Latest / Newcomer Pod / The Rug Pull Really Tied the Room Together
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome Sally. Hey everybody.
- 0:14Welcome to this week's episode of dead cat.
- 0:16It's me, Tom here joined by Eric.
- 0:18And we have as our special guest, Jacob Silverman,
- 0:21journalist of many, many topics within Tech.
- 0:24Although has been spending a lot of his time in the past couple
- 0:28years. How long has your ear?
- 0:30Tiptoe Fascination lasted. Jacob, let's see.
- 0:32It really started at the very end of 2020.
- 0:36So yeah. So about a year, a year and a
- 0:38half. Maybe.
- 0:39Okay. Okay.
- 0:39I'm relatively new as far as sort of The Scene goes right.
- 0:43But outspoken as a crypto critic and yeah I've kind of sight
- 0:47without no coin do that? Yeah yeah the gloves off a
- 0:51little bit. Yeah okay yeah so this is going
- 0:54to be a crypto episode to all those who have been paying
- 0:56attention to the brutal and Really bad crypto markets that
- 1:02have crashed. Not only in tandem with the
- 1:04equity markets but far far worse, Bitcoins down 37 percent.
- 1:09Year-to-date Luna, obviously collapsed.
- 1:13What's the theory am? I don't know was trying to?
- 1:15Yeah, everything's down, everything's down, down in a big
- 1:18way. And Jacob is obviously great to
- 1:20talk to you about this because, you know, obviously he's been
- 1:23into it and writing about it over the last year or so.
- 1:25But also you are working on an upcoming book with If Ben
- 1:30McKenzie. Yeah that Ben McKenzie.
- 1:32Ryan Atwood of OC Fame who is also probably the most prominent
- 1:37crypto critic out there these days you guys think up what's
- 1:40the backstory? There he it was actually a
- 1:43pretty pretty basic meet-cute. I guess he likes something.
- 1:49I wrote for the new Republic about Bitcoin basically being a
- 1:52scam and he DM me and then we both live in Brooklyn.
- 1:57So we went and had beers and burgers.
- 1:59And talked about crypto and he had fallen down the rabbit hole
- 2:03to at that point of the sort of critics Rabbit Hole.
- 2:05Like I fully admit much to the Chagrin of people in my life
- 2:09that I am obsessed. But, you know, I'm obsessed from
- 2:12this angle of kind of Fraud and and the absurdity of it and the
- 2:17characters involved and how could this all be happening?
- 2:19So much out in the open, right? So been kind of while I've been
- 2:23writing a bit about crypto intermittently.
- 2:25It wasn't totally my beep, a been had some time on his hands
- 2:29because Hollywood is So the shutdown, during the pandemic
- 2:31and that's how he first fell down the rabbit hole and then
- 2:34wrote me in. Right?
- 2:35Got it. And I guess we should lay out at
- 2:37the outset here, because we've talked about crypto on this show
- 2:41before we probably run the gamut, I mean Eric you're
- 2:45probably going to be on the moon, the more defensive side.
- 2:48I imagine why I was going to point out the convenient thing
- 2:51about starting to cover crypto in 2020 is you have not had to
- 2:55apologize for past Cycles where everybody took a Victory lap.
- 3:00And said this crypto thing is like a scam and then it comes
- 3:04roaring back better than ever. And then you're sort of like,
- 3:06well, it's a really it's a better scam, right guys?
- 3:10Jacob, his head. Jacob has had.
- 3:12So little time having fun. Be my position is always just
- 3:15been people have made so much money on it, like it's real.
- 3:18In that sense, I sort of wanted to throw out the question.
- 3:21Like, if you pull off a Bernie Madoff, and never go to jail,
- 3:25isn't that a success? You know what I mean?
- 3:28It's like, yeah, yeah. Yeah, I mean I honestly, I think
- 3:31that's the attitude in some ways for people within the industry.
- 3:35I mean, you hear a lot of talk about Ponzi schemes and maybe
- 3:37about that sort of Ponzi, economics, not being that bad
- 3:40necessarily. I argue that there's been almost
- 3:43a rehabilitation of the Ponzi scheme.
- 3:44So I mean, just to take Madoff. As example, he was one of the
- 3:49most successful investors on Wall Street for years.
- 3:53So, in a sense, he succeed for a long time.
- 3:55And one thing you learn is that sometimes it's not necessarily
- 3:59the Tons of a Ponzi scheme or law enforcement, that ends the
- 4:03Ponzi scheme or the scam. It can be outside forces like
- 4:07like the recession or often not being.
- 4:09When's for the bill comes due a recession hits, a your customers
- 4:13want to want to cash out suddenly you can't pay them all.
- 4:16That's I think a common way, some of these scams fail, but
- 4:19even just to bring it back to this week, the whole Tara and
- 4:24Luna thing. I mean, a lot of people thought
- 4:27that was a Ponzi scheme even supporters of Upon the same but
- 4:30there's this there's this sense that it could just be a Ponzi
- 4:34until maybe it was somehow legitimized whether it was the
- 4:3810 million dollars plus worth of bitcoin.
- 4:40Backing that do Quan was trying to build up.
- 4:42I mean he basically said that that was the defensive mechanism
- 4:45to keep this whole thing going, right?
- 4:47Well there was that interview with Sam Bank been freed right
- 4:50where he seemed to sort of admit upon Z ish level of to some of
- 4:57these projects and then you see the crypto people No, this world
- 5:00so much better than I do but like they talk about like dgeni
- 5:03boxes all the time or there's just this idea that it's like
- 5:06yeah it's like a magic box and produces money that's like
- 5:09probably broken but like yeah I'm gonna make money off the Box
- 5:13while it's working. Yeah.
- 5:15That seems to be the sort of the latest term or framing for some
- 5:17of these D5 pools and protocols and stuff like that.
- 5:21I mean the it would be, it's pretty complicated describe what
- 5:26just happened with Tara and Luna.
- 5:28I'm not sure if I even fully. I understand it really but you
- 5:31know but basically it was a way of creating a stable coin a coin
- 5:36that has a value pegged at a dollar of which there are a
- 5:39number now of serving varying trustworthiness.
- 5:43But that's how defy runs these days is on stable coins and you
- 5:46stick them in you cut you stake them or you stick them in the
- 5:48magic box. This is the the simplified
- 5:51version and then you get insane. Interest rates.
- 5:54So, in the the Tara Luna ecosystem, if you put your you
- 5:59were the Taking pool was through something called anchor, and
- 6:02there, you were getting like, you know, I actually don't know
- 6:05what the anchor rates were recently.
- 6:06But you know, these are double digit rates and some of them are
- 6:09promising. 70%, not necessarily an anchor, but some of these
- 6:12other defy. Yeah.
- 6:13That was like nineteen percent at one point.
- 6:15Yeah, they certainly fluctuate. But like, you know, you're not
- 6:17going to get a more than single digits, from a regular bank.
- 6:21So obviously they're promising, these improbable returns.
- 6:24I think it's gotten to the point where even someone like SPF has
- 6:27to admit same Band free. Yeah, I'm Sorry that's that's
- 6:30you know those of us in the know.
- 6:31Yeah we vote we both Pretend This podcast is super inside
- 6:34hurry but then try to bring people along and again some
- 6:37balancing. Please steer me away from jargon
- 6:39or her tummy to explain some other funny thing here is we've
- 6:42launched so far into this immediately.
- 6:45We didn't even really defined to a degree.
- 6:47How a stable coin works. And I mean to me that is
- 6:51probably been the biggest story of the last couple of days as
- 6:53the collapse of Luna and Tara and you sort of say that, you
- 6:56know, it's pegged to the dollar, but can you explain just
- 6:59Manically, how that's supposed to work, and why, you know, for
- 7:03whatever reason, the structure that was put in place to ensure
- 7:06stability. Clearly just collapsed.
