Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Duggar Family Deep Dive (Chapter 5)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey deserve listeners. This is chapter five and our deep dive on the Duggers.
- 0:04Let's get into it. My name is doctor Kirkhana. I'm a therapist
- 0:07and a professor. My name is and to authorize dealers to be authorized.
- 0:13So two thousand and five, we have reached two thousand and five. The
- 0:17family has had their first special that has aired on TLC. And also to
- 0:23catch you up, the family does know about Josh abusing the younger sisters and
- 0:29the babysitter of the younger sisters, five young girls, and they went to
- 0:34the police, they went to other people in the church, and they seemed
- 0:39to be moving on with their lives, assuming that Josh won't ever do it
- 0:45again, and never going to a therapist and seemingly never going to CPS.
- 0:51So two thousand and five, Josh continues to defy. This is the oldest
- 0:57child, Josh, He's the one who abused the younger children. Josh continued
- 1:00to confide in Bobby Holt. Bobby is a woman. She's in the documentary
- 1:07Shiny Happy People, and this is according to her. And trigger warning by
- 1:11the way, because it gets a little graphic here. But I think it's
- 1:15important to point out that this is what she was told that during one visit,
- 1:21Josh admitted to penetrating the vagina of a five year old girl with his
- 1:25finger. So up until this point, maybe it seems that what was told
- 1:32to the parents was that Josh had touched the girls while they were sleeping,
- 1:40over their clothes or stuff like this. But penetrating the vagina of a five
- 1:44year old girl with his finger, I mean, yikes. If it was
- 1:49ambiguous before, it's not anymore. And also, Josh told Bobby Holt that
- 1:56he had abused one of his sisters for three year years. That sister was
- 2:00from the age of two to five. Hard to know the frequency there,
- 2:06but even if it's a pretty low frequency, like once a year, that's
- 2:10still pretty alarming, right. And I point this out because the parents probably
- 2:17knew at least some of these details, if not all of them. At
- 2:21the very least they should have been informed about it. But as a therapist,
- 2:23I've heard a lot of different sorts of things in this category where you
- 2:28have a sibling who has touched a younger sibling, and I've heard a lot
- 2:34of different accounts things that are really quite mild. It's hard to know how
- 2:38the victim will feel. Even if you do have a mild interaction, so
- 2:43to speak, a mild interaction, you can still be quite traumatized by that
- 2:46as a younger person. But the trauma often does coincide or does correlate with
- 2:53the severity and the frequency and other kinds of elements like coercion and threats in
- 2:58this kind of thing. But anyway, so I would hear very mild things
- 3:01like the initial reporting of Josh having touched one of his younger siblings over the
- 3:07clothes while they were sleeping, still abusive and can be massively traumatic, but
- 3:12you might hear something and it was just one instance, and it seems pretty
- 3:15clear that it was just one instance all the way to extreme abuse behavior.
- 3:22What we're hearing from Josh from his own mouth is more towards the extreme right
- 3:29ongoing, I'm wondering, like, doesn't that seem like a cry for help
- 3:32that he would be confessing this to Bobby, Like, because you would think
- 3:38you would think if he was like very self aware that this is wrong and
- 3:40that he needs to keep it quiet because he wants to keep going, like
- 3:44he just wouldn't talk to talk to anyway, It almost seems like someone needs
- 3:49to stop me, or I don't know. It's incredible to me that he
- 3:52would be sharing that with Bobby. Yeah, I'll commend him for doing this.
- 3:58It's hard to know what his motivations were. You know. It's possible
- 4:00that Bobby Holt was just really good at extracting the information. It's hard to
- 4:04know. Certainly. You can have people, and I've worked with some people
- 4:10like this unfortunately who will like to brag about it. So was that what
- 4:15he was doing was he getting off on being able to describe it, that's
- 4:19also possible. But it's also very possible that it was a cry for help,
- 4:24that he was concerned. He was young and very worried and ashamed.
- 4:30And because that is the normal course for this sort of thing, that people
- 4:34who notice these kinds of attractions, and particularly if they act on them,
- 4:39they're usually quite alarmed with their behavior. They look at themselves and think,
- 4:44oh my god, I'm one of those people. What's wrong with me?
- 4:46I don't want to be like this. I want to be normal. I
- 4:50want to be like everyone else. How Come I have this urge and this
- 4:55desire and this attraction. I don't want this urge and attraction. That's often.
- 5:00It's not always the case, but that is often, So it's possible
- 5:02that he was saying, look, you got to know what's been happening.
