Latest / Rewire To Rise– Beyond The Mindset / Is AI Making Us Dumber? (Before You Outsource Your Mind) | Mark Sinclair Fleeton
Transcript
- 0:00AI helps you research, write, study, plan your career, and
- 0:04even make personal decisions. How do?
- 0:06Which thoughts are actually yours?
- 0:08You do it by making your own thoughts the starting point,
- 0:12because otherwise it doesn't matter.
- 0:14Then what you're doing has no value because you don't learn
- 0:18from it. So you have to start by making
- 0:21up your own mind. What is my opinion about this?
- 0:23And then you can use the feedback you get from the
- 0:26system. Maybe it changes your mind,
- 0:28maybe it doesn't change your mind, but it gives you something
- 0:30too late. Mark, what is 1 ability you
- 0:34would tell them never to outsource?
- 0:37Your own reflection, your own thoughts, because that is what
- 0:40we're, that is basically what it's about, even in just a
- 0:43discussion, even when you and I talk.
- 0:46So there is always something to learn from everybody you talk
- 0:48to, but you don't learn if you don't reflect on what you're
- 0:52being given. Generating a picture then,
- 0:55because it starts from my script, right?
- 0:58In that case, though, can be considered my piece of art.
- 1:02AI is a tool, so could pose the question to you take a picture
- 1:06with a camera, an old fashioned camera.
- 1:08You take a picture with a camera, you get a nice picture.
- 1:11Who took the picture? Did you or did the camera?
- 1:14In that case you want, you have no doubt you took the picture.
- 1:17But why is this? Why is this any different from
- 1:19the AI? That's what that's what we're
- 1:22trying to do with the interactive tool, for example.
- 1:25It's to make people reflect, make up their own decisions and
- 1:28hopefully debate this, talk to other people about it, learn
- 1:32from each other, learn from each other's perspective.
- 1:35And it's not just simply learning AI.
- 1:38That's the whole point. It is helping people use AI
- 1:42without surrendering judgement, their own judgement and.
- 1:51This episode is for people who use AI but do not want to
- 1:55surrender their judgement, creativity, or agency.
- 1:59We all use AI nowadays, but the bigger question is are you
- 2:03learning how to use it without gradually giving away your own
- 2:07judgement? So the question is no longer
- 2:10whether we will use AI, but is it how we use it without losing
- 2:14ourselves in the process. Hello, Mark Sinclair Fleeton.
- 2:19Hello. Mark, let's start with something
- 2:23very simple. How much has AI already changed
- 2:27the way ordinary people work, learn, and make decisions,
- 2:32perhaps without us fully noticing?
- 2:35Well, that's a good question because I think it depends
- 2:39greatly on where you are. But we have been gradually
- 2:42getting used to these systems over a lot of years.
- 2:45We've been using them in the streaming services and so on.
- 2:49So it's become second nature that AI is part of what we're
- 2:52doing. Recently AI has started making a
- 2:57major impact on our work situation and on the education
- 3:01side of things. Students are using AI more and
- 3:05more. And I think in, in a lot of both
- 3:08in the professional and in the study situation, we also feel
- 3:13that's what I hear from people, they feel pressure to
- 3:16increasingly deliver faster and faster.
- 3:20So they're using AI more and more.
- 3:23I think that part is something we're aware of, but the, the,
- 3:26the starting point of, of using AI everyday on our phones, on
- 3:31our computers and on our screens.
- 3:34In any case, is is, is is not something we're necessarily
- 3:39aware of and we are. And I don't think we're aware of
- 3:43the consequences at all. Can you please, from your point
- 3:48of view, tell us what would those consequences might be?
- 3:53When we're talking using AI professionally or in your
- 3:57studies, part of that is sort of letting go of your own judgement
- 4:03and letting the systems take over too many things for you to
- 4:08you outsource your thinking to the systems.
- 4:11And I guess it's it's very easy. Most of these systems will give
- 4:17you an answer out of pretty much nothing.
- 4:20And from that we tend to surrender because it's so easy.
- 4:25It's so easy, especially if you're pressed for time.
- 4:27So easy to just let the system take over and and write whatever
- 4:30you need. Mark, for those who doesn't know
- 4:33or are not familiar with the point of outsourcing, can you
- 4:37please explain them in a very, very simple way for everybody to
- 4:41understand what precisely they have to understand in regards to
- 4:46that? Well, outsourcing is pretty much
- 4:50what it sounds like. You turn over your skills to
- 4:53something else. You ask something else to do the
- 4:56job for you. That's it's a term that's been
- 4:59used within business for years that you let other people do
- 5:05part of your work for you, or in this case systems.
- 5:09Mark, we hear constantly that AI can make us faster, right?
- 5:14But do you think we are asking enough whether it's actually
- 5:18make us better at thinking? No, I don't think we are because
- 5:23we're concentrating on the making us faster part.
- 5:26This, this is where we use it both, both when we study and in,
- 5:29in our professional lives, we have deadlines to meet.
- 5:32So we focus on speed and we tend to think more about how it makes
- 5:37us faster and then maybe lose a bit of, of thinking about the
- 5:42quality and what we're doing and, and the the, the potential
- 5:46for it to actually make us smarter.
- 5:49Well, smarter in what way? Can you please elaborate
- 5:53assigning it more? Also for others to understand in
- 5:55what way? You can think of AI as a as a,
- 6:00as a tool and maybe that's too simple because you could also
- 6:03think of it as a teacher, a tutor or somebody that you can
- 6:09discuss your ideas with, someone you can play ball with, so to
- 6:13speak. And in that way, make your
- 6:16thinking actually stronger than it was before because you could
- 6:20get somebody who reacts to it. It is a bit like having a person
- 6:23to talk to, having a really smart person you can talk to.
- 6:27I have an idea about this and that.
- 6:28What do you think about that? That makes us smarter if that is
- 6:32the way we use the systems and not just tell me about or write
- 6:37write me something. So is it better for us while
- 6:42using AI to ask more and more questions in order for us to
- 6:48actually get better at thinking as my question was actually
- 6:53mentioned, or how we should do that?
- 6:57What is the right process in regards to that?
- 7:00Well, asking questions is a good place to start, but it's not
- 7:04necessarily about asking more questions, it's about doing your
- 7:07own thinking. So giving it like a tone of
- 7:11voice like that it belongs to you.
- 7:14So it becomes kind of your mirror in that sense.
- 7:17Might be. That that is one way to use it,
- 7:21but you could also use it as a discussion partner, somebody who
- 7:25who makes you smarter, somebody you can debate your ideas with,
- 7:30test your ideas, make them stronger, more resistant to
- 7:35argument, so on. Where do you personally draw the
- 7:39line between using AI to support your thinking mark and allowing
- 7:43it to think for you? Well, I don't allow it to think
- 7:47for me. How do you do that?
- 7:52Yeah, actually that's kind of difficult to it's, it's kind of
- 7:55difficult to explain. I've been trying to think about
- 7:57that. I guess my approach to AI has
- 8:00always been in research kind of way.
- 8:05So I've always been reflective in the way I use it and more and
- 8:09more really because I see how easy it is to get lost really
- 8:13and lose your, your, your own way of thinking and getting
- 8:18getting talked into something that maybe isn't what you wanted
- 8:23to do in, in the 1st place. So, so I think part of the
- 8:28answer to your question is you have to be critical.
- 8:31You have to go into this asking questions, being being critical
- 8:37about what you're being offered from these systems and, and not
- 8:40let the system take over because it can do that.
- 8:45It can, it can tell you what to do and it could be very
- 8:49persuasive in telling you what to do.
- 8:51So you have to start, and that's one of my crucial points anyway,
- 8:57is that you have to start with yourself.
- 8:59You have to start with your own thinking.
- 9:02That's your point of of start whenever dealing with this
- 9:05system is making up your own mind, having a point of
- 9:08departure, an idea you can start with.
