Latest / Newcomer Pod / The Secret to Raising $9B
Transcript
- 0:00What does it take to be a mega fund in the world of venture
- 0:03capital? Today, we're talking about a
- 0:05mega fund. You may never have heard of
- 0:07Lightspeed Venture Partners, who have done a terrific job of
- 0:10flying under the radar despite raising $9 billion alongside
- 0:15some strong exits this year. In this episode, we're going to
- 0:18dive into what makes a mega fund using the example of Lightspeed.
- 0:22We'll look at their business model, the startups they're
- 0:24invested in, the IPOs that they're leading, and how they're
- 0:27seeing significant growth while seemingly spitting in the face
- 0:31of the AI bubble. But first, we're going to
- 0:33discuss the new developments in the relationship between Amazon
- 0:37and open AI and the shifting allegiances in AI.
- 0:40This is the newcomer podcast. There, there, there was a time
- 0:52where you one of the most exciting things that could have
- 0:55happened but didn't happen in Silicon Valley would be that
- 0:58Amazon would buy Anthropic. Amazon, you know, a big cloud
- 1:03service provider invested in Anthropic doesn't seem to have
- 1:07figured out foundation models. But we've really put a nail in
- 1:12the coffin, I think this week of that idea.
- 1:16Amazon just turned around and struck a huge deal with open AI.
- 1:22Tom, you cover these cloud companies, the foundation models
- 1:27and the deals. They're striking, Yeah.
- 1:29What do you what do you make of Amazon's decision to strike an
- 1:33enormous deal with Open AI? Yeah.
- 1:36Well, we should have some caution here that it's just sort
- 1:38of in discussions right now. So I don't know if it's.
- 1:40In talks, it hasn't closed yet. Yeah.
- 1:43But I mean, the origins of this basically was a couple of months
- 1:47ago, Amazon and Open AI announced that they had signed a
- 1:52multi billion dollar cloud computing deal with AWS where it
- 1:55was going to be hosting some of Open AI models on AWS.
- 1:58And it was sort of the first big non Microsoft deal that Open AI
- 2:02struck once it got out of it it's exclusivity agreement.
- 2:06And, you know, in case you were worried after Amazon and Open AI
- 2:10struck a deal that it wasn't circular enough, fear not, fear
- 2:14not. And, you know, people always
- 2:16wonder with Open AI, how are you going to pay for it?
- 2:19The answer is more money from the cloud computing companies
- 2:21that they work with. So it looks like Open AI is in
- 2:25talks to get around $10 billion, maybe more from AWS.
- 2:29And, you know, just to, like, take some pride in the way this
- 2:33is all progressed. We did a story, I think it was a
- 2:35newsletter item a couple of weeks ago, where I talked about
- 2:39how Amazon had really started to shift away from its anthropic
- 2:43relationship, that for a time anthropic models were the Amazon
- 2:47bet, and that was the way it was discussed internally.
- 2:49I was told Jeff Bezos was going around talking about anthropic
- 2:52as the Amazon bet, and it's clear that they have shifted
- 2:56allegiances a little bit behind the scenes.
- 2:58When I wrote that, AWS was very upset with me and they said that
- 3:03to say that Anthropic is no longer, you know, our big bet
- 3:06and one we're committed to was absolutely wrong.
- 3:08And they pointed to all these press releases that Anthropic
- 3:10would make claiming that, you know, you know, Anthropic is
- 3:13still our primary provider. Sorry, AWS is still our primary
- 3:16provider and we use their chips. Yeah, that's clearly changed.
- 3:20That's that's no longer the case.
- 3:21There's been a. Shift there.
- 3:22Yeah. And, and I think as you wrote at
- 3:25the time, that newsletter item, like I think there's been
- 3:27shifting allegiances across the tech world where once Microsoft
- 3:31was the exclusive provider for open AI and then they've
- 3:34invested or planned to invest billions of dollars into
- 3:37Anthropic. Amazon obviously made their big
- 3:39play with Anthropic. Now they seem a lot more
- 3:41attached to open AI. Google is kind of relatively
- 3:45neutral, but more focused on their own models.
- 3:47And I think it just goes to show that there is just such an
- 3:51insane need for compute right now and an overall belief in AI
- 3:55that there's no reason to pick a horse.
- 3:57You really kind of just need to bet on the industry at large and
- 4:01just take as much money and give as much money to keep it going.
- 4:04Amazon's also trying to get Open AI to use its chips here, right?
- 4:07Yeah, that's part of the deal. Amazon is building chips that
- 4:11they want open AI to be using to diversify off of NVIDIA GPUs.
- 4:16Also in Anthropic deals of AI world too, they announced a
- 4:21couple months ago a deal with Google to use Google's chips.
- 4:24So Google is has a partnership with Anthropic as well in this
- 4:28even beyond, you know, focusing mostly on and their internal
- 4:31products they do have some ties to.
- 4:33Anthropic, maybe Anthropic somewhat jilted Amazon first by
- 4:37doing stuff. With Google, a Google deal.
- 4:39So then we have to circle back around here, yeah.
- 4:42Yeah. Well, but also keep in mind that
- 4:44Google had already invested money in Anthropic before that.
- 4:48They're they're they're a significant investor.
- 4:49And I actually, my understanding is that most Anthropic training
- 4:54and inferencing, at least training I know is done on TP us
- 4:58on Google's chips. So there was already like a deep
- 5:01relationship there. I mean, the fact with Amazon is
- 5:03that they're kind of like the rich kid that has to buy their
- 5:06friends. No one likes their chips.
- 5:09They just aren't very good. I'm sorry.
- 5:10I'll, I'll, I'll, I'll say this strongly on the podcast.
