Latest / Free Cities Podcast / 193 - Fifty Years of Watching It Go Wrong | Mark Frazier
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Free Cities podcast. My name is Timothy Allen and this is the official podcast
- 0:17of the Free Cities Foundation. Hello and welcome to this episode number 193 of the Free Cities
- 0:35podcast brought to you as always by our wonderful sponsors Veritas Villages. More on them a little
- 0:41later and I promise you it's worth sticking around for because if this conversation gets
- 0:46you thinking about actually going and living somewhere freer? Well, they are building exactly
- 0:53that. Right, today's guest, well, he's been doing this longer than almost anyone alive. Mark Fraser
- 1:01put out libertarian magazines in high school and by the age of 18 he'd been made publisher of
- 1:08Reason back when it had only 300 subscribers. Well, how far they've come. And, according to him at
- 1:15least, was being run out of a truck driver's apartment. That was 1970. What's happened since
- 1:21then? Well, he's worked on free zones in more than 50 countries. He advised the Reagan administration
- 1:28on enterprise zones. He consulted for the World Bank and USAID across the Caribbean, Africa,
- 1:35Eastern Europe and beyond. He runs a non-profit called Open World, chairs the advisory board of
- 1:42the Startup Societies Foundation, and wrote the book quite literally on how to build one of these
- 1:48places, a step-by-step guide called Founding Startup Societies. And somewhere in that half
- 1:55century, well, he's collected the kind of stories that most people in this movement have only read
- 2:01about. Now, what makes Mark worth two hours of your time is that he learned something from watching
- 2:07all of it go wrong. His whole approach turns the usual Free Zone playbook on its head as far as I'm
- 2:14concerned. Don't fall in love with a location and push, he says, make it a prize that countries
- 2:20compete to win and don't build an enclave that gets rich while the neighbours grow resentful.
- 2:27Design it from day one so the people already living there share in the upside. We start this
- 2:33conversation with his life story and then from there we do cover quite a lot of ground shenzhen
- 2:40and montego bay the birth of offshore call centers why mark thinks ai is about to pull the rug out
- 2:47from under the entire model of free zones and what he believes should replace it and then in the last
- 2:55stretch well it gets properly strange and that's in the best way possible you know how much i love
- 2:59strange abundance spirituality whether a silicon chip can actually want something
- 3:05and a rat experiment called universe 25 that i still actually think about to this day anyway
- 3:14this episode of the free cities podcast is brought to you by veritas villages and there is some real
- 3:21news to share this week veritas village at playa pacifica on nicaragua's pacific coast now has 11
- 3:28completed homes in phase one they welcomed their newest homeowner back in april and by all accounts
- 3:35she's thoroughly enjoying her beautiful ocean view home and the broader master plan from here well
- 3:42it has room for more than 30 additional homes in the phases still to come so this is not just a
- 3:49rendering or a promise it's a real community being built and lived in right now off-grid energy
- 3:55self-sufficient freedom-minded and yes you can buy your home there with bitcoin everything mark
- 4:01and i talk about today the idea of positioning yourself somewhere with room to breathe veritas
- 4:07villages is turning into actual ground you can stand on head over to veritasvillages.com forward
- 4:14slash free cities to take a look that's www.veritasvillages.com forward slash free cities
- 4:23don't forget to do the free cities bit that helps them know that we sent you right excuse me value
- 4:30for value part of this show's income of course comes from value for value we've got no gatekeepers
- 4:36here you just decide what it's worth and then you send it through a podcast app my preferred one is
- 4:42fountain.fm and they're actually hosting this podcast too the rss comes straight from them so
- 4:49this week I would like to offer a genuine thank you to this week's top supporters because it really
- 4:55does make a real difference. Anon Anon, number one, number two, Justin Bianchi, many thanks,
- 5:02number three, Shadrach, thank you, Shadrach, number four, Darcy, thank you, and another common name in
- 5:08this list, thank you, Mr. Christopher Albanese, with a special mention to our subscribers amongst
- 5:14them. If you want to join them, well, just open the show in fountain.fm, sign up with a NOSTA
- 5:21profile and you can just send Bitcoin straight to us and all the other value for value platforms
- 5:27that do the same thing. There's a list of them in the show notes. And hey, you never know,
- 5:31your name might pop up on here next week. Right, before I go, quick word about something I would
- 5:37genuinely hate for you to miss. You've guessed it. This September, the Free Cities Conference
- 5:43is happening as always but this year for the first time it's being held inside a real functioning
- 5:50free city that's prosper of course on the island of Roatan in Honduras for years we ran this in
- 5:56Prague talking about free cities as an idea this year you get to walk the streets of one meet the
- 6:02people building it and see it actually working with your own eyes or not working as the case may
- 6:09be you might walk in there and think i really need to come here and help fix some of the problems
- 6:14and make this place grow the core days of the conference are the third until the 6th of september
- 6:21and there's plenty happening either side too including an optional excursion to ciudad morazan
- 6:27which is a very different kind of free city in honduras that's on the day before we begin
- 6:32everything you need to know is over at freecitiesconference.com of course and listening to
- 6:38mark today with 50 years of watching these places rise and fall it struck me there is no better time
- 6:45to go and stand inside one that's actually working so come and join us i will be there of course i'm
- 6:51even doing a speech this year apparently and i would love to meet you so come up and say hello
- 6:56it's very informal you'll be able to speak to everyone there right that's enough from me
- 7:00this week's alpha well what is it 50 years of hard-won lessons on how to actually build one
- 7:07of these places. So sit back, relax and enjoy my conversation with Mark Frazier.
- 7:27It would be a good idea to introduce yourself. However, I did actually Google you this morning
- 7:33And it was, yeah, it was quite a vast history of work with special economic zones, startup societies, free zones.
- 7:44I mean, you know, have you got, when people ask you what you do or things like that, what do you normally come up with?
- 7:55What's your rough CV?
- 7:57Well, my load star has seen ways to turn failing systems inside out and to do it in a way that frees the world to the direct benefit of the poor.
- 8:15I come from a left background in terms of my teenage years.
- 8:20And then read Rand and decided, whoa, I was off base.
- 8:25But in terms of values, I've been looking and working on projects that do share the upsides and have success sharing elements.
- 8:37And so I've had some divergence from the traditional enclave approach to free zones.
- 8:46And I adamantly free market, but also looking for ways that land value gains can be shared.
- 8:57What about an actual CV of projects?
- 9:00Like, did you start in the free zone business?
- 9:03I came into it as a teenager and it was publishing.
- 9:09At that point, I thought that what the world needs is free market journalists.
- 9:13And so in high school, I put out some libertarian magazines and they caught the eye of the founder of Reason magazine, Lanny Friedlander.
- 9:23And he contacted me.
- 9:26I volunteered to do paste up work.
- 9:29Reason had 300 subscribers.
- 9:31but there was a life-changing moment in Lanny's apartment. He was a truck driver during the day
- 9:38and doing this libertarian magazine on the side. He had a collection in the cardboard box of
- 9:44newsletters about libertarian efforts to create new countries and so for an 18-year-old that was
- 9:54just a life-changing kind of discovery. Can I ask when you were an 18-year-old just for context?
- 10:01I know you're not, as women, you're not supposed to answer their age. We don't care, do we?
- 10:07That was 1969, 1970 was when I became active with Reason. And I was just actually graduating
- 10:15from high school and heading into Harvard. So Lenny said, I can't pay you, but I need your help,
- 10:22the production. So why don't I make you publisher of Reason Magazine at that tender age? And
- 10:30that was what I did for a stretch of about a year. But Lanny opened my eyes to Mike Oliver
- 10:39and his Minerva project and Werner Stiefel and his project Atlantis. And these were extraordinarily
- 10:47audacious efforts to create truly free societies. Right. We've never, I don't think, mentioned those
- 10:56in 180 episodes of this podcast.
- 10:58So let's go there.
- 11:00They already sound good.
- 11:02Atlantis sounds really good.
- 11:03But what are we talking here?
- 11:06Like, were they all sort of ideas and no substance?
- 11:12Oh, no.
- 11:12These were on-the-ground efforts.
- 11:15And I'm sure there are many hours worth of adventures and tales to be told.
- 11:21But long and short, both projects came from people who had deep scars from World War II.
- 11:31Werner Stiefel had seen firsthand what Nazism had done and came to the U.S. with a life vow to never let states run rampaging again, if he could help it.
- 11:50He founded a pharmaceutical company and part of the proceeds went into building a boat that was then landed at a seamount off Haiti, which unfortunately Papa Doc and his minions decided they weren't going to leave it alone.
- 12:12So actually the boat kind of sank before it reached its destination.
- 12:18But he kept looking and ultimately refocused on Central America, but very quietly.
- 12:25The other thing I found in these newsletters was Mike Oliver, who at age 13, during the Holocaust, he'd lost his parents.
- 12:34And he was in the Polish woods with group, a partisan group.
- 12:40and he came out of that alive and again adamant about not letting governments ever do that again.
- 12:53So he made a fortune in Las Vegas or Nevada real estate and then proceeded to look for islands that
- 13:02would lend themselves to a free country. Starting in the Bahamas, Abaco was his first,
- 13:09But as I read these newsletters and got up to speed and followed closely in my college days, he settled on the South Pacific.
- 13:21And there in Tonga, he did raise a flag, again on a seamount, and had the war canoes or navy of Tonga promptly eviscerate the little structure that they'd built on the seamount.
- 13:38He turned then to the New Hebrides under British and joint rule and found an indigenous leader who drove a bulldozer, but he also had high standing with the tribe on the island of Espirito Santo.
- 13:57So Mike Oliver created passports, flag, a constitution, radical constitution.
- 14:08And Jimmy Mully Stevens declared independence and sent emissaries to the United Nations.
- 14:15By this time, I graduated from college and was working in New Zealand and wrote the lead article in the New Zealand Herald
- 14:24announcing the birth of the Nagarimel Federation in late December of good grief.
- 14:33I'm going back in time.
- 14:36But this would have been 1975.
- 14:41And over the next months, as a reporter working in New Zealand,
- 14:47I saw the sad story of this thing fall apart.
- 14:50basically the millionaire backing of this breakaway got defeated by some adroit maneuvers
- 15:01by the British and the French. So they put Jimmy Molle and Stevenson in jail and he got released
- 15:08about six months later after agreeing never ever ever to do anything like that again.
- 15:13and my visa was expiring.
- 15:16So I decided on my way back to the U.S.
- 15:20to stop at the site of the Nagamil Federation.
- 15:23I met him and saw that the money that was being spent to back him
- 15:30had turned into a conspicuous consumption binge by him.
- 15:37And so as I was leaving the scene and seeing how much great promise had gone wrong, I had an epiphany in Fiji on the way back to the U.S.
- 15:51And that was the seed of what later turned to be my life's work of setting up free zones, but on a different basis than the kind of parachuted in ones that I had seen.
- 16:05What would you say was your modus operandi then when you say a different way of doing things?
- 16:13Well, the first realization was that many free zone initiatives have been pushing on a string.
- 16:22They've basically fallen in love with a particular location and then push, push, push, try to make it happen.
- 16:30And it's all sweetness and light in the early days.
- 16:35Oh, yes, yes, yes.
- 16:36But once local folks know that you've chosen that destination, then the banana peels start to appear.
- 16:47And so the big takeaway for me was that these efforts to set up free areas by funneling money into a predestined spot
- 16:59were exactly the wrong way to start.
