Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Recoverable Damages in the Context of Residential Real Estate Non-Disclosure & Construction Defect
Transcript
- 0:03All righty. Hello and welcome to recoverable
- 0:05damages in the context of residential real estate
- 0:08non -disclosure and construction defect cases.
- 0:11I am delighted to introduce our speaker, Robert
- 0:13Sunderland. Robert J. Sunderland is a full -time
- 0:16mediator with Signature Resolution, bringing
- 0:18more than 30 years of experience in real estate,
- 0:21law, and construction to his practice. Since
- 0:242003, he has mediated a wide range of disputes
- 0:27involving residential and commercial real estate,
- 0:30construction defects, professional liability,
- 0:32and brokerage matters. Before joining Signature
- 0:34Resolution, he was managing partner of Sunderland
- 0:37McCutcheon, where he represented real estate
- 0:39agents, brokers, mortgage, and escrow professionals,
- 0:42contractors, and suppliers. contractors in litigation,
- 0:45arbitration, and mediation throughout California,
- 0:48and more recently represented plaintiffs in real
- 0:50estate and construction matters as well. He has
- 0:53served as an expert witness in developer and
- 0:55construction defect litigation and as a special
- 0:58master drawing on his background as a licensed
- 1:00general contractor to assess causation and deliver
- 1:03forensic analysis and trial testimony. And now
- 1:06let's get started. Well, good afternoon, folks.
- 1:10Thank you for attending today. I look forward,
- 1:14certainly I have been looking forward to doing
- 1:15this this afternoon. So let's get into it. I'll
- 1:19tell you just briefly a little bit more about
- 1:21myself just to give a little more context in
- 1:24terms of my background. Another thing that I
- 1:27did earlier in my litigation career, I worked
- 1:31with a large managing general agent that brokered
- 1:35a lot of policies and I was involved in claims,
- 1:37risk management, underwriting and program administration.
- 1:41I share that simply to, you know, inform you
- 1:45a little bit about how I understand how these
- 1:47decision makers process these claims. when we're
- 1:51dealing with litigated matters. Because at the
- 1:53end of the day, we have a plaintiff, we have
- 1:56some defendants, and we're looking to resolve
- 1:57a case. We're trying to figure out where the
- 1:59money is and how we can get it. So it certainly
- 2:02helps to have an appreciation for the decision
- 2:04makers and what it is they need to see so that
- 2:08they can settle your matter. And so we're going
- 2:11to approach it kind of with that overview. And
- 2:14we're going to start pretty general. And then
- 2:17we'll delve into the actual formulation of damages
- 2:19and how you get there. Don't worry, we'll get
- 2:22to that. But I at least wanted to give you that
- 2:25brief preamble. I've also served as a discovery
- 2:29referee in various matters. And I think with
- 2:32that in mind, we'll start here on our first slide.
- 2:35And a lot of what we're talking about is what
- 2:38do you share, when do you share, and what does
- 2:41it mean? And what I mean by that is, A lot of
- 2:45people say, well, I don't want to give that much
- 2:46information. The classic example I see time and
- 2:50again in my mediations is I see the confidential
- 2:53brief. And I read this confidential brief and
- 2:56many times, none of it is really confidential.
- 2:59Everybody really knows it already or maybe a
- 3:03paragraph or two is confidential and the rest
- 3:05of it is not. And so we're going to talk about
- 3:08what's the benefit of withholding that information
- 3:11versus not withholding it. And I'm just going
- 3:14to tell you, I mean, we all know if we're going
- 3:16to resolve cases, we have to deal with an exchange
- 3:18of information. People need to appreciate what
- 3:21the damages are, what the risks are, and they're
- 3:24not going to do that without the information.
- 3:26So as I've oftentimes said, if I could patent
- 3:29a settlement machine, what would that patent
- 3:31require? Well, it would require or would have
- 3:34this machine where we'd put information in. The
- 3:37information would feed into the machine and the
- 3:39money would come out the other side. It's essentially
- 3:42the information is like the fuel that lets the
- 3:44motor turn over or the oil that lets the gears
- 3:47turn. Information equals action. Good information
- 3:51equals good action. Bad information equals less
- 3:55than good action. So we need to think about it
- 3:58that way. It's a little bit like AI. You know,
- 4:00you put a bunch of junk in there as the underlying
- 4:03information and you're going to get junk out.
- 4:05Garbage in, garbage out. Good information in,
- 4:07good action out. So it comes down to what are
- 4:10we willing to share? Next slide, please. We have
- 4:16to think about when we're sharing the information.
- 4:18what the metabolic rate is of our decision maker.
- 4:22Well, who am I talking about? In many ways, I'm
- 4:24talking about insurance claims professionals,
- 4:27the people that are underwriting this risk that
- 4:29are ensuring it. We have to think about how much
- 4:33time do they need to evaluate the information.
- 4:36If we're sharing a mediation brief the evening
- 4:39before a mediation with opposing counsel or maybe
- 4:43not sharing it at all, What does the insurance
- 4:46claims professional really know about your position?
- 4:49I guess they know what the attorneys reported
- 4:51up to date, but they haven't really seen it.
- 4:53They don't really know. And even if they get
- 4:56it the day before, two days before, what are
- 5:00they going to do with it? It's not the only file
- 5:02that they have. So I think it's important to
- 5:04consider how much information you share and doing
- 5:07it sooner than later. Because otherwise, what's
- 5:09going to happen is you're going to run into Various
- 5:12challenges. A classic example would be, okay,
- 5:15you're in the mediation. You've now shared the
- 5:17information. The mediators regurgitated big portions
- 5:21of the brief because the other side hasn't seen
- 5:23it. They spent a couple hours doing all of that.
- 5:26Claims professionals scratching their head. They're
- 5:28looking at it and they're saying, my gosh, looks
- 5:30to me like they want $250 ,000 or more. And my
- 5:36regional or my desk level of authority is $50
- 5:39,000. There's nothing they can do that day, even
- 5:42if they can get a hold of their superior. There's
- 5:44nothing they can do. They have to write a large
- 5:46loss report. It has to go up the food chain and
- 5:49then it has to come back. So that's just going
- 5:52to be the beginning of the discussion, the mediation
- 5:54as opposed to the end. So the question is, why
- 5:57don't we share the things earlier? I oftentimes
- 6:00say, you know, mediation by ambush isn't really
- 6:02mediation. It's just the beginning of a somewhat
- 6:06counterproductive discussion that delays things.
- 6:10The more you share, the sooner you share it,
- 6:13the better off you're going to be. Think about
- 6:20the brief when you're writing it. Of course,
- 6:22we all know the brief is for the mediator, but
- 6:25in many ways, it's also really for opposing counsel.
- 6:28It's for the parties that may see it, and it's
- 6:30for the carriers that may see it as well. I will
- 6:33tell you, when I was litigating, if I received
- 6:36a very well written brief that was really spot
- 6:39on, I may disagree with a little bit of the analysis
- 6:41and I knew there was some posturing in there,
- 6:43but I felt that they had a very good argument
- 6:46in there and quite frankly, it may have been
- 6:48echoing what I had been reporting along the way.
- 6:51That was very helpful. That was a way that the
- 6:55decision makers could say, hey, guess what? They
- 6:58understand what they're dealing with as well.
- 7:01It gave a better appreciation. A well -written
- 7:05brief, believe it or not, matters. And I know
- 7:07that a lot of people say, what does it really
- 7:09matter and who really reads it? But it does make
- 7:11a difference. And it's not just for the mediator.
- 7:15Obviously, that means you have to get these things
- 7:17to the mediator sooner than later. We don't want
- 7:19to be like one attorney that I had in a case
- 7:21that sent me, it was an excess of 50 pages of
- 7:25the brief. And I'm not talking about the exhibits.
- 7:27I'm just talking about the brief of all the citations
- 7:29and stuff. and I didn't receive it in my email
- 7:33inbox until 45 minutes after the mediation started.
- 7:36That was relatively worthless. I don't know who
- 7:39that was written for, other than maybe I guess
- 7:42the client got to see that this great mediation
- 7:45brief had been written. Certainly wasn't considered
- 7:48by anybody else. That's not going to help. I
- 7:51certainly do ask for my briefs in advance. I
- 7:54have this nice target of I ask for them seven
- 7:57days in advance. I know that that doesn't always
- 7:59happen. I probably shouldn't admit it, but truth
- 8:02be told, even when I receive them the night before,
- 8:04I read the brief from start to finish. I appreciate
- 8:08it if it's not 250 pages long, but I will go
- 8:12from start to finish. The advantage of receiving
- 8:15it sooner is, I'll tell you how I approach it.
- 8:17I don't think I'm very different than many thoughtful
- 8:20mediators. I take a quick read through the brief
- 8:23when I get it. Just quickly I go through it just
- 8:25to get kind of a high elevation perspective and
- 8:28I do that with all the briefs. Then I take a
- 8:30second read where I do a deep dive. I really
- 8:33take my time. I write my notes. I have my questions.
- 8:36I refer back to exhibits. I may ask follow -up
- 8:38questions of counsel. And that's really where
- 8:41I get into the meat and potatoes of it. And then
- 8:44subsequently I take a quick final review and
- 8:47go through my notes right before the mediation.
- 8:50If I have it sooner, I can do all of that. Everybody
- 8:52gets the benefit of that. People will tell you
- 8:54that have mediated with me. My gosh, this guy's
- 8:57actually read everything that I sent to him.
- 8:58And I will if I have an opportunity to do so.
- 9:01If you give me half a chance, I'll do it. Because
- 9:03I care. You've taken the time. I should take
- 9:06the time. If you don't want to share an entire
- 9:08brief, I get it. You can redact portions or you
- 9:12can do a brief for everybody. And you can just
- 9:14give me a side letter. You can give me an email
- 9:16that gives me the... super secret information
- 9:20like here's who's a lunatic, and here's what's
- 9:22not right, and here's what these other issues
- 9:24are, and here are some concerns. Heck, I can
- 9:27even do that with you in a pre -mediation call.
- 9:30But getting a brief out to the other parties,
- 9:32I think is helpful. Certainly not the night before,
- 9:35all right? Next slide, please. We should also
- 9:40think before the mediation, and maybe before
- 9:43the brief's even been written. What have we done
- 9:46prior to the session to make sure that everybody
- 9:49really knows what they're dealing with? And it's
- 9:51not just sharing a brief, but think about it.
