Latest / Reformed Thinking / The Terminal Disease of the Soul: The Peril of Intellectual Pride (Proverbs 26:12)
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to another session of reformed thinking.
- 0:03We are back at the table, stacks of notes in front of us and
- 0:07ready to tackle a subject that, to be honest, made me sweat a
- 0:11little bit while preparing. It's one of those topics.
- 0:14It is. We usually look at big cultural
- 0:17trends or, you know, complex theological systems, but today
- 0:20we are turning the camera around, we are looking at the
- 0:23machinery of our own minds. And that's a bit of a hazard for
- 0:26us, isn't it? We send so much time analyzing
- 0:29ideas out there in the world that we can forget the apparatus
- 0:32we use to do the analyzing is what's broken, right?
- 0:36And the text we're dealing with today is not a comfortable 1, is
- 0:39not the kind of verse you stitch onto a pillow or put on a
- 0:43graduation. No, it is a verse that goes for
- 0:45the jugular. We're looking at Proverbs 26.12,
- 0:48and I want to read it right at the start, so it just sort of
- 0:50hangs over this entire conversation, Solomon writes.
- 0:53Do you see a man who is wise in his own eyes?
- 0:56There is more hope for a fool than for him.
- 0:59That statement is jarring. It's meant to be a shock to the
- 1:02system. It's shocking because of how we
- 1:04usually define a fool in the Bible, and specifically in
- 1:07Proverbs. A fool, the Hebrew word is
- 1:10Kessel, is not just a guy who, you know, slips on a banana
- 1:13peel. This is a serious moral
- 1:15category. Very serious category.
- 1:18We think of the fool as the bottom of the barrel.
- 1:20He's the guy who ruins his life, ruins his family, and just
- 1:24refuses to listen to reason. You're right, the Kessel is a
- 1:28tragic figure. He's obstinate.
- 1:30He's dull hearted. He actually hates knowledge,
- 1:32hates it. Later in the Proverbs, we see
- 1:34him returning to his folly the way a dog returns to its vomit.
- 1:38It's a grotesque, irrational addiction to just bad decisions.
- 1:43So in the biblical imagination, you assume the fool is as bad as
- 1:46it gets you. Think that's rock bottom?
- 1:48You do. But then Solomon drops verse 12
- 1:50and he says essentially, you think that guy is hopeless, I
- 1:54can show you someone in a much more desperate condition.
- 1:57The premise is terrifying. There's a spiritual condition
- 2:00that is more dangerous than ignorance, more dangerous than
- 2:02open rebellion, and even more dangerous than the
- 2:05self-destructive behavior of that standard fool.
- 2:08And what is it? It's the certainty that one
- 2:10cannot be taught. It is what we might call the
- 2:12most dangerous form of blindness.
- 2:14That's our mission for this deep dive.
- 2:16We need to identify this blindness.
- 2:18And the scary part is that it's not about a lack of information.
- 2:22The man, wise in his own eyes, might have a library full of
- 2:25books. He often does.
- 2:27The problem is not the quantity of data he has, it's the posture
- 2:31of his heart toward that data. In our Reformed tradition, we
- 2:35talk about the noetic effects of sin.
- 2:37From the Greek word noose for mind.
- 2:39Exactly. Sin didn't just mess up our
- 2:42emotions or our behaviors. It broke our cognitive
- 2:44faculties. It darkened the mind.
- 2:46It affects how we reason and how we perceive reality itself.
- 2:50So the goal today is to move from into this mirror of fools
- 2:54to understanding why the only cure is what the Apostle Paul
- 2:57calls the foolishness of the cross.
- 2:59We have to go there. The Westminster Confession is
- 3:01very clear about the nature of effectual calling and
- 3:04repentance. If man is wise in his own eyes,
- 3:07he is for all practical purposes deaf to the outward call of the
- 3:11gospel. He has inoculated himself
- 3:13against the cure. He needs something to shatter
- 3:15that shell from the outside. He does.
- 3:17OK, so let's set the scene before we tear the verse apart.
- 3:20This doesn't exist in a vacuum. It's part of a specific
- 3:23collection in Proverbs, chapters 25 through 29.