- 5:08In fact, another criticism of the documentary Shining Happy People is they didn't even
- 5:13go into these details. They just surface level talked about maybe one conversation between
- 5:18Josh and Bobby Holt. I later learned that Josh was regularly talking one on
- 5:26one with Bobby Holt about what he was, what he had done, and
- 5:30over the span of a number of years. So it's hard to know what
- 5:34was going on. But I just keep thinking, if only one of the
- 5:39adults in this entire situation, because there were many adults, not only a
- 5:44police officer, but the parents, Bobby and Jim Holt, other people.
- 5:47I think if only they had reached out to a treatment specialist, because even
- 5:53if he wasn't reaching out for help, then that treatment specialist would have been
- 5:57able to help. There are treatment for people like this. There are ways
- 6:02of managing it, obviously, but there also are ways of reorienting one's sexuality.
- 6:09It can be hard work, but it can work. Often sometimes it's
- 6:14a matter of elevating or creating the opportunity for non abusive types of attractions while
- 6:21giving it enough time so that the person can get their attachment needs and sexual
- 6:26needs met in ways that are with peers right, and then over time their
- 6:30attraction starts to diminish towards children. They might always kind of have that in
- 6:35the back of their mind, but they have a venue to actually get their
- 6:39needs met. The problem is is that unless you do something along those lines,
- 6:44the individual keeps acting on their urge and it will lock in that behavior.
- 6:49So the earlier you can intervene with these people the better. Obviously,
- 6:53when they're going through puberty is a great time to intervene, and treatment specialists
- 6:58will attest to, you know, absolutely being able to help people with this.
- 7:02So it's just it's just this tragedy that and really to Josh because eventually,
- 7:09you know, long story short, spoiler alert, he ends up in
- 7:11prison. It's hard enough for any family because I think you were mentioning this
- 7:14before too. How it doesn't get reported, you know, like they're afraid
- 7:16and stuff. And then you compound it with a lot of these cults.
- 7:20They don't like to deal with outside forces. They like to deal with everything
- 7:24internally. So I think that's what his parent was parents were trying to do.
- 7:29First all, they were trying to hook him up with a with an
- 7:30adult woman to like distract him. I don't know if she was an adult
- 7:33yet, but anyway, someone more of his age. Right. In fact,
- 7:36they literally told that to his friend. The friend of the family's like
- 7:41no, because the friend of the family is like, wait, are you
- 7:43trying to use my daughter to like just like pull him away. He's like,
- 7:46yeah, that's what we're trying to do. Yeah, it was Bobby
- 7:47Holt's daughter. And then like you know, we said he went to the
- 7:53elders of the of the church, and it's like, yeah, we got
- 7:56to try to just like deal with it ourselves. So no, no idea
- 8:00of like, well maybe I should reach out to a specialist on expert,
- 8:03someone that can really help with this. Right. You imagine that there's a
- 8:07paranoia about not only just outsiders to the cult, but also liberal therapists that
- 8:13will infect the minds of Josh and we can't have that. So who knows,
- 8:18but quite possible, all right, So two thousand and six they have
- 8:22their second special This is two years later, so a pretty slow ramp up,
- 8:28you know, The first special in two thousand and four was very popular,
- 8:31but you know, you could be in the family and imagine that they're
- 8:35just like, well, okay, that was a one shot cut. Yeah,
- 8:37that's over. But then they have their second special, raising sixteen children
- 8:43is what it's called two years right, so, you know, because the
- 8:46first special was fourteen and pregnant and not fourteen years old but fourteen children impregnant.
- 8:52But now two years later it's raising sixteen children and they were becoming famous
- 8:58at this point. It occurs to me that I'm sure they did that on
- 9:01purpose as a double entendre at the time when they put the first one out,
- 9:05because in either case the title would catch people's eyes, like fourteen and
- 9:09pregnant. People might think, oh, someone's fourteen and they're pregnant, or
- 9:13in this case, no, no, actually there's fourteen kids. To be
- 9:15clear, it's called fourteen children and pregnant. Never mind. And in the
- 9:18same year they have a third special, sixteen Children and moving in. So
- 9:22this is the episode where TLC actually paid to have their seven thousand square foot
- 9:28house completed, right, yes, because they had been working on it like
- 9:31themselves, with the you know, the children doing all the hammering and stuff,
- 9:35and but it was I mean, building a house is hard enough,
- 9:37building a seven thousand square foot home. Yeah, And if you've seen this
- 9:41house, it looks like a giant compound slash barn. And it was coincidentally
- 9:50designed without thinking about them being on a reality TV show. But it's perfect
- 9:56for reality TV because it's big and it's got a big yard and lots of
- 10:01room for cameras and rooms for multiple children, this kind of thing. So
- 10:05anyway, TLC actually invested and finished the house for them, And so at
- 10:11this point TLC is really locking in on this family, you know, probably
- 10:16seeing the dollar signs, right, And also TLC is starting and transition more
- 10:20into reality TV in general. So you just got to wonder about the executive
- 10:26meetings at this point. Okay, so big event happens in two thousand and
- 10:30six, the police investigate Josh. This is a major thing that happens.
