Latest / Interfaiths / Hate to Hope: Building a New Jewish-Muslim Future
Transcript
- 0:00So I want you to imagine for a second putting
- 0:0250 like nine and 10 year olds into a single room
- 0:05to navigate one of the most deeply complex fiercely
- 0:09debated geopolitical divides in modern history.
- 0:11I mean on paper that just sounds like a recipe
- 0:13for absolute chaos. Right. Or you know at the
- 0:16very least a room full of just profound really
- 0:19uncomfortable silence. But welcome to today's
- 0:23Deep Dive. We are looking back at a very specific
- 0:26moment in the spring of 2025. And, you know,
- 0:29following the events of October 7, 2023, and
- 0:31then the Iran war of 2025, the discourse around
- 0:34Jewish and Muslim relations in America had just
- 0:37hardened. It was it was in a state of severe
- 0:40gridlock. Exactly. The headlines you're seeing
- 0:42every single day were just dominated by adult
- 0:45conflicts, stark societal divisions and, you
- 0:48know, rigid lines being drawn in the sand. Just
- 0:50heavy, overwhelming news. So heavy. But our mission
- 0:54for this deep dive is to extract insights from
- 0:56a completely contrasting, quiet sociological
- 0:59experiment that took place right in the middle
- 1:02of New York City during that exact tense period.
- 1:05Yeah, we're unpacking the Hate to Hope initiative.
- 1:07Right, which was a joint project between LM Academy
- 1:09and Kinneret Day School. Supported by Save the
- 1:13People USA, which is an important detail. Yes,
- 1:15absolutely. And, you know, reading through the
- 1:17source material for this, it honestly felt like
- 1:20finding this quiet, blooming garden right in
- 1:23the middle of a noisy, gridlocked highway. That
- 1:26is a great analogy. Because the contrast between
- 1:30the macro level geopolitical friction and this,
- 1:34you know, micro level initiative is exactly what
- 1:37makes the source material so valuable. Right.
- 1:39We are essentially looking at a real time laboratory
- 1:42for contact theory, because while the broader
- 1:45societal narrative was locked into this. Us versus
- 1:49them paradigm. Which we all remember feeling
- 1:51so intensely. Right, exactly. But these organizations
- 1:54structured a framework for 54th and 5th graders.
- 1:57So 25 from a Muslim academy and 25 from a Jewish
- 2:01day school. And the goal was to systematically
- 2:03dismantle those societal divides. Yeah, and they
- 2:05didn't do it through high -level diplomatic debate.
- 2:07I mean, they're kids. Right. No politicians at
- 2:09a podium here. Exactly. They used cultural exchange,
- 2:12the sociology of shared physical space, and just
- 2:15the gradual recognition of a shared human architecture.
- 2:19But, you know... To understand how they actually
- 2:21achieve this, I think we have to look at the
- 2:23structural foundation first. The numbers. Yeah,
- 2:25the numbers. Because my immediate skeptical reaction
- 2:29when reading about an interfaith initiative for
- 2:31children is that it's usually just a polite photo
- 2:34op. Oh, totally. Like a school assembly where
- 2:36everyone sings a song, eats a cookie, and goes
- 2:38back to their segregated lives. Exactly. But
- 2:41the interfaith journey by the numbers from the
- 2:43source documentation completely reframes the
- 2:46scale of this. They had 50 student participants.
- 2:49Backed by 15 adult chaperones, parents, and teachers.
- 2:53Which is a huge support system. It really is.
