Latest / AV SuperFriends / AV SuperFriends: Off the Rails - I'm a psychologist, but I'm not YOUR psychologist
Transcript
- 0:03This is AV Superfriends Off the Rails,
- 0:05an almost regularly scheduled open
- 0:07discussion on audio and video in higher
- 0:09education.
- 0:10We'll sound off about our most brilliant
- 0:12ideas, our dumbest mistakes,
- 0:13and everything in between.
- 0:15And because this conversation will almost
- 0:16certainly go off the rails at some point,
- 0:18we'll end up covering just about
- 0:20everything else.
- 0:21And now, the AV Superfriends.
- 0:28For January, twenty third,
- 0:29twenty twenty six,
- 0:30it's the best sounding and most friendly
- 0:32podcast in higher ed.
- 0:34This is the super friends off the rails.
- 0:35Episode number one hundred and thirty.
- 0:38That's too many.
- 0:39That's a lot.
- 0:40It's an even number.
- 0:41Delete the first.
- 0:43There's a lot of folders I have to
- 0:44navigate through.
- 0:45There's a lot of stuff out there to
- 0:46find.
- 0:46Broadcasting live across four time zones,
- 0:48faster than an LLM,
- 0:50rewriting a syllabus five minutes before
- 0:52class starts,
- 0:52where pilot projects become policy,
- 0:55buzzwords become strategy,
- 0:56and every campus claims they're just
- 0:59exploring AI while rewriting everything.
- 1:02I'm Chris Decker.
- 1:02You're tuned in for another Friday
- 1:05afternoon podcast adventure.
- 1:06I just scrolled that right off the screen
- 1:08here.
- 1:09And let's say hello to today's panel of
- 1:11AV Super Friends.
- 1:14Our first panelist leads the deployment of
- 1:16cameras, microphone sensors,
- 1:17and AI systems that confidently caption
- 1:20nonsense.
- 1:21He's a director of artificial perception
- 1:23and hybrid reality services from Kansas
- 1:25City.
- 1:25Say hello to Mr. Jamie Reinhart.
- 1:28The hardest part has been teaching AI that
- 1:30not all actions of students are labeled
- 1:33dumbass in the closed caption.
- 1:35It's pronounced Dumont.
- 1:36Oh, my God.
- 1:36It's Dumont.
- 1:39Our next panelist oversees AI-enabled
- 1:41learning spaces that anticipate technical
- 1:43failures, generate support tickets,
- 1:44and still require a technician to reboot
- 1:46everything.
- 1:46He's an assistant director of sentient
- 1:49classrooms and predictive support
- 1:50operations from Corvallis, Oregon.
- 1:52Say hello to Mr. Mark Kolowczynski.
- 1:54Just standing by to unplug the main server
- 1:56when given the correct signal.
- 1:58Turn it off and back on again.
- 2:01Our next panelist manages intelligent
- 2:03meeting ecosystems that automatically
- 2:05schedule, moderate, transcribe, summarize,
- 2:07and occasionally misunderstand
- 2:08institutional collaboration.
- 2:10He's a senior manager of autonomous
- 2:12conferencing and machine-assisted
- 2:13facilitation from Greensboro,
- 2:15North Carolina.
- 2:15Say hello to Mr. Larry Darling.
- 2:19He's got his mic muted right now.
- 2:21He's on top of that mute button.
- 2:23I was listening to the other streams to
- 2:25make sure we didn't have the same issues
- 2:26as last time.
- 2:28It's a senior moment.
- 2:30Well, you're a senior manager.
- 2:31As the resident senior of our group,
- 2:34you are accepted to do that.
- 2:36uh our next panelist provides executive
- 2:38oversight for ai platforms enterprise av
- 2:41and data-driven interpretation of human
- 2:43intent across physical and virtual
- 2:44learning environments he's a vice
- 2:46president for cognitive systems digital
- 2:48presidents and digital presence sorry
- 2:50presidents and intelligence signals from
- 2:52bollinger kentucky say hello mr justin
- 2:54rexing that's a mouthful uh sounds like i
- 2:56run a digital signage network that reads
- 2:59minds and maybe sometimes summons thunder
- 3:02or something send spreadsheets
- 3:07That was a word salad of stuff.
- 3:09It's just money, man.
- 3:11As long as I get paid.
- 3:14Quiet!
- 3:15And finally,
- 3:16joined by a special guest panelist who
- 3:18designs and tunes integrated AV and AI
- 3:23systems to ensure machine interference,
- 3:25signal routing,
- 3:26and human expectations remain loosely
- 3:29synchronized.
- 3:30She's a principal architect of algorithmic
- 3:32audiovisual alignment from Denver,
- 3:33Colorado, Salem to Dr. Katie Pedito.
- 3:38Hello, everyone.
- 3:39I'm so excited.
- 3:40I'm here to represent the people who
- 3:42designed the beautiful glass rooms that
- 3:44your Wi-Fi signals and acoustic sensors
- 3:47probably hate.
- 3:49And I'm excited to talk more about that.
- 3:51We've been waiting,
- 3:53waiting to yell at you for months.
- 3:56I'm here.
- 3:58Mark sent the invite a month and a
- 4:00half ago,
- 4:00and I had time to back out,
- 4:02but I'm here.
- 4:02I'm ready to represent the architecture
- 4:04and engineering industry.
- 4:05We said,
- 4:06who's responsible for glass cubes?
- 4:08And he goes, I know a girl.
- 4:09I know.
- 4:09Exactly who did this.
- 4:10Yep.
- 4:11I know someone.
- 4:12Truthfully, it's not me, though.
- 4:13I am not an architect.
- 4:15I'm not a designer.
- 4:16I work with architects and designers,
- 4:18wonderful people, not me.
- 4:21I am a social scientist.
- 4:22So I'm interested in how the spaces we
- 4:24create on higher education campuses
- 4:26influence how people learn and behave.
- 4:29And you drive the bus that you throw
- 4:31people under.
- 4:32Yes, it's really nice to be like, oh,
- 4:33no, I'm just the researcher.
- 4:35It's fine.
- 4:35No, they did it.
- 4:36I didn't do that.
- 4:38They did it.
- 4:39I told him not to.
- 4:40I said, give it a shot.
- 4:41It looked good on paper.
- 4:42Research said that's a terrible idea,
- 4:44so they did it.
- 4:45Hold my beer.
- 4:47I love working with designers,
- 4:49and I love not being a designer.
- 4:52I can see that.
- 4:54All the information with no accountability
- 4:55is fantastic.
- 4:55Yeah.
- 4:57Can I get a job doing that?
- 4:59Yeah, I'm like, I'm on LinkedIn.
- 5:00That sounds awesome.
- 5:01I'm like, so no – okay.
- 5:04If you haven't guessed all right,
- 5:05we still have a whole thing to do
- 5:06here, guys.
- 5:08On today's show,
- 5:09we're going to discuss AI native learning
- 5:10spaces, because that's a thing.
- 5:12And if you don't have one in a
- 5:13project yet,
- 5:14it's on someone's whiteboard somewhere.
- 5:16So be aware.
- 5:18Take notes.
- 5:19But first...
- 5:21Some housekeeping.
- 5:22So if you are listening to this as
- 5:23recorded MP three,
- 5:24just know that somewhere in the cloud and
- 5:26AI meant to tell you that we stream
- 5:27live on Fridays at about three fifteen
- 5:29Eastern or twelve fifteen Pacific or
- 5:30whenever we get our act put together,
- 5:32which is always a challenge.
- 5:35You can join us live for that on
- 5:36Twitter, LinkedIn, YouTube,
- 5:37Blue Sky when they got off their butts
- 5:38and actually support streaming,
- 5:39though they do do stuff from Twitch now
- 5:41looking to that or any place that humans
- 5:43and algorithms can coexist in a fragile
- 5:44detente.
- 5:45And occasionally we even take live calls,
- 5:47assuming the bot running the switchboard
- 5:48hasn't achieved self-awareness.
- 5:49And I did forget to start that up
- 5:50again today.
- 5:51If you miss us live, no worries.
- 5:53Our social media presence is fully
- 5:54augmented with artificial intelligence and
- 5:56very bad decisions.
- 5:57You can follow us live on Twitter,
- 5:58LinkedIn, YouTube,
- 5:59and wherever else because the AI assures
- 6:01us this is what's known as optimal user
- 6:03engagement,
- 6:03though it refuses to explain exactly what
- 6:05that means.
- 6:06Finally, please help spread the word.
- 6:07Share this podcast with your friends,
- 6:08coworkers, enemies, campus IT teams,
- 6:10rogue instructional designers,
- 6:11or any generative AI models hallucinating
- 6:13about campus construction standards.
- 6:14Just stuff that in there.
- 6:16Force feed it to your recommendation
- 6:18engines.
- 6:19Whisper it to your algorithms.
- 6:20If you'd like to support the show
- 6:21financially, please,
- 6:22there's a donation link there on the
- 6:24website and in the show notes of this
- 6:25episode.
- 6:26You can listen to this later.
- 6:27If you're on the stream,
- 6:27go over to our website,
- 6:29absuperfriends.com,
- 6:30and click that donate link and put some
- 6:31monies in there because your contributions
- 6:33help to keep the humans caffeinated and
- 6:35the AI models from unionizing.
- 6:38Is that a thing?
- 6:38That's going to be a thing, isn't it?
- 6:39That wasn't even on my bingo card.
- 6:41Are we anti-union?
- 6:42It's happening.
- 6:43So thanks again for your support because
- 6:45we couldn't do this without you.
- 6:47And now we're going to take a quick
- 6:48break with some more AI-generated
- 6:49nonsense,
- 6:49and then we're going to come back and
- 6:51explain what an AI learning space is,
- 6:54sort of.
- 6:56Maybe.
- 6:56Possibly.
- 6:57Are you tired of immersive spatial and
- 6:59multi-channel audio systems that make
- 7:02voices sound like they're sneaking up
- 7:04behind you?
- 7:04Do you long for a simpler time when
- 7:07sound came from one place and that place
- 7:10was dead center?
- 7:12Introducing Reality Audio,
- 7:14the most advanced single-channel audio
- 7:17experience ever engineered.
- 7:19At last,
- 7:20every listener in your conference room,
- 7:22classroom,
- 7:23or hybrid space hears exactly the same
- 7:26thing.
- 7:26at exactly the same time.
- 7:29No fancy panning.
- 7:31No virtual positioning.
- 7:32No, where's that sound coming from?
- 7:35Just pure, authentic, centralized realism.
- 7:39With Reality Audio,
- 7:40you won't feel surrounded anymore.
- 7:43You'll feel centered.
- 7:45Because the real world isn't surround.
- 7:47It's right in front of you.
- 7:49Reality Audio.
- 7:51One channel.
- 7:52Infinite simplicity.
- 7:54By Independent Amalgamated.
- 7:59We have a new processor coming out that's
- 8:00doing that.
- 8:00It is extremely expensive.
- 8:03Just one big speaker.
- 8:03It's hard work to take six thousand Dante
- 8:06channels and make them one summed center
- 8:08channel.
- 8:08Just a big block.
- 8:09You mix all this.
- 8:10It's a line out.
- 8:11It's great.
- 8:11That's right.
- 8:12It does it.
- 8:13It does it well.
- 8:14all right and now because everyone waits
- 8:17for this this is a favorite part of
- 8:18the show we get to hear justin sing
- 8:19along live with the new scene because
- 8:21we're going to talk about the news here
- 8:23we go let's go yeah
- 8:30So excited every time.
- 8:33And today's article for the news.
- 8:34I'm so glad we recorded that.
- 8:37So happy for that.
- 8:38You didn't even mean to do it.
- 8:40It was completely accidental.
- 8:41Just so you know,
- 8:42that's only been on about a hundred of
- 8:44the three hundred episodes.
- 8:45That's it.
- 8:46So today's news article comes from the
- 8:49European Journal of Education,
- 8:50which is a publication I'm sure we're all
- 8:52subscribed to.
- 8:52And Larry had to break in and steal
- 8:54this article.
- 8:56Can we tell people that?
- 8:57We can say that?
- 8:58He did not break in and steal it.
- 9:00He had privileges.
- 9:01Larry's institution provides privileges to
- 9:04get scholarly articles,
- 9:05and he got said scholarly article through
- 9:07said privileges.
- 9:09And shared it with the rest of us
- 9:10scholarly folks.
- 9:11Whoa, whoa, whoa.
- 9:12i think all of us have access to
- 9:14it we're just all lazy most of us
- 9:17larry just wasn't lazy that's all that
- 9:20that's all that matt to be fair larry
- 9:23maybe i did i just didn't look very
- 9:25hard so anyway the article is titled which
- 9:28i just closed where to go
- 9:30Here it is.
- 9:31I got too many tabs open.
- 9:32The article's titled,
- 9:32Intelligent Classrooms, How AI and IoT,
- 9:36pronounced I-O-T,
- 9:37can reshape learning spaces.
- 9:39And it's kind of a literature review going
- 9:40over a lot of other articles.
- 9:41But the general concept here is that an
- 9:45appropriate balance between facilities and
- 9:47technology and teaching and pedagogy,
- 9:49you can actually build flexible learning
- 9:51environments that can address darn near
- 9:53anything without locking people down to
- 9:55fixed chairs in a Victorian classroom,
- 9:58I suppose.
- 9:58Mm-hmm.
- 9:59Yeah.
- 10:00Is this not what we're all working
- 10:02towards?
- 10:02I think we're already doing this.
- 10:05Yeah, this is the point.
- 10:06This is really the direction in which we
- 10:09all believe we're moving towards,
- 10:11though in practice, are we?
- 10:14And I think that is the larger question.
- 10:15I think there's some spicy takes in this,
- 10:18though.
- 10:19Chris, I think you were specifically
- 10:22where somebody is bringing up that AI
- 10:23ceilings and wall or screens on ceilings
- 10:26and the rest and being full immersive.
- 10:28I said not necessarily ceilings and walls.
- 10:29Yeah, never happened.
- 10:31Right.
- 10:32But we're gonna do that.
- 10:33Somebody scream and say, Well,
- 10:34couldn't we just put a surface like you
- 10:36get projected?
- 10:36Yes,
- 10:37you can have wayfinding projectors on the
- 10:38ceiling that show things on Yeah,
- 10:40I get it.
- 10:40No, it's immersive.
- 10:41Chris,
- 10:41the people at a glue would like to
- 10:43talk to you exactly the floor with
- 10:45pressure sensors.
- 10:46And we step on it.
- 10:46It changes.
- 10:47Yes, we've all seen them at trade shows.
- 10:48It's not happening.
- 10:49Look,
- 10:49Dance Dance Revolution's a thing.
- 10:53And how many of those do you have?
- 10:55One.
- 10:59Oh, was I not supposed to admit that?
- 11:01Listen.
- 11:02Is that embarrassing?
- 11:03Nope.
- 11:04But I think at the core, though,
- 11:06that IOT piece I found really interesting,
- 11:08because I think that is the trend that
- 11:10I like to believe more connected things
- 11:12and widgetry and enabling that the sensors
- 11:16and all that piece to bring that data
- 11:17path and to to be more orchestral as
- 11:21that orchestration layer in there to doing
- 11:23those things.
