Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Defending Businesses to Minimize Litigation Exposure
Transcript
- 0:04Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:08Defending Businesses to Minimize Litigation Exposure.
- 0:12My name is Alapoli Castro, and I'm the Director
- 0:14of Education and Professional Development at
- 0:16Beverly Hills Bar Association. And today, I'm
- 0:18delighted to introduce our speaker, Anthony Zoller.
- 0:22Anthony is the founding partner of Zoller Law
- 0:24Group, where he represents California employers
- 0:27in employment litigation, government and investing.
- 0:30and compliance matters. Over his career, he has
- 0:34successfully defended his clients against wage
- 0:36and hour class actions, Paga claims, wrongful
- 0:39termination claims, harassment, and discrimination
- 0:42across industries, such as restaurants, technology,
- 0:45manufacturing, and entertainment. We're so excited
- 0:47to hear his insights on this subject. So I'm
- 0:49going to turn it over to him. Great. Thank you,
- 0:52Ala. Good morning, everybody. And thank you to
- 0:54the Beverly Hills Bar Association for having
- 0:56me. As she said, I'm Anthony Zoller, founding
- 1:00partner of Zoller Law Group, and we defend California
- 1:02employers. I've been doing that my entire career,
- 1:05and we really focus on the wage and hour class
- 1:09actions, private attorney general's claims, termination
- 1:12and disability disputes. You'll see today we're
- 1:15going to focus on the wage and hour issues up
- 1:17front, but we're touching on a lot today. Really
- 1:22kind of three areas that generate most of the
- 1:25liability that we're seeing for California employers
- 1:28here, the wage and hour front, terminations and
- 1:31accommodations. So my goal today is to leave
- 1:34you with both sides of the equation, preventive
- 1:37measures that reduce your client's exposure and
- 1:40the defenses that you can actually build once
- 1:42a claim arrives. So I'm going to share my screen
- 1:47here. and get into the slides. Of course, it's
- 1:53changed a little bit. Give me a minute. I'm going
- 1:56to size this. Perfect. So as usual, we're covering
- 2:08a lot today. So I've got the disclaimer here,
- 2:10as any good lawyer would do. Very high level
- 2:16today. A lot of content to get through. Any questions,
- 2:20feel free to reach out to me, but it's not legal
- 2:23advice. I can't get into any particulars. We
- 2:26will be monitoring the Q &A, so if you have any
- 2:29questions, submit that through the Q &A feature
- 2:34here in Zoom, and I'll be monitoring it, and
- 2:37I'll have some help with the producer as well
- 2:39in the background. We'll try to get to as many
- 2:43questions as possible. So I'll try to field the
- 2:45questions as I'm presenting. And so keep submitting
- 2:52the questions. And hopefully, we'll have some
- 2:54time at the end to get through a few other questions
- 2:56as well. A little bit about my firm. We're based
- 3:00here in El Segundo. All we do is defend employers.
- 3:04And litigations are bread and butter, as I mentioned,
- 3:07probably 60 % to 70 % on the wage and hour cases
- 3:11and the other 30 % to 40%, you name it. We are
- 3:16assisting employers with anywhere from advice
- 3:19and counseling policy updates to labor commissioner
- 3:23hearings or labor commissioner investigations
- 3:27and audits. So we cover the gamut on that front.
- 3:33Today, as I mentioned, I'm going to start off
- 3:37with the 2026 liability landscape, what we're
- 3:41seeing on PAGA and the wage and hour front, PAGA
- 3:43and class actions. We've got some data that I've
- 3:45been tracking here the first part of the year.
- 3:48I'll share that and really show you why most
- 3:53employers are concerned about this and rightfully
- 3:55so on the wage and hour front. And then we'll
- 3:57talk about a few of the wage and hour fundamentals
- 4:00that drive this litigation. And then we'll get
- 4:03into terminations, how to handle terminations,
- 4:07some issues we're seeing around the termination
- 4:10decision and how those are performed. And then
- 4:14I'll also talk about disabilities in the workplace
- 4:20and providing reasonable accommodations in the
- 4:22interactive process and some issues that we see
- 4:25employers get tripped up on that. Yep. And then
- 4:29really throughout today, we're going to be talking
- 4:31about some defense strategies, the policy, the
- 4:34training, consistent enforcement. And as I mentioned,
- 4:37we'll have time at the end for questions. But
- 4:40if you've got any questions, feel free to put
- 4:45those in the Q &A as I'm talking here, and we'll
- 4:49get to that. Great. So the 2026 liability landscape,
- 4:58I wanted to start out with this area here. Not
- 5:04every employee experiences harassment or discrimination,
- 5:08thankfully. Why we see a lot of claims on this
- 5:13issue is that every employee gets a paycheck.
- 5:16And wage and hour claims don't require a bad
- 5:18actor. They only require an imperfect system.
- 5:21And that's why they scale. So these numbers come
- 5:24out of our settlement database. And for full
- 5:27disclosure, I'm also co -founder of Scaled Comp,
- 5:30a software that we use to track and analyze this
- 5:33data. Paga notices are running about 849 a month.
- 5:40pace for the biggest filing year yet since Paga
- 5:43was passed in 2003 and implemented in 2004. But
- 5:48this is even despite the 2004 reform that we
- 5:52had come through. So in this number, the $1 .3
- 5:56billion in track settlements is just for the
- 5:59first half of 2026. And you heard me right. It's
- 6:02$1 .3 billion. I had to double check that. We
- 6:04actually triple checked that number. It's a lot
- 6:08of money for Cal employers and a lot of exposure
- 6:12out there that's driving these types of claims.
- 6:15So a couple of data points I want to focus on
- 6:19here too on this slide is roughly about half
- 6:23of these settlements resolve under $500 ,000.
- 6:27And the other fact I want to point out is 44
- 6:30% involved employers with fewer than 200 employees.
- 6:34So it's not a Fortune 500 problem anymore. It's
- 6:37a small to mid -size employer problem. And also
- 6:41want to point out here too that the top five
- 6:44plaintiffs firm account for about 40 % of the
- 6:47volume. So it's a very concentrated area. These
- 6:53plaintiff's firms that focus on this specialize
- 6:56in it and drive a huge amount of volume on these
- 7:00cases. Also interesting too is the average notice
- 7:04to settlement timeline is running about two years.
