Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De’ah 201:24-27. Mikvaos: Adding and Removing a Se’ah, Mikvah Construction, Colored Water, 7 Liquids Changing the Color
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning. We are in Simin Rashalif.
- 0:04We're in the middle of Sif Khalid.
- 0:05We're discussing about, about shinomare and different types of
- 0:11liquids. Can they can they go ahead and
- 0:13even starive to, to a mikvah or not mitzvah?
- 0:19So we have mentioned that that wine, you know, we're going to
- 0:26see wine. Wine's going to be a problem.
- 0:31But but but like colored water. What can is considered water?
- 0:38But if it's like alcoholic or may payless juice, things like
- 0:41that. It's not doesn't puzzle the
- 0:43mixture of the mixture, but it doesn't nor will it be mashed
- 0:47up. Alva in the middle Alva images
- 0:50Boa buying salt. But let's say the mixer has 40
- 0:53salt enough of the circle and and and one saw fell into the
- 1:01MCVA from from these things and not to be safe and saw Harris
- 1:05culture right. And if you went ahead and let's
- 1:11say you took out another saw right from the you know you you
- 1:15personally happened to be another saw came out.
- 1:17We don't say, oh, you see there this liquid is not water.
- 1:21So maybe the fact you took it out, you took out other water
- 1:25and maybe maybe it's going to now it's going to be closer from
- 1:29water and now it's going to, and it's not going to be a culture.
- 1:33We say that it's still kosher, the HPLA because it gets mixed
- 1:36around. So we say that it's that it's
- 1:39kosher. Afilu also came at Tisha Asarpa
- 1:42Amin. Even if he did this until 19 * a
- 1:46sock on a 40 saw, you did, you did, you took out 19 saw.
- 1:50You know that one saw fell in of of liquid and then you took out
- 1:53another saw and he kept on doing that forever right until 19
- 1:57times it's kosher. After that is going to be puzzle
- 2:01because we did not of nothing. So but when you that at a
- 2:06certain point the mix is going to end up being Rove other
- 2:10liquids and therefore it's not going to be kosher.
- 2:14It's not going to be kosher water and therefore it would be
- 2:18it would be problematic. It would be puzzle, although the
- 2:20mine Shuvim should not. But if it was mine Shuvim that
- 2:24fell into our buying suck sharing, it doesn't make a
- 2:28difference. It's going to be kosher, but not
- 2:30to be safe and saw and then not for the safe and saw the way.
- 2:35Let's say you took out and then another another saw fell in my
- 2:37sharing field also came at the oil and culture.
- 2:40No matter how much you put in and how much you take out, it is
- 2:44going to be it is going to be kosher at the oil because mine
- 2:48stream doesn't have that dim. Now we're now we're going to get
- 2:51into one of the one of the basically sort of of how we make
- 2:55why and how we make big vows. But there's a shaft over here
- 2:58called Satashvitz and the base Asif who says quotes derive it
- 3:02the round bottom and derive it who say or argue on this and say
- 3:07no. It's the same din as you said
- 3:09before by by other liquids. And it's only until 19 saw after
- 3:1419 saw becomes rows of Vaimshu Uvin of Nosen saw and not Tulsa.
- 3:18It is going to be puzzle and as a shot of the bases in the shots
- 3:22I'm Roy Lahacka, the bases of themselves and doesn't pass in
- 3:29like that and the gross says anyway, Roy we shine him.
- 3:34Don't go like the don't go like the round.
- 3:36The round holds Dinder. The ribbon on the rabbit holds
- 3:39it to Dinder. Isa puzzles me there.
- 3:41It's not Rovi don't go like that.
- 3:44And there's what to be not to be Savi Khan.
- 3:47However, the shark does say that it's glad to be Mahmir.
- 3:51And so that is the that you know, that is the din that which
- 3:55has been misgoggle over the past number a few 100 years or so to
- 3:59be Mahmir for the rival is the the Khazni says it has an issue
- 4:04that he doesn't really understand the rival.
