Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Negative Equity Hits 25% of Trades, Used Car Crunch, Retention Wins
Transcript
- 0:00[gentle music] Monday, February 17th, New York is in a slow snow globe.
- 0:04Our tech didn't wanna work, but we're here, we're ready to go, talking about negati- negative equity, used cars, and some crazy retention story that I had never heard of before. Everywhere I go.
- 0:14But our friend Jim Cohen, uh- Who I am and who I ain't... sent us this little article this morning. These cops just witness and see me. Good night. If it's anyone still need to be me. Good night.
- 0:20Run up on me, watch you see and believe me How, so, so, like- Well- I was tell, telling some of my Syracuse, uh, folks that remember, just because you live in a snow globe, like most other people have a normal day today.
- 0:33Yeah. Remember, there is a sun in the sky. Send us, send pictures please. [laughs] Send pictures. Oh, sorry for you, man. Yeah, like, literally I said to Paul this morning, we, it was like an email thread- [laughs]...
- 0:46and a text thread, and on all of them Paul was, like, bemoaning the, the, the weather situation that he's in. Which? [laughs] Which? Grant it, I'm in Nashville. It is sunny.
- 0:56It rained for a straight week, but it is 23 degrees out here in Nashville. Okay. Well, you know what? So, you know, it's, you know, you got- Sunny and 20.
- 1:04I'm gonna, I wish I had an easy way to just enter the show through my phone and I would just look out my window.
- 1:09[laughs] And the, I mean, you know it's time when an incurable optimist such as myself is like, "Yeah, I think I'm done." [laughs] "I think I'm done with the winter. I think it's over."
- 1:21Hey, remember- On the bright side- Like, if you're watching the video, look at this. See this? Black on black, love people more. You mean this black on black love people more? This- It's a total vibe... looks good.
- 1:30So you can get this black on black shirt at shop.asotu.com. So if you ever, like, like one of the vibes that we're wearing- Yes you can... on the show, you can just go to shop.asotu.com.
- 1:40Well, now that you mention it, I'm wearing the, the- Your-... NADA special... knobs. Yeah It's the gold and the white. And, uh, somebody actually reached out and was like, "Hey, where's that on the shop?"
- 1:50And I was like, "You texted me. Like, that's fine. Just order it and I will send you these 'cause we have these, it's just not on the shop." So we have these two. We have these two. Okay. Man. And I know. I know.
- 2:00Uh, there's a bright spot to this whole story. All right. Gi- And when I was in Costco yesterday, they had patio furniture- [laughs]... life vests, hose reels- [laughs]... sun, sun umbrellas.
- 2:14[laughs] But it's really the equivalent- So, so, so wha-... of Christmas trees in October, though.
- 2:19[laughs] I packed a few up, sat down in one, grabbed a drink from the drink cooler, and just started sipping it like I was in Florida.
- 2:26I went over to the electronics department and put on some Apple Vision Pros and I said, "Take me to another place." [laughs] That's amazing. That's amazing. Uh- Hey, Paul, we got a whole bunch of content flowing out.
- 2:38Uh, if you haven't been to the, our Auto Collabs podcast, you should check out, we got Aaron Keating of Cox Automotive, uh, with some bold product, pro- predictions.
- 2:47We've got an NADA show session that is releasing, uh, Jennifer Vianello of Cars Commerce- Yes... on why marketplaces still mattered. Uh, so that's, that's another one.
- 2:57So you can go to Auto Collabs podcast, NADA show sessions. And then also if you go to asotu.com, scroll down just a wee bit, you can register for our Quickshot 30-minute Edge webinar. Webinar time. There we go.
- 3:08This Wednesday. They're back. It's our first webinar of the new year here after NADA's kinda cleared the air. It's gonna be at 2:00 PM Eastern on Wednesday.
- 3:17Make sure you register, 'cause if you register but you can't make it 'cause there's another meeting or you got a customer in the showroom, you can watch it back. We'll send you the replay. Yeah. So.
- 3:25And the- these are so, it's so great that we're firing these back up. I think our webinars are already booked and sold out through, like, midway past the year because- Yep...
- 3:33industry partners love these because the dealers love these. [laughs] It's funny how that works together. And we get a lot of information across in 30 minutes, have some great attendance, uh, learn a lot of great things.
- 3:43And, uh, oh, Brian Ortega is in the chat. He says, "To match my gold Nikes." There you go. He is the one. Oh.
- 3:48I didn't wanna bl- I didn't wanna blow up his spot, but yeah, he's the one that ordered the, uh, the gold and white. That's cool. You gotta, gotta match. You gotta get the fit.
- 3:54We're, we're, we're all the way in planning to ASOTU CON. We're under 90 days. And, uh, we're working on what swag items will be at ASOTU CON this year. Eh.
- 4:01We're working on the scarf des- actually, the scarf design is out. I w- oh, we'll, we'll show it on the show tomorrow morning. Can't wait. Uh, I posted it on my LinkedIn. Um, yeah. A lot of great things going on.