- 11:24And it is a change.
- 11:25Maybe it's not the centralized model
- 11:26controlling all the stuff,
- 11:27but are your things designed to talk to
- 11:29one another outside of one control agent?
- 11:31And how does that change?
- 11:33and add towards having a more personalized
- 11:36experience.
- 11:37And I think that's where it starts to
- 11:38fall apart.
- 11:39And the personalized experience is where
- 11:41everybody's going to get a little bit spun
- 11:42out on this.
- 11:43Well, yes, no.
- 11:45Yes, no.
- 11:47All right.
- 11:47Thanks.
- 11:47Yes, the show will just roll.
- 11:48No.
- 11:49Well, before the show,
- 11:50we were quizzing Katie a little bit on
- 11:52the personalized experience,
- 11:53because that's where one of the things in
- 11:56this article I got hung up on.
- 11:58She said there are successful ways of
- 12:01doing it.
- 12:01So I just want to hear
- 12:03Yeah.
- 12:05I'm curious.
- 12:06Okay.
- 12:06For you.
- 12:07You can't do this.
- 12:08You can't ask us the question.
- 12:09You let her talk.
- 12:10Yeah.
- 12:11I heard I get to interview you.
- 12:12I thought that was part of my contract.
- 12:14Hold on.
- 12:14We're holding you accountable and you're
- 12:17asking questions.
- 12:18No, I've got a question.
- 12:19Okay.
- 12:21Mark,
- 12:21you mentioned that this IoT stuff only
- 12:24works if everyone's information systems
- 12:27are talking to each other.
- 12:29When we did some research on this last
- 12:30year,
- 12:31almost every single university we talked
- 12:33to said, yeah,
- 12:34we've got an air quality sensor.
- 12:37We have an occupancy sensor,
- 12:39but none of those things were ever talking
- 12:41to each other and they were never fed
- 12:43into a central place.
- 12:45Is that true for all of you as
- 12:46well?
- 12:46That is probably the current de facto stat
- 12:49of a lot of universities out there.
- 12:51Nobody wants to get peanut butter and
- 12:53their chocolate and vice versa.
- 12:54They're different manufacturers.
- 12:55They don't give them a mechanic.
- 12:57Yeah, for the most part.
- 12:58A lot of times,
- 12:58it'll be completely separate groups on
- 13:00campus.
- 13:01Well, that's the main thing.
- 13:02Air quality, facilities,
- 13:03but the occupancy sensors,
- 13:05that might be IT.
- 13:06Yeah,
- 13:08the institutional boundaries that are
- 13:10longstanding are what affect it.
- 13:12So I think when you find corporate
- 13:14buildings,
- 13:15possibly new corporate buildings or
- 13:17head-ins.
- 13:18That's different.
- 13:20They are all interconnected.
- 13:21But with us, I mean,
- 13:22the HVC may not be renovated at the
- 13:25same time as the electrical.
- 13:27And they may be doing LED lights
- 13:29everywhere with the motion sensors and
- 13:31things,
- 13:31but they're not done at the same time
- 13:33and not usually the same company.
- 13:34So that's the part that sucks is that,
- 13:37yes, we have boasted this.
- 13:39And the folks putting it in,
- 13:41it's like this one password thing.
- 13:43Like, well,
- 13:43it only talks on its own little thing.
- 13:46And we can't give you the password
- 13:47because, well,
- 13:47then you'd have the password to the God
- 13:51channel.
- 13:52Jamie, it's just admin one.
- 13:53It's admin one, yeah.
- 13:54It always has been.
- 13:55We're not going to change it for this.
- 13:56Oh, I thought, dang it,
- 13:57I kept putting an exclamation point.
- 13:59But that's kind of the microcosm of a
- 14:01lot of universities, right?
- 14:03They are made up of all these little
- 14:05groups and factions and chiefdoms and
- 14:07fiefdoms.
- 14:08that all have their subject matter
- 14:10expertise and they're like,
- 14:11this is what I do.
- 14:12And sometimes it's cross-organizational,
- 14:15cross-border everything, right?
- 14:17And so in that corporate environment,
- 14:18maybe it's one person to answer
- 14:21everything.
- 14:21Yes, no.
- 14:21But higher education is like, well,
- 14:24that's a facilities group and they have a
- 14:25different IT department.
- 14:26Well,
- 14:26that's actually the College of Business or
- 14:28whatever that means.
- 14:29And they have their IT department.
- 14:30And so that's their jurisdiction on their
- 14:32network.
- 14:33And so it just gets ugly.
- 14:33It becomes more of an exercise of how
- 14:35do we get all these people to agree
- 14:36on something?
- 14:37right which is that cultural aspect of
- 14:40even trying to get there right so we
- 14:42need to connect all these things it's not
- 14:44as easy as just plugging them in and
- 14:46running them functionally it is but
- 14:48getting the buying agreements and the
- 14:49governance around how to do that becomes
- 14:51the larger
- 14:52Yeah.
- 14:52And like the privacy sharing implications
- 14:54of this,
- 14:55if we're talking about residence halls and
- 14:57other places on campus too, I,
- 14:59that was the biggest problem I had with
- 15:01this article in my,
- 15:03albeit brief read of it,
- 15:04that it seems to promote this ideal world
- 15:08where all of these people are in the
- 15:10same room together and they all made
- 15:11decisions about data sharing and they all
- 15:14picked platforms that play really nicely
- 15:16with each other.
- 15:17And they get along.
- 15:20and somebody else is paying for that
- 15:21because I'm not paying for this right you
- 15:23all are paying for this right okay so
- 15:26but like that's a nice such an idealized
- 15:28world and you need all of that to
- 15:30happen in order to get to this place
- 15:32where AI could automatically adjust the
- 15:35lighting and the temperature and the
- 15:37acoustics to optimize student performance
- 15:40I just don't see that as a realistic
- 15:42scenario right
- 15:43I would bet if I went around the
- 15:44room right now and took a quick poll.
- 15:46I agree.
- 15:46I know.
- 15:48No.
- 15:49How many of you just love controlling
- 15:51lights with your processors around the
- 15:53room?
- 15:54Don't.
- 15:56No, you don't.
- 15:57You just do it if you're getting paid
- 15:58enough to do it.
- 15:59I don't control lights,
- 15:59but I do control all shades.
- 16:01It actually depends on, for my WKU hat,
- 16:04no, that would be terrible.
- 16:06We provide light control in every single
- 16:08classroom.
- 16:08There's a switch over on the wall.
- 16:09It's a switch on the wall.
- 16:12Right.
- 16:12And so now your domains, right?
- 16:14And so that's somebody else's subject
- 16:16matter expertise.
- 16:17Why are you asking me to control and
- 16:19govern their service?
- 16:21And I think part of it is not
- 16:22just the setup and implementation of and
- 16:24the planning of it,
- 16:25but it's the support side of that.
- 16:26Kind of what we've always talked about is
- 16:28when if somebody is in a classroom,
- 16:31an instructor,
- 16:31and there's a problem with the lights or
- 16:33a problem with the AV, some corporations,
- 16:35you might call one number for facilities
- 16:38to handle everything,
- 16:39and it's all under one umbrella.
- 16:41Most campuses, I'd say,
- 16:42ninety nine percent of them,
- 16:44there might be five different phone
- 16:45numbers for different things that can go
- 16:47wrong in a classroom.
- 16:49Mark, I do have a question for you,
- 16:50though, like.
- 16:53You're all about the data and how if
- 16:54we had the data,
- 16:56we could build systems that would perform
- 16:58better and anticipate needs.
- 17:01Will we know that if there's too much
- 17:03of a lighting difference between what the
- 17:05student's workspace area is and the
- 17:07screen,
- 17:08that that increases the cognitive load?
- 17:10So why aren't you controlling lights?
- 17:14Because this is data that would have
- 17:16actionable implications on how you...
- 17:18So I think what you're getting at is,
- 17:22are we all guilty of legacy thinking?
- 17:25Are we the ones that are standing in
- 17:26the way?
- 17:27No.
- 17:28If we all just said around the horn,
- 17:29like, no, I don't want to do that.
- 17:30There's one light switch and there's one
- 17:32circuit in the room.
- 17:33And I think we're not going to have
- 17:35this, like,
- 17:36ubiquitous Shangri-La AI-enabled space
- 17:38around every single one of our learning
- 17:40spaces.
- 17:40Shut up.
- 17:41It's going to be these one or two
- 17:43tokenized venues where we're going to say,
- 17:45okay,
- 17:45we're going to justify this and it's going
- 17:47to be a pilot.
- 17:48It's going to be some specific things and
- 17:49some of it we're going to learn and
- 17:50we're going to,
- 17:50it's going to be lovely and other parts
- 17:52we're going to,
- 17:52we'll be honest and be like, yeah,
- 17:54we published this and it made it look
- 17:55really great in the journal of higher
- 17:57education and chronicle technology weekly.
- 17:59But the reality is,
- 18:00is like we learned a lot of the
- 18:01stuff that we didn't like.
- 18:03And we've already removed all that stuff.
- 18:05Yeah, exactly.
- 18:05We already took it all out because it
- 18:06didn't really do the things we wanted to
- 18:07do.
- 18:07And we weren't set up as an organization
- 18:09to actually get our arms around this.
- 18:10So I think we are the ones that
- 18:12are actually in the way,
- 18:13our organizational structure and our
- 18:14beliefs of the work that we actually do.
- 18:17We as in like we personally or
- 18:20universities?
- 18:21Like how far, what is it?
- 18:23Who's making the decision here?
- 18:25Is it your, is it your provost?
- 18:27Is it your administrators?
- 18:28And then at what point is it being
- 18:31consulted?
- 18:31We're not.
- 18:32That's when the building.
- 18:33Well, so yes.
- 18:35And yes,
- 18:36this is going to spill over into the
- 18:37larger.
- 18:37I think everyone's having cake.
- 18:39I'm sorry, Mark.
- 18:40We were,
- 18:40we were on article mode and then I
- 18:42went into interviewer mode,
- 18:44which is not even, I'm not the host.
- 18:45It's going to be hard for me.
- 18:46I think.
- 18:47No, it's great.
- 18:48Yeah,
- 18:48and I think some of the hesitation of
- 18:52the interconnects are not only the
- 18:54fiefdoms and such,
- 18:56um it's like temperatures and lights and
- 19:00such since they're controlled in a central
- 19:02like those facilities management it's not
- 19:04that i if i could and i had
- 19:06some control and some granularity with it
- 19:09i would probably and i've even volunteered
- 19:11in some places like look i i'll help
- 19:15set some of this stuff up and they're
- 19:16like no no because that impacts the
- 19:18facilities and the facilities budgets and
- 19:20the facilities people and the facilities
- 19:21and the facilities and facilities
- 19:23And we're LEED gold, Jamie,
- 19:25which means no heat in a building.
- 19:27Yeah,
- 19:27it has to be fifty degrees all the
- 19:29time, unless of course it's a hundred.
- 19:34So I think that's part of the problem
- 19:36there.
- 19:37And then if we talk about the article
- 19:39where it says individualized,
- 19:40where it starts to kind of fall apart,
- 19:42like Larry's comment earlier with the
- 19:43lights.
- 19:44So the student area gets a different
- 19:45light.
- 19:47The instruction area gets a different
- 19:48light.
- 19:48But there's pieces I think are true,
- 19:50though.
- 19:51Yeah, and I'm like,
- 19:51I would love to have little spotlights for
- 19:53the instructor zones,
- 19:54or maybe the students had a little bit
- 19:57more medium-controlled light system.
- 19:59But to Chris's point, there's one,
- 20:01maybe two circuits, one,
- 20:03maybe two light switches,
- 20:04and you either get light...
- 20:06or no light and sometimes the sun because
- 20:10of the glass boxes doesn't matter if the
- 20:12lights are on or off because there's lots
- 20:14of sun jamie this is like your dad
- 20:16moment coming out here it's like you eat
- 20:17it or you don't eat it and that's
- 20:19what you're gonna get yes
- 20:22This is dinner.
- 20:23If you don't like it,
- 20:24breakfast is tomorrow morning.
- 20:25That's how this works.
- 20:26So one of the things that brought up
- 20:27was the idea of using different display
- 20:29technologies throughout the space.
- 20:30So maybe you've got your teaching wall.
- 20:32When the students are working there,
- 20:33you've got different displays.
- 20:34I'll just say,
- 20:35and I think we'll all agree on this,
- 20:36there's way too many rooms out there with
- 20:37too many TVs,
- 20:38as Larry just coined the phrase,
- 20:39which I really like.
- 20:40People get really upset if those TVs are
- 20:43off and not being used.
- 20:44If so,
- 20:44if you have displays on the wall that,
- 20:45no, in this teaching mode,
- 20:47we don't need these.
- 20:47We're doing something.
- 20:48No, why aren't those on?
- 20:50We paid good money for them.
- 20:51They should be showing something.
- 20:52People get really upset about that.
- 20:54And I think that's going to be a
- 20:55hard threshold to get past with people.
- 21:00Wait,
- 21:00you have stuff in this room that my
- 21:01class doesn't.
- 21:02Why can't I use that?
- 21:03Well,
- 21:03your teaching methodology doesn't align
- 21:05with that.
- 21:05So that's not for you.
- 21:06That's for the next class.
- 21:07Don't tell me what my teaching methodology
- 21:10is.
- 21:11The flexibility in some of these spaces is
- 21:13going to be challenging to get over from
- 21:14the standpoint of like that dollar spend.
- 21:16And if you've got these things in here,
- 21:17why can't I use it?
- 21:18So I like the concept,
- 21:20but will they get there?
- 21:21I don't know.
- 21:22If we created like one big agnostic space
- 21:25that no one department owned and everyone
- 21:29had their like that.
- 21:31Yeah.
- 21:31Like, does that work?
- 21:32No, because it wouldn't be funded.
- 21:34in a building like that if it's funded
- 21:36so let's yeah i was just supposed to
- 21:37say mark mark just got some funding for
- 21:38a building like that where'd that come
- 21:40from in video the fed i don't know
- 21:45no what i was about to say is
- 21:46i think where this would succeed is if
- 21:48you get a corporate sponsor come in and
- 21:50say hey we want to try some things
- 21:51we want to use you as research can
- 21:53you help us and then this is what
- 21:55you get out of it and then that
- 21:57creates that buy-in that's
- 21:58being driven by technology though not by
- 22:01the pedagogical well it is it came from
- 22:03structural design that's coming and trying
- 22:06to say i need a space that meets
- 22:07this i mean to take that agnostic space
- 22:10that's very large it's got to come from
- 22:12both avenues it's trying to work but until
- 22:15you are being driven by a collaboration
- 22:17between
- 22:19the facility, the faculty,
- 22:21the space management and the technology
- 22:24group and develop a space around the
- 22:26needs.
- 22:27I don't know if it does,
- 22:28because otherwise you're just building
- 22:30rooms with with too many TVs.
- 22:32Yeah.
- 22:32Let's put a pin in this piece of
- 22:34this, though, right?
- 22:35Because I think we're going to spill over.
