank as a senior
- 12:02lender and the lenders all had different approaches to, and no structure.
- 12:08And then we'll talk about that a little bit more in the credit proposal, but
- 12:12no structure to their presentation.
- 12:14Or their approach to financial analysis.
- 12:17So I would read these write ups and I'd have to read them two or three
- 12:21times to get a sense of what the quality of the financial analysis was.
- 12:25And usually I had to do my own financial analysis and the way I
- 12:30think about it in order to get a sense whether it was a good deal or not.
- 12:34And, but what I, what was, what I learned from that is Boy, you're
- 12:40really dependent on who your lender is on whether you get proper financing
- 12:45or not, because each lender had their separate approach to analysis.
- 12:51So if you have a consistent approach, it's going to do a number of things.
- 12:56It's going to first make sure that You're fair to all your borrowers
- 13:01and they're all being looked at in a consistent and accurate way.
- 13:05It's going to help train those individuals at the financial institution, the credit
- 13:10union, such as the board and maybe some of the other senior management who are
- 13:15involved with commercial lending but not well versed in commercial lending.
- 13:19They'll be trained in how to look at a credit.
- 13:22So it's important that consistency and completeness Comprehensive
- 13:28review is really fair to the borrower and also to those involved
- 13:33with making that credit decision.
- 13:34Yeah, and it's it there's there was a number of you see
- 13:40sometimes that the cash flows are.
- 13:43Are documented, but there was no, no attention paid to the balance
- 13:48sheet and the balance sheet had the leverage had increased over
- 13:55the year and money went out to the borrower through a stockholder loan.
- 14:00So it's important that you tie the two together.
- 14:04I like that.
- 14:04I always like to look at.
- 14:07The income and expense trends, and then whatever that cash flow net cash flow
- 14:12number is, where does it show up in the balance sheet is it being funded
- 14:16from receivables reduction inventory reduction or an increase in debt or is it.
- 14:23Being funded through the proper operations of the business.
- 14:26So there's a lot to think about when you bring those together.
- 14:29And do you bring the balance sheet?
- 14:31The balance sheet is especially important when there's activity in
- 14:34the working assets of the business.
- 14:36Meaning usually a manufacturer, you're going to see inventory and
- 14:39receivables change significantly.
- 14:43And some people are, it's really not that important when you're looking at rental
- 14:47real estate because they just collect rents and there's generally not much.
- 14:51Balance sheet activity.
- 14:52But as you said, Mark, again, there should be some discussion of the balance sheet
- 14:58and every financial analysis, because things can be happening on even more
- 15:04straightforward cashflow businesses like rental real estate, especially if they
- 15:09have a receivable, their receivables are increasing in their more than 30 days,
- 15:15that means they're not getting paid.
- 15:17So it's really important that there's.
- 15:19Some reasonable check to the balance sheet and then, and any changes to the
- 15:24balance sheet, if it's within reason and in line with the income statement.
- 15:29Got it.
- 15:29So then I, as you talk through that, I had two takeaways,
- 15:35getting the financial analysis.
- 15:37It's not just a paper exercise.
- 15:39It, you have to understand what those documents or financial statements say,
- 15:45how it flows through and what that means.
- 15:47Good or bad for the borrower.
- 15:49And then the other thing is a word that words that came to mind were
- 15:53standard operating procedures.
- 15:55You need some consistency within the organization so that if I walk into
- 16:00loan officer A versus loan officer B, that essentially the results
- 16:06should be the same because we have such good procedures and policies
- 16:09and standard operating procedures.
- 16:12That the members all get treated the same.
- 16:15Exactly.
- 16:16That's exactly it.
- 16:17And this is, as we've talked about in the credit culture
- 16:21discussion, lending, commercial lending is a value added business.
- 16:26It needs qualified people.
- 16:29To evaluate the borrower's ability.
- 16:31Cause there'd be, there are so many influences on a business.
- 16:35The lender needs to be, needs to be well qualified and capable of understanding
- 16:41those changes in the business.
