Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Kraken’s IPO, Tether’s Power Play, & Why Bitcoin Still Wins
Transcript
- 0:02It all comes down to computers communicating.
- 0:06The information superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps
- 0:09and off ramps. Bitcoin is worthless artificial
- 0:14gold. Is it still rat poison?
- 0:17Probably rat poison squared. We need to get into the world of
- 0:21OK, this is actually foundational.
- 0:23Technology. What the Internet of Money does
- 0:26is it creates a single network which can do a microtransaction
- 0:32to a giga transaction. The Internet is going to be one
- 0:38of the major forces for reducing the role of gun.
- 0:42The one thing that's missing that will soon be developed is a
- 0:46reliable E cash. Hey guys, welcome back to
- 0:52another episode of Final Settlement.
- 0:54This was an exciting and action-packed episode.
- 0:57No shortage of M&A deals and new products and releases in the
- 1:03ecosystem. Quick word from on Ramp, an on
- 1:05ramp business specifically, I'm not sure we've had a chance to
- 1:07share it here. We launched this a few weeks
- 1:10ago, incredibly excited about the product.
- 1:13We announced a case study with a large firm but also really
- 1:17foundational infrastructure needed for businesses across the
- 1:20landscape that are adopting Bitcoin as a treasury reserve
- 1:23asset. Not only is multi institution a
- 1:25superior way to custody the underlying than trusting a
- 1:29single custodian, but then naturally what's existed or what
- 1:32hasn't existed in the digital asset Bitcoin world is
- 1:37governance, access based controls and everything that
- 1:41generally exists in the traditional financial system has
- 1:44not been ported over when it comes to just treasury
- 1:46management of the underlying Bitcoin.
- 1:49And so with honor and business institutions, enterprises get
- 1:53access to multiple users. They get access to creating
- 1:57quorum of quorum so they can decide on who has access to
- 2:01check off or approve a transaction before the
- 2:04withdrawal takes place. And then you get complete audit
- 2:07controls as well as multiple wallets, different quorums,
- 2:11everything that a large scale institution would need.
- 2:14I'm really excited about this announcement.
- 2:16We're starting to onboard publicly traded companies as
- 2:18well as other large institutions.
- 2:20If you want to learn more, I'd encourage you to book a
- 2:22consultation or reach out. All right, on to the episode.
- 2:25I hope you guys enjoy. All righty gentlemen.
- 2:27Welcome back to another episode of Final Settlement.
- 2:31It is Monday, November 24th, 10:40 AM.
- 2:36We missed last week. Apologies to the listeners.
- 2:40The three of us were on the road.
- 2:41We were in Dallas. Maybe we can talk about some
- 2:43takeaways from the Dallas trip later in the show.
- 2:45But we are back, boys. How are we doing?
- 2:48Bitcoins in the shitter. We're in the 80s.
- 2:50What are we going to talk about today?
- 2:53Deals in the week. Bitcoin isn't indeed in the
- 2:56shitter. I'm glad you brought up missing
- 2:58a week. It, it pained my soul.
- 2:59But it was just scheduling. Scheduling was tough.
- 3:03But yeah, we're we're back. Turkey.
- 3:06Turkey Week What? We can.
- 3:09Be thankful for what? We can be thankful for and also
- 3:13how to how to approach the conversation.
- 3:16If you told your boomer uncle to buy Bitcoin last year at the
- 3:19Thanksgiving table, he's down 10%.
- 3:23I looked last Thanksgiving price was around 9697 K.
- 3:29So he's hurt and meanwhile the S&P is up 10%.
- 3:31So how to approach that conversation, how to tell how,
- 3:34how to tell your boomer uncle to zoom out on the price chart?
- 3:37Look, look a little, a little longer than one year, 12 month
- 3:40time frame. But let maybe let's get to the
- 3:43deals. There was a, a big one from last
- 3:45week that we obviously missed because we didn't record.
- 3:49But Kraken has confidentially filed their S1.
- 3:53They're going to go public and they raised 800 million at a $20
- 3:57billion valuation from a number of players, most notably Ken
- 4:01Griffin and Citadel. Maybe I'll hand it to Liam 1st
- 4:04and he'd dug into this a little bit, but what do you make of
- 4:07this latest move on the IPO side?
- 4:11Yeah, I there were rumors about them going public for a while
- 4:16now and I know that they've done some layoffs and and tried to
- 4:20get a little bit fitter. They do publish a lot of their
- 4:22quarterly metrics too. And they've, you know, turned
- 4:25out to be pretty profitable as of recently too.
- 4:28They're they're operating pretty well.
- 4:30It just makes too much sense for the Citadel side just because
- 4:34when you think about crack into and you know, to a lesser extent
- 4:38some of these other exchanges, they do a lot of volume,
- 4:42especially of some of these are less liquid tokens as well.
- 4:47And they've really stepped up their game on the derivative
- 4:50side. Citadel does a great job of
- 4:53getting and aggregating all the different information in order
- 4:56to have a competitive edge versus everybody else.
- 4:59And this is a little bit scary almost because especially if
- 5:04you're in the crypto space and a trader, just because seeing
- 5:08somebody like Citadel stepping in and having all the
- 5:10information just like the did it with Robin Hood is just going to
- 5:14allow them to kind of wipe the floor with all those kind of day
- 5:18traders and crypto traders out there.
- 5:21But it's, you know, to be expected as more and more people
- 5:24come into the space. It's a relatively low lift way.
- 5:27It doesn't even matter necessarily if they make their
- 5:30money on the Kraken deal in particular over the long term,
- 5:33just because a firm like this is going to make it all back and
- 5:37information and asymmetry and how they play the game over a
- 5:40long time for him. And so that's why all these
- 5:43strategic investors who are somewhat strategic would pay
- 5:46massive premiums for these businesses as well.
- 5:50Yeah, I think there's a lot to, you know, the Citadel play.
- 5:55I think Citadel is a mate. I don't want to speak, but I
- 5:58think they're a major investor into Robin Hood.
- 6:02Is that right, Liam? I don't know that for sure, but
- 6:06I do know that they get all the information flow from Robin
- 6:09Hood. Too well, that's what they get
- 6:11the the app for. But either way, Citadel, I
- 6:17believe we'll check in real time and come back.
- 6:21But the the main point was there's or the main point I
- 6:25wanted to make was that there's not a lot of assets in this
- 6:27space. And specifically when you look
- 6:30at derivative traders or derivative trading firms coupled
- 6:34with all coin markets, the historical large liquidity
- 6:38providers like the finances buy bit, buy bits of the world are
- 6:42outside of the US And you look at one of the largest or the
- 6:46largest option trading firm, which was what who did Coinbase
- 6:52buy a dare bit. So you look at that market and
- 6:58if you're looking to get exposure into the space, whether
- 7:00it's from, you know, digital assets, you're looking at
- 7:04derivatives, you're looking at anything that's going to
- 7:06orchestrate stable coins. I think Kraken just came out
- 7:10last week with AB to B to C solution, which is very popular
- 7:14across the industry because ultimately, a lot of that flow
- 7:18passes through the market makers at these firms.
- 7:20And so the way they monetize is if you can plug in and leverage
- 7:23their infrastructure as a service via money transmission
- 7:26licenses and then they take up apps on that spread.
- 7:30And so I look at that into Liam's point.
- 7:32There's a lot of downside protection.
- 7:34They're going to IPO. That was obviously part of these
- 7:36discussions because right after the investment, it's kind of a
- 7:40crazy amount of capital to be invested.