- 5:13I'll have anyone come in here and disagree with me, But every
- 5:15conversation that I've had with people in the space says that
- 5:18like the Tranium and Inferencia chips that that Amazon makes are
- 5:21like a huge tier below certainly Nvidia's chips, but also
- 5:26Google's Tpus. And so they got to, they got to
- 5:28get people to use them somehow. And $10 billion is not a
- 5:31terrible way to do it. And if there's a core financial
- 5:34engineering risk with AI, it's that I invest in you and then
- 5:42you use that investment to do me a partial favor by pretending
- 5:46like there's enthusiasm for my product, even though there isn't
- 5:50really enthusiasm, right? So in the case of chips I Amazon
- 5:55invest in, you open AI and then you turn around and use my
- 6:00chips, show a little enthusiasm, and then maybe I get a market
- 6:04premium on my stock. My stock goes up.
- 6:07That's great for everybody, you know, everybody involved and,
- 6:11and who cares, right? And similarly this, you know,
- 6:15this is the cynical case. The cloud companies benefit from
- 6:18open AI, anthropic, etcetera, spending on these enormous
- 6:22training runs, right? So they want to keep this
- 6:25foundation model game going and so keep the money going there
- 6:28also so it can turn around and spend, spend money on on us.
- 6:33So there's definitely, you know, this cynical argument that
- 6:37foundation models like Open AI and Anthropic are so valuable in
- 6:41part because the people investing them want them to be,
- 6:44you know, because they're, they're big, they're big
- 6:46customers and they're validating a lot of the products they're
- 6:50creating. And This is why to me, this is
- 6:52the bull case for Google, because Google's on both sides
- 6:55of it. If you think foundation models
- 6:57are going to be revolutionary and not only revolutionary but
- 7:00capture a lot of the economic value of what happens in AI,
- 7:03Google has Gemini. If you don't and you think all
- 7:06these models are sort of ludicrously spending on training
- 7:10runs that are just like lining the pockets of cloud providers,
- 7:14well, Google has one of those too.
- 7:15So I I think, yeah, good to be in both camps.
- 7:20Yeah, they have the chips, they have the models, they have the
- 7:23customers and they can force these AI models down the throats
- 7:26of these customers by putting it in all the different, you know,
- 7:29crevices of their products. Sorry as a gross image but I
- 7:34think like you know, this all leads to what I thought was a
- 7:37fucking hilarious video that Greg Brockman the Co founder of
- 7:42Open AI just made where he, I don't even know what it was for.
- 7:46But it's basically this video where he talks about the
- 7:49importance of compute and is like as time goes on we just
- 7:52need more and more compute. The funnier part of this video
- 7:55to me was him saying at first we tried other ways to build our
- 7:58models. Open AI did not set out with a
- 8:02thesis. The compute was the path to
- 8:04progress. It's that we tried everything
- 8:06else and the thing that worked was compute.
- 8:09We really wanted to find another way to grow our company without
- 8:12just demanding multi $100 billion of compute deals, but we
- 8:15can't. This is what it is.
- 8:17So please, it's like a, it's like APSA.
- 8:19It was like for only a dollar a day he was getting.
- 8:21Quirky with it, you know, he was doing like a oh, how do we do it
- 8:26kind of tone. I don't know.
- 8:27Yeah. It was for only for only a
- 8:29dollar a day. You too can keep Open AI afloat
- 8:32and give us the compute that we need.
- 8:33Please reach deep if you have GPUs, if you have GB 2 hundreds,
- 8:37if you have anything that you or your friends might have, please
- 8:39donate them to Open AI because that's what we need to keep
- 8:42going. I don't know what the fuck this
- 8:44video was. I don't know who it was for.
- 8:46I honestly, if you start to look back at this era from 10-15
- 8:50years from now, if it does happen to go sideways or doesn't
- 8:52turn out the way people expected, this video is going to
- 8:54be one of them. To me, that's just like, what
- 8:56were we thinking? How do we not understand that
- 8:59there was like something slightly concerning at the core
- 9:01of the way these companies run? To be clear, my point of view
- 9:04remains that we are imbuing everything with the capacity to
- 9:08be intelligent and there's going to be a huge market for that.
- 9:11And as they get more and more intelligent, they're going to
- 9:14get even more valuable. But what that what that means
- 9:17for the near term value of open AI, I've no idea, you know, glad
- 9:22that's not my job to figure out. But I do think these things all
- 9:27come back to the actual your belief on the value that AI is
- 9:31creating or not, right. If it's creating a lot of value,
- 9:34then makes sense to build chips and spend money on chips.
- 9:38It makes sense to to these huge training runs.
- 9:41But yeah, and I'll be fair to Brockman in his argument was
- 9:46that like, our products are so successful, they're in such
- 9:49demand that we need compute to be able to provide power to it,
- 9:53that, you know, we can build more of them because people want
- 9:55them so much. It's not that speculative.
- 9:57It's like we need this now. It's for our products to work.
- 10:00My only counter to that would be like what products outside of
- 10:03Chachi PT, you know, like you? Know you do these training runs
- 10:09and then everybody catches up with you tomorrow.
- 10:13Right. Well, I think that's also
- 10:14that's, that's the that's the business question that is
- 10:18completely separate from the value that AI, this technology
- 10:21creates and is transformational technology.
- 10:23I think we're all in agreement here that it is very useful and
- 10:26is very impressive and there is a ton of utility for it.
- 10:29But where the business Moat lands and how these deals as
- 10:33they are structured financially work out, that remains a little
- 10:37bit still murky. And and as you'll see in the
- 10:40segment coming up, that's why they need all the money.
- 10:42That's what the money is for, is to make the compute pay for the
- 10:46compute that open AI so desperately needs, and so
- 10:49everything has to be mega sized from that.
- 10:52Up next, we talked about Lightspeeds $9 billion
- 10:55fundraising as a venture capital firm, so we'll dig into that.