- 7:09Yeah. So there are a number of stable
- 7:12coins in the crypto economy. They're actually, if you look at
- 7:16the top 10 coins by market cap, several of them are stable coins
- 7:19because they've become very useful.
- 7:21So the most there's about 150 billion dollars worth of stable
- 7:24coins out there. These are all ones worth, at
- 7:27least. In this case, we're time at ones
- 7:28that are pegged to the dollar their ones.
- 7:29They're Peg to other currencies, but the most popular ones are
- 7:32pegged to the dollar. So tethers, the most popular.
- 7:34One also, sort of the most hazardous, the one, if that goes
- 7:38down some people really do think the economy will like, oh, yeah,
- 7:42and tethers considered disreputable and number of ways,
- 7:44they're good articles out there and Bloomberg.
- 7:46I've written a couple pieces that sort of sort of explainer
- 7:48type pieces, but there's been some good investigatory uses.
- 7:52Definitely other shoes could drop, you know, worthy attention
- 7:56to the stable coin thing because the Lunas thing isn't some
- 7:59Oddity. Their You're stable prices, that
- 8:01are so when people take to the Dollar, by the way, that
- 8:03essentially means that the value of a single coin, should not
- 8:06fall below the value US dollar. So, with most of these, like the
- 8:10biggest ones are tether and USD, see what the idea is that when
- 8:15you can buy them on exchanges from the exchange or or from
- 8:19perhaps other Traders but you know, when an institution or a
- 8:22big client goes to tether or USD, see the idea is I give you
- 8:26a hundred million dollars. You give me 100 million ten.
- 8:29Others, you know, 121 and the idea is also supposed to be that
- 8:33tether has won 2-1 backing in the bank.
- 8:36So in case there's a bank run or people want to redeem their
- 8:38tethers, they have that cash in the bank and there are there
- 8:42more than 83 billion dollars worth of tether in circulation.
- 8:46Now, the Wily, it's not even really controversial at this
- 8:48point. I mean, it's been discovered
- 8:50through some government investigations is that tether is
- 8:53not one-to-one backed. And they've also changed their
- 8:56essentially, their terms of service over the years to kind
- 8:59of The first they said they're 11 back by dollars and then it
- 9:02was sort of dollars and dollars equivalents.
- 9:04Now, it seems to be anything goes.
- 9:07There's also a wide belief that some of these which essentially
- 9:09means that they're the claim that they had.
- 9:11That there were Banks willing to redeem your your coin for
- 9:17similar amount in dollars. They just didn't have those
- 9:19contracts or the bank's just weren't willing to do that.
- 9:22Yeah, well tether has had a lot of problems with banking, you
- 9:26know some of these some of these other firms like USD, see have
- 9:29had more success. Cecil Bank relationships.
- 9:30I mean, people in crypto will tell you well this is a problem
- 9:33of the federal government of the industry making hard for crypto
- 9:35to bank. But tether has basically like a
- 9:39lot of crypto companies, moved offshore most of their banking.
- 9:42As far as I know, is done through a bank called deltek and
- 9:45the Bahamas. So there's there's a belief that
- 9:47this Bank deltek holds most of tethers money, but as you're
- 9:52getting at, it's not 83 billion dollars, it's far less, we know
- 9:56that tether holds a lot of commercial paper, which is a
- 9:58type of sort of Short-term corporate debt, which is what
- 10:02scares the shit out of everyone use.
- 10:03If they dump all that, all of a sudden, it could mess with the
- 10:05economy exact and the paper is believed to be very low-grade,
- 10:10sort of, you know, like C grade debt or whatever the equivalent
- 10:13might be. And also from what I've been
- 10:15told a lot of it probably is of Chinese companies.
- 10:18And right there was all this paranoia that like the Chinese
- 10:21like you know all those empty apartments or whatever in China
- 10:24or like tether was sort of behind some of the crazy stuff
- 10:28going on there and Andy Even if Taylor isn't deeply connected to
- 10:31like ever Grande or one of those huge Chinese developers, they
- 10:33still have, we know they have some Chinese debt.
- 10:36So, like, the Chinese property market and economy in general,
- 10:39been struggling in last 6 Plus months.
- 10:41So I mean, that could be one shoe to fall if or one Catalyst
- 10:46if the stuff all does fall apart again.
- 10:48But so the reason why stable coins are useful basically is
- 10:51that they're easy to take between exchanges a lot, every
- 10:56cryptocurrency practically is priced in terms of Of stable
- 11:01coins. So there's like a u.s.
- 11:02DT which is tether price and so it's really easy to make these
- 11:06transactions and to shift them between exchanges, it can be
- 11:09harder to cash out. It seems as if you're doing
- 11:12everything in crypto, you're not hitting dollars which has rights
- 11:15of regular right? You don't touch Banks as much
- 11:17also as exactly. So you don't touch the
- 11:20mainstream banking system, you can keep it on the exchanges or
- 11:22even off the exchanges. And also for defy, it's
- 11:28basically based on stable coin, And basically you stake your
- 11:31tokens, you give them to some project.
- 11:33They stick them in the magic black box and then supposedly an
- 11:36incredible interest rate comes out but you might not be able to
- 11:39collect on that for a certain period of time which is why
- 11:42stable Queen collapsing is so tragic for the holders because
- 11:46it's position is like this ultimate secure thing it's it's
- 11:49like dollars with an interest rate and then all of a sudden
- 11:52you lose all your what principle basically and so it's right and
- 11:57it's dating and also sample coins.
- 12:01As per the name have been advertised as stable as a refuge
- 12:04in the everyone knows. The crypto markets are volatile.
- 12:06I mean, even crip people in crypto, may know that they're
- 12:09not trustworthy and that there's a lot of scamming going on but
- 12:13you know stable coins have been widely touted as the safe place
- 12:16for your money. I mean USD see maybe the safest
- 12:19one at this point but people have been putting a lot of their
- 12:22crypto converting it into tether into u.s.
- 12:26DC and also you know until recently in To into Terra and
- 12:31Luna. Yeah.
- 12:33It's like it's like the T note I guess of the varying various
- 12:36crypto coins. So what would you say is the
- 12:39precipitating event? That is caused the entire crypto
- 12:43sector to decline in value, as rapidly as it has.
- 12:48I mean, is it purely just the flight to secure, you know,
- 12:54interests, you know, interest back notes or things like that?
- 12:58Is it that the fear that equities Calling has just caused
- 13:01a panic, more generally, I mean, why exactly are these things
- 13:03happening in tandem? Well, I think there are a few
- 13:06factors you can point to. I mean things were on the
- 13:09decline for several months. But before this most of the, the
- 13:13currency's, especially the big ones like Bitcoin etherium reach
- 13:16their all-time highs in November.
- 13:18I believe there's also a big crash in May of last year, which
- 13:21I wrote an article about for the Washington post's with my
- 13:24co-author been. But there was a big crash in
- 13:27Bitcoin and etherium last year. In May 19th, I believe in a
- 13:31bunch of exchanges, including Finance went down, which seems
- 13:33to happen when they're big price movements like this.
- 13:36So, after May 19th last year, you started seeing a decline in,
- 13:41in trading volume among retail Traders.
- 13:45So, it seems that people are losing interest.
- 13:47There are a few theories. Peter teal said Bitcoin was
- 13:50supposed to be as valuable as the entire stock market.
- 13:53Oh yeah. He said some kinds of things
- 13:54he's like, juicing it right at the end.
- 13:57Like yeah, yeah, he's been all over the place to go.
- 13:59The calls himself a bit quite Maxi.
- 14:01But you know, we saw retail volumes going down.
- 14:03I think some people are wising up.
- 14:05Some people have less disposable income or less, maybe I think
- 14:08one thing that drives people to crypto is a sense of of
- 14:11financial desperation also because, you know, there were
- 14:14people during the recession who got their, their stimulus checks
- 14:18modest as they were, and then probably put that in a coinbase
- 14:21account or something like that. So I think there is a degree of
- 14:24people not having as much money to sort of risk or play around
- 14:26with, but also some wising up, then there are other more.