- 7:08So that means, yeah, we're actually... The reform,
- 7:13we'll talk about that here in a little bit, in
- 7:152024, was passed in June of 2024. We're just
- 7:20starting to see some of the settlements under
- 7:22the reformed Paga getting approved and hitting
- 7:26our database. And we're tracking that closely
- 7:29to see how the reform has impacted, if at all,
- 7:34the settlement values of these Paga cases. So,
- 7:38yep. The next slide here. Before the reform,
- 7:45the question in a POG case was, did a violation
- 7:48occur? Now, after the reform, the question that
- 7:51matters is, did the employer do any prevent and
- 7:55correct it? Policies, training, audits, consistent
- 7:58enforcement. Those used to be compliance hygiene,
- 8:02now they're defense evidence and there's a significant
- 8:06dollar value attached to that. We'll put numbers
- 8:09into that here in a few minutes. One more connection
- 8:12to draw, most wage and hour litigation originates
- 8:15at the termination and so a departing employee
- 8:18consults a lawyer about one grievance and leaves
- 8:21that office with the Paga notice or the lawyer
- 8:25filing a Paga notice against the employer. So
- 8:27keep that in mind when we get to the termination.
- 8:29section today. I'm a big proponent for employers
- 8:33to treat that termination as respectfully and
- 8:37professionally as possible. And even though the
- 8:39employee might not agree with the decision, they
- 8:42don't leave feeling like they've been disrespected
- 8:46or feel like they should talk to a lawyer to
- 8:50rectify any problem that happened, it could lead
- 8:53to these types of claims, increased claims on
- 8:57the wage and hour front. So employers, great
- 9:02advice to them is just treat the departing employees
- 9:05professionally, have a great bedside manner,
- 9:07and try to deal with these issues before They
- 9:13go outside of the company and turn into a significant
- 9:16class action or Paga case. Now, I get asked all
- 9:22the time from clients, what can they do to prevent
- 9:25the Paga or the wage and hour class action? probably
- 9:31some of the biggest exposure California employers
- 9:33have. And we've got some clients that we're representing,
- 9:38large clients that have sometimes four to five.
- 9:42Paga cases at the same time filed against them.
- 9:46So it's, as I mentioned at the prior slide, the
- 9:50huge volume on these cases despite the reform.
- 9:53So what can an employer really do to prevent
- 9:56these and tighten up their policies? The driving
- 10:01claim for these types of wage and hour usually
- 10:04starts with the meal breaks, and the foundation
- 10:07here is the Brinker decision from the California
- 10:09Supreme Court. Now, the employer's duty is to
- 10:13provide the 30 -minute meal break, relieve the
- 10:16employee of all duty, relinquish control, and
- 10:19give a reasonable opportunity to the employees
- 10:21to take the meal break, not to police it. That
- 10:25distinction is where the cases are won and lost
- 10:27So the first meal period has to start before
- 10:31the end of the fifth hour And I've got a chart
- 10:32about that here coming up walking through the
- 10:34the timing on the next slide On rest breaks,
- 10:39the case is Augustus. On call, rest periods are
- 10:43invalid. The break has to be duty free and the
- 10:48employer has to relieve the employee of all control.
- 10:51So in that case, Augustus, it was security guards
- 10:56had the monitor, I believe it was a pager or
- 10:59cell phone during the rest break. The argument
- 11:01was they weren't really relieved. for the 10
- 11:04minute rest breaks because they had to monitor,
- 11:06they were still on call during that time period.
- 11:09So if your client's security guards or caregivers,
- 11:11we see that come up or caretakers of property
- 11:16have to carry a radio on their rest break, that's
- 11:19a potential claim. And a practice point here
- 11:22too, meal waivers are enforceable for shifts
- 11:28of six hours or less. They don't have to be in
- 11:32writing, but good advice to have those in writing.
- 11:38And employers can implement the meal waiver.
- 11:42So the employee is waiving their 30 minute meal
- 11:44break for shifts under six hours. during the
- 11:47onboarding just once and keep those in the employee
- 11:50files. So that helps a lot, especially in industries
- 11:53such as hospitality and restaurants where the
- 11:56employees are working shorter shifts. Oftentimes
- 12:00the employees don't want to clock out, take a
- 12:0230 minute meal break, lose tips, clock back in
- 12:05just for a short period of time before they go
- 12:07home. So keep that in mind. Those waivers are
- 12:10available and it's something employers should
- 12:13be taking a look at. Now, here's why the break
- 12:20cases are worse so much. The premium itself,
- 12:23so just to back up a little bit, the premium
- 12:25payment, if an employee misses a meal or a rest
- 12:30break, the employer owes one hour of the employee's
- 12:34regular rate of pay. per violation, and those
- 12:39should be documented and paid out. Big proponent
- 12:43of employers self -monitoring this and paying
- 12:46out those premium payments if and when meal breaks
- 12:49are missed based on time records. The 30 -minute
- 12:52meal break has to be recorded. The 10 -minute
- 12:54rest break does not have to be recorded. But
- 12:57even when a supervisor knows that it was busy
- 13:01and a 10 -minute rest break couldn't be taken,
- 13:04they need to proactively go out and record that
- 13:07and pay those premium payments to the employees
- 13:10for those missed breaks. I like that because
- 13:13it creates a defensible record that the employers
- 13:15has teeth to their policies and when they knew
- 13:19a break was missed, they did something about
- 13:21it. It's a lot better to defend that type of
- 13:24case than getting a case where the employer hasn't
- 13:29paid any premium payments. And then we've got
- 13:32to make the argument, which probably isn't very
- 13:36realistic that nobody ever missed a 10 minute
- 13:38rest break or a 30 minute meal break in the workplace.
- 13:44So the other issue to watch out here too under
- 13:47the Farah case says that the premium is paid
- 13:50at the regular rate of compensation, including
- 13:53non -discretionary bonuses, not the base hourly
- 13:57rate. So most payroll systems default to the
- 14:00base rate. So audit that setting and make sure
- 14:05that any bonuses that are not discretionary need
- 14:09to be figured into the regular rate of pay. That's
- 14:12an issue we're seeing come up more. regularly
- 14:14here as employers are getting more sophisticated,
- 14:19tracking their meal breaks and their rest breaks
- 14:21and getting their compliance rates really dialed
- 14:23in. The plaintiffs are changing to these different
- 14:26arguments, more technical arguments like the
- 14:28regular rate of pay issue. Then the Naranjo case,
- 14:32the 2022 decision, holds that miss break. premiums
- 14:37are wages. So an unpaid premium triggers derivative
- 14:41waiting time penalties under section 2033, wage
- 14:46statement penalties under section 226. So one
- 14:50missed break becomes three claims plus a potential
- 14:55Paga case. So that's how they stack. And that's
- 14:58why every wage and hour case is not just a break
- 15:02case. We see these derivative claims added to
- 15:05the complaint. So now just to get into a few
- 15:09quick reminders about the meal break timing requirements.
