Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Waste Management‘s Moat: Why the Buffett-Backed Trash Giant Misses
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. Today we're tackling something
- 0:03pretty fundamental, waste disposal, and specifically the
- 0:07giant in that space, Waste Management ticker WM.
- 0:11Right, the biggest in North America.
- 0:13They handle environmental services pretty much soup to
- 0:16nuts. Exactly.
- 0:17And we've got a bunch of sources here looking at, you know, how
- 0:19big they are, their recent numbers, and this this legendary
- 0:22Moat everyone talks about. Well, that definitely got a
- 0:24strong reputation. So our mission today, get past
- 0:27the headlines, want to unpack their latest quarter, really
- 0:31look at why they're so dominant using that sort of Buffett style
- 0:34checklist. And then the big question is
- 0:38this amazing business maybe a price to perfectly right now, is
- 0:42there any margin of safety left for an investor?
- 0:45It's a crucial question, and when you talk scale, WM is just
- 0:48massive. It's not some flashy tech stock.
- 0:51This is basic infrastructure. Essential.
- 0:53Essential they serve nearly 21 million customers.
- 0:56Think about that. Residential, commercial,
- 0:58industrial, and they handle something like 83,000,000 tons
- 1:02of waste every single year across the US and Canada.
- 1:05I mean it's non discretionary. The economy could boom or bust,
- 1:09but you know the trash still has to go somewhere.
- 1:12OK. So that resilience, let's test
- 1:14it right away with the latest numbers.
- 1:16Q32025 was interesting, right, kind of a paradox.
- 1:20They reported pretty strong revenue, $6.44 billion, that's
- 1:24up almost 15% from last year. Sounds great.
- 1:27On the surface, yeah, solid growth.
- 1:29But the market didn't love it. It missed the Wall Street
- 1:31estimate, which was closer to $6.50 billion, and earnings per
- 1:35share $1.98 suggested also missed.
- 1:39How does that work? How is nearly 15% growth seen as
- 1:42a miss? Well, the market was really
- 1:44zeroed in on a couple of specific areas, kind of ignoring
- 1:47the strength underneath, OK, the revenue shortfall really came
- 1:50from two things. First, and this was the big one,
- 1:53the global recycling market just tanked.
- 1:56Right, heard about that. Yeah, the average price for the
- 1:58stuff collected in the single stream bins, it fell off a
- 2:00Cliff, down nearly 35% compared to the year before.
- 2:03Ouch. How much did that hurt revenue?
- 2:05That alone probably knocked about $60 million off their
- 2:08recycling segment revenue. It's a huge commodity swing they
- 2:11can't really control. Right, completely external.
- 2:13What was the second pressure point?
- 2:15The second was maybe more internal, likely short term,
- 2:18though some modest softness in the new WM Healthcare Solutions
- 2:23business. That's the Stair Cycle
- 2:25acquisition. OK.
- 2:26So integration may be taking longer or costing more than
- 2:29expected. That seems to be the read, yeah,
- 2:31yeah. And suggest the final stages of
- 2:33folding that big piece in are, you know, a bit challenging hit
- 2:36profitability expectations slightly.
- 2:39So the market Ding them for issues and recycling, which is
- 2:43volatile anyway and integrating a big acquisition.
- 2:46But those aren't the whole story, are they?
- 2:48What about the core business, the actual trash collection and
- 2:51disposal? See, that's where the real
- 2:53strength showed. Beneath all that noise, the core
- 2:56collection and disposal part hit a record adjusted operating
- 3:00EBITDA margin 37.5%. A record margin in this
- 3:04inflationary environment. How pricing power, Simple as
- 3:07that. It was driven by a really wrong
- 3:09core price increase of 6.0 percent 6.
- 3:11Percent, OK. Yeah, so even though they're
- 3:13facing serious cost pressures, Labour's a huge chunk, 3540% of
- 3:18off X plus fuel costs, they were able to push prices up well
- 3:22above inflation. Pass it right through.
- 3:24And that protected the profit margin.
- 3:26Protected and even expanded it. That margin really shows you
- 3:29their market power in action. And did that translate into cash
- 3:32flow because that's often the bottom line?
- 3:35Absolutely. For the first nine months of the
- 3:36year, free cash flow jumped 13.5%, hit $2.11 billion.
- 3:42OK. Strong cash flow.
- 3:43And this is the really critical point for investors.