- 9:54If we're dealing in a construction defect case
- 9:56or even a non -disclosure case where there are
- 9:59defects that are alleged, have there been any
- 10:02property inspections? Has the defense seen what
- 10:06the issues are? You know, have any experts looked
- 10:09at it if they need to? Because I think in the
- 10:12end, everybody needs to understand, and I would
- 10:14say this all the time to opposing counsel, I'm
- 10:16not going to argue liability with you over the
- 10:19phone and our early phone call. That's not what
- 10:20I'm here to do. I'm here to appreciate what the
- 10:24alleged damage is. Are we arguing over a dollar
- 10:26or a million dollars? I just need to know what
- 10:29the issue is and what the value of that issue
- 10:31is. Let's forget about who's responsible. And
- 10:34I found that the sooner we could have an understanding
- 10:36of kind of the boundaries of what those damage
- 10:39claims may be, the easier it was to make headway.
- 10:44Well, how do we do that? I need to get out to
- 10:46the property with my people to see, is it a $50
- 10:49,000 problem or a $500 ,000 problem? Because
- 10:53if the plaintiff says it's a $500 ,000 problem,
- 10:56and maybe it is, I don't know that if I've never
- 10:59seen it. What's my thought going to be? That
- 11:01must be $50 ,000, must be less. I have no idea.
- 11:04I can tell you that certainly the insurance carrier
- 11:06and other decision makers are duly cynical. They're
- 11:10going to say, I don't think so. Now, on the other
- 11:12hand, if I get out there, experts get out there,
- 11:15if I was on the defense side, and I could look
- 11:17at it and say, I say, and the experts say, we've
- 11:20got a real problem here. Good to know that early.
- 11:23Good to report that timely and soon so everybody
- 11:26understands well in advance of the mediation
- 11:28what it is we're looking at. So, do inspections
- 11:31need to occur? Have the experts even spoken?
- 11:35Do we have experts identified in construction
- 11:37defect case? Is there a case management order?
- 11:40Is that something that we need to discuss? If
- 11:43we're mediating the case and it's a construction
- 11:45defect case that's covered with insurance, do
- 11:48we have an understanding of what the time on
- 11:50risk allocations are? Or is that something nobody's
- 11:53discussed and they're only going to start it
- 11:55in the mediation? Never going to settle that
- 11:56day. How many sessions is that going to take?
- 11:59So we need to work on those things. And in my
- 12:01approach generally, I ask those questions early.
- 12:04I mean, I've got a case I'm working on now, one
- 12:07of many, but one in San Diego that comes to mind.
- 12:10And the property has a lot of defects, a lot
- 12:12of issues. And everybody's like, we're going
- 12:15to mediate. And I said, well, wait a minute.
- 12:17What about all this other stuff that we need
- 12:18to do? And so instead, and it's something that
- 12:21I tend to do in more complex cases, I got all
- 12:25the council on a one hour Zoom that we scheduled
- 12:28and said, what's everybody's scope? Where do
- 12:31they fit into this? Who are their experts? What
- 12:33do we need to do? And we kind of came up with
- 12:36our own quasi little. case management order.
- 12:39We kind of had our own decision of how we were
- 12:41going to administer this thing and work productively
- 12:44to get it ready for mediation so that everybody
- 12:47could have the right understanding. I tend to
- 12:50be pretty hands -on, so I get pretty involved
- 12:52in the cases that way. I'm somebody that's known
- 12:56for, I've started a mediation session underneath
- 12:59the house. and across base in what the issue
- 13:02was and then we went around the corner to the
- 13:04office to see what we were going to do next.
- 13:06So I'm not afraid to get dirty. Next slide please.
- 13:13Now we're going to get into the damages in the
- 13:16context of a non -disclosure case. This is what
- 13:18many of you You know, probably it was one of
- 13:22the teasers that got you here. Some of you may
- 13:25have read a recent article that I wrote in the
- 13:27Daily Journal, and I had some feedback after
- 13:30that, and a lot of people said, I like the article,
- 13:31but, you know, it didn't really cover everything.
- 13:34Well, it can't because there's a page limitation
- 13:36and you can't write a treatise there. So let's
- 13:39talk about what the general rule is typically
- 13:42in a non -disclosure case. And then because we're
- 13:45lawyers, we'll talk about what the exceptions
- 13:47are to those rules. The general rule is the lost
- 13:51damages are determined by the lesser of the cost
- 13:54of repair or diminution in value, whichever is
- 13:57less. I mean, that's the whole point. And I know
- 14:00that a lot of attorneys struggle with that. And
- 14:02they say, well, I don't think that's right. I
- 14:05think there should be more. Well, there is more.
- 14:07I mean, the court will certainly add on some
- 14:09temporary lodging and storage and additional
- 14:12out -of -pocket expenses, perhaps. The question
- 14:16is, what about benefit of the bargain? What about
- 14:18this broader measure that may exist? Well, I
- 14:22think part of the general rule, the out of pocket
- 14:26rule that we're dealing with in Code Section
- 14:283343 basically is founded on the premise of We
- 14:33don't want double recovery. We think that there
- 14:35should be one damage essentially. It's the same
- 14:38thing in a case. Let's say, for example, we have
- 14:40$100 ,000 worth of damages and we have multiple
- 14:44joint tortfeasors. If one of those tortfeasors
- 14:47pays $90 ,000 and the last person standing doesn't
- 14:53settle out, they go to trial. What should their
- 14:55exposure be on the damage portion? Well, it really
- 14:58should be $10 ,000. They should get a $90 ,000
- 15:01offset of credit because you don't just get 100
- 15:04times each defendant. The damage is what the
- 15:07damage is. And so that's a little bit of the
- 15:09out of pocket loss looks like. They say you're
- 15:11going to get one or the other. It kind of comes
- 15:13down to a balance sheet. And people say, well,
- 15:15that's not really fair. Well, it might not feel
- 15:18fair, and my parents always told me life wasn't
- 15:21fair, and at some point I realized they were
- 15:23right. It isn't fair, but it's also reality at
- 15:26times. Because we're lawyers, though, we will
- 15:28talk about the exceptions, and that's where we
- 15:30talk about this Orndorf versus Christiana community
- 15:34builders case. That is a case that basically
- 15:38embrace the restatement second and said, you
- 15:41know, there can be limited situations where we
- 15:45will actually allow for a cost of repair when
- 15:49it's greater than the diminution in value. We're
- 15:52actually willing to do it. In other words, we're
- 15:54willing to go around the general rule. The general
- 15:57rule is one that's well incorporated within Mosetti
- 16:01versus City of Brisbane. That's a 67 CalAP third
- 16:05case. So let's talk about the exception. Basically
- 16:09what they say is if there's a reason personal
- 16:12to the owner for restoring to the original condition
- 16:15and where there's a reason to believe that the
- 16:17plaintiff will in fact actually make the repairs
- 16:20as opposed to the classic, oh, they get a little
- 16:23bit of money and they pocket it and they never
- 16:24do the fix and it becomes somebody else's problem
- 16:26later on, then the court may consider it. But
- 16:30that's an exception. That's a personal use exception
- 16:33rule. That is not the typical norm. There needs
- 16:37to be a specific, peculiar, and valid basis.
- 16:39Those are my words, not the court's words. When
- 16:42we look at the Orndorff case, it refers back
- 16:45to the Henninger versus Dunn case. So you can
- 16:47look at the site on Orndorff, which is here,
- 16:50and it will take you to it. There's also Kelly
- 16:53versus CB and I, Constructors. It's a 2009 case.
- 16:57It's 179 Cal App 4th. That talks about it. In
- 17:01Orndorff, the way that the court looked at it,
- 17:04they said, Well, what's the problem? We had a
- 17:07bad soils case where essentially the owners,
- 17:10the plaintiff said, you know, my foundation shot
- 17:12and the earth is moving all over the place and
- 17:15I need to do this elaborate big, big fix to correct
- 17:19the foundation and to give stability. And in
- 17:22fact, they had a cost of repair estimate a little
- 17:25bit in excess of $243 ,000 at the time. And the
- 17:30value, according to their own expert, after the
- 17:34repair was going to be less. It was going to
- 17:36be $238 ,500, a little bit less. So the question
- 17:42is, what should they get? And initially, it was,
- 17:45well, they should get the lesser. And what the
- 17:48defendant's argument was is the baseline value
- 17:51without a repair was $67 ,500. So if we have
- 17:56that baseline value and we know the post repair
- 17:59is $238 ,500, they said we should take the difference
- 18:02of the two. There should be a credit essentially
- 18:04for that underlying value. And we should really
- 18:07only be talking about $171 ,000 in terms of a
- 18:11diminution in value. And that's certainly less
- 18:14than $243 ,539 .95 that was testified to. And
- 18:22despite that, the court said, no, no, no, no.
- 18:23In this case, we're going to award the full value,
- 18:28the cost of repair, and some relocation costs
- 18:31and some other sundry expenses, etc. So there
- 18:34are exceptions to it. So when people say, well,
- 18:36you know, I read that article, but you know,
- 18:38I think there's a little more to it. Yeah, there's
- 18:40always an exception. But that's a limited exception.
- 18:45Next slide, please. Now, let's talk about an
- 18:53exception as well, where we can get around the
- 18:56general diminution of value or cost of repair,
- 18:59whichever is less. And that's where we have an
- 19:02intentional fraud by a fiduciary. As many of
- 19:04you know, when you're a fiduciary, that's obviously
- 19:08the most highest legal duty you can bear to another,
- 19:10and it kind of puts you in a different position,
- 19:12right? I'll do a higher standard. And we can
- 19:16see a string of cases in real estate that deal
- 19:19with fiduciaries and put them under an additional
- 19:22level of scrutiny and hold them to a higher standard.
- 19:26In this Frigale case, that's exactly what occurred.
- 19:30Tim and Donna Frigale bought a house in Long
- 19:32Beach, California. And in that transaction, there
- 19:36were disclosures provided by the seller saying
- 19:40there's some unpermitted construction there's
- 19:42some things here that you know happened over
- 19:44the years it's very typical you know we get the
- 19:46house where they enclose the sunroom like almost
- 19:49every sunroom in an old house has been enclosed
- 19:51maybe it doesn't have heating maybe they added
- 19:54the heating but it wasn't permitted etc maybe
- 19:56the foundation is not normal whatever it may
- 19:58be in this particular case the buyers the Frigales
- 20:04ultimately, we're plaintiffs, ask their agent
- 20:06questions like, well, what about these undisclosed
- 20:09or these unpermitted issues? What do we need
- 20:12to know about that? What's going on behind the
- 20:15wood paneling, you know, in these walls? Is there
- 20:17anything we need to know about? And ultimately,
- 20:21some of the testimony came down to, or there
- 20:23was an understanding that perhaps the agent had
- 20:26said something to the effect of, don't worry
- 20:28about it. It's OK. It's going to be good for
- 20:31you know another 20 years there's no problem.