- 15:15This is the brinkered language that I've got
- 15:17here on this slide. So first meal is required
- 15:25no later than the end of the fifth hour. And
- 15:28the second meal break is no later than the end
- 15:30of the 10th hour. So a common violation we see
- 15:34in audits isn't a missed meal break, it's a late
- 15:37one. And the California, and I'll be talking
- 15:41about this here in a minute, doesn't have a de
- 15:43minimis argument available for employers, so
- 15:46it comes down to the minute. We've got to make
- 15:48sure it's at least full 30 minutes that the break
- 15:51has been given to the employee and taken on time.
- 15:59So the lunch starting five hours and 10 minutes
- 16:02isn't a violation even, you know, it comes down
- 16:06to the minute. Five hours and one minute is a
- 16:09violation in the same. So rest break reminders
- 16:13here in this next slide. It's also straight from
- 16:20Brinker. The 10 minutes for shifts of three and
- 16:23a half to six hours. 20 minutes for shifts over
- 16:27six hours up to 10 hours and 30 minutes for shifts
- 16:31over 10 hours. So the wage orders say that employees
- 16:35get the 10 minute rest break for every four hours
- 16:38worked or major fraction thereof. We get a lot
- 16:42of questions from clients. What's this major
- 16:45fraction thereof? What's it mean? Brinker defined
- 16:48this term, major fraction, as exactly what it
- 16:52sounds like, more than half. So half of four
- 16:55hours is two. So a major fraction of four -hour
- 16:59block is anything over two hours. So in other
- 17:02words, once an employee works more than two hours
- 17:05into the next four -hour block, that partial
- 17:08block counts as full. one as a full one and the
- 17:13employee earns a rest break. So, for example,
- 17:16take a six and a half hour shift. That's one
- 17:19full four hour block plus a 2 .5 hour remainder.
- 17:24So the 2 .5 is a major fraction of four. It is.
- 17:29So that's two. And the shift earns two rest breaks.
- 17:33And that's exactly where you see employers sometimes
- 17:37get this wrong. They hear a break every four
- 17:39hours and give the 6 .5 hour employee one break
- 17:43because 6 .5 doesn't contain two four -hour blocks.
- 17:48So the major fraction rule there is why this
- 17:53chart reads the way it does. One break for three
- 17:57and a half hours, two six hours, and two breaks
- 18:02for more than six up to 10, and three for more
- 18:06than 10 up to 14. Great. The next slide. Time
- 18:14records. This is really where we're focused and
- 18:18a lot of attention is given to the time rack
- 18:21records and is key. And I know we all went to
- 18:26law school to stay away from math and Excel,
- 18:29but I'm finding myself getting back into this
- 18:31heavily now with these types of cases. It really
- 18:35comes down to, this is the evidentiary fight
- 18:37in most of these cases. The Donahue case here.
- 18:41that challenged the defense posture, a non -compliant
- 18:46meal punch was either short, late, or missing,
- 18:49raises a rebuttable presumption of a violation
- 18:52at summary judgment and at certification, and
- 18:55rounding can't be applied to meal punches. So
- 18:59no time rounding applied to meal punches was
- 19:02the holding in this Donahue case. So the whole
- 19:05game here is rebuttable evidence. And the toolkit
- 19:10comes down to compliant written policies, signed
- 19:13waivers, those waivers for shifts under six hours
- 19:17if you've got that waiver. Daily attestations,
- 19:21huge benefit for employers to have those daily
- 19:23attestations. Premium payment records showing,
- 19:26again, that you've got teeth to the policy. If
- 19:29you knew the employee missed the meal or rest
- 19:31break, you're paying that premium. And then documenting
- 19:34and following up when an employee says they couldn't
- 19:36take a break. There's another issue to flag for
- 19:40your clients here. Rest breaks don't need to
- 19:42be recorded, as I mentioned. So the plaintiff
- 19:44will claim 100 % violation rate. We typically
- 19:47see that in these types of cases. So with a good
- 19:51policy, good attestation evidence of rest misbreak
- 19:55claim can be discounted heavily at mediation
- 19:58or even throughout the case. So that's where
- 20:01it really comes down to the policy, make sure
- 20:04the clients have good policies. Those are updated.
- 20:07and your managers know how to enforce these policies
- 20:10to what the requirements are. The meal and rest
- 20:16break attestations, just a minute on these. Because
- 20:20the highest leverage document in the toolkit,
- 20:23electronic and daily is the gold standard. The
- 20:25employee confirms at clock out that the breaks
- 20:28are provided is great. It shifts the burden back
- 20:31to the employee if they challenge. the fact that
- 20:35they didn't get their meal arrest breaks after
- 20:37they left employee. Paper is fine here. We get
- 20:41the question a lot. Does it have to be electronic?
- 20:43How often? But the problem with paper, it's hard
- 20:46to track. And it's just really miserable to gather
- 20:50and analyze the paper records in litigation.
- 20:54And it takes a lot of time and costs on that.
- 20:56So we do like electronic, but it's not required.
- 20:59And also weekly or pay period attestations. You
- 21:03need to be careful. Oftentimes in litigation,
- 21:07the plaintiffs attack the pay period attestations
- 21:09by saying the employee felt forced to sign them
- 21:12in order to get paid. So we recommend moving
- 21:15these to off payroll work. weeks, if you're doing
- 21:18it weekly. And then the other key aspect to this
- 21:26is that the employer is actually looking at the
- 21:29attestations. And when an employee says they
- 21:32couldn't take a break, the employer is actually
- 21:34doing something about that, investigating it,
- 21:37doing an individualized assessment. paying the
- 21:39premium if one's owed, and really kind of systematizing
- 21:44it. Worst case scenario, you implement the satestation
- 21:48process. Nobody's watching it. Somebody's saying
- 21:50they missed the meal break and nothing's done.
- 21:53Worst case scenario there. Now moving on to...
- 22:02overtime and regular rate of pay. I've mentioned
- 22:04the regular rate of pay issue already in terms
- 22:06of premium payment, but a couple of things I
- 22:09want to talk about here too. Daily overtime in
- 22:11California is trapped for national employers.
- 22:14Their payroll platform was configured for the
- 22:18FLSA's weekly only overtime in one toggled setting
- 22:21creates a class -wide liability. And when you
- 22:24onboard a multi -state client, This is one issue
- 22:27to take a look at. The other issue here that
- 22:30I'm seeing a lot as employers are moving to electronic
- 22:33timekeeping systems and software to help do these
- 22:37calculations, the backend on that software has
- 22:42different toggles for the client to click. And
- 22:45these payroll providers are working multi -state
- 22:48across the country. And I've seen it where Yeah,
- 22:53one location or one area for whatever reason.
