Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #37: Home Rule Part 2 - Challenges Facing it, and Why You Should Care About the Debate
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, and welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast.
- 0:03I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:06Last week, we dove into the debate over home rule, which refers to a local government's
- 0:12capacity to administer its affairs apart from state government involvement.
- 0:17That included things like how The US constitution makes no mention of local
- 0:21governments, yet there is some interaction between federal and local government.
- 0:25The development of home rule historically, the antithesis to home rule, which is called
- 0:31Dillon's rule, and some of the arguments made for and against home rule and Dillon's rule.
- 0:36As a reminder, Dillon's rule basically states that local governments can only do what a state
- 0:42government specifically allows for the local level to do and what is absolutely necessary
- 0:47for the local local government to function.
- 0:50But today, we're going to look at more recent developments in home rule, whether for or
- 0:57against.
- 0:58Also, what are some of the biggest challenges to the expansion of home rule?
- 1:02What are some of the potential opportunities for the expansion of home rule?
- 1:07And, ultimately, why should you care so much about home rule?
- 1:11Now I'm not saying whether home rule or Dillon's rule is the, quote, unquote, best
- 1:16option for governance.
- 1:17As as always, I I keep my opinion out as as much as I possibly can, but it is of great
- 1:22importance to think about and to discuss.
- 1:25So let's get to it.
- 1:27First of all, recent developments regarding home rule.
- 1:31So we've seen over past couple decades increasing levels of state preemption where
- 1:38basically the state government in passes a law before local governments can address a specific
- 1:46issue.
- 1:47Ultimately, state law is supreme over local law.
- 1:51Even in more home rule oriented states, they largely have to adhere to state law.
- 1:57And there have been some prominent examples of state governments preempting the local level,
- 2:03which we'll get to in just a moment.
- 2:04But various state legislative bills are are being passed and or discussed that include what
- 2:11we call preemption clauses.
- 2:12They outright state this law preempts local regulations or something to that effect.
- 2:18So some of the examples that we see include, look at the early months of the COVID pandemic.
- 2:25States took to preempting many local laws, whether it was calling for shutdowns of
- 2:32businesses and schools and all that, or whether it was to prevent shutdowns.
- 2:38A lot of states took the initiative to instead of what local places decide or local
- 2:44governments decide whether to keep things open or not, state governments came in and said,
- 2:49everybody's gonna stay open or everybody's gonna shut down.
- 2:53Lately, immigration is a is probably the biggest flash point across states.
- 3:00States aligned with the Trump administration have taken to implementing his policies at the
- 3:05state level, pressuring local governments to conform, and Florida is a big example of that.
- 3:10We've seen some universities and county police departments sign deals with ICE to enforce
- 3:19immigration policy from the Trump administration.
- 3:22And Florida, speaking of, in recent years, they've had other issues that they have
- 3:28preempted local government on, including, back in, I wanna say, it's 2018.
- 3:34There were a couple of local governments that were looking to ban plastic straws, and so the
- 3:40state government actually stepped in and banned bans on plastic straws, said you can't ban
- 3:46plastic straws.
- 3:47So that's another example.
- 3:50And local government officials that try to defy state government preemption can potentially be
- 3:58removed by the state on various grounds.
- 4:01So it's it's even if you really strongly disagree with the state government's policy,
- 4:07local government officials can only do so much.
- 4:09And and how exactly they can be removed differs from state to state, but some of the grounds
- 4:16that state government officials can claim to remove these local officials on is malfeasance,
- 4:23which is an act that is illegal and causes physical or monetary injury.
- 4:28So if they don't follow state law, they defy state law.
- 4:32Basically, that act is illegal, and then they could say, well, this also led to a physical or
- 4:36monetary injury.
- 4:38Misfeasance, which is an improper performance of a lawful act.
- 4:42So what you did was legal, but you didn't do it the way that you were supposed to.
- 4:48And then nonfecence, which is the failure to act when action is required.
- 4:53So if you talk about immigration, for example, if a local government tries to not implement
- 5:01state government policy on immigration, that's that's probably one of the most common grounds
- 5:08you'll see state government officials try to remove local government officials by saying
- 5:13they're guilty of nonfeasance.
- 5:15They did not act when action was required on immigration.
