Latest / The Brief / Metrics that Matter
Transcript
- A dashboard can tell you occupancy, turnover, rent growth, response times, and resident satisfaction.
- But a number by itself rarely tells the whole story.
- A property can be full and still fall short of its income potential.
- A satisfaction score can look strong even as operational friction begins to build.
- And NOI confirms the result, but it does not diagnose what produced it.
- The metrics that matter help leaders make those connections, from broad economic forces to the everyday processes and decisions shaping resident experience and asset performance.
- And today, Minnesota’s multifamily industry is gathering at the Hilton Minneapolis for Maddox, celebrating outstanding work across our industry.
- Congratulations to every nominee and to the winners who will be recognized at tonight’s celebration.
- Your work is a reminder that while performance may appear on a scorecard, it is people, judgment, and daily decisions that create it.
- In the newest issue of the Advocate, “Metrics That Matter,” we look beyond surface-level numbers to what they reveal, what they miss, and how better indicators can help leaders act sooner.
- That conversation starts now on The Brief.
- You're listening to the Brief, a podcast from the Minnesota Multi-Housing Association.
- Whether you're a property owner, manager, maintenance pro, product/service partner, or just curious about the industry we've got fresh insights, and quick takes, to keep you informed and ahead of the curve.
- No fluff.
- No filler.
- If it affects your residents, your business, or your bottom line.
- You'll hear about it here.
- This industry provides more than buildings.
- It offers Minnesotans a solution for home That solution is multi housing.
- Welcome to MHAs, The Brief.
- This episode of The Brief is proudly sponsored by our founding partner, Citizens State Bank.
- Rooted in the Upper Midwest with a growing presence in Minnesota, Citizens State Bank is deeply committed to supporting the region’s housing providers and small businesses through personalized financial solutions.
- Whether you're financing a new property in the Twin Cities, refinancing in Rochester, or expanding your operations across the state, their experienced team is here to help.
- Citizens State Bank specializes in property management banking solutions tailored to meet the unique needs of Minnesota’s property owners and managers.
- From commercial real estate loans, competitive deposit accounts, and a state-of-the-art business online banking suite, they provide the local insight and resources you need to keep your business moving forward.
- Experience the difference of working with a bank that understands Minnesota communities.
- Visit csbnet.net
- to learn how Citizens State Bank can help you achieve your goals.
- Member FDIC.
- Equal Housing Lender.
- Thanks to Citizens State Bank for backing this podcast and helping us bring valuable industry insights to Minnesota and beyond—week after week.
- The September/October issue of The Advocate begins with a simple challenge.
- Housing professionals have access to more numbers than ever before.
- Occupancy, rent growth, expenses, turnover, leasing activity, resident satisfaction, and dozens of other measurements are always within reach.
- But access to data is not the same as understanding it.
- The real question is whether the numbers help you recognize what is changing, understand why it is changing, and make a better decision because of it.
- MHA President and CEO Sehsill Smith explores that distinction in “What the Dashboard Does Not Measure.”
- His point is not that dashboards are unimportant.
- It is that most of the numbers on them are outputs.
- The conditions that produced those results often began much earlier.
- A renewal percentage may show up on a report, but the resident’s decision could have been influenced by a maintenance experience months earlier.
- A turn-time report may identify a delay, but it may not show the breakdown in coordination among maintenance, vendors, and the leasing team.
- And a completed work order does not tell you whether someone noticed a recurring problem before it became a larger failure.
- Those results are shaped by people, judgment, communication, staffing, training, and the authority employees have to solve problems.
- Some of those factors can be measured.
- Others are harder to capture.
- And that creates a real leadership challenge.
- Large portfolios need standardized, auditable measurements.
- Owners and capital partners cannot manage thousands of apartments through personal observation alone.
- But the dashboard still needs interpretation.
- A number can identify where to look.
- It cannot always tell you what you will find there.
- MHA Board Chair Erin Fransen of Timberland Partners brings another perspective in “Making Every Lap Count.”
- Erin writes about growing up as a competitive swimmer, when times, intervals, and stroke counts helped her understand whether all those hours in the pool were producing progress.
- The clock did not swim the lap for her, but it gave her an objective way to measure the result.
- She applies that same thinking to property operations.
- Data does not have to remove the human side of the work.
- Used well, it can help create better outcomes for residents, employees, owners, and investors.
- Every organization needs a financial baseline.
- Income, expenses, net operating income, and cash flow are the foundation.
- But Erin’s leadership team also watches occupancy, resident retention, open positions, reputation scores, and asking rents.
- Looking at those measures together produces a much more useful story.
- Resident retention protects against vacancy loss and turnover costs.
- Open positions can signal whether teams have the capacity to maintain service levels without burning out.
- Reputation scores show how residents are experiencing the community.
- Asking rent can offer an early indication of where financial performance may be headed.