- 22:57the daily overtime toggle was turned off for
- 23:00that one location, and they have multiple locations
- 23:03throughout California. So the software is adding
- 23:06another level of complexity that employers need
- 23:09to make sure that everything's turned on properly
- 23:11across their California workforce. So it's something
- 23:14to audit, and it's one little thing that's really
- 23:17hard to catch, but it can create major liability
- 23:20if it's not being looked at and audited on a
- 23:24regular basis. And then second here, I want to
- 23:27talk about the regular rate. The Alvarado case,
- 23:30the flat -sum bonuses divided by non -overtime
- 23:34hours is California's method, not the federal
- 23:37method. So anything non -discretionary flows
- 23:39into the rate. Attendance bonus, shift the differentials,
- 23:44commissions. Regular rate errors are quiet. Key
- 23:50claims for these types of cases. So these non
- 23:56discretionary bonuses need to be figured into
- 24:00the regular rate of pay and then the Alvarado
- 24:03case. answered a narrow but expensive payroll
- 24:09math question that when an employee earns a flat
- 24:13sum bonus in a payroll period, in that case,
- 24:16it was a $15 attendance bonus for completing
- 24:19a weekend shift. How does that bonus factor into
- 24:22the regular rate for calculating overtime? The
- 24:25holding here was that the employer has to get
- 24:29to the per hour value of the flat sum bonus by
- 24:33dividing the bonus by the employees' non -overtime
- 24:37hours actually worked in the paid period, not
- 24:40by the total hours, including overtime. That's
- 24:43the federal FLSA method. So the employee gets
- 24:481 .5 times that per hour bonus valued for each
- 24:53overtime hour. The court reasoned that the flat
- 24:55sum bonus is fully earned by the straight time
- 24:58worked alone. And the employee gets that the
- 25:02same $15, whether or not they work overtime.
- 25:05So treating overtime hours as part of the divisor
- 25:07in this calculation would dilute the rate. So
- 25:11it's a good audit item. You need to check with
- 25:13the clients of what method they're using and
- 25:16make sure their payroll provider is using this
- 25:18California method. Now, some classification risks.
- 25:26On the exempt side, so for an employee to meet
- 25:30the exempt classification here in California,
- 25:32again, very high level, we generally have to
- 25:35meet two tests, the salary basis and the duties
- 25:40test. So the salary basis, I want to spend a
- 25:42little time on that here this morning, generally
- 25:45is at least twice the state minimum wage, and
- 25:50it's very black or white, the employer's paying
- 25:55it or not. And there's some exceptions to this,
- 25:58but I'll talk about that here in a minute. So
- 26:01January 1st, 2026, the state minimum wage has
- 26:07set the minimum salary for executive, administrative,
- 26:12and professional exemptions generally at $70
- 26:16,304 annually. That's $1 ,352 per week. Twice
- 26:23the state minimum wage currently set at $16 .90
- 26:27per hour. So now in January 1st, 2027, the state
- 26:32minimum wage is going up to $17 .40 an hour.
- 26:36And that's going to further increase the exempt
- 26:38salary threshold. And that's going to increase
- 26:42it from the $70 ,304 annually to $72 ,384 annually.
- 26:50And that breaks down to $1 ,392 per week. So
- 26:55another issue to be flagging for your employer
- 27:00clients here as we go into the new year. Local
- 27:04minimum wages and industry -specific rates, such
- 27:07as the fast food, health care, et cetera, may
- 27:09also affect this analysis. So for example, the
- 27:13fast food industry, we've got AB 1228. that applies
- 27:18to fast food chains with 60 or more locations
- 27:22nationwide. And they've got a separate minimum
- 27:26wage at $20 per hour. This took effect April
- 27:301st, 2024. And the fast food council can increase
- 27:34this rate annually, but we haven't seen an increase
- 27:36from the $20 that was set back in 2024. But the
- 27:40key analysis here, I raise it, is that it sets
- 27:42a different exempt salary threshold for your
- 27:46fast food employers and anybody that's covered
- 27:50by AB 1228. In order to have an employee qualify
- 27:55as an exempt covered employee under one of the
- 27:59exemptions, the minimum annual salary is $83
- 28:03,200 per year. So something key for employers
- 28:07to keep an eye on. knowing their local minimum
- 28:11wage, if that might change it. Generally, the
- 28:13local minimum wages don't. It's set to the state
- 28:16standard. But as I said out in this fast food
- 28:18industry, under AB 1228, there are some exceptions
- 28:22for different employers throughout the state,
- 28:25common too in the healthcare industry, a lot
- 28:27of different exceptions. Now, the second part
- 28:31of the exemption analysis comes down to the duties
- 28:34test, and you need to look at how the employee
- 28:36actually spends their hours. The job description
- 28:39doesn't control. A manager who spends 60 % of
- 28:43the day running the register is non -exempt no
- 28:45matter what their title is. So that's key as
- 28:50well, need to look at what their duties actually
- 28:52are and clearly communicate those duties to the
- 28:56exempt manager and tell them, hey, if you're
- 28:58doing a lot of non -exempt duties, you need to
- 29:01come let us know so we can fix that. Now on the
- 29:04independent contractor side, it's the ABC test.
- 29:08We've got this, the Dynamex case codified in
- 29:13sexual labor code section 2775. And remember
- 29:18what's at stake here, the misclassification.
- 29:21converts every wage obligation into a violation.
- 29:25So that comes down to overtime breaks, wage statements,
- 29:28reimbursements. The whole labor code comes on
- 29:32to a misclassification of an independent contractor.
- 29:36So let me just go over the structural point quickly
- 29:39here about the ABC test and what makes it so
- 29:43hard for employers to comply with this. Under
- 29:47Dynamex and now codified labor code by Every
- 29:52employer is presumed to be an employee, the hiring
- 29:56entity bears the burden of proving independent
- 29:59contractor status, and it has to satisfy all
- 30:02three prongs of the ABC test. Mist prong the
- 30:06worker is an employee and it's not a balancing
- 30:09test It's three hurdles in a row and really the
- 30:12second one is probably the one we see catch most
- 30:14employers So the first prong a is autonomy the
- 30:19worker is free from the control and direction
- 30:21of the hiring entity and Performing the work
- 30:23under both the contract and in fact the contract
- 30:27language saying an independent contractor in
- 30:31calling a worker an independent contractor is
- 30:34close to worthless if a supervisor is directing
- 30:37the daily work. Prom B, the business of the hirer.
- 30:42This is the key one to look at and catches a
- 30:45lot of employers. The worker performs work that
- 30:48is outside the usual course of the hiring entity's
- 30:51business. So this is where it really. focus your
- 30:55time on. It's a classic contrast. A plumber fixing
- 30:59a leak at a retail store is outside the store's
- 31:02usual business. A seamstress sewing dresses at
- 31:05home for a clothing manufacturer is in the manufacturer's
- 31:10business itself and would likely not be an independent
- 31:13contractor. So the worker, if the worker is doing
- 31:16the thing that your client sells, prong B fails
- 31:19and you don't even have to look at prong A or
- 31:22C. They really never come into the analysis.