- 9:10You can change your mind going along the way, but you have to
- 9:15the the starting point has to be yourself and you're thinking.
- 9:19All right, thank you so much because at this point, I have a
- 9:22question in my mind that I keep hearing over and over and over
- 9:27again from so many even specialist, but also people that
- 9:31they state that they are professionals in regards to AI,
- 9:36using AI whatsoever. So you have mentioned that early
- 9:41on, like 2 minutes ago, how people can actually, I can
- 9:45understand so much better, first of all what, how they can be
- 9:50critical and what doesn't even mean that for people to really
- 9:54understand. Because I think people just use
- 9:57it randomly without even most of them know what actually means
- 10:00and what what and how it has to be used and not missed, used or
- 10:05misunderstood. Being critical means being,
- 10:09again, reflecting on what you're doing, actually thinking about
- 10:17what you're doing, and thinking about the answers you get from
- 10:21this machine. Asking questions.
- 10:23Is this correct? Checking up, verifying, and so
- 10:27on along the way. It doesn't mean criticizing
- 10:31necessarily or or simply thinking this is fake or
- 10:35whatever. It means asking questions.
- 10:37It means thinking, doing your own thinking along the way, and
- 10:43the flexing on is this, does this feel right?
- 10:46Does it sound right? Does it look right?
- 10:49That's in my way of thinking, being critical and not just
- 10:56accepting one point of view, but actually checking out.
- 10:59But maybe there are several ways to look at this because truth or
- 11:05whatever you want to say is not necessarily one thing.
- 11:08It can be many things, and that's being critical.
- 11:12Sure. So simple as it is.
- 11:13But again, I want to be the devil here again.
- 11:16And I return to the main question.
- 11:18So you can also ask to AI why you are prompting that please be
- 11:24critical while you are analyzing or you know, searching for
- 11:28certain sources or make a research or whatsoever.
- 11:32So you can actually dive into that like just literally while
- 11:37you are prompting, writing into the prompt that please be
- 11:41critical while you're answering or replying to me.
- 11:45And that's, that's one way of doing it, but that doesn't take
- 11:48away the responsibility from you.
- 11:50You still have to be critical of the answers you get.
- 11:54So, so setting up the system to be more smart, to be more
- 11:57critical, I always ask for sources for everything I, I, I
- 12:02get because then I can check the sources.
- 12:04Is this correct or not correct? It helps asking the system and
- 12:10instructing the system putting into the prompt.
- 12:12Be critical of what you find here.
- 12:15You have to be more critical. We are keeping hearing this like
- 12:20tone of voice, tone of voice, I know very well what it means,
- 12:24but people again a lot of people who might even doesn't even know
- 12:30what it means. That and the purpose of it and
- 12:32the usage of it, the tone of voice.
- 12:35So also regards to AI at this point, because we are talking
- 12:39the main theme today is AI, right?
- 12:42How can people give or succeed to give to their AI's tools a
- 12:49ton of voice that is similar to them, or to something an avatar
- 12:54that they might want to create whatsoever?
- 12:57And that's an interesting question from several
- 12:58perspectives, because partly you can ask, is it actually
- 13:03something you want to do to give it your tone of voice?
- 13:06Or is your tone of voice what you add to the product?
- 13:10But then again, you can add your tone of voice to the AI.
- 13:15You can ask the, the, the AI to, to be more like you.
- 13:19I've, I've found that the most you could prompt it, but I've
- 13:22found that the most effective way to do that is to, to train
- 13:27it, so to speak. The more you use it, the more it
- 13:29gets to know you, the more it gets to know your tone of voice
- 13:32and the better it gets at using your tone of voice.
- 13:37So the product you get is, is something that sounds like you.
- 13:41But then again, sometimes maybe that's not what you want because
- 13:48I'm I'm asking the question whether if what you are
- 13:51presented with is in your own voice, then maybe you are less
- 13:56critical because it sounds that's.
- 13:59Exactly. Familiar.
- 14:01Yeah. It sounds familiar and, and, and
- 14:05it's already difficult because, because AI systems are so
- 14:08confident in, in when they deliver an answer or a solution
- 14:12or something like that, it, it's already difficult not just to
- 14:16accept what you're given. What happens if it comes back in
- 14:19your own voice? Isn't it even more persuasive?
- 14:24So, and, and that's why maybe you think I'm, I'm sort of
- 14:27dancing around the subject. But my point is that I don't I
- 14:31don't necessarily think it's a good thing to have the AI act in
- 14:36your voice because it could make you less critical.
- 14:40That's a good point. Seriously.
- 14:42Very much, yeah. Can I tell you what happens when
- 14:46this episode ends? I start building the next one
- 14:49and I think sometimes from this side of the screen, Rewired Rice
- 14:53can look much bigger than actually is.
- 14:56But there is no big company behind this, no big budget, no
- 14:59team making all this happen. There is just me and there is
- 15:03you. So I bring the conversations,
- 15:06but I need you to help them travel.
- 15:08So if something here made you think, helped you challenge you,
- 15:13please don't just watch and disappear.
- 15:16Subscribe, like it, leave a comment, even one sentence
- 15:20because those tiny actions from you make a very real difference
- 15:24to me and they tell to YouTube as well.
- 15:26This conversation is worth showing to someone else and that
- 15:30helps me keep building rewired to rights into something much
- 15:33bigger than just the podcast. I will keep creating it if you
- 15:36believe it should keep growing. Help me carry it further.
- 15:40So please, like, subscribe and share.
- 15:43It might seem like a small thing for you, but this is how you
- 15:46become part of it. OK, back to the conversation.
- 15:50You have to just mention while you were talking, Mark, about
- 15:54training the AI we meet meaning me and you and other people, we
- 15:59know what it's about. But for our people out there
- 16:03that they are at the beginning of the usage of AI, right AI
- 16:07tools in in particular. Can you please explain them or
- 16:11give some example, tangible example of what, what it means
- 16:15and what actually how can be done that like what it doesn't
- 16:20even mean? Because I'm sure of it, Because
- 16:23I, I have seen all this confusion like training your AI.
- 16:27But nobody, and I mean nobody explaining that at least
- 16:31slightly tiny bit to others who actually might be confused or
- 16:36doesn't have all this info available, even though they,
- 16:39there are plenty of information and details out there as
- 16:42sources, right? But still it makes it can make
- 16:46you so confused literally because there there's too much
- 16:51out there. That's the whole point and
- 16:52therefore can cause the opposite format, right, which is
- 16:56confusion. So that's why I would like to
- 16:59give to people gently if you can explain what does simply mean
- 17:04training an AI and how can be that built or created as such.
- 17:09Yeah, actually it's very imprecise when I say training,
- 17:14especially in this context, because training and AI is
- 17:18actually the technical process of giving it the the data that
- 17:23it needs and and making it teaching it how to respond to
- 17:29certain answers. It would be very wouldn't be
- 17:32able to give you the the the the in depth technical description
- 17:36of that. What I'm talking about here is
- 17:38the kind of training that you and I is, is giving the system
- 17:43everyday. And maybe training is the wrong
- 17:45word because maybe it's more like the system getting used to
- 17:49us and our ways of working our routines, the way we speak, the
- 17:55way we prompt and so on. And, and, and that sort of
- 17:59training or getting used to means that it, well, I think the
- 18:05best example is if you work with another person, you get used to
- 18:09the other person, you learn how they speak, what it means.
- 18:12If I say please do that, you will over a period of time when
- 18:17we work together, you will learn that what I mean, what I expect
- 18:20from you is this. And this is the same thing that
- 18:22happens with a large language model.