- 3:27Correct. The superscription tells us
- 3:29these are the proverbs of Solomon, which the men of
- 3:31Hezekiah, king of Judah, copied. That sounds like a bibliographic
- 3:36footnote, but you're saying it actually carries a lot of
- 3:38weight. It carries immense weight.
- 3:39I mean, think about who Hezekiah was.
- 3:41He was a reformer. He was a king trying to pull
- 3:45Judah back from the brink of idolatry and cultural collapse.
- 3:48So he's on a mission. He's on a mission.
- 3:51He wasn't just collecting sayings for a hobby.
- 3:54His men were curating A curriculum for the moral
- 3:56formation of a covenant community.
- 3:59They were trying to rebuild a culture that feared the Lord.
- 4:02So chapter 26 isn't just a random grab bag, it's
- 4:05structured. It is a gallery.
- 4:07Specifically, verses one through 11 function as a gallery of
- 4:10fools. It's like walking through a
- 4:12museum where every portrait shows you a different aspect of
- 4:14folly. What are some of those
- 4:16portraits? Well, verse one says honor
- 4:18doesn't fit a fool any more than snow fits in summer.
- 4:21It's just out of place, verse 3 says.
- 4:24Dealing with a fool is like trying to manage a brute beast.
- 4:27You need a whip for the horse and a rod for the fool's back.
- 4:30It's about containment, not instruction.
- 4:32Right. And then you have the famous,
- 4:34slightly disgusting image in verse 11 about the dog.
- 4:37It's visceral. It is like a dog that returns to
- 4:40his vomit is a fool who repeats his folly.
- 4:43It is meant to make you recoil. It's meant to be repulsive.
- 4:47Here's the thing about walking through that gallery, though.
- 4:50When I read verses one through 11, I feel pretty good about
- 4:53myself. Of course you do, I look at.
- 4:54The fool. And I think, well, I make
- 4:56mistakes, but I'm not that guy, you know?
- 4:59I don't return to my vomit. I'm not irrational.
- 5:01And that is the trap. The text is designed to elicit
- 5:05that exact reaction. You read about the fool's
- 5:08rashness and his stupidity, and you instinctively distance
- 5:12yourself. You feel a sense of moral
- 5:13superiority. You feel safe.
- 5:15You feel safe because you think I'm not acting like a maniac.
- 5:18And that is when verse 12 jumps out from behind a Bush.
- 5:21It's a total ambush. Just when the reader feels
- 5:23secure despising the fool, Solomon introduces a character
- 5:27who is worse. It's a moral escalation.
- 5:30How so? The previous verses showed fools
- 5:32doing foolish things behaviors. Verse 12 introduces a man whose
- 5:36entire identity is wrapped U in his own rightness.
- 5:40It's not just what he does, it's who he is.
- 5:42So the chapter moves from, let's say manageable folly, which is
- 5:46bad but it's obvious, to a hardened state that is much
- 5:50harder to detect. That's it.
- 5:52The fool in the earlier verses is annoying and destructive, but
- 5:55he's transparent. You can see him coming a mile
- 5:57away. The character in verse 12 has
- 5:59blocked the means of grace. He has locked the door from the
- 6:02inside. OK, let's get into the exegesis
- 6:04then. I want to diagnose his condition
- 6:06properly. The text starts with the
- 6:07question. Do you see?
- 6:08In Hebrew? That's what it does.
- 6:10And the verb is doing a lot of work.
- 6:11It is not asking if you physically see a guy standing
- 6:14there. It's a summons to observe.
- 6:17It demands spiritual perception. It's a challenge.
- 6:20It's a challenge, Solomon is asking.
- 6:22Do you have the discernment to spot this profile in the wild?
- 6:27And more uncomfortably, do you have the discernment to spot
- 6:30this profile in the mirror? And the profile is wise in his
- 6:33own eyes. Check them by Nov.
- 6:35You mentioned earlier this isn't about how smart you are to.
- 6:37Be very, very clear on this. This is not about IQ.
- 6:41It is not about how many degrees you have on your wall.
- 6:43You can have a PhD in theology and be wise in your own eyes,
- 6:48and you can be a guy with no education at all and be wise in
- 6:51your own eyes. So it's a moral category, not an
- 6:54intellectual one? Absolutely.