- 31:26Now prong C is customarily engaged the workers
- 31:30customarily engaged as an independently established
- 31:33trade occupation or business of the same nature
- 31:37So their own business that exists apart from
- 31:39this relationship think of their own clients
- 31:42their own tools a License a business entity their
- 31:46own advertising workers whose business consists
- 31:49entirely of this one hiring working for one one
- 31:54employer Probably fails, prong C. So that's a
- 31:59quick overview of some of the classification
- 32:01on the non -exempt and independent contractor
- 32:05tests. I want to talk about the off the clock
- 32:09and rounding here. I'm going to check on time.
- 32:12I'm running a little behind, so I'll get through
- 32:14this here quickly. Rounding, as I mentioned,
- 32:20the Starbucks case set out that there is no federal
- 32:23de minimis defense here in California. We're
- 32:26down to the minute. And we are watching this
- 32:32case, the Home Depot, the Camp versus Home Depot
- 32:35case here. It's fully briefed. in front of the
- 32:39California Supreme Court about whether time rounding
- 32:41is permissible here in California. We have an
- 32:44older case, the Seas Candy case that said time
- 32:47rounding is permissible in California as long
- 32:50as the rounding goes both ways and it's not just
- 32:53in the employer's favor. I have a feeling, I
- 32:56usually don't go out and predict how the California
- 32:58Supreme Court's gonna decide a case, but I have
- 33:01a feeling. California Supreme Court is going
- 33:03to change the standard and go to no time rounding
- 33:07permitted. We've already seen it in the meal
- 33:09break context, that case I discussed, the Donahue
- 33:13case, where the California Supreme Court said
- 33:16Time rounding is not permitted when you're recording
- 33:18the 30 minute meal break. So I fully expect them
- 33:22to come out and say time rounding is not just
- 33:24permitted with technology, electronic timekeeping
- 33:28systems. No reason to round is generally their
- 33:31analysis that probably is going to carry over
- 33:34from the Donahue case. But we're watching that.
- 33:37But generally I'm telling clients stay away from
- 33:39rounding right now so you don't have to change
- 33:41your policies if and when this decision comes
- 33:43out. in camp, and whether that's retroactive
- 33:47or not too. So a few things to keep your eye
- 33:52on going forward. The record -keeping obligations,
- 33:56key issues here, and I think it's often overlooked
- 33:59by employers in California. They assume that
- 34:04their payroll company is handling this for them,
- 34:08but it's something employers need to get their
- 34:11hands on. And I recommend for my clients to download
- 34:16these records, keep them on your server in the
- 34:19cloud, something that you own, because if you
- 34:21change payroll providers, it's difficult to get
- 34:25those records if... They even exist anymore.
- 34:27A lot of times, these payroll providers, when
- 34:29the employer changes, will just delete all of
- 34:31the files. If the employer didn't back them up
- 34:34themselves, they don't have them. And under the
- 34:36labor code, the employer is required to keep
- 34:39these records themselves. So generally, because
- 34:44these claims can extend back under the unfair
- 34:47competition law to a four -year statute of limitations,
- 34:50we're recommending employers keep these. records,
- 34:54the payroll records, and wage statements going
- 34:57back four years at least. I could see a case
- 35:00being made for longer. And then records requests
- 35:05under Labor Code Section 226. Employers, when
- 35:09these records requests come in, it should flag
- 35:12a few things for employers. One, potential claim
- 35:15coming up. The plaintiff's firm is looking at
- 35:19the records to see if they've got a wage violation
- 35:22potentially. So I generally recommend the employer
- 35:27contact a lawyer, have the lawyer double check
- 35:30these records before turning them over to make
- 35:33sure that there aren't any violations that they
- 35:35need to correct and get on top of. So and we've
- 35:40got some tight timing requirements here too for
- 35:44the record. Records request comes in, employers
- 35:47have 21 days for the payroll records to turn
- 35:50over and 30 days to turn over the personnel file.
- 35:54And generally, too, the other thing that I see
- 35:57from plaintiff's firms on this, they send a letter
- 36:00saying, we're contemplating litigation. You're
- 36:03hereby required to keep all these documents,
- 36:06everything under the sun, and litigation. basically
- 36:11telling the employer, you've got to keep this.
- 36:13If you don't keep all these records, we're going
- 36:14to consider it spoilation if and when we file
- 36:18a lawsuit. Generally, what I like to do is respond
- 36:21to those letters saying exactly what the employer
- 36:24is going to be keeping. And if they disagree
- 36:27with us, they contact us and work that out. Generally,
- 36:31well, I wouldn't even say generally. I don't
- 36:32think I've ever had the plaintiff's firm come
- 36:34back and say, no, you need to keep additional
- 36:36files. And that's helped us when had one arbitration
- 36:41where we went to arbitration. We didn't have
- 36:43files. We said we didn't keep them. Plaintiff
- 36:46was like, no, we asked you to keep all those
- 36:48files. They had to go back to that first letter
- 36:50they sent in this record request saying, well,
- 36:53we told you to keep all these files. We went
- 36:56back to our response saying, no, your request
- 36:58was vague. We told you exactly what we were going
- 37:00to keep. You were supposed to notify us. We were
- 37:02supposed to keep anything else. You didn't. We
- 37:04don't have an obligation to keep the files you're
- 37:05talking about. So something to think about and
- 37:08approach, just don't have a knee -jerk reaction
- 37:11and think it's boilerplate response. Now, the
- 37:15other issue that I'm bringing up here, the wage
- 37:18statement requirements. Again, I get a lot of
- 37:20clients saying, well, this is kind of like minuscule.
- 37:23Why are you asking to see my pay statements?
- 37:27Couple of reasons, it's black or white. The nine
- 37:30required items in their labor code section 226A
- 37:33are set out here on the slide, and it's either
- 37:36on the pay statement or it's not. And so we audit
- 37:40this too for clients. Again, if you change payroll
- 37:43companies, they're getting good at this, but
- 37:45we've seen in the past some payroll companies
- 37:48that are new to California or for whatever reason.
- 37:51didn't have all the required information. And
- 37:53again, the obligation falls on the employer.
- 37:56So take a look at it, good audit point here,
- 38:00and make sure that they're complying with Labor
- 38:02Code Section 226. Now, records as a defense.
- 38:13Again, keeping these records, it's really the...