- 10:58Stay tuned. Hey folks, I'm Omar, product and
- 11:01design lead at Google DeepMind. Have you ever wanted to build an
- 11:04app for yourself, your friends, or finally launched that side
- 11:07project you've been dreaming about?
- 11:09Now you can bring any idea to life, no coding background
- 11:11required, with Gemini 3 and Google AI Studio.
- 11:15It's called Vibe Coding and we're making it dead simple.
- 11:18Just describe your app and Gemini will wire up the right
- 11:20models for you so you can focus on your creative vision.
- 11:23Head to AI dot studio slash build to create your first app.
- 11:28We're about to talk about the biggest, most important venture
- 11:32capital firm that maybe you've never heard of.
- 11:34Depends how much of an insider you are.
- 11:37Lightspeed Venture Partners just raised $9 billion, which even in
- 11:44the world of venture, where we get numb to big pools of money,
- 11:49this is a venture firm with a lot of money to invest in
- 11:52startups. Here at Newcomer, we have
- 11:55published some of Lightspeed old performance numbers, so we have
- 12:00a good sense of what companies they're investing in.
- 12:03That gives the limited partners that back venture capital firms
- 12:06the confidence to re up with Lightspeed.
- 12:09And Madeline has been doing some reporting on Lightspeed to
- 12:13understand this latest fundraising can help breakdown
- 12:17all the numbers. And Tom will weigh in with his
- 12:20spicy quips as. Tom can weigh in with his
- 12:23hottest takes. I can I can really dig in on
- 12:26Lightspeed circa 2016. Yeah, exactly.
- 12:29You cared a lot. I mean, so if you if you are not
- 12:32in the venture business, you might have heard of Lightspeed
- 12:34because they were a big investor in Snapchat.
- 12:37Jeremy Liu, who we all know invested in Snapchat then I
- 12:42think as Tom helped brake had a falling out with lightspeed
- 12:46right? Did you break that story?
- 12:47I. Actually didn't break that
- 12:49story. It was it was our departed
- 12:51former Co host on Dead Cat, Katie Benner, which is a real
- 12:54blast. Really.
- 12:55Oh my God, I forgot. Yeah, it was a very different
- 12:57era where the New York Times would have written a story about
- 13:00like a fallout between a founder and the whole.
- 13:04I mean, we can we should get to your story, Madeline.
- 13:05But if you really want to a trip down memory lane, the whole
- 13:08history between Lightspeed and Snapchat is a very interesting
- 13:10one. Not even just the falling out,
- 13:12but the, the way that they made that investment.
- 13:13So we can we can talk about that then, but it's like a very.
- 13:16Different circle back to that. Yeah, it's a very different
- 13:18light speed was and is mostly a firm that invests in
- 13:24enterprises, businesses selling to other businesses.
- 13:28There are exceptions. They're a big investor in a
- 13:31firm. Max Levchin's payment advance
- 13:35company, but a lot of the big investments are firms like
- 13:39Grafana and Navon and fair, you know, it's sort of are, are the
- 13:44backbone of or not consumer facing companies.
- 13:48Right. Well, Lightspeed, I think you
- 13:50know, wants to be known for their enterprise deals more
- 13:54their their ties to Snapchat, cover the press.
- 13:57And so people think of them as a consumer first fund and they're
- 13:59quick to tell you no, we do enterprise deals.
- 14:02And to their credit, they had significant IPOs in the last two
- 14:07years. They had, they were big backers
- 14:09of Rubric, Netscope and Navon, which all went public in this
- 14:13time of IPO drought recently. So they've had big exits in the
- 14:17last couple years, which is impressive.
- 14:19You know, if you say they're the firm that flies under the radar,
- 14:22they're returning money back to their LP's, which is great when
- 14:24you're fundraising. Madeline, you want to break down
- 14:26this $9 billion fundraise and give us a sense of where all the
- 14:30money's gonna go? So this $9 billion fundraise is
- 14:33broken up across six different vehicles.
- 14:37It's all kind of multiple funds under this one umbrella to hit
- 14:40the $9 billion total. But the two, the early stage
- 14:43fund is kind of split into Lightspeed 15-A and 15-B.
- 14:48And the way you can think about that is 15 A.
- 14:50What marketing geniuses? They've got a number and they've
- 14:53got a naming scheme like Sony headphones here.
- 14:56Yeah. Well, 15-A is 980 million and
- 15:00like the title says, it is for seed up to Series A, maybe a
- 15:04smaller B deal. Lightspeed B is for is $1.2
- 15:08billion and that is going to go to things that are more entering
- 15:12product market. 5th growth Series B onward side.
- 15:15However, it's not the growth fund.
- 15:18It's just like in the age of AI, these series BS and Series A's
- 15:22and billion dollar seed rounds, they wanted a lot of capital to
- 15:26be able to properly allocate in these rounds and double down on
- 15:29concentrated bets. And when that moves earlier and
- 15:31earlier with these AI rounds that everyone wants in, they
- 15:35wanted capital for those two, wanted capital back those.
- 15:38So that's how those are structured, the select those.
- 15:42Are two earlier stages. So those are the 2 early funds.
- 15:45There's also Lightspeed Select four and Lightspeed Opportunity
- 15:49Fund three select four, A $1.8 billion fund that is for
- 15:54doubling down on bets that they want to get a higher ownership
- 15:58share in that are more growth stage.
- 16:02So think of it as a kind of medium growth fund.
- 16:05And then opportunity funds have been actually the past
- 16:09opportunity funds was where they first backed Anthropic because
- 16:11they did not get into Anthropic until the Series D, but then
- 16:16they ended up Co leading and then leading later Anthropic
- 16:20rounds as they kept raising. So they did get a larger
- 16:23ownership share later on, but that's what the opportunity fund
- 16:26would be for to double. Right now seem like great
- 16:28investments. I know they've been marked up a
- 16:30lot. There's been, you know, this
- 16:31chatter in the zeitgeist right now about like, if you're not in
- 16:35these key AI deals, you're failing behind, but they're
- 16:39mostly mentioning, you know, Cursor Mercor, Open AI,
- 16:43Lightspeed is not necessarily in those companies, but they are a
- 16:49pretty significant shareholder in Anthropic, which for as you
- 16:51can tell by now on this podcast, we're kind of fans of anthropics
- 16:54style at this point, you could say in how they they do things.
