Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Secret Informant, Secret Court
Transcript
- 0:19Adam Stirling: It involves competent complex informants and it involves very complicated sensitive matters.
- 0:25Adam Stirling: And you're the lawyers, so I'm going to let you take it from there.
- 0:28Michael Mulligan: Sure.
- 0:29Michael Mulligan: The no-doubt of sensitive matters, it's a really unusual decision that was just posted on the Supreme Court website, which I'm sure all listeners are routinely just reading through themselves.
- 0:40Michael Mulligan: But the court will post judgments on their website.
- 0:44Michael Mulligan: And this particular one caught my attention because it's listed as Rex versus unnamed person.
- 0:51Michael Mulligan: And the uh other interesting elements to it, on the front page of a court decision, there's usually a bunch of sort of tombstone information like who was the crown?
- 1:01Michael Mulligan: On this case, redacted.
- 1:03Michael Mulligan: Who was the person involved?
- 1:05Michael Mulligan: Redacted.
- 1:05Michael Mulligan: Where did the hearing occur?
- 1:07Michael Mulligan: Redacted.
- 1:08Michael Mulligan: Who's the judge?
- 1:09Michael Mulligan: Redacted.
- 1:10Michael Mulligan: When was the decision released?
- 1:12Michael Mulligan: Redacted.
- 1:13Michael Mulligan: Uh and at the top of it it says corrected judgment.
- 1:17Michael Mulligan: The text of this redacted judgment was corrected on the cover page with the addition of this correction notice to re reflect a release date of December 31st, 2025, New Year's Eve, for the purpose of publication.
- 1:33Michael Mulligan: And then place and date of judgment redacted.
- 1:36Michael Mulligan: And so it would appear that that date was picked and is not that is not even uh indicated.
- 1:40Michael Mulligan: It seems like that's sort of a a date selected, like Mr.
- 1:43Michael Mulligan: X or something.
- 1:45Michael Mulligan: Uh and so that's quite unusual, right?
- 1:48Michael Mulligan: You can't even tell what registry it came from, who the judge was, who were counsel, and what who was involved.
- 1:54Michael Mulligan: Now, that is a stark departure from how decisions are usually released because what we do is supposed to be public.
- 2:00Michael Mulligan: You know, we can see what's going on and who's making the decision and who is it about.
- 2:04Michael Mulligan: Now the reason it's been dealt with in this highly redacted fashion uh is it involved a decision about whether the unnamed person uh was a police informant.
- 2:17Michael Mulligan: Now, we do have this concept of confidential informer privilege, uh, and there are a bunch of things that get attached to that.
- 2:25Michael Mulligan: If you turn out to be a confidential police informant, um, and they include things like uh virtually absolute privilege in terms of your identity.
- 2:35Michael Mulligan: Uh sometimes there can be steps taken to uh protect the person, maintain that.
- 2:39Michael Mulligan: There are a whole bunch of things that flow from that if you're a ple confidential police informant.
- 2:44Michael Mulligan: Now, you might wonder how can that be controversial?
- 2:48Michael Mulligan: Uh and the reason that it was controversial and was controversial in this pla in this particular case is that you can become a confidential police informant uh either by uh expressly being told, hey, you're a police informant, this will be privileged, right?
- 3:05Michael Mulligan: Or if there's an implicit promise of confidentiality uh to the usually police officer, but the language is investigating authority, uh, that you will be treated in that fashion.
- 3:17Michael Mulligan: And in this particular case, it was a circumstance where the person claiming the privilege, the crown didn't want them to be a police informer.
- 3:26Michael Mulligan: And they denied that they were one, and so they litigated it.
- 3:30Michael Mulligan: Um and so the first of all, the court takes the time, whoever the court was, uh whoever the judge was or justice was, uh to set out some of the justification for why we have confidential police informants.