- 38:20first defense that you've got. And if you don't
- 38:23have the records, time records, the burden really
- 38:26shifts to the employer to prove otherwise from
- 38:30what the employee is saying happened. So again,
- 38:33if you've switched vendors, you need to download,
- 38:36have these records accessible. And I do like
- 38:39them digitally because that's a lot easier to
- 38:41analyze versus. printouts, or manual, or even
- 38:45PDFs. The software's getting better about reading
- 38:48PDFs and analyzing them, but it's key. When a
- 38:53case comes in, the client's normal, first question
- 38:56is, what's my exposure on this? And if it's gonna
- 38:59take two to three months to figure that out,
- 39:01because you've got to go through boxes of records,
- 39:03you're losing time, versus if you've got digital
- 39:06records and you can do that analysis quickly,
- 39:08you're in a lot better position to advise your
- 39:10client. Coming back to Paga for a minute. Under
- 39:20the reform, it restructured the penalties. So
- 39:24the $100 per employee per pay period as the baseline
- 39:27with reduced stacking implemented that with the
- 39:32reform. And then the main thing to take away
- 39:36from the reform, though, is that employers who
- 39:39could establish they took all reasonable steps
- 39:42to comply with the labor code before receiving
- 39:44the Paga notice or records request, the penalties
- 39:47are capped at 15%. of the total penalties. Huge
- 39:51benefit in these cases. And then if you take
- 39:55the reasonable steps after receiving the notice,
- 39:5960 days after the notice, it still gives a cap
- 40:02at 30%. So even if the employers can't establish
- 40:05reasonable steps before the notice, it's important
- 40:08to start doing that right after that notice comes
- 40:10in and drastically limits the liability on these
- 40:14Paga cases. Now, employers to establish the reasonable
- 40:18steps need to be looking at the periodic payroll
- 40:20audits with action items on the results. lawful
- 40:25written policies, training supervisors, and corrective
- 40:28action. That's the key, including discipline
- 40:31of non -compliant supervisors. So two things
- 40:34to stress with clients here. The caps are not
- 40:36automatic. The employers must think about how
- 40:38they're going to prove the reasonable steps.
- 40:40So documentation is evidence and key. And so
- 40:44even if it's just a quick meeting with managers
- 40:46on how to handle these wage and hour issues,
- 40:50breaks, and things like that, document that.
- 40:53An audit that nobody wrote down didn't happen.
- 41:00Now, the Paga penalties. I've got an example
- 41:03here. After the reform and what it can be a huge
- 41:12benefit for employers being able to establish
- 41:15the reasonable steps, as I have set out on the
- 41:17slide. Now, the other issue here that employers
- 41:22need to be thinking about are arbitration agreements
- 41:25with class action waivers. These cases they have
- 41:29here, the Viking River Cruises and Adolf and
- 41:32some US Supreme Court cases have given teeth
- 41:35to the arbitration agreements and they are enforceable
- 41:38in the employment setting and they can contain
- 41:41class action waivers. but they cannot waive the
- 41:44employee's ability to bring a Paga claim. So
- 41:47it's really, and I'll talk about it here in the
- 41:51next slide, the strategy on implementing best
- 41:54practices for employers to reduce their wage
- 41:56and hour exposure is arbitration agreements,
- 42:00enforceable arbitration agreements with the class
- 42:02action waiver, and then taking these reasonable
- 42:04steps to cap those Paga penalties. So, and again,
- 42:14I've talked about these, these pillars for the
- 42:17affirmative, this affirmative defense for the
- 42:19reasonable steps. Key to have employers doing
- 42:25that and to limit their liability on the Paga
- 42:28case. Now, the class action, coming back to this
- 42:34issue, the class action waivers and arbitration
- 42:38agreements, as I mentioned, for larger employers,
- 42:41I think it's probably, I'm not saying it's right
- 42:46for every employer, but probably one of the best
- 42:48leverage. items that they can get is implementing
- 42:51an arbitration agreement with a class action
- 42:53waiver. It eliminates the four -year statute
- 42:56of limitations under the class year, narrows
- 42:59the fight to a one -year Paga period. The statute
- 43:02of limitations under Paga is only one year. And
- 43:05so what the employer does is compel the claim
- 43:08to arbitration have the employee dismiss their
- 43:12class claims, and then you're in arbitration.
- 43:14The employee has to prove that they were injured
- 43:17in order to pursue a Paga case under the reformed
- 43:21Paga. So you've got a shot at trying to win in
- 43:23arbitration. And if you don't win in arbitration,
- 43:28they can prove even just one or two violations.
- 43:30We're only defending the Paga case. And if we
- 43:33could show reasonable steps, that Paga liability
- 43:36is a lot more reduced if we can get that 15%.
- 43:39cap established. And that's really the strategy
- 43:43employers should be thinking about to limit their
- 43:46liability. The Chamber of Commerce case that
- 43:51I have mentioned here on this slide, AB 51, it
- 43:55was regarding California, the law that said mandatory
- 44:00arbitration agreements are not, are void of their
- 44:04California law. That was challenged, went up
- 44:06to the Ninth Circuit. So mandatory arbitration
- 44:09agreements are permissible under this ruling.
- 44:13But generally, I've been telling clients, look,
- 44:16you could still make them voluntary. Most employees
- 44:19don't opt out of it. If a few do, that's fine.
- 44:22And it gives a little easier argument when you're
- 44:27moving to compel arbitration that it's a voluntary
- 44:30agreement and a few people have opted out. So
- 44:33if you've got any questions on that, feel free
- 44:35to talk to me. Happy to discuss that. So the
- 44:41first 60 days after a claim comes in, we've talked
- 44:44about this here a little bit. about the caps
- 44:47employers need to be looking at that. So key
- 44:51here is what I generally lean on and look for
- 44:54is getting an early exposure analysis off the
- 44:57client's own data. So you really know the violation
- 45:00rate before any kind of mediation, any kind of
- 45:04settlement discussions, and it sets up the strategies
- 45:06on how you're going to defend that case. And
- 45:10remember the two year average timeline. And I'm
- 45:16recommending employers try to get these cases
- 45:18into an early mediation. It's going to cut off
- 45:21that statute of limitations period, because it's
- 45:24ongoing as the case is going. And you're pushing
- 45:30for this early resolution. You're learning your
- 45:33defenses and setting up the case earlier. And
- 45:37even if you can't get it resolved early, you've
- 45:39done a lot of the work early in the case, and
- 45:42it tees up the strategy. For the case going forward
- 45:46now, moving on the terminations here. The reminder
- 45:55California's that will under 2922, but the case,
- 46:01like, as shows the practic. Practical erosion
- 46:05of the at -will doctrine here in California.