- 10:35Again, this is before they become big and household names in certain circles.
- 10:39There's still it's a still early, early, early, you know. That's
- 10:43that's the emphasis is Like the controversy that would eventually plague the Duggers was you
- 10:50know, kind of completed before they even had their own series. You know,
- 10:54they've only had three special at this point, and the fact that TLC
- 10:58and others just forged ahead, including the family, because you've got to think,
- 11:01if you're a family, it's like, yeah, maybe we should just
- 11:03avoid the limelight for a while because eventually it's going to come out. But
- 11:07anyway, TLC must have heard by that point, like, right, they
- 11:11had to have information. It'd be dumb if they didn't have at least someone
- 11:15who was looking into this sort of thing. But but I don't know.
- 11:18It's I could also see a situation where TLC, because you know, these
- 11:22reality TV producers they are on a string budget. You know, they don't
- 11:28that's why they have reality TV. It's because they don't want to spend money
- 11:31on a regular TV show. So it's possible that they just literally don't have
- 11:37the person power paid for to even bother looking into these things. But anyway,
- 11:43so Berto, do you remember a few chapters ago when I told you
- 11:48to remember the letter? Yes, I was so curious. I didn't look
- 11:50it up because I wanted to have the big reveal. Right, So why
- 11:56this was not in the documentary, I don't know. I mean this is
- 11:58a this is a big deal. Yeah, this letter is what starts the
- 12:03whole thing rolling. You know, the whole thing comes down to this letter.
- 12:09Okay, So to remind people, Josh tells his parents that he has
- 12:15been abusing the younger daughters in the family, and the parents don't know what
- 12:20to do, and they bring Josh to these family friends within the cult,
- 12:24Jim and Bobby Holt, which we've already been talking about, and they were
- 12:28supposed to be like spiritual leaders that are supposed to help Josh was actually sent
- 12:31to a facility within the cult or recommended to do that or something, and
- 12:39the church actually reviewed the situation, so the church dealt with it. Jim
- 12:43and Bobby Holt, I think a part of the cult where also and they
- 12:46were the parents of Kaylee, who was the young girl that you were mentioned
- 12:52earlier, where they were trying to get Josh to start to court a peer
- 12:58and move towards me marriage because they thought maybe that would fix Josh in and
- 13:01of itself. That's not ill conceived, you know. Earlier I was saying
- 13:05part of the treatment might actually be to help them have their needs met through
- 13:09a relation, you know, through pure relationships. But in the absence of
- 13:15all the other elements of the treatment, then it's not likely to get rid
- 13:18of the problem. And it didn't. But oh and by the way,
- 13:22also, you know, imagine you're a daughter, you know, and they're
- 13:26like, yeah, you should court this guy. He's awesome, he's great,
- 13:28he comes from this great family asterisk. Nope, not even an asterisk,
- 13:33Like, we don't know anything more about it. Yeah, and it's
- 13:37like, right, shouldn't she at least be informed? I mean, because
- 13:43she was blindsided, so so what and that feeling that you're identifying is what
- 13:46motivates the letter, I think. Anyway, So her name's Kaylee and is
- 13:52courting Josh. At this point, then the parents Jim, Bob and Michelle
- 13:56go with maybe they bring Josh I'm not sure, to Jim and Bobby Holt,
- 14:01and they inform Jim and Bobby Holt to their credit Jim Bob And it's
- 14:05really kind of hard to keep these names straight because you have Jim Bob and
- 14:07Michelle Doubler and then you have Jim and Bobby Holt. Anyway, so they
- 14:13go to Kayley's parents to say, hey, by the way, Josh has
- 14:16this problem, you know, so good on them. They could have swept
- 14:18out another rug and continued with the courting process with Kaylee, but they tell
- 14:22Jim and Bobby Holt. Kaylee either is in the room hearing this or overhears
- 14:28it and is alarmed, as you're saying, like, wait, what this
- 14:31guy that I was being groomed to, Mary has this problem? Yikes.