- 3:43Michael Mulligan: Uh and the language typically used that they repeat there is that they are an indispensable tool in the detection, prevention, and prosecution of crime, as it enables the police to obtain information that would otherwise be difficult if not impossible to gather.
- 3:56Michael Mulligan: So that is the rationale for having such people.
- 4:00Michael Mulligan: Uh the other thing pointed out uh in the decision is this, which people should be well aware of.
- 4:05Michael Mulligan: This the privilege is not only extended to those with good intentions or good character.
- 4:10Michael Mulligan: In fact, quote, the rule can operate to the advantage of the untruthful or malicious or revengeful or self-interested or even demented police informant as much as one who brings information from a high moral sense of civic duty.
- 4:25Michael Mulligan: And there's a citation for that.
- 4:27Michael Mulligan: And so, first of all, I'd point out that being a categorized as a demented police informant may not be the uh the best uh thing you could have going for you.
- 4:35Michael Mulligan: You certainly don't want on your business card.
- 4:37Michael Mulligan: I'm not sure what the demented police informant Halloween costume looks like.
- 4:40Michael Mulligan: But the concept is not all these people, and many of them wouldn't be, uh of high moral standing, right?
- 4:47Michael Mulligan: Sometimes it's an effort to, of course, get something, right?
- 4:49Michael Mulligan: Some police informants are paid uh or relocated or uh have all sorts of or have charges against some state or some other advantage uh that they might get for providing that kind of information.
- 5:03Michael Mulligan: And you may never know about it, right?
- 5:04Michael Mulligan: You could just be, well, the crown just decides to release the person on bail, or they accept uh uh a deal for the person, or no charges are approved, or various things happen.
- 5:13Michael Mulligan: Uh and the idea is all of that and the fact that the person's status would be kept secret from everyone.
- 5:19Michael Mulligan: Now, the privilege, as I mentioned, is close to absolute.
- 5:22Michael Mulligan: It's only subject to what's referred to as the innocence at stake exception, where an accused person in a criminal case, if they can prove the only way to prove their innocence is if the police informant is required to be identified so they can be called as a witness.
- 5:37Michael Mulligan: Because that's the other thing.
- 5:38Michael Mulligan: Police informants don't come and testify, they're ordinarily secretly police informants, right?
- 5:43Michael Mulligan: But let's say the police informant's advice to the police was I was there at the scene of the murder and I say it was Adam, right?
- 5:51Michael Mulligan: You might say, Well, hold on, I didn't murder anyone.
- 5:54Michael Mulligan: And if that's the only guy that was there, I need that guy.
- 5:58Michael Mulligan: So that there's that narrow exception, but if the defense makes out that that's it's the innocence of the person is at stake, the result can be just the charges are dropped rather than identifying the person.
- 6:08Michael Mulligan: That's often the outcome of that.
- 6:10Michael Mulligan: And so here it's a circumstance where this person, the unidentified person, could they even clear it could be male or female, and as un they don't say which police department or where this was, had been arrested for a serious offense of some kind, no indication what that was.
- 6:25Michael Mulligan: The police had been interviewing the person uh for two and a half hours and basically got nothing from them.
- 6:32Michael Mulligan: Uh and then what happened is the unnamed person said to the unnamed police officer, Can I use your pen?
- 6:38Michael Mulligan: To which the police officer responded, Oh God may give you some indication of the character of the person, maybe they are a demented police informant.
- 6:48Michael Mulligan: So the police officer, oh God, can I use your pen?
- 6:52Michael Mulligan: There's then some reassurance that they weren't going to use the pen violently, and the police officer hands over the pen.
- 6:58Michael Mulligan: And the person the police the person takes it and writes on their hand the word informal and is careful not to show that to the camera.
- 7:07Michael Mulligan: The police officer leans across the table, looks at the person's hand, uh, and then says something to the person uh along the lines of uh okay, so nothing else to add, uh and then turns off the recording.
- 7:22Michael Mulligan: Uh they had a recorder.