- 5:20Other developments related to home rule, though not necessarily specifically whether for or
- 5:25against home rule, but we talk about special legislation by states, which, again, that is
- 5:31legislation in state governments or legislation that state governments pass that target a
- 5:38specific local government.
- 5:40So if New York wanted to pass a law specifically for New York City or Florida was
- 5:47specifically passing a law for Miami, that's considered special legislation because it only
- 5:52affects a specific piece of the state, not the whole state.
- 5:57There's not an easy way to tell how much special legislation has been passed, but we do
- 6:03know that there's still a lot of those in states that align more with Dillon's rule.
- 6:10And you you might still see it in states that have a little bit more home rule as well.
- 6:14And it's part of why some state constitution and statutes are getting larger and larger.
- 6:20Some people might say that they're bloated.
- 6:23An example is in Alabama, which heavily restricts home rule.
- 6:28They have by far the longest state constitution.
- 6:31It's like a 50,000 words past second place, and I can't remember what the second longest
- 6:37constitution is.
- 6:38It's like Pennsylvania or something.
- 6:40And that's partly because of special legislation getting added to the constitution
- 6:45and for the state statutes.
- 6:47One particularly interesting development, in regards to home rule is there was a home rule
- 6:55amendment proposal by the National League of Cities.
- 6:59So the National League of Cities is the most prominent advocacy body for municipalities.
- 7:04And as is a local government advocate, it is obviously pro home rule.
- 7:10In 2020 or right around then, the NLC for short, they published a report called
- 7:17principles of home rule for the twenty first century.
- 7:20So the short description of it is that it gives an overview of the history of home rule, legal
- 7:26background in regards to it, arguments in favor of increasing home rule.
- 7:31But the culminating piece of the report is a model state constitutional article that the NLC
- 7:37says is a starting point for reform.
- 7:39So they're not saying that each of these states should add this exact article to every state
- 7:44constitution word for word.
- 7:46It's more of a basis.
- 7:48And they and the NLC also gives some commentary on every section of the proposed constitutional
- 7:53article to, as they put it, illuminate where the provisions draw on existing examples of
- 7:59home rule and practice and where the proposed language innovates.
- 8:05I'll include the link to it in the show notes if you are interested in looking further into
- 8:14it.
- 8:15But let's get into some of the challenges that are facing home rule.
- 8:19And this is not necessarily a comprehensive list, and each state might have its own unique
- 8:25circumstances.
- 8:26But I just wanna give a general overview of the hill that home rule if you want to expand home
- 8:34rule, the climb that it has to make because home rule does face a lot of headwinds.
- 8:40Even though there's been some times in history where home rule has gotten a little bit of
- 8:46steam.
- 8:46It's sometimes also been beaten back, but I'm gonna give eight different, challenges eight of
- 8:55the biggest challenges that we see for home rule.
- 8:59So first of all, we see less media coverage of and less importance placed on local government.
- 9:07So because there's less coverage of local governments, there's less chance for home rule,
- 9:14which is a fundamentally local issue even though it has some state and national
- 9:18implications to get attention from regular people.
- 9:22Most people don't really pay attention to local government politics.
- 9:26And why is there less coverage of local government politics?
- 9:31Fewer people care about local governments and vote on their issues and pay attention to them
- 9:35and think about local politics matters.
- 9:39There's also this erroneous belief that federal and or state governments handle more issues
- 9:45than they actually do.
- 9:46I remember seeing a, I won't say the name, but a celebrity back when Barack Obama was in
- 9:53office had some sort of issue with her one of her kids in school and was calling on Barack
- 10:00Obama to do something about it.
- 10:01It's like, well, he can't really step in there.
- 10:04That's that's not for him to step into.
- 10:06That's a local government issue.
- 10:09Not to rag on that particular person, but it's it's a it's not that uncommon for people to
- 10:16think that federal or state government steps into more circumstances than they actually do.
- 10:24So fewer people care about these local governments partly because there's so many of
- 10:29them to pay attention to.
- 10:31There's tens of thousands of local governments to account for.
- 10:35Some of them are pretty small, and then some of them are huge.
- 10:38The the really big ones will get more covers like New York City or Los Angeles or Miami or
- 10:43Chicago.
- 10:45And then these individual local governments affect fewer people.
- 10:48Each individual one affects fewer people than a state or federal government does.
- 10:54So that's also partly why local government is treated as less important.
- 11:00And then also, it's often really hard to find information about local governments.