- 3:46I think management actually lowered their full year revenue
- 3:48guidance because of those recycling and healthcare issues
- 3:51we talked about, right, But they specifically reaffirmed their
- 3:55full year guidance for core profitability, EBITDA and for
- 3:59free cash flow. OK.
- 4:00Hold on. Lower revenue, but same profit
- 4:03and cash flow targets, that sounds a little
- 4:06counterintuitive. Does that mean they're maybe you
- 4:08know, cutting back on investments or maintenance just
- 4:11to hit the number for this year? Could that hurt them long term?
- 4:14That's definitely the right question to ask.
- 4:16You have to be skeptical, but WM has historically been really
- 4:19good at managing costs and leveraging their operations.
- 4:23Affirming FCF guidance, even with millions less in revenue,
- 4:27suggests that the core waste disposal side is just so
- 4:31inherently profitable, and their cost controls are so tight that
- 4:36they could absorb those hits without sacrificing essential
- 4:38spending. So it actually reinforces the
- 4:40idea of that core business quality, those annuity like
- 4:44characteristics. I think so, yeah.
- 4:46It really speaks to the stability of that essential
- 4:48service model. OK.
- 4:49Let's shift from the quarterly numbers to that underlying
- 4:52strength. You mentioned annuity like
- 4:54characteristics, about 75% of the revenue comes from long term
- 4:58contracts. But where does that deep
- 5:00competitive advantage, the Moat, really come from?
- 5:03The real foundation, the cornerstone of their Moat and
- 5:06profitability, is the landfill segment.
- 5:08That's consistently their most profitable operation.
- 5:10How does that work? You're just charging fees.
- 5:12Basically, yeah, they charge tipping fees.
- 5:14That's the fee to dump waste at the landfill.
- 5:17They charge third party haulers, but crucially, they also charge
- 5:20their own collection trucks. OK, And that leads us to this
- 5:24idea of their unmatched network of landfill assets.
- 5:28They own what, 254 active sites? Why is that so important?
- 5:32Explain the scarcity part, the whole NMB lie thing.
- 5:34Not in my backyard. Right, N MB Y is absolutely key
- 5:38here because trying to get permits to build a new landfill
- 5:41in North America today, well, it's almost impossible.
- 5:44Really, due to regulations and local.
- 5:46Pushback. Exactly.
- 5:47Huge local opposition? Incredibly complex environmental
- 5:51rules. So this means WM isn't just
- 5:54operating a service, they own these incredibly scarce
- 5:57appreciating assets. That's appreciating how?
- 5:59As existing landfill capacity across the country fills up and
- 6:02new sites aren't being built, the value of the remaining
- 6:05permitted airspace, literally the empty volume in WM's
- 6:09existing sites, just goes up and up.
- 6:11So it's not static. The scarcity itself drives up
- 6:14the value of what they already own.
- 6:15That sounds like a classic deep Moat.
- 6:17Gives them pricing power. Huge pricing power and then you
- 6:20layer on their vertical integration.
- 6:22That's the other piece of the puzzle.
- 6:24How does that work? Well, WM takes about two thirds,
- 6:2766% of the waste their own trucks collect and dumps it in
- 6:31their own landfills. OK.
- 6:33So the collection part of WM pays a tipping fee to the
- 6:36landfill part of WM. They're basically paying
- 6:39themselves. I see internalization.
- 6:41Exactly. This means they avoid paying the
- 6:44open market tipping fees that smaller regional competitors who
- 6:48don't own landfills have to pay. It's a massive structural cost
- 6:52advantage that's very hard to replicate.
- 6:54OK, that makes a ton of sense. A really defensive structure.
- 6:57But you know no company is invincible.
- 6:59Even owning the trash infrastructure must come with
- 7:01risks. What are the main challenges WM
- 7:04is facing? Well, short term, those cost
- 7:06pressures we mentioned aren't going away.
- 7:08Labor is always a factor, finding drivers, wage inflation
- 7:11and fuel prices. Their fleet is enormous, so
- 7:13that's a big exposure. Right.
- 7:15And economic sensitivity. Yeah, definitely.
- 7:17While basic trash collection is steady, those really high margin
- 7:22waste streams like construction debris, industrial waste, those
- 7:25volumes can drop off quite a bit if the economy slows down.
- 7:29That hits profits directly. And we already saw the recycling
- 7:32volatility in Q3. That's just an ongoing risk they
- 7:35have to manage. Or indoor, really.