- 16:58And it's a it's a strong growing business with top models.
- 17:01So the two new funds they raised with this fundraise are the
- 17:04Lightspeed Co investment fund, which is about $600 million and
- 17:08a single investor vehicle that was $1.25 billion.
- 17:12Those exist for existing LP's to tack on more money to double
- 17:18down on specific bets so in and those basically exist because of
- 17:23how big AI rounds are getting. There are certain LP's who want
- 17:26to have even more exposure to top AI deals and those funds
- 17:31exist so they can opt in to give Lightspeed even more money on
- 17:35ones that they think Lightspeed has an advantage of getting into
- 17:37further rounds on and getting additional ownership.
- 17:40So those are what those two additional structures are, which
- 17:42total it up to $9 billion, which is pretty hefty fundraising.
- 17:46What was one of them? So sorry, One of them is a
- 17:48sidecar. There are two kind of sidecars.
- 17:52Like are these real funds? These are real funds, but they
- 17:56basically exist because certain LP's wanted to double down more
- 18:02on later stage deals and it's a way of balancing the pro rata
- 18:06rights in those deals to where the LP's wanted to participate
- 18:09more. So all the.
- 18:10Different terms across some of the, you know, some of the more
- 18:13favorable. To but you have to be an LP in
- 18:16the early and growth funds if you want to get into these
- 18:19special two additional funds. So it's the same LP base.
- 18:22What's interesting to me with this and like I don't have the
- 18:24perspective, but like do other funds portion out their funds or
- 18:30do other firms portion out their funds in such a regimented
- 18:32segmented way? Or is this like basically a new
- 18:35marketing scheme for LP's where you're just like you can have
- 18:38access to the select fund, but if you want further exposure to
- 18:42later stage rounds, you can be select plus, you know, the
- 18:45sidecar, whatever they call it. Like, is this all just kind of a
- 18:47different way of divvying things up so you can essentially get
- 18:50more from an LP? Well, there's a lot going on
- 18:52that we don't know, but one reason you'd want separate funds
- 18:55is venture. How are venture capitalists
- 18:57compensated? I think that's that's worth a
- 19:01discussion here, right. So venture capitalists are
- 19:04compensated based on management fees and carry management fees.
- 19:09That's the two of the famous expression 2 and 20 means that
- 19:13they get 2% a year of the assets that they've raised.
- 19:19So you have bigger and bigger funds, you get larger and larger
- 19:22management fees. And so part of what's appealing
- 19:25about mega funds is that you have so much money that the
- 19:28management fees alone become very valuable.
- 19:31And who cares how well your investments do because you can
- 19:35make, you know, if you do the, we should do the math off 9
- 19:38billion. I mean, it depend not all these
- 19:40funds are the same fee structure and we don't they don't like
- 19:43announce the fee structure, but they're making hundreds of
- 19:47millions certainly in management fees alone.
- 19:50Now you have to run a bigger firm.
- 19:52You pay employees right The. Overhead goes up among you know,
- 19:56the number of partners that sort of thing.
- 19:57So it does get diluted out, but it's it's a pretty good market
- 20:01if you can make sums like this off your management fees.
- 20:03So if you're thinking about management fees, you want to
- 20:05have a big, you just want to raise a bunch of money, right,
- 20:08That's great for management fees on the carry side, you like
- 20:12having different funds, right. So if my venture fund does
- 20:18really well and I only get paid as a venture capitalist, if I,
- 20:23you know, double the value of my holdings or if there's some
- 20:27hurdle that I have to reach, I don't want that to be dragged
- 20:30down by the fact that then we double down later at bad
- 20:33valuations. And so we're not going to make,
- 20:36you know, we, we have a bigger and bigger pool of money we have
- 20:39to pay out until we reach our hurdle.
- 20:42So there to hit carry, it can be advantageous to split out funds
- 20:50so that. Meaning like having early,
- 20:52having late. Having right early could be in
- 20:54the money, but opportunity might not, you know.
- 20:57And so then it's like, oh, we make money off.
- 20:59Whereas if early and opportunity were the same fund, it's
- 21:02possible we don't make out and LP's know this.
- 21:08And this also could be in Lightspeed's case, they have,
- 21:10you know, 15-A and 15-B, which even splits the early.
- 21:14Level. Farther so there's like seed A
- 21:16and BC. So before you even get into
- 21:20growth, they're tearing it out that.
- 21:21Way it's possible they have some overall promise to LP's.
- 21:25I don't know like how much these things are operating stand alone
- 21:31versus they're saying overall we will make the money back.
- 21:35But but yeah, I don't, I don't think it's mostly about
- 21:38marketing and they're probably let you know some LP's
- 21:42concentrate in areas they like better and you know there
- 21:45there's, there's a lot of negotiating.
- 21:48But you don't think there's a way that you can, you know, get
- 21:51L like more money from an LP by offering them exposure to
- 21:54multiple funds within the firm? Like it just feels like it's
- 21:58like one. Yeah.
- 21:59It's just like 1 chunk of money going to 1 fun versus like, you
- 22:02know, it's just like a psychological thing of little
- 22:05bits will add up to a greater number, but it doesn't feel as
- 22:08psychologically, you know, like a huge chunk that's coming out
- 22:11of your fund like you're, you're I don't know you're.
- 22:14Doing different strategies, yeah.
- 22:15Yeah, yeah. It just feels like there's an
- 22:17appeal there. It also if you wanted to get a
- 22:19larger ownership share of one specific winning bet, which
- 22:22seems to be what everyone wants to do in the.
