Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Why Smart People Make Dumb Investments
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. Today we're tackling something
- 0:03that feels like a real paradox. We've got a stack of sources
- 0:06here that all point to this one fascinating question.
- 0:09Right. Why do the smartest people, I
- 0:13mean, we're talking about people with the highest degrees,
- 0:15incredible analytical skills, Why do they so often just walk
- 0:19straight into, well, investment disasters?
- 0:22It seems so backwards, doesn't it?
- 0:24We're all conditioned to think that brilliance is the key to
- 0:27wealth. Exactly.
- 0:28But the sources we're diving into, they argue that it has
- 0:31almost nothing to do with IQ. Our mission here is to pull out
- 0:36these simple, fundamental truths that get missed when someone is
- 0:39trying too hard to, you know, look smart.
- 0:42So it's not about IQ, it's about character.
- 0:44It's all about character and temperament.
- 0:46OK, so this deep dive is for you if you want that shortcut to
- 0:49understanding the real difference between just being a
- 0:52genius with numbers and achieving, you know, lasting
- 0:55financial success. It seems you don't need to be
- 0:57the smartest person in the room. You just need to avoid the most
- 1:00predictable mistakes all. Right, let's unpack this.
- 1:03Where do we start? What's the the central flaw
- 1:05here? So it seems like all the sources
- 1:08really agree on this one core idea.
- 1:12Investing is simple, but it's not easy.
- 1:15That's it right there. The simple truths, things like
- 1:17patience, discipline, common sense, they just don't sound
- 1:21advanced enough for someone who's, you know, really
- 1:23intelligent. They feel like they need to add
- 1:25layers of complexity just to prove they're using their
- 1:27brainpower. Precisely.
- 1:29And there's this one anecdote from the 1960s that just
- 1:31perfectly captures this. It's about this individual who
- 1:34was AI mean, a genuine genius. An MITPHD.
- 1:38Wow. Yeah, apparently he could do
- 1:40staggering mental math, and he walks into this room with a
- 1:43presentation that is just designed to blow everyone away.
- 1:46And this wasn't just a quick overview.
- 1:48We're talking about a 2 hour deep dive.
- 1:50Two full hours. He had shirts, complex
- 1:52statistical models. He was thrown around all the
- 1:54jargon. Beta coefficients, you know,
- 1:56risk adjusted returns. The whole 9 yards, all the stuff
- 1:59designed to signal I am the smartest person here.
- 2:02He was obsessed with the how he really was.
- 2:05And this is where it gets interesting.
- 2:07After his two hour master class, someone asked him this
- 2:11incredibly simple question. Also like a child would ask,
- 2:15what was it? What does this company do to
- 2:16make money? Just that.
- 2:18Just that does it serve its customers and silence.
- 2:24The sources say the genius was just.
- 2:26He was completely stumped. No way.
- 2:28He couldn't clearly explain the basic business model.
- 2:31He knew everything about the stocks, volatility, but nothing
- 2:33about the actual, you know, the enterprise.
- 2:36Yeah, he missed the most important thing because he was
- 2:38so focused on looking clever. So that sounds like it ties
- 2:41directly into that classic Ben Graham teaching the one about
- 2:44the voting machine versus the weighing machine.
- 2:46Absolutely. The genius was playing the
- 2:47voting machine game, trying to predict popularity, momentum,
- 2:52what the stock might do next quarter.
- 2:53Which is just speculation really.
- 2:55It's. Pure speculation.
- 2:57The weighing machine though, that's about the business
- 2:59itself. The actual value, its ability to
- 3:01just generate cash over the long term no matter what the stock
- 3:04price is doing today. So the real question isn't what
- 3:07will the stock do tomorrow? It's more like, will this
- 3:10company still have paying customers in 10 or 20 years?
- 3:14Exactly. And if the answer is yes, then
- 3:16all that other stuff, the beta coefficients and the daily price
- 3:19swings, it's all just it's noise and distraction.
- 3:24And that focus on noise, on the irrelevant stuff, it leads right
- 3:28into the second big behavioral trap we found, which is the
- 3:31discipline of of doing nothing, the discipline of inaction.
- 3:36Which is so hard for smart, active people.