- 6:55So what is the core issue? If it isn't intelligence, What's
- 6:59the mechanism at work here? I think the best word for it is
- 7:02autonomy. The man establishes himself as
- 7:04the final authority. He becomes his own lawgiver, his
- 7:08own judge, and his own jury. This sounds this.
- 7:10This sounds like the original problem.
- 7:12This sounds like the Garden of Eden.
- 7:13It goes straight back to Genesis 3.
- 7:16Think about the temptation. The serpent didn't just offer
- 7:18fruit, he offered a rival wisdom.
- 7:21Eve saw that the tree was desirable to make one wise, but
- 7:25wise according to whom? Wise apart from God's word.
- 7:29She decided that her assessment of reality was superior to God,
- 7:32the command. So it's a kind of practical
- 7:34atheism. It is.
- 7:36It is living as if God's verdict is optional.
- 7:39The self becomes the Canon of truth.
- 7:41If I feel it, it must be true. If I think it, it must be right.
- 7:46Everything is referenced back to the self.
- 7:48And this creates what we might call a closed system.
- 7:52That is a helpful way to picture it.
- 7:54This person does not just make mistakes.
- 7:56We all make mistakes. This person defends their
- 7:58mistakes as wisdom. They have hermetically sealed
- 8:01mind. So what happens when you try to
- 8:03warn them or offer counsel? It doesn't get in.
- 8:07They filter it through self protection.
- 8:08If you rebuke them, they interpret it as hostility.
- 8:11Oh that person just hates me. Or they're just jealous.
- 8:13And if you offer advice? Then they interpret it as
- 8:15condescension. Who are you to tell me what to
- 8:17do? They can't receive it as help
- 8:19because to receive help would be to admit a need, and their whole
- 8:22system is built on not having any needs.
- 8:24The door is locked and they've swallowed the key.
- 8:26Precisely the ordinary means that God uses to teach wisdom,
- 8:30reproof Scripture, the lessons of Providence, you know, just
- 8:35life itself. They can't get in.
- 8:36And This is why it's so dangerous.
- 8:38It is not that the medicine doesn't exist, it's that the
- 8:40patient refuses to admit you're sick.
- 8:42Which brings us to the verdict in the second-half of the verse.
- 8:45There is more hope for a fool than for him.
- 8:48The Hebrew construction here uses a comparative men.
- 8:51It sets up a hierarchy of spiritual danger and it places
- 8:54the fool, the Kiesel, the vomit returning disaster for man
- 8:57higher on the scale of redemption than the self wise
- 9:00man. OK, we really need to unpack
- 9:01that. Why is there hope for the fool?
- 9:03You just told me his life is a train wreck.
- 9:05It's hopeful because it's a train wreck.
- 9:07The fool's folly is loud. It's public.
- 9:10It is self-destructive. He hits rock bottom.
- 9:12He does, and rock bottom is a very hopeful place to be.
- 9:16Consequences catch him. Poverty comes, shame comes.
- 9:20The rod for the fool's back does its work.
- 9:22The pain becomes a teacher. The pain can become a teacher.
- 9:26Here is the key. Pain and undeniable failure can
- 9:29crack the shell. The fool is interruptible.
- 9:33He is empty, and deep down he usually knows he's empty.
- 9:37His life isn't working. It's like the severe mercy of
- 9:39the law that Paul talks about. That's a great connection.
- 9:42The disaster of his life acts as a schoolmaster.
- 9:45It drives him to despair, and potentially that despair drives
- 9:48him to Christ. When you are sitting in the
- 9:51ruins of your life, it is very hard to argue that you are wise.
- 9:55The evidence is all around you. You're.
- 9:57Confronted with the undeniable fact of your own bankruptcy,
- 10:00there's an opening for grace there.
- 10:01But the self wise man, he has a way to avoid rock bottom.
- 10:05He is insulated against it. That is the hopelessness.
- 10:08He reinterprets consequences. He has a story for everything.
- 10:12He engages in what one of the sources called reflexive self
- 10:15justification. That is the term.
- 10:17It's a reflex. If he fails in business, it
- 10:20wasn't his fault, it was bad luck or the economy or his
- 10:23partners. If he sins, he was just stress
- 10:26or someone else provoked him into it.