- 18:25It gets used to you. It gets used to the way you
- 18:28present thing. It gets used to the way you ask
- 18:31questions. It gets used to the sort of
- 18:34format you want in your answers. And that's what I mean by
- 18:37training. This is the kind of training
- 18:39that you and I do every day. And this is what makes the, the
- 18:44models effective for you and me and not the I'm not talking
- 18:50about the training of the models as such, the background
- 18:53training, what they're doing at the, the tech giants, what
- 18:56they're doing at Open AI, what they're doing and Anthropic and
- 18:59so on. What I'm talking about is the
- 19:01everyday usage of the system and how to get the most out of that.
- 19:06At least for ChatGPT, but also for Gemini for example.
- 19:09So on so forth. Those AI tools can be added into
- 19:14the settings. Some of the main important
- 19:18professional background or even about yourself that from that
- 19:22basic information slash details, the AI tool itself gets the
- 19:28right information, the right to know voice, the right point of
- 19:32interaction with you or vice versa.
- 19:35That actually can or even answer reply to or even or whether it
- 19:40might be creating a document, etcetera, etcetera.
- 19:44So please correct me if I'm wrong, Mark.
- 19:46No, you're you're right. There several ways of doing
- 19:48doing this. One is like I said, that just
- 19:52the everyday usage. There's also functions within
- 19:56the system where you can put in sort of more basic knowledge.
- 19:59That's got to be the the foundation of whatever
- 20:02conversation you have in that particular space and that part
- 20:05of the of the system. So you you can and the more you
- 20:09narrow it in the better answer you will get.
- 20:12I mean if you but you could, you could also do it in a prompt.
- 20:16You are a marketing expert. I need to sell this product.
- 20:21How should I do that? And it will give you an answer
- 20:23along those lines. The more precise the better.
- 20:26And the more you are specific about what you expect and what
- 20:31you needed for the context, the better the answer.
- 20:35But there are several ways of doing this, so I always say
- 20:39people should experiment. What do they find the easiest?
- 20:43And, and sometimes I think it's, it's different from situation to
- 20:46situation because in, in some conversations, I think it's
- 20:48useful to give the the system all the information it needs
- 20:52beforehand, sort of upload whatever documents you have and
- 20:56so on. And, and make give it the
- 20:58instructions before. And other times it's easier to
- 21:00just go into and, and prompt it. Just say this is the context,
- 21:05this is what I want, this is who I am, this is who it's for.
- 21:09What is one thing people are already outsourcing to AI that
- 21:13you think deserves much more attention, Mark?
- 21:17It's our reflection, it's making up our own minds.
- 21:20This is what we're. This is what we're already
- 21:23giving over to the system. And partly because of time
- 21:28constraints, we're all feeling under pressure to deliver faster
- 21:33and faster and faster. I've written about the most
- 21:35extreme situation, and this is of course within the military.
- 21:39I've written about smart systems within the military and, and,
- 21:44and the people who has to, who has to use the smart systems are
- 21:49under constant pressure to be faster, faster, faster, make
- 21:52decisions faster, faster, faster.
- 21:54And then it becomes so much easier.
- 21:56Just let the system make the decision.
- 22:00Same thing if you're in school, you have to do a paper, it's due
- 22:04tomorrow. Much easier to just let the
- 22:07machine do it for you without actually thinking about what
- 22:11would you have written yourself. So we out, we outsource, we give
- 22:16away our own thinking process. I was thinking the part because
- 22:22I've been through that as well in the education part of it.
- 22:27So it's, it's like you're giving truly your creative giving.
- 22:32Like not even you don't use that creative part that you already
- 22:35have in the sense that you inherited and or you acquired
- 22:39that creativity throughout your life or during your life.
- 22:43So it's such, it's a pity because I mean, it's like, what
- 22:46is more beautiful than creativity?
- 22:50I'm not saying because I'm the an AI user like definitely.
- 22:54But as you have mentioned, Mark, I have learned from myself
- 22:59because you just said by experimenting like using it to
- 23:03making my mistakes and errors and so on and so forth.
- 23:07Changing the AI tools, using that, giving using another one,
- 23:12see which one it does what and how and which one it does better
- 23:16what in particular. So using one for an AI tool for
- 23:20one thing, using another type of AI tool for another thing,
- 23:24because they are having different way of being better at
- 23:28something, right? It's not that each of AI of
- 23:32those AI told that they're out, they're out out there.
- 23:36They do everything perfectly or good or exceptional.
- 23:39An exceptional work. I always say that it's what a, a
- 23:43human generates, not an AI, an exceptional one.
- 23:47In that sense, a good work is an AI, an exceptional work.
- 23:51It, it's a human mind. As such, this is my kind of my
- 23:55motto. So I mean, it's like that
- 23:59creativity. If we lose that and if you give
- 24:03up on that, it's like you're giving up part of your identity.
- 24:08And that's why also one of many other reasons I have had the
- 24:14pleasure and still have the pleasure to create this project
- 24:18podcast rewired to rise beyond the mindset, right?
- 24:22It's it's very specific. Deep dive into the name title as
- 24:26well. Because of this kind of stuff,
- 24:29because it's also related to our identity, we are going in so
- 24:33much changes that are currently and in the future, near future.
- 24:37That's the whole point and what expects us, it will be so much
- 24:42more than what we are living currently nowadays.
- 24:44So that's why I'm saying, actually, guys, from my point of
- 24:47view, again, you do whatever, but this is my personal point of
- 24:51view and my reflections that actually it's a competitive
- 24:55advantage, at least nowadays. Being creative and keeping that
- 25:00creativity to yourself and using it to your advantage by using AI
- 25:06tools, that's a different thing. What do you think, Mark?
- 25:10No, I agree. I agree creativity is going to
- 25:14be increasingly an asset in the future.
- 25:18And but I think we need to sort of distinguish because in a
- 25:24sense, you could talk about the machine creativity and human
- 25:31creativity. What you're talking about is the
- 25:33human creativity. That's what we're losing.
- 25:35But basically thinking about creativity, I always think about
- 25:39that human creativity is based on our experience, what we
- 25:43learn, what we see, what we hear and so on.
- 25:45Same as the case for for because.
- 25:49It is an experience. So while you're using AI tools,
- 25:52that's the whole point. Thank you, Mark.
- 25:53Yeah. Yeah, so there, I think there is
- 25:56such a thing as machine creativity, but it's something
- 25:58very different from from human creativity And and losing human
- 26:02creativity would be an immense loss because like you say, well,
- 26:08in a sense, I, I, I disagree with you because in a sense an
- 26:12AI, Yeah, Yeah, in a sense an AI can deliver a a perfect product.
- 26:19If we're talking about pictures, it can, it can make a perfect
- 26:23picture. But then again, do we want a
- 26:26perfect picture? Isn't what we consider beauty
- 26:29what we consider creativity and so on?
- 26:31Isn't it a human trait, something that is maybe even
- 26:37imperfect that that that's part of what we consider creative.
- 26:42So, so there are several different kinds of creativity.
- 26:47And I I think we should, we should really safeguard against
- 26:50losing the human creativity. Yeah.
- 26:54For younger generations, Mark, AI isn't something arriving
- 26:59arriving halfway through their careers.
- 27:03They are growing up with it, right?
- 27:05Obviously, what changes when AI becomes part of how you learn
- 27:10from the beginning at this point?
- 27:13AI in itself, I think is, isn't changing anything in in that
- 27:18sort of sense. What what changes is the way we
- 27:20use it, because if we use it unquestioningly, unreflectively,
- 27:28then we there are certain things that we don't learn.
- 27:33We don't learn to acquire knowledge ourselves to the
- 27:39things that you and I were taught growing up, going to
- 27:43school, when we started our professional lives.