- 11:05Even for somebody like me who does this kind of thing for a living, lots of other people who do
- 11:10this research for a living.
- 11:12And if it's hard for us to find information about these local governments, imagine just
- 11:16regular people who are not doing this for a living, who have other jobs to take care of and
- 11:21and and kids and spouses, all these other things that take their attention.
- 11:28So then they also have to try to find information about these local governments, and
- 11:32they don't even know where to find them, Partially because we don't teach people very
- 11:36well where to find this information.
- 11:37And it's partially the fault of these local governments, partially not.
- 11:40Some of these local governments could make it easier for people to find information about
- 11:45them, but some of them are just also not very well funded in that capacity.
- 11:50And I can tell you from looking at some of their websites looking for information, they
- 11:55look like they came straight out of early February geo cities.
- 11:59Some of you might be a little too too young to remember that, but it was an old format for
- 12:06websites early on in in the days of the Internet.
- 12:10And so this becomes a vicious cycle where these local governments don't get covered.
- 12:16So info was less available.
- 12:18People care less because they can't find that information, and they don't know that they
- 12:22should care about that information.
- 12:23Rinse and repeat just keeps going and going.
- 12:26And so people don't really pay attention to local government unless some sort of state or
- 12:32national implication is involved or if it's a really big municipality.
- 12:38So that's one issue that home rule faces, that lack of coverage on local governments and
- 12:45people thinking local government is just not that important.
- 12:49Number two is previous court rulings on home rule.
- 12:54Last episode, we highlighted how Dillon's rule had courts backing it, namely John Forrest
- 13:00Dillon himself, who was the state supreme or the the chief justice of the Iowa's supreme
- 13:05court.
- 13:07Even though that was specifically for Iowa, many other states took a similar view because
- 13:11he wasn't the one who came up with the concept.
- 13:14He's just the one that really popularized it.
- 13:17And so the name Dylan's role, it the the legal philosophy was attributed to him, but he was
- 13:24just saying something that was conventional wisdom at the time where, basically, local
- 13:30governments were just creatures of the state, but other states took that similar view.
- 13:38But we also saw the Cooley rule from Thomas McIntyre Cooley, who was a Michigan chief or
- 13:43the Michigan Supreme Court chief justice, who said that local governments have some inherent
- 13:48rights to self governance.
- 13:49And so there was a little bit of steam that home rule started to pick up in the late
- 13:54eighteen hundreds and early nineteen hundreds, but then it kinda got scaled back.
- 13:59So a lot of times, have ruled in favor of Dillon's rule as opposed to Home rule.
- 14:05Now it's not impossible to overturn precedent set by previous court rulings, but it doesn't
- 14:11happen all that often.
- 14:13SCOTUS Supreme Court of the United States has noticeably done that in the past with things
- 14:18like civil rights.
- 14:20We went from Dred Scott versus Sanford where black people were treated as property and had
- 14:25no inherent rights.
- 14:27Then you got to Plessy versus Ferguson, which was somewhat better, but still had that
- 14:31erroneous separate but equal philosophy where as long as you provide the same kinds of
- 14:39facilities to black people, you could keep them separate from white people, which, I mean,
- 14:44inherently does not make it equal.
- 14:46And then to Brown versus Board of Education in 1954, which basically said separate but equal
- 14:53was a bunch of crap and led to integration of schools and society in general.
- 15:01But we also saw abortion a few years ago where Roe v Wade was mostly overturned.
- 15:08So some states have taken to putting more restrictions on abortion.
- 15:14Some states courts, when it comes to state law specifically, some states courts may be more
- 15:19resistant to overturning state legal precedent than other states courts might be.
- 15:25And that's, as far as I know, there's not really a comprehensive study into that kind of
- 15:31thing as, oh, how has this state overturned president precedent in its court rulings before
- 15:37compared to this state?
- 15:38As far as I know, there's nothing like that.
- 15:40But it would be a very interesting report to see if it ever did come to fruition.
- 15:46And then each state just has different political and legal considerations when it
- 15:50comes to their court systems.
- 15:52Number one, we see various selection methods for state level judges.
- 15:56Some of them are appointed by the governor.
- 15:59Some of them are appointed by the governor, but from a list of candidates from a judicial
- 16:04nominating commission, They might be nonpartisan elections.
- 16:08They might be partisan elections.
- 16:10Legislature might choose them.