- 22:24AI. Race right, like everyone wants
- 22:26to be an open AI, everyone wants to be an anthropic with these
- 22:29kind of winner companies, you could have exposure as an LP
- 22:32from the growth fund, but you could also be in the Co
- 22:35investment fund and get more that way.
- 22:37So you could say, you know, they could sell it like, hey, if you
- 22:40want to get even more in Anthropic, you could opt into
- 22:43this additional fund. And it's doing so well.
- 22:46Why wouldn't you do that? You know, I think this new fund
- 22:50was broken in the New York Times and the way that the Times frame
- 22:55the story was like AI investment is going crazy right now.
- 22:59You need to be able to raise huge amounts of money in order
- 23:01to participate in these mega round seeds or you know,
- 23:04hundreds of millions of dollars and billion dollar valuations
- 23:06right off the bat. And this is just a response to
- 23:10the size of rounds that AI companies are are demanding.
- 23:13Is that basically what's going on here?
- 23:16When you see Lightspeed doing this, you know, astronomically
- 23:19large round comparatively to the other things just like this is
- 23:22AI, this is the bubble. This is just like the table
- 23:25stakes for participating. I I think, you know, there are
- 23:27two things going on in terms of why Lightspeed is able to raise
- 23:31this amount of money. 1 Limited partners, the the people and
- 23:35firms and institutions that invest in venture capital firms
- 23:38or sort of fleeing to the the best of the best related to the
- 23:43second phenomenon, which is companies are staying private
- 23:46forever and so there are these clear winners or apparent
- 23:50winners companies like open AI, Anthropic cursor clean data
- 23:57bricks didn't. Data bricks just raise like a
- 24:00series L. Recently, yeah.
- 24:01It's like a. 160. Billion or something?
- 24:04I'd never heard of a series L before that.
- 24:06Right. So they're staying private,
- 24:08which means that only sort of connected investors can really
- 24:12get access. And so firms like Lightspeed are
- 24:15well positioned to do those deals.
- 24:17And so they need way more than traditional venture capital
- 24:21money to invest. But what about AI specifically?
- 24:25Like is it just, I mean, is it, are we seeing rounds that are
- 24:31fewer and larger, like they're not really passing the hat
- 24:33around that widely? And so you just are entirely
- 24:36reliant on like you're saying these big name firms to give you
- 24:40allocation. You just don't have that much
- 24:41auction as an LP. Yeah, that's basically part of
- 24:45this too. There.
- 24:48He's hardly ever been, at least in my time reporting VC, just a
- 24:52clear kind of consensus view of what to invest in from all these
- 24:55firms, right? Like people have collectively
- 24:58decided that there are the winners in AI not for
- 25:01applications, the jury's still out there, but on the foundation
- 25:04model level, a lot of people think there's still a ton of
- 25:06value in these companies. There's not that many of them.
- 25:09They're very expensive operating companies, so the money they
- 25:13need to raise and keep growing is more.
- 25:16And so then the big players need more money to fund them because
- 25:19there's a sort of consensus view that these are the companies
- 25:22that we need to be backing right now.
- 25:23So it's kind of reinforcing. Yeah, I mean, you know, there's
- 25:27been some, it's almost like a meme at this point, but I've
- 25:30just seen it enough on on X to decide.
- 25:32This is like, I think people are discussing that.
- 25:34They're like only so many firms or or sorry, there are only so
- 25:38many start-ups that really matter right now in AI.
- 25:41And the ones that typically get names are like Anthropic cursor,
- 25:45open AI, Mercor for whatever reason gets gets Yeah, people.
- 25:49Love Mercor? Well, OK, I get it.
- 25:52I mean, you know, there's value in sort of, we basically do like
- 25:55reinforcement learning in human, like kind of they're basically
- 25:58like replaced scale as like kind of scale.
- 26:02Yeah, that's like the go to service.
- 26:04So sure, whatever. I don't really see those as tech
- 26:06companies, but they certainly have venture backing.
- 26:08But you basically if you're an LP, you want exposure to those
- 26:11companies and you're going to get pissed off if you don't get
- 26:14it. And so like the value that all
- 26:16of these firms basically have is say like, oh, we can get you in
- 26:19it, don't worry, don't worry, we'll get you in there and we'll
- 26:21get you in there in a big way. And it is incredibly
- 26:23concentrated. I mean, I don't know, Eric, like
- 26:25you were, you know, covering late stage venture in like the
- 26:28Uber era when there really weren't, you know, it was Uber
- 26:32and Lyft. I mean, was it the similar sort
- 26:35of competitiveness where there was just like a small number of
- 26:38firms that had access to these crazy Uber rounds?
- 26:41You know, in in the hedge fund world, people, you know, think
- 26:45it's sometimes crazy that it's like, you can raise this money
- 26:48with great fees and then you turn around and you invest in
- 26:52Meta, in Alphabet, you know, it's like anybody could do that.
- 26:56It's like what you're a genius. You like pick which one of the
- 26:59seven most important companies and go bigot it.
- 27:01And then you collect fees off of that.
- 27:03And I think there's a degree to which a only marginally more
- 27:07sophisticated version of that is now happening in venture
- 27:10capital, which is, oh, you're going to invest in open AI.
- 27:14Now VCs have the advantage of saying, well, you schlub can't
- 27:18get in open AI only I can. I, I don't totally, even though,
- 27:24you know, I follow this stuff very closely.