- 7:42I think it was close to 800 million and Citadel came up with
- 7:4525% of that. It's a very interesting dynamic.
- 7:50The interesting part about Kraken is that they've been
- 7:55around for a while. They have a very unique and tied
- 7:58relationship with Silicon Valley being based there.
- 8:01The CEO and Co founder was formerly at Social Capital,
- 8:05which is Chamoth's venture firm. I think it still exists now he
- 8:09runs Tribe Capital. Then he stepped in to be CEO.
- 8:12So they're, they have very high like not only 10 year acumen,
- 8:16but backers. And so they're an interesting
- 8:19play. But the counter to all of this
- 8:21is that there's not a lot of sophisticated institutions that
- 8:23leverage Kraken. You most flow is going to go to
- 8:26like a Coinbase. And then if you're outside of
- 8:28the US, you're going to finance and there's some intermediaries
- 8:32in between like a Cumberland. But this really feels like you
- 8:36have to make a play. There's only so many assets
- 8:38Coinbase has already spoken for, and that's where Kraken has been
- 8:41able to command a King's ransom. Yeah, I think that's exactly
- 8:44right. The obviously Coinbase is is
- 8:47spoken forward to a certain extent already public etcetera.
- 8:52So there you know, there aren't a lot of options to your point
- 8:55in terms of either partnering with or investing in crypto
- 8:59native infrastructure where there's distribution.
- 9:03And really, you know, what's stuck out to me is what what
- 9:06Liam, you alluded to around just the, the parallel or similarity
- 9:09to their relationship with a Robin Hood where they want to
- 9:13see that overflow, they want to see the data.
- 9:15And so I, I just looked this up in real time.
- 9:17So does not actually have an equity stake in Robin Hood.
- 9:20So it is just a partnership and they're their largest market
- 9:25maker. So no direct equity stake there.
- 9:27But yeah, it feels similar to that in the sense that you want
- 9:31to get closer to the data, you want to get closer to the
- 9:34underlying clients and that order flow.
- 9:36And so it doesn't make sense from that perspective, just
- 9:39given there's not a lot of assets out there to acquire that
- 9:42that have that those qualities or those assets underneath them.
- 9:45So it makes sense. Yeah, and Kraken too is is no
- 9:48scrub. Like they published their
- 9:51financial data and their assets on the platform is just under 60
- 9:56billion and Adjusted EBITDA last quarter is almost 200 million.
- 10:01So they've gotten super fit, have gone from negative to like
- 10:06pretty positive Adjusted EBITDA. And, you know, being able to
- 10:09monetize all that information flow and assets on the platform
- 10:14is definitely something that, you know, others are looking at
- 10:17is is a big player and just the brand and the fact that they
- 10:19haven't, you know, blown up is a way that, you know, lends some
- 10:24sort of credibility to them. Platform yeah that is something
- 10:27worth calling out the longevity and Lindy being around since I
- 10:30think I believe around Mount Cox time.
- 10:32I will say that I'd be very curious on some of those numbers
- 10:36when you think about like the Billings and assets on how many
- 10:41are illiquid tokens, right, Because that's an easy like
- 10:44that's the knock is that crack. It is not looked at as an
- 10:48institutional partner. They have the specifically
- 10:52around custody. They have the license in
- 10:55Wyoming. I forget the speedy and they do
- 10:57have an institutional arm there, but it's understood that there's
- 11:00not a lot of capital specifically when it relates to
- 11:02Bitcoin and a blue chip like that.
- 11:05No other assets TBD, but that's a big component of it.
- 11:09And then when you look at the revenue, you think about like
- 11:12it's very similar to like the trading revenue or the trading
- 11:15volume on a lot of these assets and where they're making their
- 11:17money in the flow and who they're passing it back to,
- 11:21especially given what we know about Gemini.
- 11:23Not to say that they're the same, but like last year was a
- 11:26very interesting year in the market when it comes to how many
- 11:28net new buyers were stepping in and where they like revenue came
- 11:31from. But either way, I think like
- 11:34we're saying that the the aspect, the last aspect I would
- 11:38like add to it is that there's not a lot of blue chip assets,
- 11:41but then also there's nothing really that looks
- 11:43differentiated. And so you start to see these
- 11:45privies, these bridges, the cracking acquisitions, they're
- 11:48going to play towards the volume and the speculation when it
- 11:52comes to the the markets, what is like the polymarket and
- 12:01Calcis of the world. But there's not really long
- 12:04standing businesses looking to help people preserve their
- 12:07wealth, educate them and grow it over time.
- 12:09And so we expect that as the asset, you know, Bitcoin goes
- 12:12until you all time highs and grows.
- 12:14That's really where the Citadel's and maybe it's not
- 12:16citadel, but other large financial institutions are going
- 12:19to look at like who's closest to the unblind and who's closest to
- 12:22custody in it and offering financial services, the
- 12:24monetization that wrap around the monetization of Bitcoin.
- 12:27We're just so early in like traffic by stepping in.
- 12:29They're still looking at the like fast moving volume.
- 12:32What are the Robin Hoods of the crypto world?
- 12:34They're not looking at wait, where are the smart money
- 12:37putting their Bitcoin? And that's where we see a lot of
- 12:39the big opportunity, at least for us and what we're investing
- 12:41in. Yeah, it's a really good point
- 12:43because if you have basically a longer term view on the
- 12:48underlying, IE Bitcoin relative to all of these other
- 12:51cryptocurrencies, then you build in a different way.
- 12:54You build products and services in a different way.
- 12:55That maps more to a long duration holding as opposed to
- 12:59this high frequency trading in and out of all these coins that
- 13:03are super far out the risk curve.
- 13:05Like it is just a different mental model of, like you said,
- 13:09getting closer to the underlying, but the underlying
- 13:11actually being the long standing sort of long duration asset that
- 13:15is Bitcoin as this sort of reserve asset, this digital
- 13:19sound money. So it's just a very different
- 13:22set of products and services that people need to basically
- 13:25have a financial plan around that asset that is a long term
- 13:29allocation. It's just very different from
- 13:31trading in and out of XYZ new protocol, new new shit coin.
- 13:36So I think that that that we're in the very early days of of
- 13:39those learnings. But maybe related to this one
- 13:42was another deal that was one of the bigger ones from last week
- 13:47and similar. And, and I say it's similar in
- 13:49the sense that, you know, Michael, to your point, like
- 13:51there aren't a lot of assets out there in terms of crypto native,
- 13:54native exchanges or even lenders in this case.
- 13:57So this is tether making a strategic investment in Leaden.
- 14:02Leaden's been around for a while as a lender in the space.
- 14:09I think earlier this year they sort of ceased support for other
- 14:13assets. So I believe now they are
- 14:15actually Bitcoin only focused firm.
- 14:18But just think this was interesting just given sort of
- 14:21Tether becoming this behemoth, not only in terms of their
- 14:24reserve assets and sort of stranglehold on on stablecoin
- 14:27market, but now making these strategic investments into other
- 14:30infrastructure and other players in the space.
- 14:32So what do you guys think about this one?