- That is an important shift.
- Instead of treating every number as an isolated result, leaders can look at how the measurements influence one another.
- An open maintenance position may contribute to longer response times.
- Longer response times may affect resident satisfaction and online reviews.
- Those experiences can influence renewals, turnover, vacancy, and eventually NOI.
- The final financial result may appear months after the first warning sign.
- Maria Pietroforte of Maria Pietroforte Consulting takes that idea further in “The Metrics That Move Value.”
- She argues that the industry’s challenge is no longer whether we have enough data.
- It is whether we are interpreting the right numbers in the right way.
- Physical occupancy is a good example.
- It tells you how full a property is, but it does not tell you how effectively that property is converting its potential income into actual income.
- A property can report strong occupancy while also carrying higher concessions, growing delinquency, underpriced renewals, vacancy loss, or elevated bad debt.
- From the outside, it may appear stable.
- Financially, it may be moving in the wrong direction.
- That is why economic occupancy matters.
- The issue compares two properties that both have 95 percent physical occupancy.
- One has an economic occupancy of 92 percent.
- The other is at 86 percent.
- The units may look equally full on a standard occupancy report, but the amount of revenue being captured is very different.
- The same principle applies to rent growth.
- A higher asking rent may look positive, but it needs to be evaluated alongside lead-to-lease conversion, concessions, delinquency, renewals, and turnover.
- If a rent increase contributes to more move-outs, longer vacancies, or higher concessions, part of that gain may disappear somewhere else in the operating equation.
- Sometimes the strongest value decision is not achieving the highest possible new lease rent.
- It may be securing a renewal that protects occupancy, reduces downtime, and avoids unnecessary turnover costs.
- Leasing velocity also needs to be viewed as more than an onsite activity measure.
- Every additional vacant day represents income the property cannot recover.
- Longer vacancy may also point toward pricing resistance, slow turns, weak follow-up, reputation concerns, or a mismatch between the property and the market.
- The issue puts that into dollars.
- For an apartment renting at $1,800 per month, ten additional vacant days represent roughly $600 in lost rent before accounting for concessions or other operating costs.
- “Days vacant” is a number.
- “Cost of vacancy” makes the consequence much clearer.
- Turnover, bad debt, application quality, collections, and repeat maintenance issues can all be viewed in the same way.
- They are not just departmental statistics.
- They affect reliable income, operating costs, NOI, and asset value.
- Maria makes an especially useful distinction: N.O.I.
- is the result, not the diagnosis.
- It tells leaders what happened.
- The operating measures beneath it help explain why it happened.
- That is also why financial fluency should not stop at the executive level.
- A leasing professional makes decisions about follow-up and concessions.
- A maintenance leader influences turn times and service consistency.
- A property manager makes choices involving renewals, collections, staffing, and expenses.
- When people understand how those daily decisions connect to cash flow and value, reports become more than something that has to be submitted.
- They become tools for managing the property.
- Of course, not every influence begins at the property.
- Matt Mullins of Bricks and Brand looks beyond individual asset performance to the economic forces shaping multifamily housing.
- Employment conditions influence whether households have the income and confidence to rent.
- Consumer sentiment can affect whether people move, form new households, or stay where they are.
- Wage growth and housing costs shape affordability.
- Interest rates and Treasury yields affect borrowing, refinancing, property values, and investment activity.
- Inflation also affects both sides of the equation.
- Housing providers face rising costs for insurance, payroll, utilities, maintenance, materials, and contracted services.
- Residents are facing their own cost pressures, which can make them more sensitive to rent increases and other housing expenses.
- Construction costs, capital availability, and local housing policy influence how much new housing can be built.
- Matt notes that development costs in many Twin Cities submarkets can exceed $300,000 per unit.
- When projects no longer pencil, fewer developments move forward.
- That may reduce new supply in the years ahead, which could strengthen conditions for existing properties.
- But it also makes it harder to deliver housing at prices residents can afford.
- One indicator can create several different effects depending on where you sit.
- That is why no single economic headline provides the answer.
- A strong employment market may support rental demand while insurance and property taxes continue to pressure margins.
- Lower interest rates may improve financing conditions, but construction costs and lengthy approval processes can still prevent development.
- National data provides context, but local conditions often tell you more about a specific property.
- Leaders need to understand the industries driving employment in their market, the supply coming into their submarket, local affordability, and how residents are responding.
- The goal is not to predict every economic turn.
- It is to recognize emerging conditions early enough to adjust pricing, budgets, capital plans, staffing, and investment decisions.
- That same focus on early indicators carries into the resident experience.
- Angie Wollan of Enclave Property Management makes the case that the satisfaction score comes last.
- By the time a resident completes a survey or leaves a review, the experience has already happened.
- A maintenance request was acknowledged, or it was not.