- 46:08There's a lot of different implied contract theories,
- 46:10and of course, at -will will never excuse a termination
- 46:13that violates FIHA or public policy. And then
- 46:17the retaliation claims are where the burdens
- 46:19get dangerous here, too. FIHA retaliation runs
- 46:23through the McDonnell Douglas under the Janowitz
- 46:26case held at, but whistleblower claims under
- 46:2911 .02 .5 run through the Lawson case held that
- 46:36contributing factor causation and the employer
- 46:39must respond with clear and convincing evidence.
- 46:42So it's really harder at summary judgment to
- 46:45get these types of retaliation claims out. And
- 46:49then the newest layer, we've got SB 497. For
- 46:54an adverse action within 90 days of a protected
- 46:57activity is presumptively retaliatory under California
- 47:01law. that 90 -day window makes the pre -termination
- 47:05file review even that more important. And it
- 47:10leads to the next slide here about documentation
- 47:12as evidence. You need to document the true reason
- 47:20at the time of the termination. The classic mistake
- 47:23is calling for a for -cause termination, a layoff,
- 47:27as a layoff to be kind to the employee. And they
- 47:29think the employer is doing the employee a favor
- 47:32when they're doing that. But this kindness becomes
- 47:35the case. And when the story challenges that
- 47:39in litigation, the inconsistency becomes pretext
- 47:42evidence. you need to have concrete conduct over
- 47:47conclusions. So the classic example I usually
- 47:50point to is documenting bad attitude that's really
- 47:53useless. You need to have documentation such
- 47:56as three documented instances on these dates
- 47:59the employee was late or spoke back to their
- 48:02manager with this said this when they're confronted
- 48:05about an issue. That wins motions. Before any
- 48:09termination, a red flag review of the file, recent
- 48:13protected leave, wage complaints, accommodation
- 48:16requests, workers comp claims. And if a red flag
- 48:20exists, document why the reason is independent
- 48:23of it. Note who made the decision. The same actor
- 48:26inference is a great defense. So if the employer
- 48:29knew about the disability or protected classification
- 48:33when they hired the employee but are making the
- 48:36decision to terminate the employee, you've got
- 48:39the same actor inference. Inconsistency, change
- 48:42of relationship form. You need to have the same
- 48:45reason listed on all these forms. Change of relationship
- 48:48form to the employee at the time of the termination,
- 48:51as well as the termination letter, any EDD responses.
- 48:56And then if it comes to deposition testimony,
- 48:58you've got to be consistent. Then if you're changing
- 49:00your story on that, it creates issues. I see
- 49:05a question came in here too. What is the typical
- 49:09corrective action for employers when an audit
- 49:12finds violation prior to any lawsuits? provide
- 49:17back pay potentially. So it gets tricky and it
- 49:22depends on what the violation is. But I like
- 49:25to see some action taken as opposed to no action.
- 49:29But the trick is there too, and it comes up when
- 49:33under the reformed Paga, there's some certain
- 49:36labor code violations that can be cured by the
- 49:39employer, but the cure procedure is not easy.
- 49:43You need to go back potentially three years and
- 49:46fix the issue. So you're dealing with former
- 49:49employees you need to rectify these issues with.
- 49:52Pay them back pay, pay them interest on that
- 49:55money, correct all the wage statements and it
- 49:59becomes very burdensome and you've got the short
- 50:01window of time to do it. So it's something to
- 50:04think about if it's like a blatant violation,
- 50:06black or white employer just didn't do it and
- 50:09you think you can correct it, got to get on that
- 50:11early. But it becomes a lot of work because you're
- 50:15dealing with these former employees and dealing
- 50:19with a lot of different issues on that. So that's
- 50:22good. Great. One other question came in. I guess
- 50:27I'll deal with it. Talk of the questions here.
- 50:31The private security industry, what if the client
- 50:34wants an employee removed from a site but they're
- 50:37not? technically terminated from a company? Good
- 50:41question. So employers, and I'll talk about that
- 50:44here as we're coming into the end about some
- 50:47reasonable accommodations as well. This same
- 50:49issue comes up. But just if you don't have work
- 50:53for the employee, it doesn't mean you have to
- 50:56terminate them, especially if it's like this
- 51:00ad hoc, it will give you work when it comes up,
- 51:03you're available. So this week we've got these
- 51:07security needs events for you to work and then
- 51:11we'll see and it changes. You don't necessarily
- 51:14have to terminate the employee when they're removed
- 51:19from one if you've got expected work coming up,
- 51:22but it's something to take a look at and be careful
- 51:24about. This came up in the entertainment industry
- 51:27where it Actors were hired just for one day of
- 51:32recording a commercial and they they made the
- 51:36argument and the argument prevailed to the most
- 51:39part that at the end of that day they were terminated.
- 51:42They were owed all their final wages at that
- 51:45time because the timing requirements for final
- 51:47pay, which I'll talk about here in the next slide.
- 51:50So it's something to think about and have that
- 51:53clearly set out and just don't go about this
- 51:57like. and figure out later, you need to think
- 52:01about it. It's a good question. And yeah, I could
- 52:03tell you're thinking about it, but talk to a
- 52:06council about it. There's a lot of different
- 52:07issues, but it is potential to have that employee
- 52:10stay on as an employee. And you don't have to
- 52:14terminate them at the end of every work. If it's
- 52:17expected, they're gonna be working with you going
- 52:19forward. So I've got on this slide, some final
- 52:23pay and timing considerations. as well. Simple
- 52:29rules, but it becomes hard. One issue that I
- 52:34see here are foreign players that are based out
- 52:37of the state. They're doing a termination here
- 52:40in California. The location here in California
- 52:43can't cut the final paycheck at the time of termination.
- 52:48So it needs to be planned and advanced. And if
- 52:50you're going to terminate somebody, it has to
- 52:52be immediately provided to that employee. And
- 52:55another issue here is the direct deposit. Just
- 53:00because the employee has direct deposit set up,
- 53:02the final paycheck, you need another fresh written
- 53:05authorization. for the final paycheck to be issued
- 53:09to the employee by direct deposit. But it could
- 53:11be an email, a text, something like that to the
- 53:14employee. Hey, do you just want that direct,
- 53:16we can do it direct deposit if you'd like. Yep,
- 53:20and so the final pay as a reminder has to include
- 53:23all earned wages and accrued an unused vacation
- 53:27in this final pay as well. Yep, so plan for that
- 53:34with the termination. Now the flip side of it,
- 53:37let's say the employer just can't get that final
- 53:39paycheck to the employee when they terminated
- 53:41them. You've got this waiting time penalties
- 53:44at the rate, the employee's regular daily rate
- 53:48for every day that you're late on the payment.
- 53:50So if it just. physically impossible to get that
- 53:53final paycheck to them, you can add that to the
- 53:56payment when you issue that final paycheck to
- 53:59the employee. But it's something that adds up
- 54:01quickly, you know, at 30 days that waiting time
- 54:04penalties under Labor Code Section 203 is capped
- 54:08at 30 days. But as in this example, I've got
- 54:12set out on this slide at $200 a day for an employee.