- 4:11But if you haven't gotten your tickets, they are being sold. They are filling up. The hotel is booking up. If you have been hearing about it and wanna go, this is your year. asotucon.com. Join us. Okay.
- 4:22All right, let's talk about stories. Okay, so today's stories, when, when we were building the show I'm like, "Man, I hate to start with two, like, negative stories to start the day," but they're not negative stories.
- 4:30They're not problems. They're challenges. And we kind of end with a little silver lining story. Not like there's patio furniture in Costco silver lining, like a real one. It's not that good.
- 4:39[laughs] Yeah, it's not that bad. That's just a desperate hope, you know, sit- [laughs] the picture of me sitting in that with Apple Vision Pros eating the Costco $1.50 hotdog combo. [laughs] Make that. Oh my goodness.
- 4:53I think we need to make that happen. I'm actually going again this afternoon just to get... I, I think I'll be the only one on the road today. All right, let's talk about it. And Costco will be open.
- 5:00All right, let's get to some news. The average negative equity on new vehicle trade-ins reached a record high in Q4 2024, increasing by- Wow... nearly $800 compared to the previous year.
- 5:12According to Edmunds, the average amount owed on underwater trade-ins was 6,838 in Q4- [whistles]... up from 6,054 in Q3. Wow, $800 in just one quarter.
- 5:24While 25% of trade-ins have negative equity, this is up from 20% a year ago. It did remain lower than the all-time high, which was 33% in Q4- Oof... of 2019.
- 5:36Edmunds reported that 25% of negative e- negative equity trade-ins had at least $10,000 rolled over. That is a- Oh my goodness...
- 5:46um, Mark Pregman, general manager of consumer lending at USAA, stated, "The concern is not the frequency, it's the severity of negative- Right... equity amounts."
- 5:55And Eric Lane, CEO of G- uh, Jerry Lane Enterprises, said his dealership group avoided selling new vehicles above sticker during the inventory shortage, which has helped its customers face less negative equity than those at other dealerships.
- 6:09He says, quote, "It's really kind of, it really kind of plays, I think, to our favor not to have gouged people."Yeah.
- 6:16The, that, I, I think that that's gonna be a separator over the next, like, 12 months when people are really looking to acquire quality used car inventory, and looking to their service lane, looking to their consumer base over that three to four-year timeline, 'cause we're starting to get to that.
- 6:29We're starting to get to the trade-in timeline of early pandemic. That was 2021.
- 6:33So think about, like, all of those vehicles are coming back in on trade from inventory shortages and high profit margins, and we're gonna start to...
- 6:42I think this is a, like, this is a precursor to the ramp-up of what's actually gonna happen. But we're talking a $10 a month payment swing right there. Um, like, it's, it's coming quick, right?
- 6:55These, these payment swings, the negative equity, the, the issues for lenders.
- 7:00Like, you, you, you see, like, how are you gonna cover up that much negative equity unless you have significant amount of rebates and incentives?
- 7:07So also, I would say watch out for some of the manufacturers that have higher inventory, uh, supplies that are pushing in incentives to start to capture some of that, uh- Okay... negative equity,
- 7:20um, and g- and get those consumers to their brand solely because of the rebates. So education early on in the consumer shopping journey, highly necessary right now. Well, while we're speaking of used cars- Stop.
- 7:31Still- Segway. Time... another dynamic coming into play. Lots on used cars.
- 7:35Well, the combination of pandemic era supply chain dis- disruptions, fewer lease returns, and rising interest rates has created a long-term supply squeeze on used cars.
- 7:45Analysts predicting these conditions will persist for at least two more years, keeping the used car market competitive- Wow... and expensive. Used car prices increased 2.2% from December, while January...
- 7:56While, while new car prices remained flat, um, the number of three-year leases ending in 2024 is expected to drop 23%, reaching- [whistles]... a decade low.
- 8:06Back to your point of saying this is, like, the leading edge of these high, high, uh, high, highly underwater vehicles coming in, uh, reducing the supply of off-lease vehicles.
- 8:15Typically, we know the major supply of used car inventory. Used car prices are still high. Financing costs are still high. Many car owners are opting to keep and repair their current vehicles rather than upgrading.
- 8:28Here's a quote from, uh, Tom Aiello, owner of Celebrity Motor Car, says, quote, "They're spending more money on repairs, but their monthly payments are less."
- 8:35New car supply has increased, uh, improved to 63 days overall, while used car supply has tightened to 48 days. Wow. Here's a quote from, um, Group One Automotive.
- 8:46Uh, one of their VPs, Pete Delongchamps, says, quote, "We would much rather overpay for a trade with a current customer that we do business with every day." So a little bit of their solution.
- 8:55Yeah, I, I think in, uh, you know, kind of in relationship but also the antithesis to the first story is, hey, if used car supply stays this tight and we continue to see a decreasing day supply, then you start to get higher used car values back into the market.
- 9:15And so you could counterbalance some of this negative equity potentially in the market with higher used car, uh, uh, higher used car prices.
- 9:24And because we're seeing a new car supply that is increasing in day supply, you're gonna start to see those rebates. So there could be a balancing act that consumers start to get from all of this.