- 14:29Or systemic factors the raising of interest rates.
- 14:31This is something that Ben McKenzie, my co-authors been
- 14:34talking to me and other people about a lot.
- 14:36He really thought that would take some of the steam out of
- 14:38the markets and it seems to be the increasing interest rates
- 14:41trouble in China. All the, the trading being sort
- 14:45of pushed off shore though, a lot of it was being done through
- 14:48vpns anyway so all that was causing months of sliding prices
- 14:52and and generally things have been declining since November
- 14:55and then this week you have a major stable coin a top
- 14:59Cryptocurrency basically going to zero exactly how that
- 15:03happened the mechanism in which it happened is it can't actually
- 15:07be fully known at this point. I think.
- 15:09Because some people believe they're sort of an outside
- 15:11attack sort of like a George Soros have a right on the
- 15:14current having people say, oh Citadel or whatever.
- 15:16Yeah, there's that rumor going around that but like Citadel and
- 15:19BlackRock are it doesn't crash. They're like Enemy Number One
- 15:22for crypto and it's right want to be host.
- 15:24It's very convenient for that to be the answer for why they're
- 15:27yeah fail. I mean and the thing is like
- 15:29everyone thought this was probably going to fail some
- 15:31point. They just thought that they can
- 15:33keep us spinning for long and Ken Griffin or whatever is it
- 15:36can go by the Constitution, right?
- 15:42So, yeah, they've been titled by him before, you know.
- 15:46So yeah. So you know, there is certainly
- 15:48a persecution complex or sense that and, you know, if there's a
- 15:51lot of money to be made, I mean there are hedge funds involved
- 15:53or high frequency trading firms. That only do crypto, you know,
- 15:57if there's money to be made on Arbitrage between exchanges or
- 16:02trying to manipulate a protocol like like the whole Tara Luna
- 16:08anchor ecosystem, they'll go for it.
- 16:10I just we just don't have evidence that they did by one
- 16:12view of crypto. It's all in the game, like
- 16:14that's fine. You're operating on the
- 16:15protocol, you're following the rules.
- 16:17Like, if you find a way to like siphon off a lot of money, I
- 16:20mean it's been funny and I want this is tragic and Museum.
- 16:25The same time, I mean you see some of these threads and
- 16:27they're like, you know, suicide hotlines.
- 16:29Getting yeah. So I cut it on the way and some
- 16:32people were but but obviously there's sort of an intellectual
- 16:35part of it that it's very amusing and in the crypto world
- 16:39you see like the hardcore Bitcoin people being like, you
- 16:41should have never believed in these stable coins, their
- 16:44centralized project, that will require all this sort of
- 16:47administration. So it's funny to watch the
- 16:50infighting, is this stuff like? Yeah else.
- 16:52Yeah. And I think there may be more
- 16:54that I mean, there's so much rationalization that goes on
- 16:57within crypto in general. On all sides, I mean, but
- 17:01especially during these times of trauma for some folks and these
- 17:05dramatic swings in the market. I mean, of course, in the normal
- 17:08stock market, if there were 30 percent slide in a day, or a
- 17:11week for the whole Market, that would be, you know, that would
- 17:14be historic or huge problem, but in crypto is just we've seen
- 17:18before, or even, you know, you guys are referring at the I
- 17:20think at the beginning the conversation to 2017. 2018,
- 17:23there's the big Ico. Boom, then a crypto winter, you
- 17:27know, I'm more new to this but the same time, I least No, a
- 17:29little bit of that history so I'm not ready to call crypto
- 17:32dead. Even if tether collapse crypto,
- 17:34I don't think we'll be dead. You know you'll always have
- 17:37people who say we need to do a better this time or decentralize
- 17:39more offshore or they'll have people to blame but I don't
- 17:43think sort of an honest internal Reckoning is going to happen.
- 17:47Well, it seems like two things need to be reconciled here.
- 17:50There's one in which like, does the central thesis of
- 17:53cryptocurrency of a decentralized, you know,
- 17:56Financial system based on a public Ledger.
- 17:58Does that work as a Knology. And and then there's the like,
- 18:02you know, is it going to replace currency?
- 18:04Is it going to, you know, Usher in a new economy?
- 18:06And I think like one can be true with the other being false.
- 18:11You know what I mean? Like, well I guess.
- 18:12No, they both kind of the central technology has to work
- 18:15in order for the second to be true, but I'm more willing to
- 18:19believe someone who looks at the, you know who's willing to
- 18:22look at the current state of a lot of these cryptocurrencies
- 18:25and stable coins and whatever. And say, yeah, obviously this is
- 18:28a horrible time. Time.
- 18:30There have been a lot of failures are brought to this
- 18:31point, but the argument that we have as to why this works and is
- 18:35important still exists. Still Still is valid.
- 18:37Do you agree with that? I don't, but I hear that.
- 18:41I understand it. I mean I think you're right
- 18:44though to sort of get back to First principles like for
- 18:47example I mean I think Financial censorship as it's sometimes
- 18:50called is an issue. I mean, but I don't to be honest
- 18:54I don't think people necessarily should be able to transact any
- 19:00Freely with anyone without any sort of right below your every
- 19:05customer has been sort of. Yeah, Central tenant of right.
- 19:09But I think we yeah, we do need to find ways to preserve and
- 19:12even boost sort of privacy and Financial Freedom of a certain
- 19:15kind. But I do think money needs to be
- 19:19subject to political governance. Now that means something
- 19:21different here than it means in Nigeria or Lebanon or where they
- 19:25have real problems with the currencies.
- 19:28And certainly the The fed and Wall Street and Goldman Sachs
- 19:32basically running. Our monetary policy is not a
- 19:34good thing, but I do think that currency in general if it is to
- 19:39act like currency and to have the protections that currency
- 19:42should have answered and the consumer protections needs to be
- 19:45subject to some form of political governance.
- 19:48And I don't mean add a bow. That's my general philosophy.
- 19:52As for the technology. I'm glad to talk about that.
- 19:54I am certainly not an expert, but I will say this, it is more
- 19:57divisive within Tech. I think.
- 19:59And almost any technology I've seen in awhile, besides, maybe
- 20:02like facial recognition or something like that.
- 20:05And I talked to a fair number of people who are computer
- 20:08scientists, technologists, someone like Nicholas Weaver's,
- 20:11very, very prominent on Twitter voice on this.
- 20:15They just think the tech isn't very good that an immutable
- 20:19blockchain with, very slow, throughput or transaction, pace
- 20:24is not the answer to a digital money system.
- 20:27And I think in some ways, the LG has been so fetishized that the
- 20:31industry is almost stuck with it.
- 20:32That I mean there could be another way of making digital
- 20:34money without blockchain. Right.
- 20:36I mean Bitcoin is certainly not a perfect system but it's just
- 20:41sort of now like this almost historic artifact that we have.
- 20:44I mean it's somewhat random that gold is our favorite metal.
- 20:48Like sir there's underlying value but it's sort of like
- 20:50that's the one we've decided a lot of Bitcoin people aren't
- 20:53really arguing Bitcoins, some perfect thing, it's just like,
- 20:56oh that's the one, that's the oh, gee.
- 20:59One. I mean do you personally think
- 21:02Bitcoin is ever gonna like go to 0?
- 21:04I mean I mean maybe it loses value when like if the US says
- 21:08you can't have it, I find that unlikely but to me it's sort of
- 21:11like it's so far down the road that like some people will see
- 21:16it as Atkins. It's proven that it's some sort
- 21:18of store value and people can own it to.
- 21:21Yeah. I'm gonna it's an interesting
- 21:23question. I don't think it'll I probably
- 21:25don't think it'll go 0. I mean, who is seen a couple
- 21:28things go to zero. Typically this week but you
- 21:30know, Bitcoin has been around for a while since was it October
- 21:342008 or 2009? I was forget if it's 0 8 or 9.