- 27:46We we've learnt how to do things ourselves, how to how to get
- 27:52knowledge, how to generate knowledge, how to be creative
- 27:56and so on. And if, if you've always just
- 28:00pressed the button and got everything delivered to you in
- 28:05a, in a perfectly acceptable products, then maybe you don't
- 28:10think there's there's a reason to learn how to, to gather this
- 28:17knowledge yourself. And you will not know how to
- 28:22gather that knowledge. Maybe that's the more important
- 28:25point. You don't have the skills to
- 28:28fall back on like you and I do. Even if we lose ourselves, we
- 28:32could still go back to saying, OK, if, if, if all the
- 28:37electricity is gone and we can't use AI, OK, we can get by.
- 28:41But if you never learnt those things, you don't, you don't
- 28:44stand a chance. So we need to find a balance in
- 28:49this because it's also, and that sounds very, very doomy, very
- 28:54gloomy when I'm, when I'm talking like this because, but,
- 28:57but the, the other side of the argument is of course, that the
- 29:00AI can make us, as we talked about in the beginning, it can
- 29:03also make us smarter. So we have to strike a balance
- 29:07where we learn how to do these things ourselves, because then
- 29:10the products we get from the AI will also be be better than just
- 29:15asking the AI to do it by itself.
- 29:17So I think it's crucial that, and we're at a crucial point
- 29:21right now where, where we need to learn how do we maintain that
- 29:27balance? How is it that we, we have to
- 29:30stop young children from using these technologies until they're
- 29:34in their late teens? Or, or is it more about learning
- 29:38how to use them? Maybe I, I, I, I'm hearing a lot
- 29:43of different solutions on this, but the most, I think the most
- 29:47sensible solutions I hear are are those who sort of think in,
- 29:51in combining you both work without, but you also work with
- 29:55the systems. So you do learn the skills
- 29:59yourself, but you also learn how to use the systems, and that's
- 30:04the balance we have to strike in education in order to make sure
- 30:07that the younger generation gets the skills they need.
- 30:11Thank you so much for mentioning this.
- 30:12I think it's so, so very important at least for the
- 30:16current situation where we are and where we at.
- 30:21But actually I would like to also add something you have also
- 30:25mentioned about is AI making us smarter.
- 30:30And I have used this. I think it's so again, also this
- 30:33part is so very much misused. And not that it's the wrong
- 30:37thing using it, but it's, it's the wrong with the it's used as
- 30:42with the wrong purpose. Meaning from my point of view,
- 30:47I, I would say I would use it as a metaphor of as a figure of
- 30:50speech, because it's not absolutely about AI making you
- 30:54as a human, as a person, individual, etcetera, smarter,
- 30:59more more intelligent. It's not about that.
- 31:01What it means for me is that what what actually happened to
- 31:06me as well. That's why I'm saying it because
- 31:08I have been experimented this right on myself, first of all,
- 31:11in first hand. So it, it actually changed me in
- 31:16a way that I haven't ever been before.
- 31:20Meaning again, what I mean by that, it completely made me be
- 31:27more critical, which I haven't ever been like that, not in this
- 31:32way. And it's so funny.
- 31:35It's true. I give my word, this is really
- 31:37literally funny. And I, I hadn't never been so
- 31:41critical in this way, in this manner.
- 31:44I, I, I have been because it's also part of my job, of my
- 31:48professional part of it, but not in this particular way.
- 31:52So very much focus orientated in in such a Pam, Pam, Pam, you
- 31:58know, direct way of being critical, not going around
- 32:03around like we tend to do as human somehow in a sense that
- 32:08meaning that we might be afraid to not hurt other person
- 32:12feelings. So I'm thoughts or we are afraid
- 32:15to be judged by others while we are talking with somebody,
- 32:19therefore, etcetera, etcetera. Therefore, that meaning that we
- 32:22are tend to avoid that direct contact going through direct
- 32:28path and straight to the point and be just critical as such,
- 32:32you know, and it helped me and it's changed me so so much like
- 32:37I have never been so in from that point of view.
- 32:41I personally Mirela can say that yes is true AI change me and
- 32:46make me smarter coating but as a metaphor so smarter in that way
- 32:51because I have acquired new skills that I have never had
- 32:55before. It's such an interesting topic.
- 32:58I I just love it, and the more I use it, the more I get into that
- 33:02purpose as such, call it whatever.
- 33:05Yeah, maybe, maybe it's more precise to say rather than
- 33:08making us smarter, it gives us the best opportunities to learn
- 33:12it or it can give us the best opportunity to learn.
- 33:15I think in my case, it, it has, it hasn't changed me, but it, it
- 33:21has enhanced some aspects of what I already do, my critical
- 33:26thinking, my, my research and so on.
- 33:29It, it, it helps me, it becomes a tool in a sense.
- 33:33And it, it, it makes more things possible.
- 33:36It makes me learn faster, it makes me learn more and so on.
- 33:42And, and I think that's part of the key.
- 33:44I mean, because it it does it, it, it teaches us in in or it
- 33:48can help to teach us more directly the way you were.
- 33:53We, we learn individually. And this is what I mean by
- 33:57making people smarter in in in general because in our education
- 34:01system it is so far been built on A1 size fit all model.
- 34:06Yeah, I agree. Unfortunately, I I have to deal
- 34:09with the remark. Yeah.
- 34:10And that means that that this fits some people.
- 34:13Of course some people flourish under this system, but some
- 34:15people fall through and and maybe are not successful or at
- 34:19least have a very difficult time and have to make their own way.
- 34:22This makes it possible from the start to actually differentiate
- 34:26because it's very difficult with just one teacher to to or, or
- 34:30one professor to actually differentiate in, in all the
- 34:35different ways that their students are are learning.
- 34:37But this makes it actually possible.
- 34:40And in that sense, it makes us smarter.
- 34:43It makes us more able to fulfil our potential, right?
- 34:47In, in a sense that, that, that saying it makes us smarter is in
- 34:52a way a, a, a metaphor for actually using the skills or
- 34:57the, the, the, yeah, the the what we can do better.
- 35:03Mark, imagine you are 20 years old and AI helps you research,
- 35:07write, study, plan your career, and even make personal
- 35:12decisions. How do you know which thoughts
- 35:15are actually yours? You do it by making your own
- 35:19thoughts the starting point and you have meaning.
- 35:23You have to make up your own mind.
- 35:25If you are writing a paper or something, make up your mind
- 35:29about what is this going to be about what, what is your opinion
- 35:33about this? And think about the AI more like
- 35:38a study group that you throw out your opinion in and, and discuss
- 35:44what what happens. And then you make up your mind
- 35:47from the discussion and so on. But you have to start with your
- 35:51own and you have to end with your own thoughts.
- 35:54And that's how you, if you always do that, then you have
- 35:58the attention that is necessary in order not to let the AI just
- 36:05take over and make, make all the come with all the the solutions
- 36:11you have. This has to be your solutions
- 36:13because otherwise it doesn't matter.
- 36:16Then what you're doing has no value because you don't learn
- 36:21from it. So you have to start by making
- 36:24up your own mind. What is my opinion about this?
- 36:27And then you can use the feedback you get from the
- 36:30system. Plenty of ideas.
- 36:34Maybe it changes your mind, maybe it doesn't change your
- 36:36mind, but it gives you something to relate to the answer you get
- 36:41from the system. So you have to start in short
- 36:44with yourself and with yourself. That's how you make sure that
- 36:49that this is this is yours and that's something you prompted
- 36:53out of machine. But do you think, Mark, that we
- 36:56are reaching a point where knowing how not to use AI could
- 37:03become just as important as knowing how to use it?
- 37:07Only in the sense that it it's, it's super important to know how
- 37:11to use it. And in that sense, it's, it's
- 37:14important to know how to, not to use it.
- 37:18I like to, even though I sometimes sound a bit doomy and
- 37:21gloomy, like I said, I like to take the positive view.
- 37:25I like to take to say, this is the potential, this is what it
- 37:30can do for you. This is how you do it.