- 14:37And so she doesn't know what to do because she is in a cult,
- 14:41and I think she's in the cult, and she's isolated, so she doesn't
- 14:45know who to talk to, right, which would be normally even if you
- 14:48weren't in a cult. I think that would be a pretty scary situation.
- 14:52And so she writes this letter. Kaylee writes this letter, and she's going
- 14:56to send it to an author that she reads books of, probably within the
- 15:00cultime thinking or at least fundamentalist Christian author And at the last minute she decides
- 15:05against sending the letter, and she folds up the letter, puts it in
- 15:09this random book and it goes in the family library. Well, that was
- 15:15a couple of years earlier to this, in two thousand, So now we're
- 15:18at two thousand and six and the family lent the book to someone within the
- 15:24church on Accedent way. Dude, Yeah, they just lent the Well,
- 15:28I don't think the parents knew the letter was there, No, of course
- 15:31not. They're just lent the book. But what a crazy like. I'm
- 15:35sure they weren't lending all their books out left and right. That's so crazy.
- 15:39Yeah. Why this wasn't in the documentary, I don't know. I
- 15:43mean, it's such an interesting story. I mean, the whole scenario is
- 15:46horrific, but as part of it, this bit is like the kind of
- 15:50thing you'd want to see in a movie. This is what you would put
- 15:52in a fictional depiction or something like this. It has so much drama.
- 15:56So apparently that person finds the letter, reads it, and I think that
- 16:03person either told someone or went straight to the church and told people in the
- 16:07church, and then the information starts spreading through their church, which is in
- 16:12the IBLP cult by the way. But still not everyone in this cult is
- 16:18completely brainwashed into the situation. Some people were, well, regardless of what
- 16:27group of people you're going to inform them about something like this, you're gonna
- 16:32see a similar breakdown in my anecdotal experience, and that some people blamed Kayley
- 16:37for being a gossip, like, how dare she Oh my gosh, dude,
- 16:41that's horrible, you know, how dare she talk about this? This
- 16:45is a private matter. It's all Cayley's fault. Some people defended the dog,
- 16:49the Duggers and Josh, you know, hey, you know, kids
- 16:52do things sometimes or whatever. But some people were very alarmed by Josh's abuse
- 16:57of the younger kids, even though they're in this cult. They're just like,
- 17:00well, wait, what's going on? You know? There were some
- 17:03people that were more relatable, shall we say, And and I think someone
- 17:10at the church actually decided to take action. And again, who was that
- 17:15person because the rest of this would never have happened if it wasn't for that
- 17:19person. Now, it could have been the person who read the letter to
- 17:23begin with, or it could have been someone that who knows. But someone
- 17:27in the church called two different people. Number one, they called the Arkansas
- 17:33Child Abuse hotline. Finally, oh my god, years in the making,
- 17:38that call, yes, and provided an anonymous report but identified Josh Dugger.
- 17:45Right. And also so because the Duggers were on their rise and fame and
- 17:52they were really starting to hit their stride with us. They don't have their
- 17:56series yet, but you know, they're they're really starting to be famous and
- 18:00tabloidy that Oprah actually invited the Duggers to come on the come on the show.
- 18:06This is the part I did know that they were gonna be on Oprah
- 18:07and someone tipto Oprah off or her team. Yeah, so this church member
- 18:12knew about this apparently and actually called Oprah, called the production team the show
- 18:19and informed about you know what was in this letter, And the show received
- 18:26this anonymous email or letter or something outlining the abuse that Josh had committed,
- 18:33and the email warned the Oprah Show to not have the Duggers on their show,
- 18:37and apparently the Oprah team, uh, you know, obliged and canceled
- 18:44the family's scheduled appearance. Now, by the way I found it, one
- 18:48thing I found odd was like how did they know? I'm glad they did,
- 18:51but how did they know that they were going to be on Oprah?
- 18:52I wondered if like they had announced it at the church or something like,
- 18:56hey, the Duggers are coming to Oprah or something, right, good point
- 19:00it probably because it's not like Oprah at the beginning of the month says here's
- 19:03our schedule, right, Yeah, because they hadn't even appeared yet. It's
- 19:07not like because usually you would record it. And yeah, I bet you
- 19:10it was the duggers themselves that shot themselves in the foot on that one.