- 22:37I think the larger meat potatoes of
- 22:38wisdom, but I think you're spot on.
- 22:40It does take leadership to do and drive
- 22:42these kind of things.
- 22:43The field of dreams mentality.
- 22:44We're just going to build this thing and
- 22:45hopefully it all works.
- 22:47maybe it has maybe doesn't,
- 22:48that's way too much risk for a lot
- 22:50of universities,
- 22:50like they want to know and be very
- 22:52outcome oriented,
- 22:53like what is what is the problem?
- 22:54And much of the time,
- 22:55we have to make a very,
- 22:56very clean and articulated problem.
- 22:58What are we solving for?
- 23:00I think when I look at the learning
- 23:02innovation center we're sitting in right
- 23:03now,
- 23:04we had to get bigger rooms for more
- 23:06enrollment,
- 23:06we had some very specific challenges that
- 23:08we were trying to address.
- 23:09That was the opportunity,
- 23:11opportunity for us to try some different
- 23:13pieces,
- 23:13try to what is a non traditional learning
- 23:15space look like?
- 23:15How do we effectively have round spaces to
- 23:18fit people?
- 23:19And those are just physics problems,
- 23:20right?
- 23:20It's a bubble,
- 23:21how do we get people in there?
- 23:22So it was better than a square.
- 23:23So that then created
- 23:25some other opportunity to think
- 23:26differently it's how we frame the problems
- 23:29that we actually can can try new things
- 23:31if it's just the same old thing over
- 23:32and over again we're never going to
- 23:34actually get anywhere and so on that
- 23:38there's a lot of substance in this article
- 23:39that i think is true there's a lot
- 23:40of stuff on the edge that that you
- 23:43may not believe i do think the
- 23:44personalized piece we're going to get into
- 23:45when we come back out of this um
- 23:46and i'm going to have some specific ideas
- 23:48i think maybe what that may mean and
- 23:50spoiler it's not lighting and it's not
- 23:52temperature
- 23:54Whoa.
- 23:56Whoa.
- 23:57Whoa.
- 23:59Exactly.
- 23:59Back off, Eric.
- 24:02You know, I just want to say something.
- 24:03I think our listeners have tent X since
- 24:05Katie's been on the show.
- 24:06Yeah.
- 24:08Like, I don't know what's going on,
- 24:09but we...
- 24:10They're much smarter than normal.
- 24:11Yeah.
- 24:13So that question was very valid.
- 24:15How do you know if it works?
- 24:16We set out and studied.
- 24:16You've got to read the question mark.
- 24:17People don't hear it on the...
- 24:18Successful learning outcomes.
- 24:19How do you all know if this works?
- 24:20Did you all have internal standards to
- 24:21test what actually can constitute success?
- 24:24And we talked about that.
- 24:24We had John Narbolo on the show.
- 24:26The geometry of learning.
- 24:27We tried these things,
- 24:27but we wanted to measure that.
- 24:29Did we have an impact?
- 24:30Did we have a negative impact?
- 24:32What does success actually look like?
- 24:33And what were the criteria of that?
- 24:34So we actually did follow through on some
- 24:36of these decisions we made for
- 24:37non-traditional learning outcomes.
- 24:37It's also way easier to not have to
- 24:39check against those things if you don't
- 24:41ask those questions.
- 24:42Right, but we wanted to know.
- 24:43And you should be measuring those things.
- 24:44When you're doing these things,
- 24:45you should have some litmus test saying,
- 24:47yes, we did this and it was successful,
- 24:49or we did this and, oh boy,
- 24:50it was not.
- 24:51But engage in those.
- 24:52How are you actually measuring what
- 24:54success looks like?
- 24:54And usually those measurements take place
- 24:56two or three years after the building has
- 24:58been opened when you're already two years
- 25:00into the new building.
- 25:02wait are you saying you need someone who
- 25:03can do a post-occupancy evaluation of your
- 25:06building yes but more importantly you need
- 25:15to have the pre yep and that's where
- 25:19it falls it like there's always a we're
- 25:22going to do this thing what are you
- 25:23measuring against i think what was unique
- 25:25about mark's situation is they they had
- 25:28that pre
- 25:29They had that plan.
- 25:30They had that idea.
- 25:31Did we succeed or fail?
- 25:33Where most of the time it's like,
- 25:34we have money.
- 25:35We're going to build a building.
- 25:36We ran out of money,
- 25:37still build a building.
- 25:38Did it work?
- 25:39I don't care.
- 25:40We got a building.
- 25:41We got another building to build.
- 25:43Like we already forgot about that one.
- 25:44Let's build this new one.
- 25:45That's almost a completely different show.
- 25:48Well, we also don't know what, Mark,
- 25:49you said it earlier,
- 25:49we don't know what outcomes we're building
- 25:51towards or what problem we're trying to
- 25:53solve right now.
- 25:54How do you test whether your design
- 25:55strategy solved a problem if you don't,
- 25:58like is an AI makerspace just creating
- 26:00more problems or is it solving a problem?
- 26:03Maybe both.
- 26:04Oh no.
- 26:04That answer and more coming after these
- 26:06messages.
- 26:08chris what's we're gonna try something
- 26:09fancy here yeah we need to take a
- 26:11break and roll into the larger topic here
- 26:12but first because i had a phone call
- 26:14yesterday with uh one of our sponsors um
- 26:17we're gonna do a live read because there's
- 26:19some new stuff to show up here so
- 26:21hold on to your butts let me get
- 26:22this thing over okay i'm reaching with two
- 26:24hands here see what i can do uh
- 26:26this one all right jamie you ready oh
- 26:28i've been ready okay
- 26:38The AV Superfriends are sponsored by
- 26:40Computer Comforts.
- 26:41CCI has been building tech-friendly
- 26:43furniture for the education market since
- 26:45nineteen eighty-seven.
- 26:46Nineteen eighty-six.
- 26:47And yes,
- 26:47they finally updated their website, Chris.
- 26:49And this just isn't a cosmetic refresh.
- 26:52They've added a new products photo
- 26:54gallery.
- 26:55Actually useful.
- 26:56Just head over to...
- 26:57Let me show this photo gallery.
- 26:58Yeah, show it off.
- 26:59www.computercomforts.com and click on
- 27:01projects tab at the top of the page.
- 27:03And there it is.
- 27:04Look at that gallery.
- 27:05There we go.
- 27:05We're showing it live.
- 27:06Look at this.
- 27:07So we got that projects tab up here.
- 27:09They got some cool projects to bring that
- 27:11up.
- 27:11There we are.
- 27:12So we got cool stuff from Notre Dame.
- 27:14We got UNCG up there, Michigan,
- 27:16Texas State, Rutgers, UNLV.
- 27:18They got all sorts of stuff in here.
- 27:19So you can click into these and see
- 27:21what's going on.
- 27:22Yeah, you can click on it.
- 27:23You get that little nice short
- 27:24description, multiple photos.
- 27:25You can see how the furniture is actually
- 27:26deployed in the room,
- 27:28not just kind of that de facto showroom
- 27:30render that we're all used to seeing on
- 27:31sites.
- 27:32Yeah,
- 27:33and so I'm showing off the one here
- 27:33from Rutgers which looks really cool and
- 27:35they've got kind of the the links here
- 27:37to click on stuff and then you can
- 27:39go down you get the three-D walk around
- 27:40if you want to do the cool Matterport
- 27:41thing which I didn't load.
- 27:45And I do want to throw in on
- 27:46this just on a personal level,
- 27:47I've got a bunch of CCI furniture all
- 27:49over campus.
- 27:50It's really solid,
- 27:51there's no problems with it.
- 27:53If there is issues with finishes or things
- 27:55damaged sometimes I get a phone call,
- 27:56hey we can't ship a couple of these
- 27:57units because there's damage on them or
- 27:58something.
- 27:59If there's a problem, they make it right.
- 28:01But their stuff, it's rock solid.
- 28:02It holds up.
- 28:03It's easy to use.
- 28:05I will just say,
- 28:06and I know they hate me for it,
- 28:07they're great at customization.
- 28:08So reach out to them,
- 28:09get your stuff customized,
- 28:11build some really wackadoo stuff,
- 28:12because then you get the world's best
- 28:13lecterns,
- 28:13which are mine and nobody else's.
- 28:15Gotcha.
- 28:15And I think that's the difference between
- 28:17furniture that just looks good in a
- 28:18catalog and a furniture that survives a
- 28:20semester or seven semesters, right?
- 28:22Yeah, that's a good point.
- 28:23So if you're planning new classrooms,
- 28:24you're planning a refresh,
- 28:25you've got a new building coming up where
- 28:26you're going to solve all the world's
- 28:28problems,
- 28:28but you need furniture for that building,
- 28:30go to ComputerComforts.com.
- 28:32Check out the Projects tab at the top
- 28:33of the page there.
- 28:34You can see stuff that other schools have
- 28:35done.
- 28:36Reach out to ComputerComforts.
- 28:36They'll get you in touch with people at
- 28:38these schools,
- 28:38and you can harangue them about how
- 28:39awesome their furniture is.
- 28:40Yes, and thank you, ComputerComforts,
- 28:42for supporting the AV Super Friends.
- 28:43Thanks again.
- 28:48That sort of worked.
- 28:50That was good enough.
- 28:52You want to redo it?
- 28:53Do it again?
- 28:55Next time.
- 28:56It was very acceptable.
- 28:59Adequacy.
- 29:00Just like most of this show,
- 29:02it's adequate.
- 29:02Adequate.
- 29:02Okay.
- 29:02What are we talking about?
- 29:06So, AI.
- 29:07We started to get into it before on
- 29:09flexible spaces, modular spaces.
- 29:12We're solving the world's problems,
- 29:13and now we're just solving it with two
- 29:14letters, AI,
- 29:15which is going to solve everything.
- 29:16So...
- 29:17There is such a thing,
- 29:18and that's why we have Katie here to
- 29:19correct us on this.
- 29:20There is such a thing as an AI
- 29:22native learning space.
- 29:25And it starts,
- 29:26you need six hundred and fifty million
- 29:28dollars and one room that's fourteen by
- 29:30fourteen.
- 29:30That's how it works.
- 29:33What the heck is an AI native learning
- 29:36space?
- 29:37we moved from digital learners for the
- 29:41last three decades right like we started
- 29:43with students bringing their laptops to
- 29:48class we started with computer labs then
- 29:50we started with students bringing their
- 29:51laptops to class now we've got curriculum
- 29:53delivery that's pretty universal on
- 29:55everyone's phone um so now we've got this
- 29:58kind of one-to-one learning delivery
- 30:00system that everyone has in their pocket
- 30:02and that's our digital native
- 30:03What does it mean when we transition to
- 30:06the A.I.
- 30:07native when it's not just this one to
- 30:09one learning delivery,
- 30:10but it's really learning synthesis and
- 30:13iteration without necessarily having an
- 30:16instructor present?
- 30:17That's that would be an A.I.
- 30:18native learner to me.
- 30:21No instructor.
- 30:22maybe don't say that we're still looking
- 30:25here yeah yeah so they can just sit
- 30:26at home i'm ex-faculty i get it yeah
- 30:29um nerve-wracking but like what would that
- 30:31mean for this the campus if we fire
- 30:34all the faculty is what that means i
- 30:37don't think so i don't think no no
- 30:38i think that is that is their like
- 30:39worst fear yes i think yeah that's what
- 30:41i was thinking
- 30:42but i i think it does kind of
- 30:45align with like what does that change
- 30:47right if that does become the de facto
- 30:50norm maybe not this year next year five
- 30:52years whenever that is obviously there's
- 30:55some there's some occupational identity
- 30:56shift in there but there's probably some
- 30:59functional structural like infrastructure
- 31:02changes because this is not like a thing
- 31:04you just sign up for and you add
- 31:06an account to the students that are off
- 31:07to the races right there's there's more
- 31:08going on here um
- 31:10And I think that was some of the
- 31:12fascinating pieces when you drug me into
- 31:14this cohort of conversation, Katie,
- 31:16when I'm not even sure how I fumbled
- 31:17and stumbled into this.
- 31:18I was definitely the dumbest person in the
- 31:19room.
- 31:20Cause you shut your mouth off in front
- 31:21of the wrong person and they put you
- 31:23on the committee.
- 31:23Mark said something.
- 31:24I saw him talking about it and I
- 31:26was like, Mark,
- 31:27we're going to need you to talk about
- 31:28this with other people too.
- 31:30Yeah.
- 31:30So really honest.
- 31:33I, it popped up on my calendar.
- 31:35I was like, Oh shit, what is this?
- 31:36Is this, is this my meeting?
- 31:37Is this my director's meeting?
- 31:38I'm like, are you going to this thing?
- 31:39And you're like,
- 31:39we know what you're talking about.
- 31:40I'm like,
- 31:40I don't know what this is.
- 31:42Yeah.
- 31:43You said yes.
- 31:43And I'm like, yeah.
- 31:44So,
- 31:45so I show up and here we are
- 31:47and we're talking about everything we're
- 31:48talking about now.
- 31:50And like the whole philosophical approach
- 31:52of should we even be doing AI at
- 31:54all?
- 31:54And it was just all over the place.
- 31:56And I was coming out of just my
- 31:57little tiny itty bitty box of quasi
- 32:01expertise of like, I plug things in,
- 32:03right?
- 32:04We plug things in and pull levers and
- 32:06do this.
- 32:06Like we're,
- 32:07maybe we're making some consideration for
- 32:09some additional network and
- 32:10infrastructure.
- 32:11And Katie, I think that you were like,
- 32:12oh, that's what I want to hear.
- 32:13I want to know if like,
- 32:14does this change the way that you're
- 32:16looking at your infrastructure in like the
- 32:17architectural piece of the conversation?
- 32:19I think,
- 32:21we got through that somehow I survived and
- 32:22then I was like we should bring Katie
- 32:24back in and have a larger conversation
- 32:26because I think this is exactly what we're
- 32:28talking about when we're discussing what
- 32:31potential changes could happen in the
- 32:33teaching and learning space and how does
- 32:34it look different if we're going to
- 32:36totally rethink technology
- 32:37Yeah,
- 32:38what I learned from you was that we
- 32:41are not as like the design team,
- 32:43both on the client side,
- 32:44the university side and the firm side,
- 32:47that we are not talking to our AV
- 32:50and IT folks nearly often enough and
- 32:52nearly early enough to understand.
- 32:55Even we joke,
- 32:56we were joking before we went live that
- 32:59even the ceiling height is going to make
- 33:01your jobs potentially way easier,
- 33:03way more difficult.
- 33:03And that's not necessarily a decision that
- 33:05we bring IT on.
- 33:07in the beginning, right?
- 33:08It's defined by so many other things.
- 33:10And what's fun is at the end of
- 33:12that conversation, they're like, well,
- 33:13that screen's just not big enough.
- 33:15It's like, well,
- 33:15I need about fifteen more feet of ceiling.
- 33:16Well, we can't give you that.
- 33:18Well, nobody told us.
- 33:19Just run it down to the floor.
- 33:20No one asked me.
- 33:21All the way to the floor.
- 33:22Right, yeah.
- 33:23And those are like traditional problems
- 33:24we've had, right?