- 20:34That was a problem. So in that case what was
- 20:37interesting was the plaintiffs didn't have all
- 20:39the experts that they needed to have and defense
- 20:42counsel in that case said wait a minute you can't
- 20:45talk about damages when you you haven't told
- 20:48me the lesser of because you don't have an expert
- 20:51to talk about some of this. The plaintiff can't
- 20:53testify about some of these valuation issues
- 20:56and so you can't determine the lesser of because
- 20:59you don't have that evidence and therefore you
- 21:01don't have a quantifiable damage. We don't know
- 21:03what it is you can't do that and initially it
- 21:06seemed like it was going to go that way but the
- 21:08appellate court struggled with it and ultimately
- 21:10the determination was when you have a fiduciary
- 21:12and in that case they deemed it a constructive
- 21:15fraud it wasn't a I'm going to lie to you and
- 21:18I'm going to cheat you and I'm trying to be a
- 21:20fraudster but a constructive fraud which is what
- 21:22you get in a fiduciary context they said we're
- 21:25going to give you the broader benefit of the
- 21:28bargain. We're going to give you that sort of
- 21:31evaluation. And it's a little bit like in the
- 21:33article I wrote. I said, you know, you have a
- 21:34guy that or gal who buys a nice property and
- 21:38it's got a four car garage. And, you know, they
- 21:41say, oh, this is everything I want because I
- 21:43can tinker with my car on the weekends. I've
- 21:45got this extra bay. This is everything to me.
- 21:48This this house is. specifically what I need,
- 21:51that garage is everything. The reality of it
- 21:54is a fourth bay in most houses doesn't really
- 21:56change the value dramatically, does it? I mean,
- 21:59it's two car garage, we all need it. Three car
- 22:02garage is great. By the time you get to the fourth
- 22:05car, probably not as necessary. That's probably
- 22:08the bay where you just put the boxes that get
- 22:10a bunch of dust. At least that's kind of how
- 22:12the market tends to evaluate it. So how much
- 22:15all things equal more as a house worth? with
- 22:18a three -car versus a four -car garage? Probably
- 22:21not a lot. In this hypothetical situation, if
- 22:24the buyer says, well, what's going on with this
- 22:27fourth bay? It looks a little different than
- 22:28the rest. Is it OK? Is it permitted? Am I going
- 22:32to have any issues? And let's say the agent says,
- 22:35don't worry about it. It's fine. Everything's
- 22:38good. You're never going to have a problem, which
- 22:40you should never do, but they do, hypothetically.
- 22:44And the buyer goes, OK, you know, it sounds reasonable.
- 22:46Sounds like you know what you're talking about.
- 22:48I'm going to rely on that reasonably. And then
- 22:50afterwards, they close Ask Grow and they pull
- 22:53a permit to do a little kitchen remodel. And
- 22:55the building inspector comes out there and pulls
- 22:57their vehicle up and sees this fourth car garage
- 23:00and goes, what's that? You can't have that. That's
- 23:03not permitted. The question is going to be, what's
- 23:05the damage? Is it the diminution in value or
- 23:08cost to repair? To make it to comply? Could be
- 23:11$150 ,000, $200 ,000. Diminution of value can
- 23:14be negligible. $20 ,000, $30 ,000 of that, perhaps.
- 23:18Big difference. Depends. Do we have a fiduciary
- 23:21that said something they shouldn't have said?
- 23:24Did they buy that exposure? So that's where you
- 23:26can get into that sort of exception. Next slide,
- 23:31please. When we're talking about damages as well,
- 23:37and I'm going to just kind of put this in there,
- 23:39it wasn't in the outline, but I did feel it would
- 23:41be important to talk about under Civil Code Section
- 23:443346, when we deal with timber cases, damages
- 23:49also can be enhanced. And people say, well, Rob,
- 23:53we don't deal with logging cases typically here
- 23:55in Southern California. Maybe we get them in
- 23:57Northern California a little bit. But these cases
- 24:00are more than just logging cases in terms of
- 24:03some big logger trespassing onto a property and
- 24:08strip mining a hillside and taking all the trees
- 24:10out, this actually can relate to cutting a tree
- 24:13down that belongs to your neighbor. That's where
- 24:16it gets interesting. I mean, we all know if a
- 24:18branch overhangs onto a neighbor's property,
- 24:20maybe the neighbor can cut it at the property
- 24:22line. Maybe they can cut roots that are invading
- 24:25into their property. But what happens when you
- 24:27cut your neighbor's tree down? What's the damage?
- 24:31What's the value of the timber? The timber may
- 24:34be worth just about nothing. But that's not necessarily
- 24:37how the court looks at it. The court may look
- 24:39at it as, oh, we look at the replacement value
- 24:43of the tree. And if it's just a negligent, you
- 24:47know, you weren't really paying attention. You
- 24:48did something stupid and you cut the tree down.
- 24:51Maybe we'll just double it. But if we think it's
- 24:53intentional and you knew what you're doing, you're
- 24:55having arguments about it or whatever, and maybe
- 24:57there's been a survey and you still cut it down
- 25:00or whatever, that's a problem. Then you can get
- 25:02into a trouble effect. They can multiply it by
- 25:05three. And attorney's fees may be awarded. So
- 25:08got to be careful when you're cutting down your
- 25:11neighbor's trees. You have to know where you're
- 25:13cutting and what you're cutting. I have some
- 25:15cases that come through and inevitably will throw
- 25:18the tree element in there if they can because
- 25:20it'll make it a little more complex. All right.
- 25:23As far as attorney's fees are concerned, as we
- 25:25all know, attorney's fees can be awarded either
- 25:28pursuant to contract if the parties agreed that
- 25:31there'd be a prevailing party attorney's fees
- 25:33provision or by statute. And the citations are
- 25:37here on the slide. If we look at the residential
- 25:39purchase agreement, the classic California Association
- 25:42of Realtors contract that we see, there is a
- 25:45prevailing party attorney's fees provision in
- 25:48that contract. That's pretty normal. The issue
- 25:52there, though, is you have to read the whole
- 25:54contract. And one of the things that that contract
- 25:57says is in order to maintain your right to request
- 26:00the recovery of your attorney's fees as the prevailing
- 26:03party, thou shalt first request mediation. The
- 26:07parties agreed in the purchase agreement that
- 26:10they would mediate disputes arising out of the
- 26:12contract before proceeding the litigation. So
- 26:15that means if you're a claimant, you should ask
- 26:17first, you know, well, you know, we want to mediate
- 26:20pursuit to the contract. And, you know, if we
- 26:22don't hear back from you within so many days,
- 26:25you know, we'll deem that a rejection perhaps,
- 26:27but they should document it and they should show
- 26:29it. Every now and then, you'll get the situation
- 26:32where somebody didn't realize that and they filed
- 26:34the lawsuit and oops, they kind of screwed that
- 26:38part up. It might be one thing if you've got
- 26:40a statute of limitations, it's going to expire
- 26:42very quickly to preserve the statute, but not
- 26:44serve it. And maybe you can request a tolling
- 26:48agreement. If they're not willing to execute
- 26:50a tolling agreement, you'll say, we'll be left
- 26:51with an alternative, but we still want to mediate
- 26:53first. But you want to be careful with that.
- 26:55Otherwise, you may deprive yourself of the right
- 26:58to recover attorney's fees. And certainly, you
- 27:00don't want to be the attorney that learns that
- 27:02the hard way. Another exception for fees could
- 27:06be a tort of another. That's essentially where
- 27:08you're required to act in your own self -preservation
- 27:12interest. by bringing or defending an action
- 27:14against a third party. I won't go too far down
- 27:16that rabbit hole, but that's yet one more reason
- 27:19where you can get your fees. Next slide, please.
- 27:26Recision. Recisions that, you know, takes us
- 27:29back to law school. You know, yes, in theory,
- 27:32we can, under certain circumstances, request
- 27:35to rescind the purchase agreement. A buyer, a
- 27:38plaintiff can ask the seller to take the property
- 27:40back. It doesn't happen that often because many
- 27:43times the seller may have moved out of state.
- 27:47They may not have the money. They may not have
- 27:49the ability. The courts may be reluctant to do
- 27:52that when damages can equally address the issue
- 27:55because otherwise there are supervision aspects
- 27:57to rescission. They've got to deal with it. It's
- 28:00an equitable remedy. So obviously, if you're
- 28:03going to ask for it, you have to have clean hands.
- 28:05You have to, you know. basically show that you're
- 28:08not at fault here and you've done your part and
- 28:11all things equal, you know, you want to rescind
- 28:13the contract and you have to give timely notice.
- 28:15You can't, you know, three years later say I
- 28:17want to return it. It's a little bit like returning.
- 28:20I guess, you know, Nordstrom says you can return
- 28:21something anytime perhaps. You don't get to do
- 28:23that with a property. You got to do it timely
- 28:25like these people that say you've got to come
- 28:27back within so many days. Next slide, please.
- 28:32Again, as we're talking about that hypothetical
- 28:37shirt that you're trying to return to Nordstrom,
- 28:39who do you get to return it to? Well, you get
- 28:41to return it to Nordstrom, not somebody else
- 28:43that you didn't buy from. Same thing would be
- 28:45when you're dealing with rescission. You don't
- 28:47get rescission against a real estate professional
- 28:49because they didn't sell you the property. The
- 28:52real estate professionals are not parties to
- 28:56the purchase agreement. Now, the contract says
- 28:58it, the case law says it. It's part of the reason
- 29:00why they're not beholden or are responsible for
- 29:03the attorney's fees under the purchase agreement.
- 29:05Unless there's some other written document that
- 29:07there's an attorney's fees provision that's clear,
- 29:10they generally might not be exposed to the attorney's
- 29:13fees. So that's an important thing to know. A
- 29:16lot of people say, well, but you know... The
- 29:19realtors, the agent, they're jointly and severally
- 29:21liable. They're not responsible for the attorney's
- 29:23fees under the purchase agreement. They're no
- 29:24more a party to the agreement than the gardener
- 29:27that mows the lawn or the pool person who throws
- 29:30some chemicals into the spa once a week. Next
- 29:33slide, please. Liquidated damages. Liquidated
- 29:39damages is another form of damages that we can
- 29:42recover. We know that we have a liquidated damages
- 29:45provision within an agreement. It can't be a
- 29:49penalty. It has to be a reasonable estimation
- 29:53of what the damages are projected as being at
- 29:56the time that the parties entered into the contract.