- 16:12So all these different considerations for how these judges are selected and where different
- 16:18kinds of pressure could come from, whether it's coming from voters or from the governor or from
- 16:22the state legislature, and then different levels of home rule already afforded to states.
- 16:28So a state that already has more home rule would probably be a little bit more amenable to
- 16:37further home rule in the future, or they might not.
- 16:39It just it it depends on the situation because we still have seen even a more home rule
- 16:44oriented states where state law or there's been a more state preemption of local law.
- 16:50Challenge number three is the perception of subservience of local to state governments.
- 16:57While there is some similarity to the relationship between federal and state
- 17:01governments, it's not a one to one comparison.
- 17:04There is that concept of federalism between federal and state governments where federal has
- 17:10some jurisdiction that belongs specifically to federal government.
- 17:14State governments have jurisdiction that belongs to them specifically, and then there's
- 17:18some cases where federal and state share jurisdiction.
- 17:23Local governments versus state governments don't really quite have that, at least not to
- 17:28the same degree.
- 17:29And then also because the US constitution mostly left it up to the states to figure out
- 17:36how to handle local government because even though it has some provision for how federal
- 17:44and state governments should interact with each other, you don't really see it's basically
- 17:50silent.
- 17:51The US constitution is basically silent on local governments.
- 17:55So local governments, even in more home rule oriented states, are treated as subdivisions of
- 18:01the state.
- 18:02State governments aren't really treated as subdivisions of federal government.
- 18:08Now maybe maybe that's a fair perception of local governments being creatures of the state
- 18:16government.
- 18:16Maybe it's not.
- 18:18Whatever the case may be, whatever your opinion is on that, that is the traditional view is to
- 18:24see local governments as merely subdivisions of the state and therefore subservient to the
- 18:31state.
- 18:32It's not really, again, not really the case for federal versus state governments.
- 18:37And then, ultimately, state law, regardless of home rule, trumps local law based on level of
- 18:44supremacy.
- 18:45So it's sometimes hard for local governments to push back.
- 18:50Fourth major challenge for home rule is the difficulty in amending state constitutions and
- 18:57differences in citizens' ability to directly impact state laws.
- 19:03So if you want stronger, longer lasting home rule provisions, you're going to need to amend
- 19:10state constitutions, not just state statutes.
- 19:13And statutes are much easier for the state legislature to change.
- 19:17So even if you got some sort of home rule provision in the state statutes and state
- 19:21codes, which are basically the same thing as statutes just compiled a little differently,
- 19:27state legislatures later on can more easily change that.
- 19:31If you have it in the state constitution, it's not so easy to change.
- 19:35And states have various methods through which to amend their state constitution.
- 19:40Some of them have a bunch of different methods.
- 19:42Some of them only have one or two.
- 19:46In some cases, citizens can get directly involved.
- 19:48You see a lot of times citizen initiated ballot measures to change the state constitution.
- 19:56And are some states that also let them have some say in changing state statutes.
- 20:04So so sometimes you'll see these things come up to a vote by the public.
- 20:09However, some states have a tougher path toward passing amendments than others.
- 20:14For example, some states have a single subject rule for ballot initiatives, which means that
- 20:20your ballot measure has to address one subject.
- 20:25Now what exactly it means to be one subject?
- 20:29That depends on state, and that depends on arguments made by plaintiffs and defendants in
- 20:34the case.
- 20:35Could state governments use this rule against home rule advocacy to say that home rule is
- 20:40encompassing more than one subject?
- 20:44I don't know.
- 20:45Maybe they can.
- 20:47It depends on how effective they are in arguing that and how receptive judges are to that
- 20:52argument.
- 20:54But home rule advocates might be able to also successfully say, this is specifically about
- 20:59home rule.
- 21:00So it is just one subject.
- 21:02Not every state has that requirement for ballot initiatives, though.
- 21:08There's different requirements for signatures.
- 21:11So you don't just get a ballot measure on the ballot just because you want it to.
- 21:16You have to have a certain percentage of the electorate signed petitions that say, I want
- 21:24this ballot measure on the ballot.
- 21:29What that threshold is, the the percentage of signatures needed, it depends on the states and
- 21:36where exactly you have to get signatures because some states might require not only do
- 21:40you need to get a specific percentage of the electorate, you might need to get a certain
- 21:44amount from each congressional district, not just anywhere in the state.