- 10:27And then if he. Is rebuked.
- 10:28If he is rebuked, the rebuker is the problem.
- 10:32They're too harsh, they're self-righteous.
- 10:34They don't understand the full story.
- 10:36He's always the victim. One of the sources used the
- 10:39analogy of a silent cancer. I found that chilling.
- 10:42It is a chilling analogy. The fool has visible gangrene.
- 10:46It is ugly, it smells, everyone sees it and you know you have to
- 10:50deal with it or you're going to die.
- 10:51But the self wise man. He has a terminal internal
- 10:54disease and he feels perfectly healthy.
- 10:57He's walking around giving life advice, feeling great while this
- 11:00thing eats him up from the inside.
- 11:02This reminds me of what Jesus said to the Pharisees in Luke
- 11:05chapter 5. They that are whole need not a
- 11:07physician. The tragedy is not that the self
- 11:10wise man is too sinful to be saved.
- 11:12There is no such thing as too sinful for grace.
- 11:14That's a key point. It is.
- 11:16The tragedy is that he thinks he is too righteous to need saving.
- 11:19He never goes to the doctor because he is convinced he's in
- 11:22peak physical condition. He's the healthiest man in the
- 11:25world in his own eyes. OK, let's move this from the
- 11:28theoretical to the practical. We need to look at what this
- 11:31looks like in the real world. Our sources identify this at its
- 11:35root as the sin of pride, taking the seed of God.
- 11:38At its root, it is idolatry. It's misdirected trust.
- 11:42You are trusting yourself more than revelation.
- 11:45And it's unbelief, A fundamental refusal to live as a dependent
- 11:49creature. The sources break this down into
- 11:52secular and religious manifestations.
- 11:54Let's start with the secular side, the Greeks, to borrow
- 11:57Paul's terminology. Well, one major manifestation is
- 12:00scientism or naturalism. Now we have to be clear here.
- 12:03We are not talking about science itself.
- 12:05Observation and experimentation are good gifts from God.
- 12:08Of course, we're talking about the philosophical arrogance of
- 12:11claiming that the cosmos is a result of random chance and that
- 12:14human reason is the ultimate judge of all things.
- 12:17It's the creature judging the creator.
- 12:19It is. It is looking at the incredible
- 12:21complexity of the universe and saying I could explain this
- 12:24without God. It is a form of being wise in
- 12:27one's own eyes that blinds you to the evidence of design
- 12:30staring you in the face. Then there's the other side of
- 12:33the secular coin, which is very prevalent right now, Subjective
- 12:37truth. This is the modern idol of lived
- 12:40experience. The idea is that my feelings
- 12:43define reality. If I feel it, it is true.
- 12:46For me. This makes the self the final
- 12:48interpreter. And it silences any external
- 12:51correction. It has to, because if you bring
- 12:54something like scripture to bear, the response is you cannot
- 12:57tell me my truth is wrong. The individual's perception is
- 13:01elevated to the level of divine revelation.
- 13:03The sources also mentioned critical theory and social
- 13:06justice ideologies in this context, and we need to be
- 13:08careful here to be precise about the theological objection.
- 13:12Yes, the issue isn't talking about justice.
- 13:14The Bible talks about justice constantly.
- 13:16The issue is when you have rival wisdoms.
- 13:19These ideologies can function as closed systems that reject
- 13:22biblical categories of sin and grace, and they replace them
- 13:26with secular categories of power dynamics.
- 13:28So if you adopt A system where your social standing or your
- 13:31group identity gives you a special insight that cannot be
- 13:34questioned by scripture. Then you are being wise in your
- 13:37own eyes. You are placing A sociological
- 13:40framework above the Word of God as the final authority.
- 13:44OK, now, before we get too comfortable pointing fingers at
- 13:47the secular world, the sources pivot hard to the church.
- 13:51Specifically to us, to Reformed believers.
- 13:54And this is where it hurts. We have to talk about the
- 13:56Pharisees doctrinal. Pride.
- 13:58It is a massive danger for Reformed believers specifically.
- 14:02And why? Because we value precision.