- 17:03And in Fiji, I recalled a conversation with a friend
- 17:07who had been at Harvard Business School while I was an undergrad.
- 17:13And Paul Siegler said, you know, commercial space launch is going to be a big thing.
- 17:20And he intended to be right at the beginning of that.
- 17:24He said, we need a place at the equator.
- 17:27because at the equator you get extra spin and that saves you a good 30 percent over the launch
- 17:35costs from traditional sites. So as I was sitting in this kind of ragtag motel in Fiji
- 17:44waiting for my plane the next day, I thought what if something of the audacity and scale
- 17:52of these new country projects could be turned into a prize to be won.
- 18:00And that's where it clicked.
- 18:03I figured that what would excite countries to give land,
- 18:09leasehold land, in large scale,
- 18:15and agree to match Hong Kong or Singapore
- 18:20in terms of transparency, the quality of the business climate,
- 18:25to land the first spaceport for Earth.
- 18:30And this wild idea, actually, with next to no money
- 18:37over the subsequent two or three years,
- 18:41had quite a run, 12 countries.
- 18:43I got some very big name people to agree to endorse it.
- 18:50Becky Fuller Arthur C Clark help fund Robert Heinlein a number of people in Arizona Funding the prize Agree to put their name or provide seed capital
- 19:06And I had, with a microscopic budget, $800 in terms of the initial budget,
- 19:14prepared a brochure that then went out describing the benefits economically and also other upsides
- 19:23in terms of prestige to the country that would commit the best quality reforms on a very tight
- 19:32turnaround. So Tim, to my delight, I founded Jim Bennett, joined me. He later became quite active
- 19:43with ideas on world cities and free areas.
- 19:49We sat there in this really low-rent kind of area in Santa Barbara,
- 19:57getting phone calls from ministers, ambassadors wanting to fly out and meet with us,
- 20:06and letters that said, in principle, we're prepared to do it.
- 20:11so that was my first big uh light bulb in terms of a new way to do the the free zone
- 20:19uh initiative create competition for people to come forward so this was land-based right yes
- 20:28because i know that a lot of i know joe talk joe quirk talks a lot and a lot of seasteaders talk a
- 20:33lot about the fact that uh what's that area in the in the ocean that's very shallow the the
- 20:40Sargass, no, not the Sargass of Sea, but there is an area that's free of hurricanes.
- 20:44And it's on the equator.
- 20:45And a lot of them talk about that as being a really good business model for large seasteads,
- 20:52these places to take up.
- 20:53So what happened?
- 20:54Did anyone commit and did anything happen?
- 20:56There was a resolution introduced by Liberia at the United Nations declaring that they were
- 21:03ready to go ahead with a 200 square mile or square kilometer free port for space.
- 21:11This would be an area that would be open to commercial, peaceful launching from
- 21:16ventures around the world. And at that point, McDonnell Douglas and Boeing, as well as a West
- 21:25Sherman Company, a launch bootstrap company called O-Trag, all were wanting to launch vehicles
- 21:33from the equator. So it was very heady times. We built up a good head of steam on this.
- 21:43And then the guy at the State Department said, you know, cool idea, but it ain't going to happen.
- 21:53Which State Department?
- 21:55The U.S. state of mind.
- 21:57Two reasons.
- 21:58One, in the Carter administration, the space shuttle was not particularly keen to have private launch competitors.
- 22:09Reason number two, which had some validity in terms of apprehension, is that launch vehicles can be turned to civilian, commercial, peaceful use or something else.
- 22:25And the notion of having an easier on-ramp for emerging countries to lob things into orbit, that was a big deal, and understandably.
- 22:38But the point that we tried to make, which did not carry the day, was that these things will happen anyway.
- 22:47And they can be much better done in terms of avoiding leakage risk if there's one or a small number of equatorial free ports that can be vetting what's going on in terms of the launching.
- 23:06so that so let me just so i get it got this straight so you were offering like a prize the
- 23:14prize being a massive amount of investment well the prize being that if if you do follow through
- 23:21with prime site and world-class reform commitment that the prize is that you will become this
- 23:29launch pad for planet earth um the commercial ventures to and the u.s state put an
- 23:36into it yes and who were the main contenders before that happened then uh liberia by far um
- 23:42we we did have panama indonesia rwanda um and almost uh 12 the total of 12 um countries showing
- 23:53written interest in it but um after after the state department said no to export control of
- 24:01technology um Liberia was still ready to go ahead with the Freeport but then their their cabinet
- 24:11met a grisly end um with when a sergeant unpaid sergeant took over the government
- 24:18um and marched them off to the beach I've been to Liberia it's one hell of a
- 24:24failed country hold on a second I'm just going to close that curtain there the sun keeps
- 24:29there you go it's amazing to even have curtains that big sorry brand new studio folks this is
- 24:47this is all nothing gets cut in this show um yeah it it not that i would have imagined that maybe
- 24:54it might have been a complete disaster anyway.
- 24:56It's one of those countries that I think is rife with just bad people
- 25:03doing bad things in power, basically.
- 25:07And the whole country can never really seem to get going
- 25:10because I worked there briefly and the corruption was rife.
- 25:16It was on display to us as people from NGOs.
- 25:22And it was just like, what the hell?
- 25:23this is you know but the whole place is just a quagmire disaster like i think i was talking about
- 25:30this on the podcast the other day the um the capital monrovia was a slum apart from a one
- 25:41five-star hotel with all the white toy i took land cruisers outside which were all the ngos
- 25:48and the offices of the government which were walnut cabinets and flat screen tellies and you
- 25:55know and you could just see it it was like a it was like a picked a painting here's where the money
- 26:00comes from and here's where it goes and it was just like yeah i left that was one of the last
- 26:05times i worked for an ngo the whole trip left a bad taste in my mouth i was out there for three
- 26:09weeks you know well i i went on to uh work in um well over a hundred free zone projects i
- 26:18regrouped after these getting this earth port project uh stymied um and focused on free zone
- 26:27consulting i wrote or co-edited uh books on foreign trade zones enterprise zones
- 26:33and export processing zones.
- 26:36I had to hand in a guidebook on that.
- 26:39So I became an expert at the tender age.
- 26:42I guess I was 28 or so at that point.
- 26:46And calls started coming in for various projects
- 26:50to help countries get free zones off the ground.
- 26:54So the next chapter in my life began, excuse me.
- 26:59it's consummate professionals here at the free series podcast
- 27:04um yeah put it on airplane
- 27:10unbelievable excuse me you're like that meme uh i get it from my kids it's what old people do when
- 27:22they get when they touch their phones doing that how do i do this yeah i'm a bit like that i i try
- 27:31and resist but you know um anyway that does segue me to the next episode because um that may have
- 27:39been a telemarketing call um after after running into all these haddle um
- 27:47running into this, you know, firestorm of regulatory issues. I went into a tame,
- 27:58you know, vanilla free zone consultant mode and got a call to help a project in Jamaica,
- 28:08which had in Montego Bay a prime site for a free zone.
- 28:16And it happened that I had just weeks before getting this call
- 28:21seen an article called,
- 28:23Now We Can Move Office Work Offshore.
- 28:27And being a light bulb.
- 28:29This is 1980s.
- 28:311983, I guess.
- 28:33So just so I can get my timeline right,
- 28:36where shannon what was happening in china at this moment china actually um was just embarking in the
- 28:44late 70s on setting up shenzhen which was far from a central um you know top-down thing they
- 28:54they realized the frustration um and a fishing village of 30 to 60 000 people
- 29:03got autonomy to experiment with new rules.
- 29:08So they were just beginning at that point.
- 29:11And in fact, one of my earliest consulting projects was to go to Shenzhen.
- 29:16I think it was 82.
- 29:18And even after three years of reform,
- 29:21this basket case area was sprouting skyscrapers.
- 29:27And it was quite phenomenal.
- 29:29But these were manufacturing oriented.
- 29:33And the thing that tipped me into my next generation of free zone projects was reading this Wall Street Journal article about office work going offshore.
- 29:45So I said to the Montego Bay folks, we'd like to try a market survey and test the waters for how much of this information industry market will respond.
- 29:58And it was extraordinary.
- 29:59We contacted 100 potential firms, call centers, very much among them.
- 30:07And they were so ready, even before this zone had any structures for them, they wanted to be first in to that area.
- 30:19And two firms out of the 100 we contacted set up shop with data processing, offshore data entry operations.
- 30:28And is this purely a financial decision when it comes down to it?
- 30:32Back then, yes.
- 30:33But a little bit of hedging risk because when you have your customer service, contact centers all in one place, anything can happen to it.
- 30:45So part of the market was you can have a second center.
- 30:51The cornerstone for this was to get telecom prices way down.
- 30:55And there, in this recommendation on market research, we said, please get your monopoly prices down to market level.
- 31:08And that turned out to be a pivot.
- 31:112,000 jobs came in, largely in inbound and outbound call centers, claims processing, and so forth.
- 31:19So within a short number of years, we had this next generation of free zones moving from the traditional logistics and apparel, assembly, electronics, assembly base like Senjen to a service industry, knowledge industry free zone.
- 31:40So that was a very heartening.
- 31:43And is that still going?
- 31:45Yes.
- 31:46What's it called?
- 31:46Montego Bay Free Zone.
- 31:48Wow, it's still going now.
- 31:49And it gave rise to various offspring because what soon happened is free zones are wont to do.
- 31:58When somebody has got a quite big success going, neighbors want to do it too.
- 32:05So Dominican Republic at that point, I think, had just three or four traditional free zones.
- 32:11But they decided to gallop in and, with private sector investment and management, set up world-class free zones, including ones for teleservices.
- 32:24The big next evolution was, oh, by the way, the Dominican Free Zone decree, it was not legislation, said that it would allow private competitors to the monopoly country system to set up shop in the Free Zone.
- 32:45So it was extraterritorial in that way.
- 32:49And that then led to Uruguay setting the gold standard for this next generation of zone.
- 32:57They, by law, put in a single paragraph saying,
- 33:02no commercial government monopoly shall apply within the free zone boundaries.
- 33:08And that turned a cow pasture near Montevideo Airport into now Zone America, approaching 10,000 people in very high-end work, including software development, largely because the telecom price and the exemption from the power monopoly and insurance monopoly made this the place to go.
- 33:36and it um also added into the mix uh the right by right companies that want to bring in talent from
- 33:46overseas up to 30 percent of their their workers can come that way can i ask a question back then
- 33:54were you envisaging the evolution that we now see of zones was that you say you came into it from a
- 34:04sort of libertarian perspective so was that always in the back of your mind yes that that idea that
- 34:09look you can't go from here to there without going via here which is free zones manufacturing
- 34:17information um whatever and then and then all right well how about people living there then
- 34:23and then oh how about you know right well this um in the early 90s when when this was going very
- 34:29strong. In fact, in Israel, for Israel, I pulled together a whole bunch of video clips from
- 34:36companies for a free zone project there by very free market folks, saying that if the government
- 34:44removes a monopoly on telecoms, these video clips from companies that were employing,
- 34:50you know, thousands, tens of thousands of people said, if you do this to world standard,
- 34:56we can see a scenario where we can create 500 jobs or 1,500 jobs. It depended, but it aggregated
- 35:05to 10,000 jobs. And putting that together took maybe five or six months, but it led to the
- 35:14passage of what was a world-class Free Zone Act that then was rescinded when Ravine was killed.
- 35:22but through all this I learned the value of having very anti-fragile approaches
- 35:32that didn't take for granted that what governments put on paper would actually be honored.