- 16:43And that's the value added piece.
- 16:44I always felt, and I think it should be explained to borrowers once a year.
- 16:49Hopefully you're visiting your borrowers at least once a year that borrower.
- 16:53For free, really their interest payment gets a financial expert to do
- 16:58a thorough review of their business.
- 17:00And that's really a very important service you can offer to your
- 17:05members and your borrowers
- 17:09and to follow up.
- 17:12It's really important then that if there are problems in your analysis.
- 17:18Or you will recognize some problems with the business in your analysis to share
- 17:22those observations with the borrower.
- 17:25And obviously that's going to be much, and said in a polite and respectful
- 17:28way, but help that borrower understand where there's some areas in their
- 17:33business and financial performance that they should be addressing.
- 17:38And again, like I said, so once a year that borrower will get
- 17:43a a financial review of their business by a financial expert.
- 17:48I think that's a pretty good value added service.
- 17:52That's great, Vin.
- 17:53Very well said.
- 17:54And you reminded me of, so back when I was an examiner and a problem case officer,
- 17:59I did get a little bit of expertise on member business lending, at least
- 18:02on par for what we knew of back then.
- 18:06And one of the things I used to do When I went in to do a commercial loan
- 18:10review, other than getting a sample of loans to look at, I would get it.
- 18:15I would ask them to show me a handful of loans that they had
- 18:18denied, which was telling it.
- 18:20You can see something on a denial.
- 18:22And in some instances.
- 18:25When I asked that question, they'd only approved loans that also gave
- 18:28me some Intel potentially as I was doing the exam relative to the risk.
- 18:32Great discussion on financial analysis.
- 18:34Anything else on this before we jump into credible you brought up denials.
- 18:39And I think that's another great area where you can provide this.
- 18:42Expertise to that member.
- 18:44Hopefully they are a member or they're going to become a member to explain
- 18:47to them, I was used to explain my denials to the bar for two reasons.
- 18:52The first make sure I didn't miss anything and give them an opportunity
- 18:56to react to the reasons for the denial, but also to help educate them on how
- 19:01they should position their business to be in a, to be in a better position.
- 19:06To borrow from at that time I was working at a bank and the same
- 19:09would apply for credit unions.
- 19:11I think you're doing them a real service if you take the time, not
- 19:14just send a declination letter, but if they're important to you
- 19:19and they're already members of your credit union, take time to explain.
- 19:23Why you made your decision and what you would need to see in order
- 19:27to approve a loan in the future.
- 19:30Got it.
- 19:31Got it.
- 19:32All right.
- 19:32So let's jump into credit proposals, right?
- 19:36What would you like to share relative to credit proposal?
- 19:39It's very similar comments.
- 19:40Make sure it's well organized and consistent.
- 19:43Again, if you go to the guide and the examiner's guidance, which you'll be able
- 19:47to click on, it does a real good job of.
- 19:50Explaining how important a standard logical format is again, for what we
- 19:55had talked about earlier to make sure there's a consistent view in your, and
- 19:59your credit culture or approving credit and your approach to credit, but when
- 20:05it's well organized, I think let's just talk about some of the important things.
- 20:09That should be included in the proposal and again, there's a
- 20:14sequence outlined in the guidance.
- 20:16I think it makes sense.
- 20:17Obviously, I was involved with writing it and it's the way I used to approach
- 20:22the organization of my proposals.
- 20:24But these are things that are important to have in your.
- 20:29credit proposal that doesn't have to follow this specific order.
- 20:33But I think if you see the order it makes sense.
- 20:35And the first section should discuss who the borrower is, explain the ownership
- 20:40structure, the type of business it is, the number of employees, what they
- 20:45do to produce revenue, products and services offered, who their customers
- 20:49are, how long they've been in business, are there any concentrations of sales
- 20:55with the limited number of customers.
- 20:57Customers
- 21:00that they had.
- 21:00Are they dependent on just a few suppliers?