- 2:56And the metric that completely changes the game
- 2:58here is the time commitment. It was over 30 hours
- 3:01of structured programming spanning five separate
- 3:04events. Which I have to say, 30 hours is a massive
- 3:07data point. Massive. When you study intergroup
- 3:09relations and prejudice reduction, brief contact
- 3:13can actually backfire. Wait, really? It can make
- 3:16it worse. Oh, absolutely. If you just throw two
- 3:18anxious groups into a room for an hour, they
- 3:21often cling to their preconceived stereotypes
- 3:23because their psychological defenses are just,
- 3:26you know, highly activated. Ah, that makes a
- 3:28lot of sense. So 30 hours reveals a deliberate
- 3:31structural commitment to outlasting that initial
- 3:35fight or flight response. The adults architecting
- 3:39this program understood that you cannot rush
- 3:42vulnerability. No, you really can't. It takes
- 3:45time to move a human brain past the polite, nervous
- 3:48facade and get it to a place where genuine curiosity
- 3:51can operate. Well, I have to challenge this premise
- 3:54just a little bit, though. OK, go for it. 30
- 3:55hours of heavy interfaith dialogue. I mean, I've
- 3:58seen adult corporate trust building retreats
- 4:00completely fall apart after three hours. Oh,
- 4:02easily. People get cynical. They check out or
- 4:04they just start staring at their phones. So how
- 4:07on earth do you keep a group of fourth and fifth
- 4:09graders engaged in this level of societal boundary
- 4:12breaking without them just completely? Completely
- 4:14zoning out. Well, you don't put them in a room
- 4:16and lecture them about the abstract concept of
- 4:18peace, right? Okay, fair point. The brilliance
- 4:21of the hate to hope curriculum is that they made
- 4:23the history physical and they made the empathy
- 4:25kinetic. Kinetic. I like that. Yeah. The organizers
- 4:29understood that children process complex sociological
- 4:32concepts through movement, environment, and interaction.
- 4:36Instead of talking at them about their respective
- 4:38histories, they had them walk through those histories
- 4:41together in carefully curated public spaces.
- 4:44Which perfectly explains the strategy behind
- 4:46their first major gathering. Right. January 14,
- 4:492025. Yeah, they meet up in lower Manhattan at
- 4:52the Museum of Jewish Heritage. And they didn't
- 4:54start with like silly icebreakers. They started
- 4:57with gravity. Yeah, they really did. These 50
- 5:00students walk through the living memorial to
- 5:02the Holocaust together. And they used gallery
- 5:04educators who were specifically trained for cross
- 5:06-tradition facilitation. Which is such a vital
- 5:09detail. Right. So these kids are physically moving
- 5:12through the deep, painful, resilient history
- 5:14of the Jewish people as a single unit. And starting
- 5:18with a space dedicated to profound historical
- 5:20trauma is a very intentional psychological anchor.
- 5:24Well, it establishes a baseline of solemn respect.
- 5:28It demonstrates the ultimate devastating consequence
- 5:31of unchecked societal hatred. Wow. Yeah. When
- 5:34you experience a memorial like that alongside
- 5:36peers from an out group, it creates a shared
- 5:39emotional resonance. The abstract concept of
- 5:42prejudice suddenly has a concrete spatial reality
- 5:45that both groups are witnessing simultaneously.