- 4:06The Khazni says that it's an interesting thing.
- 4:09So sometimes some, some mitzvah, some humrahs or you know, some
- 4:13cheetahs have have their own mozzle.
- 4:18They have some sort of mozzle that suddenly that they're
- 4:21they're we're makai and that even though makai and many other
- 4:24things, but suddenly we're makai and that.
- 4:27So this is where we're going to get into.
- 4:30We sent pictures out the basic structure of modern Mcvoes of
- 4:34because because the issue is a few issues is that.
- 4:38But what generally what we have is we have a we have a we have a
- 4:41Bort's villa there. We have a Bort's villa and we
- 4:44have what's called a bore. You know, a bore, A bore's Ria,
- 4:48right. So the So what happens is that
- 4:50there's a hole here that goes into the goes into the Bort's
- 4:53villa and you feel there's there's always Hafal saw of mine
- 4:58to hire him in the Boris Ria and you turn there's a faucet that
- 5:03goes it goes into the Borzeria and you turn on the water and
- 5:07there's a hole over here. It flow, it flow overflows and
- 5:10goes into the Borzvila. It's clean water, Pakaziosa,
- 5:14it's clean water. And that's what they do that
- 5:17every night by then we close and and that's what and that's what
- 5:23people are. That's what the that's what the
- 5:25women. That's what people are tabling.
- 5:26I mean, there's one the cooler he discusses via already one the
- 5:32cooler the Khazanin she does have, and this is not even go
- 5:35like this, but Uncle Pan and he's Koshish that the that you
- 5:39shouldn't when you when you pour the water, when you pour water
- 5:43into the Boris Rhea and it's pouring out the side that it's
- 5:47going to be Zeiflin. And he said you can't you can't
- 5:50be matched or a Boris Rhea is a Boris Rhea, it's going to be
- 5:53Zeiflin. So he says the way you the way
- 5:56you fix it is if you put if you put the part, if you, if you put
- 5:59the the pipe hole down by the bottom, then it's not going to
- 6:04be easy. And we'll get to get to these
- 6:07dining later. I'm just discussing it now
- 6:09because this is these are the things that people are not good
- 6:12for Aquaponium and the Boris Ria.
- 6:16And this is the basic, you know, basic Dino chauffonar that you
- 6:19just have a Boris via Papa Alsar.
- 6:22No matter how much water you from the faucet from the you
- 6:24know, you turn on and it goes in and it overflows into the Boris
- 6:28Vila, it's always going to be kosher.
- 6:30And it's true of a Maisha that the the Evid you know, that's
- 6:35you know, he he has a Shiloh about people who just using
- 6:38Chuvim for mikvah and he's like that.
- 6:41He like he can't do that. He's uncle Ponni has to Misaki
- 6:44in a second bore or Boris Ria in order to use may a year because
- 6:49people thought that the that the that the water from the city,
- 6:51while it comes from well, the river.
- 6:53You know, all these things that's going to be it's not mine
- 6:56Shoovy and he says it's it's mine Shoovy.
- 6:59He says it's and therefore you have to have a second bore.
- 7:04A bore is Ria as a basic as a basic basic to go ahead and to a
- 7:11mixer. Now we're going to get into is
- 7:18that again you're going to the Boris Ria now you're having a
- 7:21problem of going to the right here because it's going to be
- 7:24more than 19 saw of other water. So what what's the aids that the
- 7:29police can say different, different things is that you
- 7:35have also not only do you have a bore is a borzvilla, you have a
- 7:40borzvilla, you also have a bore hashaka.
- 7:42We're getting to help with hashaka later on.
- 7:44But you have you have a whole you have a bore, A shaka that
- 7:48that that even after you do a borzvilla, then they open the
- 7:52hole and there's hashaka between the two and that's going to be
- 7:56match here, the mixture according to the rival.
- 8:01And that's that's remember, you're right.