- 27:27I it's hard to come up with a non cynical reason why these
- 27:32companies, you know, gatekeep their investor base and
- 27:35therefore allow their investors to basically collect fees on
- 27:40what are, you know, you know, opening eyes desperate for any
- 27:43money can get right. So why does it restrict the
- 27:45investor base? I think the answer is just you
- 27:48create FOMO, you create this like sense that I need to get in
- 27:52by making it a little bit difficult by having prestigious
- 27:55people invest. And the people investing are,
- 27:58you know, bullish optimists who have an incentive to run around
- 28:02and say this is a great company. And so instead of just doing a
- 28:05fair market price, you sort of restrict the investor base and
- 28:09you create FOMO. And, you know, if you wanted to
- 28:12to to do it the normal way, you'd go public.
- 28:14So yeah, it's been this weird situation where, you know,
- 28:18insiders are getting a pretty good deal.
- 28:20Now, sometimes they get it wrong, right.
- 28:22If you dump all the money into the wrong one of these winners
- 28:25like, sometimes it doesn't work as well.
- 28:29There are, there are. Certainly concentration risk,
- 28:32right? And the traditional venture
- 28:33model was that you had a bunch of different bets that you've
- 28:37based on your research that could grow.
- 28:39But if a bunch of them didn't work, you had, you know,
- 28:42diversified and likelihood was that one or two definitely would
- 28:45go to the moon and become unicorns and exit for you and
- 28:48return your fund and make you rich and then some.
- 28:50And what's different now is you have really capital intensive
- 28:54businesses that also everyone wants to get in and it's
- 28:56mutually reinforcing to where there's this hype cycle and it's
- 29:00really exclusive to get in these deals.
- 29:02So you want to get on the cap table because it's going to be
- 29:03once in a lifetime company. And also if you're true
- 29:06believer, it's like, yeah, this is going to be maybe
- 29:08generational company and the highest technology and my LP's
- 29:11want to get it too. To bring it back to a earlier
- 29:14question of Tom's and to Lightspeed, This is why you have
- 29:16different funds. You know, you have traditional
- 29:19venture funds with diversified strategies, with premium fees
- 29:23that, you know, are looking for unexpected winners.
- 29:26And then you have these opportunity funds and sidecar
- 29:30funds that are basically like, yeah, we're gonna, you know,
- 29:33dump a bunch of money into the names that you know, and if
- 29:36you're a savvy LP, you already understand them pretty well.
- 29:39And the fees are gonna be lower, but still like you're, you're
- 29:43getting to make money by by getting your limited partners
- 29:46into pretty well known companies.
- 29:48It's almost like like a cable package or something, right?
- 29:50It's like if you're gonna get cable these days, it's like,
- 29:54yeah, it's like, I know I need ESPN.
- 29:56So like, that's a base level thing.
- 29:57If I'm gonna get a cable package, you gotta give me ESPN.
- 30:00Everything else on top of that is like, do I want the TBS
- 30:02package? Do I want like the Food Network
- 30:05package? All that stuff is just like
- 30:06spice on top of it that provides mild differentiation.
- 30:09But it's like you can't sell cable right now without ESPN.
- 30:13You can't get, you know, a VC fund without open AI.
- 30:15Anthropic. But you you also need to put
- 30:17your head more in that in the mind of the ultra rich, right?
- 30:21Their problem isn't, oh man, I just want ESPN and they're
- 30:24making me buy all this other stuff.
- 30:26Sometimes it's the opposite. It's like, I don't want to think
- 30:29about all this piddling little stuff.
- 30:31Like I want to write one huge check, you know, I don't know
- 30:34who the LP's are, but it's like, I'm Saudi Arabia.
- 30:37I don't want to see her worrying about like, oh, your venture
- 30:39strategy or I just want to be like, here's a bunch of money,
- 30:41like make me some money, you know?
- 30:43And like, part of the challenge, sincerely, of having huge pools
- 30:46of capital, even for professional investors like
- 30:49pension funds or sovereign wealth funds, is you, you want
- 30:52to put all your money in one place and get a substantial,
- 30:55reliable return. And firms like Lightspeed NEA,
- 31:00you know, is the sort of historical example of this where
- 31:03it's not necessarily aiming for classic venture capital
- 31:07performance, but saying we can do the market or better.
- 31:11And it's a huge amount of money, you know, don't worry, leave it
- 31:14with us. We'll we'll consistently return
- 31:17and. That's kind of what the mega
- 31:19funds are replicating. We talked a lot on this show
- 31:22before about the kind of maturation of venture as an
- 31:25asset class. And as it becomes more serious,
- 31:27these mega funds are functioning more like this mature asset
- 31:33class that these huge LP's, like you said, want a reliable return
- 31:37and put their money in. And traditional venture was of
- 31:40course, you know, moon shot ideas that make you really rich
- 31:42when they work. And when you're dealing with
- 31:45sums of money this big with institutional LP's with billions
- 31:48to park, they don't really want to risk losing all of it on the
- 31:52chance of like a 20X return. You know they would like
- 31:56reliable 3X4 X 5X which is not venture returns that
- 32:01historically people would be like.
- 32:02These are good but not like the crazy amazing returns, but it
- 32:06would be a great deal for your money.
- 32:08Well, the other evolution to that also seems to be Thrive,
- 32:11which, you know, I don't know how much they define this era of
- 32:16mega funds and acting as quasi private equity firms, but their
- 32:19involvement like fun to portfolio company is such a
- 32:23weird change from the way things were in the past.
- 32:26I mean, this, we weren't planning on talking about this
- 32:27in the episode, but just interesting to me that like I
- 32:30think it was this week or last week, you saw Open AI
- 32:32effectively taking some sort of a stake in Thrive.
- 32:36So like, you know, where one succeeds, the other one does
- 32:38too. The whole thing is hand in hand.
- 32:39I've been reporting on this a bit.
- 32:41It's through Thrive Holdings, their holding company vehicle,
- 32:44which Josh Joshua Kushner is also the CEO of, but is not the
- 32:49main Thrive fund, although it's under the Thrive umbrella.