- 37:34So, so I, I don't really want to focus, but you should of course
- 37:38pay attention to not just using it uncritically, But so, so in
- 37:46that sense, you could say that it's just as important to know
- 37:48how not to use it. But but in my to my mind, the
- 37:52most important thing is knowing how to use it and to to focus
- 37:56your energy there. So I completely agree,
- 37:59Absolutely. Yeah, very helpful.
- 38:02Learn to use it to learn how or when not to use it.
- 38:06Seriously. Makes completely sense.
- 38:09So if you were speaking directly to a young person using AI every
- 38:14day, Mark what it is One ability you would tell them never to
- 38:19outsource. Your own reflection, I mean your
- 38:23own thoughts make up your own mind.
- 38:27But then again, it's you could say that it's the same thing in
- 38:30connection to other people. You don't want to take just
- 38:34uncritically take over other people's opinions.
- 38:37The same thing here. You have to make up your own
- 38:39mind because otherwise you will not be able to distinguish what
- 38:44is yours and what is someone else's.
- 38:48And you will not learn because that is what we're, that is
- 38:52basically what it's about. Even in in just a discussion,
- 38:55even when you and I talk, there is always something to learn
- 38:59from everybody you talk to. But you don't learn if you don't
- 39:03reflect on what you're you're being given.
- 39:06So that is the basis of everything.
- 39:09You don't want to give away your thought process.
- 39:11You don't want to give away making up your own mind.
- 39:15Well, at this point, Mark, let's make it a little bit more
- 39:18practical. Would you personally trust an AI
- 39:22to write an important message for you?
- 39:26Depends on what kind of message. It depends on how important it
- 39:30is. If it's a personal message,
- 39:32well, no, I wouldn't and but it's not so much a matter of
- 39:36trust, it's more a matter of well, it's easier writing it
- 39:40myself and faster instead of starting to prompt a language
- 39:47model to to do it for me with. About emails for example, are
- 39:53you using it for? Emails, yes, but to a point I
- 39:59don't think I ever trust. Any AI to do a complete job?
- 40:04Same here. Yeah, yeah.
- 40:06I mean, you can ask and say I want to write an e-mail to this
- 40:10person about this subject with these questions or something and
- 40:13make it come with a suggestion. And depending on not all the
- 40:19emails are that important. We all know that from our
- 40:23professional lives and also from, from studying and not all
- 40:26of them, but you at least have to make sure that it's correct.
- 40:29What's it, what it says in the mail and it conveys the message
- 40:33you want to convey. So, so emails, so on.
- 40:38I also distinguish a lot about importance.
- 40:43What, what is, what is the importance of the message that I
- 40:46want to convey? Some things I would never trust.
- 40:51I mean, if I if I write an article then I will.
- 40:58I might let it come with a suggestion, but I I never
- 41:02published the article without actually reading through what it
- 41:05says and doesn't convey what I say.
- 41:07I'm curious what tool, tool or tools do you use to reply to
- 41:11emails or this kind of for this kind of tasks?
- 41:15I answer my own emails because in many cases it's faster.
- 41:20It's just short messages. It's, it's a lot faster just
- 41:23answering the because you're already in the in that system
- 41:28reading the the e-mail. So if it's just two lines, if
- 41:32it's part of something else, I I would probably use ChatGPT and
- 41:36give it specific instructions on what I want to do and then it
- 41:40can suggest to me a text for the e-mail.
- 41:44Also because ChatGPT nowadays is a tiny bit incorporated almost
- 41:48everywhere that I mean you have it as a plug in option blah blah
- 41:52etcetera. So.
- 41:54I think it's, it's actually, I think it's a matter of taste
- 41:59these days, especially for the simple things.
- 42:01What do you prefer? Do you prefer Gemini?
- 42:03Do you prefer Claude? I, I, I distinguish a bit
- 42:08between the the tasks because there are slight differences
- 42:14from the different models at what they're actually good at.
- 42:17But a basic e-mail or something like that.
- 42:19If you want to suggest for that I will use ChatGPT.
- 42:24Yeah, that that what I was mentioning earlier on as well.
- 42:26Yeah, yeah, definitely. I was just asking you a minute
- 42:30ago, would you trust an AI to write an an important message?
- 42:35But would you trust an AI to choose what you should study, or
- 42:42giving you career advice, or helping decide who gets hired,
- 42:47for example, even would you do that?
- 42:50I don't think it would make sense to make it allow it to
- 42:53choose what I should study that should be based on on my
- 42:57assessment. It could give me advice and and
- 43:01it can give me advice as to what the basically the choice has to
- 43:08be mine. And I mean otherwise the choice
- 43:11doesn't make sense to me. Using it for, for hiring people,
- 43:15Yes, to a certain extent. I mean, there are systems who
- 43:19can, who can do this, but that's the same weaknesses that human
- 43:23humans does because it's biased. So you have to be aware of both
- 43:28your own bias and the system's bias.
- 43:30And I, I've been speculating maybe, maybe an AI could be more
- 43:36balanced actually when hiring people, because when we as
- 43:40people sit and hire people, we tend to hire people that look
- 43:43like ourselves, that have the same background, especially if
- 43:46it's, it's for a position that we know very well, we will hire
- 43:50the same kind of people every time.
- 43:52And you can actually make an, an AI more distinguished about that
- 43:56or otherwise you have to be very aware of your own biases to
- 44:00avoid that. So so in in a sense, yes, I
- 44:04would use an AI and a hiring process.
- 44:08But also my for me personally would be a mix of both to I
- 44:12would try to not lose that my discernment as such as as a
- 44:17person might be that I'm, I'm in charge working in the HR or I'm
- 44:22the CEO whatsoever. I like to keep me grounded and
- 44:27updated. Let's put it like that on
- 44:29everything I do and I'm I'm, I'm responsible for it.
- 44:34But again, I think there's a, there's a difference between
- 44:37different kind of hiring processes.
- 44:39If you're a small company and you're hiring something that
- 44:41that doesn't make any sense, I mean, you might as well sit down
- 44:45and talk to and it it might be even more important to to hire
- 44:48somebody who who who can work with you and you can make a an
- 44:52assessment, a personal assessment.
- 44:54When you sit in front. If you're a large company that
- 44:57has to recruit a lot of different people, yeah, I would
- 45:01prefer that be a human being at the end.
- 45:03But the sorting process can be done by.
- 45:06Why are we comfortable giving AI authority in some areas but
- 45:13uncomfortable in others? And what actually determines
- 45:17that boundary? I don't think it's necessarily
- 45:21logic what we trusted to do and what we don't trust to do
- 45:24because most of us don't know enough in order to actually make
- 45:29that a differentiation. I mean, most of us doesn't
- 45:35necessarily understand yet what is an AI good at and what isn't
- 45:40it good at. And that should be the basis of
- 45:42what we, what we trusted to do and not random feelings, but
- 45:47what we are irrational beings, humans.
- 45:50And I think, I think that has a lot of influence on what we
- 45:54trust and what we don't trust. Well, AI can produce an answer
- 45:59that sounds extremely confident. We all know because it's built
- 46:03to give you a confirmation and never kind of say to you or
- 46:09reply to you no in that sense. So what should an ordinary
- 46:14person look for before the signing?
- 46:17I trust this. I guess basically I always say
- 46:22don't trust it because no, like we talked about, you have to be
- 46:26critical about it because a lot of what comes out of it you can
- 46:30trust. But if you worked as
- 46:35specifically as you and I have with these, you have experienced
- 46:41times when it delivers an answer that sounds correct, even if you
- 46:45know about the subject that you're dealing with, but it can
- 46:49still be wrong. I've had it when I, like I said,
- 46:52I always ask for sources because then I can check.
- 46:56I've had entire lists of sources being made-up from the bottom up
- 47:02and, and most of the time it doesn't.