- 19:15And then they the Oprah team forwarded the email, so not only did they
- 19:21cancel the appearance, but they also just forwarded the email to the Department of
- 19:26Human Services hotline, which is probably a similar system as the child abuse hot
- 19:30line would be in and presumably the hot line then called the police, but
- 19:36someone someone eventually calls the police, but it was probably one of these hot
- 19:38lines. So this is what should have happened from the beginning, right,
- 19:44right, that a proper investigation to protect the children, a proper investigation to
- 19:49help set up Josh with proper treatment. But so so now two thousand and
- 19:55six, before they have a series, by the way, they get this
- 20:00opportunity. Do we remember how old Josh was when I first started coming out
- 20:04to his family and things like that, that this was happening, Because I
- 20:07mean, think of all those years lost and all the abuse that happened in
- 20:11the subsequent years, and oh Josh was fourteen fourteen, Oh my gosh,
- 20:18like you could have intervened into a fourteen year old's life, which is so
- 20:22much more malleable at that point. Yeah, an adult. So now in
- 20:26two thousand and six, he's eighteen. He's eighteen at this point, and
- 20:32yeah, so and not to mention all the abuse that could have been,
- 20:36you know, potentially stopped, you know. Yeah, I mean, that's
- 20:37the main thing is that's always number one. And I went over this in
- 20:41a previous chapter that when I'm involved in cases like this, the number one
- 20:45immediate priority is to protect victims. So if that means taking Josh out of
- 20:52the house, and that's what it means, if it means literally putting him
- 20:56in a side of the house, because I've done this sort of work where
- 21:00you actually will, like if I was with one family at one time where
- 21:04this had happened. The older sibling had sexually abused the younger sibling, and
- 21:08we tried to figure out a solution to protect the younger child. Best case
- 21:14scenario, the old child would go stay with a relative that doesn't live with
- 21:17any miners. But that wasn't possible, so we had the children had to
- 21:22stay on a floor of the house, so the older kid could only be
- 21:27on one of the floors and the younger kid could only be on one of
- 21:32the other floors, and there was a door there, and the parents were
- 21:33always monitoring it. They were always home that kind of thing. So that's
- 21:37number one, And that obviously was not done, or at least seemingly not
- 21:42done. I think there were reports that maybe the parents did some things,
- 21:45but I doubt that it was robust enough to really protect the younger kids.
- 21:51Anyway, So the hotline calls the police, The police investigate the family.
- 21:56The police interviewed the five victims, the four sisters and the babysitter. But
- 22:02since there's a three year statute of limitations, Burrow, no fucking charges.
- 22:10Three years? Yes? What, Yes, it's fucking ridiculous. I mean,
- 22:18I get why a statue of limitations exists, but is this for miners?
- 22:22Is that why? It's like, what do you mean? I mean,
- 22:23is it three years if you're a miner? Like, it can't be
- 22:26three years in general? Right? It might be, but every state has
- 22:30a different statute around these. I mean, I don't know how they coincide,
- 22:34but but it's a well understood problem that you know, with regular sorts
- 22:40of crimes, like if someone murders someone or if someone you know steals your
- 22:44car, then it's very likely that you're going to report it pretty quickly.
- 22:48And the statue of limitations. It's not super intuitive to me as to why
- 22:52it's a good thing, but I've heard experts explain it to me as to
- 22:56why it's a good thing. Like the person who committed the crime, they've
- 23:00they've moved on with their life, they've changed their ways, and then all
- 23:03of a sudden, like fifteen years later, boom, they go to prison.
- 23:06It doesn't make a lot of sense in that way. Well, for
- 23:08some things though, like murder, there isn't a limit because sorry that you
- 23:14did eventually stop murdering, but you did take a life, and I think
- 23:17that so maybe we don't have to have no statute of limitations. But three
- 23:22years. But particularly it was sexual abuse because it's well understood and documented that
- 23:27when people are abused, they don't report it. You know, like I
- 23:32said, when someone's murdered or when someone is steals your car, there's not
- 23:37a barrier to reporting it. If it's worth reporting, you're going to report
- 23:41it. But you know, in general, but with sexual abuse, everyone
- 23:45understands, particularly if you're a child at the time. The chance of a
- 23:48three year old reporting to anyone that they were sexually abused is you know,
- 23:52pretty much zero. And so this notion that somehow the same statute of limitations
- 23:57or time spans apply to these kinds of crimes is really stupid, particularly when
- 24:03the law is set up presumably in part to protect the public, and a
- 24:07major component of protecting the public from a criminal is to identify them and indict
- 24:15them and put sanctions on them, maybe prison time or maybe mandated treatment,
- 24:19so no one wins when including the perpetrator who might need to be forced in
- 24:26treatment. When we have these now it's changing. There are similar to domestic
- 24:32violence. There's a partner violence. There are problems with this right because victims
- 24:37are terrified. Sorry, and by the way, like they all or nothing.