- 14:37Yeah, I'm happy to jump in. I think Heather likely is trying
- 14:42to make a move as one of their bigger lenders on the lending
- 14:47side. And so there's probably, if I
- 14:50would have assumed like they just negotiated their way into
- 14:53being able to have some sort of upside of based on the amount of
- 14:57capital that they bring to let in or just like a small equity
- 15:02stake. Because, you know, if letting is
- 15:04profitable, as they say they are, that it doesn't necessarily
- 15:07make sense to raise outside capital unless you really think
- 15:11of some strategic way. And I think that the lending
- 15:13side is is enough. But I think it makes sense, a
- 15:17ton of sense for Tether to just to get closer to the underlying
- 15:22both where the custody is a lot of them is institutional
- 15:27partners on the Latin side and just the similar to what we
- 15:30talked about with crack And it's both the information flow of,
- 15:34you know, when our clients actually getting liquidated, if
- 15:37at all. Like, does it seem like very
- 15:39frothy? Are they are a lot of people
- 15:41taking out loans and then maybe Tether would slow their
- 15:44acquisitions of of Bitcoin or are there, you know, more
- 15:49liquidations at the moment and maybe it's a a better time to
- 15:52step in? And then, you know, Tether
- 15:54obviously does a lot on as being trading pair for Bitcoin all
- 15:58across the world. So I think it it just makes more
- 16:01than it just makes so much sense for Tether to, you know, get
- 16:05more involved here. But it also just speaks to the
- 16:08limited amount of number of large players out there and just
- 16:12the fact that you want to be close to both the information as
- 16:15well as all the businesses that are, you know, creating
- 16:18different products and services out there.
- 16:21Yeah. I think the common theme with
- 16:24all of this is there's only so many relevant or reputable
- 16:27assets. There's only so many lenders
- 16:30that exist in North America that institutional or high net worth
- 16:35would go to. That's been around.
- 16:37Again, at the end of the day, you're going to want somebody
- 16:39regulated license human you can speak to in this world.
- 16:44And so tethers naturally making their play over the past year
- 16:47publicly across the world bets in Bitcoin and around Bitcoin
- 16:52adjacent industries. There's natural exposure into
- 16:55the market as it grows, letting right for acquisition.
- 16:58So from an investment perspective, they can get the
- 17:00return, but then also they have excess amount of dollars parked
- 17:04with them and if they're able to generate something over the
- 17:07nominal fed funds rate or the interest rate on treasuries to
- 17:11park it to lower the cost of capital for let in.
- 17:14So it makes complete sense. I think it'll be interesting to
- 17:19see where I mean, the last part is just really like the notion
- 17:23of international companies trying to get exposure.
- 17:27We talked about Tether launching USAT in the US and potentially
- 17:33North America. There's just a reality that you
- 17:35need to get people evangelizing, advocating for Tether.
- 17:41You need to be in there to be able to access Tether when you
- 17:43take a loan out. There's a lot of strategic
- 17:45reasons. There's not many lenders.
- 17:47So yeah, I think it makes it makes complete sense.
- 17:50Maybe a question for you guys that comes to my mind is like,
- 17:54you know, why, why couldn't or why wouldn't Tether just build
- 17:58out a lending business themselves?
- 17:59Like why would they go this route of investing in a leaden
- 18:06instead of just building it out themselves in some sense, right?
- 18:08Like I think. Well, there's two, there's two
- 18:11big angles there. One is it's kind of the notion
- 18:17of do you want to lend out a billion dollars or do you want
- 18:19to lend out $100 billion? And it obviously being a little
- 18:23hyperbolic, but then if they set up a lending desk, well then you
- 18:27look competitive to other forces.
- 18:30So there's that, But then the other aspect of it is the
- 18:35scalability of generally lending licenses depending on where
- 18:39you're based are required. And then there's the
- 18:41operational, it's, it's highly operational intensive because
- 18:46you know when you get into these margin call areas, you have
- 18:49desks that are usually stood up overnight.
- 18:51Even if they say they automate it, you still have to have some
- 18:53human component because you're looking at where their other
- 18:56assets are sitting. And so you add operational
- 19:00complexity, which others, you know, pride themselves on being
- 19:02lean. But then you also just add the,
- 19:04the aspect of Leaden has a desk there.
- 19:06Well, maybe in Latin America, Canada, North America, people
- 19:09are less prone or open to them getting involved and seen under
- 19:13the hood on the growth versus just being the the underlying
- 19:17partner for them. Yeah, yeah, 100% agree.
- 19:21It's just like, I think they just primarily want to focus on
- 19:25their core area and like they're doing so many different things.
- 19:28They could probably be the best gold custodian if they wanted to
- 19:31in the world and the best gold lender.
- 19:33But it's just like I think that they want to focus on doing
- 19:37investments in that space rather than making that the core
- 19:40business sign. Because the further that you get
- 19:43out of, you know, being the stable coin issuer, the less
- 19:47strategic competitive advantage. Now you can necessarily as they
- 19:51get to larger and larger scale, do essentially the Microsoft
- 19:54play and you know, run businesses at negative gross
- 19:57margins for long enough to bleed your company, your competitors
- 20:02dry and then you're the only player in the space.
- 20:05And then you can, you know, pretty much command whatever
- 20:07type of margin you want, but I just don't necessarily see them
- 20:10doing that right now especially, but you know, converting USDT
- 20:14over to USAT, they probably just have a lot of other things on
- 20:16their plate. Yep, that all makes sense.
- 20:21All right, through other deals to get to, I'm going to pop
- 20:24through a few. Liam, you brought this one.
- 20:27I've never heard of this company.
- 20:28Lighter raises 68,000,000 at a $1.5 billion valuation as VC
- 20:33bets flood back into Perptex infrastructure.
- 20:36What does light lighter do and and why might this be relevant?
- 20:41Yeah. I just brought this up because
- 20:43it's pretty much a lot of what we've been talking about just
- 20:46getting further and further away from the underlying asset and
- 20:49focusing on essentially things that don't have a lot of staying
- 20:55power and value in the long term.
- 20:56I don't know necessarily why perp Dexes are bringing a lot of
- 21:02value to the end consumer and just seeing founders fund Reba
- 21:06capital, really large VC in the space, just looking at
- 21:12everything under the sun other than Bitcoin itself just kind of
- 21:15shows how early we are. And like, regardless of you
- 21:19know, all of those blow UPS that you see by some of these other,
- 21:23you know, everything in the crypto space, I just don't
- 21:26necessarily see quite as much demand for these types of things
- 21:30long term. And the just the numbers are
- 21:34staggering because I'd never heard of lighter before and
- 21:36raising at 1 1/2 billion with $68 million valuation.
- 21:41The only plausible move that I can see is that they launched
- 21:44some sort of token and these guys get some sort of insider
- 21:50scoop on it. Otherwise, just looking at this
- 21:53deal it it kind of makes no sense and just brought it to my
- 21:56attention or brought it to attention because there's just a
- 22:01lot of the industry that's focused on the wrong metrics and
- 22:04wrong types of businesses in my deal.
- 22:07Yeah. I mean, the chart up on the
- 22:08screen now shows, I think you know, from their perspective why
- 22:13they would be interested in in a deal like this.
- 22:15Because you know, if you are thinking about what are other
- 22:19crypto block chains or platforms being used for today, it's high
- 22:23frequency gambling style bets, whether that's options,
- 22:26derivatives, perpetuals, etcetera.
- 22:28You can see the growth on this chart of of, you know, the the
- 22:32largest ones here are hybrid liquid and Aster, which is a
- 22:35newer entrant. But there has been growth in
- 22:37this area. And part of that speaks to what
- 22:39you know, we've talked about on on past episodes around just the
- 22:43nihilism of generally younger generations who don't feel like
- 22:46they can get ahead. So they are more prone to look
- 22:49towards gambling or higher risk bets to try to make money.
- 22:54Very short term thinking, generally speaking.