- 32:51But it's like in a billion dollar holding company to double
- 32:54down on these AI bets. That's separate from the venture
- 32:57model. And this deal is structured to
- 33:00where engineers from Thrive Holdings and engineers and
- 33:03researchers from Open AI can be embedded with each other to
- 33:06learn how best to use the models to grow their other startups,
- 33:11like in their roll ups business for example.
- 33:13What? I'm sorry, engineers that
- 33:14thrive? What are their engineers that
- 33:16thrive? They have engineers at Thrive if
- 33:18that's what they say, and they're getting to learn from
- 33:22the best and brightest models from up in AI.
- 33:25And I guess the engineers of the company, yeah, I don't know.
- 33:27And the engineers? Go in and then work on these,
- 33:29you know, roll up companies where they're like figuring out
- 33:32how to use AI services to roll up, you know it.
- 33:37Makes sense for everybody involved.
- 33:39First of all, self dealing is the name of the game these days.
- 33:43Josh Kushner is running a great well respected firm with Thrive.
- 33:48He stood by Sam Altman when the board tried to go after Altman.
- 33:51He keeps betting on open AI successfully.
- 33:54Now. What does open AI want?
- 33:56They want fucking customers. And Thrive is like, oh, we're
- 34:00going to invest in a roll up vehicle of companies that could
- 34:03embrace foundation models and use them to revolutionize
- 34:07plumbing or whatever vertical it is.
- 34:10And so then Open AI wants those customers and wants to reward
- 34:14Josh Kushner for being a loyal ally.
- 34:17So they they share brands and partner.
- 34:19Yeah, I mean, this is this is how business gets done.
- 34:22Not even, not even necessarily cynically.
- 34:24I mean, it's just it, it makes sense for both parties.
- 34:27But yeah. All this sort of deliver on that
- 34:30end is I guess TBD, but it sounds.
- 34:33I know. Well, I'm interested to see this
- 34:34roll up story there. I mean, there's so much energy
- 34:37around rollups, but it feels like everybody's interested in
- 34:40the strategy. You know, we have to see it, you
- 34:44know, play it out in the the companies.
- 34:46Yeah, it's too early for a lot of these companies that were
- 34:48really formed in some cases by the venture with the venture
- 34:52firms as basically the creators who then bring in a CEO who are
- 34:55workshop this concept and then acquire an existing service
- 34:59business or ones where the they meet a founder that wants to
- 35:04expand their services and say here's some capital, why not do
- 35:07a roll up and buy this other business.
- 35:09So they, we will see how these do.
- 35:12It's only been really in the last year or two that these
- 35:15companies have started. So the jury's still out on how
- 35:20successful this will be. Although of course, investors
- 35:23I've talked to, granted ones who've made these kind of bets,
- 35:26say that they're doing quite well, but of course they'd like
- 35:28to. Say that I want to make three
- 35:29quick points on the mega funds and Lightspeed before we wrap up
- 35:34this this portion. One, the mega funds, certainly
- 35:41Andreessen Horowitz and Lightspeed did really well in
- 35:44the beginning like we published in February Lightspeed's
- 35:47performance and you know, their first couple funds are first
- 35:52quartile venture funds. You know, they 3X TVPI, their
- 35:58first fund, you know they're outperforming other venture
- 36:03capital firms. And so it is the firm's
- 36:06obviously you know what you'd expect that did well in the
- 36:09beginning that said, oh, give us a lot of money and we'll do it
- 36:13at scale. And then you know, they've had
- 36:15successful funds, but some of them are second quartile.
- 36:20But, but what's really important here is that these venture firms
- 36:24got really big and it takes a while to prove that the really
- 36:28big strategy works as well as the venture strategy.
- 36:31So I think we're still in a period we're waiting to see
- 36:35whether they can do as well with a lot of money as they did with
- 36:38a little bit of money. The one thing that's happened
- 36:41since February when it was like, oh wow, they're, they're raising
- 36:44on an old strategy, while their strategy is much bigger is they,
- 36:48they've dumped a lot of money into anthropic.
- 36:50Even at the time, I think it was like their second largest
- 36:52holding or sign. They're really escalating their
- 36:55anthropic position. And that's only gotten marked
- 36:57up. So the AI bubble in some ways
- 37:00has only supported he's mega fun.
- 37:03So that's that's one. I think 2:00 we're just going to
- 37:06be very interested in like, you know, general catalysts, like
- 37:09will it go public? Andreessen, you know, I think
- 37:12Ben and Ben and Mark Ben Horowitz and Mark Andreessen are
- 37:15very savvy marketers. I think they had an LP meeting
- 37:19where they they opened it up. We're not thinking about going
- 37:23public, which of course, you know, raises the like, right.
- 37:26Oh, was it you bring? Up.
- 37:28Right. You know, it's like we're not,
- 37:29we're not doing it, but oh, was it on people's minds, you know?
- 37:32Questions about my Not Going Public shirt are answered by my
- 37:34Yeah, I've answered. By not public shirt so so you
- 37:38know, they're all professionalizing, they're
- 37:39hiring, you know, people from, you know, Blackstone and big
- 37:43private equity. They're getting wealth managers,
- 37:45they're pursuing multiple strategies.
- 37:49And so it's just going to be interesting to watch this asset
- 37:52class grow up. I do think, you know, small
- 37:54venture capital firms are so important for the VC ethos that
- 37:59that the sort of power struggle between mega funds and and small
- 38:04firms will be interesting to watch.
- 38:06And then the final point is just if you're in Silicon Valley, you
- 38:10got to sort of breathe a sigh of relief that firms like
- 38:13Lightspeed have all this money because their job is to deploy
- 38:16it. And so even if we're in a
- 38:17bubble, if the public market bursts tomorrow, Lightspeed
- 38:22still has all this money pretty locked up now.
- 38:25You know, they can slow down for six months, but they're probably
- 38:29going to deploy it at a fairly steady pace.