- 21:37But so it has it has a certain amount longevity in terms of in
- 21:41Tech terms. I think crypto in general and
- 21:44certain star the crypto currencies that have followed.
- 21:46In the other block chains that have followed have have almost
- 21:50been. I don't know.
- 21:52They've had their time in a way I think.
- 21:54Like we haven't, we've had 12 plus years of this stuff and
- 21:57there's isn't really serve a Inge crypto economy, without
- 22:01these glaring, security holes and wild volatility and really
- 22:05difficulty transacting widely in those currencies.
- 22:09I do think Bitcoin especially because its first and and seen
- 22:13as rather Innovative and seen as more decentralized.
- 22:16So there are certainly people working on the Bitcoin protocol
- 22:18but I think Bitcoin would have more staying power.
- 22:22I also think Bitcoin, I mean one, this isn't a monolithic
- 22:25industry. I've learned that in the last
- 22:27year they're people who dabble there.
- 22:29People who believe all kinds of things but Bitcoin does have
- 22:32sort of the strongest or most. Yeah, perhaps the strongest
- 22:36culture, which in some forms, is a cult, I think, or an ideology.
- 22:40I mean, I don't think that's everyone who likes Bitcoin or
- 22:43invest in Bitcoin, but, you know, that core of True,
- 22:45Believers is strong. And I think that might help, you
- 22:49know, sustain it in some form for y?
- 22:51Well, I mean, a lot of them would admit the cult.
- 22:54Peace. Yeah, I talk to people, they say
- 22:55they're willing to admit that sometimes.
- 22:57Yeah. Well that I mean that becomes
- 22:58very Roll with the nft crowd as well.
- 23:01I mean it's it's not a it's not a very far jump to see the
- 23:06group's built around worshipping of you know digital artifacts
- 23:11into something that has like a religious fervor behind it.
- 23:14But I mean there's a general broader truth that that things
- 23:18are give are valuable because humans attach value to them more
- 23:23than because they produce cash flow at least in the recent
- 23:27economy now. Yeah, maybe we are.
- 23:29About to see the day where we revert to ability to produce
- 23:33cash. Flow is the main thing that
- 23:34drives the value of things. But we exited that period for a
- 23:39long time. And so if You observe that and
- 23:41realize that people are making a killing on Tesla because it was
- 23:45going up, why not abstract it a level further?
- 23:48And just say we can. Yeah, make money on monkeys or
- 23:51whatever that all. We have influence that we can
- 23:54convince people that their value.
- 23:57I mean, to some degree, their being They were being more
- 24:00honest about the economy, we were living in them.
- 24:02People who are sort of saying it wasn't going to work because it
- 24:06should the world should work on cash flows.
- 24:09But you know, was it? Yeah, I think it's interesting
- 24:11because, you know, we had maybe 20 years plus, we're, we're of
- 24:15this new digital economy. I mean, not not to reduce it too
- 24:20much or oversimplify but where there was digital abundance, you
- 24:25know, the potentially infinite abundance because any file can
- 24:28be replicated Added with perfect Fidelity easily.
- 24:31And then you had things like, DRM and other sort of systems of
- 24:33try to deal with this, with piracy infinite, abundance, and
- 24:38all that. And now this is in some ways,
- 24:41what's happening with n ftes and digital assets and stuff like
- 24:43that. And blockchain base assets is
- 24:46almost a new form of DRM, or perhaps a new way of trying to
- 24:49more thoroughly, apply meatspace property rights.
- 24:53You might call them in the digital world which in turn
- 24:55leads to the ability to produce cash flows rents royalties.
- 24:59Royalties on digital assets so you can kind of at least from
- 25:03that's how I kind of see it. Whether that's possible or can
- 25:07be, successful is another question, but I see the the sort
- 25:10of the model or the economic angle being run here.
- 25:14At least that's how it appears to me.
- 25:18Yeah, I mean the funny thing about NF TS we laugh at, they're
- 25:22the easiest to laugh at but I also think they were the
- 25:24clearest where people actually said oh maybe this is an actual
- 25:28utility of blockchain, right. I mean I do even though I'm
- 25:33probably most willing to defend all this like yeah, the the
- 25:37clear use case of blockchain in any sort of besides Financial
- 25:42speculation is remains like a total mystery and at least n FTS
- 25:46were Like okay yeah you could I mean I can see why you might
- 25:50want to own objects and games and blah blah blah but I mean
- 25:53that market I think it's howling.
- 25:55I think it's also telling that if you were to explain this
- 25:57entire world to someone the one like a regular person, the one
- 26:01that I think would have the most purchased with them that they
- 26:03would understand, would probably be n FTS, you know, just digital
- 26:06rights ownership to over digital Goods or rights ownership over
- 26:10digital Goods. That makes sense to people to a
- 26:12certain degree. Where is, you know, the full
- 26:15critique of the Capital system that, you know, crypto is
- 26:19supposed to be representative of it gets like you say.
- 26:21So abstracted that, you know, the value is truly going to be
- 26:25in the people who want to take the time to understand this and
- 26:28convince other people of it. And I think also that's why, you
- 26:32know, if people are interested in the stuff.
- 26:34I I see crypto in general, a lot, like gambling and I have no
- 26:39problem with gambling. I do it.
- 26:40Occasionally, but, you know, the general rule is gamble only as
- 26:43much as you can afford to lose and people should know the risks
- 26:46and I don't Think people know the risks very well in crypto.
- 26:49But I also think that what you're talking about with that
- 26:52explanatory and so the gambling size, one reason why I see
- 26:55crypto maybe a sting or at least becoming somewhat niche in the
- 27:00future, the other or not receiving Mass, adoption the
- 27:04other part is sure that the explanatory factor that you're
- 27:07just getting a tan which is that it's hard to explain this stuff
- 27:10to people. I mean, certainly, you know, the
- 27:12elderly people my family its kind of hopeless even if they
- 27:16have their These, which they do. But, you know, it's just, it's
- 27:19hard to explain. It's taken me a long time to
- 27:20understand how some of the stuff works, and I'm still learning
- 27:22more. And that's the difference
- 27:25between something like, uber and Facebook, which, I mean, I've
- 27:30criticized those companies plenty, but the service they
- 27:32provide is clear it passes sort of the grandma test as I've
- 27:36heard a called back in from startups years ago.
- 27:39Like you can say in a sentence or two what this thing does.
- 27:43What I think, might, what crypto might need, if it survives the
- 27:46The various hurdles that it's facing is actually start.
- 27:50Speaking of abstraction is maybe like another layer above it of
- 27:55an interface that so people don't know that they're that
- 27:58they're working with the blockchain, they don't really
- 27:59know. They're working with crypto.
- 28:01For example on you know they're all these issues on Open Sea and
- 28:05these other and ft platforms where people are sent and of
- 28:09teas that they don't want, or they click, they click the wrong
- 28:12link, and then it's over because you can't really reverse any
- 28:16decisions. Their permissions that are
- 28:17involved in things like that. If the everyday user didn't have
- 28:21to deal with sort of that technical complexity and a on a
- 28:25day-to-day level, I think that would actually solve a lot of
- 28:28the onboarding issues and also the security issues to I mean
- 28:32with that, that sort of like, a reason to have optimism, to me
- 28:35for this whole world, right? I mean to like, yeah, like
- 28:40Facebook, Twitter users don't need to understand machine,
- 28:43learning to know that the service has survived.
- 28:46Up people that they want to see, or, you know, especially take
- 28:49talk now. And yes, I totally agree with
- 28:52you that a lot of the technical stuff needs to be abstracted for
- 28:57it to work, but that's, that's why it's like, it's very
- 28:59believable to me that right now in crypto, we are in the.com
- 29:03Era, you know, like most of it's totally useless is all going to
- 29:06blow up. But like so, like Amazon and
- 29:09emerges, from the.com era, like the key, like, I just find it
- 29:14hard to believe that everyone is so attached.