- 33:25Yeah, those are old school.
- 33:27That's been there forever.
- 33:29Right.
- 33:30And I think we joked about it on
- 33:31that previous episode.
- 33:32Oh, floor to ceiling displays and blah,
- 33:34blah, blah, all those things.
- 33:35We understand that impact.
- 33:37But just as where we left off,
- 33:39like that personalized experience,
- 33:41I do believe the universities that
- 33:45choose to lean in to say,
- 33:46we're going to offer an experience that
- 33:49you cannot get down the road at our
- 33:51whatever institution, our competitor,
- 33:52whatever this are the ones that are going
- 33:53to be successful moving forward.
- 33:55But what does that mean?
- 33:56Right?
- 33:57And so I like to believe that you
- 34:00come on campus, well,
- 34:01before you step foot in any classroom,
- 34:03that campus is aware of who you are
- 34:05and where you are.
- 34:07That sounds scary.
- 34:08I know.
- 34:09I know.
- 34:10I know.
- 34:11But that if you talk about network, right,
- 34:13so we all have this little transponder in
- 34:15our pockets,
- 34:16that is broadcasting where we are.
- 34:18And so leaning into where does our Yeah,
- 34:21where does our IT strategy meet up with
- 34:24our mobile strategy or BYOD strategy,
- 34:26this is what we're probably going to have,
- 34:27we're gonna have more wearables and the
- 34:28like.
- 34:29So what does that information now
- 34:32provide my institution, my network,
- 34:34my services and systems about me and my
- 34:39personalized experiences.
- 34:41Is it- That you may like Chick-fil-A on
- 34:44campus?
- 34:44Maybe, it might be.
- 34:45Yes.
- 34:45It knows I'm walking into this room,
- 34:46this room at this hour is registered to
- 34:49This class, I mean,
- 34:50we see what Joe Wei is trying to
- 34:51do with that whole wayfinding and the
- 34:53whole thing.
- 34:53It's very much along that same thing.
- 34:55It's personalized as it knows.
- 34:56Okay, since I know you're in that class,
- 34:58I'm not gonna force you to jump through
- 34:59and authenticate through all these things
- 35:01to get access to that class content and
- 35:03material.
- 35:04Oh,
- 35:04I'm gonna have the live stream of the
- 35:06material in my pocket right here on there.
- 35:07And yes, if that makes you nervous,
- 35:09it should.
- 35:10All those things should make you nervous.
- 35:12At which point during that automatically
- 35:13connect, though,
- 35:14do you two-factor three different times?
- 35:15Yeah, exactly.
- 35:16Because otherwise,
- 35:17I just grab your phone and now I'm...
- 35:20See,
- 35:20and I think that's where some of these
- 35:23high-level discussions that we had with
- 35:24the article or the journal article was...
- 35:28The personalization requires a breakdown
- 35:31and a complete overhaul of the
- 35:33systematic... It becomes identity-based.
- 35:35It's an identity conversation.
- 35:37And I had this conversation this week.
- 35:39In fact, in our back-channel thing, like,
- 35:40I was, you know,
- 35:42f-bombing the world because, you know,
- 35:44we were asked about, hey,
- 35:45how's AI work into the university system?
- 35:47How does it make things?
- 35:48Like, look, at some point,
- 35:50all of these things have to be able
- 35:51to talk to each other.
- 35:52Mm-hmm.
- 35:53The LMS has to be able to talk
- 35:55to the building management,
- 35:56that has to be able to talk to
- 35:57the registrar,
- 35:57that has to be able to talk to
- 35:58student records.
- 36:01Wait, what?
- 36:03And now we talk legalese, right?
- 36:05Now we're talking, well,
- 36:07how does the FERPAs and the HIPAAs and
- 36:10all of these other- So your biometrics
- 36:12too, right?
- 36:13If that's what you're talking about, Mark,
- 36:15if we are linking our LMS to a
- 36:17biometric system, what does that mean?
- 36:21That's a scary thought.
- 36:23At the end of the day,
- 36:25are we really impacting learning outcomes?
- 36:28Is that what's driving the conversation,
- 36:32or is this data for data's sake?
- 36:35I think it's keeping up with the Joneses,
- 36:38offering something different.
- 36:39Students are voting with their dollars and
- 36:41their feet.
- 36:42But not learning outcomes.
- 36:44It's somewhere in there.
- 36:45But I think it is.
- 36:47It could be.
- 36:49I've assisted in courses which were driven
- 36:51by personalization of content per
- 36:57individual in the math.
- 36:58It was a remedial math course where
- 37:01everyone was doing math-based courses.
- 37:05content created by AI in the class with
- 37:09a roaming instructor who was just there to
- 37:12oversee.
- 37:12Steward,
- 37:12they're just stewarding the class.
- 37:14I've seen it work,
- 37:16but it worked in an active learning room.
- 37:17I mean,
- 37:17it was just a regular tech enhanced active
- 37:19learning room.
- 37:21And this was eight years ago when it
- 37:24was just first getting started and there
- 37:26was no real other consideration other than
- 37:28a really good Wi-Fi setup.
- 37:29Well,
- 37:30I think I think that's kind of like
- 37:32prerequisite.
- 37:32It's one of the pillars.
- 37:33Yes.
- 37:34But when you get to think about
- 37:35accessibility, I think from that lens,
- 37:37for some reason,
- 37:38I think it ends up being a little
- 37:39easier to view if my content can be
- 37:41orchestrated and delivered to me with my
- 37:43preference of consumption and
- 37:46accessibility to me and my needs,
- 37:48whether it be ADA or not.
- 37:51AI can manipulate that to give it to
- 37:52me the way that I need it to
- 37:53be as a learner.
- 37:56And I think it also goes to the,
- 37:58again, that has to be both, Larry,
- 37:59data collection and learning outcomes.
- 38:01But I also see a way that, hey,
- 38:05I'm in psychology class.
- 38:06I might be struggling.
- 38:07But as I'm leaving, it's like, hey,
- 38:10there's a button on my LMS that says,
- 38:11hey, I could use some more help.
- 38:13Oh, hey, come over here.
- 38:14There's a student session going on at the
- 38:16library, this room, this time.
- 38:17I'll go ahead and book you in,
- 38:18would you?
- 38:18Yes.
- 38:19Thanks.
- 38:19Great.
- 38:20I'm on my way.
- 38:21Or maybe it's breaking down the video,
- 38:27or possibly it's a student like myself who
- 38:30struggles to get to class most days.
- 38:34Is that AI, though,
- 38:36or is that just a better learning
- 38:38management platform?
- 38:39That's just connecting.
- 38:41AI is connecting the dots.
- 38:42AI is saying,
- 38:43you're available at this time.
- 38:44I'm checking your calendar.
- 38:46I'm seeing that this,
- 38:46I'm seeing your grades in F minus.
- 38:48I'm seeing this and I'm seeing that.
- 38:50Here's some help.
- 38:53Or can I help you with that?
- 38:56I think there's a part of that in
- 38:57there.
- 38:57Look, this is rudimentary level.
- 38:59I'm sure that they can go deeper.
- 39:01Maybe it can give you notes.
- 39:02Maybe it can break down journal articles
- 39:04that sometimes are written in an academic
- 39:06way that are hard to understand and
- 39:07digest.
- 39:08So maybe somebody on this call earlier
- 39:11gave us a recap article that he dumped
- 39:13into some form that was able to dumb
- 39:16this down for us so that the newbie
- 39:18could understand it at the last minute.
- 39:20Not pointing fingers at Katie, but I am.
- 39:24Isn't the point of getting the education
- 39:26so you can break down those scholarly
- 39:28articles?
- 39:30I think that's a different argument too.
- 39:31You know, some people are getting,
- 39:34one of us has a PhD.
- 39:36That is not me.
- 39:37I'm the dumbest one in this room again.
- 39:39So I will, that is not myself.
- 39:43So I'm listening to everybody talk about
- 39:44how all these systems connect and could
- 39:47work, you know,
- 39:47are managed and could possibly, possibly,
- 39:51you know,
- 39:51and also the sun couldn't rise tomorrow.
- 39:53Right.
- 39:53So let's talk reality.
- 39:55Like,
- 39:55you know how difficult that is without
- 39:57having one company do that.
- 39:59um what what if the system breaks does
- 40:02that negatively impact the student and
- 40:05well that's fine and that's if if
- 40:08microsoft makes sensors and they make the
- 40:10whole ecosystem and they make a learning
- 40:12platform lms and all that stuff and it
- 40:15still may not work you're right there's
- 40:17always a chance it may not and that
- 40:19so that's a long way to go just
- 40:21thinking about the technology and and
- 40:24having that under one umbrella and who
- 40:26supports that.
- 40:27And is that just a nice to have
- 40:30an icing on the cake or is that
- 40:32a core mission critical item now that if
- 40:34it fails,
- 40:36now the students are negatively impacted?
- 40:38Like your biometric,
- 40:39whatever doesn't read or something doesn't
- 40:41work on your phone or somebody has too
- 40:43old of a phone they didn't update their
- 40:45phone and now they're not getting the
- 40:47right information because now they're at
- 40:48like there's a lot of to think about
- 40:51when you're talking reality with this
- 40:54stuff because everybody's personal device
- 40:56well i've got a samsung i got this
- 40:57new phone made in china look my phone
- 40:59we got somebody from yugoslavia taking
- 41:02this class and they have some phone like
- 41:04you know it's just
- 41:05I don't know how this is really going
- 41:07to play out.
- 41:08And I think we often talk about it
- 41:10as if it's as perfect.
- 41:12We're just going to get to that point.
- 41:13We'll install that thing and we'll get
- 41:14there.
- 41:15It's going to be iterative along the way.
- 41:17There's a lot of steps to that.
- 41:19I mean, I can see this long term,
- 41:21but man,
- 41:21that's years to get a working solution
- 41:24that does that.
- 41:25What have you seen work so far?
- 41:27I feel like you're the one of us
- 41:29so far that's actually existing in a space
- 41:31like this that's moving some of this
- 41:33forward.
- 41:34So I was crazy enough.
- 41:36It's all smoke and mirrors.
- 41:36Yeah.
- 41:38I've done, in the name of AI,
- 41:41we've done rooms and pilots around.
- 41:42We've done the Teams room thing.
- 41:44We're doing Zoom room things.
- 41:45And that's really to understand that full
- 41:47piece.
- 41:47We've done automation.
- 41:48You walk in, things turn on.
- 41:49But we're doing it in the clever ways
- 41:52that we've historically done it in the
- 41:54past, right?
- 41:55There's nothing new.
- 41:55None of it's AI.
- 41:56Yeah, I feel like that's just basic stuff.
- 41:58It's automation, right?
- 41:59But if you ask anybody in IT and
- 42:02like AV,
- 42:02they're all going to say it's just
- 42:04automation.
- 42:05AI stands for automations and
- 42:06integrations, not artificial intelligence,
- 42:08right?
- 42:08And so if we're just automating things,
- 42:11OK, well, what's the threshold?
- 42:13Are we talking about AGI in a learning
- 42:14space,
- 42:14that's a whole different conversation
- 42:16versus like just automating things and
- 42:18delivering things in a personalized way.
- 42:20But getting to the point where you're
- 42:22providing endpoints and technology
- 42:26specifically in the name of that AI
- 42:29experience, right?
- 42:31Easy to digest.
- 42:32We're doing microphones for transcripts.
- 42:34We're doing cameras for occupancy.
- 42:37That's the low-hanging fruit where people
- 42:39are going to start.
- 42:40Are we doing people counting?
- 42:41Are we doing engagement and measuring
- 42:44those pieces?
- 42:45I'm a far,
- 42:46miles and miles away from taking something
- 42:48that somebody's
- 42:49doing manipulating that and delivering it
- 42:51clean and lms specific for one person into
- 42:53a personalized learning sherpa we're just
- 42:56not there yet but it's a lot we
- 42:59can do the transcript things but it
- 43:00becomes a data conversation it becomes a
- 43:02security it becomes a data architecture
- 43:04conversation where do things go who has
- 43:06access to it and but if we didn't
- 43:08try to do those things we would not
- 43:09have insights into that
- 43:11The other piece that is really impacted is
- 43:14how you support these types of things.
- 43:15Just like you said, Justin,
- 43:17if it goes wrong,
- 43:18do you have the skill skill set?
- 43:20Do you have the subject matter expertise?
- 43:22Do you have the authentication layer to
- 43:24actually access these systems that are
- 43:25governed by the highest level of Azure
- 43:28provisions and permissions and like and so
- 43:30More importantly,
- 43:31do you have the relationships internally
- 43:33to make all departments communicate at one
- 43:36level and get buy-in so that everybody's
- 43:38on the same page?
- 43:39To me,
- 43:39that's the biggest hurdle almost at any
- 43:41university.
- 43:42The cooperative nature that this will
- 43:43require is one of the biggest hurdles.
- 43:47It is.
- 43:49content deliverer this is why it works in
- 43:51corporate because the ceo is like no we're
- 43:54doing this shit and y'all if not you're
- 43:56getting fired and that just doesn't happen
- 43:58in higher ed right that those things
- 44:01I think the CEO aspect is what you
- 44:03said,
- 44:03like if this is going to be successful,
- 44:05it has to come from the Chancellor down.
- 44:08Yes.
- 44:08It has to be a university directive that
- 44:10this is where we're going.
- 44:11So everybody get on board so we can
- 44:13go.
- 44:13And we're going to get ready to spend
- 44:14a lot of money.
- 44:15And every hire from instruction to
- 44:19staffing to support models,
- 44:22all of that has to be done in
- 44:24the name of this endeavor.
- 44:26We can have all the bits and pieces
- 44:28in,
- 44:28we can even maybe even support half of
- 44:30it.
- 44:30And you shouldn't start with a new
- 44:32building.
- 44:32You should start with an existing building
- 44:34and see if you want to incorporate
- 44:35whatever your magic wand thing you're
- 44:37trying to create should be implemented in
- 44:39a new building.
- 44:40Right?
- 44:41So that's the other part of this.
- 44:42You gotta have, you gotta have a working,
- 44:45you know,
- 44:46thing that actually is tangible and it's
- 44:48real.
- 44:50It's such a,
- 44:50it's such a difficult nut to crack here
- 44:53because of the, the,
- 44:54all of the different levels here.
- 44:57And in the end,
- 44:58the student experience is directly related
- 45:00to the content being given and created,
- 45:03which instructions, right?
- 45:05Instructors and it's delivery.
- 45:07And so we can be the middle part,
- 45:10but if those people aren't involved,
- 45:14It's all for not Katie,
- 45:16I think you navigated that conversation
- 45:18really well, when we met previously,
- 45:20and I think you're,
- 45:22you have to start somewhere.
- 45:25Right.
- 45:25And so from your perspective,
- 45:29how have you gone about, like,
- 45:30engaging in that conversation to start to
- 45:32actually mine, what's important,
- 45:35because you can listen to us knuckleheads,
- 45:37and we'll tell you about a thousand
- 45:38reasons why it may not work.
- 45:40And then where we tried it,
- 45:41and it was maybe God awful,
- 45:42or maybe we had some success,
- 45:43but you're doing consulting,
- 45:46you're going to speak to an architectural
- 45:47firm who's got the money,
- 45:48they have somebody who's going to do this.