- 7:24Michael Mulligan: Uh and you can see it on a video, uh, and the person testified uh that after seeing the hand, the informal, the police officer nodded their head up and down uh a little, and that was recorded, and the person testified about it, and the officer agreed to the nodding.
- 7:40Michael Mulligan: Uh and the officer claimed, however, that they were just nodding agreement to hearing something or acknowledgement, but not agreeing.
- 7:47Michael Mulligan: But then the officer picks up the recorder and turns it off in a dramatic fashion, uh, and then leaves the room, the person rubs off what they've written on their hand, the officer comes back after thirty seconds.
- 7:59Michael Mulligan: At this point, they have the tape recorder, the recorder secreted in a pocket, but they've turned it back on.
- 8:05Michael Mulligan: Uh, and the officer it's hard to hear because there's just a rustling sound on this recording and murmured conversation, so it's really hard to say exactly what's being said.
- 8:14Michael Mulligan: But they then get up, walk out of the room.
- 8:17Michael Mulligan: This is after those two and a half hours where nothing's being said, uh, and in another location that's not as clearly recorded in the police station, um, you can hear this muffled conversation, and then you can hear the police officer say we want to put bad guys in jail, like and and then there's further and then you hear another police officer, please officer B clearly say, If you guys want to hang out here and then walk away, then the unnamed person can be heard sir saying something quietly, which is redacted from the decision, uh, and the unnamed person testified the information was about other criminal activity.
- 8:54Michael Mulligan: The officer A acknowledges uh that he understood the person was telling him about this, uh, and then there's further low volume conversation you can't make out of the secreted recording device.
- 9:07Michael Mulligan: Now, the judge found that uh everyone clearly understood the person and the police officer what the word informal meant, good tip if you want to become a police informer, written on the hand, that they wanted to do that.
- 9:19Michael Mulligan: Uh but the police officer denied that they made an express offer to turn the person into an informant.
- 9:26Michael Mulligan: Now, that didn't end the inquiry.
- 9:27Michael Mulligan: The judge accepted that they didn't formally tell the person they were going to be a police informant, but that didn't end the inquiry because the person can become a uh a secret police informant if they have a reasonable basis to believe that that's what was going on.
- 9:43Michael Mulligan: Uh, and so based on those various factors, the handwriting, the naw the nodding, the turning, the dramatic turning off of the device, what the other officer said, what was picked up on the secreted recording device uh about wanting to put bad guys in jail, uh the uh judge was satisfied uh that that was enough for the person to reasonably believe they'd become a police informant uh and when they were providing that information.
- 10:09Michael Mulligan: Uh and that uh, you know, this wasn't some made-up story.
- 10:13Michael Mulligan: But the crown opposed the person being found to be that because it has various implications in terms of, for example, maintaining secrecy about what was said.
- 10:24Michael Mulligan: And it can have uh they were concerned about how this could potentially interfere with other legitim other police investigations.
- 10:32Michael Mulligan: Somebody was making this kind of thing up, and you could have to have hearings about it, and inf you know, issues about can the uh uh crown use things that they maybe got the person to say uh in a recording, maybe in their own trial.
- 10:45Michael Mulligan: Uh and they even made a suggestion that uh those facing charges shouldn't become confidential informants.
- 10:50Michael Mulligan: That's really interesting, and that's not how these things often operate.
- 10:54Michael Mulligan: That didn't get any traction from whoever the judge was that decided this case.
- 10:58Michael Mulligan: Uh and so at the end of that, despite all the concerns the Crown had, and despite opposing it, the uh judge concluded that it was more likely than not, and that's the standards of balance of probabilities, that the police made an impl implicit offer of confidentiality, and that it was reasonable for the unnamed person to believe that uh informer status was being bestowed upon them uh as a result of what the redacted, uh what they the redacted until Officer A told them that no privilege would be extended.