- 7:36It's tied to global commodity prices.
- 7:38OK. Those are sort of operational
- 7:39headwinds. What about bigger picture,
- 7:42longer term structural threats, especially to that incredibly
- 7:46profitable landfill business? The biggest one, the one
- 7:49everyone's watching, is the global push towards a a circular
- 7:53economy. Right, less waste generation
- 7:56overall. Exactly the fundamental shift
- 7:58focusing on preventing waste in the 1st place, reusing
- 8:01materials, much more advanced recycling.
- 8:03The whole goal is to break the link between economic growth and
- 8:06creating more trash. And that really takes hold.
- 8:08If it's successful long term, it means a slow, steady decline in
- 8:12the amount of stuff actually ending up in landfills, and that
- 8:15directly challenges WMS most profitable segment which makes
- 8:18money by filling up that valuable airspace.
- 8:20That's a major strategic challenge.
- 8:22If your core profit engine might shrink over decades, how do you
- 8:26hedge against that? What's WM doing?
- 8:28Their big strategic pivot is investing heavily in WM
- 8:32renewable Energy, or WMRE. OK.
- 8:34What does that involve? They're basically taking the
- 8:36methane gas that naturally comes off decomposing waste in their
- 8:41landfills, which is a potent greenhouse gas and environmental
- 8:45liability really, and they're capturing.
- 8:47It and doing what with? It they convert it into valuable
- 8:50renewable natural gas RNG or use it to generate electricity.
- 8:55Turning a problem into a product.
- 8:56Precisely. It's quite clever strategically.
- 8:59It takes an environmental issue, monetizes it, aligns them with
- 9:03decarbonization trends which are huge now, and creates a whole
- 9:05new potential growth engine. It kind of runs counter to that
- 9:09circular economy threat to landfill volume.
- 9:12Interesting hedge. OK.
- 9:13This whole picture, the strengths, the risks, the
- 9:16strategy brings us to the ultimate test, putting WM
- 9:19through that tough Buffett style checklist.
- 9:22Qualitatively, though, there's a pretty big vote of confidence
- 9:25already, isn't there? Oh yeah, you mean the Gates
- 9:26Foundation? Exactly the Bill and Melinda
- 9:29Gates Foundation trust. They hold a massive position in
- 9:31WM. Right, huge.
- 9:33It's one of their core holding over 8% ownership of the
- 9:36company. And they didn't just buy it
- 9:38yesterday, they started building that position over 2 decades ago
- 9:41and have held on. Wow, in the world of long term
- 9:45buy and hold quality investing, that's a pretty serious
- 9:48endorsement. It speaks volumes about how they
- 9:51view the durability and the mode of this business.
- 9:53Absolutely. OK, but let's get to the hard
- 9:55numbers on that checklist. This is where the paradox really
- 9:58comes into focus. Great company, but what about
- 10:01the price? Where does WM pass with flying
- 10:04colors on the? Quality and consistency metrics,
- 10:07they nail it. Just textbook examples like what
- 10:09positive and crucially consistent free cash flow year
- 10:13in year out. The FCF to revenue margin is
- 10:16always well above that 5% benchmark people look for.
- 10:19They've got an amazing unbroken 10 year streak of rising
- 10:22earnings per share. That's consistency.
- 10:24Very impressed. And the returns are strong too.
- 10:27Return on equity averages over 20%, which is really high, shows
- 10:31they made good money on shareholder capital and return
- 10:34on retained earnings. Basically how well management
- 10:36reinvest profits that averages around 16%.
- 10:38Also very good, shows effective compounding.
- 10:41OK. So check, check, check on the
- 10:42quality side. Sounds like a fantastic business
- 10:45machine, but here comes the valuation side.
- 10:48This is where it gets tricky, right?
- 10:49What about price to earnings? Price to book.
- 10:52Yeah, this is where it fails the traditional value tests pretty
- 10:55significantly. How bad is it?
- 10:56The current trailing PE ratio is around 33.66.
- 11:00A conservative value benchmark is often, you know, 15 or less.
- 11:04So it's more than double. And price to.
- 11:06Book also very high, it's about 9.38, again way above
- 11:09traditional value metrics like 1.5 or so.
- 11:12This clearly shows the market is pricing in a lot of optimism,
- 11:16pricing it for perfection essentially.
- 11:18And what about the balance sheet leverage safety ratios?
