Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Turn a Rival Into an Ally at Work
Transcript
- Lucas: So there's this product manager at a mid-sized SaaS company — let's call her Priya — who was stuck in a standoff with a senior engineer named Marcus. Every feature she proposed, he pushed back. Every timeline she suggested, he said it was unrealistic. The rest of the team saw it as a personality clash. Priya saw it as a blocked career path. Luna: Right, because if you can't get a key stakeholder on board, your projects stall, and then your reputation takes the hit. Lucas: Exactly. So Priya tried the obvious stuff — taking Marcus out for coffee, being extra prepared for meetings, even going to his manager. None of it worked. In fact, it made things worse, because Marcus felt she was going around him. Luna: That sounds like the classic escalation trap. The more you push, the more the other person digs in. Lucas: Yeah. So she switched approaches. Instead of trying to defeat Marcus's resistance, she decided to make herself useful to him on something he actually cared about. She found out he was leading a side project to modernize the deployment pipeline — something no one in product had ever shown interest in. Luna: So she offered to help with the documentation? Lucas: Not even that big. She offered to write the user-facing release notes for his pipeline project. A tiny, low-risk favor. Marcus said yes, and that small collaboration opened a door. Within three weeks, they were having real conversations about priorities. Within two months, Marcus was the one volunteering to help her on a tight deadline. Luna: There's something interesting there. It's not about the favor itself — it's about changing the pattern of interaction. Once you've helped someone, they're more likely to help you back. It's a well-documented psychological loop. Lucas: And it works because it bypasses the ego. If Priya had said 'let me help you with your pipeline,' that's an offer. But by asking for something small first — 'could I help with the release notes?' — she positioned herself as a collaborator, not a savior. That distinction matters. Luna: So the first step is to find a genuine low-stakes overlap. Not a fake compliment or a transactional favor, but something you can actually contribute to that the other person values. Lucas: Right. And step two is to make that contribution visible to them, but not to the broader team. You don't want to embarrass them or make it look like they needed help. The goal is a private shift in the relationship dynamic. Luna: And step three? Lucas: Step three is to let the reciprocity cycle spin naturally. Once they've accepted a small gesture from you, their brain starts to balance the ledger. They'll look for ways to return the favor. And when they do, you treat it as a normal collaboration — you don't call it payback. Luna: This makes me think of that research on workplace rivalries — the ones that turn toxic are usually about perceived resource scarcity, not personality. There's only one promotion, one budget, one credit line. Lucas: Exactly. And when you reframe the rivalry as a resource-allocation problem, the solution becomes about expanding the pie or finding non-competing zones. Priya and Marcus weren't actually competing for the same resources — Marcus cared about technical debt, Priya cared about feature velocity. They were just in different silos. Luna: So the rivalry was really a failure of perspective-taking. Each thought the other was the obstacle. Lucas: That's often the case. And once you see it that way, the intervention becomes obvious: you need to create a shared goal that neither can accomplish alone. Priya's small favor was the bridge to that shared goal. Luna: If today's conversation gave you a new lens on a tricky relationship at work, that's exactly what we hope for. And if you find value in episodes like this, the way we keep them ad-free is through listener support at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a simple way to say this content matters to you, and it helps us keep doing it. Lucas: Yeah, it really does make a difference. So back to the playbook — one thing Priya did that I think is underused: she made a public point of crediting Marcus's pipeline work in a product review meeting. Not over-the-top, just a quick 'and Marcus's deployment work means we can ship faster next quarter.' That cost her nothing and earned him visibility. Luna: And that public credit also signals to others that you're not in a turf war. It builds your own reputation as someone who's secure enough to share credit. Lucas: Exactly. So the fourth move is to amplify your rival's wins in a setting where senior leadership can hear it. That's often the step that accelerates the shift from rivalry to alliance. Luna: But what about situations where the rivalry is more entrenched? Say someone has actively undermined you or taken credit for your work. Lucas: That's harder, but the same principle applies — you need to find an off-ramp from the conflict cycle. The off-ramp might be a small, unexpected concession. For example, I know a case where a marketing lead was in a feud with a sales director. She volunteered to shift a campaign deadline to accommodate the sales team's forecast cycle, even though it meant extra work for her team. That gesture disarmed the sales director, because it was the opposite of what he expected. Luna: It's like the classic hostage negotiation tactic — if you make a unilateral concession, the other side feels obligated to reciprocate. Lucas: Right. And the key is that the concession has to be real. It can't feel like a trick. If you give something up that costs you, it signals genuine intent. That's why Priya's release notes offer worked — it was a small real contribution, not a fake olive branch. Luna: So the overarching framework is: identify the resource anxiety, find a non-threatening overlap, make a small genuine contribution, and then publicly amplify their wins. That's a four-step detente. Lucas: Yeah. And I'd add one more thing: timing matters. The worst time to try this is during a heated conflict or right after a setback. Wait for a neutral moment — maybe after a project launch or during a lull. Emotions need to be cool. Luna: And if they reject the initial offer? Lucas: Then you try a different offer. Or you wait. Not every rivalry can be resolved, but most can be managed. The goal isn't to become best friends — it's to get to a point where you can work together without friction. Luna: I think a lot of people underestimate how much agency they have in these situations. They feel like victims of the other person's behavior, but the research shows that the person with more social intelligence almost always sets the tone. Lucas: And that's the real power move — realizing that you can be the one to break the pattern. It's uncomfortable, because it requires vulnerability. But the payoff is massive. Priya went from dreading every interaction with Marcus to having him as a reliable collaborator. Her career trajectory changed because she solved a problem that everyone else was just complaining about. Luna: So the key takeaway: don't try to win the rivalry by defeating the other person. Instead, make it irrelevant by creating a new dynamic. Lucas: Exactly. That's the deeper lesson here — workplace politics isn't about crushing opponents. It's about aligning interests so that both of you move forward faster.