- 21:05These are all things that are not all these need to be explained in the right
- 21:09of the things you should be thinking about when you're evaluating the
- 21:11credit, who the principles are managed.
- 21:16Discuss management's abilities and structure discussion of the industry
- 21:19they're in and the repayment ability and of the borrow along with and it's real.
- 21:25Thank you.
- 21:26Important here.
- 21:27The next thing that the guidance asked for is the relationship between the
- 21:31entities, and that's really important.
- 21:33And the very important when we discuss philosophically, uh, global cashflow.
- 21:38So it's important to understand who the principals are and any entities they
- 21:43own and how the, all these entities inter inter relate to each other.
- 21:47And how do you get that information?
- 21:49That's visiting the borrower and spending some time.
- 21:52Walking through their facilities and their operation and
- 21:55getting to know them over time.
- 21:59No, I think.
- 22:01Marco, that's fine.
- 22:03So when you were at the bank
- 22:07in your time at the bank, serving as a loan officer, what was the long
- 22:12term relationship that you had with some of the borrowers at that bank?
- 22:18There was 10 year relationships.
- 22:20And then prior to that, they had already been with the bank.
- 22:23So they stayed there.
- 22:24They recognized.
- 22:25The value, hopefully they recognize that value you add as an experienced lender and
- 22:32how important that is to their business.
- 22:34And they don't always shop for the lower straight, but any business will is
- 22:39probably loyalties up to 50 basis points.
- 22:42After that, it's going, you're competing against price.
- 22:45Sure.
- 22:45And, but I think it's very important that they trust you and know that you care
- 22:50about their business and take the time to make the recommendations and structure to
- 22:55their loans that's in their best interest.
- 22:58No, that makes sense.
- 22:59That makes sense.
- 23:01Yeah.
- 23:01And another section on the, I did not see this a lot in credit unions,
- 23:08but I did see it in, I worked for a number of banks in the crazy
- 23:12nineties, but in most of the banks.
- 23:14Credit proposals.
- 23:15They had a section listing all direct and related debt.
- 23:20And as the COA restricts the total relationship of associated members
- 23:26to 15 percent or any one relationship to not exceed 15 percent of the.
- 23:31Credit unions net worth.
- 23:32So instead of others calculate that, I believe it's up to the lender to list
- 23:38that so that the approving bodies, whether that's senior manager or the credit
- 23:44committee or the board sees the total relationship and understands the total
- 23:50level of risk associated with that borrow.
- 23:52So it's a regulatory requirement under seven 23.
- 23:56Point 4C.
- 23:57Therefore, it makes sense to list that either on the front page of the
- 24:03credit proposal or a separate schedule.
- 24:06But that should be very clear what the total relationship is and considered
- 24:11as part of the credit approval.
- 24:13So I don't, I believe it's a requirement for a credit proposal.
- 24:17And like I said, often you don't see that.
- 24:20Summary of the relationship on the credit proposal.
- 24:26Got it.
- 24:26And so, yeah, so NCOA would like to see that because it shows that the
- 24:29thought process went in and that you are aware of the materiality as it
- 24:33relates to the member and also to the balance sheet of the credit union.
- 24:36Sure.
- 24:36And the board should care because it could be a violation of a reg that's.
- 24:40Serious, as we know, it's not a safety and well, safety and soundness is important,
- 24:45but it's a direct regulatory requirement.
- 24:48Therefore, it should be confirmed on.
- 24:51With each approval that it's within the regulation
- 24:56makes sense.
- 24:58So I pulled up the link that you provided me that we're going to put in the show
- 25:03notes and as I'm looking at it, I see.
- 25:11A reference to the document assigning an appropriate risk rating.
- 25:15Is that some, is risk rating something that you want to talk to relative
- 25:19to credit proposals, or is that a few podcasts in and of itself?
- 25:23I think that's a future podcast, but again, that's important that the
- 25:27risk rating be signed as part of the credit proposal and also justified.
- 25:33So it should require that it's rated.