- 5:48That is heavy, but so necessary. But an initiative
- 5:51like this cannot sustain itself purely on shared
- 5:54solemnity. You know, the narrative has to shift
- 5:56from observing trauma to sharing culture. And
- 6:00that pivot happens exactly a month later. February
- 6:0325. Right. They reconvene at the Metropolitan
- 6:05Museum of Art. And this is where the mechanism
- 6:08of the program gets genuinely fascinating to
- 6:11me. The role reversal. Yes. They didn't just
- 6:13have a museum curator walk them around. They
- 6:16instituted a complete role reversal. The Elham
- 6:19student, so the Muslim fourth and fifth graders,
- 6:22were actually put in charge. They guided the
- 6:23kindred students through the Islamic galleries
- 6:25at the Met. Which is incredible. That structural
- 6:28choice is a master class in building interpersonal
- 6:30trust. In sociological terms, it distributes
- 6:34the power dynamic equally. Right, because neither
- 6:37group is just passively listening. Exactly. When
- 6:40one group hosts the other in a space that validates
- 6:43their cultural identity, it dismantles defensive
- 6:46barriers. The Elham students are given agency
- 6:49and authority over their own narratives. And
- 6:51the source material shows them explaining the
- 6:53significance of specific items to their Jewish
- 6:56peers. Right, like the jayna moss. Yeah, the
- 6:58traditional prayer rug. And they're explaining
- 7:00the tupi, the prayer cap. They even point out
- 7:03fragments of the kiswah, the massive cloth that
- 7:06drapes the Kaaba and Mecca. It's just such a
- 7:08rich exchange. It really is. I look at this and
- 7:11I think of it like establishing a demilitarized
- 7:14zone of childhood. I love that phrasing. Like,
- 7:16if you invite a new friend over to your house
- 7:18for the first time, you naturally want to show
- 7:20them your room. room, your favorite books, the
- 7:21things that matter to you. The organizers basically
- 7:24turn a massive, imposing cultural institution
- 7:27into an intimate, shared living room. And by
- 7:31doing so, they trigger what psychologists call
- 7:33cognitive empathy in the guest group. Meaning
- 7:35what exactly? The kindred students aren't just
- 7:38reading a placard about Islamic artifacts. they're
- 7:41seeing those artifacts refracted through the
- 7:43pride and personal connection of a peer standing
- 7:45right next to them. Ah, so it's relational. Exactly.
- 7:49It forces the brain to process the information
- 7:51socially, not just academically. And we see the
- 7:54direct result of this environment in the written
- 7:57reflections the students produced. Right. There
- 7:59were over 70 written reflections generated during
- 8:02this whole 30 -hour span. Which is a goldmine
- 8:05of data. It really is. And one of those reflections
- 8:07comes from Mohamed Sudeis, a fourth grader at
- 8:10Elham Academy. His honesty is really striking.
- 8:13Yeah. What did he say? He openly admits that
- 8:15before this program, he had literally never interacted
- 8:19with a student from another faith. Wow. Never.
- 8:21Never. He wrote, quote, It was an eye -opening
- 8:25experience. It was exciting to learn about one
- 8:28another in a respectful and welcoming environment.
- 8:31End quote. Notice how he specifically points
- 8:34to the environment. Right. The architecture of
- 8:36the space itself gave him the psychological safety
- 8:39to be curious rather than guarded. Muhammad's
- 8:42reflection highlights a critical threshold. Sharing
- 8:45public history in a grand museum builds cognitive
- 8:48understanding. It helps you categorize the other
- 8:51group's culture. OK, but that's just the start,
- 8:53right? Exactly. To achieve lasting prejudice
- 8:56reduction, you have to transition from public
- 8:59macro -level history into private micro -level
- 9:02identity. You have to move the interaction from
- 9:04the museum to the dining room table. Beautifully
- 9:07said. Yeah. And that perfectly frames the psychological
- 9:09shift of their third event on March 5. The Iftar.
- 9:12Right. They leave the neutral ground of the museums
- 9:15and go directly to El Ham Academy for a shared
- 9:18Iftar. They called it Faith, Friendship, and
- 9:20Falafel, which is just great branding. It really
- 9:22is. And for context for you listening, during
- 9:25the Islamic holy month of Ramadan, Muslims fast
- 9:28from dawn to sunset, and the iftar is the meal
- 9:31where that fast is broken. Such an important
- 9:33ritual. And... The documentation paints this
- 9:36incredibly vivid scene. You have Jewish and Muslim
- 9:40children standing together in a Muslim academy,
- 9:43lighting candles, reciting blessings in both
- 9:46Arabic and Hebrew. Yes, together. And then passing
- 9:49traditional plates of food to one another to
- 9:52break the fast. The sociology of commensality,
- 9:54which is just the academic term for the act of
- 9:56eating together, is perhaps the oldest human
- 9:59technology for building alliances. The oldest
- 10:02technology. I mean. Breaking bread is universal.