- 47:03That doesn't happen, of course, but it happens once in a while.
- 47:07Do you need to make sure that this is actually correct which
- 47:11you're sitting with? So basically, don't trust it.
- 47:14Well, when AI gives gives us exactly the answer we wanted to
- 47:20hear again, because I want to insist slightly tiny bit on
- 47:23that, is that perhaps the moment we should actually question it
- 47:28more or the most? Definitely, because that's when
- 47:32we're at least critical. If we, we get the answer we
- 47:34want, then then of course we're going to say, ah, see what I
- 47:38meant? I was right from the start and
- 47:42it, and that's the easiest and that's the, that's the normal
- 47:45reaction that we have. I mean, also when you get people
- 47:48agreeing with you, then see, I'm right.
- 47:51And but you can't do that with a, with an AI.
- 47:54You have to question it. And, and in that sense, yes,
- 47:57that is the situation where you have to question it even more
- 47:59because that is when it's most difficult actually being
- 48:02critical about it. Well, let's say AI gives me the
- 48:07structure, improves my argument, rewrites 3 paragraphs and fix my
- 48:15conclusion. Even at that, at what point does
- 48:18my work stop being mine, Mark? Well, it doesn't reflect your
- 48:23thinking then it's it's it's not yours.
- 48:27You can discuss language wise and so on if if it's not your
- 48:32language and so on. But if it does reflect what you
- 48:36want and the thoughts that you've made and the arguments
- 48:40you made, then it is your work. You make this decisions.
- 48:48I mean, if you make the decision, if you decide what is
- 48:50this about, what should the arguments be, so on and so
- 48:53forth, then having it help you, helping you with the, the
- 48:59language side of it is not a problem in my book, because a
- 49:02lot of people are not strong in language.
- 49:05You and I, maybe we can write whatever we can, we can, we can
- 49:10put down on paper our thoughts and so on, but not everybody can
- 49:13do that. So, so if you're dyslexic for
- 49:18for instance, is it just because you put your thoughts in
- 49:24misspellings and whatever grammatical mistakes in it and
- 49:28it takes it and changes into something more readable?
- 49:33I think it's still your work because you deliver the thought,
- 49:38you deliver the arguments and so on.
- 49:41It's, it's only if, if, if you let it from beginning to end,
- 49:45write the whole thing, you don't make the decision as to what is
- 49:49this about, what is the arguments, what is the
- 49:52conclusions and so on. Then it's not your work.
- 49:56And that that's what happened. Some, I mean the, the, the
- 49:59dangerous thing is that you don't go all the way and then it
- 50:02slips at the end. You get a different conclusion
- 50:06than the 1 you would have made. Then it's not your work.
- 50:10Well, since we talk about this, me and my guest previously, we
- 50:14have just finished our last AI and human future life event,
- 50:20right? And it was about specific about
- 50:22AI and beauty this time. So we were actually talking also
- 50:27about this part, well, well actually in the Q&A section part
- 50:33of it. And I have asked to the guys for
- 50:35to my guest, my speakers this question as well.
- 50:37One piece of work by using AI not throughout as I mentioned
- 50:44through with my last question, by creating the structure or the
- 50:49conclusion or the argument, etcetera, right.
- 50:52But by using it Even so, you know, brainstorming etcetera and
- 50:57it gives me an end result, OK. Do you consider it still mine or
- 51:04or is mine even or not? Can I say it's mine and it's I
- 51:10have another question that is connected please Mark what in
- 51:13case of generating a picture then, because it starts from my
- 51:17script, right? In that case though, it can be
- 51:20considered my piece of art or not in that case as well please.
- 51:26I'm curious to hear your point of view.
- 51:28I, I think it's, it's an interesting discussion, but in,
- 51:31in, in my view, AI is a tool. So I could pose the question to
- 51:37you. You take a picture with a
- 51:39camera, an old fashioned camera. You take a picture with a
- 51:42camera, you get a nice picture. Who took the picture?
- 51:46Did you or did the camera? In that case you want, you have
- 51:50no doubt you took the picture. But why is it?
- 51:54Why is this any different from the the AI?
- 51:57The difference is of course is in in what you put into the
- 52:02creation. And this is the answer you got
- 52:04from your guests on your live on your live session as well.
- 52:08It depends on how much information did you give as a
- 52:15basis for the the end product, How reflect how many reflections
- 52:22did you put in? Because if you write rather long
- 52:27prompt where you make the decisions as to this is what I
- 52:31wanted the picture, this is the angle, this is the lighting,
- 52:34this, these are the persons or animals or the landscape or
- 52:38whatever. Then I would say you made the
- 52:42picture again. You could turn around and say,
- 52:45OK, what if you were a painter and you were using a brush?
- 52:50Did you do the picture or did the brush?
- 52:53The brush did, of course. No, I think it's, it's, it's,
- 53:00it's actually very simple. AI isn't that different from
- 53:05what we. Have but I always said I said
- 53:07also on my last podcast episode with Urica shows like the the
- 53:11same identical thing. I give her an example because we
- 53:14were going really fast and from so many points, personal
- 53:18branding, etcetera, so I had to make it really fast.
- 53:21But I was giving her the example of, as you just mentioned, if I
- 53:26can't afford a professional photographer, right, because I
- 53:32might need it from so many reasons.
- 53:33I have certain project projects that it's necessary to have a
- 53:38specialist, right, a professional and I can't afford
- 53:41it for many reasons because they are very expensive, at least
- 53:44those goods at it, right? So I just prefer to spend less,
- 53:49but still have a professional in this case, which is right away
- 53:53an AI tool, right. So that's what I was saying to
- 53:56Ulrika as well. So it's like, what is the
- 53:59difference then, as you just mentioned, Mark?
- 54:01And it's like for me it's, it's just, I, it wasn't a human, but
- 54:04it's still my sparring partner, so.
- 54:06Again, what? What do you need it for?
- 54:08I mean I publish a a a monthly publication about AI.
- 54:13Like you said, I don't have a budget to hire professional
- 54:16photographer. I have two options, either I go
- 54:20out and buy a rather cheap stock photo of a lot of boring people
- 54:25in an office, or I make the AI generate me something that could
- 54:30be even more exciting than just some boring people in an office.
- 54:35So, and, and I'm not necessarily claiming that this is art and,
- 54:40and this is my production, so it depends on what you need it for,
- 54:44but it's still something I did. I mean, I made the decision.
- 54:48I, I'm writing an article about this.
- 54:51I want something that illustrates that.
- 54:53And in this case, I want something photorealistic that is
- 54:56like an office it. But could we make it a bit more
- 54:59interesting or I want something more editorial that's sort of
- 55:03maybe a collage of something. What's the difference between
- 55:08that and me hiring a graphic, a professional graphic to to put
- 55:13something together? It's it's, it's still usable for
- 55:18for what I'm and I and I, I recognise the fact because I
- 55:24feel the same thing that you are in some instances more attracted
- 55:30to reading or viewing something that isn't AI produced.
- 55:34I mean there is a certain style of pictures that you just
- 55:37recognise immediately as being AI generate And you you already
- 55:42there have an opinion about the the product here is boring.
- 55:47The first impression, those 2/3 seconds because other human
- 55:51being guys consciously or in consciously even most most of
- 55:57the time in consciously. That's the whole point.
- 55:59That's why I'm saying this recognize again, without even
- 56:05knowing it, being aware of what it's been interesting for that
- 56:10person and what is not. So it's literally physically
- 56:14tangible in a tangible way about those two 3 seconds, like right
- 56:18away the impact or you have that impact.
- 56:21Aha, aha moment in the sense that, oh gosh, this is really
- 56:25capture my attention. Why is that?
- 56:27Let's dive into it in that sense.