- 25:36Four and for the following reasons, it doesn't have to be long, but it has to
- 25:42be clear why it's being rated at that level, and I'm glad you brought that up.
- 25:47Mark, you often credit proposal has a cover page and a lot of what we've talked
- 25:53about, that justification should probably be on the front page so the reader then
- 25:58knows what the risk rate is, the level of risk associated with that credit.
- 26:03A summary of the relationship that we just talked about is
- 26:07important to have on the front page.
- 26:09And another thing that's important to have on that front page
- 26:13is any exceptions to policy.
- 26:16And again, a brief explanation why it's an acceptable exception to policy.
- 26:21And what that does, if the cover page has important information like
- 26:25that, then the reader, as they review the cover page, , they're going
- 26:29to have a good sense for the deal.
- 26:32the risk associated with the deal, and if there are those policy exceptions.
- 26:37You don't want somebody to read something on page two and say, hey, wait, that's
- 26:43a policy exception, and then not explain what it is for another two pages when you
- 26:48get into the financial section, because they've just read two pages saying, hey,
- 26:52what else is wrong with this credit?
- 26:54Lay out all those issues on that front page with a summary
- 26:59justification, I think, sets the reader up to better understand that
- 27:02credit as they read through it.
- 27:05Yeah, that makes good sense.
- 27:06I wrote down exceptions to policy.
- 27:08I think that might be something we can expand on.
- 27:12At a later date as well, again, there's a lot of nuances to commercial
- 27:16lending and in a podcast like this, we can't go into every piece of it.
- 27:21But I think we're going to be digging down over time, taking
- 27:23on some of the individually.
- 27:25So very good.
- 27:27Go ahead.
- 27:27Yeah, right.
- 27:28Mark, we can't get into everything on a podcast, but if
- 27:31we've got the right references.
- 27:33That the listeners can click it into.
- 27:37I think that would be helpful.
- 27:38You got it.
- 27:39And at the end, too, I'll give my contact information where they can reach
- 27:43out if they have particular questions on some of these things as well.
- 27:46So very good.
- 27:47So let's segue.
- 27:50And have a philosophical discussion on global cash flow.
- 27:54Right.
- 27:54What is it and what is it and why is it important?
- 27:57Obviously you and the way we say it and in the rule is to see if there are any other
- 28:03influences on the borrower, the guarantor that could influence the, the bar, the.
- 28:10Entity that you're lending to it's so much can happen the interrelationship between
- 28:17companies is very important and you need to know what the stresses are on the
- 28:24guarantor, because obviously, if they've got other operations that are stressed.
- 28:30They may need the help from your borrower and that could have
- 28:33eventually impact the borrower.
- 28:35So overall, you need to know the overall risk associated with that
- 28:39credit and other entities related entities could be some of those risks.
- 28:43So how deep do you go really depends on the complexity and the level of
- 28:48risk associated with the transaction.
- 28:50If you have a large loan and there other businesses similar and
- 28:56there's movement between those.
- 28:58Companies, you need to analyze each company.
- 29:02And there's, like I said, philosophically, there's many different approaches.
- 29:09Me personally, when I was analyzing loans, I always wanted
- 29:14to know those related entities.
- 29:16I didn't want to just take K1 information.
- 29:19I wanted to know exactly how well they were operating.
- 29:23I generally at the very least asked for tax returns for those related entities.
- 29:29Entities and then also get a debt schedule.
- 29:33So instead of just seeing distributions and profit, did an actual cashflow
- 29:38analysis, see how much, if those businesses were under stress or not.
- 29:43And then once all that analysis is done, you have to, and again, this is
- 29:47up to the institution, find some way to.
- 29:51Bring it all together so you can have a reliable evaluation of the
- 29:56global cash flow and global coverage.
- 30:00So let me give you an example.
- 30:02So you've got a member, let's say new member, they come in, they apply,
- 30:10they want to buy a rental a home for rental, and they have 15 other
- 30:18rental properties in the same city.
- 30:22And this is the first they're new to the credit union.