- 10:05Truly. But here, the symbolism is operating on
- 10:08multiple levels. Imam Muhammad Shahidullah, the
- 10:11founder of Al -Ham Academy, structured this to
- 10:13show that the breaking of a physical fast could
- 10:16serve as the symbolic breaking of societal barriers.
- 10:19Which is just a stunning metaphor. And we see
- 10:21this echoed by the other adult leaders present.
- 10:23Right, like Paul Radensky from the Museum of
- 10:25Jewish Heritage. Exactly. He noted that the sheer
- 10:28act of these communities working together in
- 10:30that room proved that amazing things were possible.
- 10:33And Christine Nallel from the 67th Precinct Clergy
- 10:35Council framed it as an exercise in growing in
- 10:39understanding and love across different religious
- 10:41practices. Powerful stuff. But breaking bread
- 10:44in a communal space is one thing. Right. The
- 10:47question is, how do you get kids to open up about...
- 10:50their deeply private internal identities. Well,
- 10:53they answered that on April 3, when they took
- 10:56the intimacy a step further. They asked these
- 10:59children to bring personal treasures from their
- 11:01own homes. This is such a great shift. Because
- 11:03we are no longer talking about million -dollar
- 11:05artifacts behind glass at the Met. No, we're
- 11:08talking about real life. Exactly. We are talking
- 11:10about a Tasbik prayer beads given by an uncle,
- 11:13a Kiddush cup used by a grandmother at Shabbat,
- 11:16an Eid cap. A Megan David, you know, a Star of
- 11:20David necklace that a child has worn since birth.
- 11:22It's so personal. And they sat in circles, held
- 11:25these items, and just told the family stories
- 11:27behind them. This is the exact moment where the
- 11:29abstract concept of the other dissolves. Because
- 11:32it's suddenly so tangible. Right. A museum teaches
- 11:35you about a demographic. A grandmother's kiddush
- 11:37cup teaches you about a specific tangible person.
- 11:40Yeah, the human element. The psychological mechanism
- 11:43at play here is called in -group recategorization.
- 11:46When a Jewish child hears a Muslim child talk
- 11:49about the reverence they have for an uncle's
- 11:51prayer beads, the Jewish child's brain recognizes
- 11:54the exact same reverence they feel for their
- 11:56own family's religious heirlooms. Wow. So the
- 11:59feelings mirror each other. Exactly. The boundary
- 12:02between us and them gets completely blurred by
- 12:05the universal experience of family structure
- 12:07and sacred memory. I really want to look at how
- 12:10that recategorization actually feels to a child
- 12:13experiencing it. Oh, we have to talk about Eden.
- 12:16Yes, Eden Jaffe. There is a deeply illuminating
- 12:19reflection from her in the source material. She
- 12:22admits that at the start of this program, she
- 12:24was highly anxious. She actually believed it
- 12:26would be almost impossible for Jews and Muslims
- 12:28to interact because in her mind, they were just
- 12:30fundamentally, impossibly different. And that's
- 12:33so common. Right. So for you listening right
- 12:35now, just think about that profound level of
- 12:37cognitive dissonance Eden was experiencing. She's
- 12:41stepping into a room with people society has
- 12:43implicitly told her. are an opposing force. Right.
- 12:46What mechanism actually breaks that firewall
- 12:48down for her? It's an essential question. Because
- 12:52as adults, we often assume that bridging a geopolitical
- 12:55divide requires complex, high -level theological
- 12:57compromise. Like we have to debate the finer
- 13:00points of dogma. Exactly. We think we need to
- 13:03negotiate away our differences. But for Eden,
- 13:05the breakthrough wasn't about negotiating differences
- 13:08at all. It was the shock of discovering an existing
- 13:11shared foundational architecture. It was the
- 13:14startling realization of similarities. In her
- 13:16reflection, Eden meticulously lists them out.