- 8:03And Hazish also seems to say that that's that would be
- 8:06enough. Hazish bed some holds of just
- 8:08the bursary. He doesn't he doesn't understand
- 8:10the home of the rival. That's the menu because one even
- 8:15though so that's a just because puzzle, right, according to
- 8:18everyone but the red point of the rival.
- 8:21So maybe on the Rambam also. So then you do a Hashaka Hashaka
- 8:24is going to work now to go ahead and not share the water in here.
- 8:28According to the rival also, but there's another shash which the
- 8:34play scheme discussed is that well, wait a second.
- 8:37If you have we're going to get into this how a shuffle works.
- 8:41Does it need to be open all the time?
- 8:42Not does there been your roof, but we'll get to it.
- 8:44You know get to it later that he holds it has to be that it has
- 8:48to be open the whole time, not just once.
- 8:51It's not for now that Uncle Panim, the problem that put the
- 8:56police can bring up is that well, if now you should be
- 8:59mapping for the rival and you do a Bora Shaka and the holes open
- 9:02the whole time. Yes, it's hard to have Satan
- 9:04because now the water is going in between the Bora Shaka and
- 9:07the boar and the boards villa. And again, not of all you're
- 9:10going to have that you're going to pass of the Bora Shaka
- 9:13because you can have notes and salmon also.
- 9:14So where are you mafia? I mean, this is child's going
- 9:20back to the to the, you know, hundreds of years.
- 9:25So the the the Rashad Baba Chereba, it's the middle rib.
- 9:31I don't remember what they call him.
- 9:33One of them is Baba Chereba is a Rashad made a takana that he had
- 9:39a hot the river Rashad. OK, fine.
- 9:43I don't know. I don't know and you know,
- 9:47forgive me enough whatever of upon him for the river Rashad.
- 9:51So he had a he had a he had a shop and he said, well, no, what
- 9:54the way you know, what you should do is you have the
- 9:56Borzvila and then you create before you create a Borzvila,
- 10:00you create a borzhaka under the floor in the floor of the
- 10:05Borzvila. You create a borzhaka by
- 10:07himself. And then, you know, you cover it
- 10:09and you cover it over and there's and there's Shferzanod
- 10:15in between and that creates a keyboard and the water and and
- 10:19then the water. The water is always a shocker.
- 10:22It's never going to be, you know, not since of a not all
- 10:24sucker because it's underneath. And therefore it's going to stay
- 10:28well, even according to the right bit, it's going to be OK
- 10:30because the water is going to stay in the bore at the bottom.
- 10:33It's not. And and therefore you have a
- 10:36board. You know, you're going to have
- 10:37your board as Ria, you're going to have and you're going to have
- 10:41at the bottom, you're going to have you're going to have a you
- 10:44know, you're going to have a second bore of my aim of my
- 10:48chair and that's going to work. And that's how all mikvos of
- 10:53Habad. If you hear that the BBQ
- 10:55mixtures or Mikvos of Habad, that's how they are all made
- 11:00bore. I'll be bored now the the the
- 11:03cranium act if I am they all they all say make a tasty and
- 11:08it's you know, it's a nice Sparrow, But who says the water
- 11:13doesn't mix because of niches? We don't we don't use physica
- 11:19when it comes to when it comes to, you know, when it comes to,
- 11:24you know, making sack. Moisha says the Moisha says
- 11:28things are right. He says each Bila, we say is a
- 11:31cloud. Each Bila, which is actually
- 11:33this I mentioned. This is actually recently
- 11:35discussed in the in Tashiyomi about the fact that when water
- 11:40water mixes, no matter what, we assume that water mixes
- 11:43throughout. So therefore, just because it's
- 11:46on the bottom, who says that that it doesn't mix in the
- 11:51bottom going up. So he says it's a nice hop of
- 11:54the of the Bhavitra rabbit, but the might of the, you know,
- 11:57Rashad, but in the might it's not practical.