- 11:27Michael Mulligan: So the uh result of that is that measures will then need to be implemented, the judge says, uh, to protect the informer privilege, uh, and will have to be determined in future proceedings what all will be accorded them uh as a result of that.
- 11:40Michael Mulligan: So it's just a fascinating case, both in terms of just sort of how much effort has been put into keeping everything secret, including who the judge was, where this happened, when this happened, who the person was, who the police officer was, what charge they were facing, all of that we do not know.
- 11:55Michael Mulligan: Uh, but uh we do know that at some at some point some judge made the decision that some person uh was a confidential uh informant uh on that basis.
- 12:05Michael Mulligan: Uh and uh it it's a live question whether we will ever find out uh what measures will need to be implemented uh in order to protect the uh informant uh in oh yeah, in this case, uh given the degree of uh secrecy that's imposed.
- 12:20Michael Mulligan: I so I guess we'll never know whether this person was a demented informant, a malicious one, revengeful.
- 12:26Michael Mulligan: Uh but uh I think perhaps the officer's reaction of oh God would ask for a pen may give you some hint as to the sort of person who was being dealt with.
- 12:33Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest from well, we don't know if it's the latest, it could have been a long time ago.
- 12:37Michael Mulligan: A recently published decision by the uh DC Supreme Court dealing with uh secret informants.
- 12:43Adam Stirling: I have to ask, what is the utility in publishing anything at all in a matter like that?
- 12:48Michael Mulligan: Well, it's a real tension, right?
- 12:50Michael Mulligan: Because there's a really high expectation that things the court are doing is going to be public, we're gonna know what they're doing, how decisions were made.
- 12:58Michael Mulligan: It is a real exception that things are gonna occur in secret, right?
- 13:02Michael Mulligan: We don't live in communist China.
- 13:04Michael Mulligan: You do not want secret court decisions and secret hearings going on.
- 13:08Michael Mulligan: It's clear that this entire hearing was conducted in camera, so in in secret.
- 13:13Michael Mulligan: The degree of redaction here is quite remarkable, including not only all those factors that might directly identify people, but things like who is the judge?
- 13:21Michael Mulligan: I don't know how that's identifying the the person.
- 13:24Michael Mulligan: I guess there was some concern that even knowing when this decision was made might identify the person or who the crown was.
- 13:32Michael Mulligan: Um all of that's gone.
- 13:34Michael Mulligan: And so we do have at least the reason decision.
- 13:38Michael Mulligan: We can look at this, we can we can know this was done, we can see the basis upon which the decision was made.
- 13:43Michael Mulligan: We know that some police officer somewhere did this, but that's all.
- 13:48Michael Mulligan: And so certainly I would say it is much better that at least we know this is going on.
- 13:52Michael Mulligan: People can form their own judgments about that decision and you know consider for themselves whether, for example, is this an indispensable tool in the detection and preservation and prosecution of crime?
- 14:03Michael Mulligan: Do we want to live in a country where we have demented, self-interested, potentially lying, secret police informants?
- 14:09Michael Mulligan: Do we want that?
- 14:10Michael Mulligan: You know, it's not necessarily the case that everyone is going to agree, yeah, it's indispensable that we have demented police informants.
- 14:19Michael Mulligan: Uh you know, I think some people might reasonably say, no, maybe that's just too high a price to pay.
- 14:24Michael Mulligan: Uh, but uh that is not the law in Canada.
- 14:27Michael Mulligan: The law in Canada is that we have this near absolute privilege which can be bestowed on somebody even by implication.
- 14:35Michael Mulligan: Uh and so I do think it's important that this be released and we talk about it.
- 14:39Michael Mulligan: People can think about that.
- 14:40Michael Mulligan: And, you know, you'd ask yourself, do you want that?
- 14:43Michael Mulligan: Is that indispensable?
- 14:44Michael Mulligan: Do we want to live in a place where we have this going on?