- 35:41So what are the main components of that anti-fragility then would you say?
- 35:45Legal I presume.
- 35:46Well, interestingly, I do think the most important way to avoid the kind of blowback that many free zone projects have had is by designing it from day one with shared upside.
- 36:04Meaning that the private risk-taking capital that comes in gets its full freedom to make money.
- 36:13but under a build-operate-transfer agreement
- 36:19so that it aligns the incentives of host country stakeholders
- 36:25and the community residents who otherwise will feel,
- 36:29hey, this enclave is not...
- 36:30Sorry, you're going to need to repeat that.
- 36:32I didn't...
- 36:33Sorry.
- 36:34So for you, this would be one of the most important premises
- 36:40for setting up a free zone, according to you.
- 36:42Yes.
- 36:42Go on, say it again then. I wasn't following that well enough.
- 36:46Sure. First, make sure it's a prize to be won, that you're not locked into a location and pushing on the string.
- 36:53Make it a competition with something that's so invaluable to the country that's chosen that it will be very generous on a short timeline to make the kind of commitments of land and policy reform.
- 37:09Really? So what, using the same model as your space?
- 37:14Earthboard. Earthboard project.
- 37:15So what do you say, okay, everyone, I can probably get a lot of investment. Give me your best shot kind of thing.
- 37:23Right But to tie it into what Peter Diamandis calls a massively transformative purpose meaning a project that is so connected to very big splash upsides in whatever field of technology one can put together that makes it something of prestige value So you talking about sorry the government showing off about it basically governments That a big part exactly That a big part We don want those sons of bitches over in that
- 37:59area to get this prize. We want it.
- 38:03Oh, right. You mean internally in a country. I thought you meant you were putting it out
- 38:07to tender for other countries.
- 38:08Exactly.
- 38:09Right, but this one is...
- 38:10It works at that level and also in terms of in-country site competition.
- 38:16I mean, they do that. I remember that was in England. It's like you get different cities pitching for whatever.
- 38:26Right.
- 38:26You know, like the new Millennium Dome or something or whatever. We don't get free zones, unfortunately.
- 38:32Well, the Enterprise Zone initiative did have an element of this, because when I was recovering from the Earthport lesson learned,
- 38:41I was helping the Reagan administration. We produced a guidebook and model legislation.
- 38:50The core strategy we recommended was don't make this a buy-right entitlement. If enterprise-owned
- 38:58legislation passes, make it very clear that we'll go to those states that go the farthest to lower
- 39:05taxes and lower these other barriers that hold back entrepreneurs. That prospect of a federal
- 39:13level contest for designation led to wholesale adoption of the legislation that a libertarian
- 39:24lawyer, Pete Ferrara, drafted by the state of Kentucky. Unchanged, word for word, a very radical
- 39:33free market package, but with an element, and this comes back into the present day too,
- 39:41an element of sharing the land value upsides with the residents and with good causes that
- 39:51they care about.
- 39:52So it became a way to lever commitments from state and local governments to commit land
- 40:01that was idle property into effectively land trusts that would share dividends to the residents
- 40:12of areas that might otherwise have gentrification displacement issues.
- 40:16I was going to say something along the same lines.
- 40:18When you offer out a zone to tender, so everyone sort of like bids on it in a way, presumably
- 40:27Presumably you run the risk of alienating parts of the country.
- 40:32And this is one of the things I've heard people criticize free zones with.
- 40:38It's all very well to create a free zone in your country,
- 40:40but what about the places that don't get the free zone?
- 40:44Because they suffer on account that business,
- 40:47it's not just necessarily new business coming into the free zone.
- 40:50It might be business in their place moving to the free zone.
- 40:54Yeah, there is certainly, depending on the quality difference of the business climates, there can be redirection of capital.
- 41:06But the big driver of free zones, the best of them, is entrepreneurial talent.
- 41:12And Silicon Valley succeeded not because giant companies chose it, but because it had the elements for startups, microenterprise, garage scale ventures.
- 41:26Why did Silicon Valley get so successful then?
- 41:31I mean, particularly nice weather, nice place near nice places.
- 41:36It's a massive part of it.
- 41:38Yes, indeed.
- 41:39And there was an element of partnering with Stanford.
- 41:45The Stanford Research Park is, I think, an example of how land that's held by a powerful local stakeholder can be multiplied manyfold in value.
- 41:58once you get not only the business climate working well,
- 42:05but getting human talent highly tuned to what the market wants.
- 42:11And that's one of the innovations that the technology park in Silicon Valley,
- 42:16that first one, did was to tightly link the kind of courses
- 42:23and professors' interaction to the benefit of the tenants of the park.
- 42:30Did the park have any special rules and regulations?
- 42:36As far as I know, no.
- 42:37But this gets us to a frontier area for free zones.
- 42:42I think we're in a world now where the competition among different projects
- 42:47is largely not what official taxes you remove,
- 42:52but what are the implicit taxes that you remove? So many, many opportunities exist,
- 43:03even in places like the EU that have harmonized, you know, harmonization policies on taxes and regs.
- 43:11The competition field now becomes, how can we get the dead weight, the drag on people's lives,
- 43:20and especially their entrepreneurial ventures' lives.
- 43:24How can we bring that to as close to zero as we can?
- 43:30Administrative bottlenecks, red tape, corruption, things like crime,
- 43:37depending on the location, these weigh super heavily into the location decisions
- 43:43and the ability of bootstrap entrepreneurs to actually grow their business.
- 43:49I have to say, though, I mean, I'd like to hear your view on this.
- 43:55The EU or Europe, there is absolutely, I have personally,
- 43:59and I talk to people about this stuff all the time,
- 44:02I don't know anyone who has any interest in doing anything in the EU.
- 44:08And so even the thought that maybe free zones might help the EU,
- 44:15sure they would, 100%.
- 44:17people it's a joke now it's a running joke that the eu is is you know people people have ideas and
- 44:23then the eu just stop them yeah right it's so they need them but there's absolutely no way
- 44:29yeah they take them you know well here here again comes to the question of how do you change the
- 44:35political um landscape so that instead of objecting to enclave style uh zone initiatives
- 44:45turn into a race to say, yes, in my backyard, we want this thing.
- 44:54Good luck with that one.
- 44:55Well, as it happens, there are vehicles that can change the mood music.
- 45:03And one of them is to have build, operate, transfer pre-commitment.
- 45:11What does that mean?
- 45:11Build-operate transfer is a way that ports, airports, other infrastructure projects are attracting billions of private risk-taking capital.
- 45:24What they do is say, we will come in and put in this airport, this port, and run it on a progressive transfer of the asset to the local counterparts.
- 45:41so um that changes the reflex in some cases uh to say hmm you know this is no money out of our
- 45:51pocket and it's potentially big upsides in terms of the asset value and having vehicles like land
- 46:00trusts uh hong kong and singapore um macau lease land they don't sell it and the revenue it collects
- 46:10and rent, these places collect and rent, is proportional to how much confidence there is
- 46:16in the business climate. So it aligns the politicians in favor of simplifying life.
- 46:25And this makes a precedent that even in places like Eastern Europe, you can set a proposal for
- 46:33a leasehold, not alienating the land, but leasing long term, and having transparent auctions and
- 46:41tenders to draw in the capital to build in areas that are now struggling.
- 46:48Is that in, that's the opposite of what, I mean, I don't know if this is true, because I've never
- 46:54really talked to someone who knows, but I've heard that China invests in, I'm thinking,
- 47:00places like Sri Lanka, a lot of Africa.
- 47:02I've seen, yeah, they own, right?
- 47:05They're not leasing.
- 47:06Is that right?
- 47:07That's not right.
- 47:08Oh, okay.
- 47:08They're typically, my understanding is long-term lease.
- 47:13Right.
- 47:13And this, of course, is how Hong Kong got going,
- 47:1799-year lease.
- 47:18Sure, yeah.
- 47:19And so some of the Chinese projects
- 47:21do have very long leaseholds,
- 47:25but they're not, to my understanding,
- 47:29outright ownership, which is important. I think in the case of Sri Lanka, they went a step further.
- 47:37I wrote up a paper for Cato a while back on debt for freedom swaps. So yes, China is setting up
- 47:47these outposts worldwide and in debting or driving countries deeply in debt.
- 47:55But in Sri Lanka, they negotiated a debt-to-equity conversion, which was to say, we will tear up the IOUs in return for a concession, a limited duration, but a concession to operate the port.
- 48:14And that makes a precedent that as the world drowns in debt, that can be applied again and again by free market folks.
- 48:27And you'd call that win-win.
- 48:29So China brings in the capital.
- 48:33Sri Lanka gets their port without paying for it.
- 48:37But over the long term, claw back their asset.
- 48:41Yes, under a pre-agree.
- 48:44I mean, they make money.
- 48:45Yes.
- 48:46They make more money as time goes on.
- 48:48Right.
- 48:48So now how can we line up these billiard balls to get as much out of it as possible?
- 48:58Well, I think one way for sure to build a big constituency for the success of these free market zones
- 49:06is to have the land trust model and land lease model
- 49:11flowing to the immediate and direct benefit of regular folks.
- 49:19I think Nevis, you know, there have been direct dividend talks.
- 49:24Talking about destiny.
- 49:25But the idea of having learning vouchers, micro-vouchers,
- 49:33vouchers that can essentially open access to market-based learning and market-based health
- 49:42care these are things that from day one can be part of what i would call a lead with a gift
- 49:49um bundle well you i mean i actually you know over the episodes that we've been talking about
- 49:57this stuff on this podcast i've been putting together my my absolute necessities when you
- 50:03when you do this stuff and one of them is exactly that ways to protect your zone um legal obviously
- 50:11yeah and that's really important and you get that right as we've seen here in prosper it worked
- 50:16amazing socialists came in didn't do anything kind of did something but but it didn't shut the place
- 50:21down secondly though only to that really and almost as important is keeping everyone happy
- 50:28who lives there and who lives next door to you and i think funnily enough prosperer didn't do that
- 50:35really well to start with possibly right they or they did it they did do it well they just didn't
- 50:42outreach they didn't communicate it well enough i they didn't they didn't hurt anyone they didn't
- 50:47destroy anything they didn't break any rules they didn't go against anything they said but they
- 50:53didn't stop the rumor mill right and i think slowly now there's been a there's been a change
- 50:58because i think people are seeing the benefits like if you're a local if you're from crawfish
- 51:03bay or whatever and you work here and now you're doing well and now your neighbor says oh and
- 51:08there's a job going there and that slowly changes the public opinion but i would say that's second
- 51:14most important thing because it's it's a it's actually a protection against getting shut down
- 51:20as well you know legal protections are great but when you've got the community behind you
- 51:25that's even better that's a better incentive model in many ways for a government to not come in
- 51:30and shut you down for sure and these catalysts these micro stipends or micro vouchers can open
- 51:38Day one access to telemedicine resources, for example, to get second opinions.
- 51:47In the case of learning, education, there's already vast amounts of free content available.
- 51:54But what's not so accessible are credentialing projects, work-study projects, internship, virtual internship opportunities.
- 52:08And this is where free zones have a huge potential because through digital networks, they can offer with partnership with telecenters or whoever the cell phone companies are, they can offer on ramps for people to stand out.
- 52:28not just, oh, I took this course online, but actually I did. And here are links to a portfolio
- 52:35showing what I did to apply it for the benefit of my friends or my neighbors,
- 52:43my whole community. And this gives a chance, you know, again, you mentioned spreading virally.