- 21:49And, usually, a state's or there's there's also then when it gets on the ballot, there's
- 21:55different thresholds for actually passing constitutional amendments.
- 21:59Usually, you'll see a state require just 50% of voter approval to pass or 50% plus one.
- 22:08But at least one state requires 55% of the vote, and I can't remember which state that is.
- 22:12I wanna say it was, like, Arkansas or something, but I can't remember for sure.
- 22:16And then Florida requires 60.
- 22:19And then you see some states trying to pass or have passed legislation making it more
- 22:25difficult to collect signatures for ballot measures and get them to the ballot for a vote.
- 22:31Ballopedia says that from 2018 to 2024, '50 '7 bills or resolutions passed in the 26 states
- 22:40with a statewide initiative or referendum process.
- 22:44Most commonly, we saw it in South Dakota where there was 11 such bills or resolutions, Arizona
- 22:50with seven, Florida with six, and then Arkansas and Utah with five.
- 22:55So to actually get it into the state constitution, these home rule the home rule
- 23:04amendment, there's it's a pretty steep climb, steeper in some states versus others.
- 23:13Number five challenge for home rule is the low placement of home rule on overall political
- 23:21agendas.
- 23:21So not everything that is a an issue that is brought up any state legislative session or in
- 23:30or congress for that matter.
- 23:32Not not everything in a government that is on the political agenda will actually make it to
- 23:41make it further other than this is a thing that's been proposed, might not even make it
- 23:46out of the committee stage in a state legislature.
- 23:50Other things might become more pressing.
- 23:53And a lot and the leadership of a legislature will determine or or has the most say in
- 24:01determining which things are heard first, which things are considered more important.
- 24:08And home rule typically doesn't have quite the prominence that a lot of other issues have.
- 24:13So abortion, whether to expand it or restrict it.
- 24:16Guns, whether to loosen gun control or to tighten gun control.
- 24:23Various educational issues.
- 24:25Those kinds of things are gonna get a lot more publicity and attention by the legislature than
- 24:32home rule is usually.
- 24:35So some states also have much shorter sessions than other states.
- 24:39Some states there's a few states that are year round, but other states might only have, like,
- 24:44two or three or four months or five months.
- 24:47So because they have shorter legislative sessions, it might be more difficult for home
- 24:53rule to get on their agendas versus a state where the legislature meets year round.
- 25:00So that's another issue for home rule.
- 25:02Number six, we we talked about it earlier, the increase in state preemptions of local
- 25:08government ordinances on things like immigration and and COVID when COVID had had
- 25:15first hit.
- 25:16Early in the episode, it's we mentioned it's been become increasingly common to preempt
- 25:22local government.
- 25:24To just to recap, though, various state legislative bills are being passed and or
- 25:29discussed that include preemption clauses, which say this law preempts local regulations
- 25:35or something to that effect.
- 25:37And immigration is probably the biggest flashpoint currently.
- 25:41And because state law has supremacy over local law, it can be difficult for local governments
- 25:47to try to stop state preemption because of the threat of removal of local officials for things
- 25:53like malfeasance, malfeasance, nonfeasance.
- 25:57So there's only so much that local governments can do to try to defy state government.
- 26:05Number seven, what is the appropriate level of home rule?
- 26:09So last episode, we talked about how the National League of Cities had four categories
- 26:17where states may allow discretionary authority for local governments to implement their own
- 26:24laws.
- 26:24One is structural, so that's things like how to form a government and chartering or and
- 26:30enacting charter revisions for municipalities.
- 26:33Local charters more or less are constitutions, but for that municipality or or counties.
- 26:41Well, I don't think counties have a charter, but cities and towns that have charters, not
- 26:47necessarily that they will have more home rule, but they they generally do.
- 26:52And you might see particularly large cities have these charters.
- 26:59So that's structural.
- 27:00Number two category that local governments might have discretionary authority in is the
- 27:07functional.
- 27:08So whether they can generally exercise local self government in a broad or limited manner.
- 27:14Number three, fiscal.
- 27:16How do they determine revenue sources?
- 27:18How do they set tax rates?
- 27:19How do they borrow funds?
- 27:21Things like that.
- 27:22And then number four, which is personnel.
- 27:24So setting employment rules for local government, employment conditions, collective
- 27:29bargaining agreements.
