Latest / One to One with Octavia / When Your Manager Says No to Your Promotion
Transcript
- 0:01Hi there, it's Octavia. Thanks so much for being here.
- 0:07Now, in the last episode of this podcast, I talked about how to have what can often be one of the hardest conversations at work, which is how to ask your manager for a promotion.
- 0:22Now, in this episode, I wanna talk about what do you do next if you ask for a promotion and you don't get the answer that you want. So, let's dive in.
- 0:39Now, I am a career coach, but I also have been in the workplace myself.
- 0:46I have had conversations with my own manager about what my next step at my company at that time could look like, and I've also had direct reports who have spoken to me about what they want their next steps to look like.
- 1:05And then in my work as a coach, I have had countless conversations with really talented, ambitious, hardworking individuals who really want to advance, but have sometimes found that when they've reached out or started a conversation about a promotion possibility,
- 1:29that the door that they've been waiting for to open just hasn't opened and has remained shut.
- 1:38Now, if you're listening and you are either preparing to have that conversation or you have recently had that conversation, I wanna dive into this today because while I want the best for all of us,
- 1:55I know that if you don't ask, you definitely will not get. But there's the flip side to that, that sometimes when you do ask and you don't hear what you've been hoping to hear, what do you do next?
- 2:10And I think it's really important for each and every one of us to think through the different scenarios that we could face with any conversation that matters, and how we would respond to that, not just in a professional way, but for us to think through our options in advance.
- 2:30That way, our emotions don't cloud or drive what could be a tough moment.
- 2:38Let's be honest, um, even though we want to be as objective as possible, there's a personal piece to when you are having a conversation about not just your work, but also
- 2:51what your role could be and what your role is deemed to be worthy of. There's a lot of ourselves that is attached to the work that we do. It's, you know, the work that we do encompasses [laughs]
- 3:06our time, our effort, our focus. It matters. No one else is going to know how your career feels. They might know what it looks like, but no one else is gonna know how it feels.
- 3:18And so the stakes can feel so high with these conversations, so I wanna have a really honest conversation today about how
- 3:30you can navigate this space if it happens to you or if it is happening to you right now. So, let's talk about it. Let's talk about you are there, you're with your manager.
- 3:48You've told them that you are really excited about what you can contribute, and you've shared a goal of wanting to advance into the next opportunity, the next role, a step up.
- 4:02Now, let's imagine that your manager's response is non-committal. Um, their response could be something like, "Do you know what? I can't make any promises right now."
- 4:16Now, if that has happened or could happen to you, want you to realize that's not necessarily the end of a conversation.
- 4:27Unless you work in a really small organization and the person that you're talking to is the sole decision-maker for your advancement, it could well be that there are other stakeholders who have to be involved.
- 4:43It also could be that your organization has very specific times of year when they consider promotions. Now, sometimes there are things that happen, like a business need. There's a shift.
- 4:56There's maybe a whole load of new revenue [laughs] comes in from new clients, or maybe teams have merged and there's a reorg.
- 5:05There can be sometimes factors that drive a team needing to expand quite suddenly, and that might not fall within a certain calendar timeframe.
- 5:16But then on the flip side, and you will only, only you will know this from your own experience of where you work, there might be certain times of year, often connected to when the fiscal year starts and ends, and sometimes often connected to when performance review cycles happen, when promotions are announced.
- 5:34So think about that. Think about where you work. Think about who were the last people to be promoted.
- 5:42And based on what you know or have observed from a distance, what were some of the things that might have been in common? Were, did those promotions happen at a set time of year?
- 5:52Did they happen because of a business need? Had those people perhaps been prepared over a period of time to take on those roles, or was it perhaps something perhaps a little bit more sudden?
- 6:05Pay attention to the environment that you're in, and pay attention to- To who the decision-makers are for your promotion. And if anything about the promotion process is unclear to you, ask some questions.
- 6:22So if your manager said to you, "I can't make any promises right now," one response you might wanna give is, "Well, that's helpful to know. When would be a good time to revisit the conversation?"
- 6:34Because it could be that actually it's the wrong time of year to start that conversation.
- 6:41Now, on the flip side, if you feel that there could be other factors related to a decision about your own advancement that are down to perhaps perceived performance issues, that's also something that is worth clarifying and establishing.
- 7:00And you could ask a question along the lines of, "I'd really value your insight and advice. Can you guide me on either the skills or experience that I would need to take the next step in my career?"
- 7:19Asking open-ended questions at least provides an opportunity for you to start to get some feedback.
- 7:28Now, it could be the person that you're talking to actually needs to have conversations with other people [laughs] about what a process could look like. It could be they aren't 100% clear themselves.
- 7:45Alternatively, it could be that your manager knows exactly [laughs] what the likelihood could be or what the process would involve. And so you also need to take time to consider, before a conversation,
- 8:01what is the relationship like between myself and my manager? Do we have good communication between us? Has this person shown signs of supporting my progress in my career?
- 8:16Have we had conversations about professional development? What is that person's feeling about how I work? What have I heard in my most recent performance reviews or my one-on-ones?
- 8:32Are there any components to my role that perhaps my manager feels I need to be working on?
- 8:38So ask yourself these questions objectively before you have a conversation, and if there's anything that is perhaps unclear to you, you can use the conversation that you start to have to start to get either some provisional answers or some initial guidance on what might be needed to lay the foundation.
- 9:02The other thing I also really want you to consider is that more often than not, promotions can take time. They're not necessarily a you make the ask and it happens right away.
- 9:16Um, often, even when you have a manager that is super excited about you taking that next step and they are supportive of you advancing into that next step, there are processes that perhaps have to be followed.