- 12:00So so according to the Fasenish, according to the different kind,
- 12:07according to the different sounds, according to the Remotia
- 12:11play scheme, the the the the the combat mix vows are you it's
- 12:16caution, but it's not Yeah, but you're not you don't take away
- 12:19the problem of the rival. You won't be marketed for the
- 12:21rival, which that seems to be the what the shark says you
- 12:24should you should be. It's not that's not going to
- 12:26help. You know, does it again, it
- 12:30doesn't mean the woman who's trivial in his eye.
- 12:32You know, whatever Rd. you're shining the grosses is says
- 12:35Rohit is showing him don't go like the rabbit and OK, that's
- 12:38fine, but you want to be mapping for the rabbit.
- 12:40That's not that they hold. That's not the way to go.
- 12:44There's other Shashas the the the Satnam rabbit had a in order
- 12:50to take care of the problem of the Bora Shaka NASA TSA.
- 12:56I mean, where moisture says that basically what you do is you
- 12:59open it, open the Borja Shaka for a minute and close it.
- 13:01We're going to get to other issues about Shaka and that's
- 13:04going to be enough to mature it and to avoid all the problems.
- 13:07But other parties give Miss Kasitzka said, well, no, maybe
- 13:14you'll forget. Maybe this again.
- 13:16They're they're being mocked me because they're all shashes for
- 13:19time of you Vicaris. It's not just regular something
- 13:22to arises time of you Vicaris. So therefore is an Indian to be,
- 13:26you know, as much as as as possible from close if possible.
- 13:31So they they said, OK, well, maybe you'll take it the Bora
- 13:34Shaka and you split it down the middle.
- 13:38Something similar to the to the to the vava chereb is hot, but
- 13:42they do it in the Bora Shaka. So it's not mixing in the Bora
- 13:47Shaka. There's another Bora underneath.
- 13:49And they even say, well, then, then, then there's a shy level.
- 13:52Why isn't it mixed? So they make a smaller hole.
- 13:55I don't know all the, all the problem.
- 13:57I don't know how you know, Lameisa.
- 13:59I didn't, I didn't Lameisa. I don't know how every single
- 14:02mikvah as well is made or around the world.
- 14:07I don't know. You know, obviously if they can,
- 14:09if they can be Mahara Akhadekar. Yeah.
- 14:11According to Ramisha and the Khazanish, the that dividing the
- 14:15what's it called is not, is not going to, you know, the Malaysia
- 14:18talks about the idea of Michelson itself and he's it
- 14:21doesn't really help. So these are the HB though.
- 14:24What are you going to say? It's as far it goes, you know,
- 14:27it goes for everything, you know, and all the, all the
- 14:29Kunsin don't necessarily help the so Aquapa name that so, so
- 14:37the basic, the basic Vignon name.
- 14:39So some say they have a fourth again, some say they have a
- 14:41fourth bore in order to take care of it.
- 14:43They have, they have a bore ziria.
- 14:46Then you have your bore Ziria, you have your bore Ziria, you
- 14:49have your bore Hashaka, and then they have another, another Bora
- 14:53Shaka, which they open for a second because there's another
- 14:57Homer of Abini Rukun Hold. It has to be open the whole
- 14:59time, So you know, so in order to have 4 yaki Bora Sevilla, you
- 15:05have your Bora Shaka, which is open the whole time, and you
- 15:08have another Bora Shaka. And that takes care of all those
- 15:11issues. Again, if they have, if they
- 15:13have enough money, they go ahead and build Mcvols like that,
- 15:16great. Often the small communities, you
- 15:19know, struggle to go ahead and to and to and to build Mcvols
- 15:23and things and whatever they follow whatever they're ready
- 15:27about and say and they follow whatever they're going to say.
- 15:29But that's the basic, that's the kind of that's the basic
- 15:32structure of of Mcvols nowadays. According to this, according to
- 15:36the the sheep does of the of the you know of the of the of the
- 15:46and the and and and the Shah and the rival start stiff Cafe maid
- 15:54seva yaish lahem din mayim Liv salsa mikvah made seva die.