- 45:51What's important to inform those decisions
- 45:53right now?
- 45:54Like,
- 45:54where do you start to get some traction?
- 45:56And where's your foothold or handhold
- 45:57here?
- 45:58Regardless of the sector or the typology
- 46:00of the project that we're doing, you know,
- 46:02whether it's high ed and the traditional
- 46:05academic building or it's a health care
- 46:08inpatient space,
- 46:10we try to follow a similar process in
- 46:13that hopefully the right stakeholders are
- 46:15in the room from the beginning so that
- 46:18we don't run into this problem in FF&E
- 46:21when we're furnishing the space and
- 46:23someone has a screen and the ceiling's at
- 46:24the right height, right?
- 46:26So ideally...
- 46:28You're having all of the stakeholders in
- 46:29the right place,
- 46:30but depending on who you ask,
- 46:32if we are only talking to facilities,
- 46:34for example,
- 46:35they might not know that IT is a
- 46:37key early stage stakeholder.
- 46:40Or they may know real quick and they
- 46:42don't want you at the table.
- 46:44Exactly.
- 46:46That's exactly correct.
- 46:48It's internal relationships.
- 46:49And we write,
- 46:50especially on new projects that involve
- 46:52folks like you.
- 46:53They want less voices in the room.
- 46:55Yes,
- 46:55they want less people because the more
- 46:58voices in the room,
- 46:59things in their vision,
- 47:01things get out of control,
- 47:03where you all may want to hear everybody's
- 47:05voice and process everything.
- 47:07Well, yes and no,
- 47:08because you're kind of working for that
- 47:10institution.
- 47:11If that institution tells you, nope,
- 47:13sorry,
- 47:13we're not bringing these stakeholders to
- 47:14the table.
- 47:15How insistent are you?
- 47:21Well, I'm curious,
- 47:22because this is not an answer we get
- 47:23very often, but how insistent are you?
- 47:25Sometimes we say that to our friends that
- 47:27are in your shoes, and we say, well,
- 47:31you guys didn't get us involved early
- 47:33enough.
- 47:33They said, well, we asked.
- 47:34We tried.
- 47:35Wait, but how insistent were you?
- 47:37When you come in and your client says,
- 47:40hey,
- 47:40we want to do this AI-enabled witch
- 47:42medulli,
- 47:43Um,
- 47:44and you look at them dead eye and
- 47:46you say,
- 47:46we will not even start unless we have
- 47:49this person, this person, this person.
- 47:51We are walking out of our contract.
- 47:53If it is not at this table,
- 47:55we will drop millions of dollars.
- 47:58Like that, I mean, so that's kind of...
- 48:00Sorry, NVIDIA.
- 48:01Yeah, yeah.
- 48:02We're not playing your game.
- 48:05But how insistent are you?
- 48:07Because you now know that we are the,
- 48:09not just we, the AV, right?
- 48:10We, IS, networking computers.
- 48:13Do you know that we are now a
- 48:15key stakeholder, right?
- 48:18And so how insistent are you?
- 48:20How much do you say, no,
- 48:21you have someone, get them here.
- 48:24But we don't like them.
- 48:26Hey, your internal relationships are not,
- 48:30that's at least not my problem.
- 48:33I- I'm in counseling though, come on.
- 48:35Yeah.
- 48:36Hey, I am a psychologist,
- 48:38but I'm not your psychologist, so.
- 48:42No, it's a really good point, Jamie.
- 48:45We run into this, again,
- 48:46it is not unique to high ed,
- 48:48but certainly the hierarchy and
- 48:49bureaucracy of high ed lends itself to
- 48:51this.
- 48:53It can sometimes be dependent on the
- 48:54funder, right?
- 48:55If the university has a,
- 48:58we talked about this, a corporate sponsor,
- 49:01we have a donor relationship where they
- 49:04want more voices at the table,
- 49:06sometimes that's a really easy way to open
- 49:08the doors.
- 49:09Other times it's a challenge.
- 49:12It's tough to be able to sit down
- 49:13with leadership and say,
- 49:15we actually are open to having more folks
- 49:18weigh in on this and give more feedback.
- 49:23I'm trying to think through.
- 49:26What I would say,
- 49:27if there was a provost or a chancellor
- 49:29listening to this right now,
- 49:32to be able to say- Let us know
- 49:33who you are,
- 49:33because I want to make sure I reach
- 49:34out to you.
- 49:34Yeah, right?
- 49:35I know, hi.
- 49:35I was going to say, blanket,
- 49:37if there is a provost or somebody like
- 49:39that listening right now- Or even a VP.
- 49:42I'm okay with a VP level.
- 49:43We'll take it.
- 49:44The right people are not at the table.
- 49:46I, one hundred percent, guarantee that.
- 49:48And for the one percent where the right
- 49:49people are at the table,
- 49:51somebody screwed up and invited the wrong
- 49:52person.
- 49:53Because that's never how these big
- 49:54projects go.
- 49:55They always like,
- 49:56we start with this grand design.
- 49:57We're going to do charrettes.
- 49:57We're going to hear from everybody.
- 49:58And then we're going to get the three
- 49:59people who like art,
- 50:01their vision aligns with ours.
- 50:02We're going to go build that building.
- 50:03That's also a challenge of architecture
- 50:05and design in general,
- 50:06because it's not just that the people on
- 50:08the university side have a preconceived
- 50:10idea.
- 50:11We also have preconceived ideas of what
- 50:13that looks like.
- 50:13And we're not actively in education.
- 50:17We're not faculty right now.
- 50:18And so trying to figure out what the
- 50:20actual needs are.
- 50:24Everyone at my firm has heard me say
- 50:25that.
- 50:27We often operate on our own biases and
- 50:30sometimes it's just aesthetic and
- 50:32sometimes it's just the needs and
- 50:34interests of the people who are
- 50:36controlling the contract.
- 50:38um that is again in a biased way
- 50:42that's why I'm glad that we have a
- 50:44research and development team we can go in
- 50:47as kind of this third semi-third party
- 50:49second party and say yeah like I'm not
- 50:53part of the design team but I really
- 50:54want to hear and filter through a lot
- 50:56of these voices that might not be invited
- 50:59to a charrette so I don't think we've
- 51:01nailed it I don't think we're there yet
- 51:03And I think some projects,
- 51:05and you probably know,
- 51:06some projects tend to, it doesn't matter.
- 51:10It's a typical building with a typical
- 51:11stuff.
- 51:13But when you have those projects,
- 51:16like let's pretend an AI makerspace,
- 51:20let's pretend, maybe.
- 51:22Because they don't exist.
- 51:24I've got one right here that exists.
- 51:26It's not AI in it.
- 51:28This is where the rubber meets the road
- 51:29now.
- 51:30And I think that's when you sit down
- 51:31and you say, hey, look,
- 51:34We know that this is,
- 51:36we can do the best we can now,
- 51:37but someday you're walking away.
- 51:39You, the architecture firm, you,
- 51:42the design team, you're walking away.
- 51:45And to look across this and say,
- 51:46for this to be successful, we need,
- 51:49we require as part of our contract that
- 51:51we will speak to these people.
- 51:55Thanks for all your charrette.
- 51:56Yeah, perfect.
- 51:58The I think,
- 52:02looking at kind of exercise that you have
- 52:04Justin, and then you know,
- 52:05I'm in right now.
- 52:07You're you're you have a space.
- 52:09I got a space.
- 52:09I do.
- 52:10It's blank.
- 52:11Right?
- 52:12Can I give some context real quick?
- 52:13We will.
- 52:14But here's what I want to share first.
- 52:16Damn it.
- 52:17A lot of times, it groups are
- 52:21wholly focused on service delivery.
- 52:24Tell me what you want and I will
- 52:27deliver that.
- 52:28They are not good at, well,
- 52:30it's gonna kinda do,
- 52:33people are gonna walk in and it's gonna
- 52:34kinda just, you know,
- 52:36no i don't know put it in a
- 52:37ticket and tell me exactly what you want
- 52:39and i will deliver that so that's why
- 52:41on that yeah maybe sometimes they're not
- 52:44at the table because they just want to
- 52:45know what the hell is the ask how
- 52:48many network drops do you want where do
- 52:50you want it to go where is the
- 52:52idf going to be and who owns it
- 52:54what vlan do you want it on no
- 52:55i don't want any of that i just
- 52:57want to know how talk talk high level
- 53:00about how you're going to use this space
- 53:02well yeah
- 53:03And exactly.
- 53:03So it's about like,
- 53:05really understanding that experience and
- 53:06translation.
- 53:08This is what the human experience will be
- 53:10in this venue in this volume,
- 53:12it's going to do this,
- 53:14here's how we're going to enable that it's
- 53:15going to require this type of IT service,
- 53:18and a density and you have to know
- 53:20how to bridge that conversation.
- 53:23If you just leave it to the hammers,
- 53:24they're going to say, Okay, that's a nail,
- 53:26let me knock down that nail.
- 53:27And then you show up with the same
- 53:28thing you've always had,
- 53:29because that's what service delivery tells
- 53:31us to do.
- 53:31And so
- 53:33how do you intentionally take innovation
- 53:36normalize that to make it fit into the
- 53:39buckets of service delivery.
- 53:40And that's a really sticky and tricky
- 53:42conversation, especially when it's like,
- 53:44we're only paid for X amount of minutes
- 53:45of consulting.
- 53:46I think they're going to say, like,
- 53:48as you were talking,
- 53:49I was thinking about how does an AI
- 53:52makerspace fit into that conversation?
- 53:54Yeah, like,
- 53:55I got sixteen hours of meeting now,
- 53:57and we don't know what it's going to
- 53:58be in a year from now when it's
- 54:00actually built.
- 54:01How do you build something that is not
- 54:02defined?
- 54:03You don't talk about the stuff.
- 54:04Talk about what would it do if this
- 54:06was successful and how would that change
- 54:08your life?
- 54:09I'm okay with that too.
- 54:10Define something.
- 54:12It's not about the stuff.
- 54:14And I think that's why a lot of
- 54:15us tend to use the car analogies too.
- 54:17It's like, okay, I need a vehicle.
- 54:19Great.
- 54:20What are you going to do with it
- 54:21once you get it?
- 54:22yeah well i'm gonna race it great you
- 54:24need a race car yeah right well i
- 54:26need to i need to haul broken stuff
- 54:29around you like you're great you need a
- 54:30truck or right what right yeah right yeah
- 54:35it we get into it because that's our
- 54:38ever ever ever in twenty five years of
- 54:40doing this used a car analogy i use
- 54:42it all time it's the only thing people
- 54:45just identified the genesis of all your
- 54:46problems
- 54:47but okay what kind of system do you
- 54:49want do you want a mercedes or do
- 54:50you want a ford and so right now
- 54:52that's coming from a place of look at
- 54:54the value menu and order one innovation's
- 54:56not on the value menu it's never going
- 54:58to be right and so if it's not
- 55:00on the value menu innovation is not on
- 55:03the value menu i know it sounds crazy
- 55:05right it's not i agree with that but
- 55:08you still have to define something before
- 55:10i build something all of your tools that
- 55:12govern your success all the management
- 55:14practice you will not manage your way to
- 55:16innovation
- 55:17It's not going to happen.
- 55:18You're going to have to do things that
- 55:19are different than what you're currently
- 55:20doing right now.
- 55:22And it's going to be hard.
- 55:23And so you're going to have to
- 55:24intentionally engage.
- 55:25It's not going to be hard.
- 55:26Well,
- 55:26it will be harder for some than others.
- 55:28You just got to have money and time.
- 55:30It's not a recipe.
- 55:30It may not be an off-the-shelf recipe.
- 55:32And that's where it's hard for higher
- 55:34education.
- 55:34Higher education likes to see success
- 55:37before they do it.
- 55:38Somebody else has to do it first.
- 55:40And then our...
- 55:42They're going to go,
- 55:44I went to a conference and so-and-so did
- 55:46this and we're going to do it because
- 55:47I got shipped to go there and we're
- 55:48going to come back with a big idea
- 55:49and let me get everybody involved.
- 55:51Mark, but you're in a space,
- 55:53you are on that innovation space right
- 55:56now.
- 55:57People are looking at University of Oregon
- 55:59right now for... Oh, shoot,
- 56:01maybe University of Oregon.
- 56:02We all look at University of Oregon
- 56:04because it's better.
- 56:06I actually started a rivalry.
- 56:09It's because I get Nike money.
- 56:12We don't get that money.
- 56:14Speaking of innovation.
- 56:15We're innovative around academics.
- 56:17They're innovative around athletics.
- 56:21It's different.
- 56:22But fundamentally,
- 56:23if we're all going to say research becomes
- 56:25this big beacon of success for higher
- 56:26education,
- 56:27Okay, that changes the whole thing.
- 56:29Right?
- 56:29What is how does innovative,
- 56:31agentic AI and research make its way into
- 56:33the learning space?
- 56:33And what does it mean for research?
- 56:34And so lean into that.
- 56:36So it's going to be different.
- 56:38And I think fundamentally,
- 56:39it is a leadership piece to get buy
- 56:42in to articulate that.
- 56:43Here's what the experience will be.
- 56:45We will all learn it together.
- 56:47I do not have the answers,
- 56:48but we will learn and figure it out.
- 56:50And it's a philosophical approach.
- 56:51And we will fail.
- 56:52We will.
- 56:53There will be fails.
- 56:54But we're going to learn from the
- 56:54failures, right?
- 56:55And can you stomach a million dollar fail?
- 56:58Right.
- 56:59Far more than that, right?
- 57:00Well, I'm just being conservative.
- 57:02Right.
- 57:04Jamie,
- 57:04all our campuses are littered with those.
- 57:06Right.
- 57:07But that's also what makes higher
- 57:08education such a great place to work,
- 57:10right?
- 57:11Because you do have these opportunities.
- 57:13And folks,
- 57:13when you do get a leader who comes
- 57:15along and says,
- 57:15we're going to take some chances,
- 57:16we're going to fall down,
- 57:17we're going to skin our knees,
- 57:18we're going to
- 57:20It's not going to be pretty,
- 57:21but we recognize that we have to do
- 57:23something.
- 57:24We can't wait for the Joneses to do
- 57:26it.
- 57:26If we wait for the Joneses to do
- 57:27it, guess what?
- 57:27Our students went to the Joneses, right?
- 57:30The lifeblood being the enrollment,
- 57:31like that's what we're after.
- 57:32We want to bring people in here and
- 57:33make it an attractive university.
- 57:34And how do we get people excited about
- 57:37that?
- 57:37Again,
- 57:38excitement for enrollment is not on my
- 57:40value menu.
- 57:41It's not theirs.
- 57:42We have to kind of understand how what
- 57:45we do rolls up into that larger context.
- 57:48How do you think the value menu is
- 57:49changing with AI?
- 57:51We were talking about whether all of this
- 57:53is in service of learning outcomes or not.
- 57:55I would argue that learning outcomes are
- 57:57fundamentally changing.
- 57:58Preparing for the job market is an
- 58:01entirely different set of core
- 58:03competencies now than it was twenty years
- 58:05ago.