- 29:17To these various ideas that like nothing good comes out of it.
- 29:21And that like in a hundred years, we don't say wow like
- 29:24that, that people don't really care that there were all these,
- 29:27like frogs and there's Jesus Christ.
- 29:29That's a long time, line to prove out.
- 29:31So sure she wasn't 20 years I think.
- 29:34Yeah. Crypto will be.
- 29:35But, I mean, yeah, that's like leads to like by next question.
- 29:39Then for both of you guys, guys, I don't have an answer to it at
- 29:42all, but like, where do you see the current state of The broader
- 29:47legitimate tech industry when it comes to continuing its
- 29:50fascination with this space, right?
- 29:52I mean, like, we all know tons of people that had really great
- 29:55jobs, at tech companies that bailed to go work at open sea or
- 30:01coinbase or any of these other companies that are predicated
- 30:04entirely on the furtherance and existence of this technology.
- 30:08So many VCS that we know have shifted their focus entirely to
- 30:12back in crypto startups. That's there that's there.
- 30:15Mo like what happens to that? Now, there's a huge amount of
- 30:19money still, like, leaning on the fact that this will persist,
- 30:23are they going to back off it like, where, where, where their
- 30:26heads at right now? I'm now I'm sure there's been
- 30:28stories written about it but what are you what are you
- 30:29Gathering? I'm not a well are could
- 30:32probably speak more towards, you know, where people's heads are
- 30:35at perhaps, but I mean, I think part of it also depends on how
- 30:39big the next crash is, whether it's the ongoing slide that or
- 30:44pseudo crash that we have going. Like does that keep going?
- 30:47I mean that notice about bankruptcy that coinbase put up.
- 30:51I mean, they say yeah, they just had to do it to fulfill some
- 30:54legal requirement. But is that a sign of things to
- 30:56come? I know you're pretty well
- 30:58cattle. I would be shocked.
- 30:59I would be surprise to you, but I mean, but I don't think that
- 31:02they happen. Yeah.
- 31:03I think there's a question of how much of this stuff sort of
- 31:05crumbles and do major companies fail.
- 31:08It's certainly possible. And then in the next couple of
- 31:10years it is interesting because as you've both got out, there is
- 31:14so much money coming. In I mean, I think Andreessen
- 31:17Horowitz is ready to pour more billions into into crypto
- 31:20startups. And you have a proliferating
- 31:23number of firms and besides the already established ones or
- 31:25Paradigm and these others and Katie Han leaving a 16z to do
- 31:29her own thing. Like there doesn't seem to be
- 31:31any lack of Capital. One question might be does
- 31:35rising interest rates cut off some of that capital or at least
- 31:38you know some of the institutional investors get a
- 31:40little more skittish and want to put their money in something
- 31:42that seems safer. So I'm of two minds.
- 31:45Like I think there's been a lot of money, putting the stuff, I
- 31:48frankly don't see as much use case.
- 31:50But there is a sense in which parts of the tech industry and
- 31:54certainly the VC industry are almost like pot committed to use
- 31:57a poker analogy. Like you know, they put a lot of
- 32:00resources into this. Some of them have probably done
- 32:02pretty well by selling tokens or whatever but you know I'm sure
- 32:06lots of people would like to see something sustainable come out
- 32:08of this, right? Yeah, I agree that there's a lot
- 32:11of money out there. I think you know, a lot of the
- 32:14firm's that We're sort of Dipping their toes in crypto or
- 32:18certainly going to get even more skittish about it.
- 32:21And I think, you know, the crypto funds will slow down the
- 32:24deployment. So it'll certainly hurt sort of
- 32:27the companies that are even more peripheral.
- 32:30But yeah, it doesn't seem like money's going to dry up
- 32:32overnight. But that was sort of true of
- 32:34the.com and 2008 crashes, where it's like, it's not like the
- 32:38money disappears right away. Because just like the nature of
- 32:41startup Investments, you know, there's still there's still like
- 32:44these funds that have been raised.
- 32:45Employees. But yeah, the valuations for
- 32:48talent is an interesting question there, too, right?
- 32:51I mean, they've been these huge Talent magnets at the major
- 32:53companies, all of these, all of these crypto companies.
- 32:56And I don't want to be too far down, like the valley mindset of
- 33:01saying like, you know, Talent is enough to create a product and a
- 33:05positive result. Like I think good ideas are
- 33:07probably more important ultimately than that, but it
- 33:11will be interesting to see if there is like a rush back to
- 33:16traditional tech companies. Buy a lot of these people that
- 33:18saw it as like a new frontier and now we're disillusioned by
- 33:21the State of Affairs and you know, that could have cascading
- 33:25impacts on the industry. Jacob, this is sort of a
- 33:28different direction but I just wanted me.
- 33:30What is your sort of moral project on it?
- 33:33Or like are you want people to be aware that this is like
- 33:37gambling or like but but are you sort of do you have this
- 33:40personal stance on? Like, I want government to ban
- 33:43XYZ or I mean, Where do you sort of see?
- 33:47You're like I don't know, the sort of ideological political
- 33:51sort of part of this intersecting with what's
- 33:53happening and therefore you having some sort of perspective
- 33:56on sure what should happen if the usage of Ponzi scheme is
- 34:00like a pretty loaded. Moral term like those are
- 34:02illegal. Well, they are at the same time
- 34:06you see it being used sometimes by people within the industry.
- 34:09I mean, I would say that it's like, you know, I don't
- 34:12necessarily think people should be bad.
- 34:13Scheme is typically like not a word association.
- 34:15Date with that security man. Defensive is it creates a bond
- 34:18co-produced bonds that throwing her out.
- 34:20Anyway you know I do think that you know, I'm trying to talk to
- 34:25as many people as I can from all facets of the industry and also
- 34:28just everyday folks who trade and stuff like that.
- 34:31So I managed to talk to some folks who are true believers who
- 34:35are Executives at crypto companies, people like that and
- 34:37then a lot of Skeptics like me or or outright critics, a few
- 34:41things that I think could help. I would I prefer to The more
- 34:46sort of guardrails introduced to the system rather than it being
- 34:50just you know, smashed at a smashed wholesale a necessarily
- 34:54but I think that most cryptocurrencies should be a,
- 34:58most token should be treated Securities.
- 35:00I'm not an expert in Securities Law but from what I understand
- 35:03they seem to pass the Howey test which is sort of the standard
- 35:06for whether these should be treated as Securities.
- 35:08I mean, the SEC has done a little bit of this and some of
- 35:11their enforcement. You have, you have the other
- 35:13issue with Bitcoin being officially classified.
- 35:15As a commodity, I believe through the cftc.
- 35:18But in general, I think these are securities and I think the
- 35:21SEC has a lot of authority to do some things now that would make
- 35:27for safer, retail environment for consumers.
- 35:30So I do try to approach this mostly from a consumer
- 35:32protection standpoint. I think, I mean, I, I'm a person
- 35:36of the left, I think. That's so when my sort of left
- 35:39the politics come in, I would say, it's when I hear people
- 35:43from crypto companies, saying, we are, Loading Financial
- 35:46inclusion or word-for-word democratizing, the economy or,
- 35:50you know, those sort of the fact that idea that crypto somehow
- 35:53emancipatory or Liberatore, I think Financial Freedom is a
- 35:56real thing. But I think like, for me I would
- 35:59have and I don't claim to speak for everyone but I would have my
- 36:02more Financial Freedom. If I had universal healthcare,
- 36:05you know if I had if I perhaps had postal access to postal
- 36:09banking or a local credit union or something like that, like the
- 36:12things that would if I had stayed Sighs childcare.
- 36:16Like, that would offer me a lot more Financial Freedom than
- 36:18opportunity to speculate on wildly, volatile
- 36:21cryptocurrencies. I mean, so, I think about in
- 36:24some ways like that, like what should the government?
- 36:26What should the government's role be in?