- 24:41Part is also kind of silly, like, Okay, what if you
- 24:44do have a statute of limitations for having someone go to jail, but like
- 24:47can't they still be mandated treatment or something, you know, like a range
- 24:51of options over time. And the other thing is where all of the crimes
- 24:55older than three years or we just don't know because like that's all they knew
- 24:59about, right, I believe. I mean, so that's a huge ambiguity
- 25:03here is did Josh continue to abuse? There's no evidence of that. There's
- 25:07no reports of that. And I could see a world in which he did
- 25:11manage to suppress it, or it morphed into the child porn area which he
- 25:18gets into later. Hard to know. Is it possible that he continued to
- 25:22abuse his younger siblings? Yeah, there were very little measures taken that would
- 25:27assure that that wouldn't happen, right, But we don't know. We definitely
- 25:32know what happened for a span of time prior to fourteen, or you know,
- 25:36around the time he was fourteen, and once he made the reports.
- 25:40I haven't heard any reports of anything happening beyond that. But anyway, let's
- 25:44take a break. What do you say, bro, Let's do it all
- 25:51right, we're back from the break. So getting back to my notes here.
- 25:53Yeah, so apparently even though the police were contacted, nothing happened.
- 25:59I don't know if CPS was called and CPS just dropped the ball, or
- 26:03CPS did investigate. I didn't hear anything about that. I could imagine a
- 26:08situation in which the police didn't bother calling Child Protective Services I don't know,
- 26:14but there's no report of the CPS Child Protective Services getting involved. The police
- 26:18can do some things, but really who you want involved are ongoing caseworkers that
- 26:25are trained in this area. And I didn't hear any reports of that happening.
- 26:30And that's what I was saying, like, Okay, so let's say
- 26:32that they have the stupid three year statute of limitations. Okay, fine,
- 26:36so then don't press charges, but call CPS, like, do something that
- 26:41maybe can still help the family and the victims and the perpetrator even if fine,
- 26:45you're not going to press the criminal charges, right, And I'm glad
- 26:49to bring that up, because that is different. CPS is a different process,
- 26:53and there are different laws that dictate the CPS's actions, and there is
- 26:59no statue limitations to CPS and the laws that allow for them to take action.
- 27:03So you could tell CPS that your father, for example, abused you
- 27:11thirty five years ago, and if your father, who's now, say seven
- 27:15years old, is still in contact with children, then CPS and all likelihood
- 27:21will take action to protect the children, even though the report was made thirty
- 27:26five years later. So you know, I don't know, but I didn't
- 27:30hear any evidence that that had happened. So the details of the police report,
- 27:34the investigation that happened in two thousand and six were apparently leaked leaked to
- 27:40the internet, maybe someone on the Oprah Show, but who knows, someone
- 27:45leaked it, and message boards started to speculate about this police report or the
- 27:51details of it, and these message forums would grow as the Duggers gained more
- 27:56fame, but they were very it was a very small group of people who
- 28:00were mostly being ignored as the Duggers because because that's what's so weird about That's
- 28:07why I think it's important to go over the timeline is that everything was available
- 28:11from the beginning. Yeah, before the Duggers became even to TLC. You
- 28:15could argue, right, right, that's what's incredible. Right. It's one
- 28:19thing if you're I don't know, Michael Jackson or something and you become super
- 28:23famous and then the reports start coming out or Bill Cosby and then the report,
- 28:29But the reports were out there and available on the Internet before they started
- 28:34to have their major fame with their own series. That's one of the things
- 28:37that that blew my mind the most about the story was that I what little
- 28:42I knew. I had assumed it was like, yeah, all more recent
- 28:45or after the fact or whatever, and it was just like, wait,
- 28:48what has already happened? Like they knew this? Yeah, and that's that's
- 28:52There's another part of this story that I think the documentary doesn't emphasize enough of
- 28:57is at this point in two thousand and six, you have hundreds of people
- 29:03that are aware of what Josh did. You have the parents and maybe some
- 29:10of the siblings. You have Jim and Bobby Hoole. You have Kayleie.