- 16:02They have they have the den of mayim or like I mentioned,
- 16:04Coca-Cola different things to pasila mikva a host of a social
- 16:08Logie Avabishi mishuni mamareim. Even though we said before that
- 16:12if it's that if a social Logie is colored, it's different
- 16:16colored that we don't pasil it alcohol.
- 16:19But they have a din of mayim but a mikva shaolin but a mikva
- 16:23shaolin. We should not Fubo made seva
- 16:26even if Dai falls in the Shinumarov lo nifsa, it does not
- 16:30become puzzle. So therefore, if cleaning fluid
- 16:34falls into the mikvah and this happens and these Shilohs happen
- 16:37sometimes and they fall into the they fall into the mikvah, It
- 16:41won't and it turns to mikvah green or blue or I don't know
- 16:44what it doesn't. It doesn't parcel it Kosher king
- 16:47clean fluid is the same as made seven.
- 16:52Well, if it's OK, I'm not going to get into if it's a different
- 16:55consistency because that that's that, that that that's a
- 16:59different Nakuda and that might be a difference, a different
- 17:02type of liquid. But let's say it's like window
- 17:04cleaner. I don't know, it's usually
- 17:06mostly water anyway. Well, a lot of the cleaners is
- 17:08mostly water, you know, but not saying it was a child which
- 17:11comes up more often, which cannot can come up that the
- 17:15that, you know, they're cleaning the the floors before, you know,
- 17:17as before and it falls in. Do they have to drain the
- 17:20mikvah? Well, they don't have to drain
- 17:22the mik and then want to because they don't want women to be
- 17:25totally. That's a different thing.
- 17:26But if it's something toxic, no chlorine, often they put
- 17:32chlorine in the chlorine in the that's chemically different.
- 17:35Yeah, but it's OK. There's no, it doesn't won't be
- 17:39mashed. It won't be mashed.
- 17:40It won't be Again, first of all, a lot of the chlorine, all these
- 17:43things are watered down. But if it's pure chlorine that
- 17:48doesn't, it still has, it has a din of other liquids like the
- 17:53temperature, which won't mash in the mix up.
- 17:55It won't possible it either. And you're talking about a lot
- 17:57of water. So it doesn't, right.
- 18:01It's not different than alcohol. But I guess it won't be mash in
- 18:03the mix up. It won't possible the mix up if
- 18:06it's different consistency. We'll have to see about that.
- 18:09We'll see about the we'll see about that.
- 18:13The Kaylee they washed dishes in it and Ishtan Omarov and it
- 18:19became and changed color. Oh, Shashara.
- 18:25Oh, Shashara bow salmoneme or you are you soaked salmone put
- 18:30tea bags in. I don't know, Oakley, when you
- 18:33stand in my revol on this all like someone made a mistake,
- 18:37whatever or listen, I've been in some igvos, men's Igvos, small
- 18:43men's Igvos, you know, air of Yom Kippur and the water is not
- 18:45clear anymore. The water is a little bit of an
- 18:49interesting color, you know, and you know, so you know, you're
- 18:54close to Yom Kippur Alcopunny. That's not doesn't possible to
- 18:58make. You know, I used to play a joke
- 19:03on the you know, the first year Bachman came, you know,
- 19:06whatever. Like Well, yeah, you have to be
- 19:07sure you open your mouth all the way wide and be sure that they
- 19:10taste the water and be sure the water gets in your mouth.
- 19:13You know, whatever it's not the it's not the whatever.
- 19:16Not for the sagito yayin or MiTo or if you have wine or MiTo
- 19:21Piero Shamaine, you'd see me as they seem treat us, Tina as they
- 19:24seem. And it's like the water that the
- 19:28juice that comes out of when they first press the olives and
- 19:31there's a bit of shaman mixed in and it's blackish.