- Expectations were established, communication occurred, someone arrived, and the issue was resolved, or the resident was left waiting.
- The survey captures the result of that process.
- It does not create the result.
- That means a drop in satisfaction is a signal, not the root cause.
- Leaders may need to look at response times, repeat visits, communication practices, staffing changes, vendor transitions, or open work orders by age.
- The operational data can reveal where friction entered the experience.
- It is also important to know exactly what the organization is measuring.
- One company may consider a work order complete when the technician closes it.
- Another may not consider it complete until the resident confirms that the problem has been resolved.
- Both could report an average completion time of two days, but they are measuring two different experiences.
- Even a word like “quickly” can mean something different to a resident without heat than it does to someone waiting for a cosmetic repair.
- Better decisions do not necessarily come from having more data.
- They come from having reliable data, consistent definitions, and enough context to understand what the number represents.
- The goal is to design operating processes that consistently create a good resident experience, then use feedback to confirm whether those processes are working.
- That changes the conversation from “How do we improve the score?” to “How do we improve the system that produced it?” In her second article in this issue, Maria Pietroforte describes the next generation of KPIs as a shift from outcomes to signals.
- Most traditional metrics confirm what has already happened.
- Leading indicators expose what is beginning to happen.
- Instead of tracking only total days vacant, teams can break the process into notice-to-ready, ready-to-leased, and leased-to-move-in.
- Instead of counting completed work orders, they can track first-visit completion, repeat issues within 30 days, and open requests by age.
- Leasing teams can look at lead response time and follow-up consistency.
- Maintenance leaders can track units that were not ready by the target date and the reasons for the delay.
- Those measurements identify friction before it reaches revenue or resident retention.
- Technology adoption belongs on that list too.
- Purchasing and implementing a platform does not mean it is producing value.
- Leaders need to know whether teams are actively using it, completing work through it, and replacing old processes rather than duplicating them.
- The same applies to labor.
- Payroll is an expense, but the workforce also represents operating capacity.
- Turnover, open positions, ramp-up time, overtime, internal promotions, and employee referrals can help leaders understand whether teams have the stability and support required to perform.
- The strongest measurements also connect to behavior.
- If the goal is to reduce the time between vacancy and move-in, maintenance, leasing, managers, and regional leaders all influence the result.
- Holding one department accountable for a shared outcome can create the wrong incentives.
- This does not mean adding another dozen charts to the dashboard.
- More KPIs can create more noise.
- The opportunity is to choose a smaller number of indicators that reveal problems early, connect to meaningful outcomes, can be influenced by the team, and encourage the right behavior.
- A useful dashboard review can begin with a few questions.
- What decision would this metric change? Is it an outcome or an early signal? Does everyone define it the same way? Can the team influence it? And what other measurement would help explain why it moved? Sometimes the best improvement is not adding a metric.
- It is replacing a volume measure with one that captures effectiveness.
- Work orders completed becomes first-visit resolution.
- Days vacant becomes cost of vacancy.
- Software implemented becomes active adoption.
- A satisfaction score becomes an invitation to examine the process behind the experience.
- Taken together, the articles in “Metrics That Matter” offer a more complete view of performance.
- Economic indicators explain the environment.
- Financial metrics show the result.
- Operating measures reveal what is driving it.
- Resident feedback shows how the experience is being received.
- And people turn all of that information into action.
- The value is not in reporting another number.
- It is in identifying the right signal early enough to make a better decision.
- After the break, we are going to move from choosing the right metrics to finding reliable benchmarks.
- We’ll look at MHA’s Compensation and Benefits Survey and Operating Expense Survey.
- The latest Operating Expense Survey draws on information from more than 25,000 units, but we are not going to unload the entire spreadsheet here.
- We’ll explain what these resources can help housing providers understand, why industry participation matters, and how companies can participate in future survey cycles or purchase the available reports.
- That is coming up after these messages from our sponsors.
- Looking to refresh your flooring without the hassle? Bloomington Carpet One has you covered—with expert guidance, quality products, and solutions tailored for multi housing professionals.
- Whether it’s one unit or an entire building, their team helps you choose flooring that’s stylish, durable, and budget-friendly.
- Visit carpet-one-bloomington.com
- or stop by their Bloomington showroom to see the difference that local expertise and national buying power can make.
- Bloomington Carpet One.
- Beautiful made affordable.
- Every multifamily property depends on reliable electrical and technology systems.
- When something goes wrong—or it's time to upgrade—you need a partner who can handle it all.
- J.
- Becker Associates provides electrical service, system upgrades, EV charging, lighting, security, fire alarm, access control, networking, and preventative maintenance, all under one roof.
- One contractor.
- One point of contact.
- One team focused on keeping your properties operating safely and efficiently.
- Whether you're maintaining existing communities or planning your next renovation, we're ready to help.
- Visit j becker .com.
- J.
- Becker Associates.