- 14:47Michael Mulligan: But the wing uh is that uh no doubt sometimes this will detect uh criminal activity, although, as pointed out here, the other thing the Crown argued unsuccessfully, and it's amazing they argued it, they also argued that the privilege should only accrue if it turns out that the information provided turned out to be helpful.
- 15:06Michael Mulligan: Now, think about that.
- 15:07Michael Mulligan: As the court quite quite quite reasonably pointed out, very few people, if any, would be willing to make an offer to provide confidential information with their privilege only attached after the police determined it was useful, right?
- 15:19Michael Mulligan: That would be, hey, I was in the criminal underworld gang lair and I saw so-and-so do this.
- 15:25Michael Mulligan: Well, turns out we already do that.
- 15:27Michael Mulligan: Not helpful at all.
- 15:29Michael Mulligan: We're calling you as a witness, right?
- 15:31Michael Mulligan: You find yourself waking up dead.
- 15:33Michael Mulligan: Right.
- 15:34Michael Mulligan: So, you know, uh I it's really quite remarkable that you had Crown making some of those arguments.
- 15:39Michael Mulligan: They didn't get any traction, but boy, you know, they argued that uh only to the extent if it turned out to be useful.
- 15:46Michael Mulligan: Wow.
- 15:46Michael Mulligan: Uh but anyways, uh that's that's the latest.
- 15:49Michael Mulligan: It is important we know about this, but it's much less information than we would have.
- 15:53Michael Mulligan: So that's what really caught my attention with this thing popping up as a December 31st, 2025 decision uh in the cases that were published on the website uh this week.
- 16:03Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, it's right after this.
- 16:29Adam Stirling: How does that work?
- 16:31Michael Mulligan: So this case will actually have some reasonably significant impact, I think, sort of on practice in BC.
- 16:38Michael Mulligan: Uh, and it has to do with the interpretation of a section of the criminal code which permits witnesses to give evidence by audio or video conferencing if the court is of the opinion that it would be appropriate having regard to all the circumstances.
- 16:52Michael Mulligan: And then there's like a list, kind of a grab bag of things uh that uh a judge would need to think about, like the location of the person or costs involved, or the nature of the anticipated evidence, this kind of thing, for a judge to make that decision.
- 17:06Michael Mulligan: And as the Court of Appeal points out of this case, video tech, you know, video conferencing technology has really developed and is used a lot, right?
- 17:14Michael Mulligan: It really took off, of course, during COVID, uh, but it it's really been become sort of more routine.
- 17:20Michael Mulligan: We've all become used to, you know, being on Teams or Zoom or whatever it might be, and is used in the courtroom a lot.
- 17:25Michael Mulligan: And in the right circumstances, often by agreement and to pretty good effect, right?
- 17:30Michael Mulligan: There are certainly categories of witness where there's no particular, you know, you need the evidence, but you know, there's no real issue about is this person being truthful or, you know, the substance of their evidence.
- 17:42Michael Mulligan: And examples of that would be often things like, you know, let's say some professional expert witness on some point or other, right?
- 17:48Michael Mulligan: So yeah, you need this evidence before the judge, but nobody's suggesting that Dr.
- 17:52Michael Mulligan: So-and-so is making it all up or something, right?
- 17:55Michael Mulligan: They're just there to provide uh some evidence of that kind.
- 17:59Michael Mulligan: Now, this particular case is an interesting one.
- 18:02Michael Mulligan: It's a case that involves a appeal from a murder conviction, uh, where the uh Minister of Justice was persuaded to refer it to the Court of Appeal for an appeal long after the conviction.
- 18:14Michael Mulligan: This person had been incarcerated for 17 years, uh, and the Minister of Justice was persuaded to refer it to the Court of Appeal on the basis that they concluded there was a reasonable basis to conclude that a miscarriage of justice uh likely occurred.