- 30:26This is the first time they've come to see you and they might have these 15 rental
- 30:33companies all set up in their own LLCs.
- 30:36I know a lot of times people will do that.
- 30:38So they come in, they apply for the one loan.
- 30:41They say it's a hundred thousand dollars and I'm going to put 30 percent down and
- 30:47it should cashflow and you're looking at it saying that's great, but in that
- 30:54scenario, what's the, but what would it, you're putting your loan officer hat
- 31:00back on, what would you expect to see?
- 31:03From where you sit, and then obviously as it relates to the
- 31:06NQA regulation on member business.
- 31:07You're going to have a guarantor most likely, hopefully, because although
- 31:13it's not specifically required, it's implied that each loan be guaranteed.
- 31:18So you're going to need to know what those influences are on the guarantor that
- 31:23could impact, like I said earlier, that could add some stress to their operations.
- 31:28Are there other businesses that they have?
- 31:31that are not as successful as your borrower.
- 31:34And then can those, those, the needs of those other businesses, uh, will guarantor
- 31:43need to take that from your borrower.
- 31:44So you got to be careful that you understand the relationship
- 31:48between all the borrowers and then, then properly structure the loan.
- 31:53Uh, to protect your borrower and I'm not saying that you don't do business
- 31:58with a borrower whose guarantor has some other stresses, but if there are
- 32:03other stresses in the global tell you this, you may want to structure your
- 32:07loan a little differently and add some covenants to restrict disbursements
- 32:12and distribution from your borrower.
- 32:15So that's one reason for global cash flow, so you can properly structure
- 32:19your borrower to protect them.
- 32:21And other reasons are obviously, is this borrower a house of cards?
- 32:25And if it's a house of cards, you may not, even though not to borrow
- 32:28so much, the overall relationship is that a house of card included.
- 32:31Including the guarantor, you may want to limit or not get involved because the
- 32:38rest of the operation is very stressed.
- 32:41Yeah.
- 32:41I think that's the essence of the global cashflow.
- 32:43This particular deal may cashflow, but if other businesses that are owned by
- 32:48that borrower are not positively cash flowing, what happens to the entirety
- 32:52of it, which is the global cashflow.
- 32:54And getting back to the philosophical part of this market.
- 32:57So there's a lot of articles on global cashflow.
- 33:00And I ask.
- 33:00People to go out and research it themselves, but ultimately.
- 33:05It shouldn't be done for the sake of the NCOA.
- 33:08Nothing ever should be done for the sake of the NCOA.
- 33:11It should be done to evaluate the risk that you're taking on your
- 33:15credit union's balance sheet.
- 33:18And that's what should drive the extent of the analysis.
- 33:22However, can't ignore the reg.
- 33:25because it's a regulation and you have to follow those
- 33:28specific things the reg requires.
- 33:30But what I always used to tell credit unions and when I used to speak, I'd
- 33:35tell them I first always do a thorough risk assessment of the borrower
- 33:42and the borrower's relationships.
- 33:46Make your decision based on that, then check the reg.
- 33:49To see if you've complied.
- 33:50And I think if you've done your job and you're complete, right,
- 33:54compliance will not be an issue.
- 33:56So always focus on, do I really understand this bar or do I really know
- 34:01what's going on with the guarantor?
- 34:04What do I need to do to understand the guarantor's relationships and the
- 34:09relationship and the risks associated with that relationship, that's what
- 34:13should be driving you not to comply with, or making the examiner happy.
- 34:19Do it for your own because it's ultimately on issues with an exam.
- 34:24The real issue, is this a risky transaction and is it
- 34:27too risky for us to find it?
- 34:29Sure.
- 34:29Is it good for the credit union?
- 34:30Is it good for the borrower?
- 34:33And then it isn't always should be secondary or even last on that list.
- 34:37If you want to comply with the regulation, but you're not serving NCUA, you're
- 34:40serving them and it is, it gets calm.
- 34:42It gets very complicated, global, how far you should go.
- 34:45This is not the forum to decide.