- 27:31Because it's such a complex topic, home rule, there's a lot of room for people to disagree on
- 27:37policy and what should be encompassed by home rule.
- 27:40And that's even the case for people who are generally supportive of home rule.
- 27:44So maybe somebody is a lot more supportive of home rule in terms of how these local
- 27:50governments should be able to structure themselves, but they might be a little bit more
- 27:54hesitant to support home rule and fiscal considerations.
- 28:00So whether how these local governments can set tax rates.
- 28:04Maybe somebody who's generally supportive of home rule is not so supportive of them having
- 28:09more latitude in fiscal matters.
- 28:14And while they might agree in or they might they might agree on the fact that state
- 28:22governments have gone too far in preempting local government.
- 28:26They might not agree on where exactly that line is.
- 28:29So do they agree that states are going too far in preempting local government on immigration?
- 28:36What about with regards to COVID or abortions or guns?
- 28:43Depending on the issue, people might see a where that line is drawn, might not exactly
- 28:50agree on that even if they generally agree that there should be more home rule implemented.
- 28:55So that's challenge number seven.
- 28:56And then the eighth challenge we're gonna cover is that states with low levels of party
- 29:01competition in state politics and high levels of party uniformity, it's gonna make it much
- 29:09tougher for home rule to be implemented.
- 29:12So, arguably, more states are trending towards one party dominance in their state governments.
- 29:19There's a lot of them that are trending more towards Republican.
- 29:22There's a lot of them that are trending more towards Democrat.
- 29:25And when one party runs the show, there is less recourse for the minority party to push back,
- 29:31especially at the local level.
- 29:33And as a result, the state governments can feel empowered to tell local governments more and
- 29:39more what they have to do as there is less chance of defeating those state elected
- 29:45officials in elections.
- 29:47And there's also that tendency, and this is anybody can fall into this trap because we're
- 29:52human beings, is the tendency toward groupthink.
- 29:56Basically, because the group thinks one thing, you change your opinion to align with the
- 30:01group.
- 30:02And that can affect anybody regardless of political views, and low ranking members of the
- 30:07dominant party may be convinced to fall in line with the rest of the party on issues even if
- 30:12they might normally have a different opinion.
- 30:15And you see groupthink all the time in politics, especially in a national context.
- 30:20It's more and more common for Republicans to agree with each other on things and more and
- 30:25more common for Democrats to agree with each other on things.
- 30:29So when you have that one track mind, which, again, anybody can fall for, is in in the state
- 30:37level, they're generally going to probably try to tell local governments more and more what
- 30:42they can and cannot do.
- 30:45Now, again, that's I'm not trying to say that there needs to be home more home rule or there
- 30:50shouldn't be more home rule, but that is something to really consider.
- 30:55Because when you have low levels of party competition, it's really not good for
- 31:01governance in general because there is no room for dissent, and you can't really have
- 31:09discussions on anything.
- 31:12Competition in elections is healthy for political systems.
- 31:18Now I don't wanna make it sound like it's all doom and gloom for home rule advocates because
- 31:22there are opportunities for home rule advocates to get done what they want to get done.
- 31:28As more or less as the saying goes, there's opportunity with within adversity.
- 31:36One of the big opportunities that home rule advocates have is the ninth amendment to the US
- 31:42constitution, which basically says any rights not specified in The US constitution belong to
- 31:48the people.
- 31:49Now this is usually considered more for members of the public, not for local governments.
- 31:56But could this be successfully applied to local governments?
- 31:59Because given their proximity to regular people and how much local governments affect locals
- 32:06directly, they could possibly say that, hey.
- 32:10These state encroachments on local government on home rule are infringing upon people's
- 32:19rights that are not enumerated in the constitution, which are protected by the ninth
- 32:23government.
- 32:24But that could also run up against the tenth amendment, which is that powers not in The US
- 32:28constitution belong to state governments.
- 32:31So there might be a little bit of tug and pull there.
- 32:34Maybe there's other constitutional provisions like fourteenth amendment equal protection
- 32:39clause that you could possibly argue, depending on, well, how how well your your legal team is
- 32:48able to argue for those things.
- 32:52It might not be so easy to make those cases for local government, but maybe that will be in the
- 32:59future.
- 33:00There's also opportunity with the general frustrations boiling over with state
- 33:06governments.
- 33:07Obviously, anger is fomenting against government officials in general, and,
- 33:12unfortunately, it sometimes spills over to violence.