- 29:59They don't know necessarily what it is, but it
- 30:01can't be some outlandish penalty. Obviously,
- 30:04we've even seen that sort of concept about penalties
- 30:07when we see stipulated judgments in cases. I
- 30:10don't want to go too far off track on that, but
- 30:12it's the same sort of mentality. It has to be
- 30:15realistic. When we're dealing in a residential
- 30:18context, generally liquidated damages of up to
- 30:223 % are somewhat considered presumptively valid.
- 30:26Doesn't mean you can't disprove it. Doesn't mean
- 30:28that you can't show that they didn't have that
- 30:29damage. But generally, it may shift the burden
- 30:32of who has to prove what's reasonable and what's
- 30:34not versus a general presumption and validity
- 30:38when it gets over 3%. That's sometimes why you
- 30:41have sellers that say, I want the liquidated
- 30:43damages provision. initial between the parties,
- 30:46and I want a three percent deposit in that initial
- 30:49deposit to protect me. Next slide, please. Punitive
- 30:55damages. Well, we know that exemplary are punitive
- 30:58damages under Civil Code Section 3294 are damages
- 31:04to compensate for, you know, some pretty outrageous
- 31:06behavior, you know, for dealing with fraud, malice,
- 31:09oppression. You can get there. And then, of course,
- 31:12how are you going to determine that in a subsequent
- 31:15phase after a trial? It could be, well, now we're
- 31:17going to look at the net worth. So punitive damages
- 31:19award against a little mom and pop individual
- 31:24may be a lot different than it would be against
- 31:26Jeff Bezos, for example. So they're going to
- 31:28look at that. Punitive damages, people think
- 31:31that never happens. And in these real estate
- 31:34cases, ah, it's not going to happen. Everybody
- 31:36pleads, just like everybody pleads fraud, never
- 31:38happens. I was talking to an attorney about a
- 31:43week ago regarding a case, and they said, yeah,
- 31:46you know, the seller's counsel said there's just
- 31:48no damages. The case is ridiculous. I'm not giving
- 31:51you anything. It never offered anything. It didn't
- 31:53mediate the case, didn't offer anything, didn't
- 31:55go anywhere. And, you know, the jury came back
- 31:58and they awarded punitive damages against the
- 32:00seller in a nondisclosure case. So, you know,
- 32:03people are quick to discount it, but I wouldn't
- 32:05just ignore it outwardly. You never know what's
- 32:08going to happen. Next slide, please. Let's talk
- 32:12about the tabulation of damages. How are we going
- 32:14to determine what these numbers are? I mean,
- 32:17if I'm on the defense side, I need to know what
- 32:19the exposure is. If I'm on the plaintiff side,
- 32:22my client needs to know really what these damages
- 32:24are. We're going to have to prove this stuff
- 32:27if we go to trial. If we are suing a contractor
- 32:31or real estate broker and we're dealing with
- 32:34negligence, we have to get an expert in there
- 32:36that's going to testify to the standard of care.
- 32:38So it's a real estate broker or a general contractor
- 32:41for the standard of care. We're going to need
- 32:44an appraiser dealing with the fair market valuation
- 32:46with and without the cost of repair, perhaps.
- 32:49You don't have an appraiser. A lot of people
- 32:50will say this in the mediation. What are your
- 32:52damages? What are we here for? What's your diminution
- 32:55of value? What does the appraiser say? And a
- 32:58lot of people say, well, I don't want to spend
- 32:59the money on an appraiser yet. Well, you at least
- 33:02ought to have some cogent basis for what you
- 33:04think it is, whether you've formally retained
- 33:07an expert very early on or not, there should
- 33:10be some analysis there, some common sense analysis
- 33:13that can be shared to give some credibility because
- 33:16it will help. And I know it can be challenging
- 33:18in early mediations where maybe you're required
- 33:21to do it under the purchase agreement. But nonetheless,
- 33:25it's important to share as much information there
- 33:27as you can. Other experts you may need, you may
- 33:29need design professionals, you may need an architect,
- 33:32engineers, whether civil or structural soils
- 33:35engineers, because otherwise we don't really
- 33:37know what we're dealing with and what we're designing.
- 33:40You're going to need a general contractor for
- 33:41the cost of repair. You may need other specialty
- 33:44experts as well, whether it's an economist or
- 33:47somebody that deals with the permitting on the
- 33:49city end, or whether it's an arborist dealing
- 33:52with the value of replacing the trees and what
- 33:54the growth is and the formulas you're using.
- 33:56You're going to need to consider that. Next slide,
- 33:59please. Emotional distress. Frequently, you know,
- 34:07plaintiffs will be pretty troubled with their
- 34:10case. They're very frustrated with what they
- 34:12feel the defendants have done or failed to do.
- 34:15And you always get or not always, but almost
- 34:18always get these emotional distress claims. And,
- 34:20you know, I get it. It's a terrible situation,
- 34:24perhaps. But the question is, you know, Is it
- 34:27really recoverable? How likely is that? And the
- 34:30reality is, absent a coupling with an actual
- 34:33physical injury, generally in real estate cases,
- 34:36you're not going to see it. There's an arguable
- 34:39exception if you're dealing with an intentional
- 34:41tort. But the example that I would frequently
- 34:43use is, in a real estate nondisclosure case,
- 34:46let's say, for example, the Plaintiffs say, you
- 34:50know, it's been terrible. I'm getting headaches.
- 34:52I'm waking up in the middle of the night. I'm
- 34:54totally stressed out over this lawsuit. And it's
- 34:56called, yeah, that's litigation. Everybody feels
- 34:59that way. That's what it's like to be a lawyer.
- 35:02That happens. That's not necessarily emotional
- 35:05distress. But if you're going to show the emotional
- 35:07distress, you know, what is it? You know, if
- 35:10you saw treatment, you know, what can you back
- 35:13that up with? And typically what would come out
- 35:16is this. I'd say, look, if Hypothetically, let's
- 35:20say somebody fails to disclose a defective deck
- 35:24on the back of a house, let's say they just they
- 35:27knew about it, but they forgot they didn't tell
- 35:29you. And, you know, now you're the owner and
- 35:32you walk out on that deck and you fall straight
- 35:35through it. It's completely rotted out and you
- 35:36break your back and you're in the hospital. Well,
- 35:38now you have a physical injury and now you can
- 35:41make your emotional distress claims and you can
- 35:43couple it with that physical injury. You may
- 35:45have a basis for emotional distress. But absent
- 35:48that physical injury just the, you know, really
- 35:50is a bummer to be me, it's going to be tougher.
- 35:53I'm not saying it doesn't mean it's very real
- 35:55for the plaintiffs and it isn't a terrible situation
- 35:57for them. I'm just saying that this is the way
- 36:00that the law reads in these cases. Next slide,
- 36:04please. Betterment. We see this where Oh, you
- 36:14know, I've got this defect, you know, whether
- 36:16the contractor did it wrong or the realtor didn't
- 36:19disclose it or the seller didn't disclose it.
- 36:22And, you know, I had some mold in my kitchen
- 36:25and the cabinets had to come out. And, you know,
- 36:28the remediation company came in and they stabilized
- 36:31everything and they put Humpty Dumpty back together.
- 36:34But then, you know, since it was all torn apart
- 36:36anyway, now was the time to put in that new kitchen
- 36:39that I always wanted. So I had these, you know,
- 36:42vintage circa 1967 cheap cabinets that were in
- 36:46the kitchen. And, you know, now I'm going to
- 36:48get these, you know, hand blessed, specially
- 36:52constructed European cabinets that are going
- 36:55to be installed. Well, you don't get the great
- 36:58European cabinets, you get a generic general
- 37:01cabinet. So that's something that you're also
- 37:03going to need to consider. You don't get to just
- 37:05improve the property. And we know that when people
- 37:07tear things apart, it's just their nature to
- 37:10always want to make it a little better. Everybody
- 37:13does it. You know, as a contractor, I never built
- 37:15a house that there wasn't a change order where
- 37:17somebody didn't want to do something a little
- 37:19nicer, even in my own projects where I built
- 37:22stuff. And I said, I know exactly what I'm going
- 37:24to do. Once you're underway, you're always going
- 37:27to improve this or going to improve that. Or
- 37:29if anybody's married or has a significant other,
- 37:32trust me, that person's probably going to figure
- 37:34out what they want to improve. So that's normal.
- 37:37And so what I'm going to tell you is, from the
- 37:39plaintiff's perspective, it's OK that there's
- 37:42going to be some betterment. But if you want
- 37:44to engender credibility, maybe have a little
- 37:47line item that shows this is the delta. This
- 37:50is where we did an improvement. This was the
- 37:52baseline. As opposed to, you just have to pay
- 37:55for everything. Because then people start saying,
- 37:57yeah, you're just scamming me. But if you have
- 37:59a line item, and I've seen good attorneys do
- 38:02this, they'll say, no, we're reasonable about
- 38:05this. We improved this. There was luxury plank
- 38:09vinyl, and now we've got this 3 quarter inch
- 38:13solid wood flooring in there. That's an improvement.
- 38:16There's a difference between the two. We just
- 38:17want the LVP value. That would be different.
- 38:20Next slide, please. Market decline. A plaintiff
- 38:28may say, well, you know, I bought the property,
- 38:30and it's been a disaster, and I have all these
- 38:32defects, and I have all these damages. And that
- 38:35may well be the case, and there may be damages
- 38:37that flow from that. And now my property is just
- 38:39worth less in general because the market's gone
- 38:41down. Well, too bad, so sad. I mean, the way
- 38:45it works is that's your bargain for risk. You
- 38:48bargained to own a property, and you bargained
- 38:51for the risk that it could go up in value? or
- 38:54it could go down in value. If it goes down, it
- 38:56goes down. I guess maybe the seller's relatively
- 38:59better off. I don't know. It depends whether
- 39:01they bought something or they moved somewhere
- 39:02else or they didn't buy or what they did. But
- 39:05just like you could get the appreciation, the
- 39:07seller doesn't get that appreciation back. So
- 39:10that's a risk that you have to absorb. It's a
- 39:13bargain before risk and it's not something that
- 39:16generally is recoverable. I know there are going
- 39:18to be some attorneys going, well, wait a minute.