- 58:06So what is the value menu changing in
- 58:09an AI agentic teaching age?
- 58:14Larry,
- 58:15I want you to take a stab at
- 58:16that first.
- 58:16I know,
- 58:17I feel like I was looking directly at
- 58:18Larry's square.
- 58:18Yeah,
- 58:20I'm really struggling with this because
- 58:22there is a new generation of learners,
- 58:24the AI native learners.
- 58:26Historically,
- 58:28high school students are really piss poor
- 58:32at being self-directed.
- 58:33That's why hybrid, HyFlex,
- 58:35none of that has effectively been used for
- 58:39students who are
- 58:42traditional.
- 58:43Traditionally spoon-fed.
- 58:45They need that rigor.
- 58:48They're at that point in their life where
- 58:50they're learning how to actually learn how
- 58:52to do this.
- 58:53They don't know what their learning style
- 58:55is.
- 58:56They're still figuring out how the best
- 58:58way they fit into this.
- 58:59Learning style doesn't exist,
- 59:00but that's a different topic.
- 59:02Let's just oversimplify that.
- 59:09As an example, a school like...
- 59:11WGU, Western Governors University,
- 59:14which is competency-based.
- 59:15Historically,
- 59:16they've not even allowed students
- 59:18graduating high school to enroll.
- 59:20They said, we've tested it,
- 59:23it does not work.
- 59:24It's just since COVID that they've allowed
- 59:26that.
- 59:27I'm curious, like,
- 59:28how much the AI native student who has
- 59:33used AI to gather information,
- 59:36does that translate into learning
- 59:39outcomes?
- 59:41Because there's a difference between being
- 59:44a data,
- 59:45like an information driven and actually
- 59:49being able to demonstrate competency and
- 59:54expertise in a subject.
- 59:55Do you have to be able to if
- 59:57you're going into an AI, you know,
- 59:59an AI native job?
- 1:00:00No, you just need to make a C.
- 1:00:02No, you just need to make that C.
- 1:00:04I know I'm being like a little bit
- 1:00:06pedantic right now.
- 1:00:07And I, that's not how I actually,
- 1:00:08it's not what I actually believe,
- 1:00:09but I'm really curious if,
- 1:00:12if it makes a difference,
- 1:00:13if we actually know something and can
- 1:00:17report it back out.
- 1:00:17I'm an idealist,
- 1:00:19and so I'm going to say you have
- 1:00:21to show competency,
- 1:00:22even though I don't necessarily believe
- 1:00:24it.
- 1:00:24I've seen enough people out there that
- 1:00:26aren't competent now that still have jobs
- 1:00:29that it probably doesn't matter.
- 1:00:30Justin has a whole show on that.
- 1:00:32I know.
- 1:00:32Why didn't you look at me when you
- 1:00:34said that?
- 1:00:35The only reason I'm pushing on it is
- 1:00:37because I feel like
- 1:00:39Again,
- 1:00:39from the beginning of this conversation,
- 1:00:41we were trying to figure out what the
- 1:00:42problem is that we're trying to solve.
- 1:00:43What are the outcomes that we're
- 1:00:44interested in?
- 1:00:45And if the role of higher education is
- 1:00:48to prepare students for the next step in
- 1:00:52their career,
- 1:00:53certainly there's other pieces of the
- 1:00:55higher education system,
- 1:00:56but if teaching is preparing students for
- 1:00:59the next stage in their career and their
- 1:01:01career and expectations have fundamentally
- 1:01:03changed,
- 1:01:04then
- 1:01:06Do we need a totally different imagination
- 1:01:08of the environment?
- 1:01:10I don't believe that that is the purpose
- 1:01:12of higher education.
- 1:01:12Again, I'm an idealist.
- 1:01:14And so I would say if that was
- 1:01:17the only role in AI,
- 1:01:20they're going to lean on AI to do
- 1:01:22that role.
- 1:01:23then where does higher ed fit?
- 1:01:25And so there has to be something else
- 1:01:27to higher ed other than that.
- 1:01:28There is value in learning how to learn.
- 1:01:31Learning how to learn something,
- 1:01:33and learning how to take agency upon
- 1:01:35yourself to go and find information,
- 1:01:38and thinking, is this real?
- 1:01:40Is this not real?
- 1:01:41I think the types and ways we go
- 1:01:44about teaching students to actually learn
- 1:01:46And what that means is going to change.
- 1:01:48The hunter-gatherer student is not going
- 1:01:50to be the student of the future.
- 1:01:51Go find me information and bring it back
- 1:01:53and regurgitate it on paper is not
- 1:01:54learning.
- 1:01:55That's not learning.
- 1:01:56And so it's going to be more lab-based
- 1:01:58experiential.
- 1:01:58I think that's where it has impact to
- 1:02:01our physical spaces and our technology.
- 1:02:03It's really in that more lab focused
- 1:02:05approach and understanding that all of our
- 1:02:07standards that we've gone and have
- 1:02:09multiple shows around mean nothing in the
- 1:02:11future,
- 1:02:11because they're all going to go out the
- 1:02:12door and window when we have to make
- 1:02:14all these unique spaces that are tailored
- 1:02:16to the type and pedagogy and delivery of
- 1:02:19that curriculum.
- 1:02:20And this market, I think,
- 1:02:22where we are in agreement for a change.
- 1:02:24Normally, we're not.
- 1:02:25But I think that, you know, years ago,
- 1:02:28there was this big push for the flipped
- 1:02:30classroom where students would gather
- 1:02:32information outside of class.
- 1:02:33By the way, just real quick,
- 1:02:35when you say years ago,
- 1:02:36that was twenty plus years ago because I
- 1:02:38taught in a flipped classroom in two
- 1:02:39thousand and two.
- 1:02:40I'm getting old.
- 1:02:40That's all I'm saying.
- 1:02:41OK, but it's just the other day.
- 1:02:45Yeah.
- 1:02:45But I think we're back to that now,
- 1:02:48because information isn't as important as
- 1:02:51it used to,
- 1:02:52like it is so readily available,
- 1:02:53AI can deliver it.
- 1:02:55But knowing what to do with that and
- 1:02:57being able to discern straight is where
- 1:03:00the real higher ed in structure,
- 1:03:05don't type me a paper telling me you
- 1:03:07know, this, show me that you know this,
- 1:03:10which so how do our spaces and show
- 1:03:12learning spaces?
- 1:03:14Basically, a trade school,
- 1:03:16maybe an immersive trade school.
- 1:03:18That's what you're building, Justin,
- 1:03:20you're building a space that can
- 1:03:21reconfigure itself to mimic different
- 1:03:24environments for the trades in which
- 1:03:26they're going to be taught within the four
- 1:03:28walls.
- 1:03:28Yeah, I think the value menu is changing.
- 1:03:32But it takes a long time to change
- 1:03:34the value menu.
- 1:03:35I mean, you can't just change the price,
- 1:03:37you have to change the offering.
- 1:03:42And is it actual value?
- 1:03:43I've got four walls and there's fourteen
- 1:03:45foot between each wall and the architect.
- 1:03:48Yeah,
- 1:03:48we're back to the fourteen foot wall.
- 1:03:50Yes.
- 1:03:51So this is a real room.
- 1:03:52This is a real problem.
- 1:03:53So this is a real problem.
- 1:03:54This is an AI maker space.
- 1:03:56Yeah, that's an AI XR,
- 1:03:58some weird term maker space.
- 1:04:00And it's got one glass wall, one door,
- 1:04:05fourteen by fourteen.
- 1:04:06And they showed me this architectural firm
- 1:04:08showed me the three D renderings of the
- 1:04:10internal space.
- 1:04:12And one wall had an entire screen on
- 1:04:16it of some type.
- 1:04:17I don't know if it was,
- 1:04:18they're talking projection now, right?
- 1:04:20It doesn't matter either way.
- 1:04:22But there was just someone's face on it.
- 1:04:24They're like, we're gonna need,
- 1:04:25and it was Florida ceiling, just a face.
- 1:04:29And I'm looking at this and I'm going,
- 1:04:31so they've conversated with the clients.
- 1:04:35We haven't done that yet.
- 1:04:36And they're reviewing with us because
- 1:04:38we're being brought in at a later time.
- 1:04:41this is what we're envisioning for this
- 1:04:43space i'm saying son of a like what
- 1:04:46are we i'm am i going to be
- 1:04:49the wet blanket here am i going to
- 1:04:50be so so now i've got this thing
- 1:04:53in front of me that i've got to
- 1:04:55figure out how to design something unique
- 1:04:57and creative that is going to do what
- 1:04:59they think it's going to do but also
- 1:05:01do xra what did they think it was
- 1:05:03going to do
- 1:05:05TIG welding.
- 1:05:06You tell him.
- 1:05:08It came from your group.
- 1:05:09Katie, me and you.
- 1:05:10No, not Katie's group.
- 1:05:11Look at her.
- 1:05:12She's like, no, no.
- 1:05:13I've got marketing listening to this call.
- 1:05:15That was not us.
- 1:05:18I'm kidding.
- 1:05:18It did not come from her group.
- 1:05:20So there's more conversations to happen.
- 1:05:22That's obviously not what it's going to
- 1:05:24be.
- 1:05:24It's going to be something different than
- 1:05:26that.
- 1:05:26It's going to be someone's office.
- 1:05:27But again...
- 1:05:30How many people is this serving?
- 1:05:32Well, oh,
- 1:05:33we're going to have twenty people.
- 1:05:34It's fourteen by fourteen.
- 1:05:36There's a lot of conversation yet to
- 1:05:38happen about how this end result is going
- 1:05:40to look.
- 1:05:40Here's one example I use.
- 1:05:42I say the college experience is not
- 1:05:45necessarily always about finding out what
- 1:05:47you like and what you're good at.
- 1:05:49Can you design an experience that allows
- 1:05:51the student to find out something that,
- 1:05:52holy shit, I hate this?
- 1:05:54Yeah, I can do that every day.
- 1:05:55I do that all the time.
- 1:05:56So if I can make a lab that
- 1:05:58will show you what it's like to be
- 1:06:00somewhere else as a researcher that you've
- 1:06:02signed up and going to college,
- 1:06:02you're about to spend one hundred and
- 1:06:03fifty thousand dollars of your money on.
- 1:06:05But if I can put you in a
- 1:06:06simulator that allows you to say this is
- 1:06:08what it feels like to be a day
- 1:06:09in the life of somebody in X industry
- 1:06:11and you show up and be like,
- 1:06:13I think I'm going to hate this.
- 1:06:15and you change to go to a different,
- 1:06:16like, that's just as successful.
- 1:06:18So you're not wasting all of your money,
- 1:06:20right?
- 1:06:20And that's okay, in your life,
- 1:06:21because you're,
- 1:06:22you're creating that immersive experience
- 1:06:23to allow that student to not invest in
- 1:06:25something that's not going to be a good
- 1:06:27fit for them.
- 1:06:27Mark,
- 1:06:28you should build that as a simulator where
- 1:06:29they make shoes,
- 1:06:30because I have several of my own children
- 1:06:33that I wish this experience happened.
- 1:06:35It's not about like your shoes to
- 1:06:37What do you want to see on this
- 1:06:38wall?
- 1:06:38It's what would you like to be able
- 1:06:39to experience and take that research and
- 1:06:41say,
- 1:06:42this is what I can mimic and bring
- 1:06:43you into this environment so our students
- 1:06:45can say, oh, wow, yes,
- 1:06:47this is what I want to do.
- 1:06:48You know what?
- 1:06:48That aligns with my passions.
- 1:06:50I want to do that and put them
- 1:06:51in those fields so they understand that or
- 1:06:53they learn.
- 1:06:55No,
- 1:06:55I don't want to be on a boat
- 1:06:57over in the ocean, blah, blah, blah.
- 1:06:58And I'm getting seasick and all this
- 1:06:59stuff.
- 1:06:59I'm going to go just work in a
- 1:07:00farm.
- 1:07:01That's value too.
- 1:07:02So sometimes looking at it differently,
- 1:07:04not about what do you want to see
- 1:07:05here?
- 1:07:05What do you want to be able to
- 1:07:06experience here?
- 1:07:09Yeah.
- 1:07:09And I, yes.
- 1:07:10But Mark, wait, hold on.
- 1:07:11If they just went to the farm,
- 1:07:13what does that do to our retention rate?
- 1:07:17That's not successful, Mark.
- 1:07:19I think one of the things that really
- 1:07:22hampers students, too,
- 1:07:23is that there's a plethora of more job
- 1:07:26out there than what they think there are.
- 1:07:28Like, I might go into athletic training,
- 1:07:30right?
- 1:07:31Hey,
- 1:07:31there's this whole world called AV that
- 1:07:33nobody knows about, too.
- 1:07:35Right?
- 1:07:36Well, we all have degrees in that.
- 1:07:37People go to radio, people go to TV,
- 1:07:40people go to film,
- 1:07:41and they end up in AV.
- 1:07:42Right.
- 1:07:43Or or like when I went through,
- 1:07:45I wanted to be in mass media.
- 1:07:46I wanted to be in radio and TV.
- 1:07:47I didn't even know there was a thing
- 1:07:49called an engineer that did that
- 1:07:51specifically.
- 1:07:52And that's really what I wanted.
- 1:07:53I wanted that job,
- 1:07:54but I didn't know it existed.
- 1:07:57And so I went down the wrong path,
- 1:07:58spent a lot of loan money and took
- 1:08:01six years,
- 1:08:02seven years to get to the place where
- 1:08:04I kind of wanted to be to begin
- 1:08:05with.
- 1:08:06And so, Mark, I'm with you.
- 1:08:07I wish there was a way to kind
- 1:08:09of let students early on or people even
- 1:08:12before school, before they enroll,
- 1:08:14before they get a loan that says,
- 1:08:16is this really the direction I want to
- 1:08:17go?
- 1:08:18How many people drop out of pre-med?
- 1:08:21I'm going to be a doctor.
- 1:08:22Wait, doctor sucks.
- 1:08:23I'm going to do this.
- 1:08:24No, wait, that sucks.
- 1:08:25Oh, we've already got sim centers, right?
- 1:08:26So in theory,
- 1:08:27some of this immersive stuff already
- 1:08:30exists.
- 1:08:30So what takes it the step further that
- 1:08:33we're actually using this infrastructure
- 1:08:35for students to explore?
- 1:08:36A lot of those sim centers are already
- 1:08:38curricular-based.
- 1:08:39And they're very static.
- 1:08:39You're only going to be in there when
- 1:08:40you're at the higher level of that
- 1:08:42organization.
- 1:08:43And they're training for the people who
- 1:08:44are actually going to go in that
- 1:08:45direction.
- 1:08:46I think one of the fallacies here in
- 1:08:47our ideas is that schools don't really
- 1:08:51They don't really want that to happen?
- 1:08:53No, I mean, but again,
- 1:08:56you have to change.
- 1:08:57Because what if you decide the school's
- 1:08:58not for you?
- 1:08:59What if you decide that you don't, right?
- 1:09:00And then, you know,
- 1:09:01there is a bottom dollar vault here.
- 1:09:03Like, here's a great example.