- 3:38In every other part of their life, they get rewarded for
- 3:41solving problems, for taking action.
- 3:42Right. They feel this compulsion to be
- 3:44constantly adjusting, trading, proving their worth through
- 3:47activity. They see the market as a puzzle
- 3:50they have to solve. Like right now.
- 3:52So they build these incredibly complex strategies.
- 3:55Unbelievably complex. The sources talk about these
- 3:57strategies where you know you need 17 different things to all
- 4:00go right at the exact same time for to work.
- 4:02That just sounds brittle, like it's designed to fail.
- 4:05It is. Because what happens when only
- 4:0715 of those 17 things go right? The whole thing just collapses.
- 4:11The investor gets wiped out. Simplicity, on the other hand,
- 4:14it might only need one or two things to go right.
- 4:16It's just so much more durable. You know, that makes me think of
- 4:19that analogy that really stood out from the sources, the one
- 4:21about the fidgeting gardener. Oh, that's a great one, yeah.
- 4:25You plant an acorn because you want this big beautiful oak tree
- 4:29and the most important thing you have to do is.
- 4:31Leave it alone. You water it, you give it sun,
- 4:34and you let time and compounding do their magic.
- 4:36But the smart fidgeting investor can't do that.
- 4:39They're out there every week digging it up to check on the
- 4:42roots. Yes, they're paying fees,
- 4:44transaction cost, taxes. Yeah, they basically just annoy
- 4:48the tree to death. They're confusing all that
- 4:50activity with actual progress. Which leads to that one really
- 4:54powerful summary sentence we saw.
- 4:56The stock market is a device for transferring money from the
- 4:59active to the patient. It's as simple as that, and it
- 5:02means the best opportunities are often the ones that are just
- 5:06obvious and kind of boring. Frankly, Coca-Cola in 1988.
- 5:11Exactly. No secret formula, no complex
- 5:13algorithm, just a product that you know people will still be
- 5:16buying in 50 years. But that's precisely why this
- 5:19super smart, active people overlook it.
- 5:22It's not intellectually stimulating enough for them.
- 5:25They want the thrill of the hunt.
- 5:27And that desire for a thrill, for an intellectual challenge,
- 5:30it leads them right into the next danger Complexity.
- 5:34Right. They love derivatives hedges on
- 5:36top of hedges because I think simple means shallow.
- 5:40If the strategy isn't incredibly complex, they feel like they
- 5:42haven't thought it through enough.
- 5:44But the sources are so clear on this.
- 5:45The more complex you make something, the more ways it can
- 5:48break. And the worst part is, when it
- 5:50does break, you often have no idea why.
- 5:52The error is just buried in all those layers of complexity.
- 5:55It's like a. Black box that just self
- 5:57destructs. That's why that simple rule is
- 5:59so important. If you can't explain it to a 10
- 6:01year old, you probably shouldn't own it.
- 6:03True simplicity isn't lazy, it's actually the result of thinking
- 6:06something through so deeply that you can strip away everything
- 6:09that doesn't. Which brings us to another
- 6:11foundational idea, the circle of competence.
- 6:15Knowing what you know, but more importantly, being really honest
- 6:18about what you don't know. And this is where the smart
- 6:21investor really struggles, right?
- 6:23Because of pride. It's.
- 6:24Intellectual pride 100%. They're so used to being the
- 6:28smartest person in any room that they believe they can just
- 6:31master any field, biotech, crypto, whatever, just through
- 6:36sheer brainpower. So they step outside their
- 6:38circle. They wander way outside of it
- 6:40all because they can't stand the thought of saying I don't
- 6:43understand this or I'm going to sit this one out.
- 6:45So pride gets them in, but it also keeps them from getting out
- 6:48when they're wrong. Oh definitely.
- 6:51Admitting a mistake is incredibly hard for highly
- 6:53successful people. It's a huge psychological blow.
- 6:56So instead of just taking the loss, they'll double down, or
- 7:00they'll create these really complex new reasons to justify
- 7:02the original bad decision. And we saw a huge example of
- 7:05this in the source material, the decision to buy the failing
- 7:09Berkshire Hathaway textile mill. A perfect example.
- 7:12It wasn't a financial decision, the sources say.