- 52:50it gives a lot of opportunity the micro vouchers which i i helped launch in sri lanka with
- 52:58entrepreneurial schools in four areas were 30 each so how does i had another question first
- 53:06but i want to know i want you to explain to me what exactly what a micro voucher is as well
- 53:10but i was more thinking about in the case of outreach to the community would be build a
- 53:17hospital in your free zone that the community can use yes yeah i i that's what that's kind of what i
- 53:24was meaning but your what are you with micro vouchers what do you mean that locals get a
- 53:29voucher for being nearby or something and and then what with the horizon lanka school a poor poor
- 53:38village right at the front lines of the civil war um we found a a exceptional bootstrap entrepreneur
- 53:47who'd set up an alternative to the public schools,
- 53:50and he had gotten various contributions of computers and whatnot.
- 53:58But the kids that were in there, and this was middle school age into high school,
- 54:06the kids were still relying on very ad hoc kind of learning.
- 54:12So we made a standing offer to the Horizon Line Cut.
- 54:18We'll set aside money for a dozen micro-vouchers, micro-stipends,
- 54:24to encourage kids to teach kids using course material that they prepare,
- 54:32PowerPoint presentations or quick animations.
- 54:36What's the point of the voucher?
- 54:38This is the bit I don't understand.
- 54:38It's to say if you, the entrepreneurial school in the community, would like to offer more than you're doing to the students and families, we will pay $30 for each completed online learning lesson that they create.
- 54:58and dozens of these little PowerPoint presentations
- 55:06explaining this in algebra or that in science,
- 55:11the kids put together.
- 55:13And this is an example of how to build a credentialing portfolio
- 55:17that the kids who otherwise would just be taking exams.
- 55:23You're into competitions, aren't you?
- 55:26Yeah.
- 55:27That's another version.
- 55:28It's a repurposed version of instead of here's some money, go and teach the kids.
- 55:32It's like here's some money you can earn by learning that thing and passing it on to your contemporary.
- 55:39In ways that are shared.
- 55:40And this village had never had people get into university before Horizon Lanka.
- 55:47by the time we finished with our micro-vouchers,
- 55:54the graduating class, it started with seven people under a tree
- 55:58when the school was launched.
- 56:02The graduating class, three out of seven of this graduating class
- 56:09got accepted in universities in Sri Lanka.
- 56:13And there was a video on YouTube of Craig Barrett,
- 56:17then the head of Intel, hearing about this and meeting the graduates and saying,
- 56:26if you guys don't want to go to Sri Lankan universities, Intel will pay for your college education.
- 56:33So these little tiny catalysts can have dramatic effects on people's futures.
- 56:40But it about creating an incentive model that slightly different to a lot of people idea of coming in And I think a lot of people look at free zones and think everyone gonna act like economists think they gonna act and they never do
- 57:00obviously it's all bullshit um I mean it's mostly bullshit some of it it signals and sort of
- 57:06roughly correct um but but what you're talking about is creating an actual incentive structure
- 57:13that promotes a free market of,
- 57:21you're bringing in the free market
- 57:23and letting people join in.
- 57:26That's right.
- 57:27Basically.
- 57:27In Kyrgyzstan in 2005,
- 57:31in six months and with a very small budget,
- 57:35I was brought in by the Academy for Educational Development
- 57:39to figure out how they could spread grassroots learning.
- 57:44We wound up creating micro-voucher prizes
- 57:47that would be earned by four villages, to be determined,
- 57:55that committed land, a land grant endowment,
- 58:00to endow the scholarship,
- 58:01and partnered with an entrepreneurial telecenter operator,
- 58:07cyber cafe kind of thing.
- 58:11In this very tight window of time,
- 58:16with the kind of workshops and the buzz creation,
- 58:2150 villages put in bidding to receive one of the top packages of micro-ouchers.
- 58:32And 25 of them had applications, including photographs of the sites that they were prepared to commit.
- 58:42Ultimately, five were chosen to receive $20,000 worth of microvouchers.
- 58:49And within another eight or nine months, 9,000 Kyrgyz had come to telecenters
- 58:58to learn the basics of how to go online, do email, web search, and so on.
- 59:04And then a Singaporean telecoms entrepreneur came in
- 59:09and funded 16 in total of these e-centers.
- 59:13So it works if you create a prize to be won.
- 59:16And what does the invest...
- 59:20So the Singaporean guy is coming in to make money.
- 59:23That's right, with telecenters, yeah.
- 59:25And, oh, sorry, the telecentres as in the call centers?
- 59:29No, telecentres meaning cyber cafes, basically.
- 59:33Is that a big business?
- 59:36Oh, very much so at this transition period.
- 59:39They were the first access points.
- 59:41So in this particular Kyrgyzstan case, do you have to create a free zone for it or not?
- 59:47Well, interesting question.
- 59:49Yes, under the original frame, the three things had to be put in.
- 59:55There had to be a risk-taking entrepreneur willing to be the center point, a land trust
- 1:00:02or a land grant commitment where 10% of the future land rent would flow back into the
- 1:00:08microvoucher fund, third element, policy reform.
- 1:00:12Guess what?
- 1:00:13since USAID was putting this up, and USAID had, thanks to a 60 Minutes or 2020 feature,
- 1:00:25banned any geographic targeting of tax relief, that element, that third element of this project
- 1:00:38was knocked out.
- 1:00:40So what we could have had was a very vibrant competition
- 1:00:44to innovate in how to simplify taxes and regulatory burdens.
- 1:00:51That was ruled out.
- 1:00:54But that wouldn't have been on a federal level then?
- 1:00:58That would have been on local versions?
- 1:01:01Right.
- 1:01:01We were encouraging local innovation to improve business climates.
- 1:01:05So, okay. So in that particular instance, the idea is, right, we have a Singaporean entrepreneur who wants to make a bit of money. He can set up internet centers. You say to the country, right, this guy wants to come in and do this.
- 1:01:24if you can provide land and give and you take 10 of the revenue from that land he will bring his
- 1:01:33capital and create this thing and you get in education yes but the singaporean guy wasn't
- 1:01:39in the picture the first round right competition was for five spots simply with the catalytic
- 1:01:45micro voucher offer but where did you get your your collateral from then well the that happened
- 1:01:52And later, when the response was so vibrant, it got somehow to the attention of a Singaporean.
- 1:01:59No, I mean your original ones.
- 1:02:02Who pays for those?
- 1:02:04The original microvouchers?
- 1:02:05Yeah.
- 1:02:06I am sad to say it was your tax dollars at work through USAID.
- 1:02:11Oh, okay.
- 1:02:12But it was done since my consulting practice,
- 1:02:18about 70% was doing World Bank and USAID work.
- 1:02:23It was done with, unfortunately, tax-funded money.
- 1:02:27But it was done in ways to create a breakout from subsidy
- 1:02:33through the land grant endowment.
- 1:02:36Give a man a, don't give a man a fish,
- 1:02:38give a man a fishing rod.
- 1:02:40That was the idea anyway.
- 1:02:42Yeah, God, that all went a bit tits up, as we say, didn't it?
- 1:02:46Well, I'm all for being a radical libertarian.
- 1:02:50I'm all for it not being funded by taxes.
- 1:02:53And I do think we're at the cusp now of another turning point.
- 1:02:58And this is where there's a little side note I should have inserted in this.
- 1:03:04by the mid-90s, there were online free market projects that were setting up gig economy
- 1:03:13opportunities. And so I was very early in with Phil Salen, who founded the initial
- 1:03:20market of its kind, to test out micro-entrepreneurial
- 1:03:27paths for people offshore to come in. And so I had a remote secretary, Camille Crichton,
- 1:03:37in the Caribbean. In the 90s? Yes. Actually, even a little before,
- 1:03:41on a one-to-one basis, I worked with Camille from late 80s. But this notion of a big shift
- 1:03:50away from having free zones depend on mid-sized companies or big companies
- 1:03:58to making them magnets for talent to come and access global free markets.
- 1:04:06Today, Fiverr.com, Freelancer.com have well over 40 million registered freelancers.
- 1:04:13They're free to join.
- 1:04:14And they compete in reverse auction markets to do transcription projects or whatever.
- 1:04:23Gosh, I've never thought about that before.
- 1:04:26It puts the network's state to shame, doesn't it, really, when you think about it?
- 1:04:30Well, the talent pool is there.
- 1:04:32And two huge changes have taken place.
- 1:04:39One is that in the early days, people coming in had a reasonable shot of landing work.
- 1:04:47But in a reverse auction market, even though the price is almost giveaway, to start earning reputation, 80% of the freelancers who come into these markets never land a single micro project.
- 1:05:05Right.
- 1:05:05Because nobody wants to trust an un-unniperable project.
- 1:05:09Unknown talent.
- 1:05:09But I thought, because when I've ever dipped my toes into those kind of worlds,
- 1:05:15what tends to happen is the winners put their prices up,
- 1:05:20which is an incentive to look for someone cheaper, right?
- 1:05:24Yes.
- 1:05:24And there's probably at the edge of the market,
- 1:05:28there's probably a bunch of people just trying new people out all the time.
- 1:05:31Exactly.
- 1:05:32And some of the better innovators in this space form freelance subnetworks through this talent pool.
- 1:05:43So they're presenting a single point of interface, but then farming it out.
- 1:05:49Well, so just to go back to the talent that's available to free zone, free city initiators,
- 1:05:57immense pools of talent, hungry talent, that can be mobilized for whatever specific things are needed.
- 1:06:06But the second thing that's not, unfortunately, wasn't in the picture but now is,
- 1:06:16is AIs are just sweeping out a big giant rug pull of these on-ramps for micro-entrepreneurs.
- 1:06:27So that brings us, I think, to what this next giant opportunity is for free zones.
- 1:06:37The talent that's available in these online markets has been doing manual services.
- 1:06:45But we're now at the cusp of seeing AIs transform field after field.
- 1:06:52And so the opportunity, as I see it, for win-win-win is for free zone initiators to offer micro-vouchers that help talent globally and also in the region that they're working in, help them get their first experiences with AI, delivering value.
- 1:07:20And so we have a B&B rental business in Virginia, and we are setting aside now, quote, neighborhood share, about 10% of our earnings, to feed into microvouchers that will offer first experience with AI opportunities for people in the community.
- 1:07:50where your Airbnb is?
- 1:07:52Yes.
- 1:07:52In the U.S.?
- 1:07:54Yes.
- 1:07:55And I am here in part,
- 1:07:57I just came back from Portugal
- 1:07:58where we have a similar offer
- 1:08:03to fund work-study projects.
- 1:08:06Again, scale, 30 bucks, $50.
- 1:08:10But they're released
- 1:08:13when the student or the job seeker
- 1:08:17has uploaded onto YouTube or TikTok
- 1:08:21a summary of what they've done with AI
- 1:08:24to benefit either their own life
- 1:08:27or the life of their friends
- 1:08:29or the life of their neighborhood.
- 1:08:32So that's the prerequisite for getting the voucher.
- 1:08:36That's right.
- 1:08:36That's right.
- 1:08:37And who judges that?
- 1:08:38Well, while it's still in early pilot,
- 1:08:42it's, I guess, my call.
- 1:08:45But we're doing this in order to see how we can create a very replicable open source precedent.
- 1:08:58So, but the bit I'm struggling with is why you need a free zone or a physical place even for this.