- One partner, EVERY connection.
- Welcome back.
- Before the break, we talked about choosing metrics that reveal more than a surface-level result.
- But even the right metric needs context, and one of the most useful forms of context is a credible industry benchmark.
- A benchmark helps you move beyond asking, “Did we hit our budget?” It lets you ask how your property or company compares with similar operations and where the differences deserve a closer look.
- That does not mean every organization should match the average.
- Properties differ by size, age, location, building type, amenities, staffing model, and the residents they serve.
- But when your number looks significantly different from the benchmark, you have a place to begin asking questions.
- Is the difference intentional? Does it reflect the property? Or is it pointing toward a cost, process, or staffing issue that needs attention? MHA offers two resources to help members have those conversations: the Operating Expense Survey and the Compensation and Benefits Survey.
- The Operating Expense Survey is conducted annually and examines what professionally managed properties are spending across categories such as payroll and benefits, insurance, real estate taxes, utilities, management fees, repairs and maintenance, and marketing.
- The newly released 2025 survey is based on information from 25,235 units across 181 professionally managed properties submitted by 23 companies in the Twin Cities metropolitan area.
- At the highest level, the median operating expense was $10,766 per-apartment-unit per-year and $14,164 per-townhome-unit.
- Those figures do not include bad debt.
- Those are useful reference points, but they are not universal spending targets.
- The real value comes from being able to examine the categories beneath the total and compare properties with more similar characteristics.
- If repairs and maintenance are higher than expected, for example, that number alone does not tell you whether spending is excessive.
- The difference could relate to the age of the property, major improvements, turnover, landscaping, snow removal, elevators, parking, or other operating conditions.
- The benchmark identifies where to look.
- Your knowledge of the property helps explain what you find.
- Staffing is another major part of both operating performance and the resident experience.
- That is where MHA’s Compensation and Benefits Survey becomes valuable.
- The 2025 survey includes information from 42 MHA member organizations covering 22 positions at both the site and corporate levels.
- It includes base salary information by units managed, along with bonuses, commissions, medical, dental and vision benefits, paid time off, turnover, on-call pay, and changes in marketplace pay patterns.
- That gives employers Minnesota-specific information to support budgeting, recruiting, retention, and compensation decisions.
- It is especially useful when a position is difficult to fill or when an organization is evaluating whether its total compensation remains competitive.
- Both surveys also depend on industry participation.
- The more qualified companies contributing accurate information, the more useful the resulting benchmarks become.
- The Operating Expense Survey is conducted every year using the previous year’s property data.
- Companies with eligible properties can contact MHA at oes@mmha.com
- to learn how to participate in the next collection cycle.
- Participating companies receive a copy of the completed survey.
- The Compensation and Benefits Survey is conducted every other year.
- The next report will be published in 2027, with data collection scheduled to begin in June 2027.
- Companies interested in participating can submit their contact information through MHA’s website now.
- You do not have to participate to purchase the reports.
- The Operating Expense Survey and Compensation and Benefits Survey are available through MHA’s online store, either separately or together as a survey bundle.
- Visit mmha.com,
- open the Resources menu, select Online Store, and choose Survey Bundle.
- We will also include a direct link in the show notes.
- A benchmark will not make the decision for you.
- But it can help you ask better questions, test assumptions, and understand whether your organization’s experience reflects a broader industry trend or something happening inside your own operation.
- And just like the other metrics we have discussed today, the value is not simply having the number.
- It is knowing what to do with it.
- That brings us back to where we started.
- Metrics help us understand performance, but people create it.
- So, as Minnesota’s multifamily industry gathers for Maddox, congratulations again to all of this year’s nominees and winners.
- The work being celebrated today is what moves our communities, teams, and organizations forward.
- You can explore all the articles from “Metrics That Matter” in the September/October 2026 issue of the Advocate.
- We will include that link, along with the survey information, in the show notes.
- Then join us again on October 2, when Aubrey sits down with Jennifer Spadeenee for a conversation about leadership, service, and the legacy housing professionals can build throughout their careers.
- Follow The Brief wherever you listen, and share this episode with another housing professional who would find it useful.
- Thanks for listening.
- We’ll see you next time on The Brief.
- This has been The Brief, an original podcast produced by the Minnesota Multi Housing Association.
- It is hosted by your two favorite AI voices—me, Denise Wilson… …and me, Logan Garcia.
- Our story editor is Todd Lillgenquist.
- Aubrey Albrecht is our showrunner and managing producer.
- The Brief’s executive producer is Sesil Smith.
- Follow and listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, mmha.com,
- and wherever you get your podcasts.
- And one more big thank-you to Citizens State Bank, our founding sponsor.
- Their support powers this podcast—and their team powers smart financial solutions for Minnesota’s housing providers.
- Visit csbnet.net
- to learn more.
- See you next time!