- 13:19It's quite a list. It really is. She realizes
- 13:21they both fundamentally believe in God. Then
- 13:25she lists the shared prophets. She specifically
- 13:27names Moshe, Abraham, David, Isaac, Jacob, Solomon,
- 13:31and Joseph. Yeah, and she notes that both Muslims
- 13:34and Jews use a prayer book to study, pray, and
- 13:37anchor their daily lives. She even points out
- 13:40that both cultures share similar customs and
- 13:42values around modesty. It's like finding out
- 13:44you have the same operating system. Exactly.
- 13:46She went from believing interaction was almost
- 13:49impossible to realizing they were essentially
- 13:51reading different chapters of a deeply parallel
- 13:53script. When a child realizes that the very foundation
- 13:57of their identity their prophets their daily
- 14:01rituals their sacred texts has a direct mirror
- 14:04in someone they previously categorized as an
- 14:06outsider it completely rewires their baseline
- 14:09of empathy rewires it completely the psychological
- 14:12firewall collapses because the brain can no longer
- 14:15justify the fear of the unknown the unknown has
- 14:19suddenly been revealed as deeply fundamentally
- 14:21familiar But you know, this is where the sociological
- 14:24data from this project gets really nuanced, because
- 14:26not every single child walked into this 30 -hour
- 14:29program with Eden's level of anxiety. Right,
- 14:31that's a great point. Eden had to experience
- 14:33a profound theological revelation to cross that
- 14:36bridge. But another student's experience gives
- 14:39us a completely different lens on how empathy
- 14:42actually operates in the wild. Let's look at
- 14:45Isaac Rose. Yes, the fifth grader from Kinneret
- 14:48Day School. Isaac's story is critical because
- 14:50it forces us to look at the power of pre -existing
- 14:52exposure. His speech at the end of the program
- 14:55was so revealing. It really was. He stood up
- 14:58in front of everyone and candidly admitted that,
- 15:00unlike some of his peers, he wasn't really nervous
- 15:03to meet the Muslim students on day one. And his
- 15:05explanation for why he wasn't nervous is just...
- 15:08brilliantly grounded. Right. It has nothing to
- 15:10do with museum tours or interfaith dialogue.
- 15:12No, nothing like that. He wasn't nervous because
- 15:14his dad runs a business and his dad's business
- 15:17partners are Muslim. Isaac already knows all
- 15:19about Ramadan. It's just a normal part of his
- 15:21life. Exactly. But far more importantly, he knows
- 15:24the business partners' families. He regularly
- 15:27plays tag and hide -and -seek with their children
- 15:29right in the aisles of his dad's store. This
- 15:31perfectly illustrates how we construct our social
- 15:34realities. Isaac didn't require a structured
- 15:37curriculum to teach him that Muslim children
- 15:40were just like him. He already knew. Right. He
- 15:42already possessed the empirical data of play.
- 15:44His daily environment was already integrated.
- 15:47In sociological terms, his social environment
- 15:50had already inoculated him against the societal
- 15:53prejudice happening on the evening news. That's
- 15:55a fascinating way to put it. He essentially had
- 15:58a cognitive immune system built entirely out
- 16:01of games of hide and seek. It fundamentally proves
- 16:04that empathy is a muscle. Isaac had already been
- 16:07doing heavy reps with his empathy muscle in the
- 16:09back of his dad's store through the universal,
- 16:11unscripted language of play. Yeah, he was doing
- 16:13the work without even realizing it was work.
- 16:15Exactly. Meanwhile, students like Eden were just
- 16:18starting their very first reps within the safety
- 16:20of this structured program. And placing Isaac's
- 16:24experience right next to Eden's provides the
- 16:26most comprehensive takeaway of the sort of material.
- 16:29It proves that peace and mutual respect are not
- 16:32just high -minded concepts that must be negotiated
- 16:34by leaders at a podium in Geneva. Peace is practically
- 16:38and physically constructed in the mundane everyday
- 16:41interactions of childhood. In the aisles of a
- 16:43store? Yes. It is built by playing tag, by sharing
- 16:47a falafel, by holding an uncle's prayer beads.