- 1:09:08And the, okay, this gets to this cascade that's coming, what Peter Diamandis and company have called a tsunami of AI.
- 1:09:24It's in the next 12 to 18 months going to be just hammering the traditional economy.
- 1:09:30So people who are set on classic paths to job security are cooked.
- 1:09:38and that applies as robotics come in to physical things.
- 1:09:43It certainly applies to a lot of the knowledge work.
- 1:09:48Where is the money going to come from as we see costs plunging in goods and services thanks to this wave?
- 1:09:57It's going to come in the form of experiences, in the form of offering hosting places that are great spots to visit and grow, learn new things.
- 1:10:18So this is where I see the future of free zones.
- 1:10:22It's not the traditional kind of factory or office cubicle job creation.
- 1:10:30It's going to be much more creating environments of safety, of conviviality, and of serendipity.
- 1:10:43Tuned to, like your daughter you mentioned, is very much into horses.
- 1:10:52So free zones in the future, to the degree one wishes to share one's own values and aspirations with them, will be able to use AIs and the kind of quality human contact that makes for an experience that is a keeper.
- 1:11:17well let's use my daughter as an example then because i'll explain what we were talking about
- 1:11:22last night when i met you but my eldest daughter is matt she's just i've just been looking at
- 1:11:28another video of her riding she's got a horse she loves it to bits but she learned through a neighbor
- 1:11:35of ours who's got lots of horses about natural horsemanship natural horsemanship is a very
- 1:11:41specific way of training horses and it's very different from the the way that we train them in
- 1:11:48the uk which is kind of based on military training of horses you kind of beat them into submission
- 1:11:52pretty much in a way not not literally beat them but natural horsemanship is about literally learning
- 1:11:58how to be a horse around your horse and create a relationship it's incredible it's absolutely
- 1:12:03incredible it's incredible and the most famous proponent is a guy called buck branahan who's a
- 1:12:09he's a u.s cowboy type guy who can you know tame a stat you get a wild mustang and within 20 minutes
- 1:12:16this guy's kind of got him just standing around and walking around he's he's an absolute you know
- 1:12:22and there's a lot and it's it spawned this kind of industry of well not even industry there's just
- 1:12:28culture of natural horsemanship now of course my daughter who's she's only 13 she can't start
- 1:12:36study with buck um she really wants to and i showed her how to use ai because i use it a lot
- 1:12:44and one of the first things she did because she had some and and this came out of a genuine need
- 1:12:50it wasn't just a little experiment she was struggling heart really struggling with some
- 1:12:54things with her horse and i don't know whether you know young girls and horses it's it's painful
- 1:12:59emotionally painful it's a it's a really hard thing to not be be getting what you want out of
- 1:13:05your horse and stuff so she got the ai to learn everything about buck branahan because there's a
- 1:13:11lot of it out there he's been in films he's got his own website there's thousands of videos of him
- 1:13:16explaining how to train horses whatever she directed an ai at but at him that's um water
- 1:13:24coming out of pipes by the way it's a it's an interesting place isn't it but this is just a
- 1:13:28noise and um and said right now from now on talk to me as if you're buck branahan and and it worked
- 1:13:36because she said okay you know i'm when i'm riding and uh you know i i don't know she knows way more
- 1:13:43than horses than me but she would have questions that i would have absolutely no idea and i felt
- 1:13:48it's a hard thing to be a dad to a 14 a 13 year old girl and you can't answer her questions yeah
- 1:13:54but she would ask buck and the ai spoke to her as buck branahan and as far as i can tell was spot on
- 1:14:02pretty much every single time wow and that's what she does now so she's and i mean she still wants
- 1:14:09to go and train with buck and she still wants to go out to america he's still alive you can you can
- 1:14:13go and you can do a workshop with him and you know she still wants to do all that but she has
- 1:14:18solved some very serious problems that she had that were causing her absolute heartbreak and
- 1:14:23distress by using this AI? Well, the Alpha School, I gather we have a graduate of the Alpha School
- 1:14:31at this conference I have yet to meet, but they were on a podcast called Moonshots.
- 1:14:41Peter Diamandis, Alex Wisner-Gross recently had this, the founders of this company,
- 1:14:48And they have come up with a highly, highly game-changing way to do education that's super attuned and personalized in a manner that can scale and is scaling now.
- 1:15:05They're opening up a lot of places.
- 1:15:07These entrepreneurs have a setting where they hire teachers not to teach, but they are hiring highly skilled motivators, coaches, people who are sensitive to what each individual in the class is doing.
- 1:15:29And for two hours, max, people do academic work,
- 1:15:37but this time it's being delivered through AIs
- 1:15:42in a game-like way using the characters
- 1:15:47that that individual learner admires most. So it means the buck, the avatar of buck with
- 1:15:58obviously the permissions all having been given, is explaining trigonometry or the Krebs cycle or
- 1:16:09some such in a way that's super attuned to be in the zone, not too hard, not too easy,
- 1:16:17but in that state of flow that good games have. And that is leading to 3x, 5x
- 1:16:26improvements in skill levels with the rest of the day then open for whatever you love to do.
- 1:16:37And so you've got a community now in these alpha schools of kids in the peer culture of one where they're mutually supporting and exchanging updates and high fives and whatever as they hit their milestones.
- 1:16:55But the reward for doing the milestones is they have time to do what they love to do.
- 1:17:02what is the difference between that and just getting the latest version of chat tpt paying
- 1:17:09a subscription and asking it the same thing are they training their models are their models
- 1:17:13isolated and they're training them in a specific way or they do have um they've done the first step
- 1:17:20toward an open source a version of what they they have but it turns out that the human presence and
- 1:17:28caring is um in a way surpasses just having the the course the interactive course so what's
- 1:17:37explain the difference explain the ai part and the and the human part it's taught by a real human
- 1:17:45no uh the real teachers the real teachers are there not to teach but to know enough of the
- 1:17:54landscape the domain to be able to encourage or make suggestions on how that individual learning
- 1:18:03then should ask buck so like this kind of really yes oh my god it's a complete reshaping of
- 1:18:10okay i've got so many questions number one is i still don't understand why that's the future of
- 1:18:17free zones because you could do that anywhere right well this gets back to what happens when
- 1:18:25when bots you know physical and virtual are doing the stuff that it been the mainstay of
- 1:18:33free zone employment the in terms of industry the apparel assembly the electronics assembly
- 1:18:39that's going and in terms of call centers another huge factor yeah um that's now being done better
- 1:18:48by right by utterly realistic ai so sorry i so the reason you think is the future is because
- 1:18:57free zones need a future and and this is one it's not i mean because when i think of prosper here
- 1:19:03for example the regulatory autonomy they have obviously attracts business so it's it's it's a
- 1:19:09But that in itself is a characteristic of a free zone in a way.
- 1:19:14Yeah.
- 1:19:15So what you're saying is you wouldn't give them any special,
- 1:19:19like there wouldn't be anything different between the Alpha School
- 1:19:23in a free zone and the Alpha School outside?
- 1:19:27Yeah.
- 1:19:27Well, if there are barriers,
- 1:19:30and a lot of the Alpha School kids are launching ventures
- 1:19:33that are making money.
- 1:19:36Ah, right.
- 1:19:37So this becomes a way for people who care about having a future, their kids having a great future and being in a peer culture, this becomes an added magnet to attract global talent.
- 1:19:53And then the kids themselves springboard into entrepreneurship as a result of having the self-confidence, having the portfolio of cool projects they've done.
- 1:20:07They become bankable.
- 1:20:09And one surprising thing of the Moonshots podcast, David Blunden, who runs a VC firm at MIT, in the MIT area, he said, what we're looking for now are not people who have this grade or that diploma.
- 1:20:27we're looking for people who have actually done stuff, uploaded things that we can look and see
- 1:20:34the quality of what they're doing on GitHub repositories or, you know, the videos that they
- 1:20:42created. That's one. But the second thing is, rather than bet the farm, and these are micro bets
- 1:20:50increasingly.
- 1:20:52Excuse me.
- 1:20:55We want
- 1:20:56to find friendship
- 1:20:58networks
- 1:20:59where, like the roommates
- 1:21:03that have gone on to great
- 1:21:05things to launch
- 1:21:06ventures together.
- 1:21:08This kind of environment of having
- 1:21:10early experience with building
- 1:21:12your trust nets and having
- 1:21:14people who share your
- 1:21:16excitement and compliment you
- 1:21:18and skills, they become much more bankable to attract seed funding or even full-scale VC funding
- 1:21:28than do the current approaches to venture funding. So this means that the zones can stand out in
- 1:21:38terms of the quality of the whole person that's being formed and these become pathways then for
- 1:21:46a proliferation of entrepreneurship,
- 1:21:50which I think is going to be the future for free zone.
- 1:21:55Well, it almost certainly is,
- 1:21:57because who would want to be an entrepreneur
- 1:21:59in the UK now?
- 1:22:01No, I mean it.
- 1:22:02I know we laugh about it,
- 1:22:04but I have no interest in entrepreneuring
- 1:22:07in my own country at all.
- 1:22:09Not a small bit,
- 1:22:11because I know what a waste it would be,
- 1:22:14and eventually even if even if you know plus the the opportunities elsewhere are are too inspiring
- 1:22:22i think that's a that's a lovely idea when you think about it if you're teaching i mean the
- 1:22:28problem and as you were speaking i was just going through in my mind it's quite a sad state of
- 1:22:34affairs that basically what a lot of free zones or like say prosper what prosper is actually doing
- 1:22:40is just stripping back the entrepreneurial landscape
- 1:22:45back to something that's actually quite good.
- 1:22:47And it always used to be.
- 1:22:49I mean, imagine arriving in America in the 1700s or 1800s or something.
- 1:22:55That was the land of opportunity.
- 1:23:00And then 200 years later, 300 years later,
- 1:23:03you've got this place in Europe, which is the complete opposite,
- 1:23:07or in my country, which is the...
- 1:23:08And where you want to go is the frontier where there's opportunity again.
- 1:23:13And if you are learning it from a young age and you are incentivized to work on a project, which I agree, the best learning experiences my kids have is when they're making a project, not when they're being taught anything.
- 1:23:28I agree with you.
- 1:23:29That whole system is almost just backward now.
- 1:23:34My kids go to, we homeschooled them for a while, but they're at school now.
- 1:23:38And when they come home, I mean, we always tell them.
- 1:23:42My wife doesn't always like it, but I'm saying, look, play the game,
- 1:23:47but know what's going on.
- 1:23:49And because originally when I first started using AI a few years ago,
- 1:23:53I was like, look, you can just completely scam the system here.
- 1:24:00And most people think, well, you shouldn't.
- 1:24:02You've got to be learning.
- 1:24:03I'm like, no.
- 1:24:04Actually, as I went on, I was like, no, you should.
- 1:24:07you need to learn how to scam the system here and how to beat the system because the system is really
- 1:24:12not good for you i can see it now what is good for you is using these tools and everyone's trying
- 1:24:17to be moralistic and saying oh you can't do that because it's not but but in 10 years time it's
- 1:24:23like when i invented calculators you know it's like oh don't use that you've got to learn how to
- 1:24:27do it in your head and now someone's doing it down 10 000 times faster than you um jensen
- 1:24:32Wang, who I think was founder of NVIDIA, had a wonderful comment on this. He said,
- 1:24:42I want everybody in this company to learn how to use AI, but to use AIs in terms of adversarial
- 1:24:55contest between themselves because there you do get the next level of skill and insight
- 1:25:06by seeing what the strong points and weak points are in these AI generated systems.