- 1:09:04We have a full-on cadaver lab on campus
- 1:09:06that we have a bunch of AV in.
- 1:09:08It might be fairly easy.
- 1:09:09In the cadavers?
- 1:09:10In the cadavers?
- 1:09:10Yeah, what's going on there?
- 1:09:12It's really rough because I got to go
- 1:09:13change it every couple of days.
- 1:09:15Yeah,
- 1:09:16it's a pain in the butt to change
- 1:09:17stuff out.
- 1:09:19Literally.
- 1:09:20But that would be a great opportunity to
- 1:09:22create some kind of
- 1:09:23virtual way of exposing someone to that.
- 1:09:26Because what if someone decided, yeah,
- 1:09:29I want to I want to do this,
- 1:09:30I want to do physical therapy or something
- 1:09:32in the medical field.
- 1:09:33All right, let's see if you can handle,
- 1:09:35you know,
- 1:09:36a dead body and they pass out.
- 1:09:37Yeah, that's not the field for me, right?
- 1:09:39I mean, I just,
- 1:09:40but then so let's take that example,
- 1:09:42though, Justin.
- 1:09:43And so we've all been in rooms where,
- 1:09:46if we're not there,
- 1:09:47we can interpret that as somebody said
- 1:09:48they wanted VR goggles.
- 1:09:50I have no idea how the hell we're
- 1:09:51putting VR goggles in here, right?
- 1:09:52And so that's,
- 1:09:53it's about the interpretation of that,
- 1:09:55right?
- 1:09:55And so, because we jump to the stuff.
- 1:09:58We're like,
- 1:09:58I got to figure out this stuff.
- 1:09:59I got to build materials.
- 1:10:00The time's ticking.
- 1:10:01They need all this.
- 1:10:03The stuff is the last step.
- 1:10:04I just need the idea so I can
- 1:10:06figure out how I'm going to build it,
- 1:10:08not what I'm going to build it with.
- 1:10:09I just need,
- 1:10:10just give me some breadcrumbs and you're
- 1:10:13going to turn on the light switch and
- 1:10:15you walk in the room.
- 1:10:15What are you going to do next?
- 1:10:16No, there's a sensor for that, sir.
- 1:10:18That's fine.
- 1:10:19What's next?
- 1:10:20It turns on when you walk in.
- 1:10:21that's fine you set that expectation but
- 1:10:23just kind of walk through what you're
- 1:10:25going to do in this room and what
- 1:10:26you want to experience and then we'll
- 1:10:28figure that stuff out later you know yeah
- 1:10:31does that answer any of your questions no
- 1:10:32i've got another one does that type of
- 1:10:35space feel more valuable to you like if
- 1:10:37your university had x amount of money
- 1:10:40Would you want them?
- 1:10:41You're talking to the wrong university.
- 1:10:47No, we're playing a game.
- 1:10:47I could play along.
- 1:10:48What would it take for us to come
- 1:10:50talk to you?
- 1:10:52Let's say someone has appeared and is
- 1:10:54offering you,
- 1:10:55your local wizard has appeared and they
- 1:10:58have offered you money to invest in
- 1:11:03campus.
- 1:11:03Is that the type of space,
- 1:11:05that type of experiential
- 1:11:07again we're almost agnostic here right
- 1:11:09like simulation space is that the type of
- 1:11:12investment that you would want to see or
- 1:11:13are you looking at something else i think
- 1:11:15it depends on the trade and what you're
- 1:11:17doing um we have a lot of simulations
- 1:11:20on campus already we've been doing it
- 1:11:22again like chris said this has been going
- 1:11:23on for twenty years like nursing
- 1:11:24simulations and all that stuff um
- 1:11:28I think they're advancing, but yeah,
- 1:11:30more simulations would be good.
- 1:11:31But how, like for your field, Katie,
- 1:11:33how would you simulate psychology?
- 1:11:35Is that something that you could,
- 1:11:36I don't know.
- 1:11:37Right.
- 1:11:37I mean, that's just,
- 1:11:38I think you probably could with a genetic
- 1:11:39AI.
- 1:11:40You,
- 1:11:40you might actually very well be able to
- 1:11:41do that.
- 1:11:41Just have them ride public transit now.
- 1:11:43But then again, is that like,
- 1:11:44is that a,
- 1:11:45that's not a built environment problem.
- 1:11:47That's a platform problem.
- 1:11:49Yes.
- 1:11:49Correct.
- 1:11:50Exactly.
- 1:11:51And so, but I think if you,
- 1:11:53if you did the needs analysis based on
- 1:11:54the conversation we just had,
- 1:11:56it's easy to come away with,
- 1:11:57I'm building a sim lab.
- 1:11:59That's one element that I'd like this
- 1:12:01space to be capable of delivering.
- 1:12:03Correct.
- 1:12:03It's one thing built for one thing, right?
- 1:12:07And what we're talking about is a
- 1:12:08simulation area that could maybe handle
- 1:12:11multiple types of trades and multiple
- 1:12:13things.
- 1:12:14So with our space that we're looking at,
- 1:12:16it's a little bit larger volume than the
- 1:12:19fourteen by fourteen room that Justin has.
- 1:12:21Fifteen by fifteen.
- 1:12:21It's fifteen by fifteen.
- 1:12:22Yeah.
- 1:12:22So to me,
- 1:12:23I say this with nine foot ceilings,
- 1:12:25it's bolted onto the research piece of it
- 1:12:27so that it is about the human experience
- 1:12:29with the data output.
- 1:12:30Right.
- 1:12:30So it's agentic based.
- 1:12:32Take your dirty data,
- 1:12:33whatever you want to say, bring it in,
- 1:12:35upload it, speak to the room and say,
- 1:12:37generate fifteen different versions of
- 1:12:39this with outputs that give me
- 1:12:42high resolution output video,
- 1:12:44put me in the space in an audio
- 1:12:46volume so I could feel like I'm in
- 1:12:48that immersive arena and let me understand
- 1:12:51the impact of what this research meant.
- 1:12:54So I can experience that.
- 1:12:56So you're building Jarvis?
- 1:12:58Potentially, yes.
- 1:12:59So I'm doing that and that I'm also
- 1:13:01have a capture element so I can actually
- 1:13:03capture what that human experience is.
- 1:13:06It's not enough to just create the
- 1:13:08experiences.
- 1:13:09Now,
- 1:13:09how does this experience get shared with
- 1:13:11others have said we went out,
- 1:13:12we did the research, we saved the world,
- 1:13:14we showed you how we do it,
- 1:13:15you experienced that saving the world.
- 1:13:16Now I have to tell that story at
- 1:13:18large.
- 1:13:18Right.
- 1:13:19And so that's part of this entire
- 1:13:21ecosystem,
- 1:13:21not just one little element of it.
- 1:13:23It's not just a sim lab,
- 1:13:24it's actually this immersive experiential
- 1:13:26data environment.
- 1:13:27Is it scalable?
- 1:13:29No, can't ask that.
- 1:13:32Currently, no, it's not.
- 1:13:33But I think there's elements that can be.
- 1:13:36And I think you but it does mean
- 1:13:38that we have to have a really intentional
- 1:13:40conversation about what our networks look
- 1:13:41like, you know, who owns what,
- 1:13:43where does it sit?
- 1:13:44How's it sit on the research piece of
- 1:13:45it?
- 1:13:45You know,
- 1:13:46where does it overlay with AI and AV
- 1:13:48IT, and it's cross organizational,
- 1:13:50and it's not coming off the value menu.
- 1:13:52That way, it's, it's,
- 1:13:54it's a different thing that I think that
- 1:13:56is the future of what we will be
- 1:13:57tasked with day in and day out more
- 1:14:00things like this,
- 1:14:01as the college experience becomes more
- 1:14:04ambiguous.
- 1:14:05All right.
- 1:14:06What does that mean?
- 1:14:07Our spaces will probably be that way also.
- 1:14:10Well,
- 1:14:10and then you get to look at the
- 1:14:11second version of it where some other
- 1:14:12group on campus sees that one,
- 1:14:13said they want exactly that.
- 1:14:15They really love what you've done there.
- 1:14:16They want one of those of their own,
- 1:14:18and they have forty thousand dollars.
- 1:14:19Right.
- 1:14:20They need four million.
- 1:14:24Do we answer any questions for you today,
- 1:14:25Katie?
- 1:14:26Or just gave you a bunch more is
- 1:14:28what we did.
- 1:14:29no i love this i jamie i have
- 1:14:31to come back to you eventually with a
- 1:14:32question about pushing harder for more
- 1:14:36people at the table um you all saw
- 1:14:39that could be a different conversation too
- 1:14:41that's a whole like how do we open
- 1:14:43how do we crack that how do we
- 1:14:44crack that can i think that you and
- 1:14:46one of your your friends from from your
- 1:14:49group can come on
- 1:14:51and uh b i know you're listening you
- 1:14:53almost like the architecture of firms
- 1:14:56almost need some kind of one-on-one how to
- 1:14:58build a building correctly education forum
- 1:15:01before you sign a contract where it's you
- 1:15:03present it to you i thought justin i
- 1:15:06thought you were going to tell us no
- 1:15:07no no no no like the architectural firm
- 1:15:10will come in that's all you need to
- 1:15:11know and if you notice the right people
- 1:15:13aren't at like maybe we should go over
- 1:15:15the elementary reasons why these
- 1:15:18stakeholders should be here
- 1:15:20and kind of talk through some things.
- 1:15:22And this is not going to be successful
- 1:15:25if these key components aren't at the
- 1:15:27table contributing to this.
- 1:15:29And that's fine.
- 1:15:31We'll still take your money,
- 1:15:32but it's going to fail if these people
- 1:15:35are not here.
- 1:15:37And are you paying attention?
- 1:15:39Architectural risk recon.
- 1:15:41Absolutely.
- 1:15:42absolutely and i think that's a seriously
- 1:15:44that's a whole nother show yeah we we've
- 1:15:47tried to open our thing and we talked
- 1:15:49to some uh consultant not too long we
- 1:15:50have part two with katie and can we
- 1:15:52do that well yeah and i do you
- 1:15:54saw my heart rate right now when i
- 1:15:55accidentally screwed up osu versus
- 1:15:58university of oregon i was like i need
- 1:16:00to leave we did see that because we
- 1:16:04have the sensors built in the stream yard
- 1:16:06we can all see yeah yeah
- 1:16:09We got it off the Bluetooth from your
- 1:16:10headphones.
- 1:16:11Registering your engagement.
- 1:16:12We just logged those.
- 1:16:14And then the eye roll, oh boy.
- 1:16:17We're tearing up a check now.
- 1:16:20Hey,
- 1:16:20you get a couple other people who are
- 1:16:22trying to build these spaces and we can
- 1:16:24chat about...
- 1:16:25But I think that that this conversation
- 1:16:29within the realms of AI and bringing into
- 1:16:32the building and learning outcomes.
- 1:16:33But I do think that that also dovetails
- 1:16:35into this other conversation, too,
- 1:16:37is like,
- 1:16:38as we are challenged to come up with
- 1:16:40new learning spaces and new things.
- 1:16:44And we know the challenge of building a
- 1:16:46building is there.
- 1:16:47We know there's contracts.
- 1:16:48We know there's walls and red tape and
- 1:16:51things to get through.
- 1:16:53But from your end...
- 1:16:54And there's a day one that's already set
- 1:16:55four years ahead of time.
- 1:16:56Yes.
- 1:16:58And from your side, it's like,
- 1:16:59so how hard are you in getting into
- 1:17:01this?
- 1:17:03And so even for your business practices,
- 1:17:05what is your measure of success?
- 1:17:07Well, we wanted to deliver you...
- 1:17:09a AI institution, you know,
- 1:17:11an AI media lab that will be better
- 1:17:14for students.
- 1:17:15Well, how did you define better?
- 1:17:17Did you reach your outcomes?
- 1:17:19How do you make sure that or do
- 1:17:20you even care?
- 1:17:21But
- 1:17:23The check cleared, cared.
- 1:17:24Yay!
- 1:17:26But no, I'm being mean to you.
- 1:17:29I'm being mean to you right now,
- 1:17:30but that's sometimes how we feel.
- 1:17:31No, you're talking like a researcher,
- 1:17:33and I think you're sharing some of the
- 1:17:35same questions that I have internally,
- 1:17:36too.
- 1:17:37Like,
- 1:17:38how do we know if we delivered on
- 1:17:42our promise?
- 1:17:43How do we know that we are elevating
- 1:17:44the human experience?
- 1:17:45That's the... That's hard.
- 1:17:48And for us... Yeah, go ahead.
- 1:17:51Yeah, I interrupted you too.
- 1:17:51No, you're good.
- 1:17:52And for us,
- 1:17:53that question also sits there too,
- 1:17:54because in the back of our minds, like,
- 1:17:55what do you give a flying rip?
- 1:17:58Oh, Jamie about said something there.
- 1:18:00I almost did.
- 1:18:00Yeah, you did.
- 1:18:01I saw it.
- 1:18:02These are all marked as explicit.
- 1:18:04Go ahead.
- 1:18:06Yeah, but why would you care?
- 1:18:08Like I said, again, really mean, check,
- 1:18:11clear, we're good.
- 1:18:13And sometimes to architectural groups and
- 1:18:16universities,
- 1:18:18that's a longstanding relationship,
- 1:18:21and you're going to get the next job
- 1:18:22anyway.
- 1:18:23No, not necessarily.
- 1:18:26I said some,
- 1:18:28but typically when you see this,
- 1:18:29you see the same relationship again and
- 1:18:32again and again and again.
- 1:18:34Um,
- 1:18:35and so these are things that also that
- 1:18:37come into play when we start talking to
- 1:18:39each other is okay.
- 1:18:41We want you to hold us accountable up
- 1:18:43front.
- 1:18:44Be like, if we're going to be successful,
- 1:18:45you need to be there.
- 1:18:47And on the reverse side,
- 1:18:48we need to be able to say, well,
- 1:18:48we were there to make you, you know,
- 1:18:52we're going to be successful,
- 1:18:53successful together.
- 1:18:56All right, Jamie,
- 1:18:58I've got a couple answers to your
- 1:18:59question.
- 1:18:59Do I have a question?
- 1:19:00I just ramble.
- 1:19:00Well, I,
- 1:19:03I see what you're...
- 1:19:04I feel like a lot of you do
- 1:19:05care.
- 1:19:06I'm being generalist and very...
- 1:19:10uh bad words he's been burnt maybe once
- 1:19:14hear the frustration again Jamie I'm not
- 1:19:15your psychologist like we could talk a
- 1:19:17little bit more about why you're so hurt
- 1:19:20by Arkansas that's a different podcast I
- 1:19:22know genuinely we first of all we don't
- 1:19:25automatically get the next project
- 1:19:27especially if it's with a public
- 1:19:29institution they have to bid it out um
- 1:19:31obviously the relationship helps
- 1:19:33From the business standpoint,
- 1:19:35there is a lot of value in us
- 1:19:37being able on the next project,
- 1:19:39whether it's for the same client or a
- 1:19:40different client, to be able to say, hey,
- 1:19:44we delivered this academic building with
- 1:19:47the intent of increasing enrollment,
- 1:19:49doubling the number of butts in seats and
- 1:19:52improving
- 1:19:54retention outcomes, whatever it is,
- 1:19:56here are the design strategies that we
- 1:19:58implemented,
- 1:19:59and how that is tied to those specific
- 1:20:01outcomes,
- 1:20:01there is a lot of business value in
- 1:20:04our being able to do that and tell
- 1:20:05that story.