- 9:36Um, but still, still kind of yet to be determined.
- 9:39And, um, the, the third balancing act piece that we still don't know exactly what's gonna happen, but the Fed has already said they're gonna get aggressive, is interest rates.
- 9:47So rate buydowns and the, and the potential for people to keep quality payments should be good.
- 9:51So I think all of it's gonna balance out, but it's still a lot of education for those 25% that are seeing those high negative equity numbers. We got a comment here from Dave the Wave on YouTube.
- 10:01"294,000 miles on my Expedition, and almost every dealer I ask, I visit asks about the vehicle and rarely do they talk to me about buying a replacement." Ah.
- 10:12Hey, it's- They're just like, "Oh, I guess you're gonna keep on that." Absolutely. [laughs] That's like my Land Cruiser, right? 277,000 miles on it.
- 10:18Listen, um, I think the service conversation in here is one that we had several years ago. Mm. Yeah.
- 10:23However, if people are in this mindset to repair it, it's a great time to start, uh, putting out material, educating, creating content around, uh, what it takes to help your 100,000 mile car last to 200,000 miles or your...
- 10:36I mean- Yep... in some cases, right, people are turning in a lease so they have, like, 30, 40,000 miles. So what is it to keep that? You know, ownership expenses.
- 10:42So, you know, people are gonna make the decisions they make, but you definitely wanna continue to own that customer. Uh, speaking of owning the customer. Stop. This is an awesome- Oh... awesome story.
- 10:51[upbeat music] You may know the name Damian Lillard, but you may not know Damian Lillard Toyota in McMinnville, Oregon, uh, and its dealer principal, Brian Sanders, have been building a business model focused entirely on customer retention.
- 11:07Uh, since, uh, uh, he took over the store in 2020, he's led it to be the highest Toyota loyalty engagement percentage in the country, proving that prioritizing long-term relationships can drive success.
- 11:19Uh, Sanders said the, that, "They don't need to maximize every deal. We maximize every customer." They've been betting on customer loyalty to generate a long-term value.
- 11:30In 2019, the score, store sold 351 new Toyotas with a 63% sales efficiency. Get this: by 2023, 2024, sales soared fif- past 1,500 units- That's a big increase... with efficiency reaching
- 11:43220% sales efficiency- [laughs]... well beyond, obviously, industry norms. You see some people getting to that 100, 120.
- 11:51Um, the dealership only sells vehicles taken in on trade for used cars, skipping auctions to ensure quality and customer satisfaction. Here's the, here's the one that I think is, like, a big payoff.
- 12:01I mean, that one seem... I don't know if it's pa- Yeah... that seems crazy. But- The trade-in only, but yeah. Employees are mostly salaried. They work 40-hour work weeks.
- 12:09They get Adidas gear upon, uh, hire, and h- there's a massive low turnover. Um, so you look at, like-Hey, if your employees will stick around, your customers are probably stick- sticking around too.
- 12:22They've got an outdoor basketball court. They got obviously NADA memorabilia because, uh, Damian Lillard. Yep. Um, and a low pressure sales atmosphere. Yeah. Good stuff. So, I mean, I think...
- 12:36Okay, so I think when people see this, a lot of people will say, "Well, that's a one-off and that is a unique... I could never make my store, like migrate it to that," right? Mm. 'Cause it's kind of an extreme, right?
- 12:48You start to think of all these extreme things. But I think it's important not to just write off the whole thing because your store's model and how you do things couldn't fit into that model.
- 12:57I think the important thing is to realize, like well, what are the things that I can carry over into my store?
- 13:03And whether that's workflow, maybe it's their trade approach, maybe it's their website, maybe it's, you know, it's there's something in there to learn.
- 13:10I love the fact that this industry, even though it is so standardized, there are so many ways to play within the rules and color within the lines still and create something that no one else has created.
- 13:22I didn't know about this. Yep. You and I hear about so much stuff. And did you ev- had you ever heard about this, this store?
- 13:28I knew that Damian Lillard had stores, but I didn't know about this store in particular, so really, really cool- I- it's pretty amazing... uh, story.
- 13:34And, and they just cut a lot of the fat out of the business or a lot of the things- Yep... that everybody does to, it be- makes it more and more and more complex, right?
- 13:42And like, including, like buying cars, cars off the cur- curb, buying cars from auction, right? That's a lifeblood, uh, thing for so many dealers across the country.
- 13:50But they said, "We're going for simplicity, and we're gonna go deep instead of going wide." And just an, an opportunity, um, or an example of people who did it, so- Yeah... we, we- Yeah. Hey, it's possible.
- 14:01It's out there, and I bet y- I bet you they'd be willing to tell their story so that you can do it too. I know. We're gonna have to reach out. Listen, whether you live in sunshine or snowy weather- Ah...
- 14:10the truth is everybody's getting out there. There's somebody to serve. There's somebody to take care of. There's a business opportunity to grow. We hope you go to asotocoton.com and grow with us.
- 14:21[upbeat music]