- 56:30So that in that point, those 23 seconds, like the algorithm
- 56:34works the same thing. Or when you add the hooks or
- 56:38whatever, it might be in, in within the text body might be in
- 56:41a picture, it might be in a video, it might be, you know,
- 56:44the overlay or whatever. That's so many things that it's
- 56:48related to marked in branding, etcetera.
- 56:50So in this case of AI usage as well, like as you mentioned,
- 56:55because let's be honest and realistic, I mean, like not
- 56:59being hypocrites in that sense, we all seen even even too much.
- 57:04Again, I'm not against it, but I'm just saying like, that's it
- 57:07because it's connected to the part of the creativity, you
- 57:10know, And that's why I'm saying I'm seeing so much of AI
- 57:15generated pictures, images, whatever in that sense, but that
- 57:19they are the same. That's what I'm trying to say.
- 57:21Not because it's a bad thing using it, It's it's completely
- 57:25fine. It's it's very helpful as we
- 57:27have talked throughout all this time, right?
- 57:30But put some, you know, add your imprint, like add something that
- 57:37it's belongs to you, that is part of you, that it's part of
- 57:40your inner beauty or even external beauty.
- 57:43That is like, I'm sorry, Mike, you're a man.
- 57:46But for women, for example, you have a personal touch when you
- 57:50add your makeup or put your makeup on your face.
- 57:53I'm telling this, I'm talking to women in this case, I might be
- 57:56even men, You never know. But just saying like it's so
- 57:59deep, completely different because it's just put something
- 58:02that also literally gives that uniqueness, uniqueness in that
- 58:07sense, not that you are unique. Again, I have been talking over
- 58:11and over again about this uniqueness as well.
- 58:13Just, you know, kind of to start to differentiate yourself so you
- 58:17can have that niche. This is how you create your
- 58:20niche. Actually.
- 58:21It's not just just about being in one platform or 10 platforms
- 58:27or 20. You can do either one or even
- 58:30the other one or even both. But if you don't distinguish
- 58:33yourself by using that uniqueness that actually
- 58:36distinguish your yourself as a person, as a leader, but also as
- 58:40a professional. That's the whole point actually.
- 58:43This is your advantage, guys, just using your personality,
- 58:48your identity, even in your job, because this is actually your
- 58:53competitive advantage. This is what it's about that
- 58:57uniqueness. This is how you create your
- 59:00niche. Literally that funnel funnel in
- 59:03in the marketing used used in a lot, a lot in the marketing and
- 59:07branding is about finding one and you hear so much about also
- 59:12people that they sorry, they don't even know what they are
- 59:15talking about. Was seriously like, oh, use the
- 59:17funnel here is the funnel there or blah, blah, blah, by just
- 59:21prompting with chat TPT and then share it on social media.
- 59:24But they didn't even know how to use it or or the purpose of it,
- 59:28the of it. So my point is that, yeah, it's
- 59:31not true that you have to have, it's mandatory to have a niche.
- 59:36It's in that sense the niche is you.
- 59:39You created by just using your personality and your identity to
- 59:43give a personality and an identity to your brand.
- 59:47This is it. This is it.
- 59:51Like just saying it, it's perfect guys, take it.
- 59:54And and and and and my take on this is that you can put that
- 59:59personal touch even on AI generated material.
- 1:00:03It doesn't have to be the same as everybody else because again,
- 1:00:07you you see it not as much anymore because people are using
- 1:00:10air generated images all over the web, for example.
- 1:00:13But but not that long ago you would see people using the exact
- 1:00:17same stock folders. And especially when you're
- 1:00:20talking about tech journalism or tech blocks, they'd used exactly
- 1:00:25the same stock photos and they used them over and over again.
- 1:00:30I'm saying that you could actually do something that
- 1:00:32differentiates you more with AI generated material.
- 1:00:36But of course, you have to like everything else.
- 1:00:38You have to put an effort into it and you have to, you have to
- 1:00:42care about what you do. Be serious, be professional.
- 1:00:46Exactly. This is what it's about,
- 1:00:47Absolutely. So at this point, Mark, please,
- 1:00:50I would like you to ask you what happens to creativity again when
- 1:00:54we increasingly begin with what AI actually suggests us instead
- 1:01:00of struggling with that blank page ourselves.
- 1:01:04Yeah, we lose, we lose the ability.
- 1:01:06I mean, it's, it's like reflection.
- 1:01:08It's like making up your own mind, making your own argument,
- 1:01:11making your own points. Same thing happens to your
- 1:01:14creativity. It is a muscle that you have to
- 1:01:18use in order to become better. But, but just to be able, just
- 1:01:23to have the skill, you have to exercise that muscle and, and
- 1:01:27that's what we lose. We lose the capability of doing
- 1:01:31things ourselves if we just leave everything to the system.
- 1:01:35So Mark, at this point, please, at least from your point of
- 1:01:39view, and then I'm going to add mine personal.
- 1:01:43What did you feel was missing from the way people were being
- 1:01:48taught about AI? Because actually this was our
- 1:01:51kind of main core common track that put us together, bring us
- 1:01:57together. I think what again, at risk of
- 1:02:01of, of repeating myself, I think what was missing was the
- 1:02:08reflection making people think. And I think that's what we've
- 1:02:13done to a large extent with the the the interactive tech guide.
- 1:02:18Start a discussion, take form your own opinion about these
- 1:02:23things. That's what we're going to do
- 1:02:24when we start a dialogue on how should, how should we use this
- 1:02:30system? Because we all too often discuss
- 1:02:33what can they do instead of asking the questions of what,
- 1:02:35what should we use them for? And that's what that's what
- 1:02:39we're trying to do with the interactive tech guy, for
- 1:02:41example. It's to make people reflect,
- 1:02:45make up their own decisions and hopefully debate this, talk to
- 1:02:49other people about it, learn from each other, learn from each
- 1:02:52other's perspectives, and through that sort of shock in
- 1:02:57your own. Well from my perspective since I
- 1:03:02literally I am falling in love of this project for real.
- 1:03:09Well let's start simple right? It's a Co creation between Co
- 1:03:13creation learning library. That's the whole thing for free
- 1:03:17guys between AI portrayal and what's your digital journal
- 1:03:22platform right and rewire to rise with this this platform.
- 1:03:26And it's not just simply learning AI.
- 1:03:29That's the whole point because it's not about the AI about that
- 1:03:34it is helping people use AI without surrendering judgement,
- 1:03:40their own judgement, autonomy, they're autonomy and that
- 1:03:44strategic oversight that we have talked constantly until this
- 1:03:49point. So it contains just Mark.
- 1:03:53Please correct me if I'm I'm avoiding something by mistake.
- 1:03:57It contains models that they are made by Mark, by the way, so AI
- 1:04:02Patel that you can practice for free at your own piece at home
- 1:04:07in the car, No, in the car, no, please don't do that.
- 1:04:11But listening at least listening while you are driving whatever
- 1:04:15practical exercises even again, they are for free until when I
- 1:04:20don't know. So hurry up and even tools and
- 1:04:24articles from Mark, which by again, it's a part of the
- 1:04:29airport tail. So in in the future, near future
- 1:04:33will also create some live streams mostly for members like
- 1:04:40monthly members who want to deep dive into it like Q&A's that
- 1:04:44where me and Mark, we are going to answer or reply to your
- 1:04:48questions or whatever you might have or doubts whatsoever.
- 1:04:53There will be also events and Mark doesn't know yet, but also
- 1:04:58live in person. Don't tell him it's a surprise
- 1:05:03he doesn't know yet. And and we arrived to the really
- 1:05:09fantastic point, which it's about our community.
- 1:05:12Mark, please can you share with others what we have built there
- 1:05:16in this beautiful community, what they can find?
- 1:05:21Yes, this is exactly what I was talking about, trying to
- 1:05:24stimulate the conversation, trying to get the debate going.