- 33:15But state preemption may eventually spur further grassroots action for home rule, And
- 33:22that grassroots action has happened in the past when home rule provisions were enacted in
- 33:27various states in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century.
- 33:31Most major political trends in the nation have started off local, and home rule would be the
- 33:36same case and would be aptly so.
- 33:39After all, home rule is maybe the most local of local government issues that there is.
- 33:46So, of course, it would have to start local.
- 33:48Of course, it would have to start at the grassroots level.
- 33:52As the former, speaker of the of the US house, Tip O'Neill, said that all politics is local,
- 34:01and that is still mostly true today.
- 34:03So home rule is gonna have to start somewhere, and it's gonna have to start at the very, very
- 34:10bottom at the grassroots level.
- 34:12And then there's also opportunity in state ballot measures and conventions.
- 34:18Talked about how some states make it more difficult for ballot measures to get on the
- 34:25ballot for a vote and subsequently to get passed.
- 34:29So some some states make that easier.
- 34:32Some states make that harder, but you do have that opportunity.
- 34:36That's why the National League of Cities has that home rule amendment proposal, that basis
- 34:41for a state to implement a home rule proposal with their own tweaks specific to that state.
- 34:49And there's also the possibility of state constitutional conventions, which provide
- 34:54opportunity for more wholesale change to a state constitution.
- 35:00It's how most, if not all, states have had multiple state constitutions throughout the
- 35:05years because The US constitution, it's been amended 27 times, but it's been the same
- 35:11document for over two hundred thirty years.
- 35:15A lot of states, however, have had multiple state constitutions.
- 35:20And in fact, Ballipedia says as of 2023, there have been 233 constitutional conventions to
- 35:27deliberate state constitutions.
- 35:31And sometimes those have resulted in more or less completely new state constitutions.
- 35:37Maybe not completely new, but largely new state constitutions.
- 35:4042 states have rules that govern how a constitutional convention can be called, but 14
- 35:47states have a constitutional convention question as an automatic ballot referral.
- 35:51So it does not have to be you don't have to gather petitions to put the ballot measure on
- 35:58the ballot to say, hey.
- 36:00We need to call a constitutional convention.
- 36:01Do you agree?
- 36:03State legislatures don't need to put forth a question about a constitutional convention.
- 36:09It it it's an automatic ballot referral, so it just happens automatically.
- 36:13And that happens in 16 different states.
- 36:16So five states have ten year intervals between this constitutional convention question.
- 36:21Michigan has sixteen year intervals, and then eight states have twenty year intervals.
- 36:27Now even if they have a constitutional convention does not necessarily mean that it's
- 36:33gonna be a wholesale change to said constitution, but you could see much larger
- 36:40changes to those state constitutions.
- 36:42And with those large changes might be a change to home rule because that would be a pretty
- 36:47significant change for these state constitutions, especially in states where they
- 36:52follow Dillon's rule more than they do home rule.
- 36:57And then the last opportunity we'll cover is that if some states since some states have an
- 37:04easier time or at least theoretically would have an easier time implementing home rule in
- 37:09state law, maybe that'll lead to national momentum.
- 37:13Now, again, different political realities in each state with sometimes similar, sometimes
- 37:18unique circumstances, and we sometimes too often make the assumption that one state doing
- 37:24something will spur other states to do the same, but it could happen in this case.
- 37:27And we've seen that happen with various different issues where a couple of states were
- 37:34doing something and then other states started to pick it up.
- 37:37Maybe home rule will do that.
- 37:39And in fact, in the past, home rule was picking up steam after that Cooley rule was made, which
- 37:45said that local governments have some inherent rights to self governance.
- 37:50So if grassroots action is effective enough, you might see Home Rule eventually become a
- 37:59national issue.
- 38:02So we covered the challenges and opportunities for home rule.
- 38:08Now let's get into why you should care about this.
- 38:12It's all well and good to know all this stuff, and it's interesting stuff.
- 38:16At least I think it's very interesting stuff.
- 38:19But you also have to teach people or tell people why they should care.
- 38:25So why should you care about home rule versus Dillon's rule?
- 38:29And, again, not making an argument for home rule or for Dillon's rule.
- 38:34It's just that this is very important to consider.
- 38:37One reason it's important to consider is because local government has the most direct
- 38:42impact on your daily life.