- 14:06We value the Westminster Standards, we value the five
- 14:09points of Calvinism. And those are good things.
- 14:11We should value truth. But it is entirely possible to
- 14:15possess the right theology and use it as a shield against
- 14:18conviction, to use it as a weapon against others and a
- 14:21defense for yourself. This leads to the phenomenon of
- 14:24the cage stage Calvinist. The classic example.
- 14:26This is the guy who knows all the arguments.
- 14:28He can dismantle Arminianism in his sleep.
- 14:31He critiques the sermon every Sunday for not being nuanced
- 14:34enough on some fine point of covenant theology.
- 14:37He's technically correct. He's technically correct on the
- 14:39mechanics of salvation, but he never trembles at the text.
- 14:42He's never broken by it. He stands over the word, not
- 14:45under it. He uses theology as a weapon to
- 14:48validate his own intellect and prove his superiority.
- 14:52And the litmus test here is simple.
- 14:53How do we handle rebuke when the man, wise in his own eyes, is
- 14:57confronted about his character, maybe his harshness or his lack
- 15:01of love or his impatience? He defends himself with his
- 15:03theological resume, he says. But I'm fighting for the truth.
- 15:06I'm defending Orthodoxy. It's orthodoxy without humility.
- 15:10Which is a demon's faith, as one old writer put it.
- 15:13The devil is a better theologian than any of us.
- 15:15He knows the Bible better than we do.
- 15:16He's perfectly orthodox. But he has no submission.
- 15:19He has no love. He has no humility.
- 15:22If our theology makes us harder, not softer, we are the man in
- 15:25Proverbs 26.12. Wow, OK we have painted a bleak
- 15:29picture. You have the fool who is bad off
- 15:31and the self wise man who is worse off because he is
- 15:34unteachable. How do we get out of this?
- 15:36What is the cure? Well, the cure cannot come from
- 15:38inside the self. That is the whole point.
- 15:40The system is broken. You cannot reason your way out
- 15:42of a broken mind using a broken mind.
- 15:44You need, for lack of a better term, alien wisdom.
- 15:47Alien wisdom That sounds almost sci-fi, but it is a crucial
- 15:51theological concept. It just means wisdom from
- 15:53outside of us. Paul talks about this in First
- 15:55Corinthians. One God chose the foolish things
- 15:58of the world to shame the wise. The Gospel is an insult to human
- 16:03pride. The cross is a stumbling block.
- 16:05It is a stumbling block to the religious who want to earn their
- 16:08way through moral performance and it is foolishness to the
- 16:11intellectual who wants to reason their way through philosophy.
- 16:15The cure is to embrace the so-called foolishness of the
- 16:18cross. And this is where we have to
- 16:19look at Christ. He is the complete antithesis of
- 16:22the self wise man. He is wisdom Incarnate, but look
- 16:26at his life. Unlike the self wise man, Christ
- 16:29did not grasp equality with God. As Philippians 2 tells us.
- 16:32He emptied himself. He's submitted to the Father.
- 16:34He's submitted to scripture even when it led him to suffering.
- 16:37Not my will, but yours be done. That's the cry of true wisdom.
- 16:40And there's a theological exchange that happens here.
- 16:43We call it double imputation. This is the heart of the gospel.
- 16:46It is Christ took the record of our arrogant autonomy, our
- 16:50lifelong insistence on being our own gods, and he paid for it on
- 16:54the cross. And in exchange he gave us his
- 16:58submissive wisdom. He gave us his perfect record of
- 17:01saying not my will but yours be done.
- 17:03So we are brought into union with Christ.
- 17:06And we must be crucified with Christ.
- 17:08The I that needs to be right, the I that needs to win every
- 17:11argument that I must die. This is the beauty of
- 17:14justification by faith alone. It breaks the need for self
- 17:17justification. Unpack that a bit more.
- 17:20How does the doctrine of justification actually stop me
- 17:22from needing to be right in an argument with my wife or my Co
- 17:25worker? Well, think about it.
- 17:26If I have to justify myself, then every time you contradict
- 17:29me you are attacking my very existence.
- 17:32My sense of worth is on the line.
- 17:34I have to win the argument to prove I am valuable that I am.