- 1:05:29This is trying to provide a forum where you can come and
- 1:05:33discuss the ideas. You could take to start off with
- 1:05:37the ideas that Mirela and I present to you on the page or in
- 1:05:42in this podcast, for example. Or you could, you could set up
- 1:05:46your own discussions. What is it?
- 1:05:48Because that is, like I said, that is the point of the whole
- 1:05:51page, to make this to, to, to stimulate the conversation about
- 1:05:57what, what do we want to use this kind of technology for?
- 1:06:01We can give you some tools, but you still have to make up your
- 1:06:05own mind. And the best way to do that is
- 1:06:08through a dialogue. And that is what the that that
- 1:06:10is what the community is. So is meant to be sort of a
- 1:06:18place to unfold. So again, just to recap a mark
- 1:06:23for others who might actually tuned in afterwards or later on.
- 1:06:27This is the community as such, we didn't create a guys as a
- 1:06:33frail framed as another AI news, whatever discussion group.
- 1:06:38It is more than that. It is supposed to help people,
- 1:06:44you people guys, filter the information.
- 1:06:47That's the whole point. Preserve your judgement again
- 1:06:52and actually apply what what you have learned like throughout all
- 1:06:59that on the website interactive tech guide.
- 1:07:03So me and Mark, we going to be there constantly answer to your
- 1:07:07question. We you are not alone.
- 1:07:10I'm not saying 24/7 because otherwise we should create an A
- 1:07:13a agent and that's a little bit it's too much, AII would say,
- 1:07:19because that's the whole point that this was built to this
- 1:07:22community most of all specifically for they to
- 1:07:26interact with each other throughout leaders, but not only
- 1:07:30managers, so even normal people. Again, this community is not for
- 1:07:34experts, AI experts, it's for everyone.
- 1:07:37Even if you are from starting from the scratch, doesn't
- 1:07:40matter. Just come there with your
- 1:07:42questions. Does whatsoever try a model to
- 1:07:45try find something that you already find there for free
- 1:07:49Again, so you can also go to that community and try to catch
- 1:07:55up or what others might say or others opinions or what sort of
- 1:08:00thoughts or reflections. And again, as I mentioned, me
- 1:08:03and Mark, we were going to be there and try to interact with
- 1:08:06you most of all. So the community is not really
- 1:08:09about AI expertise again, it's all about what happens to humans
- 1:08:14when AI becomes ordinary. Guys, just for you to know.
- 1:08:18Yes, I agree completely. This is about, this is about
- 1:08:21humans. This is not about technology.
- 1:08:23It's what it does to us, it what what we want to do with it.
- 1:08:27And and for for that reason, it's not for experts, it's not
- 1:08:31for people who has long educations in the subject.
- 1:08:35It's for everybody. And it's a place to take those
- 1:08:40discussions to learn and to share what you've learned and,
- 1:08:44and discuss it with other people and to make up your own mind.
- 1:08:48Exactly, that's the point. Whole point you will have the
- 1:08:51free will to decide for yourself.
- 1:08:53Is that good? Is that good?
- 1:08:55Is it healthy? It's for me.
- 1:08:57It is not what we have talked throughout all this podcast
- 1:09:00episode until this point. I mean, this is very
- 1:09:04interesting. I, I don't think actually that
- 1:09:07there is something like that. That's that's why actually me
- 1:09:10and Mark isn't Mark, we have decided to create such a thing.
- 1:09:14But I, I do think that there is something that is missing out
- 1:09:17there in regards to that's maintaining that clarity in that
- 1:09:24sense. Again, as we have talked me and
- 1:09:26you until this point, Mark, for, for persons, for humans, not for
- 1:09:29AIS because it's full of AI agents, right?
- 1:09:32It's not a bad thing. Again, it's, I'm, I'm not
- 1:09:35talking about that. I'm not saying that.
- 1:09:37It's just that it's completely different because we, we risk to
- 1:09:40miss out like literally what we actually need and what we
- 1:09:44desire. And keep that in mind and keep
- 1:09:47our free will and our mental support so we can be balanced as
- 1:09:54such because we might have so many doubts and and questions
- 1:09:58even where do I find those questions?
- 1:10:00Because again, it's my things ironic, but it's so very true
- 1:10:05still currently that there is so much information out there that
- 1:10:10you don't know what to pick, what to select.
- 1:10:13You don't even know what to think.
- 1:10:15Is it real? Is it not real?
- 1:10:17Is it true? It's not true?
- 1:10:19How can I find if it's true or not?
- 1:10:21Then, you know, just mention mark that AI, even AI most of
- 1:10:25the time, not often, but sometimes it can give you the
- 1:10:30wrong answer reply and because it hallucinates it.
- 1:10:34That's the whole point. And it happens very often with
- 1:10:37AI's. So this community guys, it's
- 1:10:39about that at so you can get that help and that clarity so
- 1:10:44you can get the right help from professional.
- 1:10:47And that's just random individual to have the the the
- 1:10:52to arrive to a point where you can decide for yourself.
- 1:10:54Yes, that I can use this tool because it might be more
- 1:10:57suitable because I am like that or my tone of voice.
- 1:11:00It's, it's like that, isn't it, Mark?
- 1:11:03No, exactly, exactly. Couldn't have said it better
- 1:11:07myself. If someone enters the
- 1:11:09Interactive Tech Guide today, what can they actually do there
- 1:11:12rather than simply just read about AI?
- 1:11:15If you read about what AI do to you as an individual, what you
- 1:11:22should avoid, what what you should learn, it is about the
- 1:11:27human side of things and not the technology side of things.
- 1:11:31Of course, the technology is interesting.
- 1:11:33It enables us to do a lot of things.
- 1:11:35But what's important here and what we're missing in a lot of
- 1:11:39other contexts is actually to look at what it does to us as
- 1:11:44humans and what we should take care of and what we should
- 1:11:48preserve. What's important?
- 1:11:50True. Last question, I promise Mark,
- 1:11:54but not less important, actually the opposite.
- 1:11:58Well, if AI becomes more capable every year, which does?
- 1:12:05What do humans need to become better at so that we don't
- 1:12:11simply become better users of AI, but better thinkers
- 1:12:15alongside it? Well, we have to get better at
- 1:12:19being human. That's always the point for for
- 1:12:22everybody. We need to create, to preserve
- 1:12:27and to train our thinking. We need to use our experiences,
- 1:12:37what makes us unique as humans, and that is what in the end
- 1:12:42differentiates us from from these models.
- 1:12:45They sound human. They are not human.
- 1:12:48Like we talked about before, it's the imperfections that
- 1:12:53actually make something beautiful.
- 1:12:56Or even you could say it's what makes things interesting.
- 1:13:00And this is something you don't get from the technology.
- 1:13:03You get something smooth, you get something and you can of
- 1:13:08course prompt it to be more human, but it isn't you.
- 1:13:12So we have to. And this, I think, has always
- 1:13:16been the point for for for every one of us to become better at
- 1:13:22what we are, to become better at what we do, to to strengthen
- 1:13:27ourselves as humans. So true.
- 1:13:30Thank you Mark. Thank you so very much.
- 1:13:32We have arrived to achieve the end of this podcast episode.
- 1:13:35It was such an experience like always.
- 1:13:38Thank you so much, I really appreciate it.
- 1:13:40Thank you for for having me on. It was very interesting.
- 1:13:43A great discussion and a very necessary discussion right now.
- 1:13:48Indeed, indeed. And for those last thing, for
- 1:13:50those who are interested to go and catch up or see what it's
- 1:13:55about all this about interactive tech guide.
- 1:13:58You can find it in the description of this podcast
- 1:14:01episode, but also in the comments sections.
- 1:14:05So go and check the community and all the material for now,
- 1:14:09free material that you can explore or learn even.
- 1:14:14Yeah. Thank you, Mark.
- 1:14:16Thank you.