- 38:32So the fact that all this money has been put into a venture
- 38:35capital firm is a sign that as much as people yelled out, yell
- 38:39about a bubble, at least on the private markets, there's plenty
- 38:42of money to keep investing in startups and keep keep some of
- 38:46the activity level. If you know Anthropic, Open AI
- 38:49or NVIDIA, you know, correct, Maybe that means, you know,
- 38:53Lightspeed and others shift more money to new companies or, you
- 38:56know, the big companies stay private and they gobble up a lot
- 38:59of the money and then not as much for startups.
- 39:02But it's it's a large pool of money available to the startup
- 39:05ecosystem, which gives some confidence that, you know,
- 39:08Silicon Valley's not going away anytime soon.
- 39:11At the very least, it kind of papers over this narrative that
- 39:14we keep coming across, which is that we're actually in a down
- 39:16cycle for startups. And you know, a lot of people
- 39:19are are like companies are struggling to raise funds.
- 39:21And we had Kate Clark on here a couple of months ago talking
- 39:24about, you know, the plight of a lot of these early stage, you
- 39:28know, a round funds, which is a real thing, but no one really
- 39:31pays attention to it. When you can see the light
- 39:33speeds of the world raising multi $1,000,000 funds and
- 39:36startups reaching these half trillion dollar valuations, it's
- 39:39like that's the recession right now.
- 39:42It's like companies worth hundreds of billions of dollars
- 39:44is a recession, which, you know, there's a very strong case to
- 39:46make that it is one, but it just doesn't compute with, you know,
- 39:50money still flooding into a small number of megaphones.
- 39:53Well, before we wrap up on Lightspeed, Tom, what's your
- 39:56Snapchat story? Sure.
- 39:58So famously Snapchat their first investor was was Lightspeed and
- 40:03the story actually goes that. It's the Barry Eggers see like
- 40:08one of the early kind of Cove Cove cofounding partners of of
- 40:10Lightspeed. His daughter was in high school
- 40:14and she was using Snapchat and she would come home and be like
- 40:17dad, dad, dad. There's this funny app that
- 40:18everyone's using where he message and it disappears and
- 40:20it's like he's like, isn't that for sexting?
- 40:21She's like, dad, there's this really cool app that everyone's
- 40:24using. And so they were begging Evan,
- 40:28who didn't he, he didn't like the Evan Spiegel.
- 40:31He hated VC firms. And so he never wanted to
- 40:33provide any sort of access to, to, to a lot of funds.
- 40:37But eventually they broke him down.
- 40:38And Jeremy Liu, who is now kind of somewhat associated with
- 40:42Lightspeed, but fairly not. He's he's mostly retired.
- 40:45Yeah, he was able to convince him to invest, but Evan hated
- 40:48the terms and he kind of felt that they had him like bent over
- 40:52a barrel and got too much control, which, you know, that
- 40:55whole mindset from Evan ended up being like kind of a horrible
- 40:59aspect of Snapchat. I mean, he maintains.
- 41:01The company public performance has been terrible, right?
- 41:04Because. He has total control over it and
- 41:06so basically. No one can do anything.
- 41:08Yeah, no. Shareholders, you can't fire the
- 41:10guy and he's running the company in the way that he's running.
- 41:12I'm not going to make a judgment, but but anyway, it's
- 41:15kind of like a seed of destruction anyway.
- 41:17It's worth it was once like, you know, one of the sexiest social
- 41:20media companies in the world. He could have sold it.
- 41:22It's worth $13 billion. He probably could have sold it
- 41:25for 13 billion. In like 2016 or 2017, yeah.
- 41:29I mean, Facebook was going to buy it for like a single digit
- 41:32billions at one point. But at the top, at, you know, at
- 41:34the top of the market during the, the, the pandemic, I think
- 41:37it was close to 100 billion. So it's it's a disaster.
- 41:40But anyway, you know, Lightspeed ends up having a huge falling
- 41:44out with Evan because he hated the terms.
- 41:46It was kind of like a Motown artist who, you know, felt that
- 41:49he was being taken advantage of by, you know, Berry Gordy.
- 41:53Good reference to anyone who cares that.
- 41:55Was a. Great reference.
- 41:56All the best references you know are good only to you, but yeah.
- 42:00Sure. But anyway, and so, but the
- 42:03funniest part of this whole story to me is that as a way of
- 42:05like saying thank you because this is 1 of Lightspeed's
- 42:07biggest early successes. Like it kind of puts them on the
- 42:10map and to a point that I think they're annoyed because they're
- 42:13not really a consumer tech company is they end up.
- 42:17So this is a high school Barry. Barry Edgar's daughter goes to
- 42:20this high school in Silicon Valley and they happen to have
- 42:23like some sort of an endowment or or some sort of fun
- 42:26associated with the high school. And so they actually give the
- 42:29endowment some equity into Snapchat from like an A stage
- 42:34round. And when the company goes
- 42:35public, that stake ends up being worth like 10s of millions of
- 42:40dollars. And so there's like random high
- 42:42school, relatively random high school at the.
- 42:46Time Snapchat. Yeah, it was 1,000,000 on
- 42:48Snapchat. Hopefully they sold at the IPO,
- 42:50but. Yeah, anyway, they made so some
- 42:52high school made a a shit ton of money off of Snapchat because of
- 42:55Lightspeed, which is a firm that Evan Spiegel hated.
- 42:59And it's, it was one of my favorite stories that I wrote
- 43:00covering Snapchat back in the day.
- 43:02So anyway, there's my Lightspeed Snapchat story.
- 43:05Cool. Well, that's our episode.
- 43:06Thanks so much. Thank you for tuning into this
- 43:08week's episode of the podcast. If you're new here, please like
- 43:11and subscribe. It really helps out the channel.
- 43:13Listen in for new episodes every week, wherever you get your
- 43:15podcasts.