- 22:57But I think if I'm just putting myself in the shoes of these,
- 23:01these PC firms, whether they're crypto native or or trat 5 ECS
- 23:06like this is where you know, if you're looking for like actual
- 23:09on chain activity on these other protocols, like it is on the
- 23:12perpetual side, it is on the more gambling oriented stuff.
- 23:16So it is, it does seem just like they're chasing that puck,
- 23:19which, yeah, it's not great, but can see why.
- 23:22Yeah, I would make the case this is like one of the only
- 23:24investable areas because there's two aspects of this.
- 23:28And before even this chart being pulled up, I just thought about
- 23:30hyper liquid. When people look at hyper Liquid
- 23:32and the success it's had and the volume and revenue it's been
- 23:36generating, the obvious and only real use case for crypto is
- 23:40speculation. So you take that, it's my
- 23:43understanding from traders that perpetual futures are a better
- 23:46product than traditional futures because of the funding
- 23:48mechanism. And just like there's some other
- 23:50aspects to it where that's coming to equities.
- 23:54And so those products are generally crypto native.
- 23:56So you're going to need crypto native firms to build them.
- 23:59And then not only do they generate revenue because the
- 24:00volume, but then and velocity, but also they'll be right for
- 24:05acquisitions because like if Schwab or anybody if this is
- 24:07where the market's heading 12's not building out perpetual
- 24:10futures products. And so that's really where the
- 24:13acquisition, acquisitions would come from.
- 24:16But anyway. Yeah, that's a great point on
- 24:19the exit side. All right, here's another one.
- 24:24Obex Incubator, a $337 million incubator by Sky Ecosystem, Hive
- 24:30Framework and Layer Zero to fund stablecoin innovators and enable
- 24:33Sky to deploy 2.5 billion in USDS to selected projects.
- 24:38Yeah. Do you bring this one, Michael?
- 24:40Yeah, I thought it was interesting mainly because I
- 24:41think it's a, it's a fascinating format.
- 24:44There was a a couple aspects of this.
- 24:45So they raised $37,000,000 to effectively create some kind of
- 24:49like studio incubator flat platform to for people wanting
- 24:54to build stable coins with some kind of like real world like
- 24:58yield. And I think it's really
- 25:01interesting because I do think there's going to be other stable
- 25:04coins that will generate interest, whether they're US
- 25:07based or outside that will have other backings.
- 25:11So won't be necessarily like the one to one with the treasuries
- 25:14because I think that's embedded in the genius bill or like post
- 25:17it. They'll be other kind of
- 25:18mechanics on what's allowed and not allowed.
- 25:21And I do think like something like this would be interesting
- 25:23on a Bitcoin basis because there will be other formats to, again,
- 25:29we talk about like free banking and for issuers to create stable
- 25:33coins backed by Bitcoin, maybe other assets.
- 25:35How does that look? I thought that was the the
- 25:38biggest part. The other one that I didn't
- 25:39realize is Sky is a rebrand of Maker Dow, I believe.
- 25:44So that's the the aspect and they're kind of Sky's
- 25:46interesting or maker Dow is interesting because that was one
- 25:48of the first, not first kind of like algorithmic stable coins.
- 25:52Obviously it was backed by like Aetherium that has its own
- 25:55issues. But anyway, that was mainly the
- 25:57the thing to call out there. Yeah, it is very interesting.
- 26:01There's this whole dynamic around the stablecoin stuff
- 26:04where, you know, in an ideal world you hold a stablecoin and
- 26:09it, you know, bears some interest or yield as would a,
- 26:12you know, as if you were to holding AUS treasury bond, which
- 26:15is backing of these things. Now with the Genius Act passing,
- 26:19basically, you know, that piece of legislation has effectively
- 26:24ring fenced the ability to provide the yield so that
- 26:27underlying treasury yield to the stable coin holders.
- 26:30But it does seem like, you know, there are there's basically Gray
- 26:33areas surrounding that ring fence of effectively loopholes
- 26:37around like is it a reward? You know, if you call it
- 26:39something other than the US Treasury yield and it's some
- 26:43form of reward or maybe, you know, you're saving some other
- 26:47token as a a yield. So I think there's going to be a
- 26:50lot of this type of stuff where people are experimenting around
- 26:54the edges of how do we actually create competitive advantages or
- 26:59dynamics for, you know, our new XYZ stable coin.
- 27:03And I think a lot of that competition is going to come
- 27:06from these Gray areas around the loopholes around rewards versus
- 27:10yield, etcetera. So I think this is sort of
- 27:12foreshadowing out of it. Have you guys seen what slash is
- 27:16doing? No.
- 27:19They are, they're essentially a bank that's stablecoin first and
- 27:24they just hit 150 million in ARR within two years.
- 27:29They offer consumers rewards in terms of 2% of the stablecoin
- 27:34rewards that are passed back to their consumers.
- 27:37They seem to like get a start by like doing sneaker sales, like
- 27:41sneaker reselling stuff, but have really seemed to make a big
- 27:46indent within like kind of the startup and founder community
- 27:49and have gotten to an amazing like 150 million in AR within
- 27:55two years is pretty impressive to see.
- 27:57I don't know what the actual business model looks like in on
- 28:00the inside. I just put put a link in the
- 28:03chat, but seeing something like that just like shows how much
- 28:09demand there is for just better movement of money as well as the
- 28:13actual holding on to some funds on the other side.
- 28:15So I don't know what this looks like in the end, but there are
- 28:19definitely going to be people who you know, do more on this.
- 28:22It seems like it was built on like base.
- 28:26Interesting. Yeah, I hadn't heard of this
- 28:28one. Moving along, there was another
- 28:34raise here, not sure who brought this one, but Dopple raises 70
- 28:39million Series C to outpace social engineering attacks led
- 28:42by Bessemer Venture Partners. The round focus or follows 3X
- 28:46increase in valuation in six months and adds new investors
- 28:48including Crowdstrikes George Kurtz.
- 28:51Hey, everybody. Hope you're joining the episode.
- 28:53Lots of interesting dialogue going on this week around
- 28:57stablecoins, AI and a lot of the M&A activity that's happening in
- 29:00the industry. Quick word from on Ramp and
- 29:03specifically around our inheritance product.
- 29:06We have no shortage of net new clients and existing clients
- 29:09that came over to on Ramp specifically because of
- 29:11inheritance. We've all been in this current
- 29:13situation where generally Bitcoin is male dominated.
- 29:17Our significant others are perfectly fine with us
- 29:19allocating or even over allocating depending on who you
- 29:22are to the asset. But they also don't want any
- 29:25exposure have to deal with management of private keys, what
- 29:29to do if something happens to the individual harbor to see
- 29:32phrases, all the things that account for self custody.
- 29:36And so while clients sometimes feel perfectly fine with self
- 29:39custody for themselves, it really comes to legacy planning,
- 29:42whether it's with inheritance, the dynasty trust release that
- 29:45we had. Inheritance comes with every
- 29:47product and every multi institution account included
- 29:50with also insurance Iras and trade.
- 29:53But inheritance is the thing that I want to call out simply
- 29:55because as the price appreciates, as we get older, we
- 30:00start to recognize that we have to legacy plan, we have to be
- 30:03more mature with this asset and so on.
- 30:06RIP really provides Peace of Mind there.
- 30:08Even if you're not necessarily ready for something like on
- 30:10Room, but you want to learn more how we solve for that and some
- 30:13of the other, you know, financial products we offer.
- 30:15As Bitcoin naturally matures, it needs serious products and
- 30:18solutions. I'd encourage you to book time
- 30:20or you can reach out to me directly, Michael, at
- 30:22honor@bitcoin.com. We're actually piloting out some
- 30:24flat reduced base pricing that we're testing out this quarter
- 30:28and we'll go into 2026 with. If you'd like to opt into
- 30:31something like that, reach out and we'll share more.