- 39:20Of course, there's always an exception to every
- 39:22rule. I mean, it'd be different if, let's say,
- 39:24the agent was saying, I know you're an investor.
- 39:28You know, I've invested. I've done all this.
- 39:30I'm telling you that this is what it's going
- 39:32to be worth. And they step beyond the boundaries
- 39:35of where they should be advising people. And
- 39:37they wear a different hat. And they get beyond
- 39:39the mere sales puffery. That may be a different
- 39:41thing. But generally speaking, and since this
- 39:44is only an hour seminar, we're going to deal
- 39:45with the generalities. then that's not going
- 39:49to be the case. Next slide, please. Speculative,
- 39:57lost profits, the could have, would have, have
- 39:59claims, those just don't exist. And this goes
- 40:02to, it refers to the Mosetti case. In Mosetti,
- 40:04you'll see that kind of ties in with Orndorf
- 40:06that we were talking about earlier. We don't
- 40:09give speculative. We don't know what the damages
- 40:12are. Maybe they could be. We can't just imagine
- 40:15that that just becomes insanity. That's, you
- 40:18know, cats living with dogs, pure insanity may
- 40:21happen. So we're not going to do that. Next slide,
- 40:23please. Consisted with the last slide, you have
- 40:28to have certainty. Same thing again. We need
- 40:30to have a quantifiable, legitimate number that
- 40:34we know what it's going to be. This is why we
- 40:36have experts. This is why we get into a battle
- 40:38of the experts talking about it. But we're not
- 40:41going to speculate. We're not going to get into
- 40:43conjecture when it comes to damages. It's not
- 40:45to say that you may not hope that the jury embraces
- 40:49things a little more broadly, but generally that's
- 40:52the way the law is supposed to work. Next slide,
- 40:57please. Stigma damages, they're generally non
- 41:00-recoverable and stigma damages that, you know,
- 41:03well, now I'm going to have to disclose this
- 41:05when I sell the house someday and, you know,
- 41:09that's going to cost me 10%. You know, it's going
- 41:13to sell for less. Nobody's going to want the
- 41:14house because of that and certainly not at that
- 41:16price. Well, is that true? Is it a hot market?
- 41:19We know in a hot market, even a dog of a property
- 41:22can sell quickly for more than anybody ever thought
- 41:24it was going to sell for and nobody cares. We
- 41:27know in a terrible market, people are nitpicky
- 41:29and they complain about every last little possible
- 41:32thing. But this notion of stigma, you know, someday
- 41:35I'm going to have to disclose that there was
- 41:37a litigation and and now the property is going
- 41:40to sell for less, generally not recoverable.
- 41:43In the Oz case talked about that. I know that
- 41:45Oz from a Right to Repair Act and from a new
- 41:49developer perspective really doesn't matter anymore
- 41:52because it's been replaced with SB 800 to which
- 41:55I refer. But Oz did have some meaningful dialogue
- 41:59in terms of stigma, in terms of the fact that
- 42:01we're just not going to imagine what something
- 42:03could be because we don't know if there's going
- 42:04to be any actual damage. We're not going to imagine
- 42:08it. Next slide, please. Duty to mitigate. We
- 42:16all know this. I mean, if we have a problem and
- 42:20we have a claim, we have an obligation to not
- 42:23pour salt in the wounds, right? If the roof's
- 42:27leaking, you know, I get that maybe we can't
- 42:29afford to put a new roof on right away, but can
- 42:32we pay somebody to go up on the roof and put
- 42:33a tarp up there? We certainly shouldn't go out
- 42:36there with a fire hose and say, look how badly
- 42:38it's leaking. Look, look at the leaks. This is
- 42:40terrible. We're not supposed to exacerbate. the
- 42:43problem. We're supposed to do what we can within
- 42:46our means to minimize the damage. Everybody is
- 42:49supposed to work efficiently in that regard.
- 42:52So you have to show that you've been doing that.
- 42:54And it's helpful when you're making your claims
- 42:57to say, yeah, we couldn't avoid this. This is
- 42:59what we did. This is what we did to tackle it
- 43:02as best we could. We'll see a situation where
- 43:05somebody will say, yeah, there's a lot of mold.
- 43:07We remediated, but we couldn't put it back together.
- 43:09But at least we made sure the property was, the
- 43:12mold was out and we stopped the leaking and the
- 43:15most critical pressing issue. Next slide, please.
- 43:22Let's talk about the classic construction claims
- 43:25and the analysis, really the carrier's formula
- 43:28for the calculation of damages. This is what
- 43:30happens time and again in these cases. Basically,
- 43:34the defense shows up and they basically, and
- 43:37I alluded to it earlier, they say, you know,
- 43:41what's the issue? What's the problem? Is it a
- 43:45bad roof? Is it a undersized beam and the damage
- 43:49from that, what is it? So the first thing is,
- 43:52what's the problem? What's the beef, essentially?
- 43:54And that goes back to expert access to the property,
- 43:58a compilation of the findings, and the experts
- 44:01need to review these things and the insurance
- 44:03carrier needs to consider it. That needs to occur
- 44:06before anybody's going to have a number before
- 44:07they're going to know what they're willing to
- 44:09do. So you have to evaluate the defects. You
- 44:11have to consider, have you enabled the party's
- 44:15ample opportunity to do that? Then the next question
- 44:18on the defense side is, OK, what's the scope
- 44:22of work to fix it? This is the defect. What's
- 44:24it going to cost to fix it? Because they've got
- 44:26to quantify a number. They have to know what
- 44:28it's going to be. So it's what's the scope? And
- 44:31then what's the cost? And then the last thing
- 44:34is they'll say, and how long does it take to
- 44:36do it? Is this a 30 -day issue? Is this a 45
- 44:39-day issue? Are the plaintiffs going to be displaced
- 44:42for this period of time when the repairs occur?
- 44:44And that's the formula that they use to tabulate
- 44:47it. That's how they're going to look at it. And
- 44:49if they don't have that information, they're
- 44:51not really going to have any money much beyond
- 44:54nuisance for you to consider it. Next slide,
- 44:57please. Insurance. I sometimes, and I have nothing
- 45:03but deference for the insurance carriers that
- 45:04have to pay to resolve these. claims, but I sometimes
- 45:08refer to the insurance as the checkbook, because
- 45:10really, that's where a lot of this money is going
- 45:12to come from, perhaps. So you have to, and really,
- 45:15even if it's an affluent decision maker that
- 45:18isn't insured in a situation, they're still going
- 45:20to think in a somewhat similar manner. It goes
- 45:23back to what I said earlier, you got to pay to
- 45:25play. You have to give information, information
- 45:28is money. So we have to think about that. And
- 45:31then let's think about the limitations on the
- 45:33insurance coverage, because A lot of the contractors
- 45:36that get sued out there. Well, if the insurance
- 45:39isn't going to cover it, are they? How viable
- 45:43are they really? I mean, are they just driving
- 45:45around with an old Ford F -150 with a ladder
- 45:48in the back and have a couple of steel filing
- 45:50cabinets in the garage? What are you really going
- 45:52to collect from them? You know, you're generally
- 45:54looking to collect more sooner as opposed to
- 45:57less later, if ever. So we it's helpful to know
- 46:01at least what the reservations are that you're
- 46:04going to hear. it's helpful to know what these
- 46:06things are, because all these insurance policies
- 46:10can't cover everything. You know, I always say
- 46:13what the Lord giveth on page one, it takes away
- 46:15in the next hundred pages. And so the question
- 46:18is, what does the policy cover? No insurance
- 46:20can cover everything, or nobody could afford
- 46:23insurance. So there are a lot of limitations.
- 46:25And there are a lot of policies out there, particularly
- 46:28now, that offer you know, kind of Swiss cheese
- 46:32coverage. Some people refer to a lot of holes,
- 46:34perhaps. So there will be scope of work limitations
- 46:37like we don't cover anything that relates to
- 46:39plumbing unless you're a licensed plumber. That
- 46:42could be a problem if it flooded and somebody
- 46:43was doing some plumbing. They'll have a requirement
- 46:47that the contractor has to use all licensed subcontractors
- 46:51pursuant to a written contract and the subcontractor
- 46:54has to agree to indemnify them in the contract.
- 46:57I got to tell you, a lot of contractors don't
- 46:59have the greatest contracts in the world and
- 47:02they typically don't have that language and so
- 47:04that's going to be another reservation or an
- 47:06issue that's going to allow the carrier to push
- 47:08back a little bit and say you know we're kind
- 47:10of pumping the brakes on this. They'll have limitations
- 47:13as to coverage for bodily injury property damage
- 47:16they may say we're only going to cover the room
- 47:18where the person worked and not the rest of the
- 47:20property irrespective of what the damage may
- 47:22be that flows from it. We may have a multi -unit
- 47:26exclusion for condos, apartment buildings and
- 47:29HOA projects. Contractor probably doesn't even
- 47:31know he's got that in his own policy because
- 47:33generally my experience has been with these files.
- 47:36Nobody really knows what the policy shows until
- 47:39they've been to what we call the school of denial.
- 47:42They get a denied claim and they learn it really
- 47:44quickly what the policy is all about. Another
- 47:47coverage limitation they have, I love this one,
- 47:50abandoned work. And how do they define abandoned
- 47:53work? A project is deemed abandoned by an insured
- 47:57when no work has been performed on a job site
- 47:59by any insured for more than 14 consecutive calendar
- 48:02days. That's crazy. I mean, think about it. I'm
- 48:06a plumber. I go in there. I do my rough plumbing.
- 48:09I get my inspection. I leave. I may not come
- 48:12back for three months while they're doing the
- 48:14rest of the project before I come back to set
- 48:16the finish. They got to do drywall. They got
- 48:18to do, you know. flooring, they've got to set
- 48:21the cabinets, they've got to get the counters
- 48:23in, and then I come back and I set the finish.
- 48:25But yet that may be one more example. Next slide,
- 48:28please. Another issue where they may get hung
- 48:32up is they may say, we don't have an obligation
- 48:35to do anything until the insured satisfies their
- 48:39self -insured retention. And you say self -insured
- 48:41retention, those are funny words. What's that?
- 48:44Well, some people call it a deductible, but actually
- 48:47it's not exactly deductible to be hyper -technical.