- 29:12You have several church members, if not all of them, who knows how
- 29:18far this rumor went. You have people on the Oprah team, maybe Oprah
- 29:22herself. I mean literally, it's possible that Oprah Winfrey knew that Josh had
- 29:27abused the younger siblings. You have this other hot line that knows about it.
- 29:33You have this cop that will later go to prison for child porn himself.
- 29:37You have church members that are I think you know, upper admin sort
- 29:42of church members that Jim and Michelle went to initially. You have the police
- 29:49precinct that investigated this. There's probably a number of detectives. Think about all
- 29:56the people that know about someone who is at risk clearly of sexually abusing.
- 30:04I think Josh at this point probably has like ten younger siblings that are that
- 30:10are girls. I mean, and who knows it's you know, these these
- 30:12kind of people will abuse boys, dude, all the children that Josh is
- 30:15around, and in an insular situation where all the kids are being homeschooled for
- 30:21Christ's sake, I mean, you know, the kids are are imprisoned with
- 30:26this, with this known predator that had been that's been predating on the siblings
- 30:33for years prior to the age of fourteen, and nothing happened. Berto,
- 30:40I mean, you can't, like, you can't ask for a worst situation
- 30:42too, Like, you know, if you have a wolf and sheep,
- 30:45it's like the wolves living with the sheep. The wolf's already eaten several of
- 30:48the sheep and there they are. No one's doing anything about it. Yeah,
- 30:52just a complete breakdown of everything that is not supposed to break down.
- 30:56I mean, at least one of these systems, the police at this point,
- 31:00point, the CPS getting involved, I don't even know if they were
- 31:03all before the show. Yes, Like that's mind blowing. Ah. And
- 31:08I bring all this up because there are a lot of people who have been
- 31:12through this as victims or family members or something. And there's this myth out
- 31:18there that if you call the authorities, then everything will be you know,
- 31:23you just have to get the authorities involved and then everything will be fine.
- 31:29And I know some of you listening will know that that's ridiculous, but I
- 31:33was disabused of this assumption early in my career. When I was I might
- 31:37have even still been an intern, but I think I might have been just
- 31:41hired, so I would have been twenty six, twenty seven, early career,
- 31:44and I had this teenage girl who told me that she was being sexually
- 31:48abused by her father, and I she was hinting that she wanted to tell
- 31:52me something, and so I had to really work hard at making her feel
- 31:56comfortable and telling her, now, you know, I'm here for you,
- 32:00and you know, I'm saying all these things like I can help you with
- 32:02this, but I can't help you unless you tell me so what's going on.
- 32:06And then, you know, several sessions and she finally tells me that
- 32:09she's being sexually abused by her father, and you know, and I'm just
- 32:14you know, it's hard to hear, but I'm there for her, and
- 32:16I'm just like, you did the right thing. You know, good job.
- 32:20You know, I commend you advocating for yourself. And the system is
- 32:24here. At this point, I'm naive, so you know, the system
- 32:28is here to help you. You know, that's why it existed. And
- 32:30so we call CPS, and CPS gets involved, and I'm like, yeah,
- 32:35you know, da da da, And they go into the home.
- 32:37They interview her, they interview the dad, and long story short, they
- 32:42do nothing. Man, nothing happens except for now the dad knows that she
- 32:49is now the daughter is now telling people, and God knows what. You
- 32:52know, it was a long time agot to remember how it sort of resolved.
- 32:55But was she even allowed to keep going to therapy? I don't know.
- 33:00It was long twenty you know, it's almost thirty years ago, but
- 33:04I don't remember it resolving well, I don't remember resolving horrifically. But I
- 33:08imagine I didn't have much time left with her after that. I don't know,
- 33:13but that was when I learned, oh wait, so it's not the
- 33:16way that people talk about it, and it's not even the way that CPS
- 33:21talks about it. Because you talked to CPS, and they'll they'll say this
- 33:22that I will say, overall, CPS workers, and the system does often
- 33:28work. I think what happened in this case was the allegation of sexual abuse,
- 33:32and it was clearly sexual abuse was not at the level that is severe
- 33:38enough for CPS to really fly into action, and I think they said,
- 33:44well, let's work with the dad, and the overall message to the daughter
- 33:49was well, I'm still left on the lurch living with this guy, you
- 33:52know what I mean. So it's it's pretty awful. And but even if
- 33:58we say well, most of the time CPS works, you have all these
- 34:00other systems that are involved, at least in this Josh situation. You have
- 34:05the police, you have church, you have parents, you have community and
- 34:08the Internet. And yet the victims are still being victimized because we have a
- 34:15society that doesn't recognize how important this is, or at least they kind of
- 34:17do, but they don't want to do the hard work to actually fund these
- 34:22kinds of you know, programs, I mean, you know, hope we
- 34:25could go down this road of just this sort of people like the Duggers that
- 34:30vote for politicians like the Duggers, you know, they want to dismantle all
- 34:35sorts of systems, including the kinds of funded systems, that would be able
- 34:38to help situations like this, because clearly the church and the community and sometimes
- 34:43even the police don't do fucking shit. So if you give cps enough money
- 34:47and give them enough power, and you don't hinder them through stripping away regulations
- 34:53and that and power for these institutions, then you're much more likely to see
- 35:00protected children instead of believing in QAnon and Tom Hanks is drinking the blood.