- 38:44They handle public works and utilities, local courts, which you run into much more often and
- 38:50generally first before higher level courts.
- 38:52They maintain retirement and pension systems, administer and fund elections.
- 38:57Election administration is the vast majority of it is handled by local governments, provide
- 39:02certain recreational and educational services.
- 39:05They handle local parks, give local permits for various activities and functions, like for new
- 39:10businesses or for building certain structures on your property or local festivals, so on and
- 39:15so on.
- 39:16So many things that local government has an impact on.
- 39:19And, obviously, state and federal government matter too, but local government has a lot more
- 39:23of that impact on your day to day life.
- 39:26So as such, you should know what they are doing just as much as your state and federal
- 39:31governments do.
- 39:32Now whether they should take the lead on more government policies apart from the state
- 39:40government, I mean, that's that's up for you you to decide.
- 39:44The debate between Home Rule and Dillon's Rule is also a fundamental question about the will
- 39:50of the people.
- 39:51Both state and local governments are mostly, at least, elected by the people.
- 39:56There's some appointed officials here and there.
- 39:58Is the will of the people, though, being fulfilled by state preemption and thus Dillon's
- 40:04rule, or is it by home rule?
- 40:07How much should should a local government be able to dissent from the rest of a state?
- 40:13How much direct impact should the people have in general?
- 40:18So and that and that those can be come there are whole other debates that don't even
- 40:27necessarily have to do with home rule, but just some of those questions to really think about
- 40:32to really get the gears going in your mind when you think about why this is such an important
- 40:36issue.
- 40:37And then also has great importance regarding the efficiency and responsiveness of
- 40:43government.
- 40:45When is it more effective for the state government to address an issue, and when is
- 40:50that the case for local government?
- 40:52For example, when we were talking about the debate between state and home rule and Dillon's
- 40:57rule on the last episode, one of the arguments was about which one is better for addressing
- 41:03corruption because if when you invest too much power in any person or entity, they're going to
- 41:12eventually step over the line.
- 41:14But where is that line between or when it comes to state and local relations?
- 41:20You have too much state power.
- 41:22Local governments can't respond to their issues.
- 41:25Too much local power, and they can just defy state government policies when they want.
- 41:31When it comes to corruption, back in the really early days of this debate, home rule advocates
- 41:39argued that state government had been really corrupt in how they picked winners and losers
- 41:45in local government, and the local governments needed to be able to address their own issues,
- 41:50and the people need to be able to address local state government corruption more directly.
- 41:57But then, Dillard's rule advocates argued that the state government was needed so that local
- 42:01governments didn't step out of line too much.
- 42:04So a bit of a back and forth in that regard.
- 42:08But in any case, regardless of your views on the issue, when power is abused, that
- 42:15inherently leads to less efficient and less responsive government.
- 42:19And when it's a single person or a single entity that has too much power or even just a
- 42:25small handful of people or small handful of groups, you can guarantee that at some point,
- 42:31they're going to abuse that power.
- 42:33It's human nature.
- 42:35It it can happen to anybody.
- 42:37So whether Home Rule or Dillon's Rule is best for addressing that, I mean, that's up to you
- 42:43to decide, but we really do need to think about it when it comes to how efficient and
- 42:48responsive government is.
- 42:50So that's gonna do it for today's episode.
- 42:54As always, thank you so much for listening and watching.
- 42:57Please like, comment, and subscribe, and share podcast with all the people you know with your
- 43:03networks.
- 43:05Various links in the show notes, and that National League of Cities report I'll include
- 43:10in the show notes for this episode as well.
- 43:14But other things in my show notes, Facebook, LinkedIn, my book on Amazon, why independents
- 43:20rarely win elections and how they could become more competitive.
- 43:24My educational email course, short educational email course on some of the ways we
- 43:30unintentionally enhance polarization, why we make those mistakes, and how we could actually
- 43:36fix those mistakes, and a couple of other things as well.
- 43:41But thank you again so much for listening, and check all that stuff out.
- 43:47And please also rate the podcast on wherever you get the podcast whether you well, I guess
- 43:54YouTube doesn't necessarily have a rating system, but Spotify and Apple Podcast,
- 44:00preferably a good review, please.
- 44:02But I'm gonna go ahead and sign off and stop rambling.
- 44:06So as always, thank you so much for listening and watching, and until next time.
- 44:12Take care.