- 19:35You know, it's blackish liquid Ishinumara become OSHA high on
- 19:39Nisa, but that's different liquid.
- 19:40Kate said yeah, So what do you do if it's less than 40 Sai
- 19:47Yanti and you wait for rain to the more new rain to come in.
- 19:52You smile. He acts tomorrow of the marry
- 19:54mine. You wait till it fills up and it
- 19:55dilutes the color and it's fine and the age bar comes out or the
- 19:59water spills out and the age bar I bought him.
- 20:01So she ain't no need saw or be she Eva she she was not going to
- 20:05possibly Mali because say the eating the saitoi and she acts
- 20:10tomorrow of the marry mine. You go ahead and you fill it.
- 20:14You just turn the faucet on or use buckets and you.
- 20:18Fill it until the water get to the color gets diluted enough
- 20:22that it looks like that it looks like water.
- 20:26So if you know someone would decide they wanted to make a,
- 20:28you know, interesting, interesting mixture for women.
- 20:31I don't know, they could put in, you know, pink food dye and then
- 20:36pink for, you know, you know, make make the paint make for
- 20:38pink, make the make for all these interesting colors and it
- 20:41would be fine. But if it if, if a different
- 20:43type of liquid yayin or or shaman or any of these things go
- 20:49in and they've started the the color, then it's going to be
- 20:52it's called Chini Mara and it's possible until you diluted.
- 20:55So looks like a mix of if it's green, green, if it's green, if
- 21:00it's no, no, because there's three, it's three.
- 21:04Didn't we mentioned there's yayin and like Moil that comes
- 21:08from like is these are the like Shiva mash game?
- 21:12And I shouldn't one of the but that that idea that it's a
- 21:14separate type of mash game. It's not considered water with
- 21:17color. Like I said, the other one is
- 21:19dye, which has its own issues. And then they're, you know, it's
- 21:22called water and then there's and then there's other types of
- 21:26liquids like juice and things which you know, which it can
- 21:31also. I mean, it's like a whole thing
- 21:33of war juice falls in. Then it could be it's also
- 21:39promised Shinimaria also, and I'm not sure if the you know, if
- 21:47it, you know, put more water in to dilute it.
- 21:51If there was a buying sun and wine fell in and half of it,
- 22:01half of the mixture turned purple didn't mix yet in aimbo
- 22:05Mara Mayim are buying saw. There's not Mara Mayim of a
- 22:08buying saw away's elite football.
- 22:11Don't don't be. You can't be totaling that
- 22:13because it's because it's not. If if there is, you know, double
- 22:18buying saw, which all big folks have whatever there's, you know,
- 22:20double buying saw and more than the boards villa, then even if
- 22:25one section of it is a different colour, it's OK.
- 22:31And then you shouldn't and then you shouldn't be Toyville.
- 22:34So you shouldn't be Toyville in that part of it Aquaponium.
- 22:37But if there's a buying saw of regular water, then it won't
- 22:41possible to mikvah. Just don't be total in that, in
- 22:43that in that area of Zion Mikvish and Ishtano Mara Maima
- 22:51of Mahmos Asma again, it became it became old and you know, and
- 22:55the IT became old and changed colours by itself.
- 22:59Well, not for Bodova. I raise a kosher again.
- 23:01It's just let's say it's in the ground or something and
- 23:04eventually became or became dirty.
- 23:06And there was like, you know, stories of people dug the Roman
- 23:09falls from Russia, this, I don't know, whatever.
- 23:11And the water became very brackish and and gross and you
- 23:14know, alcoopane. It's still it's still a kosher
- 23:19it's still a kosher mikvah. I don't think so.
- 23:26I I don't think so. No, no, it's it's not the
- 23:30special life is if it was like sulfur water and things of
- 23:33whatever Hot Springs and things. I don't think it work.
- 23:36I don't think we're going to get to.
- 23:37I don't think that that that the mission talks about is not being
- 23:40good, but water itself becomes gross that that it's still be
- 23:43could be total.