- 36:28Sort of providing for people's Economic Opportunity and
- 36:31freedom? And I don't think that
- 36:33cryptocurrencies necessarily enhance that project, the the
- 36:37SEC and the federal government's are regulation of crypto.
- 36:41I find it extremely disillusion until like the Democratic
- 36:47project to me. It is done a poor job of it,
- 36:49that's for sure. It is similar to the scc's
- 36:52failure, to hold Elon Musk accountable to any of its own
- 36:56rules, or just sort of like, you know, the fact that California
- 37:00and New York are like democratic-controlled States and
- 37:03fail to like adhere to, like, sort of the liberal utopian like
- 37:07Vision that they would promote. So to me, I don't know, all this
- 37:10stuff makes me, you know, as sort of a die-hard Democrats
- 37:13somewhat disillusioned With the left given that they it's like
- 37:17you have to act in a like technology moves quickly.
- 37:21Like I feel like I on the one hand appreciate that, like, I
- 37:26don't have full conclusions about crypto so I wouldn't if I
- 37:29were in charge just be banning things left and right, but but
- 37:33not taking action is is a policy decision.
- 37:36You're basically like letting it happen and sort of yielding sort
- 37:40of any sense of control over over what happened.
- 37:43So those are like, the Sloan This has been an embarrassment
- 37:47for the Democratic idea of govern, but you've also seen the
- 37:49ability of regulatory bodies to when they make strong moves to
- 37:55have cute effect. I mean, I think about what they
- 37:57did with spax in the last couple of months like by raising the
- 38:01requirements and stopping companies from making on, you
- 38:04know, Anjali a basic rejection, this packs, get out first.
- 38:07Yeah, we're late. Why there's no question that
- 38:10like the window? Yeah, there's this big appetite
- 38:12for speculative companies. You know, we're going to let
- 38:14them all. I basically get out and then
- 38:17right, we're going to say, you know, like no more like it was
- 38:21obvious from the beginning that the projections is you should
- 38:24have like on the first day they could have said, oh you can't
- 38:27just like give wild projections because you're doing this weird
- 38:30loophole trick like it was self-evident.
- 38:33I don't know why that I, you know, I reported on him for a
- 38:35couple days and I like wrote that, I don't know what, why?
- 38:39It takes like months and yeah, there's no points for What's
- 38:42Happening Here, Right? My point was just that like and
- 38:46They can decision. They can do it, they have the
- 38:48ability, they shut down the telegram Ico and now that was a
- 38:52big one. Yeah.
- 38:53Right II. Hear different things.
- 38:55I mean I have a lot of frustrations and yeah, this is,
- 38:59I mean, certainly bipartisan problem.
- 39:00I mean, I also when I raise this stuff people in crypto or like
- 39:04what about Nancy Pelosi profiting off of insider trading
- 39:07and I'm like, yeah, that's horrible.
- 39:08Like I'm disgusted by that. That's an argument.
- 39:11That's a, we get off on a lot of tangents about like.
- 39:14Well Wall Street does x y z. Yeah.
- 39:15Well that does a lot of horrible things.
- 39:17I don't think cryptos necessarily response to those.
- 39:19But as for the SEC, I think, you know, there's a problem of lack
- 39:24of political will they don't want to be seen as popping the
- 39:27bubble? They don't want to be seen as
- 39:28anti Innovation, some of these cases may take a while but there
- 39:33also is just a question of why? Why is it more being done?
- 39:36Gary Gensler talks a big game at times.
- 39:39He's like an expert in crypto. Yeah he taught a course at MIT
- 39:43on blockchain. He knows this stuff.
- 39:45I mean yeah, he's a golden guy. So you have to keep one eye open
- 39:49for that. But, you know, I've talked to
- 39:51people in in sort of, I guess you'd say, state law enforcement
- 39:54or state regulatory bodies who are baffled that more isn't
- 39:59being done on the federal level but they've some of them have
- 40:02sent information to the SEC, huge files with the essential
- 40:08Parts marked and still you don't have.
- 40:12I mean that's easy, doesn't do criminal prosecutions but some
- 40:14of the stuff is going to the doj Oh in like, you know, the summer
- 40:17of 2021. There was an article in
- 40:19Bloomberg saying tether under federal investigation for bank,
- 40:23for criminal bank fraud, which is which if you read the reports
- 40:27from the New York Ag and the cftc into tether, they probably
- 40:30committed bank fraud. So there's a lot of questions.
- 40:34I think, you know, it goes back to some of those things I just
- 40:36said, but it is a failure of sort of the administrative and
- 40:39Regulatory state, right? And the judicial process that we
- 40:43don't prosecute any form of White Collar.
- 40:45Prime. That'll on.
- 40:46We've all seen that Elan musk broke Securities laws this year
- 40:49when he was accumulating his Twitter steak.
- 40:52So, it's deeply frustrating from serve top to bottom, right?
- 40:56And I don't want to come off like I'm saying, I want to
- 40:59freeze everything. I just think I'm very
- 41:01straightforward stuff. I mean this back sort of
- 41:04projections issues so easy to say, but you know, are in crypto
- 41:08world. You could just require a like
- 41:09disclosures for yes, table coin Holdings.
- 41:12Like, it's not like you have to ban things, you can just say,
- 41:14oh, we're going to create reporting requirements.
- 41:17You know, if you're claiming XYZ and I think this closure is
- 41:20huge. It is actually an, I think my
- 41:21co-author Ben McKenzie talks about is like, you know, it's a
- 41:24basic fact usually of doing business and especially
- 41:27investing in companies and stocks, you know, who you're
- 41:30doing business with, there's a person on and Company, and a
- 41:33legal entity on the other end. I mean, we don't even have to
- 41:37get into the debate about quote-unquote doxing, the board,
- 41:40a people, but I do think it is ridiculous that like, this is a
- 41:43multi-billion dollar company in the Making and they thought that
- 41:46they could be anonymous. Like, if we just had more, if
- 41:49that would be a great start, is to have more disclosure knowing
- 41:51who's behind these companies. So, people also can't rug pull
- 41:54and then pop up again, under another pseudonym, rug pull.
- 41:57Exactly. I mean, I was gonna bring that
- 41:59term up. I mean, just the idea that it's
- 42:02sort of like par for the course in crypto world that basically,
- 42:06you know, somebody will announce a project raise a bunch of money
- 42:08and then just disappear with the money.
- 42:10That's a rug pull and there's like, come back later.
- 42:12Yeah. Things like oh this guy did a
- 42:14couple of rug poles are Already. You know, but this time it's a
- 42:17good project, you know? Because I really sun, right?
- 42:20That's the rationalization. In fact I talked about earlier
- 42:22which is that people make excuses, they're such low
- 42:25expectations that they're like he apologized or he did produce
- 42:28some value for a lot of people. Let's see what he's got next or
- 42:32the person just disappears and comes up under another
- 42:34pseudonym. But you know, when I go to
- 42:37conferences and things like that and I and and Ben and I
- 42:40interview people nearly everyone, we've talked to has
- 42:43been scammed and a lot of them have Rationalizations usually it
- 42:47comes down to 0. It was my fault.
- 42:49I didn't I clicked the wrong thing.
- 42:51I didn't do enough research, I didn't realize that this risk
- 42:54XYZ, but it can be met because it's somewhat of a Libertarian
- 42:58unregulated culture that sense of responsibility comes back
- 43:02onto the individual. And I think that's also, very
- 43:05unfortunate and not a way to build a sustainable industry.
- 43:08You need not just these guardrails, but a sense of
- 43:10accountability within the industry that there, that people
- 43:14shouldn't be scammed. To write all the time that
- 43:16shouldn't be. He's just sort of the cost of
- 43:18doing business or the cost of Entry.
- 43:19It's such a bizarre world. I just realized the more you
- 43:22talk that you have both the people who are so openly cynical
- 43:26about things that they're happily willing to accept a rug
- 43:29pull or, or a scam or somebody, you know, a pump and dump is
- 43:32like not even considered a criticism.