- 18:29Michael Mulligan: Now, these I should say are are often uh things that are pursued uh by the innocence project uh that uh sort of runs that, you know, will run these kind of long, uh, long-a-go cases where there's some reason to think you may have an innocent person who's still in prison.
- 18:44Michael Mulligan: Um and so it's in that context that there was an application for fresh evidence to be heard by the Court of Appeal.
- 18:52Michael Mulligan: And now that's also unusual, right?
- 18:54Michael Mulligan: Usually you hear evidence at trial and the Court of Appeals looking at was there some mistake or whatnot.
- 18:58Michael Mulligan: But here, new uh information came out, and part of what came out was important.
- 19:03Michael Mulligan: It was a case involving this murder where the accused had an alibi that they were at work.
- 19:08Michael Mulligan: Uh, and in order to sort of make the timing work so this person could have committed the offense, exactly when the murder, apparently by gunshot, uh occurred.
- 19:18Michael Mulligan: Uh and one of the investigators has admitted that they had made errors recording the time of when witnesses said they heard the gunshots.
- 19:28Michael Mulligan: The main means the person was at work and cannot have done it.
- 19:32Michael Mulligan: Uh and it was necessary to pinpoint the exact time to make it even possible that this guy committed the crime.
- 19:38Michael Mulligan: And he's admitted that he got it wrong.
- 19:41Michael Mulligan: And so you have this person who's been in prison for two for 17 years, uh, and the defense on this appeal wanted to hear from two police officers, which has been ordered.
- 19:51Michael Mulligan: One uh they agreed to be by video, the other one was the person who admitted they wrote it down wrong, or for some reason recorded the wrong times.
- 19:59Michael Mulligan: And that's the one for whom it was a dispute about should that person be allowed to testify by video.
- 20:05Michael Mulligan: The person lived in eastern BC, uh, and so the court said, look, you know, he's retired, he's got some flexibility.
- 20:11Michael Mulligan: He says it will delay some home construction project by two days if he has to come to Vancouver.
- 20:16Michael Mulligan: It may be mildly inconvenient, uh, but pointed out that there is a presumption that witnesses are to testify in person.
- 20:24Michael Mulligan: That is the starting point.
- 20:25Michael Mulligan: It is the norm, and that remotely doing it uh is an exception.
- 20:29Michael Mulligan: Uh, and went through that case and some of those factors and found that it just wasn't made out here.
- 20:35Michael Mulligan: Given that you're dealing with sort of issues about your credibility, reliability, even though this person no longer is presumed to be innocent, it's an important thing.
- 20:43Michael Mulligan: The guy's been in prison for 17 years uh and found that fairness dictates that the uh person be able to get that evidence in uh in a live way, not having the person hook up by Microsoft Teams.
- 20:54Michael Mulligan: And so the Court of Appeal, analyzing all of that, denied the Crown application.
- 20:59Michael Mulligan: Look, it's two days, but it's an important matter, get out here.
- 21:02Michael Mulligan: And so the case is important not only on that particular fact pattern, but as something that'll likely be looked at by trial courts in the future where there is a presumption of innocence when deciding, you know, should we be allowing that when it's controversial?
- 21:16Michael Mulligan: Uh and something is lost, of course.
- 21:18Michael Mulligan: And so my expectation is this will have an impact, and it'll likely mean more of those kind of, you know, the expert witness or the non-controversial evidence from the police officer done by video, so that's more efficient.
- 21:28Michael Mulligan: But where there's some real issue like this one, this case will likely be pointed to in the future about why that should happen as but as the expectation is in person.
- 21:37Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest in the Court of Appeal on video for witnesses.
- 21:40Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking.
- 21:42Adam Stirling: Thank you so much, Michael.
- 21:44Adam Stirling: Pleasure as always.
- 21:45Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 21:45Adam Stirling: Always great to be here.
- 21:46Adam Stirling: All right, bye now.
- 21:47Adam Stirling: Quick break news is next.