- 30:33All right, hope you enjoy the rest of the episode.
- 30:35Yeah. I thought this was fascinating
- 30:36because there's a component of crypto or digital assets, but
- 30:40it's really related across the Internet.
- 30:42I don't fully know how they integrate this, but there's a
- 30:47notion of like human risk management that they site across
- 30:51different tooling, whether it's fintechs, AI, obviously digital
- 30:55assets. Having a bearer instrument that
- 30:58can be stolen or socially engineered is like one of the
- 31:00prime use cases for how do you mitigate bad actors,
- 31:03specifically around social engineering, AI, deepfakes.
- 31:07And I expect to see more of more and more of this get integrated
- 31:12Now, I still, I've seen different firms like this pop up
- 31:15and there's it's really like ephemeral, you can't touch in
- 31:18the way that they mitigate it. So there's an angle of like
- 31:21executives at a company where they put higher like thresholds
- 31:26and hygiene around how they manage, you know, their digital
- 31:29presence and maybe even some of their like permissions when they
- 31:32set up their passwords. So I don't necessarily know how
- 31:34much of it is like actual AI proprietary software versus like
- 31:39client services and implementation, but I just
- 31:42expect to see more and more of this.
- 31:44We're just not prepared as a society to deal with the
- 31:47Internet and specifically AI. We see all day long these
- 31:50pictures, It's kind of crazy. The past like 2 weeks, I think
- 31:52it's Gemini or whoever's new implementation that you can like
- 31:55insert your picture next to somebody else.
- 31:58And so I just expect to see more on both sides to combat the
- 32:02losses that will happen in the Canary is generally digital
- 32:05assets because it's the easiest to steal.
- 32:07But then you can imagine the social engineering will continue
- 32:10across to different, you know, podcast groups that, you know,
- 32:14you throw something else that's looks like it's that person, but
- 32:17it's not actually them. There's all this content out
- 32:19there. So that that was interesting.
- 32:21And $70 million is a pretty large amount of capital to be
- 32:24invested. Yeah, this is, this is certainly
- 32:28interesting. This is a real risk that, you
- 32:30know, we talk a lot about just in terms of the sort of unique
- 32:34custodial characteristics of digital bear assets and how you
- 32:38need to protect against not only physical threats, but really
- 32:42increasingly these digital social engineering attacks.
- 32:45And, and really, you know, why this is such a large issue, at
- 32:49least in my mind. And, and where most of this
- 32:52occurs is on, you know, single counterparty exchanges like a
- 32:55coin base, where a scammer or a hacker will impersonate the
- 33:01customer support reps of a coin base or another wallet provider
- 33:06or an exchange. And they will say, you know,
- 33:08something's happened to your account.
- 33:09And in order to protect you, I basically need your credentials.
- 33:13And once the individual, the end client hands over those
- 33:17credentials willingly, even though they're being socially
- 33:20engineered, basically they've, they've given up any recourse.
- 33:23And so that's, that's the really sort of insidious part about
- 33:26these types of attacks is because Coinbase basically can
- 33:29wipe their hands clean of it because the end client actually
- 33:32agreed effectively to give up their credentials that allowed
- 33:36their, you know, their account or their wallet to just be
- 33:38wiped, you know, immediately. And so it's a real problem and
- 33:43it's only going to accelerate from here, as you mentioned,
- 33:45Michael, with the onset of AI, deepfakes, etcetera, just really
- 33:50adding tools to the arsenal of these types of attackers from a
- 33:55technology standpoint. And so this is interesting to
- 33:57see, like you said, like it's, it's hard to suss out like how
- 34:00exactly they're going about this, whether it's proprietary
- 34:02tech or it's more just manual in terms of like putting more
- 34:07layers and redundancies in place in order to move funds like
- 34:12that. Ultimately, you know, I think,
- 34:14you know, when, when we think about what we do on, on the on
- 34:16our side with multi institutional custody, it's
- 34:18really this idea of like, it should be difficult to move
- 34:20these assets ultimately. And so you should, you should
- 34:23have multiple layers of redundancy that protect you
- 34:27against the assets moving quickly because they are
- 34:29digitally native and their assets, they can be moved
- 34:32quickly. And that's part of why these
- 34:33attacks are so frequent at the coin bases of the world, because
- 34:36they don't have those sort of layers that make it more
- 34:38difficult to move. Yeah, and there there's a real
- 34:41barbell problem here. I don't pretend to have the
- 34:44exact solution, but like when you think about it, you can
- 34:47either change like the logic and ROI of violence by building the
- 34:52right products and services that would cost more for social
- 34:58engineering and more thought. And so then you keep people from
- 35:00focusing on your business. When you think about what multi
- 35:03institution provides not only from like video verifications to
- 35:06additional logic to additional authentication methods all the
- 35:09way to offline, you know, signing versus the other side.
- 35:13What Brian's referencing the finances, Coinbase's large
- 35:15institutions, what one of the solutions that they provide is
- 35:20really like canvassing the Internet and looking for like
- 35:24different levels of phishing related to that website.
- 35:27So whether it's spinning up a website that looks like a domain
- 35:29that's similar to Coinbase to the different types of emails
- 35:32that you get. And then really helping police
- 35:35that and send out emails and try to get them down if they're
- 35:37especially threat, like various other reputable sites that
- 35:40somehow got, you know, corrupted or however they were to push
- 35:45those links out. But the problem is to to Brian's
- 35:48point, like that's especially in the age of AI that is continuing
- 35:52to grow. And so it's like a whack A mole.
- 35:54And and so there's a we'll see how it plays out, but my
- 35:58instincts tell me the way you change that is at the product
- 36:00level, because when you at the product level, if you make it
- 36:02really hard for those assets to be lost or stolen, well, then
- 36:05bad actors are going to go to the lower hanging fruit.
- 36:09And that's really where we think about like multi institution
- 36:11from a market structure perspective, even from being
- 36:13able to steal somebody's assets, generally people know that you
- 36:16have like 1° of movement, whether the hardware device sits
- 36:19in your house or you can authenticate with one
- 36:22institution. So people target.
- 36:24I think it was like this past week, there was like 3 different
- 36:26crazy events that happened with kidnappings and ransoms that
- 36:32happened with people in digital assets.
- 36:34But that starts to become less and less likely when you know
- 36:36that there's an actual process around the movement of those
- 36:39assets. And so we're still so early and
- 36:41this is going to be the key part for like the fidelities and
- 36:44large institutions of the world because they're just not
- 36:45prepared for that because that's just not how they manage and
- 36:47have built their businesses. So I do think they'll be more
- 36:50and more needs for like firms like this.
- 36:51And it'll be interesting to see how they grow with kind of like
- 36:53as the attack vectors grow. Very well said.
- 37:00Maybe switching gears a little bit.
- 37:03Michael, you brought this one with the caption, your chain is
- 37:06my chain. Do you want to elaborate on what
- 37:09you meant by that? There was basically some issues
- 37:12with Cardano this past weekend and the FBI was somehow
- 37:15involved. Yeah.
- 37:17So, I mean, I, I'd heard about this and then it popped up.
- 37:22Basically somebody leveraged some AI tooling on and I don't
- 37:28know exactly the implementation method, but it, it created AI
- 37:32want to say a double spend on Cardano's validator set.
- 37:37So Cardano has its own node infrastructure.