- 43:34They're like, oh yeah, it's a pump and dump.
- 43:36It's one of the pump and dump coins.
- 43:37Yeah, we had Dogecoin and then we had a billion iterations of
- 43:41Doge. It's like, oh, what a great pump
- 43:42and up. I'd yeah, yeah.
- 43:44And it's man, it's still one of the Things.
- 43:46I so I write about the gig economy and one of the saddest
- 43:48things that I came across was a driver for actually go puff who
- 43:52was telling me that she had done the research and was investing
- 43:55in not Shiba Inu but as Shiba Inu knock off and she was like,
- 44:00I've done the research and you know I went to a conference in
- 44:03Vegas and I feel really good about this and I mean I'm
- 44:06assuming that's all gone to zero at this point and she sound like
- 44:09yeah thousands and that I mean there are people who manage to
- 44:12sort of ride the volatility or you know, a coin might be worth.
- 44:15Earth, period 70's and then a number there.
- 44:19These basically worthless coins, but sometimes people buy a
- 44:23million of them and then and then ride a 10% increase in
- 44:26suddenly they made some money. But yeah, generally, those kinds
- 44:29of cases, you're not gonna make a profit part of the reason is
- 44:32like, there's not much to differentiate a lot of these
- 44:34coins. Yeah.
- 44:35They're different prices and and some of these projects are
- 44:38better funded than others, but a lot of the utility I think is
- 44:41also outside of defy Lisa's like is sort of promise for down
- 44:45there. Like this is going to get you
- 44:47into certain events or contacts with these people.
- 44:49Or you can get a letter from this celebrity or whatever else.
- 44:52But on a fundamental level a lot of it is number go up, it's
- 44:56speculation. That's built on hype and froth,
- 44:59and perhaps, disinformation and celebrity endorsements.
- 45:03And all those kinds of things that's not Universal across the
- 45:05board. But I mean, certainly at least
- 45:0795 percent of coins probably fall under that.
- 45:10So you're working with on a book with Ben, right?
- 45:12Yeah. We're frankly we're hoping to
- 45:14have some other See media projects in the future, but the
- 45:17book is definitely happening is your focus on particular
- 45:21characters or even independent of the book.
- 45:23I'm just curious, like, who you think is, who are the people,
- 45:26and sort of crypto World interests.
- 45:27You the most, we definitely have sort of Heroes, villains and
- 45:32victims, it is somewhat character, drip, and
- 45:35narrative-driven, you know, we want to tell interesting stories
- 45:38and good stories and not just browbeat people that cryptos bad
- 45:42or something like that. So, I guess I'm reluctant.
- 45:47I'm sorry to say sure. I don't want to actually you
- 45:49know because some of the stuff might change.
- 45:51Also I will say this, there was a great article in The Verge a
- 45:55month or two ago about Justin son.
- 45:58Who is the head of Tron? Big Block Chain.
- 46:00That does a lot of business with tether Justin's.
- 46:03I'm not writing my Justin son at the moment.
- 46:05I might one day, but Justin son, famously last year.
- 46:09He, I believe is a Chinese National.
- 46:11He sort of one, these peoples heard takes differences.
- 46:15And ships. And he moved to Grenada took the
- 46:18island of Grenada, the one that Reagan invaded and took Granada
- 46:21and citizenship and became their ambassador to the World Trade
- 46:24Organization. Oh my God, I mean, totally
- 46:26bizarre, but of course it's crypto.
- 46:28I mean, the first thing that comes to mind, of course, is
- 46:30that he wants diplomatic protection.
- 46:33Whether that really matters, you know, whether grenet Grenada can
- 46:36stand up to China or the u.s. is is probably unlikely.
- 46:39But there's a great article in the in the Verge, I forget the
- 46:43author's name but will include a link.
- 46:44It's called like the many The many escapes of Justin's son,
- 46:47this is from not that long ago and I really think that Justin
- 46:51son is represented figure in crypto and when I talk about the
- 46:54industry as sort of having fraudulent or perhaps even
- 46:58criminal underpinnings, I don't mean that everyone.
- 47:01But I think there are some major figures in crypto who resemble
- 47:04who are like Justin sun and they have a lot of control over the
- 47:07industry. I mean, people at tether people
- 47:10perhaps at Finance some of these big corporations and entities
- 47:15that are Based in the Seychelles, and in Malta, and in
- 47:19the Caribbean often through a number of shell companies and
- 47:22whose operators have Shady backgrounds.
- 47:25I mean, you can even look at the CEO of crypto.com, there's a
- 47:27Daily Beast article about the CEO of crypto.com.
- 47:30He basically rug pulled on his last company in Southeast Asia,
- 47:33which wasn't a crypto company. But, you know, you can see the
- 47:37history of some of these people. Like, there's a reason why this
- 47:40industry attracts scammers and sometimes at a high level, this
- 47:43is why the tech press sort of throws his hands up on.
- 47:45Stuff. It's sort of like I mean this is
- 47:47what do you do when it's so self-evident that there's yeah
- 47:50me Behavior. Like what am I even going to
- 47:52report? I mean, it's sort of like the
- 47:54same like Donald Trump political reporter problem in some ways,
- 47:58it's like, yeah, like obviously it's bad, like I don't know.
- 48:02I'm kudos to you for finding angles into it but sometimes I'm
- 48:06just like what's? But that's why the victims angle
- 48:09probably has to be the clearest one here, right?
- 48:11Because if a lot of it is just playing out in the media or on
- 48:14social media and And you know, you have these ridiculous
- 48:16characters who were like, look at me what I'm doing.
- 48:18As a rug pull, then the only real way to prove impact is by
- 48:22showing like, well, this is who was wrapped up in this person's
- 48:25quest for fame and you know, short-term Fortune.
- 48:29I'd also say that, you know, there's some basic things I
- 48:31think that people don't really realize in this goes back to
- 48:33what we want to do with our book.
- 48:35I love for the books, appeal to crypto, people, including
- 48:38hardcore crypto people. But you know, 80 plus percent of
- 48:41the American population has never bought crypto.
- 48:43So in a way, it's Be a story entertaining, one about crypto
- 48:48fraud Financial chicanery, these kinds of things that can appeal
- 48:52to the non crypto person. And maybe also make them feel a
- 48:55little bit better about missing out, but they're, you know,
- 48:57they're basic things. I think people don't know that.
- 48:59Like, for example, 80 to 90% of trading on most platforms, on
- 49:02most exchanges as wash trading, it's fake.
- 49:05So, you know, there's an idea of a free markets, like these bowl
- 49:09like buying and selling their own NF tease to.
- 49:12Yeah, the illusion that they're valuable or you own.
- 49:15Drive up the prices and you create the illusion of volume
- 49:19which has a similar effect. And there are like the bots of
- 49:22social media are astray. It's very similar that.
- 49:25I mean, they all intersect to on the stock market.
- 49:28You cannot like make trades for the intent of making it seem
- 49:32like there's a lot of buying interest when it's just you try
- 49:35that stock market. But yeah, I'm pretty sure it's
- 49:39illegal and it's nice. Right.
- 49:40Sounds, it sounds like just is not like an unfamiliar type of
- 49:43thing, that's why it's like okay yeah.
- 49:45You can regulate that. So, yeah.
- 49:47And I wish people could understand also, you can have
- 49:49sort of a quote, unquote free market, but right now you have a
- 49:52market that's free to be manipulated and it's almost
- 49:54undoubtedly manipulated. All of the exchanges, pretty
- 49:57much maybe some of like, the US based ones like, perhaps
- 50:00coinbase is better, because it is it tries to be in compliance
- 50:04with the law. It's publicly traded.
- 50:06It's based here in the US. But, you know, these overseas
- 50:09exchanges, there are plenty of academic studies on them.
- 50:12You know, read up on by answer, read my article in the
- 50:14Washington Post. And it's very hard to trust that
- 50:17these are actually quote unquote, free markets in the
- 50:19sense of kind of operating unfettered right.