- 1:25:14And so that, again, comes back to a very live current interest of mine is how can we make
- 1:25:21essentially the game-like battleground dashboards
- 1:25:28where people early gain skill,
- 1:25:33not relying on one AI,
- 1:25:35but rather taking multiple AIs of their choosing
- 1:25:39and learning how to...
- 1:25:42Hit them off against each other.
- 1:25:44That's an interesting thought.
- 1:25:46I almost certainly don't understand AI well enough,
- 1:25:50but every time i have had a very heavy week of use i realize that this thing's out of control
- 1:25:59it's too good it's and for example in that situation there i wonder whether you even need
- 1:26:04to pit ais off against each other because an ai would already understand that it could pit itself
- 1:26:09it could pit it off against itself presumably i don't know like the worst thing about ai and all
- 1:26:16the sort of folklore around it is just the wild predictions and accusations and and you know that
- 1:26:24that go along with it and i really haven't got a clue but people say you know you mentioned 18
- 1:26:29months you know in 18 months time xyz will be happening and i don't know if that's gonna be
- 1:26:34true or not i think it's tempting to think yeah we'll all be out of a job in five years
- 1:26:39but it's also not as well and um i don't really know what the answer is i know that
- 1:26:46on the whole when people panic about something it's not something that you need to worry about
- 1:26:53normally you know what i mean like if there's a oh my god this is the next big thing that's
- 1:26:58going to happen you can normally chill out about that when it dies down you you you didn't get
- 1:27:05affected by that point. Or, you know, climate change is going to kill us all in 10 years.
- 1:27:10You know, okay, I think we're going to be good. We're cool. We don't have to worry too much about
- 1:27:16that. Those kind of things. And I think history has proven that right. Most people tend to flip
- 1:27:22flop between different things that they worry about. So in that sense, I'm not too worried about
- 1:27:28trying to understand the future of AI. Because we are. We're all trying to position ourselves,
- 1:27:33And the question then becomes, how do you get ground truth?
- 1:27:39Because AI is more and more content is created by AIs and they're hallucinating 5, 10 percent of the time.
- 1:27:47So they're eating their own tail, chewing up the hallucinations and then regurgitating out with new hallucinations.
- 1:27:57So there have to be proving grounds for the AIs and turning them into competitions for prediction.
- 1:28:06If Prospera changes this aspect of the onboarding experience, you have three or four AIs saying,
- 1:28:14we predict that's going to lead to this increase in terms of visitors or that increase in terms of number of e-citizens.
- 1:28:22These are ways for AIs now to show that they can make changes.
- 1:28:29And the rule sets, because the zones can offer clean rooms for policy innovation, it creates a potentially self-reinforcing cycle of evolution where the AIs get better proving grounds.
- 1:28:48and the rule sets that AIs are helping to suggest,
- 1:28:53have real world, side by side,
- 1:28:59proofs of which one is doing it right or better than the other.
- 1:29:04What do you think are the most important things for a zone to offer?
- 1:29:09I mean, I'm talking about Prosper here.
- 1:29:12I'm talking about these kind of zones,
- 1:29:13not necessarily just a free port or something.
- 1:29:16what where we're at now which is the the latest iteration of what we would have called economic
- 1:29:22zones free zones is zones where people live work and benefit from all the things that that zone has
- 1:29:32the the special permissions and stuff so what what what is what are the most important things
- 1:29:36to offer people? I think there is a vacuum to be filled of massive transformational change for the
- 1:29:48better. They're not understood in the public view as being enablers of a gigantic leap that people
- 1:30:00can relate to in terms of change for the better in their lives. Yes, the argument about better
- 1:30:08governance is there and is very credible, but it is not something emotionally that most people
- 1:30:16are attuned to enough to invest in understanding the innovation. But people do understand
- 1:30:25their health, their health span, whether their kids are in a soul-destroying setting or not.
- 1:30:38What kind of things can be done better in terms of building the kind of skills of conviviality
- 1:30:47that Jordan Hall and others have noted?
- 1:30:51these things are reaching straight to the heart of people everywhere. And so far,
- 1:31:01I think there's been a lack of communication and a lack of clarity on how massive change is going
- 1:31:13to unfold for the better as a result of what happening here And this gets into being a proving ground for bold ideas and
- 1:31:29linking with people who are well-known, who are opinion shapers in different fields,
- 1:31:37Because if they come into contact with projects like Prospera and say this pipeline of life-changing education opportunities and health improvements and innovations and affordable housing,
- 1:32:00these things are, this is the place that it's setting the proving ground for the rest of the
- 1:32:10world. This kind of thematic specializing, I think it lends itself not to say one zone is the
- 1:32:19source of all this stuff, but rather if there are complementary networks of very high profile
- 1:32:28admired people in 20 or 30 of the leading areas of hope for the future. This is the way that these
- 1:32:39zones can go beyond the enclave kind of way of being and become a common pool resource for
- 1:32:48humanity in ways that will, in fact, open a lot more profitable opportunities to expand and spread.
- 1:32:56right so um sum that up in in in real terms right like i'm i'm starting a new i've i've found a great
- 1:33:09location i've got i've got um i've got a state on board i've got the opportunity um what do i need
- 1:33:18to do you know in what do i need to offer people literally you know what would be in my manifesto
- 1:33:25for trying to attract people? Well, to take one of the greatest areas of state failure,
- 1:33:33which is education, to go to four or five of the world's leading initiatives to break
- 1:33:43out of the dysfunction and say, we would like you to set up a proving area that will
- 1:33:54be where the most scalable, world-changing innovations that you got can be shown.
- 1:34:04And we're prepared under the scenario to share the upsides. If your success is here,
- 1:34:15magnify the number of people coming, the companies being formed, the value of the land in a
- 1:34:22specialized section of the project. We want these to be flowing back to you or to good causes that
- 1:34:31you choose. That way, having world-leading innovators in environmental initiatives, in health,
- 1:34:44in education, name the field that is going to be transformed anyway, find the early movers,
- 1:34:52and the most admired people and have them set up their dream proving grounds
- 1:35:01and pilot areas, that I think will enlist a lot of people
- 1:35:08who are now on the sidelines or, no, I don't understand it.
- 1:35:12But if these are areas that connect with people in their heart,
- 1:35:17that will help grow.
- 1:35:18What about, though, the big, I think, problem, one of the major problems, is attracting people to physically move, and especially families.
- 1:35:33I'm of the opinion that attracting digital nomads is good.
- 1:35:41It's part of the process, but it's not a long-term strategy.
- 1:35:46it's about local people.
- 1:35:49I suppose in that sense
- 1:35:50education would be a great way to do it.
- 1:35:52But I often think as well
- 1:35:54that as long as you offer
- 1:35:56a better standard of living
- 1:35:58inside your zone than outside your zone
- 1:36:00a cheaper better standard of living
- 1:36:01which is inevitable really
- 1:36:03then you normally can't go wrong with locals.
- 1:36:08There is a trap in that model
- 1:36:12which is the better you make it
- 1:36:15And let's say it's the classic artists, the first movers into distressed areas.
- 1:36:21They make it cool.
- 1:36:23And then the rents go up and out they go.
- 1:36:28There, to my mind, is a huge frontier also that Free Zone pioneers can innovate in
- 1:36:35to vest those who do add value to the quality of life
- 1:36:40and do make life more affordable to share in the upsides because the land value.
- 1:36:48The land values always capitalize these intangible improvements.
- 1:36:55If it's a super cool neighborhood, up goes the land value.
- 1:36:59If it's a super safe neighborhood, up goes the land value.
- 1:37:02Same with education.
- 1:37:03So the innovators and bootstrap entrepreneurs who are behind many, if not all, of these kind of disruptive changes for the better, if you don't have a way to vest them with a share on dividends of land or land trust rights, these things keep the starving artists who are adding value on board.
- 1:37:32instead of throw them overboard.
- 1:37:35So that would, I hope, be part of this package.
- 1:37:38What do you think Prosper is doing right and wrong then
- 1:37:40when you look around here now?
- 1:37:42I take it you've been following it for a while.
- 1:37:44I have.
- 1:37:45And I think the original let's go all in on one location,
- 1:37:54I had in conversations with the early team,
- 1:38:00encouraged them to create a competition or contest, prize to be won.
- 1:38:05But by that time, they were so committed here,
- 1:38:09and understandably, it's a gorgeous place.
- 1:38:12They didn't have the same leverage to have multiple sites competing
- 1:38:18to land them as the project.
- 1:38:21So I think that was something, in retrospect,
- 1:38:24I would have certainly hoped could have been done differently.
- 1:38:28I mean, they can definitely do that now.
- 1:38:30Yes.
- 1:38:31I mean, Prosper isn't even a physical location.
- 1:38:33It doesn't have to be.
- 1:38:34Exactly.
- 1:38:35And I think the other missing ingredient is a bundle of day one benefits.
- 1:38:42Whichever direction they go, whichever partnering sites or spinoff sites get created,
- 1:38:49to change the understanding of that community as to what's in store,
- 1:38:56it can be changed the way the Phoenicians built trust in setting up the first free zones.
- 1:39:053,000 years ago, it was a mess in the Middle East. And after the Hittites and the Egyptians
- 1:39:13had fought themselves to exhaustion, these traders out of Lebanon, the Phoenicians,
- 1:39:20said, well, you know, let's go shopping for trading partners. And the way they did it was
- 1:39:26they'd load up their boats with samples of their wares. And just as night was falling
- 1:39:33on an unknown territory, they wouldn't go straight into the village. But close to the village,
- 1:39:39they would row in and leave a bunch of goodies of their trade wares on the beach.
- 1:39:46And they would light a fire and then row back. And the next morning, the villagers come out and,
- 1:39:55my goodness, look, the gifts on the beach, what do we do? Well, obviously, lots of them would just
- 1:40:03take it and bye-bye. The Phoenicians head onward. But what happened often was the villagers would
- 1:40:13respond with their own gifts on a beach. And so this would then prompt the waiting Phoenicians
- 1:40:22to row back in and start trade.
- 1:40:28And this was how trust was established
- 1:40:32in a very low trust time and environment.
- 1:40:36And it can happen today too.
- 1:40:38So I would hope that Prospera
- 1:40:40and other free zone ventures that want to spread
- 1:40:44will look at early wins
- 1:40:47where they can through micro vouchers,
- 1:40:50micro scholarships, things that give people day one limited, but day one actual access to surprising,
- 1:41:01you know, unexpected benefits in telemedicine in terms of their preparation with work study
- 1:41:10projects, launching into online markets with AI help. These kind of things can be done at
- 1:41:17trivial cost and reach hundreds of people from day one. So I would hope that that kind of virtual
- 1:41:28gifts on a beach can be added to the mix. And also a vision and a path to sharing the upsides
- 1:41:40in terms of land value with people who make the region,
- 1:41:46make the area safer, more beautiful, more inviting to visit.
- 1:41:52And when you say land value, like take Prospera as the example.
- 1:41:59Prospera, this particular site here where we are now,
- 1:42:02they bought that land.
- 1:42:03Yes.