- 17:36OK, my identity is at stake. Your identity is at stake in
- 17:40every disagreement. But if I am justified by Christ,
- 17:43by standing before God is settled, it is secure.
- 17:46It does not depend on my rightness in this or any other
- 17:48moment. It depends on His righteousness,
- 17:51which has been given to me as a gift.
- 17:52So I can admit I was wrong. You can say those 3 words
- 17:56without feeling like you were dying.
- 17:58I was wrong because your identity isn't built on being
- 18:01right anymore, it's built on Christ.
- 18:04Repentance really is just agreeing with God against
- 18:06yourself. Say that again.
- 18:08Repentance is agreeing with God against yourself.
- 18:10It is taking God's side in the trial against your own soul.
- 18:14It's saying your verdict on me is truer than my own.
- 18:17That is a powerful definition of repentance.
- 18:20It's the only way to freedom. It's the only way.
- 18:22OK, let's land the plane with some practical application.
- 18:25We can talk about this theoretically all day, but how
- 18:28do we actually become teachable people?
- 18:31How do we practice this? I think it starts with prayer,
- 18:34but a specific kind of prayer, the prayer of Psalm 139.
- 18:38Search me, O God, and know my heart.
- 18:40Try me and know my thoughts. Notice the direction of that.
- 18:43The direction is everything. It is not God.
- 18:45Let me show you how right I am about my neighbor.
- 18:47It is search me. It is asking for exposure, not
- 18:51applause. It's an invitation for God to
- 18:53show you your blind spots. And then we have to watch our
- 18:55reaction to contradiction. This is the field test.
- 18:58This is where the rubber meets the road.
- 18:59When someone crosses you, when someone corrects you, when your
- 19:02spouse point something out, what happens physically in your
- 19:05chest? Do you heat up?
- 19:07Do you feel that flash of anger? Do you instantly start
- 19:10formulating a counter attack? Or do you listen?
- 19:12Or can you just listen? The wise man listens.
- 19:15The self wise man launches a defense.
- 19:17It also changes how we handle scripture, doesn't it?
- 19:20Completely. Do we stand over the text as
- 19:23editors, looking for verses that confirm what we already believe?
- 19:26Or do we sit under the text as disciples, ready for it to
- 19:30correct and rebuke us? If the Bible never offends you,
- 19:34you probably aren't reading it right.
- 19:35You are likely just reading a reflection of yourself.
- 19:38And finally, ecclesiology. We need the local church.
- 19:41You cannot do this alone. A church member who refuses
- 19:45accountability, who flows from church to church whenever they
- 19:47get challenged, is wise in his own eyes.
- 19:50We need elders. We need brothers and sisters who
- 19:53love us enough to see our blind spots and speak into them.
- 19:55It is the safety of the herd. It is the design of God for our
- 19:58protection from ourselves. It really all comes down to a
- 20:00paradox then. It does.
- 20:02It's what we could call the door of hope.
- 20:04There is no hope in yourself. None.
- 20:07But there is infinite hope if you come empty handed.
- 20:10Humility is the door. As James says, God opposes the
- 20:15proud but gives grace to the humble.
- 20:17So it's the great exchange, abandoning the mirror of self
- 20:21admiration for the window of grace.
- 20:23That is it. So here is the summary for
- 20:25today. We have looked at the danger,
- 20:28the certainty that prevents learning, the self wisdom that
- 20:32is more hopeless than the fool's folly.
- 20:34And we've seen the solution, the fear of the Lord, that posture
- 20:37of humility. Independence is the beginning of
- 20:39wisdom. I want to leave you, the
- 20:41listener, with a final thought to Mull over this week.
- 20:43Identify 1 area of your life. Maybe it's politics, maybe it's
- 20:46parenting, Maybe it's a specific theological .1 area where you
- 20:49are absolutely certain you are right.
- 20:51That is a dangerous question to ask yourself.
- 20:53It is, and once you've identified it, ask God to show
- 20:55you if you were actually right or if you were just being
- 20:57protected by your own pride in that area.
- 21:00Because it's better to be a fool in the eyes of the world and a
- 21:03son of God than a king in your own eyes and a stranger to
- 21:06grace. Amen to that.
- 21:08Thanks for diving in with us. Until next time.