- 48:51It's basically the insured is deemed to be self
- 48:54-insured. They are responsible for the first
- 48:57portion of their own insurance up to what you
- 49:00may think is the deductible, whether it's $5
- 49:01,000, $10 ,000, $100 ,000. They have to satisfy
- 49:05that. Until they've exhausted that, until they
- 49:08pay that, the carrier may have no obligation.
- 49:11So, you know, you've got a contractor who's being
- 49:13difficult, who's not paying the deductible. Trust
- 49:15me, they're going to say, well, that's a problem
- 49:17that we have. Next slide, please. Standard workmanship
- 49:23and resultant damage. And really, I like to refer
- 49:26to resultant damage as resultant covered damage.
- 49:31So here's an example. You're a contractor, you
- 49:33go out there, you put a roof on the house, you
- 49:36charge money to put a new roof on the house.
- 49:39Rainstorm comes, you did a rotten job, turns
- 49:42out you sent Helen Keller from the crew out there
- 49:44to do it. It leaks like a sieve. There's damage
- 49:48all over the top floor, the second floor, the
- 49:51first floor. Water goes throughout the unit.
- 49:53You got all sorts of problems, got all sorts
- 49:55of damage. What does the insurance cover and
- 49:58what does it not cover? All things equal. Well,
- 50:01it isn't going to cover putting a new roof on
- 50:03the house. Why? Because the insurance carrier
- 50:06says, We don't cover workmanship per se. We don't
- 50:10guarantee the quality of the workmanship. That's
- 50:13the contractor's responsibility. We're not a
- 50:16performance mom like that. We can't do that.
- 50:18So what we will cover is if the roof's bad and
- 50:21now the water came throughout the unit and flooring's
- 50:24damaged and drywall's damaged and insulation
- 50:27has to be replaced and there are electrical problems,
- 50:29we may have some coverage for that, but we're
- 50:32not going to pay for that specific underlying
- 50:35initial thing, perhaps. So that can be an issue.
- 50:38They're not the guarantor of the work product.
- 50:40And then I have a series of citations that you
- 50:43can refer to there. Next slide, please. Another
- 50:49thing that the carriers will oftentimes say they
- 50:51don't cover, we don't cover attorney's fees from
- 50:54the other side, expert costs, statutory damages,
- 50:58fraud or punitive damages. Well, I mean, I think
- 51:00that's probably not a surprise that fraud and
- 51:01punitive damages aren't covered. Think about
- 51:04it from a public policy perspective. If we could
- 51:06get an insurance policy that indemnified us for
- 51:10fraud, oh, my gosh. Wouldn't we just be promoting
- 51:14insanity, where everybody could just commit fraud
- 51:17and somebody else could pay for it? So no, people
- 51:19are going to have to be responsible for themselves
- 51:21when they commit fraud. And if there's a finding
- 51:23of fraud, as we know, it's not dischargeable
- 51:26in bankruptcy. We want them to be responsible.
- 51:28They don't get a free pass on that. So there
- 51:32will be limitations on that. Next slide, please.
- 51:39Despite all of those exclusions that insurance
- 51:43carriers have, particularly in your construction
- 51:45defect policies or your contractor policies.
- 51:50That doesn't mean that the carrier is not going
- 51:52to be anywhere to be seen and they're not going
- 51:54to take it seriously. The reality is, under Simple
- 51:58Code Section 2778, they have an obligation to
- 52:02defend unless the policy clearly and unambiguously
- 52:07excludes such a duty. And we have the State Farm
- 52:10case that talks about a tripartite relationship
- 52:13between the attorney and the two clients, the
- 52:15insured and the insurer. That's where it can
- 52:17start to get a little more complicated. Then
- 52:19we go down to the Montrose case and that talks
- 52:22more about, you know, what are we supposed to
- 52:25be covering? And I'll tell you the way that I
- 52:26would look at things when I looked at claims.
- 52:29rather than saying, is it not covered? Because
- 52:31we can always try to find a place where it's
- 52:33not covered. And I would write a little note
- 52:35down. This is where it might not be covered.
- 52:36This is where it might not be covered. And all
- 52:38that goes in the reservation. This might be a
- 52:40problem. That might be a problem. We don't cover
- 52:41fraud. We don't cover statutory damages. You'd
- 52:44list all those out. But when you're actually
- 52:47evaluating and analyzing the claim as it's been
- 52:50presented, the way you look at it is you say,
- 52:52is there any chance it's covered? And I don't
- 52:55even necessarily wouldn't look at the you know,
- 52:58breach of contract, negligence, fraud, I'd look
- 53:01at the underlying facts. What have they shared
- 53:03in terms of what they said the problem is? And
- 53:06could those actually potentially be covered?
- 53:09And if the answer is yes, then that duty to defend
- 53:12is triggered. It's in place. And they have to
- 53:16provide the defense to the insured. Now, they
- 53:19may have a reservation right saying they will.
- 53:21I mean, I don't think I ever got an insurance
- 53:23file that didn't have a reservation of rights.
- 53:26Yeah, they'll say we're not covering this, this
- 53:28and that they have to do that to preserve their
- 53:30position. But they'll provide the defense and
- 53:33they might even say we have a right to ask for
- 53:35recovery of the defense fees. If it turns out
- 53:37that we have no responsibility, we do declaratory
- 53:41relief action, which people will threaten to
- 53:43do, but doesn't always happen. Although there
- 53:45are a couple carriers out there that are more
- 53:47aggressive about it that I'm saying. So that
- 53:50duty will be there. And that's helpful, obviously,
- 53:52because the carrier is going to sit there and
- 53:54they're going to say, Yeah, it's going to cost
- 53:56me money to defend this thing. Even if the coverage
- 54:00is tenuous, there's some value to me to getting
- 54:02out. Doesn't mean they're going to pay everything.
- 54:03Doesn't mean they're always going to give you
- 54:05cost of defense in every file that comes through
- 54:07the door or they'd be out of business. But obviously,
- 54:09as they get closer to trial, that will become
- 54:11more of a reality for them. They'll have to think
- 54:13about it. We then talk about the San Diego Navy
- 54:17Federal Credit Union case versus Kuma's Insurance
- 54:19Society. That's the one that talks about an insurer's
- 54:23responsibility. potentially to have to pay for
- 54:25independent counsel to make sure everything's
- 54:27going the way that it should because there could
- 54:29be a potential conflict. And then we talk about
- 54:31the PPG Industries case. That will give you a
- 54:34little bit of information there. Let's go to
- 54:36the next slide. This is an interesting one that
- 54:43we'll start to see more and more, and I'm seeing
- 54:45it more and more certainly. This is the one where
- 54:47under business and professions code section 7031,
- 54:52they basically say that If you have an unlicensed
- 54:55contractor, they shouldn't be paid anything.
- 55:00So let's say you hire an unlicensed contractor
- 55:02and they do a wonderful job. Turns out they really
- 55:06should have a license. Turns out maybe they just.
- 55:09Who knows why they don't have a license, but
- 55:11they don't. They had one once. They lost it.
- 55:13They never had one. Who knows? Or they were just,
- 55:15you know, an interior designer on steroids that
- 55:18got crazy and decided they were going to act
- 55:20like the quasi contractor and they were going
- 55:22to have their subs come in and do all the work
- 55:25and they were going to supervise and manage them.
- 55:27But they don't have a license. The law says thou
- 55:30shall not charge any money to act like a contractor
- 55:34if you're not a contractor in all of the money.
- 55:37that was paid to the quasi -contractor can be
- 55:40disgorged. I guess it kind of makes sense. You
- 55:43shouldn't pretend you're a contractor when you're
- 55:45not. But people have gotten more crafty about
- 55:48the way they evaluate this. They start saying,
- 55:50well, what about when you get a rent -a -officer?
- 55:56We hear about it in real estate, right? Where
- 55:59somebody gets a rent -a -broker. It's the broker
- 56:01that never supervised anything. They live in
- 56:03Alaska, but they're loaning the license and all
- 56:06the people are swinging from the rafters and
- 56:10partying out of town doing craziness and there's
- 56:12no supervision. Well, that's not a real broker,
- 56:15even though they're a broker on paper and they're
- 56:17responsible on paper. It's the same thing with
- 56:19an RMO, with a contractor, with the officer.
- 56:22If they're not paying attention, the argument
- 56:24is, if you're not giving direct, adequate and
- 56:28appropriate supervision, We're going to say that
- 56:30essentially you're lacking valid supervision.
- 56:33And again, we're going to look to the disgorgement
- 56:35argument. People think that doesn't happen. I
- 56:38had a case that came to me right around the end
- 56:42of last year. And that argument was being made.
- 56:45And everybody said, that's ridiculous. And it
- 56:47doesn't mean anything. Well, that case settled
- 56:49on the 3rd of July. And eventually, everybody
- 56:52understood what that problem was going to look
- 56:54like. And the case that had no value all of a
- 56:56sudden had value, and it resolved because people
- 56:59were concerned about it. So you have to pay attention
- 57:01to it. It's something that you're going to hear
- 57:03about. People try to extrapolate a lack of workers
- 57:06comp, which relate to unlicensure. They translate
- 57:10it that way. So you need to watch out for that.
- 57:14Next slide, please. Breach of contract claims
- 57:17typically that goes back to the we don't cover
- 57:20the work product. We don't cover your breach
- 57:22of contract That's just something that you're
- 57:24going to need to be responsible for and that
- 57:27takes us basically right to our tail end It's
- 57:30about 457. I've got time for questions in addition
- 57:34I wanted everybody to know that I am more than
- 57:37happy You've got my email address more than happy
- 57:41to take an email from anybody afterwards that
- 57:44they got questions for me. People know that I'm
- 57:47pretty generous with my time, whether it's pre
- 57:50-session or even after session, or even when
- 57:53people say, I'm looking for a mediator. I say,
- 57:56mediators should always be willing to talk to
- 57:58you whether they've been retained or not, just
- 58:00like selecting any professional. So I'm pretty
- 58:02generous with my time, and I'm always happy to
- 58:04speak with anybody if they have questions. To
- 58:07me, it's just working with another colleague
- 58:09in the community, trying to make it better. I
- 58:12think in large part, I want to make sure that
- 58:13everybody understands that's attended today.
- 58:16There's one takeaway from this, along with the
- 58:20damage formulas and you can go down the rabbit
- 58:23hole of looking at the cases and what they cite
- 58:25to. It is to please share information early.
- 58:29If you do not share the information, you're just
- 58:32not going to get the money. Just like as a child,
- 58:35you might have gone to your parents and said,
- 58:37Mom, Dad, can I have a couple bucks for something?