- 50:22There are more free for people to manipulate them.
- 50:24And also, I think that they're free to be playgrounds for
- 50:28high-frequency trading firms, which are just cleaning up
- 50:31supposedly on some of these exchanges because they are work
- 50:35much faster and have much better information than for the average
- 50:38day trader. It's funny, the term that always
- 50:40gets thrown around in Tech in a burgeoning industry, as though,
- 50:43it's the wild west, right? Now, you know, that any time a
- 50:47new platform comes up in the number of startups?
- 50:48Go after it, you say, oh, it's the wild west, which typically
- 50:51just means, like, five or six vc-backed, companies are all
- 50:54having like, you know, territory carve-outs to see, who can
- 50:57emerge that number one. But, like the actual analogy of
- 50:59the Wild West, which is that it, there's no governance and people
- 51:02are getting shot, like, people are getting killed without any
- 51:05sort of repercussions, feels a lot more realistic to explaining
- 51:09what's happened in crypto. And also the people that made a
- 51:12lot of money during the wild west there, weren't that many
- 51:13like self-made, entrepreneurs, you Came out of nowhere to, you
- 51:17know, ended up becoming whatever Saloon owner is.
- 51:20Like there was a lot of Eastern Capital than it up funding these
- 51:22things. And those were the people that
- 51:23made out on at all. So it's finally like the analogy
- 51:26Rings true and it's and it's horrifying.
- 51:28Well, also on another way in which it might be, like the wild
- 51:31west is that in 19th century, you had private money in various
- 51:35forms. You had sort of Corporations,
- 51:38especially railroads, I think introducing their own money in
- 51:41certain regions in the west and stuff like that.
- 51:44So, there are ways in which Crypto is a return to that both
- 51:47the sort of anarchic and in Lawless quality of it.
- 51:51And also, these are basically corporations.
- 51:54I mean, sometimes are one or two people, but issuing their own
- 51:56currencies and with all the complications that then
- 52:00introduces, in closing here, it's like, I feel like the
- 52:03burden at this point can be on, you know, the defy Community the
- 52:07crypto Community to like prove that this can work within the
- 52:11regulatory system like it doesn't have to exist directly
- 52:15in Contrast to it and say, any sort of Regulation would Doom
- 52:18it. I don't think it's a very good
- 52:19system if that's the if that's the case, right?
- 52:21Like, find a way for this technology to further all of the
- 52:25goals that you have but also do it under, you know, the confines
- 52:29of a normative regulatory State and if it probably can do that.
- 52:33I mean, it's maybe more challenging for them, but
- 52:36there's no question to me that it'll be more successful and
- 52:38more beneficial if that happens. Yeah, I think you'll see fewer
- 52:41sort of social effects. I mean, right now, crypto often
- 52:45strikes me Like as a zero sum or even negative sum game with
- 52:48because it's sort of socially corrosive and the environmental
- 52:51effects. But look, if we can bring this
- 52:53into a more law-abiding and regulated system where they're
- 52:57actually protections for consumers, which I think is
- 52:59pretty key because most crypto buyers are now in the red,
- 53:02especially most Bitcoin buyers. I think that would be a lot
- 53:05better for everyone. I do think including creating
- 53:09more sustainable businesses. I mean, some people in crypto
- 53:11won't want that because then you miss out on some of the
- 53:14volatility and the Crazy highs and lows, which is how some
- 53:17folks make their money and they may be far, less exciting.
- 53:19And you may not be able to go 10,000 x in a year or whatever,
- 53:22but I think that's how you keep this stuff alive and bring it
- 53:26into the mainstream. Are we going to see like a
- 53:27series of movies? Now, I just realized, you know,
- 53:30we've gone through the cycle of tech TV shows based on like the
- 53:35last 10 years of Silicon Valley, we're probably do like a year or
- 53:39two from now from like a series of TV shows about all these
- 53:42characters. Right.
- 53:42I'm sorry to say that I hope to write one but who knows what
- 53:45will happen. Then I mean I think people just
- 53:48need to like the characters aren't as famous but I mean, I
- 53:51think that can act as well. It takes time during I always
- 53:54think Balaji is interesting. I mean, they're sort of the true
- 53:57True Believers and then there are the sort of money guys.
- 54:01And yeah, I mean there are a lot of characters but it's also
- 54:04evolving. All the text shows were about
- 54:06scamming this corruptive. I mean, I getting scammed is
- 54:10such a big part of human nature. I don't know if I have a lot of
- 54:14optimism that That it's like okay we stop people from getting
- 54:17scammed in Bitcoin. They just like they race to
- 54:20another thing. I mean that's true can protect
- 54:23them obviously because I because it's just like people do the
- 54:26terrible thing that's in front of them and if it's not in front
- 54:28of them, they don't get scammed. I mean, I don't even trade
- 54:32individual stocks and I cover the technology industry, just
- 54:35like the hubris to me, you know, that you like, I don't know.
- 54:39Some random person thinks they're going to be an expert on
- 54:41like Dogecoin or whatever. It's like, what do you there are
- 54:44people. Closer to it than you.
- 54:46I I am so disconnected from the world view of the purse like
- 54:51they know on some level they're not in touch with like power and
- 54:54like who's actually like doing these things and yet they feel
- 54:58confident enough to like ride this like crazy wave that they
- 55:02couldn't understand. Like I don't know, it's just
- 55:05like there's no humility in it to me.
- 55:07I don't know. You own any crypto, a view.
- 55:09Like I said, I've been it. I don't right now.
- 55:13I haven't, you know, it's funny like People in crypto say like,
- 55:16well, how can you understand the stuff if you don't own it or
- 55:18trade it and then you know in journalism and usually that is
- 55:21you don't really want to own something or be financially
- 55:24invested in what you cover. So that's my main reasons.
- 55:26I just don't want to be rooting for something or but I have been
- 55:31thinking about putting in service small amount into a
- 55:34portfolio because I just I do need a little, you know,
- 55:36first-hand experience with some of the stuff and hopefully I
- 55:39won't have it. Maybe next time you have me on
- 55:42the show all of had a total change of heart and now be like,
- 55:44you need to invest That's a coin, right?
- 55:46Exactly. And just think of coin.
- 55:48You've just been you just been too poor for two for too long.
- 55:51He didn't that's right. The rush.
- 55:52Well, the funny thing is that the one host on this show who
- 55:56has the most of her net worth tied up in crypto, wasn't able
- 56:00to make it today but look 8,500. And yeah.
- 56:03So now she has she bought a Bitcoin and you know it's not
- 56:06worth like whatever bitcoins worth but 9000.
- 56:10I mean, yeah, I should, we should one but there's no true
- 56:12neutrality, right? There's no neutrality on like
- 56:15what's Okay, to hold like, there's no objective right?
- 56:18Number on like the percentage of your portfolio, that should be
- 56:20in crypto, right? Like, so, therefore, you can't
- 56:22construct what I like journalistic neutral.
- 56:24Thing is because saying, it's zero is an opinion or saying
- 56:28it's 2%, is an opinion, I don't know.
- 56:31So I feel like inevitably, you're trapped and having to
- 56:33make some sort of judgment about what is control?
- 56:35Portfolio would be. Yeah, I'm not sure.
- 56:37And I would try to focus on things.
- 56:39Like I don't I probably wouldn't write about.
- 56:41I wouldn't really talk about it very much.
- 56:43I think also I have Perhaps, I'm fortunate that, I don't have a
- 56:46lot of spare money lying around to play with, so, yeah, there's
- 56:49that. Well, yeah, all right, Jacob.
- 56:52Thanks so much for joining. Thank you so much for coming on.
- 56:54This is great. Thanks a lot.
- 56:55I appreciate it. Silicon Valley, goodbye,
- 57:08goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye.
- 57:10Goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.
- 56:59Silicon Valley, goodbye, goodbye.
- 57:09Goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye.
- 57:11Goodbye.