- 37:40And whatever happened, there was a like split between some of the
- 37:44validators were picking up the traditional change or the the
- 37:48chain that should have existed. And then another one had some
- 37:50kind of like level of spend that corrupted it and nobody knew
- 37:54what was going on. And so it effectively had a
- 37:56halt. The exchanges had a halt trading
- 38:00and it was I believe like a relatively low cost effort to do
- 38:05what they did. But it ultimately shows that
- 38:07this is the ability or susceptible to any blockchain,
- 38:10any crypto currencies because of their lack of decentralization.
- 38:14Cardano was just the natural first one for it to happen to a
- 38:18recent one. In this, they try to like hide
- 38:21that Hoskinson reaches out to the FBI and that this was a one
- 38:26off and the guy that did it or who was behind it said he didn't
- 38:29know. But when you read in this
- 38:31article, they basically explain how they did this on test net
- 38:34before they actually implemented on the the main protocol.
- 38:38Like so this was coordinated. So anyway, I think that the real
- 38:43angle here is that a, you can roll back these chains, a you
- 38:46can double spend. And ultimately, whether they're
- 38:49proof of work or proof of stake, there's not enough hash rate or
- 38:53decentralization, So you can effectively change the Ledger.
- 38:58And when you do that, a it's proving that just notion of
- 39:02fundamentals, but then also you end up with these things where
- 39:05it shows that you can turn them off, you can revert them.
- 39:08And this is effectively all crypto currencies and block
- 39:10chains, including like tempo and everything else.
- 39:13And so I thought it was just good to highlight because I know
- 39:15we talked about all this stuff and it seems like either for I
- 39:18know there's definitely people listening that are like long
- 39:21other crypto assets or maybe think like, well, you know,
- 39:24close minded curmungeons, Luddites.
- 39:27The other crypto has some value. It's just like it doesn't
- 39:29because fundamentally it does not have it doesn't have the
- 39:33fundamentals required to be decentralized.
- 39:35And this was just the most recent example.
- 39:37And this is a cryptocurrency that's existed for eight years.
- 39:39So I mean, and that's been out in the wild for a while.
- 39:41Imagine another cryptocurrency that's relatively new.
- 39:45So yeah. Yeah, no, it's, I'm glad you
- 39:48brought this because it really is a sort of textbook example of
- 39:53when we talk about this notion of decentralization theater like
- 39:57this is a just a perfect example of it.
- 40:00And when things actually do breakdown, you, you start to see
- 40:04where those vectors of centralization actually reside.
- 40:08And just to add a few more details to this.
- 40:09So this is. This is the Twitter thread of
- 40:11the guy who actually did the exploit explaining the exploit.
- 40:15Basically saying sorry Cardano folks, it was me who endangered
- 40:18the network with my careless actions yesterday.
- 40:21It started off as a let's see if I can reproduce the Brad
- 40:23transaction personal challenge and then I was dumb enough to
- 40:25rely on AI instructions and how to block traffic.
- 40:28So basically he vibe coded this exploit.
- 40:32A few other details from this. This was some of Nick Carter's
- 40:36thoughts on it. A chain split between two node
- 40:38versions in which one of the forks has to be later discarded.
- 40:42Discarded is downtime because a exchanges wallets have to stop
- 40:46accepting processing transactions which occurred, if
- 40:49not, they're vulnerable to double spends and B if you
- 40:52transacted on the poison chain, your transactions will be
- 40:54discarded which equals downtime as well.
- 40:56The network is effectively down during a chain split situation
- 40:59even if block production continues.
- 41:02And then he said, regardless, a single amateur using AI to
- 41:05create a poison transaction, creating incompatibility between
- 41:09different nodes implementations is notable because it shows the
- 41:11extreme fragility of a major network.
- 41:14And yeah, I, I think last I checked, like Cardano's market
- 41:18cap is still like $20 billion, which is just insane to think
- 41:23about. But yeah, the real take away
- 41:25here is this is just a great example of, of decentralization
- 41:29theater. And when shit hit, the shit hits
- 41:31the fan. We can halt the chain.
- 41:33We we can make changes and you start to see those vectors of of
- 41:39centralization appear. Yeah.
- 41:41And and where this is really important to call out is it's
- 41:45always sad when you see really well run large multi decade over
- 41:50sometimes 100 year old financial institutions adopting crypto
- 41:54currencies because on a long enough time horizon, this is at
- 41:57the the end state. Like if you think about these
- 42:00assets accumulating 20 billion, 40 billion, sixty, eighty 100
- 42:04billion market cap and you think about a global competition for
- 42:10corrupting, stealing, like what happens when North Koreans, bad
- 42:14actors, wherever they are, are looking to do these kind of
- 42:17exploits because there's a larger bounty.
- 42:19And then if you're a large institution that's offering
- 42:22Salon or these other cryptocurrencies and you have a
- 42:24sizable weight behind your marketing engine and client base
- 42:27exposed to them and they wake up and realize this can happen or
- 42:31worse, they lose assets. What does that do to your brand
- 42:34and reputation? So this fundamentally goes back
- 42:36to the thesis of not only building and investing around
- 42:39this one asset that is the market and everything else is
- 42:42just hiding around it, generating some money generally
- 42:45for the venture capitalists and founders that are able to, you
- 42:48know, take secondaries and take private capital back into their
- 42:51personal accounts. This really is just on a lot of
- 42:53times and where all of this goes.
- 42:55But everyone just it's the same thing as like bond V negative
- 42:58yield. And nobody talks about it
- 43:00because the system is used to perpetrating or propagating that
- 43:03we're, you know, we can't because our existing businesses
- 43:06are heavily indexed to bonds or it's just not part of the common
- 43:10sentiment yet that we can say. And so this is just a real great
- 43:13example of it. It's funny that Nick's calling
- 43:15out because like, these guys invest in crypto currencies and
- 43:17there's what what makes Cardona any different than like any
- 43:20other asset? Yeah, it's all.
- 43:25Oh, go ahead, Brian. I.
- 43:26Was just going to say, what I have up on screen is this, this
- 43:29person on Twitter, Hunt and Grie who's been just doing this, this
- 43:34running thread of looking at all coins effectively and just
- 43:38pointing out all the bullshit. And so this was his one for
- 43:40Cardano. He said Cardano raised
- 43:4262,000,000, zero revenue, one transaction per second.
- 43:45Entire ecosystem is basically 1 decks and one lending protocol
- 43:48that maybe 7 people use. Ghost Chain guarded by an
- 43:51illiterate cult at the gates. It's at $21 billion full fully
- 43:55diluted valuation. So we need more of this.
- 43:58We need more people just calling out what these things are.
- 44:01This is another one in the thread, but go ahead Liam, I'll
- 44:04cut you off. No I was just going to say
- 44:07Cardano is looked at at a as a blue chip cryptocurrency.
- 44:12I just looked it up and it's the 10th largest one in the world
- 44:16and 8th if you don't include circle and tether.
- 44:19So you know, people look at these things and they see you
- 44:24know, that's why all honestly, Bitcoin is still looked at it as
- 44:28a scam like everything else, because people still group
- 44:31Bitcoin in with the rest of these crypto currencies.
- 44:34They think Cardano is the same as FTX or and the same as
- 44:37Bitcoin. And they're honestly, it's not
- 44:40enough education on why these things are actually different.
- 44:43And I'm seeing those people out there who offer everything under
- 44:47the sun and say that crypto is and Cardano is the same exact
- 44:51thing as Bitcoin is. What's going to trip up many of
- 44:54these institutions when they look at coming into the space?