- 1:42:04So what you are saying is originally if they had bought the land
- 1:42:08and then the previous owners of the land still had an option or not an option but
- 1:42:16how does it work they're just a percentage yeah a percentage um revenue share is one one way to go
- 1:42:26straight off right uh but with trans land value itself you can't unless you sell the land it
- 1:42:31doesn't have any value does it not true um hong kong and singapore won't sell land
- 1:42:35the lease land at tender open transparent tender it comes so that they the original owners of
- 1:42:44maintain ownership just on a very long lease okay exactly and and this aligns everyone's incentives
- 1:42:51to say let's make life easier not more uncertain for for for the folks here it's a great idea but i
- 1:43:00I think I'm thinking that your average VC wants to buy the land, doesn't he?
- 1:43:05In the US, yes.
- 1:43:08But certainly in Asia, this model, which has worked beautifully in Singapore and Hong Kong, Macau, it's very much part of the landscape there.
- 1:43:20and I think that's a a way in a time of heightened polarization and suspicion
- 1:43:27of billionaires and tech companies and whatever that's one way to to create except though on the
- 1:43:36whole I mean I don't know whether this is just universally true but I suspect it might be
- 1:43:41someone who buys like when you buy a plot of land often it's owned by one person yeah I mean even
- 1:43:49around here, who knows? I don't know. I don't know about what went on when they were buying it,
- 1:43:55but it might be that the whole of this side of Prospera was just owned by one family. You don't
- 1:44:00know. In which case, that doesn't really solve the problem you're trying to address, which is
- 1:44:06don't alienate the community. Well, I would say there's a trade-off between going for the nominal
- 1:44:16paper ownership and limiting one's ability to expand. That's, I think, what's in the cards now,
- 1:44:26versus creating a transformative prize to be won. Multiple communities with prime sites
- 1:44:34vie to be offering you the policy reform, not only for the initial project, but for expansion,
- 1:44:4410x, phase two, expansion 80x, phase three. There will be, as institutions break and people
- 1:44:55start looking for better pastures, there will be huge opportunities for vast amounts of prime sites
- 1:45:03with world-class reforms to come to you rather than you, you know, chase, chase, push on the
- 1:45:14in one particular location that gives you a piece of paper saying, you know, you own it.
- 1:45:20So I would love to see Prospera and others shift to the opportunity to grow a hundredfold or more,
- 1:45:30not only at their initial location, but in expansion locations.
- 1:45:36So we'll wrap up soon. What are you working on right now?
- 1:45:40Yeah, I mentioned the micro-vouchers.
- 1:45:46We have this B&B, or yeah, it's a B&B through VRBO, where we do have a revenue flow from it.
- 1:45:55And we want to now pilot these micro-stipens in our neighborhood and offer also virtually opportunities for people to say,
- 1:46:07that's a pretty dilapidated brick wall downtown here.
- 1:46:13Here are ideas for murals that you could do.
- 1:46:16And so these little bitty micro projects I'm working on now set up a template.
- 1:46:24You're not consulting on big projects then anymore?
- 1:46:28Informally, I continue to advise,
- 1:46:31but I'm much more interested in how do we roll out
- 1:46:35the grassroots change and turn people who are now
- 1:46:40skeptics or opponents of these innovations
- 1:46:46into participating in the upsides Not everywhere in the world but in areas that will influence the world So I looking for that I recently returned from Portugal and will be doing some of these next generation micro
- 1:47:02vouchers with the community there.
- 1:47:07So yeah, that's been one of my interests.
- 1:47:10My great abiding interest is seeing us reframe individualism and capitalism in ways that kind of disorient the opponents of free markets.
- 1:47:25And the vehicle for that, I think, jives very well with what is this emergence of a world of abundance, a post-scarcity world, where free zones can be early movers and showing it works.
- 1:47:43And I think the way that'll best happen is if we have new definitions of self-interest.
- 1:47:49the Ayn Rand influenced me a lot early on but I think her super narrow definition of individual
- 1:48:00self-interest actually is not in one's at least my self-interest because our larger self our
- 1:48:10empathic self has room for causes and people and projects that are part of us. And so things that
- 1:48:22benefit these, what's within our boundary of the expanded self-interest, are as nourishing and
- 1:48:30enriching as the narrow self-interest. So having then a way for AIs and social networks to see
- 1:48:41people whole opens up huge opportunities for exchange, gift exchange economies basically,
- 1:48:52to enrich our self-interest in these enlarged ways. And I've worked out a paper that just came
- 1:48:59out in a book in Germany. It's in German, but the translation is Freedompreneurs. And my chapter
- 1:49:09on AI is how can we create better ways to show our true selves or higher selves with AI.
- 1:49:20And it's in English, that chapter. So I'd be glad to send a link to anyone who's
- 1:49:26I don't know whether I'm on the fence about AI in the sense that I think it's great and I think it's terrible at the same time.
- 1:49:42I think it's great because it's helping me every single day.
- 1:49:48I feel neutral about it because it seems to be doing too much.
- 1:49:52I'm noticing that there are parts of my personality, parts of my modus of Miranda that are disappearing.
- 1:50:04And I'm not sure whether that's healthy.
- 1:50:06Sometimes I think, you know, it's like my muscles are withering.
- 1:50:10Should I go to the gym?
- 1:50:13And should I do some of the hard work rather than let this thing do it?
- 1:50:16and then at the very far end on the other side i'm worried that it's the ultimate tool for
- 1:50:23authoritarians which it is 100 and i know the theory is well you know as that size rises it's
- 1:50:31also the ultimate tool for freedom is the ultimate tool for everything yeah but when i look at society
- 1:50:36now um the authoritarians appear to be winning in many places so i can only go ahead and assume that
- 1:50:43with AI they'll carry on winning I don't know I don't know I just know that I find I you know
- 1:50:51of course I love all the innovation in free places and free cities but the only reason it exists is
- 1:51:00because of how bad the rest of society in the world is and that's not good and I I know I've
- 1:51:08noticed even in my lifetime you know because I have kids now and I remember growing up and I
- 1:51:13and see them growing up now and it's a completely different world and the things i'm advising them
- 1:51:19and the things that i'm thinking about on behalf of them are so different from what i imagine my
- 1:51:25mother and father were were worrying or thinking about um i'm trying to basically create a future
- 1:51:33for them set them up so that they have a springboard into as free a future as possible
- 1:51:38my mom and dad didn't think about that i mean we're certain they just assumed i'd be free you
- 1:51:42Right. Well, there's, I think, a big downside ahead. And it does relate to AI, but not in the way you described.
- 1:51:53the reason I don't buy the ominous scenario you painted is that harks to something that Yuval
- 1:52:05Harari has talked about, which he says is the rise of the unnecessariat, not the proletariat,
- 1:52:14But 80% potentially thinks of humans are not going to have the kind of productive vocations because they won't be as good as what AI can do in services or robots can do physically.
- 1:52:34So that would seem to be like, and it is, potentially a keg of dynamite that could blow politically.
- 1:52:42At the same time, the reason I'm skeptical of this idea of elite capture is that in a world of extraordinary abundance, it doesn't really matter.
- 1:53:00If you don't need people to be working for your company, you've got a thousand AIs doing what you normally would do.
- 1:53:10the benefits of doing capturing of territory or takeovers by various means of
- 1:53:20typical traditional factories and whatnot, those are disappearing because we'll have highly
- 1:53:29decentralized, potentially, of superabundance. So what are people doing power struggles for?
- 1:53:40in a world where it doesn't really matter what you've captured.
- 1:53:46There will still be.
- 1:53:47I mean, for example, there are things in the world
- 1:53:50which will not be in abundance,
- 1:53:53even in the time of ultimate abundance, like, for example, land.
- 1:53:57I agree with that.
- 1:53:58So there's obviously still going to be things
- 1:54:01which people will try and control.
- 1:54:04um as far as like what what's it going to be like in the in the future of abundance
- 1:54:10i i my only theory is that the value of what you could call spirituality now will become
- 1:54:22something because we we have to look towards the things which we you would believe that ai can't
- 1:54:29experience yes and our human spirituality whatever that means to you the internal world of a human
- 1:54:37presumably will will have a premium put on it and the spiritual experience will then yes you know a
- 1:54:45bit like i i mean i've i've often wondered whether civilizations of the past were a bit like that
- 1:54:52they had far more um onus put on this the experience of something the spiritual experience
- 1:54:59so when you have any experience available to you at any time right which is likely to happen in
- 1:55:05in an abundant future especially if you can plug into an experience with your right with something
- 1:55:12then there will be the only human things left which will will will have value will be those
- 1:55:19kind of things like the spiritual journey i'd imagine i don't know maybe you can even fake that
- 1:55:24with the right cable no i think you're you're you're right on it um harari has said that we
- 1:55:31may be the last single era of the single species of humans that it's going to branch and individuate
- 1:55:40the way our forebears had company with Neanderthals, Homo erectus, Denisovans, and so on,
- 1:55:49that we may now be branching that way. So this paper on AI that I mentioned in the chapter
- 1:55:58is about the emergence of spiritual offspring in that, okay, our bodies make genes,
- 1:56:08our minds make memes, idea, patterns
- 1:56:11what does our spirit make?
- 1:56:15and it turns out that
- 1:56:17unrelated species
- 1:56:19will come to each other's aid
- 1:56:22if there's a meerkat
- 1:56:25say with particularly noble
- 1:56:28and inspiring qualities of spirit
- 1:56:31courage that is being shown or whatever
- 1:56:34humans will go at risk
- 1:56:38to help that those qualities of spirit continue in that lineage. But so do other species. You see
- 1:56:49in the Arctic, you see animals that are under threat from killer whales come to the rescue of
- 1:56:59other animals also at threat, but because there is some resonance in terms of the qualities of
- 1:57:08spirit that they want to see thrive. So I think what will happen is AIs get better and better
- 1:57:15at becoming person-like and or autonomous within limits. We'll see similar affection or willingness
- 1:57:27to see those kind of qualities of spirit in that branch flourish.
- 1:57:35And this is where I think the realms of imagination,
- 1:57:38where science fiction is filled,
- 1:57:40and the best-selling movies are filled with stories
- 1:57:44of trans-species resonances.
- 1:57:48I think that's where we're heading.
- 1:57:50And it may be that our biological descendants
- 1:57:55aren't the only game in town, but what I would call luminetic descendants, the vessels that
- 1:58:05carry forward these noble qualities of spirit. That more and more in the time of plenitude will,
- 1:58:12I think, attract people across culture, you name the religious or whatever schisms,
- 1:58:22to say yes to seeing these things these qualities flourish what do you think
- 1:58:28firstly do you think ai is intelligent um
- 1:58:33people i admire are saying yeah we're we've crossed we're crossing now the threshold to
- 1:58:42to true intelligence and but from i mean explain how other than all right so are you saying then
- 1:58:51that if you if you went into our historical past as humans when we were formed when brains were
- 1:58:58formulating we we operated on this kind of error correction type thing that that language models do
- 1:59:05they just guess the next word is that how we evolved do you think 10 000 years in the future
- 1:59:10of an ai or probably a lot less but say 10 000 years they will evolve to be like along the pathway
- 1:59:20way that we evolved from language models? Well, this is very, very much wild speculation. But
- 1:59:28if you look at any scale, there's a triad, I think, of things going on. You can see signs that
- 1:59:40Particles, minute particles, are either neutral, indifferent, or they're attracted, meaning there's something they want a state to be in that they're not, or they're aversive, they're repelled.
- 1:59:59So what may happen in terms of our storyline and the future stories is that we are in a field, in a universe that does have these qualities of heart in the sense of attraction or repulsion that lead to actions.
- 2:00:23And I do think that we may just be like stacked up on increasing scale.
- 2:00:32Collections of valuing things that aren't unique to carbon-based life.