- 35:04I mean literally, that's what people believe. Yeah, that that is.
- 35:07That is one of the biggest ironies is the obsession in the last few years
- 35:10about child abuse. Which great, let's have that conversation. Let's go after
- 35:15the actual promises. Let's put up some money. How about we put up
- 35:20some tax funds. Oh, we don't want to tax people. Oh I
- 35:23see. But here here's the other thing too. The I honestly feel like
- 35:29as a system that cult, but you know, in general, like they're
- 35:31there there, they're the cult, they were a part of. Uh.
- 35:36It's more important to keep the system going than individuals suffering. So if you
- 35:39have to have some sacrifices, and I don't mean like I don't even mean
- 35:43this, Like like they were like, ha ha, well they shall suffer,
- 35:45but well no, I think it's it's kind of like how corporations with
- 35:50with stockholders in Wall Street, they'll do some pretty evil stuff and a lot
- 35:52of times the people involved either are not meaning for it to be able or
- 35:55whatever. They're just like, hey, we need to make more money for
- 35:58the stockholders. So fine, and I guess take the factory to that place
- 36:00that's more unethical. Here, it's like I feel like it's similar where like,
- 36:05look, the big thing is we need to keep our system going,
- 36:08make sure we spread it, make sure we have more power these problems.
- 36:12Yeah, it's unfortunate, but you know, like that's not as big a
- 36:15deal. Right. Stuff happens, right, You can reduce it to the
- 36:19following flow chart. Does taking action and actually trying to protect the younger children
- 36:24and really seeking help from treatment specials, you know, does addressing the problem
- 36:30in reality? Does it actually further the power of this cult and the people
- 36:37in power or not? And the answer is no, to actually take action
- 36:43and to actually address it, you threaten the cult. You threaten the administration
- 36:47because especially in this situation, because they were aware of it years prior to
- 36:52this. Yeah, and it doesn't serve them. I mean, at the
- 36:55very least, even if they don't think a bad thing will happen to them.
- 36:59There's nothing good to the organization in terms of power and money that that
- 37:04could come from even spending the resources to really try to address this. Right,
- 37:08But it goes against the core messaging like you follow these rules, everything's
- 37:13fine, Like you follow the chain of command? You followed what was the
- 37:16name? They get like you're fine, the umbrellas, right, like umbrellas,
- 37:20Yeah, you're okay. So this goes against all of that, right,
- 37:23what do you mean? This can still happen. In fact, it
- 37:25can happen and get covered up like what right? Right? Yeah? Yeah,
- 37:30And I guess as maybe an ancillary thing is it's potentially an indictment on
- 37:36having so many kids because there's less supervision and there's explicit messages to the older
- 37:42kids that they have to take care of the younger kids. So it could
- 37:44undermine that whole system, right, the older Wait, so the older kids
- 37:47aren't responsible enough to take care of the younger you know anyway, so around
- 37:52this time, you know, so just the whole to wrap this up.
- 37:55Nothing happens, Oprah wind Freeze team finds out about it. You know that
- 38:00that letter. But the one thing that happens is the Internet now knows which
- 38:07that grows over time. This same year, two thousand and six, Jim
- 38:10Bob sought the Republican nomination for the Arkansas State Senate and he lost again.
- 38:15He has lost a number of political runs, you know, for federal Senate,
- 38:22this sort of thing. But with that burto let's go to two thousand
- 38:25and seven. But the rest of this episode is just going to be for
- 38:28patrons of the podcast. So if you want to hear the rest of this
- 38:30discussion, become a patron, go to patreon dot com. Otherwise, everyone,
- 38:35please take care of yourself because you deserve it.