- 58:40I know what my parents would say. The first two
- 58:42times I approached them before I even got halfway
- 58:45through the sentence, the answer was automatically,
- 58:48no, that's probably a wise thing that they did.
- 58:52And then the third time I'd have to be a little
- 58:53more prepared and I'd have to explain it to them.
- 58:55Maybe they turned me into a lawyer. I don't know.
- 58:58But I had to show them why. You know, yeah, it's
- 59:01for a school project. Oh, it really is. Here's
- 59:03the book. Oh, you're really going to buy a school
- 59:04book. That's different. Oh, it's really for a
- 59:06school thing. OK, maybe we'll do it. But you
- 59:08have to show them. And it's no different when
- 59:10you're asking somebody else to pay a lot of money
- 59:13resolving a case. You have to share the information.
- 59:16And the more that you share, you're going to
- 59:19empower the mediator to help you. Now, you don't
- 59:21want to share it all. I get it. You don't have
- 59:24to. There are portions that you can share just
- 59:26with the mediator. But you can do that separately.
- 59:29the more that you have in common, because I find
- 59:32that people share much more than they realize
- 59:34in these cases than they don't. So I'm just going
- 59:37to encourage you to do that with your files.
- 59:40And obviously, if we've got any questions here,
- 59:42I'm happy to take questions. Let's see if we've
- 59:45got anything in here. We do actually have quite
- 59:48a few, a couple of questions if you'd like to
- 59:50take the time. I'd be happy to answer some of
- 59:54these, you bet. All right. Let's see. I was recently
- 1:00:00involved in a mediation for a case involving
- 1:00:02broker -slash -agent misrep. I acted for plaintiff.
- 1:00:06I submitted a brief, which I gave to the other
- 1:00:08side. The other side, represented by insurance
- 1:00:10counsel, refused to provide a brief. Any ideas
- 1:00:14as to why? Well, you know, I really don't know.
- 1:00:18I mean, I'd have to speculate on that one. I
- 1:00:21don't know the value of that other than perhaps
- 1:00:25the other side. wrote a harsh brief and didn't
- 1:00:31want you to see it, wrote it with the intent
- 1:00:35that only the carrier was going to read it. And
- 1:00:38I don't think that's a good idea. I applaud you
- 1:00:40for sharing your brief because in the end, you
- 1:00:43know, you need to convince the other side. You
- 1:00:45need to get them thinking what it is they're
- 1:00:47looking at. It's frustrating, though. I see attorneys
- 1:00:51tell me, well, I'm not going to share unless
- 1:00:53they share. And I always feel like I'm dealing
- 1:00:55with my kids when they were growing up in the
- 1:00:56backseat. And I'm like, Dad's going to pull the
- 1:00:58car over in a minute. What are you kids doing?
- 1:01:00What is going on? I think it should be reciprocal.
- 1:01:04But in the end, there should always at least
- 1:01:06be one adult in the room. And in this case, counsel
- 1:01:09who shared the brief, I would say I would give
- 1:01:11them credit for it. Why the other brief was not
- 1:01:14shared? I can only imagine that they had some
- 1:01:17observations in there or things they didn't want
- 1:01:19to share. But what is it, one or two paragraphs
- 1:01:21redacted or take that out all together and send
- 1:01:24that to the mediator separately? That's the sort
- 1:01:26of thing that you can give me in a pre -mediation
- 1:01:28call or in an email or in a side letter, but
- 1:01:32certainly not very helpful and certainly not
- 1:01:35something that I would recommend. Another question
- 1:01:38we had here. Do you think the cost of repair
- 1:01:41or diminution of value applies under 3343? And
- 1:01:44the question is, well, what's the lesser of the
- 1:01:46two? And the answer is yes, they can. What's
- 1:01:48the lesser generally as opposed to 3333? Let's
- 1:01:53see what else we have here. I recognize some
- 1:01:56of these well -heeled names. Let's see. All right,
- 1:02:01let's see. What if a broker represents the buyer
- 1:02:09and seller and did not actively lie, but allowed
- 1:02:13the seller to make material representations?
- 1:02:16The broker did not know the statements were false,
- 1:02:19but did not ensure that those statements were
- 1:02:21accurate. That's a really interesting question.
- 1:02:24And that relates a little bit to Robinson versus
- 1:02:26Grossman. That's kind of an earlier seminal case
- 1:02:30that essentially says that the real estate professionals
- 1:02:32do not have an obligation to verify statements
- 1:02:37that appear to be reasonable on their face. The
- 1:02:41question is, when they're taking this information,
- 1:02:45do they have reason to know it's not accurate?
- 1:02:48And they're relating it. At that point, does
- 1:02:50it become a negligent misrepresentation? It's
- 1:02:53a little interesting. I think in that case, you
- 1:02:55may have a dual agency. So that kind of has a
- 1:02:57higher level of scrutiny because you've got these
- 1:02:59fiduciary duties going on. And if there's a red
- 1:03:03flag, you know that would be the question is
- 1:03:06was there any sort of indication was there anything
- 1:03:08there that would have put the agent on notice
- 1:03:11that things were wrong when you say they allowed
- 1:03:13them to make the misrepresentation I mean I'm
- 1:03:16not sure how they allowed them to do it I mean
- 1:03:19they certainly gave them disclosure documents
- 1:03:21to fill out but it also sounds like they didn't
- 1:03:24know they were inaccurate so if they didn't know
- 1:03:26the question is should they have known that's
- 1:03:29kind of the standard did they actually know or
- 1:03:31should they have known What would they have learned
- 1:03:34in the regular course of their conduct? I mean,
- 1:03:36if they've sold many houses in the development
- 1:03:39and there's a known issue in the development,
- 1:03:42maybe that was a little bit of a red flag they
- 1:03:44should have inquired. Maybe that should have
- 1:03:45put them on notice that maybe the seller wasn't
- 1:03:47doing it right. But if they don't know, they're
- 1:03:50not automatically liable. They're not automatically
- 1:03:53jointly and severally liable for the seller's
- 1:03:55misdeed. Can liquidated damages be an exclusive
- 1:04:06remedy? Yeah, in theory, liquidated damages can
- 1:04:09be a sole and exclusive remedy. That's the whole
- 1:04:11notion of how the liquidated damage works. So,
- 1:04:15you know, classic example in a purchase agreement,
- 1:04:18a buyer says, I'm going to buy your property.
- 1:04:22I'm going to remove my contingencies. If I fail
- 1:04:26to close this transaction through any fault of
- 1:04:28my own, not fault of the seller, And we've all
- 1:04:31agreed to liquidated damages, the sole and exclusive
- 1:04:33remedy should be the liquidated damages, presuming
- 1:04:37they're under 3%, perhaps they're reasonable,
- 1:04:40they're valid. That would be the sole and exclusive
- 1:04:43remedy. Unless, I guess, in theory, everybody
- 1:04:46likes the exception, unless you could say, well,
- 1:04:48I think they were playing a game and they were
- 1:04:50just using that like an option and they were
- 1:04:52never acting in good faith and they were never
- 1:04:54going to close the transaction. And how would
- 1:04:56you show that? I've seen the example of in a
- 1:04:59hot market where a buyer who really only had
- 1:05:02the money to buy one property wrote three offers
- 1:05:05and removed all of their contingencies on all
- 1:05:09the properties. And very clearly, they were only
- 1:05:11going to close on one, but they were going to
- 1:05:13grind everybody. on the other all three transactions
- 1:05:17to see where they could get the best ultimate
- 1:05:19deal asking for this, even though they might
- 1:05:21not be entitled to it. And very clearly they
- 1:05:23were going to breach two of the contracts. If
- 1:05:25you have something like that, if you actually
- 1:05:26have that evidence, that may be a little different.
- 1:05:30How do I feel about the argument that the statute
- 1:05:32of limitations period shall be told where the
- 1:05:35parties are required to mediate for the duration
- 1:05:37of the mediation period? I think it can be a
- 1:05:39productive thing. Otherwise, all you're going
- 1:05:42to do is you're going to guarantee that a lawsuit
- 1:05:44is going to get filed. So I've engaged in tolling
- 1:05:48agreements with some regularity back in the day.
- 1:05:51It can be beneficial to do it. Getting everybody
- 1:05:53degree may be another story. If it's just a buyer
- 1:05:56and seller that's different, they may be willing
- 1:05:58to do it. But I think that's going to be certainly
- 1:06:01an option for you. Okay, the listing agent. I'm
- 1:06:14a listing agent also. And we just saw a small
- 1:06:17hole in the ceiling after taking off the popcorn.
- 1:06:21Oh, well, who's taking the popcorn off? I hope
- 1:06:23the agent's not taking the popcorn off because
- 1:06:25we don't want to be involved in the remodeling.
- 1:06:27We don't want to step out of the box of what
- 1:06:30realtors do and what they don't do. But I understand
- 1:06:32realtors sometimes help. They're in the S business.
- 1:06:35Anyway, they've taken this popcorn off or somebody's
- 1:06:38taken this popcorn off. I'm sure they've been
- 1:06:40careful and there's no asbestos and they've done
- 1:06:42everything the way they're supposed to do it.
- 1:06:45And I'm embellishing, but it has an odd look.
- 1:06:48And if I were the buyer, I'd worry about microbial
- 1:06:51growth. Do you think the person seller chooses
- 1:06:54to investigate needs to be a licensed contractor?
- 1:06:57They have a handyman doing most of the work.
- 1:06:59I'm not involved in their choices. Okay, I take
- 1:07:02a... sigh of relief now that I hear that the
- 1:07:05agent's not involved in this stuff. And of course,
- 1:07:07I want to advise to have investigated before
- 1:07:09they paint the ceiling. Do you think I need to
- 1:07:13advise them to get a mold inspection? Seems like
- 1:07:15I should. And I did make it clear it will need
- 1:07:18to be disclosed whatever they do or don't do.