- 9:31Um, is there an actual open role? Um, if so, are other people being considered? What could the timeline look like for that transition? And also, and this is a really important consideration for you,
- 9:44what will happen for the role that you currently have? Will that need to be backfilled? Is this something you're going to transition into, or is it an immediate shift?
- 9:54What implications are there, not just for the rest of the team, but perhaps other people that you work with? How does this need to be communicated?
- 10:03What other promotions might be happening that you are not part of, but also perhaps need to be planned and timed and coordinated?
- 10:12There can be so many variables that you may never get full insight into, but especially if you work alongside other teams, especially if you work in larger organizations, there can be things that have to be approved internally before, before a conversation can perhaps even progress.
- 10:35Um, it could be also there's just certain skills, experience, criteria. It could be there's even an interview process. Um, it all depends on whether there is an open role and what that transition could look like.
- 10:49So gathering as much information as possible is so valuable.
- 10:53And one great way to do this is actually talk to someone, if you can, in your organization who has been promoted in the last, let's say, 24 to 36 months, because it will still perhaps be kind of fresh in their mind, like, how did that happen?
- 11:12What did they do beforehand? Um, how long did it take? Um, you can probably get some really valuable insights.
- 11:20Now, their journey and process and experience may not be identical to yours, even if you're on the same team, even if you had the same manager.
- 11:31Um, there still can be differences because businesses shift, organizations change, um, processes can change.
- 11:40Sometimes there are freezes of budget that more junior members of the team might know nothing about, and that might mean that not only, uh, is the team not hiring, but they actually can't advance anyone in that time.
- 11:53Um, sometimes in between earning period- periods, if you're, um, a publicly traded company, there are certain things that can't happen within certain windows.
- 12:01So could be there's someone that you don't know is about to depart the team or someone that's about to join the team.
- 12:10So there can be all sorts of factors that could make your experience different to a colleague or coworkers or peers, but it's still valuable to get feedback within your organization, if possible, about how that process worked.
- 12:28It's really valuable. Now,
- 12:30your human resources team can just give you perhaps from an employee handbook perspective about [laughs] just some of the systems and processes, but I really encourage you to, if you can, talk to a peer about what their experience was of navigating this.
- 12:47And this is where
- 12:49having mentors, whether they are formally your mentor or informally your mentor, is so valuable because other stakeholders, not just your manager, but other senior leaders, if they're within your organization, can have really valuable perspectives on
- 13:11internal and external factors for you to consider about how to actually navigate this process successfully.
- 13:22Um, also, mentors or senior leaders who aren't within your own organization or company can also be valuable just to have that sounding board.
- 13:33Even if they aren't as familiar with the culture or the politics in your organization, they can still provide some objective perspective on their own teams and how they have navigated transitions for themselves, but also for their direct reports.
- 13:49So that is incredibly valuable. The most important thing, though, if you are hearing feedback that is either non-committal or you are actually told directly, "No,
- 14:05you are not either ready or we are not able to do this right now,"
- 14:12I want you to take a breath, and I want you to still ask qualifying questions that can perhaps help you understand a little bit more about what might be required, what might be possible in the future.
- 14:28If you are in a situation where you feel, "My manager is not supportive of me advancing. I should have advanced by now. I see other people who are moving forward, and I am not," something I want you to remember,
- 14:47your career ultimately is for you to define. And if you are outgrowing the environment that you're in but there isn't the space for you to expand where you are,
- 15:01while that might feel painful, that's actually also incredibly valuable to know because you can then start to objectively start to assess what should you do next, what should you explore next, and do that very thoughtfully.
- 15:19Take time to consider what that next step could look like for you if it was not within your team. Where would you want to be working? What would be the things that would excite you? What would your non-negotiables be?
- 15:33And start having conversations to explore and research and consider.
- 15:39Um, and then you can, when you start applying or talking to other people within the industry or sectors that you are interested in, you are doing it from a place of enthusiasm and confidence and excitement.
- 15:54And that's really important because if you are feeling frustrated or angry or sad, that energy can also be palpable to others.
- 16:06You don't want to carry that with you into po- possible conversations about a new opportunity.
- 16:13And often, very few people know the details [laughs] of how your day-to-day feel, but what they can pick up on is your energy, how you talk about the work that you've done, how you talk about the contribution that you can make, and how you talk about what excites you moving forward.
- 16:33So I want you to remember all of those things. Even if you feel stuck, even if you feel unsupported, this is a moment in time. It will not define you forever.
- 16:47If you have a manager who is not supportive of your advancement right now or is not able to support your advancement right now, that person won't necessarily be in your orbit, um, in the next three, four, five years.
- 17:02Who knows what you could be doing in that time?
- 17:06But you have the opportunity to be really intentional now about what you're curious about, how you want to add value, and being as professional as possible, whether you hear something encouraging from this conversation with your manager about your next steps, if you hear something that's gonna require you to have some patience, if you hear something that's gonna make you feel perhaps a little bit frustrated, still show up as your best self every single day at work regardless because your career belongs to you.
- 17:39The results that you deliver belong to you.
- 17:42They are the things that you will talk about and that will be on your resume and that you'll talk about in interviews and that your next employer and your next team will be really excited about you and what you bring to the table.
- 17:56So it's important to remember all of those things. So
- 18:00if you are embarking on this path of talking about your next steps for your career, pursuing that promotion, I have created a resource, I've dropped a link to it in the show notes, that you can read and bookmark, and it sets out how you can have this conversation with your manager and also some of the things that you can do if you have experienced either some pushback or resistance to your request.
- 18:30So remember, if this happens, it's a moment in time. Gather information that can be helpful, and continue to dream big, continue to do your best work because your career belongs to you.
- 18:48So thank you so much for being here. Until next time.