- 34:48What's appropriate and what's not it's really just to discuss what you should
- 34:51be thinking about for a an operating company that has a separate real estate
- 34:55holding company and maybe the guarantor has a couple of rental properties.
- 35:00Those are pretty easy to bring together.
- 35:02It's when you get into those large real estate transactions where there's multiple
- 35:06entities and those are the hard ones to decide how deep do I go and the answer
- 35:11is deep enough to fully understand the risk associated with your transaction.
- 35:17So the, so it sounds like a legal answer.
- 35:19So the answer is, it depends on the, the, the full body of work.
- 35:24Sometimes you've got a good bar you've done business with for years.
- 35:28They summarize their whole operation and send you cash flows and other information.
- 35:33If you're going to accept something like that, I do.
- 35:36Recommend that maybe a test a few of them just so you can say this is reliable
- 35:40information and because we know the borrower obviously and they've always
- 35:46performed as agreed and also did some additional due diligence and we checked
- 35:51a few of them and they were accurate.
- 35:53So we're going to.
- 35:54Assume that the rest of this information is accurate.
- 35:56It all, again, it depends on your relationship, the
- 35:59complexity of the relationship.
- 36:01Think about it and make sure that when you step back, that you're comfortable,
- 36:07that you've covered and fully understand the risk associated with the transaction.
- 36:13Got it.
- 36:13Got it.
- 36:13So then before we wrap up, I want to push back on one thing you said.
- 36:17What may have caught some attention and you said that guarantees are
- 36:23implied the regulation doesn't indicate that they're required.
- 36:27So, I believe in the old days, you could actually ask for waivers
- 36:32relative to that, but it was my understanding under the new rule that.
- 36:38It's nice to have, but not a need and defining need as
- 36:41the regulation required it.
- 36:43There are situations and the regulation does allow for
- 36:49there not to be a guarantee.
- 36:51Am I correct in what I just said?
- 36:53Yes, but if the way it's written, and I don't have it in front of me right
- 36:57now, Mark, but essentially what it says is if you do not get a guarantee,
- 37:02then you need to document the reasons.
- 37:05Why it's the reasons that offset the risk of not having a guarantee.
- 37:10So it says if you do not get a guarantee, so that implies you should
- 37:14start by getting the guarantee.
- 37:17But if you do not get the guarantee, then you've got to have good reason.
- 37:21They all need to be documented in the credit proposal.
- 37:24Said another way default should be.
- 37:26Yes, we are going to get.
- 37:28Guarantees and on occasion we won't and when we don't we'll have
- 37:33a really good reason and we will document that as opposed to default
- 37:37is we don't get guarantees and on occasion, we will get guaranteed.
- 37:42Yeah, and it was interesting because the reaction was.
- 37:46That all you don't need guarantees anymore.
- 37:48Oh, yes, you do.
- 37:49But if you don't get one, we don't have to go through a waiver process.
- 37:54Essentially you document in your credit proposal, what you would
- 37:57have, had you been requesting that waiver for the guarantee.
- 38:01So there's gotta be good reasons.
- 38:02Obviously the borrower has got a strong balance sheet, got good cashflow.
- 38:07I've been in business for a while, all that kind of stuff.
- 38:10And those are the types of reasons you need to waive the guarantee.
- 38:14But one reason you can't waive is one.
- 38:16Reason that's not appropriate is because the competition doesn't want one.
- 38:23Okay.
- 38:24Great.
- 38:24Excellent.
- 38:25We don't want you going over the cliff for the rhythm.
- 38:29Makes sense.
- 38:30So then let's wrap this up.
- 38:32This was great.
- 38:32I want to thank you for being my guest today, everybody.
- 38:36That's it for today.
- 38:37I'm Mark Trekel, and I hope you join me again next time.
- 38:46Thank you for joining us on this episode of With Flying Colors.
- 38:50Subscribe on your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes or subject
- 38:54matter experts of all varieties.
- 38:55We'll provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 38:59If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions,
- 39:02check out our services@marktrico.com.