- 44:58And it's going to take a lot of re education in order to
- 45:02actually get to what's the signal versus the noise.
- 45:04And that's why, you know, a lot of people have really stayed out
- 45:07of this industry thus far, too. Yeah, it's a great case study as
- 45:11we expand our team and go after institutions and and higher
- 45:15education for like certain segments of that to show this as
- 45:18an example. Because if this can happen here,
- 45:20I think it it also ties back to, I don't know who this is giving
- 45:24more credit to, but like Cardano's like a version of the
- 45:27poor man's ripple. Because what makes this whole
- 45:31like circle work is you raise capital from asset managers,
- 45:36venture capitalists that either get the the warrants on the
- 45:38token, some of the equity they get heavy war chest.
- 45:42Bitcoin doesn't have any marketing or direct budget.
- 45:45So you naturally have these companies that go out and
- 45:48evangelize. And that's what Hoskinson's
- 45:49done. He did a lot of it in Wyoming.
- 45:51You build this version, then other people host events, won't
- 45:55call any out, but there's really nice conferences we've been part
- 45:57of. But then they have like card on
- 45:59a sponsor because they've given a money and it's really hard to
- 46:01make money in Bitcoin space. You don't have them spending a
- 46:04lot of capital and that's how you end up with this reflexive
- 46:07like circle of everyone believing there's some like
- 46:09value or innovation happening when it's all, it's all for
- 46:16naughty. So anyway, it's very interesting
- 46:19incentive model. Yeah, it's very well said.
- 46:23And it's it's unfortunate that there's still that massive
- 46:27conflation. And to your point, Michael, part
- 46:28of it has to do with literally just like the lobbying efforts
- 46:31and like, you know, these these projects basically print money
- 46:35out of thin air with their tokens.
- 46:37And so they have, you know, quote UN quote money to spend on
- 46:41lobbying efforts and marketing efforts.
- 46:43And so it it adds to that conflation, which is
- 46:46unfortunate, but we can move on. I think where I wanted to go
- 46:52next was this article by Michael Green, which is make making the
- 46:59rounds over the past 24 hours or so.
- 47:01So Michael Green, he's really a trap by guy.
- 47:04He's long been sort of anti crypto, anti Bitcoin.
- 47:08But I saw this, I saw this last night starting to sort of
- 47:11percolate across crypto and Bitcoin Twitter, because
- 47:15basically what what he describes in this long form article is he
- 47:20does a deep dive into the metric of the poverty line and
- 47:25basically how that's been calculated over the years.
- 47:28And the reality that actually that calculation hasn't changed
- 47:31in several decades. So basically the, the take away
- 47:34here is the poverty line calculation or metric was
- 47:38created in the 60s. And effectively it looked at
- 47:44families that spent roughly a third of their income on food.
- 47:47And so the poverty line was effectively 3X the cost of a
- 47:53minimal food plan effectively. And so this worked in the 60s
- 47:57effectively because the other expenses to someone's living was
- 48:02were relatively cheap. So housing was relatively cheap,
- 48:04healthcare was relatively inexpensive, childcare was
- 48:07mostly done at home or by the family and and colleges were way
- 48:09cheaper. And so the formula that 3X sort
- 48:13of food inflation adjusted has remained consistent over decades
- 48:17while the rest of those expenses have increased dramatically.
- 48:21So looking at sort of the statistics today, food is really
- 48:26only 5 to 7% of household budgets, not the 33% that it was
- 48:30in the 60s. So housing now eats 35 to 45% of
- 48:34that income. Healthcare takes another 15 to
- 48:3625%, and childcare is anywhere from 20 to 40%.
- 48:40And so basically if you're taking that multiplier that 3X
- 48:43that you know comes from the original calculation, it really
- 48:46looks more like a 16X multiplier today.
- 48:49And So what Michael Green is arguing in this is basically
- 48:52that the real poverty line today is more like 130,000 to 150,000
- 48:57in annual income relative to what the current stated poverty
- 49:01line is around 31 grand. So, you know, some of the some
- 49:07of the comments to to this article are saying, you know, he
- 49:09was being way too aggressive with some of his estimations of
- 49:12current living expenses. So, you know, maybe this number
- 49:15is too high. The take away to me though, is
- 49:17that like the, the current poverty line number is wrong.
- 49:22And it's probably somewhere in between those two numbers, the
- 49:2413140 and the the 30. And so, you know, I think why
- 49:29this got picked up by Bitcoin folks and crypto Twitter is
- 49:33effectively because he's outlining the problem which we
- 49:35talked about, which is the money is broken and the debasement
- 49:38concerns here and the sort of acceleration and living expenses
- 49:42beyond the growth in in real wages.
- 49:45Now he doesn't identify the, the sort of actual problem in his
- 49:49article or a potential solution in, in Bitcoin or a better form
- 49:52of money, but he does pretty accurately layout part of the
- 49:56issue here. And what is causing basically,
- 50:00because this metric is so outdated and old, a lot of
- 50:03things stem from people making other calculations and other
- 50:06assessments and forecasts around what the what they think the
- 50:09poverty line is. And so if that's as majorly
- 50:13distorted as he's suggesting, then that has a lot of
- 50:15implications for, you know, how we think about how the economy
- 50:17is doing, generally speaking. Yeah.
- 50:21I mean, I, I think this relates to businesses in the sense of
- 50:25where the long enough time horizon.
- 50:27The thesis has always been that how we used to have a savings
- 50:30account, you'll just generally see in your bank account, it'll
- 50:33be dollars and BTC and the market will just wake up to
- 50:36there's a better savings technology that exists to offset
- 50:40this. Because I didn't read the
- 50:41article, I skimmed it, but it reminds me very similar.
- 50:44Just like the debasement trade or the denominator being broken
- 50:47is when the underlying unit that everyone's either receiving
- 50:52their payments in their salary or their savings is in including
- 50:57if their investments, they're just losing purchasing power and
- 51:00it's not keeping pace. And CPI is another great example
- 51:03of just like the distortion from what this is describing to like
- 51:06what actual CPI is. And so of course, if all these
- 51:09things are manipulated, then you're losing purchasing power.
- 51:13And on a long enough time horizon, I think within the next
- 51:15like 3 years, there'll be some emetic factors that's like,
- 51:17well, I just hold this money. And because the volatility will
- 51:23also tempt like loose and or like the volatility won't always
- 51:29be there where Bitcoin, it'll be easier to like offset what
- 51:33annual inflation is versus Bitcoin volatility where you'll
- 51:35just hold large and larger positions.
- 51:37And that's how it kind of like moves away from crypto and gold
- 51:39probably ends up sitting there as well.
- 51:42But that's like, the biggest thing I take away from this is
- 51:44that the market is slowly waking up.
- 51:46So the dollar is not retaining its purchasing power.
- 51:48And if it's not doing that, then everything else is getting more
- 51:51expensive, including like what it costs to eat and all the
- 51:53goods he's referencing. Yeah, that's very well said.
- 51:57And it just goes to how many false signals there are in the
- 52:01world. And everybody still thinks that
- 52:03the, you know, risk free rate that they should be chasing is
- 52:08the 10 year treasury yield, which we all know over a long
- 52:11time frame has been actually negative yielding in terms of
- 52:15adjusted for the increase in money supply.
- 52:16And so that is, you know, the base calculation for all
- 52:20economic activity. And it's it's wrong the fact
- 52:25that you know, businesses should not be considered based on the
- 52:30base calculation of how many more dollars they can make
- 52:33because the dollars keep on growing in value, maybe even
- 52:37inflation adjusted dollars for the amount of money, the amount
- 52:41of new dollars that are created is a little bit of a better
- 52:43metric, but plus some additional risk premium.