- 54:16It could be $4 ,000 for the employee. So make
- 54:21sure you're on that and dealing with that. Great.
- 54:26So final pay reminders. I wanted to mention severance
- 54:30here as well. I've got a few other reminders.
- 54:33I'll make these slides available about the final
- 54:35pay tips for those of you in the restaurant industry
- 54:40are not required to be on the final paycheck,
- 54:42but it's a good practice to include that. But
- 54:45it's really the wages that are accrued that are
- 54:49owed on the final pay. So severance, good to
- 54:54keep in mind. And we get this question a lot.
- 54:57If it's a difficult termination, you expect litigation
- 55:00from the employee. It's good to be thinking about
- 55:03severance and having this ready to go, a standard
- 55:07severance agreement. So normally the attorneys
- 55:11get these calls the day before or even the day
- 55:14of or letting somebody go. And it's a little
- 55:17tricky. Should we offer severance? Yes, we should.
- 55:20What form do you have? What can you give? not
- 55:26hard forms out there and said that but employees
- 55:29the attorneys need to think this through how
- 55:31it's set and it does change from time to time
- 55:34so we've got different different severance agreements
- 55:36set up that we can provide to employees and as
- 55:40I've got set out on this slide for the age discrimination
- 55:44claims under the OW BPA, for anybody that's 40
- 55:50or older, you've got to have this 21 -day consideration
- 55:54period and a seven -day revocation period for
- 55:56those employees to release those age claims and
- 56:01have that set out and thought through. But a
- 56:05good tool for employers to have the severance
- 56:08as an option when they're letting employees go.
- 56:13Great. Moving on to... disability claims here
- 56:17as we get towards the end in the last little
- 56:21block that I wanted to cover today. Disability
- 56:24is consistently at the top of the FIHA filing
- 56:27statistics. And why is that? You start with the
- 56:30standard. FIHA requires only that a condition
- 56:33that limits a major life of life activity was
- 56:37much broader than the ADA, the federal substantially
- 56:40limit standard. So more conditions qualify here
- 56:44in California than under federal law. The one
- 56:47fact pattern produces three claims. Discrimination
- 56:51under discrimination can lead to failure to accommodate,
- 56:57can lead to just a discrimination claim, and
- 57:00also lead to failure to engage in the interactive
- 57:03process. So the key point for defense counsel
- 57:07is that these are all independent claims. They
- 57:09survive, even if the discrimination claim fails,
- 57:12there could be a failure to engage in the interactive
- 57:15process. So the typical posture is an employee
- 57:19on leave, or an employee with restrictions who
- 57:23gets terminated and the accommodation claim carries
- 57:26the weight on a wrongful termination claim. So
- 57:28you need to be thinking about these independently
- 57:30and it just doesn't end too. We see a lot of
- 57:35employers get confused because their leave expires.
- 57:38They think they can let them go. We still need
- 57:40to consider reasonable accommodations and then
- 57:43extended leave of absence past protected leave
- 57:47of absence could be a form of reasonable accommodation
- 57:49as well. Now, can it be an indefinite leave?
- 57:55If the employee is like, no, I don't know when
- 57:56I can return, the employer doesn't have to keep
- 57:58that position open forever. But if it's for a
- 58:01week or two, potentially that could be a reasonable
- 58:03accommodation that the employer has to give to
- 58:06the employee. That's the Hanson v. Lucky stores
- 58:09that I have set out on this slide. A lot of different
- 58:13things the employers need to be considering the
- 58:16vacant positions. There's no duty to create new
- 58:19positions, displace others or promote employees
- 58:22as a reasonable accommodation, but any other
- 58:25vacant positions. And my standard to what I like
- 58:29to see employers do is offer these positions
- 58:31to the employee, have the employees say, no,
- 58:33I'm not interested. And that's clear. That's
- 58:36going to be a lot harder for the employee to
- 58:38come back later saying, hey, you didn't offer
- 58:40me any accommodations. The employer can point
- 58:42to all these records saying, we offered you all
- 58:44these other positions. You said, no, didn't leave
- 58:46us with any other options at that point. The
- 58:49other issue here too is that 100 % healed policy
- 58:52where the employee, the employer says you have
- 58:55to be 100 % before you get back. Not a good policy
- 58:58to have. Again, reasonable accommodation is the
- 59:02key and you need to engage in the interactive
- 59:05process of what that might look like and talk
- 59:08to the employee about that. Now, the interactive
- 59:13process is triggered. No magic words are required
- 59:17by the employee. If they give you an indication
- 59:21that they might have a medical issue, a disability,
- 59:24that they're out of work for, the employer's
- 59:27on notice. And it triggers this obligation. So
- 59:33it needs to be timely, good faith, and ongoing.
- 59:36have to be a single meeting. It could be a series
- 59:40of letters. I generally like to have letters
- 59:43asking the employee to talk to their doctor and
- 59:46give a note from the doctor, not asking for what
- 59:48their medical condition is, but can they do the
- 59:51essential functions of the job. And that's really
- 59:53where it's key to have the job duties set out
- 59:57in advance before you get to that. So you can
- 1:00:00hand over the job description with those duties
- 1:00:03and have the employee take that to their doctor
- 1:00:05to say, can they do that? And really documenting
- 1:00:10this, showing the employer did. a lot of things,
- 1:00:14a lot of different considerations as potential
- 1:00:18accommodations going to really flip these cases
- 1:00:20in favor of the employer. So that basically gets
- 1:00:27through. We're right at 11. If there's any other
- 1:00:29questions, happy to talk through any questions.
- 1:00:33I've got some ways to stay in contact with me
- 1:00:36here too. I write weekly at the California Employment
- 1:00:40Law Report, legal updates, and some other business
- 1:00:43content. We're doing videos on YouTube at the
- 1:00:49Employment Law Report. The Legal Lineup is our
- 1:00:52YouTube channel. And we put our podcasts up there
- 1:00:55too. So if you have any questions, you can stay
- 1:00:57in contact with me. Happy to... connect with
- 1:01:00anybody on LinkedIn as well. But if we've got
- 1:01:03any questions, we got through most of those during
- 1:01:05the presentation. I don't think we have any others.
- 1:01:09And we just went one minute over. So I think
- 1:01:12we could wrap it up here if that's all we've
- 1:01:15got. Looks like we don't have any more questions.
- 1:01:20This concludes today's presentation. Thank you
- 1:01:22so much Anthony for a fantastic presentation
- 1:01:25today and thank you so much to our audience for
- 1:01:27joining us. Have a great day everybody. Thank
- 1:01:30you.