- 11:21That's another area where it looks less conservative.
- 11:23Debt to equity is getting close to 3 point O, which is quite
- 11:26leveraged. And the current ratio, a measure
- 11:29of short term liquidity, is consistently below one point O,
- 11:32so it fails those traditional safety checks too.
- 11:34OK. So quality A + 1 valuation and
- 11:37safety maybe CRD given that super high market price, what
- 11:42does a discounted cash flow ADCF analysis tell us if we just use
- 11:46their historical growth rate? Right.
- 11:47So we ran ADCF sensitivity using their 10 year historical average
- 11:51free cash flow growth rate, which is a reasonable moderate
- 11:545.5% is the base case OK. 5.5% growth going.
- 11:58Forward. That nominal case gets out an
- 11:59intrinsic value of only $114.53 per share.
- 12:03Wow. $114.53 but the stock is trading over $213.
- 12:09That's a massive gap. How do you explain that?
- 12:11What is the market actually baking into that $213 plus
- 12:14price? Well, it's probably a
- 12:15combination of things. The market is putting a huge
- 12:17premium on that economic mode, the scarcity value of those
- 12:20landfills. They see it as almost permanent,
- 12:22allowing W in to raise prices forever basically.
- 12:25So valuing the asset scarcity itself maybe more than the cash
- 12:28flow growth? That seems to be a big part of
- 12:30it, yeah. Investors are likely pricing it
- 12:32based on the perpetuity of high margins and pricing power, maybe
- 12:36less on the recent historical growth rate.
- 12:39And 2nd, they're almost certainly factoring in much
- 12:41higher growth from that WM Renewable Energy segment.
- 12:44Higher than the historical 5.5% overall FCF growth.
- 12:48Oh, much higher, probably assuming double digit growth
- 12:50from WMRE, believing it's going to become a much bigger driver
- 12:53of cash flow in the future than it is today.
- 12:56So putting it all together, based on the numbers today, if
- 12:58you wanted a conservative margin of safety, say 25% below that
- 13:02calculated intrinsic value. You'd need to see the stock
- 13:05price down near $86 per share. $86 compared to over 200.
- 13:10That really frames the situation.
- 13:11It does. The conclusion seems pretty
- 13:13clear. WM is an exceptionally high
- 13:15quality company, fantastic Moat, great operations, but the market
- 13:19knows it and it's priced at a very substantial premium right
- 13:22now. Finding that margin of safety
- 13:24based on historical cash flows is very difficult today.
- 13:28OK. So let's wrap this up for you,
- 13:29the listener. What's the key take away?
- 13:32Waste management is almost like a utility, but with maybe even
- 13:36better pricing power thanks to those unique assets.
- 13:39Yeah, it's like a blue chip infrastructure play.
- 13:41And it's real strength is that pricing power rooted in those
- 13:44scarce landfills. It lets them keep profits high,
- 13:47hit cash flow targets even when parts of the business like
- 13:50recycling in Q3, face big headwinds.
- 13:52Exactly right. That resilience under pressure
- 13:54is impressive. So the final thought for you to
- 13:57chew on, maybe do some more digging yourself.
- 13:59That global push for a circular economy for less waste, if that
- 14:04really picks up speed, if we actually start decoupling
- 14:07economic growth from trash generation permanently, will
- 14:10that WM renewable energy business scale up fast enough
- 14:14and be profitable enough to make up for the potential long term
- 14:17decline in volume going into their core super profitable
- 14:20landfills? That's the fundamental tension
- 14:22isn't it? The trade off between protecting
- 14:24the old incredibly lucrative mode and scaling up the new
- 14:27strategic hedge. That's the story that will
- 14:29define WMS long term future. A really critical question in
- 14:34need. Well, thank you for walking us
- 14:36through all that. Hopefully everyone listening
- 14:38feels a lot more informed about Waste Management now.
- 14:41My pleasure, always interesting to dive into these kinds of
- 14:43businesses. Absolutely.
- 14:45Just a quick reminder before we go, all the analysis today is
- 14:48based on publicly available information and is for
- 14:51educational purposes only. It's definitely not investment
- 14:54advice. Please do your own research and
- 14:56due diligence before making any investment decisions, right?
- 15:00And if you enjoyed this deep dive and want more, you can find
- 15:03us and subscribe on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
- 15:07Just search for deep value investing.
- 15:09Thanks for tuning in.