- 16:50So how do you successfully close out? a 30 -hour
- 16:54multi -month sociological journey like this you
- 16:57have to bring it all together right you have
- 16:59all these distinct pathways of empathy from eden's
- 17:02big theological realizations to isaac's familiar
- 17:05games of tag and they all converge in the late
- 17:08spring on may 20 the organizations held collaborative
- 17:11art sessions and the structure shifts again here
- 17:13it does the kids aren't just observing history
- 17:16and they aren't just sharing personal items they
- 17:18are now tasked with co -creating they drew and
- 17:20painted collaborative panels focused focusing
- 17:22on themes of prayer, memory, and family. And
- 17:24the entire journey then culminated in a final
- 17:27exhibition and a series of speeches on June 11th.
- 17:30Moving from consumption to co -creation is the
- 17:33ultimate metric of successful integration. Because
- 17:35they're building something together. Exactly.
- 17:37They took the raw materials of their separate
- 17:39identities and synthesized something entirely
- 17:41new that belonged equally to both groups. It's
- 17:44beautiful. And the publication that documented
- 17:47this entire project captured an overarching motto.
- 17:51articulated by Kelly A. Watts of Save the People
- 17:53and Imam Muhammad Shaidullah. I love this quote.
- 17:57The motto was... Peace is not the absence of
- 18:01difference, but the presence of respect. The
- 18:04presence of respect. That is such a vital distinction
- 18:06because they never once asked these fourth and
- 18:09fifth graders to water down their identities.
- 18:11No, not at all. They didn't ask them to ignore
- 18:13their deep differences or to pretend they were
- 18:15exactly the same. They simply taught them how
- 18:17to respect the space between them. Right. There's
- 18:20a quote from the kids reflections that synthesizes
- 18:23the entire 30 hours. They wrote, we didn't just
- 18:26learn about each other. We learned from each
- 18:28other. That preposition changes everything. It
- 18:30really is. If you think about the mechanics of
- 18:33that, learning about someone is a one -way transaction.
- 18:36You can learn about a demographic from a distance.
- 18:38But learning from someone requires proximity.
- 18:42requires a relationship. Executing that specific
- 18:45type of relationship building against the backdrop
- 18:48of the spring of 2025, a period defined by intense,
- 18:52seemingly intractable global and local friction
- 18:55elevates this from a nice local story to a profound
- 18:59proof of concept. It really does. It demonstrates
- 19:02empirically that even when the macro environment
- 19:04of society is fractured and hostile, the micro
- 19:07environment, whether that is a museum gallery,
- 19:09a school cafeteria, or the aisles of a dad's
- 19:12door can be deliberately engineered for human
- 19:14connection. Which leaves us with a final provocative
- 19:17thought for you to carry with you today. We just
- 19:19spent this time deconstructing how 54th and 5th
- 19:22graders managed to bridge a massive, heavily
- 19:25fortified societal gap. An incredibly tense geopolitical
- 19:28era. Right, and they dismantled their own ingrained
- 19:31anxieties simply by asking questions, sharing
- 19:33history, and breaking bread. So look at the architecture
- 19:36of your own life and your own local community.
- 19:38What boundaries are you accepting? Exactly. What
- 19:40impossible boundaries or rigid divides are you
- 19:43currently accepting as a permanent reality? What
- 19:46walls are you assuming can never be brought down
- 19:49when they might just require the bravery of a
- 19:52shared conversation or shared meal to start dismantling?
- 19:56It's a challenge that demands self -reflection.
- 19:59Because if a nine -year -old has the capacity
- 20:01to bypass societal fear and find shared humanity,
- 20:04we certainly have the responsibility to attempt
- 20:06the same in our own spheres of influence. Without
- 20:09a doubt. Thanks for diving deep with us today.