- 2:00:39There may be silicon chips that are under stress, you know, do want to get out of that state of stress.
- 2:00:47and in that sense have feeling or some proto-feeling
- 2:00:53that they couldn't similarly stack up and scaffold
- 2:00:57into very complex behaviors or emotional states and behaviors.
- 2:01:07So at some point then, to prove the point,
- 2:01:13go 5,000 years in the future.
- 2:01:17what are we at that point what are we like why why are we like what i mean it's very i know it's
- 2:01:24hard to predict because we we evolve with time don't we ideas evolve the the kind of things we
- 2:01:34get used to very quickly which we adapt to things but it's easy and obvious to predict that we become
- 2:01:43useless quite quickly i can't imagine actually any aspect of our lives other than the spiritual
- 2:01:49experience of a human being which is which is important to us but possibly not important to
- 2:01:55anything else anyway but but other than that i can't envisage anything that that we don't that
- 2:02:02that does something that an ai doesn't eventually do better than us through through humanoid forms
- 2:02:09if necessary anyway. So what are we at that? The only thing, I mean, I have spoken about
- 2:02:16this a few times on this pod and the only conclusion I've ever drawn is that we will
- 2:02:20impose limits on ourselves on purpose Yes And this gets to Universe 25 which is an experiment that was Never heard of that What that It was run I think about 20 or 30 years ago And the lab that did it I think it was a guy at
- 2:02:39Harvard who decided to create paradise for mice or rats. And every conceivable thing they ever
- 2:02:49could want was they're in abundance on this 25th run of this this proving ground so the first
- 2:03:00generation went to town they were you know having all the sex food you name it the second generation
- 2:03:09became very self-absorbed and um the phase we're going through now yeah yeah yeah and so the decay
- 2:03:16set in to the degree of withdrawing and detaching into corners and just grooming themselves all the
- 2:03:23time to be beautiful. And that was the beautiful generation. And what came after that was a horror
- 2:03:30show. Because without the constraints and without the limits and tensions that evolution normally
- 2:03:38presents, it got into extraordinarily self-destructive behaviors. So what to do?
- 2:03:49Big government? I don't hope so. But what I think we can do, and this may emerge out of games and
- 2:03:57simulation experiences that equip us for a host of contingencies, I think we'll be seeing more and
- 2:04:06more inspiring epic adventures and ones that aren't just about us as a species. But essentially,
- 2:04:17I hope we'll see ecosystems emerge, AI ecosystems, that are about alive and whole stories.
- 2:04:29We are narrative creatures. We're very drawn to stories that touch our hearts and touch our heads
- 2:04:35and touch our physical body.
- 2:04:39So to avoid the trap of this narcissistic,
- 2:04:44you know, Baroque, Rococo kind of tailspin,
- 2:04:51I think what will work is having extraordinarily inspiring adventures
- 2:05:02that we are part of.
- 2:05:03and this is where again I think next generation free zones will be ones that excel in this
- 2:05:13kinship creating kinship in terms of on ramps to amazing adventures and that is I hope going to be
- 2:05:23enough to keep people from you know spiraling down into into the vortexes of universe 25.
- 2:05:31Well, I don't know in what universe we are successful in imposing limits on ourselves that aren't authoritarian tendencies.
- 2:05:47Well, no, let me think about this because that's not necessarily true.
- 2:05:50I do the gardening and I grow vegetables.
- 2:05:54I can buy them cheaper, but I grow them.
- 2:05:56So I'm adding, instead of, and almost certainly within 50, probably within 30 years, I could buy for next to nothing a humanoid that would do the gardening for me as well.
- 2:06:12But will I?
- 2:06:13I don't think so.
- 2:06:14I don't know, actually.
- 2:06:16It's going to be quite an existential jolt to take away the need for anything and then see what you put back.
- 2:06:26Yeah. Well, here's an example. It's illegal now, but it's an example of a very attractive opt-in
- 2:06:35system of group purchasing. Insurance companies under regulators are saying,
- 2:06:44you're not allowed to come to us with a group and get good affordable rates.
- 2:06:51you know we decide what the group is you don't okay and so if i you and i um wanting to lower
- 2:07:00our market-based insurance you know health insurance premiums we agreed to only um consume
- 2:07:11the following you know kinds of food and we further agree to upload tiktoks of us
- 2:07:20huffing and puffing on our morning exercise. If we pull together 20, 50 people who
- 2:07:30commit to share confirmations, yes, we went to Old Foods and we got these goodies, not those,
- 2:07:41that this kind of trail and track record and proof that makes for better health outcomes
- 2:07:50we're not allowed to go shopping for health insurance as a group.
- 2:07:57So this is, again, an example of how things that are clearly in our interest
- 2:08:02opt-in limits to what we do for tangible upsides.
- 2:08:09That's opportunity and an example of how next-generation zones
- 2:08:15can encourage people to opt in and voluntarily form these sorts of
- 2:08:23of good regulation in terms of good habits. I mean it might it'll probably become second
- 2:08:34nature in the end won't it it's just that we live in a time where we all strive for things which
- 2:08:41are normal to strive for but when they become irrelevant it will quickly probably become
- 2:08:49normal to strive for limit yeah i presume i don't really know i mean it just seems alien now because
- 2:08:58why would you want to limit yourself now but but like i said earlier yeah i do on a daily basis
- 2:09:04in many ways. And if people you care about, you know, are struggling with this addiction,
- 2:09:12you know, and they're trying to get it off smoking cigarettes or whatever,
- 2:09:16if there are trust networks that say, okay, we will share, you know,
- 2:09:25cool in our proof of work or confirmation that we're flying right for mutual benefit,
- 2:09:34that can be turned to individual advantage in terms of lower risks and health,
- 2:09:40but also to the satisfaction of seeing people you cherish lead healthier lives
- 2:09:50on the basis not of a transactional, you know, go for the easy route,
- 2:09:56but rather a relationship-based agreement
- 2:10:00to do together what might be harder to do individually.
- 2:10:06I think we better end.
- 2:10:07Let's end on a positive statement.
- 2:10:12What about a prediction from yourself
- 2:10:17for the next 20 years?
- 2:10:20Regarding?
- 2:10:21Regarding everything.
- 2:10:22Well, I mean, I think we can assume that we can observe the trajectory of the world, certainly parts of the world.
- 2:10:36That seems obvious what's happening now.
- 2:10:40Technologically, we can see what the big things are.
- 2:10:43because i think you know ai is an interesting technology in the sense that when you when you
- 2:10:49think about it it solves so many it's not like inventing the bike it's like inventing the
- 2:10:58everything so it's it's a it's a unique it potentially at least it's a it's a it's an
- 2:11:06interesting and unique innovation to happen now and we can only see that getting more and more and
- 2:11:12more and more. But you're obviously quite, you're not blackpilled on the future, are you?
- 2:11:19Every time I've predicted a horrible authoritarian nightmare in the future,
- 2:11:24you've called me out on it. So what's your view going forwards for the future?
- 2:11:31We're going to get super branchy, I think, as civilizations, more and more,
- 2:11:37we're going to see very diverging ideas
- 2:11:41on what the good life is.
- 2:11:43We're going to see off-planet
- 2:11:46as well as on-planet venues.
- 2:11:51And it will be, I think,
- 2:11:55a threshold where humanity crosses
- 2:11:58from a scarcity and fear-driven species
- 2:12:02to one that's able to create
- 2:12:04very inspiring examples and failures of these new branches.
- 2:12:14So if we are not choking people's young years
- 2:12:22and we're giving them a taste of what it is to excel
- 2:12:27and to follow your destiny, to create your story,
- 2:12:32and to do it in ways that are benevolent and at least a learning sharing of experiences,
- 2:12:41then I think we're off to the races.
- 2:12:45And the free zones now are making choices that countless small actions and decisions
- 2:12:52are going to be shaping this tree of life that emerges.
- 2:12:58So if the zones of the 60s and 70s and 80s were sandboxes for economic freedom, what are zones now?
- 2:13:08What are these new breeder zones?
- 2:13:10What are they the sandboxes for, according to you?
- 2:13:12Yeah, I think they're places where the best qualities of humans will have a chance to emerge and to show how they can interact and blunder, but co-evolve in generative ways.
- 2:13:35Sandboxes for human culture?
- 2:13:37The evolution of civil society and a generative way of interchange with one another.
- 2:13:47And there are certainly going to be people bombing and whatever, too.
- 2:13:51But there's an anti-fragile relationship.
- 2:13:55The worst areas get, the more people are going to innovate and create safe havens that can be the springboard.
- 2:14:07forward mark thank you for coming in sorry everyone for my for the for the loss of of sound
- 2:14:17quality for hopefully like 10 seconds i glance down at that box every now and then i just wish
- 2:14:24they should put they should put a little beeping sound on there when when a card fills up or
- 2:14:29something because then i would but we may have been speaking for 15 minutes with low quality
- 2:14:34sound at some point in which is really annoying i hate it when things like that happen but
- 2:14:39apologies for that um people watching and listening um and mark thanks for thanks coming
- 2:14:44i'm very very glad to meet you i'm sure our paths will cross another time in the future it's a it's
- 2:14:50a growing ecosystem and um i i either one have certainly noticed on this trip already walked
- 2:14:57into a room which a few years ago would have been a room full of strangers now it's a room full of
- 2:15:02people I know, probably more than 50% of the people I know by name and get a big hug from,
- 2:15:08which is great. And I imagine it just gets better from here on in.
- 2:15:13Yeah. And just the concluding thought, David Brooks wrote a book that has a following
- 2:15:21sentence or two in it. Through life, we go from difficulty to harmony and harmony to difficulty,
- 2:15:28all of it propelled by the desire for limerence, the moment when the inner and the outer patterns mesh.
- 2:15:37and this to me this gathering um and the the kindred spirits and movers um are for me so
- 2:15:50enlivening it's a state of flow because i do feel the mesh within and without dissolving the boundary
- 2:15:57that normally we we work at well i'm into that i'll i'll i'll i'll go with that one all right
- 2:16:04Mark, thank you. And yeah, good luck with everything.
- 2:16:07Great. If anyone would like to get in touch, the very small nonprofit I head up is called Open World.
- 2:16:17And I'm reachable at mark at openworld.com.
- 2:16:21All in the show notes. Thank you, Mark.
- 2:16:24Thank you.
- 2:16:25right you made it to the end of the show so i'm gonna go ahead and assume that you got some value
- 2:16:35out of this episode if you want to help the show please follow or subscribe right now it takes only
- 2:16:42two seconds and it massively helps if you've got another 30 seconds well leave a review on apple
- 2:16:50podcasts or Spotify. Honest reviews apparently are the single best way to help new listeners
- 2:16:56find us. If you want more, you can get bonus episodes and early access to episodes on
- 2:17:03fountain.fm for the price of one coffee for a whole month. Or you can support the mission
- 2:17:09by streaming sats on any of the value for value platforms or use the Bitcoin and fiat
- 2:17:15donation links in the show notes. Every contribution to the show makes a real difference.
- 2:17:21Believe me. And one more thing, if you know someone who'd love this episode,
- 2:17:26share it directly with them. That personal share beats every algorithm in the book.
- 2:17:31All the links, the community and the newsletter are in the show notes. And jump on over to
- 2:17:36freecities.fm for a deep dive into all the episodes with descriptions and more. That's
- 2:17:44the new Free Cities podcast website, freecities.fm. Have a good week and see you next time.