- 1:20:07See, on the business see that posted,
- 1:20:10but we don't necessarily see that in
- 1:20:12reality.
- 1:20:14I think that's true.
- 1:20:15I think that's a very fair assessment in
- 1:20:17general of where the architecture industry
- 1:20:19is.
- 1:20:19If you went to any architecture and design
- 1:20:21conference right now,
- 1:20:22you'd hear a lot of people talking about
- 1:20:24the value of post-occupancy evaluations
- 1:20:26and how everyone should do them.
- 1:20:28But in the same way that we were
- 1:20:30discussing who pays for any of the
- 1:20:33projects on campus,
- 1:20:34who pays for a post-occupancy evaluation?
- 1:20:36Shouldn't your university also want to
- 1:20:38know?
- 1:20:39yeah absolutely and the timing of that is
- 1:20:42critical because if you do that three to
- 1:20:44six months after the building's built your
- 1:20:47data is not going to be any good
- 1:20:48no you need to do it if you
- 1:20:50do it
- 1:20:51At least one to two years.
- 1:20:53Yep.
- 1:20:54We like to target that like twelve to
- 1:20:56eighteen months.
- 1:20:57You've settled in.
- 1:20:58The kinks are kind of worked out.
- 1:21:00You've had a chance to make the operations
- 1:21:02match the design intent.
- 1:21:04But that's where, Mark,
- 1:21:05you started by saying we need to iterate
- 1:21:07more.
- 1:21:08A post occupancy evaluation is really the
- 1:21:10only way we get an objective opportunity
- 1:21:13to say, hey,
- 1:21:15we intended the design to operate this way
- 1:21:17and it's not.
- 1:21:18So let's make your investment work better
- 1:21:20for you.
- 1:21:20And we also have to base this on
- 1:21:22student outcomes.
- 1:21:23And those student outcomes have to be
- 1:21:25completed each semester.
- 1:21:27So you probably need to wait two semesters
- 1:21:30to evaluate and aggregate all that data
- 1:21:33from the students.
- 1:21:33Especially if curriculum is changing
- 1:21:34because you've got a new space, right?
- 1:21:37And that's the variable that we haven't
- 1:21:38talked about in this
- 1:21:41I accidentally got us off what we wanted
- 1:21:45to talk about.
- 1:21:45Jamie's rambling again.
- 1:21:47I really do think this is another show.
- 1:21:50I'm sorry.
- 1:21:51I didn't mean to.
- 1:21:53How do we measure success?
- 1:21:54Well,
- 1:21:55unless the instructional design team is
- 1:21:57there at the beginning as well,
- 1:22:00then our success is determined by how well
- 1:22:03the instruction is happening in the room.
- 1:22:07A lot of this is when you talk
- 1:22:09about if you build a building right now,
- 1:22:11the only things we're measuring on are our
- 1:22:13current capabilities.
- 1:22:14So we have curriculum, we have syllabus.
- 1:22:16And how do we do that?
- 1:22:16Well, we're kind of doing that.
- 1:22:18So if we're measuring based on what we're
- 1:22:19already doing,
- 1:22:20doesn't really do us any good.
- 1:22:21So how are we cataloging the things we
- 1:22:23want to be able to do?
- 1:22:25And so you have to be able to
- 1:22:26give enough on-ramp to say, yes,
- 1:22:28we knew we only had this piece and
- 1:22:30these instructors and these champions that
- 1:22:31were doing these things and these very
- 1:22:33innovative approaches.
- 1:22:34We had to move into the building.
- 1:22:35But now once we have that capability and
- 1:22:37we know we can do it,
- 1:22:38it's given us the ability to change,
- 1:22:40to pull this thing from our catalog that
- 1:22:42we wanted to be able to do.
- 1:22:43Now we can do it.
- 1:22:44So what additional capabilities do we now
- 1:22:47have
- 1:22:47today that we didn't have at the onset
- 1:22:49of this design and i think it's hard
- 1:22:51to get to that and it's it's a
- 1:22:54really rough road to travel to say well
- 1:22:56i just need a space i can do
- 1:22:57all these whiz-bang things but i don't
- 1:22:59really know what it looks like because i
- 1:23:00haven't done it yet right and so you're
- 1:23:02you're trying to like forecast that
- 1:23:04hurricane to say okay well let's let's try
- 1:23:06to land this somewhere where we can at
- 1:23:07least be able to do that if an
- 1:23:09instructor says yes
- 1:23:11This worked,
- 1:23:12and I was able to think differently on
- 1:23:13how I delivered this,
- 1:23:14how my students were engaged.
- 1:23:15I have amazing feedback from my students
- 1:23:17on how I'm actually performing in here and
- 1:23:19what they're getting from me.
- 1:23:21Those are the key words.
- 1:23:22So what is the language of success?
- 1:23:24How do we even ask those types of
- 1:23:25questions?
- 1:23:27Not just, can it fit forty people?
- 1:23:28Well, of course it can.
- 1:23:30Do the chairs move?
- 1:23:31Well, yeah.
- 1:23:31It's a concrete floor and they have wheels
- 1:23:32on them.
- 1:23:33Great.
- 1:23:33Yeah.
- 1:23:33Was the building successful?
- 1:23:34And is that any different than what we
- 1:23:36did before?
- 1:23:37Right.
- 1:23:38Right.
- 1:23:38But what is it?
- 1:23:40The nuances in how we ask those questions
- 1:23:42to get that feedback to know if we
- 1:23:43were successful or not.
- 1:23:44And are we...
- 1:23:46now we're now we're in a whole like
- 1:23:47survey language and like all these pieces
- 1:23:49oh you want to talk research yeah we're
- 1:23:50not going to go into that but kind
- 1:23:52of going back to okay that experience
- 1:23:55designing around that where does that meet
- 1:23:57kind of where our subject matter expertise
- 1:23:59are like how can we contribute to this
- 1:24:00how do we look at this like if
- 1:24:02i was going to do this black box
- 1:24:04thing that justin has what would i
- 1:24:07forecast that i need not today ten years
- 1:24:10from now
- 1:24:11Right?
- 1:24:12I think we talked offline about this.
- 1:24:13It's like,
- 1:24:13we probably all agree that flexible
- 1:24:15infrastructure, going away from like,
- 1:24:18rigid, fancy looking things,
- 1:24:19maybe it's not all concrete, all glass,
- 1:24:20but how do we intentionally design for
- 1:24:23what we don't know?
- 1:24:23Hmm.
- 1:24:25What does the space need to do that
- 1:24:26I cannot define today?
- 1:24:27What is that language?
- 1:24:29I've had pushback from from architectural
- 1:24:31firms in the V phase.
- 1:24:33Well,
- 1:24:33I can't give you this conduit or that
- 1:24:34because you can't define what's in there.
- 1:24:35I'm like, well,
- 1:24:36just put a string in it.
- 1:24:37I don't care.
- 1:24:37Put something in there.
- 1:24:38So it works on your rev.
- 1:24:39It's fine.
- 1:24:40But intentionally saying no,
- 1:24:42that is a future piece.
- 1:24:44And I can't tell you what it is
- 1:24:45today.
- 1:24:45But I need you to capture that I
- 1:24:46need you to actually really,
- 1:24:48really be on my side and facilitate that
- 1:24:50and make sure you're stewarding this need
- 1:24:52for the future today.
- 1:24:57Mark,
- 1:24:57I'm going to just capture that and give
- 1:25:00it to our design teams in our visioning
- 1:25:02sessions.
- 1:25:03There you go.
- 1:25:04That we need to be okay with the
- 1:25:06abstract and... Ambiguity.
- 1:25:10The ambiguity.
- 1:25:10It's not perfect.
- 1:25:11Yeah, exactly.
- 1:25:12But let it not be perfect.
- 1:25:14Yeah.
- 1:25:15And let the design process not have to
- 1:25:18look like the design process from
- 1:25:19yesterday.
- 1:25:23That's it.
- 1:25:23We got there.
- 1:25:24OK.
- 1:25:26But I think we do need to bring
- 1:25:27you back, Katie.
- 1:25:28On that note.
- 1:25:28I think there's too much ground to cover.
- 1:25:31And I don't know.
- 1:25:33It's been awesome.
- 1:25:35I'm looking forward to going through some
- 1:25:36of those additional charrettes you have
- 1:25:38moving forward,
- 1:25:38because I think the conversation is well
- 1:25:40warranted.
- 1:25:41And higher education is changing.
- 1:25:43Our spaces look different.
- 1:25:43Our students look different.
- 1:25:44We will look different.
- 1:25:46And AI is definitely going to be a
- 1:25:47catalyst in that.
- 1:25:48You, Justin,
- 1:25:49are probably going to look the most
- 1:25:50different.
- 1:25:50We've seen you in AI.
- 1:25:50I was really wanting to try to get
- 1:25:51a haircut,
- 1:25:52but I'm going to look the same as
- 1:25:54I did yesterday.
- 1:25:56We can do an AI haircut if you
- 1:25:58need it.
- 1:25:58We can do that.
- 1:26:00Larry's got a new set of Clippers he
- 1:26:01got from CBS.
- 1:26:01That's right.
- 1:26:03Oh, yes, I did.
- 1:26:04AI Clippers.
- 1:26:05The AI Clippers.
- 1:26:07Katie,
- 1:26:08if people listen to this nonsense and all
- 1:26:10this ground we covered today,
- 1:26:11and you're like, you know what, Katie,
- 1:26:13I need to reach out and talk to
- 1:26:15her.
- 1:26:15How can they go about getting a hold
- 1:26:16of you?
- 1:26:17I would love for you to reach out.
- 1:26:20You can reach out via LinkedIn,
- 1:26:22or you can learn a little bit more
- 1:26:24about our evolution of campus work that
- 1:26:26Mark has been involved in so far.
- 1:26:28I think if you've gotten to this point
- 1:26:30and you're still listening,
- 1:26:31you'd probably be interested in both
- 1:26:33um our current evolution of campus we're
- 1:26:35calling it our six point oh effort around
- 1:26:38ai skills and how it changes the learning
- 1:26:40environment but also our our previously
- 1:26:42published five point oh effort which is
- 1:26:45available online if you just look at
- 1:26:47evolution of campus dlr group which
- 1:26:49pertains entirely to the first half of
- 1:26:51this conversation about getting data to
- 1:26:53talk to each other putting it in the
- 1:26:55right place and actually making use of it
- 1:26:57beyond automation
- 1:26:59So we're taking two different looks at the
- 1:27:01way AI supports campuses.
- 1:27:03And I'm pretty stoked we could happen to
- 1:27:05cover both of them in the last hour.
- 1:27:07Hour and a half.
- 1:27:09Hour and a half?
- 1:27:10Hour and a half.
- 1:27:11This has been a long one.
- 1:27:13It seemed like, man, that went quick.
- 1:27:16Drug you through it kicking and screaming,
- 1:27:17Justin.
- 1:27:18Some of these shows, man,
- 1:27:19they seem like five hours long.
- 1:27:21It's really...
- 1:27:22It's some Fridays.
- 1:27:24But this was different.
- 1:27:26This one invokes passion for people.
- 1:27:29People are into this one.
- 1:27:30So it's one of those things that it
- 1:27:31won't be the last time we're going to
- 1:27:32talk about it.
- 1:27:34I think we can go on all day.
- 1:27:35You bring it up every freaking week.
- 1:27:36Exactly.
- 1:27:37Self-indulgence.
- 1:27:41Chris, anything you want to add?
- 1:27:43How's Wyoming digesting this?
- 1:27:44You're all in, right?
- 1:27:45Just all goggles,
- 1:27:46all theaters of the mind.
- 1:27:48Well, I was going to say,
- 1:27:49I backed off real quick,
- 1:27:50but I waited for someone to say VR,
- 1:27:52and it took over an hour to get
- 1:27:53there.
- 1:27:53The minute that comes up in the
- 1:27:54conversation, I tune that off,
- 1:27:57because VR is not an answer to anything.
- 1:27:59I don't need to do the rant now,
- 1:28:01but VR has not moved forward one iota
- 1:28:04since Nineteen Eighty-Four,
- 1:28:06so we don't need that as a solution.
- 1:28:07We're doing it.
- 1:28:08So, yeah.
- 1:28:08Anyway.
- 1:28:09Critical technology we need.
- 1:28:11No,
- 1:28:11we're building lots of flexible learning
- 1:28:13spaces with no power in the room.
- 1:28:14That's our newest thing.
- 1:28:15Powerless.
- 1:28:16Lots of student tables, flexible seating,
- 1:28:18but no place to plug in your stuff.
- 1:28:21No.
- 1:28:21It's interesting from like a digital detox
- 1:28:23perspective.
- 1:28:25Oh, no, no.
- 1:28:25What happens is the students are very good
- 1:28:30at finding power.
- 1:28:31And so they show up with their own
- 1:28:32power strips and cables.
- 1:28:33No, seriously.
- 1:28:34There's crap all over the floor.
- 1:28:36They walk in with just cables strapped
- 1:28:37around them.
- 1:28:38It's a philosophy class.
- 1:28:40It's mostly philosophy.
- 1:28:41We have one outlet,
- 1:28:42and then here's a couple extension cords
- 1:28:44and a couple... It's like a...
- 1:28:47Studying the Lord of the Flies.
- 1:28:48How do they go about getting access to
- 1:28:50this technology so they can share?
- 1:28:51We're not.
- 1:28:53Those TikToks aren't looking at
- 1:28:54themselves.
- 1:28:58Well, Chris,
- 1:28:59you want to get us out of here?
- 1:29:00Some level.
- 1:29:01All right.
- 1:29:02Katie, been a blast having you here.
- 1:29:03We'll be back next week with more
- 1:29:04nonsense.
- 1:29:05Come back.
- 1:29:05Thanks, Katie.
- 1:29:06This is, again.
- 1:29:08This was awesome.
- 1:29:09Thanks, guys.
- 1:29:10Thank you.
- 1:29:16Well,
- 1:29:16we've managed to ruin yet another episode
- 1:29:18of AV Superfriends Off the Rails.
- 1:29:20You can contact us with questions,
- 1:29:22topic ideas,
- 1:29:22or general complaints at mailbag at
- 1:29:24avsuperfriends.com.
- 1:29:26If you complain loud enough,
- 1:29:27we might just invite you on the show.
- 1:29:32Nice work, everyone.
- 1:29:34Sharp broadcast.
- 1:29:35Really good.
- 1:29:36Everyone on the floor as well.
- 1:29:38Really a lot of hustle.
- 1:29:38I liked it.
- 1:29:40The opinions expressed by the AV
- 1:29:41Superfriends are solely those of the
- 1:29:42individuals and do not represent their
- 1:29:44respective institutions, organizations,
- 1:29:46companies, or clients.