- 52:46But it's all going to change as you as it relates to what is the
- 52:51base calculation in order to retain your purchasing power
- 52:55over time. And that's going to be a scarce
- 52:57asset. And then you can layer on equity
- 53:00risk premium on top of that and illiquidity risk and whatever
- 53:03else you want. And you know, early riders is
- 53:07pretty early to this trend, but and it's going to take a while
- 53:10just because you can see these false metrics being really
- 53:15benchmark for a really long time.
- 53:17But those who, you know, continue to look at these false
- 53:21signals as the North Star are going to continue to
- 53:25underperform as it relates to, you know, both allocating
- 53:29capital as well as, you know, being able to just save and
- 53:33throw your purchasing power over time.
- 53:36Yep, agree with all that. Very well said.
- 53:39The the sort of parallel to just thinking about other government
- 53:43issued statistics like ACPI that we know is understating the true
- 53:48level of debasement and currency devaluation.
- 53:51This is very similar. The this is just understating
- 53:55what the actual line at which a family is struggling effectively
- 53:59in the United States. And so we just haven't even
- 54:01updated this methodology in, you know, 60 years.
- 54:04And so there are going to be knock on effects of that in
- 54:07terms of how we're using that data to forecast other things
- 54:11and, you know, get a general sense for the health of the
- 54:13economy and the health, you know, the health of citizens.
- 54:16We're not getting a real picture of that today.
- 54:20Yeah. And maybe this ties in because I
- 54:22know we have limited time. We didn't get to chat last week.
- 54:25We don't have to pull it up. But the Square launch and a lot
- 54:28of the tooling they're providing for SMBs is really important
- 54:32here because the same way an individual can't recognize the
- 54:34problem, the same problem exists with businesses in the sense of
- 54:39whether their unit economics and margins are decreasing or going
- 54:43out of business, they naturally need a better form of money to
- 54:46manage their treasury. And so that's a going to be a
- 54:48huge lift given I think that 54,000,000 merchants.
- 54:52And so there's more and more tooling, more and more education
- 54:55that will come. And I think that similar with
- 54:57like the stablecoin proliferation, combating deep
- 55:01fakes, there's going to be multiple implementations.
- 55:03This is a like global phenomenon when you think about deep fakes,
- 55:06when you think about money movement and then when you think
- 55:08about savings technology. And so it's this, it's going to
- 55:11be a very interesting area to watch play out, but also invest
- 55:14in because there's going to be a number of winners.
- 55:16There won't be 1 implementation or one like Counterparty that
- 55:19wins all when it comes to accepting and saving the better
- 55:22form of money. Yep.
- 55:25Agree with all that unless you guys had anything else want to
- 55:30end on perhaps a slightly bullish note as we mentioned at
- 55:33the jump, the prices in the 80s, but you know, maybe something to
- 55:39to bring to your your boomer uncle who you talked to on
- 55:42Thanksgiving. We used to joke about crashing
- 55:44to 85 gay. So this is a this is a tweet
- 55:47from CZ back in December of 2020, waiting for the headline
- 55:51Bitcoin crashes from one O 1K to 85K Save the tweet.
- 55:55And this is this is one of many of these types of tweets from
- 55:58four or five years ago where people were meaning the notion
- 56:01that we would be crashing to these much higher levels from
- 56:04where we were back then. And that's exactly what's
- 56:06happening right now. And people are acting like the
- 56:08sky is falling. But ultimately this is, you
- 56:11know, frankly how we all expected it to play out.
- 56:13We're going to make higher highs and higher lows.
- 56:15And that's kind of just what's happening.
- 56:17So don't get chicken out. We're 3035% below all time highs
- 56:22from, you know, a month and a half ago.
- 56:24So zoom out, have some context and tackle that that
- 56:29conversation with your boomer uncle who who you had by AT97K.
- 56:33Yeah. I mean if we're we're doing the
- 56:35Thanksgiving advice, we also have to recommend, you know it's
- 56:39cherry pick cherry picking where we're at for a year time frame
- 56:42from last Thanksgiving. But if you look across any asset
- 56:45class in any time frame that's generally not 12 to 24 months,
- 56:50Bitcoin has outperformed everything else.
- 56:52And so I think that's the angle. And then obviously making sure
- 56:55they size it appropriately so they can do the education and go
- 56:59and understand well, if it crashes 25%, it's not get out of
- 57:03the trade. It's just this is Park horse so
- 57:06yeah should be think I think we'll have an exciting 2026
- 57:09shouldn't be too too too. You know it could be a lot worse
- 57:12Thanksgiving. Imagine this is sitting at
- 57:1425,000 or 35,000. There's been some very.
- 57:17Could always be worse, could always be nice.
- 57:20But back in the day in 2021, we crashed from 69 to 58 K and and
- 57:26I was screaming at everybody in my family to buy Bitcoin then
- 57:29before going down all the way to 16,000.
- 57:31So we've been through this rodeo before and that turned out fine,
- 57:36even though it may or may not have been happy the next
- 57:40Thanksgiving. But it's all about a long term
- 57:42approach. Long term approach sales are on
- 57:45sale. Black Friday came early.
- 57:49Yeah. That's the right.
- 57:50That's the right mentality. Anything else gentlemen want to
- 57:53wrap? Well, the the one thing I was
- 57:55going to call out was the 2022 Thanksgiving must have been very
- 58:00tough because if you remember 2021, I think it was like near
- 58:0350 sixties and 2022, that was a $17,000 Thanksgiving.
- 58:10So yeah, things are on there. Could always be worse.
- 58:13Could. Always be worse.
- 58:16All right? Thanks, boys.
- 58:17See you next week. Hey guys, I hope you enjoyed the
- 58:21show. If you liked it, please give it
- 58:23a like and a share or. Subscription, Like I mentioned,
- 58:27we'll be out in Dallas, the team from early.
- 58:30Writers and On Ramp will be hosting a few events.
- 58:32If you're curious on what early. Writers have been up to you can
- 58:34go to early writers. Com See some of the portfolio
- 58:37companies we haven't publicly announced.
- 58:39Yet there's some very exciting announcements that are coming
- 58:42into the next few weeks when it comes to, you know, looking at.
- 58:46From the first Treasury. Company Bitcoin treasury company
- 58:49business in the space that we backed when it looks at the
- 58:53quote UN quote debasement trade that's now being talked about
- 58:55today. Back to company playing in the
- 58:58golden Bitcoin space all the way to new firms building globally
- 59:03on multi institution custody. There's a lot of exciting
- 59:06things, including the stables with the accelerator that we
- 59:09launched and then we have new teammates joining across the
- 59:11world from investment banking to traditional portfolio
- 59:14management, we are really building.
- 59:16A very exciting platform that should be pioneering.
- 59:20What asset management on a Bitcoin standard looks like.
- 59:23If you're interested in getting involved, I'd encourage you to
- 59:25reach out or you can shoot me an e-mail at
- 59:26michael@earlywriters.com. All right, hope you guys have a
- 59:29great week. We'll have a awesome podcast
- 59:31this week and see you next Monday.
- 59:33Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 59:36If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 59:38episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 59:41app. All the links we discussed in
- 59:42today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 59:45Before we finish, a quick reminder that Onramp Media is
- 59:48for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 59:51nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 59:54Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 59:56to hear from you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com/contact
- 1:00:00to schedule a consultation with one of our private Client
- 1:00:02Advisors.