- 1:07:21It will be in my report since I saw it. And I
- 1:07:23think that's precisely the issue. A couple of
- 1:07:25things. Number one. Buyers and sellers and real
- 1:07:28estate professionals, in fact, are entitled to
- 1:07:31rely upon third party professionals in the disclosure
- 1:07:35process. That's the law under civil code section
- 1:07:381102 .4. And I think that law is probably created
- 1:07:42because people need to rely on title reports,
- 1:07:47right? We have to know that the title. insurance
- 1:07:49is in place and that we know we've got valid
- 1:07:51title of the property but it's been extended
- 1:07:53under certain cases like that Lika versus cornerstone
- 1:07:56that was a physical inspector case where they
- 1:07:59say that other parties can rely on these these
- 1:08:03experts these people that do inspections for
- 1:08:06example the idea is if a expert whose job it
- 1:08:08is to ferret out defects doesn't see it why would
- 1:08:11I know So I think it's helpful for a seller to
- 1:08:15have a licensed person look at things. And I'll
- 1:08:18give you an example of what I've done when I've
- 1:08:20sold property. In my counter offer, I've made
- 1:08:24a condition of the contract, not a request, but
- 1:08:28an affirmative condition that the buyer shall
- 1:08:30have an inspection performed by a certified inspector
- 1:08:33within a certain number of days of contract formation
- 1:08:36or I had the right to terminate the sale. I wanted
- 1:08:40them to get that inspection done. I wanted them
- 1:08:42to investigate things for a lot of reasons. One,
- 1:08:45I'm the perfect person to sue, licensed general
- 1:08:47contractor, probably did a fair amount of work
- 1:08:49on the property myself. Doesn't matter that I
- 1:08:52gave 57 pages of disclosures. I still want to
- 1:08:55know that they've had people look at it. And
- 1:08:58the handyman isn't licensed. You can't really
- 1:09:00rely on that. On the other hand, you've got this
- 1:09:03RSB Vineyard case. that talks about people being
- 1:09:07able to rely on licensees. A seller in that case
- 1:09:10was sued. They said you didn't disclose things.
- 1:09:13And the seller said, I hired a licensed contractor.
- 1:09:15I'm not a contractor. I don't know. The contractor
- 1:09:17said it was all fine. I get to rely on that contractor.
- 1:09:21That's reasonable. So a licensed contractor you
- 1:09:24can rely on, handyman from the corner of Home
- 1:09:26Depot with a bucket and a bag of nails, probably
- 1:09:28not. They don't really have the pedigree for
- 1:09:30it. Doesn't mean they don't work hard, but they're
- 1:09:32not licensed. From your perspective, I think
- 1:09:35you've hit the nail on the head, which is, I'm
- 1:09:37going to simply say, the seller had an individual
- 1:09:41scrape the popcorn off. I saw a substance that
- 1:09:45was discolored. I don't know that I would say
- 1:09:47it's microbial. I'd say, I don't know what it
- 1:09:49is. I saw a different color substance. I don't
- 1:09:52know what it was. Then usually, I'd go one step
- 1:09:54further and say, you know. buyer should investigate
- 1:09:57to their own satisfaction sort of thing. And
- 1:10:00that would be what I would do. And I would always
- 1:10:02tell the seller in advance, I'd show them my
- 1:10:04disclosure, I tell them what I'm doing to manage
- 1:10:06the expectation. So they don't think that I'm
- 1:10:08working against them. But yeah, you need to disclose
- 1:10:12it. And I think that's how you would do it. You
- 1:10:13know, whether they get a mold inspection or not,
- 1:10:16they don't have to. Obviously, they may get a
- 1:10:19mold inspection. And if it says there's mold,
- 1:10:21they're going to be bummed out that they got
- 1:10:23it because they're going to have to disclose
- 1:10:24that report and or they're going to be asked
- 1:10:27to do those repairs by a certified individual
- 1:10:30or company. So that's going to be their call,
- 1:10:32whether they want to do it or not. But from your
- 1:10:33perspective, you've got to make sure that it's
- 1:10:35fully disclosed. That's what you're going to
- 1:10:36worry about. If the seller made disclosures,
- 1:10:41but the seller's agent failed to pass on the
- 1:10:43disclosure to the buyer and the buyer's agent
- 1:10:46failed to notice the omission, is there any liability
- 1:10:48on the buyer's agent for failure to do his diligence
- 1:10:52in following up on the disclosure documents?
- 1:10:55Absolutely. The buyer's agent is kind of a gatekeeper.
- 1:11:00They are a protectionary layer. They're supposed
- 1:11:03to be the one that makes sure that things don't
- 1:11:05go too far right. And I'll give you an example.
- 1:11:08Let's say, for example, you get a transfer disclosure
- 1:11:10statement, and they leave a portion blank. It's
- 1:11:15the agent's job, the buyer's agent's job to go
- 1:11:17to the listing agent and say, hey, this is blank.
- 1:11:21We need this answer. Or if they didn't do it
- 1:11:24by DocuSign, but in the old world days, they'd
- 1:11:27check the yes box and no box and then they scribble
- 1:11:30some illegible thing. What the heck is that?
- 1:11:33What's going on? You need to ask as the buyer's
- 1:11:37agent. You need to follow up to get that information.
- 1:11:40And then after you get the information as the
- 1:11:42buyer's agent, you say, this is what I got. This
- 1:11:45is what they said. I don't know whether it's
- 1:11:47true or not. This is what they shared. I'm giving
- 1:11:49you everything I have. I'm not holding anything
- 1:11:53back. That's the way you do it. Now, if the seller's
- 1:11:57agent says, leave me alone. You're ridiculous.
- 1:12:00You're asking too many questions. I've already
- 1:12:02answered it. Or what we used to see with a bank
- 1:12:05that would say, we're not giving you anything.
- 1:12:07We're not required to go to hell. Then you'd
- 1:12:10say, I've asked several times. I'm not getting
- 1:12:13a response. You need to know that, buyer. You
- 1:12:16need to know that I'm not getting a response
- 1:12:18or a complete response. What would you like to
- 1:12:20do? And maybe that gives them a right to put
- 1:12:23the brakes on. Maybe they can delay removing
- 1:12:25their contingency. Maybe that gives them a right
- 1:12:28under the law. Maybe they should talk to a lawyer,
- 1:12:30perhaps, if it becomes an issue about removing
- 1:12:32contingencies, because you're not going to give
- 1:12:34them legal advice. But that's what you need to
- 1:12:36do. You need to be careful with it. And then
- 1:12:41I said, yeah, so thank you. So license contractor
- 1:12:45first, and then if he or she says mold, then
- 1:12:47they can decide whether they wanted it. I think
- 1:12:49that's the safe way to go. I'm a believer and
- 1:12:51I like to rely on licensees. as opposed to non
- 1:12:55-licensees. It doesn't mean that non -licensees
- 1:12:57aren't good, hard -working people, but we just
- 1:13:00don't get to rely on them. I guess it's like
- 1:13:02a doctor. I don't go to the guy at the fair on
- 1:13:06a Saturday that seems really nice, but maybe
- 1:13:09isn't a doctor. It doesn't mean I won't talk
- 1:13:11to them too, but I still believe in modern medicine
- 1:13:13too. If the broker is a dual agent, is it their
- 1:13:17responsibility to vet information provided? I'll
- 1:13:20start with that one. Well, that the information,
- 1:13:23I mean, I guess the question is, what do you
- 1:13:24mean by that? Do you mean performing offsite
- 1:13:28inspections? Let's say the seller says it's fully
- 1:13:33permitted. Does that mean that the agent now
- 1:13:35has an obligation to go down to the building
- 1:13:37department and see if the permits were pulled
- 1:13:39on it? The answer to that one would be no. I
- 1:13:41don't think an agent generally ever has an obligation
- 1:13:45to perform an offsite inspection. However, if
- 1:13:48they represent the buyer, they should tell the
- 1:13:51buyer, The seller has said this. This relates
- 1:13:54to permits. I'm not a permit expert. There are
- 1:13:58people that are experts in that. They're called
- 1:14:00architects, engineers, and or contractors. And
- 1:14:04that is the person that you should have verify
- 1:14:06this information. And they'll say, why can't
- 1:14:09you do it? And then you could say, well, part
- 1:14:11of my job is to tell you what I know and part
- 1:14:13of my job is to tell you what I don't know. OK,
- 1:14:16and here's what I don't know. I don't know the
- 1:14:19right questions to ask them at the building department.
- 1:14:22Here's what I know. If I go to the building department,
- 1:14:25arguably, what am I doing? I'm interrupting a
- 1:14:28civil servant's next break time that they're
- 1:14:29looking to take perhaps. They may tell me anything
- 1:14:32to get me out of there. I could ask the wrong
- 1:14:35question. Here's a perfect example. Was a permit
- 1:14:37ever pulled for the kitchen? And the bureaucrat
- 1:14:41goes, they type into their keyboard, yes. Okay,
- 1:14:46well, that's yes. But did you know the right
- 1:14:49follow -up questions? Was it final? Was there
- 1:14:52a certificate of occupancy? You don't know all
- 1:14:55those questions to ask. So they don't want you
- 1:14:58going down there because you don't even know
- 1:15:00what you don't know. It's not appropriate. You
- 1:15:02shouldn't practice medicine. You shouldn't practice
- 1:15:04construction and permitting. So the answer is
- 1:15:07this is where you tell them, remember that buyer's
- 1:15:09inspection advisory? Remember that document?
- 1:15:11It tells you about all the important things you
- 1:15:13can do with these other people. Now I'm going
- 1:15:15to remind you about that again to give it a little
- 1:15:17more meaning. That's not what I did. Then also
- 1:15:22the broker agreement requires a broker to request
- 1:15:24necessary documentation. Absolutely. I mean,
- 1:15:26you should always ask your seller, do you have
- 1:15:28any documentation for any of this? Because they
- 1:15:31should give it. I do it. I sell my property.
- 1:15:34I give them everything. I give them every document
- 1:15:38that I have. I make copies of it and I make sure
- 1:15:40they sign for it with a receipt for reports.
- 1:15:43I mean, I give them every document. I tell them
- 1:15:45everything that ever happened. The classic example
- 1:15:48I use is Forgive me, Father, for I have sinned.
- 1:15:50My dog urinated in the corner of the dining room
- 1:15:52in 2008. It was immediately cleaned up. But I
- 1:15:55wanted you to know. And that's in the disclosures.
- 1:15:58And so if they pull the carpet up and they think
- 1:16:00they see something someday, I told them. So you
- 1:16:03tell them everything. But you certainly don't
- 1:16:06go off site. You don't start doing all these
- 1:16:08investigations. All right? All right, Robert,
- 1:16:14that looks like we're up for questions. Thank
- 1:16:15you so much for staying over to answer our audience's
- 1:16:19questions today. And thank you so much to our
- 1:16:21audience for joining us. Yeah, my pleasure. Thank
- 1:16:25you.