- 7:14It was a purely emotional one, driven by anger at the
- 7:17management team. So pride and anger led to a
- 7:19terrible business decision A. Terrible decision that just
- 7:22became this anchor for years and the estimated opportunity cost
- 7:27of that one emotional mistake, it's staggering.
- 7:30Over $100 billion. $100 billion, that's the power of compounding
- 7:35that was lost because that capital was stuffed in a dying
- 7:38business. It just proves that the most
- 7:40important skill isn't a high IQ. It's the humility to just say I
- 7:44was wrong and move on. And that humility, that's the
- 7:47foundation for the final key idea from Ben Graham, the margin
- 7:51of safety. This isn't about being perfectly
- 7:53right with your numbers. Not at all.
- 7:55It's about being OK with being a little bit wrong.
- 7:58It means you pay a price that's so far below your estimate of
- 8:01the real value that you create this huge.
- 8:04Buffer, I love that bridge analogy they used.
- 8:06You design A bridge that can hold £10,000.
- 8:09But you never, ever let a 9000 LB truck drive over it.
- 8:13You need that buffer for bad luck, for mistakes, for a world
- 8:17that you just can't predict perfectly.
- 8:18But the smart person's error is that they fall in love with
- 8:21their own models. They think their Monte Carlo
- 8:23simulations are, you know, flawless predictables of the
- 8:27future. Their intellectual arrogance
- 8:29tells them they don't need a margin of safety, Their math is
- 8:31perfect, so they pay a price right up to the theoretical
- 8:34limit, leaving 0 room for error. And then one little thing goes
- 8:37wrong and it's a catastrophe. It's also fascinating how we see
- 8:41this cycle of like, intellectual amnesia.
- 8:44The sources talk about living through the crashes 74872000,
- 8:482008 and yet every single time smart people seem to forget the
- 8:53basic lessons. Every single time they invent
- 8:55these complex new theories for why this time is different.
- 8:58I mean thinkaboutthe.com bubble in 99 and 2000.
- 9:01Right, all these brilliant analysts are talking about
- 9:03network effects eyeballs. And the new economy All to
- 9:06justify why a company with no profits and no clear path to
- 9:11ever making a profit should be worth billions of dollars.
- 9:14When the simple weighing machine truth was that it made
- 9:17absolutely no sense. So why do they keep forgetting
- 9:20that human nature, that fear and greed, never changes?
- 9:24Because they see a new technology, you know, the
- 9:26Internet or AI, and they believe their superior intellect can
- 9:30somehow conquer those basic human emotions.
- 9:34They think they're too smart to fall for herd mentality.
- 9:37Nobody is. Nobody is.
- 9:39Those emotions are primal. They destroy discipline.
- 9:42The ultimate test that the sources keep coming back to is
- 9:45this. If you're not willing to own a
- 9:47stocks for 10 years, you shouldn't own it for 10 minutes.
- 9:50The goal is just to buy good companies at a fair price, not
- 9:53to outsmart the entire market. So after all of this, what does
- 9:57this actually mean for you? For the listener who's just
- 9:59trying to navigate all this. I think it means that you have
- 10:02to realize investing is fundamentally a game of
- 10:04behavior, not a game of intelligence.
- 10:07You don't need a HD to understand how a company makes
- 10:09money or to gras the power of compounding interest.
- 10:12It's more about patience, discipline, humility.
- 10:15And rigorous emotional control that's more important than any
- 10:18quantitative skill you could have.
- 10:19So you don't need to be a genius, you just need to avoid
- 10:22being foolish, which ironically means being disciplined enough
- 10:26to do nothing most of the time. Exactly.
- 10:29Your big advantage comes from consistently avoiding the major
- 10:32mistakes, not from some brilliant complex move that
- 10:36nobody else has thought of. And to leave you with something
- 10:38to think about, here's a final provocative thought based on
- 10:41what we've seen. If highly intelligent people get
- 10:44rewarded in every other field, in medicine, in engineering, for
- 10:47their quick action and complex problem solving, what is it
- 10:51about the very culture of intelligence that makes the
- 10:53critical inaction needed for investing so psychologically
- 10:57painful? It's the one arena where often
- 10:59the less you do, the more you make, and that's something for
- 11:02you to Mull over on your own.